CONGRESS OF THF PHILIPPINES RECORDS AND ACAI 13 stand ies OP - S¥#NATE ” - >) eee 2-CP tA eae SESSION Republic of the Philippines SENATE Pasay City COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) DATE : Wednesday, November 7, 2012 TIME 2 9:30am. VENUE Session Hall 2" Floor, Senate of the Philippines, Financial Center, Roxas Boulevard, Pasay City AGENDA PRIVILEGE SPEECH OF SENATE PRESIDENT JUAN PONCE ENRILE RE: RICE SMUGGLING AT THE SUBIC BAY FREEPORT ZONE ATTENDANCE SENATORS PRESENT: HON. FRANCIS N. PANGILINAN - Chairman, Committee ‘on Agriculture and Food HON. JUAN PONCE ENRILE - Senate President ‘ ot To BH TAT OF TEE RuGulbs Aoi BiaseCommittee on Agriculture and Food Joint with Committeas on Ways and Means; ‘Trade and Commerce; and Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations (Blue Ribbon) Session Hall November 7, 2012 Poge 2 GUESTS/ RESOURCE PERSONS: Mr, Rozzano Rufino Biazon- Commissioner, Bureau of Customs (BoC) Mr. Peter M. Manzano - Deputy Commissioner, Revenue Collection Monitoring Group, BOC Ms, Carmelita Talusan - Customs Collector at the Port of Subic Mr. Errol Albano - Former Customs Collector at the Port of Subic Mr. Leovigildo Dayoja - Collector, Port of Legazpi, Albay Mr. Ernani M. Dionisio - Program Director, Philippine Business Registry; and Head, Technical Committee on Business Registration System, Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) Mr. Jovanni Platero - Deputy Executive Director, Cooperatives Development Authority (CDA) Mr. Joel S.Rudinas = —_—Undersecretary for Regional Operations, Department of Agriculture (DA) Mr. Gerardo del Rosario - Assistant Director, Company Registration Department, Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) Assistant Administrator for Marketing Operations, National Food Authority (NFA) Provincial Manager, NFA Bulacan Provincial Office Atty. Jose D. Cordero Mr. Serafin Manalili Ms. Yolanda Navarro Provincial Manager, NFA Albay Provincial Office Mr. Roberto Garcia. == ~—Chairman and Administrator Subic Bay Metropolitan Authority (SBMA) Mr, Stefani Safio - Senior Deputy Administrator, SBMA Atty. Redentor S. Tuazon- Senior Deputy Administrator for Operations, SBMA Mr. Edmundo Arugay - Deputy Director for Special Investigation Services, National Bureau of Investigation (NBI)Committee on Agricutture and Food Joint with Committees on Ways and Means; ‘Trade and Commerce; and Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations (Blue Ribbon) ‘Session Hall November 7, 2012 Page 3 Mr. Antonio C. Camacho Jr.- Owner, Metro Eastern Trading Corporation Mr. Cesar Bulaon - Vice President, Metro Eastern Trading Corporation Mr. Vicente “Bong” P. Cuevas - President, CAM) Construction Inc. Mr. Patrick Ronas = General Manager MStar Ship Agencies Inc. ‘Shipping Agent for the Indian Rice Mr. Cesar Ramirez = —_—‘Federation of San Miguel Cooperatives and Robson Agro-Ventures Corporation Mr. Alfredo Cruz - GPT San Miguel Multipurpose Cooperative, Tartaro, San Miguel, Bulacan Atty. Leonardo W. Bernabe - Notary Public of the Affidavit of Undertaking of Mr. Marfil Atty. Raymond C. De Castro - Ongkiko Custodio Manhit and Acorda Law Offices Mr. Magdangal Diego Maralit Bayani III ~ St. Andrews Field Grains and Cereal Trading Ms. Jane Artuz = General Manager, Port Area Cargo Services, Port Area, Manila SENATORS’ STAFF: Ms. Peachy Dulay Ms. Cecile Palines Mr. Rey Nanale O/S Pangitinan O/S Pangilinan O/S Pangilinan Ms. Neliza Macapayag - —_O/SP Enrile Ms. AnneT. Ramos - —O/SP Enrile Ms, Desiree Guasch - —O/S Recto Ms. Golda Benjamin - — 0/S Guingona Ms, Rachel Sucgang O/S EstradaCommittee on Agricutture and Food Joint with Committe ‘Trade and Commeres ‘and Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations (Blue Ribbon) ‘Session Hall November 7, 2012 Page + SENATE SECRETARIAT: Mr. Horace R, Cruda - Committee Secretary Atty. Rodolfo Noel Quimbo - Director General, Blue Ribbon Oversight Office Management (BROOM) Atty. Rodelio T. Dascil > Director General, Senate Tax Study and Research Office (STSRO) Atty. Emmanuel Alonzo - Director 11, STSRO Ms. Rechilda B. Gascon - Director 111, STSRO Mr. Bong Villanueva - Director If, STSRO Ms, Elizabeth F. Agas - LSO Iv, STSRO Ms, Elsie T. Jesalva = LSO II, STSRO Ms, Ma. Rosalinda J. Catadman- Committee Stenographer Ms. Ma. Emperatriz L. Novero- Committee Stenographer Ms, Norma G. Dizon - Committee Stenographer Mr. Guillermo €. Sapinoso Jr.