Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ammonia Synthesis
ABSTRACT
Over 140 million tons of ammonia is produced worldwide each year. The rewards for reducing
costs, increasing efficiency and improving the profitability of ammonia plants are enormous.
Computer simulation of the plant is the first step towards identifying which parameters control the
conversion rate, product purity, energy usage, and the production rate of an existing facility.
This casebook demonstrates the use of PRO/II in the simulation of an ammonia synthesis process.
The entire plant is modeled, from the reforming of the hydrocarbon feedstream to synthesis gas
through its purification to its conversion to ammonia in a synthesis reactor.
The ammonia synthesis loop involves a large recycle compared to the feed and product rates. In
addition there are several thermal recycles and two control loops. Special thermodynamics are used
to ensure the accurate prediction of the separation of ammonia from the other materials.
The casebook also outlines the use of the simulation for parametric studies in the evolution of a
control strategy.
Egypt Agent
Cairo, Egypt
T +20 2 753 7061
The natural supplies of fixed nitrogen were adequate for many centuries to satisfy the normal
processes of nature. However, by the beginning of the 19th century, the increase in world population
along with the growth of big cities created a demand from the more industrialized countries for
supplemental sources of fixed nitrogen.
This supplement was first found in imported guano and sodium nitrate and later in ammoniacal
solutions and ammonium sulphate by-products from the carbonization of coal in gas-works and
coke ovens.
By the start of the 20th century the demand for fertilizer nitrogen again outstripped supply. Three
different processes for the fixation of nitrogen were designed and put in commercial operation to
ensure adequate supplies of fertilizer nitrogen.
One of those three was the direct synthesis of ammonia from nitrogen and hydrogen by the Haber-
Bosch process. This was developed in Germany between 1905 and 1913 and virtually all fixed
nitrogen is now produced by this process.
The total world production in 2005 was over 140 million tons of fixed nitrogen. Global demand for
ammonia is expected to increase about 2% per year for the foreseeable future. More than 90% of
this is produced as ammonia and about 85% of the total fixed nitrogen production is used in
fertilizers.
Kellogg Brown & Root (KBR) is the largest licensor of Ammonia Synthesis Technology with over
170 Kellogg plants and over 25 Braun (now owned by KBR) plants. These plants have accounted
for more ammonia capacity worldwide than any other licensor.1
1
“Ammonia”, by Kellogg Brown & Root, 2000
At over 170 units worldwide, the Kellogg process has been installed in more ammonia plants than
any other process. The simulation considered in this Casebook is a generic Kellogg process. A full
flowsheet may be found in Appendix A.
Although the Kellogg process is a licensed process, operational benefits can be gained from
changing a number of the variable parameters: temperatures, recycle rates, air and steam quantities
and so on. Recently there has been some work on lowering the steam to carbon ratio to the primary
reformer and modifying the catalysts used in the shift converters.The emphasis in ammonia plants
today is for lower energy usage. New Kellogg plants claim 6.85Gcal/short ton for all energy
requirements over one year.
The main feedstock for this ammonia process is 6 million SCFD of natural gas at a temperature of
60oF and a pressure of 340 psig. Its composition is shown in Table 1.
Before entering the primary reformer, the natural gas is mixed with superheated steam at 334 psig
and 950 F. Nitrogen is supplied from the air which is fed to the secondary reformer at 289 psig and
330 F. The composition of air is displayed in Table 2.
There is also a water feed which is used to saturate the syngas in the MEA plant.
Products
The main product of an ammonia plant is, of course, ammonia. The ammonia product stream must
have a purity greater than 99.5%. The major impurities are hydrogen, nitrogen, argon and methane.
The other product streams are:
Detailed descriptions of the product streams may be found at the end of the Simulation section in
Table 3.
Following sulfur removal, the primary steam reformer converts about 70% of the hydrocarbon feed
into raw synthesis gas in the presence of steam using a nickel catalyst.
In the secondary reformer, air is introduced to supply the nitrogen. The heat of combustion of the
partially reformed gas raises the temperature and supplies the energy to reform most of the
remaining hydrocarbon feed.
The reformer product stream is used to generate steam and to preheat the natural gas feed.
The shift conversion is carried out in two stages. The first uses a high temperature catalyst and the
second uses a low temperature one.
The shift converters remove the carbon monoxide produced in the reforming stage by converting it
to carbon dioxide by the reaction:
CO + H2O ↔ CO2 + H2
This reaction also creates additional hydrogen for the ammonia synthesis.
