Professional Documents
Culture Documents
between caustic soda (sodium hydroxide) or caustic potash (potassium hydroxide) with
animal and/or vegetable fats (oils). Soap has surface active properties (seesurfactant)
to wet a greasy (oily) soiled surface and suspendthe oil and dirt in the water for rinsing
off. Synthetic soaps (called detergents) are made from petroleum-basedproducts, and
some heavy soaps (made from lead, zinc, or other heavy-metal compounds) are water-
insoluble and are used mainly in lubricating greases.
Usually, a process by which triglycerides are reacted with sodium orpotassium hydroxide to
produce glycerol and a fatty acid salt, called 'soap'. When sodium hydroxide is used, a hard
soap is produced. Using potassium hydroxide results in a soft soap.
1
What's the Difference Between Sodium Hydroxide…
2
Where to Buy Lye in Europe, Canada & Austra…
3
Where to Buy Lye
4
What Sort of Soap Can I Use While Camping?
5
Use a Liquid Lye Solution in Soap Making
About.com
About Home
Candle & Soap Making
Soap & Candle Making FAQs, Reference & Glossaries
What's the Difference
Between Sodium
Hydroxide and Potassium
Hydroxide?
Ads
Pure Soap
Buy Soap
By David Fisher
Candle & Soap Making Expert
SHARE
PIN
What's the Difference Between Sodium Hydroxide (or NaOH) & Potassium
Hydroxide (or KOH)?
I once had a soap maker email me saying, "I know I've measured everything right, but my soap
just won't harden! I've let it sit for two days now and it's still this messy, liquidy goo! What went
wrong?"
Well, there are several errors that could have caused this such as making a big mis-measure in
your lye or oils (think of a soap with a 50% superfat) But what had gone wrong in this instance
is that she had used potassium hydroxide instead of sodium hydroxide in her recipe.
So what's the difference? They're both white, flaky powders that make soap. Quite simply:
sodium hydroxide (often called just "lye") makes bar soap - solid, opaque
bar soap
potassium hydroxide (often called "potash") makes liquid soap - flowing,
clear or translucent liquid soap
Soap is technically a "salt" that is made by combining an alkali with fats or fatty acids. The alkali
is the lye that we use.
SIGN UP
CANDLE & SOAP MAKING CATEGORIES
Home
FAQ
Contact Us
Laundering
Clothes washed in hard water often look dingy and feel harsh and scratchy. The hardness minerals combine
with some soils to form insoluble salts, making them difficult to remove. Soil on clothes can introduce even
more hardness minerals into the wash water. Continuous laundering in hard water can damage fibers and
shorten the life of clothes by up to 40 percent.
Bathing
Bathing with soap in hard water leaves a film of sticky soap curd on the skin. The film may prevent removal
of soil and bacteria. Soap curd interferes with the return of skin to its normal, slightly acid condition, and
may lead to irritation. Soap curd on hair may make it dull, lifeless and difficult to manage.
Dishwashers
When washing dishes, especially in a dishwasher, hard water may cause spotting and filming on your
crockery. The minerals from hard water are released faster when it comes into contact with heat, causing an
increase in the amount of spotting and filming that occurs. This problem is not a health risk, but it can be a
nuisance to clean and reduce the quality of your crockery.
Problems in Water Boiler Systems and Pipework
Hard water also contributes to inefficient and costly operation of water-using appliances. Heated hard water
forms a scale of calcium and magnesium minerals (limescale deposits) that can contribute to the inefficient
operation or failure of water-using appliances. Pipes can become clogged with scale that reduces water flow
and ultimately requires pipe replacement. Limescale has been known to increase energy bills by up to 25%
Solar heating, often used for heating swimming pools is prone to limescale buildup, which can reduce the
efficiency of the electronic pump and therefore the overall systems performance will deteriorate. A low cost
solution to this problem is to install a magnetic water conditioner before the pump, this will prevent
limescale buildup and, over time, it will remove existing limescale.
Hard water is not a health hazard. In fact, the National Research Council (National Academy of Sciences)
states that hard drinking water generally contributes a small amount toward total calcium and magnesium
human dietary needs. They further state that in some instances, where dissolved calcium and magnesium
are very high, water could be a major contributor of calcium and magnesium to the diet.
The ideal solution would be to leave the calcium in the water, but alter its state so that it couldn’t form
limescale. This is exactly what magnetic water conditioners do.
