The Artificial Intelligence Revolution - Part 1 - Wait But Why

20/03/2017 The Articial Intelligence Revolution: Part 1 - Wait But Why
Followthesespecialmen
394,313 35,451
108,768
about archive minis theshed dinnertable store supportwbw Search

270.5k
Join501,839otherhumansand
TheAIRevolution:TheRoadto
havenewpostsemailedtoyou
Superintelligence
Email Address
SEND ME NEW POSTS
January22,2015 ByTimUrban
PDF:WemadeafancyPDFofthispostforprintingandofflineviewing.Buyithere.(Orseeapreview.) 35,451
394,313 108,768
Note:ThereasonthisposttookthreeweekstofinishisthatasIdugintoresearchonArtificial
Intelligence,IcouldnotbelievewhatIwasreading.Ithitmeprettyquicklythatwhatshappeningin
theworldofAIisnotjustanimportanttopic,butbyfarTHEmostimportanttopicforourfuture.SoI
wantedtolearnasmuchasIcouldaboutit,andonceIdidthat,IwantedtomakesureIwroteapost
thatreallyexplainedthiswholesituationandwhyitmatterssomuch.Notshockingly,thatbecame
outrageouslylong,soIbrokeitintotwoparts.ThisisPart1Part2ishere.
_______________
WeareontheedgeofchangecomparabletotheriseofhumanlifeonEarth.VernorVinge
Whatdoesitfeelliketostandhere?
PopularPosts
TheAIRevolution
854

WhyProcrastinators
Procrastinate
354

Itseemslikeaprettyintenseplacetobestandingbutthenyouhavetoremembersomethingabout
TheFermiParadox
whatitsliketostandonatimegraph:youcantseewhatstoyourright.Sohereshowitactuallyfeels
tostandthere: 893

TheElonMuskSeries
394

HowtoPickaLifePartner
148

WhyGenYYuppiesAre
Unhappy
http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/articial-intelligence-revolution-1.html 1/14
993

7WaystobeInsufferable
394,313 onFacebook 35,451
108,768
679

PuttingTimeIn
Perspective
270.5k 462

HowtoNameaBaby
248

WhyYouShouldStop
CaringWhatOther
PeopleThink
Whichprobablyfeelsprettynormal
194
_______________
TheFarFutureComingSoon Religionforthe
Nonreligious
Imaginetakingatimemachinebackto1750atimewhentheworldwasinapermanentpower 528

outage,long-distancecommunicationmeanteitheryellingloudlyorfiringacannonintheair,andall
transportationranonhay.Whenyougetthere,youretrieveadude,bringhimto2015,andthenwalk 10Typesof30-Year-Old
SingleGuys
himaroundandwatchhimreacttoeverything.Itsimpossibleforustounderstandwhatitwouldbe
likeforhimtoseeshinycapsulesracingbyonahighway,talktopeoplewhohadbeenontheotherside 321

