Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Table of Contents
Threat #1:
A Crippling EMP Attack------------------------------------------------------- 3
Threat #2:
Devastating Solar Storms----------------------------------------------------- 4
Threat #3:
Cyber Security Malicious Code------------------------------------------- 7
Threat #4:
Stormy Weather the Edge of Reliability-------------------------------- 10
Threat #5:
The Not-So-Smart Smart Grid----------------------------------------------- 12
Threat #6:
Informers in your Home------------------------------------------------------ 15
Threat #7:
Big Business, Big Government, Big Mess--------------------------------- 19
Threat #8:
Fuel Prices Up, Up and Away--------------------------------------------- 20
Threat #9:
Transmission Capacity On Overload--------------------------------------- 25
Threat #10:
Everyone Wants Some-------------------------------------------------------- 28
2
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #1:
A Crippling EMP Attack
Airplanes would literally fall from What the U.S. Must Do Now, pulls no
the sky, cars and trucks would stop punches. The consequences of an EMP
working, and water, sewer, and electrical attack would be catastrophic. According
networks would fail. to the report, Food would rot, medical
services would collapse, and transportation
It sounds like something from an
would become almost non-existent.
apocalyptic Hollywood movie but the
threat is very real. That threat is EMP, The resulting chaos that would
short for electromagnetic pulse as well ensue if that were to happen is nearly
as HEMP, a newer term, which stands for unimaginable. Unlike a nuclear bomb
high-altitude electromagnetic pulse. In a detonated at ground level, an EMP device
report recently released by the Heritage would not kill the surrounding population
Foundation, a leading U.S. think tank, immediately. Instead, it would destroy the
national security experts warned President grid, returning America to a pre-industrial
Obama about the potential EMP threat level of technology. Millions of people
from hostile nations or even terrorists. would suffer slow, agonizing deaths from
starvation, lack of clean water, and lack of
A nuclear bomb detonated high above
medical care.
the earths atmosphere wouldnt have its
energy converted to blast energy by the While hostile nations may have the
atmosphere. So it cant destroy people capability for a large-scale EMP attack,
or property directly. Instead, the bombs even a smaller EMP attack by terrorists
energy would go out as electromagnetic would have catastrophic consequences.
energy, or an EMP. This could severely A nuclear bomb capable of producing an
damage, if not completely destroy the EMP can fit in a backpack and be launched
electrical power grid. An EMP weapon from the back of a tractor trailer or from
would also destroy all things electronic a shipping container on a cargo ship. An
airplanes, vehicles, communications even smaller device called an explosively
networks, computers, and more. pumped flux compression generator
(EPFCG)1 could be carried by a single
The report, entitled EMP Attacks
3
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
individual. In the hands of a terrorist, this years, if society could survive long enough
device could release pulses in the millions to accomplish them. The equipment
of amperes and tens of terawatts, and it needed for these repairs isnt just sitting
does it without a nuclear bomb. in warehouses, waiting to be used. In
the meantime, with no power, cities and
An EPFCG set off in New York City could
suburbs would become a very dangerous
conceivably create an EMP that would
place to live. In a report put out by the
stop the entire Northeast corridor cold.
DHS, an EMP attack of this type could
A single nuclear bomb, launched from
ultimately cause the death of 90 percent
a cargo ship in the Gulf of Mexico, could
of the U.S. population. People who live
create a large enough EMP to destroy the
in the countryside, with access to arable
electronics across over 90 percent of the
land, well water, and who have alternative
United States.
energy sources, would have the best
Repairs to the grid would literally take chances for survival.
Threat #2:
Devastating Solar Storms
While an EMP attack from a hostile so powerful that they tear away chunks of
power is possible, theres an equally solar mass. These chunks become balls of
devastating threat thats even more likely. magnetized plasma, hurtling into space.
