Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Management Information System, Challenges and Solutions
Management Information System, Challenges and Solutions
com
vol.2, No. 3(s), pp. 374-381 ISSN 1805-3602
Corresponding author: Mehdi Babaei, Banab branch, Islamic Azad University, Banab, Iran. E-mail:
Mehdibabaei39@yahoo.com
374
Social science section
discussion is focused on these systems. It can be said The management information system is an in-
that in Iran namely in governmental organizations, tegrated, computerized and machine user system
management information systems with the common providing the required information to support the
concept of MIS in the developed countries are less operation and decision making. The main elements
used and in some organizations any information sys- of this system are:
tem, even the other kinds as: Transaction Processing 1- An integrated system to give service to many
Systems (TPS) presenting some reports for the manag- users, 2-The computer system linking some of in-
ers of the organizations are called MIS. Although these formation software via a database.3- User-machine
systems don’t have all the features of a real MIS, MIS interface responding to the temporary and immedi-
is less observed in its real meaning and many informa- ate searches. 4- Presenting the information to all
tion systems are organized in the organizations in Iran. management level, 5- Supporting the operation and
The present study attempted to use mostly the govern- decision making(Awad, 1988).
mental organizations as study population.
All the management information system being The introduction of different kinds of information
established in these systems and being applied by systems
their managers are considered MIS with a little neg- As it was mentioned, the information systems
ligence and they are called MIS in the present study. are one of the suitable tools of the organizations and
The management information systems in- by these tools to achieve the goals and increasing the
creased the managers’ information and even the efficiency, they are used. There are different kinds
experts of various levels of the organization and by of information systems and they are used in various
raising new concepts not only extended their knowl- positions in the organization. There are various at-
edge scope about what they can do and what is their titudes in determining different information systems
decision and helped them in doing their activities and their classification but in most of the classifica-
and responsibilities( Jams&Kent,2003).Based on tions, the followings are observed:
the important feature of management information The Management Information System (MIS)
system, the managers of these systems are of great Executive information system (E.I.S)
importance. These people income in USA is annu- Decision Support System (D.S.S)
ally 100000 to 300000 dollars (Momeni, 1993). Expert Systems (E.S)
Work Group Support System (W.G.S.S)
The definition of management information systems Transaction Processing Support (T.P.S)
Various definitions of management information Office Automation Systems (O.A.S) [11], [12],
systems are presented and some of them are as: [13], [14].
“MIS is a comprehensive human-machine sys- Information Systems can be conceptualized in
tem providing the supporting information of deci- terms of three types of systems: Transactional Pro-
sion and operation in a social formation and organi- cessing Systems (TPS), Management Information
zation (Schoderbeck, Kefalas & Charles, 1975). Systems (MIS), and Expert Systems. MIS has sev-
“MIS” is the comprehensive structure of data- eral subsets such as Decision Support Systems and
base and information flow in all the organization Executive Information Systems. The role of MIS in
levels that by collection, exchange and presentation decision support is best discussed in the context of the
of information, the organization needs are met as subset referred to as Decision Support System (DSS).
well(long , 1989 ). A DSS is a computer based system (an application
“MIS” is a computer system presenting the in- program) capable of analyzing an organizational (or
formation to the users(Mcleoo, 1998). business) data and then presents it in a way that helps
“MIS” is a combination of human attempts by the user to make business decisions more efficiently
computer to collect, store, recover information by and effectively. It is basically an informational ap-
using communication systems for good manage- plication which depends on the information already
ment of organization activities (Kelly, 1984). input while answering to a given query. For example,
“MIS” is the formal methods of providing ex- a decision support system could provide:
act and timely information to facilitate the decision - Comparative sales figures for one week/month
making process of the managers during the plan- and the next
ning, control and taking effective and optimum de- - Projected revenue figures based on new prod-
cisions of the organization (Momeni, 1993). uct sales assumptions
- Consequences of different decision alterna- cultivate an environment that encourages the growth
tives, given past experience and viable sprouting of quality information.
