The New Mistoricism Edited by H.ARAM VEESER NewYork Londonti in 1989 by owe ‘vat of Roa, Chpan nd Hal Biers seer New Yor NY 1001 Paid in Gi Bia by Reeser ape Linon ECAP AEE ony © 1999 by Roe, Chapa nd Hallo ine Ui! See of Ameen iepeesipa emanate ana kms ee ed macy ay elon ee sea opto nwa 3 aes ike of Cons Calogagifubinton Dts “oe New Hr feed by] Hod Veet ash 041590057 SBN 0415900700 [ph Horm, 1 Vet, Hie 50> maa wae Bish ry Calping in aeicn Data The New bine 1, Ler ck Inpesions clin oso Ian 045300097 ISaNoaiss00700 MX Contents Acknowledgments vi Inedarson by HL Aram Vinee 4 2 Towards Pos of Coane ‘Seper Grenblt 1 ‘rofeing the Resnnce The Posts snd Flic of Clare ‘Lovie A. Monte as Marsa and he New Hiri “Cather Galgher ” “The History ofthe Ando Fiction and Paton Joe Foner ° Englih Romantics nd Cla reduction Jon Klencher ” “he Use and Mise of Giambia Vio: Rherore, Ora, nd Toor of Dicoise John D. Schaef 8 “The Sen of he ats Ings, Tent, and Obj be Fosnaton of Hiorl Catacouzes ie Nowe Cenary Bin ‘Stephen Bane 1a ‘Te Stage forthe Carl Hest: Chrisina Stead Relucons Chal Dickens and Mak Twin, othe ae ne Tee Ameo Anas Won, Wa, ant Mado “ane areas ma10, History as Us Feminism and the "New Hioris” Sith Lower Newton 11, Coopttion ‘Gerald Graff 12, The New Hors and other Lachioned Tonics ‘Boot Thome 13, The Nationa Imagined Commanity Jian Prono 14, Literary Con and he Plt of he New Hiri ‘leabethFox-Gerovse 15, tere Clot inhi Cas? tan Teoma 16, Foucals Lega: A New Hotorism? “rank Lennie 17, The Limi of Local Krowdge Vince P Pecos 18, The New Hiram: Plc Cmmiament the Poemosern Cie ‘Gay Chater Speak 19. New Hiram: A Comment eae Whe Commentary: The Young and the Restless ‘Stanley Fish Notes on Constant a2 am 23 ns ai as Eo as 203 a71 Towards a Poetics of Culture Stephen Greenblatt Heal seme ae poston, which nt patilayproming voy bei, aT might wel expan why My own week as always Teen done with ese of jst hang Yo go abou and Go, without csuablshing fest eae what my theorecal postion iA fen year ago ‘wa ased by Gee toda seein of Renssabe esos, and sd OK Teoleced bch of ess andthe, oof ind of desperation wo et ‘Selon ong, wt athe eas repeated something ele ne histori.” Ve eer Bes ery ood at ming up aaneing hrs of hs kind: for eons ht wold be ute meen xpong ‘Erte pointe sume ack mach noe han ter ames Fey erly ‘ad vent oe the jean fac ave trina pero sO {ge for of tal boot he new hitorcs” hie or ore eton ‘Ausalais ald Neohisoecis thre ae ais about stacks on, ‘eferences ita diserains the whole ing makes regi iy With ‘maenent In any ene pat of thi prsiar phenomenon {have be sled 1 say someting ofa theoreti knd aber the work Im ing So Taba ey If oto dee ee Bsr tao sates Driers prise the than» Sooner at ea el and oal be he ae fo knew) so decree al ‘One af he pecsar cacti ofthe "ew histo” io Uaey srs precsely bow used and in wore ways ésicgenuos i bas [rent ive been-abou te reston to leary thor. On he oe and ‘tacoma to me thats openens to he theresa fret of eat ew years is pecsly what desgushes he ew historic fom the onie Fistor colarhp of se ely emits eay. Ceri he pretence (tN! Foust 09h Berle campo for etended rn dig the lve sea yar ore and ore pnealy she mura Armes ‘ol Earopan and epecly en andropeeie and acl ct Sas hey to shape my ov Inve teal pace, On the the: hand Fisontar ees bave ne wile Ben ulin eae eras ‘neo the ther of he deniran theoreti! emp. T want speculate on wby ths hold Be ying sure mys in2 Sper Geeber sation to Maram onthe ne hand, pd porstscalom on he thet [theo ned o tech cous with names ine" Aes ‘nthe Behe som This cate to a glorious end when wae Gn Sich courte mat hae ben the ma 197D—ad remember ase ting very srry with me. Now ue at ede