(b) Rockshed tunnel is provided at dangerous gullies crosaing the main roads/railway for protecting the important transportation route against rockfall/slope failure. {c) Retaining wall with net fences on its top is provided along. the dangerous slopes which have important properties and/or transportation routes on or nearby the slopes. Shot-creting works are provided on the slope for not only preventing weathering action but also fixing unstable rocks. Though the appurtenant structures will be required for the definite individual plan in each area, it is considered that the structures explained above are reasonable measures at this stage of study. Besides the matters mentioned above, the following matters are considered for structural plan. (A) Availability of materials Materials usually used in the basin and materials available nearby the site are selected. (8) Easiness of construction Special structures which will have difficulties for construction are avoided. As a conclusion, it is judged that all the structural plans are technically viable. 11-3 Bconomic Evaluation The results of EIRR for structural plan of each divided area are obtained as follows: Group Mean BIRR( i). "AY 6.59 Qda of "1 5.98 Spe of "B" 3.89 As a general, the BIRR of Group "A" is more or less than Group "B", though the EIRR of some areas in Group higher than some areas in Group "A". there is no definite criteria of BIRR for the economic viability, as the conditions of evaluation are different by the country, region, kind of project and etc. However, it is generally said that the disaster prevention project should be viable even in case of comparatively small EIRR such as 2 or 3%. X-11-3Though some areas in Group "8" showed comparatively small EIRR values which are less than 2% or 38, it is considered to be not reasonable to remove these areas from the proposed project. due to the following reasons. fa) (b) te) a The most important and beneficial object is to prevent the traffic blockage of main roads and railway. The project will make full function for this object after all the probable danger areas are protected by the structures, The results of BIRR calculation will be easily changed by the method of assumptions for various conditions such as damage rate of each damageable items, economic development rate in the future and etc. The calculation is made for all the areas by assuming that the construction will start from the fiscal year of 1990 for comparing the results on the same condition. However, it will be actually difficult to start the construction at the same time for all the areas of Groups "A" and "B", If the projects will start later, the EIRR values for these areas will be much higher than the case of earlier start. Most serious damage will be injury and death of human. However, such factor is not counted as a economic loss. It is concluded that the structural plans proposed in areas of Groups "A" and "BY are economically viable as a whole. 11.4 Proposed Structural Plan The structural plans for all the areas in Groups "A" and "B' are to be recommended as the proposed project. ‘the proposed project is summarized in Table X-11-1 where the following items are shown. (a) (b) (c) (a) (e) Name of project areas ‘Type of structural plan (for Qda areas) List of proposed main structures in each area Economic project cost EIRR In addition, the following figures are prepared for brief understanding of proposed project for debris flow and slope failure disaster prevention. (a) Classification of ‘Type of Qda Areas + Fig. -1i-1 x-11-4wy te) ‘The fa) (b) () Proposed Structural Plans for Qda Areas (Schematical Features of 5 types of Structural plan in Quebrada and Proposed Structural Plans for Qda Areas) : Big. X-1-2 Proposed Structures for Spe Areas 1 Fig, X-11-3 reason of project viability is summarized as follows: All the structural plans are technically viable. The economic aspects of structural plans for Group "B" as well as Group "A" are viable as a whole. Social impact will be strong on the safety of human life and the acceleration of regional development. Especially, it is usual to consider the priority on the importance of human life in case of disaster prevention project. X-11-5Tables(2) sesiog + tty kaze guamyoaes 0 ourt 399205 9: Galt # tw eopaoee SUT THSSAE! Jo 90D ee 08 exmaeaey D8) oe! one"? 37309 ° sci 6005, wepunp pt cet’ 00") berm s0' ‘00% cemnzseyon casi 00'9t doen 606" o0E'8 sooy eae ou‘ 005", wrembuess ° oye o00'se coors oe core 000° owen, ogs'z 608: Sarre ce corte seed ose: ooze exes cotta ost ocetet reed oot? oxmnqene) oot!) (erreneseera) sage oes ‘SkemaneD ons" omy 0'3 oowesred Dott ‘c0'8 00's 06's cet 08's ces ¢ a a t 8 daa SB aR 88 13388 ARGS RESRSERRSRERRRERG: 888888 tO = wunnsed soramagse jo omy “OH, & cay t C/) sraee xevuneras dorvm 30 RIMIVEE Waroumya ex oTaELSRRBSRESRRR S8SRR8R88R858 eegsonbey “D ofeysenure) °) a be (c/2) Svaer RWVINETEL YOrH Jo RUMLYEE TaIONTNZ T-e- x OTE, ‘sopreangrn 30 ae on weRS S89 9888 B88R8 RES) Rg ae 288 agaa SRS Geengsn 89 ors6r + sem a ==) 38pg wabeoy : sits aSazeny (©) werasioty aders tazy Seong Tle Ole Ge o we Se ete ca w (en) smmey 201s so panna eto eE~ x TNLgee 88 $8888 8888 ose oor ore 80 03 eds 003 ous f ee 07" 0c 0808 0708 (@) voaea ofors 30 oom & is ES u (2/2) SvREY BeOTS 30 FURIES TWETOMTUE THE x OTEBLTable X-4-1 Galssification of Group A, B or G for Qda Area (1/4) _ We Bistecive Object [Danger] Overall Romans ___| House [Transportation [Public Stusture [Overall Level |(Grovo] = A A 8 c A |B | 8 (cH) (RW) Re % B e xs [6 (cs) ca x c t ALS 6 Ra x 5 c a] 8 | 8 (cH) AB 5 5 5 B [A] 8 [Bisaster (RW.) (club) in March 1987 {MB} Re * 6 € K [AT ®_ [Disaster (CH) lin March 1987 RF x 8 c x | A [A Disaster CH) in March_1987 Fe x 8 € [A] 4_foisaster (cH) in March_ 1987, #S x 3 c a | A | A [Disaster (cH) in March_ 1987, Rio | 8 3 a) a] 8 (RW) (Schoo!) (MB Ait E 8 c Bae (RW. (CH) wise c a es |e R13 c 8 8 6 pay 8. (cH) (Schoo!) (RW) aa | c € (a a Ris [ec B c 8 | A | 8 [Possible secondary (C.H.) disaster due to damm- (RW.) a ling in the main river Rie |e 5 5 B |B |B [Outer of Gdais sot (cH) (Mine) Jctear as a mine is a (RW) located thera m7 [6 3 € BA [8 [Under construction (cH) for relocation of CH. 1 w.) Note; C.H.: Garretora Central (Major National Road) MLR. Main Road RW.: RailwayTable X-4-1 Glassiiication of Group A. 8 or C for Qda Area (2/4) _ No. Protective _ Object Danger|Overall Remarks: House [Transportation [Public Structure [Overalll Level_|(Group) Rie c c B | A | B [dito oor Rid Cc } B A A [Qda runs on tunnel (C.H.-(t)) R.W Station (M.R.) (RW. -(1)2,(b) _L R20 Cc Cc Cc Cc B C {Relocation of C.H. was completed Ret c c c CA of ditto — R22 c c c B +8 ‘C_|ditto— rat Reo a B Cc 8 B B (M.R.~(b)) (R.W.-(b)) 4 R24 B B Cc B B B (M.R.-(b)) (R.W.-(b}) R26 A B B A B B (R.W.-(b)) | (Government Office, School) R26 Cc B Cc Cc R27 c oc TA [Relocation of road is completed and the eee lbridge is high enough | R28 Cc Cc A [New main road crosse: JQda but the bridge is fhigh enough RS c C(B) C © [S| CS |New relocated road is (C-H.-(b)) lunder construction on ithe opposit bank of river R30 B c B Cc c R31 B c B B B [New road is under (C.H.-(b)). I Jconstruction on the (B.W.-(b)) Jopposit bank of. ver | Note; Bridge : Tunnel {c): CulvertTable_X-4-1 Classification of Group A, B or C for Gda Area (3/4) No. Protective Object Bangor} Overali Romarks Tiouse_| Transportation | Public Structure [OveralllLevel_|(Grou Rae a B B A | A | A [Possibiity of dammin Matucanal (CH) (Government in the main river is Otice, School) high. Ras € B 3 > 8 | 8 ) (Mino) Raa c € B [| 8 | 8 |Possibiity of damming in the main river is high R35 5 8 3s | 8 | 6 Station) R36 c c Bol ¢ Ra7 c (By B | 8 | 8 [Railway crosses on (R.W.-(c)) | Intake of Electro} Jembankment with Lima) loulvert channel for JQda, Spoil bank at the confluence, RaE € 5 c By oy} ¢ (C,H) R39 ¢ 8 8 B | CS | © |Mine facilities at the (C.H.-(c)) (Mine) outlet of Qda. Run-off through culvert Rao. Cc € c c Rat B 8 B B (C.H.) (Schoo!) (B.W.-(c)) Raz 5 (B) c B | © | C [Large scale spot bank (C.H.) Jat Qda Outlot. Run-off through culvert Rag cy 5 c 8 c (ditto = 4{C.H.) 7 Raa € B B B | C | ©” [Railway crosses on (R.W.-(c)) | (Substation) Jembankment with lculvert_channe! Ras x B c A, of] ¢ (M.W.). Ras c B € c¢yctT<¢ (C.H.) (R.W.) Ray c c ¢ cj ets Rae c 8 c B | Cc | C” [Railway crosses on (R.W.-(c)) Jembankment with lculvert_ channelTable X-A-1 Classification of Group A, B or © for Qda Area (4/4) Te, Protective Object Banger|Overall Remarks Transportation | Public Structure [Overaill evel, |(@roup, a si B 8 A | A | A [Disaster (MR) (Schooi, etc.) in March 19867 Se 5 B B Bp AB (MR) (Schoo!) c B as 6 (MR) € c € ose B 8 c 3B | 8 | 8 (MR) c c c cee c 8 c By oc jc MR) c 8 8 spoT ec (MB) (intake) c B B | cy ¢ | (MR) c c G oes c c ¢ [~~] c~ |iain road corsses the - lway of Oda Sie | t c c Ce fe ato - S13| CG c c Ce ST S14 | C cc c [oA S-15_[_C ¢ ¢ Cee aitto S-16 | C c c [a ET S-17 |G Cc a Ce" GF ito = S18] _C c ¢c cfc fC ito - $19 | C C ¢ [6 fe Fito $20 | c ¢ Ce [cE aitto = ‘S-2t ¢ B ¢ B [Cc | C~ [Lagoons inthe (MA=(b)) upstream area S-22 oT c 8 8 c eT ditto - Le (Power Station) S25, € C C c Ce] 6 ato = s-24 | B c Bf c | c | dito (M.R.-(b) S25 |e 5 € a a a (M.B.) ‘S226 c a c c cS CK ditto = ‘S87 € 8 c 8 c calito = (MR)Table X-4-2 Classification of Group A, B or C for Spe Area (1/2) _ Proteciive Objects. Danger [Overall Transportation | Overali_|' Level | (Group). : R(-/0) RCA R(O/2) RAS) R(2/4) (3/5) (476) B(S/10 (6/7. (7/8) R(B/9) R(9/-) A(ios-y RC (42) R(i1/13) RG2/14) R(13/16) R(14/15) | CROS/22) R(16/17) R(18/19) R(49/20) (20/21) R(21/23) R(22/27) (26/29) LH eae oe ee L lojololojalajojelajolo}a}a}a|.