26

,
1
Simon Clarke, Warwick

.

. ,

, ,

.


. 1930,
, ,
(
).

.
-

.

.


,
.

 27

.


(Anderson, 1976).


.
,
,
. ,

. ,

, .
, ,
,

,
.


.

.
,


,
.
, ,
,
,
.

[structural functionalism],
.

,

28

.
.

.
,

,

[civil society]. 0

,

, .
-
,

.
-
.

,
.
,

. 0
.


.

,
.
,

 29

,
,
, .


,
. ,
.
- -

.

,
.

,
,

,

.


,
.
,
,

2.

,
[ ] .


,
.

,

,
30

,
(Negri, 1976,
. 7-8).

,
.
,
,
, . 0

,

.


,
.
-

. ,

.

.

.
,
.

,

.
0 -
Ralph Miliband3.
Miliband
,
.

.
, -
 31

,

. ,

,
(, 1968, .
70). -

. , ,
-
4.
,
.

- ,
.
.

.

III.



.
,
.
,
,

5.
, .

,
.
.
,

( ,
32

), ,
6.
,
.
,

,
.

.

,
,
.

,

(Marx, , . 116)7.

,


[Corn Laws],
. ,

8.
1857 1867


. ,

. ,

.
1857
,
,

, . Gnmdrisse
1857-8,
 33

.
,

. -


,

. ,

, .


,
,
.


(
)9.


,
, Grundrisse
.
, ,
,
,

[positing]
[presuppositions],

Grundrisse, ,
, ,
-
,
, , ,
. ,

,
34

,


.
-
-
,
10.


,
,
.
,
. ,
,


.

,
.
(

) .
,
,
,
. ,
,
,
.


li. ,

. ,
[va-
 35

lorization process]
.



.
,

(,
),
,
(. Coletti, 1972, . 97-108).



.

,
.

,
.

, -
.

,
.
, -

. ,
-
,
.


. , -


.
36

0

12.
,
, .
0
.
,
.
.
,

.
,

.

.

,
,
13.
,

.

,

.
-
,

.
.
 37

-

,
,
. , ,

-
-
,

,

. ,
,
,
-
.


.


.

,

.
,
,
, -
,
,

.

,
, -
.


38

,
14.

, ,
, -
-
.
15,

, ,

16.
,
.
,
,
/ (Althusser Balibar, 1970, . 17).
.
,
.
,
,
.
,

,
.


,
, , .

,

,
,
.


.
 39

Miliband

.



.


,
,
( )

, 17.
, .


.

-,

.

. ,

.
,
. .


.
,
,
18.

(Political Power and Social Classes, . 95). ,
,
,

.
,
40

,
. ,
,
19. ,
,
, .

.
,
( -
),
.


. ,
,

. ,


, -
.

, ,
,
.
,
.
,
,
, , ,
, ,
- -
.


. , -
, ...
(Marx, 1973, . 485).
,
 41

,
,
.
,-

. ,
(Marx, 1962, . 90).
,
,
. ,


.



.

.
, ,

, --
( , Verwertung) . -

.
,
,
.
, , ,
,


. ,
,
.

,
.



42

,
. ,

,
.
,
, , ,
[ ]

20. -


.

,

.

(,
, , , ..)
21.
,
,
,
.

,
.

,
, .
-
.
,
' ,
a priori (Marx,
1962b, . 456).
. , -
, ,
, [speculative] .
 43

V.
.

oj [integrationist] -
.

, , -
.
,
. ,
. ,
,
, , ,
, , , .

-
.
,
.

.
--
(Political Power and Social Classes,
. 37), ,
22.


...
(.., . 44-45)23.
,
(, ),

, -
.

,

(.., . 50-56)24.

44

:
,
.

25. 0


,
.
...
...

,
(.., . 127).
,


.

. ,

. ,

26. ,
,
. -

,
,-
.
, ,
,
.

. ,

, .
,
 45

, ,


( .., . 53). ,


(
)
(.., . 128).
, ,
.
,
,
.
,
,
.

.
,

. , ,
,
, ,

. ,


, . ,
,

,
. ,
,
,
,
,
(Pashu-
kanis, 1951, . V).
, ,
46

.

'

, ,

... ...
(Political Power and Social Classes, . 207).
,

.

(.., . 208)27. -

. ,

. , -
,

,
, 28.

. ,
,
.

, []
. , ,

.
.
,
,
(..,
. 51, 54, 115). , ,

. ,
,
.
 47

,
, ( )
,
(.., . 209).
'
,
.
,

.

