BAB III

PEMBAHASAN

3.1 Tabel OMH Perbaikan 1

Nama Jarak ongkos

No berat (kg) Total OMH
Fasilitas Fasilitas (m) (RP)
1 REC-STO 6.84 12465.4 4000 27374.33
2 STO-TBG1 7.78 4280.2 3000 23327.45
3 TBG1-BPC1 2.24 4280.2 3000 6708.20
4 BPC1-RPS1 8.33 4237.398 3000 24986.35
5 RPS1-MGL1 12.82 4195.024 3000 38451.77
6 MGL1-MAK1 10.58 4153.0738 3000 31743.56
7 STO-TBG2 5.54 990.36 2000 11079.50
8 STO-MXR1 10.83 990.36 2000 21660.69
9 TBG2-MXR1 5.29 990.36 2000 10581.19
10 MXR1-MAK2 10.88 1980.72 2000 21761.53
11 MAK2-EVP 4.97 1881.684 2000 9949.36
12 EVP-PST1 4.11 1693.5156 2000 8215.84
13 PST1-AUT 2.49 1659.6453 2000 4974.68
14 AUT-MXR2 8.03 1643.0488 2000 16058.41
15 MXR2-SPD1 9.98 1626.6183 2000 19964.07
16 STO-APG1 7.78 2182.56 2000 15551.63
17 APG1-TBG2 2.24 2138.9088 2000 4472.14
18 TBG2-BPC2 8.35 2138.9088 2000 16690.24
19 BPC2-MPR 12.20 2117.5197 2000 24403.53
20 MPR-MPS 9.15 2117.5197 2000 18294.48
21 MPS-PYR 4.17 2011.6437 2000 8345.12
22 PYR-BPD 3.35 1991.5273 2000 6708.20
23 BPD-RPS2 2.49 1991.5273 2000 4974.68
24 RPS2-SPD2 3.31 1971.612 2000 6611.60
25 SPD2-MGL2 4.17 1971.612 2000 8345.12
26 MGL2-MAK3 8.35 1971.612 2000 16690.24
27 STO-MXR3 10.83 1555.2 2000 21660.69
28 MAK1-MXR3 8.05 3903.8894 2000 16091.09
29 MXR3-RFM 8.05 5404.4985 3000 24136.63
30 STO-MXR4 10.83 604.8 2000 21660.69
31 SPD1-MXR4 6.11 1463.9565 2000 12218.10
32 MAK3-MXR4 10.28 1951.8959 2000 20563.22
33 MXR4-MXR5 10.58 3980.4459 2000 21162.37
34 RFM-MXR5 4.17 5404.4985 3000 12517.68
35 MXR5-MEK 3.05 9291.0949 3000 9163.58
36 MEK-MCP 3.86 8826.5402 3000 11569.94
37 MCP-SCP 3.86 8650.0094 3000 11569.94
38 SCP-OVN 3.86 8477.0092 3000 11569.94
39 OVN-CLM 10.78 8477.0092 3000 32352.47
40 STO-RPM1 6.66 864 2000 13315.57
41 CLM-RPM1 8.05 8477.0092 3000 24136.63
42 STO-RPM2 7.78 864 2000 15551.63
43 RPM1-RPM2 3.35 9341.0092 3000 10062.31
44 STO-WHS 14.97 133.92 2000 29937.73
45 RPM2-WHS 4.96 9341.0092 3000 14870.94
46 WHS-SHP 7.05 9474.9292 3000 21152.51

TOTAL
763187.53
 REC STO TBG1 BPC1 RPS1 MGL1 MAK1 APG1 TBG2 MXR1 MAK2 EVP PST1 AUT MXR2 SPD1 BPC2 MPR MPS PYR BPD RPS2 SPD2 MGL2 MAK3 MXR3 RFM MXR4 MXR5 MEK MCP SCP OVN CLM RPM1 RPM2 WHS SHP TOTAL

REC 27374.33 27374.3257

STO 23327.45 15551.63 11079.50 21660.69 21660.69 21660.69 13315.57 15551.63 29937.73 173745.564
TBG 1 6708.20 6708.20393
BPC 1 24986.35 24986.3482
RPS 1 38451.77 38451.7658
MGL 1 31743.56 31743.5618
MAK 1 16091.09 16091.086
APG 1 4472.14 4472.13595
TBG 2 10581.19 4472.14 15053.3232
MXR 1 21761.53 21761.5272
MAK 2 9949.36 9949.36153
EVP 8215.84 8215.83836
3.2 Peta Dari-Ke Perbaikan

