Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IAS Mains Law 2016 PDF
IAS Mains Law 2016 PDF
• , EY,..:,. U"''....1....·'10
セ Nセ@ 16
-
M-ESC-U-LAW
"fcriU HセMGqQヲiI@
ャセZエri@ セZRUP@
セMGqQヲ@ fcnllt:4 セ@
Hセ@ m CfiT "3m セ@ セ@ セ@ PI8R1Rsa セ@ セ@ セ@ uThセcィ@ セI@
セ@ ano m セ@ セ@ Gl セ@ lt ヲ・セ@ セ@ ッセ@ セ@ aTR セ@ GRTlt セi@
Mアエセ_Nヲ@ em ¥1 セ@ >rrn セ@ "3m セ@ セ@ 1
LAW (PAPER-I)
ITime Allowed : Three Hours I Maximum Marks : 250 I
QUESTION paeセ@ SPECIFIC INSTRUCTIONS
(Please read each of the following instructions carefully before attempting questions)
There are EIGHT questions divided in two Sections and printed both in HINDI and
in ENGLISH.
Candidate has to attempt FIVE questions in all.
Question Nos. 1 and 5 are compulsory and out of the remaining, THREE are to be attempted
choosing at least ONE question from each Section.
The number of marks carried by a question/part is indicated against it.
Answers must be written in the medium authorized in the Admission Certificate which
must be stated clearly on the cover of this Question-cum-Answer (QCA) Booklet in the
space provided. No marks will be given for answers written in a medium other than the
authorized one.
Word limit in questions, if specified, should be adhered to.
Attempts of questions shall be counted in sequential order. Unless struck off, attempt of a
question shall be counted even if attempted partly. Any page or portion of the page left blank
in the Question-cum-Answer Booklet must be clearly struck off.
1 [ P.T.O.
www.examrace.com
セMa@ / SECTION-A
(c) "SPWfl f?lq:; 00 f.rqfur q;8 cfil SGQciセTヲゥ、@ I DQHGTセ@ セM f.rqfur cnr 3'1 q セエUQT@ t I" セ@ セ@ I
"The need for administrative rule making entails delegated legislation."
Comment. 15
3. (a) セ@ cfil Cfli441R-!Cfll セ@ "Cf)l "Ba)-q セ@ $ セL@ RlitttCfl{ (fif セ・イ@ ・イセ@ セ@ セ@
3'1 セ@ {1\7414 Cfim cnr 3ij)4 Iel"i ""i 'Cf)"{ \% mI
Briefly enumerate the executive powers of the President, especially when two or
more States are involved in non-observance of an inter-State agreement. 15
www.examrace.com
{b) Yセ@ Bwヲゥセ@ セ@ 2014 ll 3"lr(1f.tf%a fu;&Rr cf?r ヲ」エセhi@ セ@ S'Q. セ@ セ@ '3'iXf '"414k141 ll
セエャイ・@ cf?r セ@ cf?r セ@ セ@ "tR セi@
While discussing the underlying principle of the 99th Amendment Act, 2014,
comment on the present system of appointment of judges to the Higher
Judiciary in the country. 20
4. (a)
11 Q
セ@ q)T f.l<:rq Hセ@ 31'fq; "ffi')' Ch!"lf-14(1 セ@ fu;&Rr "q\ 31ltnft'a t Hヲセ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ -rnt; q)T
(c) " ᄋセ@ <f?.TT ャセウッエ@ セL@ cf?r セ@ セエュ@ t fct SQエMGBTセ\ィ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ m cg
"Wn t1" セ@ セ@ ヲ」ャセ]アッエ@ セi@
" 'The Policy and Guideline Theory' presupposes delivery of justice by
quasi-judicial authority." Elaborate it. 15
セMb@ / SECTION-B
www.examrace.com
(d) cp;n セ@ ^イセ@ cfit セG@ セ@ 1:% セ@ "3'ffiTl rn "B\fi >ICfiR セ@ Sュセ@ cnr セ@ a:t2lCn セ・ョ@
fcmq ・ョセ@ >ICfiR セ@ Sュセ@ cnr セ@ 3l2lCn Sュセ@ cnr セ@ セ@ t Shtセスア@ セ@ セ@
fcrcf;m セ@ Gfltrcfi t? セBciQ@ セi@
