O V E RV O LTA G E P R O T E C T I O N

Dimensioning,

E S
GUIDELINE
testing and application
of metal oxide

E L I N
surge arresters
in medium voltage
networks

PPLICATION I D
G U
I O N
L I C A T
Please visit us on the Internet: http://www.abb.ch/hos CHHOS / AR 3257.99E (D)

ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd.

Division Surge Arresters
Presented by: EN ISO 9001
Jurastrasse 45
CH-5430 Wettingen 1
Switzerland
P

Telephone ++41 56 / 205 29 11

Telefax ++41 56 / 205 55 70
Internet salessa @ chhos.mail.abb.com

Printed in Switzerland (99-09-1000 D/E)

P
 Foreword
ts in s time interval

U in V peak value of the overvoltage of a travelling wave (mainly given in kV)

Uc in V maximum continuous operating voltage of the arrester (mainly given in kV, rms)

UE in V maximum overvoltage at the end of an open line (mainly given in kV, peak value)

UK in V maximum overvoltage at cable end (mainly given in kV, peak value)

Um in V maximum voltage between phases (mainly given in kV, rms)

Up in V protection level of the arrester at In (mainly given in kV, peak value)

Ur in V rated voltage (mainly given in kV, rms)

Uref in V reference voltage (mainly given in kV, rms)

UT in V overvoltage at the transformer (mainly given in kV, peak value)

The first edition of our directions for dimensioning,
testing and application of metal oxide surge arresters UTOV in V power frequency overvoltage of a limited duration (mainly given in kV, rms)
in medium voltage networks, which appeared in 1994,
was received very positively. We were pleased to get u(t) in V time function of a lightning overvoltage
such a reception, which attested our belief that com-
petent consulting with regard to the application of our v in m/s speed of the travelling wave, v = 300 m / s in the air
products is as important as the quality of the products
Z in surge impedance of a distribution line conductor Z = 300........450
itself.
ZK in surge impendance of a cable conductor ZK = 20 ...... 60
The technological progress made it now necessary to revise and renew the present booklet for the third
edition. L load rejection factor of a generator
The dimensioning and the theoretical basis for the optimal application of the surge arresters are not changed
and therefore they were taken as such in the new edition. Mr. Ren Rudolph, who was at the time of the first
1 1
angular frequency of the power frequency, at 50 Hz is = 314
edition responsible for the consulting concerning application in the surge arrester division, took on the task S S
of revising the tables. That was necessary because of the improvement of the technical data of the surge
arresters and the enlargement of our product range. We would like to thank Mr. Ren Rudolph for his efforts.
Mr. Bernhard Richter, who is now responsible for engineering and application of the overvoltage protective
devices in the surge arrester division of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, took on gladly the task of the
general revision of this booklet.
Mr. Richter is a member in different working groups of IEC SC 37 A and IEC TC 81, and his activity field
includes, besides the development and testing, mainly the application of the surge arresters.

The silicon technology, which is used in medium voltage by ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, and the
further developing of the metal oxide material opens new application spheres. All these are taken into
account in the new edition.

We hope, that you as a reader will be satisfied with our new revised edition and you will find it useful for your
purpose. We welcome amendments and suggestions in order to meet all possible customer needs.

ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd

Wettingen, July 1999
First published: November 1994
2.revised edition: September 1995
3.revised edition: July 1999

All rights reserved.

Neither the booklet or parts of it may be either copied or reproduced,
transmitted in any way or translated info other languages without
the prior permission of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd.

ABB High Voltage Technologogies Ltd

Division Surge Arresters, Wettingen, Switzerland

1 26
Index of symbols used Contents

a in m conductor length

BIL in kV Basic Impulse Insulation Level (peak value)

1 Introduction 8.3 Networks with solidly earthed neutral systems (Ce < 1.4)
b in m conductor length
2 Surge arrrester technology 8.4 Networks with low-ohmic neutral transformer earthing
C in F capacitance (given in nF or uF) which do not uniformly have Ce < 1.4
2.1 MO-arresters and spark-gap arresters
Ce earth fault factor, Ce x Um / 3 is the maximum voltage 8.5 Low-ohmic neutral earthing networks and Ce > 1.4
between phase and earth in the case of an earth fault 3 Metal oxide resistors as arrester elements
8.6 Arresters between phases (Neptune design)
d in m section length of an overhead line before the substation 4 Medium voltage arresters from ABB
8.7 Operating voltage with harmonic oscillation
E in J energy absorbed by the arrester (mainly given in kJ or kJ / kVUc ) 4.1 Construction of the arrester
9 Protective distance of the surge arrester
Ec in J discharge energy absorbed by the arrester (mainly given in kJ)
4.2 Insulation made of silicone rubber
9.1 Theoretical projection for the protective distance L
I in A
4.3 Energy absorption capability and cool-down time
long duration current impulse 9.2 Expected steepness S from lightning overvoltages in
4.4 Nominal discharge current and energy MV-substations
In in A nominal discharge current (mainly given in kA, peak value)
absorption capability
9.3 Influences on the protective distance through electrical
IK in A 50 Hz fault current (mainly given in kA, rms- value) equipment, the types of the arresters and the arrangement
5 Special operating conditions
of the arresters
Iref in A reference current (mainly given in mA, peak value) 5.1 Network short circuit power
9.4 Fault hazards in electrical equipment and their distance
i in A peak current of the stroke current (mainly given in kA, peak value) 5.2 Elevated ambient temperature from the surge arrester
i(t) in A time function of the stroke current 5.3 Mechanical stability 10 Some special cases
K corona damping constant 5.4 Air pollution
10.1 Overvoltage protection in cable sections
L in H inductance of a line trap 5.5 Altitude adjustment for arrester housing
10.2 Cable sheath protection
L in m protective distance
6 Protection characteristics of the surge arrester, 10.3 Transformers at the end of cables
LK in m
stability
cable length
10.4 Transformer connected to a lightning endangered line on
6.1 Surge arrester protection level one side only
MCOV in V Maximum Continuous Operating Voltage = Uc (mainly given in kV, rms- value)
6.2 Questions of stability of MO-surge arresters 10.5 Arresters in metal enclosed MV-substation
P in W power losses of the arrester in the case of Uc
6.3 Temporary overvoltages 10.6 Generator connected to a lightning endangered MV-line
p.u. per unit, 1 p.u. = 2 x Um /3
7 Tests 10.7 Arrester protection for motors
Q in W heat flow from the active arrester parts to the external environment (cooling)
7.1 Type tests 10.8 Overvoltage protection in locomotives
S in V /s maximum steepness of a voltage increase (mainly given in kV / s)
7.2 Routine tests 10.9 Arresters parallel to a capacitor battery
S(t) in V / s time function of the steepness of a voltage increase (mainly given in kV / s)
7.3 Acceptance tests 10.10 Line traps (parallel protection)
So in V / s steepness of the lightning overvoltage at the point of the stroke (mainly given in kV / s)
7.4 Special tests 11 Arresters for d.c.voltage
SK in Var three-phase reactive power of a capacitor bank
8 Selection of surge arresters and determination 12 Consulting concerning questions on the use of arresters
T withstand strength against temporary overvoltages UTOV = T x Uc of Uc
Networks with earth fault compensation or 13 Conclusions
T in C temperature 8.1
with a high-ohmic insulated neutral system
Index of symbols used
t in s time
8.2 Networks with high-ohmic insulated neutral
system and automatic earth fault clearing Bibliography

25 2
1 Introduction
Overvoltages in electrical supply networks result from the effects
of lightning strokes and switching actions and cannot be avoided.
They endanger the electrical equipment because, due to
economical reasons, the insulation cannot be designed for all
possible cases. A more economical and safe on-line network calls
for extensive protection of the electrical equipment against
unacceptable overvoltage loads. This applies to high voltage as
well as medium and low voltage networks.
Overvoltage protection can be basically achieved in two ways:
Avoiding lightning overvoltage at the point of origin, for instance
through shilding earth wires in front of the substation that
intercept lightning.
Limit overvoltage near the electrical equipment, for instance
through surge arresters in the vicinity of the electrical equipment.
In high voltage networks both methods of protection are usual.
The earth wire protection in medium voltage networks is generally
not very effective. Due to the small distance between the earth wire
and the line wires, a direct lightning stroke hits usally the line wires
as well. In addition, induced overvoltages in the line wires (indirect
effects of the lightning strokes) cannot be avoided by the earth
wires.
The most effective protection against overvoltages in a medium
voltage network is therefore the use of surge arresters in the
vicinity of the electrical equipment.
The magnitude of the overvoltage is usually given in p.u.
(per unit). It is defined as
1 p.u. = 2 x Um / 3 ,
the Um means the maximum r.m.s voltage value between the
phases in an undisturbed network operation [1].
Three types of overvoltages are essentially distinguished [2]:
Temporary overvoltages occur for instance during load rejection
or because of earth connection faults. The duration of such
operating frequency oscillating overvoltage lies between 0.1
seconds and several hours. In general the surge does not exeed 3
p.u. and therefore it is of no danger to the network operation,
however it is decisive for the dimensioning of the arrester.
Switching overvoltages occur during switching actions and
consist mostly of heavily damped oscillations with frequencies up
to several kHz and a magnitude up to 3 p.u.
A special case is switching in inductive electrical circuits. Here
the front time of the overvoltage lies between 0.1 and 10 s and
the peak value can reach 4 p.u.. Fast-front overvoltages are also
possible when lines or cables are switched on.The peak value lies
then below 2.2 p.u. and does not endanger the network system.
Lightning overvoltages originate in atmospheric discharges.
They reach their peak value within a few s and subsequenly decay
very rapidly. The magnitude of these unipolar overvoltages in a
medium voltage network can reach well over 10 p.u.
Lightning overvoltages are the greatest threat to the medium
voltage networks. Overvoltage protection must be arranged in
such a way as to confine the overvoltage to non-damaging values.
3 24
2 Surge Arrester Technology
The so-called "conventional" surge arresters were exclusively
employed in MV networks (MV = medium voltage) until about the
middle of the eight decade of our century. They consisted of a
series connection of SiC resistors and plate spark-gaps. During the
overvoltage rising there emerges a short circuit to the earth when
the spark-gaps come into action. The series connection of SiC
resistors limits the follow current from the power supply and
allows in this way the disappeareance of the arcs between the plate
spark-gaps the next time the voltage reaches the zero crossing.
In the last years there were two fundamental improvements of
surge arresters used in MV networks. On one hand the series
connection of SiC resistors and the plate spark-gaps were replaced
with the metalloxid resistors (MO-resistors) without plate spark-
gaps, on the other hand the housings of the surge arresters made
of porcelain were replaced with new ones made of polymer
material (synthetic material).
2.1 MO-Arresters and Spark-Gap Arresters
The arresters protect the electrical equipment no matter whether
some other types of arresters are present. Therefore it is possible
to have at work in the same installation both the conventional
spark-gap arresters and the modern MO-arresters. It is not even
necessary that an electrical equipment should be protected in all
its three phases by the same type of arrester. The user can
therefore simply replace a spark-gap arrester as soon as it is out of
work with a MO-arrester. That allows the user to introduce cost-
saving the MO-arresters that have an elevated operating safety.
A fundamental advantage of the MO-arresters is the fact that
because of their extremely non-linear characteristic of the MO-
resistors they do not need any spark-gaps. The current starts to
flow already through the arrester before the overvoltage achieves
the value Up. The MO-arresters reduce therefore the overvoltage
sooner as the spark-gap arresters. The last ones are able to
conduct after the overvoltage was increased to Up. That is why
their protection distance is shorter in many cases. This means that
the overvoltage to the electrical equipment is higher when a spark-
gap arrester instead of a MO-arrester is installed as both types of
arresters are at the same distance from equipment to be protected.
The response voltage of the spark-gaps increases when the rise
time becomes steeper (< 1s). This causes a deterioration of the
protection possiblity of the spark-gap arresters in case of an
overvoltage wave with steep front .
If the outside insulation of the arrester is very dirty the potential
distribution along the humid surface is very uneven. It is possible
that between the sheds partial arcings appear which can induce
overvoltages in the active part. This situation is especially critical
with a spark-gap arrester, because it can bring it regularly to spark
over and at the end destroy it. This is the reason why MO-arresters
without spark-gaps have a fundamentally higher pollution resi-
stence.
If more spark-gap arresters are parallel connected usually only
one arrester switches on during an overvoltage. This reduces then
the overvoltage to a value that lies under the sparking voltage of
the other parallel arresters. Therefore it is not possible to distribute
the energy of the overvoltage on more spark-gap arresters which
are parallel connected. In case that this energy is too high the
arrester that switched on will be overloaded. This applies
especially to the spark-gap arresters which are parallel connected
to capacitor batteries with a higher reactive power.
Bibliography
[1] IEC Publication 99-5, First edition 1996-02 : Surge arresters Part 5 : Selection and
application recommendations.
[2] R. Rudolph und A. Mayer: berspannungsschutz von Mittelspannungskabeln. Bull.
SEV/VSE 76 (1985) 4, S. 204-208.
[3] R. Rudolph: Bemessung, Prfung und Einsatz von Metalloxid-Ableitern. Bull.
SEV/VSE 75 (1984) 23, S. 1407-1412.
[4] A. Mayer und R. Rudolph: Funkenstreckenlose berspannungsableiter ermglichen
optimalen berspannungsschutz. Brown Boveri Technik 72(1985) 12, S. 576-585.
[5] W. Schmidt: Metalloxid, ein fast idealer berspannungsableiter. Bull.
SEV/VSE 7 / 1998, S. 13-20.
[6] IEC Publication 60099-4, Edition 1.1, 1998-08: Surge arresters Part 4: Metal-oxide
surge arresters without gaps for a.c. systems.
[7] ANSI/IEEE Publication C62.11 1993: IEEE Standard for Metal-Oxide Surge Arresters
for Alternating Current Power Circuits.
[8] R. Rudolph: ZnO-Ableiter. Eine Alternative zu konventionellen Ableitern. Elektrotechnik
und Maschinenbau 5 (1983), S. 195-200.
[9] IEC Publication 71-1 (1993-12): Insulation coordination - Part 1: Definitions, principles
and rules.
[10] IEC Publication 71-2 (1996-12): Insulation coordination Part 2: Application guide.
[11] G. Balzer und K.H. Weck: Isolationskoordination von gasisolierten Schaltanlagen.
ETG - Fachbericht 32 (1990), S. 71-89.
[12] VDEW Strungs- und Schadensstatistik 1990. Verlags- und Wirtschaftsgesellschaft
der Elektrizittswerke m.b.H.
[13] A.J. Eriksson et al.: Guide to procedures for estimating the lightning performance of
transmission lines. Report of WG 01 of CIGRE Study Committee 33, Oct. 1991.
[14] K. Berger: Methoden und Resultate der Blitzforschung auf dem Monte San Salvatore bei
Lugano in den Jahren 1963 bis 1971. Bull. SEV/VSE 63 (1972) 24, S. 1403-1422.
[15] Surge arrester application guide. IEC 37 (Sec) 85, Jan 1992.
[16] R.B. Anderson and A.J. Eriksson: Lightning parameters for engineering application.
Electra, 69 (1980), S. 65-102.
[17] A.J. Eriksson et al.: A study of lightning stresses on metal oxide surge arresters.
Cigre paper 33-08 (1986).
[18] M. Christoffel: Der Einfluss von Kabelstrecken auf die berspannungsvorgnge in
bertragungssystemen mittlerer und hoher Spannungen. Brown Boveri Mitt. 51 (1964)
6, S. 369-376.
[19] A. Braun: Schirmspannungen und Schirmverluste bei Mittelspannungs-VPE-Kabeln.
Elektrizittswirtschaft 88 (1989) 26, S. 1898-1906.
[20] M. Darveniza und D.R. Mercer: Lightning protection of pole mounted transformers.
IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, Vol. 4, No. 2, April 1989, S. 1087-1093.
[21] G. Balzer: Schaltvorgnge in Mittelspannungsnetzen und deren Bercksichtigung bei
der Planung. Brown Boveri Technik, 73 (1983) 5, S. 270-278.
[22] Non-linear metal-oxide resistor polymeric housed surge arresters without sparkgaps.
IEC 37 / 154 / CD; March 1996
[23] W.Schmidt: Die neuen POLIM -berspannungsableiter mit Silikonisolation fr
Mittelspannungsnetze. ABB Revue 2/96
During unusual operational conditions, for example when a
system flashover takes place, all the parallel arresters in the
network are overloaded equally by the operational frequency
overvoltage. If metal oxide arresters are in use, it is possible to
induce a particular arrester to become over-charged first, rather
than a random one. For example, an indoor arrester in a substation
building is selected with Uc approx. 10% higher than that of the
outdoor arrester. As soon as an abnormal operational frequency
overvoltage occurs, the outdoor arrester will be over-charged first.
This arrester limits the overvoltage by producing an outdoor
flashover and thus preventing arcing inside the substation
building.
A similar situation exists when very high temporary overvoltages
are expected in a MV network, and these occur only very
infrequently. In order to avoid an over-charge on the arrester also
in this rare case, a 15% higher Uc is necessary. Such arresters
must be employed with electrical equipment. The drawback is, that
the protection is reduced by 15%.
Two sets of arresters provide an acceptable solution to the
problem. One set with 15% higher Uc is installed next to the
electrical equipment, and a second set with a lower Uc is placed
some distance away. In this way two metal oxide arresters are
switched parallel in each phase. Should a lightning overvoltage
occur, both sets would be conductive and together produce the
same protection level for the electrical equipment as would be
possible with a single arrester set with a lower Uc. During the above
mentioned very high overvoltage, only the arresters which are at
a distance from the electrical equipment become over-charged.
Therefore, the resulting flashovers cannot damage the equipment.
Furthermore, since such an overload rarely occurs, the
subsequent interruption of operation can be risked.
When installing the arrester, two points must be carefully
observed. Both are equally important for achieving the best
possible protection level. The lightning endangered line must be
guided to the high voltage connection of the arrester first, and only
thereafter led to the equipment to be protected. A short distance
between the high voltage connection of the arrester and the
equipment is certainly important, but not of crucial significance.
Secondly the galvanic connection from the earth side of the
arrester to the earth of the electrical equipment must be as short as
possible. This distance must be below 2 m for lines with earthed
cross arms. The distance for wooden pole lines must be shorter
than :
1 m for Um < 24 kV
0.6 m for Um > 24 kV
If this is not possible, the cross arms on the last 3 poles before the
substation or the electrical equipment must be earthed or another
set of arresters must be installed one pole in front of the
substation. In this case the upper limit for the earth connection is 2
m. The connection lines to the arrester in the case of a cable must
be as short as possible.
23
The MO-resistors make up the active part of the MO-arrester. The
All the parallel MO-columns of the MO-arresters without spark- MO-resistors are compressed and sintered in the form of round
gaps conduct current at the same time. The energy of the blocks out of different metall oxides in powder form. The diameters
overvoltage is in this way distributed on all the parallel arresters, so of the MO-resistors of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, made
that the energy capacity as a limiting parameter disappears. for the usage in the medium voltage, lie between 38 mm and 75
mm. The height of the blocks is generally between 23 mm and 46
MO-arresters can be used both with 50 Hz and with 16 2/3 Hz mm. The diameter of the MO-resistors decides the carrying
because they do not conduct any follow current. On the other capacity of the current, the height of the MO-resistors (or resistor
hand in the spark-gap arresters the follow current flows with stack) decides the voltage in continuous operation and the energy
16 2/3 Hz three times longer than with 50 Hz. As a result the spark- capability. The diameter of MO-resistors correlate with the line
gaps and the SiC resistors are loaded with a corresponding higher discharge classes corresponding to IEC 60099-4, as shown in
energy. In order to prevent this it is necessary to reduce the peak Table 1.
value of the follow current. This asks for spark-gap arresters
with a higher nominal voltage, which however makes a consi-
derable increasing of the protection level necessary. For the Line discharge class 1 2 3 4
better understanding of the facts it is necessary to add that the MO- acc. to IEC 60099-4
arrester may be used with d.c. voltage, the arrester with plate
spark-gaps however cannot resist this strain. Diameter of blocks in mm 38 47 62 75
Square wave, 2000 s in A 250 550 1000 1350
Energy capability in (kJ / kVUc ) 3.6 5.5 9.0 13.3
3 Metal Oxide Resistors as Arrester Elements
Table 1
Correlation between typical MO-resistors and the line discharge
The voltage current characteristic of metal oxide resistors is
extremely non-linear. In Figure 1 the characteristic curve for such classes acc. to IEC. Line discharge class 5 is important only in
high-voltage systems above 420 kV, and not mentioned here.
resistors is plotted. In is the nominal discharge current (in Figure 1
e.g. In=10 kA). Up is the protection level. It is defined as the
maximum voltage at the resistor during the flow of In. Uc is defined
as the r.m.s.value of the Maximum Continuous Operating Voltage The contact areas of the MO-resistors are metallized with soft
aluminium up to the edge of the block, the surface is passivated
(MCOV) of the resistor.
with glass. In this way the MO-material of the MO-resistors
produced by ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd is completely
covered. The Figure 2 shows MO-resistors which are used in the
In = 10 kA medium voltage arresters.
20
[kV] The energy capability of the MO-resistors depends besides the
volume also on the construction of the arrester (carrying-off of
13 Up = 4 p.u heat). Chapter 4 gives more details concerning this.
10
MO
5.66 2 x Uc
SiC
200A
0
10-4 10-2 1 10 2 10 4 [A]
d.c. voltage measurement current wave 8 / 20 ms
Semi-logarithmic plot of the current-voltage characteristics of
MO and SiC resistors for Uc = 4 kV
Figure 1
The characteristic curve in Figure 1 corresponds to a resistor with
Uc = 4 kV. In the case of a d.c. voltage load with 2 x Uc = 5.66 kV a
d.c.current in the range of 0.1 mA flows. The capacitive component
at 50 Hz and the value of Uc lies in the vicinity of 0.5 mA. The
protective level Up when In = 10 kA amounts to 13 kV.
In comparison, the diagram also shows the curve of a SiC resistor,
which has also Up =13 kV. Since SiC exhibits a considerably less
non-linearity, the continous current of a SiC arrester without spark-
gaps at a nominal load would amount to about 200 A. Naturally, for
thermal reasons, such an arrester would not be feasible. Besides it Figure 2
would strain the electrical network much too much. Consequently
conventional arresters need spark-gaps in series, which take over MO-resistors (collection) produced by ABB
the voltage in continuous operation.
4