And it doesnt come from any earthly These are called coronal mass ejections
power. (CMEs). When they hit the Earths
atmosphere, they not only interact with
Approximately every 22 years, the
our planets magnetic field and cause the
sun enters a period of intense magnetic
northern lights (aurora borealis), but they
storms typified by the appearance of
also threaten satellites and astronauts
numerous sunspots. During these storms,
with intense radiation bursts. In 1958, a
the sun ejects plumes of hot gas and
massive CME produced northern lights
magnetic energy. One flare can contain the
that could be seen in Mexico.
equivalent of one-sixth of the suns total
energy. And this happens in one second. CMEs dont just make pretty lights in
the midnight sky. Huge CMEs can knock
Most flares are small. But some are
4
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
out power. On Friday March 10, 1989, min. Solar CME storms have produced
astronomers witnessed a billion ton cloud fields as large as 2000 nT/min. However,
of solar plasma (electrically charged gas) a solar storm on May 1415 in 1921 that
wrench itself from the suns corona and disrupted telegraphs across the country
head straight toward the Earth at a million may have reached 4800 to 5000 nT/min.
miles an hour. On Sunday, March 12, the
plasma cloud reached Earths magnetic Its Not a Question of If
field, causing a geomagnetic storm. The Its a Question of When
northern lights in stunning shades of red, Under direction of the Federal
purple, and green could be seen as far Emergency Management Agency (FEMA),
south as Florida and Cuba. the Metatech Corporation carried out
a study of the North American grids
This wasnt just a pretty light show.
vulnerabilities to geomagnetic storms.
The magnetic disturbance created a
According to the studys principle
geomagnetic-induced current, or GIC, in
investigator, John Kappenman, the big
the ground beneath North America. When
reason the grid is vulnerable stems from
an EMP occurs on the high-voltage grid,
the need to transmit large amounts of
large amounts of additional current GIC
power over long distances cheaply. The
are induced in power lines. The current
fact that the grid is overstretched and
passes on to generators and transformers
overloaded makes the catastrophic multi-
down the line. Since there is so much
regional impact of a magnetic storm all
current in the system, transformers
the more likely.3
can overload, overheat, and fail or
sometimes even explode. Current operating procedures used
on the grid were adapted in the wake of
Just past 2:44 AM on March 13, 1989,
the March 1989 event and are designed to
Quebecs power grid crashed, cutting
boost operational reserves but they still
off nearly 2,000 megawatts of power to
leave us with a gaping vulnerability. They
the northeastern U.S.2 Six million people
do not prevent or reduce GIC flowing onto
lost power for nine hours. Weather
the grid.
temperatures in some parts of Quebec
were at a dangerous -15F. One of the chief hardware
vulnerabilities is the huge multi-ton
Though the 1989 storm was serious,
extra-high voltage (EHV) transformers
Canada got off lightly. Geomagnetic field
that dot switching yards throughout the
severity is measured in nanotesla per
country. Kappenman says that these giant
minute (nT/min). The 1989 storm only
pieces of vital hardware undergo well-
reached an intensity of about 480 nT/
5
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
6
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #3:
Cyber Security Malicious Code
Imagine that youre relaxing at home Twenty minutes later, your power
after a long and chaotic day when suddenly, goes out again. An hour later, it comes on.
for no apparent reason, your lights go out. Again, TV news reports the same thing:
Not only do you see that all the lights in While most had their power out, a few
the homes on your street are out, but you areas reported their power had remained
also discover the electricity is out for as far on. Twenty minutes later, your power is
as you can see. About an hour later, power out again. And the entire cycle repeats for
comes back on and you learn from local 6 more hours throughout the night.
TV news that, while power was out in a Something weird has happened.
300-mile radius for a period of time, other As you go about your daily business,
areas did not lose power.
7
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
8
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
these common tools be able to do? The official was quoted as saying, There are
risk that this exercise demonstrated is intrusions, and they are growing. There
greater than we can imagine. were a lot last year.
