Ulrasound Obstet. Gynecol. 8 (1996) 11-15
Transabdominal fetoscopy in fetal anomalies
diagnosed by ultrasound in the first trimester
of pregnancy
Y. Ville, J. P. Rernard, S. Doumerc, O. Multon, H. Fernandez, R. Frydman and G. Barki
Unite de Médecine Foetale et de Diagnostic Antenatal, Service de Gynécologie Obstétrique hépital A. Béclere,
Clamart, France
Key words: FETOSCONY, FIKSI IKIMESTER, AMNIOCENTESIS, PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS
ABSTRACT
The ability of ultrasound to diagnose fetal anomalies
4s linuted in the carly stages of gestation. We deseribe a
microendoscope thut can be used with an 18-yauge needle
at the time of amniocentesis to provide more precise
diagnostic information when the first-trimester ultrasound
examination suggests problems
INTRODUCTION
The current approach to prenatal diagnosis relies mainly
on high-resolution ulteasonography in the first and second
trimesters of pregnancy. Early prenatal diagnosis by ultua-
sonography is often limited in terms of making a precise
assessment of fetal anomalies and becomes an indication
for further evaluation. This can be done by decailed ultta
sound examination in the second trimester of pregnancy or
by fetoscopy: Rapid advances in diaguostic fetwscopy have
been hindered by its invasiveness: however, we have at
tempted to refine the technology and have developed a
semi-rigid endoscope 1mm in diamerer thar can be used
through an 18-gauge (1.3 mm) needle. This provides a
cleat image uf the external anacomy of the fetus, and per-
mits early fetal rssue sampling
MATERIALS AND METHODS
‘A sern-tigid 0° end-view microendoscope (Miniscope) has
a diameter of 1 mm and is 20 cm in length. It has a 70°
field of view and comprises more than 10 000. picture
clements (pixels). The Miniscope is connected to ite focus-
ing eye piece through a flexible portion 100 em in length
(ART 11510, Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany). The trocar
can be a single 18-gauge needle’ or carry a 20-gauge
(0.9 mm) side operative channel (Figure 1). A 24-gange
needle can therefore be used under full endoscopie vision,
‘The light guide is connected to the ocular and to a xenon
light souree {175 W 615B, Karl Sto12, Tutlingen, Ger
many). The camera used is equipped with a zoom (Telecam
2021001, Karl Storz, Tuttlingen, Germany}. Local analge-
sia is given by injecting 10 ml of 1% non-adrenalized xylo-
subcutaneous tissues down to the
‘myometrium. The needle is then inserted transabdominally
into the amniotic cavity uncer continuous sonographic
guidance. Amniocentesis can be performed either before or
after feroxcopy
caine into the
CASE REPORTS
Case 1
A 25-year-old patient in her second pregnancy was referred
at LL weeks’ gestation with suspected bilateral malposition
of the fetal hands diagnosed by ultrasound (Figure 2a). The
crown-rump length was 50 mm and nuchal tansluceney
Figure 1 Semi rigid Miniscope (1 mm in diameter; 0°, 70° angle
‘of view) (Karl Store, Tutlingen, Germany)
Correspondence: De Ville, Fetal Medicine Unit, St. George's Hospital Medics! School, Cranmer Tesrace London SW17 ORE, UK
Received 4
Revised 29-12-95,
Accepted 194-6‘Transabdominal fetoscopy in first trimester
was Imm, The patient was counselled to have another
scan 2-4 weeks later of fetoscopy at 12 weeks’ gestation.