4 Medium Voltage Arresters of ABB
It was the wish to increase the reliability and the safety of the
arresters and correspondingly to it also the increasing of the
energy supply that brought about the development of the MO-
arresters with silicon housing in the 1980s. For more than 30
years is silicon known as an excellent insulation material for the
high voltage technology, as for instance the long rod insulators and
bushings. The first MO-arresters with silicon housing of the typical
ABB execution (direct moulding) were used in 1986. Now, in 1999
there are everywhere in the world more than 600 000 arresters in
use under very different ambient conditions.
4.1 Arrester construction
Generally an arrester is made up of two parts, the active part,
consisting of one or more piled up MO-resistors, and an insulating
housing, that guarantees both the insulation and the mechanical
strength.
The MO-resistors have been shortly described in the last chapter.
Fundamentally there are three different possibilities of
construction:
a glass-fibre reinforced tube is shed with an insulating material.
These so called hollow insulators have the same problems as the
porcelain insulators, they need a sealing and pressure relief
system, they can have inner partial discharges under pollution.
the active part is wrapped with glass-fibre material and is soaked
with resin, which makes up the whole into a rigid body. The
insulating polymeric housing is then thrust over the resin block or
shrunk on it. This costruction has the disadvantage that it forcible
breaks apart when the MO-blocks are overloaded. Another
disadvantage is the fact that there are different insulating
materials, which also means that there are more boundary layers.
Therefore it is necessary to take special measures for
sealing.
the active part is hold mechanically together with glass-fibre
reinforced loops or bands. The silicon is directly put on the MO-
resistors. This direct moulding has the advantage that no gas
volume stays in the arrester. Sealing problems and inner partial
discharges are in this way out of question. There are no interfaces
between polymeric materials where humidity can go in. An
explosion or a shattering of the housing is not possible.
All the medium voltage arresters of ABB are build up
corresponding to the third principle (direct moulding).
The requirements to the arresters depend on the operation
necessities and the type of the equipment to be protected. That is
why ABB offers a large selection of different types of arresters for
the medium voltage network and for special applications. The
construction, the functioning and the characteristics of the
arresters are described for instance in [5]. In the Table 2 there are
the electrical main data of the medium voltage arresters to be
found.
5 22
If, for a certain arrester type, the reactive power of the parallel
Arrester type In Up / Uc High current E / Uc Square wave capacitor bank exeeds the limiting values in Table 9, an arrester
On the other hand most of the d.c. current networks are
railnetworks. If the arresters are used on a rolling material
kA kA kJ / kV I in A t in ms with better energy qualities must be selected. For networks not (locomotive) the safety is especially important (safety of persons).
5 65 2000
operating under standard voltages, the limiting values in the
POLIM-DN 3.33 2.6 150
column with the lower standard voltage apply for SK. If the reactive
The arresters produced by ABB are suitable to be used on d.c.
POLIM-D 10 3.5 100 3.6 250 2000 power is very large, arresters connected parallel must be chosen.
current networks and especially also in the railnetworks and on
In such a case the arrester supplier must be informed in order to
locomotives and traction vehicles.
POLIM-DA 10 3.33 100 3.5 350 2000 take measures to guarantee a sufficiently good current distribution
in the parallel arresters. The supplier should also be consulted The producer has to be informed by all means if the arrester is used
MWK / MWD 10 3.07 100 5.5 550 2000 when arresters with Uc < Um are to be used. in d.c. current networks. For the dimensioning of the arrester it is
also necessary to take contact with the producer.
POLIM-I 10 3.07 100 5.5 550 2000
10.10 Line Traps (Parallel Protection)
POLIM-S 10 3.00 100 9.0 1000 2000
POLIM-H 20 3.19 100 13.3 1350 2000 Line traps are air-core chokes which are switched in connection
with the high voltage lines. Their inductivity L is in the range of mH. 12 Consulting Concernig Questions on the
Table 2 If no measures are taken, the lightning currents in the conductor
Electrical main data of the MV-surge arresters from ABB must flow through the line trap. Even relatively small current rates Use of Arresters
(most common types). E / Uc as tested in the operating duty test. of rise of several kA /s would produce overvoltages on the line
trap amounting to several 1000 kV and resulting in a flashover. In
order to prevent this, MV-arresters are connected parallel to the During many discussions with the users of surge arresters it was
line trap. These will take over lightning currents and limit the noticed that a profound consulting on the use of arresters is
overvoltage to its residual voltage. welcome. This is necessary both by changes in technology, as for
The outdoor arresters have sheded housings made of silicon. The instance from the spark-gap arresters with insulation of porcelain
type MWD for the use indoor has a smooth silicon housing. (see When a short to earth occurs in a high voltage network, the fault to the MO-arresters with silicon housing, and by the choosing of
Figure 3 and 3a) current IK flows through the conductor. This power frequency the arresters for additional equipment of alredy existing
current would overload the arrester. Uc must therefore be selected installations or the planing of new installation in the medium and
so that the current flows through the line trap. It induces a low voltage networks. Especially in the new fields of application, as
temporary overvoltage of UTOV = x L x IK, standard for Uc, at the for instance in the d.c. current networks, or the designs for the
line trap. If the fault current duration is t < 3s, then T = 1.28. This protection against overvoltages and lightning danger in whole
results in the following for Uc : installations it is necessary a profound observation. The evaluation
of the existing installations from the point of view of the power
UTOV x L x IK transfer (higher system voltage) or the reliability and availability
stipulate clear protection concepts, taking into account an optimal
Uc > ---------- = ----------------
economic and technical solution.
T 1.28
Hence we offer gladly consultig and calculation for the protection
IK : maximum fault current through the line trap against overvoltage and lightning, which exceed the above
described instructions.
L : inductivity of the line trap
13. Conclusions
Figure 3
MO-surge arresters with silicone housing. (POLIM-family)
11 Arresters for D.C. Voltage
Lightning overvoltages are a hazard for all the electrical equipment
For the time being there are no international valid regulations or in a MV network. However, surge arresters assure reliable protect-
directions for the use of the arresters in d.c.voltage networks. On ion against excessive overvoltage stresses. The closer the arrester
principle in d.c.voltage networks there also appear voltages to the electrical equipment, the better the protection.
produced by lightning or other activities, which may endanger the
equipment and the insulation. In this case it is also necessary the
When determining the arrester Uc, two contradictory requirements
use of an arrester as protection against overvoltages. For such
must be considered.
situation the MO surge arresters are especially suitable, because
they do not conduct any follow current after the limiting of the On the one hand, UP must be as small as possible so that the
overvoltage, and therefore it is not necessary to extinguish any arrester can limit the overvoltage to the lowest possible values. On
d.c.current arc. There are two fundamental items to be taken into the other hand, Uc must be selected at a value high enough to allow
consideration when using the MO-arresters in the d.c.current the arrester to fulfill the requirements of network operation.
networks. On one hand it is necessary to make sure that the MO Modern MO-arresters with no spark-gaps meet both these
material is stable for a long period of time from the point of view of requirements and provide sufficient protection from overvoltage,
the d.c. voltage continuous operation. This is not the case with all as well as simultaneously assuring safe network operation.
the MO materials which are comercially available.
Figure 3a
MO-surge arresters with silicone housing
left: MWK for outdoor application
right: MWD for indoor application
The arrester type POLIM-H 15 is sufficient. Its protection level at I =
10 kA is 43.5 kV. This special arrester guarantees a 11% lower
protection level. In addition this arrester has also advantages with
regard to operational safety thanks to its substantially higher
energy absorption capability (see Table 2).
Generators have a larger capacity between phase and earth. As
seen in Figure 14, this capacity results in a considerably shorter
arrester protective distance. Therefore it is especially important to
place arresters near the generator.
10.7 Arrester Protection for Motors
High voltage motors can become over-stressed by multiple re-
starts being switched off during the run-up. This is applicable
when the cut-off current is less than 600 A. In order to protect
these motors it is recommended that surge arresters be placed
directly at the motor terminals or, alternatively, at the circuit
breaker. The layout of Uc according to the recommendations can
be seen in section 8.
In special cases, i.e. aged winding insulation, it becomes
necessary to additionally decrease the protection level of the
arrester. One way of doing this is to decrease Uc. This procedure is
justifiable when temporary overvoltages taken into account for Uc
occur very infrequently. The fact that in such a rare case the
arrester could become overloaded has been deliberately taken into
account. Resulting drawbacks, such as operation interruptions
and arrester replacement are outweighted by the advantage of
better overvoltage protection. However Uc smaller than Um / 3
may never be selected.
However such a decrease of Uc is not recommended in a generator.
The risk exists that this would cause a two-phase short circuit at
the generator terminals. The resulting asymmetrical short circuit
current in the windings produces an extremely high mechanical
load on the rotor.
10.8 Overvoltage Protection in Locomotives
In the case of locomotives, the highest standards with respect to
operational safety are placed on the arresters. Therefore, the
arresters of the POLIM-H series are recommended. The strong
mechanical construction meets all the requirements for railway
operation. The completely moulding in silicon guarantees the
highest mechanical safety even during extreme shock loads. When
an arrester is overloaded the special construction of this arrester
prevents the housing from bursting. This arrester type is proved up
to a fault current in the network of 65 kA and can be considered
sure from the point of view of explosion and disintegration.
Additional advantages of this arrester type are its low protection
level and its high energy absorption capability.
10.9 Arresters Parallel to a Capacitor Bank
Normally no overvoltage occurs when a capacitor bank is
switched. The circuit breaker interrupts the current in the natural
current zero crossing and the voltage in the capacitor to earth
reaches a max. of 1.5 p.u. As a result of the network voltage vary-
ing at the power frequency, a voltage across the open circuit
breaker of 2.5 p.u. is caused. If the breaker re-strikes, a high
frequency transient effect takes place between the capacitor
voltage and the operating voltage.
21
During this process the capacitor is charged with a higher voltage The diameter of the MO-resistors is proportional to the energy In the last 15 years most of the modern MO-arresters were set in
[21]. The overvoltage of the capacitor between phase and earth absorption capability E and the nominal discharge current In. The new installations in high-voltage networks [4]. Up until a few years
[15] reaches a max. of 3 p.u. If the capacitors are connected in a special arresters of the type POLIM-S and POLIM-H have resistors ago conventional arresters,consisting of SiC resistors and series
star, they are discharged between phase and earth by the arrester like the ones of the high voltage arresters. These types of arresters spark-gaps were still installed in distribution systems. Now a days,
parallel to the bank. During the discharge up to a voltage of 2 x set new standards in the medium voltage network ; they are able to MO-arresters without spark-gaps are in use, especially those with
Uc, in terms of power, the arrrester is loaded with: resist the strongest stress and at the same time they guarantee a polymer housing. The reasons for this technological change are
low protection level. The continuous operating voltage Uc of the increasing operation efficiency, lower protection level with very
MV-arresters in the Table 3 reaches from 4 kV up to 36 kV. steep overvoltages and high pollution resistance [5].
SK
Ec = ----------- x [3 - (Uc / Um)2]
In addition to the already mentioned types ABB manufactures also Due to the simple construction of the active part without spark-
the special arrester POLIM-C. This arrester is also built up gaps, which means a very high stability from the mechanical point
SK : 3-phase reactive power of the capacitor bank according to the already mentioned principle of direct moulding. of view, and also due to the simple construction generally
Ec : the discharge energy taken up by the arrester The nominal discharge current is In = 10 kA and the continuous speaking, such arresters can also undertake the support insulator
operating voltage Uc reaches from1 kV up to 7.2 kV. In the medium function and are not in danger of exploding in case of an overload.
Assuming that the arrester must carry out this process 3 times voltage system this type of arrester is used among other Silicone is the best insulating material concerning dirt, and that is
with no cool down phase, it follows with Uc > Um that applications for the protection of non-earthed cable sheath. why the arresters which are insulated with silicone behave
favourable especially with high pollution.
The functioning of an arrester, which consists only of series
Ec 6 x SK
---- > ------------- connections of MO-resistors (without spark-gaps), is extremely
simple. During an overvoltage at the arrester terminals the current
Uc x Um rises continuously and without delay through the arrester corre-
4.2 Insulation made of silicone rubber
sponding to the shown U-I characteristic, Figure 4, which means
The power consumption capacity E of the arrester must be that no really spark over takes place, but the arrester goes Silicone rubber (usually referred to simply as 'silicone') is an
adjusted to the reactive power of the bank. Table 9 shows the continuously to the conducting condition. After the decreasing of excellent insulating material for high-voltage components.
maximum allowable reactive power values for different types of the overvoltage the current becomes low again corresponding to Comparisons with traditional insulating materials, such as
ABB MV-arresters parallel to the bank. the U-I characteristic. Unlike the spark-gap arresters there flows ceramic, glass and other synthetics (eg, Ethylene-Propylene-
no follow current. Diene Monomer, or short EPDM) show clearly the superiority of
silicone. As already short mentioned, during the manufacture of
If the neutral of the capacitor bank is insulated, the arrester cannot the surge arrester the silicone insulation is bonded to the arrester
discharge the charged capacitor between phase and earth. The
assembly through casting (or injection) of the liquid rubber in
arrester does not get charged. It must be noted that after a re-strike moulds at a high temperature. Different moulds can be used to
of the breaker, the neutral of the bank increases to 2 p.u. A voltage U
4/10ms obtain an optimum match between the insulator and the
flashover of the neutral to earth results in the arrester having to [p.u.]
component assembly. The arrester insulator thus produced
1/5ms
discharge the capacitor. The arresters parallel to a bank with an exhibits the following properties:
insulated neutral must, in terms of power, be adjusted to their 8/20ms
reactive power. 1.0
30/60ms
2000ms
No hydrocarbon is present in the main chemical chain; this
If the bank remains disconnected from the network after a shut- property is partially the reason for the high immunity of the
down, the arresters discharge the voltage to zero, not merely to insulator to serious surface pollution and is also largely
2 x Uc. Below 2 x Ucthe discharge current through the arrester 0.5 responsible for preventing carbonized creepage paths from
is very small, so that the remaining discharge takes a long time. forming.
During this time the arrester can cool down. It releases more heat
than it receives during the remaining discharge. Therefore it was The material is water-repellent, so that even after excessive
justified in the above calculation of Ec to take into account only the 0
contact with water only very few drops adhere to the surface. This
energy taken up by the arrester, up to the discharge at 2 x Uc. 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 I [A] property is referred to in the industry as hydrophobicity. Drops of
water that do cling to the surface are quickly removed by the effect
Figure 4 of gravity or through normal exposure to wind.
Arrester type POLIM-D MWK POLIM-S POLIM-H Normalised current-voltage ( U-I)
Uc > Um MWD characteristic of a MO-surge arrester with In = 10 kA
POLIM-I
The hydrophobicity effect is also partly transferred to any dirt
E/Uc [kJ/kV] 3.6 5.5 9.0 13.3 deposits on the surface, which as a result does not become coated
The number of the resistors in a stack depends on the Uc of the with layers of semiconducting material as quickly as with other
Um [kV] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] arrester. The stack of cylindrical MO-resistors is moulded in types of insulation. Because of this, the surface leakage currents
polymeric material (silicone) as described. flowing on silicone insulators are extremely low. The technical
3.6 0.67 1.03 1.69 2.50 literature explains the transfer of the hydrophobicity effect to dirt
7.2 1.35 2.07 3.39 5.01 The resistor stack behaves itself capacitive under Uc. The stray deposits as being due to low-molar silicone evaporating. The
capacitances of each individual resistor towards the earth cause hydrophobicity effect is temporarily reduced by strong electrical
12 2.26 3.45 5.65 8.35 the nonlinearity of the voltage distribution along the axes of partial discharges or extreme exposure to water, but to a lesser
arrester under Uc. This nonlinearity increases with the lenght of the degree with silicone than with other materials. This is clearly
17.5 3.29 5.03 8.24 12.18
resistor stack [3]. That is why high voltage arresters need grading shown by the artificial aging af EPDM and silicone in accordance
24 4.52 6.90 11.30 16.70 rings, which compensate mainly the unfavourable influence of the with IEC 1109, see Figure 5. After 5,000 hours of alternated
stray capacitances. Due to the relatively short length of the active precipitation, salt-fog and UV radition, the silicone still retains 50
36 6.78 10.36 16.95 25.05 part of the distribution surge arresters the nonlinear voltage percent of its water-repellent properties, whereas EPDM loses
distribution is so low that it can be neglected. These arresters do these properties. Tests have further shown that the hydrophobicity
not need any grading rings. effect can be restored to its original state by drying the silicone for
Table 9 several hours.
Arrester parellel to capacitor bank. Maximum allowable reactive The salt-fog test to IEC 507 also demonstrated that, assuming the
power SK of the bank for the indicated arrester types. Three same salinity in each case, the creepage paths required for silicone
discharges without a cool down phase are allowed for the insulation are, on average, 30 percent shorter than the paths
arresters. necessary with ceramic isolators, see Figure 5a. As a result, the
E/Uc: The arrester energy absorbtion capability in relation to Uc. creepage path of the silicone isolators could be reduced by this
amount.
6
 0%=^ 7 4.3 Energy absorption capability and cool-down time 10.4 Transformer Connected to a Lightning Endangered Conditions are different when arresters must contain switching
Line on One Side Only overvoltages rather than lightning overvoltages. The former could
6
The arresters in the network can work reliable if their energy occur during switching, when an inductive current is interrupted
absorption capability is bigger than the energy strain expected in before it reaches its natural zero crossing. When such switching
5 In general, all transformer exits which are directly linked to overvoltages occur, the current load on the arrester is very low, so
HC Hydrophobicity

the system operation. Some examples of the stress on the lightning endangered lines must be equipped with arresters
arresters in the network are shown in the Table 3. The arresters of that a nominal discharge current of 5 kA is sufficient. On this case
4 between phase and earth. If a transformer connects a high voltage the maximum overvoltage is considerably lower than Up for MO-
the line discharge class 1 have the highest energy stress with the network with a MV network, and only the line on the high voltage
3 high current (65 kA respectively 100 kA). To prove the thermal arresters. Therefore, shorter distances between arresters and
side is lightning endangered, arresters are required there. Because between the arrester and earth are possible, facilitating the
stability under this stress, a special type test has to be performed. overvoltages occur very quickly, up to 40% of the overvoltage on
2 installation of arresters in the cells. The lower values for these
the high voltage side is capacitively carried over to the MV side distances are prescribed in the respective national regulations and
^1 3.5 p.u. Charging voltage current wave form through the transformer (10). It is therefore often necessary to are sufficient for metal oxide arresters.
100%= Arrester type foresee overvoltage protection for the transformer on the MV side,
In High current
200 km line 10 km cable 4/10 ms even though no lightning overvoltages occur on the MV side,
0 8/20 ms The maximum voltage for arresters with spark-gaps reaches Up
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 h 5000 according to the above assumptions. According to (9), this
tv test time kJ/kV Uc kJ/kV Uc kA kJ/kV Uc kA kJ/kV Uc overvoltage protection can be a long MV cable, a low-inductance also during switching overvoltages. The minimum distances for
POLIM-DN capacitor, or a combination of these two elements. They must be these arresters must therefore be longer in order to prevent
0.4 0.33 5 0.26 65 2.6 flashovers. This can make arrester installation in the cells
Figure 5 connected as close as possible to the MV exit of the transformer
POLIM-D 0.4 0.33 10 0.55 100 3.6 and together possess a capacity of at least 50 nF per phase. significantly more difficult, particularly when there are especially
Change of hydrophobicity of EPDM (black) and silicone (white) tight spacing conditions.
in the accelerated ageing test acc. to IEC 1109. POLIM-DA 0.4 0.33 10 0.53 100 3.5
The overvoltage protection can also come from a MV arrester. This
MWK, MWD solution has two essential advantages. First, it must be noted that 10.6 Generator Connected to a Lightning Endangered
POLIM-I 0.4 0.33 10 0.48 100 3.4 inductively transferred overvoltage can be incraesed by Distribution Line
capacitors. Carefully chosen damping resistors in series to the
POLIM-S 0.4 0.33 10 0.47 100 3.3 capacitors make possible a partial decrease of this additional
The short-time tests acc. to IEC 507 provide the basis for the Overvoltage protection is the result of arresters placed between
0.4 0.33
voltage load on the transformers. When a MO-arrester without a phase and earth. If a loaded generator is suddenly disconnected
dimensions of the insulator. In certain cases, the insulator be- POLIM-H 20 1.0 100 3.2
spark-gap is used, this additional load does not occur. from the network, its terminal voltage increases until the voltage
haviour may deviate under actual field conditions as a result of
other parameters (eg, due to the shape of the sheds). However, it is Table 3 regulator has readjusted itself after a few seconds. The relationship
generally true for silicone as well as for the ceramic insulators that Energy load of arresters in MV-networks Secondly, primary voltage encroaches on the MV-voltage during a between this temporary overvoltage and the normal operating
extreme pollution calls for a longer creepage path. voltage flashover in the transformer and can cause additional voltage is called the load rejection factor uL. This factor can reach a
The guaranteed energy absorption capability of the types of the damage there. When the MV side is protected with arresters, the value of up to 1.5. In the worst case, the arrresters could be
The mentioned temporary reduction in hydrophobicity was taken
line discharge class 2 and higher can be proved by the means of arrester sacrifices itself, causing a short to earth, and leaving the charged with a temporary overvoltage of UTOV = uL x Um, wich
into account in the design of the POLIM arresters, and the specific
rectangular current stresses, similar to the examination of the high damage essentially restricted to the transformer. The advantage of must be taken into account when choosing Uc.
creepage path was not reduced. All of the discussed surge
voltage arresters. an arrester versus a capacitor is particularly evident when the
arresters with silicone insulation have been designed with a
The guarantee data contain a certain amount of energy reserve and transformer is connected to a generator, and the arrester protects
specific creepage path of at least 25 mm per kV, providing a more uL x Um
therefore do not mean the limit of the thermal stability of the the generator from subsequent damage.
than adequate safety margin. Whenever possible, all the pollution Uc > ----------------
and lifetime tests were carried out on complete MO arresters. The arrester.
Similar conditions exist with a distribution transformer, which T
tests were performed to the various standards (eg, the 1,000-hour
humidity room test to IEC 1109, the 5,000-hour aging cycle test Anyway the arresters will be very strongly warmed up when they connects a MV network to a low-voltage network. Again, lightning
and the salt-fog test to IEC 507) and showed that the silicone overvoltage from the MV network is transferred through the The duration t of UTOV determines T and lies in a range from 3 to 10
have to carry very high lightning currents. Therefore they need
insulation performs better after ten years in service that the other transformer capacitively to the low voltage side. Therefore, seconds. In the following example, Uc of type MWK arresters is
between two such stresses a suitable cool-down time. This
types of insulation. arresters in the low voltage side are necessary, even when only the determined:
reduction is however not important because it is most unlikely that
the same arrester has to carry a second very high ligtning current MV side is lightning endangered. If, on the other hand, only the low
during its cool-down time. That is the reason why the test sample voltage side is endangered, frequently no arresters are mounted on Um = 14 kV uL = 1.4
is allowed to be cooled-down to 60 C during the type test with the MV side. In this case, it is assumed that the low voltage
high current [6] between the two surges. arrester can also adequately protect the MV side from overvoltage
8
coming from the low voltage side. Several cases of transformer t = 10 s T = 1.26 (from Figure 8)
cm/kVrms
failure caused by lightning overvoltage on the 415 volt side are
5 The needed cool-down time of the arrester depends among other reported in [20]. The author's opinion is that these overvoltages,
4 things on the ambient temperature and the height of the operating when they are of long durations, are transferred inductively with
3 voltage. It increases with the ambient temperature and the opera- the turn ratio of the transformer to the 11 kV side. In any case, the 1.4 x 14 kV
ting voltage. In the most unfavourable case, with 45C air 415 volt arresters were unable to prevent flashovers in the 11 kV
temperature and Uc the following values are valid: Uc > ------------------- = 15.56 kV
2 windings. In regions with high lightning activity, it is therefore
1.26
Creapage

Cool-down time between two high ligtning current stresses (65 kA recommended to install arresters on the MV side of the
respectively 100 kA): transformer.
1 Type POLIM-S and POLIM-H no break necessary The arrester type needed is called MWK 16. Its Uc is 16 kV and the
The other arrester types 75 minutes protection level at In = 10 kA is 49.1 kV.
2.5
0 10.5 Arresters in Metal Enclosed MV Substations
0 3 4 5 7 10 15 20 30 40 kg/m3 80
Cool-down time between two energy stresses acc. the Table 2: The high operational safety requirements for generators make the
salt content of water use of arresters with the lowest possible protection level desirable.
Type POLIM-S and POLIM-H 60 minutes It is often necessary to place arresters in a metal enclosed MV Therefore the special POLIM-H series arrester is recommended for
The other arrester types 60 minutes substation. If a cable connects the cell with a lightning endangered generator protection. Not only is the protection level lower, but also
Figure 5a line, the nominal discharge current of the arrester at the cable head at the same time is T larger.
Comparison of the specific creapage distance of porcelain (black) in the cell should be 10 kA. The voltage on the arrester can be
expected to reach Up. In order to prevent flashovers in the cell, the
and silicone insulators (white), depending on the salt content in the 4.4 Nominal Discharge Current and Energy Absorption For t =10 s, T = 1.31 is permitted, which results in:
minimum distances between the arresters and the arresters and
salt fog test acc. to IEC 507 Capability earth recommended by the supplier must be observed.

