Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Arvind Dessertation Latest PDF
Arvind Dessertation Latest PDF
The only way to keep your health is to eat what you don't want, drink what you
don't like, and do what you'd rather not.
Mark Twain
There are several very painful experiences that one suffers in stillness as it is a
discomforting topic to be even discussed. Haemorrhoids is such a common occurrence
in adults but is very rarely talked about because of the embarrassing nature of the
condition. Many people are even too embarrassed to consult their doctor about
haemorrhoids. Nearly every patient visiting the general or colon and rectal surgeon
with anal problems comes in complaining of "haemorrhoids". Treatment for
haemorrhoids is only needed if they are truly symptomatic. The mere presence of
haemorrhoids is not an indication for any therapeutic intervention.
Haemorrhoids if untreated can potentially pose serious medical problems and
can be a symptom of a bigger problem. Haemorrhoids, also called piles or varicose
veins of the anus and rectum are masses or clumps or cushions of tissues
consisting of muscle and elastic fibers with enlarged, bulging blood vessels and
surrounding supporting tissues present in the anal canal of an individual suffering
from the disease. Many myths exist regarding the etiology and pathophysiology of
internal haemorrhoids. The development of haemorrhoids has been attributed to
prolonged periods of driving, sitting on cold seats or benches, eating spicy foods, and
doing manual labour. In addition to this there are misconceptions regarding the
etiology of haemorrhoids among the lay members of our community.
The misconceptions related to haemorrhoids have been perpetuated throughout
many surgical texts. Haemorrhoids are part of the normal anatomy within the
anal canal and are believed to be important in maintaining continence.
When an individual coughs, strains or sneezes, these fibro vascular cushions engorge
and maintain closure of the anal canal in order to prevent leakage of stool in the
presence of increased intrarectal pressure. Therefore, surgical removal may result in
varying degrees of incontinence particularly in individuals with marginal preoperative
control about which most people are unaware. Haemorrhoids are of two types, the
one which is placed inside is named as Internal Haemorrhoids and is structured just
under the tissue that lines the inside of the rectum. They are not noticeable till they
become big and will make them to collapse and jut out through the anus. On the other
hand, the vein
1
that forms outside the rectum and surround the anus is called External
Haemorrhoids. The main causes that utter into this painful position, is hereditary and
postponing of visits to toilet.
In India approximately 40,723,288 people are reported to have haemorrhoids.
1 million new cases are reported annually and prevalence increases with age, common
in age group of 45-65yrs. It is estimated that 50-85% of people around the world and
in India 75% of the population is estimated to have haemorrhoids. Current statistics
suggest that almost half of people in their fifties have piles.[1] Age is not the only
factor though, haemorrhoids can affect people of any age group or gender. Bleeding
haemorrhoids should be considered severe only if you start losing a lot of blood and
you get dizzy and weak. Even though haemorrhoids are usually the most common
reason for your rectum to bleed, one should still consult a doctor if he or she have this
symptom. There are lots of other serious conditions such as ulcerative colitis, anal
fissures, polyps and certain types of cancers that will cause rectal bleeding, that is why
it is crucial to eliminate the possibilities by consulting the doctor.
Even though a precise definition of haemorrhoids does not exist, they can be
described as masses or "cushions" of tissue within the anal canal that contain blood
vessels and the surrounding, supporting tissue made up of muscle and elastic fibres.
The anal canal is the last four centimeters through which stool passes as it goes from
the rectum to the outside. Most people think haemorrhoids are abnormal, but they are
present in everyone. It is only when the haemorrhoid cushions enlarge,
haemorrhoids can cause problems and be considered abnormal or a disease.
Haemorrhoids should not be considered a taboo subject especially now that there are
many remedies discovered in curing haemorrhoids. These treatments may range from
medical to surgical procedures.
Aims & Objective
The aim of the study is to compare the following points between Ultrasonic
Scalpel Haemorrhoidectomy and Diathermy Haemorrhoidectomy.
Post-operative pain
Post-operative analgesia requirement
Post-operative complication
Efficacy of treatment
Duration of hospital stay
Review of literature
HISTORICAL REVIEW
Haemorrhoids are one of the oldest diseases suffered by mankind well
recorded in ancient texts of Greeks, Egyptians, Hindus, And Bible. Many great
personalities have suffered from haemorrhoids like the Philistines, Napoleon
Bonaparte, Don Juan Demorann.[2]
Hippocrates thought haemorrhoidal disease facilitates purification of various
organisms expelling petrified matter also correlated liver disease, portal hypertension
and haemorrhoids. Duret suggested increase in portal venous pressure due to straining
during defecation as the cause of haemorrhoids.
John Morgan first attempted sclerotherapy to obliterate haemorrhoids in 1869
with iron persulphate. Anderson (1924) and Bacon (1949) outlined injection
treatment and later Albright used 5% phenol in almond oil. In 1774, John Louie
Petit proposed sub mucosal method of ligation of haemorrhoids. In 1835, Salmon
was the first to isolate the pedicle of haemorrhoid. In 1882, Whithead described the
circumferential amputation of haemorrhoids. In 1903, Mitchell described a method of
clamping of haemorrhoids and excision with partial wound closure. Earl and Bacon
popularized the technique later. In 1919, Miles modified Salmons original
technique of high excision with open haemorrhoidectomy by suggesting a lower
ligation to reduce the amount of raw tissue in the anal canal. In 1959, Ferguson and
Heaton described a technique of closed haemorrhoidectomy.
