Professional Documents
Culture Documents
. O N
ON
Rawls ,
- Justice as Fairness (1958), Theory of Justice
(1971),
1999 1975.
, Political Liberalism (1993),
-
,
Law of Peoples (1999)
. Rawls -
,
, -
.1 , Kantian Constru-
ctivism,
, ,
Scheffler,2 -
. Rawls
,
Justice as Fairness: A Restatement (2001), -
, -
, ,
.
230
Rawls -
-
,
. -
-
. , -
, ,
.
O Rawls : -
, , ,
.3 , -
, .4
( )
.
-
,
. , Rawls, -
. -
. -
Rawls, -
Hart .
,
Political Liberalism.
.
Rawls
.
Rawls -
, -
,
.
231
1. OO O
O Rawls
, -
( ) 1960,
.5 -
, -
-
,
.6
-
,
Rawls -
.
, -
, , Locke, Rousseau Kant.7 O Rawls
Hobbes , , ,
.8 , -
(reasonable) (rational).9 -
232
, -
, -
,
-
.
, Rawls -
, , -
:
(standards of judgment)
.10
-
.11
Rawls,
,12
-
,13 -
-
Rawls,14
,15 Rawls
-
16 . -
-
-
(burdens of judgment) Law of Peoples, 87.
10. . Justice as Fairness, 57 Justice as Reciprocity, 206.
11. . Justice as Fairness, 53 Sense of Justice, 98.
12. . Nagel, Rawls on Justice, 8-9 Raz, Morality of Freedom, 126 Mulhall Swift,
Liberals and Communitarians, 124 Lyons, Rawls vs. Utilitarianism, 544. Haslett (Equal
Consideration, 209),
.
.
13. . Sen, Equality of What?, 476 . Wolff, Understanding Rawls, 97.
14. . .. Lyons, Ethics, 142 Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously, 151-152.
15. . Nagel, Rawls on Justice, 6 Wolff, Understanding Rawls, 3.
16. . Hall, Justice as Fairness, 57 Becker, Distributive Justice, 713 .
Wolff (Understanding Rawls, 191 Refutation of Rawls Theorem, 80 ..)
. Kolm Theories of Justice, 194.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 233
233
.17
O Rawls
,
(
). A
. -
, -
, -
. -
, , .18
, -
. -
-
,
. ,
Rawls -
. O Rawls -
,
.19
O Rawls -
,
, -
, , ,
-
.20 ,
,
:
, -
17. ,
, Di Quattro (Justice, 106).
18. . Political not Metaphysical, 411.
19. , 622.
20. , 176 . Reply to Alexander, 237 Restatement, 86.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 234
234
-
.21 O Rawls : [K]
, , -
.22 . -
,
.23 O
, -
.24
- - . de
novo, 25 -
,
. -
.26
,27 ,28
Rawls . -
,
.29 -
, -
.30 -
21. -
MacIntyre (After Virtue, 23) . Walzer, Liberalism, 324 Sandel, -
, 118. , Sandel -
.
22. , 38-39 . Restatement, 4.
23. , 39.
24. , 591.
25. Justice as Fairness, 58 . Sidgwick, Methods of Ethics, 473-474.
26. . Kymlicka, Liberalism, 51-52, Rawls Political
Liberalism, 27, . 29.
27. , 176.
28. Political not Metaphysical, 400, 404 Restatement, 17, 80, 83, 85. -
, . . Restatement, 86, . 5.
29. , 37, 42. To -
(Political not Metaphysical, 400). B. ,
, 111-115.
30. . Justice as Fairness, 59 Distributive Justice, 135 Justice as Reciprocity, 223
. 23 Reply to Alexander, 237.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 235
235
,31 o
,
,
.32 Rawls
, -
, , -
.
Rawls -
, -
. ,
-
. ,
. -
,33 ,
,
.34
O Rawls
( ),
-
, .
-
, -
, .35
( )
, -
, , .36
, , -
Rawls
,
236
37
.38 ,
-
,
,
-
. -
-
. -
,
.39 -
-
-
, -
.
O Rawls
,
( ) -
. -
, Rawls -
.
, -
.
-
, .
, Rawls,
.
237
.
. -
-
.40
,
. , -
. ,
-
.
. -
-
, -
.41
,
-
,
,
,
, -
. -
. -
, -
. , -
, -
, , .,
.
,
.42
238
Rawls -
, -
.