Exhibit B: The North American Electric Reliability
In the spring of 2007, a sustained cyber- Corporation (NERC) warned that the
attack hit Estonian government computer electrical grid is not adequately protected
systems over a period of weeks. While not from cyber-attack. Between late 2008
the biggest European country, it was the and April 2009, the Pentagon spent $100
most wired. Virtually all bank transactions million repairing cyber damage.
were electronic, and 82 percent of all tax Exhibit D:
declarations were via Internet. Nearly
On April 8, 2010, state-owned China
every school used e-learning. Internet
Telecom computers posted network
traffic to government websites normally
routing instructions that diverted massive
totaled 1,000 visits per day. The denial of
volumes of U.S. and other foreign Internet
service attack barraged their system with
traffic through Chinese servers for 18
2,000 visits per second. Government web
minutes. This included information traffic
services ceased, and three of the biggest
to and from U.S. government and military
news organizations went offline. Financial
sites, including the Secretary of Defenses
operations shut down almost all ATMs
office, and some commercial websites.
and forced the largest bank, Hansabank,
U.S. cyber-security experts warned the
to close online banking operations. In
network diversion hinted at data mining
response, Estonia closed large parts of its
and posed many possibly malicious
network to the outside world.8
activities.10
Exhibit C: At first blush, it seems that only
In April of 2009, the Wall Street Journal governments would have the capability
published a story (later confirmed by the to launch cyber-attacks. The truth is, of
U.S. government) that cyber spies from course, that anyone with a computer and
China, Russia, and several other countries the knowledge to use hacking tools and
had gained access to the electrical grid. software (all readily available online) can
The spies also left behind programs that learn how to infiltrate any security firewall.
had the potential to disrupt the U.S. The shutting down of Estonia in 2007
grid on command.9 When informed of turned out to be a unified effort (called
the pervasiveness of the breach, an hacktivism) by ethnic Estonian Russians
anonymous former Homeland Security angry at the Estonian government for
9
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
removing a bronze statue of a Russian Add to this the fact that these attacks
soldier. are being equally committed by foreign
The attack was a distributed denial- governments, angry cyber-mobs, or bored
of-service attack using zombie or bot teenagers. Installing a defense that can
personal computers that are located all match the capabilities of such adversaries
over the world, including those hijacked could become an endless cyber-arms race.
without their owners knowledge here in The DOE estimates that 60 percent of
the U.S.11 the U.S. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is
Its almost impossible to overstate tied to the grid. That means that when the
the potential security threats to the smart power goes off, two-thirds of the economy
grid. Attacks can take the form of breaches, grinds to a halt, and each hour without
deliberate reconnaissance, vandalism, electricity costs millions of dollars.12 One
network hijacking, and implantation of way or another, those lost dollars come
malware. All require effective defenses. out of your pocket.
Threat #4:
Stormy Weather the
Edge of Reliability
It hits the ground like a runaway areas, many rural parts of the country do
freight train, eating up and spitting out not. When a tornado crosses paths with
everything in its path for two and a half a 30-year-old high-tension line in parts of
miles. At 300 yards wide with 160 mph the Midwest or west Texas, whole regions
winds, nothing can stop it. can go dark for days.
Each year, the U.S. experiences an Hurricanes are less destructive
average of 1,000 tornadoes, with the most than tornadoes, but the destruction
powerful storms destroying whole towns covers a much broader area. When large
and knotting up high-voltage transmission hurricanes, like Katrina and Sandy, hit
towers like twist-ties. While some power regions of the United States, they can wipe
lines have backups in heavily populated out electrical service for the whole region.