The pacents opted for fetoscopic evaluation. This was cat-
ried out with the Miniscope as described above and, at the
same time, a sample of 15 ml of clear amniotic fluid was
raken for karyoryping, Fetoscopic examination confirmed
bilateral club hands and hypoplastic forcarms, (Figures 2b
and 2c); the fetal face and lower limbs appeared to be
normal. The fetal karyotype was known 8 days later and
was 47,XX+18. The parents opted for termination of the
pregnancy. Although trisomy 18 is a specific entity, radial
aplasia has been reported antenatally to occur in assucia
tion with thrombocytopenia (thrombocytopenia with ab-
sent radii (TAR) syndrome!!. The patient gave consent for
cordacentesis to be performed before induction, A 24-
gauge needle was passed through the 20-gauge side opera
{a} Club hand suspected by ulteasound at 1 weeks’
Figure 2
gestation; (h) ilareral chub hand and short forearm, as shown by
fetoscopy; (c} drawing of the fetoscopic picture
12 Ultrasound in Obstervice and Gynecology
Ville et a
tive channel, and the cord was punctured under full
endoscopic vision (Figure 3). The procedure was compli
cated by anmiotic fluid concamination causing platelet
aggregation. Termination was achieved with the use of
mifepristone and prostaglandins at 13 weeks’ gestation.
Bilateral club hands with radial aplasia were confirmed
postmortem and 2 small sacral myclomeningocele, which
hhad not been seen on the scan or by fetoscopy, was also
observed.
Case 2
A 37-year-old patient (G3, P2) had had ewo babies affected
by a large midline cleft lip and palate. The anomaly was,
not recognized antenatally in the frst pregnancy and the
lesion was diagnosed at 23 weeks in che second child
Plastic surgery had been performed on three occasions on
both children. This pregnancy was unplanned and the
patient asked for an eazly diagnostic rest as well as arn.
centesis for feral karyorype. Fetoscopic evaluation was
offered at 12. weeks’ gestation, because the scan suggested
Figure 4a). A large median facial
cleft was clearly seen by fetoscopy (Figure 4b); introduction
of the tip of the miniscope in the fetal mouth strongly
suggested a defect of both upper lip and palate, The couple
asked for termination of the pregnancy, but declined the
use of prostaglandins. Dilatation and curettage were per-
formed under general anesthesia. Pathological examination
confirmed the fetal facial defect but did not provide a
complete postmortem informations the fetal karyotype was
AGXY.
recurrence of facial clef
Case 3
A 27-year-old primigravida underwent ultrasound exan
nation at 9 weeks’ gestation for precise dating of the preg-
Abnormal bulging of the fetal cranium was
diagnosed and frontal encephalocele was strongly sus-
pected (Figure Sa). The patient was counselled to have
another scan 2-4 weeks later or fetoscopy at 11 weeks’
gestation. Fetoscopy was performed with the miniscope
after local analgesia, as already described, and amnio-
Figure 3
Umbilical cord sampling at 13 weeks’ gestation under
endoscopic vision. The needle approaches the cord (left) and punc:
toes the voi (rightTransabdominal feroscopy in first trimester
Figure4 (a) Ultrasound examination of the fetal face at 12
weeks’ gestation. A lateral facial cleft is suspected (caliper); (b)
‘endoscopic vision of a large median cleft of the upper lip and
palate (arrowhend);(c} drawing ofthe ftoscopie picture
centesis was performed at the same time. A. frontal
encephalocele was confirmed (Figure Sb); in addition, a
midline facial clef way found, bur no ocher anomaly could
be seen. The patient requested termination of the preg-
nancy and declined the use of prostaglandins. Dilatation
and cnrertage were performed under general anesthesia,
Postmortem examination confirmed the association of
encephalocele and facial cleft, but could not provide
further details on the fetal anatomy. The fetal karyotype
was 46.XX,
DISCUSSION
Historically, embryoscopy was first performed transcervi
cally, with the use of various types of hysteroscopes, rang-
ing in diameter from 2.2 to 10 mm*', The scope was
Ville etal
passed under ultrasound guidance into the exocelomic
cavity, without disturbing the amnion. This technique can
not be used after I weeks’ gestation, when the exocelomic
space is reduced and trauma to the amnion becomes more
likely. Embryoscopy is therefore confined to the diagnosis
of severe syndromes that show external structural
anomalies with a high risk of recurrence, Ultrasound ex:
amination of the fetus is best performed after 11-12 weeks?
