10  3 
1390 
1-18 


 !" 
 
     
  

2
! "#$ 1  

%& ' ()   

 *+  ,./ 45$ 67: ;:. +   :
>?$@ #   @, A  B C  ! 6  D 45$  ,$ <=
 ! (.J= #'  I'  ,$ ;#@H . F. 
 (,# E#&
M?C   @  @, L (.J= #' ( BK , K .@, A
6Q@?$ 6,P?) ;  O, .@@K :  ! #  (C, *&"N  @@K '
? 6,P) ;  I'  . $  (.J=   
  D *! #R#K
(?.J?= F?R  ?$  B!) ,$ *! #R#K 6Q@$ B S (
(K O, +  6,P) ; . $  :T = ;  ; R @& B 
 ( T@ 6,P) (/ BTS . $  FQ 
#) ? R# U B  $
V?#W  B7Q +@ B  $  B@
$)  BC=% *&"N (/.  (,7
V?#W Y? . ?$  R$ (# & V#W  (!$ *LT X  *&"N
*?! ?#R#K B?K Z @K BK Q/   @K #>   B> R X ,
 @ ,$  $ 
 B> Q@  (.J=    
  D
 (.J= #'   ! 
 B  B> *! #R#K MC X ;  R$
(?$  ? D *?! ?#R#K !  (.J= A   @, ' $ 
.@, A  


 !
"# $%  ! # $%    
 :


.& '(  ! $%

  [ # 

 VZ;#   (K (Q
 .1
  [ # 
 VZ;#   (K (Q
 .2
1390/06/28 :BZA : \
1390/09/20 :BZA  U`) \
  :BZA Xa @
E-mail: osanlou@gmail.com
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (   ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 2

#$
( ?!  J?) (?,:  ?)? ! /  B (! ,  T (
 b
*?!  L?K B>  @: &    B / Q ! B c#% d,
*?! #R#K  B ef K b &  +@ B 
  .  
.) / ($   B>
?5#W (,'  AZ N B B.@H VA V& ;# *NC  VA *"T
$ b   *&"N U)  #d#) h& g< ; BK @K 7K R
?C, B? ,V  BK  C  #d#) (, #T'  #   ; .
?@? ;#?@d, ?,?$ .[30] $ V#! $  B> *! #R#K  
? ?@, 6,K  .#d#) BK ,$ .[10] @, 6,K  @@K k`S  .#d#)
?5#W *?##n #lm? V?A  ?! ?! c?#$  ?@@K T$  K 7K 
.#d#) @, E#C5 (,c#$ @@K k`S  .#d#) BK ,$ .@@K +:W
 AZ? ?o  g?@  c,  e#K ( , (QS   @, BT$ 
? ?,\?$) (?,B@7. ;    B.@H ' (,V=  @, 
5#W
(.J=  ,$ ;#@H p#W  qr *% BT$  .[22] @, ' B+="
?K *?##n  .?#d#) ? ? ?,?$  `?)E?#C5 #?   #.
(?, ?#' .?@@K? tR=   U)  (.J= (, #' ,$ ; .[43]@,
 B H  k`S  &"N BH @K ;##T BK $ ,B  (B&Q (.J=
.[41] #. ' +  #& BH MC ;    #R
h& #d#) p#W ; BK @@K #ZT: '  ) # 5#W  ,$ 
.@? B? ?$ (?,?S!  .?. (?, ?  *% 
 
? ? ?A  ?Q  ?
 *?K  ,?./ e?K ?+@ B ,$
B?K ?,?$ .?@, BT$  !  (.J= #'  ,/ (,%  , 
*?&"N  ?@@K ?' M?C ? ? @  @, L (.J= #' (
*! #R#K @,r ,$ Bd@H ;@ .[34] @@K :  ! #  (C,
F?R ?! (?,?$   *?< ?@@K ? ?R  E#& * B  !
.@, ' +   (.J=
.?#. *? ?$ *?! #R#K 6Q@$ =  (/  T$ 6,P) ; 
?:T *?! ?#R#K ?=  ; R @& B   (.J= FR +@ ;
 .c??K $  (.J=    
  D *! #R#K  cK
3 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