Blaisdell in 1954 invented the instrument and technique for outpatient ligation
of internal haemorrhoids using silk thread for ligation. This instrument was later
modified by Barron in 1963 who used rubber bands for ligation. Lords in 1968
described anal stretch for haemorrhoids and Noratas in 1971 proposed lateral
subcutaneous sphincterotomy to reduce the activity of internal sphincter, overactivity
of which was proposed as a cause. Lewis introduced cryosurgery in treatment of
haemorrhoids. Neiger introduced photocoagulation in 1979. Most recently, laser
haemorrhoidectomy has been tried. Longo in 1998 has described stapled
haemorrhoidopexy for painless treatment of haemorrhoids.
ANATOMY
The anal canal is the terminal portion of gastrointestinal tract, begins at the
anorectal junction is about 4 cms long and terminates at the anal verge. The anorectal
junction is angulated in relation to the rectum due to pull of puborectalis muscle
producing anorectal angle. It lies 2-3 cms in front of and slightly below tip of coccyx,
where the ampulla of rectum suddenly narrows and pierces the pelvic diaphragm,
which is opposite apex of prostrate in males.
The anal verge is marked by a sharp turn where the squamous epithelium
which lines the lower anal canal becomes continuous with skin of perineum.
[3]
Embryologically the superior two thirds of the anorectal canal is derived from the
distal part of hindgut, whereas the inferior one third of anorectal canal is derived from
ectodermal pit called the anal pit or proctoderm. The pit is created when the
mesenchyme around anal membrane proliferates to form a raised border.
The anal membrane thus separates the endodermal and ectodermal portions of
anorectal canal, the former location of this membrane is marked in adult by irregular
folding of mucosa called pectinate line.
In both sexes the anal canal is related anteriorly to the perineal body. Perineal
body in males separates anal canal from membranous urethra and penile bulb, and
separates from lower vagina in females. Posteriorly the anal canal is related to the tip
of the coccyx and anococcygeal ligament and laterally to loose adipose tissue of
ischiorectal fossa.
INTERIOR OF THE ANAL CANAL
The anal canal is encircled by internal and external anal sphincters separated by the
longitudinal layer and has connection superiorly to puborectalis and transverse perinei
muscles.
Fig. 1: Musculature of the anal canal
8
1) Internal anal sphincter
The internal anal sphincter is a well-defined ring of obliquely oriented smooth
muscle fibres continuous with circular muscles of the rectum, terminating at the
junction of superficial and subcutaneous component of external sphincter. Thickness
of internal sphincter varies between 1.5 to 3.5 mm. The lower portion of sphincter is
crossed by fibres from conjoint longitudinal coat which passes into submucosa of the
lower canal.
Vascular supply
The vascular supply of internal sphincter is from the terminal branches of
superior rectal vessels and branches of inferior rectal vessel.
2) External anal sphincter
The external anal sphincter is a elliptical cylinder of skeletal muscle
surrounding the anal canal. The lowest portion occupies a position below and slightly
lateral to internal sphincter, a palpable groove at this level has been referred to as
inter sphincteric groove.
The lowest part is traversed by the conjoint longitudinal muscle. The
intermediate portion is attached to coccyx by posterior extension of muscle fibres
forming the anococcygeal ligament. The deep portion of external sphincter is devoid
of posterior attachment and proximally becomes continuous with puborectalis muscle.
Anteriorly the high fibres of external sphincter is attached to perineal body.
Vascular supply
Terminal branches of inferior rectal vessels with contribution forms median
sacral artery.
3)Conjoint longitudinal muscle
At the level of anorectal ring the longitudinal muscle coat of rectum is joined
by fibres of levatorani and puborectalis, the conjoint muscle thus formed descends
between internal and external anal sphincter. Many of these fibres traverse the lower
portion of external sphincter to gain insertion into perianal skin referred as corrugator
cutis ani. somefibres of conjoint longitudinal muscle may form a longitudinal layer of
muscle on the inner aspect of internal sphincter naming it muscularis sub mucosa ani.
Some fibres that traverse the internal sphincter and become inserted just below
anal valves returned as mucosal suspensory ligament. It has been suggested that the
role of conjoint longitudinal muscle is to affix the anal canal and avert the anus during
defecation.
9
4) Anorectal ring
This is a muscular ring present at the anorectal junction, formed by fusion of
puborectalis muscle, deep external sphincter and internal sphincter, less marked
anteriorly where fibres of the puborectalis are absent.
The arterial supply of anal canal above pectinate line is by the superior,
middle rectal artery and the arterial supply below pectinate line is by the inferior
rectal artery.
The venous drainage of the upper anal canal mucosa, internal anal sphincter
and conjoint longitudinal coat passes via terminal branches of the superior rectal veins
into the inferior mesenteric vein to portal system. The lower anal canal and
external sphincter drain via inferior rectal branch of pudendal vein into internal iliac
vein.
1) Internal rectal venous plexus (haemorrhoidal plexus)
The haemorrhoidal plexus lie in submucosa of anal canal and drains mainly in
superior rectal vein but communicates freely with external plexus and thus with
middle and inferior rectal veins, so internal plexus is a important site for porto-
systemic anastomosis. Veins present in three anal columns at 3, 7, 11 oclock
positions are large and they constitute potential sites for primary internal piles.