- Committee Stenographer Ms. Rosemarie J. Ortiz - Committee Stenographer Ms. Cecilia T. Sotto - Committee Stenographer Ms, Rommel P. Alger - Committee Stenographer Ms. Maribel P. Mendoza - Committee Stenographer Ms. Bathaluman H. Gonzales - Committee Stenographer Mr. Helen S. Gayapa = Committee Stenographer Ms, Paulette L. Manuel - Committee Stenographer Mr. Eric Catia = LegComClerk Mr. Jeffrey Padre Juan = LegComClerk Mr. Anthony A. Arrieta - LegComPage Mr. Oscar F. Rugayan - LegComPage Mr. Rolando R. Tancioco = -_~—s LegComPage. Mr. Christian John L. Tentia - — LegComPage Mr. Manuel H. Duka - Audio Technician Mr. Antonio A. Lazaga Audio Technician Mr. Roel M. Fernandez = Audio Technician‘Committee on Agricuiture and Food Joint with Committees on Ways and Means; Trade and Commerce; and Accountability of Public Ofticers and Investigations (Blue Ribbon) Session Hail November 7, 2012 Page 5 (For complete list, please see attached Attendance Sheet)COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MR. CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13 a.m. 1 AT 10:13 A.M. HON. FRANCIS “KIKO” PANGILINAN, CHAIRMAN OF THE COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD, CALLED THE HEARING TO ORDER. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). We would like to call this hearing of the Committees on Agriculture and Food, Ways and Means, Trade and Commerce and Public Accountability—Committee on Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations to order. The Chair declares the presence of a quorum. This is the committee hearing on the privilege speech of the Honorable Senate President on rice smuggling. For the information of our Senate President and our guests, in the previous hearing, there was a motion to have several rice traders and representatives of cooperatives appear in today’s hearing. And the information that we have received is that there were 26 traders and rice cooperative representatives subpoeanaed for today’s hearing Of these 26 subpoenas, 21 were served; five have yet to be served because these five addresses apparently are fictitious and, therefore, we are trying to determine, of these five fictitious addresses, if there fr 6COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R.CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13.a.m. 2 are other addresses available on record that we may be able to serve and, therefore, we have jurisdiction only over 21 individuals representing either a trading company or a cooperative. Of these 21, for the record, 11 have written this Committee, Mr. President, saying they will not be able to attend Of the 21, another four have sent their lawyers, and one of the 21 appeared. And so, five have not responded, have not written, have not sent lawyers, Mr. President. In any event, Mr. President, of the 21, only one has appeared. This is Mrs. Jane Artuz. Where is Mrs. Jane Artuz? Why are you over there? In view of this, Mr. President, this Committee is constrained on the basis of the non-compliance with a subpoena issued by the Committee, Mr. President, we are constrained to enforce the powers of the Senate and of its Committees. Mr. President?COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R, CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13 a.m. 3 THE SENATE PRESIDENT. { second your—is that in the form of a motion? THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Hindi pa po, Mr. President. But Section 16, if I may place on record, of our Rules Governing Inquiries in Aid of Legistation—Section 18, “The Committee by a vote of—may punish for contempt any witness before it who disobeys any order of the Committee or refuses to be sworn. “so forth and so on. So, Section 18, the power to punish for contempt individuals or persons who refused—who disobeys any order of this Committee. The order to appear, Mr. President, is a lawful order of this Committee. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. Is that a motion? THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). And, therefore, the Chairman will move that we cite those who have failed to attend today’s hearing in contempt of the Senate and that an arrest order be issued. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. I second the motion,COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MR, CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13 a.m. 4 THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Thank you, Mr. President, And the motion— THE SENATE PRESIDENT. May I make a suggestion, Mr. Chairman? Given the fact that these people seem to be reluctant to appear here, and it gives me the suspicion that they do not exist as organization. And if they exist, they are nothing but paper organization and, therefore, dummies of certain interested and influential parties. I move that we direct the National Bureau of Investigation to conduct a thorough inquiry into the background of all of these named identities, and report the matter to this—its findings to this Committee so that we can take proper action against them, including their principats. I think it’s time that we enforce the laws in this country and arrest all these people and send them to jail, if we could THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). We second the motion of the Senate President that the NBI is requested—COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R.CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13a.m. 5 THE SENATE PRESIDENT. Kindly—maybe we should--the Chair, we should direct—if you need my assistance as head of the Senate, 1 will do so gladly: direct the proper agencies of government to assist in a full scale investigation of this whole thing. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). The ComSec is hereby directed to make the necessary representations and the official communication with the National Bureau of Investigation. I think we have a representative of the agency—of the bureau, Atty. Arugay is here. Would you care to comment? MR. ARUGAY. Good morning, sirs, Your Honors We will wait for the official communications, Your Honors, before we start the investigation. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Thank you, Atty. Arugay. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. There is too much looseness in the application of laws in this country, and this is the cause of the disorderly nature of the society wherein we live, It is about time we rt 10COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R.CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13 a.m. 6 show that there is a government that must be obeyed by everyone. ‘And if anybody wants to fool with it, then they must answer for their misconduct. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). We agree completely with the manifestation of the Senate President. And also for the record, the motion to cite the individuals who failed to appear today in contempt shall be decided, Mr. President, in a meeting perhaps later in the afternoon. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. And look, I received a letter here from Mr. Guha, a foreigner. He left the country while we are conducting this investigation with the, probably, advice of his lawyer, and now he claims that he is sick and that he does not want to submit himself to jurisdiction of this Committee THE CHAIRMAN (SEN, PANGILINAN). We will have to tackle this matter during our— THE SENATE PRESIDENT. And I think we also request the Bureau of Immigration to ban him from entering this country, once aLCOMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R.CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13a.m. 7 and for all. If this is the way these people are treating the Senate of the Republic, I will not agree with it THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). We are in receipt, Mr. President, of that letter dated November 5, and perhaps during the meeting for the purpose of voting on the motion to have the traders and the cooperative representatives cited in contempt, we can also tackle this. May we also direct the Committee Secretary to make the necessary representations with the OSAA, the Sergeant-At-Arms, considering that these would be 21 individuals—or 20, excluding Ms. Jane Artuz, who is here, 20 individuals who may be subjected to, precisely, being detained under the custody of the Sergeant-At-Arms, That this ComSec make the necessary representations with our Office of the Sergeant-At-Arms, and coordinate with the BJMP, the PNP, and the DILG should the same become necessary. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. We are through with the problem of the rice at the moment, 12COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH THE COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) M.R. CATADMAN I-1 November 7, 2012 10:13.a.m. 8 1 would like to submit to you formally a list of big importers of packed and bulk palm oil, Palm Olei , as reported to this representation, and including their importation and the pricing of those importation, which shows that there is a rampant smuggling of this commodity and, perhaps, other commodities in this country. And I think it’s time that we unravel the whole problem of smuggling in this country, which the Bureau of Customs seems to be powerless to control. And take appropriate legislation, if we have to increase the penalties for people who are smuggling and creating havoc in our economic life, let alone the fact that they are cheating the government of its revenues, then.../mrjc 13COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO II-1 November 7, 2012 10:23 a.m, 1 THE SENATE PRESIDENT. of its revenues, then we must do so. I’m handing to you this. I'll just request the Secretariat to give me a copy. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Yes. This was earlier manifested by the Senate President and placed on record and we are committing to conduct hearings on this and other agricultural produce such as meat, livestock, and vegetables, onions, and we will be inviting again our representatives of the Bureau of Customs to be present as well as the Department of Agriculture. Hopefully, if it’s the agricultural products, apart from rice, that we will have the Secretary attend, Usec Rudinas. ‘And in the next hearing, when that hearing is called, we would like to know what is the status of the negotiations between the DA and the BoC on the IFM, the Inward Foreign Manifest. I am told, on record, that this is now being made available, however, due to some computer considerations, the same has not been effectively implemented. Is that correct, Usec Rudinas, Commissioner? MR. BIAZON. Yes, Mr. Chairman, Mr. Senate President, good morning. . 14COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO II-1 November 7, 2012 1 3am. 2 We have already entered into an arrangement with the Department of Agriculture with regard to the Inward Foreign Manifest. We have given them access to our computer system, Their personnel were trained on how to use it as well as the standard procedure of giving them access to the hard copies. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). 50 this is now— MR. BIAZON. It’s being implemented, Your Honor. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Ah, okay. Thank you Thank you for that clarification, Commissioner Biazon. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. Mr. Chairman. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Yes, Mr. President. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. If you remember, earlier in the hearing of this rice importation, Indian rice importation, we requested the Bureau of Customs to check with the customs authorities of Indonesia about certain information. Have you gotten anything from them? MR. BIAZON. Your Honor, they have just given us an acknowledgement of our request. They have not yet submitted the 15COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO = II-1 November 7, 2012 10:23 a.m. 3 exact data that we requested from them, We will do continuing follow- up, Your Honor. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). May we have a copy of the acknowledgement? MR. BIAZON. Yes, Your Honor. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Thank you, Commissioner Biazon. With that, Mr. President, I suggest that we suspend this committee hearing to a later date until such time that we have been able to secure jurisdiction over the persons as well as their physical presence here in the committee hearing, specifically the traders that we have subpoenaed The following were subpoenaed, just for the record: Emily Alabado, Ma. Crisanta Reyes, Mr. Elpidio Mendoza, Mr. Maximo Hernandez, Mr. Juanito David, Mrs. Jane Artuz—all representatives of farmers organizations and cooperatives. And the following, as well, traders: Mr. Efren John Frac, Mr, Michael Villanueva, Mr. Gil Calipayan, Ms. Sandra Lim, Ms. Mary Joyce Lim, Mr. Jeffrey Daradal, Mr. Willy © Sy, Mr. Ifigo Espiritu, Mr. Jason Colocado, Mr. Jupiter Ong, Mr. Denis. + 16COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO II-1 November 7, 2012 10:23 a.m. 4 Gonzales, Ms. Jenny Reyes, Ms. Jenny Alfonso, Mr. Michael Cao. Also Mr. Ricarda Gatuz, Mr. Juanita Evangelista, Mr, Ronald Valdez, Ms. Zenaida Abanio and Mr. Felix Villena Sr. All these subpoenaed, Mr. President—and Atty. Eugene Guiang Pioquinto. Of all these subpoenaed, only Mrs. Jane Artuz appeared here personally. THE SENATE PRESIDENT. Mr. Chairman, we'll now ask the NBI to conduct the investigation and submit the report and before that report is submitted, we will suspend the hearing so that when we get the report of the NBI, we will know what to do with those—with the whole problem. In the meantime, I think we will order the arrest of all the officials that we subpoenaed and who did not appear here and hold them detained until we get the result of the investigation of the National Bureau of Investigation. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). And one more concern, Mr. President, Mr. Bayani is here. Well, he is currently detained in the Senate detention room. 7 17COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO = II-1 November 7, 2012 10:23a.m, 5 Do you wish to clear yourself of the contempt citation by answering the questions of the Senate President? Or do you continue to maintain that this is your right against privacy? MR. BAYANI. Good morning, Your Honors. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). The right to privacy, rather, MR. BAYANI. Until now, my financiers did not give me any way na sabihin ko po sa inyo kung sino siya until now, pero yung pakikipag- usap naman po nung lawyer ko na even na nandidito ako, nakikipag- usap po sila para sabihin or para bigyan nila ako ng right para sabihin kung sino sita THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Mr. President, he maintains his refusal to divulge the information and the Senate Committee has left with no choice but to continue to detain Mr. Bayani But Mr. Bayani, we would like to inform you that anytime you wish to divulge the information, as requested, and answer the questions of the Senate President, we will make the necessary— undertake the necessary processes to give you that opportunity. But in g 18COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE AND FOOD JOINT WITH COMMITTEES ON WAYS AND MEANS; TRADE AND COMMERCE; AND ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) MELNOVERO II-1 November 7, 2012 10:23 a.m. 6 the meantime, you will have to stay in the detention room of the Senate, MR. BAYANI. Thank you, Your Honor. THE CHAIRMAN (SEN. PANGILINAN). Thank you, too With that, we will suspend the committee hearing of the Committees on Agriculture and Food, Ways and Means, Trade and Commerce, and Accountability of Public Officers and Investigations until further notice. We will have a committee hearing this afternoon to dispose of the issue of the motion to cite those earlier mentioned in contempt and order their arrest, for the record, The committee hearing is hereby suspended. (THE HEARING WAS SUSPENDED AT 10:30 A.M.). my 19Y Republic of the Philippies CONGRESS OF THE PHILIPPINES SENATE Pasay City COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE & FOOD, COMMITTEE ON WAYS AND MEANS, COMMITTEE ON TRADE AND COMMERCE and COMMITTEE ON ACCOUNTABILITY OF PUBLIC OFFICERS AND INVESTIGATIONS (BLUE RIBBON) ‘Wednesday, 07 November 2012. 