You are on page 1of 11

Review Article

Achondroplasia:
Manifestations and Treatment

Abstract
Eric D. Shirley, MD Achondroplasia, the most common skeletal dysplasia, is caused by
Michael C. Ain, MD a mutation of fibroblast growth factor receptor-3. This disorder is
characterized by frontal bossing, midface hypoplasia, otolaryngeal
system dysfunction, and rhizomelic short stature. Orthopaedic
manifestations are exhibited in the spine and the extremities. In the
infant with achondroplasia, foramen magnum stenosis may result in
brainstem compression with apnea and sudden death.
Thoracolumbar kyphosis is seen in most infants, but typically it
resolves when the child begins to walk. Anatomic anomalies of the
vertebral column place the patient at risk for spinal stenosis as
early as the first decade and especially during adulthood. Radial
head dislocation is one manifestation in the upper extremity. Lower
extremity alignment often is characterized by genu varum, which
may require correction osteotomy. Medical and surgical options are
available to increase patient height, but indications are
controversial, and treatment often consumes a large portion of the
child’s life.

G
Dr. Shirley is Lieutenant lobally, achondroplasia is the most growth factor receptor-3 (FGFR3)
Commander, Medical Corps, United
common skeletal dysplasia, with on the distal short arm of chromo-
States Navy, and Attending Pediatric
Orthopaedic Surgeon, Naval Medical an incidence of 1 in 30,000 live some 4.5 FGFR3 mutations also have
Center Portsmouth, Portsmouth, VA. births annually.1 The term achondro- been found in individuals with than-
Dr. Ain is Associate Professor, plasia—meaning “without cartilage atophoric dysplasia and hypochon-
Departments of Orthopaedic Surgery formation”—was first used by Par-
and Neurosurgery, Johns Hopkins droplasia. Most persons with the
rot2 in 1878 to distinguish the dys-
Hospital, Baltimore, MD. typical clinical features of achondro-
plasia from rickets, which manifests
None of the following authors or a with proportionately short stature. plasia have the same recurrent
member of their immediate families Achondroplasia is characterized by G380R mutation. This mutation
has received anything of value from substitutes an arginine for a glycine
foramen magnum stenosis, thora-
or owns stock in a commercial
columbar kyphosis, spinal stenosis, residue in the transmembrane do-
company or institution related
directly or indirectly to the subject of genu varum, and short stature.3,4 Be- main of the tyrosine-coupled trans-
this article: Dr. Shirley and Dr. Ain. cause these manifestations may be- membrane receptor in the physis.6
Reprint requests: Dr. Ain, c/o Elaine
come symptomatic during childhood The typical product of the FGFR3
P. Henze, BJ, ELS, Medical Editor, or adulthood, patients with achon- gene is an FGFR3 monomer. The
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, droplasia are treated by specialists in monomers dimerize when fibroblast
Johns Hopkins Bayview Medical pediatric or adult orthopaedic sur-
growth factor ligands bind to
Center, 4940 Eastern Avenue, gery.
#A672, Baltimore, MD 21224. FGFR3. Dimerization alters the re-
ceptor and activates its tyrosine ki-
J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2009;17:
231-241 Etiology nase activity, which leads to phos-
phorylation of selected tyrosine
Copyright 2009 by the American
Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons. Achondroplasia is caused by muta- residues in the cytoplasmic domain
tions of the gene encoding fibroblast of the receptor. Phosphorylation of