O Rawls , -
. -
, -
, -
. -
, , ,
, -
, ,
, -
. ,
Rawls , (
-
, ) (
), .43
O Rawls , -
. -
, ,
-
.44
,
-
.
, Rawls
, -
.45 O Rawls -
, -
.46
43. . , 118-119.
44. Reply to Alexander, 236 Kantian Conception of Equality, 264.
45. . , 121.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 239
239
-
.47
O Nozick Rawls
.
,
. , -
, -
,
, ,
.48 Nozick -
. -
, -
(end-state).49 H
-
.50
. -
.51 Nozick
Rawls .
O
, Rawls -
-
240
. -
-
, ,
,
. ,52
, -
,
.53 ,54
-
, .55
,
.56 O Rawls -
52. .. , 188: ,
.
53. .. Maximin Criterion, 227 Reply to Alexander, 238 Political not Metaphysi-
cal, 391 Preface for the French, 416. , -
, -
, (, 389)
[] , , -
(566).
54. , , 384 507 .
Sidgwick, Methods of Ethics, 91 Sumner, Welfare, 210, 213. O Rawls
,
Mill .
Mill , -
. Nietzsche, -
, -
Marx (. .. Arneson, Market Socialism, 293 -
). () Mill, . -
, Mill (21-43), -
.
55.
,
(, 490, 478).
Rawls
N (. vii.1-14 x.1-5). . . 20, . 490.
Goodin (Actual Preferences, 119)
.
56. O , Rawls, -
, -
( ), -
. . , 71. -
( ) -
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 241
241
,
.
-
,
ad hoc .
,57
, -
.
-
.
, -
,
(
). Rawls:
,
. [] ,
,
. -
-
. -
, ,
-
, -
, -
. , -
.
, ,
. , ,
.58
242
Rawls .59 -
,
.
. -
. ,
.
, -
Rawls. -
, -
60 . .61
-
-
. O Rawls
.62
, , -
.63 ,
.
Rawls
,
. O
Rawls -
64 -
,65 -
59. . , 41.
60. , 179.
61. ,
, ,
Kymlicka, Political Philosophy, 67.
62. . Kagan, Limits of Morality, 40, Rawls, Kantian Constructivism, 518.
63. Justice as Reciprocity, 220 , 56 Distributive Justice, 131.
64. O
(. , 46). O Rawls -
(77).
65. . -
, , , ,
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 243
243
.66
Rawls, , -
, -
, .67
-
,
.68 ,
-
-
. ,
.
, Rawls -
69
,
. , -
-
,
Rawls
, -
(, 46-47) . Fairness to Goodness, 270.
66. . Brandt, Theory of the Good, 235. . Rawls, Kantian Con-
structivism, 519.
67. . Independence of Moral Theory, 286-287, 289-290, 296, 301-302.
68. Independence of Moral Theory, 289-290.
69.
. . Independence of Moral Theory, 289 Kantian Construct-
ivism, 534 Restatement, 31. O Rawls . .
Daniels, Wide Reflective Equilibrium, 155-159. O Kukathas Pettit (Rawls
A Theory, 70) -
-
, . O
Daniels (.., 166, 169) , ,
, -
.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 244
244
. -
. -
. Rawls,
, -
, , .
,
-
.
Rawls
.70 -
Rawls -
-
. , -
,
. -
.71 -
-
. ,
, .72
H
.
E 73 , -
, Rawls -
.74
70. -
(, 122)
(Kantian Constructivism, 572) Distributive
Justice, 151 . Decision Procedure, 12.
71. . Independence of Moral Theory, 294 Restatement, 55-56 , 657, 662.
72. Barry (Liberal Theory) .
Hare, Rawls Theory of Justice, Part I ,
1973, Understanding Rawls Wolff.
.
73. . .. Melden, Rights and Persons, 27.
74.
-
.
-
(, 222).
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 245
245
. Sidgwick,75
Rawls, ,
, .76
-
-
. , , agan (1989)
,
,
-
,
Rawls. O
-
,
-
.
O Rawls -
-
, :77 -
,
.78 -
,
.79 ,
75. . Sidgwick, Methods of Ethics, 97-98, 201. O Taylor (Sources of the Self, 23), -
Sidgwick ,
.
76. . Rawls (, 82, . 28) Sidgwick (Methods of Ethics, 373).
77. . , 157. -
(200), markedly distinct (TJ, 161). , -
. Reply to Alexander, 239, , -
,
( ) []
(
) .
