Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cerebral Palsy Causes Pathways and The - 2015 - American Journal of Obstetri PDF
Cerebral Palsy Causes Pathways and The - 2015 - American Journal of Obstetri PDF
From the Australian Collaborative Cerebral Palsy Research Group at the Robinson Research Institute, the University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia
(Dr MacLennan); and Department of Paediatric Neurology, Adelaide Womens and Childrens Hospital (Dr Thompson) and Neurogenetics Research
Program (Dr Gecz), School of Pediatrics and Reproductive Health, the University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia.
Received Jan. 28, 2015; revised May 11, 2015; accepted May 15, 2015.
These studies have been supported by grants from the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (1041920 and 1019928), Cerebral Palsy
Foundation, Tenix Foundation, Womens and Childrens Research Foundation, and Robinson Research Institute Foundation.
The authors report no conict of interest.
Corresponding author: Alastair H. MacLennan, MD, FRANZCOG. alastair.maclennan@adelaide.edu.au
0002-9378 Crown Copyright 2015 Published by Elsevier Inc. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-
nc-nd/4.0/). http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ajog.2015.05.034
Click Supplemental Materials under the article title in the online Table of Contents
cases with acute hypoxia have yet to heart rate patterns, low Apgar scores, ascertain if clinically severe hypoxia is
signicantly lower overall rates. Only and neonatal encephalopathy could all contributing to the poor condition of
a small percentage of cases are associ- be associated with either acute intra- the newborn. When metabolic acidosis is
ated solely with acute intrapartum partum timing or chronic long-standing proven to be present, this is evidence of
hypoxia.5-8 Despite this, many cases are timing of the pathologies (ie, beginning either acute hypoxia beginning in labor
mislabeled as due to birth asphyxia. before labor and during pregnancy). or chronic hypoxia (ie, long-standing
The same signs can be caused by not compromise in pregnancy beginning
Birth asphyxia only hypoxia and/or ischemia, but also before labor). Secondary asphyxia in la-
Birth asphyxia is an outdated term that by other factors such as infection, bor is not necessarily the initial cause of
may wrongly convey that a baby born placental and umbilical vessel throm- the brain injury but may be a subsequent
with signs of fetal and neonatal bosis, or an altered fetal inammatory result of the established neuropatholog-
compromise must have undergone an response.1 Very recent studies suggest ical process. International consensus
acute hypoxic event in late labor and/or that many cases of CP are associated criteria have been published and rened
birth. These clinical signs may also be with genetic alterations (mutations) that to help dene cases where neuropa-
present when there has been much may either directly cause CP or thology may have become established
longer-standing fetal compromise with contribute to susceptibility to CP.11,12 As only in labor and birth.1,2 These 9 cri-
possible secondary hypoxia near de- yet, they are not detectable antenatally or teria have helped recognize the few cases
livery.1 Similarly, the term hypoxic preventable. of severe de novo acute intrapartum
ischemic encephalopathy has been hypoxia (Table 1). These criteria, as a
replaced by the term neonatal enceph- International consensus criteria to group, have been well veried.15 The
alopathy as the large majority of identify severe acute intrapartum rst 4 essential criteria have a high
newborn infants showing signs of en- hypoxia but not individually perfect correlation
cephalopathy does not have objective There is now increasing evidence that (94-100%) in acutely asphyxiated neo-
proof of acute hypoxia or ischemia at babies given a birth asphyxia label due nates. The 5 nonspecic timing criteria
birth, but have other causes of perinatal to clinical signs such as low Apgar scores were individually less predictive, but
compromise such as infectious or ge- often do not have primary asphyxia.13,14 were to be assessed together, and
netic.9 Of note, only 13% of term babies Many such babies are in ill health due their consensus helps understand the
who exhibit neonatal encephalopathy to longer-standing problems. Acute or likely timing of the neuropathology. In
are later diagnosed with CP.10 chronic hypoxia can cause a metabolic 2014, a third consensus statement
At birth, nonspecic signs of fetal acidosis in the blood of the newborn and similarly examined neonatal encepha-
compromise such as meconium-stained this has to be objectively measured in lopathy, rather than CP, and largely
amniotic uid, nonreassuring fetal umbilical arterial blood gases at birth to supported the criteria that dene a
TABLE 1
International consensus criteria to determine a severe acute hypoxic event as a potential cause of cerebral palsy
Essential criteria to show presence of hypoxia at birth are:
1. A metabolic acidosis at birth (pH <7.00 and Base Excess <e12).
2. Early moderate to severe neonatal encephalopathy.
3. Cerebral palsy of spastic quadriplegic or dyskinetic type.
4. Exclusion of other identifiable causes of cerebral palsy, eg, coagulation or genetic disorders, infectious conditions, intrapartum pyrexia,
antepartum hemorrhage, prematurity, intrauterine growth restriction, tight nuchal cord, complications of multiple pregnancy.
Five nonspecific criteria collectively point toward acute or chronic causes of hypoxia.
If most are met they suggest timing of neuropathology near delivery. If most are not met they suggest longer-standing pathological process. These
criteria are:
5. Sentinel (signal) hypoxic event sufficient to cause sudden severe hypoxia in healthy fetus, eg, cord prolapse, antepartum hemorrhage, ruptured
uterus.
6. Sudden sustained fetal heart rate bradycardia from that event.
7. Apgar score <4 after 5 min.
8. Signs of multisystem failure in neonate.
9. Early (within 5 d) neuroimaging signs of edema and intracranial hemorrhage.
In 2003, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists/American Academy of Pediatrics Cerebral Palsy Expert Task Force2 updated 1999 criteria1 on basis of published evidence to that date.
Task force agreed with 1999 task force criteria and added fourth essential criterion was necessary, ie, that no major chronic cause of neuropathology should be present if intrapartum acute asphyxial
cause was to be presumed. Also acute de novo intrapartum event severe enough to be associated with cerebral palsy would cause Apgar scores to remain at 3 after 5 min of birth. Lastly, it only
accepted evidence of severe metabolic acidosis from arterial umbilical samples taken at birth, as blood gases can improve or worsen in first hour depending on successful or problematic neonatal
resuscitation.
MacLennan. Cerebral palsies: new insights and causes. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015.
term and preterm babies. Growth- inammatory response in the fetus and uterus, abnormal placental site), or
restricted babies with birth defects were the neonate.29,30 An excessive or abnor- pathological (eg, preeclampsia, diabetes,
at special risk of CP. The strong associa- mal rise in cytokines (due to genetic systemic lupus) causes. IUGR increases
tion with congenital abnormalities sug- predisposition or mutations) following in late pregnancy when growth velocity
gests possible genetic factors although infection and an inammatory response, should be at its greatest and fetal demand
congenital infections, nutritional disor- which is part of the bodys normal defense may outstrip placental and maternal
ders, and teratogenic inuences all mechanism against infection or toxins, supply. This usually creates an asym-
contribute to maldevelopment. may cause an autoimmune type of metrical growth restriction where the
attack on the fetal or neonatal developing baby is lighter than its length suggests.
Intrauterine infection nerve cells. The prematurely delivered This gives a low ponderal index (birth-
There are many probable antenatal babys immature brain is even more weight/length3 100) and can suggest
causes of white-matter damage and vulnerable to these proinammatory unsuspected late growth restriction.34
risk factors for CP (Table 2). Some of cytokines. In previous genetic associa- Use of the ponderal index and custom-
these causes include damage acquired tion studies, hereditary thrombophilia ized weight for gestation charts improve
following perinatal infection (ie, ma- (the methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase the recognition of growth restriction at
ternal infection that affects the fetus and cC677T mutation and the prothrombin birth and the risk of subsequent CP.35
its brain during pregnancy and/or labor gene c20210G>A variant) and some When IUGR is suspected during
or in the neonatal period).26 Viral or cytokine polymorphisms (interleukin-6, pregnancy there are no published ran-
bacterial infections may be relatively si- interleukin-8, tumor necrosis factor, and domized quality data to suggest that
lent during pregnancy and not recog- mannose binding lectin) were associated earlier delivery reduces the risk of CP.