oftheoceanearlierintheday,watchsportsthatwerebeingplayed1,000milesaway,hearamusical
performancethathappened50yearsago,andplaywithmymagicalwizardrectanglethathecoulduse TheTailEnd
tocaptureareal-lifeimageorrecordalivingmoment,generateamapwithaparanormalmovingblue
150
dotthatshowshimwhereheis,lookatsomeonesfaceandchatwiththemeventhoughtheyreonthe
othersideofthecountry,andworldsofotherinconceivablesorcery.Thisisallbeforeyoushowhimthe
internetorexplainthingsliketheInternationalSpaceStation,theLargeHadronCollider,nuclear
weapons,orgeneralrelativity.
Thisexperienceforhimwouldntbesurprisingorshockingorevenmind-blowingthosewordsarent
bigenough.Hemightactuallydie.
Butherestheinterestingthingifhethenwentbackto1750andgotjealousthatwegottoseehis
reactionanddecidedhewantedtotrythesamething,hedtakethetimemachineandgobackthe
samedistance,getsomeonefromaroundtheyear1500,bringhimto1750,andshowhimeverything.
Andthe1500guywouldbeshockedbyalotofthingsbuthewouldntdie.Itwouldbefarlessofan
insaneexperienceforhim,becausewhile1500and1750wereverydifferent,theyweremuchless
differentthan1750to2015.The1500guywouldlearnsomemind-bendingshitaboutspaceand
physics,hedbeimpressedwithhowcommittedEuropeturnedouttobewiththatnewimperialismfad,
andhedhavetodosomemajorrevisionsofhisworldmapconception.Butwatchingeverydaylifego
byin1750transportation,communication,etc.definitelywouldntmakehimdie.
No,inorderforthe1750guytohaveasmuchfunaswehadwithhim,hedhavetogomuchfarther
backmaybeallthewaybacktoabout12,000BC,beforetheFirstAgriculturalRevolutiongaveriseto
thefirstcitiesandtotheconceptofcivilization.Ifsomeonefromapurelyhunter-gathererworldfrom
atimewhenhumanswere,moreorless,justanotheranimalspeciessawthevasthumanempiresof
1750withtheirtoweringchurches,theirocean-crossingships,theirconceptofbeinginside,andtheir
enormousmountainofcollective,accumulatedhumanknowledgeanddiscoveryhedlikelydie.
Andthenwhatif,afterdying,hegotjealousandwantedtodothesamething.Ifhewentback12,000
yearsto24,000BCandgotaguyandbroughthimto12,000BC,hedshowtheguyeverythingandthe
guywouldbelike,Okaywhatsyourpointwhocares.Forthe12,000BCguytohavethesamefun,
hedhavetogobackover100,000yearsandgetsomeonehecouldshowfireandlanguagetoforthe
firsttime.
Inorderforsomeonetobetransportedintothefutureanddiefromthelevelofshocktheyd
experience,theyhavetogoenoughyearsaheadthatadielevelofprogress,oraDieProgressUnit
(DPU)hasbeenachieved.SoaDPUtookover100,000yearsinhunter-gatherertimes,butatthepost-
AgriculturalRevolutionrate,itonlytookabout12,000years.Thepost-IndustrialRevolutionworldhas
movedsoquicklythata1750persononlyneedstogoforwardacouplehundredyearsforaDPUto
havehappened.
ThispatternhumanprogressmovingquickerandquickerastimegoesoniswhatfuturistRay
KurzweilcallshumanhistorysLawofAcceleratingReturns.Thishappensbecausemoreadvanced
societieshavetheabilitytoprogressatafasterratethanlessadvancedsocietiesbecausetheyre
moreadvanced.19thcenturyhumanityknewmoreandhadbettertechnologythan15thcentury 394,313 35,451
108,768
humanity,soitsnosurprisethathumanitymadefarmoreadvancesinthe19thcenturythaninthe
15thcentury15thcenturyhumanitywasnomatchfor19thcenturyhumanity. 1 1 openthese
Thisworksonsmallerscalestoo.ThemovieBacktotheFuturecameoutin1985,andthepasttook
placein1955.Inthemovie,whenMichaelJ.Foxwentbackto1955,hewascaughtoff-guardbythe
270.5knewnessofTVs,thepricesofsoda,thelackofloveforshrillelectricguitar,andthevariationinslang.It
wasadifferentworld,yesbutifthemovieweremadetodayandthepasttookplacein1985,the
moviecouldhavehadmuchmorefunwithmuchbiggerdifferences.Thecharacterwouldbeinatime
beforepersonalcomputers,internet,orcellphonestodaysMartyMcFly,ateenagerborninthelate
90s,wouldbemuchmoreoutofplacein1985thanthemoviesMartyMcFlywasin1955.
ThisisforthesamereasonwejustdiscussedtheLawofAcceleratingReturns.Theaveragerateof
advancementbetween1985and2015washigherthantheratebetween1955and1985becausethe
formerwasamoreadvancedworldsomuchmorechangehappenedinthemostrecent30yearsthan
intheprior30.
Soadvancesaregettingbiggerandbiggerandhappeningmoreandmorequickly.Thissuggests
someprettyintensethingsaboutourfuture,right?
Kurzweilsuggeststhattheprogressoftheentire20thcenturywouldhavebeenachievedinonly20
yearsattherateofadvancementintheyear2000inotherwords,by2000,therateofprogresswas
fivetimesfasterthantheaveragerateofprogressduringthe20thcentury.Hebelievesanother20th
centurysworthofprogresshappenedbetween2000and2014andthatanother20thcenturysworth
ofprogresswillhappenby2021,inonlysevenyears.Acoupledecadeslater,hebelievesa20th
centurysworthofprogresswillhappenmultipletimesinthesameyear,andevenlater,inlessthan
onemonth.Allinall,becauseoftheLawofAcceleratingReturns,Kurzweilbelievesthatthe21stcentury
willachieve1,000timestheprogressofthe20thcentury.
2
IfKurzweilandotherswhoagreewithhimarecorrect,thenwemaybeasblownawayby2030asour
1750guywasby2015i.e.thenextDPUmightonlytakeacoupledecadesandtheworldin2050
mightbesovastlydifferentthantodaysworldthatwewouldbarelyrecognizeit.
Thisisntsciencefiction.ItswhatmanyscientistssmarterandmoreknowledgeablethanyouorIfirmly
believeandifyoulookathistory,itswhatweshouldlogicallypredict.
Sothenwhy,whenyouhearmesaysomethingliketheworld35yearsfromnowmightbetotally
unrecognizable,areyouthinking,Cool.butnahhhhhhh?Threereasonswereskepticalof
outlandishforecastsofthefuture:
1)Whenitcomestohistory,wethinkinstraightlines.Whenweimaginetheprogressofthenext30
years,welookbacktotheprogressoftheprevious30asanindicatorofhowmuchwilllikelyhappen.
Whenwethinkabouttheextenttowhichtheworldwillchangeinthe21stcentury,wejusttakethe
20thcenturyprogressandaddittotheyear2000.Thiswasthesamemistakeour1750guymadewhen
hegotsomeonefrom1500andexpectedtoblowhismindasmuchashisownwasblowngoingthe
samedistanceahead.Itsmostintuitiveforustothinklinearly,whenweshouldbethinking
exponentially.Ifsomeoneisbeingmorecleveraboutit,theymightpredicttheadvancesofthenext30
yearsnotbylookingattheprevious30years,butbytakingthecurrentrateofprogressandjudging
