Cook, Nicholas.

Analysing Musical
Multimedia. Oxford & New York:
Oxford University Press, 1998),
Mo.tcls of Mul.iΙnedia 98-129.

τι πE ιHlrΦ |pd foNald |hl

n EιΣE b one ιDoιlrcι bgeιbΦ

*']than aΜ.nι€n tmilology Ιoι de
Φsorofιhεαrrplro.mul
fu.d|a .nΦunlαcd s far h thb boo
uhq lsociiΦd ψιιλ ιλ.m ε|9 pmi

ΙndπtetadUonaΙωuΦetιoπsol
aωοunb οr nbι!ιΙy n,Φnε|b.d α

ιψo ois, tλ.n, ψ|δ the ffd rcΦη ηT-T*Ed

!oωwtλlhcdω4ΙfuafoEThr

Riuε 1,Ι ψnΩM ine nιε!ωsb'Φ Φrdffibtoi Φlta

|
.dιng cmllπεηe, αrμε

Φ anddilΙΘΦ: e tn lΦiσl
ιh* lhe thE mod* shodd bc rht€{t thnuΦ whει r .ε[ ιλc shι
bΙiξ, e* Φd ιΙ. diΙftnm 6 (shom b, ιη. rlθ.gΙB), rc.]c,'onlλεοthαλand,.οur
Tl'e ω!.dty te b bπ.d on ihe
]οhnsonmakebdffi Φ$tsEnt and.ohΦι οιbpboa' Thεy mΙs b Ιoundfrg,. bMυ* bolh Φrdms aE br.d on lne Δli3nnεnt oΙ
ιovc dιλ ε g voyξq ,n Laιol'aηd Ιdbnsιι lcrboιoσ' δω.

6 uM s λ ]οιer; ιh]s ιΦ b.hind Φ.h fΦΦΦ|.ιl elφiιsοΒ a Los ιo{dJft.rnll rlδh,a' oΦ -

ε bιιιΦ thc ιcΕk of ! iffiby-rE ifriii.L;s τlik donmitJ"p
'or mtrtrgc h on rhe mck'.! κΙ { t e a d f od f u .a n d of ω u f i Φ
lohnloΙ3 tmino|oιv' aΦ Φhα6( bcωrc uεy m aΙ vafut of uαdalytg MΦor Ιm 6 Λ ]rrπ in dii'αcn' wυys, ιλεFJω
Ιm l λ FιΙr| b δb 3m* 1hΦ,flι nε.ιh.c. Buι ιhdε il Φoιhcι "nd
eΙιlο b oΙc rott€r oη|y* ι πnΦα ι\a1h b 9r ιfuωΦ ιh.n
scm h ,bftb itΨ do no!frt bgeιnσ' ι€aM sa.λ Mρ* ωr E
albnsΙfo b a dΦιknd l@, cΔiΣoryof 6siιiδ.eiandΞ3-uchΤtτ.
Ιo rblhoncι] dif.G@ bdsω ,ou
EiΙrωa Φmρriωn of we'E 8οιEn ,ThfuΝht|onΦιp b boΙωfug, πd
rtbb dtdιv lo σe anoιhΦ (assol| ω ω ι,i l λ tffiΙ
 and ΙonDren's,(1ιε dmsy cιρre\ on

so. fo)r 'AΙdundcΙ Νtιsιy

Φc ob]Φι of |ΙΔ t ιiquc, Btrι , romΦ

ιdurcs aid fic ιhbra.

'ΙυJ.
Eh!αλhΦ oι fmmljc dt|]iΥΦΦ beι{Φtr ιhem 1ω ugιnn ιh.
syηEsιhcd.ideηtir,wbrchnιtΙstιl

ιhcdtΔdtctdcnΙllsιoιPΙonιpι?tlιry

nοι ο11hc pjσu6 ρΙojcdinq nι ΦttDι ι ιhc mDd.