ole those Marit fue who mar trated lio o Mesa Welo Besoin ee ‘fey athe than the ler Lik, ad 0 forth—and | rember somone Sealy gor up and screamed orn ca "Youle ethers Bacher or 2 “Menthe op your faking min” snd tes slammed te doo. t travail autng bor though aos aerwade ad eine hal Ses sue whether wat « Menshenl bu eanly was a Bob ‘Mer that advo ach our wines Hike “Curaral Pes" + tre tht In il more aneny wks plans rary pespecive hat ‘antouche by Masse agin, byt that doen't ea me to eborst Propostons or erase parle psopy, pols Hear, fie ei, “Thos the cra denniing gers made bythe most dinpished Anescan Mans arsbene theorist, Fete Jameson, ser me ih. Problems Levu tke, for example, he lowing fogiet psig rom Te Poa! Unconcons siege vine a poaiiargeceensterntceee reeimcomiesecet ecco iret deere eentepeea ene el cecessatepen ene cede eR ote renames net at Ss een Spmuuitiee sierra! working dinesion between curl ext shat asia! and pli and hoe tt ae nota a ast domain that iin oe rth ff fom the scr insttons that ae operative elsewhere in fultre—becomes for arson a ralgnmtsrapiom of “privatization” ‘Way sould “pie” medal nero he isnt tl? Does the kel so pte propery an othe owrethp a the eae at Production a the regalo of the mde of onsompao? Is hats ‘Rehisogsl relation erween ths moe of econo rganzton sed 2 terkingdinesonberween the plical adhe pet? would ea hat In ping etalon inthe sone med, eat nner ose nt “piatzaton” bit tothe dnc sonmanaliesion of all discus, tbe ontation of 25 eve larger mast audience, te organiaton ofa ome ‘Sleperesspinedand cell rae by ecompardiney mest Towsrisa Pos of Canoe 3 amps in precopialnsodesr opine pb zou Morton, ‘Fine pute havea commana spre af tht Sine from tet rmmusl spheres ft conmunal erenaon second by hele ef propery, north ominae pace apa soo, maniferyinthe fim and lesion industries bat alo, sce the invention of movable pe, ‘nthe produon of poems od nove well Would we really An ss seating tobe no etinton al betwen the pola andthe poetic ‘heaton, le vey daa Cain's Cal Revolution? for tha ‘mae, do we Bnd ata bersting have new cunay Bovered pat ara who ln ehecunnipy a patholo indent the ttadiionldfrenation beeen atny ond rely? Tor The Pola Uncomour any demarcation f the sree mat be signe wh be pate whe um ged wih he pycholge he po, tnd te fehl dtr fro the pu, hess snd the Pola Al of tee ineodkig dicts, none af wich sms vo me losophielly or even hist bond up with the rig working sinc," atthe date dos of aps wikis powerto “main” ‘snd "paras asd ajc” Though we a ada dilferens- Sow beween coal actu tate wee tad clara deco {hat areocal or poli wel blot the Enopen seven centr, ad Incaluresta sem far remove from he epi mae of prodocon, Jsmeson isis at sorthow the perpetrator and agent ofthe alleged ‘maiming eapialm.Asalowy opposition sasared ween the “nl ‘dual” (ad ad the ind sje” (god) adel the massing of theater eae the fomer, “The whole passage ae the retonaneof an allegory ofthe fl of mans ooze ere ole ape, epee wee nda ube Ba oot ‘nasal we bad no pcb doie rom hare othe oie oles and pony war one Then capa aree and kteed har Hous, benign taal. The ms chow thoaphos Jao’ ook, ough byte cose ias been escurloglly revised so tht thew es oti a past reveaed we hive vay aeady fallen ba nthe elses ‘ure. A phlvopical cin then appeals oan absent erpiial even. ‘And neratre is ovoked at once the dark token of fallenns nd the Simmer enblen of be bent iasgraton Tr of cous postures sed eit quions boot ach vision, hallegiog bh mandy oppostion: andthe primal orn ‘iy that posts ss ther una eiaor opin, exhale? “This challenge as already pety media houph by no means spy places Mane cour, I cult exemplify this complex interaction