Shift reactor effluent is cooled and the condensed water is separated. The gas is then passed to the
purification section where carbon dioxide is removed from the synthesis gas in any one of a number
of systems such as hot carbonate, MEA, Selexol etc.
After the purification stage, the last traces of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide are removed in
the methanation reactions:
CO + 3H2O ↔ CH4 + H2
CO2 + 4H2 ↔ CH4 + 2H2O
The methanation reaction is necessary not only to remove the carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide,
but also to create water which can then be removed in the compression stage. This will add
efficiency to the process in that any water that is removed will not have to be circulated in the large
recycle loop in the ammonia synthesis stage.
The purified synthesis gas is cooled and the condensed water is removed. The gas is then
compressed in a three stage unit. The centrifugal compressors are driven by steam turbines using
steam generated in the plant itself, reducing overall power consumption.
The compressed synthesis gas is dried, mixed with a recycle stream and introduced into the
synthesis loop after the recycle compressor. The gas mixture is chilled and liquid ammonia is
removed from the secondary separator. The vapor is heated and passed to the ammonia converter.
The feed is preheated inside the converter before entering the catalyst bed.
N2 + 3H2 ↔ 2NH3
Very high pressures (typically in excess of 300 atmospheres) are required in order to obtain a
reasonable conversion. The conversion of hydrogen per pass is still less than 30% and so a large
recycle of unreacted gases is necessary.
The converter vapor product is cooled by ammonia refrigeration in the primary separator to
condense the ammonia product.
A purge is removed from the remaining gases to prevent the build up of inerts in the loop. The
molar concentration of inerts (argon and methane) in the converter feed is maintained at 12%.
In the Reformer
The primary reformer passes the natural gas and steam mixture through catalyst-packed tubes in a
furnace. The furnace exhaust gases are used to generate steam in a series of boilers. This steam is
then used to drive the compressors.
The effluent from the secondary reformer is used in a waste heat boiler and then to preheat the feed
to the desulfurizer.
The effluent from the low temperature shift reaction is used in another reboiler.
In the Conversion
The products from the ammonia converter are mixed with the synthesis gas from the compressors
and cooled for ammonia separation by exchange with the converter feed. The converter feed is
preheated by the products inside the converter vessel.
MATERIAL RECYCLE
The final stage, the Synthesis Loop, is a recycle operation. The conversion of nitrogen and
hydrogen to ammonia in the converter is very low - less than 30% of the hydrogen is converted per
pass. Therefore there has to be a large recycle in order to convert all the feed and ensure that the
final ammonia product reaches the required purity.
The “Simulation Flowsheets” shown below differ from the previous process flowsheets in that they
include stream identifiers and show the way the simulation is solved. This becomes especially
important for recycle solutions, both for thermal recycles and material recycles. A full flowsheet
may be found in Appendix A.
General Data
Because stage 4 of this process involves a loop which has a large recycle rate in comparison to the
product rates, it is essential that the flowsheet is in mass balance. The normal stream component
recycle convergence tolerance must therefore be tightened - in this case to 0.05%. The stream
Temperature and Pressure recycle tolerances were also tightened to 0.1 and 0.001 respectively. The
threshold mole fraction limit for trace components in the recycle is also reduced to 0.0001 in order
to ensure that all components are checked for the loop convergence. The maximum allowed
number of recycle trials is increased to 150 to ensure that the number of recycle trials is sufficient
to converge the flowsheet. The Wegstein acceleration option is used to help speed up convergence.
The graphic below shows the data entry window for the recycle convergence and acceleration
options.
Component Data
All the components in the simulation are available in the PRO/II data bank.
Thermodynamic Data
For most of the units in the flowsheet the Soave-Redlich-Kwong (SRK) equation of state is an
excellent predictor of phase equilibrium and thermal properties. However, in stage 4 where the
ammonia is being separated from the recycle gas in flash units, a more accurate prediction is
needed to represent the interaction between ammonia and the other components in the streams. For
Invoking the use of the second thermodynamic set for the ammonia separators is as simple as
selecting the second thermodynamic set from the Thermodynamic System drop-down window in
the Flash drum data entry window. The graphic below depict this drop down list with the available
thermodynamic methods.