(?$  ? B?> *?! ?#R#K /  R$   BK c#, Z XC B $ ;
(?+ ?C ?$ B +@ ; .#Q@$    Q (.J=    $
BTZ5   *! #R#K 6Q@$ (,X  T#$ q#N  c#!) MC ;  S
B? *! #R#K 6Q@$ (,X BK , 
  FQ (,6,P)  .c '
B? 6,P?) ;?  ?@  .B:  ' R$   (.J=   XT N
? ? ?
 ? D *?! #R#K 6Q@$ +@ B R X b uN XC
V?  *?! ?#R#K  B5  `.#l c V& BK (W B c#,  (.J=
;?  B?K  ?' ?$ ?  .. (,BC@S   *! #R#K BCZ .
*?! (?@/: ?#R#K  *?! ?@: ?#R#K .?   / ?$ XC B 6,P)
 ?S *?# ? B? (BrK (,6,P) ($ b FQ  +@ ; .c#
?  *?! ?#R#K 6Q@$ qr (,X ;#@d, c#!) $ (.J= =
 ?
 ? D *?! ?#R#K 6Q@$ B@#  c (,#n  c ' $
 ;:?. b?K   K E#R  (.J= #n   ,#n ; Jv$ .c >$@
.c B>  6,P) R X ,#n E#' >$@ S  BTZ5 (+ C
c?)? ?$ (?.J= =  S (+ C  B  6,P) ; 
 R?$   c#@K uN *! #R#K  ! (,$  B5   w=C Jv$
*?&"N V?#W  B?7Q h?W B?  c#?@K? B?>  6,P?) R X eZ5 ;
.c) 6,P) (,@
#)  Y B>   (/IS

%&
  '
() : !"
 ?)  K Q ! #) S  ! B C ! T  #T ,$  :
q?T .?@@K? ($  ! ON S  ! B C 6!     )
:c#@K   ; ;&  ! B BK $  B> (.J= #'  (T
p#?W x?%!   FL *&"N $ b / EN  BK $ (@: (.J=
I?'  .[15] ?@K? V?& / [$  K #R  *&"N ;  K eK 6:N
 [? .[9] ?@,? ?@T ?! k?Q B? / EN  : BK $ (@/: (.J=
? V&  *&"N B#S  #R QS ( ;#:N VT @& B  (.J= ,
? ,F7#  (B&Q  (.J= ;K$ .[28] @@K qT *&"N / [$
J) .[20] @K r
 V&   #R D (  $ (,B  ,$ BK
.[31] $ V&  ($FR VA KK  (T @H B) ( $ (.J=
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (  ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 4

 B?N 5#W BC  ! D [$  ,$ T@ (,BC U  E5

 ? ? I@  , #ZT:  pC XC (,F7#  BC E5@  ! @,z (.J=
.[7] @@K VT
7?Q e?S B?K ?K >$@ (.J= #' (  x! .P R, b XK
V?z u? B ,.P ; . @$  #R c: Vw ,@: $  (.J= 
:@,
b? p? . g .J=  (.J= . ($ ,  B
 (.J= -1
, . VT  Q ,/  E#C5 ( BK ,  65#W    K
#?R  ?#CT  *?&"N U?) ?: ? BK @K V& K #: Bw B $
?   ( (,VT  BK $ &S $ b , .[41] `. #lm h=C
b @& B   pC (#. @:  ( *"T ; EN    E

 ?| (Q?S  $ b .[44] #. ' + ,$  A#C5  ) BZA
, $ ;   6! ON p#W  *"T EN  6! , K 
.[34] @K qT  @# Bd/ (.J= EN   6!
?@: 1978 X?$  }?7@# . ?$ B?`. (,BQ B  J) (.J= -2
 ,?
 V?' (?, Z @& B  /   ' $   $  ($ C,
 B!$   H B`. kQ ( J) .[36]  qT B`. (#.c#% :
?,: wK .$ 
 N!  $  *#% `!   H  $ b  ~@,:
B?K Bd/  
# ,B .[13] $ B`. (,B [$  $   FQ *#& 
?$  .?? B!?$ B?`. #?R [?$   B!$ @/ @#6#) [$ 
 ?$ ?$ ?  B?: 
   (/IS *&"N [$  .\$) W
.#. ' #lm W C' (,#R  & [$   *&"N BK $ 
 ?S V? ;? ,$  . $ @T  (,p#W @@KS (.J= -3
#R +@ B ef F $ *#=  . S / ##n   $ l p#W BK
.?@@K? cQ ,6r /  ,!  = S  #Km   p#W  ! '
.?@@K? (?@B?ACN ?,/  R c+ Q +@ B   r
 (,6r ,/
., ##n  @,z (,X  BK @K E!  ,B
  Q (,!$
?  ?: B : b : &S (,BZA  . &S BC@S (.J= -4
o=  *#% ,$  . Z#!  T'   S $ ;  $ B
;?@ . [17] ?? `! K @,! S  *#% / BK   6    
5 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

