Professional Documents
Culture Documents
T302
Beatrice Ng (S10162733D)
Claudia Ng (S10164086G)
Kenneth Tan (S10163656E)
1
Content Page
1.0 Introduction 3
2.1 Definitions 4
2.2 State of Sexualisation of Minors In Graphic Novels Around 4
The World
2.3 State Of Sexualisation Of Minors In Graphic Novels In Asia 5
2.4 State Of Sexualisation Of Minors In Manga In Japan 7
2.4.1 Political 7
2.4.2 Economical 8
2.4.3 Social 8
2.4.4 Technological 10
2.5 Research Gap 11
4.0 Methodology 13
6.0 Recommendations 21
7.0 Conclusion 23
2
1.0. Introduction
In June 2014, the Japanese government banned the possession of real images that
novels was often brought up in debates since it is still legal under the law. Unfortunately,
explicit graphic novels in Japan has led to the issue of a high number of child abuse
cases, suggesting that there is a need to tackle the issue from all three aspects. The
target audience, the United Nations International Children's Emergency Fund (UNICEF),
is invested in protecting and defending the rights of children. This research proposal will
eventually ban the consumption, possession and production of graphic novels that
sexualise minors in Japan, ultimately decreasing related child abuse cases and creating
a safe haven for Japanese children. This research proposal focuses on the
sexualisation of minors in graphic novels in Japan. Japan was chosen as the focus
country as its graphic novel (manga) industry is highly profitable. Graphic novels are
also commonly read by Japanese people, and form the basis of many anime
3
2.0 Literature Review
2.1 Definitions
persons under the age of 18 (Arnett 156). Graphic novels refer to stories that are
the research perimeter has been streamlined to only include manga, which refers to
Globally, there has been multiple reported cases of graphic novelists punished by law
In the United States (US), 2010, Christopher Hendley, a comic book collector, was
sentenced to prison under the 2003 PROTECT Act for importing and possessing seven
Japanese comic books depicting cartoon children having sex. Hendley’s case was
confiscated a package mailed from Japan to him containing Japanese comic books
featuring graphics of minor females engaged in sex with older males and animals.
Further investigations from the US Postal Inspection Services also indicated findings
from Hendley’s house which included drawings of children engaged in sexually abusive
acts (Masuchika).
4
The Comic Book Legal Defense Fund is a non-profit organisation in the US which fights
against the censorship of comic books and protects the First Amendment right to free
speech. It also provides legal representation for comic artists facing prosecution
In the United Kingdom in 2014, manga fan Robul Hoque became the first man in Britain
setting of the images, they explicitly depict young girls in school uniforms exposing
Through research, it is found that no other country besides the US has an organisation
In Asia, countries like Singapore has legislation to counter explicit content. Singapore’s
way that is injurious to the public good, exploits nudity in children and breaks the
standards of morality, decency and propriety that are generally accepted by reasonable
members of the community. Section 292 of the Penal Code also supports the act, by
stating that whoever sells, lets to hire, distributes, transmits by electronic means,
5
publicly exhibits or in any manner puts into circulation, or for purposes of sale, hire,
figure, or any other obscene object whatsoever (“Section 292”). Additionally, it is also
against the law to keep, distribute or sell pornographic films under sections 29 and 30 of
In South Korea, laws surrounding child pornography were revised in 2011 to include
materials like photographs, drawings and visual recordings, featuring visual and
nonvisual minors in sexual situations. The law treats imaginary sex with an imaginary
child the same as sex with a real child, and individuals caught in both acts face the
same minimum sentence. As such, Koreans caught downloading manga with images
Through research, it is found that the consumption, possession and production of virtual
6
2.4 State Of Sexualisation Of Minors In Manga In Japan
2.4.1 Political
In June 2014, Japan banned the possession of child pornography images that
depict real children. Potential offenders were given a year to dispose the images.
imprisoned for up to one year and fined up to 1 million yen. However, the law
excludes child pornography images in manga, animated films and video games
(Hellmann).