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 231


Achondroplasia: Manifestations and Treatment

Figure 1 Figure 2 shape of the distal femoral physes


with normal distal femoral epiphyses
(Figure 2). The metacarpals and
metatarsals are all almost equal in
length.
Occasionally, the diagnosis can be
established by prenatal testing.
When the family history is positive
and the parents desire a prenatal di-
agnosis, chorionic villus sampling at
11 to 13 weeks of gestation or am-
niocentesis after 15 weeks of gesta-
tion can be performed. These tests
allow the use of polymerase chain re-
action and restriction enzyme frag-
Anteroposterior radiograph
demonstrating interpediculate ment polymorphism to detect the
narrowing of the lumbar spine in a FGFR3 G380R point mutation.
13-year-old boy with
achondroplasia.
Development of
Manifestations
these tyrosine residues allows them Anteroposterior radiograph of the
to serve as docking sites for signaling distal femur demonstrating an The multiple manifestations of
inverted-V–shaped physis achondroplasia present at different
molecules that are recruited to the
characteristic of achondroplasia in stages of life. Short stature is evident
receptor and subsequently initiate a 6-year-old boy.
the propagation of signals that result at birth, with trunk length in the
in the inhibition of chondrocyte pro- lower range of normal and extremi-
achondroplasia than in the general ties shortened in a rhizomelic pat-
liferation and differentiation.7 The
population, which suggests that de tern.3 The face is characterized by
precise mechanism is unknown, but
novo mutations of paternal origin frontal bossing and midface hypo-
the stabilization of FGFR3 dimeriza-
are involved.1 plasia secondary to the endochon-
tion by mutation results in a gain of
function by enhancing the receptor’s dral origin of facial bones. Although
kinase activity.7 mental development is normal, mo-
Diagnosis tor development may be delayed. De-
The clinical result of this mutation
is underdevelopment and shortening When achondroplasia is clinically layed motor development or apnea
of the long bones formed by endo- suspected, radiographs from a skele- in infants may be the result of fora-
chondral ossification. It is not tal survey can generate a differential men magnum stenosis. As affected
known why growth zones of the diagnosis and confirm the definitive infants age and begin to sit, most de-
proximal portions of the extremities diagnosis.8 The key feature is the velop thoracolumbar kyphosis. Genu
are affected more than the distal narrowing of the interpediculate dis- varum may increase as the child
ones and more than those in the tance from L1 to L5 on the antero- grows, and lumbosacral hyperlordo-
trunk. Articular cartilage formation posterior (AP) lumbar spine radio- sis may become evident. Spinal
is normal in the patient with achon- graph (Figure 1). Although this stenosis may become symptomatic in
droplasia. radiographic finding is characteristic the adolescent or adult child with
Inheritance is transmitted as a fully of achondroplasia, it is not present in achondroplasia.
penetrant autosomal dominant trait. all patients with the condition. Other
However, more than 80% of cases radiographic abnormalities include Foramen Magnum Stenosis
are sporadic, and the individuals are underdeveloped facial bones, skull Foramen magnum stenosis is the first
the offspring of parents of normal base, and foramen magnum; squared spinal manifestation to appear in the
stature.1 Paternal age at the time of iliac wings; rhizomelic shortening development of the person with
conception has been reported to be and flared metaphyses of the long achondroplasia. This condition is re-
higher in fathers of patients with bones; and a pronounced inverted-V sponsible for the higher mortality

232 Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons


Eric D. Shirley, MD, and Michael C. Ain, MD

rate (2% to 5%) seen in infants with Figure 3 Figure 4


achondroplasia.9 Foramen magnum
stenosis also may cause signs or
symptoms of chronic brainstem com-
pression (eg, apnea, lower cranial
nerve dysfunction, difficulty swal-
lowing, hyperreflexia, hypotonia,
weakness or paresis, clonus) and se-
vere developmental delay. The most
common presenting symptom is res-
piratory difficulty with excessive
snoring or apnea.10
The American Academy of Pediatrics
recommends screening for foramen
magnum stenosis with polysomnogra-
phy and computed tomography (CT)
or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
in all infants with achondroplasia.9 T1-weighted magnetic resonance
Because CT and MRI require seda- imaging scan demonstrating
foramen magnum stenosis in a
tion, an alternative screening ap-
7-year-old girl.
proach is to obtain advanced imag-
ing only when the sleep study is Clinical photograph of an infant
positive. MRI is preferred to CT be- Thoracolumbar Kyphosis with thoracolumbar kyphosis with a
kyphotic angle of 45°.
cause the former provides better vi- Thoracolumbar kyphosis develops in
sualization of the brainstem and up- most infants with achondroplasia
per cervical spinal cord (Figure 3). (Figures 4 and 5). The newborn with logic compromise with paresthesias,
Foramen magnum stenosis most achondroplasia typically has a thora- sciatic pain, inability to walk, and
commonly presents and requires columbar kyphosis of 20°.11 When neurologic incontinence.
treatment during the first 2 years of sitting begins, the infant often Pauli et al12 recommend early pro-
life, but affected persons may be- slumps forward because of trunk hy- hibition of unsupported sitting with
come symptomatic later in life. Bag- potonia in combination with a rela- bracing as needed to prevent persis-
ley et al10 reviewed 43 children with tively oversized head, a flat chest, tent kyphosis. Before the infant
achondroplasia with foramen mag- and a protuberant abdomen. Re- reaches age 1 year, parents are coun-
num stenosis who underwent a fora- peated slumping forward results in a seled to prohibit unsupported sitting
men magnum decompression and gentle kyphosis that typically in- and to use firm-backed seating de-
upper cervical laminectomy, with or volves T10 to L4, with or without vices, avoid curling the infant into a
without duraplasty. The mean age at anterior vertebral wedging. C-position, use hand counterpressure
the time of operation was 70 months The frequency of kyphosis in when holding the infant, and pro-
(range, 2 to 199 months), and achondroplasia is 87% from age 1 hibit sitting up more than 60°. Sit-
the mean duration of symptoms was year to 2 years, 39% from age 2 to 5 ting in a seat that has been adjusted
7 months (range, 1 to 12 months). years, and 11% from age 5 to 10 to a 45° angle allows the infant to in-
Intraoperative ultrasonography was years.11 The decrease in frequency teract with others without placing
used to confirm satisfactory spinal occurs because most kyphoses tend disproportionate weight on the ante-
canal decompression. Duraplasty was to resolve at age 12 to 18 months as rior part of the vertebrae. Bracing is
performed when compression persisted trunk strength improves and the initiated if the kyphosis develops a
despite bony and fibrous decom- child begins to walk. Persistent ky- fixed component >30° (based on
pression. Complications included cer- phosis can result in deformity pro- prone lateral radiographs), substan-
ebral spinal fluid leaks in seven pa- gression, hip flexion contracture, tial anterior wedging, or posterior
tients, recurrent stenosis requiring and hyperlordosis. In addition, the displacement of the vertebrae at the
revision surgery in five, and infection kyphosis can increase the severity of apex. A thoracolumbosacral orthosis
in four. spinal stenosis, resulting in neuro- is worn until the child walks inde-

