Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Biorefineries Industrial Processes and Products Status Quo and Future Directions PDF
Biorefineries Industrial Processes and Products Status Quo and Future Directions PDF
Edited by
Birgit Kamm,
Patrick R. Gruber,
and Michael Kamm
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
Related Titles
Elvers, B. (Ed.)
Handbook of Fuels
Energy Sources for Transportation
2006
ISBN 3-527-30740-0
Shahidi, F. (Ed.)
Ocic, O.
Volume 1
Edited by
Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, and Michael Kamm
The Editors n All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully
produced. Nevertheless, authors, editors, and
Dr. Birgit Kamm publisher do not warrant the information contained
Research Institute in these books, including this book, to be free of
Bioactive Polymer Systems errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that
biopos e.V. statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or
Kantstr. 55 other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
14513 Teltow
Germany
ISBN-13: 978-3-527-31027-2
ISBN-10: 3-527-31027-4
V
Contents
Foreword XXIII
Henning Hopf
Foreword XXV
Paul T. Anastas
Volume 1
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
VI Contents
3 Development of Biorefineries –
Technical and Economic Considerations 67
Bill Dean, Tim Dodge, Fernando Valle, and Gopal Chotani
3.1 Introduction 67
3.2 Overview: The Biorefinery Model 68
3.3 Feedstock and Conversion to Fermentable Sugar 68
3.3.1 Sucrose 70
3.3.2 Starch 70
3.3.3 Cellulose 71
3.4 Technical Challenges 74
3.4.1 Cellulase Enzymes 74
3.4.1.1 Improved Cellulase Production Economics 74
3.4.1.2 Improved Cellulase Enzyme Performance 76
3.4.2 Fermentation Organisms 77
3.4.2.1 Biomass Hydrolyzate as Fermentable Carbon Source 78
3.4.2.2 Production Process as a Whole 79
3.4.2.3 Emerging Solutions 80
3.5 Conclusions 81
Acknowledgments 82
References 82
Fuel-oriented Biorefineries
10 Sugar-based Biorefinery –
Technology for Integrated Production
of Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate), Sugar, and Ethanol 209
Carlos Eduardo Vaz Rossell, Paulo E. Mantelatto, José A. M. Agnelli,
and Jefter Nascimento
10.1 Introduction 209
10.2 Sugar Cane Agro Industry in Brazil – Historical Outline 209
10.2.1 Sugar and Ethanol Production 209
10.2.2 The Sugar Cane Agroindustry and the Green Cycle 210
10.3 Biodegradable Plastics from Sugar Cane 212
10.3.1 Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) 212
10.3.1.1 Biodegradable Plastics and the Environment 212
10.3.1.2 General Aspects of Biodegradability 213
10.3.2 Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Polymer 214
10.3.2.1 General Characteristics of Poly(3-hydroxybutyric Acid)
and its Copolymer Poly(3-hydroxybutyric Acid-co-3-
hydroxyvaleric Acid) 214
10.3.2.2 Processing of Poly(Hydroxybutyrates) 215
10.4 Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Production Process 217
10.4.1 Sugar Fermentation to Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid)
by Ralstonia eutropha 217
10.4.2 Downstream Processing for Recovery and Purification of Intracellular
Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) 218
10.4.2.1 Processes for Extraction and Purification
of Poly(hydroxyalkanoates) 218
10.4.2.2 Chemical Digestion 218
10.4.2.3 Enzymatic Digestion 219
10.4.2.4 Solvent Extraction 219
10.4.3 Integration of Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Production
in a Sugar Mill 221
XII Contents
Green Biorefineries
17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine
Chemicals from Renewable Resources 385
Thomas Willke, Ulf Prüße, and Klaus-Dieter Vorlop
17.1 Introduction 385
17.1.1 Renewable Resources 385
17.1.2 Products 386
17.1.2.1 Bulk Chemicals and Intermediates 386
17.1.2.2 Fine Chemicals and Specialties 386
17.2 Historical Outline 387
17.3 Processes 388
17.3.1 Immobilization 389
17.3.2 Biocatalytic Routes from Renewable Resources to Solvents
or Fuels 390
17.3.2.1 Ethanol Production with Bacteria or Yeasts? 390
17.3.3 Biocatalytic Route from Glycerol to 1,3-Propanediol 393
17.3.3.1 Introduction 393
17.3.3.2 The Process 393
Contents XVII
Volume 2
7 Protein-based Polymers:
Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering 217
Dan W. Urry
16 Industrial Biotech –
Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential 445
Rolf Bachmann and Jens Riese
Editor’s Preface
In the year 2003 when the idea for this set of books “Biorefineries, Biobased In-
dustrial Processes, and Products” arose, the topic of biorefineries as means of
processing industrial material and efficient utilization of renewable products
had been primarily a side issue beyond the borders of the United States of
America. This situation has changed dramatically over the last two years. Today
in almost every developed and emerging nation much work is being conducted
on biorefinery systems, driven by the rising cost of oil and the desire of to move
away from petrochemical-based systems.
In these books we do not claim to describe and discuss everything that be-
longs or even might belong to the topic of biorefineries – that would be impos-
sible. There are many types of biorefinery, and the state of the technology is
changing very rapidly as new and focused effort is directed toward making bio-
refineries a commercial reality. It is a very exciting time for those interested in
biorefineries – technologies for bio-conversion have advanced to a state in which
they are becoming practical on a large scale, economics are leaning more fa-
vourably to the direction of renewable feedstocks, and chemical process knowl-
edge is being applied to biobased systems.
As the editors of the first comprehensive biorefinery book we saw it as our
duty to provide, first of all, a general framework for the subject – addressing
the main issues associated with biorefineries, the principles and basics of biore-
finery systems, the basic technology, industrial products which fall within the
scope of biorefineries, and, finally, technology and products that will fall within
the scope of biorefineries in the future.
To provide a reliable description of the state of biorefinery research and devel-
opment and of industrial implementations, strategies, and future developments
we asked eighty-five experts from universities, research and development insti-
tutes, and industry and commerce to present their views, their results, their im-
plementations, and their ideas on the topic. The results of their contributions
are thirty-three articles organized into seven sections. Our very special thanks
go to all the authors.
We are especially indebted to Dr. Hubert Pelc from Wiley-VCH publishing,
who worked with us on the concept and then, later, on the development and
implementation of the book. Thanks go also to Dr. Bettina Bems from Wiley-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXII Editor’s Preface
VCH publishing, who managed with admirable professionalism and very much
patience, and to the three editors and eighty-five authors from three different
continents. We are also indebted to Hans-Jochen Schmitt, also of Wiley-VCH
publishing, who had the not always easy task of arranging the manuscripts in a
form ready for publication.
Maybe in 2030, when a biobased economy utilizing biorefinery technology
has become a fundamental part of national and globally connected economies,
someone will wonder what had been thought and written about the subject of
biorefineries at the beginning of the 21st century. Hopefully this book will be
highly representative. Until then we hope it will contribute to the promotion of
international biorefinery developments.
November 2005
XXIII
Foreword
One-hundred-and-fifty years after the beginning of coal-based chemistry and 50
years after the beginning of petroleum-based chemistry industrial chemistry is
now entering a new era. In the twenty-first century utilization of renewable raw
materials will gain importance in the chemical conversion of substances in in-
dustry. Partial or even complete re-adjustment of whole economies to renewable
raw materials will require completely new approaches in research, development,
and production. Chemical and biological sciences will play a leading role in the
building of future industries. New synergies between biological, physical, chem-
ical, and technical sciences must be elaborated and established and special re-
quirements will be placed on raw material and on product-line efficiency and
sustainability. The necessary change from chemistry based on a fossil raw mate-
rial to biology-based modern science and technology is an intellectual challenge
for both researchers and engineers. Chemists should support this change and
collaborate closely with their colleagues in adjoining disciplines, for example
biotechnology, agriculture, forestry, and the material sciences.
The German Chemical Society will help direct this necessary development by
supporting within its structure new kinds of organization for chemists to work
on this subject in universities, research institutes, and industry.
This two-volume book is based on the approach developed by biorefinery-sys-
tems – transfer of the logic and efficiency of today’s petrochemical product lines
and product family trees into manipulation of biomass. Raw biomass materials
are mechanically separated into substances for chemical conversion into other
products by different methods, which may be biotechnological, thermochemical,
and thermal. Review of biomass processes and products developed in the past
but widely forgotten in the petroleum age will be as important as the presenta-
tion of new methods, processes, and products that still require an enormous
amount of research and development today.
Henning Hopf
President of the German Chemical Society
Frankfurt (Germany)
November 2005
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXV
Foreword
On October 5, 2005, the Nobel Prize Committee made an interesting and im-
portant statement with regard to the prize in chemistry. It said, “This represents
a great step forward for ‘green chemistry’, reducing potentially hazardous waste
through smarter production. [This research] is an example of how important ba-
sic science has been applied for the benefit of man, society and the environ-
ment.” By making this statement, the Nobel committee recognized what a new
generation of scientists has known for quite some time, that by working at the
most fundamental level – the molecular level – we are able to design our prod-
ucts, processes, and systems in ways that are sustainable.
There is general recognition that the current system by which we produce the
goods and services needed by society is not sustainable. This unsustainability
takes many forms. It would be legitimate to note that in our current system of
production we rely largely on finite feedstocks extracted from the Earth that are
being depleted at a rate that cannot be sustained indefinitely. It is equally legiti-
mate to recognize that our current production efficiency results in more than
90% of the material used in the production process ending up as waste, i.e. less
than 10% of the material ends up in the desired product. Yet another condition
of unsustainability is in our current energy use; this not only relies largely on fi-
nite energy sources but also results in degradation of the environment that can-
not be continued as the growing population and demands of the developing
world emerge over the course of the twenty-first century. Finally, the products
and processes we have designed since the industrial revolution have accom-
plished their goals without full consideration of their impact and consequence
on humans and the biosphere, with many examples of toxic and hazardous sub-
stances being distributed throughout the globe and into our bodies.
If we are to change this unsustainable path, it will need the direct and com-
mitted engagement of our best scientists and engineers to design the future dif-
ferently from the past. We will need to proceed with a broader perspective such
that when we design for efficiency, effectiveness, and performance, we now
must recognize that these terms include sustainability – a minimized impact
on humans and the environment.
An essential part of meeting the challenge of designing for sustainability will
be based on the nature of the materials we use as starting materials and feed-
stocks. Any sustainable future must ensure that the materials on which we base
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXVI Foreword
our economic infrastructure are renewable rather than depleting. The rate of re-
newability is also important because certainly one could argue that petroleum is
renewable if you have a few million years to wait. Serious analysis would, how-
ever, necessitate that the rate of renewability is connected to the rate of use.
There are options for how to approach this technological challenge, for example
using waste products from one process as a feedstock for another, that are well
thought through in industrial ecology models. There is, however, recognition
that an essential part of a sustainable future will be based on appropriate and
innovative uses of our biologically-based feedstocks.
This book addresses the essential questions and challenges of moving toward
a sustainable society in which bio-based feedstocks, processes, and products are
fundamental pillars of the economy. The authors discuss not only the important
scientific and technical issues surrounding this transition but also the necessary
topics of economics, infrastructure, and policy. It is only by means of this type
of holistic approach that movement toward genuine sustainability will be able
to occur where the societal, economic, and environmental needs are met for the
current generation while preserving the ability of future generations to meet
their needs.
While it will be clear to the reader that the topics presented in this book are
important, it is at least as important that the reader understand that these topics
– and the transition to a sustainable path that they address – are urgent. At this
point in history it is necessary that all who are capable of advancing the transi-
tion to a more sustainable society, engage in doing so with the level of energy,
innovation, and creativity that is required to meet the challenge.
Paul T. Anastas
Director of the Green Chemistry Institute
Washington, D.C.
November, 2005
XXVII
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXVIII List of Contributors
Seungdo Kim
Department of Chemical Engineering
and Materials Science
Michigan State University
East Lansing, MI 48824
USA
List of Contributors XXXI
Todd Werpy
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
P.O. Box 999/K2-12
Richland, WA 99352
USA
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part I
Background and Outline – Principles and Fundamentals
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
3
1
Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
Birgit Kamm, Michael Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, and Stefan Kromus
1.1
Introduction
The preservation and management of our diverse resources are fundamental po-
litical tasks to foster sustainable development in the 21st century. Sustainable
economic growth requires safe and sustainable resources for industrial produc-
tion, a long-term and confident investment and finance system, ecological
safety, and sustainable life and work perspectives for the public. Fossil resources
are not regarded as sustainable, however, and their availability is more than
questionable in the long-term. Because of the increasing price of fossil re-
sources, moreover, the feasibility of their utilization is declining.
It is, therefore, essential to establish solutions which reduce the rapid con-
sumption of fossil resources, which are not renewable (petroleum, natural gas,
coal, minerals). A forward looking approach is the stepwise conversion of large
parts of the global economy into a sustainable biobased economy with bio-
energy, biofuels, and biobased products as its main pillars (Fig. 1.1).
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
4 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
1.2
Historical Outline
1.2.1
Historical Technological Outline and Industrial Resources
Today’s biorefinery technologies are based (1) on the utilization of the whole
plant or complex biomass and (2) on integration of traditional and modern pro-
cesses for utilization of biological raw materials. In the 19th and the beginning
of the 20th century large-scale utilization of renewable resources was focused
on pulp and paper production from wood, saccharification of wood, nitration of
cellulose for guncotton and viscose silk, production of soluble cellulose for fi-
bers, fat curing, and the production of furfural for Nylon. Furthermore, the
technology of sugar refining, starch production, and oil milling, the separation
of proteins as feed, and the extraction of chlorophyll for industrial use with al-
falfa as raw material were of great historical importance. But also processes like
wet grinding of crops and biotechnological processes like the production of
ethanol, acetic acid, lactic acid, and citric acid used to be fundamental in the
19th and 20th century.
