T. Kalman, V.

Sigmund Superposition of Modal Responses in Spectral Analysis

ISSN 1330-3651
UDC/UDK 624.042.7 : 543.42

SUPERPOZICIJA MODALNIH ODGOVORA SPEKTRALNE ANALIZE

7DQMD.DOPDQ9ODGLPLU6LJPXQG
Prethodno priopenje
0RGDOQDDQDOL]DMHVWDQGDUGQDPHWRGDOLQHDUQHVHL]PLNHDQDOL]HNRQVWUXNFLMD6XSHUSR]LFLMDSRMHGLQLKWRQRYDQLMHVWDQGDUGL]LUDQDLSRVWRMHUD]
OLLWHSUHSRUXNH]DSULPMHQXSRMHGLQLKPHWRGD8UDGXVXGLVNXWLUDQLUH]XOWDWLYUQLKGLQDPLNLKRGJRYRUDQXPHULNLKPRGHODDUPLUDQREHWRQVNH
RNYLUQHNRQVWUXNFLMHVLVSXQDPDVLEH]WRU]LRQLKIRUPLRVFLOLUDQMDRSWHUHHQLVSHNWURPRGJRYRUDLYUHPHQVNLP]DSLVRPUHSUH]HQWDWLYQLKSRWUH
VD8VSRUHHQLVXUH]XOWDWLGRELYHQLVWULPHWRGHPRGDOQHVXSHUSR]LFLMH$%66566L&4&VSULSDGDMXLPYULMHGQRVWLPDGRELYHQLPYUHPHQVNLP
]DSLVRPSRWUHVDUDGLXWYULYDQMDWRQRVWLXSRUDEOMHQLKNRPELQDFLMVNLKSUDYLOD$QDOL]LUDQLVXUH]XOWDWL]DVYHPRGHOHLPHWRGHVXSHUSR]LFLMHWHVX
GDWHSUHSRUXNH]DSULPMHQXSRMHGLQLKPHWRGD
.OMXQHULMHLVSHNWUDOQDDQDOL]DYUHPHQVNLRGJRYRUPHWRGHVXSHUSR]LFLMHNRPELQDFLMHPRGDOQLKRGJRYRUD

Superposition of Modal Responses in Spectral Analysis

Preliminary notes
0RGDODQDO\VLVLVDVWDQGDUGPHWKRGIRUDVWUXFWXUHHDUWKTXDNHUHVSRQVHDQDO\VLV7KHFRPELQDWLRQRIYDULRXVUHVSRQVHPRGHVLVQRWVWDQGDUGL]HG
DQGWKHUHDUHWKUHHPRVWRIWHQXVHGPHWKRGVRIPRGDOVXSHUSRVLWLRQ$%66566DQG&4&([DFWUHVXOWVRIVHLVPLFUHVSRQVHDUHREWDLQHGE\
WLPHKLVWRU\DQDO\VLVZHXVLQJDVHWRIUHSUHVHQWDWLYHHDUWKTXDNHV,QRUGHUWRHYDOXDWHWKHYDOLGLW\RIGLIIHUHQWVXSHUSRVLWLRQPHWKRGVZHUHGH
ILQHGEXLOGLQJPRGHOVWKDWFRYHUDEURDGUDQJHRILQWHUHVWUHJDUGLQJVWLIIQHVVDQGLWVGLVWULEXWLRQDORQJWKHKHLJKWDQGLQIORRUDQGWKHLUUHVSRQVH
WLPHKLVWRULHVZHUHDQDO\]HGIRUDVHWRIJURXQGPRWLRQVWKDWUHSUHVHQWVRIWDQGVWLIIJURXQG7KHVXJJHVWLRQVIRUHYHU\GD\XVHZHUHRXWOLQHG

.H\ZRUGVVSHFWUDODQDO\VLVWLPHKLVWRU\PRGHOVWUXFWXUHVUHVSRQVHFRPELQDWLRQUXOHV

1 
Uvod
Introduction
-HGQD RG QDMYDQLMLK SULPMHQD WHRULMH GLQDPLNH
NRQVWUXNFLMD X JUDHYLQDUVWYX MH RGJRYRU NRQVWUXNFLMD
SUL GMHORYDQMX SRWUHVD =D GRELYDQMH RGJRYRUD NRQ
VWUXNFLMHHVWRVH]DRSWHUHHQMHSRWUHVRPNRULVWL]DSLV
YULMHGQRVWLRGJRYRUD]DSURPDWUDQLSRWUHV