2) External rectal venous plexus
The external rectal venous plexus lie outside the muscular coat of rectum and
anal canal, communicating freely with internal plexus. The lower part of external
plexus is drained by inferior rectal vein into internal pudendal vein, the middle part by
middle rectal vein into internal iliac vein, upper part by superior rectal vein which
continues as inferior mesentric vein, a tributary of the portal vein.
3) Anal veins
The anal veins are arranged radially around the anal margin. They
communicate with internal rectal plexus and inferior rectal veins.
Lymphatics from the upper anal mucosa, internal anal sphincter and conjoint
longitudinal coat drain upwards into the submucosa and intramural lymphatics of the
rectum. The lower anal canal epithelium and external anal sphincter lymphatics drain
10
Fig. 5: Venous drainage of anal canal
12
downwards via perianal plexus into vessels, which drain into external inguinal lymph
nodes. The lymphatics of puborectalis muscle drain into internal iliac lymph nodes.
The sympathetic nerve supply of anal canal above the pectinate line is from the
inferior hypogastric plexus (L1,2), the parasympathetic nerve supply is from pelvic
splanchnic nerves (S2,3,4) (pain sensations carried by both). The somatic nerve supply
below the pectinate line is from inferior rectal (S2,3,4) nerves. The function of the
anorectal region is not only to act as a reservoir for faeces but also to facilitate
effortless, unimpeded voiding during defecation.
PHYSIOLOGY
ANAL CONTINENCE
Maintaining anal continence is a complex matter because it is controlled by
local reflex mechanisms as well as conscious will. Normal continence depends on
highly integrated series of complicated events.
RESERVOIR FUNCTION OF RECTUM
The distal part of large intestine has a reservoir function that is important for
continence. Lateral angulations of sigmoid colon and the valves of houstonprovide
amechanical barrier and retard progressions of stools. The adaptive compliance of
rectum along with rectal capacity and distensibility also contribute to differences in
pressure patterns between distal and proximal levels of anal canal resulting in
development of force vector in the direction of rectum. Angulation between the rectum
and anal canal due to continuous tonic activity of puborectalis muscle as well as high-
pressure zone in anal canal contributeto the reservoir function.
SPHINCTERIC FACTORS
Activity of the anal sphincters is believed to be the most important factor for
continence. They are responsible for the high-pressure zone (average 25-120 mmHg)
in anal canal that appears to provide a barrier against high rectal pressure (average 5-
20 mmHg). The high-pressure zone as demonstrated by pull through recordings has
an average length of 3.5 cm and results from continuous tonic activity of both
sphincters.
MECHANICAL FACTORS
Angulation between rectum and anal canal is the most important component for
gross fecal continence due to continuous tonic activity of puborectalis muscle. As
measured by defecography the angle between axis of anal canal and rectum in resting
state is about 90 degree and radiographic studies have elucidated changes during
defecation.
Flutter valve theory: It has been suggested that additional protection of
continence might be afforded by intra abdominal pressure being transmitted
laterally to the side of the anal canal just at the level of the anorectal junction.
Flap valve theory: The flap valve theory was advanced by parks et al and
the theory proposed any increase in the intra abdominal pressure tends to
accentuate the anorectal angle and forces the anterior rectal wall to lie firmly
over upper end of anal canal producing a flap valve effect.
Peak between age 45 to 65 years and a subsequent decline after the age of 65
years. The presence of haemorrhoids in patients less than 20 years is unusual.
2. SEX
4. OCCUPATION
The varicose vein theory stemmed from assumptions that dilatations of veins
of internal rectal plexus result from pathological change, is shown as invalid by
confirming the dilatations are in fact normal.
The fact that haemorrhoids are no more common in patients with portal
hypertension than in population at large is additional evidence against this theory. This
theory also fails to account for the fact that haemorrhoids frequently occur singly and
more common in right anterior position.
Dysrythmia within the internal sphincter and higher anal resting pressure have
been demonstrated in patients with haemorrhoids. Hancock believed that an internal
sphincter abnormality may be a causative factor. Roe et al found a reduction in anal
pressure after haemorrhoidectomy and believed it might be possible that
haemorrhoidal tissue itself is responsible for rise in pressure. Sun, Read, Shorthouse
suggested that abnormally high pressures in anal canal in patients with haemorrhoids
may be due to increased vascular pressures in the anal cushions.[7]
PATHOLOGY
Histologically, haemorrhoids consist of dilated veins in the mucosa and
submucosa. There may be evidence of hemosiderin deposition from a previous
episode of bleeding depending on whether the haemorrhoids arise above or below the
dentate line. They may be covered by columnar, transitional or non-keratinzing
squamous epithelium. The organization and re-canalization of thrombi can lead to
florid papillary endothelial hyperplasia.[9]
Microscopic examination of tissue submitted with clinical diagnosis of
haemorrhoids, rarely may show non-specific granulomas, tuberculosis, malignant
lymphomas, koilocytotic changes, dysplasia/carcinoma in situ, invasive squamous cell
carcinoma or even malignant melanoma.
CLASSIFICATION OF HAEMORRHOIDS
CLASSIFICATION 1 CLASSIFICATION 2
CLASSIFICATION 1
INTERNAL HAEMORRHOIDS
They bulge into the lumen of anal canal and produce painless bleeding.
They are those that are permanently prolapsed and irreducible despite attempts
at manual reduction.