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 233


Achondroplasia: Manifestations and Treatment

Figure 5 patient is large enough to allow for


the use of instrumentation.
The traditional approach to the
treatment of kyphosis in the patient
with achondroplasia has been to
minimize correction and avoid poste-
rior instrumentation in most cases
because of the high risk of transient
and permanent neurologic inju-
ries.13,14 In one series of 17 patients
(age range, 3 to 39 years) who un-
derwent surgery for thoracolumbar
kyphosis, the incidence of changes
in somatosensory-evoked potentials
during wire insertion exceeded
50%.14 Mean correction on final ra-
diographs was 20%.
However, more recent studies have
shown the safety and efficacy of instru-
mentation in such patients.15-17 The
current surgical options are posterior
arthrodesis with instrumentation or
combined anterior-posterior arthro-
Preoperative (A) and postoperative (B) lateral radiographs of a patient with desis. Anterior arthrodesis is consid-
thoracolumbar kyphosis who was treated with posterior spinal fusion.
ered for kyphosis >50° on a pre-
operative hyperextension lateral
pendently, the anterior corners of the racic cages and preexisting respira- radiograph. However, our threshold
vertebrae reconstitute, and the fixed tory dysfunction. for performing an anterior arthrode-
component of the curve stops im- We consider bracing to be an op- sis has decreased with the increased
proving. tion for ambulatory patients with rigidity achieved by the placement of
Pauli et al12 reviewed 66 infants progressive kyphoses and vertebral pedicle screws at every level. In addi-
treated with this regimen of early wedging. We discuss with the parents tion, when a preoperative MRI scan
prohibition of unsupported sitting the pros and cons of bracing, along shows severe cord impingement, a
and bracing as needed. Of those 66 with the levels of evidence, so that corpectomy is performed. There is
patients, 20 required bracing (mean an informed decision can be made. no consensus regarding single- versus
duration, 15 months). The kyphosis When bracing fails to correct the de- multistage procedures or for postop-
responded to brace treatment in all formity, the options are nonsurgical erative cast or brace management.
patients, with a mean residual ky- treatment with the use of hyperex- We described four patients who
phosis of 8°. No patient developed tension casts that include the thighs, underwent a combined two-stage an-
progressive kyphosis. This series was or surgical management. terior and posterior spinal arthrode-
not a prospective, randomized study, Because the natural history of per- sis with anterior instrumentation.
however. Level I or level II evidence sistent kyphosis is not well described, Correction ranged from 23% to
to support bracing in such patients is it remains unclear which kyphoses 31%, and there were no complica-
still lacking. In addition, there are should be corrected before neuro- tions.16 Ain and Browne15 reported
other concerns regarding the indica- logic symptoms develop. We recom- on 12 patients (mean age, 12 years;
tion for bracing. The patient may be mend surgery for kyphoses with neu- range, 4 to 21 years) who underwent
at risk for falls because a large brace rologic compromise or for kyphoses posterior spinal arthrodesis with
is placed on a small body with poor >50° because of the risk of progres- instrumentation alone (7 patients),
trunk control and developmental de- sion to a rigid kyphosis with neuro- combined AP arthrodesis with poste-
lay. In addition, braces may have a logic compromise. Unless the kypho- rior instrumentation (2 patients), or
detrimental effect on pulmonary sis is rapidly progressing, surgery is combined AP arthrodesis with ante-
function in children with small tho- delayed until age 4 years so that the rior instrumentation (3 patients). Pa-