2
Modalna analiza i odgovori konstrukcije u ovisnosti
o vremenu
Modal Analysis and Time History Responses
0RGDOQDDQDOL]DMHGLQDPLNDDQDOL]DOLQHDUQLKVX
XEU]DQMDWODXRYLVQRVWLRYUHPHQXHQJWLPHKLVWRU\
2GJRYRUL NRQVWUXNFLMH X WDNYRP VOXDMX RSWHUHHQMD
GDMXUHIHUHQWQHYULMHGQRVWLDOLXIXQNFLMLYUHPHQD
'UXJD PHWRGD SRPRX NRMH VH GLUHNWQR RGUHXMX
YUQL RGJRYRUL NRQVWUXNFLMH MH VSHNWDU RGJRYRUD HQJ
VWDYDV1VWXSQMHYDVORERGHNRMDVH]DVQLYDQDPHWRGL
UD]YLMDQMD SRYODVWLWLPREOLFLPDLOLWRQRYLPD2YDPH
WRGD MH SULPMHQMLYDDNRMHYUHPHQVNDRYLVQRVWVLODSR
EXGHVYLKPDVDLVWDLOLUD]PMHUQRLVWDWRXVOXDMXSRW
UHVQRJRSWHUHHQMD]DGRYROMDYDWUDHQLXYMHW
UHVSRQVHVSHFWUD6SHNWDURGJRYRUDVHGRELYDL]]DSLVD 5MHHQMHSUREOHPDVYRGLVHQDUMHDYDQMHPDWULQH
SRWUHVD DNFHOHUDFLMH X YUHPHQX L SUHGVWDYOMD YUQL RG GLIHUHQFLMDOQHMHGQDGEH
JRYRU VYLK PRJXLK OLQHDUQLK VXVWDYD V MHGQLP VWXS 
QMHP VORERGH L]ORHQLK RGUHHQRM NRPSRQHQWL SRWUHV [P] {X}+ [F] {X}+ [N ] {X} = {S(W )}
QRJ RSWHUHHQMD L SULND]XMH IXQNFLMX YUQRJ RGJRYRUD 
DNFHOHUDFLMH EU]LQH LOL SRPDND X RYLVQRVWL R SULURG JGMHMH
QRPSHULRGX7LOLIUHNYHQFLMLI6YDNLWDNDYSULND]LPD [P]GLMDJRQDOQDPDWULFDPDVD
ILNVQXYULMHGQRVWNRHILFLMHQWDSULJXHQMD
3UL RSWHUHHQMX JUDHYLQH VSHNWURP RGJRYRUD GR
[N ] SXQDPDWULFDNUXWRVWL
ELYDMX VH SULEOLQH YULMHGQRVWL YUQRJ RGJRYRUD MHU {X}{
 X} {X}YHNWRULXEU]DQMDEU]LQHLSRPDNDNDWD
NRPELQDFLMD PRGDOQLK RGJRYRUD X]LPD X RE]LU YUQH {S(W )}RSWHUHHQMH
YULMHGQRVWLRGJRYRUD]DSRMHGLQHREOLNHQHYH]XMXLVH 
]DYUHPHQVNLNRUDNXNRMHPVXYUQHYULMHGQRVWLQDVWD 'LMDJRQDOL]DFLMRP PDWULFH SULJXHQMD L PDWULFH
OH2YDNYDPHWRGDVPDWUDVHGRVWDWQRWRQRP]DLQH NUXWRVWLUDVWDYOMDVHGLVNUHWDQVXVWDYV1VWXSQMHYDVOR
QMHUVNX SULPMHQX XNROLNR RGUHHQD NRPELQDFLMD PR ERGH QD 1 QH]DYLVQLK GLVNUHWQLK VXVWDYD RG NRMLK MH
GDOQLKRGJRYRUDGDMHGRVWDWQRUHIHUHQWQHYULMHGQRVWL VYDNL V MHGQLP VWXSQMHP VORERGH 2YDNYR UDVWDYOMDQMH
8UDGXHVHL]YULWLXVSRUHGEDNRPELQDFLMDVSHN VHQD]LYDPRGDOQDDQDOL]D
WUDOQH DQDOL]H $%6 6566 &4& V DQDOL]RP ]DSLVD 'DELVHL]YULODGLMDJRQDOL]DFLMDPDWULFDFLN
SRWUHVDXIXQNFLMLYUHPHQDNRMDGDMHUHIHUHQWQH

TEHNIKI VJESNIK 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24 17

Superpozicija modalnih odgovora spektralne analize T. Kalman, V. Sigmund

XYRGLVHWUDQVIRUPDFLMDNRRUGLQDWD  X SULMHQRVX VHL]PLNRJ RSWHUHHQMD ]QDWQR PDQML]ERJ

 PDOLKYULMHGQRVWLSRPDNDYLLKYODVWLWLKREOLND
{X} = [ ] {< } 3UHPD WRPH X VOXDMX RSWHUHHQMD VLODPD SRWUHVD
PRGDOQDMHGQDGEDSRSULPDREOLN