Discuss whether the trend of convention providing a special clause prohibiting
all kinds of reservations or some or specific or special kind of reservation or
prohibiting reservations totally will hinder the growth of International Law. 10
6. (a) セ@ >renT\ \ffiCf セ@ 3H1<ft)ll セG@ セ@ セ@ CfiT 3{rr GR TRff t, ヲ」ャセBci@ セi@ セイHャ\ヲエI@ セ@ 1J;Cf
セ@ セ@ セ@ ャセ@ fcriltn\ffif cfit セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ イャエ_セ@ rn セ@ fcrtt:r cnr >f"lM fcnlll セG@
セi@
Discuss how International Law becomes part of the law of the labd in India. In
case of conflict between the International Law and Municipal Law, which one
would be applied by the Municipal Courts of this country? Explain. 20
(b) cp;rf 'lmf, \ffiCf-1i.o セッ@ セ@ qJ<fCtll\q) セ@ *it51ll(11 Clim セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セG@ セ@ fcf; セ@
rl!llllt?lli セ@ セ@ セ@ 'q)'ql ッセ@ lFft t?lhsf{11 セ@ セ@ "Y'lfuf セ@ セ@ セ@ 1i.o セッ@ セ@ セ@ セ@
セ@ TRff t セ@ セ@ cfit lllTr セ@ セ@ t? Oli'Tl§lll セi@
Can India invoke the India-UK Mutual Legal Assistance Agreement for
extraditing an Indian national who has run away to UK in spite of an Indian
Court order in respect of fraud and money laundering against him? Explain. 15
(c) 3ir(l<ltlll ャrcヲゥMセエ@ fcrtt:r 1J;Cf 3ir(l<it)ll lfRCi セ@ fcrtt:r セ@ セ@ Sゥciセャア[@ セ@ cp;n セ_@
Oli'Tl§lll セ@ I
What are the essential differences between the International Humanitarian
Law and International Human Rights Law? Explain. 15
(c) 1i.o "tBo ア[セイjBQ@ 3i"f;{ G "ffi 3ili; G m, 1982 Nセ@ a:tuntfR セ@ ᄋ セBャ\hエ_@ セBャエ_@ "tfiT< G "ffi 3ili;
G mHセッ@ tlo セッ@ a:ilo セッI@ セ@ セ G@ セ@ 1J;Cf セ@ CfiT "CI'uR セi@
Discuss the functions, powers and jurisdiction of the International Tribunal
for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) established under the UN Convention on the Law
of the Sea, 1982. 10
?Jt-ese-u-.th/52 4
www.examrace.com
i'
(C) <i_O セP@ セP@ セP@ セP@ セP W@ 2015 セ@ 3'Rf1fct セ@ cn\R .q Sセヲオゥ」エ@ 3TRP:r セ@ cnl 195 M。ゥイセ@
セ@ "B セ@ M セi@ Cfim セ@ セN@ 31clmfto セ@ Hセッ@ tlo セッI@ セ@ セ@
セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ 。セ@ <i_o "Q3o セッ@ セッ@ セッ@ セッ@ セ」ュNQエ@ ュセ@ セ@ セ@ yTゥセ」エ@ fcfi<n セ@ セ@
fen '"WTfl'fi' Wn m セ@ セ@ "IDU f;!mfta セi@ セ Z@ セ@ G・ョセ@ セL@ t 3H'HTtl'4 セ@
セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ '"'1111 セ@ 3ltPlR セᄋ@ <n '"'1111 セ@ ウゥGヲエセャZQ@ セL@ m7ft 1
セ@ 311<:H'4cn "TTI cn1 セ@ セ@ セL@ セ@ cnm セ@ SアQセャ」エ@ セ@ セ@ fcrcrn セ@ セ@ 1
Final words of Paris Agreement under the UNFCCC, 2015 was adopted
unanimously by 195 countries. According to this Agreement, Nationally
Determined Contributions (NDC) are to be reported every 5 years and are to be
registered with UNFCCC Secretariat which will be 'progressive' depending upon
the targets set by each country itself and therefore contributions have been
made 'non-binding' as a matter of International Law and there will be a 'name
and shame system' or 'name and encourage plan'.
After explaining essential features, comment on the effectiveness of such an
Agreement. 20
***
m-&se-u-.t/lkl/ 52 5 7BS-630
www.examrace.com
..
.