|0|>|a|alojolo}>|>|>|>| loe}a}alo|o}o}afo|aja|ajolojm|o|a|a|a|a}o|0|0\0}alolajalolalololm|ola|a|o|ajojojojalalatc R(27/28) (33/38) R(34/36) R(35/37). R(36/38. (38/39) (39/44) (40/44) (41/42) R(42/43) R(43/46. R(44/45) CR(45/47). jal alololm|m\o|o|elesola|olalala}e|co|clc|m|a|ao|alo|ojalo|a}a|a|ele|m|>|a\a]>loJo]>|>|>|>} lalofofojofojelolafojolofo}a|a}olo}e}a|a}a|a|0}a}a}.} lololololalolololalojolojajelelolololo|a|a|a|alolajolo|alo|a|ala|o|a|a|\a\o|o|a/olo}a|alx}s5 DJOlo}o|m|2]o]a]a)\olololo[o|a]o/o}olo}Table X-4-2 A, Bor C for Spo Area (2/2) Llassitication of Gro No. Protective Objects Bangor : “Transportation | Overall_|_Level ‘Gverali (Group) SCAY SC/4) jojo S(4/2) iit ESEZEN S(3/5) t | co} oo] [_S(4/6) Sl) S(6/8) tr S (7/40) folo}ajo|= || olc} S(9/12) S(10741) S113) rsa2ns S(18/14) s(r4/te) SOSA S(16/18) lalolola|alalojalolalojolo|a| S(17/20) H 4 S(18/19) S(19/22) S$ (20/21) lolajo} 4 S(31/24) it S (22/23) 'S(23/26) 'S(24/25) 'S(25/27) ‘cfalolafajolo}ajajololalojololojelolololo|ele|=|ajai lolololala lolelolo|alolojale|ojajojo|alajalolalo|alola}mla|a|| PRR Pere rert olojojojololalollojelolojololajo}eBeiped ep ul Zuy 1 sod ewnion ysodeg :, 4 x ZL x .008'rL )s210N | coeres o0r'6s 006861 vo orez veniged PPD oos'sz oor‘ort o02'z6z ro aie 0003 034 200) oos'ez oot'vel ooz's9z ‘ o00'zo4. sh ‘oenteyse9 &P0| ose oor'et o0e'rz, b ooztiz a ‘S07Bu00 BPD} oz cos'e ots ‘ oor'y ro ojsore9 ep vest 0016, ooz'gel t ooz‘zst gol reGaiped 2pO| oos‘at oor'z6 ooz'rat b wok oun Pd] TEmyRTS Ew) ere0s Tea) areas TY Hoey Ena BON wiersioys(s)| wero (>) juuer-6u07_(¢) |__vowonpeys A queuiysre9 (1)| eo} euRN, ‘aUnIDA WOE ysodeq (e101 (2) edly tps ised eum ieaastteliresy tek ceerpnu st A0€ PUP sTxGep ey sFs0dep Zo ROL 3EUR ReuNSse sy AF 720K, SLUTS suoszed 09t suossed o0e“z suoszed 01'S pepunon, suoszed t suosied 6 suoszed $f uaeeG ‘smemep weary eB 08'S em once 00's peut . g 006/2T el 00L 8S, et 00e ‘62t step Jo TescusE SHTOR VOT SENT TSNTOE Asp sro skep z shep e TET Aeuxoaey, Aenzoaey Kenzeqey (euyt 03091) 72030 a (eq cro) sed T (FU L'0) aoRTa T xed - - > Tree 7 = 7 PTE & oot woe EH & 008 ad woz woe“ = 905 © (exeqazep Teza¥00) peow SerTTISET ‘TSRAUIOMTTE OT TANS = e 5 put aseareq x008 ey so eT eT puey a8eaze4 Pood puey Urey 7 son t #993330 ‘A09 sox t $993570"A00 sx0820 7 On T son T reowss 2 7 7 sexe DUPE THRE TTTaTE oy of st | se ort | oe oe ost {os fone. reser of or oz 08 oz oor 06 oe ost seeto ronot at s s oF or oz 06 oz oF SseTD oTPeTH ° ° ° seer sedda (Cosy. etoH pasozssep | pexorasep | pakoz3e2p| pexoz3s0p| posozasep] pasozasep| pedoz3sap| pesozas9p| pekoz38ep| Arterazea | -sues | Atreaox | Arrerazea] tues | Atteaoe | Atresazea| -rwes | Atresou, = wea w193-a20u8 uz0a-PTH. ux09-6u07 Asprrquqoxa OTEIOD YOO NI ALIZNWAD gOWWa ¢-S-K BTaME“paw sy oe pue sTxGep SF arsodep zo ¥oL IeUa poUMesE sz ar iea0N PERE OTT suoszod 002, susexed 001% suoszed 008°L popunou ‘uoszed suoszed $2 suoszed 59 ware ‘SoRURE TEE 22 009s 002/82 et 908'96 pe 22 002’ET 8 005'59 em 00U'TET eTaqep 30 Teaowny LOR WOPIETTT FORTE ep 5-0 skep € shep OTT Z Benzosen, Aenzozey, (wey 0220973) sau20 = (eu Z'0) Sorte T (eu 270) aoeTd T weg Z 7 ~ Tre8M OT “oN son T 6p Ese © 00€ 008'T “uH & o9e'2 cea 08 #008 HO w0o2'E — (pxexaze9 Tex2020) peoe “wD SorTEET, PSSINIONATE OTIS 7 : - puet soarey x00 7 = : buet soared poss PORT, a sz0u20 “ont ron € von ¢ oouas : = 7 aexzen BUPOTERE FTES oe} or fs cet f sh ee soe | se | see Tern, oz s € ort sz oat sor oF sei SseTO ZeK0T ot s z cr oz ott sot se ost sse7o CTP TE ° 3 ° @ ° 8 oe ° ° sseto sedan Con): BSH pefoaasep | pefozasep | pefozasep| pefoxsep| pefoxasap| pefoxasep| pefoxasep| pefoxssep| vefoassep Srreyazea |" ~tues | Arreaos | Atrerazea] ~rwes | Arresoa | Atrerazeal rues | Atrez0 er erees Treas ures-Pm uz03-Buer Aayrygegozs Twoguaza YOO NI ASTENWIO SOWIWG ¢-S-K STEVErpmu st goe pue ST2q9p ST 2FE0dep Jo eoL TUT pauNssY sy ar 1030 ‘SoemEp TOT suoszed 0 suoszed 06 suoszed oe pepuaon, uoszed 9 suoezod 0 suoszed z aged ‘SeeUEp TEU, eH 002 2 oot’t e 0012 pow “ eu 005 eu o0s‘e £5 0005, staqep go TeAowsH SRTORWOTTETTT TORUS, Hep 2°0 ep 1 skep z OTT . 7 - 930 - : : zee c = ci Trem : . 5 ‘efpyaE woz “HD 00% "HD wosz —(eeReze9 TexRUED) peow “ED, SOraTTIES ‘PeSROIONTIS OTTO - - 7 pueT qseazey 2008 im 2 : BURT Jsenzey Pood poe Urey - - - 830430 - - son T yoouDs 7 - - exreH Doerr a ee se_| sf os oF | ot oe qeren, g z ° oz s of oz § os sseT0 zoN0T s 6 ° St ° oe oe § oe | ‘S8eT OTRDTH ‘sseyo s8ddn a K (Cox) SECO peiozasep | pafozasep | pexozasep| pesoxasep| pexoxasap| vefozasep| refozasep| pefox2sep| pefoz3sep Aqreyazea | -twos | Atreaos [Atterazea] tues | Arteaog |Atrevaxea| -tues | Atrezo, WSIT wx93-320u5 e103-PTH wz03-6407 Aayrrgeaoze OrSO¥D Wad RE ALILNEND aM p-S-x aTEKEspas} 30¢ pue stzqep st aTsod=p zo goL 2EYR POMNSSe ST ar :870N SORE TAT suosz08 og euoczed 910" suoszed 081 ‘t pepunoy suoazes 9 sooszed 2 suoszed 5 ‘yaeed ‘SBEUER CET ett 008 oot e 0084 pu ee 000r ea 0088 eH 00% "UT staqep 30 Teaowey SATO UOT TET TESS Aap 20 skep Shep c OT Sse, a z z 29420 = : = wae - - a Trou = 7 - pe oz oR wos ew & coe wk Of “ED woo RD 00S (exeaeze9 Te=aU89) peod “HD SSrTTTS PSSROENTTE SITS x - - puet asearey) 3008 - eu $0 ey sto PUET aseazey Pood ‘pUET UTE a x 7 sx0u20 - ° ° oouss - - - 307M ‘PUPPY OFTEN et o¢ yj 06 sz} ss | op | ot og Teor $ € ° st $ = w $ ve sseto zeao1 é 6 ° ot 0 st 92 8 oz sseT> OTPET sseto zedsn + Con) SEroH petozasep | pefozasep | pefozasep| pexozasep| paxozasep| pefozasep| pesozasep| paxoxasep| pefozasop| Arerszeg | -tHes Arreros | strerazea} -twes | Atteson | Atrerazea| -rues | Arteaoy, Terr wre? sous 163-07 wres-svot Aaprraeqoza SaTeRoo va NI ALTINYND SOwWA $-s-x STEMspots} Qe PUR sTIGeP ST a;s0dep Jo 404 2eU2 poURSSe ST aT 19308 (sorse3s “uggeTsdearren) fpeaepunay oq THM eseH eusoE “fn PeuED oF 3o07eR SUPT TTS pee euo. |_9o |_z [SO a0: 0 Jo | Te30%, ° ° ° z ° ° ° ° z seer xon0T sserp OTDPEH ssero eden Con) Bet patozasep | pokoxasep | pekoxasep| paXozasep| pexo22sep| pefozasop| pafoz3sap| poser asap] poiozzsep| sryerazea |" yeog | Arteaos | Atvevazea| -rvas_| Atreaon | Atverazea| eos | Aetez0n, aT urea-az00s wax02-PTW wxa2-6u0T Aayreaeqoza cogs Org Wad NI ALIENEND sowIa 9-$-x sTEWEspnu st 40¢ pue eTaqeP ¢F azsedop Zo 40L sua POMNECE oF aE _toR0N soe woszed 9 ssoezed 90t evoezed 902 pepuney woezed 9 oozed 9 voszed waeed seems Ce 2 000°9 2 008°62 oH 004 ‘6s pm 8 006Et e 009"69 e002 6et stagep 30 Tehowse SRW WOT TETTTCETSE, fee so sae z skep POOLS TEEE 7 - 4 00e't owe 70420 7 7 (ee 2-0) sete T wae : > > rreH, 7 7 = sere : 7 uw oge’t © (exeseze9 Te29H89) peey “09 OTITIS # son titeag eatery _ con Ti woanu a COR 1 #997350"03 #29030 : oN t eouss : 7 7 3e1eK BOTET TESTES ojo ° oct | oy te zz | 09 | oe qeren ° © ° 09 oz st cor oe oz sero s0Ko7 ° ° 6 oL oz $ cet oe ot se0t> sTPPHH seeys tedan Con) SRtCH pokoszeep | poscazsop | paxozasep| paiozasep| pafoz3eep| pefoz3ee9| poxoz3s90| pefozasep| pesoxaeep Kerevazea |" "sues | "ktresor [Atrevazea| -vwos | Atreses | Atrevssea| rae” | Atteaes, al uxoa-az0us Exe2-0TH ure3-B10y Aastrgegoza woureé WOD NT ASIENWOD sow L-9-x STEWE‘pmurss aoe pue syxG9P SF aFSodep Fo. goL_3eUa PEUNSSE ST 37 iea0n SRCUES STIS suoezed 0g suoexed 016 svoez0d 029't pepunon uoszed 9 voszed 0 voszad wed ‘soemeg Tenn, e# 0008 8 082/09 e 008/08 pry em 008 '8T et 006 ‘86 et 00L'4L8T sTIqep JO Teacway “SAOEVOTTETTTYIETSE ep $0 wept shep € OO STTIERE nou ppsn 9g you 30g SOTSTTHDEZ GaTD ou30 - 7 - weed = - : TH 7 e 7 sbprza Boor “8 4 00S'T SH 008/t new : - u 00S (exeaaxeD yexaU09) peow are) SOTTTTTOET TESINFONIGT OT TIS z - - puer iSaareq 008 wy so ee One ey ore puet asanreq Pood pUrT es 7 - - sx0m0 : : (eq L*0 tpun0x6 Seta) “ON T yoouDS 7 : = axon BUPPT TM STON EEE Eee EEE eee os | | ot op | ott ‘rea0n, $ z ° og 5 $ oe s s sseqo zener 8 o ° oz $ os 5 or seer sTpOGT seero sedan (Con) SSO paxozasep | patoxseop | pafox3sep| pexoz3se| pafoz3s0p| pexox3sep| pekoz3sep| pesozasep| pafozasep Arrevazea |" twas | “Arrezou |Arrerasea| | —rwes | “Arveson | Atrerazea|” -twos | Arteaos wesT 703-3704 urea-pEN wx09-6u07 1 sarrrqegora WEOUNHWHSWD WOO NI ALTUNYNO GOWWG —@-S-x STEWSTABLE X-5-9 DAMAGE AMOUNTIN GDA GUIIO nit Goat Long-Term Mid-Term Short-Term hem, (106 tots) (106 tntis) (106 Jats) (106 Ins) TD 80, POTD. SD. PDL TO. SD. PD, House Upper class 2.45/n0. o fo} o jfofolo)|o Middia class 0.70/n0. 12.60] 12.60] 3,50) 4.20] 2.80 | 1.75 1.40 Lower class 0.19/n0. 2.34 11.70] 1.30] 2.08] 2.08 | 0.65 | 0.78 ‘Sub-total Et 9.46 2. Public Building Market 1s.76/n0. ° ° ° ‘Schoo! 2.50/n0. 25 2.5 ° Government offos |9.50/n0. 3.5 a8 ° ‘Sub-total 8.0 8.0 ° 3. Farm Land. “Good harvest o.03/na 0.03 Poor harvest o.0t/na ° Sub-total Public_Suuctures Paved road Jo.ooarma 18.0 0.72 Nonpaved oad |0.0001/m2 0.40 0.05 Main bridge o.008/m2. ° 0 Common bridge |o.003/m2 ° Park o.o00s/me 0 Others (watenvay) |LS. 5 Sub-total 27 Rehabilitation Works! Romoval of debris ]0.00020/m3 25.86 12.94 2.58 Removal of mud |0.00007/n3 3.88 1:94 0.38 Sub-total 29.74 14:88 2.98 6. Other Direct Damage |10% of (1-5) 42.75 22 1.37 7. Total of Diroct__| 140.23 15.08 Damage 8. Tratfle Block lasveay 75.0 50.0 125 ©. Qthor Indizoet 10% of 7 14,02 7.95 1.51 Damage | 10. Total of inditoct 99.02 57.92 14.01 Damage Total 229.25 197.41 29.09 Noto: (1) T.D.; Totally destroyed, S.0.; Somi-dostroyed, P.D.; Partially destroyed. (2) {and 2 Include the indoor movablos. (8) Specific quantities of 4 aro estimated for ‘each item though not shown.‘TABLE X-5-10 DAMAGE AMOUNT IN QDA PEDREGAL oat ot targe-Term Wis-Torm [Shar tam $06. Int {G8 ns) (300 i (106 ins) BS, FO] TD, 80, FOL TO. SD. PO, House Uppers ——Je.asine. | 0 | 0 | 147] 0 o | o| o Mddociass —Jo.7omne. | 119.21 12.25] 14.70] 69.90 142] 1.75] 1.40 toworeass fartaine, | 22.04] _'2.00] 4:29] 14.04 22 | 0152 Subst 176.38 #2 Publ Bulag, Marat 3.701n0. ° School 2's0!no. Ts Governmontoffeo |2:50/n0. 