PST 1 4974.68 4974.68

AUT 16058.41 16058.4129
MXR 2 19964.07 19964.0693
SPD 1 12218.10 12218.1026
BPC 2 24403.53 24403.5322
MPR 18294.48 18294.4808
MPS 8345.12 8345.1193
PYR 6708.20 6708.20393
BPD 4974.68 4974.68077
RPS 2 6611.60 6611.59613
SPD 2 8345.12 8345.1193
MGL2 16690.24 16690.2386
MAK 3 20563.22 20563.2219
MXR 3 24136.63 24136.629
RFM 12517.68 12517.679
MXR 4 21162.37 21162.3746
MXR 5 9163.58 9163.57699
MEK 11569.94 11569.9403
MCP 11569.94 11569.9403
SCP 11569.94 11569.9403
OVN 32352.47 32352.4674
CLM 24136.63 24136.629
RPM1 10062.31 10062.3059
RPM2 14870.94 14870.9375
WHS 21152.51 21152.5114
SHP 0
TOTAL 0 27374.33 23327.451 6708.204 24986.35 38451.77 31743.56 15551.634 15551.63 32241.87 21761.527 9949.3615 8215.84 4974.681 16058.41 19964.069 4472.14 24403.532 18294.481 8345.119 6708.204 4974.681 6611.6 8345.12 16690.24 37751.77 24136.63 54442.01 33680.05 9163.58 11569.94 11569.94 11569.94 32352.467 37452.19 25613.94 44808.665 21152.51 680747.048
 OUT
REC STO TBG1 BPC1 RPS1 MGL1 MAK1 APG1 TBG2 MXR1 MAK2 EVP PST1 AUT MXR2 SPD1 BPC2 MPR MPS PYR BPD RPS2 SPD2 MGL2 MAK3 MXR3 RFM MXR4 MXR5 MEK MCP SCP OVN CLM RPM1 RPM2 WHS SHP TOTAL
IN
1.00 1
REC
1
0.134262 0.089508 0.063769 0.12467 0.12467 0.12467 0.07664 0.08951 0.17231 1
STO
1 1 0.71243 0.67182 0.57377 0.39787 0.35553 0.60716 0.66812
1 1
TBG1
1
1 1
BPC1
1
1 1
RPS1
1
1 1
MGL1
1
1 1
MAK1
0.42623
1 1
APG1
0.28757
0.702914 0.29709 1
TBG2
0.32818 1
1 1
MXR1
1
1 1
MAK2
1
1 1
EVP
1
1 1
PST1
1
1 1
AUT
1
1 1
MXR2
1
1 1
SPD1
0.22442
3.3 Peta Inflow-Outflow Perbaikan

1 1
BPC2
1
1 1
MPR
1
1 1
MPS
1
1 1
PVR
1
1 1
BPD
1
1 1
RPS2
1
1 1
SPD2
1
1 1
MGL2
1
1 1
MAK3
0.37771
1 1
MXR3
1
1 1
RFM
0.37166
1 1
MXR4
0.62834
1 1
MXR5
1
1 1
MEK
1
1 1
MCP
1
1 1
SCP
1
1 1
OVN
1
1 1
CLM
0.64447
1 1
RPM1
0.39284
1 1
RPM2
0.33188
1 1
WHS
1
0.00
SHP

TOTAL 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 30
3.4 Skala Prioritas Perbaikan
Prioritas
No. Simbol
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
2
1 REC
1
9 35 8 36 10 26 28 3 37
2 STO
0.0637685 0.076638306 0.08950809 0.08950809 0.124668996 0.124668996 0.124668996 0.134262136 0.172307869
4
3 TBG1
1
5
4 BPC1
1
6
5 RPS1
1
7
6 MGL1
1
26
7 MAK1
1
9
8 APG1
1
17 10
9 TBG2
0.29708629 0.70291371
11
10 MXR1
1
12
11 MAK2
1
13
12 EVP
1
14
13 PST1
1
15
14 AUT
1
16
15 MXR2
1
28
16 SPD1
1
18
17 BPC2
1
19
18 MPR
1
20
19 MPS
1
21
20 PYR
1
22
21 BPD
1
23
22 RPS2
1
24
23 SPD2
1
25
24 MGL2
1
28
25 MAK3
1
27
26 MXR3
1
29
27 RFM
1
29
28 MXR4
1
30
29 MXR5
1
31
30 MEK
1
32
31 MCP
1
33
32 SCP
1
34
33 OVN
1
35
34 CLM
1
36
35 RPM1
1
37
36 RPM2
1
38
37 WHS
1