EXTERNAL HAEMORRHOIDS
INTERNO-EXTERNAL HAEMORRHOIDS
PRIMARY HAEMORRHOIDS
Associated with anal pressure & anal tone. High anal canal pressure are
particularly recorded in men younger than 40 yrs with Istdeegre haemorrhoids & lower
resting anal pressure associate with in women more than 40 yrs with prolapsing piles.
SECONDARY HAEMORRHOIDS
BLEEDING
PROLAPSE
Prolapse is a much later symptom, to start with protrusion is slight and occurs
only at defecation and it does not reduce spontaneously but have to be replaced
digitally. Still if prolapse occurs often during exertion and it may go on to become
permanently prolapsed.
Fig. 7: Classification of internal haemorroids
PAIN
ANAEMIA
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
CLINICAL EXAMINATION
Position:
Left lateral (sims position):This is the most popular position for anorectal
examination with patient lying on left side, buttocks projecting over the edge of the
table with hips and knees are well flexed.[11]
Inspection:
Anal tags and IVth degree haemorrhoids are usually visible. IIIrd degree
haemorrhoids become visible on making the patient strain as in passing stools.
Thrombosed and strangulated external haemorrhoids can never be missed on local
examination.
Digital
examination:
This should be done gently explaining to the patient what is being done, with clear
instructions to the patient to open his mouth and breathe in and out deeply. After
wearing gloves and applying local anaesthetic jelly, the right index finger is laid flat
on anal verge, gentle pressure is exerted till sphincter yields and finger is slowly
pushed in by rotatory movement. Uncomplicated piles are not usually felt unless
thrombosed or fibrosed or sometime may be felt as a longitudinal fold when finger is
swept around lower rectum.
Proctoscopy:
These investigations may not be possible in all cases but in cases suspicious of
sigmoid/rectal neoplasm, polyps may have to go through these investigations
mandatorily.
COMPLICATIONS OF HAEMORRHOIDS
HAEMORRHAGE
Profuse haemorrhage is not rare, most often it occurs in early stages of second
degree haemorrhoids, bleeding mainly occurs externally but it may continue internally
after haemorrhoids has retracted in which case rectum is found to contain blood.
Occasionally it can lead to severe anemia.
STRANGULATION
One or more of the internal haemorrhoids prolapse and become gripped by the
external sphincter. Further, congestion follows because the venous return is impended.
Second-degree haemorrhoids are most often complicated in this manner that is
accompanied by considerable pain. Unless the internal haemorrhoids can be reduced
within 1 or 2 hours, strangulation is followed by thrombosis.
THROMBOSIS
The affected haemorrhoid become dark purple and black and feels solid.
Considerable oedema of anal margins accompanies thrombosis.
ULCERATION
GANGRENE
SUPPURATION
INVESTIGATIONS
BLOOD EXAMINATION
URINE EXAMINATION
STOOL EXAMINATION
CHEST X-RAY
ECG
1. Defecation habits
2. Local hygiene
3. Dietary manipulations
4. Topical applications
OUTPATIENT AND MINOR PROCEDURES
1. Band ligation
2. Sclerotherapy
3. Cryosurgery
4. Infra red photocoagulation
SURGICAL PROCEDURES
1. Haemorrhoidectomy
Ultrasonic Scalpel
Diathermy
2. Submucoushaemorrhoidectomy
3. Staple haemorrhoidopexy
4. Laser haemorrhoidectomy
Neglecting the first urge to defecate, spending a prolonged time at the toilet,
straining are common defecation errors, which can be corrected.
2. LOCAL HYGIENE
Haemorrhoids particularly IIIrd and IVth degree are associated with mucous
staining and itching these symptoms require advice about anal hygiene to prevent
perianal dermatitis and to ameliorate symptoms. The use of hot sitz bath and warm
soaks also ameliorate symptomatic haemorrhoids.
3. DIETARY MANIPULATION
4. TOPICAL APPLICATIONS
Rubber band ligation is one of the most frequently applied methods for
treatment of internal haemorrhoids. The instrument for rubber band ligation was
originally described by Blaisdell in 1954 and later modified by Barron in 1963.
Principle
Rubber bands applied to the pedicle of mucosa of internal haemorrhoids causes
ischemia, necrosis and scarring preventing further bleeding or prolapse of the
respective haemorrhoids and gradually cuts off through the tissues and within a period
of seven to ten days these haemorrhoids slough off.
Procedure
Rubber band ligation is done as a minor operation theatre procedure. Soap water or
sodium biphosphate enema is given both on night before and the morning of the
procedure. Patient can be put in lithotomy or left lateral (sims position).
Patient
Ideally for a case of IInd degree haemorrhoids and some selected cases of IIIrd
degree haemorrhoids.
Technique
2. INJECTION SCLEROTHERAPY
Contraindications
a) Thrombosed piles
b) Prolapsed piles
c) In presence of
d) Proctitis
e) Fissure in ano
f) Fistula in ano
g) Pregnancy
h) Diabetes mellitus
Technique
No special preparation necessary other than a empty rectum. The proctoscope
is introduced and haemorrhoids are displayed, proctoscope is further introduced until
haemorrhoids almost disappear with only upper end visible. The injection is made at
this point above the main mass of the haemorrhoid into the submucosa or just above
the anorectal ring injecting 1 ml of sclerosant with the bevel of needle towards the
rectal wall. It is most important not to inject too deeply, particularly anteriorly,
because of the risk of entering the prostate, seminal vesical, or even in base of urinary
bladder causing hematuria, hematospermia&prostitis. Sufficient sclerosant should be
injected under the
mucosa to raise a white wheal, which eventually ulcerates and cause mucosal fixation,
thus preventing the haemorrhoids from decending into the lower anal canal. The
injection should produce elevation and pallor of the mucosa. All three piles can be
injected separately 1 ml in each site in single sitting. Technique can be repeated after 6
weeks.