The arresters with a nominal discharge current of 5 kA proved to be 1.4 x 14 kV

enough reliable in the MV- network. That is why generally the type Uc > ------------------ = 14.96 kV
POLIM-D respectively the type POLIM-DN are used. 1.31

7 20
Naturally, cables in overhead lines are lightning endangered on
both sides. Therefore it must be taken into account that in cables
with one-sided protection, overvoltage can also come from the
unprotected side. In this case, the protection effectiveness of the
arrester at the other end would be strongly reduced. The allowable
length of cables in overhead lines with one-sided protection is
therefore smaller. The length is especially short for cables in
connection with wooden pole lines, as shown in Table 7. The given
values for LK are valid for arresters with In = 10 kA. The surge
impedance across the entire cable section must be constant so that
the voltage reflections do not cause a decrease in LK. This is the
case, for example, with cable junctions or when a cable section
with a single cable is connected to a section with two parallel
cables.
10.2 Cable Sheath Protection
Due to thermal principles, the sheath for single conductor cables
are generally only earthed on one side. Under these circumstances
the sheath on the unearthed side can take on up to 50 % of the
voltage peak value of the overvoltage entering on the inner
conductor. The sheath insulation cannnot withstand this
overvoltage demand. Momentary flashovers can occur between
the sheath and the earth, consequently damaging the outer sheath
insulation.
Therefore, the unearthed cable sheath must be protected against
lightning overvoltage with an arrester [2]. The special arrester
POLIM-C is particularly well-suited for this purposes. The voltage
induced along the cable sheath during a short circuit is decisive for
Uc of the arrester. According to [19] it reaches maximum 0.3 kV per
kA of fault current and km of cable length. When T = 1.28 and the
fault current duration is t < 3 s, the following results:
Uc > 0.24 x IK x LK in kV
IK: max. 50 Hz fault current in kA
LK: length of the unearthed cable section in km
U UK UT MV
K N
b a
F
A1 A2
Transformer at the end of a cable
F: lightning endangered line
U: lightning overvoltage
K: long cable
A1, A2: arresters
a, b: length of the connecting lines
UK : maximum voltage at the cable end
UT: maximum voltage at the transformer
MV::
LV:
medium voltage side
low voltage side
Figure 17
10.3 Transformers at the End of Cables The energy absorption capability of these types is much higher In porcelain housed arresters the ensuing electric arc causes the
than the expected stresses in the network, exepting the very high gas pressure in the housing to elevate quickly. If the network short
According to the direction in Figure 17, a cable of at least 100 m in ligtning currents. These currents can also be commanded by the circuit current is not too high, the pressure relief valve in the
length is connected on one end to a lightning endangered line. At arresters, it is however most unlikely that they appear. Such high arrester opens before the housing bursting pressure is reached.
the other end, a bus bar consisting of sections a and b connects the lightning currents can flow through the arrester only when a On the other hand, if the current is extremely high, the possibility of
cable end on the other side with a transformer. Arrester A1 takes lightning hits directly the top of the arrester. The energy values are the housing exploding cannot be ruled out.
over the overvoltage protection on the line side. The cable end and given in Table 2 and 3. With ABB silicon-polymer arresters there is no danger of bursting
the transformer must each be protected with an additional arrester By aerial lines with wooden poles even far away lightning strokes in the case of an overload. There is no air space between the active
when the connecting distance between the two is especially long. can cause relatively high currents that flow through the arrester. If part of the arrester and its silicon insulation, thus there is no place
The following example indicates under what circumstances the sparkover voltage of the wire against the earth is U = 3000 kV for pressure to build up. In the case of an overload, holes appear in
arrester A2 offers sufficient overvoltage protection, in addition to and the characteristic wave impedance of the wire is Z = 450 W the casing which immediately leads to initiation of the external
arrester A1. from the equation (3) ensue that lightning currents up to13 kA are flashover.
to be expected in the arrester. This current produce in arresters The MV-arresters of the types POLIM-D, MWK and MWD are
with In = 5 kA a residual stress which lies 15% over Up. In this way proved with short circuit currents up to 20 kA. The types POLIM-I,
The overvoltage reflection U at the junction from the line to the
cable causes a strong flattening of the voltage rate of rise in the the protection of the electrical equipment gets worse. For instance POLIM-S and POLIM-H are tested with short circuit currents up to
cable. However, this has practically no influence on the allowable if it lies at the end of an aerial line of 10 km it will be once in three 65 kA. Because of their special construction the arresters are also
length of the connection b, because with increasing length of b the years exposed to such an increased voltage stress. That is why up to the highest short circuit currents insured against explosion
voltage UK increases very quickly. Optimal overvoltage protection, ABB has also in the assortment of the MV-arresters the types and destruction.
therefore, requires that arrester A2 be placed as close as possible MWK, MWD, POLIM-I, POLIM-S and POLIM-H. They posses
to the cable end, in order to shorten the distance b (see section 10.1). nominal discharge currents of 10 kA respectively 20 kA. Their
employment is recommended everywhere where in terms of
5.2 Elevated Ambient Temperatures
stress, operation safety and protection level the highest
requirements are set. The guaranteed values for Uc are valid for an ambient temperature
of up to 45 C. In the case of outdoor arresters, extreme solar
This is the case in radiation (1.1 kW/m2) is taken into account. If there are other heat
MO-surge arrester with sources in the vicinity of the arrester, the increase in radiation
Up = 3.8 p.u. bei
In = 10 kA
wooden poles earthed crossarms regions with high lightning activity exposure must also be taken into account and the value of Uc
increased if necessary. If the ambient temperature exceeds 45 C,
erial lines with concrete or wooden poles and non-earthed
Uc must be increased by 2 % for every 5 C of temperature eleva-
ZK [] 30 60 30 60
crossarms tion.
Um [kV] a [m] a [m] a [m] a [m] arresters, which are placed on locations where people are often
to be found 5.3 Mechanical Stability
3.6 300 300 500 500
on lines, which set exeptional high requirements
7.2 43 37 53 53
concerning the operation safety MV-arresters produced by ABB are operationally reliable even in
areas of high earthquake activity. Silicon arresters from ABB can
12 20 14 20 14 protection of engines, generators and cables also have a support function. In the case of cantilever strength, it
must be distinguished between temporary and operational loads
17.5 17 10 16 10 areas with high industrial pollution, or when the arresters are according to DIN 48113. The permissible loads result from the
24 19 12 19 12 not farther than 1000 m from the sea. product of arrester altitude and maximum permissible momentum
load. In Table 4 there are the mechanical data of different arrester
36 16 11 20 11
In cases where the 10 kA arresters are recommended is also a types to be read.
higher energy absorption capability advantageous and an arrester
Table 8 type with a line discharge class 2 or more should be chosen. That is
why these arresters have a higher energy capability of at least 5.5 Vertical
Canti lever strength Torsion
LV Maximum permissible distance a between cable end and kJ/kVUc (MWK, POLIM-I, POLIM-S) Arrester type Nm Nm
Load
transformer according Figure 17 with b=O. The cable is connected
to a lightning endangered line and protected at both ends with The peculiarity of some electrical equipment, as for instance POLIM-DN 250 50 625
MO-surge arresters (type MWK or MWD with Uc = Um)
The transformer has no additional arrester protection.
arc furnace POLIM-D 250 50 625
ZK: Surge impedance of the cable. big capacitor batteries POLIM-DA 350 50 1000
very long cable sections MWK, MWD 350 68 1200
expensive rotating machines
POLIM-I 2500 100 2000
can make a higher energy absorption capability necessary. In such
POLIM-S 4000 100 3000
The line section a is different. Here UT increases more slowly with cases the special type POLIM-H with In = 20 kA and with 13.3
the increasing length of a. Therefore, the transformer is adequately kJ/kVUc is preferred. POLIM-H 6000 100 4000
protected, even at a relatively far distance from the arrester. The Table 4
maximum allowable values for a are indicated in Table 8. The
capacity of the transformer is assumed to be 2 nF. Smaller values 5 Special Operating Conditions Mechanical data of MV-surge arresters, produced by ABB
result in greater distances of a.
5.4 Air Pollution
5.1 Network Short Circuit Power
Silicon is the best insulating material against pollution. This is
Any arrester can be overloaded. The causes are extremely high mainly because the material is water-repellent. Silicon arresters
stroke currents, a large number of multiple strokes [16, 17] or the behave more favourably under conditions of heavy air pollution
so-called system flashover. This is understood to be a short circuit than porcelain housed arresters or other polymer insulation
between two different voltage levels. The voltage at the arrester on materials. In addition the self-cleaning feature of silicon itself is
the lower voltage level rises above the allowable limit. An overload outstanding. Pollutants and dirt cannot adhere well to the flexible
of any kind causes a flashover or puncture in the resistor. An arc covering and are washed away by rain.
results in the arrester and the current from this arc is defined by the
short circuit power of the network.
19 8
 A true comparison with a MO-arrester necessitates a rise time The shorter the sum of the connecting lines a + b compared with L The flashover of a bus bar or a conductor of a line toward the earth
which also lies in the range of 50 ns. With such a steep front the in Figure 14, the lower the failure rate. In other words, a + b must be causes a short operation shutdown at the most. Subsequent
sparkover voltage reaches a value of at least 1.4 Up. It follows that as small as possible , and L must be as large as possible. The latter damage is, however extremly rare. In cables, flashover behaviour
by a steep rise the limiting voltage of the spark-gap arrester is at is achieved by choosing the proper line direction. As can be seen in is completely different. Flashovers in cable insulation can cause
least 24 % higher than that of the MO-arrester. Figure 15, the line must be first connected with the arrester and disturbances and require extensive repairs. Flashovers along the
then connected with the transformer. In this case b = 0 and L cable heads can damage these and exibit the same damage as with
The behaviour of the arrester during switching overvoltages is a becomes maximal. The connecting line L can be held short by insulation flashovers. Cables must therefore be treated as station
further feature of the protection characteristics. In spark-gap placing the arrester as close as possible to the transformer. Both equipment and protected against lightning overvoltage with
arresters the sparkover voltage reaches approx. the value of Up measures together make it possible to fulfill the requirements of arresters.
with these relatively slowly rising overvoltages. MO-arresters have a + b << L and therefore keep the failure rate considerably below The arresters are to be placed directly next to the cable heads. The
no sparkover voltage. With MV-arresters the switching protection 10%. junction lines should be as short as possible. It must be noted that
level is given through the residual voltage at 500 A of the current the earth connection of the arrester is attached to the cable sheath.
wave 30/60 ms. The residual voltage reaches 0.77.... 0.83 Up If the transformer is connected to a wooden pole line, and if
depending on the arrester type. The limiting voltage during
Figure 6 switching overvoltages of spark-gap arresters is at least 20 % U U
b<1m when Um < 24 kV Arrester with LK LK
Repelling water on silicone surface (hydrophobicity-effect) higher than that of MO-arresters. Up = 3.8 p.u. for MO
Up = 4 p.u. for SiC
At the same continuous operating voltage the MO-arresters and In = 10 kA
therefore demonstrate a more favorable protection characteristic b < 0.6 m when Um > 24 kV
5.5 Altitude Adjustement for Arrester Housing than spark-gap arresters. The above mentioned figures are valid Type of Line Wooden pole earthed Wooden pole earthed
for arresters employed in networks with high-ohmic insulated cannot be maintained, then the line is to be modified so that crossarms crossarms
Normal MV-arresters from ABB can be used at altitudes of up to neutral. Regarding the operational safety, MO-arresters have an regarding the overvoltage at the substation and the protective Arrester Type MO SiC MO SiC MO SiC MO SiC
1800 m above sea level. additional advantage in the fact that they can also resist temporary distance, it behaves as favourably as a line with earthed cross Um ZK LK LK LK LK LK LK LK LK
overvoltages as shown in Figure 8. arms. [kV] [] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m]
At higher altitudes the air density is so low that the withstand
MO and spark-gap arresters must be dimensioned differently in 30 7 6 17 17

8 8

8 8

8 8

8 8
voltage of the arrester housing may be no longer sufficient against 3.6
networks with solidly earthed neutral systems [8]. The result is 60 3 3 10 10
external flashovers. In this case the unaltered active parts of the The necessary measures for this are relatively simple: the cross 30 64 30 64 28 9 9 22 14
arrester (same protection level) must be placed in an elongated that Uc can be chosen 28 % lower than the rated voltage of the arms of the last three poles before the station are to be earthed. The 7.2
60 45 20 50 19 4 4 13 11
housing with a larger flashover distance. spark-gap arrester. Thereby a protection characteristic results for overvoltage which runs into the station from the modified lines 30 40 15 40 14 9 7 19 9
the MO technology which, depending on the wave form, lies 28 % now have the same form as if it came from a line with continuous 12
60 30 11 32 10 4 3 14 7
to 42 % lower. earthed crossarms. The disadvantage of this solution is that
As an orientation value one may consider that for every 1000 m 17.5
30 25 6 26 5 6 4 15 4
over 1800 m above sea level the flashover distance of the housing additional lightning overvoltages cause flashovers between the 60 21 4 22 4 3 2 13 3
must be enlarged by 12 %. For example, at an altitude of 3300 m conductor and the earth owing to the reduced insulation level of the 30 28 6 28 5 10 5 17 4
6.2 Questions of Stability of MO Surge Arresters line. A more efficient method than the earthing the cross arms 24
above sea level the flashover distance of the housing must be 18 % 60 23 5 24 4 5 3 15 3
larger than of a normal arrester. would be to install another set of arresters one pole in front of the 30 22 1 22 1 8 1 15 1
In Figure 7, P is the power loss of the MO-resistors in an arrester 36
substation. The effect is a very strong reduction in the amplitude of 60 20 1 20 1 4 1 14 1
when Uc is applied. It is evident how P exponentially increases with the incoming overvoltage. This in turn leads to a protective
the MO temperature, which also results in an increased warming of behaviour of the arrester at the equipment which is better than that Table 7
6 Protection Characteristics of the Surge the active parts. The cooling of the resistors results from the flow of earthed cross arms. Maximum allowable length LK of cable sections with one-sided
arrester protection. The cable is connected to a lightning
of heat Q from the active part to the exterior. At temperatures above
Arrester, Stability the critical point is P > Q. Here the cooling is not sufficient to endangered line.
dissipate the power loss. The resistors would continue to heat up Lightning overvoltage and momentary value of system voltage
and the arrester would be destroyed by overheating. Through having different polarities.
6.1 Surge Arrester Protection Level
suitably dimensioning of the resistors and through design
10 Some Special Cases
measures that enable the cool down of the blocks, it is possible to Junction length arrester to cable 1 m
The protection level Up is the maximum voltage at the arrester raise the critical point to such a level, that even if during the On one hand the protective distance of an arrester is, in some ZK: Surge impedance of the cable
terminals during the flow of the nominal discharge current which, operation the highest energies are likely to occur, this critical point cases, not especially long. This applies mostly to electrical equip- MO: Metal oxide arrester
according to definition, shows a current form of 8/20 s. The peak is impossible to be reached. ment which is subject to capacitance in substations with a high SiC: Arrester with spark-gap
value of the current is reached after approx. 8 s and after approx. On the other hand, the mechanism described clearly shows the network voltage and which are connected to wooden poles (see
20 s it has decayed to 50 % of the peak value. In the case of spark- limits of the energy absorption capacity of the MO-arrester. The Figure 14), on the other hand pieces of electrical equipment in a
gap arresters Up is additionally given by the standard lightning amount of energy fed to it must never exceed the critical point. substation are seldom placed close together. Usually they are so Longer cables require arrester protection at both ends. For short
impulse sparkover voltage. This is the lowest prospective peak Then P < Q and the MO discs cool down until the stable operating far apart from each other that one arrester could not protect several cables sections onesided protection is, in some cases, sufficient.
value of a standard lightning voltage impulse (1.2/50 s) which, point is again reached. pieces of equipment at the same time. Under this conditions, each This is because an arrester at only one end can still offer sufficient
when applied to the arrester, causes sparkovers on every piece of electrical equipment requires a separate arrester set (one lightning overvoltage protection to the other end.
application. Virtually the same protection level is possible through arrester each per phase to earth). A cable which connects the overhead line with the substation is
MO and spark-gap arresters having identical continuous service P,Q often only endagered by lightning on the line. The arrester must
thermal runaway
voltage Uc. It lies at about Up = 3.33 Uc or under this value. More therefore be mounted to the line at the cable junction. No second
precise values are available in the corresponding booklets. arrester is necessary at the other end of the cable, as long as the
10.1 Overvoltage Protection in Cable Sections cable length LK does not exceed the values which are given in the
The protection characteristics of an arrester consists not only of critical point Table 7. At first glance, it should be noted that LK is unlimited in 3.6
the value Up, but of two additional features. The first is the The essential difference between the electrical data of overhead kV networks. This is because of the relatively high BIL of 13.6 p.u.
behaviour of the arrester during steep wave fronts, which is lines and cables is the surge impedance of their conductors to at this network level. The arrester at the line side of the cable limits
especially important for MV equipment. The test for MO-arresters Q P earth. Values for overhead distribution lines are approximately the overvoltage to approximately 4 p.u. As a result of voltage
takes place with the nominal discharge current, the front time of 300 to 450 and for cables in the 20 to 60 range. First of all, reflections in the cable, the overvoltage at the other end of the cable
stable
which is reduced from 8 s to 1 s. The residual voltage over the operating point this difference causes a marked decrease of the lightning over- is higher, but under 10 p.u. At this level, the overvoltage is
arrester reaches a maximum of 1.13 Up at this steep current wave. voltage as soon as the travelling wave reaches the cable entrance. harmless to the cable. This, however, does not apply to
Because of the non linearity of the current-voltage-characteristic The reduced voltage wave flows through the cable and it is equipments in the substation. With these equipments additional
of the MO-arrester, the front time of this residual voltage lies in the reflected at the end so that the voltage is nearly doubled. voltage reflections can increase the overvoltage, so that for their
order of magnitude of 50 ns. Subsequently the wave returns to the cable entrance and is once protection, in case of necessity, arresters must be provided. The
T more reflected, etc. In this way, the overvoltage in the cable is built maximum allowable length for a cable section with onesided
up gradually although the overvoltage slope in the cable is actually protection is higher for MO-arresters than for those with spark-
In comparison with it the front-of-wave sparkover voltage is often gaps. This is based on the favourable protection properties of MO-
referred to for spark-gap arresters. It lies at approx. 1.15 Up. In this Figure 7 lower, the peak value is near that of lightning overvoltage on the
Power loss P of the MO discs and heat flow Q from the active line [18]. arresters, which begin conducting before Up is reached.
test the length of the rise time is adjusted to approx. 400 ns.
arrester parts to the exterior as a function of the MO
temperature T at the continuous operating voltage Uc

9 18
 6.3 Temporary Overvoltages The following example should illustrate the use of Figure 8:
S=800 kV / ms
U F An arrester MWK 24 with Uc = 24 kV could be operated for as long
U=660 kV a time as one wishes with Uc. The environmental temperature
U v The meaning of Temporary Over-Voltages UTOV is the operating
a UT
frequency overvoltages of a limited duration. The spark-gap surrounding the arrester amounts to a maximum of 45 C. At the
T arresters require special measures regarding these voltages. In time t = 0 the arrester is charged with the specified energy E = 5.5
b
these arresters the follow current increases very strongly with the kJ/kV Uc.
operating voltage. If this voltage lies above the rated voltage of the Immediately following the temporary overvoltage UTOV = 28 kV
30 c
arrester, the follow current through the arrester will be too high. occurs. Thus:
20 C=0 Under these conditions, the spark-gaps can no longer extinguish T= UTOV / Uc = 28 kV / 24kV = 1.17
A T A T A T the arc, that is they ignite it again in each of the following half cycles
C C C
C=0,5nF
until the arrester is destroyed by overheating. In networks with For T= 1.17 it follows that from curve b the time t = 400 s.
10 1 2 3 temporary overvoltages the rated voltage of the spark-gap arrester Therefore the duration of UTOV is limited to 400 seconds. Following
L (m)
must be raised to UTOV, which also requires the raising of the this the arrester is again capable of bearing Uc and cools down. If it
Arrangements for arresters and electrical equipment protection level of the arrester. is expected that UTOV has to occur for longer than 400 seconds on
5
the line, then an arrester with the corresponding elevated Uc must
evaluation of the connections: F: lightning endangered line
3
be selected.
U: lightning overvoltage
C=2nF 1: poor A: arrester
2 2: good T: electrical equipment (transformer) 1.4
3: excellent C: capacitance of T to earth
1.35 7 Tests
1
0 1 2 3 4 5 Figure 15 T 1.3 a
b (m)
1.25 The tests for ABB arresters follow internationally agreed upon
Figure 14b recommendations. IEC 60099-4 has been valid for the MO-
1.2 b arresters since August 1998 [6]. In the USA - Norm ANSI C62.11-
UTOV
1.15 1993 is applied [7], which coincides with the IEC. The MV-
Uc arresters from ABB fulfill both norms.The tests are made in
1.1 accordance to type, routine, and acceptance tests.
Arrester protective distance L in the network
level Um = 17.5 kV and 24 kV with respect to 1.05 Furthermore the arresters are submitted to special tests, which are
the conductor length b. not mentioned in the international regulations.
1.0
1 10 100 1000 10'000 t (s)
If a + b L, then UT BIL / 1,2 7.1 Type Tests

C: transformer T capacitance between

phase and earth
MO-arrester
spark-gap arrester
Up= 4 p.u. when In = 5 kA
14a): line with wooden poles
14b): line with earthed cross arms
This is of special significance in regard to arrester protection for
transformers, because they have a capacitance to earth which
should not be underestimated. Additionally noteworthy is the
marked decrease of L with the conductor length b. The connection
from the lightning endangered line to the high voltage connection
of the arrester should therefore be as direct as possible. In Figure
15, three connection possibilities are schematically represented
and evaluated.
The larger protective distance of the arrester in lines with earthed
cross arms (Figure 14 b) stems from the less magnitude of the
overvoltage running into the substation (lower flashover voltage
line to earth). From this a lower current through the arrester and a
lower limiting voltage result which enable a larger value for L.
In networks where Um = 12 kV, the protective distance of the
arrester are about 10% longer than represented in Figure 14. On
the other hand, when Um =36 kV, the distance is about 30%
shorter. At this network operating level, it should also be noted that
when S = 1550 kV / s (wooden pole lines), the value of L sharply
decreases as soon as b > 0.6
The protective properties of the arresters are somewhat reduced
with different polarity of the lightning overvoltage and the
momentary value of the phase voltage, this is taken into account in
the calculation of L. Additionally it is assumed a very short galva-
nic connection between the earth side of the arrrester to the
transformer tank. This is to be taken into consideration when
connecting the arrester.
Figure 16
MO-surge arrester type POLIM-D 12 N with disconnector,
installed on a distribution transformer
Otherwise it becomes necessary to increase the length of the
conductor length b in Figure 13 due to the additional earth
connection. Branching between the arrester and electrical equip-
ment to other electrical equipment creates additional voltage
oscillations which in most cases results in a reduction of L.
9.4 Fault Hazards in Electrical Equipment and Their
Distance from the Surge Arrester
An arrester placed at a distance L from the electrical equipment
limits the overvoltage to a value of BIL / 1.2 as long as the
overvoltage steepness S at the station is not larger than
1550 kV/s for wooden pole lines
800 kV/s for earthed cross arm lines
However, on the average this steepness will be exceeded once
every 400 years. In this case an overvoltage in the electrical
equipment can reach a value above its BIL causing permanent
damage. If the life expectancy of the equipment, e.g. a transformer,
is put at about 40 years, then in the time interval ts = 400 years
there exists a 90 % probability that no damage will occur. However
this includes a failure rate caused by overvoltages during this 40
years which amounts to 10 %. Even though an arrester is mounted
at the distance L from the transformer.
Figure 8
Strength T=UTOV / Uc with respect to temporary overvoltages UTOV
as a function of their duration t at an ambient temperature (air
temperature outside the arrester) of 45C. The curve a applies to
an arrester without preload, the curve b to an arrester, preloaded
with the guaranteed energy E. t is the time duration of the
overvoltage with power frequency.
The curves apply for the MO-surge arrester type MWK.
In MO-arresters there is no follow current because this is
prevented by the extremely non-linear voltage current charac-
teristic (Figure 4). It is for this reason that MO arresters are capable
of bearing increased operational voltages over a longer period of
time. The strength T of the arrester in the presence of such tempor-
ary overvoltages is described in Figure 8.
UTOV = T x Uc
T is then a measure for the permissible height of UTOV.
The curve a in Figure 8 is valid for arresters without a significant
energy preloading. The higher T and respectively UTOV, the greater
the power generated in the arrester. Because the MO temperature
cannot exceed a certain value for reasons of stability, is the energy
supplied to the arrester also limited. For that reason the
permissible load duration t decreases with the magnitude of T
resp. UTOV. The curve b is valid for arresters which at the time t = 0
are already preloaded with the specified energy E. Naturally, curve
b lies beneath curve a. Arresters which are already preloaded with
the E / Uc values specified in Table 2 can nevertheless withstand
temporary overvoltages correstonding to curve b. This implies
that the entire energy absorption capability of the arrester exceeds
these guaranteed data. In the time interval t the energy can be
supplied to the arrester at any given moment in the form of energy
impulses. The sum of the impulses however must not exceed the
amount E.
At the completion of the development of an arrester design, type
tests are carried out. They furnish proof that they comply with the
relevant standard. The following tests are designated for MV-
arresters:
Isolation withstand tests on the arrester housing: these tests
demonstrate that the external housing insulation meets the
expected voltage demands.
Residual voltage tests: The function of these tests is to certify that
the protection level of the arrester does not exceed the guaranteed
data.
Long duration current impulse withstand test: this test is
performed to prove that the MO resistors withstand possible
dielectric and energy demands without puncture, flashover and
cracking.
Time accelerated ageing test: in this test resistors are subjected
to a temperature of 115 C for 1000 hours with a voltage above Uc.
In doing so it is watched if and how intensive the power losses of
the resistors increase over their life span. The life span is
understood to be 110 years according to [7]. In this time ABB
resistors demonstrate no increase of power losses: therefore they
are not subject to any ageing process.
Operating duty tests: the following values are of significance in
this test:
Reference current Iref
This is the peak value of the ohmic current component by which the
reference voltage is measured. Iref should be large enough so that
this measurement cannot be influenced by the stray capacitance of
the arrester components. The reference current must be specified
by the manufacturer. For ABB MV-arresters the following values
are valid for Iref:
1.4 mA for POLIM-DN
1.4 mA for POLIM-D, MVK
1.6 mA for POLIM-DA
2.2 mA for MWK, MWD, POLIM-I, POLIM-C
3.6 mA for POLIM-S
5.0 mA for POLIM-H

17 10
 Reference voltage Uref
This is defined as the operation frequency voltage at the arrester at
which Iref flows. Uref is determined by the peak value of the voltage
divided by 2.
Rated voltage Ur
This is the highest permissible r.m.s. value of the power frequency
voltage for which the arrester is dimensioned in order to operate
correctly under temporary overvoltage conditions as established
in the operating duty tests
Here it is necessary to carry out long term tests in order to prove
the ageing stability of the insulation material and the
impermeability of the construction. All the arresters produced by
ABB are succesfully tested with cyclical long term tests.
It is assumed here that 8 lightning strokes per year per 100 km
overhead distribution line occur, on the premisies that multi-phase
lightning strokes appear more often than single-phase ones. On
the average, this steepness S is extended once every 400 years.
The time-function of the overvoltage increase is parabolic and has
the steepness S when the value U is reached:
t2 x S 2
u( t ) = ------------ (2)
4xU
For the configuration according to Figure 13, protective distances
of the arresters were calculated. The increase of the overvoltage
wave is assumed to be parabolic and it is assumed that the arrester
has a value of Up = 4 p.u. when In = 5 kA. With b < 1m, the result for
the network voltages up to 7.2 kV is
.
L = 20 m in the case of wooden pole lines, C = 0
L = 6 m in the case of wooden pole lines, C = 2 nF
L = 25 m in the case of earthed cross arms, C = 0
L = 15 m in the case of earthed cross arms, C = 2 nF