JGMHMH
 /
<Q +  Q Q <Q + Q <Q = Q XJ W  
{X}  YHNWRU SUYRELWQLK JHQHUDOL]LUDQLK QHSR]QDWLK 0Q
NRRUGLQDWD Q =  1 
[]  PDWULFD WUDQVIRUPDFLMH LML VX VWXSFL SURSRU 
FLRQDOQLYHNWRULPDYODVWLWLKREOLND 5MHHQMH RYH GLIHUHQFLMDOQH MHGQDGEH GDQR MH X
{< }YHNWRUQRUPDOQLKNRRUGLQDWD SR]QDWRM IRUPL 'XKDPHORYRJ LQWHJUDOD L] NRMHJVHGR
 ELYDPRGDOQLSRPDN<QW
3ULPMHQRPRVRELQHRUWRJRQDOQRVWLPDVDNUXWRVWLL 
SULJXHQMD /  W
<Q W  = Q XJ   H Q Q (W ) VLQ[ Q' (W )] G
 0 Q Q' 
7Q P M =   7Q N M =   7Q F M =   
W
Q M 
 - Q W  = XJ   H Q Q (W ) VLQ [ Q' (W )] G 
 
L XYRHQMHP R]QDND ]D JHQHUDOL]LUDQX PDVX 0Q JHQH 
UDOL]LUDQXNUXWRVW.QJHQHUDOL]LUDQXVLOX3QWLJHQHUD 8QXWDUQMH VLOH X VXVWDYX SRSUHQH NDWQH VLOH L
OL]LUDQRSULJXHQMH&Q]DWRQQ PRPHQWL QDVWDOH SUHWKRGQR GRELYHQLP YULMHGQRVWLPD
 GHIRUPDFLMD VXVWDYD RGUHXMH VH SULPMHQRP NRQFHSWD
0 Q = 7Q P Q  . Q = 7Q N Q  3Q W  = 7Q S W   HNYLYDOHQWQLKERQLKVLODI7RVXRQHVLOHNRMHSULPLMH
&Q = 7Q F Q  QMHQHQDVXVWDYX]URNXMXSRPDNH
8NXSQDSRSUHQDVLODXUD]LQLWHPHOMD]JUDGH
 
GRELYDVHGLIHUHQFLMDOQDMHGQDGEDNRMDVHRGQRVLQDQ
WL REOLN RVFLOLUDQMD GLVNUHWQRJ VXVWDYD VD 1 VWXSQMHYD
1
/Q  Q 
9 W  = - Q 
VORERGHVOMHGHHJREOLND Q = 0 Q Q'
 
0 Q <Q + &Q <Q + . Q <Q = 3Q W   Q =  1  8NXSQLPRPHQWXUD]LQLWHPHOMD]JUDGH
 
1 /Q Q 
0RGDOQDGLIHUHQFLMDOQDMHGQDGED]DWRQQYUL
MHGLLXVOXDMXSRWUHVDSULHPXMH
0  = {
K K  K M  K1 P Q - Q }
Q = 0 Q Q'
 
3Q W  = 7Q SHI = 7Q P XJ W  ,  
 2GJRYRU NRQVWUXNFLMH GHIRUPDFLMD XQXWDUQMHVLOH
JGMHMH QDSUH]DQMDQDGMHORYDQMHSRWUHVDX]LPDMXLXRE]LU]D
SHI   YDQMVNH HIHNWLYQH VLOH MHGQDNH SURGXNWX NDWQLK SLV SRWUHVD X IXQNFLML DNFHOHUDFLMH WOD MHGQDN MH ]EURMX
PDVDLXEU]DQMDSRGORJH SRMHGLQDQLK GRSULQRVD VYDNRJ YODVWLWRJ REOLND X MHG
XJ W  XEU]DQMHWHPHOMQRJWODSRGORJH QRPYUHPHQVNRPNRUDNX

,MHGLQLQLYHNWRUVWXSDF U (W ) = U (W ) + U (W ) +  + UQ W  +  + U1 (W ) 

6RE]LURPGDMHPDWULFDPDVDGLMDJRQDOQDPRHVH 
SLVDWL 3
 Spektralna analiza
1 Spectral Analysis
7Q P , = PL QL = /Q 
M = 8VOXDMXRSWHUHHQMDNRQVWUXNFLMHVSHNWURPRGJR
 YRUD GRELYHQLP L] ]DSLVD SRWUHVD SUL DQDOL]L VXVWDYD V
 MHGQLPVWXSQMHPVORERGHYULMHGLL]UD]
9ULMHGQRVW /Q SUHGVWDYOMD IDNWRU XHD LOL SDUWLFL 
SDFLMHRGQRVQRL]QRVVNRMLP QWLWRQXHVWYXMHXSUL 6 6
X PD[ = 6 G = Y = D 
MHQRVXVHL]PLNRJRSWHUHHQMD2YDMIDNWRUVHVPDQMXMH
VSRYHDQMHPEURMDWRQDMHUMHGRSULQRVYLLKWRQRYD

