Ationa Hernander
Peer - Donna Boo
UWP 1: Expository Writing
Instruetor: Jonathan Radocay
Peer Review and Revision Worksheet 10/11/2017
Instructions:
Reviewing: Carefully review the two drafts from your classmates. Then reread the essays and
complete a review sheet for each one. Plan to allow time to review worksheets and drafts with
writer.
Revising: Consider and discuss the comments you receive. You do not need to make all (or any)
recommended changes, but you should consider them.
1. In your own words, what is the author’s literacy “problem”? Does this problem unfold and
resolve as the narrative proceeds? Why or why not? In other words, does the introduction
clearly present the writer’s goal or main idea? If so, please write the main idea of the essay
PelOW. “The author Wes Wot Takoentel Tate Ferny Watt Kr. Rivas
Witrobuted per Torte this would, The problem wes wefold
TEA parramive pridlterds Looks eolou the pees, Rid pasts
Ue how the problem stosbTictredaet aud solved.
The metho, gave a Tutereeting oad Clete Tuts ductile
irtemy conte wclsleiea
2, Are the key thomsits in Mleracy development adeseaily stbstindved Wil solid and
concrete examples? How well does the writer describe these key moments?
ae WE developed Wrtt. Oret Cvou $,
= e 3 oe
3. Does the narrative smoothly transition in and/or out of analysis? How well does it flow from
one idea to the next? In other words, is the structure of the literacy narrative logical, and do
you think the writer made good organizational choices?
Yes
4, Are there any areas of analysis or examples that seem unclear or are difficult to understand?
If so, list them here.‘Are there any areas of analysis or examples that are particularly good and make the paper
stronger? If so, list them here.
College Obes
Does the narrative maintain your interest, and is it written in an engaging way? List the most
interesting part(s).
ey
Does the conclusion adequately tie the narrative up? Does it answer any unanswered
questions? Does it leave the reader with a sense of closure?
Tie tig a week port because FT dott
Fel ow cease of closure -
Comment briefly on the grammar and mechanics.
Jrest