Ur is determined by the arrester supplier and lies with ABB
arresters at 1.25 x Uc. The voltages Ur and Uc applied during the
test are correspondingly to be raised if:
The resistors show an increase in the power losses in the
accelerated ageing test
The reference voltage of the test sample is higher than the
guaranteed minimum value for the arrester.
The operating duty tests serve as proof of the thermal stability of
the arrester. It does this in two steps. First the conditioning of the
resistors is carried out. This is done by applying a voltage of 1.2 x
Uc to the resistors. To this voltage 20 impulse with nominal
discharge current are superimposed. The conditioning can be
carried out at the complete arrester, too.
Afterwards the resistors are installed in the arrester housing and
loaded with a first high current impulse. After the test sample has
cooled down, it is heated to 60 C and loaded with a second high
current impulse. At the latest 100ms after the second impulse the
test sample is subjected to the power frequency voltage Ur for 10 s
and then to Uc for 30 minutes. In the last phase the test must
demonstrate if the test sample remains thermally stable or
becomes unstable.
The test described here is valid for MV-arresters with a nominal
discharge current of 5 kA and 10 kA of the line discharge class 1.
The arrester has passed the test if
Thermal stability has been achieved
Changes in the residual voltage, measured before and after the
test, do not exceed 5 %
Examination reveals no evidence of puncture, flashover or
cracking of the resistors.
Power frequency voltage versus time characteristic: this test
serves to confirm through experimental means the curves in
Figure 8 which are generally proved mathematically. Therefore it
serves as a proof of the sufficient stability of the arrester against
temporary overvoltages.
Pressure-relief test: for arresters with a pressure-relief device.
These tests prove that the arrester housing can endure fault
current without bursting under predetermined test conditions. The
arresters with housing made of synthetic material which do not
have a pressure-relief device are tested in a special way: they are
electrical overstressed purposefully in order to watch their
behaviour in case of overloading.
Artificial pollution test: this test demonstrates that the internal
parts of the arrester get no damage through external pollution. The
elevated temperature strain of the active parts produced by the
uneven voltage distribution along the soiled external insulation are
to be observed in particular. With non-ceramic insulations like
silicone the short time tests are not significant.
Figure 9
MO-surge arrester type MWK after overload test with
20kA (0,2 sec) short circuit current.
7.2. Routine Tests
Routine tests are carried out on every arrester or parts of it (e.g. on
the resisors) in order to ascertain that the product meets the
requirements of the design specification.
Reference voltage measurement: the measured value of the
reference voltage Uref must lie within the stated tolerance range
allowed by the manufacturer. The lower limit of the Uref guarantees
the termal stability of the arrester. The higher the value of Uref in the
routine test of an arrester, the smaller the power losses at Uc and
therefore better stabililty during network operation.
Residual voltage test: this proves that the guaranteed protection
level of the arrester is not exceeded. Residual voltage can be
measured on the individual resistors at nominal current.
Partial discharge test: this test serves to prove that the arrester is
free of partial discharge. The measurement takes place at a voltage
of 1.05 x Uc on the entire arrester. According to IEC [6] a partial
dischage level of < 50 pC is permissible. ABB arresters are tested
more strictly though and must be kept within the 5 pC limit.
Leakage test: this test proves that the porcelain housing
hermetically seals the active parts of the arrester. This test is not
done on silicone polymer arresters because the active parts are
directly sealed in silicone polymer.
In addition to the IEC recommended tests, ABB MV-arresters are
subject to the two following tests:
measurement of the continous current at Uc for every arrester
time accelerated ageing test over 300 hours on at least two
resistors in every production lot. This test insures that in every
assembly only resistors without any ageing process are
used.
Equation (2) is defined for the time interval 0 < t < 2 x U/S. U = 660
kV is assumed for lines with earthed cross arms. This is
approximately the flashover voltage of a 20 kV line insulator when
there are chopped voltage impulses with a steepness of 800 kV / s
and negative polarity. U v S
If one puts the values U and S into equation (2), then it becomes a UT
clear that the temporal rise in overvoltage u(t) runs about the same
b T
for both types of line. Because the arrester limits the voltage to well
below U, the higher value S in wooden pole lines has no effect
regarding the protective distance of the arrester. Nevertheless, the c
A Up
protective distances for both of these line types are different. The
reason lies in the difference in height U of the incoming
overvoltage wave. The lightning current i that passes through the
Overvoltage at transformer T
arrester reaches the approximately peak value.
U: incoming overvoltage wave a, b: length of the connecting lines
v: propagation velocity of U T: transformer
2 x U - Up S: maximum steepness of U C: capacitance of T between
i = ----------------- (3) A: arrester phase and earth
Z Up: protection level of A UT: overvoltage at T
Therefore, in the case of wooden pole lines (U = 3000 kV), when Z =
Figure 13
450 , a current of 13 kA can be expected through the arrester.
In regard to lines with earthed cross arms (U = 660 kV ), the current
lies below 3 kA. This difference influences the limiting voltage of
the arrester. This lies therefore higher in the case of wooden pole These values apply to both MO and spark-gap arresters. The
lines which leads, with this sort of line, to a shorter protective influence of capacitance C of the electrical equipment on the length
distance of the arrester. of L is clearly seen. The protective distance of the arrester for the
network operating levels of Um = 17.5 kV and 24 kV are described
in Figure 14. Here it is also clear how L decreases with the
increasing capacitance of the electrical equipment.
9.3. Influences on the Protective Distance through
Electical Equipment, the Types of Arresters and
the Arrangement of the Arresters.
S=1550 kV / ms
Using BIL and Up from Table 5 and the above values of S in
equation (1), the following protective distances result: U=3000 kV
U v
a UT
L = 2.3. m in the case of wooden pole lines 30 T
b
L = 4.5 m in the case of earthed crossed arm lines
20
c
C=0
These values are valid for the simplified assumption according to
Figure 11. Therefore they need to be corrected as depicted in 10
Figure 13. Generally speaking, the electrical equipment, in this
L (m)
case a transformer, has a capacity C to earth. This causes voltage b (m)
5
C=0,5nF
oscillations in the connections a and b, with the result being that
the voltage UT increases with C. This leads to a reduction of the
protective distance. However the parabolic rise of the lightning 3
overvoltage has an opposite influence. The arrester limits the
C=2nF
overvoltage to well below its peak value. The maximum steepness,
2
which occurs only in the region of the voltage maximum, therefore
has no effect. 1
0 0,5 b (m) 1 1,5
In deriving L according to equation (1) it is assumed that the
arrester will become conductive only when the voltage at its
terminals has reached the value Up. This is the case with spark-gap Figure 14a
arresters. MO-arresters without spark-gaps are conductive before
the terminal voltage has reached Up. Therefore the protective
properties begin working at an earlier point. Under certain
circumstances therefore, MO arresters protect remote electrical
equipment better, which is equivalent to a longer protective
distance.

11 16

Z x di / dt
S=
2 occurrence. It is customary, instead of the probability, to indicate
u(t) = Z x i(t)
2 strike the conductor in a route section of d = 135 m cause in the
i(t) t maximum continuous operating voltage Uc:
i/2 i/2 u(t)
Z leads to a reduction in the current rate of rise in the individual lines
F and therefore lowers the voltage rate of rise.
Lightning overvoltage caused by a lightning strike on an overhead Line.
F: overhead Line
Z: surge impedance of F
t: time
i(t): total stroke current as a function of time
di / dt: maximum steepness of i(t)
u(t): lightning overvoltage as a function of time
S: maximum steepness of u(T)
Figure 12
In 10% of all lightnings, the maximum stroke current change di/dt
is higher than 32 kA/s. When Z = 450 , every 10th lightning
stroke will cause a maximum voltage steepness S > 7200 kV/s. A
steepness of this order is to be expected in the substation only if
the lightning strikes neareby. The probability of this happening is
relatively small. As an example, a lightning stroke with a current
rate of rise of over 32 kA/s striking within 25 m of a station would
occur on the average once every 5000 years.
Substantially smaller voltage rates of rise are to be expected at the
station when the lightning stroke occurs far from the substation.
Due to corona damping, the front of the overvoltage wave flattens
out as it proceeds from the point of the stroke towards the station.
If So is the steepness at the location of the stroke, the steepness
along the length d of the line decreases to the value
1 insulation-material.
S = -----------------
1/So + K x d
The constant K is dependent upon the geometry of the overhead
line. In [11] it is approximated to be K = 5 x 10-6 s/kVm for MV
lines. Supposing that the location of the stroke is d =135 m remote
from the station a lightning stroke causes an infinitely large voltage
rate of rise So. According to the above formula , the steepness S at
the substation will be less than 1500 kV/s due to the corona
damping. That means that only lightnings which strike the con-
ductor in front of the station in a route track of d =135 m can have
the effect of S > 1500 kV/s at the station.
It can be derived from [12] that approximately 8 lightning strokes
hit a 100 km long overhead distribution line per year. This number
is valid for German MV networks of 10 , 20 and 30 kV. In Germany
the average ground flash density is 3 strokes per year per km2.
According to [13] this amounts to approximately 25 lightning
strokes per year per 100 km of distribution line. This factor 3 larger
value which was mathematically determined supposes a MV line
on a level terrain . The difference must be attributed to the fact that
MV lines are often not out in the open . Frequently they are shielded
from lightning by neighboring lines, buildings and forests . The
following demonstration uses the empirical value of 8 lightning
strokes per year per 100 km overhead line. However it is to be kept
in mind that more lightning strokes are to be expected in
unfavorable topographical conditions. In areas with extremely
high lightning activity the possibility of 100 strokes per year per
100 km overhead line cannot be ruled out.
The probability of a lightning stroke in a route section of d = 135 m
is therefore 0.01 per year. In an MV substation, lightning
overvoltages which have the steepness over 1500 kV/s can be
expected at the most once every 100 years .
15
These two arbitrarily chosen examples should show that large 7.3. Acceptance Tests 8 Selection of Surge Arresters and
voltage rates of rise occur less often than small ones. The expected
value of a steepness is always linked with the probability of the
If acceptance tests are stipulated at the time of order, the following Determination of Uc
the time interval ts, which on the average passes between two tests are carried out on a number of the to be delivered arresters
(the number of arresters to be tested is determined by taking the
events. Certainly, in the above example not all lightnings which
cube root of the delivery amount and rounding it down to a whole For the arrester to meet the needs of the network system, two
station a steepness higher than 1500 kV/s. With some of the number): conditons are necessary to be fulfilled in the selection of the
lightnings the steepness of the current increase is too low. Many
lightnings strike more than just one of the three conductors, which
reference voltage measurement Uc must be higher than the constant power frequency voltage at
the arrester terminal.
Of further signifance is the fact that the stroke current rise is measurement of the residual voltage of the arrester at nominal
concave [13]. That is why the highest steepness of the overvoltage discharge current T x Uc must be higher than the expected temporary overvoltage at
occurs in the range of the voltage maximum, as shown in the Fig- the arrester terminal. According to Figure 8, T is determined by the
ure 11. In voltage waves with a high stroke current peak value a duration t of the temporary overvoltage. Thus in determining T, t is
flashover from the line to earth takes place before the voltage partial discharge level measurement at 1.05 x Uc with the more
also to be taken into account. For reasons of safety, the lower curve
maximum has been reached. The upper part of the wave is thereby stringend value < 5 pC, as compared with the IEC. in Figure 8 will generally be used.
cut off so that the highest steepness does not become effective.
Therefore only a fraction of the lightnings which hit the route In selecting the arresters in a three-phase network, the location of
section d =135 m of the line generates S > 1500 kV/s at the station. 7.4 Special Tests the arrester plays the deciding role: between phase and earth,
The probability of S > 1500 kV/s is therefore significantly less than between transformer neutral and earth or between phases. The
0.01 per year. This can be evaluated with the help of the lightning maximum operating voltage at the arrester terminal connection
current statistics from Berger [14]. Assuming a parabolic In the newest editon of the relevant IEC instructions [6] the
performed tests refer to the arresters with porcelain insulation. In can be calculated with the help of the maximum voltage Um
progression of the current increase, then the values indicated in between phases. If this is not known, then Um should be replaced
Table 6 result for the expected steepness in a MV substation. The the IEC working paper for MO-arresters with polymeric housing
[22] there are disscused tests special for arresters with polymer with the highest voltage of the system or the highest voltage for the
lower values for S in the lines with earthed cross arms are a result of electrical equipment.
the smaller flashover voltages of the insulators versus the flashover housing. In conformity with this working paper and also exceeding
voltages along the wooden poles. it ABB performed the following tests for the MV-arresters with
silicone insulation. In three-phase networks special attention must be paid to the
The values of ts in Table 6 were determined under the assumption
temporary overvoltage UTOV. It occurs most frequently during
that 8 lightning strokes per year and per 100 km of distribution line
Overload test: this test shows the behaviour of the arrester under earth faults. Its value is given by the method of neutral system
would occur. For the value ts only lightnings which strike the line
overload. During the test the arrester is loaded deliberately with earthing. Additionally the system management is of significance
within 300 m of the station are of significance. If this stretch of the
increasing voltage up to destruction and up to the appearance of because it determines the duration t of the temporary overvoltage
line is free standing, that is not shielded from lightning by the
the system short current. Because of the special construction and with that it decides the value of T (t) for Uc.
neighbouring lines, buildings and woods, then the value of ts is 3
times smaller. If in addition there is an extremely high degree of (completely moulded) and the chosen insulation material
lightning activity in the vicinity, then the value is even 12 times (silicone) the ABB MV-arresters are safe from explosion and UTOV
smaller. destruction up to the highest tested currents. Silicone is a self Uc > ----------
extinguishing material. Fire is not caused by downfalling burning T(t)
Type of overhead Wooden poles with 3000kV 20 kV network with
distribution line flashover voltage earthed cross arms Weather-aging test: the test shows the long time behaviour of the
insulation material and the construction in case of cyclical
8.1 Networks with Earth Fault Compensation or with
High- Ohmic Insulated Neutral
Time interval 1 2 1 2 environmental situations like warmth, humidity, rain, saltfog and
ts [years] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] UV rays during the continuous voltage applied. The test extends on
a totally duration of 5000 hours. Under the conditions for earth-fault, the voltage increases at
600 1940 1850 1060 820 "healthy phases to a maximum of Um:
UV radiation: the insulation material is exposed 1000 hours to the
400 1630 1530 920 730 UV radiation and it is additionally damp. The insulation chara- Uc > Um for an arrester between phase and earth
cteristics of silicon are not negatively influenced because of it. On
300 1450 1350 820 660 the contrary, the UV radiation promotes the process of the The voltage at transformer neutral can reach a maximum of Um / 3:
permanent renewal of the hydrophobicity of the silicon
200 1200 1100 700 580 surface.
100 820 660 520 440
Deep temperature: the construction as well as the materials used Um
of the ABB MV-arresters with silicone housing endure Uc > ------ for the arrester between transformer neutral and earth
Table 6 temperatures up to - 60 C without changes of the electrical and 3
Expected steepness S from lightning overvoltages in MV sub- mechanical characteristics. Furthermore cyclical freezing up to
stations: The shown values of S will, on the average, be exceeded -40 C in water showed that the construction and especially the
once in the time interval ts. surface of the silicon are not injured through the formation of
ice. In every network there exists inductance and capacitance which
1 in the case of single phase lightning strikes produce oscillating circuits. If their resonant frequency is similar
2 in the case of three phase lightning strikes to that of the operating frequency, then the voltage between phase
Humidity: long term tests of more than 2 years, in which the and earth can basically become higher than that of Um in single-
arresters were exposed to a relatively air humidity of more than
Overhead line Wooden poles Earthed cross pole earth faults. The system management must avoid the
90%, showed that the electrical behaviour of the arrester was not occurrence of such resonances. If this is not possible, then Uc of a
arms influenced because of the penetration of humidity, or the arrester
corresponding magnitude should be chosen.
did not get out of order.
U [kV] 3000 660
S [kV/s] 1550 800
12
8.2 Networks with High-Ohmic Insulated Neutral 8.5 Low-Ohmic Neutral Earthing Networks and Ce > 1.4 8.7 Operating Voltage with Harmonic Oscillation
Systems and Automatic Earth Fault Clearing
This concerns networks which are earthed with an impedance so Harmonic currents generate harmonic oscillations under
Temporary overvoltages are of the same magnitude as those in that the fault current is limited, for example, to 2 kA. In the case of operating voltage frequencies. For this reason it is possible that the U v S
Section 8.1. Though early cut-off of earth faults enables a an earth fault the voltage increases for a "healthy phase to Um. peak value of phase-to-phase voltage can be greater than 2 x
reduction of Uc by the factor T. If, for example, the earth fault cut- With a resistive earthed neutral the voltage can be 5 % higher than Um. If this difference is less than 5 % a correspondingly higher Uc a UE
off results after a maximum of t = 10 s, then, with the help of Um. If the clearing time of the earth fault does not exceed t = 10 s, must be used as long as Uc is lower then 1.05 x Um / 3 for
Figure 8 it follows that T = 1.26. then results T = 1.26 (for the MWK): arresters between phase and earth and lower than 1.05 x Um for
Um arresters between phases. On the other hand, if due to the b E
Uc > ---------- for an arrester between phase and earth 1.05 x Um harmonic wave the voltage increase is higher than 5 % the choice
Uc > ------------- = 0.83 Um of Uc must be discussed with the arrester supplier. The same is
T valid for forms of voltage which can often be seen in the vicinity of
Um T
thyristor converters: voltage steps, ignition peaks, asymmetry in A Up
Uc > ----------- for an arrester between transformer neutral and earth 8.6 Arresters between Phases ( Neptune Design ) the two half cycles. Overvoltage at the line end E
T x 3
In special cases like, e.g. transformers in arc furnace installations, U: incoming overvoltage wave
8.3. Networks with Solidly Earthed Neutral Systems (Ce < 1.4) switching overvoltages can occur which are insufficiently limited 9. Protective Distance of the Surge Arrester v: propagation velocity of U
S: steepness (front of wave) of U
by arresters between phase and earth. In this case arresters A: arrester
between phases are to be used: The more the Basic Insulation Level (BIL) exceeds the protection Up: protection level of A
In this type of network, there are at least enough transformers in
level UP of the arrester, the better the electrical equipment is a, b: length of the connecting lines
low-ohmic neutral earthing, that during an earth fault the phase E: line end
U c > Um for arresters between phases. protected against lightning overvoltages. Modern arresters with
voltage never exceeds 1.4 p.u. in the entire system (earth fault UE: overvoltage at E
UP = 3.33 x UC and under this value, maintain UP < 4 p.u. even
factor Ce < 1.4 ). Therefore is UTOV < 1.4 x Um / 3. It can be
The arrester arrangement is then composed of 6 arresters, 3 when placed in a system with high-ohmic insulated neutral. For
assumed that the clearing time of the earth fault amounts to at the electrical equipment which is subject to lightning overvoltages ,
most t = 3 s. It follows for instance for the arrester MWK that T = between phase and earth and 3 between the phases.
the [9] recommends the indicated BIL values given in Table 5. In Figure 11
1.28, and therefore: addition, the IEC [10] recommends for MV networks BIL > 1.4 x
Figure 10 shows the modification of an arrester arrangement, UP. As can be seen in Table 5, modern arresters fulfill this
1.4 x Um 1.1 x Um which is known as the Neptune design because of its requirement.
Uc > ------------- = ------------- for an arrester between phase and earth configuration. It is composed of 4 identical arresters. Two 2 x S x (a + b)
1.28 x 3 3 arresters in series each are fitted between phase and earth and UE = UP + -------------------- v = 300 m/s
Um kV 3.6 7.2 12 17.5 24 36
between the phases. This configuration delivers overvoltage v
The voltage of the neutral of non-earth transformers reaches a protection between the phases. However it does have an BIL kV 40 60 75 95 125 170
maximum of UTOV = 0.4 x Um: Experience has shown that a safety factor of 1.2 is sufficient
appreciable disadvantage compared to the above described between the BIL of the electrical equipment and the lightning
configuration with 6 arresters. In the case of an earth fault, e.g. in Up kV 12 24 40 58.3 79.9 119.9
overvoltage UE at the electrical equipment.
0.4 x Um the phase of arrester A1, arresters A1 and A4 are parallel
Uc > ------------- = 0.32 x Um for an arrester between BIL / Up 3.33 2.5 1.88 1.63 1.56 1.42
connected. Since the arresters behave in a capacitive manner
1.28 transformer neutral and earth. during continuous operating voltage, all 4 arresters together build
up an asymmetrical capacitive system. This results in arresters A2 BIL 2 x S x (a + b)
8.4 Networks with Low-Ohmic Neutral Earthing which do and A3 reaching a value of 0.667 x Um. All 4 arresters must Table 5 ------ > UE = Up + --------------------
not have Uniformly Ce < 1 .4 therefore be dimensioned for Withstand voltage (BIL) acc. IEC [9] and protection level of modern 1.2 v
surge arresters with Up = 4p.u.
For arresters in the vicinity of neutral earth transformers, Uc can be Uc > 0.667 x U m
chosen according to Section 8.3, because Ce < 1.4 is applicable The factor 1.4 is generously calculated because it is to be taken into If the limiting value is set at L = a + b, then the required equation (1)
here. The protection level of this arrangement in which there are always account that the overvoltage can exceed UP in the electrical follows for
two arresters in series is the same as that of an arrester with Uc equipment. Reflection effects cause increasing overvoltage at the
electrical equipment with increasing distance from the arrester. v BIL
Care is required if the arrester is located just a few kilometers from 1.334 x Um, whereas by a configuration with 6 arresters Uc > Um L = --------- x [ ----------- - Up ] (1)
the transformer, e.g. if there is a remote connection between an is sufficent. The protection level of the Neptune design is After a certain distance the arrester protection is insufficient. The
overhead line and a cable. If the ground is dried out or consists of consequently 33 % higher as that of the configuration with 6 protective distance L is understood to be the maximum distance 2xS 1.2
rock, then it has a relatively high resistance. This can lead to a arresters. between the arrester and the electrical equipment allowing
phase voltage at the location of the arrester which approaches Um. sufficient protection. If the sum of the connecting lines a + b is smaller than the
In this case it is recommended protective distance L of the arrester, then the electrical equipment
Uc > U m In order to effectively lay out overvoltage protection, it is necessary is adequately protected at point E. In order to determine the
Um to know these protective distances. They will be estimated for protective distance L from the equation (1), the steepness S must
T T arresters in MV-systems below. be known. The expected value of S is estimated in the following
Uc > ----------- for arresters between phase and earth. section.
T
Generally speaking, the earth fault monitoring would switch off the 9.2 Expected Steepness S from Lightning Overevoltages
earth fault quickly (t < 3 s ): therefore T = 1.28. 9.1 Theoretical Projection for the Protective Distance L
Under extremely poor earthing conditions, e.g. in desert regions, in MV Substations
Uc > U m A1 A2 A3
only a slight fault current flows in the case of a remote earth fault. If On the overhead distribution line in Figure 11 an overvoltage U
this is not caught by monitoring, switching off will not take place. runs as a travelling wave with the speed v toward the line terminal Figure 12 shows a lightnig stroke on a conductor of a distribution
The arresters in the vicinity of the earth fault are then loaded for a a) b) A4 Uc > 0,667 x Um E. At point E is the electrical equipment to be protected. For the line. The time function of the stroke current is designated by i(t).
long period of time with Um. In such cases it is advisable to choose following example it is considered that the electrical equipment to From the point where the lightning hits the conductor, the lightning
Uc > Um. Overvoltage protection between phase and earth be protected is high-ohmic (transformator, open connection). current i/2 flows out in both directions. If Z is the surge impedance
and between phases. When the travelling wave reaches E, it is reflected and the voltage of the conductor to earth, then this current generates a lightning
For keeping in mind: If, as in the above described network, the T: transformer increases to 2 x U. It is the function of the arrester A to protect overvoltage u(t) with the steepness of the voltage increase S(t)
arrester is located at a transformer with a low-ohmic neutral
a): protection with 6 arresters electrical equipment from reaching unacceptable high voltage between the conductor and the earth. As indicated in Figure 12,
b): neptun design values. Under the simplified assumption that the front of wave
earthing, then Uc > 1.4 x Um / 1.28 x 3 is permissible. It is A1, A2, A3, A4 four identical arresters with Uc > 0.667 x Um S(t) is not constant with time. From now on the maxiumum
steepness S of the incoming overvoltage wave is time constant, the steepness of the rise of an overvoltage wave will be indicated by S.
recommended that the earth connections of the arresters have a
follwing relationship is valid for the maximum value UE :
galvanic connection to the transformer tank and these connections
should be kept as short as possible.
Figure 10

