International Studies in the History of Rhetoric tor Laurent Pemot, Ecce Eto, Suasoure France Craig Kallendorf, Clee station, USA. Abisory Boat Be Bre whmegen, Nethetands Rudong Chen, Beg, Cina Manfred Kraus, Tobigen, Germany Gabriella Morett, Teno, aly Luisa Angelica Puig Llano, Mexio Gi Mesico Christine Sutherland, Caguy, Canada vous ‘Dh te pubsed sere are Usted at rile Enargeia in Classical Antiquity and the Early Modern Age ‘The Aesthetics of Evidence » Heinrich F, Plete BRILL Lupe « aosrow "12nay go Cg Pan Fate ata hey te es hate tne rcs nan en bi fog Sy la aes coxrits sper minced ae Se regocearees hd pe) — Sings stl) tt ee pice goer (Anat Ga aneeat anata steele: Mrs Rm Cle Been FeO enn 7 Thora say a hee Aclnowlgements = ie haya Ls of listione << 4 mee Intedaeton eer seonitan Peg aa 1 tase Sources and Ther mani Reception ‘hs non ea ening Mp i cars ‘Sram i Get pene ea ar SEAR ate pe hep 1 ara in Humans Wat nd ts Theoret a res ona ener 8 ‘Sverasonraiis eu IL Shakespeare and Erg (A) omnes 5 SECIS ec prob Ou Hd he, ¥ Bape of Paces and Petees movem—nne—nen 37 [Btinties nto ue le \ hqremtion sh hru aa te se ie igo en ey pea Eeecleprec ae ae reel VE The Poet of phrase 87 Shen smirk woe Poe ee ‘atom wasn ty cry tac tol UL Stkespeare and Ena (8) sonnei 6 ‘sein ncn es! wn yor es soso en he aber 7 1X Baargia in Operate Libre chan cy i ma poe rey Kei Bl specs et eae a al uae 1X. Rnarsia ta Maemoner nd Mediation ear an XI Baoan the Visual AsXI Earl and Perspective na XIV. Shakespeare and Ears (C) XV. args Theory and Pre ofthe Vial snd Verbal Are [XVI The Enageia of Music a Theory and Practice a iit ‘nargi and Related Term 86 nnn Index af Names avn Inex of ners FoREWoRD The rset study ha is oii nan nvietion fom Best Hinton pres ent of Geman Neo Latin Soiety (Deutsche Neulteische Gesell [DNG]) to deliver the keynote address at their annual conference om February 209 a he Univer af Bn, That ete te ita ‘Zur Rhetork der Prasene i den Artes der Fen Neuse (vient Cn the Retr of Presence in the Arto he Ely Modern Ae ater re nt a ager work whieh ook ito aesoint many mae eared Sources, anno onl of Noa provenance Since the nal seurcer dite ck wo Classi Aniguly, eiuasly to Grek and Roman ret, itwas an cbviows sep to disuse these thoretal outs ws wel dt rove ilstatons Hom ancien dase "The su isa more exten treatment ofthe top, ut ota ae tive on the Intetion Is rater to slate and ve futher states to A the lcanae that te undobtedy prem Mes ely thee ean ‘ot be completly smite fort bso slew to whi hee ‘ie belong depend onthe inentons of ftte generations of erie ‘esearcets au oth contingency they owe their permanent dyna ‘ct Noattenpe willed re to dent sch desert in th spat ‘emporal contra of present dy Scholars. Tat the ears nd ‘emeneae tak of dial env eders regu of hl coun ‘ny of erg, ther language an the age into which Uy are Dore The Study at andi tus canetved 2 yo tothe convertion which the (German looper Hans Georg Gamer considered ae pulile ofhemeneaten sgt eine aes wo ie Reet wer et eed ‘teria da mec Bensbungen get hen ee etn Aue nen de retane Grr in Gspeoh "hot wi ue a Vsti et peck erent ‘These woul be 20ers nd tes tal rtanig nd apoecot dnt am he bs of ba anes ml een i cms of howe ae oni mee At ‘iad lesan woul ave to besoap“i rorewoxn ‘hi emi om Gadaners Rhstone, Hemmeneutes, and Meloieat Cc” ty) atest, nthe, he enence af umanies researc, We ad hee ony the fling Te inet fo hie method Ase om retort ts radon at races back more han hee ‘housand years. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This book would no ave come about witht the ep of many people ‘am esecaly tefl to Myra Sele (Amstelveen and Bete Hine (Goan for ranting lst Sha Bars (Chis) Spe Cane (feims) an Thomas Shen (Sabha for providing relevant wares oF ‘eset erature, ad above alto Renate Pet for er repeted erie ‘evewingof the ene texts fina shape oves eat dey her mary ‘ef sggescos. nally Yann debe to Gen ana foreign Haves fer geeronty making texts apd strtons avalabe tat prove ad enable forthe present ues. tne twenty cetay thea ea ‘Shute of arse supplemented by ich nfrmaton sls access ser of he Inte ee,LUST OF mLusrmaTIONS «Joann Joadum Vincente page (from: okannJschins Winckel, Gadanko aber ae ‘Nochahmang der grchschen Werke der Mares eed ‘lhe se) epee eon Bern 5 Nerden Lcchtensei: Kaus Rep 198 ame », Johann Jochen Winckelmenn, tation ofthe epae (eo: jun ouch Winkcimann. Gone be ae Nchahmang der rcshen Werke der Malet wd Blane 3 Rept of the edton Bern 85: Nendla/ Mechentois Krs Rept 68. 1 Sano Rotel: Le Calum Ape (Contes of Kasson Inst of the Univer of Gta, AS) ne 2. Alves Dares Desir Frama fated (Grom atrce Dare at gr Austeuny des Germanichen ‘Nasonalaseus Neraben Mal bi Ags 7, Minchen: reel 7 febton catalogue) =~ ss Hans Hotbeln: Saar (Prone Eran von tera, Das Lob der Trt. Mit Toleinischen Rapdzechnangen herausgegeben You Ezal Major Buel Bdiwes, pes) “ln Adaph ase or) (From Bookdet accompanying aud-CD of eegrnt a Spoke dt Nose Signore [Nets Tas 5455202 98]) | Unonada da Vine Sept (Contes of blocs Reales) ee {Edmund Spenser: The Perales (From The Poms of mand Spenser Fa} Sith Ede Selincourt Londo: OUF 11960) umn 1 Nicos Fos: Slt pore. (From: Christopher Wht, Pousin Gemale: cher Wererstns Landsat, ec 198) ee {Nicolas Poussin: The Judgement of Solomon (a9) (From: Ghstopher Wight, Poss Geri riches Weert Landsat, 2001989) one 17Maas raewaldsenhoim ar St Jon poling tthe cred Ost. (Grom: Michal Seber, er enhsimer Altar: Gscikte Deaaung—Hinergrinde, Sttgat Vache 2007) oom so. Rape: Madara da Palin 3) (fom: aes Sarinche Madonna Lterarishe Zeus us ave jbthunderten Gesmamet und einet so Michal Lei: Dora Pt, 2) en = 14, Macias Grtpenald,Iebeim aa Te Amancio (from: MicaelSehuber, Der benkemer Altar Gescihie— Deatyg—Hintergrnie Sagat: aca, 397) 1, Glovan Hata Pag: Sek porvalt wi pera o as sche: {roms Jodl Ganson. ie Pets of Peroni the Ralan onaance, Camb CUP, 300) vane 1g: Vaca Cranach the Fer: "Venna Cision? (Couresy of Ake Paka Manehen) an ~ 4 embran:The Menno preacher lay Al ar his wife (From: Amy Golan. Rombrand adn The Arts ‘Boothe of cet Poetry and History. Amer: Amer Univer Prev 3009) oe 1. Cares Letra: Pore (Couey of tesidenzlne, Stabe) ne 18 Albrecht Date Mdemena 7 (Prom: Abc Dare 9p Austell des Genmaniacen Nationale Winery ai bis ‘Ags 7 MUncben: Pest rgfeshibiton eto) Francicus Lang De wfc tte (From: Frans Lang Abhanding er de Shoup ‘perstat und herougogebeo von Alexander Ran. Bem / Minchen: Pranche 7) ‘A. Claio Monteverde page ofthe mare (Fron brat