. Kavka,
Average and Total Utility, 331 Scheffler, Rawls and Utilitarianism, 443, 455, . 11.
78. , 314.
79. , 162.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 246
246
, Rawls -
. , :
,
-
,
,80 -
, , .81
( )
, Rawls
,
. -
, ,
-
, -
,82 -
Pareto .83
Rawls. -
Barry,
, . ,
.84 Barry
80. , 39.
81., 41, 56. , -
(, 56-57, )
. Justice as Reciprocity, 203.
82. . .. , 99-101:
, ,
,
, -
. , ,
, -
(, 138).
(, 139) . Some Addenda, 155.
83. o Rawls
,
prima facie . . Scanlon, What We Owe, 228.
84. Barry, Liberal Theory, 119. O Brandt (Theory of the Good, 322) -
Rawls,
. . . 236.
Sen (Personal Utilities, 546),
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 247
247
-
Rawls
. , Rawls -
maximin -
,85 -
maximin -
, -
.86 maximin -
, Rawls, -
.
,
,
,
.87
Rawls ,
.
2.
O Rawls , -
, -
, -
Arrow, -
( Arrow), -
. maximin -
, -
. , Arrow, -
, -
.
85. maximin (Altham, Rawlss Difference
Principle, 99). O A. Brown (Political Philosophy, 60),
Rawls, . H
maximum minimorum, .
, 192, . 21 Restatement, 97.
86. , 115 . Maximin Criterion, 225 Restatement, 43, . 3. -
maximin,
.
87. , 118 . 663.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 248
248
. -
. ,
.
[] 88
status quo.89
, ,
, , -
.90 -
,91
,
,92
-
.
,
, ,
. O Rawls, ,
. ,
. , -
.93
, ,
-
, ,
. Rawls
,
249
, , -
. O
, . -
. O -
, .94
O Rawls -
. -
.95
-
. -
-
,
.96 -
, .
, -
.97
-
, .98
O
-
, ,
94. . , 198, 81, 166, 244, 657 Independence of Moral Theory, 292 Basic
Liberties, 143. . Copp, Justice and the Difference Principle, 108-109,
Rawls .
95. . Political not Metaphysical, 399, 407, 402, 413 Restatement, 10, 42, 95.
96. . , 29, 162 Justice as Fairness, 53 Justice as Reciprocity, 199.
97. . , 612 Kantian Constructivism, 536 Reply to Alexander, 234. O -
-
Rawls .
98. . , O Sandel , 25-43.
. B-
, M , 20-25, 66-67.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 250
250
.
-
, -
(, , ),
, -
, .
,
, -
,
,
, ,
, .99
-
-
.100
, -
. , -
. -
, .
-
,
.101 -
-
-
,
, . L. A.
Hart Concept of Law.102
251
O
( -
-
). , ,
,103 Rawls .104
,
: ,105
,106
107 ..
108
-
. O
-
. -
109 ,
-
. O -
, (, .),
103. Brandt, Theory of the Good, 237. Arrow (Ordinalist Utilitarian Notes, 248)
.
104. , 173-177 Restatement, 15 Kantian Constructivism, 522-523.
105. O Rawls ,
, . . Haslett, Equal Consideration, 206. O Levine (Rawls Kanti-
anism, 348) .
106. . .. Melden, Rights and Persons, 84.
107. . .. Brandt, Theory of the Good, 243.
108. O
-
(, 44 , 512, 662, 665 Restatement, 15, 17 Maximin Criterion, 226).
109. threat advantage (TJ, 134/TJrev., 116), -
, , 171 . 11 . Restatement, 16 . 16
Kantian Constructivism, 549 Justice as Fairness, 58, . 11 Justice as Reciprocity, 207,
. 13 Political not Metaphysical, 400. . Harman Justice and
Moral Bargaining, 123-124.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 252
252
( -
, ),
, .
, -
. ,
, ,
( ). -
,
,
.
( -
)
o. -
Rawls :
(
, ) -
:
.110
O .
, , -
. -
, , -
. ,
Rawls, -
,
,
.
,
-
:
, -
, .111
- -
253
Rawls. -
,
,
.112 O Rawls ( )
, -
, -
.113 -
,
-
.114 /
-
,
,
.115
,
,
, ,
, . -
.
, . -
.116 ,
, . O Rawls
,
, .