gestation and is currently offered for precise dating of
Pregnancy and as part of screening programs for fetal
aneuploidies. The most common abnormalities diagnosed
or suspected at this stage of pregnancy include exencephaly
cr anencephaly, abnormal nuchal thickness (eystic hygro
‘maca 01 nuchal wauslucency),exomphalos, facial cleft, ab-
normal position of the limbs and hydrops fetalis
Complete examination of a 12 weeks’ fetus by ultra-
sound is very unlikely, and lethal or complex anomalies a¢
wel as isolated structural defects can be associated with
ther abnormalities that may not be recognized by ultra
sound examination. One option is to wait for a detailed
ultrasound examination in the second trimester, but this is
rarely welcomed by the parents whose anxiety calls for
rapid and complete fetal evaluation, especially when tui
nation of pregnancy isa possible option
Confirmation of prenatally diagnosed anomalies is
critical for effective patient counselling. However, when
termination of the pregna
trimester, some patients will decline the burden of &
minilabor induced by prostaglandins, and dilatation
aspiration techniques leave very little material for post
y ig requested in the first
Precise assessment of the fetal anatomy should be ar
sied uu prive w evacuation, and wransabdominal fecoscopy
is another option’’. Further development and refinement
of this technology have allowed direct visualization of the
ferns witha fiberoptic endoscope that could be directed in
the amniotic cavity theough a 19-20-gauge needle" and
performed at the time of amniocentesis. However, micro:
endoscopy with a flexible 750-um endoscope has several
limitations: che resolution depth is short (up to 10 mm), the
field of view is very narrow (approximately $ mm at 1 cm)
and the light is often insufficient. These limitations result
from a compromise between the number of optic and light
fibers thar the endoscope can accommodate (currently
3000 fibers). Therefore, visualization of the fetal anatomy
can only be partial and ie dependent on high-resolution
ulrasound co divect the needle wowace (etal part under
investigation. The new microendoscope (Miniscope) pre
sented here allows a better visualization with an increased
depth (1-3 cm) and a 70° angle of view (2.cm field at 1em
depth). Furthermore, the light delivered by the light source
ives a clear innage of the fetus, and the procedure can
therefore be shortened.
There are several concerns regarding the use ofthis new
method of investigation,
1} Care should be taken in making a diagnosis of fetal
anomaly in the first trimestec!. This i particularly
important since, even in the first trimester, fetoscopy
Ultrasound im Obstetrics and Gynecology 13Transabdominal fetoscopy in first trimester
Figure 5
gestation; [b} endoscopic vision of the encephalocele (arrowhead)
(a} Suspected encephalocele by ultrasound at ¥ weeks
(¢) drawing of che fetoscopic pictur; (d) visualization of a facial
cleft (arrowhead); (e) drawing of the fetoscopic picture
offers only an incomplete evaluation of fetal anatomy.
rormalities of the internal fetal anatomy
Associated al
can be missed by ultrasound in the first trimester. For
example, spina bifida was missed in case 1, because of
the position of the fetus. Firsttrimester ferascopy is
directed towards a very limited part of the fetus, and
rmust be carried out under ultrasound control.
The possible risks to the developing retina from expo:
sure to embryoscopic or fetoscopic white light are still
under question; however no retinal damage or other
developmental abnormalities could be demonstrated
in chicken’ or sheep!” embryos. Human data are still
limited, bur infants born after first-trimester trans-
cervical embryoscopy did not demonstrate any visual
abnormality"
(3) The risk of abortion following the procedure is,
at present unknown. Before the development of high-
alteasonogeaphy, transabdominal_ fetos-
copy!!! was performed with the use of 6mm and
22m endoscopes for exataination of the human
fetus in combination with fetal blood sampling or fetal
biopsy; however, fetal loss rates were as high as 4-8%.