6 Subrotal zs Farm Land ood o.09/ma ° ° ° Poor harvest |0.08/ha ° ° ° Subsctal 8 3 o Public Sructures Paved cad o.o0a7me 49.2 20.8 1.08 Nompaved road |0.00017m2 15 0.75 os Maia biage — [0.008/m2 ° 3 ° Common edge }0:009/m2 0.15 0.18 0.15 Par o:o005/m2 10 10 ° Others (waternay) [LS. 20 to 02 Subvotal 47s a7 1.58 habitation Works| Removal of abi ]0,00020/ma 20.98 19.19 2.64 Removal otmud |0,00007/m3 2.98, 197 O39 Subtotal 30.3 155 2.08 . Other Dect Damage |10% of (1-5) 26.47 15.9 4.28 Total of Dect 174.97 19.78 “Damage | Tate Blk __f2sreay 150 75 13.5 omer indirect _|100% of 7 20,70 17.49 1.98 Damage Total of tdiroct, 170.78 92.49 13.48 Damage Tota 466.61 267.96 27.86 Note: (1) T.0.; Totally destroyed, $.0.; Somi-dastroyed, 2.0. Partially destroyed. (2) {and 2 include the Indoor movables. @) Specific quantities of 4 ato ostimated for ‘ach item though not shown,‘TABLEX:5-11 DAMAGE AMOUNT IN GDA CAROSIO. Jian Cost Targo-forn waeTorm SRon Tarn hom, (106 avis) | {106 ini) (108 tots) (106 tots) Th 80. FTTH, SD POP TO. SO. PD 1. House ‘Upper dass 2. asic. o | o | o o|o Nidaio class o.70/n0. 18.90] 1.75] 2. 0 | 0.70 Lower class 0.13/n0. 5.85] 0.32] 0, 0.13| 0.13 ‘Sub-total 30:14 9:96 2. Public Building Market 3.76/n0. ° 0 ° ‘School 2.50/00. 2.5 0 ° Government ottica |3.0/n0. ° 0 ° Sub-total 2.5 9 0 Farm Land, ‘Good harvest lo.os/na ° ° ° Poor harvest loco1sha 0 ° ° Sub-total 9. 8 0 4. Public: Stuctures Paved road lo.003/m2 9.0 0.72 Non-paved road |0.0001/m2. 0 ° Main bridge jo. 008/m2 0 ° Common bridge f0.009/m2 9 ° Others Ls. 0 0 ‘Subtotal 9.0 2 5. Rehabilitation Wor Removal of dabris |0,00020/m3 0.50 0.10 Famoval of mud |0.00007/m3 0.07 o.0t Sub-total 0.87, ott, 6. Other Direct Damage |10% of (1-5) 4.28 2.68 0.18 7. Total of Diroct 47.07 20.8 1.97 Damage Trattic Block. lesiaay 50 25 5.0 8. Other Indirect 100% of 7 474 2.95 0.20 Barmago _| 10. Total of indirect S474 5.2 Damage Total 101.78 57.45 717 Note: (1) 7.0, Totally destroyed, .- P.D.; Partially dostroyod. (2) 1 and 2 Include the indoor movablos. (®) Specific quantitios of 4 aro ostimated for ‘each item though net shown, Somi-dostroyed,‘TABLE X-5-12, DAMAGE AMOUNT IN GDA CORRALES unit Goer Tong-Torna tad-Torm Short-Term tem, (106 _Intis (198 nts) (108 ints) (108 tes) Tsp. Pb] 10, SO, POTD. SO PD Upper clase 2.48/n0. o | o o {oo} o Jo f ojo] o Micoto class 0.707n0. 12.60 1.75 2.80] 9.48] 0 | 1.40] 0 | 0 | o.ae Lowor class 0.13/n0. 3.51] 0.32 0.52 1.76] 0.92] 9.99] 0 | 0.20] 0.33 Sub-total 21,50 13,32 9.75 2. Public Building Market [a.76/no. ° ° 0 ‘Schoo! 2.50/no. o 0 0 Govarnment office |3.50/n0. ° ° ° Sub-total 8 a. oO 3. farm Land. “Good harvest lo.o3/na 0.02 ° Poor harvest lo.ot/na ° ° Sub-total 0.02 9. Public Structures Paved road lo,cos/me 7.2 1.08 Nonpaved road [0.0001/m2 0.02 0.01 Main bridgo Jo.008/m2 0 0 Comnion bridge —_fo.o0s/me ° 0 Others Ls. ° 0 Subsiotal 1.22 4.09 5. Bichabiltation Works| Flamoval of debris |0.00020/m3 9.48 1.74 0.34 Removalof mud |0.00007/m3 0.82 0.26 0.06 Sub-total 4.00 2.00 9.40 6. _Qthor Direct Damage |10% of (1-5) 4.97 2.26 0.22 7. otal of Direct 38.04 24.82 2.48 Damage. 8, Trattle_ Block lesvday 75 50 5.0 8. Othor indirect 100% of 7 4.80 2.48 0.25 Damage. 10, Total of Indirect 79.80 52.48 5.25 Demege____t Total 127.84 77.30 204 Note: (1) T.D.; Totally dostroyed, 8.0.; Semi-destroyed, @ @) P.D.; Partially destroyed. {Land 2 Include the Indoor movablos. Specific quantities of 4 are estimated for ‘each item though nat shown,TABLEX-5:13. DAMAGE AMOUNT IN QDA RIO SECO junit Gost Tong-Term idem ‘Shon Term tom. (408 _Intis (106 tls) (106 tnts) {808 lati) TS, 80, PB] FD, 8, SD. PD. House. ‘Upper class 2.45/n0, ° ° o }o} o Jo of} o Middle class o.70/n0, 0 ° o | o}o | o oo Lower class o.13/n0. 0.29] 0 o | o | o | og of o Sub-total 0.29, 2. Public Building Market 3.76/n0. ° ° ° Schoo! 2-80/no. 0 0 9 Government oifico |3.50/no, ° ° ° Sub-total ° ° 2 3. Farm Land ‘Good harvest lo.oa/ha 0.87 0.42 0.24 Poor harvest jo.otyha 0.08 0.02 0.02 Sub-total 0.65 44 0.26, Public: Structures. Paved road Jo.003/m2 24.0 12.0 1.20 Non-paved road |o.0001/m2 0.08 0.05 0.02 Main bridge. lo.o08/m2, 0 0 0 Common bridge |0.003/m2 0.09 0.08 0.08 ‘Others (Tunney {LS 3.0 2.0 4.0 Sub-total 27.47 14.44 2.31 5. Rehabilitation works| ‘Removal of dabris}0.00020/m3. 40.98 20.49 Removal of mud |0.00007/m3 8.15 3.08 Sub-total 74a 23.57, 6. Other Direct Damage 110% of (1-5)] 1.82 7. Tcralot Duet | a2 12.02 Damage} 8. rattle Block. 2siday 125 50 42.5 8 Other tnglrect 100% of 7 2.27 4.20 0.60 Damage | 10, Total of tnsiract 139.27, 54.20 13.30 Damage Total 218.97 96.22 21.92 Note: (1) T.D.; Totaly destroyed, $.0.; Somi-destroyed, e) 8) PD. Partially destroyed. 11and 2 include the indoor movables. ‘Specific quantities of 4 ar siimated for ‘each item though not shown,‘TABLE X-5:14 DAMAGE AMOUNT IN QDA PAIUA. Unit Cost Tong-Tara Wider Shoit-Torm tem (108 _Intis) (406 lati) (498 Ils) (308 tats) TD, Sb, PD] TD, $0, FOL TD. 60. FD, 1. House Uppor class 2.48/n0. ° of of o of of of of Middle class 0.70/n0. 6.30] 10.50} 16.80] 3.15) 7.00 9.80) 0 | | Lower class 0.13/n0. 2.34] 1105] 2.60) 1.76] 1.90] 1.56] 0] | Sub-total 40.49 24.87, o 2. Public Building Market 3.76/n0. ° ° ‘Schoo! 2.50/no, 5.00 ° Government office {3:50/no. 7.00 ° Sub-total 12.00, 0 98. Farm Land ‘Good harvast lo.03/ha ° ° 0 Poor harvest lo.otvha ° ° 0 Sub-total ©. o. 9. . Public: Structures Paved road }o.003/m2 31.20 ° o Non-paved read |0.0008/m2 0 ° 0 Main bridge lo.008/m2 0 0 0 Common bridge [0.008/m2 0 0 0 Park lo.0008/m2. 10 0 ° Othors (Raiay) |LS. 5.0 0 0 Sub-total 372 8 2 5. Rohabiltation Works Romovai of debris ]0,00020/m3 27.88 13.92 2.78 Removatot mud {0.00007/ma. ane 2.09, 0.42 Sub-total 32.03 18.01 20, 6, Other Direct Damage |10% of (1-5) 42.47 5.26 0.32 7 Total of Direct 133.87 57.84 3.52 Damage 8. rattle Block 25/day 75 50 12.5 8 _Othor Indiract 100% of 7 13.99 5.78 0.85 Damage 10, Total of insirect 38.39 55.78 12.85 Damage Total 222.28 118.62 16.87 Note: (1) T.D.; Totally destroyed, $.0.; Seml-destroyed, P.D.; Panlally destroyed, (2) and 2 Include the Indoor movables. (8) Specific quantities of 4 are estimated for ‘each item though not shown.‘TABLE X545 DAMAGE AMOUNT INQDACASHAHUACRA 7 [Cat Cot TaAg-Tenmn [Me terar Short-Term Hom {(106 latte) {18 Ins) (108 Inti 106 tes) TD, Sb. PD] TO SO PDP ID. SD 1. House Upper Gass 12.45/n0. o of} of o of of of a o Middle claes 0.70!n0. 6.aq 1.78| 7.00 3.20 0 | 2.80) of} of 0 Lower clase 0.19/00. 0.58] 0.32] 0.78] 0.58] 0.82] 0.78) 0 | 0.13] 0.13] Sub-total 18.73 7.88, 0.26 2. Public Building Market 3.76/n0. ° ° ° Schoo! 2.500. 2.50 0 ° Governmont offco |3.60/n0. 0 6 ° Sub-total 2.50 0. ° 3. Farm Land, ‘Good harvest 0.03/na oat 0.06 0.02 Poor harvest o.01/ha 0 0 0 Sub-total 0.24 0.06 9.02 4. Public Structures. Paved road lo. 003/m2 10.50 ° 0 Nonpavod road |0.0001/m2 0.78 0.75 0.05 ‘Main bridge o.coa/ma 0 0 0 Commen bridge |0.003/m2. ° ° 0 Others Ls. 0 ° 0 ‘Sub-total 11.25 0.75, 0.08 5, Rehabilitation Works Fiemoval of dabris ]0.00020/m3. 37.54 18.77 3.76 Removal ot mud |0.00007/m3 5.64 2.82 0.86 ‘Sub-total 43.18 21.59 4.32 6, Other Direct Damage [10% of (1-5) 7.39 0.46 7, Total of Direct 126 33.09 52 Danage 8. Trae Block 2Siday 18 25 1.25. 9, Other Indirect oom of 7 313 3.31 0.51 “Banage__| 10, Total of Indirect 15.63 5.01 1.78 Damage ___ Total 96.89 38.90 6.88 Nowe: (1) T.D.; Totally destioyed, 8.D.; Semi-dostroyed, P.D.; Panlally dostroyed, 2) 1.and 2 include the indoor movables. 8) Specitic quantiles of 4 are estimated for ‘ach item though not shown.Ox sro x 1 ix 2-1 x 009s x © 930t Joos ‘og. jooz’ ToT. j9"0 Is" ‘BUnoMT *O} ss loos-z> Jooz “se je-0 i-3 orrnaerut-o| fs ooo-s8 Joos-rer je-0 ze speoped -0) zs os ze2 looo-va» le-o J>-oer sera “O) Lek porte oozbe feo le-o7 essa ‘3] S88 ot-ezt looz-s¢e eo fee evoued “o] ree looser oosze p-0 les oxeauvoram -0] cee Joos “eet pozusz Po fe-ve ofeenong> “O| tee loor-ez joos“9¢ p-0 s-9 ee loos-2 joot-sor Fo le-re esesen “3 bce loos ‘sz looe“es 0 lee sxoens “of eau loos ‘vs joouéor |s-0 le-or onea toa “3| Te joos “ts jooo ‘est jg-o je7st epetes =nby 5) ote looe“er looss6 je-0 je-s ‘oqesenp “ol 9Te loor“etr looe“ees lr-0 lo-err erreoewouey ora -O| Sr lcor ‘se looz~zer je-c e-6 swrdeo -8] ene Jooo's6 looe-tez je-o ser wee sass “| Rt loos “6c looe“est r be weao or 3] te loozeet oors5z I jo-st wanaueo er -3] st loos ‘or ou ‘ze t + eyseK e5099 “3) oF loos “Fe ooz“ert It re srereprre -o] loou't looses It fa esessoe “3, 2 x loooze ooo“ser I: le-6 cfeserseg 3] TE jexea-s70uS (5, Gres-PIN (S)| Sxea-bUeT Is) (ay soaseF | Tzu) Sony | ‘wors00po “Seomoxea| SERS SHORT BOE TT | (e +. 