(?,V?T  D?
 ? ?K E?N  BK $ ,z # T  (BC $
D?
 c?: ?@T B? ?@ &S (.J= .[24]  F  BT$ B &S
b?  ?W g?S *&"N U) . V 7#  D
 (,BQ B  #
.[35] ,  $  W  XC B W gS  @,: !$
?$ ?K $ $ BL   (.J= FR b . $ F (.J= -5
*?&"N B$#) (,S ,/ .@, BNf *&"N S  : ,$  .[40]
' b .@@K r$  ,/  "& , #T' (.J= (  K B B 
?@T  ; .[29]  D V=   V
 @& B $ ; *&"N S x!
#?R  ?#CT B?K ?$ ?@T  B #. * F *&"N (/IS BK #
B$#) * B W (, K . FQ F * B  (/IS *&"N
r?$  [?C' B? C? F? ?N B  BH Z ) *&"N (/IS B
B? r?$  [C' ;  @@K F'  (/IS *&"N B$#) S  *&"N
. $ "K  ! (,VT 45$  , D B # V#Z
,? .?@K? 7?K ?,/  Cr@   K B# VL , B (.J= -6
B?K ?@? U?) (: p$ ,!$ ; .@, ($ (@/ (,!$ er@
 (? e?r@ ,? .?$? R# R $ ; BK  Bd/  (}7 J=
 .@@K V& E: # ;  @ ,/  FK , @  @# c V& B 
B?K B?d/ B? ?,? u?  ?,/ ?#A: ?@, FQ  Bd/ BK $  ;
B? ? k! BQ# BK  g< ; B  B ; ,$  .K (7B
e?'  ? ?QK B?   ' QK     O, ( $ BK / $
 .?  B? 6,? S B? C? ?$ 6   er@ ,  F &
? B?Q (?, ?#T' B  @T !@ #ZT:    (.J= FR ,$
.[45] $ 7K
B?@ B? B?S ? .$ + B $ ,| B  E#' B/  
# (.J= -7
qW $  $ *&"N b#R B=  @   #!   ,  :
M? *?&"N q?W ? ?#T' ($$ B V V& F @,  : .#. *
.#. ' T B=  / $  '  $ J= #ZCA $ c Bd/ @  

!0& 
,-. /
0) ! ! + *!"
e#K ;#@d,  7 Q ( :  (#. +@ B !@ .#d#) (a
$ #:|  $ *C& (C, .#d#) .[19]  B:. K B g@ (,DW
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (   ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 6

? ?' B?  

5#W .#.c#% .(T @H * B 65#W #R  D 
(?,u?N .[27] ?@@K kr ! B#Z B [$   ,C,  @, ' $
 ?K X?C'  *?&"N B?K ?@@K V& &"N .QS (,!$ @& B B#Z
B?> +@ B DW  r
 ( ,uN (.J=  .@@K @,  *#&
*?+=" ?$ 45?$  .[16] ?? B?:. ?K B ; (,KK  ,@
#)
?#T'  D ?,V?  B?Q u"?  k?r (? ,uN @& B (C,
. K B (C,
~@Z .@@K #ZT: AZ ,$ (,uN @& B x! 5#W ' ;@H
(?C, (#.c#% ( !@ kHH @& B  (C, T H [37] , 
?W (C,   T H ; ."K p#W  X%W (
 e#' :K $@
7?K V?TRZ  AZ? (?C' ? We#' $ b .  K B $ b 
b? .?@K? ?#K O,  ! E>"&  W(
 $ b BKZ= .@K
b? . B?# ?
rl  ?#R#K ?  ?@K 7K $ V!  WX%W $
(?C, ?+  .?@K #Km T@ p#W  ! (,  h=C  Wp#W $
 ?K u"?  VT  ! @@K #R  #CT  ! p#W BK  #d#) (,$
 e?#K  ?#d#) ?5#W *?&"N BK   #' ;  @@K R$ B.@H T 
u"?  V?T (? ?$ ?#:| ?@& B 5#W .#d#) ;@ .[27] @@K B7Q
 $ (.J= V=  !@ ; BH . . qT (T @H (, Z=  65#W
. $ 5#W c>"& B ,@T  ($FR  (`.K B#$ B , #T'