39
37
D-7
37A
DM1
40
32A D-8
Feed Streams
The main feed streams - natural gas, steam, and air - are defined in the normal way by rate,
composition, temperature, and pressure. In addition there is a water feed to the MEA plant which
ensures that the syngas leaves the plant saturated.
Recycle Streams
There is a recycle stream in stage 4. The large flowrate of this recycle stream relative to the
flowsheet feeds and products along with the fact that the ammonia species is created in the recycle,
necessitates an initial estimate of the rate and composition of the recycle stream. The stream initial
estimates are entered into stream 31R below:
Other Streams
There are several thermal recycles in this flowsheet. These may be simulated in one of several
different ways:
In stage 2, the feed to the low temperature shift reactor (stream 13) is referenced to the high
temperature shift product (stream 11). This defines all the properties of stream 13 as the same as
stream 11. Temperature and pressure are over-written and defined as 400 oF and 274 psig. Similarly,
stream 21 is referenced to stream 19 with a temperature of 675 oF and a pressure of 254 psig. These
reference streams allow the heat exchangers to be solved separately after converging the air
flowrate controller loop.
Stream 13 is not defined as a product from a unit operation. However, in stage 4, stream 38B is a
unit operation product. Nevertheless, in order to eliminate a thermal recycle around the Ammonia
Converter, it is referenced to stream 38.
This means that stream 38B takes its composition and rate at all times from stream 38 but its
temperature and pressure are calculated by the heat exchanger from which it is a product.
Input
Since there is no sulfur in the input, the Desulfurizer RX1 is modeled as an isothermal flash to set
the temperature and pressure of the reformer feed.
Both the reformers, RX2 and RX3, are modeled as Gibbs Free Energy reactors with typical
temperature approaches specified.
The rate of air feed to the secondary reformer must be such that the syngas product from stage 2
has the correct nitrogen:hydrogen ratio. This is achieved by putting a controller on the stage 2
Methanator product and varying the air feed rate to the secondary reformer. This means that stages
1 and 2 are in a controller loop.
To satisfy the primary reformer, the molar ratio of steam (stream 5) to natural gas (stream 1) should
be 6:1. The flow rate of the steam could be set to the correct value in the Stream Data Section.
However, that would involve calculating the molar rate of natural gas (the stream is known only in
volume units) before the simulation begins. It is much easier to let PRO/II perform that calculation.
Furthermore, allowing PRO/II to perform this calculation allows the natural gas stream to be
The secondary reformer product (stream 8) is used to preheat the desulfurizer feed (stream 2). This
thermal recycle is not a simple one in that the process demands a fixed temperature for both the
products from exchanger X-1. This is achieved by dividing the exchanger into two halves: the cold
side is X-1A and is solved before the desulfurizer; the secondary reformed product is cooled in H-1,
a combination of waste heat boiler WHB1 and the hot side of X-1.
After stages 1 and 2 have solved, H-1 is divided into WHB1 and the hot side of X-1 (X-1B). This
can be achieved because PRO/II allows the use of reference streams to link two streams. The define
feature is similar to reference stream feature except that it links unit operation parameters. The
define feature was used to link the duties from one exchanger to another. In this case stream 8_R1
was referenced to stream 8 and the duties for X1-B and WHB1 were defined as the duties for X-1A
and H-1 respectively.
The graphics below illustrate the use of the define feature to line the duties together.
Results
The stream calculator determines the steam flowrate as 3952.7 lb mole/hr which is six times the
natural gas flowrate.
Virtually all of the C2 and higher hydrocarbons are broken down in the primary reformer and
converted to hydrogen, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide. 58% of the methane in the feed is
also converted. 95% of the residual methane is converted in the secondary reformer along with the
remaining traces of ethane and propane. All of the oxygen is consumed in the secondary reformer.
The duties of WHB1 and X-1 are 53.62 and 4.17 MM Btu/hr respectively.
Input
Both the High Temperature Shift Reactor (RX4) and the Low Temperature Shift Reactor (RX5) are
modeled by an equillibrium reactor unit operation using the built-in shift reaction equilibrium data.
They operate adiabatically and the products are assumed to be at equilibrium.
The MEA plant removes the bulk (99.92%) of the carbon dioxide from the shift reactor product and
is modeled as a stream calculator (T-1). The treated gas is saturated with water in flash unit SAT
and excess water discharged.