008 JO SYREN YOO NI DiNTOA SISOSEG WAUSYSIO T-S-x STEETable X- Name of Qda 6-2 Ratioof Damage Amount in Each Seale of Group "AY Long-term scale Mid-term scale Short-term scale Amount: Amount Ratio Amount — Ratio Ratio Quirio 229 1 137 0.60 29 0.13 Pedregal 467 1 267 0.57 28 0.06 Carosio 102 1 87 0.56 7 0.07 Corrales 128 1 7 0.60 8 0.06 Rio Seco 216 1 96 0.44 21 0.10 Paihua 222 1 114 0.51 16 0.07 Cashahuacra a7 1 39 0.40 1 0.07 Mean - 1 - 0.52 - 0.08 Note + unit of amount is x 106 Intiscoc on ee ‘Table X-6-3 DAMAGE ON HOUSES (C1) oeevexren pene ene D No. Reduction Class Damage on Houses er eee eee eee of Houses Factor (F) of Houses LD Chaclacayo (RL) 100-200 a High 367.5 x 106 Chacrasana (R2) 20-30 1 Low 3.25 x 108 california (R3) 50-100 1 High 183.75 x 106 Santa Maria (Rd) 30-50 1 Low 5.2 x 108 ha Cantuta (RS) 20-40 1 High 73.5 x 106 a Ronda (R10) 100-200 2 Middle 105.0 x 106 Santa Ana (R11) S15 0.8 Low 1.04 x 106 Cupiche (R13) 15-20 0.8 Low 1.78 x 106 Rio Canchacalla (R15) ° 0.4 - ° Guayabo (R16) 1-3, 0.8 Low 0.21 x 106 Agua Salada (R17) ° 0.6 - 0 Del Pate (R18) 1 0.6 Low 0.07 x 108 Huacre (R23) 2-3 0.4 Miadie 0.70 x 106 Matata (R24) 10-15 0.4 Middle 3.50 x 106 Cuchimachay (R25) 100-150 0.4 Middle 35.0 x 108 Chucumayo (R31) 20-30 0.4 Middle 4.20 x 106 Chacahuacra (R33) 10-15 0.4 Low 0.65 x 106 Pancha (R34) 3-2 0.2 Low 0.04 x 106 Viso (R35) 20 0.2 Middle 1.40 x 106 Parac (R37) ° 0.2 - Redonda (32) 20-20 0.8 Miadie 8.40 x 106 Infiernille ($3) S10 0.8 Miaaie 4.21 x 106 Lucuma (85) 5-10 0.6 Middle 3.16 x 106 Note : (1) Unit Cost of house High Miaale LowTable X-6-4 DAMAGE AMOUNT FOR DEPOSTT REMOVAL (C2) Estimated Necessary Damage on Houses Name and No. of Qda Deposit ratio of nA Volume (m3) removal. Q. Chaclacayo (R1) 174 x 103 High 27,36 x 106 Q. Chacrasana (R2) 83.5 x 103 High 13.36 x 106 Q. California (R3) 149.2 x 103 High 23.87 x 106 Q. Santa Maria (R4) 81.7 x 103 High 13.07 x 106 Q. La Cantuta (R5) 266.4 x 103 High 42.62 x 106 Q. ba Ronda (R10) 159.8 x 103 High 25.57 x 106 Q. Santa Ana (R11) 191.8 x 103 High 30.69 x 106 Q. Cupiche (R13) 132.2 x 103 High 21.15 x 106 Q. Rio Canchacalla (R15) 838.3 x 109 Low 26.83 x 106 Q. Guayabo (R16) 96.6 x 109 High 15.46 x 106 Q. Agua Salada (R17) 163.0 x 103 High 26.08 x 106 Q. Del Pate (R18) 109.7 x 103 High 17.55 x 10° Q. Huacre (R23) 53.3 x 103 High 8.53 x 106 Q. Matata (R24) 105.2 x 103 High 16.82 x 108 Q. Cuchimachay (R25) 46.9 x 103 High 7.50 x 106 Q. Chucumayo (R31) 247.2 x 103 High 39.55 x 106 Q. Chacahuacra (R33) 37.6 x 109 High 6.02 x 106 Q. Pancha (R34) 246.2 x 103 Low 7.88 x 106 Q. Viso (R35) 74.2 x 103 Middle 5.94 x 106 Q. Parac (R37) 464.0 x 103 Low 14.85 x 106 Q. Redonda ($2) a7. x 103 nigh 27.50 x 106 Q. Infiernillo ($3) 98.2 x 103 High 15,23 x 106 Q. Lucuma ($5) 101.2 x 103 High 16.19 x 106 Note : (1) Unit Cost of deposit removal works;1./ 160 per m9 (2) Necessary ratio of removal (a) High : 1.0 (b) Middle: 0.5 (ce) Low 2 0.2‘Table X-6-5 DAMAGE DUS 10 TRAFFIC BEOCK (C3) o. oO. Q. a. a a. a Q. Qo. a Q. o. Q. a a QO. Q. Days of Damage Cost Damage on Name and No. of Qda traffic Blcok Per day (I./) Traffic (I./) Chaclacayo (R1) 4 25. x 106 100 x 106 Chacrasana (R2) 3 25. x 106 75 x 106 California (R3) 4 1.0, x 106 4 x 106 Santa Maria (R4) 3 25. x 106 75 x 106 La Cantuta (R5) 5 1.0. x 106 5 x 106 La Ronda (R10) 4 1,0. x 106 4 x 106 Santa Ana (R11) Ss 25. x 106 125 x 106 Cupiche (R13) 4 25. x 106 100 x 106 Rio Canchacalla (R15) 5* 25. x 106 125 x 106 Guayabo (R16) 4 25. x 106 200 x 106 Agua Salada (R17) 4 25. x 106 100 x 106 Del Pate (R18) 4 25. x 106 100 x 106 Huacre (R23) 3 1.0. x 106 3 x 106 Matata (R24) 4 21.0. x 106 4 x 106 Cuchimachay (R25) 3 1.0. x 106 3 x 106 Chucumayo (R31) 5 x 106 100 x 106 Chacahuacra (R33) 2 x 106 50 x 106 Pancha (R34) as x 106 50 x 106 Viso (R35) 2* x 106 50 x 106 Parac (R37) as x 108 100 x 10 Redonda (S2) 4 x 106 10 x 106 Infiernillo ($3) x 106 10 x 106 Lucuma (85) x 106 10 x 106 Note : (1) * Reduction of days for deposit removal volume is considered as these quebradas are located on the opposit side of main road. @ Unit cost. of traffic block (per day) National Road 1./25 x 106 Sta Eulalia road 1./2.5 x 106 Other main road -I,/1.0 x 106‘Table X-6~6 ESTIMATED DAMAGE OF QDA AREA (LONG-TERM SCALE) Damage Amout. (./ x 10%) Name and No. of Qda House Deposit Removal Traffic Block Total (ch (c2) (c3) (Cc) Chaclacayo (R1) 367.5 27.36 100 583.8 Q. Chacrasana (R2) 3.25 13.36 75 102.4 Q. California (R3) 183.75, 23.87 4 253.5 Q. Santa Maria (R4) 5.2 13,07 15 104.4 Q. ba Cantuta (R5) 73.5 42.62 5 144.8 La Ronda (R10) 105.0 25.57 4 161.1 Q. Santa Ana (R11) 1.04 30.69 125 175.6 Q. Cupiche (Ri3) 1.78 21,15 100 137.5 Rio Canchacalla 0 26.83 125 169.7 (R15) Guayabo (R16) o.21 15.46 100 128.8 Q. Agua Salada (R17) 0 26.08 100 138.7 Q. Del Pate (R18) 0.07 17.55 100 131.1 Q. Muacre (R23) 0.70 8.53 3 14.4 Matata (R24) 3.50 16.82 4 28.8 Q. Cuchimachay (R25) 35.0 7.50 3 54.3 Q. Chucumayo (R31) 4,20 39.55 100 162.5 Q. Chacahuacra (R33) 0.65 6.02 50 63.0 Q. Pancha (R34) 0.04 7.88 50 64.5 Q. Viso (R35) 1.40 5.94 50 63.8 Q. Parac (R37) 0 14.85 100 127.8 Q. Redonda (S2) 8.40 27.50 10 54.1 Q. Infiernillo (S3) 4.21 15.23 10 34.3 Q. Lucuma (85) 3.16 16.19 10 34.2 * Ce = (C1 + C2) x 1.2 403 x11Table X-6-7 ESTIMAGHD DAMAGE OF QDA AREA (MID~TERM AND SHORT-TERM) Damage Amout (I./ x 106) Name and No. of Qda Long-term scall Mid-term scale Short-term scale Q. Chaclacayo (R1) 583.8 303.6 46.7 Q. Chacrasana (R2) 102.4 53.2 8.2 Q. California (R3) 253.5 131.8 20.3 Q. Santa Maria (R4) 104.4 54.3 8.4 ©. La Cantuta (RS) 144.8 15.3 11.6 Q. La Ronda (R10) 161.1 83.8 12.9 Q. Santa Ana (R11) 175.6 21.3 14.0 Q. Cupiche (R13) 137.5 71.5 12.0 Q. Rio Canchacalla 169.7 88.2 13.6 (ri) Q. Guayabo (R16) 128.8 67.0 10.3 Q. Agua Salada (R17) 138.7 RA wa Q. Del Pate (RLS) 131.1 68.2 10.5 Q. Huacre (R23) 14.4 1S 1.2 Q. Matata (R24) 28.8 15.0 2.3 Q. Cuchimachay (R25) 54.3 28.2 4.3 Q. Chucumayo (R32) 162.5 84.5 13.0 Q. Chacahuacra (R33) 63.0 32.8 5.0 Q. Pancha (R34) 64.5 33.5 5.2 Q. Viso (R35) 63.8 33.2 5.2 Q. Parac (R37) 127.8 66.4 10.2 Q. Redonda (S2) 54.2 28.1 4.3 Q. Infiernilo (83) 34.3 17.8 2.7 Q. Lucuma (85) 34.2 17.8 2.7 Note : Damage of Mid-term scale = 0.52 x Damage of long-term scale Damage of Short-term scale = 0,08 x Damage of lont-term scaleTable X-6-8 REDUCITON FACTOR FOR DAMAGE ESTIMATE IN SPE AREAS Vegetation Factor of Reduction Name and No. of Qda Factor (Fl) Slope Factor (F) gradient River mouth-Jicamarca (R-~/0) 1 0.05 0.05 River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-7/1) 1 0.05 0.05 Jicamarca Chacrasana (R-0/2) 1 0.05 0.05 Chaclacayo-California (R-1/3) 1 on On Snata Maria-Quirio (R-4/6) 1 oun O.2 La Cantuta-La Ronda (R-5/10) 1 ot oa Pedregal-Carosio (R-7-8) 1 0.3 0.3 Carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) 1 0.5 0.5 Corrales-Cashahuacra (R-9/- and $-"/1) 1 0.3 0.3 La Ronda-Confluence (R-10/-) 1 0.2 0.2 Confluence-Santa Ana (R-~/11) 1 0.2 0.2 Confluence-San Juan (R-~/12) 1 o.4 0.4 Santa Ana-Cupiche (R-"11/13) 1 0.3 0.3 Cupiche-Guayabo (R~13/16) 1 0.2 0.2 Guayabo-Agua Salada (R-16/17) 1 0.3 0.3 R.Seco-Esperanza (R-19/20) 1 0.4 0.4 Eseranza-Verrugas (R-20/21) 1 0.4 0.4 Verrugas-Huaere (R-21/23) 0.8 0.4 0.32 Linday~Yamajune (R-22/27) 0.8 0.4 0.32 Chacamaza~Barranco (R-26/29) 0.8 0.3 0.24 Chucumayo-Chacahuaro (R-31/33) 0.6 0. 0.12 Parac-R, Blanco (R-37/40) 0.4 0.4 0.16 Confluence-Alcula (8-4) 1 0.3 0.3 Cashahuacra-Redonda (S~1/2) 1 0.2 0.2 Rendonda-Infiernillo (S-2/3) 2 0.2 0.2‘Table X-6-9 DAMAGE ON HOUSES IN SPE AREA (LONG-TERM) Name and No. of Qda River mouth-dicamarca (R-7/0) River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-~/1) Sicamarca Chacrasana (R-0/2) Chaclacayo-California (R-1/3) Snata Maria-Quirio (R-4/6) hha Cantuta-La Ronda (R-5/10) Pedregal-Carosio (R-7-8) Carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) Corrales~Cashahuacra (R-9/- and $~"/1) a Ronda-Confluence (R-10/-) Confluence-Santa Ana (R-"/11) Confluence~San Juan (R-~/12) Santa Ana~Cupiche (R-"11/13) Cupiche-Guayabo (R-13/16) Guayabo-Agua Salada (R-16/17) R.Seco-Esperanza (R-19/20) Eseranza-Verrugas (R-20/21) Verrugas-Huacre (R-21/23) Linday-Yamajune (R-22/27) Chacamaza-Barranco (R-26/29) Chucumayo-Chacahuaro (R-31/33) Parac-R. Blanco (R-37/40) Confluence-Alcula (8-74) Cashahuacra-Redonda (S-1/2) Rendonda-Infiernillo (S-2/3) Class of Damage on Houses Houses 500-1000 1000-5000 Middle 131.2 x 1000-2000 1000-3000 Middle 100-200 100-200 5-10 5-10 5-10 10-20 100-200 100-200 50-70 50-100 0 30-50 20-30 10-20 0 5-10 30-70 10-20 0 10-20 0 0 5-10 100-150 0 0 1-5 5-10 0-3 0 5-10 5-10 0 5-10 5-10 0-5 80-130 50-100 100-200 50-100 5-10 10-20 5-10 10-20 0-5 10-20 (1) Unit Cost of House (UCh) High Class 1/.2.45 x 106 Middle Class T/.0.7 x 106 Low Class I/.0.13 x 106 (2) Amount = Number of ho x F x Uch (3) F : Refer to Table Iv-6-8 Low High Low Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle Low Middle Middle Middle Middle Middle 122.5 % 2.0 « 3.7 « 0.3 x 3.9 x 5.3% 2.6 * 1.6 x 0.2 x 6.8 x 4.0 x 0 37.0 x 0 2.8 x 0.4 x 3.4 x 1.6 x 0.3 x 15.1 x 25.2 2.1% 3.2% 3.0 10® 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 2106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 106 10610 LENGTH OF SLOPE AND NUMBER OF GULLEX/QUEBRADA IN DANGER OF SPE AREA (FOR TRAFFIC DAMAGE ) Table X, Name and No. of Spe Area 1 Been See eee EEE SEP et (km) n(G)N() (KM) AN (G) (QD River mouth-Jicamarca (R-~/0) 0 0 o 0 0 0 River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-~/1) 05 0 ° 0 0 0 River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-"/1) 05 0 ° 0 0 0 Chaclacayo-California (R~1/3) 0 0 0 ° 0 0 Snata Maria~Quirio (R-4/6) 0 0 0 0 0 0 La Cantuta~La Ronda (R-5/10) 0 0 ° 0 6 0 Pedregal-Carosio (R-7-8) 0 0 0 ° 0 0 Carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) ° 0 ° ° 0 0 Corrales-Cashahuacra (R-9/- and S-"/1) 0 0 ° 0 ° 0 La Ronda-Confluence (R-10/-) 0 0 0 1 0 ° Confluence-Santa Ana (R-~/11) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Confluence-San Juan (R-7/12) ° 0 0 9 0 ° Santa Ana-Cupiche (R-~11/13) 1 2 1 05 1 0 Cupiche-Guayabo | (R-13/16) 1 2 0 2.0 5 ° Guayabo-agua Salada (R-16/17) 1.000 2 0 0 0 0 R.Seco-Esperanza (R-19/20) 2.5 3 1 2.5 5 1 Eseranza-Verrugas (R-20/21) 2.5 6 ae ee eee 1 Verrugas-Huacre (R~21/23) 2 3 1 4.0 5 a Linday-Yamajune (R-22/27) 2.5 2 1 ° 0 0 Chacamaza-Barranco (R-26/29) 0 0 0 3.0 7 0 Chucumayo-Chacahuaro (R~31/33) ° o 0 3.0 3 0 Parac-R. Blanco (R-37/40) 0 2 2 0 2 2 Confluence-Alcula (S-74) 0 0 0 0 0 0 Cashahuacra-Redonda (S-1/2) 0 0 o 2.0 5 1 Rendonda-Infiernillo (S~2/3) 0 0 o 1S 4 0 Total w422 720 44 6 Le14km L'=20 Ni=74Table X-6-11 ANNUAL, DAMAGE DUE TO TRAFFIC BLOCK IN SPE AREA Name and No. of Spe Area 2 on pay 1" nt Day! — Damage Amount, River mouth=Jicamarca (R-“/10) 0 0 0 0 0 0 ° River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-“/1) 0.5 0 0.018 @ o 0 4.5 x105 Jicamarca Chacrasana (R-0/2) 0 6 0 0 0 0 0 Chaclacayo-California (R-1/3) 0 0 0 0 0.0 0 Snata Maria-Quirio (R-4/6) 0 0 0 0 9 0 0 