Ωηt (bdεω iι mιkζ ju{ fu sa@

pιn jn ΡruDaλωΔ .Ιordbg ]h. ]nusj. * d l|rc
DΙoj.αbg the
uDΦr trιι ρΦι &aiη. on€ m1g|Ιιcq 'nuJι
ιΦ1s Ιn &1ndhsιy s ,λl fu,ψ orciΦιing ιhz dιgc adbn oΙ ιhε
nae a(ior Dfol..dngιlrc'rΙ.πυNic oΙ ιhc nυt pω]dιig ιh..oious:

15 λ:.]nn η c.iνg.ι ι. .ειh

Φt Ιl@chofιhcoι]rσs:!
Γ

W!}ls cnΦ cαmmta]s, ιhe Φmo

lhe ιxta| shilffiΦ iaskbg a EiBΙ!. .ontadidbn, (Γhaι ι how d|

ρur woΙkl Λid δ. smε spo]l.s Φ
nnkts d!]r.don bdwftn ιs Ιoπu

ΙcΙatoo, bdwrn ωund ond sghι.

Thsr .oιiΗdidions. thεΙ, ζEhΙijh ι

ri
ψιιδ d|1ταωι rΨΙa?i€j) ω

J6irtsltrs!Pim.oιh{oΛ.m
." δ, *
" -d,-..,"
|k|, Ary |MM h
φ;. "h,.h
-

Drζ .uιy cΙιboΙιtd cia.naιic dιg

,ρ τ 4 Φοi Λrif, Φ
',,
6.) τn ωi as 1noιhσ Elp(b. cΦιBι ια r ιh€ oppιdιg c]fue |Φψ

.-
.π..."" i.,a"lη'",ι" iι. rd ιhc .βd,r'ηL]yhers
'ωιlc -
δ;ι;ι Χ bιnnft'l|y dyΙric aDd .oη!*ual'
ynrcprefnιcdb,ιΙcιbid

yi6 ni?,1Ι4ι 9d ]η . d s 6i Φ&

mΦ ρωiιi!ιjΙy, Ιt miΦι bc ωmDiΙω

kn,e b€ιφωΙ ιhc α]nsdlrΙι ηedh of Δn ιMΙ * troΦiω_ιi]j b
i tΦm ΦiΙοσπc;s n $e
inι afo i oπΙ
'!

C'Φ] Thc ιh.Φ of c|a$tn|

πt tceι oΦ ind |ΙtriΦ ιhe iω€

eΦηd lθm,Ιn put 1ι! snd πvs

,,, ,,o, n α !.;i..

'1,e!,,L'n

η b h,.Ts ii.' ωn
 Pιlπ.cy Md EιPEsion τh.ory

po{nshmσι !ρm'πd hy n|m

ι Φvιλ ft i,ψη h-i ai]itωt o'ηΦ Ιol$ι ;iαii;iι ns mυr θtΦ*,ωo o
.ιir-h.;r'
, αDloImm.d b'.οηFJf t λεΙdι/s nodd oι ndιlΦξlh a !Ι' f
-,],. e.ty υn;n;,;,j,;ρd- sπ {.h f JΦdΦ it ιιi Mdα
{as l mιlnωin) ηu|i|n.djΘ i
',
ιiumριbns εo b!.ι s iιr r ih€ ιh
ΦP ot , , r. ,e η rL] ι \ ο l \l .
'i, ust (whth, htbfua|r,, i8 α.
t r r , , aι η!, nλ 6' r M'δ
be ΙοundΦfthτi ' h o ,.
9v. ωΦlrωt mah suΦ ornυΙιm.dh$Φry)i
j! TΙ.
I |ωι ιnd the mclody'
rΦηd oM o1 ιhe Ωntne shows in
ι yoDιhbg|' ran, oΦηι ισ!
Ιorlnω b ιkc Ι.(dd ΙMsoη.{.atgory oΙ ]rupωιtorι hybΙiιl .ιbe
dΦrtΙ *hω hc adds ιhaι hamo,y and Ιι,thm nst.οbw ιhε
an lorm, jη whtcλ ιbe objαs οr pmdu4s ol ιwo loΙ πoΙq (t ψc
8imp]y Johω ιΦ.$tr and pξΘtd
. uηit' . ι1']hcΦntibuflng d.rΦι
l a,d noι'. basDιryid.da.on.tc6dmΦty$ynoΦlsotm$ttxιd]€ o ryfum
by m€4bι r dislufun ο
oti ffuD cuidα zπl|no, caιi]eι
tσs, hoψerα ι ι iη eΙτ.ι nu|ι.
' MonEErd| cluck and (of ωu6Φ.o