18 TECHNICAL GAZETTE 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24

T. Kalman, V. Sigmund Superposition of Modal Responses in Spectral Analysis

JGMHVX  2YD PRGDOQD NRPELQDFLMD SUHWSRVWDYOMD GD VX

6GVSHNWUDOQLSRPDN PDNVLPDOQH PRGDOQH YULMHGQRVWL VWDWLVWLNL QHRYLVQH
6YVSHNWUDOQDSVHXGREU]LQD .DNRVHUDGLRNYDGUDWLPDYULMHGQRVWLVYDNDYUQDYUL
6DVSDNWUDOQDSVHXGRDNFHOHUDFLMD MHGQRVW SRVWDMH SR]LWLYQD 8 VOXDMX NRQVWUXNFLMD NRG
 NRMLKMHYHOLNLEURMSULURGQLKIUHNYHQFLMDJRWRYRLGHQWL
8PRGDOQRMDQDOL]LRYHYHOLLQHLPDMXVOMHGHHR] DQ RYD SUHWSRVWDYND QHH YULMHGLWL L RYD PRGDOQD
QDNHXRYLVQRVWLRSRMHGLQLPREOLFLPD NRPELQDFLMDWDGDQHHGDWL]DGRYROMDYDMXHYULMHGQRVWL
 XNXSQRJRGJRYRUD
6 GQ = 6 G ( Q  Q )  6YQ = 6Y ( Q  Q )  6 DQ = 6 D ( Q  Q )  &4&  NRPSOHWQD NYDGUDWQD NRPELQDFLMD HQJ
Q =  1  FRPSOHWH TXDGUDWLF FRPELQDWLRQ SUHGVWDYOMD SURGXNW
YUQLK YULMHGQRVWL LWRJ L QWRJ REOLND L NRUHODFLMVNRJ

0RGDOQL SRPDN X VOXDMX VSHNWUDOQH WHRULMH LPD NRHILFLMHQWD LQ ]DWDGYDREOLND.RUHODFLMVNLNRHILFL
PDNVLPDOQXYULMHGQRVW MHQWYDULUDL]PHXYULMHGQRVWLLLMHGQDNMHMHGLQL
 QRMYULMHGQRVWL]D L = Q 
/ 
<Q = Q 6 GQ   
0Q 1 1
U LQ UL  UQ  
 L = Q =
0DNVLPDOQH YULMHGQRVWL SUHVMHQLK VLOD XUD]LQLWH 
PHOMD -HGQDGEDPRHVHQDSLVDWLLXVOMHGHHPREOLNX
 
/Q / 1  
9 Q = 6 DQ  0  Q = Q 6 DQ K M P M MQ  1  1 1
0Q 0Q M =
U UQ  + LQ UL  UQ   L Q 
Q = L = Q =
Q =  1 

 -HGQDGEDSUHGVWDYOMDXSUYRMVXPLNRPELQD
0DNVLPDOQL RGJRYRU NRQVWUXNFLMH GHIRUPDFLMD FLMX6566NRMDGDMHSR]LWLYQLODQVRE]LURPQDWRRG
XQXWDUQMH VLOH QDSUH]DQMD QD GMHORYDQMH SRWUHVD X]L JRYRU GRELYHQ &4&NRPELQDFLMRPPRHELWLPDQMLLOL
PDMXLXRE]LUVSHNWDURGJRYRUDMHGQDNMHNRPELQDFLML YHLRGRGJRYRUDGRELYHQLP6566NRPELQDFLMRP
PDNVLPDOQLK SRMHGLQDQLK GRSULQRVD VYDNRJ YODVWLWRJ .RUHODFLMVNLNRHILFLMHQWSUHPD'HU.LXUHJKLDQX
REOLNDSULHPXVH]DQHPDUXMXYUHPHQVNLNRUDFLXNR 
MLPDVXGRVHJQXWHPDNVLPDOQHYULMHGQRVWL
 L Q ( LQ L + Q ) LQ
 
.RPELQDFLMH NRMH VH NRULVWH X VSHNWUDOQRM DQDOL]L LQ = 
GDMX YULMHGQRVWL SULEOLQH VWYDUQRP RGJRYRUX NRQ
VWUXNFLMH
( ) +  ( + )+ (
LQ
 