!( 4 !
&
" 1  23  ! ! + *!"
B?>  ?Rr (?,.? B?K  (? .?@@K K?
 (C, (#.c#% @:
??# ??,  R??$ ?? ??#ZT: B?? x??%!  c#??% .??@K?? ??#. ??@,??
C? (? ?, (#.c#% .[37] $ (.J=  ' ;  $ .#.c#%
 #T kr  ,B@7. ; B # #T' V#W V @  [22] $ T 
U?. (? ?$ (?o& U"? (#.c#%   *C& B .[39]  V 7#
. $ (.J= V BK $ ,B@7. kr * B c#,R
X?N  q?r (?,.? e#K  7 @& B B.@H (,. ;:. + 
x%!  $ .#.c#% (, V ,. ; . qT (#.c#%
7 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

D   ?  ! p#W  ,$ (#.c#% @:  . $ (S (, #T'

.$ J= E#& D  W5$



 5&6 78)
B @,z % . M / *!  $  (
 *K B $ @,z %
 ?$/ 7#: #T' # NC (, #ZT:  #' (BR#| #R#K  $ #R#K
.   $ @KK :    eT (7# 
;,z  $ @,z % Bd@H .@K V& #: b @& B $ @,z %
? B? ?@/:  BQ#  MC  (
 ; BK "
  k! ! (

B$#) * B *"
 . . B:.  @,z % B#$ B (  L=
Z= ;#@H  . R@ @,z %  Ur FQ$ Cw @,z % , (
.[11]  @,! D BK $ (7#H /    X= B R#K *"



 !" 9
;
 $    pC (,(a  (,6,P)  (.J= $ AT 7#Q.
/  ? BK $ &S $@
 ' c#,R BS  (.J= #' .$ @f
. R$  h=C = 
  ?,DW @KK B H BK  qT N; (.J= $ b ;5 
 ?? e?K 5H ,kHH ; B@  #. K B ! R (,kHH
. ($ ,$ @:  pC & EN  F N B B H
 ?@,!? ?,$  : BK $ (! (,@:  V (.J= FR
 @,: (W  *&"N U) @: (.J= .@ ,/  V& W  , 
$ *! B> e#K H (T 7:   @  , 4#<  @: /
(?W   K D B  @,: (,X  *&"N U) @: B 6  
.[11] #$


   5)
 !
&


;#@d,  6! (A +@ B !  (#Z K , @K kQ  ' 
,B$  , K #A: ., A C' $ ;#   !  S  @K U" (/$
? ? `?.#l V& $  C'  
  
# BH , !@ .  ( = 
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (   ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 8

B?K ?, K? . ?$ B?: 67: *!   ' #! (,X$  "& B . $
 ? ?Q *?##n B @  @@K eK 
 *+  ,#  W#W !@
 .?@@K ;#?o ?C' ?$ B? C?  ?! ?#A: ?@ @, C$@ \$) 
67?: .?#.? ?' B?S K  (7K B, @& B (
 ! (,$
 ?/ (?,B?$!  *?+ 45?$ 67: / IC B  
 6  ,,./ 45$
. $ B!$  (S 6ZH   ,$ ; ! (,$
;#? ?R (?@T .?@K? q?T R N B  #R#K  @@KO% 
?@#& .P  BC@S b V # #R#K .@K Q 7 #   #R#K
*?!  L?K B? : @,z 6@K #.  #R#K BKZ=  $   
?Q *?R ?,*?o' # BK $ L #C BS  () #R#K ;@ . $
.[33] @K

57< / !
&=  5>

  !23 53
0 
(?,#n , B ,$ & 6Q@$  *! #R#K 6Q@$  $ (,X
X?S ;? .? B> B"! N B 2  1 XS  / C#
) ba C  M
p?$ ? B?> R X 7S (W B b ,   (,X BK @, 

.@@K #>  EAW
 B  "(@/:"  "@:" T  B (W B BK / ,X 1 XS 
  @?, (?@/:  @: T  B *! #R#K b#R B M C#
) C I' 
(?@/:  ?@: ?#R#K T   X (,#n B (W B BK / ,X 2 XS
"?C& ?#'" "*?! ?#'" "*?! W?" "[W V&" V *!
.K  "Z,"  "N! @#N" ".\$)"

+ D,6C EF G D / BC @% >  ! $% ( A .1 > ?