ιh LiΙdμ.t fuldhn o1[|m

dΦ i rc|ιιοΙ b ΦoΦα) hdΦd, 3omdh|ng sirir m1Φι bc s8id,

ωτ,i, Φn'i,α',, o, αηηranτ€ dM

ιhc coπnιUent ",,.!fri ιhal he tes εn ov€ΓJl qhgns€ h .Ξ,h!$]Φ!n
n.db nΦΙ.J Ιis!l|y, ιn.n d]c abiaΙ|σ rd djΙθΙ.
,hι lmΦndπ |bb3
Ξ;ιdιi knd
di1Ι€E,ι rc|α phy€n by J|]Ι€Eoι
66eiE; 'i'in pι ιλ. 1ιbα hω ιn

ir,λ !λ-ιb ι1fu frι-' l"!*..i'

'"r ".J
,ρ ,,,, ,, .d ,i-"M "
"'"'..'

Ι
 ω]os', tb€ ψr']ng, of lftρh κξηd
hωarh"" b h| h].h' fi'4iar Φld Δ Dri r'h! ι[ oι
r,f'],|ι1,,r,1, -F Φ .|ni,lσoσωmι. '$'
ftanm dl lιwnιhg ι\raΦσ,
Thc nΙωa]. ι,r rιns λ ιhn, tr sιhoρo"hΝα gω" m b ;y' ,.ui

ΠU r--ζοαΙ, ρtr, n ,n,ng hr cu]rr"ι o,, hftrιΠL,,,'o'

Φ! } hJ ibyα σφ ed$,δ nΦΦrl

n,g q.dζ, ι|'" .ηi mδ.ρ";, α

"ιυ

sb!uΙ.l ι,e IhE{1iDI oΙ'hcothσ Bu

ιandingo1the ωnpοΙcs α,u

s nοt dΙinsε: aΙ ιh( hapEπ b
tΜι ιhο Drh!ry and llbordbat to!
, ωι;".sυ. ,,-ι.
s,nΦ€nnofu|undrωh
-1ω;"π"
usig tb( uDmbiguοus ΩtΦsι o| the Φπaψ lbt ulιiEd.
auιnoΙιΦt muιic ss a khd of inc|
5{ωrcη rnωr, bdnυ| ρ!Rι ω6|a|
,pυ
ιhιι|on h€ιwccn ΦυrtD' rd

ΑΙ|ιhftl.abξ' t wou]dmιiob'n .

flΦpιψ ηΦ dpnm&y ηd sbolnh

*(

i fu,1jqι,ι,'ll iΦt ΦιΦιij oe,

'(

Lι|
 ws ddαtd η ιrs ΦBdαlu| ιΙΙot e

i r ,Φ,h lf,"ψ Jr ,,ι ndild sιιicv.d by ιh. opαυ; 'b $e cηd'. h

nαοc tnΦ' aDι $ 'bη
on), and ιhε ρloι ι snpD M ΦΝ Ιor ιhe sr

Ι e'σh Ι;mL Eor lhin dΦit' k or naι. iι Eorc ιlt.l α α.dlb|.'' lα 3hσι. 1b ρn
'
rc ιι.'Eο;h"
ρoιt d vjcw ol oFa a! dΙmυ.r Yoυ.njs a.d (€tri,s ]nE.ρatθιoδ

c6.d, ινc οΦι usrυy ω

δ.,€υ,. D" Pon e, ρb' wJ,a ρuΦ! π,,.
b $e ο&α] tn pdicuιι $c m]Φι
pΙiηciPlεlnanyrρttθlΕa|iσ'Ιti

Eddhπ of.ri b ιh;ι ι bo

υi'N,,ΓF,r,h"nn,{l
hΦ sh{ h. is obj..fug b is ιh.
Φ,rωtsΦαo|'ns,.lι..

ow]enscιhπ Enιαs mσ. r!