La Cantuta-La Ronda (R5/10) o 0 0 o 0 0 0 Pedregal-Carosio (R-7-8) 0 0 Oo 0 0 0 0 Carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Corrales-Cashahuacra (R-9/~ and S-~/1) 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 La Ronda-Confluence (R-10/-) 0 0 0 2 0 0.012 0.3 x108 Confluence-Santa Ana (R-~/11) 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 Confluence-San Juan (R-"/12) 0 00 0 0 0 0 Santa Ana-Cupiche (R-"11/13) 1.5 7 0.115 0.5 1 0,009 28,98x105 Cupiche-Guayabo (R-13/16) 1.5 2 0.071 2.0 5 0,042 18,8 x105 Guayabo~Agua Salada (R-16/17) 1.0 2 0.053 0 o 0 13.25x105 R,Seco-Esperanza (R~19/20) 2.5 8 0.159 2.5°10 0.065 41.38x105 Eseranza-Verrugas (R~20/21) 2.5 11 0,186 2.5 12 0.072 48.3 x105 Verrugas-Huacre (R-21/23) 2 8 0,142 4.0 10 0.084 37.6 x109 Linday~Yamajune (R-22/27) 2.5 7 0.151 0 0 0 37.8 x105 Chacamaza~Barranco (R-26/29) 0 o 0 3.0 7 0,061 1.52x105 Chucumayo~Chacahuaro (R~31/33) 0 oo 3.0 3 0.048 1.20x105 Parac-R. Blanco (R-37/40) 0 12 0,105 0 12 0,040 27.25x105 Confluence-Aleula (S~~4) o 0 0 0 0 0 o Cashahuacra-Redonda (S-1/2) 0 0 0 1.2.10 0.046 1.15x105 Rendonda~Infiernillo (S-2/3) 0 0 0 1.5 4 0.032 0.80x105 Day = D1 + Do 2 2N Day 0.5 day 20 km 74 zeo 57 The description of each letter is to referred to Sub-Section 6.3.2. uct = 1./25 x 106/day uct'= 1./2.5 x 108/day‘Table x, 12 SUMMARY OF ESTIMATED DAMAGE OF SPE AREA Name and No. of Spe Area ______Direct Damage Indirect Damage_ Long-term Mid-term Short-term (Annual) 1 1 acal: River mouth-Jicamarca (R-“/10) 196.8 102.3 15.7 ° River mouth-Chaclacayo (R-"/1) 183.8 95.6 34.7 0.495 dicamarea Chacrasana (R-0/2) 3.0 1.6 0.2 ° Chaclacayo-California (R-1/3) 5.5 2.9 0.4 0 Snata Maria-Quiric (R-4/6) 0.5 0.2 on ° Ta Cantuta-ta Ronda (R5/10) 5.9 3.4 0.8 ° Pedregal-Carosio (R-7~8) 8.0 4.2 0.6 0 Carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) 3.9 2.0 o. 0 Corrales-Cashahuacra (R-9/- and 8-7/1) 2.4 1.2 0.2 ° La Ronda~Confluence (R-10/~) 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.033 Confluence-Santa Ana (R-~/71) 13.7 7a aa 0 Confluence-San Juan (R-“/12) 6.4 3.3 0.8 0 Santa Ana-Cupiche (R-"11/13) ° 0 o 3.188 Cupiche-Guayabo (R-13/16) 27.8 14.5 2.2 2.068 GuayabowAgua Salada (R-16/17) ° ° ° 1.458 R.Seco-Boperanza (R~19/20) 44 2.3 0.4 4.552 Hseranza~Verrugas (R-20-21) 0.5 0.3 o. 9.313 Verrugas-Huacre (R~21/23) 5.2 2.8 0.4 4,136 Linday-Yamajune (R-22/27) 24 1.2 0.2 4.158 Chacamaza-Barranco (R-26/29) 0.4 0.2 0.2 0.167 ‘Chucumayo-Chacahuaro_(R~31/33) 22.7 1a 1.8 0.132 Parac-R. Blanco (R~37/40) 37.8 19.6 3.0 2.998 Confluence-Alowla (S-"4) 12 3.8 0.6 ° Cashahuacra-Redonda (8-1/2) 4.8 2.5 0.4 0.126 Rendonda~Infiernillo (3-2/3) as 2.3 0.3 0.088 Note: (1) Direct damage = Damage on House x 1.5 (2) Indirect damage = Traffic damage x 1.1 (3) Mid-term scale damage = Large scale damae x 0.52 (4) Short-term scali damage = Large scale damage x 0.08 (5) Probable period of occurence is much different by the Area. (6) Indizect damage is shown as an annual amount as the recurrence period will be estimated later for the evaluation of the project.€9°0 = ¥9 670 5 PO $970 = 49 (Po~49/¥9 = 0 enor year ee ee ‘oe = 8 (ower-ouen (f=.0)/uea = pO TIT Tut $9070 F'BT/T 82T Be TeT'O B6/T 00T Rzoenyeysea = -L Let Ont 60T"O «9° TL/T €6T 6°T 99270 S/T FIT enuted 9 ue vet pera powt ez bet genre wrot/t gee coos ore“ ee bat SZT'O FOT/T se T6°T ete zS/t eT soqerz09 +p ot let geo bert ot ine geo eet crores -¢ 3 TE oorre svete te cer ero ert ee rebospea “2 8 et ze0-0 Gvet/t 6 set tero ante orn (208/¢u)d> (PO-2D)/¥2__ PO {z/o)uoy —_(298/Euw) a} (PO-¥D/x9 PO. ouey (998 / Eur) MD "PPD sree Use qostoad 4nousta Pyyo-unxz yeag 3° carey (9338 weg 70 uear3sdn) doOTE ATEYEONE UVER-0OT OS MOTE CMW CNY ST¥EIa JO esO-NOY WWSA —T-9-K STAVE(penuqueo 29 ot) osz : - sh > oF : sou ssomeu voigep = out : = ooe's = g0ett : whe favosus yom um SPO UOADBIONS + 4 : 2 + 08 - 00) yea Bus.je ~ costs : 08 - 0 - eno 1910000 IP ° - - 8 a) : wwino ‘rau00 eygane oos's : = 008s > o0ete : wo 919.0000 - ooo'et : + ooet = 008 : wna sreverew wepuEs YM PRE = ooe'ot : = o's + Gorey - wre VoUAED ‘UOHENESKS + weg rosvon vossara sod “i sz : ost ° or. ov so ose + Gost =~ 008s 000" ©~— ag" arts st - ae st os *” eva, : ° ar) ° ° ° urna eianues ieee - ° egueeaat ° ° ° urna ‘sin.0ue0 algae = oes + aos'or 002" one's wine 1850000 - osy + 008! 0z"k = 008, 900"F wo sreverew wepuer Wm IE>DeE = o's = 0084 0089 ooze ©=—onsee © wr UousUoD “UoHENOKS = Jeg yosvo9 Uo}sONS JOM 03 : : + oF ov. sou sermeu voReD - oon" : : > o00' ode" urd: Kauozous row KR SOK UOIDSION! = s2h : : - 98 Le ‘uot ea BuBIOWUIEN = 00's 7 : ~ — oo0"LLoas‘et wre sres0U09 OER ° oos'et o0s'ez Wino ‘ax9u00 ergan ooo'er o08'2 —000'y wn ‘900'8 : : + goe'z2 ooz'te win sfevorew wepues : ooe'se . - > 0062 = od'sz uno ‘YOUR “UOREAEDES = weg Ut PETERS — SRT BSS OT FHRIIBS SFR OHO — TTT TRESS =O 0 0 FO =O (2/1) 2¥. dnoip jo seeny #9 WI SxHONA UOHINAsUCD UREN 19 ANUEND Wom Z-8-X eREL,o8 ws (w 027) Bana Aemyes mon = ozt be (w c2=7) eBpuq peor men - 08 w % : 08 w 09 w ‘seimonaig Jo 1wewerorduy “tA 38 905 ose'z seu ssomeu uolgeo = ooe'2 —06"F one's ws d= 0 ° ° suo} : ° @ ° wna) ° ° ° wena ° ° ° wre oos'st 0 06's urna oes = oz cove wn ooe'e 02's wna oos'ez ost © o'r urea ° ° 7 1 By 1 wn reuum peyspouebpug men = st ° 09 SZ 098 oe sou ‘seamvew uoigeD = ooe'z 0 o0o'F © ove'e == oz"a ste urbe Aasoseu iam yum SOM UoNDeIO%d = ° ° ° ° ° ° U0} eq Susiojuiey - ° ° ozs 8 ° ° urna eres2u00 HOES = oor oo o0z't 00» ostoz ~—ons"at urna) ° ° 0 ° ° ° turn o 0 008 008, ose! §— ooz'tt wr oos'tz 9000's orl 0076 us'azt oo'oz: © wn ooo “vOHEAEDXS ‘SHON FeUUeYD “AL BERT —enIET SSO SORE SRS —eieweg SIO RS TT TORSO OB 50, 2D, 20, 0, (272) .v, door j0 seary pO SY0)A voRDNASUED UPN Jo AiRLERD WOM 28K OREL{penugve0 €¢ 01) Tae vse £0 ot cosy so ree 982 coe wes se ret ooz92 sua, oo oo cosy area oo oo co's? wre ores o'ses 20°08 urn ey re 20% weno syoyorew Wepues an peeE — ese sree 00°F us ‘Uaiwe® "VaEAEONS = ‘veg fv09 wojsor s0ddn “tl THeT se Te as ae rerrans cu be ro oo a cosy 204 ssomiew vorgsy - ee os zee tee ooze uss Kuosew tom um 0m so oF ee or ret cose uy eq Bu suse 0 00 oo oo cosy urea cjanueo ° ° oo oo oo onsy wre ‘610U00 eiqaNY - cost —orese ova 967 o's oo-08 urna 10.0409 - os er zs 9 re oo urna syevereat weoves wim mpges - Ber 08 For ele B'0as 007 uno oun "VonEAEOKS - wed fenueg uojsorg 2907 “IL rer Fast Tar reiovng ez : : oe et co's so ssonmms uorep « 2:08 : : + 099 why oaree wos uosew 12m uum SYH0M UoneO! = eee : : + ez wet arzaz svat "9 : osor : : > ser sz09, vray wn ‘ye.0U00 IPED = ° : > SiL09S'Szo"s 00's wn ete.0u09 araanis = orose’s : : + ore oe 00-08 wr 21020009 * oroe : : : S992 o'r weno sreyoqew wepes wim nipseE - zsoe 820) Oty wr ‘oun "voyenearg - weg ue 7 TEARS PERT ESTE Saas GTO HOST TaRePIIG =O = 0 0 50 iawn wn (211). dnoio jo seany epO U1 SOIR UORERUSUED LIE J 1809 osLOURS CB AGEL“sya snoevejeostu 20} 1200 84 epm>UI OU Seqp WUNOUE OL « set TRMOry Fists Fees FOE sise9 «bers 4 SWIOL FOL oes : : : ost tte oy0l - - : : ozs ws seat : : : [he a an : : : > gare a bese : : : > bbe a revum peo Jo venues ~ seurpng je wouenoy 1p TE rT morane wss sez eon : - : = oor sau ssomen von - ozs ety ses : : : = g0z% ws Auosew vom tam spam voroore © ° 8 ° : : : + ooze =m ma 8 ° ° oosy urna 8 ° ° cosy uno ° ° ° 008 urna er 8 o-00s coor une ott Se ee oo ero ee ° ere 80 oe ore Bek Break 00 uno ve Til Fast Tat o oO ere “ss ose 1 WN ‘sBpyayeuun peysyooy - fo ° ze Fe ree co's ou stonteu wore) gos °O ase ge oely 00ree we Aswosew Jam Yim SOM ONDA) ° ° coo oo | ese am ° ° ors (Oo oo | Geer sez 3 $9 oes szea Gosh uno ° ° oo 8 eo = oes urns o o ve ze e'9y 00'r wna ose G02 ror Sue cosy oo urns om ewse¥9 “At SERIE) WHEE OOS NI) BR — ROAR SRO HS BT ToT sso eo eo evsiun on {@re} 22. dnoro J0 see1y epD U1 SOKA UoRoNEUEN IEW 101809 OROUODG EE K OI0ELTable X-8-4 Compensation Cost in Areas of Group "A' tand Relocation “Compensation Name of Qda ——Acgusition __of house __cost_ Area Unit Cost No. Unit Cost Total ee SoS eae oe ee eae Ue Qda Quirio 50 0.2 10.0 30 0.7 21.0 31.0 (1,033.3) Qda Redregal 50 0.2 10.0 60 0.7 42.0 52.0 (1,733.3) Qda Carosio 2 0.2 04° 5 0.7 3.5 3.9 (230.0) Qda Carrales 5 0.2 1.0 10 0.7 3.5 4.8 (250.0) Qda Rio seco 50 0.1 5.0 0 0.7 0 5.0 (166.7) Qda Paihua 2 0.1 0.2 0 07 0 0.2 (6.7) Qda Cashahuacra 20 0.1 0.2 5 0.7 0.35 0.55 (38.3) Unit : Area; x 103 m unit cost; x 106 Intis (x 103 US$)Coe te + 12 + FO 8ST (1 + 7% + 71) 508s" “Z 70 45 rea0n brLSO’E «= T'ZbHO GS SHT/E StHSOYE «= L'ZEy/T = pr ePg‘TT PrEzo"E TeI0n sep £'008 e-0tb B6E 8°98T g6ts/T @*b2t/T Xousbuyguop TeoTsud “Ss voyaezaszurupe quewuzeaoy pue srst 8°06e 8°06T eset 6°98 L90L E25 soyazes Buyxeeuroug eer “9 Eegst o°0st O° O8T ereentt €°€00/T uoTqesuedwoy *¢ rosp/z —-s'9G6'h Bt haz‘z = ErOTZ/Z 6 6LE Lreze’e LL89'S TeIOL-ans srp2t Br Lez zrett scott ore z99g pr haz snosuettsostn (9) - 8-08 Sere - - = - Keatrex pue peox 30 woTq0eq0%a (¢) zeee o o-20%/t = c = exTP xeptog/Suturery (5) rete 0°07 - 97967 srese grugs‘e 9°9so'z syzon Teuueys (€) L°et2'T 9° TéE - oreog’T = FBS Brele't | S768 wep Surqsozze pues /Tox3UOD vOTsOra (Zz) - e°9te’ - - - rrete’t z-ese’z wep y08uD (T) sxIOM UOTONTISUOD +z set arLee zert SOIT over w99e prez syzoy Azogezedeza ‘Tt ezoenyeuseo enyyeg oo8g OTH saTeIT0D oysoreD Tebarpey oF ITN uoradyz0seq (ssa g0T x :97Un) wn Inox 30 seazy epy uy 3609 aoefora oTWOUCOE ¢-8-K ETALTable X-8-6 Annual Benefit for Qda Quirio Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL, DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qaa. No.: QUIRIO Case unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incremental Incre- Deblis — deblis—deblis Roturn Proba- mental flow flow flow period bility value damage damage damage. 