1.2 Historical Outline 5
1.2.2
The Beginning – A Digest
Ethanol can be used as fuel either blended with traditional hydrocarbon fuel or
as pure ethanol. Ethanol is also an important platform chemical for further pro-
cessing [8].
1.2.2.4 Furfural
Döbereiner was the first to report the formation and separation of furfural by
distillation of bran with diluted sulfuric acid in 1831. In 1845 the English Che-
mist G. Fownes proposed the name “furfurol” (furfur – bran; oleum – oil). Later
the suffix “ol” was changed to “al” because of the aldehyde function [9, 10].
Treatment of hemicellulose-rich raw materials with dry steam in the presence of
hydrogen chloride gave especially good results [11]. Industrial technology for pro-
duction of furfural from pentose is based on a development of an Anglo-American
company named Quaker Oats. The process was been developed in the nineteen-
twenties [E. P. 203 691 (1923), F. P. 570 531 (1923)]. Since 1922 Quaker Oats Cereal
Mill in Cedar Rapids/Iowa, USA, has produced up to 2.5 tons of furfural per day
from oat husks. Since 1934 the process had been established as an industrial fur-
fural plant. Furfural was the cheapest aldehyde, at 16–17 cents per lb (lb = pound;
1 metric ton = 1000 kg = 2204.62442 lb; 1 kg = 0.453592 lb) [12]. Until approxi-
mately 1960 DuPont used furfural as a precursor of Nylon-6.6. Furfural has since
been substituted by fossil based precursors.
1.2.2.7 Lipids
From 1850 onward European import of tropical plant fats, for example palm-oil
and coconut oil, started. Together with the soda process, invented by the French
N. Leblanc in 1791, the industrialization of the soap production began and soap
changed from luxury goods into consumer goods. The developing textile indus-
try also demanded fat based products. In 1902 the German chemist W. Nor-
mann discovered that liquid plant oils are converting into tempered fat by aug-
mentation of hydrogen. Using nickel as catalyst Norman produced tempered
stearic acid by catalytic hydration of liquid fatty acids [19]. The so called “fat
hardening” led to the use of European plant oils in the food industry (marga-
rine) and other industries.
factories, and the leather, textile, and food industries made the company the
leading supplier. In 1932 W. H. Carothers, who was also the inventor of polya-
mide-6.6, developed, together with van Natta, a polyester made from lactic acid,
poly(lactic acid) [24]. In the late 1990s this poly(lactic acid) was commercialized
by the company NatureWorks (Cargill, the former Cargill Dow) [25].
1.2.3
The Origins of Integrated Biobased Production
In the year 1940 the German chemist P. von Walden (noted for his “Inversion
of configuration at substitution reactions”, the so-called “Walden-Reversion”) cal-
culated that in 1940 Germany produced 13 million tons of cellulose leaving 5 to
6 million tons of lignin suitable only as wastage. He then formulated the ques-
tion: How long can national economy tolerate this [26]? Approaches to inte-
grated production during industrial processing of renewable primary products
have a long tradition, starting from the time when industrial cellulose produc-
tion expanded continuously, as also did the related waste-products. Typical ex-
amples of this will be mentioned.
As early as 1878 A. Mitscherlich, a German chemist, started to improve the
sulfite pulp process by fermentation of sugar to ethyl alcohol – it should be
mentioned that sugar is a substance in the waste liquor during sulfite pulp pro-
duction. He also put into practice a procedure to obtain paper glue from the
waste liquor. Both processes were implemented in his plant located in Hof, Ger-
many, in the year 1898 [27].
In 1927 the American Marathon Corporation assigned a group of chemists
and engineers to the task of developing commercial products from the organic
solids in the spent sulfite liquor from the Marathon’s Rothschild pulp and paper
operations close to Wausau, Wisconsin, USA. The first products to show prom-
ise were leather tanning agents. Later, the characteristics of lignin as dispersing
agents became evident. By the mid 1930s, with a considerable amount of basic
research accomplished, Marathon transferred operations from a research pilot
plant to full-scale production [28].
One of the most well known examples is the production of furfural by the Qua-
ker Oats Company since 1922, thus coupling food, i.e. oat flakes, production and
chemical products obtained from the waste [10] (Section 1.2.2). On the basis of fur-
fural a whole section of chemical production developed – furan chemistry.
Agribusiness, especially, strived to achieve combined production from the very
beginning. Modern corn refining started in the middle of the 18th century
when T. Kingsford commenced operation of his corn refining plant in Oswego,
New York [29]. Corn refining is distinguished from corn milling because the re-
fining process separates corn grain into its components, for example starch, fi-
ber, protein and oil, and starch is further processed into a substantial number
of products [30].
The extensive usage of green crops has been aim of industry for decades, be-
cause there are several advantages. Particularly worthy of mention is the work
1.2 Historical Outline 9
of Osborn (1920) and Slade and Birkinshaw (1939) on the extraction of proteins
from green crops, for example grass or alfalfa [31].
In 1937 N. W. Pirie developed the technical separation and extraction methods
needed for this use of green crops [32, 33]. By means of sophisticated methods
all the botanical material should have been used, both for production of animal
feed, isolated proteins for human nutrition, and as raw material for further in-
dustrial processes, for example glue production. The residual material, juices
rich in nutrients, had initially been used as fertilizer; later they were used for
generation of fermentation heat based on biogas production [34, 35].
These developments resulted in market-leading technology, for example the
Proxan and Alfaprox procedures, used for generation of protein–xanthophyll
concentrates, including utilization of the by-products, however, predominantly
in agriculture [36].
In the United States commercial production of chlorophyll and carotene by
extraction from alfalfa leaf meal had started in 1930 [37, 38]. For example
Strong, Cobb and Company produced 0.5 ton chlorophyll per day from alfalfa
as early as 1952. The water-soluble chlorophyll, or chlorophyllin, found use as
deodorizing agent in toothpastes, soaps, shampoos, candy, deodorants, and
pharmaceuticals [39].
A historical important step for today’s biorefinery developments was the in-
dustry-politics-approach of “Chemurgy”, founded in 1925 in the US by the Che-
mist W. J. Hale, son-in-law of H. Dow, the founder of Dow Chemical, and C. H.
Herty, a former President of the American Chemical Society. They soon found
prominent support from H. Ford and T. A. Edisons. Chemurgy, an abbreviation
of “chemistry” and “ergon”, the Greek word for work [40], means by analogy
“chemistry from the acre” that is the connection of agriculture with the chemi-
cal industry.
Chemurgy was soon shown to have a serious industrial political philosophy –
the objective of utilizing agricultural resources, nowadays called renewable re-
sources, in industry. There have been common conferences between agriculture,
industry, and science since 1935 with a national council called the “National
Farm Chemurgic Council” [41]. The end of Chemurgy started with the flooding
of the world market with cheap crude oil after World War II; numerous inven-
tions and production processes remained, however, and are again highly news-
worthy. One was a car, introduced by Henry Ford 1941, whose car interior lin-
ing and car body consisted 100% of bio-synthetics; to be specific it had been
made from a cellulose meal, soy meal, formaldehyde resin composite material
in the proportions 70% : 20% : 10%, respectively. The alternative fuel for this car
was pyrolysis methanol produced from cannabis. Throughout the thirties more
than 30 industrial products based on soy bean were created by researchers from
the Ford company; this made it necessary to apply complex conversion methods
[42]. Hale was a Pioneer of ethyl alcohol and hydrocarbon fuel mixture (Power
Alcohol, Gasohol) [43]. This fuel mixture, nowadays called E10-Fuel, consisting
of 10 percent bioethanol and 90 percent hydrocarbon-based fuel, has been the
national standard since the beginning of this millennium in the United States.
10 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
Associated with the work of Bergius, 1933 [44], and Scholler, 1923 and 1935
[45, 46], wood saccharification was reanimated at the end of WW II. Beside opti-
mization of the process, use of lignocelluloses was of great interest. The con-
tinuously growing agribusiness left behind millions of tons of unused straw.
Two Americans, Othmer and Katzen, were the main pioneers in the field of
wood saccharification [47]. Between the years 1935 and 1960 several hydrolysis
plants were built in Germany and the United States; in these deal, wood flour,
surplus lumber, and also straw were hydrolyzed [48]. One of the most well
known plants are those of Scholler/Tornesch located in Tornesch, Germany,
with a production rate of 13,000 tons per year, in Dessau, Germany, production
rate 42,000 tons per year, based on wood, in Holzminden, Germany, production
rate of 24,000 tons per year, also based on wood, in Ems, Switzerland, with a
production rate of 35,000 tons per year, also wood based, and the plants in Ma-
dison and Springfield, United States, and the Bergius plants in Rheinau, Ger-
many (Rheinau I, built 1930, with a production rate of 8000 tons per year, based
on surplus lumber; Rheinau II, built 1960 with a production rate of 1200 tons
per year, based on wood) and the plant in Regensburg, Germany, with a produc-
tion rate of 36,000 tons per year [49].
During WW II the plant in Springfield, Oregon, US (using the Scholler-Tor-
nesch process as modified by Katzen) produced 15,000 gallons of ethyl alcohol
per day from 300 tons wood flour and sawdust, i.e. 50 gallons per ton of wood
[50]. The plant in Tornesch, Germany, has been producing approximately 200 li-
ters of ethyl alcohol, purity 100%, per ton wood and approximately 40 kg yeast
per ton of wood. In 1965 there were 14 plants in what was then the Soviet
Union, with a total capacity of 700,000 tons per year and an overall annual
wood consumption of 4 million tons [6].
During the nineteen-sixties wood chemistry had its climax. Projects had been
developed, which made it possible to produce nearly all chemical products on
the basis of wood. Examples are the complex chemical technological approaches
of wood processing from Timell 1961 [51], Stamm 1964 [52], James 1969 [53],
Brink and Pohlmann 1972 [54], and the wood-based chemical product trees by
Oshima 1965 [55]. Although these developments did not make their way into in-
dustrial production, they are an outstanding platform for today’s lignocellulose
conversions, product family trees, and LCF biorefineries (Section 1.5.2).
Most of the above mentioned technologies and products, some of which were
excellent, could not compete with the fossil-based industry and economy; nowa-
days, however, they are prevailing again. The basis for this revival started in the
seventies, when the oil crisis and continuously increasing environmental pollution
resulted in a broad awareness that plants could be more than food and animal
feed. At the same time the disadvantages of intensive agricultural usage, for exam-
ple over-fertilization, soil erosion, and the enormous amounts of waste, were re-
vealed. From this situation developed complex concepts, which have been pub-
lished, in which the aim was, and still is, technological and economical coopera-
tion of agriculture, forestry, the food-production industry, and conventional indus-
try, or at least consideration of integrated utilization of renewable resources.
1.3 Situation 11
1.3
Situation
1.3.1
Some Current Aspects of Biorefinery Research and Development
Since the beginning of the 1990s the utilization of renewable resources for pro-
duction of non-food products has fostered research and development which has
received increasing attention from industry and politicians [68–70]. Integrated
processes, biomass refinery technology, and biorefinery technology have become
object of research and development. Accordingly, the term “biorefinery” was es-
tablished in the 1990s [1, 71–80]. The respective biorefinery projects are focused
on the fabrication of fuels, solvents, chemicals, plastics, and food for human
beings. In some countries these biorefinery products are made from waste bio-
mass. At first the main processes in the biorefinery involved ethanol fermenta-
tion for fuels (ethanol-oriented biorefineries) [81–85], lactic acid (LA) fermenta-
tion [25, 86], propanediol (PDO) fermentation [87], and the lysine fermentation
[88] especially for polymer production. The biobased polymers poly(lactic acid)
[25], propandiol-derived polymers [89], and polylysine [88] have been completed
by polyhydroxyalkanoates [90] and polymerized oils [91].
Many hybrid technologies were developed from different fields, for example
bioengineering, polymer chemistry, food science and agriculture. Biorefinery sys-
tems based on cereals [92, 93], lignocelluloses [94, 95], and grass and alfalfa [35,
96], and biorefinery optimization tools are currently being developed [97, 98].
The integration of molecular plant genetics to support the raw material supply
is currently being discussed intensely [99, 100].
12 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
Broin and Associates has begun the development of a second generation of dry
mill refineries and E. I. du Pont de Nemours has developed an integrated corn-
based biorefinery. In 2001 NatureWorks LCC (to Cargill, former Cargill Dow
LLC) started the industrial production of PLA (PLA-oriented Biorefinery) on the
basis of maize.
Biorefineries are of interest ecologically [101], economically, and to business,
government, and politicians [102–107]. National programs [108, 109], biobased
visions [110], and plans [111] have been developed and the international ex-
change of information is increasing, for example as a result, among others, of
series of international congresses and symposia:
1. BIO World Congress on Industrial Biotechnology and Bioprocessing [112];
2. biomass conferences [113, 114];
3. The Green and Sustainable Chemistry Congress [115]; and
4. the Biorefinica symposia series [116, 117].
1.3.2
Raw Material Biomass
Fig. 1.2 Products and product classes based on biological raw materials [78].
14 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
cardboard, construction, and chemical industries. Field fruits are an pool of or-
ganic chemicals from which fuels, chemicals, chemical products, and biomate-
rials are produced (Fig. 1.2), [69]. Waste biomass and biomass of nature and
agricultural cultivation are valuable organic reservoirs of raw material and must
be used in accordance with their organic composition. During the development
of biorefinery systems the term “waste biomass” will become obsolete in the
medium-term [119].
1.3.3
National Vision and Goals and Plan for Biomass Technology in the United States
The Biomass Advisory Committee has established specific research and develop-
ment objectives for feedstock production research. Target crops should include
oil and cellulose-producing crops that can provide optimum energy content and
usable plant components. Currently, however, there is a lack of understanding
of plant biochemistry and inadequate genomic and metabolic information about
many potential crops. Specific research to produce enhanced enzymes and
chemical catalysts could advance biotechnology capabilities.