acompanyng the fst ecordng of Montevers Ort by Sicelts Harmencoart [Teleunken eee 96)) ws 55, we ivtropuction ‘he ope of thi dy not erly new ler to stad tha teacher afar barks lac Greco Roman Any. Te ntenton bore |S to explore that wailon, but nthe frm of = monograph Fora the appended iba ndcates, varios ales have alendy appeared ‘onthe topk though away wth nite itr sepents as the oc Purhermor, several analogs presen a rosd spectrum of ef ons| om enarela The vohmes Die ede od Cas Ly & Let Pe ot) from 9, Rats of Dp awn Pe rom e620 dnt fed. GasieleWiebock, Karn Leonhard & Markus Fi) from aor conan forthe mor part otstandig cnn, "A mavogaphi teament af the concept of enargela or oiler reques« coberent presentation. Thi not way to alee give the teen the ane and orl hore wing to practi eeu ‘nan the ther to fog eink between he varus verbal, hl ad tonalartcs. Separate sections are devoted to each ofthese, which some casts ive themati ovelp. One stance of ach an ove found isthe dscasion of pte pees. Thee can be no doe about ‘he telly relations’ beeween erate andthe sil ats, atc inthe Early Moder Age As Wim Wins. and Cleanth Brooke ‘pressed 50 plate in el hoy of tery ees ey relatos Detmen pst athe wl a mee oa ‘Sted drag the th entay by agra tuo, Sn Helin nl ee oe sain of oie lesa sap ol nd meds nh oepopae agmae anwktheC r f oy d Eed of Pape, op Spee Tore wt ao the fh tation of cea py by vig dunes aed tas ai lg ae Shy cay pr ch om "he Count Co ater Te ads de Pn de wie wd add Vp-p Sch ten wae hee ft ache { Wincannons Cdon hr Rarng dr pcos Mer de Nal het The se hope is ok nan sion of shes laud putes a woo st feel pages, Aponemnon ding sa hater on he ge tthe punters ete een eon he ayy Sop En esc ann pre dc pay by Hp a sgt hi Sak beter hmm pp pk Tespree ofthe tes bossa mee psptn in 6 be mart totale of hein pe erento recede. he Despite the importance Wimsatt and Brooks abe tothe selaton beeen ieatre and the van as hi ot he main concer of te Stuy at hand. The thera oes bere is much move onthe with i aby to cae the tmapotion of uth restr of at aed tt ecplnts Not el dene, painted or texted nage re cent ttie “Asus, but metal images which bah precede the ote iages fd are generated by them Becae ttre by reaton of oii ie pmanye matter of he word, paral interesting fo ety in eich the evocation of ment unages na ha see the wud ar: tpl pes Al the impor pet ofthe Easy Modern Age ake lea we of setrealonargoi in det ag abou an eective in tao naterae Bec ths const noting ative presence of the Alverbed mbjec the eat ein deep env relia ithe gest Her ‘ny work ofthe age: ftom Lodonco Ass Oran Pur the Pty fa he Pade, lian Staspear’s Halt and Job Mikes Pradee lst to the ode fan Dryden ard Frese Gotlieb Klopstoc ‘Te vere a of Willan Shakespeare occupies a spec lace nthe aly Modern Agesnce ths English deatsmore han ay there rats of aterm eof enargia ta sti devo. Jo the ‘American compese Pp Gls inserted ‘Kee Flys tos opera The (oa Was a work oeeastaned by the 984 Summer Opies the chapters devoted Shakespeare are not diresions btn asl terminology ‘ind fore passages that ee peeing the sue aor but ead Se acing ler facet hr work These section can hereire brendan thei ovn, oe ater the oe. The fl igcence however, becomes apparent only in the contest