The final part of stage 2 is the Methanator (RX6), modeled by an equillibrium reactor unit
operation using the built-in methanator and shift reaction equilibrium data. The reactor operates
adiabatically and equilibrium is assumed to be achieved.
The syngas must have a hydrogen:nitrogen molar ratio of 3:1 to satisfy the stoichiometry of the
ammonia reaction. This is accomplished by inserting a controller to measure that ratio in the
Methanator product and vary the air feed to the Secondary Reformer until the required ratio is
achieved. Thus there is a significant loop involving most of the units of stages 1 and 2. This makes
it more important for any thermal recycles within that loop to be eliminated if at all possible.
The thermal recycle in stage 2 of the plant is a complex one, involving preheating the Methanator
feed first with its own product and then with the RX4 product. This recycle is eliminated by
referencing streams 13 and 21 to bypass these exchangers completely.
After the control loop has solved, exchangers X-2, WHB2 and X-3 are solved in the normal way.
Results
The controller solves after 3 trials with an air flowrate of 1008 lb mole/hr. This produces the
required hydrogen:nitrogen ratio in the product from the methanator.
85% of the carbon monoxide is converted in RX-4 and 93% of the remainder is converted in RX-5.
This gives a concentration of 0.055% carbon monoxide and 11.1% carbon dioxide in the exit gas
from RX-5. The concentration of carbon dioxide is reduced to 0.02% in the MEA Plant.
The final removal of all the carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide is carried out in the methanator
reactor.
Input
The Condensate Separator (D-2) is modeled as a flash unit, decanting water in a declared water
stream and using the PRO/II built-in water solubility data.
The compressors are modeled as single stage isentropic compressions with a specified adiabatic
efficiency of 95%. Each one has an aftercooler reducing the product temperature to 95 F. The first
and second compressors also have water decantation streams to knock out any liquid water that
may have condensed in the aftercoolers. Finally, all the remaining water is removed in a drying unit
(SEP1), modeled as a stream calculator.
Results
The compressor work for the three stages is 1752, 1831 and 1776 HP respectively. The
corresponding aftercooler duties are 4.73, 4.70 and 4.35 MM Btu/hr.
Most of the water is removed after the first compressor with a small amount removed after the
second compressor. The final separator removes all remaining water from the synthesis loop feed.
Input
The fourth compressor (CP-4) is in the ammonia recycle loop. The loop starts at that unit, stream
31R being the main recycle stream. An initial estimate for this stream is needed, as discussed in the
Stream Data Section above.
The Ammonia Converter feed is preheated by exchanging inside the converter with its product
stream. This exchanger is modeled separately in the flowsheet as FDEF. The exchangers before the
separators do not appear on the simulation flowsheet as they are combined with the separators.
There are two thermal recycles in the loop. The loop involving the convertor and feed preheater is
split by referencing the convertor feed (stream 38B) to the product from exchanger X-4 (stream 38)
in the Stream Data Section. FDEF is then solved after the convertor when both feed streams have
been calculated.
The loop involving exchanger X-4 is solved explicitly as it appears in the flowsheet. This involves
introducing an inner loop within the ammonia recycle loop. This loop could also be eliminated by
using the devices mentioned above.
The Ammonia Converter (RX-7) is modeled using an equilibrium reactor model with supplied
equilibrium data.
Ln (Keq) = A + B/T
The equilibrium constant is computed at a temperature equal to the reaction temperature minus the
approach temperature difference given.
The feed to the reactor has to contain 12 mole% of inerts (argon and methane). This is achieved by
varying the rate of the recycle stream 31R using a controller (CTL1). This action of the controller
could conflict with the recycle convergence because this stream is also the recycle stream for the
main loop. This is avoided by solving the recycle before the controller is invoked.
In order to maintain the inerts material balance, a purge stream is taken off the recycle stream. The
rate of this stream is calculated in calculator (BD-1). This would act similar to a valve on the purge
stream regulating the flow.
The synthesis loop solves with a production of 1539.6 lb mole/hr of 99.7% purity ammonia. The
product compositions are shown in Table 4. The overall conversion to ammonia is 98% with a
reactor conversion per pass of 27.4% based on Nitrogen. The recycle stream rate is 10654 lb
mole/hr giving a recycle:feed ratio of 3.3:1. The purge stream is 74.1 lbmol/hr which is 0.7% of the
total recycle flowrate.
The results of these simulations have been put into practice in a number of installations and these
have consistently led to improved productivity and higher conversion efficiency.