basedonthat.Theydbemoreaccurate,butstillwayoff.Inordertothinkaboutthefuturecorrectly,
youneedtoimaginethingsmovingatamuchfasterratethantheyremovingnow.
394,313 35,451
108,768
270.5k
2)Thetrajectoryofveryrecenthistoryoftentellsadistortedstory.First,evenasteepexponential
curveseemslinearwhenyouonlylookatatinysliceofit,thesamewayifyoulookatalittlesegmentof
ahugecircleupclose,itlooksalmostlikeastraightline.Second,exponentialgrowthisnttotally
smoothanduniform.KurzweilexplainsthatprogresshappensinS-curves:
AnSiscreatedbythewaveofprogresswhenanewparadigmsweepstheworld.Thecurvegoes
throughthreephases:
1.Slowgrowth(theearlyphaseofexponentialgrowth)
2.Rapidgrowth(thelate,explosivephaseofexponentialgrowth)
3.Alevelingoffastheparticularparadigmmatures 3
Ifyoulookonlyatveryrecenthistory,thepartoftheS-curveyoureonatthemomentcanobscureyour
perceptionofhowfastthingsareadvancing.Thechunkoftimebetween1995and2007sawthe
explosionoftheinternet,theintroductionofMicrosoft,Google,andFacebookintothepublic
consciousness,thebirthofsocialnetworking,andtheintroductionofcellphonesandthensmart
phones.ThatwasPhase2:thegrowthspurtpartoftheS.But2008to2015hasbeenless
groundbreaking,atleastonthetechnologicalfront.Someonethinkingaboutthefuturetodaymight
examinethelastfewyearstogaugethecurrentrateofadvancement,butthatsmissingthebigger
picture.Infact,anew,hugePhase2growthspurtmightbebrewingrightnow.
3)Ourownexperiencemakesusstubbornoldmenaboutthefuture.Webaseourideasaboutthe
worldonourpersonalexperience,andthatexperiencehasingrainedtherateofgrowthoftherecent
pastinourheadsasthewaythingshappen.Werealsolimitedbyourimagination,whichtakesour
experienceandusesittoconjurefuturepredictionsbutoften,whatweknowsimplydoesntgiveus
thetoolstothinkaccuratelyaboutthefuture. Whenwehearapredictionaboutthefuturethat
2
contradictsourexperience-basednotionofhowthingswork,ourinstinctisthatthepredictionmustbe
naive.IfItellyou,laterinthispost,thatyoumaylivetobe150,or250,ornotdieatall,yourinstinctwill
be,ThatsstupidiftheresonethingIknowfromhistory,itsthateverybodydies.Andyes,noonein
thepasthasnotdied.Butnooneflewairplanesbeforeairplaneswereinventedeither.
Sowhilenahhhhhmightfeelrightasyoureadthispost,itsprobablyactuallywrong.Thefactis,if
werebeingtrulylogicalandexpectinghistoricalpatternstocontinue,weshouldconcludethatmuch,
much,muchmoreshouldchangeinthecomingdecadesthanweintuitivelyexpect.Logicalsosuggests
thatifthemostadvancedspeciesonaplanetkeepsmakinglargerandlargerleapsforwardatanever- 394,313 35,451
108,768
fasterrate,atsomepoint,theyllmakealeapsogreatthatitcompletelyalterslifeastheyknowitand
theperceptiontheyhaveofwhatitmeanstobeahumankindoflikehowevolutionkeptmaking
greatleapstowardintelligenceuntilfinallyitmadesuchalargeleaptothehumanbeingthatit
completelyalteredwhatitmeantforanycreaturetoliveonplanetEarth.Andifyouspendsometime
readingaboutwhatsgoingontodayinscienceandtechnology,youstarttoseealotofsignsquietly
270.5khintingthatlifeaswecurrentlyknowitcannotwithstandtheleapthatscomingnext.
_______________
TheRoadtoSuperintelligence
WhatIsAI?
Ifyourelikeme,youusedtothinkArtificialIntelligencewasasillysci-ficoncept,butlatelyyouvebeen
hearingitmentionedbyseriouspeople,andyoudontreallyquitegetit.
TherearethreereasonsalotofpeopleareconfusedaboutthetermAI:
1)WeassociateAIwithmovies.StarWars.Terminator.2001:ASpaceOdyssey.EventheJetsons.And
thosearefiction,asaretherobotcharacters.SoitmakesAIsoundalittlefictionaltous.
2)AIisabroadtopic.Itrangesfromyourphonescalculatortoself-drivingcarstosomethinginthe
futurethatmightchangetheworlddramatically.AIreferstoallofthesethings,whichisconfusing.
3)WeuseAIallthetimeinourdailylives,butweoftendontrealizeitsAI.JohnMcCarthy,who
coinedthetermArtificialIntelligencein1956,complainedthatassoonasitworks,noonecallsitAI
anymore. Becauseofthisphenomenon,AIoftensoundslikeamythicalfuturepredictionmorethan
4
areality.Atthesametime,itmakesitsoundlikeapopconceptfromthepastthatnevercameto
fruition.RayKurzweilsayshehearspeoplesaythatAIwitheredinthe1980s,whichhecomparesto
insistingthattheInternetdiedinthedot-combustoftheearly2000s.
5
Soletsclearthingsup.First,stopthinkingofrobots.ArobotisacontainerforAI,sometimesmimicking
thehumanform,sometimesnotbuttheAIitselfisthecomputerinsidetherobot.AIisthebrain,and
therobotisitsbodyifitevenhasabody.Forexample,thesoftwareanddatabehindSiriisAI,the
womansvoicewehearisapersonificationofthatAI,andtheresnorobotinvolvedatall.
Secondly,youveprobablyheardthetermsingularityortechnologicalsingularity.Thistermhas
beenusedinmathtodescribeanasymptote-likesituationwherenormalrulesnolongerapply.Its
beenusedinphysicstodescribeaphenomenonlikeaninfinitelysmall,denseblackholeorthepoint
wewereallsquishedintorightbeforetheBigBang.Again,situationswheretheusualrulesdontapply.
In1993,VernorVingewroteafamousessayinwhichheappliedthetermtothemomentinthefuture
whenourtechnologysintelligenceexceedsourownamomentforhimwhenlifeasweknowitwillbe
foreverchangedandnormalruleswillnolongerapply.RayKurzweilthenmuddledthingsabitby
definingthesingularityasthetimewhentheLawofAcceleratingReturnshasreachedsuchanextreme
pacethattechnologicalprogressishappeningataseemingly-infinitepace,andafterwhichwellbe
livinginawholenewworld.IfoundthatmanyoftodaysAIthinkershavestoppedusingtheterm,and
itsconfusinganyway,soIwontuseitmuchhere(eventhoughwellbefocusingonthatidea
throughout).
Finally,whiletherearemanydifferenttypesorformsofAIsinceAIisabroadconcept,thecritical
categoriesweneedtothinkaboutarebasedonanAIscaliber.TherearethreemajorAIcaliber
categories:
AICaliber1)ArtificialNarrowIntelligence(ANI):SometimesreferredtoasWeakAI,ArtificialNarrow
IntelligenceisAIthatspecializesinonearea.TheresAIthatcanbeattheworldchesschampionin
chess,butthatstheonlythingitdoes.Askittofigureoutabetterwaytostoredataonaharddrive,
anditlllookatyoublankly.
AICaliber2)ArtificialGeneralIntelligence(AGI):SometimesreferredtoasStrongAI,orHuman-