of Ue lage dein. ‘While the mais focus of thi book son Clase Antieley and the aly Modem Ags thi dos no nan that nara played no en the ‘arte in the Middle Agro a tnoera or portnodem ines. Cite on ‘he contane alo deeply rooted In thos ctrl eps a arous ‘nasal sues hav shown, While thi uggs a nares souk Ise eve to the sats of + unk pencpe of represen this 18 ot the aim ofthe present stu. Is meh more concerned with “ule ae Gt as Csi ha Hy Now a ee, epee te Suimesee Bey gre. Jann Joc Winkle pgeFe. Joing och Welln ataton resenting dis concep a fenton In sgcant epochs of Easy ‘ean care, both in theories and in concrete examples of he vastus fare. The approach can Defoe be described as comparative. Pht to the discon is he des Norman F Land expe in his Dok le The Viewer as Poet (og) For the present undertaking could be fr Imulated move grea ab Uh eer ar art” wih "eri sabeming ‘epreenatives ofall he ert: oto, port, pater nuns Bu lst as wal be phased The recent as vewer wih the pled “tel? derstood ota opi bt ingiatve Perper ‘ion comes covert to aptring the uence of enargea cones con sidered equally sndamental forthe succes eaton and reepion of {sin he Yarous media. Retetaly speaking it sicace fi {othe momess oncepn Ast. contemporary Geraan piu, Towever drachauung—the Geran county of he Greck engl the Latin elena nt dense in elton otto ncn ‘onto he specie of te Neve Hef fr nope of ye devoted to Anschotng ale dsthetiche Kategorie” Ths rhetorical connection rot however, nthe aesthetics of Atexader Gated Baumgaten {he sapnaatonal tsk flog schol today is heer io reomsrct ‘hs elon by coining a sty of here! documents witha clemipes. Inthe yar 7 the Royal Peston Academy n Ben published nun ber paper unde he ie Disertationes ad guest de EVIDENT ab fede Ri Berlin propostaespetantes The it prob hy moa interesting of hee wots onthe tpi fede I nt ‘lg Disrtaide endef eu on mathematic ad del oie ‘vith the dln of maps and theology The remaining papers {result devoted to the humanities, butt ther dines arly ‘eter and oratory, ows and poet a theory an both pling and seule, muse theory ant compsison all s practised in the Early Moder Age. Even the Ate tgs) of AxanderGotle Baun ten (7-162), the List modem work an axes a «pilot {al diciptine connie a ston (88 847-8) on evden west [Rhetone however as the og ofthe coneps daa erage ‘occupies a cental postion i bt works fr fom the ier t the ‘ehnenh entry formed the Fondation of thee sud hamantan ‘he canes cane waced back Greck and Homan weting handed low tow rors Clncl Antiquity I herfre with a dsm of ‘ore sures that th dy wl bog ae en eee mii aandia ithe meamectnmer an eprint eas TEE ae nun sso ie oie arpa ome ae Excise Pcie Beier ee cae Secioss Seca See eer Sey mn pl at‘CLASSICAL SOUNCES AND THE HUMANIST RECEPTION in Book i fis tno Ort the Roman hetoriin Quinlan (e. Meas Fabius Quintana ea, -ca 9) deserbes bow be woul ro ‘ved in cou es he publ prosecutor ia order see ec gure: on ela qe a pra cine i ‘cis nabs on foresee seis eampe” no euro ‘eatin xmas oa ae on ren Sree Viet a imo mags et pale ems crema re sp Supine | compuinng ht sonar he bes me Am 919 sey my as rams iho ae pened cing event Wille sean ut sensed erin wen ey fora eer a tr mary oy 0 ape? ‘Suntan ang tw Sd the thes ing? Wi