13 14
8.2 Networks with High-Ohmic Insulated Neutral 8.5 Low-Ohmic Neutral Earthing Networks and Ce > 1.4 8.7 Operating Voltage with Harmonic Oscillation
Systems and Automatic Earth Fault Clearing
This concerns networks which are earthed with an impedance so Harmonic currents generate harmonic oscillations under
Temporary overvoltages are of the same magnitude as those in that the fault current is limited, for example, to 2 kA. In the case of operating voltage frequencies. For this reason it is possible that the U v S
Section 8.1. Though early cut-off of earth faults enables a an earth fault the voltage increases for a "healthy phase to Um. peak value of phase-to-phase voltage can be greater than 2 x
reduction of Uc by the factor T. If, for example, the earth fault cut- With a resistive earthed neutral the voltage can be 5 % higher than Um. If this difference is less than 5 % a correspondingly higher Uc a UE
off results after a maximum of t = 10 s, then, with the help of Um. If the clearing time of the earth fault does not exceed t = 10 s, must be used as long as Uc is lower then 1.05 x Um / 3 for
Figure 8 it follows that T = 1.26. then results T = 1.26 (for the MWK): arresters between phase and earth and lower than 1.05 x Um for
Um arresters between phases. On the other hand, if due to the b E
Uc > ---------- for an arrester between phase and earth 1.05 x Um harmonic wave the voltage increase is higher than 5 % the choice
Uc > ------------- = 0.83 Um of Uc must be discussed with the arrester supplier. The same is
T valid for forms of voltage which can often be seen in the vicinity of
Um T
thyristor converters: voltage steps, ignition peaks, asymmetry in A Up
Uc > ----------- for an arrester between transformer neutral and earth 8.6 Arresters between Phases ( Neptune Design ) the two half cycles. Overvoltage at the line end E
T x 3
In special cases like, e.g. transformers in arc furnace installations, U: incoming overvoltage wave
8.3. Networks with Solidly Earthed Neutral Systems (Ce < 1.4) switching overvoltages can occur which are insufficiently limited 9. Protective Distance of the Surge Arrester v: propagation velocity of U
S: steepness (front of wave) of U
by arresters between phase and earth. In this case arresters A: arrester
between phases are to be used: The more the Basic Insulation Level (BIL) exceeds the protection Up: protection level of A
In this type of network, there are at least enough transformers in
level UP of the arrester, the better the electrical equipment is a, b: length of the connecting lines
low-ohmic neutral earthing, that during an earth fault the phase E: line end
U c > Um for arresters between phases. protected against lightning overvoltages. Modern arresters with
voltage never exceeds 1.4 p.u. in the entire system (earth fault UE: overvoltage at E
UP = 3.33 x UC and under this value, maintain UP < 4 p.u. even
factor Ce < 1.4 ). Therefore is UTOV < 1.4 x Um / 3. It can be
The arrester arrangement is then composed of 6 arresters, 3 when placed in a system with high-ohmic insulated neutral. For
assumed that the clearing time of the earth fault amounts to at the electrical equipment which is subject to lightning overvoltages ,
most t = 3 s. It follows for instance for the arrester MWK that T = between phase and earth and 3 between the phases.
the [9] recommends the indicated BIL values given in Table 5. In Figure 11
1.28, and therefore: addition, the IEC [10] recommends for MV networks BIL > 1.4 x
Figure 10 shows the modification of an arrester arrangement, UP. As can be seen in Table 5, modern arresters fulfill this
1.4 x Um 1.1 x Um which is known as the Neptune design because of its requirement.
Uc > ------------- = ------------- for an arrester between phase and earth configuration. It is composed of 4 identical arresters. Two 2 x S x (a + b)
1.28 x 3 3 arresters in series each are fitted between phase and earth and UE = UP + -------------------- v = 300 m/s
Um kV 3.6 7.2 12 17.5 24 36
between the phases. This configuration delivers overvoltage v
The voltage of the neutral of non-earth transformers reaches a protection between the phases. However it does have an BIL kV 40 60 75 95 125 170
maximum of UTOV = 0.4 x Um: Experience has shown that a safety factor of 1.2 is sufficient
appreciable disadvantage compared to the above described between the BIL of the electrical equipment and the lightning
configuration with 6 arresters. In the case of an earth fault, e.g. in Up kV 12 24 40 58.3 79.9 119.9
overvoltage UE at the electrical equipment.
0.4 x Um the phase of arrester A1, arresters A1 and A4 are parallel
Uc > ------------- = 0.32 x Um for an arrester between BIL / Up 3.33 2.5 1.88 1.63 1.56 1.42
connected. Since the arresters behave in a capacitive manner
1.28 transformer neutral and earth. during continuous operating voltage, all 4 arresters together build
up an asymmetrical capacitive system. This results in arresters A2 BIL 2 x S x (a + b)
8.4 Networks with Low-Ohmic Neutral Earthing which do and A3 reaching a value of 0.667 x Um. All 4 arresters must Table 5 ------ > UE = Up + --------------------
not have Uniformly Ce < 1 .4 therefore be dimensioned for Withstand voltage (BIL) acc. IEC [9] and protection level of modern 1.2 v
surge arresters with Up = 4p.u.
For arresters in the vicinity of neutral earth transformers, Uc can be Uc > 0.667 x U m
chosen according to Section 8.3, because Ce < 1.4 is applicable The factor 1.4 is generously calculated because it is to be taken into If the limiting value is set at L = a + b, then the required equation (1)
here. The protection level of this arrangement in which there are always account that the overvoltage can exceed UP in the electrical follows for
two arresters in series is the same as that of an arrester with Uc equipment. Reflection effects cause increasing overvoltage at the
electrical equipment with increasing distance from the arrester. v BIL
Care is required if the arrester is located just a few kilometers from 1.334 x Um, whereas by a configuration with 6 arresters Uc > Um L = --------- x [ ----------- - Up ] (1)
the transformer, e.g. if there is a remote connection between an is sufficent. The protection level of the Neptune design is After a certain distance the arrester protection is insufficient. The
overhead line and a cable. If the ground is dried out or consists of consequently 33 % higher as that of the configuration with 6 protective distance L is understood to be the maximum distance 2xS 1.2
rock, then it has a relatively high resistance. This can lead to a arresters. between the arrester and the electrical equipment allowing
phase voltage at the location of the arrester which approaches Um. sufficient protection. If the sum of the connecting lines a + b is smaller than the
In this case it is recommended protective distance L of the arrester, then the electrical equipment
Uc > U m In order to effectively lay out overvoltage protection, it is necessary is adequately protected at point E. In order to determine the
Um to know these protective distances. They will be estimated for protective distance L from the equation (1), the steepness S must
T T arresters in MV-systems below. be known. The expected value of S is estimated in the following
Uc > ----------- for arresters between phase and earth. section.
T
Generally speaking, the earth fault monitoring would switch off the 9.2 Expected Steepness S from Lightning Overevoltages
earth fault quickly (t < 3 s ): therefore T = 1.28. 9.1 Theoretical Projection for the Protective Distance L
Under extremely poor earthing conditions, e.g. in desert regions, in MV Substations
Uc > U m A1 A2 A3
only a slight fault current flows in the case of a remote earth fault. If On the overhead distribution line in Figure 11 an overvoltage U
this is not caught by monitoring, switching off will not take place. runs as a travelling wave with the speed v toward the line terminal Figure 12 shows a lightnig stroke on a conductor of a distribution
The arresters in the vicinity of the earth fault are then loaded for a a) b) A4 Uc > 0,667 x Um E. At point E is the electrical equipment to be protected. For the line. The time function of the stroke current is designated by i(t).
long period of time with Um. In such cases it is advisable to choose following example it is considered that the electrical equipment to From the point where the lightning hits the conductor, the lightning
Uc > Um. Overvoltage protection between phase and earth be protected is high-ohmic (transformator, open connection). current i/2 flows out in both directions. If Z is the surge impedance
and between phases. When the travelling wave reaches E, it is reflected and the voltage of the conductor to earth, then this current generates a lightning
For keeping in mind: If, as in the above described network, the T: transformer increases to 2 x U. It is the function of the arrester A to protect overvoltage u(t) with the steepness of the voltage increase S(t)
arrester is located at a transformer with a low-ohmic neutral
a): protection with 6 arresters electrical equipment from reaching unacceptable high voltage between the conductor and the earth. As indicated in Figure 12,
b): neptun design values. Under the simplified assumption that the front of wave
earthing, then Uc > 1.4 x Um / 1.28 x 3 is permissible. It is A1, A2, A3, A4 four identical arresters with Uc > 0.667 x Um S(t) is not constant with time. From now on the maxiumum
steepness S of the incoming overvoltage wave is time constant, the steepness of the rise of an overvoltage wave will be indicated by S.
recommended that the earth connections of the arresters have a
follwing relationship is valid for the maximum value UE :
galvanic connection to the transformer tank and these connections
should be kept as short as possible.
Figure 10

13 14

Z x di / dt
S=
2 occurrence. It is customary, instead of the probability, to indicate
u(t) = Z x i(t)
2 strike the conductor in a route section of d = 135 m cause in the
i(t) t maximum continuous operating voltage Uc:
i/2 i/2 u(t)
Z leads to a reduction in the current rate of rise in the individual lines
F and therefore lowers the voltage rate of rise.
Lightning overvoltage caused by a lightning strike on an overhead Line.
F: overhead Line
Z: surge impedance of F
t: time
i(t): total stroke current as a function of time
di / dt: maximum steepness of i(t)
u(t): lightning overvoltage as a function of time
S: maximum steepness of u(T)
Figure 12
In 10% of all lightnings, the maximum stroke current change di/dt
is higher than 32 kA/s. When Z = 450 , every 10th lightning
stroke will cause a maximum voltage steepness S > 7200 kV/s. A
steepness of this order is to be expected in the substation only if
the lightning strikes neareby. The probability of this happening is
relatively small. As an example, a lightning stroke with a current
rate of rise of over 32 kA/s striking within 25 m of a station would
occur on the average once every 5000 years.
Substantially smaller voltage rates of rise are to be expected at the
station when the lightning stroke occurs far from the substation.
Due to corona damping, the front of the overvoltage wave flattens
out as it proceeds from the point of the stroke towards the station.
If So is the steepness at the location of the stroke, the steepness
along the length d of the line decreases to the value
1 insulation-material.
S = -----------------
1/So + K x d
The constant K is dependent upon the geometry of the overhead
line. In [11] it is approximated to be K = 5 x 10-6 s/kVm for MV
lines. Supposing that the location of the stroke is d =135 m remote
from the station a lightning stroke causes an infinitely large voltage
rate of rise So. According to the above formula , the steepness S at
the substation will be less than 1500 kV/s due to the corona
damping. That means that only lightnings which strike the con-
ductor in front of the station in a route track of d =135 m can have
the effect of S > 1500 kV/s at the station.
It can be derived from [12] that approximately 8 lightning strokes
hit a 100 km long overhead distribution line per year. This number
is valid for German MV networks of 10 , 20 and 30 kV. In Germany
the average ground flash density is 3 strokes per year per km2.
According to [13] this amounts to approximately 25 lightning
strokes per year per 100 km of distribution line. This factor 3 larger
value which was mathematically determined supposes a MV line
on a level terrain . The difference must be attributed to the fact that
MV lines are often not out in the open . Frequently they are shielded
from lightning by neighboring lines, buildings and forests . The
following demonstration uses the empirical value of 8 lightning
strokes per year per 100 km overhead line. However it is to be kept
in mind that more lightning strokes are to be expected in
unfavorable topographical conditions. In areas with extremely
high lightning activity the possibility of 100 strokes per year per
100 km overhead line cannot be ruled out.
The probability of a lightning stroke in a route section of d = 135 m
is therefore 0.01 per year. In an MV substation, lightning
overvoltages which have the steepness over 1500 kV/s can be
expected at the most once every 100 years .
15
These two arbitrarily chosen examples should show that large 7.3. Acceptance Tests 8 Selection of Surge Arresters and
voltage rates of rise occur less often than small ones. The expected
value of a steepness is always linked with the probability of the
If acceptance tests are stipulated at the time of order, the following Determination of Uc
the time interval ts, which on the average passes between two tests are carried out on a number of the to be delivered arresters
(the number of arresters to be tested is determined by taking the
events. Certainly, in the above example not all lightnings which
cube root of the delivery amount and rounding it down to a whole For the arrester to meet the needs of the network system, two
station a steepness higher than 1500 kV/s. With some of the number): conditons are necessary to be fulfilled in the selection of the
lightnings the steepness of the current increase is too low. Many
lightnings strike more than just one of the three conductors, which
reference voltage measurement Uc must be higher than the constant power frequency voltage at
the arrester terminal.
Of further signifance is the fact that the stroke current rise is measurement of the residual voltage of the arrester at nominal
concave [13]. That is why the highest steepness of the overvoltage discharge current T x Uc must be higher than the expected temporary overvoltage at
occurs in the range of the voltage maximum, as shown in the Fig- the arrester terminal. According to Figure 8, T is determined by the
ure 11. In voltage waves with a high stroke current peak value a duration t of the temporary overvoltage. Thus in determining T, t is
flashover from the line to earth takes place before the voltage partial discharge level measurement at 1.05 x Uc with the more
also to be taken into account. For reasons of safety, the lower curve
maximum has been reached. The upper part of the wave is thereby stringend value < 5 pC, as compared with the IEC. in Figure 8 will generally be used.
cut off so that the highest steepness does not become effective.
Therefore only a fraction of the lightnings which hit the route In selecting the arresters in a three-phase network, the location of
section d =135 m of the line generates S > 1500 kV/s at the station. 7.4 Special Tests the arrester plays the deciding role: between phase and earth,
The probability of S > 1500 kV/s is therefore significantly less than between transformer neutral and earth or between phases. The
0.01 per year. This can be evaluated with the help of the lightning maximum operating voltage at the arrester terminal connection
current statistics from Berger [14]. Assuming a parabolic In the newest editon of the relevant IEC instructions [6] the
performed tests refer to the arresters with porcelain insulation. In can be calculated with the help of the maximum voltage Um
progression of the current increase, then the values indicated in between phases. If this is not known, then Um should be replaced
Table 6 result for the expected steepness in a MV substation. The the IEC working paper for MO-arresters with polymeric housing
[22] there are disscused tests special for arresters with polymer with the highest voltage of the system or the highest voltage for the
lower values for S in the lines with earthed cross arms are a result of electrical equipment.
the smaller flashover voltages of the insulators versus the flashover housing. In conformity with this working paper and also exceeding
voltages along the wooden poles. it ABB performed the following tests for the MV-arresters with
silicone insulation. In three-phase networks special attention must be paid to the
The values of ts in Table 6 were determined under the assumption
temporary overvoltage UTOV. It occurs most frequently during
that 8 lightning strokes per year and per 100 km of distribution line
Overload test: this test shows the behaviour of the arrester under earth faults. Its value is given by the method of neutral system
would occur. For the value ts only lightnings which strike the line
overload. During the test the arrester is loaded deliberately with earthing. Additionally the system management is of significance
within 300 m of the station are of significance. If this stretch of the
increasing voltage up to destruction and up to the appearance of because it determines the duration t of the temporary overvoltage
line is free standing, that is not shielded from lightning by the
the system short current. Because of the special construction and with that it decides the value of T (t) for Uc.
neighbouring lines, buildings and woods, then the value of ts is 3
times smaller. If in addition there is an extremely high degree of (completely moulded) and the chosen insulation material
lightning activity in the vicinity, then the value is even 12 times (silicone) the ABB MV-arresters are safe from explosion and UTOV
smaller. destruction up to the highest tested currents. Silicone is a self Uc > ----------
extinguishing material. Fire is not caused by downfalling burning T(t)
Type of overhead Wooden poles with 3000kV 20 kV network with
distribution line flashover voltage earthed cross arms Weather-aging test: the test shows the long time behaviour of the
insulation material and the construction in case of cyclical
8.1 Networks with Earth Fault Compensation or with
High- Ohmic Insulated Neutral
Time interval 1 2 1 2 environmental situations like warmth, humidity, rain, saltfog and
ts [years] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] S[kV/ms] UV rays during the continuous voltage applied. The test extends on
a totally duration of 5000 hours. Under the conditions for earth-fault, the voltage increases at
600 1940 1850 1060 820 "healthy phases to a maximum of Um:
UV radiation: the insulation material is exposed 1000 hours to the
400 1630 1530 920 730 UV radiation and it is additionally damp. The insulation chara- Uc > Um for an arrester between phase and earth
cteristics of silicon are not negatively influenced because of it. On
300 1450 1350 820 660 the contrary, the UV radiation promotes the process of the The voltage at transformer neutral can reach a maximum of Um / 3:
permanent renewal of the hydrophobicity of the silicon
200 1200 1100 700 580 surface.
100 820 660 520 440
Deep temperature: the construction as well as the materials used Um
of the ABB MV-arresters with silicone housing endure Uc > ------ for the arrester between transformer neutral and earth
Table 6 temperatures up to - 60 C without changes of the electrical and 3
Expected steepness S from lightning overvoltages in MV sub- mechanical characteristics. Furthermore cyclical freezing up to
stations: The shown values of S will, on the average, be exceeded -40 C in water showed that the construction and especially the
once in the time interval ts. surface of the silicon are not injured through the formation of
ice. In every network there exists inductance and capacitance which
1 in the case of single phase lightning strikes produce oscillating circuits. If their resonant frequency is similar
2 in the case of three phase lightning strikes to that of the operating frequency, then the voltage between phase
Humidity: long term tests of more than 2 years, in which the and earth can basically become higher than that of Um in single-
arresters were exposed to a relatively air humidity of more than
Overhead line Wooden poles Earthed cross pole earth faults. The system management must avoid the
90%, showed that the electrical behaviour of the arrester was not occurrence of such resonances. If this is not possible, then Uc of a
arms influenced because of the penetration of humidity, or the arrester
corresponding magnitude should be chosen.
did not get out of order.
U [kV] 3000 660
S [kV/s] 1550 800
12
 Reference voltage Uref
This is defined as the operation frequency voltage at the arrester at
which Iref flows. Uref is determined by the peak value of the voltage
divided by 2.
Rated voltage Ur
This is the highest permissible r.m.s. value of the power frequency
voltage for which the arrester is dimensioned in order to operate
correctly under temporary overvoltage conditions as established
in the operating duty tests
Here it is necessary to carry out long term tests in order to prove
the ageing stability of the insulation material and the
impermeability of the construction. All the arresters produced by
ABB are succesfully tested with cyclical long term tests.
It is assumed here that 8 lightning strokes per year per 100 km
overhead distribution line occur, on the premisies that multi-phase
lightning strokes appear more often than single-phase ones. On
the average, this steepness S is extended once every 400 years.
The time-function of the overvoltage increase is parabolic and has
the steepness S when the value U is reached:
t2 x S 2
u( t ) = ------------ (2)
4xU
For the configuration according to Figure 13, protective distances
of the arresters were calculated. The increase of the overvoltage
wave is assumed to be parabolic and it is assumed that the arrester
has a value of Up = 4 p.u. when In = 5 kA. With b < 1m, the result for
the network voltages up to 7.2 kV is
.
L = 20 m in the case of wooden pole lines, C = 0
L = 6 m in the case of wooden pole lines, C = 2 nF
L = 25 m in the case of earthed cross arms, C = 0
L = 15 m in the case of earthed cross arms, C = 2 nF

Ur is determined by the arrester supplier and lies with ABB
arresters at 1.25 x Uc. The voltages Ur and Uc applied during the
test are correspondingly to be raised if:
The resistors show an increase in the power losses in the
accelerated ageing test
The reference voltage of the test sample is higher than the
guaranteed minimum value for the arrester.
The operating duty tests serve as proof of the thermal stability of
the arrester. It does this in two steps. First the conditioning of the
resistors is carried out. This is done by applying a voltage of 1.2 x
Uc to the resistors. To this voltage 20 impulse with nominal
discharge current are superimposed. The conditioning can be
carried out at the complete arrester, too.
Afterwards the resistors are installed in the arrester housing and
loaded with a first high current impulse. After the test sample has
cooled down, it is heated to 60 C and loaded with a second high
current impulse. At the latest 100ms after the second impulse the
test sample is subjected to the power frequency voltage Ur for 10 s
and then to Uc for 30 minutes. In the last phase the test must
demonstrate if the test sample remains thermally stable or
becomes unstable.
The test described here is valid for MV-arresters with a nominal
discharge current of 5 kA and 10 kA of the line discharge class 1.
The arrester has passed the test if
Thermal stability has been achieved
Changes in the residual voltage, measured before and after the
test, do not exceed 5 %
Examination reveals no evidence of puncture, flashover or
cracking of the resistors.
Power frequency voltage versus time characteristic: this test
serves to confirm through experimental means the curves in
Figure 8 which are generally proved mathematically. Therefore it
serves as a proof of the sufficient stability of the arrester against
temporary overvoltages.
Pressure-relief test: for arresters with a pressure-relief device.
These tests prove that the arrester housing can endure fault
current without bursting under predetermined test conditions. The
arresters with housing made of synthetic material which do not
have a pressure-relief device are tested in a special way: they are
electrical overstressed purposefully in order to watch their
behaviour in case of overloading.
Artificial pollution test: this test demonstrates that the internal
parts of the arrester get no damage through external pollution. The
elevated temperature strain of the active parts produced by the
uneven voltage distribution along the soiled external insulation are
to be observed in particular. With non-ceramic insulations like
silicone the short time tests are not significant.
Figure 9
MO-surge arrester type MWK after overload test with
20kA (0,2 sec) short circuit current.
7.2. Routine Tests
Routine tests are carried out on every arrester or parts of it (e.g. on
the resisors) in order to ascertain that the product meets the
requirements of the design specification.
Reference voltage measurement: the measured value of the
reference voltage Uref must lie within the stated tolerance range
allowed by the manufacturer. The lower limit of the Uref guarantees
the termal stability of the arrester. The higher the value of Uref in the
routine test of an arrester, the smaller the power losses at Uc and
therefore better stabililty during network operation.
Residual voltage test: this proves that the guaranteed protection
level of the arrester is not exceeded. Residual voltage can be
measured on the individual resistors at nominal current.
Partial discharge test: this test serves to prove that the arrester is
free of partial discharge. The measurement takes place at a voltage
of 1.05 x Uc on the entire arrester. According to IEC [6] a partial
dischage level of < 50 pC is permissible. ABB arresters are tested
more strictly though and must be kept within the 5 pC limit.
Leakage test: this test proves that the porcelain housing
hermetically seals the active parts of the arrester. This test is not
done on silicone polymer arresters because the active parts are
directly sealed in silicone polymer.
In addition to the IEC recommended tests, ABB MV-arresters are
subject to the two following tests:
measurement of the continous current at Uc for every arrester
time accelerated ageing test over 300 hours on at least two
resistors in every production lot. This test insures that in every
assembly only resistors without any ageing process are
used.
Equation (2) is defined for the time interval 0 < t < 2 x U/S. U = 660
kV is assumed for lines with earthed cross arms. This is
approximately the flashover voltage of a 20 kV line insulator when
there are chopped voltage impulses with a steepness of 800 kV / s
and negative polarity. U v S
If one puts the values U and S into equation (2), then it becomes a UT
clear that the temporal rise in overvoltage u(t) runs about the same
b T
for both types of line. Because the arrester limits the voltage to well
below U, the higher value S in wooden pole lines has no effect
regarding the protective distance of the arrester. Nevertheless, the c
A Up
protective distances for both of these line types are different. The
reason lies in the difference in height U of the incoming
overvoltage wave. The lightning current i that passes through the
Overvoltage at transformer T
arrester reaches the approximately peak value.
U: incoming overvoltage wave a, b: length of the connecting lines
v: propagation velocity of U T: transformer
2 x U - Up S: maximum steepness of U C: capacitance of T between
i = ----------------- (3) A: arrester phase and earth
Z Up: protection level of A UT: overvoltage at T
Therefore, in the case of wooden pole lines (U = 3000 kV), when Z =
Figure 13
450 , a current of 13 kA can be expected through the arrester.
In regard to lines with earthed cross arms (U = 660 kV ), the current
lies below 3 kA. This difference influences the limiting voltage of
the arrester. This lies therefore higher in the case of wooden pole These values apply to both MO and spark-gap arresters. The
lines which leads, with this sort of line, to a shorter protective influence of capacitance C of the electrical equipment on the length
distance of the arrester. of L is clearly seen. The protective distance of the arrester for the
network operating levels of Um = 17.5 kV and 24 kV are described
in Figure 14. Here it is also clear how L decreases with the
increasing capacitance of the electrical equipment.
9.3. Influences on the Protective Distance through
Electical Equipment, the Types of Arresters and
the Arrangement of the Arresters.
S=1550 kV / ms
Using BIL and Up from Table 5 and the above values of S in
equation (1), the following protective distances result: U=3000 kV
U v
a UT
L = 2.3. m in the case of wooden pole lines 30 T
b
L = 4.5 m in the case of earthed crossed arm lines
20
c
C=0
These values are valid for the simplified assumption according to
Figure 11. Therefore they need to be corrected as depicted in 10
Figure 13. Generally speaking, the electrical equipment, in this
L (m)
case a transformer, has a capacity C to earth. This causes voltage b (m)
5
C=0,5nF
oscillations in the connections a and b, with the result being that
the voltage UT increases with C. This leads to a reduction of the
protective distance. However the parabolic rise of the lightning 3
overvoltage has an opposite influence. The arrester limits the
C=2nF
overvoltage to well below its peak value. The maximum steepness,
2
which occurs only in the region of the voltage maximum, therefore
has no effect. 1
0 0,5 b (m) 1 1,5
In deriving L according to equation (1) it is assumed that the
arrester will become conductive only when the voltage at its
terminals has reached the value Up. This is the case with spark-gap Figure 14a
arresters. MO-arresters without spark-gaps are conductive before
the terminal voltage has reached Up. Therefore the protective
properties begin working at an earlier point. Under certain
circumstances therefore, MO arresters protect remote electrical
equipment better, which is equivalent to a longer protective
distance.