2.01 0.9901 = 4 - : 1.5 0.6667 0.3234 0.00 0.00 0.00 2 0.5000 0.1667 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 0.2000 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0.00 10 0.1000 0.1000 969.67 484.84 48.08 20 0.0500 0.0500 2100.14 1534.91 76,75 30 0.0333 0.0167 3006.13 2553.14 42.64 40 0.0250 0.0083 3807.19 3406.66 28,28 50 0.0200 0.0050 4570.33 4188.76 20.94 80 0.0125. 9.0075 6501.22 5535.78 41,52 100 0,0100 0.0025 7641.67 7071.45 17.68 200 0.0050 0.0050 TOTAL 0.9852 276,28 Table X-8-7 Annual Benefit for Qda Pedregal Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No,: PEDREGAL Case: Unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incremental Incre- Deblis deblis_——deblis. Return Proba- mental flow flow flow period damage damage == damage i 0.00 0.00 0,00 2 0.1667, 0.00 0.00 0.00 3 0.3000 0.00 0.00 9.00 10 0.1000 922.00 461.00 46.10 20 0.0500 2762.63 1842.32 92.12 30 0.0167 4548.52. 3655.58 61.05 40 0.0083 6316.92 5432.72 45.09 50 0.0050 8912.00 7624.46 38.07 80 0.0075 13291.92 1101.96 83.26 100 0.0025 19553.67 14422.80 36.06 TOTAL 0.9851 401.75wable X-8-8 Annual Benefit for Qda Carosio Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No.: CAROSTO Case: Unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incremental Incre- Deblis deblis ——deblis Return Proba- mental flow Flow flow period bility value damage © damage damage. 1.5 0.6667 0.3234 0,00 0.00 0.00 2 0.5000 0.1667 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 0.2000 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0,00 10 0.1000 0.1000 239.00 © 119.50 11.95 20 0.0500 0.0500 662.03 450.52 22.53 30 0.0333 0.0167 1055.97 859.00 14.35 40 0.0250 0.0083 1436.19 1246.08 10.34 50 0.0200 0,0050 1915.00 1675.60 8.38 80 0.0125 0.0075 2882.30 2398.65 17.99 100 0.0100 0.0025 3426.00 3154.15 7.89 200 0.0050 0.0050 TOTAL 0.9852, 93,42 Table X-8-9 Annual Benefit for Qda Corrales Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No.: CORRALES Case Unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incremental Incre- Deblis —deblis —deblis Return Proba- mental flow flow flow period bility value damage damage daniage 1.01 0.9901 - - : - 1.5 0.6667 0.3234 0,00 0,00 0.00 2 0.5000 | 0.1667 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 0.2000 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0,00 10 0.1000 0.1000 257.00 128.50 12.85 20 0.0500 0.0500 775.48 = 516.24 25,81 30 0.0333 0.0167 1276.33 1025.91 17.13 40 0,0250 0.0083 1772.13 1524.23, 12.65 50 0.0200. 0.0050 2576.67 2174.40 10.87 80 0.0125 0.0075. 3726.88 3151.78 23.64 100 0.0100 0.0025 4261.33 3994.11 9,99 200 0.0050 0.0050 ‘TOTAL 0.9852, 112.94,table ¥-8-10 Annual Benefit for Qda Rio Seco Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No.: RIO SECO Case: Unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incromental Inere- Deblis deblis—deblis Return Proba- mental flow flow flow period bility value damage damage = damage 1.01 : : : : 15 03234 0.00 0.00 0.00 2 0.1667 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0.00 10 0.1000 710.67 355.34 35.53 20 010500 1588.47 1149.57 97.48 30 0.0167 2346.29 1967.38 32.86 40 0.0083 3033.65 2689.97 22.33 50 0.0050 3207.33 3120.49 15.60 80 0.0075 5428.90 4328.12 32.39 300 0.0025 7199.00 6313.95 15.78 200 0.0050 TOTAL 0.9851 211.97 Table X-8-11 Annual Benefit for Qda Pathua Table ESTINATION OF EXPEGTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No.: PAIHUA Case Unit : US$ 10°3 Averaged Incremental Imere- Deblis deblis —deblis Return Proba- mental flow flow flow period bility value damage damage — damage 1,01 0,901 = : : 3234 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.5 0.6667 0 2 0.5000 0.1667 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 0.2000 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0.00 10 0.1000 0.1000 545,67 272,84 27,28 20 0.0500 0.0500 1440.70 993.19 49.66 30 0.0333 0.0167 2264.19 1852.45 30.9% 40 0.0250 0.0083 3049.55 2656.87 22.05 50 0.0200 0.0050 3787.33 3418.44 17.09 80 0.0125 0.0075 5986.38 4886.86 36,65 100 0.0100 0.0025 7409.33 6697.86 16.74 200 0.0050Table X-6-12 Annual Benefit for Oda cashahuacra Table ESTIMATION OF EXPECTED MEAN ANNUAL DAMAGE OF-DEBLIS FLOW Qda. No.: CASHAHUACRA Case: Unit : US$ 10° Averaged Incremental Incre- Deblis deblis —deblis Return Proba- mental flow flow flow period bility value damage damage damage. 1.01 0,9901 1.5 0.6667 0.3234 0.00 0.00 0.00 2 0.5000 0.1667 0.00 0,00 0.00 5 0.2000 0.3000 0.00 0.00 0.00 20 0.1000 0.1000 229.33 11.67 11.47 20 0.0500 0.0500 ~ 576,50 402.92 20.15 30 0.0333 0.0167 900.66 «738.58 12.33 40 0.0250 0.0083 1208.34 1054.50 8,75, 50 0.0200 0.0050 1296.67 1252.51. 6.26 80 0.0125 0.0075 2351.13 1823.90 13.68 100 0.0100 0.0025 3229.67 2790.40 6.98 200 0.0050 ‘TOTAL 0.9851 79.62Table X-8-13 BIRR Calculation for Qda Quirio ese o€ Qucbeade ¢— QUIRIO Feonomie developeent rate + SX/yenr Discounted rates 5.2606 2 Unk + USS 10°3 cost srRzatt BENErIE STREAY Year Fisica Gonat= Discounted Diecounted Wot Your suotion O&M Cost Total Anmual-‘Tobel..Frosent Cott cont Total cont Benefit Renefit Worth 3 690/1001 4,728.7 B27 a,e36.7 3.8 630.79 2 ro0ryreaz 3,440.4 3,409.4 3,223.9 0.0 (9,213.07 3 1992/1068 1,726.7 21.6 1,746.2 “1,407.8 78,0 180.4 (4,947.79 4 1993/3906 4,726.7 22.6 1,746.2 1,429.1 175.0 142.8 (2,280.4) 5 10941005 wo. "ast [334 38000 ao 287.8 1605/3008 wed Ad mT 8805 205.2 233.8 7 1996/3907 a 1 a2 ahs ass ae 8 1897/1098 wel W128 aHHO Bet 8 1690/1969 wl lm ma LE 10 189972000 wot G1 88 0.823.327 31 2000/2002 wot at meas 8.5, 32 2001/2002 ee ee 13 2002/2003 wat 2a 8208.8 14 2005/2008 a wa ase make 45 2004/2005, aad 2.078888. 16 2005/2008 wat 10 BST 17 17 2006/2007 wat @l wl 99.0 209, 202.0 1 2007/2000 wa @t 2 Sth 2088 8.5 18 2000/2009, 42a 4216.3 520,4 200.9 18K. 20 2009/2010 sad 43.1 18.5 545.9 80,0 180.5 24 2010/2011 a4? SLT tet aa 22 2021/2012 wea ATS aT. 23 2012/2013 wl asd 13.8 505.8 188.7 170.8 2% 2013/2016 at 268? 78.887 25 2014/2013 2G .0 sek 75.9. 26 2013/2018, 1 G2 Awe 80,8 29 2016/2017 wal 210.8 670.7 5.87.7 28 2017/2018 wl 4a 10.3 a0.8 88H, 20 2026/2010 a 98s aes ‘90 2019/2020 wal 2 8888788 2 2020/2021 ea a 781887 ‘32 2021/2022 oa 4n ms wa Mee 33 2022/2028 61 Ga 00.8 448.0 140.0 ‘36 2029/2026 B13. eae ke 187.3 95 2094/2025 waa ma L718 98 2025/2028 ea at @75,0 138.7 131.9 {97 2026/2027 eb oo1.9 135.8 123.9 98 2027/2028 waa at 25,9 192.8 128.7 139 2028/2028 an 96.2 390.0 kt 10 2020/2030 Ba Gt eee 127.2 Ah. 1 2090/2031 wa 8.2 2,04 3245 110.2 42 2031/2032 wa O10 aa 43 2032/2038 a at 1,078.2 8.2 1 2029/2094 a. 2,108.5 116.7 45 2024/2085 wa a7, 8.2 16 2035/2036 ea 16.0 11.8 17 2030/2037 ea saa 109.4 ‘8 2037/2038 waa 2.8 207.0 49 2036/2030 waa 1,288.0 108.8 50 2039/2040 wa 38, aas.e 0a. Total 8,623, 2,026.5 20,640,0 0,278,1 94,326.9 0,270,1 0.0Table X-8-14 BIRR Calculation for Qda Pedregal Mane of Quebrada: PEDREGAL Economie development. r2to : 32/yene Discoant rate *. 5.6548 2 Unit ¢ uss 0° Cost STREAM proeert stars Yonr Fisteal comt= Discounted Discounted Ret Your uetion O&M Cost Total Annual. Totel Present, Cost Cost Total cost, Benofit Benefit Worth 2 800/268 2,329. 2,329.8 2,208.2 0.0 (2,205.2) 2 1901/1092 4,850.8 A659. 4,374.3 0.0 (4,274.9) 3 1002/1993 2,320.9 2,389.0 2,000.2, 235.8 (1,784.4) 4 1903/1004 2,920.8 2,250.0. 1,803.2 2,686.9) 5 2008/3005 se2 0 M42 32.4 6 1095/1008 320 Le 335.0 7 1996/1997 582 30.6 a8 8 1907/1008 5320375 320.7 8 1908,/1089 582 38.8 313.7 410 1000/2000 50.2 92.6 308.8 1 2000/2001 52818 300.2 42 2001/2002 38.2 30.1 293.4 213 2002/2003 sez 28.5 206.8 1 2003/2008 58.2 27.0 280.5 415 2004/2008 50.285 2m. 36 2005/2008 582 242 260.0 17 2008/2007 2.9 282.0 18 2007/2008 a6 256.2 18 2008/2008 20.3 250.2 20 2000/2010 sez 108.4 24.5, 21 2010/2011 58.2 10.3 230.9 22 2011/2012 50.2 ak 23.5 29 2012/2013 bs.2 16.4 228.1 24 2019/2014 50.2 15.5 2.8 25 2014/2015, 38.2 17 a7 26 2015/2016 50.2 3.9 22.6 29 2016/2017 38.2 13.2 207.7 20 2017/2018 50.2 12.5 202.8 20 2018/2010 see no 190.1 30 2018/2020 a2 193.4 31 2020/2021 38.2 10.6, 103.0 32 2021/2022 50.2 10.0 104.5 33 2022/2023 50.2 2.5 200.1 34 2023/2024 2.0 175.8 35 2024/2025 a3 m.7 36 2025/2026 5.0 167.6 37 2026/2027 18 163.6 38 2029/2028 22 150.7 139 2026/2020 oe 355.0 40 20zs/2030 6s 132.2 42 zos0y2001 ea 348.6 42 2osi/2092 5.0 443.0 43 2032/2038 55 ans 14 2033/2086 52 390.3 45 zose/2005 ao 14.8 46 2035/2036 ae a1 47 2098/2087 ae waka ce 8 2037/2038 aa 125.3 0.0 4 2038/2030 3.9 a22.2 50 2039/2000 37 nes yoo =. _. ee See 2.00 otal 11,680,4 2,737.6 14,387,0 11,033.3 40,627-1 11,053.5 (@.0)Table X-8-15 BIRR Calculation for Qda Carosio Esovonte davelopeant abe £3 K/yese Mane of Gusbeada + chnosi0 BERR = 905% 0.0259260 cost sree Year Piston.” Const ~~ pieeounted Yoar ructlon 06M Cost Total Cost cost. Total cost Yies0/i001 «28.8 wao.8 988.9 2 agoii992 573.2 5. W769 3 i0z/1902 429.8 3.6 499.t 927.0 © 1903/1908 7272 bo 5 1994/1005 727k © ag05/1988 ne 72 A 7 1996/1997 na 728 8 a907/1990 120072 2 1998/2998 220072 10, 1998/2000 220 7228 1 2000/2003, 7272S 32 20012002 72 72 88 18 2002/2003 na 7B BA 14 2003/2004 ne 7k 8 15 200472005, 120 7k 26 2008/2006 n2 0 72 18 27 2006/2007 na 72s 18 2007/2008 720 7B 48 28 2008/2008 n2 00 72 42 20 zooay2010 120 ran 2x 2010/2011 2 72 Le 22 2013/2012 7200722208 23 2012/2013, na 72 08 24 2013/2014 720 7a 08 25 2oue/2013 ra. 7B? 2s 2015/2016 na 72 08 27 2016/2017 r20 7208 28 2ouz/2018 720072 08 29 2018/2010 rn. 78S, 30 2010/2020 na 72k 31 zoz0y2001 ne 72s 32 2021/2002 na TRO 33 2022/2025 727k 8 ‘36 2023/2024 720 7.2 08 35 2024/2025 na. 7B 08 36 zozs/2008 ce 37 2026/2027 TA TR On 36 2027/2028 ra 7k 02 30 2026/2020 rR 7k OR 40 2020/2080 r2 0 7k Ok 42 2050/2081 ne 7 Oe 42 2031/2082 ne 72 Od 49 2032/2033 na 7k ot 4 2032/2084 272, On 45 2034/2085 na 7k 8d 4 2095/2096 na 7.8 08 47 2030/2037 na RO 46 2037/2036 120 7k Od 49 2036/2030 n200 72 Od $0 2030/2040 na kt Fouk 1602.7 800.8 17S. 1aAT.e Dott £ uss 10°3 ‘RENEPIT STREA Discounted Mat Annual Total Prexint, Benefit Benefit Rocth 0.0 «as1.3) 0.0 (974.8) 743.3 (283.8) aes ho a3 7h,0 60s yao ok 6.3 15.5 65.0 8d a3 7.8 ye 72 Rb w72 838. was $0.37 Mss Meo 42 aad ise AL 98.3 3590 38.0 37.2 13.8 3 3k we? 0.2 92.7 vas 32.0 30.7 1700 30,0 28.8 mes mae art 19.0 26.4 25.4 195.6 2888 mie 2 207.5 7.8 2h 219.7204 10,7 220.2 18.1 18,5 226.7 18.0 23.5 16.8 16.3 20,5 15.8 15.3, a7 ma 25.20 9S. 22,0 13.0 20,7 ke weet 297.2 7 10.5 205.8 a8. 