texte tephra he py of gaa ‘nym? a ‘he erator who incapable of eich an nga ete called by Quine tian euphantsieten, dt Se “oe whe exceptionally god a real Cally imagining to himself hing word, and ation (Rl, The ek ofthis acy I “enarge wat Ceo calle dati nd enon 4 quay which make ns seem not x0 much to betaling at some things exbtng (Lg). Anoter Latin sponge or enargi e * Quan th nn, itd dtd by ool as 5 ‘nae oon nao gp ose uae ‘Tapa ina Geyer hp fn Cnt apr ihe ee ei rns Goce eo ne ‘Teme limite 1, St ut at Ke enti. que xin Gece meee TRE tet tre ten oy gn ‘Trencphanc 2 sey gue a vdeo ee Fei ascrects erage nae aa5 cuarrmone demonstra, fox whit the Rhtrice a Heron (v.68) provides {he following definite Boosie ce a veri expire mete re ae bedar ene estar en ptt et pot tne rt nat copes st es oem ot ea ‘no rende Bris Seamste beac an thei te ps vy bre auree> The car act by cling wht pce lla dss Pantene et or by epg ey tos conseuenes he ‘Start ckcumdtces nit denoting ht nit ome fst peso ma t sdw er aly ai Th cme ha pry heh se ion at mae tee of ermal (nape sta) ‘Soni rt somes itt ofa Te wy chance ar noe hence ithe Tn Vt uc tr, ih te omen son ena) aan Quan aan xp face ope then bt sip lg tp Soe abe ht agate co tte cma one ccna ran po insects a pt Sete As apenas gue retool Ce spre ‘le per domes 2 ona Bammae rcs ear ego to ‘rer re wi hen ans ‘Splsusrun cores nate ote Hoe ae ‘gen hum dcr et set a prokcoan eee ‘apie nia tone} Cnt ae: Uta pce Scenes eracmueeteamomnens 2 Eien meena re meme eed ee eS cece ul des te sont fa ine ‘la iv rt po po One of as cles Map Sate ae aeomaee, SS eel oe ma ncuraamieas anes atone ety oy Ceuissica, SOURCES AND THBIRNIMAANST RAMON etn tient pans pees ica tate aa {ie pononen ent, cn une ns sn i, “cet pants nena ome oper Crt nt aon tu ee uo oe “omar rea it ert er li sb i so ‘gee glade le nt Or VN} No dus seg 1 ty the cy was ome so embice ewan Ip in sch date but ths communi at tere dee a8 tour the emai ye expand eething wih i apt i te oe ‘or the ween vw mes mig ough out abd op {he cae lingo angle sud nade of many en he ind Ital some ete aging dearest ates of ‘Shenae vommen he fen wham a aking showed tose ts ay then wl core the plage of proper sear nce, the ened acy f planes cng oh Daya ing ck 1 more the prises en cha be torte abe ‘ho ws obey ber ch th ean hw vrs gig nae “hover he spd eee Sahoo doen asl comp ‘Rein ie nu se apr esa Screed mang he ats vt they te le wl Sen Sena inet hig he i hat any ceva) Sub pei retorinthen, the wie whale (tr) fa team les relevant than the mali oft pars omnia bea ony the ater nak he subj of eserpion det palpable (mana From Guin: ‘lan frter renaks on eras and ot eden can cone 1. Wi commando betel eehnigus ihe etre t rate ‘gael. ne hati agin senes Ths present the verbal ‘teeanc of martin sch wy tht the event dsr seo ‘happening he et mn belo the inner ee af the eit 2 To the extent dha the orto scene in eating the sion of pes nc he can cam for himsal he aplatoner¢raiaes nt. Viigo). A specie Kind of imagination ie eereby abated othe ‘rte a Lind otto be unrstond a viel inpe—wheten by ‘Apollo othe Musso nthe Chan rte ly Spinto the se ‘Urania (eg nf Mons Parse Lt) Dito oriatig i he rtor hime who arly prodaces tna act of atealeton 5 Qing Phe Otel ht 1 a Aree et on Pet i ns Pn ok