,h.$ waysr. dΦι , he lεyg.bοιh N

rJ'hc'mDsηb'η of iΙtrNi

λαbΦ o|krd b ιlEd 6,rοr 1ψ

l
bgιψen udhry. Φωt
t μ4Ηs !, Thc Βτ]L he Φ'i. minlnsΦ |hf thΔlt l.hcmh fuιn
]:ry,, , ιU|ιlhdc|y MadσΙiηck

mοnaΙ.atgory, b ιrιtd ,s ιt ι wσ€ iι.lΙ a shι.υΙ;l λ!ωL Ι .in

c]πi' ιhs by ;Ιrd;g fov ιh. idctro

l
isιhι,sυrριι,nιiraιagivΦlMMm

ι*ξ οΙ ρΙr1πDng|ιl' ψe dΦι Φ|Ι ιhii i'Φ,,,edΦa shrc ιhc dιd ι

ω ..n,ηΦ ιh. nωnιng ιh4 h a|r.idy prc;cnι h a gfun mαioΦ

ιty rc|aιbnshιρ f ι]ιlΙ.nnΦ bΦwΦn ιhcη υΙr hμr Mii ιhi aE i ταιy δΦg .a b s ιryof Φξ,"
(Reman s c]!iD' ιhω
ι doξ,) ιΙ 6e fiκ ΥdiΣ' hoΨ

in8 r an α!ηlc 1jre δuiμion Φhι we nouιd haα]ψ boιnα wtιΙ the
hc ωΙc o1nulic t a subotnind.
one w. ni3hι nos ιΦ !ιns ρ,l&
ιnio l ncι ι]omJn,bπit
'ΙιJimΔ m Φ dtr oιhu. bM ηnbα
lcrJnisrsrc foΙ,P \.lro $en,Eo]αΔ ιh.

n.nbιin, l1t loιονs ιhaι ι1 ψ Ιιι ι'

σJs ρroiαιing lιs mωniηg ) The
lbt t!,,iππιι Thaι i ψbaι (cmr
d.ωhRsωιrlμΦιιoιtDfu. ;f... Mt"*" .,hd R"bι"'. b d

ιorr e*blιhω by ιhe ηnun]!ι. Mdlng wth R]ιacs ωιoo.ι ot a rehtd sifoaton]
dilogue'a2

ιcχι und mu,c' ιoD ${h an ιauniurιn{rebιΦιLωηΦd'cιa

. rr,in in dbρυε ) Νoι sιΦis

lngΙy'ιhendωcDtthaιighιιybdι

,ΦJ* Φd lm ,|ω |s'ι ι,

Φn aι m{δt8mD|jΦth. rΘDing oΙ ιo Φ€!Ι' buι may d.pεΙd a|p lpon ιhe σimhdω d Δc E.iDtnι'
ni ψc Ι.d ιo look ιo 1i|r ιhcory .oι ι

.b; m,.o,""'l
"
'11 ιd ι, ovoid the imEesioD ιhιι

]Φ ιh,t nadΦ .inηα ahqy$ he sure αhπ dlαs r sa,1ξ 8bouι

konιheffi1πdo9olΦral

bpftih€i lo.abuΙrry plΦs oΙ]y a

mΝ. eid'σ fitliΜ oΙ ΣΙtm wh

,pt! 2. ι tr€d ,Φ"Ess]οζtne

ιhal πΘnhq, (when tr.D,,o

niiiτ 'nnq5
dd .','Ι-.iΦ dr€ ssp.πs or
tλει αeαιel iι η) τhc pΦn|.η iιa bm
EΙaιlv.|,cωyιodjsθnlι\c.onmpt

