Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Av a i l a b l ea t w w w . s ci e n ce d i r ec t . c o m
ScienceDirect
journalhomepage:www.ejcancer.com
a b
Great North Childrens Hospital, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom
CRCTU, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom
c d
Nottingham Clinical Trials Unit, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Alder Hey Childrens Hospital, Liverpool, United Kingdom
e f
Addenbroookes Hopsital, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Leeds General Infirmary, Leeds, United Kingdom
g
Royal Marsden Hospital, Surrey, London, United Kingdom
h Sheeld Childrens Hospital, Sheeld, United Kingdom
i
Great Ormond Street Hospital For Sick Children, London, United Kingdom
KEYWORDS Abstract Diffuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG) has a dismal prognosis with no chemother-apy regimen
Diffuse intrinsic pontine so far resulting in any significant improvement over standard radiotherapy. In this trial, a prolonged
glioma (DIPG) regimen (21/28 d) of temozolomide was studied with the aim of over-coming O -methylguanine
6
Temozolomide methyltransferase (MGMT) mediated resistance.
Forty-three patients with a defined clinico-radiological diagnosis of DIPG received radiother-apy
and concomitant temozolomide (75 mg/m 2) after which up to 12 courses of 21 d of adju-vant
temozolomide (75100 mg/m2) were given 4 weekly. The trial used a 2-stage design and passed
interim analysis.
Corresponding author: Address: Sir James Spence Institute of Child Health, Royal Victoria Infirmary, Queen Victoria Road, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 4LP,
United Kingdom. Tel.: +44 0191 2825395.
E-mail addresses: simon.bailey@ncl.ac.uk (S. Bailey), a.j.howman@bham.ac.uk (A. Howman), k.wheatley@bham.ac.uk (K. Wheatley),
d.wherton@bham.ac.uk (D. Wherton), nazia.boota@gmail.com (N. Boota), barry.pizer@alderhey.nhs.uk (B. Pizer), fishers@addenbrookes.nhs.uk (D.
Fisher), p.r.kearns@bham.ac.uk (P. Kearns), susan.picton@leedsth.nhs.uk (S. Picton), frank.saran@rmh.nhs.uk (F. Saran), m.j.gibson@ bham.ac.uk (M.
Gibson), Adam.Glaser@leedsth.nhs.uk (A. Glaser), Daniel.Connolly@sth.nhs.uk (D.J.A. Connolly), darren.hargrave@nhs.net (D. Hargrave).
0959-8049 2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-SA license.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejca.2013.08.006
S. Bailey et al. / European Journal of Cancer 49 (2013) 38563862 3857
At diagnosis median age was 8 years (220 years), 81% had cranial nerve abnormalities, 76%
ataxia and 57% long tract signs. Median Karnofsky/Lansky score was 80 (10100). Patients
received a median of three courses of adjuvant temozolomide, five received all 12 courses and
seven did not start adjuvant treatment. Three patients were withdrawn from study treat-ment due to
haematological toxicity and 10 had a dose reduction. No other significant toxicity related to
temozolomide was noted. Overall survival (OS) (95% confidence interval (CI)) was 56% (40%,
69%) at 9 months, 35% (21%, 49%) at 1 year and 17% (7%, 30%) at 2 years. Median survival was
9.5 months (range 7.511.4 months). There were five 2-year survivors with a med-ian age of 13.6
years at diagnosis.
This trial demonstrated no survival benefit of the addition of dose dense temozolomide, to standard
radiotherapy in children with classical DIPG. However, a subgroup of adolescent DIPG patients
did have a prolonged survival, which needs further exploration.
2013 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. Open access under CC BY-NC-SA license.
for the remaining cycles up to a maximum of 12 months PD (progressive disease) at least a 20% increase in the
providing there was no clinical progression (Fig. 1). sum of the LD of target lesions, taking as refer-ence the
smallest sum LD recorded since the treat-ment started or
2.3. Response evaluation the appearance of one or more new lesions.
75%
% still alive
50%
25%
17%
0%
0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
time (months)
At Risk
1 : 43 41 34 24 15 9 7 6 5
% still
on alive and
treatment
75%
50%
25%
7%
0%
0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
time (months)
At Risk
1 : 43 35 19 12 5 4 4 3 3
Fig. 1. Overall and progression free survival of children treated on the diuse intrinsic pontine glioma (DIPG)
temozolomide trial.