234 Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons


Eric D. Shirley, MD, and Michael C. Ain, MD

tients in whom no instrumentation droplasia may have lumbosacral Figure 6


was placed posteriorly underwent re- hyperlordosis11 (Figure 6). The hy-
peat posterior bone grafting at 4 perlordosis is the result of excessive
months after surgery. Patients who anterior pelvic tilt while standing
underwent posterior instrumentation and produces a prominent abdomen
spent 6 months postoperatively in a and buttocks with hip flexion con-
brace, whereas those who did not tractures. Children with achondro-
spent 6 months in a cast. Successful plasia and spinal stenosis often squat
fusion was obtained in all patients, to obtain symptomatic relief, likely
and there were no intraoperative or by decreasing the degree of hyperlor-
dosis, but the exact neurologic signif-
postoperative neurologic complica-
icance of the hyperlordosis is not
tions. Mean improvement in the ky-
clear. Treatment indications for lum-
phosis was 50%. There were three
bosacral hyperlordosis are also
instrumentation fractures and one
poorly defined.
dural leak.
Nonsurgical management with psoas
Sarlak et al17 reported the results of
stretching has been tried without
one-stage, two-level (T12 and L1) success.11 Park et al19 evaluated the
posterior column resection, pedicle effects of bilateral tibial lengthening
screw fixation, and posterior spinal (seven patients) versus femoral and
arthrodesis from T4 to L4 in a 13- tibial lengthening (three patients) on
year-old patient with achondroplasia lumbosacral hyperlordosis in pa-
and 97° of thoracolumbar kyphosis. tients who underwent the procedures
Postoperative kyphosis was 32°, and for stature augmentation. The au-
the 2-year follow-up was uneventful. thors measured the lumbar lordosis
Surgical considerations are differ- angle, lumbosacral angle, and sacral
ent in the adult with achondroplasia inclination angle (angle between the Clinical photograph of a patient
because there is often coexistent spi- with lumbar hyperlordosis and
vertical plane line and a line along widespread achondroplastic
nal stenosis. Qi et al18 described four the posterior border of the body of changes.
patients (mean age, 32.5 years; the first and second sacral vertebrae).
range, 15 to 60 years) with neuro- Tibial lengthening had no effect on
logic deficit secondary to thora- lumbosacral hyperlordosis. Femoral crease in symptoms of spinal stenosis
columbar kyphosis. Posterior osteot- lengthening improved the clinical ap- that developed after limb lengthen-
omy with segmental instrumentation pearance of the hyperlordosis with ing. There were no neurologic com-
was performed in all four patients. decreased prominence of the abdo- plications in the combined femoral
Pedicle subtraction osteotomy was men and buttocks, but the lumbar and tibial lengthening group in
performed in two patients without a lordosis angle was not changed. which the clinical appearance of the
hypoplastic apical vertebra, and Femoral lengthening did change the hyperlordosis was improved.
spondylectomy with anterior column sacral inclination angle, which likely In our own experience, we have not
reconstruction was performed in two accounted for the change in clinical noted any marked clinical or radio-
patients with hypoplastic apical ver- appearance. These authors hypothe- graphic changes in lumbosacral hyper-
tebrae. All patients obtained neuro- sized that the sacral tilt was im- lordosis after limb lengthening, nor
logic improvement. The mean preop- proved by making the osteotomy have we seen any improvement in neu-
erative kyphosis was 96.3° (range, proximal to the gluteus maximus in- rologic symptoms. The neurologic con-
57° to 117°), and the mean postoper- sertion, which tightened the muscle sequences of lumbosacral hyperlor-
ative kyphosis was 55.3° (range, 30° and resulted in decreased sacral tilt. dosis before and after lengthening
to 110°), with a mean correction of The neurologic outcome after cor- procedures require additional investi-
43.6% (range, 6% to 71%). rection of the lumbosacral hyper- gation.
lordosis is unclear. In the study by
Lumbosacral Hyperlordosis Park et al,19 one patient in the tibial Spinal Stenosis
In addition to thoracolumbar kypho- lengthening group required spinal The endochondral ossification de-
sis, up to 80% of children with achon- decompression because of an in- fects in achondroplasia result in mul-

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 235


Achondroplasia: Manifestations and Treatment

Figure 7 usually is present. Pyeritz et al24 re-


viewed 22 patients with achondro-
plasia who underwent laminectomy
for spinal stenosis. Only 12 patients
had functional improvement lasting
longer than 5 years, and 11 of the 22
required revision surgery. Because of
the high rate of revision surgery,
these authors suggested that the first
laminectomy should extend three
levels cephalad to the myelographic
block and caudad to at least S2.
Postlaminectomy kyphosis is a com-
mon complication in the skeletally
immature patient but not in the adult
with achondroplasia.24 Ain et al25 re-
viewed 10 consecutive skeletally im-
mature patients with achondroplasia
who underwent surgical treatment of
symptomatic spinal stenosis during a
10-year period. The average patient
age was 9.2 years (range, 6 to 16
years), and the mean preoperative
kyphosis was 31° (range, 10° to 50°)
(Figure 8, A). All patients underwent
T1-weighted coronal (A) and sagittal (B) magnetic resonance imaging scans
demonstrating multilevel spinal stenosis (arrows) in a 19-year-old woman. five- to eight-level thoracolumbar
laminectomies. Despite preservation
of >50% of each medial facet, post-
tiple morphologic abnormalities of develop before adolescence. The re- laminectomy thoracolumbar kypho-
the entire spinal column, which place ported incidence of symptomatic spinal ses (mean, 94°; range, 78° to 135°)
the patient at risk for spinal stenosis stenosis in patients with achondropla- developed in all patients (Figure 8,
(Figure 7). The vertebral bodies are sia ranges from 37% to 89%.22 B). In addition, all patients required
shortened and enlarged at the supe- Approximately one fourth of all secondary arthrodesis to address the
rior and inferior aspects, and the patients with achondroplasia require kyphoses 10 months to 2.6 years
pedicles are short and thickened by surgery for spinal stenosis.23 Surgical after the initial surgery (Figure 8, C).
30%.20 The interpediculate distance indications include progressive symp- Because of the high risk of develop-
typically decreases from L1 to L5, toms, urinary retention, severe clau- ing a postlaminectomy kyphosis,
and the pedicle diameter increases in dication (symptoms manifesting after these authors recommended con-
the same direction.20 In addition, the walking fewer than two city blocks), current spinal arthrodesis in the
intervertebral disks and ligamentum and neurologic symptoms at rest. skeletally immature patient with
flavum are hyperplastic. These ab- Lesser degrees of symptoms, includ- achondroplasia who is undergoing
normalities result in a 40% reduc- ing pain controlled by activity thoracolumbar laminectomy of at
tion in size of the sagittal and coro- modification and anti-inflammatory least five levels.25
nal diameters of the spinal canal medications, can be managed non-
from the foramen magnum to the surgically. Spinal Instrumentation in the
sacrum, compared with those of Historically, surgical management Patient With Achondroplasia
healthy patients.21 The spinal cord of spinal stenosis in the patient with Because of the presence of a nar-
and neural elements are of normal achondroplasia has been challenging. rowed spinal canal, the use of instru-
size. Laminectomy alone is not sufficient mentation that enters the canal (eg,
Symptomatic spinal stenosis in such for decompression, and the nerve wires, laminar hooks) is contraindi-
individuals usually does not occur un- root recesses on both sides must be cated in patients with achondropla-
til the third or fourth decade, but it may explored because lateral stenosis sia. The use of fixation devices such