11 16
 6.3 Temporary Overvoltages The following example should illustrate the use of Figure 8:
S=800 kV / ms
U F An arrester MWK 24 with Uc = 24 kV could be operated for as long
U=660 kV a time as one wishes with Uc. The environmental temperature
U v The meaning of Temporary Over-Voltages UTOV is the operating
a UT
frequency overvoltages of a limited duration. The spark-gap surrounding the arrester amounts to a maximum of 45 C. At the
T arresters require special measures regarding these voltages. In time t = 0 the arrester is charged with the specified energy E = 5.5
b
these arresters the follow current increases very strongly with the kJ/kV Uc.
operating voltage. If this voltage lies above the rated voltage of the Immediately following the temporary overvoltage UTOV = 28 kV
30 c
arrester, the follow current through the arrester will be too high. occurs. Thus:
20 C=0 Under these conditions, the spark-gaps can no longer extinguish T= UTOV / Uc = 28 kV / 24kV = 1.17
A T A T A T the arc, that is they ignite it again in each of the following half cycles
C C C
C=0,5nF
until the arrester is destroyed by overheating. In networks with For T= 1.17 it follows that from curve b the time t = 400 s.
10 1 2 3 temporary overvoltages the rated voltage of the spark-gap arrester Therefore the duration of UTOV is limited to 400 seconds. Following
L (m)
must be raised to UTOV, which also requires the raising of the this the arrester is again capable of bearing Uc and cools down. If it
Arrangements for arresters and electrical equipment protection level of the arrester. is expected that UTOV has to occur for longer than 400 seconds on
5
the line, then an arrester with the corresponding elevated Uc must
evaluation of the connections: F: lightning endangered line
3
be selected.
U: lightning overvoltage
C=2nF 1: poor A: arrester
2 2: good T: electrical equipment (transformer) 1.4
3: excellent C: capacitance of T to earth
1.35 7 Tests
1
0 1 2 3 4 5 Figure 15 T 1.3 a
b (m)
1.25 The tests for ABB arresters follow internationally agreed upon
Figure 14b recommendations. IEC 60099-4 has been valid for the MO-
1.2 b arresters since August 1998 [6]. In the USA - Norm ANSI C62.11-
UTOV
1.15 1993 is applied [7], which coincides with the IEC. The MV-
Uc arresters from ABB fulfill both norms.The tests are made in
1.1 accordance to type, routine, and acceptance tests.
Arrester protective distance L in the network
level Um = 17.5 kV and 24 kV with respect to 1.05 Furthermore the arresters are submitted to special tests, which are
the conductor length b. not mentioned in the international regulations.
1.0
1 10 100 1000 10'000 t (s)
If a + b L, then UT BIL / 1,2 7.1 Type Tests

C: transformer T capacitance between

phase and earth
MO-arrester
spark-gap arrester
Up= 4 p.u. when In = 5 kA
14a): line with wooden poles
14b): line with earthed cross arms
This is of special significance in regard to arrester protection for
transformers, because they have a capacitance to earth which
should not be underestimated. Additionally noteworthy is the
marked decrease of L with the conductor length b. The connection
from the lightning endangered line to the high voltage connection
of the arrester should therefore be as direct as possible. In Figure
15, three connection possibilities are schematically represented
and evaluated.
The larger protective distance of the arrester in lines with earthed
cross arms (Figure 14 b) stems from the less magnitude of the
overvoltage running into the substation (lower flashover voltage
line to earth). From this a lower current through the arrester and a
lower limiting voltage result which enable a larger value for L.
In networks where Um = 12 kV, the protective distance of the
arrester are about 10% longer than represented in Figure 14. On
the other hand, when Um =36 kV, the distance is about 30%
shorter. At this network operating level, it should also be noted that
when S = 1550 kV / s (wooden pole lines), the value of L sharply
decreases as soon as b > 0.6
The protective properties of the arresters are somewhat reduced
with different polarity of the lightning overvoltage and the
momentary value of the phase voltage, this is taken into account in
the calculation of L. Additionally it is assumed a very short galva-
nic connection between the earth side of the arrrester to the
transformer tank. This is to be taken into consideration when
connecting the arrester.
Figure 16
MO-surge arrester type POLIM-D 12 N with disconnector,
installed on a distribution transformer
Otherwise it becomes necessary to increase the length of the
conductor length b in Figure 13 due to the additional earth
connection. Branching between the arrester and electrical equip-
ment to other electrical equipment creates additional voltage
oscillations which in most cases results in a reduction of L.
9.4 Fault Hazards in Electrical Equipment and Their
Distance from the Surge Arrester
An arrester placed at a distance L from the electrical equipment
limits the overvoltage to a value of BIL / 1.2 as long as the
overvoltage steepness S at the station is not larger than
1550 kV/s for wooden pole lines
800 kV/s for earthed cross arm lines
However, on the average this steepness will be exceeded once
every 400 years. In this case an overvoltage in the electrical
equipment can reach a value above its BIL causing permanent
damage. If the life expectancy of the equipment, e.g. a transformer,
is put at about 40 years, then in the time interval ts = 400 years
there exists a 90 % probability that no damage will occur. However
this includes a failure rate caused by overvoltages during this 40
years which amounts to 10 %. Even though an arrester is mounted
at the distance L from the transformer.
Figure 8
Strength T=UTOV / Uc with respect to temporary overvoltages UTOV
as a function of their duration t at an ambient temperature (air
temperature outside the arrester) of 45C. The curve a applies to
an arrester without preload, the curve b to an arrester, preloaded
with the guaranteed energy E. t is the time duration of the
overvoltage with power frequency.
The curves apply for the MO-surge arrester type MWK.
In MO-arresters there is no follow current because this is
prevented by the extremely non-linear voltage current charac-
teristic (Figure 4). It is for this reason that MO arresters are capable
of bearing increased operational voltages over a longer period of
time. The strength T of the arrester in the presence of such tempor-
ary overvoltages is described in Figure 8.
UTOV = T x Uc
T is then a measure for the permissible height of UTOV.
The curve a in Figure 8 is valid for arresters without a significant
energy preloading. The higher T and respectively UTOV, the greater
the power generated in the arrester. Because the MO temperature
cannot exceed a certain value for reasons of stability, is the energy
supplied to the arrester also limited. For that reason the
permissible load duration t decreases with the magnitude of T
resp. UTOV. The curve b is valid for arresters which at the time t = 0
are already preloaded with the specified energy E. Naturally, curve
b lies beneath curve a. Arresters which are already preloaded with
the E / Uc values specified in Table 2 can nevertheless withstand
temporary overvoltages correstonding to curve b. This implies
that the entire energy absorption capability of the arrester exceeds
these guaranteed data. In the time interval t the energy can be
supplied to the arrester at any given moment in the form of energy
impulses. The sum of the impulses however must not exceed the
amount E.
At the completion of the development of an arrester design, type
tests are carried out. They furnish proof that they comply with the
relevant standard. The following tests are designated for MV-
arresters:
Isolation withstand tests on the arrester housing: these tests
demonstrate that the external housing insulation meets the
expected voltage demands.
Residual voltage tests: The function of these tests is to certify that
the protection level of the arrester does not exceed the guaranteed
data.
Long duration current impulse withstand test: this test is
performed to prove that the MO resistors withstand possible
dielectric and energy demands without puncture, flashover and
cracking.
Time accelerated ageing test: in this test resistors are subjected
to a temperature of 115 C for 1000 hours with a voltage above Uc.
In doing so it is watched if and how intensive the power losses of
the resistors increase over their life span. The life span is
understood to be 110 years according to [7]. In this time ABB
resistors demonstrate no increase of power losses: therefore they
are not subject to any ageing process.
Operating duty tests: the following values are of significance in
this test:
Reference current Iref
This is the peak value of the ohmic current component by which the
reference voltage is measured. Iref should be large enough so that
this measurement cannot be influenced by the stray capacitance of
the arrester components. The reference current must be specified
by the manufacturer. For ABB MV-arresters the following values
are valid for Iref:
1.4 mA for POLIM-DN
1.4 mA for POLIM-D, MVK
1.6 mA for POLIM-DA
2.2 mA for MWK, MWD, POLIM-I, POLIM-C
3.6 mA for POLIM-S
5.0 mA for POLIM-H

17 10
 A true comparison with a MO-arrester necessitates a rise time The shorter the sum of the connecting lines a + b compared with L The flashover of a bus bar or a conductor of a line toward the earth
which also lies in the range of 50 ns. With such a steep front the in Figure 14, the lower the failure rate. In other words, a + b must be causes a short operation shutdown at the most. Subsequent
sparkover voltage reaches a value of at least 1.4 Up. It follows that as small as possible , and L must be as large as possible. The latter damage is, however extremly rare. In cables, flashover behaviour
by a steep rise the limiting voltage of the spark-gap arrester is at is achieved by choosing the proper line direction. As can be seen in is completely different. Flashovers in cable insulation can cause
least 24 % higher than that of the MO-arrester. Figure 15, the line must be first connected with the arrester and disturbances and require extensive repairs. Flashovers along the
then connected with the transformer. In this case b = 0 and L cable heads can damage these and exibit the same damage as with
The behaviour of the arrester during switching overvoltages is a becomes maximal. The connecting line L can be held short by insulation flashovers. Cables must therefore be treated as station
further feature of the protection characteristics. In spark-gap placing the arrester as close as possible to the transformer. Both equipment and protected against lightning overvoltage with
arresters the sparkover voltage reaches approx. the value of Up measures together make it possible to fulfill the requirements of arresters.
with these relatively slowly rising overvoltages. MO-arresters have a + b << L and therefore keep the failure rate considerably below The arresters are to be placed directly next to the cable heads. The
no sparkover voltage. With MV-arresters the switching protection 10%. junction lines should be as short as possible. It must be noted that
level is given through the residual voltage at 500 A of the current the earth connection of the arrester is attached to the cable sheath.
wave 30/60 ms. The residual voltage reaches 0.77.... 0.83 Up If the transformer is connected to a wooden pole line, and if
depending on the arrester type. The limiting voltage during
Figure 6 switching overvoltages of spark-gap arresters is at least 20 % U U
b<1m when Um < 24 kV Arrester with LK LK
Repelling water on silicone surface (hydrophobicity-effect) higher than that of MO-arresters. Up = 3.8 p.u. for MO
Up = 4 p.u. for SiC
At the same continuous operating voltage the MO-arresters and In = 10 kA
therefore demonstrate a more favorable protection characteristic b < 0.6 m when Um > 24 kV
5.5 Altitude Adjustement for Arrester Housing than spark-gap arresters. The above mentioned figures are valid Type of Line Wooden pole earthed Wooden pole earthed
for arresters employed in networks with high-ohmic insulated cannot be maintained, then the line is to be modified so that crossarms crossarms
Normal MV-arresters from ABB can be used at altitudes of up to neutral. Regarding the operational safety, MO-arresters have an regarding the overvoltage at the substation and the protective Arrester Type MO SiC MO SiC MO SiC MO SiC
1800 m above sea level. additional advantage in the fact that they can also resist temporary distance, it behaves as favourably as a line with earthed cross Um ZK LK LK LK LK LK LK LK LK
overvoltages as shown in Figure 8. arms. [kV] [] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m] [m]
At higher altitudes the air density is so low that the withstand
MO and spark-gap arresters must be dimensioned differently in 30 7 6 17 17

8 8

8 8

8 8

8 8
voltage of the arrester housing may be no longer sufficient against 3.6
networks with solidly earthed neutral systems [8]. The result is 60 3 3 10 10
external flashovers. In this case the unaltered active parts of the The necessary measures for this are relatively simple: the cross 30 64 30 64 28 9 9 22 14
arrester (same protection level) must be placed in an elongated that Uc can be chosen 28 % lower than the rated voltage of the arms of the last three poles before the station are to be earthed. The 7.2
60 45 20 50 19 4 4 13 11
housing with a larger flashover distance. spark-gap arrester. Thereby a protection characteristic results for overvoltage which runs into the station from the modified lines 30 40 15 40 14 9 7 19 9
the MO technology which, depending on the wave form, lies 28 % now have the same form as if it came from a line with continuous 12
60 30 11 32 10 4 3 14 7
to 42 % lower. earthed crossarms. The disadvantage of this solution is that
As an orientation value one may consider that for every 1000 m 17.5
30 25 6 26 5 6 4 15 4
over 1800 m above sea level the flashover distance of the housing additional lightning overvoltages cause flashovers between the 60 21 4 22 4 3 2 13 3
must be enlarged by 12 %. For example, at an altitude of 3300 m conductor and the earth owing to the reduced insulation level of the 30 28 6 28 5 10 5 17 4
6.2 Questions of Stability of MO Surge Arresters line. A more efficient method than the earthing the cross arms 24
above sea level the flashover distance of the housing must be 18 % 60 23 5 24 4 5 3 15 3
larger than of a normal arrester. would be to install another set of arresters one pole in front of the 30 22 1 22 1 8 1 15 1
In Figure 7, P is the power loss of the MO-resistors in an arrester 36
substation. The effect is a very strong reduction in the amplitude of 60 20 1 20 1 4 1 14 1
when Uc is applied. It is evident how P exponentially increases with the incoming overvoltage. This in turn leads to a protective
the MO temperature, which also results in an increased warming of behaviour of the arrester at the equipment which is better than that Table 7
6 Protection Characteristics of the Surge the active parts. The cooling of the resistors results from the flow of earthed cross arms. Maximum allowable length LK of cable sections with one-sided
arrester protection. The cable is connected to a lightning
of heat Q from the active part to the exterior. At temperatures above
Arrester, Stability the critical point is P > Q. Here the cooling is not sufficient to endangered line.
dissipate the power loss. The resistors would continue to heat up Lightning overvoltage and momentary value of system voltage
and the arrester would be destroyed by overheating. Through having different polarities.
6.1 Surge Arrester Protection Level
suitably dimensioning of the resistors and through design
10 Some Special Cases
measures that enable the cool down of the blocks, it is possible to Junction length arrester to cable 1 m
The protection level Up is the maximum voltage at the arrester raise the critical point to such a level, that even if during the On one hand the protective distance of an arrester is, in some ZK: Surge impedance of the cable
terminals during the flow of the nominal discharge current which, operation the highest energies are likely to occur, this critical point cases, not especially long. This applies mostly to electrical equip- MO: Metal oxide arrester
according to definition, shows a current form of 8/20 s. The peak is impossible to be reached. ment which is subject to capacitance in substations with a high SiC: Arrester with spark-gap
value of the current is reached after approx. 8 s and after approx. On the other hand, the mechanism described clearly shows the network voltage and which are connected to wooden poles (see
20 s it has decayed to 50 % of the peak value. In the case of spark- limits of the energy absorption capacity of the MO-arrester. The Figure 14), on the other hand pieces of electrical equipment in a
gap arresters Up is additionally given by the standard lightning amount of energy fed to it must never exceed the critical point. substation are seldom placed close together. Usually they are so Longer cables require arrester protection at both ends. For short
impulse sparkover voltage. This is the lowest prospective peak Then P < Q and the MO discs cool down until the stable operating far apart from each other that one arrester could not protect several cables sections onesided protection is, in some cases, sufficient.
value of a standard lightning voltage impulse (1.2/50 s) which, point is again reached. pieces of equipment at the same time. Under this conditions, each This is because an arrester at only one end can still offer sufficient
when applied to the arrester, causes sparkovers on every piece of electrical equipment requires a separate arrester set (one lightning overvoltage protection to the other end.
application. Virtually the same protection level is possible through arrester each per phase to earth). A cable which connects the overhead line with the substation is
MO and spark-gap arresters having identical continuous service P,Q often only endagered by lightning on the line. The arrester must
thermal runaway
voltage Uc. It lies at about Up = 3.33 Uc or under this value. More therefore be mounted to the line at the cable junction. No second
precise values are available in the corresponding booklets. arrester is necessary at the other end of the cable, as long as the
10.1 Overvoltage Protection in Cable Sections cable length LK does not exceed the values which are given in the
The protection characteristics of an arrester consists not only of critical point Table 7. At first glance, it should be noted that LK is unlimited in 3.6
the value Up, but of two additional features. The first is the The essential difference between the electrical data of overhead kV networks. This is because of the relatively high BIL of 13.6 p.u.
behaviour of the arrester during steep wave fronts, which is lines and cables is the surge impedance of their conductors to at this network level. The arrester at the line side of the cable limits
especially important for MV equipment. The test for MO-arresters Q P earth. Values for overhead distribution lines are approximately the overvoltage to approximately 4 p.u. As a result of voltage
takes place with the nominal discharge current, the front time of 300 to 450 and for cables in the 20 to 60 range. First of all, reflections in the cable, the overvoltage at the other end of the cable
stable
which is reduced from 8 s to 1 s. The residual voltage over the operating point this difference causes a marked decrease of the lightning over- is higher, but under 10 p.u. At this level, the overvoltage is
arrester reaches a maximum of 1.13 Up at this steep current wave. voltage as soon as the travelling wave reaches the cable entrance. harmless to the cable. This, however, does not apply to
Because of the non linearity of the current-voltage-characteristic The reduced voltage wave flows through the cable and it is equipments in the substation. With these equipments additional
of the MO-arrester, the front time of this residual voltage lies in the reflected at the end so that the voltage is nearly doubled. voltage reflections can increase the overvoltage, so that for their
order of magnitude of 50 ns. Subsequently the wave returns to the cable entrance and is once protection, in case of necessity, arresters must be provided. The
T more reflected, etc. In this way, the overvoltage in the cable is built maximum allowable length for a cable section with onesided
up gradually although the overvoltage slope in the cable is actually protection is higher for MO-arresters than for those with spark-
In comparison with it the front-of-wave sparkover voltage is often gaps. This is based on the favourable protection properties of MO-
referred to for spark-gap arresters. It lies at approx. 1.15 Up. In this Figure 7 lower, the peak value is near that of lightning overvoltage on the
Power loss P of the MO discs and heat flow Q from the active line [18]. arresters, which begin conducting before Up is reached.
test the length of the rise time is adjusted to approx. 400 ns.
arrester parts to the exterior as a function of the MO
temperature T at the continuous operating voltage Uc

9 18
Naturally, cables in overhead lines are lightning endangered on
both sides. Therefore it must be taken into account that in cables
with one-sided protection, overvoltage can also come from the
unprotected side. In this case, the protection effectiveness of the
arrester at the other end would be strongly reduced. The allowable
length of cables in overhead lines with one-sided protection is
therefore smaller. The length is especially short for cables in
connection with wooden pole lines, as shown in Table 7. The given
values for LK are valid for arresters with In = 10 kA. The surge
impedance across the entire cable section must be constant so that
the voltage reflections do not cause a decrease in LK. This is the
case, for example, with cable junctions or when a cable section
with a single cable is connected to a section with two parallel
cables.
10.2 Cable Sheath Protection
Due to thermal principles, the sheath for single conductor cables
are generally only earthed on one side. Under these circumstances
the sheath on the unearthed side can take on up to 50 % of the
voltage peak value of the overvoltage entering on the inner
conductor. The sheath insulation cannnot withstand this
overvoltage demand. Momentary flashovers can occur between
the sheath and the earth, consequently damaging the outer sheath
insulation.
Therefore, the unearthed cable sheath must be protected against
lightning overvoltage with an arrester [2]. The special arrester
POLIM-C is particularly well-suited for this purposes. The voltage
induced along the cable sheath during a short circuit is decisive for
Uc of the arrester. According to [19] it reaches maximum 0.3 kV per
kA of fault current and km of cable length. When T = 1.28 and the
fault current duration is t < 3 s, the following results:
Uc > 0.24 x IK x LK in kV
IK: max. 50 Hz fault current in kA
LK: length of the unearthed cable section in km
U UK UT MV
K N
b a
F
A1 A2
Transformer at the end of a cable
F: lightning endangered line
U: lightning overvoltage
K: long cable
A1, A2: arresters
a, b: length of the connecting lines
UK : maximum voltage at the cable end
UT: maximum voltage at the transformer
MV::
LV:
medium voltage side
low voltage side
Figure 17
10.3 Transformers at the End of Cables The energy absorption capability of these types is much higher In porcelain housed arresters the ensuing electric arc causes the
than the expected stresses in the network, exepting the very high gas pressure in the housing to elevate quickly. If the network short
According to the direction in Figure 17, a cable of at least 100 m in ligtning currents. These currents can also be commanded by the circuit current is not too high, the pressure relief valve in the
length is connected on one end to a lightning endangered line. At arresters, it is however most unlikely that they appear. Such high arrester opens before the housing bursting pressure is reached.
the other end, a bus bar consisting of sections a and b connects the lightning currents can flow through the arrester only when a On the other hand, if the current is extremely high, the possibility of
cable end on the other side with a transformer. Arrester A1 takes lightning hits directly the top of the arrester. The energy values are the housing exploding cannot be ruled out.
over the overvoltage protection on the line side. The cable end and given in Table 2 and 3. With ABB silicon-polymer arresters there is no danger of bursting
the transformer must each be protected with an additional arrester By aerial lines with wooden poles even far away lightning strokes in the case of an overload. There is no air space between the active
when the connecting distance between the two is especially long. can cause relatively high currents that flow through the arrester. If part of the arrester and its silicon insulation, thus there is no place
The following example indicates under what circumstances the sparkover voltage of the wire against the earth is U = 3000 kV for pressure to build up. In the case of an overload, holes appear in
arrester A2 offers sufficient overvoltage protection, in addition to and the characteristic wave impedance of the wire is Z = 450 W the casing which immediately leads to initiation of the external
arrester A1. from the equation (3) ensue that lightning currents up to13 kA are flashover.
to be expected in the arrester. This current produce in arresters The MV-arresters of the types POLIM-D, MWK and MWD are
with In = 5 kA a residual stress which lies 15% over Up. In this way proved with short circuit currents up to 20 kA. The types POLIM-I,
The overvoltage reflection U at the junction from the line to the
cable causes a strong flattening of the voltage rate of rise in the the protection of the electrical equipment gets worse. For instance POLIM-S and POLIM-H are tested with short circuit currents up to
cable. However, this has practically no influence on the allowable if it lies at the end of an aerial line of 10 km it will be once in three 65 kA. Because of their special construction the arresters are also
length of the connection b, because with increasing length of b the years exposed to such an increased voltage stress. That is why up to the highest short circuit currents insured against explosion
voltage UK increases very quickly. Optimal overvoltage protection, ABB has also in the assortment of the MV-arresters the types and destruction.
therefore, requires that arrester A2 be placed as close as possible MWK, MWD, POLIM-I, POLIM-S and POLIM-H. They posses
to the cable end, in order to shorten the distance b (see section 10.1). nominal discharge currents of 10 kA respectively 20 kA. Their
employment is recommended everywhere where in terms of
5.2 Elevated Ambient Temperatures
stress, operation safety and protection level the highest
requirements are set. The guaranteed values for Uc are valid for an ambient temperature
of up to 45 C. In the case of outdoor arresters, extreme solar
This is the case in radiation (1.1 kW/m2) is taken into account. If there are other heat
MO-surge arrester with sources in the vicinity of the arrester, the increase in radiation
Up = 3.8 p.u. bei
In = 10 kA
wooden poles earthed crossarms regions with high lightning activity exposure must also be taken into account and the value of Uc
increased if necessary. If the ambient temperature exceeds 45 C,
erial lines with concrete or wooden poles and non-earthed
Uc must be increased by 2 % for every 5 C of temperature eleva-
ZK [] 30 60 30 60
crossarms tion.
Um [kV] a [m] a [m] a [m] a [m] arresters, which are placed on locations where people are often
to be found 5.3 Mechanical Stability
3.6 300 300 500 500
on lines, which set exeptional high requirements
7.2 43 37 53 53
concerning the operation safety MV-arresters produced by ABB are operationally reliable even in
areas of high earthquake activity. Silicon arresters from ABB can
12 20 14 20 14 protection of engines, generators and cables also have a support function. In the case of cantilever strength, it
must be distinguished between temporary and operational loads
17.5 17 10 16 10 areas with high industrial pollution, or when the arresters are according to DIN 48113. The permissible loads result from the
24 19 12 19 12 not farther than 1000 m from the sea. product of arrester altitude and maximum permissible momentum
load. In Table 4 there are the mechanical data of different arrester
36 16 11 20 11
In cases where the 10 kA arresters are recommended is also a types to be read.
higher energy absorption capability advantageous and an arrester
Table 8 type with a line discharge class 2 or more should be chosen. That is
why these arresters have a higher energy capability of at least 5.5 Vertical
Canti lever strength Torsion
LV Maximum permissible distance a between cable end and kJ/kVUc (MWK, POLIM-I, POLIM-S) Arrester type Nm Nm
Load
transformer according Figure 17 with b=O. The cable is connected
to a lightning endangered line and protected at both ends with The peculiarity of some electrical equipment, as for instance POLIM-DN 250 50 625
MO-surge arresters (type MWK or MWD with Uc = Um)
The transformer has no additional arrester protection.
arc furnace POLIM-D 250 50 625
ZK: Surge impedance of the cable. big capacitor batteries POLIM-DA 350 50 1000
very long cable sections MWK, MWD 350 68 1200
expensive rotating machines
POLIM-I 2500 100 2000
can make a higher energy absorption capability necessary. In such
POLIM-S 4000 100 3000
The line section a is different. Here UT increases more slowly with cases the special type POLIM-H with In = 20 kA and with 13.3
the increasing length of a. Therefore, the transformer is adequately kJ/kVUc is preferred. POLIM-H 6000 100 4000
protected, even at a relatively far distance from the arrester. The Table 4
maximum allowable values for a are indicated in Table 8. The
capacity of the transformer is assumed to be 2 nF. Smaller values 5 Special Operating Conditions Mechanical data of MV-surge arresters, produced by ABB
result in greater distances of a.
5.4 Air Pollution
5.1 Network Short Circuit Power
Silicon is the best insulating material against pollution. This is
Any arrester can be overloaded. The causes are extremely high mainly because the material is water-repellent. Silicon arresters
stroke currents, a large number of multiple strokes [16, 17] or the behave more favourably under conditions of heavy air pollution
so-called system flashover. This is understood to be a short circuit than porcelain housed arresters or other polymer insulation
between two different voltage levels. The voltage at the arrester on materials. In addition the self-cleaning feature of silicon itself is
the lower voltage level rises above the allowable limit. An overload outstanding. Pollutants and dirt cannot adhere well to the flexible
of any kind causes a flashover or puncture in the resistor. An arc covering and are washed away by rain.
results in the arrester and the current from this arc is defined by the
short circuit power of the network.
19 8
 0%=^ 7 4.3 Energy absorption capability and cool-down time 10.4 Transformer Connected to a Lightning Endangered Conditions are different when arresters must contain switching
Line on One Side Only overvoltages rather than lightning overvoltages. The former could
6
The arresters in the network can work reliable if their energy occur during switching, when an inductive current is interrupted
absorption capability is bigger than the energy strain expected in before it reaches its natural zero crossing. When such switching
5 In general, all transformer exits which are directly linked to overvoltages occur, the current load on the arrester is very low, so
HC Hydrophobicity