$%" A + D,6C ( A $%" A + D,6C ( A
+ D,6C EF G D
> "  !
"# > "  ! #
@,z F @#& r$ [21] *! #R#K (T B$ X

*! c#$ #R#K *! c#$ #R#K [8] *! #R#K (BZC F+ [#A
:$ @: #R#K
  H :@/: (BR#| #R#K [25] . X
(7#H BH
9 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45
  ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 10
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  ( 

&?@ 57< /

 X? (?,#n E?AW p$   (+ C  B:. * *TZ5  R$ 
 ? ! + Jv$ .
. r$ R X b eZ'  / 6Q@$ (,!
  $@ (,!  ,#n  B5  ,
 #$  ,b eT $@K
? ? ;#?@d,  ?,#n #?r  E#R V# +@ B  B> R X
 ? F?Q (?,BC=?%  V?= Y . : ,(a   >$@ (,#n
X? (?,#n ? ?&  ? ?$@ (?,#n X? *?! #R#K #n  B5
?T  ? $@ (,#n    V= (@IS  !$ EC5@ $)
?= ? 1 X?S ? ?$@ (,#n BK  /  K= *! (@/:  @: #R#K
?#R#K =  6,P) R X FQ$ BK  .$ $) X   
 @: #R#K X ;  . $  B> Vz (,#n  (@/:  @: 6r   *!
 `?. #l *! @, B> $ @,z %  $ ($   B> (@/:
(.J= FQ$  `. #l ,/  (.J=  
   Q @,z %
?#R#K ?  ?,? V  $  B> *!  / D 
   Q
? FQ (,BC=% Y BK $ Kz B FL .`. #l 
  D *!
*?! ?#R#K  ? (.J= @,z % (,#n  # 
H *##n X& B Q@
.
 
  D

/ BC @% > .1 H&

11 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

  ! BS  T' $ B BK *! @: #R#K : ! # $% .1
 (?
 B?K ?$ (7?#H / $ .#. '    B> ! B@  T
? ?@#& (#? B? ?@@KO?% p?$ ef  ! $ .@K : $
?#'  *?! W? [?W V& V& B$ V *! @: #R#K .[25] 
. $ *!
 ?,B?  ,?@/: #R#K B #&  @/: #R#K :  !
"# $% .2
?#R#K *! O%  #Z c, B BS  .  
 B *! B>  #Z
;? .?#.? '   (
 ($  ! FQ F @,  XT N B @/:
(#? B? e?f    ! @@K :  @@KB> ;# VT B  #R#K  %@&
?.\?$) ?C& ?#' V?& V *! (@/: #R#K .[25]  D @,z
. $ Z,  N! @#N
M? ?#R#K  W5?$ B  D *! #R#K :& '(  ! $% .3
?&  /  J?)  ?$ (?$   B> *! : ;#= (
 BK 
45?$ ? ?   K 
#  &  D 45$ ; .@K D $
?&  B#Z +  & 45$  T &  < . +  &
.[8] $ *+ /   D

&?@ 
AB
59C 
AB
? ? ?
 ? D *?! ?#R#K 6Q@?$" X V&  b , ;# -1
. S (@T  Cw MC ,/ B M (,!  " (.J=
S (@T  Cw MC *! #R#K T  b ,  "@,z %" V& ;# -2
.
. S (@T  Cw MC / T  "*! @: #R#K" V& ;# -3
. S (@T  Cw MC / T  "*! (@/: #R#K" V& ;# -4
. S (@T  Cw MC " (.J=" V&  "@,z %" V& ;# -5
 ?Cw M?C "? D *?! ?#R#K" V?&  "? (?.J=" V& ;# -6
. S (@T
  ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 12
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  ( 

(?! B?ZA ;?  ?&: *#?<: Kz  e5  LN  (#.S V#Z B
.cK

&?@ 5
D
? ? ?
 ? D *?! ?#R#K 6Q@?$ ?<= 6,P) O, BK Q/ 
g?  R#? *?&"N (/. W +   (K O, +   $  (.J=
.[3] $ T5A U / U  $ 
#)


,-. ! HEFG !
&D
: $  u B 6,P) ;  *&"N (/. (,U ;c
BC?  (B?rK I?@  R?$ : ?@ (Q?S  (BrK *TZ5
*?#  (?+ C B@#  *&"N (/. S ( @) *&"N S
.g< 6,P)
 ?,b? eT? ?$@K  ?  BC=% :(BC=%) :
K (,6,P)
V?# ?+@ B? ?,/ (,@?
#)  *+ (/IS S ,
 #$
.,(a   >$@ (,#n   ;#@d,  ,#n #r  E#R
 B7Q ( *&"N  , (/IS +@ B :(B@
$)] # (,6,P)
.V#W