LevelAI,ArtificialGeneralIntelligencereferstoacomputerthatisassmartasahumanacrossthe
boardamachinethatcanperformanyintellectualtaskthatahumanbeingcan.CreatingAGIisa
muchhardertaskthancreatingANI,andwereyettodoit.ProfessorLindaGottfredsondescribes
intelligenceasaverygeneralmentalcapabilitythat,amongotherthings,involvestheabilitytoreason,
plan,solveproblems,thinkabstractly,comprehendcomplexideas,learnquickly,andlearnfrom
experience.AGIwouldbeabletodoallofthosethingsaseasilyasyoucan.
AICaliber3)ArtificialSuperintelligence(ASI):OxfordphilosopherandleadingAIthinkerNick
Bostromdefinessuperintelligenceasanintellectthatismuchsmarterthanthebesthumanbrainsin
practicallyeveryfield,includingscientificcreativity,generalwisdomandsocialskills.Artificial
Superintelligencerangesfromacomputerthatsjustalittlesmarterthanahumantoonethats 394,313 35,451
108,768
trillionsoftimessmarteracrosstheboard.ASIisthereasonthetopicofAIissuchaspicymeatball
andwhythewordsimmortalityandextinctionwillbothappearinthesepostsmultipletimes.
Asofnow,humanshaveconqueredthelowestcaliberofAIANIinmanyways,anditseverywhere.
TheAIRevolutionistheroadfromANI,throughAGI,toASIaroadwemayormaynotsurvivebutthat,
270.5keitherway,willchangeeverything.
Letstakeacloselookatwhattheleadingthinkersinthefieldbelievethisroadlookslikeandwhythis
revolutionmighthappenwaysoonerthanyoumightthink:
WhereWeAreCurrentlyAWorldRunningonANI
ArtificialNarrowIntelligenceismachineintelligencethatequalsorexceedshumanintelligenceor
efficiencyataspecificthing.Afewexamples:
CarsarefullofANIsystems,fromthecomputerthatfiguresoutwhentheanti-lockbrakesshould
kickintothecomputerthattunestheparametersofthefuelinjectionsystems.Googlesself-
drivingcar,whichisbeingtestednow,willcontainrobustANIsystemsthatallowittoperceiveand
reacttotheworldaroundit.
YourphoneisalittleANIfactory.Whenyounavigateusingyourmapapp,receivetailoredmusic
recommendationsfromPandora,checktomorrowsweather,talktoSiri,ordozensofother
everydayactivities,youreusingANI.
YouremailspamfilterisaclassictypeofANIitstartsoffloadedwithintelligenceabouthowto
figureoutwhatsspamandwhatsnot,andthenitlearnsandtailorsitsintelligencetoyouasit
getsexperiencewithyourparticularpreferences.TheNestThermostatdoesthesamethingasit
startstofigureoutyourtypicalroutineandactaccordingly.
YouknowthewholecreepythingthatgoesonwhenyousearchforaproductonAmazonand
thenyouseethatasarecommendedforyouproductonadifferentsite,orwhenFacebook
somehowknowswhoitmakessenseforyoutoaddasafriend?ThatsanetworkofANIsystems,
workingtogethertoinformeachotheraboutwhoyouareandwhatyoulikeandthenusingthat
informationtodecidewhattoshowyou.SamegoesforAmazonsPeoplewhoboughtthisalso
boughtthingthatsanANIsystemwhosejobitistogatherinfofromthebehaviorofmillions
ofcustomersandsynthesizethatinfotocleverlyupsellyousoyoullbuymorethings.
GoogleTranslateisanotherclassicANIsystemimpressivelygoodatonenarrowtask.Voice
recognitionisanother,andthereareabunchofappsthatusethosetwoANIsasatagteam,
allowingyoutospeakasentenceinonelanguageandhavethephonespitoutthesamesentence
inanother.
Whenyourplanelands,itsnotahumanthatdecideswhichgateitshouldgoto.Justlikeitsnota
humanthatdeterminedthepriceofyourticket.
TheworldsbestCheckers,Chess,Scrabble,Backgammon,andOthelloplayersarenowallANI
systems.
GooglesearchisonelargeANIbrainwithincrediblysophisticatedmethodsforrankingpagesand
figuringoutwhattoshowyouinparticular.SamegoesforFacebooksNewsfeed.
Andthosearejustintheconsumerworld.SophisticatedANIsystemsarewidelyusedinsectors
andindustrieslikemilitary,manufacturing,andfinance(algorithmichigh-frequencyAItraders
accountformorethanhalfofequitysharestradedonUSmarkets ),andinexpertsystemslike
6
thosethathelpdoctorsmakediagnosesand,mostfamously,IBMsWatson,whocontained
enoughfactsandunderstoodcoyTrebek-speakwellenoughtosoundlybeatthemostprolific
Jeopardychampions.
ANIsystemsastheyarenowarentespeciallyscary.Atworst,aglitchyorbadly-programmedANIcan
causeanisolatedcatastrophelikeknockingoutapowergrid,causingaharmfulnuclearpowerplant
malfunction,ortriggeringafinancialmarketsdisaster(likethe2010FlashCrashwhenanANIprogram
reactedthewrongwaytoanunexpectedsituationandcausedthestockmarkettobrieflyplummet,
taking$1trillionofmarketvaluewithit,onlypartofwhichwasrecoveredwhenthemistakewas
corrected).
ButwhileANIdoesnthavethecapabilitytocauseanexistentialthreat,weshouldseethisincreasingly
largeandcomplexecosystemofrelatively-harmlessANIasaprecursoroftheworld-alteringhurricane
thatsontheway.EachnewANIinnovationquietlyaddsanotherbrickontotheroadtoAGIandASI.Or
asAaronSaenzseesit,ourworldsANIsystemsareliketheaminoacidsintheearlyEarthsprimordial
oozetheinanimatestuffoflifethat,oneunexpectedday,wokeup.
TheRoadFromANItoAGI
TheRoadFromANItoAGI
WhyItsSoHard
394,313 35,451
108,768
Nothingwillmakeyouappreciatehumanintelligencelikelearningabouthowunbelievablychallenging
itistotrytocreateacomputerassmartasweare.Buildingskyscrapers,puttinghumansinspace,
figuringoutthedetailsofhowtheBigBangwentdownallfareasierthanunderstandingourown
brainorhowtomakesomethingascoolasit.Asofnow,thehumanbrainisthemostcomplexobjectin
theknownuniverse.
270.5k
WhatsinterestingisthatthehardpartsoftryingtobuildAGI(acomputerassmartashumansin
general,notjustatonenarrowspecialty)arenotintuitivelywhatyoudthinktheyare.Buildacomputer
thatcanmultiplytwoten-digitnumbersinasplitsecondincrediblyeasy.Buildonethatcanlookata
dogandanswerwhetheritsadogoracatspectacularlydifficult.MakeAIthatcanbeatanyhumanin
chess?Done.Makeonethatcanreadaparagraphfromasix-year-oldspicturebookandnotjust
recognizethewordsbutunderstandthemeaningofthem?Googleiscurrentlyspendingbillionsof
dollarstryingtodoit.Hardthingslikecalculus,financialmarketstrategy,andlanguagetranslation
aremind-numbinglyeasyforacomputer,whileeasythingslikevision,motion,movement,and
perceptionareinsanelyhardforit.Or,ascomputerscientistDonaldKnuthputsit,AIhasbynow
succeededindoingessentiallyeverythingthatrequiresthinkingbuthasfailedtodomostofwhat