,_
www.examrace.com
..
cs IM-6Sc-D-LAW I
セOlaw@
セM@ II I Paper II
f.#.rffi:?r triRf : rft:r eR セSゥ」ョZRUP@
Time Allowed : Three Hours Maximu m Marks : 250
www.examrace.com
セa@
SECTION A
(c) "3N)" m"R QSrセBゥ@ セipゥヲcエ@ セ@ セ@ 11 mtf qf{qJ"i 3l1<IT セ@ 1" flcqoft 」ィャセA|@ I
''No fault liability rule has undergone a drastic change in the recent
past." Comment. 10
www.examrace.com
Q2. (a) G|Qゥャセエ@ -a セ@ Nセ@ュ cfiT mu 124A, セ@ セ@ セr」エゥ@ セ@ セ@ セ@
セSQ@ q;) セ、@ 19(1)(a) WU q;«fi セG@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ I セ@ セ@
セ@ cヲャYfセi、_AN@ セQ@ セ@ ヲ・オ、セ@ "tR Sャェセ|@ 41«1--4"1 セ@ <fm Ufcf\TR セ@
セ@ 19(2) -ij セ@ ''"ffiq; VTアセ@ セ@ セ@ -ij" -ij セ@ セ@ セ@ 1" flcqoft 」ィャセA|@ I
"Section 124A of the IPC dealing with sedition is ultra-vires of the
Constitutio n insofar as it seeks to punish merely bad feelings against
the Governmen t. It is an unreasonab le restriction on freedom of speech
and expression guaranteed under Article 19(1)(a) and is not saved under
Article 19(2) of the Constitutio n by the expression uin the interest of
public order"." Comment. 20
(b) Bセ@ "J:fRCf C{tl, セ@ fiHT ttcf4l\il"1 セG@ 3ll<ffi -ij 3lfCfi\ セゥエBQcヲャ@ セ@ -ij Cfilf{d
QT, "ffi セ@ セ@ -;ffll セ@ 1" am f.tofll\il fcrttr セ@ ュセ@ セ@ ア[セ@ CflT セゥエBャHGヲ」@
WPJ"Gr 4>l セ@ l!\ I
"Culpable homicide is not murder, if if is committed without
premeditat ion, in a sudden fight in the heat of passion." Critically
examine the statement with leading case law. 15
Q3. (a) BセPQ@ M。セ@ cfiT セ@ Qlf.f, ";{ "ffi セ@ 8.lfa w・ヲエセ@ セ@ ";{ セ@ アャセヲ@ 1" セ@
qf{JlJOfl3 1l. 041&41 」ィャセA|@ I
"Harm suffered voluntarily does not constitute a legal injury and is not
actionable. " Elaborate along with its limitations . 20
www.examrace.com
Q4. (a) Gセ@ m&lUT セG@ 1986 セ@ セ@ d("ihlci)"'f 51CIRfd セ@ セ@ fcrftr セ@
セ@ セ@ 3iRtRm mlT ;r fcti セ@ 3i641Cfi<Ul -ij セ@ 1" セ@ セ@ "ChT
e 41 セ@ =q"'f k4 Ch tRT&lUT 」Zヲ[Iセ@ Q\ 1
"Provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 shall be in addition to
and not in derogation of the provisions of any other law for the time
being in force." Critically examine the statement. 15
(b) GセZエ@ q;) セ@ iRH セ@ fcrftr "Cf)l セ@ セ@ em セ@ セ@ セ@ "tR セ@
dJ 11"11 セL@ セ@ mtl"'f1 セ@ セ@ 41\it"'f セ@ >rft(f m\jff(ft セ@
1" &II&II c:f)) Nl Q\ I
"The law making conspiracy a crime is designed to curb immoderat e
power to do mischief which is gained by a combinatio n of the means."