38 SHP
3.5 ARD Perbaikan (Semua Alternatif)

REC STO APG 1 TBG 1 BPC 1 MAK2 EVP

RPM 2 RPM 1 TGB 2 MXR 1 RPS1 AUT PST
WHS MXR3 MXR4 BPC2 MGL1 MXR2 MPS
SHP CLM MAK 1 MAK 3 SPD 1 MPR PYR
OVN MXR5 RFM MGL2 SPD 2 RPS 2 BPD
SCP MCP MEK

REC STO APG1 TBG 1 BPC 1 MAK2 EVP

RPM 2 RPM 1 TBG 2 MXR 1 RPS1 AUT PST

WHS MXR 3 MXR 4 BPC 2 MGL 1 MXR2 MPS

SHP CLM MAK 1 MAK 3 SPD 1 MPR PYR

OVN MXR 5 RFM MGL 2 SPD 2 RPS 2 BPD

SCP MCP MEK

Keterangan:
: melewati 0 fasilitas
: melewati 1 fasilitas
: melewati 2 fasilitas
: melewati 3 fasilitas

3.6 Perhitungan jarak Perbaikan

No. Simbol Perhitungan Jarak Jarak Dipilih

1 REC-STO 2.42+4.42 6.84 dipilih
2 STO-TBG1
STO-APG1-TGB1 4.42+(2*1.12)+1.12 7.78 dipilih
3 TBG1-BPC1 1.12+1.12 2.24 dipilih
4 BPC1-RPS1 1.12+2.24 3.36 dipilih
5 RPS1-MGL1 2.24+2.24 4.48 dipilih
6 MGL1-MAK1
MGL1-BPC2-MXR4-MAK1 2.24+(2*1.12)+(2*1.94)+2.24 10.6 dipilih
MGL1-BPC2-MAK3-MAK1 2.24+(2*1.12)+(2*2.24)+2.24 11.2
MGL1-SPD1-MAK3-MAK1 2.24+(2*1.94)+(2*2.24)+2.24 12.84
7 STO-TBG2
STO-APG1-TGB2 4.42+(2*1.12)+1.12 7.78 dipilih
STO-RPM1-TBG2 4.42+(2*2.24)+1.12 10.02
8 STO-MXR1
STO-APG1-TBG1-MXR1 4.42+(2*1.12)+(2*1.12)+1.94 10.84 dipilih
 STO-APG1-TBG2-MXR1 4.42+(2*1.12)+(2*1.12)+1.94 10.84
STO-RPM1-TGB2-MXR1 4.42+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+1.94 13.08
9 TBG2-MXR1 1.12+1.94 3.06 dipilih
10 MXR1-MAK2
MXR1-TBG1-BPC1-MAK2 1.94+(2*1.12)+(2*1.12)+2.24 8.66 dipilih
MXR1-RPS1-BPC1-MAK2 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+2.24 10.9
MXR1-RPS1-AUT-MAK2 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+2.24 10.9
11 MAK2-EVP 2.24+2.74 4.98 dipilih
12 EVP-PST1 2.74+1.37 4.11 dipilih
13 PST1-AUT 1.37+1.12 2.49 dipilih
14 AUT-MXR2 1.12+1.94 3.06 dipilih
15 MXR2-SPD1
MXR2-MPR-SPD1 1.94+(2*2.74)+1.94 9.36
MXR2-MGL1-SPD1 1.94+(2*2.24)+1.94 8.36 dipilih
16 STO-APG1 4.42+1.12 5.54 dipilih
17 APG1-TBG2 1.12+1.12 2.24 dipilih
18 TBG2-BPC2
TBG2-MXR1-BPC2 1.12+(2*1.94)+1.12 6.12 dipilih
TBG2-MXR4-BPC2 1.12+(2*1.94)+1.12 6.12 dipilih
19 BPC2-MPR
BPC2-MGL1-MXR2-MPR 1.12+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+2.74 12.22
BPC2-MAK3-SPD1-MPR 1.12+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+2.74 12.22 dipilih
BPC2-MGL1-SPD1-MPR 1.12+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+2.74 12.22