9:20 AM, Senate Session Hal SENATE OF THE PHILIPPINES. GSIS CENTER, PASAY CITY AGENDA: PRIVILEGE SPEECH OF SENATE PRESIDENT JUAN PONCE ENRILE RE: RICE SMUGGLING AT THE SUBIC BAY FREEPORT ZONE ATTENDANCE MEMBERS | |] represented BY 4 2. SEN. RALPH G. RECTO, _ | | Lt | 3, SEN, MANNY VILLAR, Chavon, ¢ . SEN. TEOFISTO L. GUINGONA Ill, Chavman Committee an Accountability of tie | eons (ie Rebbe | 5. SEN. FRANKLIN M. DRILON [s.sen EDGARDO J. ANGARA 7, SEN. LOREN 8. LEGAROA cs SEN, PANFILO MM. LACSON | 9. SEN, SERGIO R, OSMERA i 10. SEN, GREGORIO B. HONASAN I | 1. SEN. MIRIAM OEFENSOR SANTIAGO | 12 SEN, MANUEL "LITO" W,LAPIO [13 SEN. PIAS, CAYETANO | 14 SEN. RAMON “BONG” REVILLA JR |15.SEN. FERDINAND R. MARCOS, JR | 18. SEN. ANTONIO “Sonny” F. TRILLANES IV | 17. SEN. FRANCIS “CHIZ"G. ESCUDERO 18. SEN, AQUILINO °KOKO" PIMENTEL I [79 SEN. JOKER P, ARROYO | 20. SEN. JINGGOY EJERCITO ESTRADA, E-Oticn Mumter | 21. SEN. VICENTE C. SOTTO, & Otto Ho 22. SEN. ALAN PETER 8. CAYETANO, fy Oitcv Yentar | 23. SEN. JUAN PONCE ENRILE. rey TF T | | | py tt ee ee Vi)SENATE SECRETARIAT NAME ——=—=«| DES IGNATION/OFFICE HORACE R. CRUDA beg, tom, See SIGNATURE ERIC CANA JEFFREY PADRE JUAN ROSALIN avail is, = MA. ERAPERAIRIZ NOVERO z= Hogue Dizon, LWA dtnnico | Guubramo Avorn Ronee ORTIZ Ceouia Lotro | Rowen AL Gee | Marie, Menje7A iY BATA LUMA GONZALES — | HtLen Gayars eet TE SALA ULE TTL Le —t- | ~ pala werd tet [Emavnue. Nae aR finite t Ae a “(sow / TSO | My iar Bacall —Duce-br Gemal SB ny A_-ARRIETA WSA4 bei compaceE ct [Antonio p Lazagn, LUA PeeL_ta, FER WADE? 221SENATORS STAFF NAME DESIGNATION/OFFICE| SIGNATURE | GOW FEnSArmin ole, GuinanA Lukde (2A_MalAeeMie Ow {pet Zama orp IPE Kew Carpe OS ET — mba a | DbSieee gunce) “O/q Reez0 a eer fa dec expader LYE t — Ling _| Ren N Fro OB tera" J ofc kids | - r an + - = .92GUESTS/ RESOURCE PERSONS NAME OE OENCE | EMATZContact No, | Signature a et ae i Bou | atoll z re drt Cubic, | (eo bertaba2 © yale wince fp eade | COS | mane hia ne ie iz Givens Plate | COA [Man nplae g hn |GET ROWED CONCEPEIDY) CDA ee t fe pho a LkOyIGieLDG DATA | Ge ~ #5. | Johans Gurtorte~ [Feels - AY. RICA srt | tral Ani et RAINS 4 ony te ™ bea ee 6 6 ¥ 177 «!4 eee ESC) 6 pez 22 40, = Tne tn Papin | Puan Corry Le I Sawwif sua hk MIRA foods FLIRT TLC AE: dap pee peye Guo HP key) v cru | CB5(0. Winona Cetan i _ Cniro AT IRINES OMA | IGaacio GAecra ! — fegetes S Peper - | AN PAIFF ~Pekpentca Thaced | Skea [erase eases Pita Pres} ara OB a Fey. st0e12 Bunn | Hamcona tap 01% E207 - Lose CoeOean | NOTA hay doe Pate Foeree | Fear ban Hes loys LRT Evusion heres Ppp Leads UE Ont gary oo SE 19GUESTS/RESOURCE PERSONS 7 DESIGNATION! OFFICE “S. Mendorn_| Duta ery OPH (ele FP) [ity beial Uiflanvenn | NFA Office. Neves bepeaer [PRE alla __ Fitri. | Pt mrs Cay. v “Hah ity ae Wu Hoc . #d | Ceanset | ae “lituvs hou — Us SDs Tame TONLE (OO face ALBANS Seely am ON Se Jon Poke Dine i ies Duda Ab Niele ets L + bean Ag ae FO atay OKT AeA | Mefideastem | Gevera F. Ces ARF. Ran per Arey ewe OCkHPD Bong buwar Ause rh Linunay Sintong Re bald PERT E Houtle de Teed, ree ee ear ud pi) Y ie Bi KARINA Port RACE Reehen. Sal bated MIC Beg BOS IPE | Hee [et eal EMAIL/Contact No. | Signature Jarre |Prel Mor PK ‘il her joes i fa Lng 17 60 vet | ve Cr baa. “eR SEL EE IDI eL ET i f | tf te. oO ote cm | { Sima a Onze oC * pepe Sn OLLT GAS AOIF | Aeas97 0039 — oF aca rce A Mh | 9209500370 | p97 efay69 { AG GIAO | AL Qe Sev) Geeanbue 4 Bidegh= 2 0989-330- Gi74 | SHG 9 Ga2e | ORE 0222 | 50934dm | t | OG $¥9087 > | Cfo hera7s | eeqesys apes ere2 csc a CT |, O417 - 4423471 OTT (GF Caves