the system operation. Some examples of the stress on the lightning endangered lines must be equipped with arresters
arresters in the network are shown in the Table 3. The arresters of that a nominal discharge current of 5 kA is sufficient. On this case
4 between phase and earth. If a transformer connects a high voltage the maximum overvoltage is considerably lower than Up for MO-
the line discharge class 1 have the highest energy stress with the network with a MV network, and only the line on the high voltage
3 high current (65 kA respectively 100 kA). To prove the thermal arresters. Therefore, shorter distances between arresters and
side is lightning endangered, arresters are required there. Because between the arrester and earth are possible, facilitating the
stability under this stress, a special type test has to be performed. overvoltages occur very quickly, up to 40% of the overvoltage on
2 installation of arresters in the cells. The lower values for these
the high voltage side is capacitively carried over to the MV side distances are prescribed in the respective national regulations and
^1 3.5 p.u. Charging voltage current wave form through the transformer (10). It is therefore often necessary to are sufficient for metal oxide arresters.
100%= Arrester type foresee overvoltage protection for the transformer on the MV side,
In High current
200 km line 10 km cable 4/10 ms even though no lightning overvoltages occur on the MV side,
0 8/20 ms The maximum voltage for arresters with spark-gaps reaches Up
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 h 5000 according to the above assumptions. According to (9), this
tv test time kJ/kV Uc kJ/kV Uc kA kJ/kV Uc kA kJ/kV Uc overvoltage protection can be a long MV cable, a low-inductance also during switching overvoltages. The minimum distances for
POLIM-DN capacitor, or a combination of these two elements. They must be these arresters must therefore be longer in order to prevent
0.4 0.33 5 0.26 65 2.6 flashovers. This can make arrester installation in the cells
Figure 5 connected as close as possible to the MV exit of the transformer
POLIM-D 0.4 0.33 10 0.55 100 3.6 and together possess a capacity of at least 50 nF per phase. significantly more difficult, particularly when there are especially
Change of hydrophobicity of EPDM (black) and silicone (white) tight spacing conditions.
in the accelerated ageing test acc. to IEC 1109. POLIM-DA 0.4 0.33 10 0.53 100 3.5
The overvoltage protection can also come from a MV arrester. This
MWK, MWD solution has two essential advantages. First, it must be noted that 10.6 Generator Connected to a Lightning Endangered
POLIM-I 0.4 0.33 10 0.48 100 3.4 inductively transferred overvoltage can be incraesed by Distribution Line
capacitors. Carefully chosen damping resistors in series to the
POLIM-S 0.4 0.33 10 0.47 100 3.3 capacitors make possible a partial decrease of this additional
The short-time tests acc. to IEC 507 provide the basis for the Overvoltage protection is the result of arresters placed between
0.4 0.33
voltage load on the transformers. When a MO-arrester without a phase and earth. If a loaded generator is suddenly disconnected
dimensions of the insulator. In certain cases, the insulator be- POLIM-H 20 1.0 100 3.2
spark-gap is used, this additional load does not occur. from the network, its terminal voltage increases until the voltage
haviour may deviate under actual field conditions as a result of
other parameters (eg, due to the shape of the sheds). However, it is Table 3 regulator has readjusted itself after a few seconds. The relationship
generally true for silicone as well as for the ceramic insulators that Energy load of arresters in MV-networks Secondly, primary voltage encroaches on the MV-voltage during a between this temporary overvoltage and the normal operating
extreme pollution calls for a longer creepage path. voltage flashover in the transformer and can cause additional voltage is called the load rejection factor uL. This factor can reach a
The guaranteed energy absorption capability of the types of the damage there. When the MV side is protected with arresters, the value of up to 1.5. In the worst case, the arrresters could be
The mentioned temporary reduction in hydrophobicity was taken
line discharge class 2 and higher can be proved by the means of arrester sacrifices itself, causing a short to earth, and leaving the charged with a temporary overvoltage of UTOV = uL x Um, wich
into account in the design of the POLIM arresters, and the specific
rectangular current stresses, similar to the examination of the high damage essentially restricted to the transformer. The advantage of must be taken into account when choosing Uc.
creepage path was not reduced. All of the discussed surge
voltage arresters. an arrester versus a capacitor is particularly evident when the
arresters with silicone insulation have been designed with a
The guarantee data contain a certain amount of energy reserve and transformer is connected to a generator, and the arrester protects
specific creepage path of at least 25 mm per kV, providing a more uL x Um
therefore do not mean the limit of the thermal stability of the the generator from subsequent damage.
than adequate safety margin. Whenever possible, all the pollution Uc > ----------------
and lifetime tests were carried out on complete MO arresters. The arrester.
Similar conditions exist with a distribution transformer, which T
tests were performed to the various standards (eg, the 1,000-hour
humidity room test to IEC 1109, the 5,000-hour aging cycle test Anyway the arresters will be very strongly warmed up when they connects a MV network to a low-voltage network. Again, lightning
and the salt-fog test to IEC 507) and showed that the silicone overvoltage from the MV network is transferred through the The duration t of UTOV determines T and lies in a range from 3 to 10
have to carry very high lightning currents. Therefore they need
insulation performs better after ten years in service that the other transformer capacitively to the low voltage side. Therefore, seconds. In the following example, Uc of type MWK arresters is
between two such stresses a suitable cool-down time. This
types of insulation. arresters in the low voltage side are necessary, even when only the determined:
reduction is however not important because it is most unlikely that
the same arrester has to carry a second very high ligtning current MV side is lightning endangered. If, on the other hand, only the low
during its cool-down time. That is the reason why the test sample voltage side is endangered, frequently no arresters are mounted on Um = 14 kV uL = 1.4
is allowed to be cooled-down to 60 C during the type test with the MV side. In this case, it is assumed that the low voltage
high current [6] between the two surges. arrester can also adequately protect the MV side from overvoltage
8
coming from the low voltage side. Several cases of transformer t = 10 s T = 1.26 (from Figure 8)
cm/kVrms
failure caused by lightning overvoltage on the 415 volt side are
5 The needed cool-down time of the arrester depends among other reported in [20]. The author's opinion is that these overvoltages,
4 things on the ambient temperature and the height of the operating when they are of long durations, are transferred inductively with
3 voltage. It increases with the ambient temperature and the opera- the turn ratio of the transformer to the 11 kV side. In any case, the 1.4 x 14 kV
ting voltage. In the most unfavourable case, with 45C air 415 volt arresters were unable to prevent flashovers in the 11 kV
temperature and Uc the following values are valid: Uc > ------------------- = 15.56 kV
2 windings. In regions with high lightning activity, it is therefore
1.26
Creapage

Cool-down time between two high ligtning current stresses (65 kA recommended to install arresters on the MV side of the
respectively 100 kA): transformer.
1 Type POLIM-S and POLIM-H no break necessary The arrester type needed is called MWK 16. Its Uc is 16 kV and the
The other arrester types 75 minutes protection level at In = 10 kA is 49.1 kV.
2.5
0 10.5 Arresters in Metal Enclosed MV Substations
0 3 4 5 7 10 15 20 30 40 kg/m3 80
Cool-down time between two energy stresses acc. the Table 2: The high operational safety requirements for generators make the
salt content of water use of arresters with the lowest possible protection level desirable.
Type POLIM-S and POLIM-H 60 minutes It is often necessary to place arresters in a metal enclosed MV Therefore the special POLIM-H series arrester is recommended for
The other arrester types 60 minutes substation. If a cable connects the cell with a lightning endangered generator protection. Not only is the protection level lower, but also
Figure 5a line, the nominal discharge current of the arrester at the cable head at the same time is T larger.
Comparison of the specific creapage distance of porcelain (black) in the cell should be 10 kA. The voltage on the arrester can be
expected to reach Up. In order to prevent flashovers in the cell, the
and silicone insulators (white), depending on the salt content in the 4.4 Nominal Discharge Current and Energy Absorption For t =10 s, T = 1.31 is permitted, which results in:
minimum distances between the arresters and the arresters and
salt fog test acc. to IEC 507 Capability earth recommended by the supplier must be observed.

The arresters with a nominal discharge current of 5 kA proved to be 1.4 x 14 kV

enough reliable in the MV- network. That is why generally the type Uc > ------------------ = 14.96 kV
POLIM-D respectively the type POLIM-DN are used. 1.31

7 20
The arrester type POLIM-H 15 is sufficient. Its protection level at I =
10 kA is 43.5 kV. This special arrester guarantees a 11% lower
protection level. In addition this arrester has also advantages with
regard to operational safety thanks to its substantially higher
energy absorption capability (see Table 2).
Generators have a larger capacity between phase and earth. As
seen in Figure 14, this capacity results in a considerably shorter
arrester protective distance. Therefore it is especially important to
place arresters near the generator.
10.7 Arrester Protection for Motors
High voltage motors can become over-stressed by multiple re-
starts being switched off during the run-up. This is applicable
when the cut-off current is less than 600 A. In order to protect
these motors it is recommended that surge arresters be placed
directly at the motor terminals or, alternatively, at the circuit
breaker. The layout of Uc according to the recommendations can
be seen in section 8.
In special cases, i.e. aged winding insulation, it becomes
necessary to additionally decrease the protection level of the
arrester. One way of doing this is to decrease Uc. This procedure is
justifiable when temporary overvoltages taken into account for Uc
occur very infrequently. The fact that in such a rare case the
arrester could become overloaded has been deliberately taken into
account. Resulting drawbacks, such as operation interruptions
and arrester replacement are outweighted by the advantage of
better overvoltage protection. However Uc smaller than Um / 3
may never be selected.
However such a decrease of Uc is not recommended in a generator.
The risk exists that this would cause a two-phase short circuit at
the generator terminals. The resulting asymmetrical short circuit
current in the windings produces an extremely high mechanical
load on the rotor.
10.8 Overvoltage Protection in Locomotives
In the case of locomotives, the highest standards with respect to
operational safety are placed on the arresters. Therefore, the
arresters of the POLIM-H series are recommended. The strong
mechanical construction meets all the requirements for railway
operation. The completely moulding in silicon guarantees the
highest mechanical safety even during extreme shock loads. When
an arrester is overloaded the special construction of this arrester
prevents the housing from bursting. This arrester type is proved up
to a fault current in the network of 65 kA and can be considered
sure from the point of view of explosion and disintegration.
Additional advantages of this arrester type are its low protection
level and its high energy absorption capability.
10.9 Arresters Parallel to a Capacitor Bank
Normally no overvoltage occurs when a capacitor bank is
switched. The circuit breaker interrupts the current in the natural
current zero crossing and the voltage in the capacitor to earth
reaches a max. of 1.5 p.u. As a result of the network voltage vary-
ing at the power frequency, a voltage across the open circuit
breaker of 2.5 p.u. is caused. If the breaker re-strikes, a high
frequency transient effect takes place between the capacitor
voltage and the operating voltage.
21
During this process the capacitor is charged with a higher voltage The diameter of the MO-resistors is proportional to the energy In the last 15 years most of the modern MO-arresters were set in
[21]. The overvoltage of the capacitor between phase and earth absorption capability E and the nominal discharge current In. The new installations in high-voltage networks [4]. Up until a few years
[15] reaches a max. of 3 p.u. If the capacitors are connected in a special arresters of the type POLIM-S and POLIM-H have resistors ago conventional arresters,consisting of SiC resistors and series
star, they are discharged between phase and earth by the arrester like the ones of the high voltage arresters. These types of arresters spark-gaps were still installed in distribution systems. Now a days,
parallel to the bank. During the discharge up to a voltage of 2 x set new standards in the medium voltage network ; they are able to MO-arresters without spark-gaps are in use, especially those with
Uc, in terms of power, the arrrester is loaded with: resist the strongest stress and at the same time they guarantee a polymer housing. The reasons for this technological change are
low protection level. The continuous operating voltage Uc of the increasing operation efficiency, lower protection level with very
MV-arresters in the Table 3 reaches from 4 kV up to 36 kV. steep overvoltages and high pollution resistance [5].
SK
Ec = ----------- x [3 - (Uc / Um)2]
In addition to the already mentioned types ABB manufactures also Due to the simple construction of the active part without spark-
the special arrester POLIM-C. This arrester is also built up gaps, which means a very high stability from the mechanical point
SK : 3-phase reactive power of the capacitor bank according to the already mentioned principle of direct moulding. of view, and also due to the simple construction generally
Ec : the discharge energy taken up by the arrester The nominal discharge current is In = 10 kA and the continuous speaking, such arresters can also undertake the support insulator
operating voltage Uc reaches from1 kV up to 7.2 kV. In the medium function and are not in danger of exploding in case of an overload.
Assuming that the arrester must carry out this process 3 times voltage system this type of arrester is used among other Silicone is the best insulating material concerning dirt, and that is
with no cool down phase, it follows with Uc > Um that applications for the protection of non-earthed cable sheath. why the arresters which are insulated with silicone behave
favourable especially with high pollution.
The functioning of an arrester, which consists only of series
Ec 6 x SK
---- > ------------- connections of MO-resistors (without spark-gaps), is extremely
simple. During an overvoltage at the arrester terminals the current
Uc x Um rises continuously and without delay through the arrester corre-
4.2 Insulation made of silicone rubber
sponding to the shown U-I characteristic, Figure 4, which means
The power consumption capacity E of the arrester must be that no really spark over takes place, but the arrester goes Silicone rubber (usually referred to simply as 'silicone') is an
adjusted to the reactive power of the bank. Table 9 shows the continuously to the conducting condition. After the decreasing of excellent insulating material for high-voltage components.
maximum allowable reactive power values for different types of the overvoltage the current becomes low again corresponding to Comparisons with traditional insulating materials, such as
ABB MV-arresters parallel to the bank. the U-I characteristic. Unlike the spark-gap arresters there flows ceramic, glass and other synthetics (eg, Ethylene-Propylene-
no follow current. Diene Monomer, or short EPDM) show clearly the superiority of
silicone. As already short mentioned, during the manufacture of
If the neutral of the capacitor bank is insulated, the arrester cannot the surge arrester the silicone insulation is bonded to the arrester
discharge the charged capacitor between phase and earth. The
assembly through casting (or injection) of the liquid rubber in
arrester does not get charged. It must be noted that after a re-strike moulds at a high temperature. Different moulds can be used to
of the breaker, the neutral of the bank increases to 2 p.u. A voltage U
4/10ms obtain an optimum match between the insulator and the
flashover of the neutral to earth results in the arrester having to [p.u.]
component assembly. The arrester insulator thus produced
1/5ms
discharge the capacitor. The arresters parallel to a bank with an exhibits the following properties:
insulated neutral must, in terms of power, be adjusted to their 8/20ms
reactive power. 1.0
30/60ms
2000ms
No hydrocarbon is present in the main chemical chain; this
If the bank remains disconnected from the network after a shut- property is partially the reason for the high immunity of the
down, the arresters discharge the voltage to zero, not merely to insulator to serious surface pollution and is also largely
2 x Uc. Below 2 x Ucthe discharge current through the arrester 0.5 responsible for preventing carbonized creepage paths from
is very small, so that the remaining discharge takes a long time. forming.
During this time the arrester can cool down. It releases more heat
than it receives during the remaining discharge. Therefore it was The material is water-repellent, so that even after excessive
justified in the above calculation of Ec to take into account only the 0
contact with water only very few drops adhere to the surface. This
energy taken up by the arrester, up to the discharge at 2 x Uc. 10-4 10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103 104 I [A] property is referred to in the industry as hydrophobicity. Drops of
water that do cling to the surface are quickly removed by the effect
Figure 4 of gravity or through normal exposure to wind.
Arrester type POLIM-D MWK POLIM-S POLIM-H Normalised current-voltage ( U-I)
Uc > Um MWD characteristic of a MO-surge arrester with In = 10 kA
POLIM-I
The hydrophobicity effect is also partly transferred to any dirt
E/Uc [kJ/kV] 3.6 5.5 9.0 13.3 deposits on the surface, which as a result does not become coated
The number of the resistors in a stack depends on the Uc of the with layers of semiconducting material as quickly as with other
Um [kV] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] SK[MVA] arrester. The stack of cylindrical MO-resistors is moulded in types of insulation. Because of this, the surface leakage currents
polymeric material (silicone) as described. flowing on silicone insulators are extremely low. The technical
3.6 0.67 1.03 1.69 2.50 literature explains the transfer of the hydrophobicity effect to dirt
7.2 1.35 2.07 3.39 5.01 The resistor stack behaves itself capacitive under Uc. The stray deposits as being due to low-molar silicone evaporating. The
capacitances of each individual resistor towards the earth cause hydrophobicity effect is temporarily reduced by strong electrical
12 2.26 3.45 5.65 8.35 the nonlinearity of the voltage distribution along the axes of partial discharges or extreme exposure to water, but to a lesser
arrester under Uc. This nonlinearity increases with the lenght of the degree with silicone than with other materials. This is clearly
17.5 3.29 5.03 8.24 12.18
resistor stack [3]. That is why high voltage arresters need grading shown by the artificial aging af EPDM and silicone in accordance
24 4.52 6.90 11.30 16.70 rings, which compensate mainly the unfavourable influence of the with IEC 1109, see Figure 5. After 5,000 hours of alternated
stray capacitances. Due to the relatively short length of the active precipitation, salt-fog and UV radition, the silicone still retains 50
36 6.78 10.36 16.95 25.05 part of the distribution surge arresters the nonlinear voltage percent of its water-repellent properties, whereas EPDM loses
distribution is so low that it can be neglected. These arresters do these properties. Tests have further shown that the hydrophobicity
not need any grading rings. effect can be restored to its original state by drying the silicone for
Table 9 several hours.
Arrester parellel to capacitor bank. Maximum allowable reactive The salt-fog test to IEC 507 also demonstrated that, assuming the
power SK of the bank for the indicated arrester types. Three same salinity in each case, the creepage paths required for silicone
discharges without a cool down phase are allowed for the insulation are, on average, 30 percent shorter than the paths
arresters. necessary with ceramic isolators, see Figure 5a. As a result, the
E/Uc: The arrester energy absorbtion capability in relation to Uc. creepage path of the silicone isolators could be reduced by this
amount.
6