VI.


. ,
(.., . 62-
66)29. , , ,
,
.
, ,

.
,

, ,

, -
- .

.

.
, ,
.
,

(../. 63),
, ,
.
48

.
, , ,
.
,
(Classes in Contemporary Capitalism, . 18)30. ,
,

, .
,
,


. ,

,
(Political Power and Social Classes, . 70).
, ,

( . . 62-64).
,
,
-
.

.
() .
,
,
.

.

,
,
-
.

,
 49

. ,

,
(.., . 77-
85). ,
,

. , ,
,
(.., .
107).
,
,
( )
( . ., . 112).
,

,

,

. -
,

,
,

,

,
.

,
. ,

, ,
31.

,
.
50

. ,

. ,

, , ,
(.., . 248-249). ,
.
,
.
, ,
, ,

.


,

32. ,
, ,
, . ,

,

,
. ,
,

:



.

.
, ,
.

- .
,
 51

,
.

.
,

.
,

.

,
.
.
,
, .
,
,
(Marx 1962a, . 96).
, , ,
Weston ,


(Marx 1962c, . 401-408).
,


.

, , ,
. -
,

.
,
.

,
,
.
52

,

.

,

,
.

,
, ,
,

.

, ,

.
,
.
, ,

. -
.

,

. , ,

,
,

,
.


,
,
 53

(Political Power and Social Classes, .

102).

,
33,
- - ,
.

,
.

VII.

-
.

,
.
.
,
. ,

.
(
),
, ,
,
,

. , ,

(.., . 274),
.

,
,

,
,
54

.
,

.
,
(.., . 42, 46,
76, 93-95, 187)34. ,

. ,

.
, -
,
. ,

.

.
,
, .

, -

. ,
(.., . 99, 104-112)35.
,
,
.

.

,
,
.
,
(.., . 100, 115-116).


(.., . 53, 137, 187). ,
 55

, ...

- , ...
, ,

.
, .

,
-
, . 0

(.., . 130-137)36. ,
,


(.., . 137-141).
. 0

,

,
.


(.., 191-194).
,

,

(.., . 282). ,

,
(.., . 256-257, 282-288, 299)37.
,
,
,

.

 55

...

- , ...
. ,

.
, .

,
-
, . 0

('... . 130-137)36. ,
,


(.., . 137-141).
. 0

,

,
.


(.., 191-194).
,

,

(.., . 282). ,

,
(.., . 256-257, 282-288, 299)37.
,
,
,

.

56

,
.
,
,
, -
. ,



,
. 0
,
,
.

0
.

. 0

,
38.
- ,

.
,
, ..,

.
.
,

. ,
.
, .

,
.
,

.
 57

.

,

.
-
.
,

,
, ,
,

.

VIII.

[integrationism]


. ,
-
. ,
, -
- .


.
.

.
,
,
.

.


,
58

.

.
-
39,

.

, (Political
Power and Social Classes, . 157-167). To

,
,
.

-
-
.

,
.

,
.

.


,

.

. ,
.

 59

,
. ,

(
),
.


( ,
).

...

.

(, )
:

(.., . 160-161).


, -
.
,
,
.
,
. ,
, , ,
, .
,
, ,
, ,
.
-
, - -
,
.

-
60

. ,
,
. ,


,
,
,
,
.

,
40.

,

,
,
.
, ,

.

.

,
.
,
,
...
(.., . 38, 40, 60, 195-206, 208).


,
.


. , ,
, ,
 61

,

.
,
,
. -
,
.
, ,
41.
,
,
(

) .

. ,


,
.

IX.

,
(Althusser, 1973, . 48-49).

,
,
. ,
,
,
(Poulantzas, 1973).


.

0

62

.

,
,

( , . 18, 20, 21)42.

,
,
.
.
,

,
. ,

,

, .

.


. ,
,
.

,
.

,
,

,
. ,
, -

. ,

 63

.
,

.



43, -

44,
.


, . ,


,
.
,
.

.

X. : 0
,
.
,
.

,
,
.
- .
,
,

,
.

64

. , -
[integrationist]
. ,

.
,
. ,

,

, , ,
, .


. ,

. , -
.

, -
,

(Coser, 1956).

,
,
, (Political
Power and Social Classes, . 208).
,
.

.
, ,

45
,
,
.

,
 65

,
,
,
,
. ,


1960, -

,

.

.

.


. 0

,
,

.
, .

.
: .

