Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hematology 2012 Mannucci 168 73 PDF
Hematology 2012 Mannucci 168 73 PDF
1Scientific Direction, Istituto di Ricovero e Cura a Carattere Scientifico (IRCCS) Ca Granda Maggiore
Policlinico Hospital Foundation, Milan, Italy; and 2Angelo Bianchi Bonomi Hemophilia and Thrombosis
Center, IRCCS Ca Granda Maggiore Policlinico Hospital Foundation and Department of Clinical Sciences
and Community Health, University of Milan, Milan, Italy
Multiple and complex abnormalities of hemostasis are revealed by laboratory tests in such common diseases as
cirrhosis and end-stage renal insufficiency. Because these abnormalities are associated with a bleeding tendency, a
causal relationship is plausible. Accordingly, an array of transfusional and nontransfusional medications that improve
or correct these abnormalities is used to prevent or stop hemorrhage. However, recent data indicate that the use of
hemostatic drugs is scarcely justified mechanistically or clinically. In patients with uremia, the bleeding tendency
(mainly expressed by gastrointestinal bleeding and hematoma formation at kidney biopsy) is reduced dramatically by
the improvement of anemia obtained with the regular use of erythropoietin. In cirrhosis, the most severe and frequent
hemorrhagic symptom (acute bleeding from esophageal varices) is not explained by abnormalities in such coagulation
screening tests as the prothrombin and partial thromboplastin times, because formation of thrombin the final
coagulation enzyme is rebalanced by low naturally occurring anticoagulant factors in plasma that compensate for the
concomitant decrease of procoagulants. Rebalance also occurs for hyperfibrinolysis and platelet abnormalities. These
findings are consistent with clinical observations that transfusional and nontransfusional hemostatic medications are
of little value as adjuvants to control bleeding in advanced liver disease. Particularly in uremia, but also in cirrhosis,
thrombosis is becoming a cogent problem.
product rich in VWF) and desmopressin (a synthetic derivative of Table 2 shows the recommended regimens of administration of
the antidiuretic hormone that increases plasma VWF levels) shorten drugs that are indicated in the prevention and control of uremic
the bleeding time in uremia.7,8 A contributory role for the enhanced bleeding for their capacity to shorten the prolonged bleeding time
endogenous production of nitric oxide (a vasodilator and platelet (ie, the laboratory test that reflects the deranged primary hemostasis
function inhibitor) was postulated on the basis of the effect on the of uremic patients and the underlying defects causing hemorrhage).
bleeding time induced by conjugated estrogens,9 which quench the A current practical problem is that many laboratories have taken the
production of nitric oxide.13,14 However, the current thinking is that bleeding time off of their list of approved tests, so that the
anemia, a constant feature in advanced renal insufficiency, is a management of uremic bleeding with drugs can no longer be easily
critical determinant of defective platelet adhesion to the vessel wall monitored using this test. The successful control of bleeding by
and the resulting prolongation of the skin bleeding time. erythropoietin has perhaps thwarted the development and evaluation
in uremia of tests alternative to the bleeding time, with the exception
A pioneer observation was made in 1982 by Livio et al, who of PFA-100, the closure time of which has been found to be
demonstrated in uremic patients that the bleeding time is prolonged prolonged in patients with uremia, but the clinical value of this test
in proportion to the degree of anemia, and that this test is shortened remains to be established.21
or corrected when the hematocrit is increased to at least 30% by
RBC transfusion.15 The improvement of anemia improves platelet
adhesion because more RBCs in the circulation push more platelets Hemostasis defects in cirrhosis
and leucocytes from the axial center of flowing blood toward the The majority of patients with end-stage liver disease (approximately
periphery, thereby enhancing cell contacts with the vessel wall and 400 000 are on the waiting list for transplantation in the United
the formation of the primary hemostatic plug.16 Additional mecha- States) have complex and multifactorial alterations that involve all
nisms that contribute to the effect exerted by the improvement of of the components of hemostasis.1 With regard to primary hemosta-
anemia on defective primary hemostasis are the release from RBCs sis (Table 3), thrombocytopenia is a frequent finding, with platelet