10
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
11
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #5:
The Not-So-Smart
Smart Grid
12
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
kWh, and knowing that your cost will go and automatic protection schemes to
up during the day, you decide to set your improve the reliability of the system. The
thermostat to 80 degrees. Just before smart grid will essentially function as both
you leave, you unplug phone chargers, power grid and computer network.
the home wireless system, dial up the This is where the Smart Grids
refrigerator, turn off the de-humidifier, vulnerability lies. According to an article
and reset the water heater to vacation. published on CNN.com, it would take a
At work, you find your employer is hacker with just $500 worth of equipment
equally aware of the days electricity and knowledge of electronics and software
costs. Only some of the lights are on, and engineering to take command and
air conditioning is rationed, with priority control of the smart grids smart meter
going to servers and executives. Even the system. The smart meter, now installed in
water coolers chiller is turned off. At 11 millions of homes across the country, is a
AM, you visit the web address of your smart key point of entry for malicious hackers.
meter. You find that your electricity price
has jumped to 12/kWh. You remotely set Once in the system, a
your air conditioner higher to 82 degrees. hacker could gain control of
An hour later over lunch, you check again thousands, even millions,
and your utility has broadcast a message of meters and shut them
offering a $2 rebate for access to your air off simultaneously. A
conditioners control cycle. hacker also might be able
to dramatically increase or
You decline, hoping the rebate will go
decrease the demand for
up to $5 like last time.
power, disrupting the load
And so the day goes, with more balance on the local power
and more of your productive time being grid and causing a blackout.
sucked away to chase and tweak the real- These experts said such
time price changes of your electricity. a localized power outage
Does it sound far-fetched? Its not. would cascade to other parts
This could well be what life is like in the of the grid, expanding the
fast-approaching age of the smart grid. blackout. No one knows how
The Department of Energy has big it could get.14
described the smart grid as a suite of Malware and viruses can also be
technologies that will allow customers introduced into the system to shut it down.
and the utility to better manage electricity
In theory, a smart grid allows power
demand, and will include self-monitoring
13
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
14
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #6:
Informers in your Home
The next threat on our list isnt Your refrigerator could even put
a threat to the grid. Its how the grid together a shopping list for you, featuring
threatens you or, more specifically, your your favorite items on sale at your local
privacy. The smart grid will encourage the grocery store. In a smart-grid scenario,
use of smart appliances. Smart appliances your appliances talk about you and your
are self-monitoring and use their Internet family. Sure, it sounds convenient to have
connection to report their status to their your refrigerator tell you when its time
owners. For instance, in a smart grid to buy mustard, but a lot of information
scenario in the very near future, your can be strung together from small pieces.
refrigerator could track its energy use Your refrigerator could report its entire
and calculate its power consumption and contents to a data-collection company
operating cost for the day. for use by different food marketing
companies, including your local grocery
It can also take inventory of its
store. It could report when and where an
contents through the miniature radio
item was purchased, how often that item
frequency (RF) transmitters on labels
was used, and how long it lasted.
that are becoming increasingly common.
Walmart pioneered the widespread use of
RF transmitters in the retail industry a few
Big government
years ago, and others have since jumped
snooping in your
on the bandwagon. Stores use these labels
refrigerator?
to gather inventory information such as With smart appliances, the amount
how many cans of peas are in stock, or the of information collected on you and your
age of the boxes of mac-and-cheese. With family would be enormous. Smart TVs,
a smart refrigerator, you dont need to Blu-ray players, and cable boxes could
open the door to see what you have and instantaneously report what you watch.
how old it is. It can read RF labels and show Water heaters could report energy use
the entire contents of the refrigerator on a and flow rates to show the number of
display on the door. showers a family takes.
15
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
16
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
agencies or even corporations could Their goal is to see how much money they
create this sort of scenario, just for the can milk from people, in order to fund
purpose of stimulating sales, or even to their own activities. They really dont care
cause people to buy something that has if they are helping or harming the people
additional technology in it, allowing an they are getting the money from, as they
even greater invasion of their privacy. dont feel any sense of responsibility
towards them; after all, they are nothing
Ultimately, both the government and
more than someplace to take money from.
big business look upon the general public
as only one thing ... a source of funds.
