Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Circle Diagram Approach For SEIG PDF
Circle Diagram Approach For SEIG PDF
May 1993
NOTICE
NOTICE: This report was prepared as an account of work sponsored by an agency of the United States government. Neither the United States government
nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, express or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy,
completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights.
Reference herein to any specific commercial product, process, or service by trade name, trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise does not necessarily
constitute or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United States government or any agency thereof. The views and opinions of authors
expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States government or any agency thereof.
Codes are used for pricing all publications. The code is determined by the number of pages in the publication. Information pertaining to the pricing codes
can be found in the current issue of the following publications which are generally available in most libraries: Energy Research Abstracts (ERA); Government
Reports Announcements and Index (GRA and I); Scientific and Technical Abstract Reports (STAR); and publication NTJS-PR-360 available from NTIS at the
above address.
.....
t Printed on recycled paper
CIRCLE DIAGRAM APPROACH FOR
SELF EXCITED INDUCTION GENERATORS
1
Rs J Xls (6)
where
Is
a2 = Rx w4 C2 Llrl2
Rr'/S
a1 = Rr1 + Rr1 R; w2 C2 + Rr1 Lis w4 C2
- 2 R L 16 w 2 c
Using the slip found from equation 6 and the data given, the
corresponding magnetizing inductance can be found. Thus, the
operating flux corresponding to this flux level can be found
from the non linear characteristics Lm' versus the flux given in
appendix 2. From the given information on frequency and the
ot o vorlobteo f'rE'queoncy air-gap flux, the air-gap voltage Vg can be found. After solving
for Lm' and Vg from the slip computed above, the rest of the
operating conditions can be solved. The equation to solve for
[ l-l
Fig. 2: Per phase equivalent circuit of series compensation Lm' can be derived from equation 5:
R 1 _)2 Rr I
absorbed by the stator and load branch. Similarly, the equilib ()2+ (Lls __ ( --)2+L lr1 2
w w2C Sw
rium of the reactive power is maintained by balancing the
reactive power absorbed by the rotor branch, magnetizing
branch, and the stator branch and the reactive power produced Another way to solve for the operating point of the system is
by the capacitor C. Equation l can be separated into two by solving the frequency for a given slip and the parameter of
equations governing each reactive power and real power. the induction machine. The equation to solve for the frequency
is
Real part of (Y. + Ym' + Yr') = 0 (2) (8)
and
where
1
Imaginary part of (Y. + Ym' + Yr') = 0 (3) A2 = Rr1 S Lis C2 + Rx C2 L1r 2 52
c
=
2 2 I s 2
Al Rx R r I + Rr R; c
The above equations can be written in final version as follows: - 2 Rr1 S L18 C
Ao = Rr S I
L li I 2
The basic principle of the above equations can be translated
1 (5)
+ -,...,..=
..., -=0
--
into an admittance diagram. The admittance diagram method
Lm l Rl
( -I-)2+L lr12 can be used to illustrate the behavior of the induction generator
SW
at different operating points. From the equivalent circuit (series
compensated) in Fig. 2, the admittance diagram can be simpli
fied into the following equations. The stator and the load
admittance can be determined as follows:
From the two equations presented above. it is obvious that for
any fixed load (RL and C) and fixed frequency, the two (9)
variables governing the equilibrium will be the slip and th.!
saturation level at the magnetizing branch. The saturation level
affects the operating point of the system. The size of magnetiz
ing inductance varies at different flux levels of the induction
machine. where
Xl
The operating point of the system can be found by solving the Rs+RL
Rl = __
two equations above. For a given set of parameters (R, L and w
C) and frequency, the slip can be computed by solving equation 1
= ( Lls-- - )
2
we
4 above.
2
The impedance can be expressed in terms of its admittance as the operating point travels along the perimeter of the circle.
The admittance of the rotor branch is represented by a phasor
(IO) from the origin to the point on the perimeter of the circle.