#
@ 5

@  5
 "?$ /  [? #  (,
 #$ p$ B@
$) ; (W C&
. ?$ ?! FL ?C&   $ B:. ' #m  B:= ; +e=  R @H
? . ?$ ? R?$ ?& V?#W  B@?
$) & C& 6Q@$ +@ B ;#@d,
 ?+ ? (?,!? B@?
$) ?/ B?K  r
  & V#W  R$
 X$ 33 V 6,P) ; #W X  S (,#n .[4] #!  @K (#.
R 170V (B B@
$) & C& 6Q@$ S . $  K V& R, eZ'
.cK kr *) @& B    (,b qr eT   $@K 
 J?) . 0/5  K B@
$) X$ B$ ( V= D & V#W (S  J)
13 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

B? KMO X?S ' #n 30 (  & V#W Q FQ  #n B$ ; O`=
B?= ;#  / $ B *K XS ;#@d, K #>  , RK / $
? 7?# B@?
$) ?) 6Q@?$ ?+@ B? . #>  *L$ B#K & V#W FQ
?$ ? 83 XT BK ? . BC$W CK (RZ/ e< SPSS 7:F  R$
. B@
$) & #' @,
 / $ e< ./

!"#37F3 !
&D  #37F3 % *!
H #(
G
R? b? V'?= ( B?K ,?=  :  (B&Q  $ *C& (/ BTS b
/ B?TZ5 ? B?K $ (/ BTS  &: B&Q b 7# B . .[3] @ D

?<= 6,P?) (?/ B?TS .[4] ?, c#T (/ BTS VK B  BQ# $ ' EAW
+  W (/ BTS ; BK S /  . $   (,b qr eT V
/ $ B X:  6,P) ( #  (B cQ= BC$W S  $  B:.
. $ / $ B 332 B T  [1]  R$ W (/ BTS  B


,-. I9J)  #+) !
&D
B?>  ? D *?! ?#R#K   (.J= ;# MC 6Q@$ ( 6,P) ; 
$  R$ (# & V#W  (!$ *LT X  B@# ;  R X
. $ LISREL 7: F 6,P) ;  R$  7: F .[3]

&?@ !
&# B

?S! B BS  ., 
 6,P) *#<:  b , (  X7#Z S! Vz V
5  ?K / ?A B?d@H B?K ?/ $ B C df  2 A c#A  A X7#Z
? 6,P?) ;? X?  C? ; A . $ X U  e$@ @, 
 
? X? ;#r  / $ B RMSEA A ;#@d, . $ 5  bHK  O"!
B? A ;  K 6,P) X (,6r B,  7# A ; BK  0/08  bHK
0/9  
#  7# X ;#r  / $ B IFI  CFI A ;#@d, . $ / $
B BS  K N B .[5] @ 0.9  L / $ B & ; X ;  BK @
!? ?WZ  6,P) R X BK c#. BQ# X ;#r  / $ B &
: $   
 Vz XS  X U (,! A . $ k! # e$@
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (  ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 14

> J
I! & .3 > ?

2 df P-value RMSEA CFI IFI

213.39 104 0.00 0.079 0.90 0.91

(?@T X? (@T & 6 Z=  (# & V#W  R$  ;#@d,
? e?< b? . ?$   6 X (,6r  b , B M e< b b
?b?HK -2 ?&   }7 2 &  / (@T &   @T B@ ( )
BK :. BQ#   @ 2  }7 / $ e< B#K X ;  BK .
X? #?R  V?=  ?C, (,? B BS  .@, @T X (,) B#K
B?#K) ?$ ;#?r ?Z=  ? (.J=   ,$ *! #R#K 6Q@$
X *#<: BK :. BQ#  (@T e< B#K) (@T e<  ( Cw ,
B?> R X  . #> UBN &: *#<: B#K , B 6,P) c
 
. $ C$@ X 6,P)  

(
( A (Q / *G $O  (
G >) / BC  K# L M >NO ? ! .2H&
15 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