Sometimes there is an overlap between the Essentially, before deciding on which MIS strategy
broad categories of IS and a DSS could be capable to use, it is vital to ensure that the choice made is fully
of presenting information graphically through an compatible with your current system. This will not only
expert system or artificial intelligence (AI). Usually help in avoiding erratic choices but it will also save you
the DSS is used by all levels of people within a busi- the time and money that would have been otherwise
ness organization. Top level management uses DSS wasted by that person (Jahangir, 2005& Rhodes, 2010).
for strategic decisions, middle management uses for In addition to that, it is noteworthy for the MIS strat-
tactical decision while first line supervisors use de- egy or tool used to be in line with the decisions that are
ploy it for day-to-day operational decisions. There- to be made. In other words, there should be a connect-
fore, the process of decision-making in any business ing point between the decision to be made and the MIS
is an inherently vital aspect not just for organizations to be used by individual or corporate business owners
but also for individuals who greatly rely on these de- (Jarboe, 2005).As a key consideration, Management
cisions for their survival in the highly competitive Information Systems is a highly complex and delicate
arena of entrepreneurship (Al-Zhrani, 2010). arena that calls for a lot of caution to be taken by its
managers. It is for this reason that it is recommendable
The Role of Management Information Systems for organizations to ensure that they carefully select the
Two main roles are played by the decision making individuals who are placed to control the systems. The
of the managers. First it helps the managers to take more cautious and professional a person is, the better
decision based on the information being prepared. the person gets an assurance of positive prospects of in
Second when the decision making and decisions are MIS with regards to decision making and other related
fixed and only the input data change, it is as a suitable areas of business (Lingham, 2006).
repeating to support different types of managers deci- To begin with, MIS provides a fitting platform
sions. It means that MIS is the tool that as the orga- for good decision making (Kumar, 2006).
nizational information source provides the required Essentially, without the established systems of get-
information of the managers and makes them pre- ting information in MIS, it would be extremely dif-
pared for their decision making. The managers use ficult for organizations to make their decisions. This
MIS as a tool to define the problems being faced. As is because they would be forced to making baseless in-
MIS helps the managers to understand the problems formation due to the lack of confirmed information.
and find the solutions (Shafiie, 2005; Mcleoo, 1998). Moreover, MIS normally lays a firm foundation for the
establishment of concrete decisions through its system-
Role of MIS in Improving decision making atic tools, timely information and adequate managerial
Preliminarily, it is inherent to state that decision policies and regulations. Furthermore, Management
making is an integral part of any business (The ma- information Systems’ statutes regarding businesses act
niac, n.d.). This is because a majority of operations in as guidelines to business owners when making critical
an organization revolve around decisions made by the decisions about their businesses. As a result, managers
management and other key stakeholders in the organi- and key decision makers are bridled from overstepping
zation. And in order for decision to be made adequate- their boundaries or exceeding their business mandate.
ly, it is vital for there to be a good information system This is very crucial as it helps in keeping businesses
since decisions are based on information available. checked and balanced thus ensuring that only proven
In relations to this Jahangir (2005) states that decisions are considered while the untried ones are
based on the significant role that information plays thwarted. More importantly, the capacity to guide de-
in choice of decision to be made, organizations must cision-making facilitates progress and improvement of
ensure that they have a good management informa- the operations in a company(Lingham, 2006). In addi-
tion system. As a notable general observation, a good tion, most MIS programs are endowed with the capacity
MIS ensures good decision making just in the same to give real-time updates of the occurrences in company
way bad MIS propel the making of bad decisions. or system. By real-time, scholars simply refer to imme-
UStudy.in (2010) supports the above observation diate updates of occurrences in a system. These imme-
by saying that “The quality of managerial decision- diate updates help mangers to take necessary actions as
making depends directly on the quality of available soon as is deemed appropriate especially during the dis-
information” and the managers should therefore covery and management of crises. This augments prog-
ress and improvement in company operations through towards providing future places of information retriev-
timely decisionmaking. This is important for compa- al. Principally, the record keeping and data-basing tool
nies in the modern-day generation where any slight of MIS definitely ensures that decisions are made vi-
lapse in decision making can lead to very huge losses. ably while businesses run smoothly.