Graphical Representation:
PG001
CO2
PG000
17 T-1
7
19A
5
WAT
4 6 13 16
SAT
S1 15
CW-1
XS
14 D-1
3 RX-4
RX-2 RX-3 RX-5 18
8 10
RX-1
13X REB1
11
21X
X-1A WHB2 22
1 2
H-1
GASHEATER 21
12
8_R1 CT1
9 10X X-2
RX-6
WHB1 X1-B
20 19
23
CW2
24
Stage 2 - Catalytic Shift and Methanation
PG002 PG003
38B
WA3
31X
29A
27
26 28A
BD1
FDEF X-4
CP-2
CP-1 CP-3 RX-7
38
WA2 SEP1
WA1 36A
25
28 REFC CAL1
S1
34
31P DM2
29 M1
SP1
36
D-2
CTL1
24W
31A 31RA 33
31 37 39
31R CP-4
D-7
37A
DM1
DUM1
DUM2 40
32
32A D-8
D-6
DM4
Stage 4 - Conversion
4 6
S1
3 RX-2 RX-3
8 10
RX-1
X-1A
8_R1
9 10X
WHB1 X1-B
CO2
17 T-1
19A
10 WAT
13 16
SAT
15
CW-1
XS
14 D-1
RX-4 18
RX-5
13X REB1
11
21X
WHB2 22
21
12
CT1
X-2
RX-6
20 19
X-3
23
CW2
24
Stage 2 - Catalytic Shift and Methanation
27
26 28A
CP-2
CP-1 CP-3
WA2 SEP1
WA1
25
28
D-2
24W
Stage 3 - Compression
38B
31X
29A
BD1
FDEF X-4
RX-7
38
36A
28 REFC CAL1
S1
34
31P DM2
29 M1
SP1
36
CTL1
31A 31RA 33
31 37 39
31RB
D-7
DM3 31R CP-4 DM1
37A
DUM1
DUM2 40
32
32A D-8
D-6
DM4
Stage 4 - Conversion
The chart below was taken from the PRO/II output file. This depicts the overall plant mass balance
as calculated by PRO/II:
The chart below was taken from the PRO/II output file. This depicts the summary of RX-7,7, the
ammonia converter.
OPERATING CONDITIONS
INLET OUTLET
----------- -----------
FEED 38B
VAPOR PRODUCT 29A
TEMPERATURE, F 571.29 926.82
PRESSURE, PSIG 4760.0000 4730.0000
REACTION DATA
LB-MOL/HR FRACTION
BASE COMPONENT REACTION CONVERTED CONVERTED(1)
------------------ ----------- ----------- ------------
6 N2 1 787.0843 0.2737
Component Rates
Stream Name NATGAS 5 7 31P 39 40
Description NAT GAS STEAM AIR PURGE LET DWN GAS NH3 PROD
Phase Vapor Vapor Vapor Vapor Vapor Liquid
Temperature F 60.00 950.00 330.00 85.00 79.42 79.42
Pressure PSIG 340.0 334.0 289.0 4660.0 350.0 350.0
Molecular Weight 20.30 18.02 28.96 12.03 14.70 17.02
Component Molar Rates LB-MOL/HR
H2O 3952.74
O2 211.67 0.00 0.00 0.00
CO 0.00 0.00 0.00
CO2 19.43 0.00 0.00 0.00
H2 42.39 21.45 1.69
N2 20.09 786.70 14.39 6.15 0.44
A 9.58 4.97 4.05 0.56
C1 531.97 6.11 7.68 1.92
C2 49.08 0.00 0.00 0.00
C3 21.41 0.00 0.00 0.00
NC4 15.22 0.00 0.00 0.00
NC5 1.58 0.00 0.00 0.00
NH3 6.27 33.28 1535.03
Total LB-MOL/HR 658.79 3952.74 1007.95 74.12 72.61 1539.64
Component Mole Fractions
H2O 1.00
O2 0.21 0.00 0.00 0.00
CO 0.00 0.00 0.00
CO2 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00
H2 0.57 0.30 0.00
N2 0.03 0.78 0.19 0.08 0.00
A 0.01 0.07 0.06 0.00
C1 0.81 0.08 0.11 0.00
C2 0.07 0.00 0.00 0.00
C3 0.03 0.00 0.00 0.00
NC4 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00
NC5 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
NH3 0.08 0.46 1.00