308.7 en ma.8 26 323.2 aa 332.0 76 342.0 aa 259.2 67 300.8 a 37.7 3.9 306.0 35 307.5 5.2 300.5 woeece waz so 08 He a ware soasee 1.00 34,580.0 120 0.0Table xX-8~16 News of Quebrada + B.LR, Yowr Pisteet Your 2 2 2 30 2 39 . 35 36 28 20 4 a a 43 “ “5 ” a 0 50 900/691 1091/2002 1902/2009, 3000/1008 1994,2095, 1995/1096 1096/3097 1997/2008 1698/1000 1099/2000, 2000/2002 2001/2002 ‘2002/2003 2003/2008 2004/2005 2005/2008 2008/2007 2007/2008 2008/2000 2009/2010 2010/2032 2011/2012 2012/2013 zors/z018 zo1s)2015, 2015/2016 2018/2017 2or7/2018 2018/2019 2019/2020 2020/2001 2021/2022 2022/2029 2023/2024 zorera025 2025/2026 2026/2027 2oa7p2028 2020/2020 2029/2030 2030/2031 2081/2032, 2032/2033, 2093/2038 2034/2035 2095)2036, 2036/2037 2037/2028 2030/2039 2039/2010 Totad onat= cost, ore. 122.8 a16.4 3,054.5 BIRR Calculation for Qda Corrales Feonoate developeant rate : 3 t/year ‘conn 6.02 2 0.0029200, cost sma Discounted ORM Cost total Cost Total cost, O68 eae A221. 1,067.0 7.6 meee 775.6 sa 159k 5.3 15.3ane 3.33598 35.3 38.2 oa 3.3 1598s 3s 8 1.315.988 3301588 30 ase 335.9 3.94567 315.9 8b 1.3 15.3 6.0 3.3 asa 57 1.3159 5.8 35.3 1595.0 a3 91334 a3 15a ae wa asa ao 33159088 35.9453 as ia 3533.8 439 45,30 ae 21530 1.3159 one 3459 8.3 15.92 909g 1.345222 1.300159 ad 1.3 15320 Bs asad, 13003 Le asa a3 a 5.3 1520 Le 5.30 15.90 3 tse a 1838 a9 ass ak 45.30 asa 42 ws asa ad 5.335.310 3.3 350 Le a 183 oe 315.308 13 153 oe 725.4 3,770.0 2,826.4 Unit uss 103 ewerrT stews Discovited Nee Anguel Totel— Peésent, Benefit, Bonerit. Worth eh.3) 2,007.0) 7.2) o7.8 98.4 23.0 ¥,008.8 2,026.2 6.0Table X-8-17 BIRR Calculation for Qda Rio Seco Nase of Quebrada : RIO SECO Fconcmle developaent, rato + 3t/yoae Discount wate = 10.1167 7 Untt + Use 10°3 ‘cost STREAY nerre STREAM Year Fisicel Const= Discounted Discounted Rat, Your ruction O&M Cost Total Annual Total, «Present ‘cost Cost Total Cost Benaeit Benefit Worth ¥ 1900/1091 oa. ee era 0 ara) 2 3901/1902 1,258.4 2,250.4 2,097.8 0.0 (1,037.0) 3 se02/2e09 oW3.8 7,9 52.8 72,7 TON. (AS.27 4 1989/1904 35.7 15.7.7 280.7 77.3188.8 5 1906/1995 15.7187 8.7 288.8 65.9 5 1005/1098 15.7057 ak 278.8 ast 2 1996/2007 35.7 15.7 © 28h. aas.a 12 1907/1998 45.7457 7.8 208.5 05.7 8 1998/1098 oe ee cr) 40 1999/2000 15.7017 8H. 11 2000/2001 700870. 12 2001/2002 1715.7 00,3 3.9 49 2002/2003, 35.77 OLR ok 4 2003/2008 35.7017 2D 0.0 35 2004/2005 a7 5.7? 30.8.0 18 2003/2005, wT TT 78,3 17 2008/2007 357017 3a 8TH 1 2007/2008 35.7 15.728 kh 89.8 20 2008/2009 36.7 158.7 aS 408.2 SL 20 2000/2010 15.78.70 2a zonoyz0nt 707 ak ak aro 22 2011/2012 wr 7 23.9 23 2012/2013 77 t8. 24 2013/2018 6.715.708 25 zo14/2015 337487 LA tas a8. 26 2015/2016 15.7 18.719 400.8 H0.8 2 2018;2017 a2 7 SS a8 28 2017/2018 35.757 88.7 20 2018/2019 1715.7 LO 48.9 8 ‘30 2019/2020 a7 45.70 Sean 31 2020/2021 3587.7 870.2 20 32 2021/2022 35.7 35.70? 506.5 27.8 33 2022/2023 157570785 34 2023/2008 715762288 3 2024/2025 187 70.5 BSL aR 36 2025/2026 a7 35.70 ok 20.8 37 2026/2027 a7 3s.7 oe BLD 38 2027/2028 13.7 15.7 Oka 39 2u28/2000 17 Tk 8a ‘0 2029/2030 7157 35.7 8.0 ‘ 2030/2031 15.7 15.79.3783 180 2 2081/2002 35.7 15.70.30 3 2032/2033, a7 457k BST ‘4 2033/2034 13.71.7503 45 2024/2038, 78a 16 2035/2036 1575.7 0.202.810. 47 2096/2037 15.7 5.70.2 a8. 10.0 48 2037/2038 15.70 15.7) 0287.8 8h 48 2038/2039 33.7 15.7888 s0 2030/2040 137 18.7 ats. Total «SMS. 707.2 9,008,02,722,7 26,807.1 2,722.7 0.0Table X--8-18 EIRR Calculation for Qda Pathua 103 Net Wort 26.0) (2,338.2), a.ou.e (955.5) waa v0.2 107.5 154.8 62.2 159.5 156.9 154.3 151.6 aus.2 146.7 aua.e 79.0 mse yen Nano of Qvabysdn ¢ PATHUA Feoneate davelopent rate i 3 t/yeae EER = 5.0008 Vals + Use ‘cost srnEas NEP SIREN Yosr Fisteat Const Discounted Dizcounted Year ruction O&M Cost Total Armas Total cost Cost Total Cost Benetit Benwttt Y is00/ieer 1,288.4 3,288.4 1,226.0, 0 2 1001/1082 2,576.0 2,575.8 2,309.8 0.0 9 teve/ies 1,289.4 36.2 2,908.5 1,324.0 109.4 4 tegs/ioee 1,288.4 26.1 1,308,5 1,080.5 104.1 5 1994/1085 32.20 922 35. reo. 6 to9s/1e96 32.2 322 23.0 ao. 7 1906/1807 32.2 32.2 22.8 100.2 8 1007/1008 sae 922 a7 156.5 8 1090/1000 92.2 92.2 20,6 182.8 40 1999/2000 a2 219.8 won 41 2000/2003 2220 322 18.7 uss 32 2001/2002 32.20 9227.8 va 13 2002/2003 32.2 32.2 46.9 160.6 46 2002/2006 222922 a6. 105.3, 25 2004/2005 322 922 15.3 152.0 46 2005/2008, we 322 es a3e.8 17 2008/2007 gaz 223, 155.6 18 2007/2008 32.2 92.2 6 13.2 332.5 139 2000/2000 32.20 2.2 aa. 169.5 20 2009/2010 gaz 9221 166.5 2 2010/2012 saz 322 aa 149.6 22 2011/2012 sa2 9228407 23 2012/2013 s22 3220 10.8 aaa aa7. 2a 2013/2014, ae 3228s das. 25 2018/2015 322 922083485182. 26 2025/2016. a2 228829 27 2016/2017 B28 a. ze 2017/2018, oan 322 © smo 1.8 2 2018/2019 20 82 788.0 aan. 30 2019/2020 220 723 sas te. 3 2020/2021 a2 2 8S 32 2021/2022 e220 9226838 39 2022/2023 saa 22633808 34 2029/2024 sez 322 6.0 598,2 0.8 35 2024/2025 22.2 922° 5.7 6l.2 ‘38 2025/2026. 92.20 92.20 Sk OT 37 2026/2027 ag ek? 98 2027/2028 m2 ak 88 ora 38 2028/2020 220 3248 40 2028/2080 a2 22a 41 2030/2031 32.20 922 42 42 2031/2032 32.2 32.2 4.0 43 2032/2093 322 3223.8 46 2039/2034 322 a3 45 zose/2035 22 naa 146 2038/2036 220 m2 47 2036/2037 22002 48 2007/2008 52.2 322 3.0 49 2020/2000 3220 32228 +50 2038/2040 a22 9222.7 0.9 otal 6,642.1 1,519.0 7,056.0 6,218.7 4,784.0 €,210,7 0.0 1.00Table x-8~: ‘able X-8-19 BIRR Calculation for Qda Cashahvacra Nang of Quebeade : CASHAMUACRA Econonte davolopaent rate # 3 Yiyaar ETRR 4.35907 nde ¢ USS 10°93 cost Thea pIMEPYY sraEnt Your Pistoal Const Discounted Discounted Nee Your suction OGM Cost Total Amal. Total Prasont Cost Cont Total Cost Benefit Boneftt Hove 2 toooyiset 637.2 2 e806 0.0 (ea0.e) 2 s9e4/ie%e 1,229.0 1,223.0 1,227.4 0.9 (4,127.4) 39 igez/iess 917.2 7.6 28.0 10.8 see 3 075.29 4 1093/1804 330 ae 78 2 70.2 5 19941695 asa 153s tae asa 6 1005/1008 15,315.30 03. me one 7 1906/1007 35.2 35.90 S788. 1997/1998 35.3 15.90 oto. 78.6 8S 9 1998/1089 43.9 15.3 6s 787 oad 20 1900/2000 15.3 15.3 10.2 m8 6.8 4 2000/2001 15.20 15.30 9.8 ak 78.9 x2 2001/2002 15.3153 Ok aa x9 2002/2008 5.900 15.9 0 ea 78.8 2 2009/2008 298.9 5 2004/2009, ass 15383 as 788 6 2005/2008 Ws 1590 807 437 2006/2007 wa 015900 778 118 2007/2000 36.3083 8m 19 2008/2009 wa 37 aS, 20 2008/2010 1.3 15.3 AST 2x 2010/2018, 315.9851 22 2012/2012 13.3153 62 18.7 23 2012/2013, wa 15.90 60 26 2019/2014 20153 588.8 25 2014/2015 35.90 15,3 5.5 aR 26 2015/2018 1.9 15.95.37 27 2916/2007 313 Aa, 28 2017/2018 315.38 88.0 29 2018/2010 530153 208.0 ‘30 2010/2020 a0 359 StL 31 2020/2021 a2 359 32 2021/2022 a9 15842 ah 133 2022/2023 15.3 15.3 007 ‘36 2023/2028 530 15.8 88ST 38 2024/2025 asa sa 2a 36 2025/2026 915.98 sR 37 2026/2027 15.2 15.3848 38 2027/2028 a3 538A 39 2028/2029 323278, 40 2029/2030 wa 83 088.7 41 2090/2031, 35.9 15.302 aR. 42 2091/2092 15.9 15.828 tO 43 2092/2035, ass a2 27 310.0 46 2038/2034 1.3328 388 45 2094/2035 asa 2k ash 48 2035/2036, 15.95.38 47 2096/2037 35a 18228 38.0 ‘60 2097/2038 15.3 18.30 eRe 49 2038/2039 aaa 2a aOR 50 2039/2040 335920 as Jotul 8,057.4 725.3-3,709,9 9,108.2 0,077.8 9,108.2Table X-9-1 Type of Qda Areas of Group "BY Name and No. of Qda type Q. Chaclacayo (Ra) AL Q. Chacrasana (2) AL Q. California (R3) AL Q. Santa Maria (Ra) Al Q. La Cantuta (R5) AL Q. La Ronda (R10) AL Q. Santa ana (R11) BL Q. Cupiche (R13) B1 Q. Rio Canchacalla (R15) c Q. Guayabo (R16) B2 Q. Agua Salada (R17) B1 Q. del Pate (R18) Bl Q. Huacre (R23) B1 ©. Matata (R24) Bl Q. Cuchimachay (R25) AL Q. Chucumayo (R31) B2 Q. Chacahuacra (R33) 32 Q. Pancha (R34) c Q. Viso (R35) © Q. Parac (R37) c Q. Redonda (2) B2 Q. Infiernillo (s3) Bl Q. Lucuma (ss) Bl Note : Al : Quirio/Redregal Type a2 : Carosio/Corrales Type Bl: Rio Seco Type B2 : Cashahuacra Type © : Paihua Typerable X-9-2 Name and No. of Oda. - Chaclacayo (Ri) chacrasana (2) California (R3) santa Maria (Ra) Ta Cantuta 15) La Ronda (R10) santa Ana (R11) - Cupiche (213) Rio Canchacalla (R15) Guayabo (R16) Agua Salada (R17) Del Pate ais) Huacre (R23) Matata (R24) Cuchimachay (25) Chucumayo (R31) chacahuacra (R33) Pancha (R34) Wao (R35) Parac (R37) Redonda (s2) Infiernillo (83) Lucuma 485) Quantity of structural Plan for Qda Areas of Group "B” Q'ty of structure Teagth of Tength of channel Works 3.3 km um Lea 2 1.3 - 1.0 - Le - 13 - ca.ay 0.6 km (0.4) 0.5 (0.5) 0.5 0.4 - (0-5) 0.5 - 0.4 (0.5) 0.5 (0.5) 0.8 wat - 0.7 1.6 0.3 - (0.5) - (0.5) = (0.3) 7 1.3 1.3 (0.4) 0.4 (0.9) 0.9 Note: Channel works with parenthesis others pike Sechion Road & Railway Protection = ditto - Road & Railway Protection = ditto = = ditto ~ = ditto - = ditto ~ Road & Raileay Protection = ditto - Pxeavation for improvement of existing channelTable X-9-3 Economic Project Cost Estimated for Structural Plan for Qda Areas of Group "B" (unit: x 203 uss) —_____—-Senatmuction Gost _______ Project cost 9 Name of No. of oda Dam Channel Dike Others. ‘Total Works. SEE Q. Chaclacayo (Ri) 3,149.4 2,604.3 = 302.8 6,056.5 9, 448.2 @. Chacrasana (R2) 1,511.3, 1,249.8 - 48.3 -2,906.4 4,834.0 Q. California (R3) 2,100.5 2,233.1 259.7 5,293.3. 