Allen, Heurtebise & Turnbull (2010). Still, Manage- In contributing to the arguments regarding role of
ment information systems are very elemental improving MIS in improving decision making, Rhodes also adds
company securities .For example, in many instances, that: Management information systems give managers
most management information systems can be easily quick access to information. This can include interac-
programmed by the owner to conduct certain actions at tion with other decision support systems, information
certain times. In effect, managers can program the sys- inquiries, crossreferencing of external information
tem to perform certain routine checks which can help and potential data mining techniques. These systems
in improving efficiency of a company through easy dis- can also compare strategic goals with practical deci-
covery of bugs or problems. Furthermore, the program- sions, giving managers a sense of how their decisions
mability of most MIS saves a lot of priceless time and fit organizational strategy. In summary, Rhodes simply
resources for owners. In other words, through program- believes that management information systems are a
mability, business managers can program the systems huge contributing factor in the getting of viable infor-
to automatically discover certain deficiencies and even mation from organizations. Sadly, very few organiza-
solve them. Consequently, the manager or system op- tions have been able to ardently take up on this role
erator can use the time and resources he/she would have and even lead other organization in the society in do-
used in monitoring or fixing problems for other key uses. ing the same. It is for this reason that there has been a
By routinely programming a Management Information limited improvement in decision making based on the
System, the business is bound to make positive progress tailoring of viable information. A candid way of solving
since time and resources can be easily channeled into this challenge is given later in this paper under recom-
rightful business paths .Davenport& Short (1990). mendations. (Rhodes, 2010).
As a fundamental point, a good number of MIS Over the recent years, there has also been an in-
used today can perform multiple tasks all at the same creased usage of automated Management Information
time. This potential to multitask increases efficiency Systems. To a large extent, these automated systems
in a company since several business operations can be have hugely revolutionized the decision-making pro-
conducted simultaneously. With special regards to de- cess in a positive way .UStudy.in. (2010). For instance,
cision making, the capacity to multitask ensures that by using automated MIS, companies no longer have to
decisions are made speedily when compared to those rely on 24-hour services from workers. Instead, the ma-
systems which can only handle one task at a time. chines are able to be programmed to do things on our
Closely related to the above point, Jahangir says behalf (Jarboe, 2005). Of course this offers a huge plus in
that some MIS allow multiple users to access the same decision-making since managers are relieved of making
content all at the same time without any discrepan- some decisions-especially the technical ones which can
cies. This potentiality boosts accountability from the be best interpreted and solved by the automated system.
business operators since multiple people can access a As a cautionary point, organizations should not entirely
particular content and verify whether they are consis- rely on automated systems-- especially when the deci-
tent or whether they are not. As a matter of fact, most sions to be made have adverse implications to the orga-
organizations tend to suffer due to poor accountability nization. This is based on the alleged observation that
from those charged with the mandate to manage cer- auto systems may sometimes be faulty and thus require
tain details. This safeguard action of some MIS is what frequent periodic monitoring (Demetrius, 1996)So in
macroeconomists refer to as the “gate-keeping” role order not to fall a victim of over-relying on automated
of MIS in decision making and overall well-being of systems, Jahangir advices managers and company own-
the organization. On another level, a good number of ers to ensure that they find a balance in utilizing the hu-
MIS play the role of record keeping or institutionaliza- man element in operating while assigning some duties to
tion of data bases that can easily keep confidential or the automate system. By blending the duties of these two
invaluable information. In essence, decision making extremes, Jahangir states that, this will ensure that both
often calls for the reading of certain past work (Jah- ends of the organization continue to actualize together
angir, 2005). This is where record-keeping comes in while maximizing the potential for each side through
handy. On the flipside, databases normally function check and balances of operations done by the manage-
ment. Again, MIS is renowned for vesting its operations • The lack of understanding of the managers of
on systematic methods of operations(Jahangir, 2005). software and information systems.