nized clinically at the time and the with an increased risk of CP.31,32 It is not possible to detect or predict
placenta is often discarded without his- when in pregnancy the neuropathology
tological examination for inammatory Intrauterine growth restriction of CP begins, becomes established,
pathology. Maternal reports of fever or IUGR is associated with up to a 10- to and is irreversible. A growth-restricted
infection during pregnancy are signi- 30-fold increase in the risk of CP at fetus may show signs of possible fetal
cantly associated with an increased term.20,33 In particular, spastic CP in- compromise during labor. This can
risk of CP in our recent large Australian creases with the degree of fetal growth reect reduced capacity/reserves to
case-control study.27 Evidence of intra- restriction. Our large epidemiological withstand the normal stresses of labor,
uterine infection, evidenced by histo- study of Australian children and normal established neurological and ongoing
logical chorioamnionitis in the placenta controls clearly conrms IUGR as a fetal compromise, or both. It is not
and membranes or intrapartum pyrexia, major risk factor for CP.27 The risk of CP possible to distinguish between these
is associated with a 4-fold increase in increased from values <20th percentile timings.
CP (odds ratio 3.8; 95% condence in- and the risk escalated greatly in babies
terval, 1.5e10.1) in term infants.28 under the third percentile (Figure 2).
Multiple pregnancy
IUGR can be due to many known and Multiple pregnancy increases CP risk
Abnormal fetal inflammatory unknown causes, but usually reects 2-fold in each twin. In vitro fertiliza-
response and thrombophilia poor implantation and poor placenta- tion twins each have >4-fold risk
Another possible related cause and tion from genetic, anatomical (eg, uter- (9.5/1000), giving another reason to
mechanism of CP is an abnormal ine broids, congenitally abnormal encourage single embryo transfer in
fertility programs.36
Placental pathology
Chorioamnionitis, funisitis, and in pa-
rticular necrotizing funisitis all are evi- Customized birthweight centile and cerebral palsy (CP).27
dence of infection predating labor, and CI, confidence interval.
are associated in all epidemiological MacLennan. Cerebral palsies: new insights and causes. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015.
studies with an increased risk of
CP.28,29,38 Chronic villitis, large infarcts,
fetal thrombotic vasculopathy, and CP.42 Individually, these inborn errors 2%.46 With the advent of affordable
meconium-associated fetal vascular ne- of metabolism IEMS are all very rare new-generation DNA sequencing the
crosis are all risk factors for subsequent (1:10,000-1:250,000). Together, they focus of genetic investigations in CP
CP or neurological impairment.39 The may contribute to only 0.1-0.2% of cases shifted from gene association studies
increased prevalence of placental and of CP, but are important as many can be to the identication of the likely
cord abnormalities in children subse- treated or controlled. New-generation causal variants. Several of the currently
quently diagnosed with CP underlines sequencing is likely to facilitate new known single-gene causes of CP have
the importance of requesting placental IEMs that exhibit CP-like symptoms. been identied through study of fam-
histology and cord arterial gases in all ilies with 2 individuals with CP, such
cases where the baby is delivered in Genetic causes of CP as the KANK1, AP4MI, and GAD1 gene
poor condition.13 Genetic causes have long been suspected mutations.47-50 Until recently, though,
because of the link with congenital only a few singleton cases with CP
Viral infection in pregnancy malformations, and increased risk in had been resolved. Cases with auto-
Studies using polymerase chain reaction consanguineous families and mono- somal recessive, rare autosomal domi-
techniques on neonatal blood spots from zygotic twins.43 Although initially candi- nant, or X-linked forms have also been
CP cases and controls show increased CP date gene association studies suggested described.51
risk after both Cytomegalovirus and that several genes may be linked to One example of a success of an iden-
Epstein-Barr virus infections during CP, the power of these studies was low tication of a novel gene and muta-
pregnancy.40 Epidemiological studies and multiple comparisons weakened tion leading to CP is the ZC4H2 gene.