between Man and possrucuralm by ascsig Jameson's owe most recor work in whch a il rom the pepe of portodere ‘i, cplrng he ou of ee "wesking dtinon ht teat enabled4 Spier Grama ‘helo ions enenie an nlite a ei program Bato ara nfo man fo for inal on he work of Jee frangois Lyotard Hea fa The Plc! Unonsiony, the Sitineson beeen SScuie fell once agains ate: for Lyotard xine of proper mes makes posible hecoenineof te wort Kn ed erie nd omie— ‘hse won which of oue pct he sme obec, at nih aoe ‘heb he tof hopes er commen exes ‘Sines apes one a when cn be frm a eer Lyoras mode for tht dered Scour i te exec of propernames Barrow tte leo capal or dear carve ‘Grin buy gut oppose oma rach danas tenable "Capa iS won a ge ego enews a ee Stops tying wren tu 58) yor peopl eb of ae ‘Senge yep one ingle anger aie wos ell ‘onlogte=ts Fane's den he ocean bind dea eRe oem aon hee mo fn an oer ‘Sry an om te mop ure wos of mane = “i bln wih i Scone nn eRe ci te pray incest n eneminating name slong, wth the pesos who posed hoe name: on conta they kena a was compa wh {Spi of mas mdr ena al cr anh ok forward toa ime in whic hey cold sae ter accompahnen wih al ror by erably’ em dedeed wo he are of he wet eophl donoyed The festa firs onan noran epee “inns Lyd omy bt aengt oh say rene ou subsanialandyerfatle The buena an Epcrean pedo" ents erm yore or tbr yo here det 0" re eee STipimposl for you 0 prove tat dent thee” hol Probl what nthe nencof mas mer? How relatives? Tre tie convinang grounds fr denying or doubting the dosed ‘nt ofthe oreo th round bow may weiner he nets STB ha so cat ont pon he ron or “Thr fees pate yard fhe urine th an Insane of cpa hry w ame coi of Fav opto sl apis won scone Beinn inrmne of monolgarSe t Spy te spc of ep that reeled oe portion ‘euimeron finda dei odo he demarason of boundaries Sepang thw ide, We may ape, of coun ht te cialis Insite pon aii trade, Bt iif, ik keep Tow Foote of abet § fermen i nei nnn Sori ree etree Med ects geo tnt seme enema tice aches Scones mina one t Leeann are inimsniininarmcedgernaetial Juste Srprewentlnncal eh eye Peon eaters Eppereite rh eacre nant Seviga eases kawrer Sot Oats SG oe ent cn I opt epee anton nin Sige te poe area Sienna TEAR Se eee Soslic ilcy oneea a Kees St mee pl fen ters Spar tenet arate agate ee Seow cnn ha ce Se iia an i aaa a See mencenaieteesntyetomn nae soerbren gi dbempn toy tron toc neliicmoeterteellene eno spats repeat naira as 6 a malign philosophical principle” iret pe pty er nn ARCURS ete oer re Sab chcea eran eee Sreetieecay ae foy oe oe ies pos Orda Ses axe plete tep nec iwenoesiy Sotiapeh nein logracuoel ioe ie ae Soe Dae Teron aeons fiery Rede Se vpn deta a eee cee ee re gent eye ae =e emote yee cui kpc pte Bona od ine eigenen a cee ‘Sink nic ctr dice pe re igieceeeaiteyeetie a taee oe een Tecaauaam6 sSpher Gran 1 capital ie invoked not ats unary demonic pencil, bat a 2 copie ail novenest ba word without pra opine ca expects ten an nq no he elon twee sta ose) ‘aplealuc nut edee ot the lormation othe wekigdisinion ton whi aneson eek andthe totaling mpateapon whieh Lyotard ‘etna For expat hs charscerly gained weir eis i tric ll dcouss sem coordinated nor rpmes in which they wet Thus ised or dcontnuoay bu rpm wc the dave oats ‘triton aa tbe ve towards monlogil oration operat se lanes or tea ona 0 oily wernt he penn of multe Tn popes evel ann amen eed pone from 2 Whe Hae spc, mow recent generated a epmene on 8S "Say Mint th plsl sont anahieree Micha Rog ‘Reet ebured the mer of tne Present Reaan hs, at rie ‘momen ni cre, ted ins rms own roe poplars. The Present man, Rola reat, "whose mos spontaneous momest— {hee do we fd wach ren?” abo the Ameian D-Dey dea amt baying this