Optimising crude
unit design
Real retrofit examples demonstrate how crude units can be successfully optimised with
the crude slates currently being processed. Process design strategies are discussed in detail
and highlight how retrofit targets are achieved
Soun Ho Lee and Ian Buttridge GTC Technology
ihe basic function of a crude
| distillation unit (CDU) Is. to
provide initial separation of the
‘tude oil feed mixture into the desired
factions to be further processed in the
downstream units. The crude unit's
quality of pesformance impacts heavily
con the downstream unit's performance,
A lot of crude units currently operate
With different feed slates to their original
feed specifications. This change in feed
‘composition often results in inferior
‘crude unit performance and reduces
the units run length. Reoptimising
the design and operation of the
crude unit with current feed slates
is essential to maximise a refiner’
economics. In addition, recent crude
cil price fluctuations and increased
economle pressure further emphasise
the importance of optimising crude unit
performance.
Crude atmospheric column
The crude atmospheric column Is the
CDUS core piece of equipment. In a
typleal crude unit design, crude oll is
hheated and introduced to the cnade
atmospheric column's fash zone. The
light products are typically recovered a5
distillates from multiple liquid product
duaws. and the remaining crude is
discharged atthe column's bottom. The
‘original process aangement relied on a
Single top refx flow. The column top
reflux provided condensation for all the
required product draws, plus. the
foverflash, This approach created high
Variations in the intemal vapour-liqud
trathc throughout the column (from
column top to flash zone), with a
‘maximum rex loading a the top and
the lower wash section receiving only a
small amount of liquid, wash oll. The
columns were then sized according to
the greatest load, top section intemal
trafic, which resulted in an oversized
column diameter. Moreover therequlted
size of the overhead condenser was
substanvilly increased
To minimise these liquid. traffic
variations, Inter-condenser design
Jay J Ha GS Caltex Corporation
sage
Pumparound
reflux
Falatve stage locaton
‘elstve nana molar iid ate
Figure 1 Comporison of internal-eflux rates for three methods of providing reflux
| t= oft
| “tse
ke
one
es |
Figure 2 Typical crude atmospheric column overhead configurations
philosophy was adapted in the crude rate variations through the crude
atmospheric column design. Inter atmospheric column {from column top
condensers can be configured a either to flash zone) among three reflux
pumpback or pumparound circuits. methods.’ The pumparound reflux
Figure 1 compares typical internal reflux method achieves more uniform liquid
Pra c2 2009 61oft as
Unsabatied
op PA naphtha
— seca
Kerosene
Figure 3 Crade atmospheric column configurations — previous retrofit
balancing through the column than the overhead _condenser_size/limitations.
other two reflux methods. This ‘Typical crude atmospheric column
“uniformity of liquid enables the column overhead configurations are depicted in
to be sized at a smaller diameter for Figure 2 for cases A.C. Case A shows that
reduced investment cost, The higher the top section reflux is provided by a
pumparound draw temperaturesincrease top pumparound circuit only. In this
the opportunity for heat recovery for configuration, the column — top
lower energy consumption. In addition, temperature is relatively high and the
‘the overhead condenser size Is reduced, chance of water condensing at the
The main trade-off is that the column top can be minimised. In
pumparound circuit design requites addition, the overhead condenser size
more trays and/or packing for heat can be minimised due to a lack of top
transfer performance. In summary, the reflux stream. However, the top
advantages of the pumparound reflux pumparound trays and/or packing do
arrangements far outweigh any not contribute towards fractionation,
‘disadvantages, and as a result it has An additional fractionation section is
replaced the pumphack reflux method required to achieve the desired
inmost modem crude atmospheric fractionation between the overhead.
‘column designs. distillate and the first side product,
The presence of a top pumparound which increases the overall column
‘ircult depends on overhead distillate height.
yield/fractionation requirements, Case B depicts a crude atmospheric
‘column top temperature control and top section with a top reflux without a
62 wa 02 209
top pumparound circult This top reflux
temperature is usually lower than the
reflux through the top pumparound
circuit. In this case, fractionation
performance between the overhead
distillate and the frst side product can
be maximised at the given column
Iheight. However, the required overhead
‘condenser duty ishigher and the column,
top temperature is lower than for
Case A
Case C is somewhat of a compromis-
ing design between Cases A and B, This
configuration has a top reflux irigation
line as well asa top pumparound circuit.
‘The amount of cold reflux (from top
reflux) and hot reflux (from top
pumparound) can be controlled at given,
processing conditions, This configura-
tion is suitable forthe crude atmospheric
‘column, which faces high variations in.
‘overhead distillates and yields
Crude column intemal vapour and
luguld wafficrely heavily on pumparound
‘circuit locations. The number and
location of pumparound circuits are
determined by crude slate structures,
product yield patterns, fractionation
equlrements, overhead condenser size
and other factors. The crude atmospheric
‘column is designed to provide the best
performance for specific ranges of crude
slates and product yields. Therefore, a
large change from design conditions
‘may induce performance downgrading
in the crude unit. Fractionation
performance between adjacent products
requires specific design internal reflux at
a given number of fractionating trays or
packed bed depth. Crude overhead
condenser duty Is also determined by
design heat balances.
In most cases, the actual crude slate
structures processed in the crude unit