Explain. 15
(c) Bセヲゥ@ "ChT セ@ セ@ セ@ ChRICIIe mor セG@ セ@ CfQ elchtf.ICh ChiOJIR -ij <IT m
セ@ m -ij m, セ@ -ij m, \itセ@ lfT1if -ij \ifii'B (Sf;{\Cf){OI セ@ セ@ m
I" Ptof4\i1
fcrftr eta e セhT、@ I セ@ セ@ GTRJ q;) セ@ c:f)) セ@ Q\ I
''Every confineme nt of the person is an imprisonm ent, whether it be in a
common prison or in a private house, or in the stocks or even by forcibly
detaining one in the public streets." Explain with the help of case law. 20
M-6SC-D -LAW
www.examrace.com
セb@
SECTIO NB
Q5. f.h.. {f;wfuift siセcヲゥ@ ctrr セ@ M•lcq•l 150 セ@ 1l i.f\f"Gtl{ I 34Y)'ffi ftfftrcn セNqt@ 3ffi
セゥイエャ」@ f.loiqf cfiT ヲエセャ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ ctrr Gヲエャセ@ chlf"Gtl{ I
An9wcr the followin g in about 150 キョイャセ@ P.Rr.h. Suppor t yolU" answer
with relevan t legal provisio ns and decided cases. 1 Ox5=50
(a) ''f<=fttRI セ@ セ@ SFRtlq cfflt セ@ セ@ joirZャセ@ cfiT \ikt<ft セG@ lH41J:S{ cfiT セ@ セ@ セ@
セ@ I (fQ セ@ セ@ Cfi«ft セ@ セ@ -;r crrtm セ@ \iff セcィ」エャ@ 3fu: -;r セ@ セ@ \iff
-rr=-:::rr'''
セcィ」エャ@ I セjZゥDャQ|@
Mセ@ I
"An offer is to an acceptance what a lighted match-st ick is to a train of
gunpowder. It produces somethin g which cannot be recalled or
undone" - Anson. Explain. 10
(b) Gセ@ ef4GI -ij セ@ W Gil '10{1R-fq; Glfil<:"CI' Qlm セL@ セcィゥ@ セ@ セ@ Sゥャアセiqcィ@
m<rr セ@ I セ@ セ@ Gエヲセ@ セ@ 41R-fq; Glfli<:"CI セ@ セ@ -ij Sゥセcヲ^@ W<IT セG@ mセ@
ef4G' W1 CfiT GWT WIT, セ@ 61 セ@ セ@ c€t セ@ セ@ セヲuirMエ。@ cfiT セ@ セ@ Gil
-;fflT 1" Pfo\'4\it fcrttl セ@ セ@ セ@ cヲIセ@ CfiT セjoゥャBアGQイcィ@ Mアエセ@ ・ィャセq|@ I
"Every contract contains a 'core' or 'fundam ental obligation' which must
be performed. If one party fails to perform this fundame ntal obligation,
he will be guilty of a breach of contract whether or not any exemptin g
clause has been inserted which purports to protect him." Critically
examine the statemen t with case law. 10
(d) aセ@ B-e- セ@ 1,000 セ@ "fWrr, "tfig セ@ qfhftJOJI セG@ 1963 セ@ セ@ cィャセ\ヲエ」@
セ@ I 。セアサャッZゥェ@ aセ@ セ@ @セ cfiT セ@ セ@ 1,000 セ@ "CflG セ@ R-ff€fct q:q;r 1R セ。Zr@
fc6m I セ@ CfKR cfiT セ@ CfiT セ@ ehlNlQ\ I
A owed B セ@ 1,000, but the debt is barred by the Limitati on Act, 1963.
Subsequ ently A signs a written promise to pay セ@ 1,000 on account of the
previous debt. Decide the validity of this agreeme nt. 10
M-6SC,. .D-LAW 5
www.examrace.com
(e) ''q<sol'"4 Ri@a セ@ セ@ q|cヲ^joャセ@ rエゥyiセL@ "tfR CITffi m セエゥ、ヲ」ィGャ@ m セ@
1".
fl€ftctl<-1,
セ@ rエゥyiセcィL@ fl€ftctl<-1, "tfR セ@ <rr セ・ゥヲ」ィ、QL@ セ@ セエゥ、ヲ」ィ。@ <rr q<Sf)IJOfOI "Ch\ セ@
t -ij, エゥ、cィ]M@セ 3:ft\ q{Sf)IJOfOI セ@ セ@ セ@ セ、ャA|@ セ@
CJ Gセエゥ、cィ]M@ セ@ sicィャセ@
セ@ fcfimf SIChiU cfiT セ@ セ@ 」ャゥセA|@ I
"Every sole maker, drawer , payee or endorsee, or all of joint makers ,
drawer s, payees, or endorse es, of a negotia ble instrum ent may endorse
and negotia te it." In the light of the above stateme nt, disting uish
betwee n endorse ment and negotia tion and also explain differen t kinds of
'endors ements '. 10
Q6. (a) Gセ@ セ@ セG@ 2005, siセcィ@ "ffict> セ@ cfiT Chl4:ncll -ij アャサセヲ、@ Cf
|ゥcヲャセ@ -ChT セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ fcf;m ll<rr セ@ 1" TRf Ga セ@ -ij, セ@