b, aΙια ε]]..!]uoυy Φplbh olbein8 usn ciιnr ψay Go $aι h lhe me

or muJ. v|deo,Ιοr hΦan.c t m'gΙι Ωm jus Δ niιucJ b b]ι abοut

nωΦ ,laε pmbιn |lel b 3n lppΙoach

ιhaι bειjπs Φ idmu1ying one
mω]σ r ιE,ignnrmΦdΦ, θ.d
md, J ,d$ dnJΙ ι!*. u
Φdιy, 'fuΦΦ
Thω λ nοφb.ι ιhιι .uch aD ;inΙo.at ιηε ιiΙs
'pDΙoaih
. .r do ]υsι* b Φ!ιiim€dh

j 1,'al fJn rwσι φ'l n ιhιn,uιn u"rEι

ιaιζ p|aΦ.on.e i9in' tι h.mpιm
b bc αιne| b an,bio3 rυnω| ηlltim€dh.
1"r""'l'iJ::''-..*-*"
 duΦs fu,b€ ιne Ιngutιc holbb Mr ψΙh lhι ιtα woΙd ιmELΙωj, ,.
ψhΙ.h (d6pi. MalΦal| MdΙhπ\ b€{ sfiofrs) imm.d|υιty holiζs ι

ι ι mlhJh a|;ζi1nnt thn u Eσ

h.g".;! ;"d.ιsrη ..]|ι!*ιr" lb"
" dfu,$h..Jm,
,,,, n b Inao ωιn qhΣ nd tr trbJη
lo1 r" Io rι i.
iLωfoEs ιn{ sι-d d.Φb .EbιJd.d i
Φ'n, 1t c r,θ!, jlιh,,bοgh homo|oEcsr ω μlια|dιnι ιtaι tο sp.Ιιth€m oi υou|db. b Φuι
9 vtv not juΙ d rι, buι oΙ ιh. Er bam|tι,T|rαcr'howσα,amonιαJhi
fdijrote-aιl,r.ψτ,L.ι,,
. "η"Ψ' .: ξ-:r 1 | ! Ψγ ,f π" ΨJ
rc ιnε isιc mσ36 slιh pr.

Φund hd'c 1ιDdaiιnω|lr ιliΙlcEDι oh.nom€ηo|ogts b P|o,] (oΙ

,Α|ftldy in
Φuft) ιnd fuidodε' ρΙxιt h the !η.bnι wοid'. sh. siys,

jDιιιζdbk Ιdω Φe m s! o{Jr oΙ 1EιιqJ or!]!lslο!Ιfs πd ΙΦtd

l v{c, E'1ξ' .amd sαc r an cΙPLηnioΙ of ιhe ob*ι
r hραlr'hg
r ΦιnΦnιhm d b ι on ,
; ω.,' b h,,τ,c1 ,i οJ,,.- .
ω,I d!-aj |h J Ιd b . o |, F , ! no..o

Γenn ω fih mυd. Φ Φ.ρΜ ι

Λmο α]pιεΙdη !, eιi ι(oΙding
dasjar astn.ια! wιh ιs .mρhalb (D EEΦbtioo Φftρrton gιh ιhc cyc "ΓoEιd wt
lψhethα ii 69

o |]r ιo' J, npm,|hι υfurρ1oo bJ

'n

io,'rg,n,yi J σig- nιj'

',ρr'
ιjΙ|o',d,|v Φ,,b, Φ.r', ]b,
dtδeι| b Φs lιιθ]f qlι aι uηlcαs,Ξs ','] ω
smehoψ ιh€ naιυral

cr.',n i rιhe ιl se, t οΦ,3, ΙιlsdulrcιιΙωιarΙsbωιΦmplcnmι

.

ιε,, nphι,.ng, Φ t,d'.' η ιhr w;;α mεdeαρ|tdι iΙ hh |ft

 o/ t6jι' bmed ω ι ii on the ph,J.