The US’ 2015 “Country Reports on Human Rights Practices” critiqued Japan for
not having laws to address the availability of sexually explicit cartoons, comics
and video games in Japan. They suggested that Japan’s culture was one that
accepted the depiction of child sexual abuse. This caused strains in political
7
2.4.2 Economical
yearly, which boosts the economy. In 2016, the manga industry generated
USD3.91 billion in physical and digital sales. This was a USD3 million increase in
In 2016, the sale of digital manga volumes increased by 27.1% from 2015. This
aligns with the technological observation of a high smartphone penetration rate and
2.4.3 Social
Crimes related to child abuse in Japan increased fivefold from 2004 to 2014. At
least 600 children fell victim to paedophile directors and photographers yearly
(McNeill). These child abuse images were featured in various mediums that
detrimental. There is a general belief that manga with sexually explicit images of
8
minors are a venting mechanism for individuals with paedophile fantasies
(Varley), and that reading them is fine. However, critics have expressed that
even if no one is harmed in the creation of the explicit manga, it can normalise,
After Tokyo’s metropolitan government revised the law of illegal sexual or violent
acts or sex involving anyone under the age of 18, while also prohibiting children
under 13 from posing for materials that portray them in suggestive ways, Japan’s
top 10 publishers boycotted the Tokyo International Anime Fair. Manga artists
and publishers have resisted on the ban of certain images, as they feel that it is a
9
2.4.4 Technological
Mangas that sexualise minors are readily available on the web. New digital
Now, sites like Epubor.com display numerous websites where consumers can
read a large variety of manga online for free. They are also able to access
manga that sexualise minors since these websites often do not implement an
10
2.5 Research Gap
Lack of examples from the larger Asian regions such as China and India makes it hard
to justify that the issue of sexualisation of minors in manga context happening in Japan
No external organisations have taken any other actions besides issuing a warning to
To date, only UNICEF has stepped up to verbally urge Japan to ban images that
11
3.0 Research Question
How can the UNICEF work with the Japanese government to explore ways to reduce
the sexualisation of minors in manga to address child sexual abuse cases and create a
12
4.0 Methodology
Due to resource constraints and the fact that the issue resides in Japan, conducting
primary research is unlikely. Thus, secondary research will be used to answer the
research question and make recommendations. Secondary research can deepen the
understanding of past and current campaigns by UNICEF in and out of Japan, and will
However, there is a lack of research and campaigns by UNICEF targeted towards the
sexualisation of minors in graphics novels in and out of Japan. Examples found mainly
cover larger issues like child pornography and sexual violence. Reason potentially
being, these forms of sexualisation deals with the exploitation of real-life children and
graphic novels. Despite that, consequences arising from the sexualisation of minors in
real life are still closely linked to those of a fictional context. As such, information about
past and current campaigns by UNICEF dealing with child pornography and sexual
violence, in and out of Japan, will be needed. Information about UNICEF’s partnerships
The content analysed will comprise mainly of quantitative research through the study of
13
Through the analysis of past and current UNICEF campaigns, practices and
collaborations with governments and NGOs, there will be greater insight on how
UNICEF can effectively work with the Japanese Government to reduce the
14
5.0 Findings and Analysis
Since 1996, UNICEF has been combating child pornography in Japan when the first
World Congress against Commercial Sexual Exploitation of Children was held (“Child
rights advocates”). The World Congress helped Japanese delegates examine their
country’s attitudes and perceptions as to what was accepted as legal tolerance towards
child pornography. In 1999, a new law against the commercial sexual exploitation of
and Kasai).
In 2008, the Japan Committee for UNICEF and its non-governmental partner
reform Japanese law. The proposed new legislation would make the possession of child
pornography illegal, even if the offender had no intention of selling or distributing the
content. The law was successfully reformed in 2014. (“Child rights advocates”)
The past efforts of UNICEF were done to tackle child pornography and the commercial
sexual exploitation of children in Japan. The World Congress questioned Japan’s legal
tolerance towards child pornography, and alongside the 2008 campaign, paved the way
15
However, since the 2008 campaign, there has been no other campaigns by UNICEF to
In 2009, UNICEF worked with then-Filipino president Gloria Arroyo to pass the
Filipino children from abusers and create “a safe haven for children” (“Success for
UNICEF”). The act would penalise anyone who produces, distributes or assists in the
In December 2017, UNICEF’s Philippines study revealed that it “is still among the
the need to raise awareness and vigilance of the issue, so that parents, who
occasionally contribute to the statistic by arranging child sexual abuse on camera, will
know that child sexual abuse is morally wrong and affects a child’s health and mental
development.