236 Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons


Eric D. Shirley, MD, and Michael C. Ain, MD

Figure 8

Lateral radiographs taken before (A) and after (B) decompression, demonstrating alignment (22° and 88°, respectively)
in a 14-year-old boy. C, Lateral radiograph demonstrating pedicle screw instrumentation to correct the postlaminectomy
kyphosis. (Reproduced with permission from Ain MC, Shirley ED, Pirouzmanesh A, Hariri A, Carson BS:
Postlaminectomy kyphosis in the skeletally immature achondroplast. Spine 2006;31:197-201.)

as pedicle screws, which do not enter Upper Extremity Figure 9


the spinal canal, is favored. How- Manifestations
ever, pedicle screw instrumentation
The upper extremity in the patient
in patients with achondroplasia and
with achondroplasia is characterized
other patients with short stature
by rhizomelic shortening secondary
can be challenging. Safe insertion
to short humeri. The fingertips reach
requires technical experience and
only to the tops of the greater tro-
knowledge of the achondroplastic
pedicle morphometry, which differs chanters. This rhizomelic shortening
markedly from that of the normal can create disability because of diffi-
spine. culty in reaching the top of the head
The pedicles are directed cranially and the perineum for hygiene care.4
at all levels. Average pedicle lengths Disability from shortness of the
are nearly 10 mm shorter than in upper limbs may be exacerbated by
persons who do not have achondro- flexion contractures of the elbows. Clinical photograph of a trident
hand in an infant with
plasia.26 Screws 20 to 25 mm in The flexion contractures likely are achondroplasia.
length can be used for lower thoracic the result of flexion deformities of
and lumbar pedicles in most adults the distal humerus. In addition, sub-
three groups and giving the hand a
with achondroplasia. Compared luxation of the radial heads may be
trident appearance (Figure 9).
with the normal spine, the achondro- present. Typically, elbow abnormali-
plastic transverse pedicle diameter is ties do not require treatment because
similar and the sagittal diameter is functional limitations usually are ab- Genu Varum
smaller.26 Screw diameters of 5 to 7 sent. Characteristically, there is an
mm are safe in most adult patients extra space between the third and Genu varum is a clinical hallmark
with achondroplasia. fourth rays, separating the digits into of achondroplasia3 (Figure 10). The