20 MPR-MPS
MPR-MXR2-MPS 2.74+(2*1.94)+1.94 8.56 dipilih
MPR-PYR-MPS 2.74+(2*2.24)+1.94 9.16
21 MPS-PYR 1.94+2.24 4.18 dipilih
22 PYR-BPD 2.24+1.12 3.36 dipilih
23 BPD-RPS2 1.12+1.37 2.49 dipilih
24 RPS2-SPD2 1.37+1.94 3.31 dipilih
25 SPD2-MGL2 1.94+2.24 4.18 dipilih
26 MGL2-MAK3 2.24+2.24 4.48 dipilih
27 STO-MXR3
STO-RPM1-MXR3 4.42+(2*2.24)+1.94 10.84 dipilih
28 MAK1-MXR3
MAK1-MXR4-MXR3 2.24+(2*1.94)+1.94 8.06 dipilih
MAK1-CLM-MXR3 2.24+(2*1.94)+1.94 8.06
29 MXR3-RFM
MXR3-MXR4-MAK1-RFM 1.94+(2*1.94)+(2*2.24)+2.24 12.54
MXR3-CLM-MAK1-RFM 1.94+(2*1.94)+(2*2.24)+2.24 12.54
 MXR3-CLM-MXR5-RFM 1.94+(2*1.94)+(2*1.94)+2.24 11.94 dipilih
30 STO-MXR4
STO-APG1-TBG2-MXR4 4.42+(2*1.12)+(2*1.12)+1.94 10.84 dipilih
STO-RPM1-TBG2-MXR4 4.42+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+1.94 13.08
STO-RPM1-MXR3-MXR4 4.42+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+1.94 14.72
31 SPD1-MXR4
SPD1-MGL1-BPC2-MXR4 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+1.94 10.6 dipilih
SPD1-MAK3-MAK1-MXR4 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*2.24)+1.94 12.84
SPD1-MAK3-BPC2-MXR4 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+1.94 10.6
32 MAK3-MXR4
MAK3-BPC2-MXR4 2.24+(2*1.12)+1.94 6.42 dipilih
MAK3-MAK1-MXR4 2.24+(2*2.24)+1.94 8.66
33 MXR4-MXR5
MXR4-MXR3-CLM-MXR5 1.94+(2*1.94)+(2*1.94)+1.94 11.64 dipilih
MXR4-MAK1-RFM-MXR5 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*2.24)+1.94 12.84
MXR4-MAK1-CLM-MXR5 1.94+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+1.94 12.24
34 RFM-MXR5 2.24+1.94 4.18 dipilih
35 MXR5-MEK
MXR5-RFM-MEK 1.94+(2*2.24)+1.12 7.54 dipilih
MXR5-MCP-MEK 1.94+(2*2.74)+1.12 8.54
36 MEK-MCP 1.12+2.74 3.86 dipilih
37 MCP-SCP 2.74+1.12 3.86 dipilih
38 SCP-OVN 1.12+2.74 3.86 dipilih
39 OVN-CLM
OVN-MXR5-CLM 2.74+(2*1.94)+1.94 8.56 dipilih
40 STO-RPM1 4.42+2.24 6.66 dipilih
41 CLM-RPM1
CLM-MXR3-RPM1 1.94+(2*1.94)+2.24 8.06 dipilih
42 STO-RPM2
STO-RPM1-RPM2 4.42+(2*2.24)+1.12 10.02 dipilih
43 RPM1-RPM2 2.24+1.12 3.36 dipilih
44 STO-WHS
STO-RPM1-RPM2-WHS 4.42+(2*2.24)+(2*1.12)+3.84 14.98 dipilih
STO-RPM1-MXR3-WHS 4.42+(2*2.24)+(2*1.94)+3.84 16.62
45 RPM2-WHS 1.12+3.84 4.96 dipilih
46 WHS-SHP 3.84+3.21 7.05 dipilih
3.7 Tabel OMH Perbaikan 2