1.3.4
Vision and Goals and Plan for Biomass Technology
in the European Union and Germany
Member States of the EU have been requested to define national guidelines for
a minimum amounts of biofuels and other renewable fuels (with a reference
value of 2% by 2005 and 5.75% by 2010 calculated on the basis of energy con-
tent of all petrol and diesel fuels for transport purposes). Table 1.2 summarizes
this goal of the EU and also those of Germany with regard to establishment of
renewable energy and biofuel [122, 123].
Today there are no guidelines concerning “biobased products” in the Europe-
an Union and in Germany. After passing directives relating to bioenergy and
biofuels, however, such a decision is on the political agenda. The “biofuels” di-
rective already includes ethanol, methanol, dimethyl ether, hydrogen, and bio-
mass pyrolysis which are fundamental product lines of the future biobased
chemical industry.
16 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
1.4
Principles of Biorefineries
1.4.1
Fundamentals
Fig. 1.3 Comparison of the basic-principles of the petroleum refinery and the biorefinery.
18 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
hemicellulose composites [129]. These treatments are still mostly thermal, ther-
momechanical, or thermochemical, and require considerable input of energy.
The arsenal for microbial conversion of substances from glucose is large, and
the reactions are energetically profitable. It is necessary to combine degradation
1.4 Principles of Biorefineries 19
processes via glucose to bulk chemicals with the building processes to their sub-
sequent products and materials (Fig. 1.5).
Among the variety of microbial and chemical products possibly accessible
from glucose, lactic acid, ethanol, acetic acid, and levulinic acid, in particular,
are favorable intermediates for generation of industrially relevant product family
trees. Here, two potential strategies are considered: first, development of new,
possibly biologically degradable products (follow-up products from lactic and le-
vulinic acids) or, second, entry as intermediates into conventional product lines
(acrylic acid, 2,3-pentanedione) of petrochemical refineries [78].
1.4.2
Definition of the Term “Biorefinery”
1.4.3
The Role of Biotechnology
1.4.4
Building Blocks, Chemicals and Potential Screening
A team from Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) and NREL sub-
mitted a list of twelve potential biobased chemicals [98]. A key area of the inves-
tigation as biomass precursors, platforms, building blocks, secondary chemicals,
intermediates, products and uses (Fig. 1.8).
The final selection of 12 building blocks began with a list of more than 300
candidates. A shorter list of 30 potential candidates was selected by using an
iterative review process based on the petrochemical model of building blocks,
chemical data, known market data, properties, performance of the potential can-
didates, and previous industry experience of the team at PNNL and NREL. This
list of 30 was ultimately reduced to 12 by examining the potential markets for
the building blocks and their derivatives and the technical complexity of the
synthetic pathways.
The reported block chemicals can be produced from sugar by biological and
chemical conversions. The building blocks can be subsequently converted to
several high-value biobased chemicals or materials. Building-block chemicals, as
considered for this analysis, are molecules with multiple functional groups with
the potential to be transformed into new families of useful molecules. The
twelve sugar-based building blocks are 1,4-diacids (succinic, fumaric, and malic),
2,5-furandicarboxylic acid, 3-hydroxypropionic acid, aspartic acid, glucaric acid,
glutamic acid, itaconic acid, levulinic acid, 3-hydroxybutyrolactone, glycerol, sor-
bitol, and xylitol/arabinitol [98].
A second-tier group of building blocks was also identified as viable candi-
dates. These include gluconic acid, lactic acid, malonic acid, propionic acid, the
triacids citric and aconitic, xylonic acid, acetoin, furfural, levuglucosan, lysine,
serine, and threonine. Recommendations for moving forward include:
· examining top value products from biomass components, for example aro-
matic compounds, polysaccharides, and oils;
· evaluating technical challenges in more detail in relation to chemical and bio-
logical conversion; and
· increasing the suites of potential pathways to these candidates.
1.5 Biorefinery Systems and Design 23
Fig. 1.8 Model of a biobased product flow-chart for biomass feedstock [98].
No products simpler than syngas were selected. For the purposes of this study
hydrogen and methanol comprise the best short-term prospects for biobased
commodity chemical production, because obtaining simple alcohols, aldehydes,
mixed alcohols, and Fischer-Tropsch liquids from biomass is not economically
viable and requires additional development [98].
1.5
Biorefinery Systems and Design
1.5.1
Introduction
Biobased products are prepared for a usable economic use by meaningful com-
bination of different methods and processes (physical, chemical, biological, and
thermal). It is therefore necessary that basic biorefinery technologies are devel-
oped. For this reason profound interdisciplinary cooperation of various disci-
plines in research and development is inevitable. It seems reasonable, therefore,
to refer to the term “biorefinery design”, which means: “bringing together well
founded scientific and technological basics, with similar technologies, products,
and product lines, inside biorefineries”. The basic conversions of each biorefin-
ery can be summarized as follows. In the first step, the precursor-containing
biomass is separated by physical methods. The main products (M1–Mn) and the
by-products (B1–Bn) will subsequently be subjected to microbiological or chemi-
24 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
cal methods. The follow-up products (F1–Fn) of the main and by-products can
also be converted or enter the conventional refinery (Fig. 1.6).
Currently four complex biorefinery systems are used in research and develop-
ment:
1. the “lignocellulosic feedstock biorefinery” which use “nature-dry” raw
material, for example cellulose-containing biomass and waste;
2. the “whole crop biorefinery” which uses raw material such as cereals or
maize;
3. the “green biorefineries” which use “nature-wet” biomasses such as green
grass, alfalfa, clover, or immature cereal [78, 79]; and
4. the “biorefinery two platforms concept” includes the sugar platform and the
syngas platform [98].
1.5.2
Lignocellulosic Feedstock Biorefinery
Fig. 1.9 A possible general equation for conversion at the LCF biorefinery.
1.5 Biorefinery Systems and Design 25
There are, however, still some unsatisfactory aspects of the LCF, for example
the utilization of lignin as fuel, adhesive, or binder. Unsatisfactory because the
lignin scaffold contains substantial amounts of mono-aromatic hydrocarbons,
which, if isolated in an economically efficient way, could add a significant in-
crease in value to the primary processes. It should be noticed there are no natu-
ral enzymes capable of splitting the naturally formed lignin into basic mono-
mers as easily as is possible for natural polymeric carbohydrates or proteins
[137].
An attractive process accompanying the biomass-nylon-process is the already
mentioned hydrolysis of the cellulose to glucose and the production of ethanol.
Some yeasts cause disproportionation of the glucose molecule during their gen-
eration of ethanol from glucose, which shifts almost all its metabolism into
ethanol production, making the compound obtainable in 90% yield (w/w; with
regard to the chemical equation for the process).
On the basis of recent technology a plant has been conceived for production
of the main products furfural and ethanol from LC feedstock from West Central
Missouri (USA). Optimal profitability can be achieved with a daily consumption
of approximately 4360 tons of feedstock. The plant produces 47.5 million gallon
of ethanol and 323,000 tons of furfural annually [74].
Ethanol can be used as a fuel additive. It is also a connecting product to the
petrochemical refinery, because it can be converted into ethene by chemical
methods and it is well-known that ethene is at the start of a series of large-scale
technical chemical syntheses for production of important commodities such as
polyethylene or poly(vinyl acetate). Other petrochemically produced substances,
for example hydrogen, methane, propanol, acetone, butanol, butandiol, itaconic
acid, and succinic acid, can also be manufactured by microbial conversion of
glucose [138, 139].
1.5.3
Whole-crop Biorefinery
Raw materials for the “whole crop biorefinery” are cereals such as rye, wheat,
triticale, and maize. The first step is mechanical separation into corn and straw,
approximately 10 and 90% (w/w), respectively [140]. Straw is a mixture of chaff,
nodes, ears, and leaves. The straw is an LC feedstock and may further be pro-
cessed in a LCF biorefinery.
There is the possibility of separation into cellulose, hemicellulose, and lignin
and their further conversion in separate product lines which are shown in the
LCF biorefinery. The straw is also a starting material for production of syngas
by pyrolysis technology. Syngas is the basic material for synthesis of fuels and
methanol (Fig. 1.13).
The corn may either be converted into starch or used directly after grinding to
meal. Further processing may be conducted by four processes – breaking up, plas-
ticization, chemical modification, or biotechnological conversion via glucose. The
meal can be treated and finished by extrusion into binder, adhesives, and filler.
1.5 Biorefinery Systems and Design 27
generates other products (e.g. gluten meal, gluten feed, oil) [62]. An overview
about the product range is shown in Fig. 1.15.
1.5.4
Green Biorefinery
Green biorefineries are also multi-product systems and furnish cuts, fractions,
and products in accordance with the physiology of the corresponding plant ma-
terial, which maintains and utilizes the diversity of syntheses achieved by na-
ture. Most green biomass is green crops, for example grass from cultivation of
permanent grass land, closure fields, nature reserves, or green crops, such as lu-
cerne, clover, and immature cereals from extensive land cultivation. Green crops
are a natural chemical factory and food plant and are primarily used as forage
and as a source of leafy vegetables. A process called wet-fractionation of green
biomass, green crop fractionation, can be used for simultaneous manufacture
of both food and non food items [145].
Scientists in several countries, in Europe and elsewhere, have developed green
crop fractionation [146–148]. Green crop fractionation is now studied in approxi-
mately 80 countries [149]. Several hundred temperate and tropical plant species
have been investigated for green crop fractionation [148, 150, 151] and more
than 300,000 higher plants species have still to be investigated. The subject has
been covered by several reviews [73, 146–148, 151–155]. Green biorefineries can,
30 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
by fractionation of green plants, process from a few tonnes of green crops per
hour (farm scale process) to more than 100 tonnes per hour (industrial scale
commercial process).
Careful wet fractionation technology is used as a first step (primary refinery)
to isolate the contents of the green crop (or humid organic waste goods) in their
natural form. Thus, they are separated into a fiber-rich press cake (PC) and a
nutrient-rich green juice (GJ).
The advantages of the green biorefinery are high biomass profit per hectare,
good coupling with agricultural production, and low price of the raw materials.
Simple technology can be used and there is good biotechnical and chemical po-
tential for further conversion (Fig. 1.16). Rapid primary processing or use of
preservation methods, for example silage production or drying, are necessary,
both for the raw materials and the primary products, although each method of
preservation changes the content of the materials.
In addition to cellulose and starch, the press cake contains valuable dyes and
pigments, crude drugs and other organic compounds. The green juice contains
proteins, free amino acids, organic acids, dyes, enzymes, hormones, other or-
ganic substances, and minerals. Application of the methods of biotechnology re-
sults in conversion, because the plant water can simultaneously be used for
further treatment. In addition, the lignin–cellulose composite is not as intract-
able as lignocellulose-feedstock materials. Starting from green juice the main fo-
cus is directed toward products such as lactic acid and its derivatives, amino
acids, ethanol, and proteins. The press cake can be used for production of green
feed pellets, as raw material for production of chemicals, for example levulinic
acid, and for conversion to syngas and hydrocarbons (synthetic biofuels). The
residues of substantial conversion are suitable for production of biogas com-
bined with generation of heat and electricity (Fig. 1.17). Reviews have been pub-
lished on the concepts, contents, and goals of the green biorefinery [73, 75,
119].
1.5.5
Two-platform Concept and Syngas
Fig. 1.18 The sugar platform and the syngas platform [131].
for example saccharification and syngas technology. The sugar platform also en-
ables access to a huge range of family tree-capable chemicals (Figs. 1.7 and 1.8).
In-situ conversion of biomass feedstock into liquid or gas could be one way of
using existing infrastructure (developed pipe network), but with the disadvan-
tages of the need to remove hetero-atoms (O, N, S) and minerals present in the
biomass and the highly endothermic nature of the syngas process [157]. Cur-
rently, production of simple alcohols, aldehydes, mixed alcohols, and Fischer-
Tropsch liquids from biomass is not economically viable and additional develop-
ments are required [98] (Fig. 1.19).
1.6
Outlook and Perspectives
References
1 National Research Council; Biobased In- tres, Anné 1748 [Preußische Akademie,
dustrial Products, Priorities for Research Berlin, 1749]
and Commercialization [National Aca- 3 Marggraf, A. S.; Chym. Schriften (Che-
demic Press, Washington D.C., 2000, mische Schriften) 2 Bd., Berlin 1761 till
ISBN 0-309-05392-7] a) 74 1767
2 Marggraf, A. S.; In: Histoire de l’Acadé- 4 Kirchhoff, G. S. C.; Schweigers Journal für
mie Royale des Sciences et Belles Let- Chemie und Physik, 4 (1812) 108
34 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
5 Graebe, C.; History of Organic Chemis- das aromatische Princip der Vanille. Ber.
try. Bd 1 [Verlag Julius Springer, Berlin, dt. chem. Ges., 7 (1874) 608–623
1920, germ.] a) 28, b) 122 f 22 Dignum, M. J. W.; Kerler, J., Verpoorte,
6 Kosaric, N.; Vardar-Sukan, F.; Potential R.; Vanilla Production: Technological,
Sources of Energy and Chemical Prod- Chemical and Biosynthetic Aspects. Food
ucts; In: The Biotechnology of Ethanol Rev. Intern., 17 (2001) 199–219.