4 Medium Voltage Arresters of ABB
It was the wish to increase the reliability and the safety of the
arresters and correspondingly to it also the increasing of the
energy supply that brought about the development of the MO-
arresters with silicon housing in the 1980s. For more than 30
years is silicon known as an excellent insulation material for the
high voltage technology, as for instance the long rod insulators and
bushings. The first MO-arresters with silicon housing of the typical
ABB execution (direct moulding) were used in 1986. Now, in 1999
there are everywhere in the world more than 600 000 arresters in
use under very different ambient conditions.
4.1 Arrester construction
Generally an arrester is made up of two parts, the active part,
consisting of one or more piled up MO-resistors, and an insulating
housing, that guarantees both the insulation and the mechanical
strength.
The MO-resistors have been shortly described in the last chapter.
Fundamentally there are three different possibilities of
construction:
a glass-fibre reinforced tube is shed with an insulating material.
These so called hollow insulators have the same problems as the
porcelain insulators, they need a sealing and pressure relief
system, they can have inner partial discharges under pollution.
the active part is wrapped with glass-fibre material and is soaked
with resin, which makes up the whole into a rigid body. The
insulating polymeric housing is then thrust over the resin block or
shrunk on it. This costruction has the disadvantage that it forcible
breaks apart when the MO-blocks are overloaded. Another
disadvantage is the fact that there are different insulating
materials, which also means that there are more boundary layers.
Therefore it is necessary to take special measures for
sealing.
the active part is hold mechanically together with glass-fibre
reinforced loops or bands. The silicon is directly put on the MO-
resistors. This direct moulding has the advantage that no gas
volume stays in the arrester. Sealing problems and inner partial
discharges are in this way out of question. There are no interfaces
between polymeric materials where humidity can go in. An
explosion or a shattering of the housing is not possible.
All the medium voltage arresters of ABB are build up
corresponding to the third principle (direct moulding).
The requirements to the arresters depend on the operation
necessities and the type of the equipment to be protected. That is
why ABB offers a large selection of different types of arresters for
the medium voltage network and for special applications. The
construction, the functioning and the characteristics of the
arresters are described for instance in [5]. In the Table 2 there are
the electrical main data of the medium voltage arresters to be
found.
5 22
If, for a certain arrester type, the reactive power of the parallel
Arrester type In Up / Uc High current E / Uc Square wave capacitor bank exeeds the limiting values in Table 9, an arrester
On the other hand most of the d.c. current networks are
railnetworks. If the arresters are used on a rolling material
kA kA kJ / kV I in A t in ms with better energy qualities must be selected. For networks not (locomotive) the safety is especially important (safety of persons).
5 65 2000
operating under standard voltages, the limiting values in the
POLIM-DN 3.33 2.6 150
column with the lower standard voltage apply for SK. If the reactive
The arresters produced by ABB are suitable to be used on d.c.
POLIM-D 10 3.5 100 3.6 250 2000 power is very large, arresters connected parallel must be chosen.
current networks and especially also in the railnetworks and on
In such a case the arrester supplier must be informed in order to
locomotives and traction vehicles.
POLIM-DA 10 3.33 100 3.5 350 2000 take measures to guarantee a sufficiently good current distribution
in the parallel arresters. The supplier should also be consulted The producer has to be informed by all means if the arrester is used
MWK / MWD 10 3.07 100 5.5 550 2000 when arresters with Uc < Um are to be used. in d.c. current networks. For the dimensioning of the arrester it is
also necessary to take contact with the producer.
POLIM-I 10 3.07 100 5.5 550 2000
10.10 Line Traps (Parallel Protection)
POLIM-S 10 3.00 100 9.0 1000 2000
POLIM-H 20 3.19 100 13.3 1350 2000 Line traps are air-core chokes which are switched in connection
with the high voltage lines. Their inductivity L is in the range of mH. 12 Consulting Concernig Questions on the
Table 2 If no measures are taken, the lightning currents in the conductor
Electrical main data of the MV-surge arresters from ABB must flow through the line trap. Even relatively small current rates Use of Arresters
(most common types). E / Uc as tested in the operating duty test. of rise of several kA /s would produce overvoltages on the line
trap amounting to several 1000 kV and resulting in a flashover. In
order to prevent this, MV-arresters are connected parallel to the During many discussions with the users of surge arresters it was
line trap. These will take over lightning currents and limit the noticed that a profound consulting on the use of arresters is
overvoltage to its residual voltage. welcome. This is necessary both by changes in technology, as for
The outdoor arresters have sheded housings made of silicon. The instance from the spark-gap arresters with insulation of porcelain
type MWD for the use indoor has a smooth silicon housing. (see When a short to earth occurs in a high voltage network, the fault to the MO-arresters with silicon housing, and by the choosing of
Figure 3 and 3a) current IK flows through the conductor. This power frequency the arresters for additional equipment of alredy existing
current would overload the arrester. Uc must therefore be selected installations or the planing of new installation in the medium and
so that the current flows through the line trap. It induces a low voltage networks. Especially in the new fields of application, as
temporary overvoltage of UTOV = x L x IK, standard for Uc, at the for instance in the d.c. current networks, or the designs for the
line trap. If the fault current duration is t < 3s, then T = 1.28. This protection against overvoltages and lightning danger in whole
results in the following for Uc : installations it is necessary a profound observation. The evaluation
of the existing installations from the point of view of the power
UTOV x L x IK transfer (higher system voltage) or the reliability and availability
stipulate clear protection concepts, taking into account an optimal
Uc > ---------- = ----------------
economic and technical solution.
T 1.28
Hence we offer gladly consultig and calculation for the protection
IK : maximum fault current through the line trap against overvoltage and lightning, which exceed the above
described instructions.
L : inductivity of the line trap
13. Conclusions
Figure 3
MO-surge arresters with silicone housing. (POLIM-family)
11 Arresters for D.C. Voltage
Lightning overvoltages are a hazard for all the electrical equipment
For the time being there are no international valid regulations or in a MV network. However, surge arresters assure reliable protect-
directions for the use of the arresters in d.c.voltage networks. On ion against excessive overvoltage stresses. The closer the arrester
principle in d.c.voltage networks there also appear voltages to the electrical equipment, the better the protection.
produced by lightning or other activities, which may endanger the
equipment and the insulation. In this case it is also necessary the
When determining the arrester Uc, two contradictory requirements
use of an arrester as protection against overvoltages. For such
must be considered.
situation the MO surge arresters are especially suitable, because
they do not conduct any follow current after the limiting of the On the one hand, UP must be as small as possible so that the
overvoltage, and therefore it is not necessary to extinguish any arrester can limit the overvoltage to the lowest possible values. On
d.c.current arc. There are two fundamental items to be taken into the other hand, Uc must be selected at a value high enough to allow
consideration when using the MO-arresters in the d.c.current the arrester to fulfill the requirements of network operation.
networks. On one hand it is necessary to make sure that the MO Modern MO-arresters with no spark-gaps meet both these
material is stable for a long period of time from the point of view of requirements and provide sufficient protection from overvoltage,
the d.c. voltage continuous operation. This is not the case with all as well as simultaneously assuring safe network operation.
the MO materials which are comercially available.
Figure 3a
MO-surge arresters with silicone housing
left: MWK for outdoor application
right: MWD for indoor application
During unusual operational conditions, for example when a
system flashover takes place, all the parallel arresters in the
network are overloaded equally by the operational frequency
overvoltage. If metal oxide arresters are in use, it is possible to
induce a particular arrester to become over-charged first, rather
than a random one. For example, an indoor arrester in a substation
building is selected with Uc approx. 10% higher than that of the
outdoor arrester. As soon as an abnormal operational frequency
overvoltage occurs, the outdoor arrester will be over-charged first.
This arrester limits the overvoltage by producing an outdoor
flashover and thus preventing arcing inside the substation
building.
A similar situation exists when very high temporary overvoltages
are expected in a MV network, and these occur only very
infrequently. In order to avoid an over-charge on the arrester also
in this rare case, a 15% higher Uc is necessary. Such arresters
must be employed with electrical equipment. The drawback is, that
the protection is reduced by 15%.
Two sets of arresters provide an acceptable solution to the
problem. One set with 15% higher Uc is installed next to the
electrical equipment, and a second set with a lower Uc is placed
some distance away. In this way two metal oxide arresters are
switched parallel in each phase. Should a lightning overvoltage
occur, both sets would be conductive and together produce the
same protection level for the electrical equipment as would be
possible with a single arrester set with a lower Uc. During the above
mentioned very high overvoltage, only the arresters which are at
a distance from the electrical equipment become over-charged.
Therefore, the resulting flashovers cannot damage the equipment.
Furthermore, since such an overload rarely occurs, the
subsequent interruption of operation can be risked.
When installing the arrester, two points must be carefully
observed. Both are equally important for achieving the best
possible protection level. The lightning endangered line must be
guided to the high voltage connection of the arrester first, and only
thereafter led to the equipment to be protected. A short distance
between the high voltage connection of the arrester and the
equipment is certainly important, but not of crucial significance.
Secondly the galvanic connection from the earth side of the
arrester to the earth of the electrical equipment must be as short as
possible. This distance must be below 2 m for lines with earthed
cross arms. The distance for wooden pole lines must be shorter
than :
1 m for Um < 24 kV
0.6 m for Um > 24 kV
If this is not possible, the cross arms on the last 3 poles before the
substation or the electrical equipment must be earthed or another
set of arresters must be installed one pole in front of the
substation. In this case the upper limit for the earth connection is 2
m. The connection lines to the arrester in the case of a cable must
be as short as possible.
23
The MO-resistors make up the active part of the MO-arrester. The
All the parallel MO-columns of the MO-arresters without spark- MO-resistors are compressed and sintered in the form of round
gaps conduct current at the same time. The energy of the blocks out of different metall oxides in powder form. The diameters
overvoltage is in this way distributed on all the parallel arresters, so of the MO-resistors of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, made
that the energy capacity as a limiting parameter disappears. for the usage in the medium voltage, lie between 38 mm and 75
mm. The height of the blocks is generally between 23 mm and 46
MO-arresters can be used both with 50 Hz and with 16 2/3 Hz mm. The diameter of the MO-resistors decides the carrying
because they do not conduct any follow current. On the other capacity of the current, the height of the MO-resistors (or resistor
hand in the spark-gap arresters the follow current flows with stack) decides the voltage in continuous operation and the energy
16 2/3 Hz three times longer than with 50 Hz. As a result the spark- capability. The diameter of MO-resistors correlate with the line
gaps and the SiC resistors are loaded with a corresponding higher discharge classes corresponding to IEC 60099-4, as shown in
energy. In order to prevent this it is necessary to reduce the peak Table 1.
value of the follow current. This asks for spark-gap arresters
with a higher nominal voltage, which however makes a consi-
derable increasing of the protection level necessary. For the Line discharge class 1 2 3 4
better understanding of the facts it is necessary to add that the MO- acc. to IEC 60099-4
arrester may be used with d.c. voltage, the arrester with plate
spark-gaps however cannot resist this strain. Diameter of blocks in mm 38 47 62 75
Square wave, 2000 s in A 250 550 1000 1350
Energy capability in (kJ / kVUc ) 3.6 5.5 9.0 13.3
3 Metal Oxide Resistors as Arrester Elements
Table 1
Correlation between typical MO-resistors and the line discharge
The voltage current characteristic of metal oxide resistors is
extremely non-linear. In Figure 1 the characteristic curve for such classes acc. to IEC. Line discharge class 5 is important only in
high-voltage systems above 420 kV, and not mentioned here.
resistors is plotted. In is the nominal discharge current (in Figure 1
e.g. In=10 kA). Up is the protection level. It is defined as the
maximum voltage at the resistor during the flow of In. Uc is defined
as the r.m.s.value of the Maximum Continuous Operating Voltage The contact areas of the MO-resistors are metallized with soft
aluminium up to the edge of the block, the surface is passivated
(MCOV) of the resistor.
with glass. In this way the MO-material of the MO-resistors
produced by ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd is completely
covered. The Figure 2 shows MO-resistors which are used in the
In = 10 kA medium voltage arresters.
20
[kV] The energy capability of the MO-resistors depends besides the
volume also on the construction of the arrester (carrying-off of
13 Up = 4 p.u heat). Chapter 4 gives more details concerning this.
10
MO
5.66 2 x Uc
SiC
200A
0
10-4 10-2 1 10 2 10 4 [A]
d.c. voltage measurement current wave 8 / 20 ms
Semi-logarithmic plot of the current-voltage characteristics of
MO and SiC resistors for Uc = 4 kV
Figure 1
The characteristic curve in Figure 1 corresponds to a resistor with
Uc = 4 kV. In the case of a d.c. voltage load with 2 x Uc = 5.66 kV a
d.c.current in the range of 0.1 mA flows. The capacitive component
at 50 Hz and the value of Uc lies in the vicinity of 0.5 mA. The
protective level Up when In = 10 kA amounts to 13 kV.
In comparison, the diagram also shows the curve of a SiC resistor,
which has also Up =13 kV. Since SiC exhibits a considerably less
non-linearity, the continous current of a SiC arrester without spark-
gaps at a nominal load would amount to about 200 A. Naturally, for
thermal reasons, such an arrester would not be feasible. Besides it Figure 2
would strain the electrical network much too much. Consequently
conventional arresters need spark-gaps in series, which take over MO-resistors (collection) produced by ABB
the voltage in continuous operation.
4
1 Introduction
Overvoltages in electrical supply networks result from the effects
of lightning strokes and switching actions and cannot be avoided.
They endanger the electrical equipment because, due to
economical reasons, the insulation cannot be designed for all
possible cases. A more economical and safe on-line network calls
for extensive protection of the electrical equipment against
unacceptable overvoltage loads. This applies to high voltage as
well as medium and low voltage networks.
Overvoltage protection can be basically achieved in two ways:
Avoiding lightning overvoltage at the point of origin, for instance
through shilding earth wires in front of the substation that
intercept lightning.
Limit overvoltage near the electrical equipment, for instance
through surge arresters in the vicinity of the electrical equipment.
In high voltage networks both methods of protection are usual.
The earth wire protection in medium voltage networks is generally
not very effective. Due to the small distance between the earth wire
and the line wires, a direct lightning stroke hits usally the line wires
as well. In addition, induced overvoltages in the line wires (indirect
effects of the lightning strokes) cannot be avoided by the earth
wires.
The most effective protection against overvoltages in a medium
voltage network is therefore the use of surge arresters in the
vicinity of the electrical equipment.
The magnitude of the overvoltage is usually given in p.u.
(per unit). It is defined as
1 p.u. = 2 x Um / 3 ,
the Um means the maximum r.m.s voltage value between the
phases in an undisturbed network operation [1].
Three types of overvoltages are essentially distinguished [2]:
Temporary overvoltages occur for instance during load rejection
or because of earth connection faults. The duration of such
operating frequency oscillating overvoltage lies between 0.1
seconds and several hours. In general the surge does not exeed 3
p.u. and therefore it is of no danger to the network operation,
however it is decisive for the dimensioning of the arrester.
Switching overvoltages occur during switching actions and
consist mostly of heavily damped oscillations with frequencies up
to several kHz and a magnitude up to 3 p.u.
A special case is switching in inductive electrical circuits. Here
the front time of the overvoltage lies between 0.1 and 10 s and
the peak value can reach 4 p.u.. Fast-front overvoltages are also
possible when lines or cables are switched on.The peak value lies
then below 2.2 p.u. and does not endanger the network system.
Lightning overvoltages originate in atmospheric discharges.
They reach their peak value within a few s and subsequenly decay
very rapidly. The magnitude of these unipolar overvoltages in a
medium voltage network can reach well over 10 p.u.
Lightning overvoltages are the greatest threat to the medium
voltage networks. Overvoltage protection must be arranged in
such a way as to confine the overvoltage to non-damaging values.
3 24
2 Surge Arrester Technology
The so-called "conventional" surge arresters were exclusively
employed in MV networks (MV = medium voltage) until about the
middle of the eight decade of our century. They consisted of a
series connection of SiC resistors and plate spark-gaps. During the
overvoltage rising there emerges a short circuit to the earth when
the spark-gaps come into action. The series connection of SiC
resistors limits the follow current from the power supply and
allows in this way the disappeareance of the arcs between the plate
spark-gaps the next time the voltage reaches the zero crossing.
In the last years there were two fundamental improvements of
surge arresters used in MV networks. On one hand the series
connection of SiC resistors and the plate spark-gaps were replaced
with the metalloxid resistors (MO-resistors) without plate spark-
gaps, on the other hand the housings of the surge arresters made
of porcelain were replaced with new ones made of polymer
material (synthetic material).
2.1 MO-Arresters and Spark-Gap Arresters
The arresters protect the electrical equipment no matter whether
some other types of arresters are present. Therefore it is possible
to have at work in the same installation both the conventional
spark-gap arresters and the modern MO-arresters. It is not even
necessary that an electrical equipment should be protected in all
its three phases by the same type of arrester. The user can
therefore simply replace a spark-gap arrester as soon as it is out of
work with a MO-arrester. That allows the user to introduce cost-
saving the MO-arresters that have an elevated operating safety.
A fundamental advantage of the MO-arresters is the fact that
because of their extremely non-linear characteristic of the MO-
resistors they do not need any spark-gaps. The current starts to
flow already through the arrester before the overvoltage achieves
the value Up. The MO-arresters reduce therefore the overvoltage
sooner as the spark-gap arresters. The last ones are able to
conduct after the overvoltage was increased to Up. That is why
their protection distance is shorter in many cases. This means that
the overvoltage to the electrical equipment is higher when a spark-
gap arrester instead of a MO-arrester is installed as both types of
arresters are at the same distance from equipment to be protected.
The response voltage of the spark-gaps increases when the rise
time becomes steeper (< 1s). This causes a deterioration of the
protection possiblity of the spark-gap arresters in case of an
overvoltage wave with steep front .
If the outside insulation of the arrester is very dirty the potential
distribution along the humid surface is very uneven. It is possible
that between the sheds partial arcings appear which can induce
overvoltages in the active part. This situation is especially critical
with a spark-gap arrester, because it can bring it regularly to spark
over and at the end destroy it. This is the reason why MO-arresters
without spark-gaps have a fundamentally higher pollution resi-
stence.
If more spark-gap arresters are parallel connected usually only
one arrester switches on during an overvoltage. This reduces then
the overvoltage to a value that lies under the sparking voltage of
the other parallel arresters. Therefore it is not possible to distribute
the energy of the overvoltage on more spark-gap arresters which
are parallel connected. In case that this energy is too high the
arrester that switched on will be overloaded. This applies
especially to the spark-gap arresters which are parallel connected
to capacitor batteries with a higher reactive power.
Bibliography
[1] IEC Publication 99-5, First edition 1996-02 : Surge arresters Part 5 : Selection and
application recommendations.
[2] R. Rudolph und A. Mayer: berspannungsschutz von Mittelspannungskabeln. Bull.
SEV/VSE 76 (1985) 4, S. 204-208.
[3] R. Rudolph: Bemessung, Prfung und Einsatz von Metalloxid-Ableitern. Bull.
SEV/VSE 75 (1984) 23, S. 1407-1412.
[4] A. Mayer und R. Rudolph: Funkenstreckenlose berspannungsableiter ermglichen
optimalen berspannungsschutz. Brown Boveri Technik 72(1985) 12, S. 576-585.
[5] W. Schmidt: Metalloxid, ein fast idealer berspannungsableiter. Bull.
SEV/VSE 7 / 1998, S. 13-20.
[6] IEC Publication 60099-4, Edition 1.1, 1998-08: Surge arresters Part 4: Metal-oxide
surge arresters without gaps for a.c. systems.
[7] ANSI/IEEE Publication C62.11 1993: IEEE Standard for Metal-Oxide Surge Arresters
for Alternating Current Power Circuits.
[8] R. Rudolph: ZnO-Ableiter. Eine Alternative zu konventionellen Ableitern. Elektrotechnik
und Maschinenbau 5 (1983), S. 195-200.
[9] IEC Publication 71-1 (1993-12): Insulation coordination - Part 1: Definitions, principles
and rules.
[10] IEC Publication 71-2 (1996-12): Insulation coordination Part 2: Application guide.
[11] G. Balzer und K.H. Weck: Isolationskoordination von gasisolierten Schaltanlagen.
ETG - Fachbericht 32 (1990), S. 71-89.
[12] VDEW Strungs- und Schadensstatistik 1990. Verlags- und Wirtschaftsgesellschaft
der Elektrizittswerke m.b.H.
[13] A.J. Eriksson et al.: Guide to procedures for estimating the lightning performance of
transmission lines. Report of WG 01 of CIGRE Study Committee 33, Oct. 1991.
[14] K. Berger: Methoden und Resultate der Blitzforschung auf dem Monte San Salvatore bei
Lugano in den Jahren 1963 bis 1971. Bull. SEV/VSE 63 (1972) 24, S. 1403-1422.
[15] Surge arrester application guide. IEC 37 (Sec) 85, Jan 1992.
[16] R.B. Anderson and A.J. Eriksson: Lightning parameters for engineering application.
Electra, 69 (1980), S. 65-102.
[17] A.J. Eriksson et al.: A study of lightning stresses on metal oxide surge arresters.
Cigre paper 33-08 (1986).
[18] M. Christoffel: Der Einfluss von Kabelstrecken auf die berspannungsvorgnge in
bertragungssystemen mittlerer und hoher Spannungen. Brown Boveri Mitt. 51 (1964)
6, S. 369-376.
[19] A. Braun: Schirmspannungen und Schirmverluste bei Mittelspannungs-VPE-Kabeln.
Elektrizittswirtschaft 88 (1989) 26, S. 1898-1906.
[20] M. Darveniza und D.R. Mercer: Lightning protection of pole mounted transformers.
IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery, Vol. 4, No. 2, April 1989, S. 1087-1093.
[21] G. Balzer: Schaltvorgnge in Mittelspannungsnetzen und deren Bercksichtigung bei
der Planung. Brown Boveri Technik, 73 (1983) 5, S. 270-278.
[22] Non-linear metal-oxide resistor polymeric housed surge arresters without sparkgaps.
IEC 37 / 154 / CD; March 1996
[23] W.Schmidt: Die neuen POLIM -berspannungsableiter mit Silikonisolation fr
Mittelspannungsnetze. ABB Revue 2/96
Index of symbols used Contents

a in m conductor length

BIL in kV Basic Impulse Insulation Level (peak value)

1 Introduction 8.3 Networks with solidly earthed neutral systems (Ce < 1.4)
b in m conductor length
2 Surge arrrester technology 8.4 Networks with low-ohmic neutral transformer earthing
C in F capacitance (given in nF or uF) which do not uniformly have Ce < 1.4
2.1 MO-arresters and spark-gap arresters
Ce earth fault factor, Ce x Um / 3 is the maximum voltage 8.5 Low-ohmic neutral earthing networks and Ce > 1.4
between phase and earth in the case of an earth fault 3 Metal oxide resistors as arrester elements
8.6 Arresters between phases (Neptune design)
d in m section length of an overhead line before the substation 4 Medium voltage arresters from ABB
8.7 Operating voltage with harmonic oscillation
E in J energy absorbed by the arrester (mainly given in kJ or kJ / kVUc ) 4.1 Construction of the arrester
9 Protective distance of the surge arrester
Ec in J discharge energy absorbed by the arrester (mainly given in kJ)
4.2 Insulation made of silicone rubber
9.1 Theoretical projection for the protective distance L
I in A
4.3 Energy absorption capability and cool-down time
long duration current impulse 9.2 Expected steepness S from lightning overvoltages in
4.4 Nominal discharge current and energy MV-substations
In in A nominal discharge current (mainly given in kA, peak value)
absorption capability
9.3 Influences on the protective distance through electrical
IK in A 50 Hz fault current (mainly given in kA, rms- value) equipment, the types of the arresters and the arrangement
5 Special operating conditions
of the arresters
Iref in A reference current (mainly given in mA, peak value) 5.1 Network short circuit power
9.4 Fault hazards in electrical equipment and their distance
i in A peak current of the stroke current (mainly given in kA, peak value) 5.2 Elevated ambient temperature from the surge arrester
i(t) in A time function of the stroke current 5.3 Mechanical stability 10 Some special cases
K corona damping constant 5.4 Air pollution
10.1 Overvoltage protection in cable sections
L in H inductance of a line trap 5.5 Altitude adjustment for arrester housing
10.2 Cable sheath protection
L in m protective distance
6 Protection characteristics of the surge arrester, 10.3 Transformers at the end of cables
LK in m
stability
cable length
10.4 Transformer connected to a lightning endangered line on
6.1 Surge arrester protection level one side only
MCOV in V Maximum Continuous Operating Voltage = Uc (mainly given in kV, rms- value)
6.2 Questions of stability of MO-surge arresters 10.5 Arresters in metal enclosed MV-substation
P in W power losses of the arrester in the case of Uc
6.3 Temporary overvoltages 10.6 Generator connected to a lightning endangered MV-line
p.u. per unit, 1 p.u. = 2 x Um /3
7 Tests 10.7 Arrester protection for motors
Q in W heat flow from the active arrester parts to the external environment (cooling)
7.1 Type tests 10.8 Overvoltage protection in locomotives
S in V /s maximum steepness of a voltage increase (mainly given in kV / s)
7.2 Routine tests 10.9 Arresters parallel to a capacitor battery
S(t) in V / s time function of the steepness of a voltage increase (mainly given in kV / s)
7.3 Acceptance tests 10.10 Line traps (parallel protection)
So in V / s steepness of the lightning overvoltage at the point of the stroke (mainly given in kV / s)
7.4 Special tests 11 Arresters for d.c.voltage
SK in Var three-phase reactive power of a capacitor bank
8 Selection of surge arresters and determination 12 Consulting concerning questions on the use of arresters
T withstand strength against temporary overvoltages UTOV = T x Uc of Uc
Networks with earth fault compensation or 13 Conclusions
T in C temperature 8.1
with a high-ohmic insulated neutral system
Index of symbols used
t in s time
8.2 Networks with high-ohmic insulated neutral
system and automatic earth fault clearing Bibliography

25 2
 Foreword
ts in s time interval

U in V peak value of the overvoltage of a travelling wave (mainly given in kV)

Uc in V maximum continuous operating voltage of the arrester (mainly given in kV, rms)

UE in V maximum overvoltage at the end of an open line (mainly given in kV, peak value)

UK in V maximum overvoltage at cable end (mainly given in kV, peak value)

Um in V maximum voltage between phases (mainly given in kV, rms)

Up in V protection level of the arrester at In (mainly given in kV, peak value)

Ur in V rated voltage (mainly given in kV, rms)

Uref in V reference voltage (mainly given in kV, rms)

UT in V overvoltage at the transformer (mainly given in kV, peak value)

The first edition of our directions for dimensioning,
testing and application of metal oxide surge arresters UTOV in V power frequency overvoltage of a limited duration (mainly given in kV, rms)
in medium voltage networks, which appeared in 1994,
was received very positively. We were pleased to get u(t) in V time function of a lightning overvoltage
such a reception, which attested our belief that com-
petent consulting with regard to the application of our v in m/s speed of the travelling wave, v = 300 m / s in the air
products is as important as the quality of the products
Z in surge impedance of a distribution line conductor Z = 300........450
itself.
ZK in surge impendance of a cable conductor ZK = 20 ...... 60
The technological progress made it now necessary to revise and renew the present booklet for the third
edition. L load rejection factor of a generator
The dimensioning and the theoretical basis for the optimal application of the surge arresters are not changed
and therefore they were taken as such in the new edition. Mr. Ren Rudolph, who was at the time of the first
1 1
angular frequency of the power frequency, at 50 Hz is = 314
edition responsible for the consulting concerning application in the surge arrester division, took on the task S S
of revising the tables. That was necessary because of the improvement of the technical data of the surge
arresters and the enlargement of our product range. We would like to thank Mr. Ren Rudolph for his efforts.
Mr. Bernhard Richter, who is now responsible for engineering and application of the overvoltage protective
devices in the surge arrester division of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, took on gladly the task of the
general revision of this booklet.
Mr. Richter is a member in different working groups of IEC SC 37 A and IEC TC 81, and his activity field
includes, besides the development and testing, mainly the application of the surge arresters.

The silicon technology, which is used in medium voltage by ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd, and the
further developing of the metal oxide material opens new application spheres. All these are taken into
account in the new edition.

We hope, that you as a reader will be satisfied with our new revised edition and you will find it useful for your
purpose. We welcome amendments and suggestions in order to meet all possible customer needs.

ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd

Wettingen, July 1999
First published: November 1994
2.revised edition: September 1995
3.revised edition: July 1999

All rights reserved.

Neither the booklet or parts of it may be either copied or reproduced,
transmitted in any way or translated info other languages without
the prior permission of ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd.

ABB High Voltage Technologogies Ltd

Division Surge Arresters, Wettingen, Switzerland

1 26
 O V E RV O LTA G E P R O T E C T I O N
Dimensioning,

E S
GUIDELINE
testing and application
of metal oxide

E L I N
surge arresters
in medium voltage
networks

PPLICATION I D
G U
I O N
L I C A T
Please visit us on the Internet: http://www.abb.ch/hos CHHOS / AR 3257.99E (D)

ABB High Voltage Technologies Ltd.

Division Surge Arresters
Presented by: EN ISO 9001
Jurastrasse 45
CH-5430 Wettingen 1
Switzerland
P

Telephone ++41 56 / 205 29 11

Telefax ++41 56 / 205 55 70
Internet salessa @ chhos.mail.abb.com

Printed in Switzerland (99-09-1000 D/E)

P