2) United States Patent (io Patent No: US. 8,576,687 BI
‘US008576687B1
chréder (45) Date of Patent: Nov. 5, 2013
(Si) COMPACT TANGENTIAL TRACKING 4208851 4 + 8198 Duvsea soos
TONEARM MECHANISM Stl A” Sb Boe
(71) Appian Frank Seer, Beta (DE) Agm28 Ae ase His sass
(72) Inventor: Frank Seer, Betn (DF) SG fat Eig Satan aed
PGs mas Eanes Sean so
oo. r—™—*s—C—==?==s_=™" Bx
patent is extended of adjusted under 35
eee POREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
(21) Appl. Nos 137685,812 » sros7761 A * 3/1982
(22) Filed: Oet.8,2012 * citod by examiner
Primary Examiner — Brian Miller
(74) Awtornes, Agent, or Firm — Coben & Grigsby, BC.
(60) Provisional application No. 61/$43.956, filed on Ost. (57) ABSTRACT
6.2011, provisional application No. 61/549,302, filed
fon Oxt, 20, 2011
Related U.S. Application Data
The invention relates to tonearm tracking mechanisms in
shonograph players and mechanical devices constructed for
en eee {he purpose of rprodicing oF paying back rvordod aio
Gute 10 (2006.01) ‘material previous impressed nthe oem or grooves, ono
eanuse surface ofa disk, which are commonly called phonograph
a seoman;s6o72ss_layersortmtables, Such disk is commonly eae, among
‘thr similar words phonograph cord oa vinyl disk. The
Co) a eee resent invention i tangential tracking tonearm mecha
USPC 369/220, 244.1, 245,255,220 PS tngental tracking =
nism, wherein the toneam bearing subassembly has (wo
rotary bearings in the lateral plane and a coupling linkage
built into a compact subassembly. The collective contribution
Se application ile for complete search history.
669, References Cited of thse elements, when propery configured and apprope
US. PATENT DOCUMENTS ately adjusted, make, during playback of audio material on a
tisk, reduced playback distortion over radial tacking mecha-
3476304 A 1969 Bich nisms and closely mimics the conditions under which nearly
3sis100 A 81994 Mayer fll imesters are ede
Ssesos A 7974 Bich
4153286 851979 Gah 14 Claims, 6 Drawing SheetsU.S. Patent Nov. 5, 2013 Sheet 1 of 6 US 8,576,687 B1
15 21
8
31
FIG. 1U.S. Patent Nov. 5, 2013 Sheet 2 of 6 US 8,576,687 B1
ky
J x
NhUS 8,576,687 BL
Sheet 3 of 6
Nov. 5, 2013
U.S, PatentU.S, Patent Nov. 5, 2013, Sheet 4 of 6 US 8,576,687 B1U.S. Patent Nov. 5, 2013 Sheet 5 of 6 US 8,576,687 B1U.S. Patent Nov. 5, 2013 Sheet 6 of 6 US 8,576,687 B1
40
Fig. 6
30US 8,576,687 BI
1
COMPACT TANGENTIAL TRACKING.
‘TONEARM MECHANISM.
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
‘he present invention relates to tonearm tracking mecha
nisms in phonograph players. More particularly the present
invention relates 10 mechanical devices constrocted for the
purposco repreducing or playing hack recorded dio mte-
Fial previously impressed, in the form or grooves, onto &
surfice of a disk, Such devices are eomtmonly called phono-
‘graph players or turntables, Such disk is commonly calle,
nong othe similar words, a phonograph record or a Vinyl
slsk. Even more particularly, the preseat invention describes
‘8 novel design of the tonearm mechanism, «component pat
‘ofa phonograph player which is capable of tracking a groove
jn a phonographie disk in a congolled fishion, most espe-
ily ina tangential manner.