[M. Roehr (ed.), Wiley–VCH, Weinheim 23 Vaupel, L., Vanille and Vanillin. Pharm.
et al, 2001 ISBN 3-527-30199-2] 132 Zeit., 38 (2002)
7 Prescott, S. C.; Dunn, C. G.; Industrial 24 Carothers, H.; Dorough, G. L.; and Van
Microbiology. 3rd Ed. [McGraw-Hill, Natta, F. J.; J. Am. Chem. Soc., 54 (1932)
New York, Toronto, London, 1959] 761
8 Osteroth, D.; From Coal to Biomass 25 Gruber, P. R.; O’Brien, M.; Polylactides
[Springer, New York, 1989, ISBN 0-387- “Nature Works” PLA; In: Biopolymers,
50712-4, germ.] 192 ff Polyester III [Y. Doi, A. Steinbüchel
9 McKillip, W. J.; Furan and Derivatives in (eds.), Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002]
Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Industrial 26 Walden, P., History of Organic Chemis-
Chemistry. 6th Ed., Vol. 15 [Wiley–VCH, try since 1880. Bd. 2 [Graebe, C. (Ed.),
Weinheim, 2003] 187 ff Verlag Julius Springer, Berlin, 1941,
10 www.furan.com germ.] 686
11 Pringsheim, H.; Cellulosechemie, 2 (1921) 27 Pötsch, W. R.; Lexicon of famous Chem-
123 ists. [Bibliographisches Institut, Leipzig,
12 Ullmann, F.; Enzyklopädie der Tech- 1988, ISBN 3-323-00185-0, germ.] a) 305
nischen Chemie. 2. Aufl., 5. Bd. [Urban 28 Borregaard LignoTech; marathon co.;
und Schwarzenberg, Berlin und Wien, http://www.ltus.com.
1930] 442 ff 29 Peckham; B. W.; The First Hundred
13 Payen, A.; Comptes rendus de l’Académie Years of Corn Refining in the United
des Sciences (C. r.), 8 (1839) 51 States. In Corn Annual 2000 [Corn Refi-
14 Gruber, E.; Krause Th., Schurz, J.: Cellu- ners Association, Washington, DC, 2000]
lose; In: Ullmann, Enzyklopädie der 30 Johnson, D. L.; The Corn Wet milling
technischen Chemie, 4. Aufl. Bd. 9 [Ver- and Corn Dry milling industry [in this
lag Chemie, Weinheim, 1975] 184–191 book, 2005]
15 Mulder, G. J.; J. Prakt. Chem., 21 (1840) 31 Slade, R. E.; Birkinshaw, J. H. (ICI); Im-
219 provement in or related to the utilization
16 A. E. Staley, Mfg. Co. A. E. (Decatur Ill.); of grass and other green crops. Brit. Pat.
Levulinic Acid 1942 [C.A. 36, 1612] BP 511,525 (1939)
17 Kitano et al., Levulinic Acid, A New 32 Pirie, N. W.; Chem. Ind., 61 (1942) 45
Chemical Raw Material – Its Chemistry 33 Pirie, N. W.; Nature, 149 (1942) 251
and Use. Chemical Economy and Engi- 34 Heier, W.; Grundlagen der Landtechnik 33
neering Review (1975) 25–29 (1983) 45–55
18 Leonard, R. H.; Levulinic acid as a Basic 35 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; The Green Biore-
Chemical Raw Material. Ind. Eng. Chem., finery – Principles, Technologies and
1956, 1331–1341 Products. In: Proceed. 2nd Intern. Symp.
19 Norman, W.; Process for Converting Un- Green Biorefinery, October, 13–14, 1999
saturated Fatty Acids or their Glycerides [SUSTAIN (eds), Feldbach, Austria, 1999]
into Saturated Compounds. BP 1515 , S. 46–69
1903 36 Knuckles, B. E.; Bickoff, E. M.; Kohler,
20 Sandermann, W.; Grundlagen der Che- G. O.; J. Agric. Food Chem., 20 (1972)
mie und chemischen Technologie des 1055
Holzes [Akademische Verlagsge- 37 Schertz, F. M.; Ind. Eng. Chem., 30
sellschaft, Leipzig, 1956] 147 (1938) 1073–1075
21 Tiemann, F., Haarmann, W., Ueber das 38 Shearon, W. H.; Gee, O. F.; Ind. Eng.
Coniferin und seine Umwandlung in Chem., 41 (1949) 218–226
References 35
39 Judah, M. A.; Burdack, E. M.; Caroll, 57 Shen, S. Y.; Wood Grass Production Sys-
R. G.; Ind. Eng. Chem., 46 (1954) 2262– tems for Biomass. Proceed. Midwest For-
2271 est Economist Meeting, Duluth, Minne-
40 Hale, W. J.: The Farm Chemurgic [The sota, April 1982
Stratford Co., Boston, 1934] 58 Shen, S. Y.; Biological Engineering for
41 Borth, Ch.; Pioneers of Plenthy [Bobbs- Sustainable Biomass Production; In: Bio-
Merril Co, Indianapolis, New York, 1939] diversity [E. O. Wilson, Harvard Univer-
42 Lewis, D. L.; The Public Image of Henry sity (ed.), National Academy of Sciences/
Ford [Wayne State University Press, De- Smithsonian Institution, National Aca-
troit, 1976] demic Press, Washington DC, 1988, Ger-
43 Brandt, E. N.; Growth Company – Dow man Edition: “Ende der biologischen
Chemical’s First Century [Michigan State Vielfalt?”, 1992, ISBN 3-89330-661-7]
University press, East Lansing, 1997] 404–416
44 Bergius, F.; Trans. Inst. Chem. Eng. (Lon- 59 Carlsson, R.; Trends for future applica-
don), 11 (1933) 162 tions of green crops. In: Forage Protein
45 Scholler, H.; Dissertation, Technical Uni- Conservation and Utilization. Proceed. of
versity of Munich, Germany 1923 EFC Conf. 1982 [EFC Press, Dublin, Ire-
46 Scholler, H.; French Patent, F.P. 777,824 land, 1982] 57–81
(1935) 60 Carlsson, R.; Green Biomass of Native
47 Katzen, R.; Tsao, G. T.; A View of the Plants and new Cultivated Crops for
History of Biochemical Engineering IN. Multiple Use: Food, Fodder, Fuel, Fibre
Advances in Biochemical Engineering/ for Industry, Photochemical Products
Biotechnology, Vol. 70 [Springer, Berlin, and Medicine. In: New Crops for Food
2000] and Industry [G. E. Wickens, N. Haq,
48 Conrad, T. F.; Holzzuckerbrennerei; In: and P. Day (eds.), Chapman and Hall,
Die Hefen, Vol. II 8 F. Reiff, R. Kautz- London, 1989]
mann, H. Lüers, M. Lindemann (eds.) 61 Dale, B. E.; Biomass refining: protein
[Verlag Hans Carl, Nürnberg, 1962] 437– and ethanol from alfalfa. Ind. Eng. Prod-
444 uct Research and Development, 22 (1983)
49 Prescott, S. C.; Dunn, C. G.; Industrial 446
Microbiology. 3rd Ed. [McGraw-Hill, 62 Hacking, A. J.; The American wet
New York, Toronto, London, 1959] milling industry. In: Economic Aspects
50 Harris, E. E. et al; Madison Wood Sugar of Biotechnology [Cambridge University
Process. Ind. Eng. Chem., 38 (1946) 896– Press, New York, 1986] 214–221
904 63 White, D. H.; Wolf, D.; Research in Ther-
51 Timell, T. E.; Tappi, 44 (1961) 99 mochemical Biomass Conversion [A. V.
52 Stamm, A. J.; Wood and Cellulose Bridgewater, J. L. Kuester (eds.), Elsevier
Science [Ronald Press, New York, 1964] Applied Science, New York, 1988]
53 James, R. L.; In: The pulping of wood, 64 Lipinsky, E. S.; Chemicals from Biomass:
2nd edn., vol. 1 [McGraw-Hill, New York, petrochemical substitution options.
1969] 34 Science, 212 (1981) 1465–1471
54 Brink, D. L.; Pohlmann, A. A.; Tappi, 55 65 Wise, D. L. (ed.); Organic Chemical from
(1972) 381 ff. Biomass [The Benjamin/Cummings
55 Oshima, M.; Wood Chemistry – Process Publishing Co., Inc., Menlo Park, Cali-
Engineering Aspects [Noyes development fornia, 1983]
Corp. New York, 1965, No. 10965] 66 Bailey, J. E.; Ollis, D. F.; Biochemical En-
56 Puls, J.; Dietrichs, H. H.; In: Energy gineering Fundamentals. 2nd edition.
from Biomass. Proceed. of First Europe- [McGraw-Hill, New York, 1986]
an Comm. Inter. Conf. on Biomass, 67 Szmant, H. H.; Industrial Utilization of
Brighton, UK, November 1980 [W. Palz, Renewable Resources [Technomic Pub-
P. Chartier, D.O. Hall (eds), Elsevier, lishing, Lancaster, Pa., 1987]
1981, ISBN: 0-85334-970-3] 348 68 Eggersdorfer, M.; Meyer J.; Eckes, P.;
Use of renewable resources for non-food
36 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
materials. FEMS Microbiolol. Rev., 103 vironmental and Economics (E3) Hand-
(1992) 355–364 book [www.bioproducts-bioenergy.gov]
69 Morris D. J.; Ahmed I.; The carbohydrate 81 Lynd L. R.; Cushman J. H.; Nichols R. J.;
Economy: Making Chemicals and Indus- Wyman C. E.; Fuel Ethanol from Cellulo-
trial Materials from Plant Matter [Insti- sic Biomass. Science, 251 (1991) 1318.
tute of Local Self Reliance, Washington 82 Keller, F. A. Integrated bioprocess devel-
D.C. 1992] opment for bioethanol production. In:
70 Bozell, J. J.; Landucci, R.; Alternative handbook ob bioethanol: production and
feedstock program – technical and eco- utilization. [C. E. Wyman (ed), Taylor and
nomic assessment [US Department of Francis, Bristol, Pa. 1996] 351–379
Energy, 1992] 83 Wyman C. E.; Handbook on Bioethanol:
71 Schilling, L. B.; Chemicals from alterna- Production and Utilization. Applied En-
tive feedstock in the United States. ergy Technology Series [Taylor and Fran-
FEMS Microbiol. Rev., 16 (1995) 1001– cis, 1996]
1110 84 Lynd, L.; Overview and evaluation of fuel
72 de la Ross, L. B.; Dale, B. E.; Reshamwa- ethanol from cellulosics biomass: tech-
la, S. T.; Latimer, V. M.; Stuart, E. D.; nology, economics, the environment, and
Shawky, B. T.; An integrated process for policy. Annual Review of Energy and the
protein and ethanol from coastal Bermu- Environment, 21 (1996) 403–465
da grass. Appl. Biochem. Biotechnol., 45/ 85 Galbe, M.; Zacci, G.; A review of the pro-
46 (1994) 483–497 duction of ethanol from softwood. Appl.
73 Soyez, K.; Kamm, B.; Kamm, M. (eds.); Microbiol. Biotechnol., 59 (2002) 618–628
The Green Biorefinery, Proceedings of. 86 Datta, R.; Tasi, S.-P.; Bonsignore, P.;
1st International Green Biorefinery Con- Moon, S. H.; Frank, J. R.; Technological
ference, Neuruppin, Germany, 1997 [Ver- and economics potential of poly (lactic
lag GÖT, Berlin, 1998, ISBN 3-929672- acid) and lactic acid derivatives. FEMS
06-5, German and English] Microbiol. Rev., 16 (1995) 221–231
74 Van Dyne D. L.; Blasé M. G.; Clements 87 Witt, U.; Müller R. J.; Widdecke, H.;
L. D.; A strategy for returning agriculture Deckwer, W.-D.; Synthesis, properties
and rural America to long-term full em- and biodegradability of polyesters based
ployment using biomass refineries. In: on 1,3-propanediol. Macrom. Chem.
Perspectives on new crops and new uses. Phys., 195 (1994) 793–802
[J. Janeck (ed), ASHS Press, Alexandria, 88 Yosida, T.; Nagasawa, T.; e-Poly-L-lysine:
Va., 1999] pp 114–123 microbial production, biodegradation
75 Narodoslawsky, M.; The Green Biorefin- and application potential. Appl. Microbiol.
ery, Proceedings 2nd Intern. Symp. Biotechnol., 62 (2003) 21–26
Green Biorefinery, Feldbach, Austria 89 Potera, C.; Genencor and DuPont create
[SUSTAIN, (ed.), TU Graz, 1999] “green” polyester. Genet. Eng. News, 17
76 Nonato R. V.; Mantellato, P. E.; Rossel (1997) 17
C. E. V.; Integrated production of biodeg- 90 Poirier, Y.; Nawrath, C.; Somerville, C.;
radable plastic, sugar and ethanol. Appl. Production of polyhydroxyalkanoates, a
Microbiol. Biotechnol., 57 (2001) 1–5 family of biodegradable plastics. Bio/tech-
77 Ohara, H. Biorefinery. Appl. Microb. Bio- nology, 13 (1995) 142–150
techn. (AMB), 62 (2003) 474–477 91 Warwel, S.; Brüse, F.; Demes, C.; Kunz,
78 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Principles of M.; Rüsch gen Klaas, M.; Polymers and
Biorefineries. Appl. Microbiol., Biotechnol., Surfactants on the basis of renewable re-
(AMB), 64 (2004) 137–145 sources. Chemosphere, 43 (2001) 39–48
79 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Biorefinery-Sys- 92 Bozell, J. J.; Alternative Feedstocks for
tems. Chem. Biochem. Eng. Q., 18 (2004) Bioprocessing; In: Encyclopedia of Plant
1–6 and Crop Science [R.M. Goodman (ed.),
80 U.S. Department of Energy (DEO); Na- Dekker, New York, 2004, 0-8247-4268-0]
tional Biomass Initiative and Energy, En-
References 37
93 Webb, C.; Koutinas, A. A.; Wang, R.; ergy and Value-Added Products [R. P.
Developing a Sustainable Bioproces- Overend and E. Chornet (eds.), Perga-
sing Strategy Based on a Generic Feed- mon Press, Oxford, UK, 1999] 867–872
stock. Adv. Biochem Eng./Biotechn., 87 104 Bachmann, R.; Bastianelli, E.; Riese, J.;
(2004) 195–268 Schlenzka, W.; Using plants as plants.