mlrophone Me. Green dating th 1980 New Hompehire ‘rim debe} ately peed ond projcteon yb ars ‘utr be es fom ad movie" To remattale eet, Rosld Renan, ‘tho ade ha al Holywood lm, The Kills 1964 omnes ive ‘win tbe mies he as been shaped by them, ows mach of i cold war ‘Theor from ten, ah canox or wl nt dings beawen them ad an ‘reli, Inded pli career Bas pened pom analy 2 ‘roe mel ant mate ance nc rnin wc ere 3 0 Eftncun beweentmalaton apd ray : “To respon frm Anthony Bolan, 2 Whi Howe specter who swat ask commen oo Ripper, wos highly eeang. "What bes Isl yng.” Dolan mpgs," tht al of ware deeply fered by UnigielyAmeian at for te move.” Rogan et argue at the pein charac "ax prod from the convergence of vo ts tof sabitaon which poerated Colé War countersbvesion nthe 1940 ‘nd under ts1980s evial—she politcal placement of Nation by Com ‘nom wish apa ey tate Bo he {Sishitifom anembosed ifn siclcram nf.” Bod he pote Sind the poyoolgal abutaton wee numa Bound pi Ronald ‘Ragu carer inthe movin Doan in espose ee Rogan’ thsi seaebration ofthe pomer of “a niga American at for” sage“ fae” Movies, Dols ld he New York Times reporter, "heighten realy tater ha eee Sich stator pec to welche colle ofthe woking dine tion berween hese ad the real tease nob 3 Tawar Pats of Cue 7 el but myofibers we alii Bat the the Drokcsman we onto ar tht the Preset “ony ces Bis ‘Thon ne” Thar nse moment sf spoon a ret ‘eksomledges tbe i boronng rom thease a ne sco ge th enn of worg dation, nso deng be expects andere ‘ath sno ch dees beween own prc! Gcue td ‘Keon whieh he hina oe twp yar cs Sonics hisown nner fom scr olan pr pnd sad ey arte si of he ie bd economic tem tab eprtetFor {hetaptaln sete demand anon lelgment-hene thease maths ‘of propery rig tht ar fed on the seen or sre in extend ‘Re poll ar a hates Tht ito scold Ihen the Present Sve seths writen by Anbony Doon oF Oe Scot appr conn anon thi harioog beth acer oprtng roca of Amsco ota Bat woud cone pope ite Pe er eed specs that wee lied witoo ekowiedgnent om od ‘moi, He woud then sem ot kaw the deer Been any nd ey, Nod that igh br aleming "The Whi Hoot, of coe ear or fponding theoreti problem, ‘othe mplnton har show te rr a to yc he was quoting or aeraivey hate dear rand hove reps ‘Sefacn oir emake smote pores inpronon nso reson he 2 ind of sepa he eta lagi. To vail hoe mp the Wie Hoos poesman need tle to ve diferent be ba him snort blr endrmie “Th mokenmas rear wre hasty apd a hos but ed nthe select to rprdic te cone net of dicen abet ‘Teron rors arne Tet ese power pie eu Sy now vioaly ouphen i aera seen lec ont ‘pate the Buna atom th oben of hve buna an ‘Hore sich ms that expldin the work of Jameson or Lyotard. Bu the tft of uch an fo 0 rene el rm the ery pheno had ‘proposed t aay, nancy the relation between anand sarang, Scores incapitalclare For he elie ivcation of vo appar trp conraiaty scan fot hte of mean pans ieee ray nn oe fle Seen ctv te eel n ble od ope ‘Wecoud ari, folowng neo, hat th eablahent ote dine sion the piel ec wit iw towards aang om ov lagna y slag lassi apt, spel rea. Or me ‘Sal oe, flowing Lytacha he soa le dan ‘rmspa lc, hs Yomi tc ead recs By1 Spin Grab cabling single, mooliheidecopea sacar Bo if we raked to othe elation betwen captain and exec production. Fo fom tbe rien conan, when te elec for at of alaetock company ogee on rene the preplanned power (omaine snd the collape of those dass ito one antbet I this ces cuclltion rae than he earn of pts xed postion eat costes the dint power of cpsasm, The individ) eementi—a age of dscoinuoes dace on ean hate moll ule fon ofa dncoumes an the hry be Foard uly aed nother [conan snd scl se oly eal bas mnaged to geet a (Szaing, engl nese cesabon bowen