R' (12)
Z 1 =-r- +J'L 1
r lr
SUJ
(II)
(13)
Ys IMog< Ys)
___. C 1ncroses
Rpol<Y totl
Reol<Y s)
RE'oiCYM>
11oet;us 11<2 Ltr'l
The size of the magnetizing branch inductance varies with the . -xl
ys = + ] ---
(14)
saturation level. At high saturation, the size of the inductance R:+x:
becomes very low (at high flux density). The corresponding
admittance diagram for different level of saturation is illustrated 1
where X1 = Lls -
in Fig. 3. The core loss is assumed to be negligible in this UJ2C
analysis. The effect of the core loss on the admittance of the
(IS)
magnetizing branch will offset the admittance by introducing the Y'
m
real part of the admittance. An increase of core loss will move
the end of the admittance to the right.
The rotor branch can be represented as an equation of a circle
Yr ' (16)
with the radius proportional to I/2; where ; is the leakage
inductance of the rotor circuit. As the slip or frequency varies,
3
C. Effect of Varying the Capacitor
The effect of varying the capacitor will appear as an operating Equation 18 is an equation of a circle that has a center at 0, t
point moving along the semicircle describing the stator-load 11(2X1) and a radius of l /(2X1). Thus, as can be seen from the
admittance. As the size of the capacitor increases, the imagi admittance diagram, at constant frequency and a constant
nary part of the stator-load admittance increases until the maxi capacitor value the radius of the semicircle is constant. The
mum condition is achieved when the imaginary part of the higher the size of the capacitor, the larger the radius becomes.
stator-load is equal to the size of the radius of the stator-load The operating point of the system travels along the perimeter of
semicircle (i.e. equals to 1/(R, + RJ ). the semicircle as the size of the load is varied (refer to Fig. 5).
The increment of the size of susceptance is counteracted by As can be seen from the diagram, these operating points affect
the increment of the size of the magnetizing branch admittance, the slip and level of the air-gap flux.
which corresponds to the level of air-gap flux saturation. The
E. Steady State Calculation
level of saturation translates to the size of the air-gap voltage,
which in turn will affect the torque size and output power. From the equations derived above, the steady-state calculation
is performed to compute the characteristics of the induction
D. Effect of Varying the Resistive Load
machine operated in the generating mode. The magnetizing
The admittance diagram of the stator and the load presented inductance saturation is given in appendix 1, and the parameter
in Figs. 3 and 4 are based on the assumption that the resistive of the induction machine is presented in the appendix 2. In the
load is constant. Thus, the size of the radius l/2R1 (R1 RL =
calculation, the value of the resistive load is kept constant for
+ R,) is constant. As the size of the capacitor is varied, the
two values of capacitor, and the value of the capacitor is kept
operating point travels along the perimeter of the semicircle. constant for two values of resistor. Fig. 6 shows the air-gap
On the other hand if the size of the capacitor is constant while voltage versus speed. It is clear that, in general, the capacitor
the size of the resistive load is varied the admittance diagram
for the stator and load can be modified.
Consider the stator-load impedance in equation 10. The Air-Gap Voltage- Speed
imaginary part of the stator impedance can be represented in 250 ------.
terms of its conductance G I and susceptance B I :
200
B1 (17)
X =---
1
G{+B{
0--------.--,---.--.---.---
1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200 2300 2400 2500
Speed (rpm)
where
Ys ll'"lag<Ys>
--+ C incr--E'OSE"S
mcrement related to a higher voltage. This is similar to Fig. Sa,
where as the size of the capacitor is increased at constant
Reol(s)
Rodle<S = 11<2 RIJ
resistive load, the size of the imaginary part of the admittance
increases, which correlates to the increase of the saturation
level. Similarly, if the size of the capacitor is kept constant
while decreasing the size of the resistive load RL, the air-gap
voltage increases. Fig. 5b shows, a decrease in resistance load
will increase the air-gap voltage. Fig. 7 shows the stator current
s
versus speed. This graph relates to Fig. 6, where the air-gap
RodiuS = J/( 2 XI>
voltage and the size of the load impedance affect the size of the
f RL decr-E"oses
ReolCYs)
sta or current. Fig. 8 shows the output power versus speed.
Th1s figure relates to the size of the stator current (Fig. 7) and
the size of the resistive load. The computed torque speed
characteristics shown in Fig. 9 can be approximated from Fig.