94 Gravitis, J.; Suzuki, M.; Biomass Refin- Biotechnology will transform the pro-
ery – A Way to produce Value Added duction of chemicals. The McKinsey
Products and Base for Agricultural Quarterly, 2 (2000) 92–99
Zero Emissions Systems; In: Proc. 99 105 Hettenhaus, J. R.; Wooley, B.; Biomass
Intern. Conference on Agric. Engineer- Commercialization: Prospect in the
ing, Beijing, China 1999 [United Na- Next 2 to 5 Years [NREL, Golden Color-
tions University Press, Tokyo, 1999] ado, 2000, No. NREL/ACO-9-29-039-01]
III-9–III-23 106 Woolsey, J.; Hydrocarbons to Carbohy-
95 Van Dyne, D. L., et al., Estimating the drates, The strategic Dimension; In:
Economic Feasibility of Converting Lig- The Biobased Economy of the 21st
no-Cellulosic Feedstocks to Ethanol Century: Agriculture Expanding into
and Higher Value Chemicals under the Health, Energy, Chemicals, and Materi-
refinery concept: A Phase II Study als. NABC Report 12 [National Agricul-
[University of Missouri, 1999, tural Biotechnology Council, Ithaca,
OR22072-58] New York, 2000, No. 14853]
96 Kurtanjek, Z. (ed.); Chemical and Bio- 107 Eaglesham, A.; Brown, W. F.; Hardy,
chemical Engineering Quarterly, Special R. W. F. (eds.); The Biobased Economy
Issue, 18 (2004) 1–88 of the 21st Century: Agriculture Ex-
97 Marano, J. J.; Jechura, J. L.; Biorefinery panding into Health, Energy, Chemi-
Optimization Tools – Development and cals, and Materials. NABC Report 12
Validation. In: 25th. Symposium on [National Agricultural Biotechnology
Biotechnology for Fuels and Chemi- Council, Ithaca, New York, 2000, No.
cals: Program and Abstracts [National 14853]
Renewable Energy Laboratory, Golden, 108 US President: Developing and Promot-
CO, No. NREL/BK-510-33708, 2003] ing Biobased Products and Bioenergy,
104 Executive Order 13101/13134 [William
98 T. Werpy, G. Petersen (eds.); Top Value J. Clinton, The White House, Washing-
Added Chemicals from biomass (ed) ton D.C. 1999]
[U.S. Department of Energy, Office of 109 US Congress; Biomass Research and
scientific and technical information, Development, Act of 2000 [Washington
2004, No.: DOE/GO-102004-1992, D.C., 2000]
www.osti.gov/bridge] 110 Biomass R&D, Technical Advisory
99 Goddijn, O. J. M.; Plants as bioreactors. Committee; Vision for Bioenergy and
Trends Biotechnol., 13 (1995) 379–387 Biobased Products in the United States
100 Wilke, D.; Chemicals from biotechnol- [Washington D. C. Oct. 2002, www.bio-
ogy: molecular plant genetic will chal- products-bioenergy.gov/pdfs/BioVi-
lenge the chemical and the fermenta- sion_03_Web.pd]
tion industry. Appl. Microbiol. Biotech- 111 Biomass R&D, Technical Advisory
nol., (AMB), 52 (1999) 135–145 Committee; Roadmap for Biomass
101 Anex, R. (ed.).; Journal of Ind. Ecology, Technologies in the United States
Special Issue, 7 (2003) 1–235 [Washington D.C., Dec. 2002, www.bio-
102 Ludgar, R. G.; Woolsey, R. J.; The new products-bioenergy.gov/pdfs/FinalBio-
petroleum. Foreign Affairs, 78 (1999) massRoadmap.pdf ]
88–102 112 Biotechnology Industrial Organisation;
103 Wyman, C. E.; Production of Low Cost World Congress on Industrial biotech-
Sugars from Biomass: Progress, Oppor- nology and Bioprocessing, http://
tunities, and Challenges; In: Biomass: www.bio.org/World%20Congress
A Growth Opportunity in Green En-
38 1 Biorefinery Systems – An Overview
157 Lancaster, M.; The Syngas Economy; 160 Lancaster, M.; The Biorefinery. In:
In: Green Chemistry [The Royal So- Green Chemistry [The Royal Society of
ciety of Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, Chemistry, Cambridge, UK, 2002,
2002, ISBN: 0-85404-620-8] 205 ISBN: 0-85404-620-8] 207
158 Matlack, A. S.; The Use of Synthesis 161 Anastas, P. T.; Warner, J. C.; Green
Gas from Biomass; In: Introduction to Chemistry. Theory and Practice [Oxford
Green Chemistry [Marcel Dekker, New University Press, New York, 1998]
York, 2001, ISBN: 0824704118] 369
159 Clark, J. H.; Green Chemistry. Chal-
lenges and opportunities. Green Chem-
istry, 1 (1999) 1–8
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
41
2
Biomass Refining Global Impact –
The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
Bruce E. Dale and Seungdo Kim
2.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
42 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
2.2
Historical Outline
2.2.1
Background and Development of the Fossil Carbon-processing Industries
Materials that contain carbon, including the primary commercial fuels, virtually
all food and fiber products, and most commodity chemicals, pharmaceuticals,
and nondurable manufactured goods, play an integral role in the world econo-
my [1]. Carbon-rich raw materials originate through the process of photosynthe-
sis in which plants and some bacteria use solar energy to convert atmospheric
carbon dioxide into organic substances including simple sugars, polysacchari-
des, amino acids, proteins, lipids, and aromatic compounds such as lignin.
Some carbon-rich raw materials are derived from fossil sources such as petro-
leum, coal, and natural gas. Fossil sources result from photosynthesis in ancient
times and comprise a large, but nonrenewable, reserve. In contrast, present day
photosynthesis provides a potentially renewable source of carbon.
Renewable agricultural and forestry resources have been used since ancient
times as fuels and raw materials for numerous products. Starting in the late
1700s, at the beginning of the Industrial Revolution, coal began to displace
wood as a fuel. In the mid 1800s the large-scale processing of petroleum to fuel
and chemical products began, taking away some markets from coal and many
more from renewable carbon sources. In the last half of the 20th century, uses
of natural gas began to expand greatly, both as a fuel and as a feedstock for
chemical production [Ref. 1, Chapter 1]. Currently petroleum provides 40% of
the United States’ and 35% of the world’s direct primary energy supply whereas
plant material in all forms provides approximately 10% of the world’s energy
supply.
Although remaining supplies of petroleum, coal, and natural gas are very
large, it is, nonetheless, obvious that the world is using these essentially nonre-
newable resources at a huge and growing rate. Natural processes are simply not
replacing fossil carbon at even a minute fraction of the rate at which we are
using it. For example, some experts believe that the peak rate of production of
conventional oil will occur within this decade whereas others predict this will
occur before mid-century [2, 3]. After that point, conventional, inexpensive oil
production will irreversibly decline. Natural gas production will peak later than
conventional oil, but will still begin permanent decline within the next few de-
cades. Although other sources of petroleum exist (e.g., tar sands, deep-water
oil), they will be more difficult and much more expensive to produce. Whatever
the exact date of peak oil production, we are approaching a major change in the
way we must provide energy and other services to the world’s population.
This paper addresses two related questions:
1. is it realistic to believe that renewable sources of carbon can provide a large
share of the energy and other services currently provided by fossil carbon, par-
ticularly petroleum?
2.2 Historical Outline 43
We will touch somewhat on question 1 but will treat question 2 more exten-
sively.
An extensive ongoing project called the Role of Biomass in America’s Energy
Future (RBAEF Project) sponsored by the US Department of Energy and the
Energy Foundation is attempting to address the first question with considerable
breadth and depth. The RBAEF Project is led by Professor Lee R. Lynd of Dart-
mouth College (Hanover, New Hampshire, USA), Dr John Sheehan of the Na-
tional Renewable Energy Laboratory (Golden, Colorado, USA), and Mr Natha-
nael Greene of the Natural Resources Defense Council (New York, New York,
USA). We encourage all readers of this article to make themselves aware of the
findings of the RBAEF team as these findings become available. Dr Lynd pro-
vides an outline of some of the expected results in another article in this vol-
ume.
2.2.2
The Existing Biobased Economy: Renewable Carbon
vide the approximately 750 billion kilograms per year of refined petroleum prod-
ucts used in the United States [8]. That quantity of renewable carbon must
come from crop and forestry residues and energy crops (crops grown specifical-
ly to produce energy products) – not from food/feed grain.
In addition to existing uses of renewable carbon to produce organic chemicals
and fuels, renewable carbon sources provide about 90% of organic materials
such as lumber and paper, natural fibers, and composites, cellulosics, and some
proteins [Ref. 1, Chapter 2]. Finally, renewable carbon provides nearly all of our
food and animal feed. There is no reasonable alternative to using renewable car-
bon to meet food/feed demand, although the efficiency with which this demand
is met is certainly subject to change and innovation. We briefly explore some
possible innovations for food and feed production in this paper – a much more
complete discussion will be available in the RBAEF reports.
In total, the organic chemical, fuels (solid, liquid, and gaseous), carbon-based
materials, food, and feed components of the US domestic economy exceed US
$ 2 trillion per year. Much of this economic activity is already based on renew-
able carbon. The question which naturally arises is: could the fraction of fuels
and chemicals from renewable carbon be significantly increased without inter-
fering with other essential uses of plant material?
Before addressing this issue, we wish to point out two important facts that we
will explore in more detail below. First, there are several largely unexplored alter-
natives for coproducing animal feed and human food with fuels. Doing so would
make the whole enterprise more efficient, and very probably more economically
competitive. Second, both US and European agriculture are currently constrained
by demand, not by ability to produce. Respective national governments have been
paying farmers not to produce to capacity for many years. If large new demands
for renewable carbon were to arise, there is every reason to believe that much more
plant material could be produced on the same or similar acreages.
2.2.3
Toward a Much Larger Biobased Economy
Given the amount of grain available in the US and the EU and the ability to
supply very pure dextrose in large quantities for around US $ 0.20 per kg at
corn wet mills, we suggest that material supply, convenience, and purity consid-
erations favor dextrose derived from corn (and perhaps other grain) as a feed-
stock for organic chemical manufacture. The supply of grain dextrose is more
than adequate to produce all organic chemicals that conceivably can be made
from dextrose. Furthermore, corn yields are tending to increase with time. Giv-
en historical yield increases, each year US agriculture produces an additional
3.5 ´ 109 kg new dextrose equivalents. The biobased products industry will need
to grow very rapidly even to consume the additional dextrose made available
from new corn production. A switch from fossil carbon to renewable carbon for
organic chemicals will occur as conversion technologies improve, conversion
costs decline, and various barriers to entry are overcome.
2.3 Supplying the Biorefinery 45
2.3
Supplying the Biorefinery
2.3.1
What Raw Materials do Biorefineries Require and What Products Can They Make?
tional economic stability and opportunities for new product development. Biore-
fineries can also use a wider range of raw materials than can petroleum refi-
neries. Among the products that might be produced from biomass are liquid
transportation fuels (including both gasoline and diesel substitutes), electricity
and steam, a tremendous variety of chemicals containing carbon, oxygen, hydro-
gen, and nitrogen and combinations of these elements, monomers and poly-
mers, lubricants, adhesives, fertilizers and, significantly, animal feeds and hu-
man foods. Some of these products are summarized in Fig. 2.2 in their life cy-
cle context as possible replacements for petroleum-based or petroleum-depen-
dent products [9].
A disadvantage of biorefineries compared with petroleum refineries is that a
relatively larger range of processing technologies is needed. This is particularly
true for conversion and/or separation of the wider range of components of the
renewable feedstock raw materials, as shown in Fig. 2.1. It is important to note
in Fig. 2.2 that biorefineries will probably operate by first preprocessing (sepa-
rating and reacting) the inlet raw materials to a relatively small range of inter-
mediate products including carbohydrates, protein, syngas (mixtures of carbon
monoxide, hydrogen and carbon dioxide) and a few other products. These inter-
mediate products will then be upgraded by further reaction and separation steps
to a very wide variety of final products. Some of these reaction and separation
steps are well developed, others remain to be developed. In particular, the pro-
cessing technologies to convert lignocellulosic materials economically and in
high yield to carbohydrates and other products are not yet fully available. Once
these and other processing technologies are developed and deployed, however,
they will find use for a much wider variety and much more geographically dis-
persed set of renewable raw materials than is true for petroleum.
Fig. 2.2 Life cycle overview of biobased products [9].
2.3 Supplying the Biorefinery
47
48 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
Prototype biorefineries already exist, including corn wet and dry mills, pulp and
paper mills, and other renewable carbon-based processing facilities. Corn wet
mills perhaps best exemplify many of the features that are likely to be found in
mature biorefineries for large-scale fuel production. Wet mills are large, highly
integrated facilities producing a wide range of chemical, biochemical, feed, food,
and fuel products, as outlined in Fig. 2.2. Over 90% of the inlet corn leaves as
value-added products (selling price per kilogram greater than corn feedstock)
[Ref. 1, Chapter 3]. Corn wet mills have continued to add products with time,
particularly higher value chemical/biochemical products. Similarly to petroleum
refineries, wet mills alter their product mix to meet changing market condi-
tions, including seasonal variations in demand.
2.3.2
Comparing Biomass Feedstock Costs with Petroleum Costs
Fig. 2.3 Relative costs of biomass and petroleum by mass and energy content.
(arrow #1 in Fig. 2.3). On a mass basis, however, corn is less than half the cost of
petroleum (arrow #2) – giving corn starch and other corn components real poten-
tial as a feedstock for chemical production to replace petroleum-derived chemicals.
