Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unfortunately you cant always prevent dying, but maybe we could make it our choice.
The definition of assisted suicide found on google states, The suicide of a patient
suffering from an incurable disease, affected by the taking of lethal drugs provided by a
doctor for this purpose. Assisted suicide has been a debate for centuries; even the idea
of Euthanasia has been around since before 500 BC-16th Century AD as found on
ProCon.org. One side states that it should not be legal for one to assist in suicide or for
an individual to inflict it upon themselves no matter the circumstance. The other side
argues that it should be a persons right to terminate their life when life is inevitably
going to end anyway, and they are potentially in continuous agonizing pain too. In the
following essay I will present both sides separately for my readers from information that
every one of the United States. The subject has continuously been seen by people as
being against certain religions, and immoral among many other things. As stated in
Assisted Suicide: The Philosophers Brief, paragraph 3, It defines a very general oral
and constitutional principle - that every competent person has the right to make
momentous personal decisions Second, it recognizes that people may make such
momentous decisions impulsively or out of emotional depression, when their act does
not reflect enduring convictions States may be allowed to prevent suicide by people
who-it is plausible to think-would later be grateful if they were prevented from dying.
Most people deny the idea of P.A.S. because they are afraid of regulations not being
used correctly as stated in the same previously stated article. For example the state
doesnt want to give someone a lethal dose of drugs when they are not actually ill and
just think they might die, or not in their right mind. They may also think that people
may happen because the hospital has a shortage of rooms or necessary equipment to
take care of an individual so instead they subtly (or possibly not so subtly) will hint at
them to take the lethal dosage. Because of just that one possibility, if they were to take
P.A.S. into consideration in more states than they would also have to consider all of the
new restrictions that need to be put on any kind of medical professional. There are too
many variables that people think could go wrong, and they dont want to end a persons
life if they can potentially live even another year. In addition to this, it is against many
major religions to end life as stated in an article called Major Religions Oppose Assisted
Suicide for example, ...only God should be able to end life, and, Preserving life is the
most important aspect in Judaism. Just its religious ties could cause someone to
Despite there being more states that illegalized Physician Assisted Suicide many
people are actually coming around to the idea, and more people are starting to agree to
make it legal. Many people agree that if it is in the right conditions then people should
have that right, and it can potentially not only be less painful on the ill individual but
those around them as well. This is shown in the report How does physician-assisted
suicide affect the family? when it states, Doctors interviewed family members around a
year after a physician-assisted death, by lethal prescription. They found 11 in 100 had
some form of depression, and 2 in 100 still had symptoms of grief People whose
family member had opted for physician-assisted death felt more prepared for and
accepting of the death. In addition, if there has been anything majorly wrong in any of
the states that have allowed P.A.S. I was unable to find anything about it. In fact I found
an article named Assisted Suicide: How One Woman Chose to Die, Then Survived and
it states, I didnt want to live, Hall said. I was just going to say, give me the
barbiturates and call it good. For weeks, Stevens resisted giving Hall the lethal dose
of drugs, hoping he could convince her to change her mind. There is so many worries
that have been expressed about how medical professionals may abuse their power, but
there this is actual proof of the opposite. This doctor could have easily given up just like
Mrs. Hall, but instead he kept trying to convince her to save her life instead.
The controversy of physician assisted suicide is a very hard issue to address for
multiple reasons. The people on both sides of the topic have very good reasons for
throughout all the years you can see it becoming more and more popular among the
masses. Perhaps it will still stay widely illegal in the states, or it will continue to slowly
become legal. Those who dislike the idea have very real reasons to in most cases
because it is definitely possible for someone to abuse the power of a lethal dose. Those
who like the idea believe they should be able to control their fate before it controls them.
In either instance it is always important for everyone to express their emotions on such
issues, but I encourage everyone to look at the facts as well to decide which side they
- ProCon.org
https://euthanasia.procon.org/view.timeline.php?timelineID=000022
http://www.nybooks.com/articles/1997/03/27/assisted-suicide-the-philosophers-br
ief/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2585714/
https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2009/10/how-does-physician-assisted
-suicide-affect-the-family/index.htm
http://www.scpr.org/news/2015/05/14/51609/major-religions-oppose-assisted-sui
cide/
http://dailysignal.com/2015/05/18/assisted-suicide-how-one-woman-chose-to-die-then-s
urvived/