he ‘My ne ofthe tem relation bere influenced bythe wrk of Jasqos [bend bursenstiiy othe racial steps of eptatonsdexange pend lee opon ostaerrltheory than upton ayes tern plc Ande acl Po oat is 2% poli se Sore wane rrtore of roducion and eonrampdon-te senate [rgnandon of rina le and conscounese—thtpowates be pars luda making and brestng, he scan erweendemaraed ob ta eres we eo tobe aon oa tverhing depen upon the iq lest that ste word—of Roald Reap, that be alone bas managed ro generate the enormonsy efecive ‘hurling herween mane, uivesalzng fantasies and cele that ‘arate is diiron. Tht aso les in tr to wha eb {lros Rowe ha cle the hamsaiaeazaon of per, tition ‘Satine loa poi expsion nh belt that the fas {rent Arca iti are the podsct oe ma and wl ps wth bin. On the conzary, Ronald Regus s manifest he prod larger nd more drab Areas srctre—oot oa are of pow ie logeal exer and ary, bat ol plea, recreton na rest ¢ "Sra tha shapes te spares we conto for ores the Way We reat "the neh fanaa we daly consume on elvis or in the ‘vis th entetimet h we cneceiealiy make and ae Tam uggening then athe cclon Seweet ttn and if ‘ncvuniarny dhe sera of same anaryth tproiertion ‘tdi entesin short bere Loire xp od Jameson A buns te pono everyday bebviorn Arena Let come, for example note Presiden's Holywood exer bua far moze incent Cabos pasting, a wip wo Yosemite National Park, One of she most ppl wale at Youre he Nevada Falls Tal So popular, indeed is "ht wal that hea Serie shad pave th ft mie of he wal Toa Pos of Cuore 9 xe woke them om bing int ech bythe henry wf. A ‘in po esp stops ad you encounter sign hat el You Bat ‘you ar ening the ides. You ve posed then fromthe National ress the sound te proves that see pial 25 atest edness get cmp sagen bt omiquous—to the park el marked by he payment of ison wo te ‘unformed tanger atthe enene kos, and finally oid and pve tone of pba) emscsted Netre. Th 2a, eed the Wider ‘nie by he bre eto of he pb nd bya an hate ‘es fhe that ou mae sow cbc: ho gyn itera, ey, oeamping witboats permit nda for The were ben ale by ‘nsmwnaifesion the rl onienieston hat eeveratheconeion of ‘a ecpe fom te spi "Yoacon contin on hs ithe nl you each step citfonto which the pacns ofthe widereshaethoughly bed a eee ews. ‘The away kad to 2 bie hat sans ring ove, om he ‘dd fh be you retarded with aspen view of Nevada Fall. ‘So therling tnt ke you oe fang your death ae you enor Your ‘tin fhe lds, teres igs emtion about the diners ‘tbe fll warnings Spine seerping Yo cn the teachers, se Sckened rocks, wal markers for those who ish to wal frther—and an ‘node lumina plague ae which are inscbed spinal, apsely ‘Wordsvorhian sentiments b the California envionment John Mu ‘The passage as best I ean eases you tht in yeas mc ou wil trance oeimageyouhave ote you Ard net hes Word al eed Ino he aluminum, pecaly a nage: potoppa of Nevada Fs ‘hen rom he very po on ich you sa “The lest of thi omar—beyond the peste ofthe mostain it snd th wate pd the prt Boller andthe dep foes of Lederle Sr Jey pears rome unusual ead pings of the proses of ‘relation that shapes he wile experineof th park. The wires is atone secured ae biter bythe ofl gestae that elk its ound; the ara erover gant he ria rough means that ‘ender soch an opposition mingle. The ef pases fom the "araral” eae cde noet we eslaneion fg ome lie (Gierasch paral Wy set spy stank plea even a hr eens ec re sy 20 Ines complee—on be nara, parks ike Yee are eo the Ways In whih te acon beeen mature tl aac coasted uF sociry—andyerthe Park Series plague onthe Nevada Falls bridge cove ley calls atencon to the interpenetration of atte and ance hat ‘nat the diincion possi10 Sep Great Whats ming from his exemplary