-τn dis llntrωωg .hd" .,Ι **

πn 3o q Ιaι ιowaιds ιhΦΦ

rΦiΦ|, ω tb ω]εωc ιd atιtu

μfl#ψπ$ψ$
 j::,**jsJι;iιi.:ii'ΓiιH.:,]::"i,ι*:'J:i]}
:J1.":
l"jffi
n rι w. } 1ι,,η,, n,,' |U,Φ,
cnrιins d.nτc]!s, flιhg h J ιnq
Banh.i oιι.rc t1Ι! ;hftω in mσι ;iΦ ιo, ! ; ΙΦιi msF and ndc π, Lr ρ4r|,!o|r.
n .xJmpb) nιc hιgs l|ΙsιΓιιι
,lι:i πD ιnc ι1,.ds ψhth. shduaψ' uc Pσrnl( oα dt
ΦuD*

m"..,he.|rcπ,',Φ',

α indhιi mtjy Ιj]Ιiilh ry gιm Φd*L

slhειbcolydghιsugsι:c.om

-,λ.,,ιa.δ
 4hι.]. who ouo6 κ'oJfm r
πsu|t t obsunι,' bluηing' md ωn

.aιlω thaι is mσι .|cΦ|y lΦ whω

l. o1η,oΛc,,'] oΙc:uJgr L! L.'dδ Φ !i.,.d;G

ωhυ,h..ωlωιJb,lhfeΦt,

,
s.h 9ΞjnΦj@Ιa-μ'ΦΦ-a E*s 9u!!!g!!!Φ9j'ηq ]qrrΦ
Γ!!!! 1tr ,M 9 bι ΛvΦη m.5ι
l; ιΙ;ι b ΠcuG o!aι |.δJΙi!quΞ';ιtη"ηqψ" τr J
!| FG : h ν oi D" Mo nrJ '
'
{rιaΙ {,i. η o o'}1 ψJ Fr ψ Φιtr muιh.nra doα not aιwrF (inded dΦ ηοι uu,]ιy] h,οιe
u, j 4F u1,|ω Φ
'Γι"! 'r
Φ.Φ |&.ccoftq Ι]iΙs rvnich(a3h. Ρt ι) ts'ψ-Ι.ψ&ι wmqhι ]
ωrΦrrd!]Ι σiωσtΦ&eby |i]|ncnι whth 8iyB mst qo
.η (or po{.mω.m) ξc' Eor|Ι.k 9 au|tneΦπι6eonιyoPdοn:sο
oF.b,Φrri.πarφ,σnrm ;.mDαr hd! s spι, ω ba,F' h
'o

ρddon hpas. b s€ιhB λ{arc|l,s ο

ιuly, Moη1μy nad .hrΙbr,cd ιh

cεο Poιη asπ h ααt dcbΙ w'|Ι t{ ι d'".ne ιIΙaιkwrtnΦ r]..j".

ilI
ιΗι ιhe muj. a3 no moΙc ιhaD 'ι lu
o|.mmhωD b ΦnΗ, fuΙe|'] g{y cs ida or mng r !h9 aψrc.
οrΦr,ιmc!ωιω ! ιh. μ!ρ4b._,b" 6, th,t h*..-"i;;
lΦ mΦ]Umb s ψblιh ι b iιiιhlbi|,Lb ω. ii Aρι Em υE(dhrfue
eεmni. ) Thc kt b qΦili-m
 syi. 3nd so ,|]Ι mυΩ. θpPΦ.
pndq, ιhe ιfm Φ ωnιηdi4 Φth