/
66

Althusser, L. (1 9 6 9 ) F o r M a r x . L ondon.
Althusser, L. (1971) L e n in a n d P h ilo so p h y a n d O th er E s s a y s . London.
Althusser, L. and Balibar, E . (1970) R e a d in g C a p ita l. L ondon.
A nderson, P. (1976) C o n sid era tio n s on W estern M a r x is m . L ondon.
Balibar, E . (1973) Self Criticism , T h eoretical P ra c tic e , 7/8.
B anaji, J. ( ) M o d e s o f P ro d u c tio n in a M a te r ia list C on ception
o f H isto r y (m im eo).

Clarke, S. (1976) A lth u sse ria n M a r x is m , (m im eo).

Colletti, L. (1972) F r o m R o u s se a u to L e n in . L ondon.
Coser, L. (1 9 5 6 ) T he F u n c tio n s o f S o cial C o n flict. London.
Cutler, A. (1971) F ascism an d Political T heory . T h eoretical P ra ctice , 2.
E ngels, F. (1 9 6 2 ) K arl M arx, A C o n trib u tio n to the C ritiq u e o f P o litic a l E c o
n o m y , K . M arx an d F. E ngels: Selected W orks, Vol. 1, Moscow.

G lucksm ann, A. (1972) A Ventriloquist Structuralism , N e w L e ft R eview , 72.

H ilferding, R. (1 9 4 9 ) B o h m -B aw e rk s Criticism of K arl M arx , E.
B ohm -B aw erk: K a r l M a r x a n d the C lose o f h is S y stem , New York.
H indess, B. an d Hirst, P. (1975) P r e - c a p ita lis t M o d e s o f P ro d u c tio n , L ondon.
Itoh, M. (1975) M arxs Theory of C risis , C S E B id le tin , IV, 1.
L aclau, E . (1975) The Specificity of the Political , E c o n o m y a n d Society, 4, 1.
Lenin, V.I. (1961) P h ilo so p h ica l N oteb ook s, C ollected W orks, Vol. 38, Moscow.
M arx, K . ( ). P o v e rty o f P h ilo so p h y , Moscow.
M arx, K . (1 9 6 2 a) W age L a b o u r a n d C a p ita l, in M arx an d E n gels, Selected
W orks, Vol. 1, Moscow.

Marx, K . (1962b ) A fterw ord to the Second Edition of C a p ita l, in M arx an d

E n gels: Selected W orks, Vol. 1, Moscow.
Marx, K . (1962c) W ag es, P ric e a n d P ro fit, in M arx an d Engels, Selected W orks,
Vol. 1, Moscow.
Marx, K . (1973) G ru n d risse . London.
Marx, K . (1976) C a p ita l, Vol. 1. L ondon.
M iliband, R. (1 9 6 9 ) T he S ta te in C a p ita list Society, L ondon.
M iliband, R. (1970) T he Capitalist State , N e w L e ft R ev iew , 59.
 67

Miliband, R. (1973) Poulantzas and the Capitalist State , New Left Review, 82.
Negri, A. (1976) Su r quelques tendances de la thorie com m uniste de F
E tat la p lu s rcente , Revue critique. A C SES Colloque su r l Etat. M im eo.
, Critica dell Diritto, 3.
Pash ukan is, E . B. (1951) General Theory of Law and Marxism (1924, 1927),
B abb: Soviet Legal Philosophy, Boston.
N icolaus, M. (1 9 6 8 ) T he U nknow n M arx , New Left Review, 48.
Nicolaus, M. (1973) Forew ord to Grundrisse, M arx (1973).
Poulantzas, N. (1 9 6 6 ) Vers une thorie m arxiste , Temps Modernes, 240.
Poulantzas, N. (1967) M arxist Political Theory in Great B ritain , New Left
Review,i3.
Poulantzas, N. (1969) The Problem of the Capitalist State, New Left Review, 58.
Poulantzas, N. (1973) Political Power and Social Classes. L ondon.
Poulantzas, N. (1974) Fascism and Dictatorship. London.
Poulantzas, N. (1975) Classes in Contemporary Capitalism. L ondon.
Poulantzas, N. (1976) The Capitalist State: A Reply to Miliband and Laclau.
New Left Review, 95.
Rancire, J. (1974) La leon dAlthusser. Paris.
Rosdolsky, R. (1968) Zur Entstehungsgeschichte des Marxischen Kapital. Frankfurt.
Rubin, I. (1972) Essays on Marxs Theory of Value. Detroit.
Walton, P. an d Gamble, A. (1972) From Alienation to Surplus Value. L ondon.
Wright, E. .., (1975-6) Som e Recent D evelopm ents in the M arxist Theory
of the State , Monthly Review, 27.