セ@ セG@ 2005 wu セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ (j'Cp "5I"Tt(f セSti@ セ@ ? 3ltR "3ffi: Cf)f
SQセGア]Mエォjoヲcィ@ ヲTセャエッ L@ 31qCf1Gl CJ Pfof;q\il fcrttl セ@ HQセT、ャ@ セ@ 」ャゥセA|@ I
"The Right to Inform ation Act, 2005 was enacted in order to promot e
transpa rency and accoun tability m the workin g of every public
authori ty." How far has this goal been achieved by the Right to
Inform ation Act, 2005 in the last ten years ? Critically analyse your
answer with the suppor t of exceptions and case law. 15
(b) Gセ@ ゥヲャセTQ@ f4:qROI HセI@ セ@ セ@ セ@ @セ セ@ G@セ 、セin L@ 1fSl セ@ セ@
セ@ セMヲ・エゥ、@ 3ltt セMヲ・エゥ、@ -ij TGQセ@ -ChT ュセ@ lR セ@ 3ltR
fcrcm: )ICf)l セ@ cfiT ヲ・エ、セャ@ セ@ I セ@ f4:qi{OI CfiT ;;ql41<-14 セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@
セュ・ョ@ 」rtセ@M 」ャゥセA|@ I 1" セ@ セ@ Cf)f Pfof;q\il fcfftlm%o SQセャッア]Mエォjoヲcィ@
''Though there is no law for media trial, however, in freedom of
express ion and speech under fundam ental rights, media has the freedom
to express its views based on evidence. This trial has no authori ty before
the court of law." Critical ly examin e the statem ent with case law. 15
(c) Gセ@ セ@ cfiT \iii=-!Chltl -ij セ@ アセZH]Mエ@ CfiT セ@ SQセヲ」エ@ -ij m3ltt セ@ セ@ セ@
セ@ セ@ PTcヲセr@ Cf)Bf GゥZャセ。Q@ -m, セ@ 0\ft アセGゥZヲャ]Mエ@ ctiT セ@ -m セ@ セ@ 1 セ@
エヲセ@ I;:it WU セ@ fct;m ll<rr ;rn:r Chi C'"tt P!Ch セL@ "ffi q セZア@ loot cfiT セ@ セ@ セ@ mTft 1"
セ@ セ@ Cf)f 3m Pfof;q\il fcrttJ セ@ セ@ wセ@ 」ャゥセA|@ I
''There can be a mistak e of identity only when a person bearing a
particu lar identity exists within the knowledge of the plaintiff, and the
plaintif f intends to deal with him only. If the name assume d by the
swindle r is fictitious, there will be no mistake of identity ." Examin e the
statem ent with leading case law. 20
M-6SG -D-LAW
www.examrace.com
Q7. (a) ャヲGuiセ@ セ@ セ@ セG@ 1996 -ij ャヲGuiセjl@ セ@ セ@ HセI@ セG@
2015 セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ GBャセヲciA_@ セ@ "tR: >renm ウゥセq|@ 1
Highli ght the impor tant amend ments wade in the Arbitr ation and
Conciliation Act, 1996 by the Arbitr ation and Concil iation (Amen dment )
Act, 2015. 15
QS. (a) Gセヲ」ャQ@ WI セ@ セ@ j<:hl81o:ft cfiT SゥセャGヲエ@ CfiT セ@ 」ヲエセ。@ Mアセ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ -ij セ@
セL@ セ@ セ@ セ@ dCf) セ@ セ@ fc6m \iff セ@ セL@ セ@ % セ@ mR セ@ @セ m 1"
• セ@ セ@ sャ」ッセ@ -q, セャ@ セM@ m セ@ "5fCf)R cfiT jc:hi81Ptlli
セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ ? セ@ セ@ ェ」Zィセャッヲエ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ cfiT セ@ Olll&u
・ヲゥIセq|@ I
"The object of award ing damag es for a breach of contra ct is to put the
injure d party in the same position, so far as money can do it, as if he had
not been injured ." In the light of the above statem ent, explai n the
variou s kinds of damag es that the court can award . Also explai n the
ョQャヲ セ r@ rP.lHt.ing to assess ment of damag es.
20
(c) Gセ@ セイ・エ@ セ@ セG@ 1991 CfiT セ@ &o<"ilco (q({ecoc'"lll) ailli1 -ij
セ@ @セ セjゥ@ セ@ Mァセ@ セ@ セ@ セ@ 31;<J セ@ セ@ 3R1TcfT セ@ セ@ CfiBr
M-6SC ..D-LA W
www.examrace.com
www.examrace.com