L Q LQ LQ

L

)
+ Q LQ


$%6  VXPD DSVROXWQLK YULMHGQRVWL HQJ DEVROXWH 

VXPPRGDOQDNRPELQDFLMDNRMDSUHWSRVWDYOMDGDVYH JGMHMH
YUQH YULMHGQRVWL PRGDOQLK RGJRYRUD QDVWDMX X LVWRP IDNWRUSULJXHQMD
YUHPHQVNRPNRUDNXSULHPXMHXNXSQLRGJRYRUVXPD
LQ = L   NRHILFLMHQW RGQRVD YODVWLWLK IUHNYHQFLMD L
DSVROXWQLK YULMHGQRVWL SRMHGLQDQLK YUQLK RGJRYRUD Q
WRQRYD WRJLQWRJREOLND
 
1
8NROLNRSRVWRMLLVWLIDNWRUSULJXHQMD]DVYHWRQRYH
U UQ  
Q =
MHGQDGEDVHSRMHGQRVWDYOMXMHLJODVL


  ( + LQ ) LQ
 
2YD NRPELQDFLMD GDMH QDMYHH PRJXH YULMHGQRVWL LQ = 
RGJRYRUD NRQVWUXNFLMH L ]ERJ WRJD VH ULMHWNR NRULVWL X
LQHQMHUVNRMSUDNVL
( ) + 
LQ
 
LQ ( + LQ )


6566  NYDGUDWQL NRULMHQ L] VXPH NYDGUDWD HQJ 

VTXDUHURRWRIVXPRIVTXDUHVPRGDOQDNRPELQDFLMD .RUHODFLMVNL NRHILFLMHQW QDJOR VH VPDQMXMH XNROLNR
NRMD NYDGULUD YUQX YULMHGQRVW VYDNRJ REOLND .RULMHQ L]PHXGYLMHSULURGQHIUHNYHQFLMH LLQSRVWRMLYHOLND
VXPHNYDGUDWDWLKYUQLKYULMHGQRVWLGDMHXNXSQLRGJR UD]OLND7RMHQDURLWRVOXDMVNRQVWUXNFLMDPDVPDOLP
YRU SULJXHQMHP =D NRQVWUXNFLMH V GREUR UDVSRGLMHOMHQLP
 SULURGQLPIUHNYHQFLMDPDNRUHODFLMVNLNRHILFLMHQWVHJX
  ELSDNRPELQDFLMVNRSUDYLOR&4&SUHOD]LX6566
1 
U UQ  
Q =

TEHNIKI VJESNIK 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24 19

Superpozicija modalnih odgovora spektralne analize T. Kalman, V. Sigmund

.RPELQDFLMVND SUDYLOD GDYDWL H ]DGRYROMDYDMXH WRQRYDRGRGNULWLQRJ

YULMHGQRVWL ]D SRWUHVQH X]EXGH NRMH LPDMX LURN RSVHJ 6YLKSHWPRGHODLPDMXLVWHWORFUWQHGLPHQ]LMHLYL
YODVWLWLKIUHNYHQFLMDVGXJDNLPID]DPDYLVRNLKDPSOL VLQHHWDDNDRLGLPHQ]LMHNRQVWUXNWLYQLKHOHPHQDWD
WXGD SRWUHVD NRMH VX QHNROLNR SXWD GXH RG SULURGQLK 0RGHO$MHNDUDNWHULVWLQLDUPLUDQREHWRQVNLRNYLU
SHULRGDNRQVWUXNFLMHLQLVXSUHPDORSULJXHQHRGQRVQR GRNVXPRGHOLPD%L&GRGDQH]LGDQHLVSXQHUD]OLLWR
PRGDOQHNRPELQDFLMHQHHELWLSRJRGQH]DNUDWNRWUDMQH UD]PMHWHQHSRWORULVX
LPSXOVQHKDUPRQLQHSRWUHVQHX]EXGH 8PRGHOX%MH]LGDQDLVSXQDUDVSRUHHQDVLPHWUL
 QRSRWORULVXLYLVLQL]JUDGHGRNMHXPRGHOX%SULP
4 MHULVWHUDVSRGMHOH]LGDQHLVSXQHSRWORULVXDOLVPHNLP
Numeriki modeli SUL]HPOMHP
Numerical Models 8 PRGHOX & LVSXQD MH UDVSRUHHQD QHVLPHWULQR
SR WORULVX DOL LPD MHGQROLN UDVSRUHG LVSXQD SR YLVLQL
8QXPHULNRPGLMHOXUDGDREUDHQLVXUH]XOWDWL]D GRN X PRGHOX & LVSXQD UDVSRUHHQD QHVLPHWULQR SR
SHWPRGHODSULHPXMHVYDNLRGQMLKELRRSWHUHHQVWUL WORULVXLYLVLQL]JUDGHSUL]HPOMHLPDUDVSRGMHOXNDNRMH
SRWUHVDVYDNLXGYLMHKRUL]RQWDOQHNRPSRQHQWHWHVX SULND]DQRXWDEOLFLGRNRVWDOHHWDHLPDMXUDVSRGMHOX
XVSRUHLYDQLUH]XOWDWLYUHPHQVNRJRGJRYRUDLVSHNWUDO LVSXQHNDRPRGHO&
QHDQDOL]H =D QXPHULNR PRGHOLUDQMH NRULWHQ MH SURJUDP
3UHWSRVWDYOMHQMHNRHILFLMHQWSULJXHQMDNRGVYLK
(7$%6YHU>@