8,102.6 Q. Santa Maria (Rd) 1,478.8 3,222.8 - 142.2 2,043.8 4,436.3 . Ba Cantuta (R5) 4,821.8 3,987.3 - 463.6 9,272.8 14, 465.5, Q. La Ronda (R10) 2,992.3 2,391.7 ~ 278.2 5,862.2 8,677.1 Q. Senta Ana (R11) - - 923.9 566.3 1,490.2 2,071.4 Q. Cupiche (R13) - - 636.9 390.3 1,027.2 1,427.8 Q. Rio Canchacalla —-19,221.6 - 426.3 1,245.1 20,893.0 27,160.9 (RLS) Q. Guayabo (R16) 438.7 250.7 - 197.0 895.3 1,101.2 Q. Agua Salada (R17) - - 785.2 481.3 1,266.5 1,760.4 Q. Del Pate (R16) - - 528.5 323.9 952.4 1,184.8 Q. Huacre (R23) - - 286.7 157.4 414.2 575.6 Q. Matata (R24) - - 506-3 310.3 816.6 1,235.1 . Cuchimachay (R25) 848.9 701.0 - 81.6 1,632.5 2,946.7 . Chucumayo (R31) 4,122.6 183.3 847.7. -124.6 2,292.1 2,818.1 . Chacahuacra (R33) 170-7 127.9 - 46.3 348.4 428.6 . Pancha (R34) 5,645.2 - = 90.9 6,136.2 7,976.9 Q. Viso (R35) 2,875.3, - ~ 280.0 3,125.32, 404.2 @, Parac (R37) 10, 639.2 - = 925.1 11,864.315,033.6 Q. Redonda (S2) 790.7 127.4. «589.8 -79-7--1,593.2 1,959.7 Q. Infiernillo ($3) - - 450.6 281.1 739.7 1,028.2 Q. Lucuma ($5) - - 487.5 298.8 786.3 1,093.0 Note : (2) Unit uss x 106 (2) Project cost 1.56 x Construction cost for Al type 4.54 x " for A2 type 1.39 x for Bl type 1123 x for B2 type 1530 x " for ¢ typeTable X-9-4 structures and Its Quantities in Spe Area of Group "B" ~ Rind af Stniictire and Numbar_oxhength Ona) Name and No. of spe Area Bridga Bock.§.‘tunnel__-Retain. Wall other Road Rail _Road__Rai__iligh __Law River mouth-Jicamarca - 7 7 - - 3 (R-7/0) River mough-Chaclacayo - - - - 0.5 17.5 rst) Jicamarca-Chacrasana - - - - 0.5 1.5 (R-0/2) chaclacayo-California - - - - - 0.05 (8-1/3) Santa Maria-guirio - - - _ - ou (R46) la Cantuta-Za Ronda - 7 a 7 7 as (8-5/10) pedregal-Carosio - 7 - - - 0.68 (R-7/8) carosio-corrales - - - - =. 02 (R-8/9) : corrales-Cashauacra - - - - - 02 (R-9/2) and (S~"/1) La Ronda-Confluence - - - - - 0.04 (R-10/-) confluence-Santa Ana ~ - 7 z = 0.32 (R-/11) Confluence-san Juan - - - - - 0,08 7/12) santa hna-Cupiche 1 - 2 1 150 (11/13) cupiche~Guayabo - - 2 5 1.8 0.66 (13/16) Guayabo-agua Salada - - 2 ° 100 (16/17) R. Seco-Eeperanza 1 a 3 5 2.5 0.05 (w-19/20) Esperanza-Verrugas 1 a 6 7 2.8 0.01 (R-20/21) verrugas-Huacre 1 2 3 5 2.0 0.08 (21/23) Linday~Yamajune 1 - 2 - 2.5 0.08 (22/27) chacamaza~Barzanco - - - 7 - 0.04 (R-26/29) Chucumayo-Chacahuaro - - - 3 - 0.9 (833/33) Parac-Rio Blanco 2 2 2 2 - dae (R-37/40) confluence-Alcula - - - - ~ 0.4 "/4) cashahuacya-Redonda - 1 - 5 ~ Ot (8-1/2) Redonda~Infiernillo - - - 4 ~ 0,09 (8-2/3)Table X-9-5 Unit Cost of Typical Structures for Spe Areas of Group ‘ Unit ,Cost Kind of structure Type unit OPs53 bss) 1. Bridge Road No. 139.2 2. Bridge Railway No. 88.0 3. Rockshed tunnel Road No. 127.2 4. Rockshed tunnel Railway No. 42.4 Retaining wall High n 1.2 Retaining wall Low m 0.7 Note: (1) Roadway bridge 1 = 20 m 8 m, US$ 870/n2 (2) Roadway bridge 1 = 20 m, b = 4 m, USS 1,100/m2 (3) Rockshed tunnel (Road) 1 = 30 m, US$ 4,240/m2 (4) Rockshed tunnel (Railway) 1 = 20 m, US$ 2,120/m2 (5) Unit cost of retaining wall includes the cost of slope surface protection works by concrete spraying method for approximately 30 m for high wall section and 20 m for low wall section. Unit cost of spraying works is assumed at US$20 per 1 m@,Table X-9-6 River mouth~Jicamarca (R7/0) River mough-Chaclacayo (R71) Jicamarca-Chacrasana (R-0/2) chaclacayo-California (R-1/3) Santa Maria-Quirio (R-4/6) La Cantuta~La Ronda (R-5/10) Pedregal-Carosio (R-7/8) carosio-Corrales (R-8/9) Corrales~Cashauacra (R-9/1) and (8-7/1) La Ronda-Confluence (R-10/~) conflvence-Santa Ana e/1) conflvence-san Juan (R—7/12) Santa Ana-Cupiche (R-11/13) cupiche-Guayabo (R-13/16) Guayabo~Agua Salada (R-16/17) R. Seco-Esperanza (R-19/20) Eeperanza~Verrugas (R-20/21) Verrugas-Huacre (R-21/23) Linday~Yamajune (R-22/27) chacamaza—Barranco (R-26/29) chucumayo~Chacahuaro (R-31/33) Parac-Rio Blanco (R-37-40) Confluence-Aleula (s—=/4) Cashahuacra-Redonda (8-1/2) Redonda-Infiernillo —1s=2/2. Note; (1) Project Cost = 1.41 * Construction Cost. (2) 1.41 is the mean in case of Qda areas of Group "A" Name and No. of Spe Area ——----_Saniskituction cost ——_____-____ Bridge. Economic Project Cost for Spe Areas of Group "B" conitz x 106 uss) Project Rs Tunnel __R, Wall Others _Total__cost__ 139 227 227 +227 139 454 0.297 0.486 0.254 0.594 1.060 0.594 0.254 0.297 0.127 0.339 0.221 0.170 10.5 12.85 1.65 0.035 0.077 2.08 0.476 0.14 14 0.028, 0.226 0.086 1.8 2.262 1.2 3.035 3.007 2.456 3.028 0.028 0.63 0.784 0.077 0.077 0.063 0.583 0.676 0.087 0.002 0.004 9.055 0.025 0.007 0.007 0.002 0.012 0.003 0.120 0.144 0.076 0.203 0,226 0.172 0.180 0.017 0.040 0,083 0.004 0.015 0.012 11.053 15.585 13.53 ama 0.037 0.081 1.105 0.501 0.297 0.147 0.029 0.236 0.059 2.354 2.072 1.530 4.089 4.820 3.449 3.601 0.342 0.797 1.60 0.081 0.304 0.245, 19. 2. 0. o. Le ° 0. 0.3 0. 0. 0. 3 4s 2 8. 6. 4 5 ° a 2. ° 0 077 453 052 a4 558 .706 207 207 om 333 083 +319 049 157 723 373 +963 077 482 err) 34 14 429 345,table X-9-7 Results of Economic Evaluation for Qdd Areas of Group "B" Projegt Cost BIRR Name and No. of Qda ets uss a Q. Chaclacayo (Ri) 9,448.2 8.99 Q. Chacrasana (R2) 4,534.0 3.19 Q. California (R3) 8,101.6 4.79 Q. Santa Maria (R4) 4,436.3 3.39 Q. La Cantuta (RS) 14, 465-5 0.24 Q. ba Ronda (R10) 8,677.1 2.31 Q. Santa Ana (R11) 2,071.4 11.54 Q. Cupiche (R13) 1,427.8 12.79 Q. Rio Canchacalla (R15) 27,160.9 ~2.09 Q. Guayabo (R16) 4,202.2 14.94 Q. Agua Salada (R17) 1,760.4 10.90 Q. Del Pate (R18) 1,184.8 14.30 Q. Huacre (R23) 515.6 3.75 Q, Matata (R24) 2,135.1 3.71 Q. Cuchimachay (R25) 2,546.7 2.90 Q. Chucumayo (R31) 2,818.1 8.45 Q. Chacahuacra (R33) 428.6 17.90 Q. Pancha (R34) 7,976.9 1.07 Q. Viso (R35) 2,404.2 3.96 Q. Parac (R37) 15, 033.6 -0.89 Q. Redonda (32) 1,959.7 4.12 Q. Infiernillo (53) 1,028.2 5.07 Q. Lucuma ($4) 1,093.0 4.73 Note: Discount rate for Present value is 8%.Table X-9-8 Results of Economic Evaluation for Spe Areas of Group "B" Projegt Cost BIRR (x 107 uss) a Name and No. of Spe Area River mouth-Jicamarea 15,585 0.68 (R-7/0) River mough-Chaclacayo 19,077 0.04 (R-7/1) Jicamarca-Chacrasana 2,453 - (R=0/2) Chaclacayo~California 582 13.67 {R-1/3) Santa Maria-Quirio 0,114 -2.42 (R-4/6) La Cantuta~La Ronda 1,585 -4.06 (R=5/10) Pedregal-Carosio 106 0.15 (R-7/8) carosio-Corrales 207 2.29 (R-8/9) Corrales~Cashavacra 207 0.45 (R-9/1) and (S-"/1) la Ronda~Confluence aa 6.68 (R-10/~) Confluence-Santa Ana 333 6.23 (R-7/21) Confluence-San Juan 83 10.64 (R-7/12) Santa Ana-Cupiche 3,319 5.22 (R-11/12) cupiche-Guayabo 4,049 3.64 (R-13/16) Guayabo-Agua Salada 2,157 3.46 (R-16/17) R. Seco-Esperanza 5,723 4.39 (R-19/20) Esperanza-Verrugas 6,373 4.50 (R-20/21) Verrugas-Huacre 4,863 4.76 (R-21/23) Linday-Yamajune 5,077 4.47 (R-22/27) chacamaza~Barranco 492 1,02 {R-26/29) Chucumayo-Chacahuaro 2,224 3.50 {R-31/33) parac-Rio Blanco 2,340 8.92 (8-37-40) Confluence-alcula a4 9.30 (s-7/4) cashahnacra~Redonda 429 3.02 (S-1/2) Redonda~Infiernillo 345 2.86 (82203)‘Tabla Xti-4 Proposed Proje for Dabs Flow an Spo File Disasior Proven Fraps an Saas Baan Desetison of Prolect Avoas yoo [Dat Ehsina Oe |Ordge| nna Rana] pest ox | ERR sia. Pan| ” [Wouns| Wall" | Gero uss} “¢ sea} tet] tena} event avogt “temp A) Group A (Fist Pry) (a) ounce: 7aroas RS aout a fadas z]-].- a2.) 5.2 R7Q petepat a fos | 4s, ayo] t | ater] se R38 Gcuesi x [a [oa aye ft tas27] 98g) R98 G. comes we fafor}>}i fa] 2 siosas| 6.02] R10 Siiecan ao fet laste | a airasa] 10.4 R32 O.Patua e Jaf: fal Spo: eae] 5.0 St Qcaucca ez ft fos fizsf i | | 2 sos at |—tb sees: Hone = ta) croup @ (Second Pry) (3) Often: 28 aus e.camaey0 a fafaaf- |. |. 2.Chacesart a fa farp oy: 0. Calor a fa faap ops ft Sentara a fafprop oto poy: O.tacenite a fafa} sf: : Olaf a fadaalioy opi yt Seen a |S fosfos] a |: O.cipcho e fs fosfos| a] i]: 2 Carconata e |e jostos|: |i]: cniroo se fafoe/} 4a fit kg Sods a |= fostosy + |i] 2 @.Erpeanea Bt w festa fi |: Otis at f[: fostes| : Ota er |: fosfos| a |: Cewnmacnay wa fadaaf yy poy: Qetacamye se |i for|rs| i f chart pe fi foaf ue} i poy: Orenta e | 3 fos]: ales aso e [2 jos|: a Pare e | 5 fos}: si]: Foxe se ft faafaaf sy fof: ©. Inertia Br |. foeloufs fof: Oluucuea eo [> fosyos] if: |: 24 aoa iver mouth -icamarea |. f |. | 18.0 Five meuth - Checrseaye spe pt pt fe | ie steam - Chea : yt pt pate hocacayo » Calin soft fe ps ft pe | oss Sania Marin Ronda soft de de eps fon ‘uit - Pesreoat seeds Ppl yt pa Podrepal-Caresio sof fe pepe ds | ose Carrio - Contes Ppl pt pi ye ye ‘crries = Ceitvence SEI ‘i 02 La onda -Cononce zi] e |= | 06 Centoonea = Senta Ana spe Pa pips ds fos R--/12 Convene = San Juan fide pipe ya pee R-14/19. Santa Ana-Copiche spade pipe 9 R-12/18 Copiche-Gusyeto SPP PI Po] ly 2 | oe aeteit7 + 2 fifi pipe fades 19/20 PoP DPI Pl] 2 | a8 | ots R.20/21 2 fs fe fe | 2 fe | eo Re21/23 ote fe fe fa | 2 | oe Roza/27 2 fits fe] e fz | ese 2629 fy] ede fe fa | eo f-91/33 Chweamaye-crossmwo | 2 | 2 | 2 2 | a | t | oo 37/40 Paras A. Blanco sof e ps dips fe pe Si-/4 Contonca = Alta ffs fe pede ont 8-1/2 Casajusera = Redonda sft pe pi ya ds pont 5.2/3 Redonda = Infra, stipe tit ta | oe + Inctusing 8-4 Contence - CashahuncraFiguresFig. X-2-1 Division of Quebrada and Slope AreasZA Legend = Group A Group 8 pin Pig. Remarks : Name and features of Quebrada Areas ‘and Slope Areas are respectively shown in Table X-3-! and Table x-3~ 2. X=4-1 Division of Quebrada and Slope areas with Groups A,B and C Classification == aeLegend : Sj Totally Destroyed Area EEEH S Semi Destroyed Area EZA Other Atfected Area Assumed Disaster Area with Classification of Disasier« Totally Destroyed Area EFEBL SEQ Other Attected Area Eats) Fig. X-5-2 Assumed Disaster Area with o> Classification of Disaster Level in <“¢ @ Qda. Quirio (R-6) (Mid. Term)(RQ cent: Cd y S = = Totly Destroyed Aveo HER {Semi Destryed Area Z| AN Other Altected Assumed Disaster Area with Classification of Disaster Level in Qda, Quitio (R-6) ( Short - Term)Legend : Totally Destroyed Area Semi Destrqyed Area ZA Other Attected Area N Qe Assumed Disaster Areo with Classification of Disaster Level in Qda, Pedregal (R-7) (Long Term)