of ADP, a powerful inducer of platelet aggregation,17 and the counts usually ranging between 30 and 100 109/L. Defective
scavenging effect exerted by hemoglobin on nitric oxide.18 The platelet aggregation explains why the skin bleeding time is often
aforementioned defects of primary hemostasis may be exacerbated more prolonged than would be predicted from the degree of
by multiple medications that are taken by uremic patients (Table 1). thrombocytopenia. At variance with uremia, there are no equivalent
data that anemia plays a role in causing the prolongation of the
bleeding time and the hemorrhagic tendency in liver disease. The
Therapeutic control of bleeding in uremia results of screening tests commonly used to explore the coagulation
The adoption of maintenance dialysis was the first step that phase of hemostasis (ie, prothrombin time and partial thromboplas-
improved the bleeding tendency in uremia, although not fully tin time) are consistently prolonged because multiple coagulation
satisfactorily. The management of spontaneous bleeding and its factors are low in plasma in proportion to the degree of compro-
prevention at the time of invasive procedures or surgery was further mised protein synthetic capacity of the liver. Plasma hyperfibrinoly-
improved in the 1980s by the demonstration that some drugs sis is reported in cirrhosis on the basis of the increase of tissue
shortened the prolonged bleeding time (ie, desmopressin with a plasminogen activator and decrease of the naturally occurring
short-lasting effect8 and conjugated estrogens with a more pro- inhibitors of plasmin. These multiple and complex alterations of
longed effect9). Because these medications cannot be administered
prophylactically for prolonged periods of time, the long-lasting
prevention of the bleeding tendency in uremia remained unsettled. Table 2. How I treat bleeding in patients with chronic renal disease
A step forward was the finding in 1987 that the regular use of untreated or unresponsive to erythropoietin
recombinant erythropoietin for the management of anemia caused a Acute bleeding
marked and sustained shortening of the bleeding time.19 This Desmopressin, 0.3 g/kg IV (added to 50 mL of saline over 30 min) or
positive effect could be obtained after the attainment of hematocrit subcutaneously (same dosage)
values of approximately 30%,20 thereby confirming the early Intranasal desmopressin at a dose of 3 g/kg is also effective
observations on this critical threshold made by Livio et al9 with The effect of desmopressin lasts only a few hours and tends to
RBC transfusions. In general, clinical experience is that the lose efficacy when repeatedly administered
improvement of anemia obtained through the regular administration Chronic bleeding
Conjugated estrogens (a cumulative dose of 3 mg/kg divided as single
of erythropoietin has minimized the frequency and severity of
IV doses of 0.6 mg/kg for 5 consecutive days)
bleeding symptoms in patients with end-stage renal insufficiency
laboratory methods have traditionally led the clinician to infer that Platelet concentrates are used in the attempt to increase the low
in cirrhosis, hemostasis is globally impaired and is the main cause of platelet count of cirrhosis patients, even though it is unclear which
the bleeding diathesis seen so frequently in these patients.1 count threshold triggers the need for concentrate transfusion. Most
clinicians set this threshold to at least 50 109/L and optimally at
This concept was first challenged by the demonstration that routine 100 109/L, but there are limited laboratory28 and clinical data34
hemostasis tests fail to reflect the bleeding tendency in cirrhosis, providing evidence that these are the critical values. Neither is it
with their poor capacity to predict the onset and severity of bleeding known which dose of platelet should be transfused; the most
from esophageal varices, after liver biopsy, and at the time of major commonly used regimen is one standard adult concentrate (corre-
operations such as transplantation. In addition, more recent findings sponding to approximately 300 33 109 platelets). According to
show unequivocally that the aforementioned laboratory alterations our clinical experience, this regimen barely increases the platelet
consistent with an impaired hemostasis are indeed accompanied by count and fails to ensure the normalization of such global hemosta-
opposing prothrombotic alterations (Table 3).22-24 With regard to sis tests as thrombin generation and thromboelastography, perhaps
primary hemostasis, thrombocytopenia and thrombocytopathy are because most transfused platelets are trapped in the spleen and liver.