7DEOLFD3ULND]JHRPHWULMVNLKLPDWHULMDOQLKNDUDNWHULVWLNDQXPHULNLKPRGHOD
7DEOH6FKHPHRIJHRPHWU\DQGPDWHULDOFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIQXPHULFDOPRGHOV
MATERIJALNE
GEOMETRIJSKE KARAKTERISTIKE
KARAKTERISTIKE
M M M ploa d (cm) 18
O O O beton C30/37
7 2
D D D greda b/h (cm) 30/50 E =3,2510 kN/m
E E E
L L L elik RA 400/500
8 2
stup b/h (cm) 50/50 E =210 kN/m
A B1 C1
opeka
B2 C2 zid d (cm) 20 6 2
E =510 kN/m

3UL QXPHULNRP PRGHOLUDQMX SRWUHVQRJ RSWHUHH  MHWDNDYGDSRNULYDSRGUXMHRGNUXWLKGRPHNLKWODWM

QMD NRULWHQD VX GYD QDLQD ]DSLV XEU]DQMD WOD X YUH
PHQXLVSHNWDURGJRYRUD]DWULSRWUHVDXGYLMHKRUL]RQ
WDOQHNRPSRQHQWH=DSRWUHVQDRSWHUHHQMDNRULWHQLVX
]DSLVLSRWUHVDVLQWHQ]LWHWRPNRMLRGJRYDUD,;SRWUHV
QRM]RQLSR06.VNDOLWHVYULMHGQRVWLPDPDNVLPDOQLK
SRNULYDMXSURMHNWQRLQWHUHVDQWQRSRGUXMH
6PMHUVMHYHUMXJ]DGDQMHXVPMHUX[DVPMHULVWRN
]DSDG X VPMHUX \ JOREDOQRJ NRRUGLQDWQRJ VXVWDYD L LV
WRYUHPHQR MH ]DGDYDQD SREXGD X GYD RNRPLWD VPMHUD
VPMHU[VDYULMHGQRVWLLVPMHU\VDYULMHG
XEU]DQMDJJ)UHNYHQWQLVDVWDYSRWUHVD QRVWL

7DEOLFD9UQHYULMHGQRVWLSRWUHVD
7DEOH3HDNYDOXHVRIHDUWKTXDNH

VREMENSKI ZAPIS SPEKTAR ODGOVORA

X Y X Y

EL CENTRO 0,349g 0,214g 1,154g 0,790g

BAR 0,375g 0,363g 1,235g 1,758g

PETROVAC 0,484g 0,341g 2,556g 1,644g

  

20 TECHNICAL GAZETTE 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24

T. Kalman, V. Sigmund Superposition of Modal Responses in Spectral Analysis

PROSTORNI PRIKAZ TLORIS

MODEL A
MODEL B1
MODEL B2
MODEL C1
MODEL C2

6OLND3URVWRUQLSULND]LLWORULVLPRGHODVUDVSRGMHORP]LGDQLKLVSXQD
)LJ'DQGJURXQGSODQVFKHPHRIPRGHOVZLWKGLVWULEXWLRQRIZDOOILOOLQJ

  

TEHNIKI VJESNIK 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24 21

Superpozicija modalnih odgovora spektralne analize T. Kalman, V. Sigmund

6OLND6SHNWULRGJRYRUD]DREDKRUL]RQWDOQDVPMHUDFUQDFUWD;VPMHULVLYDFUWD<VPMHU
)LJ6SHFWUXPVRIDQVZHUVIRUERWKKRUL]RQWDOGLUHFWLRQVEODFNOLQH;GLUHFWLRQDQGJUH\OLQH<GLUHFWLRQ