peopleandanimalsdowithoutthinking.' 7
Whatyouquicklyrealizewhenyouthinkaboutthisisthatthosethingsthatseemeasytousareactually
unbelievablycomplicated,andtheyonlyseemeasybecausethoseskillshavebeenoptimizedinus(and
mostanimals)byhundredsofmillionsofyearsofanimalevolution.Whenyoureachyourhandup
towardanobject,themuscles,tendons,andbonesinyourshoulder,elbow,andwristinstantlyperform
alongseriesofphysicsoperations,inconjunctionwithyoureyes,toallowyoutomoveyourhandina
straightlinethroughthreedimensions.Itseemseffortlesstoyoubecauseyouhaveperfectedsoftware
inyourbrainfordoingit.Sameideagoesforwhyitsnotthatmalwareisdumbfornotbeingableto
figureouttheslantywordrecognitiontestwhenyousignupforanewaccountonasiteitsthatyour
brainissuperimpressiveforbeingableto.
Ontheotherhand,multiplyingbignumbersorplayingchessarenewactivitiesforbiologicalcreatures
andwehaventhadanytimetoevolveaproficiencyatthem,soacomputerdoesntneedtoworktoo
hardtobeatus.Thinkaboutitwhichwouldyouratherdo,buildaprogramthatcouldmultiplybig
numbersoronethatcouldunderstandtheessenceofaBwellenoughthatyoucouldshowitaBinany
oneofthousandsofunpredictablefontsorhandwritinganditcouldinstantlyknowitwasaB?
Onefunexamplewhenyoulookatthis,youandacomputerbothcanfigureoutthatitsarectangle
withtwodistinctshades,alternating:
Tiedsofar.Butifyoupickuptheblackandrevealthewholeimage
394,313 35,451
108,768
270.5k
youhavenoproblemgivingafulldescriptionofthevariousopaqueandtranslucentcylinders,slats,
and3-Dcorners,butthecomputerwouldfailmiserably.Itwoulddescribewhatitseesavarietyof
two-dimensionalshapesinseveraldifferentshadeswhichisactuallywhatsthere.Yourbrainisdoing
atonoffancyshittointerprettheimplieddepth,shade-mixing,androomlightingthepictureistrying
toportray. Andlookingatthepicturebelow,acomputerseesatwo-dimensionalwhite,black,and
8
graycollage,whileyoueasilyseewhatitreallyisaphotoofanentirely-black,3-Drock:
Credit:MatthewLloyd
Andeverythingwejustmentionedisstillonlytakinginstagnantinformationandprocessingit.Tobe
human-levelintelligent,acomputerwouldhavetounderstandthingslikethedifferencebetweensubtle
facialexpressions,thedistinctionbetweenbeingpleased,relieved,content,satisfied,andglad,andwhy
BraveheartwasgreatbutThePatriotwasterrible.
Daunting.
Sohowdowegetthere?
FirstKeytoCreatingAGI:IncreasingComputationalPower
OnethingthatdefinitelyneedstohappenforAGItobeapossibilityisanincreaseinthepowerof
computerhardware.IfanAIsystemisgoingtobeasintelligentasthebrain,itllneedtoequalthe
brainsrawcomputingcapacity.
Onewaytoexpressthiscapacityisinthetotalcalculationspersecond(cps)thebraincouldmanage,
andyoucouldcometothisnumberbyfiguringoutthemaximumcpsofeachstructureinthebrainand
thenaddingthemalltogether.
RayKurzweilcameupwithashortcutbytakingsomeonesprofessionalestimateforthecpsofone
structureandthatstructuresweightcomparedtothatofthewholebrainandthenmultiplying
proportionallytogetanestimateforthetotal.Soundsalittleiffy,buthedidthisabunchoftimeswith
variousprofessionalestimatesofdifferentregions,andthetotalalwaysarrivedinthesameballpark
around1016,or10quadrillioncps.
Currently,theworldsfastestsupercomputer,ChinasTianhe-2,hasactuallybeatenthatnumber,
clockinginatabout34quadrillioncps.ButTianhe-2isalsoadick,takingup720squaremetersofspace,
using24megawattsofpower(thebrainrunsonjust20watts),andcosting$390milliontobuild.Not
especiallyapplicabletowideusage,orevenmostcommercialorindustrialusageyet.
Kurzweilsuggeststhatwethinkaboutthestateofcomputersbylookingathowmanycpsyoucanbuy
for$1,000.Whenthatnumberreacheshuman-level10quadrillioncpsthenthatllmeanAGIcould
becomeaveryrealpartoflife.
MooresLawisahistorically-reliablerulethattheworldsmaximumcomputingpowerdoubles Followthesespecialmen
approximatelyeverytwoyears,meaningcomputerhardwareadvancement,likegeneralhuman 35,451
394,313 108,768
advancementthroughhistory,growsexponentially.LookingathowthisrelatestoKurzweilscps/$1,000
metric,werecurrentlyatabout10trillioncps/$1,000,rightonpacewiththisgraphspredicted
trajectory:
9
270.5k
Sotheworlds$1,000computersarenowbeatingthemousebrainandtheyreataboutathousandth
ofhumanlevel.Thisdoesntsoundlikemuchuntilyourememberthatwewereataboutatrillionthof
humanlevelin1985,abillionthin1995,andamillionthin2005.Beingatathousandthin2015putsus
rightonpacetogettoanaffordablecomputerby2025thatrivalsthepowerofthebrain.
Soonthehardwareside,therawpowerneededforAGIistechnicallyavailablenow,inChina,andwell
bereadyforaffordable,widespreadAGI-caliberhardwarewithin10years.Butrawcomputational
poweralonedoesntmakeacomputergenerallyintelligentthenextquestionis,howdowebring
human-levelintelligencetoallthatpower?
SecondKeytoCreatingAGI:MakingItSmart
Thisistheickypart.Thetruthis,noonereallyknowshowtomakeitsmartwerestilldebatinghowto
makeacomputerhuman-levelintelligentandcapableofknowingwhatadogandaweird-writtenBand
amediocremovieis.Butthereareabunchoffar-fetchedstrategiesoutthereandatsomepoint,oneof
themwillwork.HerearethethreemostcommonstrategiesIcameacross:
1)Plagiarizethebrain.
Thisislikescientiststoilingoverhowthatkidwhositsnexttotheminclassissosmartandkeepsdoing
sowellonthetests,andeventhoughtheykeepstudyingdiligently,theycantdonearlyaswellasthat
kid,andthentheyfinallydecidekfuckitImjustgonnacopythatkidsanswers.Itmakessense
werestumpedtryingtobuildasuper-complexcomputer,andtherehappenstobeaperfectprototype
foroneineachofourheads.
Thescienceworldisworkinghardonreverseengineeringthebraintofigureouthowevolutionmade
sucharadthingoptimisticestimatessaywecandothisby2030.Oncewedothat,wellknowallthe
secretsofhowthebrainrunssopowerfullyandefficientlyandwecandrawinspirationfromitandsteal
itsinnovations.Oneexampleofcomputerarchitecturethatmimicsthebrainistheartificialneural
network.Itstartsoutasanetworkoftransistorneurons,connectedtoeachotherwithinputsand
outputs,anditknowsnothinglikeaninfantbrain.Thewayitlearnsisittriestodoatask,say
handwritingrecognition,andatfirst,itsneuralfiringsandsubsequentguessesatdecipheringeach