&?@ 
<@  !"# 3
? (?.J=   
  D *! #R#K 6Q@$ O,  <= 6,P)
F  R$   (/IS *&"N   B> R X +@ ; . $  FQ
(?,B?: (?@C ? (?#.B?Q# 6r ;  . :. ' V#W  B7Q  X7#Z 7:
B?> 6,P?) Y?  b , x%!  (K *@
#)  $ B:. * 6,P)
:BK , 
 *&"N V#W  B7Q Y . $ 
 / $ B  C, A B#K BK Q/  . #> 6,P) R X .1
X  / $ B (@T e< B#K  @, @T  Cw *&"N V#W  B7Q
?? @
#) @  . #> 6,P) R X ;@ @, @T (&
 R?$ ? ?#. ?K B   (.J=   *! #R#K 6Q@$ X ,$
 ? ?./ ? B? !  B> *! #R#K  X ;   qT p  V&
.#. K B  (.J=   $ *! #R#K A   / Y
(?$  ? B?> *?! ?#R#K  
  D *! #R#K 6Q@$ .2
;  (.J=  @,z % H &  $ pC (@/:  @: T   $
?T ?E?#' 6Q@?$ ?+@ B ,$  @
#) @  .@@K VT  MC
6Q@?$  (@/:  @: T    *! #R#K 
 B  B> *! #R#K
?#R#K ?E?#' ?$ ?+@ B 6,P) X T   :T (,#n   @, '
.@@K R$ $ *!
 *?! @: #R#K T *! #'  *! W [W V& V& B$ .3
 *?! ?#R#K (?@/: ?T Z,  N! @#N .\$) C& #' V& H
?
   ?@,z % $ ($  *! T ;  b , B> W .Q@$
6Q@?$ ? ?/ BK    (.J= Q h& @,z % ;  @K Q
V?&  ? ? (.J= BK Q/  . $ MC  
  D *! #R#K
(.J=   @
#)  $ 
  D *! #R#K  `.#l (#K
E?N  / ?T  c#,R   Y ! (,$ x%rZ& ,$  
B?@ $  
 B *! @, B> @KK P B $ @KK B U/
. BT$ ,$   (.J= (, #'  
?Q (?.J=  $ ($   : *!  
   / .4
?R ?   .VT b 6A V& ;  $ MC  $ / ($    
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  (   ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 16

 P? B? *?! ?#R#K h?W ?#,  ?,  ' p B BS  .@K
?%r  6 * $  B  A  B5   @
#) ! (,$
 ?#$ ?  ? (7?B? ?' B? 
 B R#K *! B> S @KK
!  ,$ ; $ FL I'  . Y  B *!  LK B>  (@/:
?%& (?) (#  BK H v *! B> B  (.J=     ##n 
.@K ;##T  ,$ K= # BK $ (`.#l V&  ; <=

E

?
 ? (?/ V#W -   / K  / (1387) %@ @ X& z/ .1
.F S  $
7?K ? & 6r  *! #R#K 6Q@$ (1382)  = ( Z .2
. T@ *A#AW  U/
? (?: F&  E#AW (,U (1385) (Q= BZ. [C& , $ .3
.B./ 

#?? ??W  C>?? ??W  ??  E??#AW (??,U (1381) ?? ??$ .4
.F H 7B   6,P)  U/ Z& B$  (S)
(cS?) >@# (n *Z X"S & V#W $/ (@, (1380) V) ;"K .5
. $ 

?  ?
 ? *?! ?#R#K  (1384) T $#K < #$ ;S#$ .6
.6
7. Abrahamsen Morten H., Henneberg Stephan C. & Naud, Peter. (2012).
Sensemaking in business networks: Introducing dottograms to analyse network
changes. Industrial Marketing Management, In Press, Corrected Proof,
Available online 18 February 2012.
8. Adliagan, A. H., & Buttle, F. A. (2002). SYSTRA-SQ: A New measure of
bank service quality. International Journal of Service Industry Management,
13, 362-338.
9. Adobor, Henry. (2005). Trust as sensemaking: the microdynamics of trust in
interfirm alliances. Journal of Business Research, 58, 330-337.
10. Boisot, M., & Child. J. (1999). Organizations as adaptive systems in complex
environments: The case of China. Organization Science, 10, 237-252.
11. Boulding, W., Moore, M. C., Staelin, R., & Corfman, K. P. (1994).
Understanding managers strategic decision making process. Marketing
Letters, 5, 413-426.
17 )))))))))))))))))))))))))  
 (   + ,6 & '(  ! $% /45