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 237


Achondroplasia: Manifestations and Treatment

Figure 10 fibula to the knee and ankle joints


were not associated with the align- Short Stature and Elective
ment of the lower extremity, con- Limb Lengthening
cluding that fibular overgrowth did
The infant with achondroplasia is
not correlate with the severity of the
shorter than unaffected infants; this
genu varum.
height deficit increases markedly in
Lee et al29 also investigated the re-
the first years of life. On average, the
lation of fibular overgrowth to the
length differential is −1.5 SD at
development of genu varum by mea-
birth, −3.2 SD at 6 months, −4.4 SD
suring the standing radiographs of
at 1 year, and −5.0 at 2 years.31 This
30 skeletally immature and 23 skele-
last rate remains constant until pu-
tally mature patients. Using different
berty, at which time additional loss
parameters from those of Ain et al,28
in height occurs. The average height
the authors found that the fibula-to-
in the adult with achondroplasia is
tibia length ratio correlated with the
132 cm (range, 118 to 145 cm [52,
medial proximal tibia angle and me-
46.5, and 57 inches, respectively])
chanical axis deviation in skeletally for men and 125 cm (range, 112 to
immature patients but not in skele- 136 cm [49, 44, and 53.5 inches, re-
tally mature patients. spectively]) for women,31 which cor-
The management of genu varum in responds to a height 6 to 7 SD below
patients with achondroplasia has var- the average for unaffected individu-
ied. Treatment indications are dif- als.
ficult to define clearly because there Paley et al32 calculated total height
Anteroposterior radiograph of a
patient with genu varum. are no natural history studies show- multipliers from two separate data-
ing which degree of deformity causes bases by dividing height at maturity
joint degeneration in patients with by height at each respective age for
malalignment may be asymptomatic achondroplasia. Bracing has been both sexes. Lower limb and total
or may be associated with pain, neu- tried without success. In general, sur- height growth rates were slower than
rologic symptoms, knee instability, gical indications are to correct symp- those in healthy persons. Sitting
limitation of knee joint function, tomatic deformity, fibular thrust, or height multipliers were closely re-
waddling gait, malalignment of severe malalignment. Tibial osteot- lated to those for healthy persons.
stance, or lateral gapping of the knee omy with or without femoral osteot- Growth charts for the height, weight,
when standing. omy (opening or closing wedge, with and head circumference developed
The cause of genu varum in achon- internal or external fixation) can cor- specifically for children with achon-
droplasia remains controversial. Hy- rect the deformity reliably. Concur- droplasia may be used to predict
potheses include lateral collateral lig- rent tibial torsion must be addressed adult height.31 Alternatively, final
ament laxity and fibular overgrowth at the time of surgery. The lower ex- height may be predicted with the
because the fibula nearly always is tremity rotational profiles are charac- multiplier method, although the ac-
longer than the tibia in patients with terized by persistently decreased ex- curacy of these predictions remains
achondroplasia. Stanley et al27 pro- ternal tibial torsion and the lack of a to be validated.32
posed that the cause was age- normal decrease in femoral antever- The decision to augment stature is
dependent, secondary to overgrowth sion during growth.30 Procedures difficult and controversial. Impair-
of the proximal fibula combined that address the fibula alone, includ- ments as a result of short stature in-
with lateral collateral ligament laxity ing partial excisional osteotomy and clude conducting business at coun-
in patients aged 2 to 6 years and sec- fibular epiphysiodesis, have been ad- tertops, face washing, hair combing,
ondary to overgrowth of the distal vocated,29 but their efficacy has not using a public restroom, playing
fibula in patients aged 8 to 11 years. been established. Until such effi- sports, and engaging in hobbies in-
Ain et al28 reviewed the radiographs ciency has been documented, we be- volving physical activity. Other diffi-
of 48 children with achondroplasia lieve that surgery should be directed culties may be associated with social
and found that the distances from at the site of the tibial and/or femo- and emotional relationships. How-
the proximal and distal ends of the ral deformity. ever, a functional benefit in these im-

238 Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons


Eric D. Shirley, MD, and Michael C. Ain, MD

pairments after elective limb length- length was 10.2 ± 1.25 cm (4.0 ± 0.5 developmental milestones later than
ening has not been established. inches) (range, 8 to 12 cm [3.2 to 4.7 do those of average stature. The av-
Kanazawa et al33 showed a statisti- inches]); treatment time averaged 9 erage age at which unaided walking
cally significant effect on height gain months, and there were no complica- is achieved is 17 months, in contrast
from growth hormone (GH) therapy tions. to 12 to 16 months for unaffected
over a 1-year period; GH therapy in- Complications of surgical limb children. The cause of the develop-
creased annual height gain from 3.9 lengthening can be substantial. In the mental delay is not clear, although
± 1.2 cm/yr (1.53 ± 0.47 inches) to series by Aldegheri and Dall’Oca,35 foramen magnum stenosis must be
7.2 ± 1.4 cm/yr (2.83 ± 0.55 inches) 43% of patients who underwent ruled out. Cognitive development is
(P < 0.05). In a 5-year GH treatment limb lengthening had complications, normal.
study, with 1 year without treatment, including fractures, early consolida- Maintaining an ideal body weight is
Hertel et al34 showed that GH treat- tion, failed union, malalignment, a continuous challenge for many indi-
ment improved height without ad- joint stiffness, and infection. There is viduals with achondroplasia, and obe-
verse effects on trunk-leg dispropor- anecdotal evidence and at least one
sity is more common than in the gen-
tion. The advantages of gaining 6 to report in the literature of increased
eral population.9 Weight-for-height
8 cm (2.4 to 3.1 inches) in height symptoms of lumbar spinal stenosis
and weight-for-age curves used for
needs to be weighed against the in- after limb lengthening, requiring
the general population are not appli-
convenience of nearly 5 years of lumbar decompression.19 The effect
cable in determining ideal weight,
daily injections. of limb lengthening on spinal steno-
but triceps skin-fold thickness mea-
Surgical lengthening may achieve sis needs additional investigation.
surement can be helpful. Sports par-
greater increases in height. How-
ticipation, especially swimming and
ever, surgical lengthening is a time-
Medical Complications biking, should be encouraged. The
consuming process. At some centers,
child should avoid gymnastics and
lengthening is performed at two sepa-
Impairment from achondroplasia is collision sports because of the poten-
rate time periods. The first lengthening
not limited to the musculoskeletal tial for neurologic complications sec-
typically occurs at approximately age
system. Hydrocephalus may occur ondary to cervical stenosis.9
7 years and the second at approxi-
during the newborn and infantile pe- Patients with achondroplasia are
mately age 12 years. The total duration
riod.36 Because children with achon- very healthy compared with patients
for surgery and postoperative therapy
droplasia have relatively large heads with other dysplasias, but mortality
may be up to 3 years. Other centers pre-
and frontal bossing, diagnosis may rates in all age groups are higher
fer to delay lengthening until early
be difficult. Diagnosis is made by than those in the general population
adolescence to increase the patient’s par-
closely monitoring the head circum- because of sudden death in young in-
ticipation with the rehabilitation pro-
ference and motor development and fants, central nervous system and
cess. Complications during rehabilita-
by comparing those measurements respiratory problems in older chil-
tion may require that the lengthening
with standard achondroplastic data. dren, and cardiovascular problems in
stops short of the desired goal. The psy-
Ventricular shunting is required in young adults.37
chological impact on the child when
lengthening is stopped short of the approximately 5% of patients.23
stated goal cannot be underestimated. Otolaryngeal problems also are prev-
Quality of Life
Surgical limb lengthening is a alent: 90% of patients with achondro-
complicated endeavor. Aldegheri and plasia experience otitis media before age The quality of life experienced by the
Dall’Oca35 reviewed 140 patients 2 years, and half require placement of patient with achondroplasia reflects the
with short stature (including 80 with tympanostomy tubes.23 Relative ade- social challenges experienced by pa-
achondroplasia) who underwent sur- notonsillar hypertrophy secondary to tients of short stature. In one quality-
gical lower limb (femur or tibia) midface hypoplasia can cause ob- of-life study, these individuals were
lengthening. The average gain in leg structive sleep apnea. Otitis media found to have lower annual income and
length was 20.5 ± 4.7 cm (8.1 ± 1.9 and adenotonsillar hypertrophy may less education and were less likely to be
inches), and the average treatment result in conductive hearing loss that married than were unaffected indi-
time was 31 months (range, 18 to 40 can impair speech development. viduals.38 Patients with achondropla-
months). Ten patients also under- These problems may lead to disabili- sia also had significantly lower self-
went upper extremity (humerus) ties in communication and learning. esteem values and significantly lower
lengthening. The average gain in arm Children with achondroplasia meet quality-of-life indices across four