FOAM SCLEROTHERAPY
Foam sclerotherapy is a technique that involves injecting foamed sclerosant
drugs within a blood vessel using a syringe. The sclerosant drugs (sodium tetradecyl
sulfate or polidocanol) are mixed with air or a physiological gas (carbon dioxide) in
a syringe or by using mechanical pumps. This increases the surface area of the drug.
The foam sclerosant drug is more efficacious than the liquid one in
causing sclerosis (thickening of the vessel wall and sealing off the blood flow), for it
does not mix with the blood in the vessel and in fact displaces it, thus avoiding
dilution of the drug and causing maximal sclerosant action. Experts in foam
sclerotherapy have created tooth paste like thick foam for their injections, which has
revolutionized the use in haemorrhoids.
2. CRYOSURGERY
SURGICAL PROCEDURES
1. HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY
Types
Open haemorrhoidectomy
Close haemorrhoidectomy
Submucoushaemorrhoidectomy
Laser haemorrhoidectomy
Indications
b) CLOSED HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY
The largest and most redundant haemorrhoid should be excised first. With this
approach the original plans to excise three quadrants may be modified so that only
two- quadrant haemorrhoidectomy is necessary.[17,18,19]
Ultrasonic Scalpel
Diathermy
Principle
The ultrasonic scalpel is an ultrasonically-activated instrument, which vibrates
at a rate of 55000 MHz per second.[19] It is known for its ability to coagulate small
and medium sized vessels by converting electrical energy to a mechanical one.A
ultrasonic scalpel cuts via vibration. The high frequency vibration of tissue molecules
generates stress and friction in tissue, which generates heat and causes protein
denaturation. This technique causes minimal energy transfer to surrounding tissue,
Procedure
All patients received enema before the surgery. Spinal anaesthesia was given.
Patients were placed in the lithotomy position for surgery. In ultrasonic scalpel
haemorrhoidectomy, haemorrhoid pedicles were excised upto apex region using
the ultrasonic scalpel without damaging the internal sphincter with the help of
vascular forceps and the wounds were left open. In all patients, adjacent areas of
perianal skin and rectal mucosa were left intact to prevent anal stricture.
Patient
Ideally for a case of IIIrddegreehaemorrhoids and some selected cases of
IVthdegreehaemorrhoids.[21]
Post-procedure advice
Post procedure pain is relieved with oral analgesia. Hot sitz bath also helps
greatly to relieve the pain. Patient is advised to take liquid and semisolids for one day
following the procedure, so that attempts at defecation are minimal. Patients are
advised oral intake of bulk forming agents for at least 6-8 weeks.
COMPLICATIONS OF ULTRASONIC SCALPEL HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY [28]
1. Pain
2. Urinary retention
3. Bleeding
DIATHERMY
Principle
Heat is produced with high frequency electric current. It uses 300 KHz to 3
MHz to activate nerve and muscles. This electic current used to stimulate coagulation
or destroy tissues at temperature higher than 1500C. [22, 23, 24]
Instruments used
1. Proctoscope
2. Allis forcep
3. Vascular forcep
4. Electrocautery device
Fig. 14: Instruments used in Ultrasonic Scalpel
Haemorrhoidectomy
Fig. 15: Ultrasonic Scalpel Haemorrhoidectomy (Intra-op)
c) SUBMUCOUS HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY[29]
d) LASER HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY
Laser has been used with some success in patients for treatment of polyps and
rectal carcinoma. Laser has also been used for performing haemorrhoidectomy. Yu
and Eddy reported excellent success with Nd:Yag laser haemorrhoidectomy
performed in
134 patients, the procedure was done on outpatient basis. Iwagaki et al reported on
1816 patients who underwent CO2 laser haemorrhoidectomy with excellent results.
Laser surgery is said to be less painful.[31,32]
The initial enthusiasm due to the mystique of laser and myth of its painless
nature dampened slowly.The evaporation of haemorrhoids, the excision of external
haemorrhoids and other forms of superficial therapy have confused patients regarding
the effectiveness and most importantly the painless nature of this form of therapy.
Senogore et al showed in a prospective study that surgical haemorrhoidectomy done
with Nd:Yag laser offered no patient care advantage over the traditional Ferguson
closed haemorrhoidectomy. As refinement in technology occur, laser
haemorrhoidectomy may become more common.
2. STAPLED HAEMORRHOIDOPEXY
Most recently a modified circular stapler approach has been advocated for
surgical management of haemorrhoids. The so called procedure for prolapsed
haemorrhoids (pph) was described initially by Longo in 1998.[33,34,36]
Principle
Is based on the concept of interruption of the superior and middle
haemorrhoidal vessel and upward lifting of the prolapsed anorectal mucosa and
repositioning of the vascular cushions back into the anal canal which causes the
haemorrhoidal tissue to atrophy.
Indications
Mainly advocated for IIIrd and IVth degree internal haemorrhoids. Conversely
external haemorrhoids are not appropriately treated but the tags and external
component can be concomitantly excised if indicated.