S. Bailey et al. / European Journal of Cancer 49 (2013) 38563862 3859
2.5. Statistical methods infection (10%), leucopaenia (8%) and nausea (8%). Grade
3/4 toxicity associated with radiotherapy/tem-ozolomide
This trial was originally designed as a Case-Morgan was very rare. One case each of ataxia, head-
design [27]. This method was chosen to allow the trial to aches/vomiting (both same patient) and elevated alanine
stop early for futility. It was a single arm study, test-ing a aminotransferase (ALT). The most common grade 3/4
null hypothesis of 50% overall survival at 9 months against toxicities associated with maintenance temozolomide were:
an alternate hypothesis of 70%. The level of sig-nificance lymphopaenia (68% of patients with at least one episode),
for the study was set at a 1-tailed alpha of 0.05. There was infection (24%), leukocytopaenia (21%) neu-tropaenia
one intermediate analysis for futility, which did not result (15%), thrombocytopaenia (12%) and fatigue (12%). The
in the trial stopping. The primary hypoth-esis test in the reasons for withdrawal from treatment are detailed in Table
study was a 1-tailed test of the survival at 9 months. No 1.
other hypothesis testing was carried out where Based on the post radiotherapy assessment (RECIST),
appropriate, point estimates are presented with 2-tailed 11 children had partial response (PR), 26 stable disease
95% confidence intervals. (SD), four progressive disease (PD), and two not available.
Overall survival has been calculated as time from study Seven children had an increased tumour size on their post
entry to death from any cause, with patients cen-sored at radiotherapy scan (four PD and three SD on RECIST
date last seen if lost to follow up. Time to treat-ment failure criteria). Of these, four had progressive disease by RECIST
has been calculated as time from study entry to stopping criteria and three stable disease. Of these seven children the
temozolomide for any reason (except reaching the end of survival time ranged from 87 to 420 days (median 212 d)
the maintenance course without pro-gression) or death. that was not statis-tically significant from the cohort as a
whole.
Overall survival (95% confidence interval (CI)) was
56% (40%, 69%) at 9 months. The comparison against the
3. Results null hypothesis rate of 50% gave a 1-tailed p value of 0.23.
A likelihood Bayesian approach suggested that there was a
3.1. Patient characteristics 77% chance that OS was >50% at 9 months. OS at 1 year
was 0.35 (0.21, 0.49), and 0.17 (0.07, 0.30) at 2 years.
Between February 2008 and July 2010, 43 patients from Median survival was 9.5 months (7.5, 11.4) (Fig. 1).
16 centres with clinically and radiologically diag-nosed Median time to treatment failure (stopping tem-ozolomide
DIPG were registered and treated according to the protocol usually due to progression) was 168 d, with 88% of patients
described above (CCLG CNS 2007/4). either dying or withdrawing from treat-ment by 1 year. Six
The median age at presentation was 8 years (2 20 patients had not died as at last fol-low up. These had been
years) and the male: female ratio was 24:19. Eighty-one followed up for between 14 months and 3 years. All were
percent of patients presented with cranial nerve last recorded as having had stable disease without
abnormalities, 76% with ataxia and 57% with long tract additional treatment. There were five 2 year survivors with
signs. Median Karnofsky/Lansky score was 80 (mean 79; ages of 9, 12, 13, 16
range 10100). The median time from onset of symp-toms
to starting treatment was 32 d, range 9194, (sec-ond
highest 130).
Thirty-eight patients received the full course of induc- Table 1
Reasons for withdrawal of temozolomide.
tion temozolomide, and a further three had dose reduc-
tions (two due to thrombocytopenia and one due to
abdominal obstruction). In two cases it is unknown
whether the full induction course was received. One child
stopped radiotherapy after 18 Gy due to the need for
surgical intervention (Ventriculoperitoneal shunt). Two
others had short interruptions but received the total dose.