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 239


Achondroplasia: Manifestations and Treatment

subdomains: health and functioning, 4. Kopits SE: Orthopedic complications of thoracolumbar kyphosis in patients with
dwarfism. Clin Orthop Relat Res 1976; achondroplasia. Spine 2006;31:E606-
social and economic, psychological 114:153-179. E610.
and spiritual, and family.38
5. Rousseau F, Bonaventure J, Legeai- 19. Park HW, Kim HS, Hahn SB, et al:
Mallet L, et al: Mutations in the gene Correction of lumbosacral hyperlordosis
encoding fibroblast growth factor in achondroplasia. Clin Orthop Relat
Summary receptor-3 in achondroplasia. Nature Res 2003;414:242-249.
1994;371:252-254.
20. Lutter LD, Longstein JE, Winter RB,
Achondroplasia is the most common 6. Horton WA: Recent milestones in Langer LO: Anatomy of the
skeletal dysplasia. Manifestations are achondroplasia research. Am J Med achondroplastic lumbar canal. Clin
Genet A 2006;140:166-169. Orthop Relat Res 1977;126:139-142.
seen in the spine, the upper and lower
extremities, and the otolaryngeal sys- 7. Webster MK, Donoghue DJ: Constitutive 21. Lutter LD, Langer LO: Neurological
activation of fibroblast growth factor symptoms in achondroplastic dwarfs:
tem. Foramen magnum stenosis may receptor 3 by the transmembrane Surgical treatment. J Bone Joint Surg Am
become symptomatic in the first 2 years domain point mutation found in 1977;59:87-92.
achondroplasia. EMBO J 1996;15:520-
of life and require decompression. Al- 527. 22. Bethem D, Winter RB, Lutter L, et al:
though thoracolumbar kyphosis typi- Spinal disorders of dwarfism: Review of
8. Unger S: A genetic approach to the the literature and report of eighty cases.
cally resolves, surgery may be necessary diagnosis of skeletal dysplasia. Clin J Bone Joint Surg Am 1981;63:1412-
for spinal stenosis. Genu varum may re- Orthop Relat Res 2002;401:32-38. 1425.