letterwillbecompletelyrandom.Butwhenitstolditgotsomethingright,thetransistorconnectionsin
thefiringpathwaysthathappenedtocreatethatanswerarestrengthened;whenitstolditwaswrong,
thosepathwaysconnectionsareweakened.Afteralotofthistrialandfeedback,thenetworkhas,by
itself,formedsmartneuralpathwaysandthemachinehasbecomeoptimizedforthetask.Thebrain
learnsabitlikethisbutinamoresophisticatedway,andaswecontinuetostudythebrain,were
discoveringingeniousnewwaystotakeadvantageofneuralcircuitry.
Moreextremeplagiarisminvolvesastrategycalledwholebrainemulation,wherethegoalistoslicea 35,451
394,313 108,768
realbrainintothinlayers,scaneachone,usesoftwaretoassembleanaccuratereconstructed3-D
model,andthenimplementthemodelonapowerfulcomputer.Wedthenhaveacomputerofficially
capableofeverythingthebrainiscapableofitwouldjustneedtolearnandgatherinformation.If
engineersgetreallygood,theydbeabletoemulatearealbrainwithsuchexactaccuracythatthe
brainsfullpersonalityandmemorywouldbeintactoncethebrainarchitecturehasbeenuploadedtoa
270.5kcomputer.IfthebrainbelongedtoJimrightbeforehepassedaway,thecomputerwouldnowwakeup
asJim(?),whichwouldbearobusthuman-levelAGI,andwecouldnowworkonturningJimintoan
unimaginablysmartASI,whichhedprobablybereallyexcitedabout.
Howfararewefromachievingwholebrainemulation?Wellsofar,wevenotyetjustrecentlybeenable
toemulatea1mm-longflatwormbrain,whichconsistsofjust302totalneurons.Thehumanbrain
contains100billion.Ifthatmakesitseemlikeahopelessproject,rememberthepowerofexponential
progressnowthatweveconqueredthetinywormbrain,anantmighthappenbeforetoolong,
followedbyamouse,andsuddenlythiswillseemmuchmoreplausible.
2)Trytomakeevolutiondowhatitdidbeforebutforusthistime.
Soifwedecidethesmartkidstestistoohardtocopy,wecantrytocopythewayhestudiesforthe
testsinstead.
Heressomethingweknow.Buildingacomputeraspowerfulasthebrainispossibleourownbrains
evolutionisproof.Andifthebrainisjusttoocomplexforustoemulate,wecouldtrytoemulate
evolutioninstead.Thefactis,evenifwecanemulateabrain,thatmightbeliketryingtobuildan
airplanebycopyingabirdswing-flappingmotionsoften,machinesarebestdesignedusingafresh,
machine-orientedapproach,notbymimickingbiologyexactly.
SohowcanwesimulateevolutiontobuildAGI?Themethod,calledgeneticalgorithms,wouldwork
somethinglikethis:therewouldbeaperformance-and-evaluationprocessthatwouldhappenagain
andagain(thesamewaybiologicalcreaturesperformbylivinglifeandareevaluatedbywhether
theymanagetoreproduceornot).Agroupofcomputerswouldtrytodotasks,andthemostsuccessful
oneswouldbebredwitheachotherbyhavinghalfofeachoftheirprogrammingmergedtogetherinto
anewcomputer.Thelesssuccessfuloneswouldbeeliminated.Overmany,manyiterations,this
naturalselectionprocesswouldproducebetterandbettercomputers.Thechallengewouldbecreating
anautomatedevaluationandbreedingcyclesothisevolutionprocesscouldrunonitsown.
Thedownsideofcopyingevolutionisthatevolutionlikestotakeabillionyearstodothingsandwe
wanttodothisinafewdecades.
Butwehavealotofadvantagesoverevolution.First,evolutionhasnoforesightandworksrandomly
itproducesmoreunhelpfulmutationsthanhelpfulones,butwewouldcontroltheprocesssoitwould
onlybedrivenbybeneficialglitchesandtargetedtweaks.Secondly,evolutiondoesntaimforanything,
includingintelligencesometimesanenvironmentmightevenselectagainsthigherintelligence(since
itusesalotofenergy).We,ontheotherhand,couldspecificallydirectthisevolutionaryprocesstoward
increasingintelligence.Third,toselectforintelligence,evolutionhastoinnovateinabunchofother
waystofacilitateintelligencelikerevampingthewayscellsproduceenergywhenwecanremove
thoseextraburdensandusethingslikeelectricity.Itsnodoubtwedbemuch,muchfasterthan
evolutionbutitsstillnotclearwhetherwellbeabletoimproveuponevolutionenoughtomakethisa
viablestrategy.
3)Makethiswholethingthecomputersproblem,notours.
Thisiswhenscientistsgetdesperateandtrytoprogramthetesttotakeitself.Butitmightbethemost
promisingmethodwehave.
TheideaisthatwedbuildacomputerwhosetwomajorskillswouldbedoingresearchonAIand
codingchangesintoitselfallowingittonotonlylearnbuttoimproveitsownarchitecture.Wedteach
computerstobecomputerscientistssotheycouldbootstraptheirowndevelopment.Andthatwould
betheirmainjobfiguringouthowtomakethemselvessmarter.Moreonthislater.
AllofThisCouldHappenSoon
Rapidadvancementsinhardwareandinnovativeexperimentationwithsoftwarearehappening
simultaneously,andAGIcouldcreepuponusquicklyandunexpectedlyfortwomainreasons:
1)Exponentialgrowthisintenseandwhatseemslikeasnailspaceofadvancementcanquicklyrace
upwardsthisGIFillustratesthisconceptnicely:
394,313 35,451
108,768
270.5k
Source
2)Whenitcomestosoftware,progresscanseemslow,butthenoneepiphanycaninstantlychangethe
rateofadvancement(kindoflikethewayscience,duringthetimehumansthoughttheuniversewas
geocentric,washavingdifficultycalculatinghowtheuniverseworked,butthenthediscoverythatitwas
heliocentricsuddenlymadeeverythingmucheasier).Or,whenitcomestosomethinglikeacomputer
thatimprovesitself,wemightseemfarawaybutactuallybejustonetweakofthesystemawayfrom
havingitbecome1,000timesmoreeffectiveandzoomingupwardtohuman-levelintelligence.
TheRoadFromAGItoASI
Atsomepoint,wellhaveachievedAGIcomputerswithhuman-levelgeneralintelligence.Justabunch
ofpeopleandcomputerslivingtogetherinequality.
Ohactuallynotatall.
Thethingis,AGIwithanidenticallevelofintelligenceandcomputationalcapacityasahumanwould
stillhavesignificantadvantagesoverhumans.Like:
Hardware:
Speed.Thebrainsneuronsmaxoutataround200Hz,whiletodaysmicroprocessors(whichare
muchslowerthantheywillbewhenwereachAGI)runat2GHz,or10milliontimesfasterthanour
neurons.Andthebrainsinternalcommunications,whichcanmoveatabout120m/s,arehorribly
outmatchedbyacomputersabilitytocommunicateopticallyatthespeedoflight.
Sizeandstorage.Thebrainislockedintoitssizebytheshapeofourskulls,anditcouldntget
muchbiggeranyway,orthe120m/sinternalcommunicationswouldtaketoolongtogetfrom
onebrainstructuretoanother.Computerscanexpandtoanyphysicalsize,allowingfarmore