Patients received a median of three courses of maintenance
temozolomide, five received all 12 courses and seven did
not start maintenance (six due to progression and one due
to patient choice). Three patients were withdrawn from
study treatment due to haematological toxicity and 10 had
a dose reduction on at least one course. The most common
grade 3/4 tox-icities associated with induction
temozolomide were: lymphopaenia (45% of patients with
at least one epi-sode), neutropaenia (12%),
thrombocytopaenia (10%),
3860 S. Bailey et al. / European Journal of Cancer 49 (2013) 38563862
and 18, the median age of 13.6 years being greater than the be tested. However in a study by Zarghooni [32] MGMT
whole study median age of 8 years. One patient received expression was not seen in DIPG patient material. Another
two maintenance courses, one 6 courses and three all 12 explanation of lack of activity in DIPG may be poor drug
courses. One had a partial response after radiotherapy, the delivery and it possible that temozolomide, although
other four had stable disease. There were no other unusual known to penetrate the central nervous sys-tem, fails to
clinical or radiological features apart from age to predict achieve sucient tumour concentrations due to a greater
that these children would be alive at 2 years. integrity of the blood brain barrier in a typical DIPG. This
is suggested by the lack of contrast enhancement in the
majority of these tumours. A num-ber of newer delivery
4. Discussion strategies have been suggested such as convection-
enhanced delivery of chemothera-peutic agents [33,34].
This study treating children and young people with
DIPG with a prolonged dose dense temozolomide regi-men To date no novel therapeutic strategies have been shown
in addition to focal radiotherapy showed no overall to oer a survival benefit over and above stan-dard
survival benefit over radiotherapy alone [4]. The median radiotherapy (reviewed by Hargrave et al. [1] and Jansen et
survival of 9.5 months is compatible with that reported in al. [3]). The reasons for this may include; lack of biological
other trials in this disease [1,3,1821]. This study also knowledge due to limited access to tumour samples, lack of
showed no improvement in 1 year survival, however the 2 DIPG preclinical models, tumour heterogeneity and poor
year survival was 17% and better than the majority of drug delivery [35]. However, these issues are starting to be
reported series. This must be treated with caution as the addressed and a better understanding of the molecular
numbers are small and may not be a true reflection of a biology of DIPG is now emerging [32,36], with specific
definite survival advantage. Interestingly, the group of muta-tions in histone H3 characterising pontine glioma
patients surviving for 2 years or longer has an older median [37 39]. There is now a drive to develop appropriate cell
age (13.6, range 918 years) than a typical DIPG patient. It culture and animal models to assist in developing DIPG
is already known that children less than 3 years of age tend specific targeted therapies.
to have a better outlook [28], and it could be questioned as
to whether there is another subgroup of older adolescent The issue of biopsy of DIPG should now be reconsid-
DIPG patients that may have a better outcome, possibly ered as part of future clinical trials as this would allow both
due to a dierence in underlying biology. This raises prospective patient stratification/enrichment if a target
important questions as to whether age stratification should exists and also retrospective analysis of patients based on
be considered in DIPG trials to ensure an adequate sample biology to identify and explain subgroups of patients with
size to iden-tify possible age related prognostic factors. longer survival that may benefit from a given therapy.
The prolonged temozolomide regime was well toler-ated Unless further evidence becomes available, single agent
with the main toxicity being haematological which resulted temozolomide cannot be recommended for rou-tine use in
in three children withdrawing from treatment for this children with DIPG and its use in adolescents and in
reason and 10 children having at least one dose reduction. combination with other agents requires further evaluation.
There were no treatment related deaths and this regime did Future DIPG studies should consider possi-ble emerging
not have any greater toxicity than the 5/28 d regime [18 clinical and biological prognostic sub-groups and be
20]. Although, a prolonged adminis-tration schedule may stratified and powered accordingly.
make the drug more eective in maintaining depleted
MGMT, our results did not sup-port this treatment strategy.
An on-going US trial with mandatory biopsy and biological Conflict of interest statement
analysis prior to treat-ment where temozolomide will be
given in MGMT hypermethylated tumours, may help to None declared.
answer this question [29,30].
[37] Wu G, Broniscer A, McEachron TA, et al. Somatic histone H3 distinct subgroups of pediatric diuse intrinsic pontine gliomas.
alterations in pediatric diuse intrinsic pontine gliomas and non- Acta Neuropathol 2012;124:43947.
brainstem glioblastomas. Nat Genet 2012;44:2513. [39] Schwartzentruber J, Korshunov A, Liu XY, et al. Driver mutations in
[38] Khuong-Quang DA, Buczkowicz P, Rakopoulos P, et al. K27M histone H3.3 and chromatin remodelling genes in paediatric
mutation in histone H3.3 defines clinically and biologically glioblastoma. Nature 2012;482:22631.