Fig. 5 : Admittance diagram for constant resistive load and constant 8, where the torque is approximately equal to output power
capacitor value at a single frequency divided by speed.
4
III. PARALLEL COMPENSATION
Stator Current- Speed
An equivalent circuit of a parallel compensated induction
25 ,-------
generator is shown below. The principle of excitation for the
parallel compensated system is the same as in the series
20 compensation, that is, the balance of real and reactive power
I must be maintained.
8.
E
15
1:: Rs j X:ls
,. ,,.
8 10
Rrts
0 RL __j___
1il J (
00 5
01 0 SII'IQIE' frf'qt.IE'I'ICy
Ys
'
0+-------.---.-----r--
I
1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200 2300 2400 2500
't lo
Speed (rpm) 1
----- Elw j L"'
RL/'* j .. c
Is
I
Pout- Speed Rl/"' -----
J c
8000
o1 o vnr,nbiP rrpqAPncy
6000
f 5000
.!. Fig. 10 : Equivalent circuit of parallel compensation
Qj 4000 a. at a single frequency
1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200 2300 2400 2500
Speed (rpm) The above equation can be expanded into the equation for
imaginary and real parts as shown in the following two equa
Fig. 8: Output power tor series compensated system tions.
(20)
Torque- Speed
0
[ZS"euF; .Sohms I
1
L '
,.,:_
... "'<:::::1 I
-5
1 lr =0 (21)
' ' -...___ Lm' ( Rl ) 2+ (Ll)2 R r -)2+L
(- ' 12
- 10
(J) Sw
lr
e
I
-20
{?.
.. -'................
!2eeuF; s.oohmsf-...
-25
-30 . ..
I
-35 --r----.- . - - --
-- _ _J
I
'
1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200 2300 2400 2500
The real and imaginary parts of the admittance are given
Speed (rpm)
above. Thus for a given parameter set of the induction machine
and the operating frequency, the slip can be solved from the
Fig. 9: Torque for series compensated system
real part of the admittance.
5
Theoretically, the lowest minimum resistance at any frequen
cy will be limited by the radius of the semicircle describing the
(22) rotor admittance (i.e. it depends on the size of 1/;).
Ys s
lnog<Y ) j C ;ncreosE's o1 conston1 Rl
where
Rl decreOSE"S
ot constoot C ____.
a =RL L1r'2 w2 + Rs L1r'2 w2 +Rs W4 Ri C2 L1r'2
2 Reoi(Ysl
a1 = Rr'R;w2RiCL2 Rr'W2RiCL1s+Rr' Lis W4 Ri C2
+ 2 Rr' RL Rs+Rr' Lis w2 + Rr' Ri + Rr' R;
a0 =RL Rr'2+Rs Rr'2 + Rs w2 Ri C2 Rr'2
Yn lrmg(Ynl RE'oi(Yn>
RE'OI()'r')
After solving the above equation for the slip, the magnetizing so turo t1on inc,- E'OSE'S
D '""'
To illustrate parallel compensation in circle diagram ap
proach, a simplification is to be made. For a parallel compen
sated system, the equivalent circuit can be simplified by
assuming that the stator resistance and stator leakage inductance j \_ . "" ,,..,
:1
crease the air-gap flux (i.e. the air-gap voltage and the output
voltage). This also means that more power will be dissipated
by the resistive load and, consequently, the torque will in
crease. 0 160 ..
z. I
Q)
l
140
_j
80
Consequently, this will correspond to a lower slip and lower
output power, which translates into a lower output torque. On
----,.-----,
----r -------r _____
60
the other hand, if the size of the resistive load is reduced the 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400 2600
w'
size of the real part of the admittance will be larger, hich Speed (rpm)
corresponds to the higher output power and higher torque.