Go To Section:
o Home
o Hard Water Problems
o Hard Water Testing
o Minimising Effects
o Water Conditioner Comparison
o Water Softener Comparison
o Water Treatment
o FAQ
o Contact Us
Other Sites
o Water Guide
o Water Treatment Info
o Water Pollution Guide
First you need to know a little about soap making history to help you in your decision making processes.
Back when soap making started there were probably as many opinions about how it should be made as
there were families. One of the most common was to make soap was with ashes from a fire that were
boiled. Boiling the ashes of a fire, particularly hardwood, would produce pot ash or potassium hydroxide.
The potassium hydroxide was the active ingredient that would help saponify the oils and fats (saponify, or
saponification, is a more recent term meaning to turn into soap.). A lot of these older recipes used
different techniques to tell when you had reached saponification, but there was no numerical standard.
More recently scientist have continued to do what they do best, experiment, and have produced
saponification tables for different oils and fats. These tables show how much lye, or sodium hydroxide, is
needed to saponify the specified oils and fats. Some tables are in grams and some in ounces. To make
this process even easier, so you don't have to do it by hand, some websites provide a "lye calculator" that
adds up the amount of lye you need to saponify the oils you choose. It is truly much more simple today
than it was in the days of the pioneers. Still, there are some questions that aren't easily answered.
If you are like me and have some background in chemistry, but not in soap, you might think that this
process is similar to polymerization and that the only part that really matters is the hydroxide. The truth is
that saponification is dependent on the hydroxide but also acts as a salt. Therefore, you will get different
results depending on which hydroxide you use. Typically you will get a harder soap from sodium
hydroxide than from potassium hydroxide. Older recipes that used pot ash would typically have you add
salt, sodium chloride, to harden the soap. One other difference is that you tend to get more lather from
the potassium hydroxide than the sodium hydroxide.
I want to make a shaving soap and do it all myself. I have read several different articles and a lot of them
seem to mention that there is potassium in shaving soap because it helps give a better lather, but none of
them seem to mention the softer soap. I tried using just olive oil and used 100% sodium hydroxide, 50%
sodium hydroxide 50% potassium hydroxide, and 100% potassium hydroxide in three different batches.
The first batch was a little soft but hardened up after some time curing, while the second batch was like
mush and the third just stayed a liquid. It turns out that olive oil produces a soft low lather soap anyway,
which made it less than ideal for my test, so it was hard to get it to lather. However, even with the low
amount of lather I noticed that the 50/50 mixture produced a better lather than the 100% sodium
hydroxide.
So if you want a bar of soap you should probably stick to sodium hydroxide, but if you want a liquid soap
us potassium hydroxide. However, if you are looking for lathering characteristics look first at the
properties of the oils, because that will make your biggest difference, and then pick your hydroxide. I
personally will be experimenting more with a blend of the two and trying different oils to produce the best
lather for shaving. I hoped this helps.
Posted by Trevor
Reactions:
2 comments:
1.
Did the 100% KOH lather well? Or did it give the best lather?
Thanks for sharing this info Appreciate it.
ReplyDelete
Replies
1.
The 100% KOH lathered better. I used just olive oil, which doesn't lather very well on its
own. I would suggest using an oil that lathers better, maybe palm oil.
Delete
Reply
Add comment
Load more...
Blog Archive
▼ 2013 (10)
o ► June (3)
o ▼ March (1)
Potassium Hydroxide VS. Sodium Hydroxide in soap m...
o ► February (2)
o ► January (4)
About Me Follow
Trevor
http://indianapublicmedia.org/amomentofscience/soap-hard-water-mix/
NEW
HOT
VIDEO
by Nina Spitzer
Print
When water falls as rain, it's "soft" and free of minerals. It picks up minerals as it
passes through rock, sand and soil. Hard water is high in mineral salts, especially
calcium and magnesium ions. Water hardness is measured in grains per gallon,
with a degree of hardness ranging from 1 to over 10. Hard water, generally, is not
harmful to our health.
Even though other minerals exist in hard water, it's the calcium and magnesium
that create problems. When heated, these minerals precipitate out of water and
encrust themselves onto items as "scale" or mineral deposits, affecting the
performance of household appliances. These scale mineral deposits are
unsightly in bathrooms and kitchens, and they're challenging to remove. Soaps
and detergents lather poorly in hard water, so we tend to use more, resulting in a
soapy film or scum residue.
o Hard water minerals can clog pipes and reduce water flow.
o Film and scale can accumulate on tile and bath/kitchen fixtures.
o An invisible soapy film on skin can leave it feeling dry.
o Excess filmy shampoo residue on hair can leave it looking dull and limp.
o Deposits of scale shortens the life of water heaters.
o Utility bills can increase due to accumulated scale in the water
heater. (Scale is a poor conductor of heat, increasing the energy needed to
heat water.)
o Glasses and dishes remain white filmed and spotted even after cleaning.
o Reduced sudsing action can leave clothes looking gray and dingy.
o Harsh minerals in hard water reduce the life of clothes.
o Hard water can affect the taste of tea and coffee.