Corn wet millers often use net corn cost to reflect the cost of starch available for
chemical and fuel production after coproduct credits (e.g. for protein and oil) are
subtracted. Typical net corn costs are roughly 70% of the purchase cost of corn,
further reducing the actual cost of corn starch for chemical or fuel production.
Ethanol production from corn grain currently requires various financial incen-
tives to be competitive with gasoline from oil. No such incentives are required
for chemicals from corn starch. Very large efforts are currently in progress to
50 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
1. Economical
2. Stable price and availability
3. Consistent composition
4. Low cost
5. Favorable co-products and by-products
6. Multiple product opportunities
7. Inexpensive
8. Environmentally benign or beneficial
9. Storable
10. Inexpensive
produce chemicals (e.g. lactic acid, 1,3 propanediol, etc.) from corn starch by
either wet milling or dry milling. This is precisely how the petroleum refining
industry developed. Additional valuable products such as plastics were added to
the refinery over a period of decades as these products and processes were in-
vented or improved and economics became attractive for the new products.
Second, lignocellulosic biomass such as crop residues and herbaceous species
(grasses, hays, forage crops) is available at prices that are a fraction (one fifth to
one half) of petroleum costs (at $ 35 per barrel) on an energy basis, and even
less on a mass basis (arrows #3 and #4 in Fig. 2.3). Therefore, given processing
technology that economically and efficiently converts the energy content of lig-
nocellulosic biomass to liquid fuels, we can reasonably expect to derive fuel
products that are available at prices similar to current gasoline and diesel prices.
Sugar fermentation to ethanol is one such process. Over 90% of the energy con-
tent of glucose is captured in the ethanol product from high-yield fermenta-
tions.
Feedstock costs are absolutely critical to commodity chemicals and fuels, and
biomass feedstocks are already much less expensive than petroleum on both a
mass and energy basis. It is impossible to overstate the importance of low cost
renewable carbon feedstocks to the eventual commercial success of large-scale,
integrated biorefineries. Dr Paul Roessler of Dow Chemical (US) makes this
point in a humorous and effective way in his list of ten required biomass feed-
stock properties, given as Table 2.1. In line with the historical development of
other processing industries, as the biomass processing industry develops and
the related technology matures, raw material costs will become dominant in the
cost of manufacture.
2.3.3
How Much Biomass Feedstock Can be Provided at What Cost?
Renewable carbon feedstock prices are critical to the economic success of biore-
fineries. Although we believe data on likely biomass prices are encouraging, the
ultimate possible scale of the industry, and hence its ability to displace petro-
2.3 Supplying the Biorefinery 51
Corn stover 0.0 33.9 28.6 134 0.0 0.2 7.2 204
Barley straw 0.0 2.0 44.2 9.9 0.2 1.9 0.3 58.5
Oat straw 0.0 0.3 6.8 2.8 0.0 0.5 0.2 10.6
Rice straw 20.9 668 3.9 10.9 2.8 1.7 23.5 731
Wheat straw 5.3 145 133 50.1 2.8 8.6 9.8 354
Sorghum 0.0 0.0 0.4 6.9 1.2 0.3 1.5 10.3
straw
Bagasse 11.7 74.9 0.0 4.6 19.2 6.5 63.8 181
Subtotal 38.0 924 217 219 26.1 19.7 106 1549
52 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
largely on the productivity of crop and pasture lands. The RBAEF Project will
treat this subject of productivity in great detail. We simply observe here that the
US has nearly 16 million ha in its Conservation Reserve Program (CRP), land
which is removed from grain crop production but which would be very suitable
for grass and hay production.
In the US, pasture lands (including crop land used as pasture) average about
5600 kg of biomass per ha per year [16]. There is little incentive to increase
production on these lands, because there are no markets for increased hay
production. Biomass production for energy would provide increased incentive
to use these lands efficiently and a severalfold increase in average yield over
time seems entirely likely. For example, some lands supporting dairy cattle in
Michigan are managed intensively for maximum biomass production, including
the use of winter cover crops and corn harvested as silage. Such lands are
currently yielding 20 000 kg dry biomass per ha per year. Double these yields
(40 000 kg ha–1 per year) of other species such as sugarcane and elephant grass
have also been achieved on degraded lands [17]. If all the CRP lands and one
half of crop land used as pasture (15 million ha) achieved 20 000 kg ha–1, an
additional 600 ´ 109 kg biomass would be produced annually in the US.
We believe the large scale conversion of cellulosic biomass to fuel will be
based first on crop residues, given their low cost and availability. There is more
than enough low-cost crop residue in the US and elsewhere to begin such an
industry. As the industry expands, and processing economics improve with re-
search and experience, the “demand pull” for additional biomass will cause the
agricultural research and production sector to learn how to produce much larger
amounts of herbaceous biomass profitably at costs approximating $ 50 per
1000 kg on lands that compete only modestly or not at all with food crop pro-
duction. In addition, biorefineries producing fuels will also produce both pro-
tein and energy feeds for animals, just as corn wet and dry mills producing
ethanol fuel do today. Coproduction of animal feeds with fuel and chemical
products in biorefineries will increase feed supplies and reduce pressure on
cropland.
Before concluding this treatment of biomass feedstock costs, we note that the
wide geographic availability, abundance and variety of biomass will tend to re-
duce the risks of raw material supply availability and reduce price swings. Un-
certain availability and price volatility are major features of the current petro-
leum economy. As an essentially fixed world endowment of easily recoverable
petroleum is gradually consumed, these risks will only grow and an increasing
price paid in terms of national security and stability [2, 18]. Therefore, this eco-
nomic and energy security issue can only grow in importance. Furthermore,
many developed and developing nations which lack petroleum can grow large
quantities of plant biomass, and thereby begin to escape the “development trap”
that petroleum dependence brings in an era of decreasing petroleum supplies
and high and volatile prices [18].
2.4 How Will Biorefineries Develop Technologically? 53
2.4
How Will Biorefineries Develop Technologically?
2.4.1
Product Yield: The Dominant Technoeconomic Factor
Yield (kg salable products per kg purchased raw materials) is usually the domi-
nant factor governing the economics of a given reaction/separation system to
produce commercial products. Because, essentially, all chemical and biological
reactions produce multiple products, the yield of salable products influences the
economics of the system in the following ways.
1. Raw material cost increases per unit of product as yield declines. For exam-
ple, at $ 0.10 per pound of glucose and 90% yield of lactic acid produced by
fermentation of this glucose, the glucose raw material cost is $ 0.11 per
pound of lactic acid. At 50% yield, the raw material cost is $ 0.20 per pound
of lactic acid. Because the cost of manufacturing commodity fuels and chemi-
cals is very dependent on raw material costs, a lower yield significantly in-
creases the cost of manufacture.
2. The cost of the reaction system increases. If a fixed total annual production
rate is required, then at 50% yield almost twice the total reactor volume is
needed compared with 90% yield to provide that amount of product.
3. The cost of the separation system increases even more rapidly than the reac-
tion system. The cost of separation is proportional to the volume of fluid
handled. Under similar reaction conditions, a lower yield means lower con-
centration of product and, therefore, a greater volume of reaction fluid must
be handled for a given production rate. The cost of separation also increases
with the number of components needing separation. Decreasing yield usually
means there are more components that must be separated.
4. The cost of waste treatment increases. Either markets for byproducts must be
found, which is not always possible, or the resulting waste streams must be
treated before disposal, adding to both the capital and operating expense of
the overall system.
number of products will increase over time as will the yield of salable products
per unit of raw material(s) consumed. This is precisely the trend that has oc-
curred historically in the petroleum refining industry.
Because we have pointed out several probable similarities between petroleum
refineries and biorefineries, it is worth pointing out here a very significant dif-
ference between them. Both genetic tools and conventional plant breeding can
be used to develop biomass feedstocks that are particularly designed for process-
ing in the biorefinery. For example, lignin content can be altered to make ligno-
cellulosic biomass easier to process. Also, valuable products such as enzymes
can be produced in plants and recovered in the biorefinery [Ref. 1, Chapter 1].
This capability has no parallel in petroleum refining and is a major advantage
for biorefineries. Continuing advances in the life sciences virtually guarantee
that this advantage will grow with time.
2.4.2
Product Diversification: Using the Whole Barrel of Biomass
The importance of finding valuable uses for all biomass components is illustrat-
ed by the following example based on the composition outlined in Fig. 2.1. As-
sume a corn stover-based biorefinery producing 378 million liters per year of
fuel ethanol at a yield of 420 liters of ethanol per 1000 kg stover. At a 50% re-
moval rate for stover, approximately 200 000 ha corn will be required to provide
the stover. Such a biorefinery will also produce nearly 21 ´ 106 kg minerals (Ca,
K, Mg and P), 20 ´ 106 kg lipids, fats, and waxes, 52 ´ 106 kg protein (equivalent
to the protein produced from nearly 70 000 ha soybeans), electricity from burn-
ing the lignin residue and probably residual sugars for animal feeding. These
conclusions arise directly from the chemical nature of the components of bio-
mass and the realities of chemical and biological processing outlined in Sec-
tion 2.4.1, above. A biorefinery will be in many businesses (fuels, chemicals,
power, feed, etc.) simultaneously. This fact cannot be evaded, but must be faced
and dealt with, hopefully to the benefit of the overall biorefining system.
One significant potential benefit that arises from this analysis is that the net
requirement for agricultural land to provide feed protein decreases by 70 000 ha,
or about 1/3 of the land from which stover is harvested. Put another way, 3 ha
of corn production are now able to replace 1 ha of soybean production, while
still providing all the grain these corn acres produced before and 900 ´ 106 kg
stover for liquid fuel production. If herbaceous biomass species, for example
switchgrass, are grown for energy production, they will probably be higher
yielding and will also contain significantly more protein than corn stover. Thus
such crops should provide even greater net savings of crop land required to
meet protein needs. For example, if switchgrass or another herbaceous species
such as coastal Bermuda grass is produced at dry matter yields of 20 000 kg ha–1
per year (about 9 tons acre–1 year–1) and contains 10% protein of which 80% is
recovered [19, 20], the system will produce 1,600 kg ha–1 protein, over twice the
amount of protein produced per ha of soybeans. Because the United States cur-
2.4 How Will Biorefineries Develop Technologically? 55
2.4.3
Process Development and a Technical Prerequisite for Cellulosic Biorefineries
If plant raw material is already inexpensive compared with petroleum and suffi-
ciently abundant to support a large scale biorefining industry, one may legiti-
mately ask: “Why has such an industry not already emerged?” We note that
such industries have arisen: corn wet and dry mills and pulp and paper mills
are examples. For these industries, inexpensive raw materials are coupled with
well developed and efficient processing technology to convert the plant raw ma-
terials to products. For large scale liquid fuel production from cellulosic materi-
als, however, the missing part of the equation is demonstrated, inexpensive pro-
cessing technology to convert inexpensive and abundant cellulosic raw materials
to fuels.
While we believe that the entire barrel of biomass must be used effectively,
use of the carbohydrate component (cellulose and hemicellulose represent ap-
proximately 70% of cellulosic biomass) is the sine qua non for cellulosic biorefi-
neries [Ref. 1, Chapters 4 and 21]. The accessibility (reactivity) of cellulose and
hemicellulose must be increased without significantly degrading these compo-
nents. These carbohydrate polymers must somehow be converted into chemi-
cally reactive intermediate species, as shown in Fig. 2.2. Achieving this objective
56 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
2.5
Sustainability of Integrated Biorefining Systems
2.5.1
Integrated Biorefining Systems: “All Biomass is Local”
Because biomass feedstocks are solids and tend to be bulky, there is consider-
able incentive to refine them close to where they are grown. Likewise the waste
streams from biorefineries will tend to be high in organic material and there-
fore biological oxygen demand. But these biorefinery wastes will not be particu-
larly toxic. Many of these waste streams are therefore suitable candidates for re-
turning to agricultural land. Given the capital and operating costs associated
with waste handling in the biorefinery, there is a strong economic incentive to
apply these wastes to land.
Furthermore, agriculture is, by nature, a regional or local activity because of
differences in soil and climate. Therefore crops grown for biorefineries can be
or will be adapted to local conditions. The relatively smaller scale of biorefi-
neries (compared with petroleum refineries) also enhances the likelihood that
the farmers who produce the crops will have some sort of formal or informal
“ownership” of the biorefinery. This pattern of local ownership of the biorefine-
ry, or at least participation in ownership, is observed in many corn dry mills in
2.5 Sustainability of Integrated Biorefining Systems 57
the US. Corn wet mills are, however, much larger than dry mills (the largest
wet mills approach the mass throughput rate of petroleum refineries) and are
not farmer-owned. Local ownership of the biorefinery will give farmers an addi-
tional incentive to utilize animal feeds, mineral fertilizers, and organic waste
streams from the biorefinery. We call this framework the “All Biomass is Local”
concept; it is illustrated in Fig. 2.5.
We envisage farmers using locally appropriate agricultural systems growing
biomass specifically for the biorefinery. In the biorefinery, biomass is separated
into its major components. Some of these components (e.g., protein and miner-
als or “ash”) may be salable or usable without further upgrading. The ash is re-
turned as fertilizer to the land. Protein is fed to animals, preferably in a nearby
location to avoid costs of drying and transportation. Animal wastes and organic
waste streams from the biorefinery are used in the agricultural system. The na-
ture of these waste streams makes them particularly appropriate for land appli-
cation to perennial grass systems, where the potential for runoff and leaching
to groundwater is minimized.
Therefore, the convergence of these factors:
· local ownership/participation in biorefineries,
· the widespread geographical distribution of these refineries,
· the fact that biorefineries will be intimately involved with land use practices,
and
· society’s continuing concern with the environment
virtually guarantee that biorefineries will be conceived, designed, built, and op-
erated with an unprecedented emphasis on their local and global environmental
impact. Petroleum refineries largely avoided environmental/social issues when
that industry was in its infancy, but now are being forced to do so at great cost.
