Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Change Management
Change Management
Sr No Topic PgNo
1. Change Management An Introduction
3
4. Case Study 6
4.1 Contents of the Case Study
4.2 Change Management at ICICI
4.3 Contents of the Case Study
6. Change Challenges
10-12
6.1 Change Challenges Part I
6.2 Change Challenges Part II
6.3 Change Challenges Part III
7. Conclusion 13
1 | Page
8. Questions for Discussions
14
2 | Page
Change Management: An Introduction
It's always been said that one thing you can count
on is change. Perhaps more than any other time in
history, change is a constant in business. Economic
crisis, globalization, changing markets and
competitionall are forcing a much faster pace
and a much larger. scale of transformation. Change
is occurring at an unprecedented rate and is
challenging virtually every organization.
3 | Page
Change Management: Need & Requirement
4 | Page
Role of Change Management in an Organization
5 | Page
Change management plays an important role in any organization
since the task of managing change is not an easy one. When we
say managing change we mean to say that making changes in a
planned and systemic fashion. With reference to the IT projects
we can say the change in the versions of a project and managing
these versions properly. Changes in the organization or a project
can be initiated from within the organization or externally. For
example a product that is popular among the customers may
undergo a change in design based on the triggering factor like a
competitive product from some other manufacturer. This is an
example of external factor that triggers a change within the
organization. How the organization responds to these changes is
what that is more concerned. Managing these changes come
under change management. Reactive and proactive responses to
these changes are possible from an organization.
6 | Page
Case Study
To have a insight of this subject, let us know look at how this concept of Change Management was used
at ICICI. This below piece of vital information would tell us how a change in the leadership led to a
change in an organizations culture, value, employees and above all the whole of the organization.
This case study shall throw light on the below topics for further discussions and analysis.
Change Leadership.
Change Challenges.
Change Management
at ICICI
From the Leaders..
"What role am I supposed to play in this ever-changing entity? Has anyone worked out the basis on
which roles are being allocated today?"
7 | Page
- A middle level ICICI manager, in 1998.
"We do put people under stress by raising the bar constantly. That is the only way to ensure that
performers lead the change process."
8 | Page
Background Note
ICICI was established by the Government of India in 1955 as a public limited company to promote
industrial development in India. The major institutional shareholders were the Unit Trust of India (UTI),
the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) and the General Insurance Corporation of India (GIC)
and its subsidiaries. The equity of the corporation was supplemented by borrowings from the
Government of India, the World Bank, the Development Loan Fund (now merged with the Agency for
International Development), Kreditanstalt fur Wiederaufbau (an agency of the Government of
Germany), the UK government and the Industrial Development
Explanatory
Since the mid 1980s, ICICI diversified rapidly into areas like
merchant banking and retailing. In 1987, ICICI co-promoted
India's first credit rating agency, Credit Rating and
Information Services of India Limited (CRISIL),
to rate debt obligations of Indian companies.
9 | Page
the counter Exchange of India (OCTEI).
10 | P a g e
Explanatory contd
11 | P a g e
The Change Leader
In May 1996, K.V. Kamath (Kamath) replaced Narayan Vaghul
(Vaghul), CEO of India's leading financial services company
Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India (ICICI).
Immediately after taking charge, Kamath introduced massive
changes in the organizational structure and the emphasis of the
organization changed - from a development bank mode to that
of a market-driven financial conglomerate.
Kamath's moves were prompted by his decision to create new
divisions to tap new markets and to introduce flexibility in the
organization to increase its ability to respond to market changes.
12 | P a g e
Change Challenges Part I
ICICI was a part of the club of developmental finance institutions (DFIs
ICICI, IDBI and IFCI) who were the sole providers of long term funds to
the Indian industry. If the requirement was large, all three pooled in the
money. However, the deregulation beginning in the early 1990s, allowed
Indian corporates' to raise long term funds abroad, putting an end to the
DFI monopoly. The government also stopped giving DFIs subsidized
funds. Eventually in 1997, the practice of consortium lending by DFIs was
phased out. It was amidst this newfound independent status that Kamath,
who had been away from ICICI for eight years working abroad, returned
to the helm. At this point of time, ICICI had limited expertise, with its key
activity being the disbursement of eight year loans to big clients like
Reliance Industries and Telco through its nine zonal offices. In effect, the
company had one basic product, and a customer orientation, which was
largely regional in nature. Kamath, having seen the changes occurring in
the financial sector abroad, wanted ICICI to become a one stop shop for
financial services. He realized that in the deregulated environment ICICI
was neither a low cost player nor was it a differentiator in terms of
customer service. The Indian commercial banks' cost of funds was much
lower, and the foreign banks were much more savvy when it came to
understanding customer needs and developing solutions. Kamath identified
the main problem as the company's ignorance regarding the nuances of
lending practices in newly opened sectors like infrastructure.
Kamath was quick to deny this allegation as well, "Just because somebody is within the MCG does not
guarantee him success. And these assignments are not permanent. Today's MCG man could easily by
tomorrow's GCG person and vice-versa." Complaints against these changes put in continued and ICICI
was blamed for not putting in adequate systems in place to develop the right people.
The manner, which ICICI recognized an individual's efforts - the feedback process - was also
questioned.
A manager remarked, "Last year the bonuses varied from Rs 30,000 to Rs 250,000 depending on the
performance. In many cases the appraisal scores were same but the bonus amount was not. And we
were not told why."
14 | P a g e
Change Challenges Part III
With Kamath's stated objective to make ICICI provide almost every financial
service separating the customer service people from the product development
groups was another problem area. In the current scheme of things an MCG or
GCG person acted as a clients' representative inside ICICI.
The MCG or GCG person understood the client's need and got the relevant
internal skill department to develop a solution. Unlike foreign banks there were
no demarcations between these internal skill groups and client service person.
(Demarcation helped in preventing an internal skills person from cannibalizing
business being developed by the client service group.) With no such systems in
place at ICICI this distorted the compensation packages between the competing
divisions.
15 | P a g e
Conclusion
The ability of organisations to manage change effectively has become more important because of the
rapid advances in technology and the increasing uncertainty and risk associated with the business
environment. Managing change requires flexibility, good planning, an effective decision making system
and an efficient management information system, as well as effective communication systems and
channels.
Managers must show leadership, have behavioural knowledge, especially with regards to the
management of teams, demonstrate analytical skills in basic economic reasoning, be agents of change,
proactive rather than reactive; be able to tolerate ambiguity and uncertainty, and understand why change
is so often perceived as threatening.
The possibility of change tends to provoke resistance among the employees that the change will affect.
This is due to a very natural fear and mistrust of the unknown. This resistance will manifest itself in
different ways, ranging from outright refusal to cooperate through to a covert undermining of proposals.
This mistrust can be best overcome by a deliberate policy of keeping people informed about what is
being proposed and getting them involved as far as possible in the discussions and decision making.
16 | P a g e
Questions for Discussions:
1. What are the major issues discussed in the Change Management case study of ICICI?
2. What were the shortcomings because of one product view of ICICI prior to diversification?
3. What were the different problems/issues that rose due to Change in Leadership?
4. What are your personal views on this situation of Change Management?
5. What was one of the first initiatives that ICICI put in place to check this unrest?
6. What are the different aspects of HR Management that were considered in this case study?
7. What was the outcome of working in Groups?
8. Enumerate any such instance that has worked well for an organization due to Change
Management?
9. Explain your views in terms of need to learn new techniques, skills and methodology of work
due to a Change Management.
10. List all the various trival and big challenges seen in the above case study and state which aspect
of HR Management shall solve this.
17 | P a g e