fable of capital asthe i the soptey orem ens te he Nin Fa cy cr tpi that gaeton though te slop Wf pro pubic pace. Everone ov sept, That clog spews saed by the actual deeopren ofa park Hk Yori, ih experi hate, 8 reaarant that hts descr, ony i chops and he ban ey ‘ey emptied oat even the aniston of he ght ing Secreta of ‘heir Janes Wat stoped shor of ermting apenas pl core be contracted on pak grounds and here wat pubic ourape when ‘ein preduton company that had conacedofim sere in Yost ‘te cided to pun te rocks ro make the look more relate. Whar we ‘ged an example thst combine recreation of ene sett, ‘he pul phere and pte propery. The example mow compeing to erry cre ike myself ino polis caer or» national pa bt oe Jn 1976 «conve named Gary Gilmore was meted fom a fer ela and moved Pov, Uh Sever! moti lesb eb ut Ewe men, ram sored or the ein, rome’ of nore ‘The eat became amour when Clore demanded ne be execs Psishnent hat Bad not ben ified in Aer for soe ea, doe legal preictions—and, over the suenous ojeton of he meen Ge [bets Ungn ard the National Assocation for he Adrants of Cle ‘ote Peopl had is ay. Theleg mance ad tere apn ‘econ ese national meds event, Well blr thedenouemctthe prcrdings ad come tothe arto of Norman Male nd hs pblsher ‘Warner Boks whichis announces tle pains Ware Comm Betons Company.” Males research asst ee Herenber. td Ick wie aol intrvewer,Latrenee Sey, cased exe Inte ‘eos and sulted dorumee cade of ork pressdngs ad feos ‘apes such athe insnate ers Between Gimote ands ite Some ofthese materi were inthe public demain but many of tem were so ‘hey were purchase andthe etal ofthe purchases tenses become rt ofthe mater tat were reworked by Male ito The Exetonrs ong "ve life soa?” ais nee tht linn combiner Sto ‘zig irs emg en opr cesses signaled ot oly y the shew of ‘ing reviews uty th Ui Prods Coe proton paperback ‘book eves Iwas sbsequeny made io a NBC-TV mise where ‘om sce erenngs I helped tal eat, sop pwd and destora ‘Maer bok ha fare ad le preiberon We be was working on The Exeoner’s Son, thet wie a stile on Mal ‘People rngacne, The ace caught te ontion of omit nae ack 1H. Abtot who waote ofr in rihanna on he eoitons Towa «Pot of Cate 11 of pron le. An exchange of ltrs Bein, nd Maer sew nating ‘presed nr only we Sted infor ba oh wha al ‘Ber inerry pee Tae lene were ca and ranged by + Rabon Howse eter, Bel Doral, ang appeared 3 90k tad Ia he Bly of he Beas. Tas Bock tos was widely csimed aod onsbute, wis Male’ bly in pare for i saon “As Iam wing thse wr,” Maer rome inthe Iteducton to ‘Abort Bok, inks Abbot wil be reas on paroehi immer. Teena the tne or bingo pt vt" ave nes cme ne fly ont wih another bana beng inmost weny yest te Albert Snir ook exept comity acts orga of lene” (2). Shey ater ekse,Abbor a eli, approached a wae ian alight restaran ang asked ws the mens oom. The waiter—Richard Adan, an, ‘sping ace and plyigh—tld Abbot the restaurant bad no me's ‘oom apd asked hi to ponte. When An fllowed bin on the tiewal, Abbe appoeny sinking ht he was bing calngd abbed ‘Adan inthe het whiten kale Abt wae aed and convicted ‘nce aa of mae The ema ane thems beh ae io sk le the ely of Boa tat ee opened to ey ear ei hs a faa et of tas fo he relionsip between 1 work ofartand the hiorol evento whch rele: we spk ofaiion, ‘mboliation, aleprstn, eepsentason and sbove a met. Each ‘ofthese terms basa ich sory and ily indipeecle rl ye they all sem euousl laadeqan tothe cla peromenon whieh Maer beck and Abbots and the lersion es and the play conte. And ther inadeqoncyemendsto pects noon of cntmpory ear ba of the ela hep. We sed wo Snip tea occ ie ways ‘whch muneralere fei! Soca Purse popes newopape eli igs and vo fortes wandered