‘Conventional toneaem mechanisms Fall generally into 16
‘categories: 1) a radial tracking mechanism wherein the path
‘ofa stylus, Which is attached via several subcomponents t0
theendofoncend ofatoncarm, fllowsacurved pathover the
surface of a grooved disk. The curved path is portion of @
rele centered about point near and outside te outer cir-
‘cumference of te disk; and 2) tangential tacking meh
nism wherein the path of @ stylus, which is attached via
several subcomponents tothe end of a tonearm, follows 3
Tinear path over the surface of a grooved disk. The linear path
‘over the surface corresponds 0 radial line fromthe center of
the disk and the mechanism that is employed to achieve the
linear path isa form of linear bearing,
‘Kaownin the artis athied category of toncarma mechanism,
namely on that has tracking characteristic that achieves the
proove-40-siylus relationship of a tangential racking mecha-
nism but is constructed from rotational bearings similar 10
those found in a radial tracking: mechanism. In this third
‘category of tonearm mechanisms, the stylus need not follow
‘single radial line coming from the center of the phonograph
disk, Tangential tracking mechanisms are considered 10 be
‘capable of more accurately rendering the reconied
‘ona disk because the motion of a playback stylus relat
‘8 groove of a disk more accurately mimies the manner in,
‘which the original audio material was eut into a surfece of 3
master disk. Tangential tracking mechanisms are not as com-
‘mon as racial racking mechanisms becaise tangential track=
jing mechanisms tend to be more complicated, pysically
Jager, and more costly to precuve than ral tracking mecha-
nisms. The presen invention falls into this thid category of
tonearm mechanisms. US. Pat, Nos. 3,476,394; 3,813,100:
3,826,505; 4,153,256; 4,344,168; 4,346,466; and 4,580,258
disclose various tonearms of this category.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
Lathes used to ent masters of analog audio material on
lacquer disks have (commonly) a cutting bead that moves
slovily ina radial direetion, thos assuring that a groove ere
sted by a euttng diamond! stylus is alvays oriented perpen-
dicular to a radius of the disk, Positive (groves, versus
molded inverse “hills”) copies or sueli masters may be played
back using a phonograph player witha playback transducer
having a stylus, a canridge with internal components that
hold the stylus, headshell that supports the eartidge, the
hheadshellatached to a tonearm which in tur is held by @
tonearm bearing subassembly. When, during playback, the
‘manner of playback closely matches the manner in which the
‘original or master disk was produced, particularly with regard
0
o
2
tothe relative angular orientation ofthe stylus and the groove,
fone key source of systematic reproduction errors is essen.
‘ally eliminate.
"The various components ofthe tonearm mechanism must
work together tallow a faithful rendering of audio material
recorded onadisk. To achieve this revit, the tonearm hearing
subassembly must apply a foree on the styhis to hold the
Stylus in the groove during tracking (ie. while the disk is
rotating aboot its axis) without applying so much force that
the stylus wears surfaces of the groove; and the headsbell
cartidge and siyhos must rise and fall during tacking +0
‘aecommodate changes in the Vertical height ofthe op surface
ofthe disk e.g dveto a warped condition ofthe disk);and the
‘onearm bearing assembly should not allow the tonearm 10
rock about its own axis significantly; nd the tonearm bearing
‘assembly must allow the tonearm to track the graove in the
disk as successive revolutions a the disk change the position
ofthe stylus relative tothe center of the disk.
‘The tacking properties of @toneaem assembly govern the
Aidelty of a signal erated by a playback transducer. A tan-
gentialtrocking tonearm allows the cartridge to play back the
fudio material ina way that very closely approximates the
‘way in which the original master was ereated, and leads to
superior sound fidelity compared to an otherwise similat,
radial tacking tonearm (in the reproduced), A radial tracking
‘tonearm plays back the audio material in a way that loosely
approximates the way in which the original master was ere-
fated, and leads to reduced sound fidelity, Terms commonly
‘used to desribe signal errors da to inaccurate rendering of
the recorded material boeauso the tracking during playback
‘doesnot closely match the conditions under which the origi
‘al master Was ereated are “playhack distortion” and “track-
ing distortion.”