paralleled by a marked increase of plasma VWF, the main platelet-
Preliminary results indicate that the thrombopoietin receptor agonist
vessel wall adhesive protein.25 In vitro experiments carried out
eltrombopag increases platelet counts in cirrhosis more markedly
under flow conditions that mimic those occurring in vivo demon-
than transfusion, but the study of this drug was interrupted due the
strated that due to high plasma VWF, platelet adhesion to the vessel
occurrence of thrombotic complications.35
wall is normal or even increased in cirrhosis notwithstanding the
presence of thrombocytopenia and platelet function abnormalities.25
Recombinant activated factor VII (rFVIIa), originally developed
Pertaining to blood coagulation, low procoagulant factors are
rebalanced by the concomitant decrease of naturally occurring and licensed for the treatment of bleeding in hemophilia A
anticoagulants in plasma.26 An additional important contribution to complicated by alloantibodies inhibiting factor VIII, was also used
coagulation rebalance is provided by the increase of factor VIII in off-label for its capacity to generate a strong thrombin burst at the
plasma.26 Similarly, laboratory changes consistent with hyperfibrin- site of bleeding in clinical conditions such as variceal bleeding and
olysis tend to be compensated for by antifibrinolytic abnormalities major surgical operations such as hepatectomy and liver transplanta-
(Table 3).27 That the concomitant alterations of both prohemostatic tion. The majority of studies carried out in these settings are
and antihemostatic components in cirrhosis ultimately result in a negative with regard to the effect of rFVIIa on clinically relevant
restored balance22-24 is unequivocally demonstrated by global tests outcomes (ie, arrest of bleeding, reduction of rebleeding, and
such as thrombin generation assays,26,28 which explore both the pro- mortality),36 with the exception of a modest reduction of transfusion
and anticoagulant components at the same time. However, these need and hematocrit loss in liver transplantation.37 Accordingly, the
global tests are not yet standardized, validated, or used widely use of rFVIIa is not recommended as an adjunctive hemostatic
enough in the clinical context, making it still premature to propose treatment for variceal bleeding, nor for bleeding prophylaxis in
them as routine alternatives to the clearly inadequate traditional patients undergoing liver biopsy, transplantation, or resection.38,39
tests (prothrombin and partial thromboplastin time).29-31 Concentrates of vitamin K dependent factors (also called prothrom-
bin complex concentrates) had been used in patients with advanced
liver disease when our current knowledge on the poor clinical
Therapeutic control of bleeding in cirrhosis
relationship between bleeding and coagulation factor deficiencies
Fresh-frozen plasma is often used to prevent bleeding during liver
biopsy or other potentially hemorrhagic invasive procedures in was not available.3 Indeed, these plasma-derived products shorten
patients presenting with a prolonged prothrombin and/or partial or fully correct the prolonged coagulation tests and factor deficien-
thromboplastin time. Plasma is also used when patients bleed cies,3 but their clinical effect on actual bleeding is not substantiated,
acutely from esophageal varices, despite no evidence of its efficacy and the risk of thrombosis is significant with them and rFVIIa.
from randomized clinical trials. The use of plasma is still a common
practice despite the guidelines of the American Association for the Among the antifibrinolytic drugs, a potential candidate is tranexamic
Study of Liver Disease32 and in vitro studies showing that plasma acid, which, given orally or IV, blocks the binding to fibrin of
shortens the prothrombin time but does not affect the amount of plasminogen and thus the activation of this fibrinolysis proenzyme
thrombin formed.33 Against the use of plasma stands not only to the enzyme plasmin. According to a Cochrane meta-analysis, this
current knowledge that the abnormalities of standard coagulation medication is not effective in the management of acute variceal
tests do not reflect the bleeding tendency in liver disease,29-31 but bleeding as an adjuvant along with endoscopic therapy and such
also that plasma may contribute through volume expansion to drugs as cimetidine and protein pump inhibitors.40 In patients
increase portal vein hypertension, aggravate decompensation, and undergoing orthotopic liver transplantation, tranexamic acid re-
increase the risk of bleeding and rebleeding from esophageal duces to a small degree blood loss and transfusion requirements,41,42
varices. but the overall clinical benefit is generally trivial because the