You are on page 1of 1

Has Imran failed?

HADI | June 27, 2017

Substantial majority of people of South Asian


descent try to mechanically evaluate performance
(success or failure) of movements, without having
insights into the philosophical dynamics collateral to
an event. A great movement yields result over the
course of decades, if its a movement in its very
sense. Short-sightedness, illiteracy and to some
extent prevalence of nonideological inclinations,
prevent them from diagnosis of prospective gigantic
[permanent] changes that people-powered-
movements CAN bring. Movements greatest success
lies in situation of inequalities of everyday life on Pakistani opposition politician and
national agenda. According to Noam Chomsky, as cricket legend, Imran Khan, speaks out
against President Pervez Musharraf and
mentioned in his book 'Occupy', if a movement has emergency rule at a press conference
November 22, 2007 in Islamabad,
influenced public perception and communication Pakistan. Khan was imprisoned by the
and dominated media or successfully manipulated government under terrorism charges
after trying to lead a student protest in
national agenda, then it must be termed as a Lahore. (Photo by John Moore/Getty
successful movement, whether it has achieved Images)
proclaimed objectives in short-run or not, it is
successful. Although, alteration of narrative on desired terms is a successful victory
toward change in everything else.

It took Mandela a lifetime of struggle, including 27 years of incarceration, to extricate


South Africa from quagmire of apartheid.

Similarly, have glance at Mohandas Karamchand's non-violent & non-cooperation


movement of 1920. Did colonists spare us in immediate aftermath of that movement?
No!
So, can we label it as a failed movement? Obviously, NO! Because it, now, cannot be
overlooked in the process of emancipation from British hegemony. That movement
was successful. Similarly, if Imran's movements arent producing desired results
immediately. We can't label them as "failed ones".

You might also like