The present invention is a tangential tracking toneam
‘mechanism, wherein the lonearm bearing subassembly has
‘to roary bearings in the lateral plane anda coupling linkage
built nto compact subassembly. The collective contribution
of these elements, when properly configured and appropri-
tly adjusted, make, during playback of audio material on &
‘isk, rexduced playback distortion over radial tacking mecha-
isms and elosely mimics the conditions under which nearly
all masters are made.
tis an object of the present invention to rede tracking,
sistoion by orienting the playback stylus in the disk’s
fgroove during playback in a manner designed to closely
:mimie the motion of the cutting stylus used during eration of
the master
isan object ofthe present invention to maintain tangency
‘of the stylus in the groove during playback.
Itisan objec of the present invention to provide tonearm
smechuanism that may be atached, or retrofited, tan existing
tumtable
I's. an object ofthe present invention to incorporate bear
‘ng technology that redices frictional losses in order to mi
‘mize wear onthe walls ofthe groove being played back and to
‘assist in maintaining accurate tangeney inthe orientation or
the stylus with respect tothe groove throughout playback
Tis. an objet ofthe present inveation to incomporate mag
pel technology to reduce the degree of errr fom tangency
tracking.
is also an object ofthe present invention to incorporate
specially shaped magnetic components inthe path of ink-
‘age magnetic field for setting the racking characterises ofa
stylus ine tonesem mechanism,
isan object ofthe present invention to incorporate, into a
tonearm mechanism, linkage mechanisms comprising non-
manet and non-magnetic components and (0 Verically=US 8,576,687 BI
3
‘oriented rotary bearings to control the angular and transi
tional disposition of a stylus during playback 10 achieve
substantially tangential tracking
tis an objct ofthe present invention to provide a linkage
‘means for tailoring the path a stylus follows, both in angular
‘orientation and in displacement, during playback
Punter ebjects and advantages will be described in suc-
‘ceeding setions ofthis specification,
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
FIG. 1 is a top view of a phonograph player and shows
here the tonearm subassembly resides relative to other cr
ponents of « phonognph player
FIG. 2is.a schematic diagram, side view, of the bearings
and linkage ofthe toncarm mechanism, where the magnet is
‘tan inner end of the magnet guide;
FIG. 3 isa schematic diagram, side view, ofthe bearings
‘and linkage ofthe tonearm mechanism, where the magnets
fan outer end of the magnet guide:
FIG. 4 isa schematic diagram, top view, of portion the
toncarm mechanism showing the disposition of the vertical
bearings when the magnet is at an inner end ofthe magnet
uid:
FIG. 8 isa schematic diapram, top view, ofa portionof the
tonearm mechanism showing the disposition of the vertical
bearings when the magnet is near the outer end ofthe magnet
uide:
FIG. 6 is schematic diagram, top view, of portion the
toncarm mechanism showing the path followed by the mage
net during playback ofa phonographic disk,
DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
Referring now to the drawings, the invention is shown in
FIGS. 1 through 6 as a set of components of @ toneam
mechanism 10 assembled stop a planar surface of » phono-
graph turntable In FIG. 1, attachedabove turntable surface 11
fs tonearm bearing subassembly 12, which in tar supports
tonearm 13, A component of tonearm bearing subassembly
12, showen in FIG. 3, i tonearm mounting collar 14 which is
alixed, via base screw 15 to tumtable surface 11. Supported
by tonearm mounting collar 14 is a vertically-oriented base
bearing subassembly 16, Referring to FIG. 3, attached or
‘ncomporated within base bearing subassembly 16 are vertical
bearing housing 17, base bearing 34, guide platform 18 and
magnet guide 19, and base shaft 20
‘Referring again to FIG. 3, attachod 1 the op of base shat