expertise and listening to the voice of youth” (Kon), which paved the way for Brunei’s
efforts in the cyber protection of children through the 2013 establishment of a Child
Online Protection framework. Brunei was the first country in the Southeast-Asian region
16
to do so. The framework builds on an existing legislation in Brunei which criminalises
the possession of child pornography and causing a person under 16 to watch a sexual
The past efforts of UNICEF were done to tackle and bring attention to the issues of child
pornography and child sexual abuse in the world. The studies highlight the situation of
child pornography and sexual abuse in other asian countries and raises questions on
UNICEF’s global “The State of the World’s Children 2017” report indicates global digital
safety as one of its core focus. It has embarked on uncovering how the Internet and
digital technology is helping and hindering children’s learning, well-being and social
relationships, and has shedded light on the positive and detrimental effects of digital
technology (“The State of”). One specific segment focused on child sexual abuse and
UNICEF then ensured a call to action for the digital technology sector in the government
and telecom industries to make expanding internet access and protecting the children a
17
The information provided from this report will be useful in helping to push for reforms to
protect children from online sexual exploitation in the future, as people will come to see
that digital technology can be used negatively, and should not be taken lightly.
UNICEF has collaborated with the Japanese government to protect children and women
UNICEF, in partnership with the Myanmar government, will work to prevent and respond
to cases of gender based violence, and contribute to the ongoing development and
capacity building of key government departments and civil groups, through the provision
The one-year programme aimed to raise awareness to prevent child sexual abuse and
violence, and aimed to reach one million children by building sustainable government
social services. In addition, a new module on violence and protection of children was
This effort helps UNICEF gain reputation and credibility for working with governments to
push for reforms and new legislations. This thus places them in a better position to work
18
5.5 UNICEF Collaborations with NGOS
learning not to respond to uneventful familiar stimuli, would be able to conserve energy
and attend to other stimuli that is important (Passer and Smith 195). Similarly,
desensitisation from the large exposure to the sexualisation of girls will occur over time,
To counter these findings, UNICEF has participated in projects like Together for Girls, a
violence against girls (“Who We Are”). This partnership group works on a “Data,
Advocacy, Action” basis, where they find data on issues like child sexual violence. They
will act on the data through advocacy and action in terms of legal and policy reforms in
This project has proved its success in various countries like Nigeria. Nigerian President
Muhammadu Buhari has taken action in response to the shocking findings from the
Violence Against Children Survey done in their country. Supported by UNICEF Nigeria,
he launched the Year of Action to End Violence in September 2015, which called on
19
parents and children to come together to prevent and respond to physical, sexual and
20
6.0 Recommendations
Findings indicate that UNICEF’s past efforts were channelled towards protecting
children from the dangers of child pornographic film. However, there has been minimal
efforts done to protect children from the dangers of long-term exposure to graphic
imagery featuring sexualised minors. The Japanese government has previously worked
with UNICEF to impose legislation which banned the possession of real-life images of
children engaging in sexual acts. UNICEF can build on this partnership to earn support
from the Japanese government to provide the necessary statistical resources to conduct
this study, so that they can support the Japanese government in building a healthier,
predator-free society for Japan. Since UNICEF is an interest group, they reside in the
extramedia level in the Shoemaker and Reese model (Keith). This means that UNICEF
can influence the type of messages circulating in the media, which serves as a
motivation for the Japanese government to work with UNICEF to tackle the
consumption and possession of fictional graphic imagery that sexualise minors in the
long run.
The statistic of crimes related to child abuse images calls for urgent action towards
protecting Japanese minors from sexual predators. The media has strong effects on
consumers without their awareness, especially those without strong “family values”
21
(Strasburger 254). This indicates that exposure to media materials, including fiction, can
have negative effects on users. As manga that sexualises minors is still legal, long-time
consumers of such content may develop paedophilic tendencies (Arnett 156). Hence,
UNICEF should work with family organisations to raise awareness of this issue so that
there is stronger vigilance against child sexual predators to protect and create a safer
therefore pressure the Japanese government to progressively integrate a law that bans
the sexualisation of minors in manga, with an end goal of introducing a law that will
eventually ban the consumption, possession and production of all virtual imagery that
relook at their current legislation. Further research will also seek to put UNICEF in a
22
7.0 Conclusion
To answer the research question, UNICEF can persuade the Japanese government to
recognise the severity of the issue and pressure them to create legislation to combat
graphic novels sexualising children. With their joint efforts, they can develop good
policies to change the Japanese publishers’ perception about publishing materials that
sexualise children. This will ensure a reduction in the amount of graphic novels
sexualising minors, thus combating child abuse cases and creating a safe haven for
children.