hardwaretobeputtowork,amuchlargerworkingmemory(RAM),andalongtermmemory(hard
drivestorage)thathasbothfargreatercapacityandprecisionthanourown.
Reliabilityanddurability.Itsnotonlythememoriesofacomputerthatwouldbemoreprecise.
Computertransistorsaremoreaccuratethanbiologicalneurons,andtheyrelesslikelyto
deteriorate(andcanberepairedorreplacediftheydo).Humanbrainsalsogetfatiguedeasily,
whilecomputerscanrunnonstop,atpeakperformance,24/7.
Software:
Editability,upgradability,andawiderbreadthofpossibility.Unlikethehumanbrain,
computersoftwarecanreceiveupdatesandfixesandcanbeeasilyexperimentedon.The
upgradescouldalsospantoareaswherehumanbrainsareweak.Humanvisionsoftwareis
superblyadvanced,whileitscomplexengineeringcapabilityisprettylow-grade.Computerscould
matchthehumanonvisionsoftwarebutcouldalsobecomeequallyoptimizedinengineeringand
anyotherarea.
Collectivecapability.Humanscrushallotherspeciesatbuildingavastcollectiveintelligence.
Beginningwiththedevelopmentoflanguageandtheformingoflarge,densecommunities,
advancingthroughtheinventionsofwritingandprinting,andnowintensifiedthroughtoolslike
theinternet,humanityscollectiveintelligenceisoneofthemajorreasonswevebeenabletoget
sofaraheadofallotherspecies.Andcomputerswillbewaybetteratitthanweare.Aworldwide
networkofAIrunningaparticularprogramcouldregularlysyncwithitselfsothatanythingany
onecomputerlearnedwouldbeinstantlyuploadedtoallothercomputers.Thegroupcouldalso
takeononegoalasaunit,becausetherewouldntnecessarilybedissentingopinionsand
motivationsandself-interest,likewehavewithinthehumanpopulation. 10
AI,whichwilllikelygettoAGIbybeingprogrammedtoself-improve,wouldntseehuman-level
intelligenceassomeimportantmilestoneitsonlyarelevantmarkerfromourpointofviewand
wouldnthaveanyreasontostopatourlevel.Andgiventheadvantagesoverusthatevenhuman
intelligence-equivalentAGIwouldhave,itsprettyobviousthatitwouldonlyhithumanintelligencefor 394,313 35,451
108,768
abriefinstantbeforeracingonwardstotherealmofsuperior-to-humanintelligence.
Thismayshocktheshitoutofuswhenithappens.Thereasonisthatfromourperspective,A)whilethe
intelligenceofdifferentkindsofanimalsvaries,themaincharacteristicwereawareofaboutany
animalsintelligenceisthatitsfarlowerthanours,andB)weviewthesmartesthumansasWAY
270.5ksmarterthanthedumbesthumans.Kindoflikethis:
SoasAIzoomsupwardinintelligencetowardus,wellseeitassimplybecomingsmarter,forananimal.
Then,whenithitsthelowestcapacityofhumanityNickBostromusesthetermthevillageidiot
wellbelike,Ohwow,itslikeadumbhuman.Cute!Theonlythingis,inthegrandspectrumof
intelligence,allhumans,fromthevillageidiottoEinstein,arewithinaverysmallrangesojustafter
hittingvillageidiotlevelandbeingdeclaredtobeAGI,itllsuddenlybesmarterthanEinsteinandwe
wontknowwhathitus:
Andwhathappensafterthat?
AnIntelligenceExplosion
Ihopeyouenjoyednormaltime,becausethisiswhenthistopicgetsunnormalandscary,andits
gonnastaythatwayfromhereforward.IwanttopauseheretoremindyouthateverysinglethingIm
goingtosayisrealrealscienceandrealforecastsofthefuturefromalargearrayofthemost
respectedthinkersandscientists.Justkeeprememberingthat.
Anyway,asIsaidabove,mostofourcurrentmodelsforgettingtoAGIinvolvetheAIgettingthereby
self-improvement.AndonceitgetstoAGI,evensystemsthatformedandgrewthroughmethodsthat
didntinvolveself-improvementwouldnowbesmartenoughtobeginself-improvingiftheywantedto.
3
394,313 35,451
108,768
Andhereswherewegettoanintenseconcept:recursiveself-improvement.Itworkslikethis
AnAIsystematacertainlevelletssayhumanvillageidiotisprogrammedwiththegoalof
improvingitsownintelligence.Onceitdoes,itssmartermaybeatthispointitsatEinsteinslevelso
nowwhenitworkstoimproveitsintelligence,withanEinstein-levelintellect,ithasaneasiertimeandit
270.5k
canmakebiggerleaps.Theseleapsmakeitmuchsmarterthananyhuman,allowingittomakeeven
biggerleaps.Astheleapsgrowlargerandhappenmorerapidly,theAGIsoarsupwardsinintelligence
andsoonreachesthesuperintelligentlevelofanASIsystem.ThisiscalledanIntelligenceExplosion,
11
anditstheultimateexampleofTheLawofAcceleratingReturns.
ThereissomedebateabouthowsoonAIwillreachhuman-levelgeneralintelligence.Themedianyear
onasurveyofhundredsofscientistsaboutwhentheybelievedwedbemorelikelythannottohave
reachedAGIwas2040 12 thatsonly25yearsfromnow,whichdoesntsoundthathugeuntilyou
considerthatmanyofthethinkersinthisfieldthinkitslikelythattheprogressionfromAGItoASI
happensveryquickly.Likethiscouldhappen:
IttakesdecadesforthefirstAIsystemtoreachlow-levelgeneralintelligence,butitfinallyhappens.A
computerisabletounderstandtheworldarounditaswellasahumanfour-year-old.Suddenly,within
anhourofhittingthatmilestone,thesystempumpsoutthegrandtheoryofphysicsthatunifies
generalrelativityandquantummechanics,somethingnohumanhasbeenabletodefinitivelydo.90
minutesafterthat,theAIhasbecomeanASI,170,000timesmoreintelligentthanahuman.
Superintelligenceofthatmagnitudeisnotsomethingwecanremotelygrasp,anymorethana
bumblebeecanwrapitsheadaroundKeynesianEconomics.Inourworld,smartmeansa130IQand
stupidmeansan85IQwedonthaveawordforanIQof12,952.
WhatwedoknowisthathumansutterdominanceonthisEarthsuggestsaclearrule:withintelligence
comespower.WhichmeansanASI,whenwecreateit,willbethemostpowerfulbeinginthehistoryof
lifeonEarth,andalllivingthings,includinghumans,willbeentirelyatitswhimandthismighthappen
inthenextfewdecades.
Ifourmeagerbrainswereabletoinventwifi,thensomething100or1,000or1billiontimessmarter
thanweareshouldhavenoproblemcontrollingthepositioningofeachandeveryatomintheworldin
anywayitlikes,atanytimeeverythingweconsidermagic,everypowerweimagineasupremeGodto
havewillbeasmundaneanactivityfortheASIasflippingonalightswitchisforus.Creatingthe
technologytoreversehumanaging,curingdiseaseandhungerandevenmortality,reprogrammingthe
weathertoprotectthefutureoflifeonEarthallsuddenlypossible.Alsopossibleistheimmediateend
ofalllifeonEarth.Asfaraswereconcerned,ifanASIcomestobeing,thereisnowanomnipotentGod
onEarthandtheall-importantquestionforusis:
WillitbeaniceGod?