Jarak
ongkos
No Nama Fasilitas Fasilitas berat (kg) Total OMH
(RP)
(m)
1 REC-STO 6.84 12465.4 4000 27360.00
2 STO-TBG1 7.78 4280.2 3000 23340.00
3 TBG1-BPC1 2.24 4280.2 3000 6720.00
4 BPC1-RPS1 3.36 4237.398 3000 10080.00
5 RPS1-MGL1 4.48 4195.02402 3000 13440.00
6 MGL1-MAK1 10.60 4153.07378 3000 31800.00
7 STO-TBG2 7.78 990.36 2000 15560.00
8 STO-MXR1 10.84 990.36 2000 21680.00
9 TBG2-MXR1 3.06 990.36 2000 6120.00
10 MXR1-MAK2 8.66 1980.72 2000 17320.00
11 MAK2-EVP 4.98 1881.684 2000 9960.00
12 EVP-PST1 4.11 1693.5156 2000 8220.00
13 PST1-AUT 2.49 1659.645288 2000 4980.00
14 AUT-MXR2 3.06 1643.048835 2000 6120.00
15 MXR2-SPD1 8.36 1626.618347 2000 16720.00
16 STO-APG1 5.54 2182.56 2000 11080.00
17 APG1-TBG2 2.24 2138.9088 2000 4480.00
18 TBG2-BPC2 6.12 2138.9088 2000 12240.00
19 BPC2-MPR 12.22 2117.519712 2000 24440.00
20 MPR-MPS 8.56 2117.519712 2000 17120.00
21 MPS-PYR 4.18 2011.643726 2000 8360.00
22 PYR-BPD 3.36 1991.527289 2000 6720.00
23 BPD-RPS2 2.49 1991.527289 2000 4980.00
24 RPS2-SPD2 3.31 1971.612016 2000 6620.00
25 SPD2-MGL2 4.18 1971.612016 2000 8360.00
26 MGL2-MAK3 4.48 1971.612016 2000 8960.00
27 STO-MXR3 10.84 1555.2 2000 21680.00
28 MAK1-MXR3 8.06 3903.889353 2000 16120.00
29 MXR3-RFM 11.94 5404.498459 3000 35820.00
30 STO-MXR4 10.84 604.8 2000 21680.00
31 SPD1-MXR4 10.60 1463.956512 2000 21200.00
32 MAK3-MXR4 6.42 1951.895896 2000 12840.00
33 MXR4-MXR5 11.64 3980.445884 2000 23280.00
34 RFM-MXR5 4.18 5404.498459 3000 12540.00
35 MXR5-MEK 7.54 9291.0949 3000 22620.00
36 MEK-MCP 3.86 8826.540155 3000 11580.00
 37 MCP-SCP 3.86 8650.009352 3000 11580.00
38 SCP-OVN 3.86 8477.009165 3000 11580.00
39 OVN-CLM 8.56 8477.009165 3000 25680.00
40 STO-RPM1 6.66 864 2000 13320.00
41 CLM-RPM1 8.06 8477.009165 3000 24180.00
42 STO-RPM2 10.02 864 2000 20040.00
43 RPM1-RPM2 3.36 9341.009165 3000 10080.00
44 STO-WHS 14.98 133.92 2000 29960.00
45 RPM2-WHS 4.96 9341.009165 3000 14880.00
46 WHS-SHP 7.05 9474.929165 3000 21150.00
TOTAL 714590.00

3.8 ARD yang Dipilih

REC STO APG1 TBG 1 BPC 1 MAK2 EVP

RPM 2 RPM 1 TBG 2 MXR 1 RPS1 AUT PST

WHS MXR 3 MXR 4 BPC 2 MGL 1 MXR2 MPS

SHP CLM MAK 1 MAK 3 SPD 1 MPR PYR

OVN MXR 5 RFM MGL 2 SPD 2 RPS 2 BPD

SCP MCP MEK

Keterangan:
: melewati 0 fasilitas
: melewati 1 fasilitas
: melewati 2 fasilitas
: melewati 3 fasilitas