Crucially, this ensures that decisions made in a • The lack of information of most of the ana-
business are orderly and well-planned which, in ef- lysts and programmers (designers) with new system
fect, encourages objectivity during decision making. work environment.
As a result, businesses and the decisionmaking pro- • The lack of acceptance of the system execut-
cess are improved through its systematic and orderly ers and resistance against the change.
formula of operating (Jawadekar,2006). • The lack of accuracy in the data collected
istrative management are weakened because IT na- namely in public organizations. Thus, the managers
ture is mostly technocratic rather than democratic. of these organizations should apply the required so-
Some people believe that by IT, the democratic lutions to hold good training courses and participa-
values as pluralism, freedom of speech, etc are im- tion of the managers and employees of the organiza-
proved. In communication world, direct control was tion in these periods and other short-term courses
replaced with indirect tools as standardization and or academic year in the educational institutions and
education. Information is the basis of power and universities.
exclusion of power has negative outcomes in long- 4- Holding the suitable conferences at national
term and damages the society and makes problem and international level to develop the information
for all the government (Zahedi, 2001). system culture in Iran.
MIS in Iran namely in public organizations is 5- The formation of the information services
applied rarely in Iran and it was mostly used after institutions in all the important administrative or-
the Islamic Revolution of Iran and 70s, 80s. This ganizations and determining the institutions as the
is for the reason that the experience of using MIS supporters (MIS) of the organizations.
in the organizations namely Iran organizations and 6- As the managers have important role in MIS
namely the public organizations was not a successful in the organizations compared to the designers and
experience and the reasons were mentioned before. directors. The change of their attitude to computer,
To eliminate these problems, it is presented to the information systems namely MIS is recommended.
managers (namely the managers of administrative To do this, the public organizations managers and
organizations), designers and directors to be con- government by predicting required solutions should
sidered by the executive managers of Iran in public create the attitude change within a short time among
or private sector (GhazizadeFard,1 996). the managers.
Finally, Management Information systems play 7- During the design, establishment and appli-
the crucial role of providing a wide range of stream- cation process (MIS) in the organization, the man-
lined options from which decision-makers are able to agers should consider the behavioral aspects of the
make their preferred choices Vittal & Shivraj(2008). employees of the organization namely system direc-
Vitally, this ensures that whatever choices are made tors and participate them in system creation process.
by decision makers, the outcome, more often than 8- As the foundation of MIS is based on ac-
not, becomes positive. This, as a matter of fact, is tive computer and Transaction Processing Systems
the reason why many decision makers tend to prefer (TPS) in the organization, before or at the same
using MIS tools when making tough business choic- time with the design and application of MIS, TPS
es. And as renowned concept, having good decision should be used in various organization sectors.
choices guarantees viable decisions in our business- 9- Providing a comprehensive plan is necessary
es.Vittal&Shivraj (2008), Jawadekar (2006). for using information systems in the organizations
There would be some suggestions and recom- before using MIS.
mendation as follows: 10- Absorbing the efficient and skillful employ-
1- The designing and determining a suitable ees and creating suitable motivations for the stability
policy to develop MIS in Iran namely public orga- of the existing employees.
nizations. To do this, the organizations in Iran (e.g. 11- The consideration of the government to the
management and planning organization, commu- private consulting companies (or public consulting
nication information technology ministry, and In- companies) and not using their employees in design
formatics high council in Iran) should take the re- and establishment of information systems to reduce
quired measurements. privatization policy and elimination of the problems
2- The public organizations generally and man- of the companies.
agement and planning organization specifically de- 12- Forming MIS council or MIS directing
fined more study plans to identify the existing barri- committee from the initial stages of MIS project in
ers in these organizations to use MIS better and get the organization.
help from the academic centers to execute them and
define some projects in the form of their thesis for Acknowledgment
MA and PhD students.
3- The development of the culture of using com- My gratitude goes Dr. Beikzad who helped me
puter and information systems is necessary in Iran sincerely in this study.