To soften or not to soften? A water softener will take care of the hard water
problem, but there are other things to consider before converting over to a soft
water system:
These recommendations can lessen hard water problems and, in some cases,
save you some money, too:
Drinking hard water can reduce your risk of osteoporosis because of the calcium
carbonate in the water. For this to be true, however, a good supply of vitamin D is
necessary in the diet since it helps your body absorb calcium. A 2004 Finnish
study suggests the minerals in hard water can help prevent heart disease, as
well.
Comments
Follow Us
327k
53.8k
68.4k
5.4k
RSS
Adam Levi ne & Behati Pri nsloo's playful l oft is fi t for a roc k star
Earth D ay i ns pirati on: 16 differ ent ways to upc ycl e your ottoman
15 spri ng gardening cr afts you can do with your ki ds
Subscribe to
SheKnows Daily News
Sign Up
Related Articles
9 creative — and cheap — ways to upcycle your old furnitureby Mady Dahlstrom, SheKnows Expert
4 days ago
I've remodeled my home twice — here's what I learned from itby Rachel Hollis, SheKnows Expert
4 days ago
Why putting in a shower porch was one of my best ideas yetby Phyllis Moore, SheKnows Expert
1 week ago
2. I suck at sports, but my vagina is breaking records with my new kegel app
and Saponification
pts
are produced during the chemical reaction known as saponification.
nification is the reaction between a fat or oil and a base, producing glycerol and a salt (soap)
or oil + base -----> glycerol + salt (soap)
are usually sodium or potassium salts of long-chain fatty acids
are cleaning agents or detergents.
cules of soap are made up of two parts:
on-polar, hydrophobic tail consisting of a long hydrocarbon chain
ydrophilic, negatively charged, carboxylate ion (anion) head
ophobic: aversion to water, not readily wettable by water.
drophilic: affinity for water, wettable by water
tion
heat glycerol salt
+ base +
-----> (alkanol) (soap)
+ NaOH
heat
----->
R'OH + RCOO-Na+ Search this Sit
You can search this site using a key term or
find tutorials, tests, exams and learning ac
(games).
O
Become an AUS
|| H TUTE Membe
|
O- C -(CH2)16-CH3
H- C -OH
O
|| |
AUS-e-TUTE's B
O- C -(CH2)16-CH3 + 3NaOH ---> H- C -OH + 3CH3(CH2)16COO-Na+
O | Subscribe to our
||
H- C -OH Newsletter
O- C -(CH2)16-CH3 Email
| subscribe to AUS-e-TUTE's free qua
H newsletter, AUS-e-NEWS.
are made from vegetable oils such as olive oil, palm oil and coconut oil.
are made from animal fats (tallows).
oaps tend to be softer and more water-soluble than the corresponding sodium soap.
unsaturated fatty acids are softer than those from saturated fatty acids.
Action of Soaps
such as sodium stearate dissolves in water, carboxylate anions and metal cations are
water
H3(CH2)16COO-Na+ CH3(CH2)16COO-(aq) + Na+(aq)
----->
s, clusters of soap molecules in which the hydrocarbon chains Ask Chris, the Che
to each other by Van der Waals forces (dispersion forces,
es, weak intermolecular forces), surround the non-polar dirt particle, with the anion a Question
ed to the surrounding water.
The quickest way to find the definition o
to ask Chris, the AUS-e-TUTE Chem
ed, the soil particle surrounded by soap micelles breaks free and remains dispersed in
water because the carboxylate anions repel each other.
s not function well in acidic solutions because of the formation of insoluble fatty acid
H3(CH2)16COO-Na+(aq) + HCl(aq) -----> CH3(CH2)16COOH(s) + Na+(aq) + Cl-(aq)
ms insoluble precipitates with Ca2+ and Mg2+ ions present in hard water, forming a scum Chris can also send you to the rel
CH3(CH2)16COO-Na+(aq) + Ca2+(aq) -----> [CH3(CH2)16COO-]2Ca2+(s) + 2Na+(aq) AUS-e-TUTE tutorial topic pa
gents are increasingly being used instead of soaps because they do not suffer from
antages to the same extent.