Biorefineries that do not adequately address appropriate environmental and so-
cial issues will be at substantial risk of failure.
We believe these environmental and social issues surrounding biorefineries
are best addressed using the concept of sustainability as an organizing frame-
work and life cycle analysis as a powerful analytical methodology [22]. As we il-
lustrate below, we believe that thoughtful, intelligent design and implementa-
tion of integrated agricultural production and biorefining systems can do much
more than simply maintain the environmental status quo. Rather, we believe it
is possible to effect significant improvements in the local, regional, and global
environment by using life cycle analysis of integrated crop production and refin-
ing systems.
2.5.2
Agricultural/Forestry Ecosystem Modeling: New Tools for an Age of Sustainability
Sustainability is a very broad subject. In this paper we do not have the scope to
treat all aspects of sustainability in relation to crop production and biorefining
systems such as those represented in Fig. 2.6. To illustrate an approach that
58 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
Fig. 2.5 All biomass is local: integrating agriculture and the biorefinery.
2.5 Sustainability of Integrated Biorefining Systems 59
might be taken, however, we consider the dynamics of carbon and nitrogen flow
in agricultural ecosystems. We then analyze how those flows might be manipu-
lated to enhance the sustainability of the agricultural production and biorefining
system when taken as an integrated whole. We also point out what seem to be
some emerging principles for understanding the sustainability of these systems.
Analyzing and modeling carbon and nitrogen flows in agricultural ecosystems
has been an active area of research for over thirty years [23, 24]. Researchers
have studied a variety of biological and nonbiological processes connected with
plant growth. These processes occur in the soil, on the surface and above the
surface of the ground. Researchers have estimated the rates of these processes
based on local factors such as temperature, soil type, rainfall, plant genetic po-
tential and existing pools of carbon such as microbial carbon, standing dead
plant, carbon, etc. Tillage and harvesting practices have also been taken into ac-
count, as have other human inputs such as fertilizers and irrigation. As a result
of such work, flexible, powerful agricultural ecosystem models such as the CEN-
TURY model have been developed [25, 26]. To illustrate the breadth of processes
considered in such ecosystem level studies, a diagram for carbon flow in the
CENTURY model is given below.
Similar agricultural ecosystem models have been developed for nitrogen-con-
taining species and are being developed for phosphorus-containing compounds.
When these ecosystem models are combined with models of the biorefinery
processes, we can use them to evaluate and then improve the sustainability of
integrated biorefining systems. We illustrate this approach below.
2.5.3
Analyzing the Sustainability of Integrated Biorefining Systems: Some Results
ganic carbon levels are possible as shown in Fig. 2.7, below, as long as cultiva-
tion is no till. The use of winter cover crops enables very substantial removal of
corn stover for industrial uses while still enhancing soil quality over time.
The total amount of protein, lipids, lignin and carbohydrate (including starch,
cellulose and hemicellulose) produced by each of the cropping systems above
was estimated over a 40 year period. Based on data from biorefinery operations
and crop production databases, greenhouse gases were also calculated in kilo-
gram carbon dioxide equivalents per kilogram of each of these species produced.
Figure 2.8 shows greenhouse gas production per kilogram of carbohydrate for
each of the six scenarios.
Once again, the cropping system chosen has a significant effect on the re-
sults. The results range from a net production of 560 g of CO2 kg–1 carbohy-
drate for conventional corn–soybean rotation to 9 g (net carbon sequestration)
kg–1 carbohydrate for continuous corn cultivation under no-till conditions with
winter wheat and 70% stover removal.
A similar life-cycle approach is taken to estimate the greenhouse gas reduction
when ethanol produced using the biorefinery systems outlined above is consumed
in a mid-sized passenger vehicle. Figure 2.9 summarizes these results. All of the
cropping systems result in net greenhouse gas reduction, but there are substantial
differences between cropping systems. Aggressive corn stover removal when
coupled with winter cover crops can result in over 70% reduction in greenhouse
gas formation compared with a gasoline fueled vehicle. But as Fig. 2.7 shows, soil
health can continue to improve even when large amounts of stover are removed.
Finally, even more dramatic reductions in leached nitrogen (inorganic nitro-
gen species escaping the root zone of plants) are possible by judicious choice of
cropping systems and agricultural system management. Using the nitrogen
flow submodel of the CENTURY model to predict the effects of different agri-
cultural practices, it seems possible to reduce inorganic nitrogen losses more
Fig. 2.7 Soil organic carbon trends under different agricultural practices.
2.5 Sustainability of Integrated Biorefining Systems 63
than a factor of ten by use of conventional corn production as the base case.
These results are summarized in Fig. 2.10. The results are for a 40 year period
in which these practices are used in a specific geographic location – Washington
County, Illinois, USA.
As expected, the use of winter cover crops greatly reduces nitrogen leaching.
It is also interesting to note that stover removal seems to reduce nitrogen leach-
ing – compare CC with CC (56%). One mechanistic explanation of these results
is that the nitrogen content of the corn stover (approx. 1% by weight) is not
available for conversion to soluble inorganic nitrogen species when the stover is
removed, thereby reducing leaching. Also, the carbohydrates in harvested stover
are not then available to provide metabolic energy for microbial processes that
64 2 Biomass Refining Global Impact – The Biobased Economy of the 21st Century
Fig. 2.10 Inorganic nitrogen losses over 40 years – Washington Country, Illinois.
convert organic nitrogen into inorganic nitrogen. Although stover removal must
be carefully managed to maintain soil fertility, stover removal has powerful envi-
ronmental benefits. These benefits include providing renewable carbon for bior-
efining to fuels and chemicals and reduced inorganic nitrogen leaching.
On the basis of these and other results, we believe that a combination of crea-
tive system design, careful planning and use of powerful ecosystem and biore-
finery modeling tools can help us achieve very significant environmental im-
provements as we develop the biobased economy of the 21st century. We need
not be content with maintaining the environmental status quo or even with
modest improvements. Instead, very significant improvements are possible if
we are both wise and informed.
2.6
Conclusions
The biobased economy will grow rapidly during the 21st century. A combination
of low-cost plant raw materials and gradually improving biorefinery process
technology for converting these raw materials into a variety of fuels, chemicals,
materials, food, and feed will drive the adoption of the biobased economy. The
biological sciences will have a particularly powerful impact on both the raw ma-
terials and the processing technologies underlying the biobased economy. The
biobased economy, and its associated biorefineries, will be shaped by many of
the same forces that shaped the development of the hydrocarbon economy and
its refineries over the past century. These similarities include the importance of
yield (using the whole “barrel of biomass”), continuing diversification of prod-
ucts, and gradual process improvement in functioning biorefineries.
References 65
However, significant differences between the biobased economy and the hy-
drocarbon economy are also apparent. Among these are the great compositional
variety of plant raw material, requiring a greater range of processing technolo-
gies to add value to the basic components, and the much wider geographic dis-
tribution of both raw materials and the associated refineries. This wide geo-
graphic distribution of both raw materials and biorefineries will promote greater
economic/national security and more equitable distribution of wealth. We be-
lieve that supposed limits on agricultural productivity to support the biobased
economy are mostly illusory. There is no “food vs. fuel” conflict. Economic prof-
itability and process efficiency will force the adoption of “food and fuel” scena-
rios. Biorefineries and their associated crop production systems will be highly
integrated. Furthermore, integrated biorefining systems will be designed to
achieve not only economic profitability but also environmental benefits. Truly
transformational environmental benefits can be achieved by creative design of
these integrated biorefining systems.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge support from Cargill Dow, LLP, from Du-
Pont Biobased Materials, Inc., and from the Center for Plant Products and Tech-
nology at Michigan State University.
References
17 J. A. Stricker, et al., Production and Man- 24 P. Smith, et al., Quantifying the change in
agement of Biomass/Energy Crops on Phos- greenhouse gas emissions due to natural re-
phatic Clay in Central Florida, Univ. of source conservation practice application in
Florida Cooperative Extension Service Indiana, Final report to the Indiana Con-
Circular 1084, USA, 1993. servation Partnership, Colorado State
18 R. G. Lugar, R.J. Woolsey, Foreign Affairs. University Natural Resource Ecology
1999, 78(1), 88–102. Laboratory and USDA Natural Resources
19 M. E. Ensminger, C. G. Olentine, Jr., Conservation Service, USA, 2002.
Feeds and Nutrition – Complete, The Ens- 25 A. K. Metherall, L. A. Harding, C. V. Cole,
minger Publishing Company, USA, W. J. Parton, CENTURY Soil organic
1978. matter model environment. Technical
20 L. B. de la Rosa, et al., Appl. Biochem. & documentation. Agroecosystem version
Biotech. 1994, 45/46, 483–497. 4.0. Great Plains System Research Unit
21 L. R. Lynd, C. E. Wyman, T. U. Gern- Technical Report No. 4. UDSA-ARS,
gross, Biotech. Prog. 1999, 15, 777–793. USA, 1993.
22 R. Anex (Ed.), J. Ind. Ecol. 2004, 7(3/4). 26 R. H. Kelly, et al., Geoderma 1999, 81,
See articles on pages 75–92, 93–116, 75–90.
117–146 and 147–162. 27 J. Sheehan, et al., Is ethanol from corn
23 L. Kristen, et al., Parameterizing Century stover sustainable?, National Renewable
to model cultivated and noncultivated sites Energy Laboratory Draft Report, USA,
in the loess region of western Iowa, US December 2002.
Geological Survey Report 00-508, US De-
partment of the Interior, USA, 2000.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
67
3
Development of Biorefineries –
Technical and Economic Considerations
Bill Dean, Tim Dodge, Fernando Valle, and Gopal Chotani
3.1
Introduction
As the world’s population and economy continue to grow, so does the demand
for goods to sustain that growth. Growth has come at the expense of our non-
renewable resources. It is only a matter of time before the price of petroleum,
upon which the world economy is heavily dependent, will rise to a point where
we will be forced by economic factors to find alternatives. We suspect this time
is not far off in the future and the time is now to explore viable alternatives.
Our nation is fortunate to have abundant agricultural and forest renewable re-
sources and a climate that is amenable to their productive use. If we put our
mind to it, these renewable assets can go a long way to replace our heavy de-
pendence on petroleum and other non-renewables. That process has, in a way,
already begun, as we have been in the business of “bio-refining” in the broader
sense for quite some time. Our forests are harvested to produce a host of prod-
ucts including paper, solvents, building materials, and many more. Our agricul-
ture industry can produce large quantities of grain and other crops, which can
and are being used to produce a host of materials. Starch from grain crops and
sucrose from beet, sugar cane, and other materials are being converted to an in-
creasing number of products and chemicals. Some of the chemicals now being
produced include ethanol, 1,3-propanediol, lactic acid, and ascorbic acid. As the
technology of pathway engineering advances, one can expect many more chemi-
cals (and polymers) to be produced from sugar as a carbon source [1, 2].
Increasing demand for sugars will eventually result in increasing sugar prices
and, ultimately, supply problems. It is logical to assume that as more chemicals
and materials are produced from fermentable sugars as the carbon source, mar-
ket forces will inevitably drive fundamental changes in the agriculture and
chemical sectors.
Genencor International has been active in developing technologies that have
affected the evolution of biorefineries. As part of our efforts in this area, we
have actively explored the concept of using cellulosic biomass to provide the car-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
68 3 Development of Biorefineries – Technical and Economic Considerations
bon source for such future refineries. In this pursuit, we have focused on the
conversion of cellulosic biomass into fermentable sugars and on the challenges
of biocatalysis in utilizing those sugar streams [3, 4].
Advances in pathway engineering will result in commercially viable and com-
petitive processes based on renewable feedstocks which in many cases will pro-
vide the low-cost route to production. The cost of carbon to feed biocatalysis is
often more than 50% of the total direct cost of production, and therefore efforts
to reduce this cost play an important role in the overall development of the bio-
refinery concept. It is not surprising that many have focused on cellulosic bio-
mass (e.g., agricultural waste) as the ultimate low cost source of the fermentable
sugar in the biorefinery. Much knowledge has been gained and progress made
on the understanding of cellulosic biomass saccharification to fermentable su-
gars to be used for bioconversion to chemicals.
The challenge before us is to develop the technologies that will be required to
enable this upcoming industry. We will focus here on two of these technologies:
1. enzymes required for conversion of cellulosic biomass to fermentable sugars
within an enabling cost structure; and
2. engineered organisms to produce chemicals competitively.
3.2
Overview: The Biorefinery Model
3.3
Feedstock and Conversion to Fermentable Sugar
Three basic biorefinery approaches, as portrayed in Fig. 3.2, are evolving on the
basis of the nature of the feedstock, i.e. sucrose, starch, or cellulose.
On a fermentable-carbon-cost basis, the sucrose-based Biorefinery I is cur-
rently the most cost-competitive. In recent years, however, the starch-based Bio-
3.3 Feedstock and Conversion to Fermentable Sugar 69
Fig. 3.3 Change of cost of fermentable carbon with time for different carbohydrate sources.
3.3.1
Sucrose
The simplest biorefinery system uses sucrose as feedstock (sugar beet, cane,
etc.). Sugar is first extracted from the feedstock. Lignin and cellulosic residuals,
if sugar cane is used, are utilized separately or burned for energy to run the op-
eration. The sucrose-based industry is a significant biorefinery opportunity today
and into the future. Sucrose is second only to cellulose in availability and cur-
rent output far exceeds all other commercial carbohydrates combined. It is esti-
mated that only 1.7% of annual sucrose production goes to non-food uses. It is
possible to imagine a sugar biorefinery as an integrated producer, not only of
sucrose and ethanol, but of important high-value products whose manufacture
could be scaled up or down depending on circumstances, economics, and de-
mand [5]. Not surprisingly, more than 50% of ethanol volume produced in the
world today has sucrose as feedstock.