12. Brandy, M. K., & Cronin, J. J. (2001). Some new thoughts and conceptualizing
perceived service quality: A hierarchial approach. Journal of Marketing. 65,
34-49.
13. Brown, A. D., & Starkey, K. (2000). Organisational identity and learning: A
psychdynamic perspective. Academy of Management Review. 25, 102-120.
14. Burns, T., & Stalker G. M. (1961). The management of innovation. London:
Tavistock.
15. Cardon, Melissa S., Stevens, Christopher E. & Potter, D. Ryland. (2011).
Misfortunes or mistakes?: Cultural sensemaking of entrepreneurial failure,
Journal of Business Venturing, 26, 79-92.
16. Cook, S. D. N., & Yanow, D. (1993). Culture and organizational learning.
Journal of Management Inquiry. 2, 373-390.
17. Craig-Lees, M. (2001). Sense making. Psychology and Marketing. 18, 513-
526.
18. Cyert, R. M., & March, J. G. (1963). A behavioral theory of the firm.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
19. Dougherty, D. (1992). Interpretive barriers to successful product innovation in
large firms. Organization Science. 3, 179-202.
20. Ericson, Thomas. (2001). Sensemaking in organisations towards a
conceptual framework for understanding strategic change. Scandinavian
Journal of Management, 17, 109-131.
21. Galloway, L., Sam, Ho. (1996). A model of service quality for training.
Training for Quality. 4, 20-26.
22. Gell-Mann, M. (1994). The Quark and the Jaguar: Adventures in the simple and
the complex. New York: W.H. Freeman.
23. Ghobadian, A., Speller, S., & Jones, M. (1994). Service quality: Concepts and
models. International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management. 11, 43-
66.
24. Gioia, D. A., Majken, S., & Corley, K. G. (2000). Organisational identity,
image and adaptive instability. Academy of Management Review. 25, 63-81.
25. Gronroos, C. (2000). Service management and marketing. John wiley & Sons
Ltd.
26. Hambrick, D. C., Cho, T. S., & Chen, M. (1996). The influence of top
management team heterogeneity on firms competitive moves. Administrative
Science. 4, 659-684.
27. Hutt, M.D., Reingen, P.H., & Ronchetto, J. R. (1988). Tracing emergent
processes in marketing strategy formation. Journal of Marketing. 52, 419-512.
28. Jrgensen, Lene, Jordan, Silvia & Mitterhofer, Hermann. (2012).
Sensemaking and discourse analyses in inter-organizational research: A review
and suggested advances. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 28, 107-120.
29. Mintzberg, H. (1978). Patterns in strategy formation. Management Science.
24, 934-948.
  ))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))) 18
1390 + ,- 10  *& 3  ( 

30. Neill, D. M. K., & Gregory, M. R. (2007). Developing the organization's

sensemaking capability: Precursorto an adaptive strategic marketing response.
Industrial Marketing Management. 36, 731744.
31. Papadimitriou K. & Pellegrin C. (2007). Dynamics of a project through
Intermediary Objects of Design (IODs): A sensemaking perspective.
International Journal of Project Management, 25, 437-445.
32. Parassuraman, A., Zeithaml, V. A., & Berry, L. L. (1988). SERVQUAL: A
Multiple-Item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality.
Journal of Retailing. 64, 12-40.
33. Parassuraman, A., Zeithaml, V. A., & Berry, L. L. (1991). Understanding
customer expectations of services. Sloan Management Review. Spring, 39-48.
34. Patriotta, Gerardo & Brown, Andrew D. (2011). Sensemaking, metaphors and
performance evaluation. Scandinavian Journal of Management, 27, 34-43.
35. Qu, Yan & Furnas, George W. (2008). Model-driven formative evaluation of
exploratory search: A study under a sensemaking framework. Information
Processing & Management, 44, 534-555.
36. Sackman, S. (1991). Cultural knowledge in organizations: Exploring the
collective mind. Newbury Park CA: Sage.
37. Schroder, H. M., Driver, M.J., & Streufert, S. (1967). Human information
processing. New York: Holt Rinehart and Winston.
38. Starbuck, W. H. (1983). Organizations as action generators. American
Sociological Review. 48, 91-102.
39. Streufert, S., Swezey, R.W. (1986). Complexity, managers, and organizations.
Orlando FL: Academic Press.
40. Thiry, Michel. (2001). Sensemaking in value management practice.
International Journal of Project Management, 19, 71-77.
41. Thomas, J.B., Clark, S.M., & Gioia, D.A. (1993). Strategic sense making and
organizational performance: Linkages among scanning, interpretation, action,
and outcomes. Academy of Management Journal. 36, 239270.
42. Walsh, J. P., & Ungson, G. R. (1991). Organizational memory. Academy of
Management Review. 26, 57-91.
43. Weick, K.E. (1995). Sense making in organizations. Thousand Oaks CA: Sage.
44. Weick, K.E., Sutcliffe, K.M., & Obstfeld, D. (2005). Organizing and the
process of Sense making. Organization Science. 16, 409421.
45. Wrzesniewski, Amy, Dutton Jane E. & Debebe, Gelaye. (2003). Interpersonal
sensemaking and the meaning of work. Research in Organizational Behavior ,
25, 93-135.