guΦ bι h gh rc|tr π s qJ9flnαl ωοιur σqaΓ., 4,,] hζ gΦs m

b lΦtde sch .msαe η rΦ6 οΙ .xιmp]6 lron |]dhoιm,

li €Φdv!&!!!qn (whon ιhc nus

iΙ.dtrg!ιιy), jΜoΙ (ιιhω ιne ru

tul|d,sφnq!Ιe (Wh.nl]t nun. dΦts.b qΦs'c nΦΦn ll

.ruιΙ way oι i ι .rudaΙ nofuηι ), (Ι
and ht d(ofrωιie Φdiιgs r h

Ι,γhΦhcdrs.υsN.ftiι6nis.σ
s.bcιbαgl ιλc BΦΙ o'l,t Ι]0ψ,Φ cι
c .lntnl (by ιhis l rcr smε d b th{ ut suρααdjnΦ sωc
s ιhfrad dΙrι,)' m.εsυιε 6€ ι"iι ιhε cbd. ωmΦη has *εη. *
mυic agftn t, ωd
fi;,lhΦ li sbn& b r;"
ι d(ortuο ψj]. !ω!
s;at k , , ihd Γfuc|pη :@ψ|i
d, Ι,νhal hε dos ια do ts Ωd --mrb " 'hc
| : 6 Ι - o' 1 | Φ r ,, ν τ h e ,, ο.,, m
ιhc nυJc a 3ysεπnic mmα 1ir
pEc. Mi;iiΙ'dni;id. tr ιhc ΙΦos, dteια| Φw d ]9η!vd
'n
dωrun( Ιι.gg.ι!ΦΦ!.η nJωja]]zn η Β drrorqrJl
Φmrrg EιAl oοτh'βbdψRn nlcnt[ln. ind sι nι]:]s ιhΙ ψΦ
'\ p ;, .,ιl ι, .on,,n',o,;| w.dr .n, h-
"|-8 .Th. '
λdodfsb'p b 6t \
;τ;,ii Eδ;i,$"h*b"ry -., *ιd b hλ 4Ωy

ρΙJh t'n,i a hBhα ιvd,". Λιd ι

D|ιe b bιisbn αmmα;i'ls' Ω.b δ

potπιi| bδnaΙh, d ιh. advdιΦ\ d6

ncnιιy ln the vidα, dt Madoηηi's 'Ma
drhbilE ιhs ιιtiaΙchy of ιιr n.ni
ιn any d lne .onv.n!ons]
mudcιhcorcιia] *αf0' wbΙc $€ corsΦndbg υxis h knguιgt

Eιn.iρι ap.Ιes, ωd ιn$ ι!ιhe PΙin.ipΙe δaι, rcΙαΩd b d the ι,cεru

njng of ιhι .haρk τarηΦιa| daΦε6Φ)DΙαωι nωs ιrc iu$

rΙJΦ!ιibeqL6Φ,ibιιι |d m.dι !ηhυi|y; Φe kγ;|o.l .l

 ,ιJ,ρι,Φ-α 'liξ ,.!ο u" |ι. hnq, ,
o sυρt.ia]n ]ΦeΙ:sacraι Φd lιrιtι' ν!o 9'd olliιΦΛcn whο |ooι.d to nct 1οra m€Eιy .nG
.σΓJ;.t94e
ba& y1.|d' . ιhc smι ιε|o@Φt εJ ε sFphoπy.'ι, (sυ.h ιncnα'

mιn;Jd.f,,-'u, .,i,s,
ι 1'aJ,ffir, Φcmι.|f
'τ,'
gtrεgc ρΙοvids a Φnιd Φωe| lor ι
why ιhc nnknμy
oΙ E htlahγ WhΦ ι'ds ft d ψe ψiih orc σ;e;
hdd*b|ly Φ ι schΦ"heΦr oΙ {and]ntrn |nhd
cnδ rι i8 ιc nmrι", 1h9t a.h ncdiπ b. pm|tω ι,
Mu|ιhed|ι ωd Autonomy 'Ξ'ωιcd, 'it,Ι,. , , Φ),
.ωιy Buι lD Ιlansliι}

οseitaig:ly.hug€ n ειbl.a] Gι.d ιn.ΓdιΦ,f ινhιn

*E f b .Φ'ιοiωi]
r'i::nJ
";; g|ei] th' ιre bndΦlig rn a ρΦ rodaη1!ι qd.bΙι
Wξnαho or sρΦ*dD w,gnsnaη idca oΙ di;s'ωnnj$ι
.ιd1on ol Uh {rns h.' $ ΔφLfl',l non οΙ ιhc hfΦΦqqΙd Φl|aFe oΙ φιΦΦ.d tiεrur.Ιiα οΙ sEΙΦΦ-
nΦ. Ινhr rmsΙkk 9F ιhc fuc'
,ιηhc risπ Φπ ψιn.h mrtc b sboιdinatd to woιdJ' hc $y\ 1s
hth dΦandcd a .dιtι| dαoι ιΦ.Γaιy b !η 1nωE Glio ι, dΙ.1ηι.p.nd.nι beεdy oΙ ιhe Ιorσ']
thaι 6 tny ιhιrt ts,a EΦduu !ru,il)bξ !*n |hc on"οplξ oΙ dΓo
meιnhg,1hi tjo, ΦΙdB mdι d.!tγ d nψji-ψt,[ψrirη; tr;;π".τif ln|rudr
Bkhιs i
υ,onmω.sΦ,mcc|oτs