23
8.0 Works Cited
Arnett, Jeffrey Jensen. Encyclopedia of children, adolescents, and the media. 2nd ed.,
Barnette, David. “'Draw and you'll go to jail': the fight to save comics from the censor.”
www.theguardian.com/books/2016/sep/25/fight-to-save-comics-from-censor-neil-
Chan, Aleksander. “Japan Bans Possession of Child Porn, Excludes Anime and
www.gawker.com/japan-bans-possession-of-child-porn-excludes-anime-and-159
“Child pornography is still widely available in Japan, a year after it was criminalised.”
2017.
“Child rights advocates seek to strengthen laws against child pornography in Japan.”
Fletcher, James. “Why hasn’t Japan banned child-porn comics?” BBC News, 7 Jan
24
Friedman, Uri. “The Battle Over Manga: Japan Debates the Sexual Representation of
www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2011/02/the-battle-over-manga-japan
Nov 2017.
Gilly, Casey. “South Korean Child Pornography Law Targets Drawings, Animation.”
www.cbldf.org/2013/08/south-korean-child-pornography-law-targets-drawings-ani
Hellmann, Melissa. “Japan Finally Bans Child Pornography.” Time, 18 June 2014,
15 Nov 2017.
Janowski, Tomasz and Teppei Kasai. “Pressure on Japan for stronger laws on child
www.reuters.com/article/japan-pornography/pressure-on-japan-for-stronger-laws-
“Japan and UNICEF team up to strengthen protection of children and women [EN/MY].”
25
ReliefWeb, 21 Sept 2016,
www.reliefweb.int/report/myanmar/japan-and-unicef-team-strengthen-protection-
Hierarchy of Influences on Media Content for a Newer Media Era.” The E.W.
www.borneobulletin.com.bn/bruneis-cyber-protection-of-children-draws-un-appla
Lightfoot, Gareth. “Fan of Japanese anime makes British legal history after conviction
www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/fan-japanese-anime-makes-british-4470102.
www.comicsbeat.com/must-read-digital-is-overtaking-print-in-japanese-manga-p
and the Law.” Reference & User Services Quarterly, vol. 54, no.4, 2015, pp.
26
54-59, www.journals.ala.org/index.php/rusq/article/viewFile/5709/7102. Web.
McCurry, Justin. “Japan urged to ban manga child abuse images.” The Guardian, 27
Oct 2015,
www.theguardian.com/world/2015/oct/27/japan-urged-to-ban-manga-child-abuse
McNeill, David. “Manga and anime industries to be exempt from Japan's new law
www.independent.co.uk/news/world/asia/manga-and-anime-industries-to-be-exe
mpt-from-japans-new-law-banning-images-of-child-abuse-9546990.html. Web.
2017.
“Not An Object: On Sexualization and Exploitation of Women and Girls.” UNICEF USA,
9 May 2016,
www.unicefusa.org/stories/not-object-sexualization-and-exploitation-women-and-
Passer, Michael W., and Ronald Edward Smith. Psychology: the science of mind and
27
“Philippines still among world’s top sources of child porn: UNICEF.” Coconuts Manila,
14 Dec 2017,
www.coconuts.co/manila/news/philippines-still-among-worlds-top-sources-child-p
“Section 292, Chapter 224, Penal Code.” Singapore Government. Singapore Statutes
16 Dec 2017.
www.emarketer.com/Article/Slow-Steady-Smartphone-User-Growth-Japan/10140
Strasburger, Victor C.et. al. Children, Adolescents and the Media. SAGE Publications,
“Success for UNICEF and partners as anti-child pornography law passed.” UNICEF,
Sudo, Tadashi. “Japan's Manga Market Grows 0.4% in 2016, Digital Sees 27.5%
www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2017-03-18/japan-manga-market-grows-0.4-
Nov 2017.
28
“The State of the World's Children 2017.” UNICEF, 11 Dec. 2017,
www.unicef.org/sowc2017/index_101553.html#R1625255-6e9eef06-A99S03.
Varley, Ciaran. “Is Japan turning a blind eye to paedophilia?” BBC, 8 Mar 2017,
www.bbc.co.uk/bbcthree/item/57eaaf23-0cef-48c8-961f-41f2563b38aa. Web.
28 Dec 2017.
Yan, Iris. “30 Free Manga Sites to Read Manga Online.” Epubor, 24 Dec 2017,
www.epubor.com/free-manga-sites-to-read-manga-online-for-free.html. Web.
29