/
68

. : : C a p ita l a n d C la s s , . 2, 1977.
2 . Negri (1976). ,
Vic Allen New Left Re
view, . R. M iliband (1969)

(Poulantzas, 1976, . 64),
.
(. . 44 ) (. Poulantzas,
1967).
3 . Poulantzas 1969, 1976
M iliband 1970, 1973.
4 . . , . 9, 21.
5 . , , -
(L. Althusser, 1969, . 166).
.
(1976)
,
.
. .
G lucksm ann (1972) J. Rancire (1974)
. .

(1966).
6 .
(L . A l
thusser an d . Balibar, 1970).
7 .0 B. H indess R Hirst (1975)
,

.
:
, . ,
H in dess H irst
!
8 . ,


... (K . Marx, 1976, . 9 6 ' . M arx, 1973, . 8 3-88).
L. Coletti,
 69

( Coletti, 1972),
,
, .

. -

,
, ,
.
9 .

K . Marx, 1973, . 304-308.
10. ,

, . . M andel, In tro d u c tio n to
M a r x (1976), . 20-21. G ru n d risse , . .
N icolaus (1968, 1973) . Itoh (1975) R. R odolsky

Pluto.
11.
.
.
12. P o litic a l P o w er a n d Social
C la sse s ( ) ,
..
1 3 .0 J. B an aji ( )
,
.
(1938)
14. ,
, (L.
Althusser, 1971, . 82-83). ,



(P o litic a l P o w er a n d S ocial C la sse s, . 86).
15. .
16. . -

, .
70

, .
17. -
. -
, .

Walton A. Gamble (1972, . 110).
0
(1966) (. P o litical P ow er an d Social
C la ss e s , . 40). 0 Rancire (1974, . 2 2 9 -2 3 0 )
.
18. ,
,
.

.
.
,

.
19. ,
,
- - - [structured-in-dom inance].
.
,
, ,
, ,
.

.
2 0 . G ru n d risse (M arx, 1973, . 83-
100 ) .

21. ,



.
-
. . R.
Hill'erding, 1949' 1. Rubin, 1972' . M andel, , 1976,
. 3 8 -4 6 ' L. Coletti, 1972, . 76-97. . . M andel,
, 1976, . 17-25' . Nicolaus, 1973, . 24-44' V. Lenin,
 71

1961 ' F. E ngels, 1962.

, -
,
.
2 2 .0
, ,
.
2 3 .0 ,
, ( Political Power and
Social Classes, . 47, . 17)
(.., . 50).

,
.
(1974, . 3 02).
2 4 .
.
2 5 . Political Power and Social Classes, . 29,

. (1965, . 81' . Political
Power and Social Classes, . 126).
2 6 .0 [hom ologyl
[correspondence] ( Political Power
and Social Classes, . 27, . 11),
.
27. -
.
2 8 .0 . Laclau (1975, . 100-101) . A. Cutler
(1971)

(. 12),
,
.
2 9 . ,
-

( Political Power and Social Classes, . 65).
3 0 .
(Classes in Contemporary Capitalism), -
 72

. ,


( . . , . 221). 0
,

.


.
.
31. ,
,

[estates].
32.
(1969, . 184).
33. ,
( Classes in
Contemporary Capitalism, . 107).
34.0
.
35. . 0

. ,
,

. .
,
.

(Political Power and Social
Classes, . 113). ,
.
36.
(Political Power and Social Classes, .
129), .
,
, ,
,

 73

.
.

.
37.
,
, ,
( P o litic a l P o w e r a n d S o cial C la sse s, . 243-44).
,
,
( P o litic a l P o w er
a n d S o cial C la sse s, . 248-249). ,
,
,
. ,

. ,

,
.
38. ,
,

.

.

( F a s c is m a n d D ic ta to rsh ip , . 11).

.

3 9 . .
,
.

,
. .
,

. .
4 0 . ,

. P o litic a l P o w e r a n d S o cial C la sse s, . 198).
74

.
41. A lthusser (1966),

( )
- ( -
- ) [functionalist-gestaltist]. ,

. ,
.

4 2 .
.
(1973).


,
. 0
.
H indess Hirst
.
4 3 .
(A . Cutler, 1971, . 7-8'
H in dess Hirst, 1975, . 37-39).

. ,
,
- .
44. -
, M iliband (1970, 1973)' .
W right . (1975-1976).
-
.
4 5 .

,
[integrationism |, -

Coser .