Threat #7:
Big Business, Big
Government, Big Mess
Who gets a say in how energy gets got bogged down and delayed in state
into your home? FERC, NERC, DOE, EPA, approval procedures and red tape for
ISOs, RTOs, and a whole host of alphabet years.
soup federal agencies, as well as utilities
With EPACT05, Congress sought to
companies across the nation. Your home
streamline the whole mess. They put the
energy is smack-dab in the middle of a
grid under federal jurisdiction and gave
tug-of-war between competing entities.
FERC the ability to have final authority
Prior to the Energy Policy Act of on state siting issues. It was a power grab
2005 (EPACT05), FERC (Federal Energy for FERC literally. The act enabled FERC
Regulatory Commission) had the power to acquire rights-of-way by use of federal
to approve transmission projects and eminent domain powers to condemn
establish rates. However, each proposed private land.20 But things still were not
transmission right-of-way (referred to as simple as intended. If a state failed to
in the industry as siting) had to be act on a siting permit application within a
approved by each state that right-of-way year, or even rejected it, the transmission
entered. It was no big deal in western line developer could bypass the state
states. But projects in the Northeast often process and bring its application to FERC
17
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
for approval. Not so fast, said the Fourth regulations (not laws passed by Congress)
Circuit Court of Appeals. It muddied the could also affect natural gas power plants.
waters further when it ruled that a states About 40 percent of the nations electrical
decision to reject a project could not be generating capability comes from coal
appealed to FERC because the commission power plants, with natural gas accounting
does not have jurisdiction. for an additional 27 percent. So, these new
regulations would have a major impact
This has left several new transmission
on the price of electricity, as well as the
line projects in limbo. These projects
countrys ability to produce electrical
are being fought by local residents. Even
power.
though FERC officials are paid by the
taxpayer, they arent working for them, The new regulations were supposedly
as this situation clearly illustrates. FERC written to attack the emissions of
permits transmission companies in the greenhouse gases by these power
midst of a project facing legal delays to plants. However, for the sake of this
recoup their legal expenses by adding regulation, the EPA has determined that
the tab to consumers electric bills. carbon dioxide is a greenhouse gas. This
is surprising, as all plant life breathes in
Thats not the only clash between
carbon dioxide and breathes out oxygen,
agency rules and government energy
just as animal life (including humans)
policies. Case in point: the North American
breathes in oxygen and breathes out
Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC)
carbon dioxide. It appears that there is no
is an international regulatory authority
real reason for making this determination,
established by the FERC to evaluate
other than to attack coal-fired power
reliability of the bulk power system in
plants.
North America. Recently, it warned that
impending EPA regulations endangered The coal-fired power plants are one of
the production of 1,201 coal, gas, and oil the older parts of the grid, with 63 percent
steam-generating plants (responsible for of the plants being 40 years old or more;
generating about 252 gigawatts of power) almost half of the existing coal-fired plants
and nearly one-third of all nuclear plants are over 50 years old, already having
(about 60 gigawatts more). surpassed their expected life-expectancy.
The new regulations supposedly are
In June of 2014, the EPA proposed new
intended to make the older plants more
regulations on the emissions generated by
efficient, so that they reach the emissions
coal-fired electric power plants. These new
18
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
levels of newer plants. However, the actual Ultimately, the true goal of these
emissions levels being required from regulations isnt to make coal power
these new regulations are based upon cleaner, but to shut down the coal power
experimental technology which is not industry, a stated goal of President Obama.
ready for installation in the power plants. This would mean less power to go around
at a time when generation capacity is
This will result in the power industry
already stretched thin, increasing the
being required to shut down and replace
likelihood of power shortages.
most of these power plants, as retrofitting
them with the new technology is not Regulations continue to be debated
practical. In studies conducted by power and contracts haggled over, while
companies, it would cost more to retrofit consumers are left, literally, to sweat it out
power plants, than it would cost to build until things are settled.
new ones.
Threat #8:
Fuel Prices Up, Up and Away
Its economics 101. When demand for uses to generate electrical power are coal
a commodity increases, the price goes up. and natural gas.21 Of the two, coal is the
This is a basic truth of the market whether cheapest but not for much longer.
that commodity is beef, soybeans, or America is the largest producer of
fossil fuels such as natural gas and coal. recoverable coal, which means that the
Another truth is that many things can miners can get to the coal to mine it.
squeeze a commoditys supply and raise
In 2009, nearly 1.075 billion tons
prices, including striking workers, new
was dug out of the U.S. coal fields.22 Coal
environmental regulations or competing
is divided into four broad categories:
demand from a foreign country. anthracite, bituminous, sub-bituminous,
and lignite. Each group burns differently;
Old King Coal is Still King some burn hot and clean, while others
The two biggest fuel sources America burn poorly. Coal that burns hot and
efficiently goes to generate power in 47
19
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
20
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
21
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
By September 2008, as the financial enormous amounts in their first year, but
crisis killed investments and jobs, energy dwindling rapidly to only 25-50 percent of
prices slid. By September 2009, natural their initial amounts the following year.
gas prices dipped lower than a deflated It is widely calculated that the actual
hot air balloon. From $13.69/ average commercial life of
mmBtu prices sank by a whopping The Energy a shale gas well is seven
80 percent, to only $2.409 per Information years. Some last no more
mmBTU. Suddenly, there was Administration than four.
so much natural gas in storage was forced to
The Energy Information
that ships loaded with liquefied revise its shale
Administration (EIA) was
natural gas had no port to deliver gas production
forced to revise its shale
it. estimates.
gas production estimates,
Shale gas is
For the next several years, discovering the volume
looking more
the price of natural gas remained output was far less.26
and more like
relatively steady.
an over-hyped Companies made
So how do low natural gas gamble. massive investments in
prices threaten the grid? For expensive equipment and
starters, estimated gas reserves mining rights in the hope
might only be hype. One industry poster- that extracting fantastic amounts of natural
child is the Kardell Gas Unit 1H, pumping gas would recoup their investment. They
in the Haynesville Shale in San Augustine guessed wrong. All those hundreds of
County, Texas. In October 2009, this well
25
trillions of cubic feet of gas, unfortunately,
achieved a continuous 24-hour flow rate just arent there.
of 30.7 million cubic feet (Mcf) with a flow
The bottom line: higher fuel costs
pressure of 6,824 psi. Impressive to be
coal and natural gas will get passed on
sure but unique.
to you, the consumer.
Most wells are like big balloons, yielding
Amazing Solar Generator Is Like Having A Secret Power Plant Hidden In Your Home!
Solar Powered Backup System Provides Instant Electrical Power In Any Outage Or Disaster. Even
Better... Backup Kit Produces An Endless Supply Of Electricity For Free! There are several models to
choose from, depending on your power needs.
22
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #9:
Transmission Capacity
On Overload
Ever hear about the guy who started The 2003 reports conclusion reads:
putting up a few Christmas lights on his The system is being operated closer to
roof and used a scrawny little extension the edge of reliability than it was just a few
cord? Every year, he put up more and years ago.27 How much more true is that
more lights but kept using that scrawny today, than it was when it was written?
little extension cord. One year, he put up
Many sections of the grid in the U.S. are
so many lights that it looked like his house
just like that scrawny extension cord. They
might be seen from space until he
are analogous to a single line transmitting
plugged in that scrawny extension cord.
huge amounts of power from city to city,
It melted and set fire to his house. and theyre constantly monitored to
prevent overload. Many are 80 years old.
The official government report on the
Power lines have a maximum safe load
Great Northeastern Blackout of 2003 said
they can carry. Beyond it, they stretch,
that no utility had undertaken any major
sag, break, or even melt. Overloaded
transmission project in over a decade.
power lines pose a threat to commerce
Now, more than a decade later, the same
and national security. The Department of
can still be said. Rather than improving
Energy (DOE) estimates the annual cost of
the capability of the existing grid by
power outages to be $25 $180 billion.28
adding more transmission capability, the
Transmission utilities are required to
electrical power industry is investing in
carefully manage instances when demand
better control of the existing transmission
causes congestion. The power line wires
capability with the smart grid. Like the guy
themselves do not actually get congested.
with his Christmas lights and his scrawny
Rather, utility companies must wait to
extension cord, utilities have been pushing
transmit power because so few lines are
the system harder and harder.
available. Picture three lanes of highway
23
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
traffic trying to suddenly merge into a FERC sets the prices for transmission, FERC
single remaining lane. Flow bogs down. offers incentives that guarantee a return
According to the DOE, there are four on equity. In plain English, transmission
congested areas in the U.S.: mid-state New utilities get to charge more and these
York southward along the Atlantic coastal charges are passed on to you.
plain to northern Virginia; the urban areas
This doesnt mean they can just string
of southern California; the San Francisco
new wires. Rights-of-way must be sited
Peninsula; and the Seattle-Portland area.29
to be big enough to safely transmit high
While the FERC and its ISOs do their best to
voltage power.
prevent abuse, it does happen, especially
where state energy regulatory laws are For example, a power line corridor
overly complex. might be the right size to handle towers
for 115,000-volt lines (115kV), but be
Transmission companies can make
unsuitable for towers holding 230kV or
a killing by deliberately overbooking
even 345kV lines or higher.
the transmission schedules. Because of
complex deregulation rules in California Some of these new rights-of-way
in 2000, the state paid congestion fees as pass through national parks, schools,
an incentive for power providers to solve a and suburban subdivisions. Many people
congestion problem. During the California in various states are fighting these,
energy crisis, energy transmission concerned about potential dangers to the
companies profited from the rules by environment, health (through electro-
routinely scheduling more transmissions magnetic fields) and property values.
than they had capacity even though the Yet, the bigger threat is that new
actual demand did not exist. transmission projects also cost billions of
The answer to congestion problems, dollars. Consumers ultimately foot the bill
of course, is to build more power lines through cost-sharing agreements among
or build them with greater handling groups of states. In population-dense
capacity. Beginning in 2003, FERC offered areas like the northeast, the cost is spread
incentives for transmission line projects out around millions of people, appearing
as a shot in the arm to encourage utilities as just another fee on monthly usage bills.
to invest more in the grid. By 2004, utility But in recent years, the FERCs equity
investment in transmission shot up from incentive to the transmission industry
$2 billion to $6.5 billion.30 Specifically, since has gone from a shot in the arm to a
24
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
25
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Threat #10:
Everyone Wants Some
Its hard to imagine life in the 21st they expect to own certain things: a TV, a
century without electricity. In the past 15 computer, an alarm clock, a refrigerator, a
years, Americas use of electrical power stove, a water heater, a dishwasher, and air
has skyrocketed. We get up in the morning conditioning. And thats just for starters.
to the frantic beeping of a digital alarm Population growth between 2010 and
clock. We scrub ourselves clean in our nice 2020 is projected to be 36 million.37 Thats
hot showers with water from our electric 36 million more consumers of electricity.
water heaters. These additional 36 million consumers are
enough of a strain on the system, but add
We gulp steaming hot coffee freshly
to that the forecasts of how many people
brewed by our digitally-programmed
will be moving to the sunbelt some cities
coffee maker as we surf the news sites on
are expected to see an increase of up to
the web or listen to the news on our flat- 80% in their population38 and there will
screen TV. We turn on our cell phones and be even more of a strain on the system.
bustle off to work where we sort through Thats because in any sunbelt home, the
megabytes of electronic information, hour appliance that uses the most electricity is
after hour. air conditioning. In fact, air conditioning
All the while, generators are spinning, typically eats two-thirds of a homes
indicator lights are flashing, and high- summer monthly usage.
tension wires are humming as billions of Do we have enough coal and natural
watts of energy flood through the grid to gas to generate electricity and enough
power us through our day at work and at power lines to transmit it to support 36
home. Demand for electricity is exploding million more Americans? No.
as the countrys population grows. In
Heres why: demand for electricity
the past 30 years, urban sprawl has
fluctuates from moment to moment.
stretched the grid to power condos and
When demand is highest, usually in the
convenience stores where cornfields once
afternoon, many power plants are working
stood. As people set up their households,
at their highest capacity. Sometimes this
26
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
27
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
Completely silent
Maintenance-free For a
toxic fumes
No
Provides an endless free information
Easy setup supply
of free electricity. kit, call
1-877-327-0365
28
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
References:
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explosively_pumped_flux_compression_generator
2. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/03/090316144521.htm
3. http://lasp.colorado.edu/education/journalists/solar_dynamics_ws/papers/
lowres%20Severe%20Space%20Weather%20FINAL.pdf
4. http://homeland.house.gov/Documents/20090722115623-56876.pdf
5. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/09/100901073405.htm
6. http://www.sandia.gov/ccss/documents/Cyber_Effects_Analysis_Using_VCSE_09.
pdf
7. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eligible_Receiver_97
8. http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200910/ldselect/ldeucom/68/6805.
htm
9. http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123914805204099085.html
10. http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6AI4HJ20101119
11. http://www.upi.com/Business_News/Security-Industry/2007/06/11/Analysis-
Who-cyber-smacked-Estonia/UPI-26831181580439
12. http://www.ee.washington.edu/faculty/radha/dhs_cps.pdf
13. http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/tableb1.html
14. http://edition.cnn.com/2009/TECH/03/20/smartgrid.vulnerability/
15. http://energyandenvironmentblog.dallasnews.com/archives/2010/03/couple-
sues-oncor-over-smart-m.html
16. http://www.keepmecurrent.com/lakes_region_weekly/news/article_2c5601d0-
094d-11e0-ab1e-001cc4c002e0.html
17. http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2010/11/08/18663541.php
18. http://www.forbes.com/2009/10/21/smart-grid-utilities-business-energy-meters.
html
19. http://gigaom.com/cleantech/pges-smart-meter-report-a-case-study-of-
infrastructure-over-customer/
20. http://www.epa.gov/oust/fedlaws/publ_109-058.pdf
21. http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epm/epm_sum.html
29
Published By: Off The Grid News
BLACK OUT The Top 10 Threats To the Power Grid
22. http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/coal/page/acr/table10.html).
23. http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/coal/page/coalnews/cnmarchive.html
24. http://www.tri-cityherald.com/2010/11/16/1255129/coal-industry-seeks-to-
export.html
25. http://www.rigzone.com/news/article.asp?a_id=82017
26. http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSTRE6343RW20100405
27. https://reports.energy.gov/BlackoutFinal-Web.pdf
28. http://www.ee.washington.edu/faculty/radha/dhs_cps.pdf
29. http://congestion09.anl.gov/documents/docs/Congestion_Study_2009.pdf
30. http://fpc.state.gov/documents/organization/122949.pdf
31. http://www.pathtransmission.com
32. http://www.aep.com/environmental/news/?id=1426
33. http://www.aep.com/investors/present/documents/LazardConferenceHandout.
pdf
34. http://www.stopthelines.com
35. http://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/2010/11/18/pseg-considering-ma-
regulated-segments-drive-growth
36. http://www.pest-03.org/articles/member_application12.htm
37. http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article.cfm?articleid=1510
38. http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/papers/1319.pdf
30
Published By: Off The Grid News