from one dare spre acter snd becomes aesthetic propery woul, thik, bes mike toga ths rots as un-dieional~ fom acl decoute tose daoure—not ‘obese the aes dco nh cae so etily Bound wp wih ‘Spal venare bt beeauethe sol desu sendy change wih ‘Sse energie Ner ony wat lor ep Sad overals mored bythe lm veion of Ont Few Over the Gucko's Nex bat hie ee per of behavior es tobe bea shaped the characte ere: ‘tony of American popula ton, adoaing Maer own Micha Boranallone arse rece tha at and scars concep om wo feet hinds tga of human experience. Unhomalogoas ysteateertns pu pon inerpentaig bj raters.” consequence, he age, aby stem Tele he vo ae Samy oe ofthe em i machete hes, but keri oof12 Supt Crna wha odicaton hasbeen essry since this ia necessary pat of co's Infomation” Ir inertive tt me ecole the modtcnon and ada way to maar degre, fries ony mach restr ha ve proedaray~but me be suplemered yan unermandng thar he wore Sf ais no elf pate ae tot esa ie eee of oo speculns Rather te wotk ofa lel he prod ofr of maipalons some of ther ou a (mos singin te cas of works het were no orginally fonedved at atl bt ther asonsthing che—rtve obec, prop fanca, poet, ands ol any exes underaen ete eonsction of the orga wosk That the mark of a the product of messtasan a creor oda of sor shipped wi a compie consnanaly sbaredpensecl common andthe imtson an prac fone In over to achive the aegotition, risen vo ree» carey tt ‘ulidforamesingl mal profableexchangeisinoraero empha. sie tat he proces invlres ot simply appropeaton bu exchange, Since the exten of art alvays plies a return, a era normally mesure Pesos and ist Tahould a tat he ose dominar cures, fpeney aa peti, a svarahy involved, bt Ya ere ing the ee "ent map to deine he senate sare el leo and lin of edt eer to mabe sm exchange o take place “Tees “curency" an "negottion” sete igs four nanialion zd adjasnest of te relive snes ‘Much cea hora wk mt hak be undetood in the context rh fora new eof ems to understand the eral phenomenon ave ted to dese. Hence, for example, Wolfgang et wees of the craton ofthe ashe dean trogh the “dynam erin” ‘rene two dase the Eat Geman Mart Rare Wein apes oat fhe poco mig cashing on’ om become ipa ns ng te hgs and pes) ahh ef speptin mt ‘eee vaya aes weve not ony eto ol ums be ensiontouge eeaton nd epapaion “Anshony Gis proposes that we substi concept fetal diac ‘on for sha ofthe strony ofthe ext, that we cn tly gasp the recive chaser” of foi le a09 of lpsapt.” Each of ee {omalatone—and of cout tee ar uigucant direc among them pallsavay fom Sable, mine ear oft ad tempo contra Towards Pete of are 13 in ad an inept model that will mre adequately account forthe Shelingceaton of mati and dicore th, ave rue he ‘ln of ere sched pic is in repo ots pac tst ‘auteprny hor must ste ele nox one nerpreton, bat 9 ‘RENEE Pact f sept and xchane Noses 1, Tash aku p he Unf Wee Atala on Spi 19th en opin stunner Te nf oper 2 Jon To Piel osm Marat a ely Spa a ica oi et al be nh “Janene ona be ae rl ig sue at kg to aged et aps Felony EA iin bag te koe eps a aa cd {aban cn sy ire hoa ‘Siew ano mater eg pn br rte el Sah cece ee ic oe ‘prt domo one po an pn ni 8 ‘en aac rales done roc wy. esteet bepeetn pee cman won pe ery aren oi od ptoden cared in mor sh om fla arte rei ee a! ep Lp TRIAL te iptor p sooh oyele ong 1 Skoda tee nD 1. scene lant "a, Thera A Sy nfs sss Ed sb Ce U.P 48. 7 in olsun oan eet a a SeeiAr en fda Tr Secnoe oan aoe et alana" its lacing ey ie re 1 eh Roi, onl Regen Ot Epa Peis Deh gry bao ata Ps el te tan NY ae Sp1 Sep Grnbon ie ony To ee of Ratan Can! A. Ramayan AS toni Cont Om 18 Nn, TE Sr ew Ye Wr a, 179 ac een ia hee ba tf Pe oh el tnd he sn ne 1M. Ain The Am of grin Reem 2