Goodness, 283 Kantian Constructivism, 521, 525, 543 Political not Metaphysical, 397-398,
408 Preface for the French Edition, 417 Basic Liberties, 118, 129, 121, 129, 152 Restatement,
19, 113.
112. . , 190. .
highest-order interest (TJrev. 131) . , 616 Kant-
ian Constructivism, 522, 525, 544.
113. . Social Unity, 365, 381 Independence of Moral Theory, 299. Maximin
Criterion, 228, [ ],
,
, , 616, .
114. . Fairness to Goodness, 269.
115. . , 616, 617.
116. , 183.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 254
254
, -
. Rawls ,
-
.117 O Rawls ,
(
),
, -
,
.118 , -
,
.119
, -
.120
,
.
, -
,
. -
. -
. O
, -
, . O
, .
, -
, -
255
. O
. ,
.121 -
, ,
, , -
, -
.122
,
, -
.123
O Rawls , -
,124 -
, 125
.126 , o
, -
,
, .
-
, -
. O Rawls -
127 (
, -
, ),
-
.128
256
-
,129 Rawls
-
.
-
, . -
,130 -
, , , ,
-
.
.131 -
Rawls ,
Hobbes. Hobbes -
,
.132 -
,
, .133
Hume, , ,
-
. , ,
, Hume, -
.134
O Hume
,
257
, -
-
. , ,
-
, Hobbes, Hume Rawls.
O, Rawls -
135 Sidgwick, -
,136
, -
.
,
. -
, -
.137 E -
.138
Rawls. -
, ,
.139
-
-
,140
.
258
O Rawls
, :
. -
, ,141
,
. O -
.142
, , -
. O , -
, -
.
-
, ,
,
.143 ,
.144
-
Rejection, 22 Raz, Morality of Freedom, 297 Frankena, Ethics, 20 Oppenheim, Political Concepts,
131 Cottingham, Partiality, 366 Hausman McPherson, Economic Analysis, 29.
141.
-
, , -
, -
,
.
, ,
. . , 230-231. -
, -
-
. , , -
, -
, Rawls (232-3).
142. , 565, 173, 653.
143. , 154.
144. , 413 Justice as Fairness, 55 Justice as Reciprocity, 203. -
-
(. .. Overlapping Consensus, 425 Restatement, 46) -
-
, Rawls -
. . Restatement (4,
32), (84, 151).
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 259
259
,
-
,
.145
. .
. -
,146 -
(
)
. Rawls -
.147
-
, .148
( )
.
Rawls
, -
.
(
) -
,149 ,
260
.150 -
(
) .151 -
,
Rawls. -
. -
( ) -
o
. O Rawls
, -
.152 -
.153 Rawls -
, -
,154
.
,
.155
.
.156
261
,
, -
.
.157 O Rawls -
.
-
158
. ,
, Rawls -
-
,
.159 T -
-
,
.160 , ,
,
.161
O o : ()
, ()
, ()
, () , ()
. O -
, , -
157. , 126.
158. , -
: ,
,
( 64). O -
(,
515).
159. . Kantian Constructivism, 527 Social Unity, 374, 386 Preface for the French
Edition, 417.
160. Priority of Right, 257.
161. . Priority of Right, 276. -
(Restatement, 58). Basic Liberties,
124, ,
[]
.
2. molivas teliko* 30/11/2005 10:40 262
262
..162 ,
, .163
.164
,
. , -
-
, .
-
.
, -
. -
( -
) -
, -
. , ..
, ,165
,
.
, -
-
, -
. Teitelman, -
, -
(
), ,
.
,
263
,
,
,
.166
-
,
.
O
T Rawls
, -
,
, -
, ,
, -
,
. O -
,
- -
.167
-
.
, :
()
, ,
() ,
.
264
( )
O -
, , -
. :
()
()
.
( -
)
. :
()
()
.168
Hart,169 Rawls
-
.170
-
,
Rawls .
168. , 355-356.
169. . Preface for the French Edition, 416 Basic Liberties, 106, 108, . 6, 148,
188, 189.
Hart (Restatement, 42, . 2).
170. O Rawls The Basic Liberties and their Priority, -
1982 Tanner Lectures -
Political Liberalism ( 8). . Basic
Liberties, 107, Political not Metaphysical, 392.
, Rawls ,
-
(. Justice as Fairness, 48 Sense of Justice, 98 Distri-
butive Justice, 133 Justice as Reciprocity, 193.) -
Reply to Alexan-
der, 238 Kantian Conception of Equality, 258 Social Unity, 362.