Technique
A modified 33 mm circular stapler is used to perform the stapled
haemorrhoidopexy. This operation is facilitated by the use of the pph procedural set
consisting of a circular stapler (hcs 33), a suture threader (st 100) a circular anal
dilator (cad 33), and a purse string suture anoscope (psa 33). The technique of pph
involves placement of a purse string suture using non-absorbable monofilament
material approximately 2-4 cm cephalad to the dentate line. The suture is placed into
the mucosa and sub mucosa of the lower rectum avoiding the muscular layer and
vagina. Care must be taken to place the purse string sufficiently high so that when
fired it does not incorporate the anal mucosa and underlying internal sphincter. If this
were to occur, severe pain might ensure, in addition to the risk of stricture and
mucosal ectropion, these complications are avoided if purse string is placed atleast 2
cm above the dentate
line.
The single greatest advantage of stapled haemorrhoidopexy is reduction in
postoperative pain. The pain after pph is described as vague and dull and analogous to
Fig. 17: Stapled Haemorrhoidopexy
39
tenesmus. Michigan and coworkers prospectively randomized 40 patients to undergo
pphhaemorrhoidopexy versus Milligan Morgan haemorrhoidectomy. The average
postoperative pain score from day zero to day ten significantly lower in pph and also
patients had shorter hospital stay and a faster return to full activity. Postoperative
complication rates have been similar with that of conventional haemorrhoidectomy.
One downslide is the cost of the equipment. But undoubtedly this new technique is a
exciting development in the search of a relatively painless procedure to treat
haemorrhoidal disease.
COMPLICATIONS OF HAEMORRHOIDECTOMY
May be early or late:
EARLY COMPLICATIONS:
Pain
Retention of urine
Reactionary hemorrhage
Secondary hemorrhage
LATE COMPLICATIONS:
Anal stricture
Anal incontinence
Anal fissure
Abscess or fistula
The haemorrhoid is dissected and excised with 1.25 cm of adjacent skin. The
pear shaped wound is left to granulate, the relief of pain is immediate and permanent
in cases of strangulation and thrombosis. It was earlier believed that surgery would
promote pylephlebitis. If adequate antibiotic cover is given, pylephlebitis does not
occur and immediate surgery is justified. Besides adequate pain relief, bed rest with
frequent hot baths and warm saline compress, usually causes pile masses to shrink
considerably in 3-4 days, and then standard ligation and excision can be carried out.
Some surgeons consider operation at this stage increases the risk of postoperative
40
stenosis and delay surgery for a month or so. Inspite of low risk of pylephlebitis
caution should dictate a non-interventional policy whenever practical.
2. SEVERE HAEMORRHAGE
SPECIAL SITUATIONS
HAEMORRHOIDS IN PREGNANCY
INCLUSION CRITERIA
Patients with complaints of bleeding per rectum, mass per rectum, pain,
irritation, discharge per rectum
Patients with 3rd& 4th degree haemorrhoids
Both male and female
Patients fit for surgery
EXCLUSION CRITERIA
Patients with 1st and 2nd degree haemorrhoids
Immunocompromised patients
Patients with bleeding disorders
Patients with deranged liver function tests
Pregnant & pediatric patient
Inflammatory bowel disease
SUBJECTS
A total of 50 cases included after admission they underwent thorough
investigation and preoperative investigation for assessment of fitness for anaesthesia.
Pateints who were fit, were explained about the procedure and were operated after
taking written informed consent.
PREPARATION
Proctoclysis enema was given to evacuate the rectum on the night before and
the morning of the planned day of procedure.
POSITION
Patient was put in lithotomy position while the procedure was performed.
PROCEDURE
Anaesthetically fit patients were taken on the operating table with an injectable
antibiotic ceftriaxone sodium 1gm given preoperatively at the time of induction of
anaesthesiaand patients were operated randomly by Ultrasonic scalpel
haemorrhoidectomy and diathermy haemorrhoidectomy.
POST-OPERATIVE CARE
Started clear liquids orally after 4-6 hours.
Analgesics were given in form of intramuscular diclofenac sodium for 24 hours.
After 24 hours oral administration of diclofenac tablet according to
requirement were given.
Patients were educated and encouraged to get ambulatory and were
encouraged to pass urine as early as possible.
Patients were examined at 6 & 24 hours post-operatively for pain assessment
and complications.
Antibiotics were continued for 7 to 10 days in all cases, longer in those
developing wound complications.
Patients were advised to take high fibre diet and plenty of fluids orally and hot
sitz bath.
Patients were encouraged to start normal activities as early as possible.
SCORE PAIN
0-1 No pain
10 Unbearable pain.
0 - No pain.
Feeling perfectly normal.
1 - Very Mild
Very light barely noticeable pain, like a mosquito bite or a poison ivy itch.
Most of the time you never think about the pain.
2 Discomforting
Minor pain, like lightly pinching the fold of skin between the thumb and first
finger with the other hand, using the fingernails. Note that people react differently to
this self test.
3 Tolerable
Very noticeable pain, like an accidental cut, a blow to the nose causing a
bloody nose, or a doctor giving you an injection. The pain is not so strong that you
cannot get used to it. Eventually, most of the time you don't notice the pain. You have
adaptedto it.