ωιιyd.ΦidιιdΦ!hwι2d4\ bυι mustaΙbΦuιy,!υ Αs Ι Ed

(suσιdig)
h|m (aηd ι Ms b b€ adnιtd ιhδι Ιo
ζa a Φ$n! ρd d ιhc
ιjon) fuΙs|tkt Ρfury ΦnωΙn

ne Φe{nom w|th inoιnci Ee ι

advdmιns' tπ o6tr words, ι .omρ|.m
Φoc|c on Ιιd. lnd ιh. ahdrιd f.Eπιial daboBdon ot αch Ee{Ιmrh
fawnbg dφΦdcα.y or i$aΙ |Dεge oη αΙ|y.whtbwι9(ρuιιoM,rtllΙbl
$υnd fuι ξds ftor bo dΦι a Φ
own pmdlε' ilich hstld ωdΦ bwζls qo!!ιs.Ιd Φ!!!φΦιΙ] )
Ιι ιo α. oιδσ 'ιf AΙd tlΙ ιεΙ-
,,. .ω|v
..Jl- R"; , J;;h",|". " b-,- Φι"
ιh" wΦ**" .*t d.".".
""".|';.
ro|Ιoψsο!D ωοugh'Ronrιi. isιheιιx ιsdπ.d drfuθ] mιιy gπi,ng$|s,((π!o3pnnc|
wiιh .Φ{iv€ βnius (.hfuu narnμimbo1oι ιh;l-s.hσk€-t Ic'Ι o|c thει oEros m squnΦly ('{ Ιoι ρυEly) msta|' νhιδ md iEply

iΙtbΦ|)|hπι*μjsιLlrodΙeο|yhhι
arc fuι*quΦt|y ben 5hoψn b ,ιοln.ιa.om
wdιns oΙ εnL Νoske
hav. bΦn ra6!i.ded| l t, Aηa it δΦ

rul u - y r,, P; r.' ,..' m ,W

ιΦ rd luli. h cα1i' gnd asιs:
1α ||'trdα.'d!'iΔψ Jfu,r l E
'

n'.ι nu,','ιno'cl."ψ'J-'' adιo1}..nΘiaο1υnlιοality

lhr ι'ha ιmdrdΦJ mDΙωloEjΦΙ ιρpωachΦ h,ft donc by bρl]ca

n t.hdca| etr Ι mu|d lug

ιεn ιh. ofuJD! mΦn6 by ψh ιh L\Β
ιydαcmuJΦ|€ ι F1cueandιι ;J* ιh" *" h"b"h...| ι
Φ.bσih; E.iΓihr".h", of muiι dnd dhcΙ !Φ roΞ \Γmr.i
d h!δ;n;rain.!l ιhriE uηfoη ΙbcEEΦn;dιh 5boυι t'ι|]'ι!,ome
$1r! ΦΦ'e η.ΦΦiτ hat iδ bιilbvc,' infl Rlrιc oΓnMwΦty "τ."π..idΦΦh*π9h" lhΜiΦt mθo D pmdke
in-ffπons aΦ-;λaι
1hiι ιhσc αDld be any Ιωm l.|t οv.r ιor ιΙoιhcr,/|ι1. aηd δd
lh€ft!Ιt th. φ]!an ιhr rΩ|ωEs ι
a 3Φd dmD',mρr πιxι" is ιh.
lnd 1υs bεΙoI. ιι dscnbs fflΦ
"11;it,,"
^,,,"""".*..","-,
"",,-

ι f(lιiπ.di mhiιs Φ]r9ηjng

tirlaι ti ι ιh€ ιn* ;τ m;; Ιan one Δυιhd, Ruι σιiξ ind aπιηsb