7DEOLFD9ULMHGQRVWLSHULRGD]DSUYLKHVWWRQRYDSRPRGHOLPD
7DEOH9DOXHVRISHULRGVIRUWKHILUVWVL[WRQHVE\PRGHOV
Model A Model B1 Model B2 Model C1 Model C2
OBLIK T, s T, s T, s T, s T, s
1 1,405 0,414 0,755 0,786 0,720
2 1,306 0,357 0,713 0,361 0,423
3 1,304 0,265 0,643 0,299 0,303
4 0,449 0,134 0,194 0,250 0,223
5 0,422 0,118 0,166 0,143 0,138
6 0,419 0,089 0,116 0,118 0,128

5 
Rezultati
Results
8REUDGLSRGDWDNDXVSRUHHQLVXSHULRGLSRMHGLQLK
PRGHODSRWRQRYLPDLXDQDOL]LUHDNFLMDYULMHGQRVWLGR
ELYHQH NRPELQDFLMDPD PRGDOQLK RGJRYRUD $%6
6566 &4& L WRQLK YULMHGQRVWL GRELYHQLK DQDOL]RP
YUHPHQVNRJ]DSLVDSRWUHVD
3UHPDYUHPHQVNRMDQDOL]LPRHVHXWYUGLWLNRMDH
NRPELQDFLMD GDWL WRQLMH YULMHGQRVWL V RE]LURPQDEOLV
NRVW YULMHGQRVWL SHULRGD GYD X]DVWRSQD REOLND RG]LYD
NRQVWUXNFLMH8NROLNRMHYULMHGQRVWSHULRGDGUXJRJPR
GD X RGQRVX QD SUHWKRGQL YHD RG   SUHWKRGQH QH
GRELYHQLUH]XOWDWLGDOLUHSUH]HQWDWLYQHYULMHGQRVWL
6SHNWUDOQD DQDOL]D L NRPELQDFLMH PRGDOQLK RGJR
YRUD ]D VYH PRGHOH L SRWUHVH GDOH VX GRVWDWDQ UDVSRQ
YULMHGQRVWLNRMHVXXVSRUHHQHVUHSUH]HQWDWLYQLPD
0HWRGDVSHNWUDOQHDQDOL]HGLUHNWQRGDMHLGHDOL]LUD
QH PDNVLPDOQH YULMHGQRVWL RGJRYRUD NRQVWUXNFLMH SRW
UHEQH]DSURUDXQGRNPHWRGDVRSWHUHHQMHP]DSLVRP
SRWUHVD X YUHPHQX GDMH WRQH RGJRYRUH NRQVWUXNFLMH
DOLXRYLVQRVWLRYUHPHQX
9UHPHQVNDDQDOL]DRGJRYRUDNRQVWUXNFLMHNRMDGD
MH WRQH YULMHGQRVWL RGJRYRUD X YUHPHQX RPRJXDYD
XVSRUHGEX UH]XOWDWD V UD]OLLWLP PHWRGDPD PRGDOQLK
NRPELQDFLMD ,] UH]XOWDWD NRML SRNULYDMX LURN VSHNWDU
IUHNYHQFLMDJUDHYLQDRGLQWHUHVDVDLEH]XWMHFDMDWRU
SUHSRUXDVHXSRUDED6566QHJR&4&NRPELQDFLMH ]LMH LURN VSHNWDU SREXGD QD PHNLP L NUXWLP WOLPD
5H]XOWDWL VX VH XVSRUHLYDOL QD RVQRYX YULMHGQRVWL PRHVH]DNOMXLWLRXSRUDELYRVWLPHWRGD
SRSUHQLKUHDNFLMD]DREDKRUL]RQWDOQDVPMHUDLPRPH 6566 NRPELQDFLMD GDMH YHH UD]OLNH X RGQRVX QD
QDWD WRU]LMH X UXEQLP VWXSRYLPD PRGHOD 3ULND] XVSR VWYDUQH WRQH YULMHGQRVWL RGJRYRUD X VOXDMX WRQRYD V
UHGQLK YULMHGQRVWL SR NRPELQDFLMDPD L SRWUHVLPD ]D X]DVWRSQLP EOLVNLP YULMHGQRVWLPD SHULRGD 7DNYH UD]
PRGHO&YLGOMLYMHQDVOLFL OLNHSRNULYDNRPELQDFLMD&4&8VOXDMXQHUHJXODUQLK
 NRQVWUXNFLMDXSUDYLOXVHMDYOMDMXIUHNYHQFLMHMHGQROLNH
6 XSDUXWRQRYDSDMHSUHSRUXOMLYRNRULVWLWL&4&NRPEL
Zakljuak QDFLMX
Conclusion $%6 NRPELQDFLMD GDMH XYLMHN YHH YULMHGQRVWL WR
MHYLGOMLYRLXSURYHGHQRMDQDOL]LVSURVMHQLPSRYHD
8 UDGX MH L]YUHQD DQDOL]D SHW PRGHOD LVWLK WORFUW QMHPRGRNRSDMHNDRPRJXDPHWRGDNRPEL
QLK GLPHQ]LMD L YLVLQD HWDD DOL UD]OLLWLK NUXWRVWL SR QDFLMH PRGDOQLK RGJRYRUD XSRUDEOMLYD VDPR V FLOMHP
WORULVXLSRYLVLQLWRMHXWMHFDORQDYULMHGQRVWLSULURGQLK RVWDMDQMDQDVWUDQLVLJXUQRVWL
SHULRGDIRUPLRVFLOLUDQMDWHNDUDNWHULVWLNDRGJRYRUD &4& PRGDOQD NRPELQDFLMD GDMH QDMPDQMD RGVWX
6YL PRGHOL VX RSWHUHHQL SRWUHVLPD X YLGX ]DSLVD SDQMDRGWRQLKYULMHGQRVWLNRGVYLKUD]PDWUDQLKPRGH
SRWUHVDXYUHPHQXXGYLMHNRPSRQHQWHWHVXWDNR ODXSURVMHNXRNRWHVHSUHSRUXXMHNDRQDMSRX]
GDQLMD]DLQHQMHUVNXSUDNVX