4 - Distressing
Strong, deep pain, like an average toothache, the initial pain from a bee sting,
or minor trauma to part of the body, such as stubbing your toe real hard. So strong you
notice the pain all the time and cannot completely adapt. This pain level can be
simulated by pinching the fold of skin between the thumb and first finger with the
other hand, using the finger nails and squeezing real hard. Note how the simulated
pain is initially piercing but becomes dull after that.
5 - Very Distressing
Strong, deep, piercing pain, such as a sprained ankle when you stand on it
wrong or mild back pain. Not only do you notice the pain all the time, you are now so
preoccupied with managing it that you normal lifestyle is curtailed. Temporary
personality disorders are frequent.
6 - Intense
Strong, deep, piercing pain so strong it seems to partially dominate your
senses, causing you to think somewhat unclearly. At this point you begin to have
trouble holding a job or maintaining normal social relationships. Comparable to a bad
non- migraine headache combined with several bees tings or a bad back pain.
7 Very Intense
Same as 6 except the pain completely dominates your senses, causing you to
think unclearly about half the time. At this point you are effectively disabled and
frequently cannot live alone. Comparable to an average migraine headache.
8 Utterly Horrible
46
Pain so intense you can no longer think clearly at all, and have often
undergone severe personality change if the painhas been present for a long time.
Suicide is
47
frequently contemplated and sometimes tried. Comparable to child birth or a real bad
migraine headache.
9 Excruciating Unbearable
Pain so intense you cannot tolerate it and demand pain killers or surgery, no
matter what the side effects or risk. If this doesn't work, suicide is frequent since there
is no more joy in life whatsoever. Comparable to throat cancer.
10 Unimaginable Unspeakable
Pain so intense you will go unconscious shortly. Most people have never
experienced this level of pain. Those who have suffered a severe accident, such as a
crushed hand, and lost consciousness as a result of the pain and not blood loss, have
experienced level 10.
Mild (1-3)
Does not interfere with most activities. Able to adapt to pain psychologically
and with medication or devices such as cushions.
Moderate (4-6)
Interferes with many activities. Requires lifestyle changes but patient remains
independent. Unable to adapt to pain.
Severe (7-10)
POST-PROCEDURE ADVICE
Post-procedure pain was relieved by oral analgesia if necessary. Hot sitz bath
was also advised postoperatively in all patients. Post-op pain evaluation was done
using visual analogue scale (VAS) ranging from 0 to 10. Score 4 considererd as
cut off value for post-op analgesia requirement. Patient was advised to take liquids
and semisolids for one day following the procedure so that attempts at defecation are
minimal. Oral intake of bulk forming agents was advised to all patients. All patients
were evaluated for post procedure pain, discomfort, bleeding, urinary retention, sepsis,
need for analgesia and days off work.
FOLLOW UP ADVICE
Patient was followed up on 7th day, one and third months for symptoms as
pain, bleeding, prolapse, irritation, mucous discharge. Patients were advised to take
oral analgesia if needed. Patients were also advised to take high fibre diet to avoid
straining on defecation. The patient was monitored for post procedure pain,
discomfort, bleeding, irritation, urinary retention, sepsis, recurrence and were
enquired whether pre- procedure symptoms had mostly resolved or residual symptoms
were present. Patients were requested to assess the form of treatment as excellent,
moderately successful or of little help based on their results post-procedure.
.
RESULT AND
ANALYSIS
TABLE 1: DISTRIBUTION OF CASES IN DIFFEREN AGE GROUPS
ULTRASONIC DIATHERMY
AGE IN YEARS SCALPEL TOTAL
No Of % No Of %
Cases Cases
11 -20 00 00 00 00 00
21-30 03 12 01 04 04
31-40 06 24 04 16 10
41-50 09 36 06 24 15
51-60 04 16 08 32 12
61-70 03 12 06 24 09
TOTAL 25 100 25 100 50
120
100
80
ULTRASONIC SCALPEL
60
ULTRASONIC SCALPEL
40
DIATHERMY
20
DIATHER
MY
DIATHER
MY
0
The maximum age recorded is 70 years. In both males and females USHG were more
common in the age group 41-50 years while in DHG between 50-60 years.
TABLE 2:DISTRIBUTION OF CASES IN BOTH SEXES
ULTRASONIC SCALPEL DIATHERMY
SEX TOTAL
No Of Cases % No Of Cases %
MALE 20 80 21 84 41
FEMALE 05 20 04 16 09
TOTAL 25 100 25 100 50
MALE
FEMALE
TOTAL
In this study out of 50 patients, 41 were male & 9 were female. The male- female ratio
is 4.5:1 respectively. Male were more affected of haemorrhoid in our study.
TABLE 3:DISTRIBUTION ON BASIS OF OPERATIVE TIME
ULTRASONIC DIATHERMY
OPERATIVE SCALPEL TOTAL
TIME IN No Of % No Of %
MINUTES Cases Cases
30 mins 12 48 5 20 17
31 60 mins 13 52 20 80 33
TOTAL 25 100 25 100 50
OPERATIVE
TIME IN
MINUTES
30 mins
31 60 mins
TOTAL
Average time for ultrasonic scalpel haemorrhoidectomy is 20-35 mins and diathermy
haemorrhoidectomy process is 30-45 mins.