20 sive! platfonn 21 Inserted ina hole in swivel platform
21 and rigidly affixed is venically-oriented tonearm bearing-
housing 22, containing upper swivel bearing 38 and lower
swivel bearing 36, into which is placed tonearm shaft 23. The
{opoftoncurm shaft 23 supports tonearm pivothousing 4, To
the bottom of tonearm shaft 23s attached magnet platform 28
‘upon which is affixed magnet 26,
‘Referring now to FIG. 2 and FIG. 3, within tonearm pivot
housing 24 are two point pivot bearings, left point pivot
bearing 27 and right point pivot beating 28 which, together,
support tonearm 13. Left point pivot bearing 27'and right
point pivot earing 28 together define shorizontally-oriented
bearingandserveto restrict, within tonearm pivot housing 24,
tonearm 13 to rotation about tonearm pivot aki 48. To the rear
‘of tonearm 13 is attached counterweight 29, The counter-
‘weight 29 features an inner sleeve, made from a marginally
‘compliant material, such as an acetal resin, Delrin (a regis
tered trademark of, and manufactured and sold by FI
DuPont De Nemours and Company) ora oorinated hydro-
0
o
4
carbon polymer sueh as Teflon (a registered trademark of and
‘manufactured and sold by E. DuPont De Nemours and
Company). grub sew, accesible from above, compresses
the sleeve such thatthe effective eoupling intensity ean be
adjusted by varying the screw torque, In other words, the
counterweight canbe slid—against varying tition —to
adjust the tracking force unless the grub serew is tightened
silficienlly to secure the position To the font of tonearm 13
js attached headshell 30. Contained within or held below
Ibeadshell 30 is a cartridge, not shown, containing compo-
‘ents, not shown, leading toa cantilever 37 to which a play-
back Stylus 31 is attohed
‘In further detail, again refering to FIGS. 1 through 8, the
combined effect of the various components isto produce &
desired motion of playback stylus 31, during playback of
recorded material embodied ina groove 32, impressed, in a
spiral fashion, on phonograph disk 33. Tangential tracking is
achieved by providing two paths for the force applied to
playback stylus 31 to reach the vertcaly-oriented bearings.
‘One sul path i strictly mechanical and ean be regarded as
setting the angular position of toneann shaft 23; another path
incorporates Hinkage tat, in effect, sets the angular position
fof base shall 20, which, inthe process of rotating, shits the
position of tonearm pivot housing 24. The shape of magnet
ude 19 provides a means for continuously controling the
‘degree of such shifing as the positon of playback stylus 31
changes during playback. The simplified drawing of FIG. 6
illustrates magnet path 44, shown as a dashed line, as fol
lowed during playback of a phonograph disk
‘The two paths, generally described above, by which lateral
(ein the plane ofthe top surface of phonograph disk 33)
{ores acting upon stylus 31 are transmitted throghout the
‘earings and linkage, shall now he describ in greater det
Aft path forthe foree applied to playback stylus 3 starts
‘with toncarm mounting cola 14, which is altached to turn-
table surf 11 by base serew 18, Tonearm mounting colar
114 contains within it wertieally-oriented base bearing sub
sembly 16 which allows the rigid connection of toncarm
bearing subsssembly 12 to the turntable or its “tonearm
Doan” via a single eecentrcally oriented sere. Is second
function stoallow for sting the height ofthe tonearm 13, or
‘more correctly, vertical tacking angle ("VTA"). Tis ean be
achieved by a grub screw in tonearm mounting collar 14
effectively clamping bearing subassembly 16 when in gular
‘operation, but, aller loosening the grub screw, allowing for
the bearing subassembly 16 tobe slid up or down to account
{or different turntable/platter and or cartridge dimensions,
‘one component of which is veical bearing housing 17 into
Which base shat 20, fre to rotate about base vertical axis 38
is inserted. Atachod to base shaft 20 is swivel platform 21,
which rotates ina horizontal plane as bese shalt 20 rotates.