Fig. 12: Air-gap voltage for parallel compensated system
6
level is not directly affected by the change of the size of the of the resistive load. The output power is equal to the voltage
resistive load. squared over the resistive load. Thus, the output power can be
In Fig. 13, the stator current I, is shown. The stator current predicted from the air-gap voltage. Fig. 15 shows the torque
flows in the stator winding. It is the sum of the current versus speed, which can be derived from the power-versus
entering the resistive load and the current entering the capaci speed characteristic. The torque is approximately proportional
tor. Since the current in the resistive load and the current in to the power divided by the speed; thus the trends for different
the capacitor are not in phase, the stator current I, is not the loads can be predicted from the power-speed characteristics.
algebraic sum of the resistive and capacitive current. Instead, For both series and parallel compensation, as the speed
they are a vectorial summation. Thus, for the two different increases the frequency also increases and slip remains small.
resistive loads at the same capacitor size, the difference between Thus, the stator current variation is also reasonably acceptable,
the two is not apparent. For the same load but two different allowing the induction generator to operate over a wide range
capacitors, (20 ohms at two different capacitor) stator currents of rotor speeds.
are separated apart because the air gap voltage for the larger
capacitor is higher, which will affect the resistive and capacitive
currents. In Fig. 1 4, the output power (electrical output) is
shown. The output power for a parallel load can be found Torque-Speed
directly from the air-gap voltage shown in Fig. 12 and the size 0
-10
Stator Current-Speed
40 e -15
Q)
35 " -20
UJ
30 {?. -25
Q)
a.
E 25 -30 .
...
1:
20 -35
"
u 15 -40
1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400 2600
0
1ij Speed (rpm)
10
Cii
5 Fig. 15: Torque for parallel compensated system
0
1200 1400 .' 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400 2600
Speed (rpm) IV. CONCLUSION
Using of circle diagram approach helps clarify the concept of
Fig. 13: Stator current for parallel compensated system
self excitation both for series and parallel compensation. From
the circle diagram, it is easy to see how the operating condition
of the induction generator changes as the parameters are
changed.
From the discussions presented above, both the series
Pout-Speed compensation and parallel compensation can be implemented for
8000
j288uF: 20ohms I.
. JI
isolated operation. With the correct choice of capacitor sizes,
operation over a wide range of speed can be realized. As can
7000
be seen from the graphs, in isolated operation, induction
. _,./ Jl
6000 . / generator has a wider speed range with a relatively low slip.
.- t)l
/., .-
/ "joouF;20ohms I
f
5000
.!. 4000
,... . . . .. .. . .. . . ACKNOWLEDGMENT
:;
0 _.- _,. The authors wish to thank Narayan Rau, Yih-huei Wan, and
. IF-::.-_;-288uF;
_.. .. .. . .
a..
40ohms
/
. .
.
3000 Erik Nelsen from NREL for valuable discussions and for
. .. '
. .-..-- ..-"'
2000 . . .. . .. . reviewing this manuscript.
1000
REFERENCES
__..
ol+-------,-----.-----r--,------r--
1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 2200 2400 2600
I] E. Muljadi, "Series Compensated PWM Inverter with Battery
Supply Applied to an Isolated Induction Generator," Ph. D. Thesis,
Speed (rpm) University of Wisconsin, Madison, 1987.
[2] E. Muljadi, T.A. Lipo and D.W. Novotny, "Power Factor
Enhancement of Induction Machine by Means of Solid-state
Fig. 14: Output power for parallel compensated system Excitation," IEEE Trans. on Power Electronics, Vol.. 4, No. 4,
October 1989, pp. 409-418.
[3] W.J. Hunt, "Steady State Performance of Electronically Self
7
Excited Induction Machine," M.Sc. Thesis, University of Wisconsin,
Madison, 1984.
[4] C.F. Wagner, "Self Excitation of Induction Motors with Series
Capacitors," AlEE Trans., 1941, Vol. 60, pp. 1241-1247
[5] D.W. Novotny, D.J. Gritter, and G.H. Studtmann, "Self
excitation in Inverter Driven Induction Machines," IEEE Trans. on
Power Apparatus and Systems, NO. 4, July/August 1977, pp. 1117-
1125.
[6] L. Quazene and G. McPherson, "Analysis of the Isolated
Induction Generator," IEEE Trans. on Power Apparatus and
Systems, Vol. PAS 102, No. 8, August 1983, pp. 2793-2798.
APPENDIX I
Magnetizing Inductance
45
40
35
30
I'
. 25 .
E
'...1
20
5+----.-----.----
0.5 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
V glw (volts/rad/sec)
APPENDIX 2