The procedure-related risk of miscarriage for the
14 Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology
Ville etal
present technique is probably nor much greater than
that of firs-trimester amniocentesis (2-3% increased
risk)", The semi-flexible microendoscope is passed
through an 18-gauge needle and adds an extra 1 min
to the procedure of amniocentesis, which can be per
formed at the same time, Fetoscopy should therefore
taut add siucls ww the background risk of amniocentesis,
performed at the same gestational age. However, this
remains to be demonstrated and patients should be
counselled accordingly, especially if this technique
finds widespread application in early fetal diagnosis
and therapy".
REFERENCES
I. Labeuney P., Pons, J.C., Khalil, M., Mislsse, V., Imbert,
M.C., Odievee, M., Daffos, F., Tehernia, G. and Frydman, R
1993}. Antenatal thrombocytopenia in three patients with
‘TAR syndrome. Prenat. Diagn, 13, 463-6
2, Westin, B, (1954), Hysteroscopy in early pregnancy. Lancet,
2.872
Roume, I, Aubry, M.C, Labbe, F, Dumez, Y., Aubry, JP
and Henrion, R. (1985). Prenatal diagnosis of limb and digital
abnormalities: evaluation from 1979 t0 1983, J. Genet. Hum,
33,457-61Transabdominal fetoscopy in first rimester
4. Dumez, ¥., Dommergues, M., Gubler, M.C., Bunduki, V.,
Narey, F, Lemerrer, M., Mandelbrot, L. and Berkowitz, R
(1994), Meckel Gruber syndrome: arenatal diagnosis at 10
menstrual weeks using embryoscopy. Prenat. Digg, I, 141-4
45. Reece, E. A, (1992). Embryoscopy: new developments in pre-
natal medicine. Curr. Opin. Obstet. Gynecol. 4 447-55
6. Hobbins, J.C., Jones, O. W., Gottesfeld, S. and Persutte, W.
(1994), Transvaginal ultrasonography ‘and transabdominal
embryoscopy in the frst trimester diagnosis of Smith-Leml
Opitz syndrome type Ml. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol, 171, 545-9
7. Quinteto, R.A. Abuhamad, A., Hobbins J.C. and Mahoney,
MM. J. (1995). Transabdominal thin-gauge embryofetoscopy: a
technique for early prenatal diagnosis and its use in the
nosis of a case of Meckel Gruber syndrome. Am, J. Obstet.
Gynecol, 168, 1552-7
8. Pennchouat, G. H., Lhebault, ¥. Ville, Y.. Medelenat, P. and
Nicolaides, K.H. (1992). Fust-ttimester transahdominal feto-
scopy. Lancet, $40, 429
9. Quintero, K. A., Crossland, W. J-and Cotton, D. B. (1994),
Effect of endoscopic white light on the developing visual path:
10.
a
1.
13.
4
Ville et al
way: histologic, histochemical, and behavioral study. Amt. J
Obstet. Gynecol, 171, 1142-8
DePres, I, Luks, F. and Van den Berghe, K. (1994). Etfect of
endoscopic white light on the developing sheep eye. IEMSS
“Meeting, May, Anowerp
DDumez, Y. and Datos, . (1990) L’échographie intervention
nelle en medecne fetal. In Gilet, P.(e.} Echograpie des
‘malformation foetales, pp 407-8. (Pars: Vigot)
Valent, C. (1972). Endoamnioscopy and fetal biopsy: anew
technique. Am. J. Obstet. Gynecol, 141, S61—4
Serimgeour J.B. (19/3). Other technigues for antenatal dag-
nosis In Emery, A Ez (ed) Antenatal Diagnosis of Genetic
‘Disease, pp. 4-97. (edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone)
Nicolaides, KHL, Bezot, M, Patel, F and Snijders, RS. ML
(1984). Companson of chorvone villus sampling and amnion
entess foe lel karyoryping at 10-13 weeks gestation. Lane
ety 344, 435-9
Reece, EA. Homko, C., Goldstein, L and Wizmitaer, A.
(1995), Toward fetal therapy using needle embryotetoscopy
Ultrasound Obstet. Gynecol 5, 281-8
Ulerasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 1S