ThatsthetopicofPart2ofthispost.
___________
SourcesatthebottomofPart2.
RelatedWaitButWhyPosts
TheFermiParadoxWhydontweseeanysignsofalienlife?
How(andWhy)SpaceXWillColonizeMarsApostIgottoworkonwithElonMuskandonethat
reframedmymentalpictureofthefuture.
Orforsomethingtotallydifferentandyetsomehowrelated,WhyProcrastinatorsProcrastinate
AndheresYear1ofWaitButWhyonanebook.
Like 188K Share 7points 383 61,604
StumbleUpon 394,313 35,451
108,768
270.5k
PreviousPost NextPost
RECOMMENDEDPOSTS
WhyCryonicsMakes EverythingYouShould HorizontalHistory

Sense KnowAboutSound
419 Comments Sort by Oldest
Add a comment...
Home Archive
WaitButWhy2017
Contact PartnerWithUs
PrivacyPolicy

The Artificial Intelligence Revolution - Part 1 - Wait But Why

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

The Artificial Intelligence Revolution - Part 1 - Wait But Why

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

20/03/2017 The Articial Intelligence Revolution: Part 1 - Wait But Why

about archive minis theshed dinnertable store supportwbw Search

SEND ME NEW POSTS

WhyCryonicsMakes EverythingYouShould HorizontalHistory

419 Comments Sort by Oldest

You might also like