Pre-Discussion Notes

Student Struggles Strengths Deeper Analysis of

Theme
Student 1 Not evidence to support Interpretation present Emerging
Makes connections throughout the text
Student 2 All opinion Evidence to support, but not strong No
No interpretation or analysis
Student 3 No evidence to support Interpretation Emerging (but vague)
Limited analysis or connections outside text
Student 4 Not Complete No
Student 5 Evidence not directly related Evidence present Emerging
Interpretation
Student 6 Opinion No
No evidence to support
Student 7 First person Interpretation No
Student 8 Does not fully answer prompt Interpretation of final act is emerging Emerging
No direct evidence
Student 9 Citation of evidence Connection of actions from the beginning of the novel Emerging, but not strong
Analysis not really connected back to the theme of to the end
existentialism
Student 10 First person Connection of emotions to existentialism Emerging
Limited interpretations and analysis
Student 11 First person No
No connection to the theme of novel
Not strongly connected to the prompt
Student 12 No specific evidence to connect to analysis Connection of emotion with existentialism and Emerging
nonchalant demeanor
Student 13 Not Completed No
Student 14 Connect to his final action (right now it is just before Connection to religion Emerging
his decision to be a martyr) Evidence to support
Connection to theme or existentialism
Student 15 Not Completed No
Student 16 Connection to the death to the earth and the lack of Yes
judgment both hold
Student 17 First person No
No evidence
Somewhat off prompt
Student 18 First person Connection of little time left connects to existentialism Emerging
Student 19 Connection to final statement would have been a great Evidence to support Yes
addition Connection of theme to religion and his death
Student 20 Connection to religion, not final action. Religion as a theme of existentialism is good Emerging
Student 21 First person Beginning to connect to the final act Emerging
No specific evidence/citation Interpretation of final act emerging
Student 22 No specific quotes Interpretation and analysis emerging Emerging
Connection to existentialist ideas
Student 23 Not Complete No
Student 24 No interpretation or analysis, just summary No
Student 25 Little interpretation or analysis of quote Great quote No
Response is the quote she found to support TS
Student 26 No evidence to support Connection with no religious believes of afterlife to No
support existentialist ideas
Student 27 Mostly summary No
Student 28 No specific evidence Connection of how religion plays into his existentialist Emerging
More of a connection with discussion with the Chaplin, beliefs
than his action as a Martyr
Student 29 His final actions not connected to existentialism No
Student 30 Doesnt connect to the prompt No
Student 31 Off prompt No