Swivel platform 21 suppors ands rigidly alixed to tonearm
bearing subassembly 12. Tonearm bearing subassembly 12
contains a second bearing assembly, also having a vertical
axis of rotation, herein referred tas vertical bearing housing.
22. Into this vertical tonearm bearing inserted tonesem shalt
23, which extends from below the bottom of tonearm bearing
subassembly 12 to above the top of tonearm beating subas-
sembly 12, Rigidly attached to tonearm shaft 23 ata poi
above tonearm bearing subassembly 12 is tonearm pivot
housing 24, which can be connected by a serew or manufse-
tured such tht it i a one piece component. Tonearm pivot
‘housing 24 has horizonally-oriented tonearm clearance hole
39 through which tonearm 13 is placed. Tonearm clearance
hole 39s larger in diameter than the diameter of tonearm 13
‘which enables tonearm 13 when follwing vertical motion oF
playback stylus M, to move within a vertical tracking planeUS 8,576,687 BI
5
that contains a center axis of tonearm clearance hole 39. To
‘constrain tonearm 13 fo angular motion inthe vertical tck=
ing plane, toneaem pivot hole 4, peependicuar to tonearm
‘clearance hole 39 and perpendictlar to the vertical trcking
plane is constricted in toneamn pivot housing 24, Tonear
Pivot howsing 24 intersects tonearm clearance hole 39, form-
‘ng two distintly separate sections o the toneam pivot hole
‘One of the two sections shall be called lft pivot hole 42,
andthe other section shall becalled right pivot hole 43. The
taxis of left pivot hole 42 andthe axis of ight pivot hole 43 are
‘collinear, Inve left pivot hole 42 is placed left point pivot
bearings 27 and into right pivot hole 4 is placed right point
pivot bearing 28, These two pivot point bearings serve in
concert, once aligned with receptacle features, not shown in
the figures, on tonearm 13 and fixed in place, to create @
tonearm pivot axis about which tonearm 13 i Fee to rote
‘Counterweight 29 is placed on one end of tonearm 13, the
‘exact position of counterweight 29 along toneanm 13 being
‘easily adjustable. On the other end of toneanm 13 is attached,
hheadshell 30 or similar supporting assembly. To headsell 30
jis attached a trnscacer subassembly having various compo=
nents, neof which i playback sylus 31 Playback stylis $1
supported by cantilever 47 is the one and only element that
touches groove 32 in phonograph disk 39. The force with
‘which playback stylus 1 presses down and into groove 32s,
set by an adjustment procedure that involves placing and
fixing counterweight 29 ina position along toneae 13 such
that a desired amount of force is applied. In tonearm assem-
blies designed to track (tangentially) groove in a phono-
raph disk, the stylus, tthe point where the stylus contacts a
[groove is oriented to trck the groove sich thatthe stylus
‘orientation equals tht oF the cuting sil, i. runs parallel
to, the vertical tracking plane is in, o at least runs parallel to
the vertical racking plane,
"A second path forthe force applied to playback stylus 31
starts with the tonearm mounting collar 14. separate com
ponent, not deseribed previously, spar of vertical
base bearing subassembly 16, This part shall be called guide
platform 14: its attached tothe outside of vertical bearing
housing 17. ‘The angular orientation of guide platform 18,
about the axis of hase shat 20, is adjustable, Once adjusted
and fixed place, guide platform 18s notpermited to move,
unlike base shal 20, To the botlom of guide platform 18 is
attached a magnetically aetive magnet guide 19. Magnet
uide 19 contoured in sucha way tht tangential tacking is
‘achieved, Finally, to the bottom of tonearm shaft 23 is,
attached! magnet platform 28, which ean be attached by
screwed! connection, press fit, glued or riveted means. Magnet
platform 28 moves in concert with any angular motion, in a
horizontal plane, of tonearm 13. To the far end of magnet
platform 25 is attached magnet 26, which is press fit or inter
erence ft andl ean be glued or secured by a screw, or prefer
‘ably a small horizontal grub sorew, Te top of magnet 26 is