do not associate upper respiratory in- their validity.31,32 A multivariable analy- With the aid of whole exome sequencing
fections during pregnancy with CP, sis of 39 candidate genes from single- (WES) or X-chromosome exome se-
but some studies have associated in- nucleotide polymorphism association quencing across a large set of families
creased risk with bacterial urinary tract studies with CP was conducted with sta- with different clinical presentations,
infections.26,41 tistical allowance for type I error. This primarily intellectual disability, mu-
study did not statistically conrm previ- tations have been identied in the
Treatable and nontreatable inborn ous gene associations in CP causation.44 zinc-nger gene ZC4H2 in 5 different
errors of metabolism presenting A recent study showing an association families and at least 3 singletons. In-
as CP with the apolipoprotein E e3 allele spec- terestingly, the clinical presentations
A recent systematic review of the world ulated that those with the APOEe2 and of ZC4H2 gene mutations are broad
literature has described 67 treatable APOEe4 alleles were more likely to die in and variable within and between fam-
inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) utero.45 ilies, including CP spasticity pheno-
belonging to 13 different biochemical Previous estimates have suggested type and shared comorbidities, namely
categories and >20 currently untreat- that the contribution of genetic vari- intellectual disability and seizures.52
able IEMs with symptoms that mimic ants to the burden of CP was about Functional studies of these variants
Male sex
In most epidemiological studies, males
are more at risk of CP than females:
A, Outgrowth of spinal cord motoneurons and formation of neuromuscular junctions (arrows)
1.3:1.5,7,27 Recessive X-linked chromo-
are morphologically affected in ZC4H2 morphants, but not in controls. B, Superimposed images
some variants may contribute to this
of tail movement at 48 hours postfertilization. Compared to animals injected with control MOs,
difference and males may be more
ZC4H2-knockdown zebrafish (lower) show weak swimming contraction.
vulnerable to genetic mutation (point
MO, morpholino oligonucleotide.
or copy number) than females.60
Adapted from Hirata et al.52
MacLennan. Cerebral palsies: new insights and causes. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2015.
Interventions to prevent CP
Over the last 50 years, CP rates have
remained the same despite major ad-
vances in obstetrics and neonatology
including a 6-fold increase in cesarean Although prospective randomized con- delivery can always practically and
delivery rates and liberal induction pol- trol trials are not ethically possible, safely be achieved in <30 minutes or that
icies to reduce postmaturity (Figure 1). all observational studies show no pro- rapid delivery changes the neurological
Currently there are no proven obstetric tective effect of elective or emergency outcome.63
clinical policies that have been shown to cesarean delivery for CP outcome (as In very preterm infants maternal
reduce CP in term babies, other than opposed to neonatal encephalopathy, magnesium sulfate infusion in labor re-
head cooling in selected cases. In cases which is a different clinical diagnosis duces slightly the risk of CP. Numbers
with neonatal encephalopathy, early with often different causes).62 It has not needed to treat to prevent 1 case 63.64
neonatal head cooling reduces the risk of been shown that earlier rapid delivery
death or major neurological disability in of a fetus by cesarean delivery, when a CP classification by causation
1 of 6 of these selected cases treated.61 compromised fetus is rst suspected There is considerable debate in the in-
Policies that have been ineffectual in- during labor in an obstetric hospital, ternational literature whether to remove
clude elective cesarean delivery, earlier changes the risk of a CP outcome. the diagnosis of CP in nonprogressive
emergency delivery in pregnancy, and Audits of decision-to-delivery reaction cases that fulll the clinical denition,
electronic fetal heart rate monitoring. times often do not show that cesarean when a genetic cause is found.65 Recent
women at risk of preterm birth for neuro- developmental brain disorders database Australians. Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol
protection of the fetus. Cochrane Database Syst (DBDB): a curated neurogenetics knowl- 2011;51:479-84.
Rev 2009;1:CD004661. edge base with clinical and research ap- 68. Cerebral Palsy Alliance Research Institute.
65. The denition and classication of cerebral plications. Am J Med Genet A 2014;164A: Australian Cerebral Palsy Register. Report 2013.
palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol 2007;49:1-44. 1503-11. Available at: https://www.cpregister.com/pubs/
66. Mirzaa GM, Millen KJ, Barkovich AJ, 67. Maclennan AH. A no-fault cerebral pdf/ACPR-Report_Web_2013.pdf. Accessed
Dobyns WB, Paciorkowski AR. The palsy pension scheme would benet all June 24, 2015.