Share this Pag
What would you like to do now?
© AUS-e-TUTE
INTRODUCTION
Soap is produced by the saponification (hydrolysis) of a triglyceride (fat or oil). (See Figure 1.)
In this process the triglyceride is reacted with a strong base such as sodium or potassium
hydroxide to produce glycerol and fatty acid salts. The salt of the fatty acid is called a soap.
Fatty acids are straight-chain monocarboxylic acids. The most common fatty acids range in size
from 10-20 carbons and most often have an even number of carbon atoms including the carboxyl
group carbon. The carbon-carbon bonds in saturated fatty acids are all single bonds, while
unsaturated fatty acids have one or more carbon-carbon double bonds in their chains. One
example of a saturated fatty acid is palmitic acid, CH3-(CH2)14-CO2H.
Fatty acids are seldom found as free molecules in nature but are most often a part of a larger
molecule called a triglyceride. Triglycerides consist of a three-membered carbon chain (glycerol
backbone) with a fatty acid bonded to each of the three carbon atoms in the glycerol backbone.
The bond between the fatty acid and the glycerol backbone is referred to as an ester linkage. In
the saponification process the ester linkage is broken to form glycerol and soap.
Figure 1. Saponification of a triglyceride
2. Assemble a hot water bath by filling an 800 mL beaker approximately 3/4 full with
water and begin heating the water with a bunsen burner.
3. Add three or four boiling chips to the water in the hot water bath to prevent the
water from boiling over.
Preparing the reaction mixture
4. In a 150 mL beaker add the following ingredients.
B. 20 mL of 20% NaOH
C. 10 mL of ethanol
D. 3 boiling chips (These will help prevent the mixture from boiling over while it is
being heating.)
5. Note the total volume (level) in the 150 mL beaker and how many layers the
ingredients initially form.
7. Using a stirring rod, stir the reaction mixture frequently so that it does not boil over.
8. Maintain the total volume of the reaction mixture by adding small quantities of 1:1
(volume/volume) ethanol-deionized water.
9. After the initial 25 minute heating there should be no separation of layers in the
beaker.
Isolating the soap CAUTION: Remember that the beaker and clamp are hot!
11. When the saponification process is complete, turn the bunsen burner off, add 25
mL of deionized water to the beaker and place the beaker on the bench top to cool for
about 5-6 minutes. Then place the soap reaction beaker into an ice bath and cool for
about 10 minutes.
12. At this point, measure out about 50 mL of saturated NaCl solution and cool it also
for about 5-6 minutes in the ice bath.
13. After the cooling time is complete for the soap reaction mixture, decant any liquid
from the beaker. (Be careful not to pour off the soap.)
14. Next add, add the 50 mL cold, saturated NaCl solution to the soap beaker and stir
thoroughly with a glass rod. This process separates the soap from the glycerol and
excess base and is called "salting out."
15. Collect the solid soap, using a Buchner funnel. [Note: Decant as much liquid off
before adding the solid soap to the Buchner funnel.]
16. While the air is being drawn over the soap in the funnel, wash the soap with two
20 mL volumes of ice cold deionized water. Continue to draw air over the soap for
another 3 minutes.
A. Test the pH of the first tube by dipping a clean stirring rod into the solution and
touching the solution to both red and blue litmus paper. Record your observations
on the Data Sheet.
B. In the second test tube add several drops of calcium chloride solution. Record
your observations.
C. In the third test tube add several drops of iron(III) chloride solution. Record your
observations.
D. In the fourth test tube add a single drop of kerosene and shake the solution.
Record your observations.
18. Pour the contents of the four test tubes into the designated waste container.
Soap disposal
19. Place the soap in the designated container.
20. Thoroughly rinse all of the glassware with water before storing.
Salts and esters of carboxylic acids are called carboxylates. When a carboxyl group is deprotonated,
its conjugate base forms a carboxylate anion. Carboxylate ions are resonance-stabilized, and this
increased stability makes carboxylic acids more acidic than alcohols. Carboxylic acids can be seen
as reduced or alkylated forms of the Lewis acid carbon dioxide; under some circumstances they can
be decarboxylated to yield carbon dioxide.
carboxylate is a salt or ester of a carboxylic acid. Carboxylate salts have the general formula
M(RCOO)n, where M is a metal andn is 1,2,...; carboxylate esters have the general formula RCOOR'.
R and R' are organic groups; R'≠H.
A carboxylate ion is the conjugate base of a carboxylic acid, RCOO−. It is an ion with negative
charge.