quire corrective osteotomy. The indica- 9. Trotter TL, Hall JG, American Academy 23. Hunter AG, Bankier A, Rogers JG,
of Pediatrics Committee on Genetics: Sillence D, Scott CI Jr: Medical
tions and outcomes of limb lengthen-
Health supervision for children with complications of achondroplasia: A
ing for patients with achondroplasia achondroplasia. Pediatrics 2005;116: multicentre patient review. J Med Genet
remain controversial. Because the man- 771-783. 1998;35:705-712.
ifestations appear in multiple locations, 10. Bagley CA, Pindrik JA, Bookland MJ, 24. Pyeritz RE, Sack GH Jr, Udvarhelyi GB:
pediatricians and orthopaedic surgeons Camara-Quintana JQ, Carson BS: Thoracolumbosacral laminectomy in
Cervicomedullary decompression for achondroplasia: Long-term results in 22
from multiple specialties need to take foramen magnum stenosis in patients. Am J Med Genet 1987;28:433-
part in providing care for the patient achondroplasia. J Neurosurg 2006;104(3 444.
suppl):166-172.
with achondroplasia. 25. Ain MC, Shirley ED, Pirouzmanesh A,
11. Kopits SE: Thoracolumbar kyphosis and Hariri A, Carson BS: Postlaminectomy
lumbosacral hyperlordosis in kyphosis in the skeletally immature
achondroplastic children. Basic Life Sci achondroplast. Spine 2006;31:197-201.
References 1988;48:241-255.
26. Srikumaran U, Woodard EJ, Leet AI,
12. Pauli RM, Breed A, Horton VK, Glinski Rigamonti D, Sponseller PD, Ain MC:
Evidence-based Medicine: Reference 34 LP, Reiser CA: Prevention of fixed, Pedicle and spinal canal parameters of
is a level II randomized control study, angular kyphosis in achondroplasia. the lower thoracic and lumbar vertebrae
J Pediatr Orthop 1997;17:726-733. in the achondroplast population. Spine
and reference 19 is a level III case- 2007;32:2423-2431.
13. Lonstein JE: Treatment of kyphosis and
control study. Most of the other refer-
lumbar stenosis in achondroplasia. Basic 27. Stanley G, McLoughlin S, Beals RK:
ences presented are level IV case series Life Sci 1988;48:283-292. Observations on the cause of bowlegs in
(10, 12, 14-18, 21, 24, 25, 27-29, 33, achondroplasia. J Pediatr Orthop 2002;
14. Tolo VT: Surgical treatment of kyphosis 22:112-116.
and 35), level V expert opinion series in achondroplasia. Basic Life Sci 1988;
48:257-259. 28. Ain MC, Shirley ED, Pirouzmanesh A,
(11 and 13), or cadaveric, biomechan-
Skolasky RL, Leet AI: Genu varum in
ical, and anatomic studies. 15. Ain MC, Browne JA: Spinal arthrodesis achondroplasia. J Pediatr Orthop 2006;
with instrumentation for thoracolumbar 26:375-379.
Citation numbers printed in bold type kyphosis in pediatric achondroplasia.
indicate references published within the Spine 2004;29:2075-2080. 29. Lee ST, Song HR, Mahajan R, Makwana
V, Suh SW, Lee SH: Development of
past 5 years. 16. Ain MC, Shirley ED: Spinal fusion for genu varum in achondroplasia: Relation
kyphosis in achondroplasia. J Pediatr to fibular overgrowth. J Bone Joint Surg
1. Oberklaid F, Danks DM, Jensen F, Stace Orthop 2004;24:541-545. Br 2007;89:57-61.
L, Rosshandler S: Achondroplasia and
hypochondroplasia: Comments on 17. Sarlak AY, Buluç L, Anik Y, Memişoğlu 30. Song HR, Choonia AT, Hong SJ, et al:
frequency, mutation rate, and K, Kurtgöz B: Treatment of fixed Rotational profile of the lower extremity
radiological features in skull and spine. thoracolumbar kyphosis in immature in achondroplasia: Computed
J Med Genet 1979;16:140-146. achondroplastic patient: Posterior tomographic examination of 25 patients.
column resection combined with Skeletal Radiol 2006;35:929-934.
2. Parrot MJ: Sur la malformation segmental pedicle screw fixation and
achondroplasique et le Dieu Phtah. Bull posterolateral fusion. Eur Spine J 2004; 31. Horton WA, Rotter JI, Rimoin DL, Scott
Soc Anthropol 1878;1:296-308. 13:458-461. CI, Hall JG: Standard growth curves for
achondroplasia. J Pediatr 1978;93:435-
3. Bailey JA II : Orthopaedic aspects of 18. Qi X, Matsumoto M, Ishii K, Nakamura 438.
achondroplasia. J Bone Joint Surg Am M, Chiba K, Toyama Y: Posterior
1970;52:1285-1301. osteotomy and instrumentation for 32. Paley D, Matz AL, Kurland DB, Lamm

240 Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons


Eric D. Shirley, MD, and Michael C. Ain, MD

BM, Herzenberg JE: Multiplier method 34. Hertel NT, Eklöf O, Ivarsson S, et al: 36. Haga N: Management of disabilities
for prediction of adult height in patients Growth hormone treatment in 35 associated with achondroplasia.
with achondroplasia. J Pediatr Orthop prepubertal children with J Orthop Sci 2004;9:103-107.
2005;25:539-542. achondroplasia: A five-year dose-
response trial. Acta Paediatr 2005;94: 37. Hecht JT, Francomano CA, Horton WA,
33. Kanazawa H, Tanaka H, Inoue M, 1402-1410. Annegers JF: Mortality in
Yamanaka Y, Namba N, Seino Y: achondroplasia. Am J Hum Genet 1987;
Efficacy of growth hormone therapy for 35. Aldegheri R, Dall’Oca C: Limb 41:454-464.
patients with skeletal dysplasia. J Bone lengthening in short stature patients.
Miner Metab 2003;21:307-310. J Pediatr Orthop B 2001;10:238-247. 38. Gollust SE, Thompson RE, Gooding HC,
Biesecker BB: Living with
achondroplasia in an average-sized
world: An assessment of quality of life.
Am J Med Genet A 2003;120A:447-458.

April 2009, Vol 17, No 4 241

You might also like