TABLE 4:POST-OPERATIVE REQUIERMENT OF ANALGESIA
ULTRASONIC DIATHERMY
POST- SCALPEL
OPERATIVE No Of % No Of % TOTAL
ANALGESIA Cases Cases
REQUIREMENT
1st DAY 20 80 22 88 44
3rd DAY 04 16 15 60 19
7th DAY 00 00 5 20 05
24 HRS
48 HRS
72
HRS
TOTA
L
PAIN
1st Day
3rd Day
7th Day
1st Day
7th Day
1 Month
URINARY RETENTION
1st Day
3rd Day
7th Day
1st week
2nd week
3rd week
TOTAL
ULTRASONIC SCALPEL
DIATHERMY
The above data are average value of VAS score of patients in each group. Post-
operative complication pain according to VAS is little high in diathermy
haemorrhoidectomy as compare to ultrasonic scalpel haemorrhoidectomy.
DISCUSSIO
N
Haemorrhoidectomy is the most effective and definitive treatment for IIIrd and
IVthdegree haemorrhoids. Pain after haemorrhoidectomy continues to be a major
problem. The ultrasonically activated scalpel divides tissue using high-frequency
ultrasonic energy. Because the instrument operates at temperature less than
100C, less lateral thermal damage, it is associated with less undesirable tissue
desiccation, char formation and zone of thermal injury compared with
diathermy. The early and delayed complication rates of either surgery were
comparable to conventional haemorrhoidectomy, and no serious complications were
noted. As stated in previous studies, postoperative pain is felt at the highest level on
the 1st day and decreases later.[35,38] In our study, postoperative pain scores were
highest in day 1 in both groups. In comparison with Diathermy method, Ultrasonic
Scalpel haemorrhoidectomy had a shorter operating time and had less blood loss. The
VAS pain scores at day 1, 3 and 7 were less in USHG than DHG. Intra operative
bleeding is more in Diathermy group in comparison to Ultrasonic Scalpel group, so
the operative time is more in Diathermy group.[39,40]
A decreased lateral thermal injury (at the surgical site) is translated into
decreased postoperative pain. The main disadvantage of surgical
haemorrhoidectomy is the postoperative pain resulting from the surgical raw area in
the sensitive perianal skin. Much of this discomfort arises from the thermal injury
induced by the Diathermy. In different procedures it was found that ultrasonic
scalpel offers many benefits, including less pain, shorter hospital stay, reduced
analgesic requirement, less damage to tissues, quicker recovery and reduced
scarring. We found that duration of surgery was significantly shorter in the
Ultrasonic scalpel group
AGE DISTRIBUTION:
Studies No Range
Present Study 50 20-70
H Bulus et al 151 25-71
Comparing with other studies, the number of cases were higher in other groups
as in H Bulus et al study (151 cases), whereas the upper age limit was 70 yr and lower
limit was 25 yr.
SEX DISTRIBUTION:
In present study male : female is 4.5:1, which is comparable with H Bulus et al
who showed a 1.1:1 male : female ratio respectively.
Studies Male Female
Present Study 82 % 18%
H Bulus et al 58% 42%
ANAESTHESIA:
All 50 cases underwent ultrasonic scalpel haemorrhoidectomy and diathermy
haemorrhoidectomy under spinal anaesthesia. In H Bulus et al patient operated under
intravenous sedation and caudal block.
OPERATIVE TIME:
In our present study average time for ultrasonic scalpel haemorrhoidectomy is
20 to 35 mins and diathermy haemorrhoidectomy it is 30 to 45 minutes. In H Bulus et
al 18 min was operative time for ultrasonic scalpel and 25 min was for diathermy
haemorrhoidectomy.
ANALGESIA:
In our present comparative study
B. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
88% cases required analgesia for day 1
60% cases required analgesia for day 3
36% cases required analgesia for day 7
Compare with past study with H Bulus et alrequire 44% cases post-operative analgesia
for 1 day & 32 % cases require for 3 day & 18% cases require for 7 day.
POST-OPERATIVE STAY:
In our present comparative study
Compare with past study with Bursch et al require 66 % cases post-operative stay for
24 hours & 54 % cases require for 48 hours & 18 % cases require for 72 hours.
A. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
48 % patient required hospitalisation till 48 hrs
52 % patient required hospitalisation till 72 hrs
Compare with past study with Schrey require 46 % cases post-operative stay for 24
hours & 44 % cases require for 48 hours & 18 % cases require for 72 hours.
Post-operative stay Present Study Schrey
DIATHERMY
24 HRS 00% 46%
48 HRS 48% 44%
72 HRS 52% 18%
In H Buluset al study 90 % cases having post-operative pain for 1 day, 06% cases
having pain for 7 days.
B. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
100% patient having pain on 1stpost-operative day
20% patient having pain till 7thpost-operative day
In H Bulus et alstudy 88 % cases having post-op pain for 1 day, 06 % cases having
pain for 7 days.
BLEEDING P/R:
In our present comparative study
A. In ultrasonic scalpel haemorrhoidectomy
4 % patient having c/o bleeding per rectal on 1stpost-operative day
B. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
12 % patient having c/o bleeding per rectal on 1stpost-operative day
URINARY RETNTION:
In our present comparative study
2. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
RESUMPTION TO WORK:
In our present comparative study
B. In diathermy haemorrhoidectomy
40 % patient started routine work within 2nd week
60 % patient started routine work within 3rd week
The present study was done to compare the effectiveness of ultrasonic scalpel
& diathermy haemorrhoidectomy in the treatment of IIIrd&IVth degree haemorrhoids.
Name: Age
Address: Sex: