Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jan Hatzius that real GDP growth will average 1½% at 4 Total 4
jan.hatzius@gs.com an annual rate for the rest of the year. Fiscal Stimulus
Inventories
212 902 0394 3 3
However, we have cut our forecast for 2011
Ed McKelvey as lawmakers’ resistance to renewing fiscal 2 2
ed.mckelvey@gs.com stimulus has risen while various headwinds 1 1
212 902 3393 to private-sector growth persist. We now Forecast
think growth will stay at 1½% in the first 0 0
Alec Phillips
alec.phillips@gs.com
quarter and then rise gradually to 3% by -1 -1
202 637 3746 year-end. At 2¼% from fourth quarter to
fourth quarter, the new profile is 0.9 -2 -2
David Kelley
easing by late 2010/early 2011 as the jobless
david.kelley@gs.com rate approaches 10%. Although it is a close 4 4
212 902 3053 call, we expect the FOMC to take a “baby
step” in this direction at next week’s meeting 3 3
Maria Acosta-Cruz by deciding to reinvest MBS paydowns in
maria.acosta-cruz@gs.com US Treasuries. Later measures would 2 2
212 902 6709 include a stronger commitment to keep rates
low and/or asset purchases of at least $1 1
Consumer Price Index:
1
trillion, most likely also in Treasuries. Rent of Primary Residence
Owners' Equivalent Rent of Residences
Exhibit 2: Fiscal and Inventory Supports Fade July. Although the extension eventually passed, this
Percentage points, annual rate Percentage points, annual rate
was more than six weeks after the benefits had lapsed
5 5 in early June. Moreover, the renewal lasts only until
Impact on GDP Growth: November, at which time it seems likely—judging
4 Total 4 from the current political climate—that any further
Fiscal Stimulus
Inventories renewal will require an offset elsewhere in the federal
3 3 budget. This would reduce the effect on economic
activity significantly. Meanwhile, a $26bn package of
2 2
federal aid to state governments barely cleared the
1 1 Senate this week, and extension of the tax cuts enacted
Forecast in 2001 and 2003, which once seemed like a done deal
0 0 for all but upper-bracket taxpayers, is far from certain
less than five months before they are due to expire.
-1 -1
This resistance was on full display during the latest 3. Consumers appear unlikely to reduce saving
debate on extending emergency jobless benefits in materially. One of the most striking elements of
the annual GDP revision was the upward revision
to the personal saving rate, shown in Exhibit 5.
1
For further details on the construction of the fiscal The household financial balance (not shown) was
component of Exhibit 2, see “The Fiscal ‘Swing’—
2
Federal, State, and Local,” US Daily Comment, July See “The End of the Road for Fiscal Stimulus?” US
28, 2010. Daily Comment, July 20, 2010.
3.00
…Raising Fears of a Double Dip… 1200
3
The household financial balance is an alternative 2 2
gauge of saving that we highlighted earlier this spring. Personal Saving Rate:
See “Housing Holds the Key to the Consumer Current
Conundrum,” US Economics Analyst, April 9, 2010. Previous
4 0 0
See “Squaring the Fiscal Circle: Could a Fiscal Rule 90 92 94 96 98 00 02 04 06 08 10
Help?” US Economics Analyst, July 23, 2010. Source: Department of Commerce.
as the minutes to the June FOMC meeting revealed Exhibit 6: Jobless Rate Signals Downturns
only a small downgrade to the committee’s growth
Percent of labor f orce Percent of labor f orce
forecast and provided only a fleeting and highly 12 12
qualified reference to the possibility that renewed
easing might be needed. Moreover, Chairman 10 10
Bernanke largely stuck to the party line at the policy
hearings in July, at least in his prepared testimony.
8 8
Chairman Bernanke also outlined three possible tools The one member who has publicly spoken on these
for further easing: (1) to strengthen the commitment to alternatives is James Bullard, president of the St.
keep short-term rates “exceptionally low for an Louis Federal Reserve Bank. In a recent paper, he
extended period;” (2) to cut the interest rate on excess argued that additional stimulus—if needed—should
reserves (IOER) from its current 25-basis-point level; take the form of purchasing Treasury securities rather
and (3) to resume asset purchases. He also said that than beefing up the rate commitment language, which
the FOMC would review all of its options, including he sees as potentially counterproductive.5 Elsewhere
the possibility of reinvesting MBS prepayments and we have shown that both have had similar effects in
redemptions. Currently, these proceeds are not being reducing long-term interest rates. However, we think
reinvested, with the result that the Fed’s balance sheet that the FOMC is likely to opt for asset purchases as
is set to shrink slowly over time. This amounts to a the more effective way to provide additional stimulus.
slight tightening bias in the current policy stance, This is because most members appear uncomfortable
albeit one that may not have much effect given the with the type of policy rate commitment needed to
enormous volume of excess reserves in the system. push real long-term rates down materially—for
example, one that promises to hold rates low until
With the IOER already close to zero, we see little to inflation rises to a certain level.6
be gained from cutting it further, other than to signal a
switch in policy orientation. The incentive for banks That said, one possibility would be for Chairman
to make new loans would increase only marginally, Bernanke, after consultation with the FOMC, to speak
while money market funds would have a tougher time out publicly about research that shows how the
eking out positive returns as yields on other short-term FOMC’s past rate-setting behavior would currently
assets moved even closer to zero. Besides, the FOMC imply a federal funds rate well below zero. By
could send the same signal by taking up the MBS suggesting, even indirectly, how long it would take for
reinvestment option. Although it is a close call, we this desired funds rate to get back to zero, he could
now expect this to occur at next week’s meeting. have a meaningful impact on market expectations.
Some of this research is ours, but notably it also
Implementation of the “bigger” options—a stronger includes contributions from the San Francisco Fed.7
commitment to keep the federal funds rate near zero
and/or more asset purchases—will require both more 5
See James Bullard, “Seven Faces of ‘The Peril’,”
discussion and more evidence of economic weakness. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review
Recall in this regard that most FOMC members are (forthcoming) September-October 2010.
starting from a more robust economic outlook than 6
See “‘Extended Period’ vs. Asset Purchases: How
ours; as recently as late June, the committee’s “central Effective are the Fed’s Unconventional Policies,” US
tendency” range for growth in 2010 was 3% to 3½%. Daily Comment, August 3, 2010.
These figures would undoubtedly be lower now, but 7
See “No Rush for the Exit,” Global Economics Paper
probably not to the point where most members see a No. 200, June 30, 2010, and Glenn Rudebusch, “The
7 7
2 2
6 6
Consumer Price Index:
1 1
Rent of Primary Residence
5 5
Owners' Equivalent Rent of Residences
0 0
4 4
3 3 -1 -1
50 55 60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05 10 06 07 08 09 10
Source: Department of Commerce. Source: Department of Labor.
We, Jan Hatzius, Ed McKelvey, Alec Phillips, Sven Jari Stehn and Andrew Tilton hereby certify that all of the views expressed in this report accurately reflect personal views, which have not been influenced by considerations
of the firm’s business or client relationships.
Time Estimate
Date (EST) Indicator GS Consensus Last Report
Tue Aug 10 8:30 Nonfarm Productivity (Q2-Preliminary) +0.6% +0.2% +2.8%
8:30 Unit Labor Costs -0.8% +1.5% -1.3%
10:00 Wholesale Inventories (Jun) n.a. +0.5% +0.5%
14:15 FOMC Meeting Results 0.25% 0.25% 0.25%
Wed Aug 11 8:30 Trade Balance (Jun) -$42.6bn -$42.3bn -$42.3bn
14:00 Federal Budget Balance (Jul) -$160.0bn -$169.0bn -$180.7bn
Thu Aug 12 8:30 Import & Export Prices (Jul) n.a. +0.4% -1.3%
8:30 Initial Jobless Claims n.a. 465,000 479,000
8:30 Continuing Claims n.a. 4,540,000 4,537,000
10:00 Fed Gov Duke spks at Chicago Fed on Reinvestment Act
Fri Aug 13 8:30 Consumer Price Index (Jul) +0.30% +0.2% -0.1%
Ex Food and Energy +0.10% +0.1% +0.2%
NSA Index 218.175 218.172 217.965
8:30 Retail Sales (Jul) +0.4% +0.5% -0.5%
Ex Autos +0.3% +0.3% -0.1%
9:55 Reuters/U. Mich Consumer Sentiment—Prel (Aug) n.a. 69.4 67.8
10:00 Business Inventories (Jun) n.a +0.2% +0.1%
11:30 KC Fed Pres Hoenig spks in Lincoln, NE on
“Too Big to Fail or Too Big to Succeed? Wall Street,
Main Street, and America’s Economic Security”