22 TECHNICAL GAZETTE 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24

T. Kalman, V. Sigmund Superposition of Modal Responses in Spectral Analysis

ELCENTRO BAR PETROVAC

ABS
SRSS
CQC
TH

6OLND5HDNFLMHXUXEQLPVWXSRYLPDSRNRPELQDFLMDPDLSRWUHVLPD]DPRGHO&
)LJ5HDFWLRQIRUFHVLQNHUESLOODUVE\FRPELQDWLRQVDQGHDUWKTXDNHVIRUPRGHO&

7DEOLFD7DEOLFDUH]XOWDWDVUHGQMLKYULMHGQRVWLSRPRGHOLPDLSRWUHVLPDXRGQRVXQDMHGLQLQHYULMHGQRVWLGRELYHQHYUHPHQVNLP]DSLVRP
7DEOH5HVXOWVRIPLGGOHYDOXHVE\PRGHOVDQGHDUWKTXDNHVLQUHODWLRQWRYDOXHVREWDLQHGZLWKWLPHHQWU\
ABS SRSS CQC
EL CENTRO 1,364 0,962 0,963
MODEL A BAR 1,252 1,058 1,059
PETROVAC 1,526 0,951 0,954
EL CENTRO 1,200 0,961 0,962
MODEL B1 BAR 1,218 0,962 0,964
PETROVAC 1,216 1,061 1,062
EL CENTRO 1,119 1,098 1,098
MODEL B2 BAR 1,060 1,046 1,046
PETROVAC 1,131 0,990 0,990
EL CENTRO 1,407 1,049 1,048
MODEL C1 BAR 1,351 1,044 1,042
PETROVAC 1,628 1,092 1,083
EL CENTRO 1,482 1,214 1,210
MODEL C2 BAR 1,390 1,114 1,112
PETROVAC 1,112 0,925 0,923

TEHNIKI VJESNIK 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24 23

Superpozicija modalnih odgovora spektralne analize T. Kalman, V. Sigmund

6  
Literatura
References
>@ &KRSUD$QLO.'\QDPLFVRI6WUXFWXUHV3UHQWLFH+DOO
1HZ-HUVH\
>@ DXHYL 0HKPHG 3RWUHVQR LQHQMHUVWYR RGDEUDQD
SRJODYOMDNROVNDNQMLJD=DJUHE
>@ (7$%6YHU7KUHH'LPHQVLRQDO6WDWLFDQG'\QDPLF
$QDO\VLV RI 6WUXFWXUHV &RPSXWHUV DQG VWUXFWXUHV ,QF
%HUNOH\

$XWKRUV$GGUHVV$GUHVDDXWRUD
7DQMD.DOPDQGLSOLQJJUD
*UDHYLQVNLIDNXOWHWX2VLMHNX
6YHXLOLWH-RVLSD-XUMD6WURVVPD\HUD
&UNYHQDXOLFD2VLMHN
HPDLOWNDOPDQ#JIRVKU

24
3URIGUVF9ODGLPLU6LJPXQGGLSOLQJJUD 
*UDHYLQVNLIDNXOWHWX2VLMHNX
6YHXLOLWH-RVLSD-XUMD6WURVVPD\HUD
&UNYHQDXOLFD2VLMHN
HPDLOVLJPXQG#JIRV
TECHNICAL GAZETTE 14 (2007)(1,2)17-24