3.3.2
Starch
3.3.3
Cellulose
Fig. 3.4 Cost components production of fuel ethanol from corn and corn stover [6].
Fig. 3.5 Cellulase enzyme cost estimate based on the NREL assay [6].
74 3 Development of Biorefineries – Technical and Economic Considerations
3.4
Technical Challenges
3.4.1
Cellulase Enzymes
Total cost Fermentation cost (fixed direct) Recovery cost (fixed direct)
Formulation cost (fixed direct)
2
3.4 Technical Challenges 75
Most current commercial cellulase products are sold as cell-free, stabilized con-
centrates. Although these formulations meet market needs with regard to appli-
cation and cost, for many enzyme products it is not uncommon for the recovery
and formulation costs to be a major portion of the overall cost. It then follows
that reduced post-fermentation processing would possibly lead to reduced cost,
with no post-fermentation processing being the lowest cost. This is, however,
only practical if the resulting product still meets the needs of the application.
Fermentation broth with no processing was tested in saccharification of pre-
treated corn stover. Performance in the saccharification was indistinguishable
among fresh whole fermentation broth, fresh fully-recovered and formulated
product, and 28-day old fermentation broth. These results suggest that typical re-
covery and formulation costs can be eliminated for use in biorefinery operations,
especially in an integrated plant that both makes and uses the cellulase enzymes.
This leaves the fermentation costs that can be broken down into fixed costs,
for example depreciation and labor, and direct costs, for example utilities and
raw materials.
The single largest cost component for the fermentation process was estimated
to be the carbon/energy source for the culture. For Trichoderma cellulase, the
carbon source has historically been lactose. The cost per unit enzyme produced
is a function of the yield of enzyme on the carbon source and the cost of the
carbon source itself. When performed in a similar manner, the other costs are
proportional to the rate of enzyme production, as measured by volumetric pro-
ductivity. An integrated plan of action was taken to affect both enzyme expres-
sion and the fermentation process. Improvements were made on the production
organism, the production process, and in their interactions.
A conventional mutagenesis and screening approach was applied to the exist-
ing production strain. The work had several objectives. One was to find strains
capable of fast and efficient growth on cellulose. A useful screening method
was adapted from the method of Toyama [7]. In this method, mutated spores
are poured in large numbers with agar in the bottom of a Petri dish. A second
layer is added on top containing cellulose as the sole carbon source. The spores
germinate and grow through the agar eventually emerging on top of the cellu-
lose-agar layer. Those that erupt first are more likely to grow quickly and effi-
ciently on cellulose. Another goal was to disrupt existing regulatory mecha-
nisms that result in catabolite repression and the need for induction of cellulase
expression. Several plate screening methods were developed that used a high
glucose concentration to overcome catabolite repression or glycerol as the car-
bon source to find expression without induction. A third goal was to improve
the secretion of cellulases. Resistance to different chemical agents and selection
for hyper-branched morphological mutants were both employed.
76 3 Development of Biorefineries – Technical and Economic Considerations
CBH I to improve thermal stability also required several strategies. CBH I struc-
ture analysis suggested sites that could affect thermal stability, as did comparing
the structures of CBH I homologues. Random mutagenesis and screening were
also used. An important part of this effort was the development of a small-scale
screening method to quickly and accurately measure the effect of the changes
made. By the incorporation of a large number of specific site changes, Tm of
CBH I was improved significantly. Placing the engineered CBH I into a produc-
tion strain in which the native CBH I gene was deleted did not have a negative
effect on enzyme production levels.
Along with the ability to engineer proteins for increased thermal stability, it is
imperative that the engineered proteins can be expressed at high levels in pro-
duction strains without negatively affecting the other cellulase components.
This has proven to be the case for both T. reesei-engineered CBH I and for
homologues from other fungi. The homologue from Humicola grisea var thermo-
idea was expressed at levels similar to the wild-type CBH I without negatively af-
fecting the production of the other cellulase components.
By analysis of the CBH I structure, several sites were selected that were hy-
pothesized to affect binding of substrate and products in the active site cleft.
Several mutants were made, with significant effects on both Km, the Michaelis-
Menten constant and kcat, the catalytic rate constant.
Many of these improved enzymes have been produced effectively in whole cel-
lulase production strains. As discussed above, improved cellulase production
has been maintained with the improved enzymes incorporated. The resulting
products have been tested in the NREL process scheme and have resulted in an
approximately threefold reduction in enzyme loading.
The work discussed above was performed by Genencor International and col-
laborators as part of a subcontract funded by the DOE administered by NREL.
A similar subcontract was also awarded to Novozymes. The improvements re-
ported to date by both the groups have been quantitatively very similar. The
approaches taken have also been similar. Together, it is clear that the cost of en-
zymes for biomass saccharification has been dramatically reduced from the
baseline in 2000. Enzyme cost can no longer be regarded as the largest barrier
to commercialization of biorefineries.
3.4.2
Fermentation Organisms
Acid pK Value
Pyruvic 2.50
Fumaric 3.03
Malic 3.40
Itaconic 3.84
Lactic 3.86
Aspartic 3.90
Succinic 4.19
Glutamic 4.20
Oxalic 4.21
80 3 Development of Biorefineries – Technical and Economic Considerations
derstand the types of physiological response that occur when cells are exposed
to stressful conditions. For example, comparison of E. coli strains capable of
producing ethanol at different levels has shown that increased ethanol tolerance
results from a combination of multiple changes affecting different aspects of
cell physiology [20].
3.5
Conclusions
The importance of the biorefinery concept is growing and the recent increased
demand for fuel ethanol has in large part driven that growth, as shown in
Fig. 3.6.
New products such as the lactic acid and 1,3-propanediol produced from su-
gar in engineered organisms are recent examples of the biorefinery concept pro-
gressing toward reality. Apart from co-product streams resulting from the pro-
cessing of grain or biomass, the resulting sugars are being used as carbon feed
to furnish an ever-growing list of products including fuel and the building
blocks for the synthesis of chemicals and polymers. Commercial production of
1,3-propanediol for Sorona, based on technology developed in a close collabora-
tion between DuPont and Genencor, will mark the emergence of commercial vi-
able application of the biorefinery concept for production of basic chemical
building blocks in competition with petrochemical-derived materials [21].
Many of the biorefinery elements required for financial success seem to be
currently present, for example:
· high-volume, low-cost application (fuel ethanol);
· multiple alternate product streams;
· ability to shift to different products quickly when required; and
· acceptable cost structure (at least for sucrose, starch).
Fig. 3.6 World demand for fuel ethanol over the years.
82 3 Development of Biorefineries – Technical and Economic Considerations
In summary, the concept of the biorefinery is not new. In its simplistic form,
several pieces have been in operation for thousands of years. Biorefineries con-
tinue to evolve depending on market needs, and growth now is being driven by
the rising demand for fuel ethanol. It will continue to evolve in a manner simi-
lar to the petroleum refineries in the 1900s. Ultimately, as technological devel-
opments expand and the range of products grows, biorefineries will utilize a
wide variety of feedstocks, including cellulosic biomass.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported in part by a subcontract from The Office of Biomass
Program, within the DOE Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy.
The authors thank Colin Mitchinson and Mike Knauf of Genencor International
for their guidance of the work presented.
References
85
4
Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry –
A Dutch Point of View
Ed de Jong, René van Ree, Robert van Tuil, and Wolter Elbersen
4.1
Introduction
As a major policy goal for 2020, the Dutch government has stipulated that 10%
of its energy use should be provided by renewable sources to meet its Kyoto ob-
jectives. Biomass is expected to be a major contributor with an expected share
of more than 50% of the policy goal mentioned. Further, the Ministry of Eco-
nomic Affairs has defined some very ambitious policy targets for biomass in the
longer term (2040), namely 30% fossil fuel substitution in the power and trans-
port sector and 20–45% fossil-based raw material substitution in the industrial
sector. It has been calculated that the energy-substitution policy goal corre-
sponds to a long-term required biomass substitution volume of about 600–
1000 PJth annum–1, in a scenario in which severe energy savings have also been
taken into account (Ministry of Economic Affairs 2003). Adding the very ambi-
tious raw material policy goal an additional biomass substitution volume of sev-
eral hundreds of PJth annum–1 will be required.
Biomass in the Netherlands that is not currently used for food applications is
mainly used as animal feed or as fuel for power (and heat) production. Biomass
is converted mainly by means of direct/indirect cofiring in conventional coal-fired
power plants and also by stand-alone combustion plants (Cuijk, Lelystad). To meet
the longer-term policy ambitions biomass must be applied in additional market
sectors of the Dutch economy, using new thermochemical and (bio)chemical con-
version/production processes, for example advanced gasification and fermentation
technology. A current disadvantage of these processes is that final products will be
produced that are more expensive than their fossil-based alternatives. Prolonged
financial governmental support (e.g. investment subsidies, fiscal measures) neces-
sary to support successful market implementation is currently lacking in the Neth-
erlands. Further, to meet the longer-term policy ambitions, the use of potentially
available relatively cheap organic side- and waste streams will not be sufficient.
The use of dedicated, relatively expensive “energy” crops grown both in and out-
side the Netherlands (imports) is therefore inescapable.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
86 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
Within this framework it is believed biorefineries will play a major role in the
transition to a more sustainable Dutch economy. Realization of high-efficiency bior-
efining processes at places where biomass can be gathered, grown, and/or imported
and where the “green” products can be sold to a cluster of chemical and material
industries are believed to be key technologies to meet the longer-term policy goals.
The chemical and material industries are founded on innovation. Because of
the emerging interaction between chemistry, biology, and process engineering
the industries of 2020 will be significantly different from those of today. Not
only does technological development encourage changes in the design of pro-
cesses and products, however, pressure from consumers and the general public
also fuels a transition to a more sustainable industry. This stimulates discussion
on if and how the use of renewable resources can add to a future scenario of a
continuing innovative chemical industry taking into account the wishes and
constraints of all current and future stakeholders.
This paper first provides the societal and institutional context for the transi-
tion to sustainability in the evolution of the chemical industry. Second, it reviews
different perspectives on the future of a modified chemical industry, partly result-
ing from emerging technological opportunities. Third, taking into account these
emerging technological opportunities, this paper discusses the potential of the
use of biomass in the chemical industry of today and tomorrow. Special emphasis
will be given to the potential that “biorefineries” offer the chemical industry.
4.2
Historical Outline – The Chemical Industry: Current Situation and Perspectives
4.2.1
Overview of Products and Markets
The oil industry may be divided into several important refinery sectors and
products including: gas for commercial energy supply, heavy gasoline for car
fuels, naphtha for the petrochemical industry, kerosene for aviation fuel, and oil
residues used in bitumen and lubricating oils. This review focuses on the
naphtha fraction in the petrochemical industry and the gamut of chemicals,
products, applications, and markets that can be derived from it.
The current chemical industry’s most important feedstock is naphtha which
can be cracked to obtain a range of olefins, for example ethylene and butanes,
and other small (un)saturated hydrocarbons and aromatic compounds, for ex-
4.2 Historical Outline – The Chemical Industry: Current Situation and Perspectives 87
ample benzene and alkyl benzenes. These simple hydrocarbons form the back-
bone of the possible products that are generated in the chemical industry today.
The scope of different chemicals (and transformations) that can be achieved
from naphtha for the chemical industry is illustrated schematically in Fig. 4.1.
In principal these materials can be transformed to the bulk of chemicals pro-
duced by two initial key pathways:
· they may be directly isolated, used, and transformed by a variety of chemical
techniques to a range of compounds; or
· they may undergo a gasification process to form synthesis gas (CO and H2)
which on recombination enables access to another branch of alternative
chemicals and technologies.
The chemicals described in Fig. 4.1, derived from the small (un)saturated hydro-
carbons and synthesis gas, enables an array of chemicals of technological and
economically important products, applications, and markets to be obtained. For
example:
· vinyl monomers for plastics used in pipe, packaging, and rubber applications;
· monomers for polyester and amide synthesis used in fibers (for textiles), en-
gineering materials, and some container materials;
· solvents for, among others, the paint industry;
· chemicals for the pharmaceutical industry; and
· chemicals for the insecticide and herbicide industry.
4.2.2
Technological Pathways
4.2.3
Biomass-based Industrial Products
in the food and beverage industry, although increasing amounts are also used
in bio-based transportation fuels and to prepare non-food industrial chemical
products. Although ethanol is perhaps the most widely known example of a bio-
based chemical product both in the Netherlands and worldwide, a range of
other bio-based chemical products is produced and used in a variety of indus-
trial applications. These fall into several generic categories:
· naturally occurring carbohydrate polymers;
· fats and oils of plant origin (and, to a lesser extent, of animal origin);
· terpene-based materials;
· chemical products of carbohydrate-containing materials; and
· fermentation products of carbohydrate-containing sources.
4.2.3.1 Carbohydrates
Today’s bio-based products include commodity and specialty chemicals, fuels,
and materials. Some of these products result from the direct physical or chemi-
cal processing of biomass cellulose, starch, oils, protein, lignin, and terpenes.
Most biomass consists of natural polymers and most biomass is carbohydrate in
nature. This means that most biomass is in the form of carbohydrate polymers
(polysaccharides). These natural polymers can be used both as nature provides
them and as the skeletal framework of other derived polymers.
By far the most abundant of these carbohydrate polymers is cellulose, the
principal component of the cell walls of all higher plants. It is estimated that 75
90 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
billion tons of cellulose are biosynthesized and disappear each year, most of the
disappearance being through natural decay. Cellulosic plant materials are used
as fuel, lumber, mechanical pulp, and textiles. Purified cellulose is currently
used to make wood-free paper, cellophane, photographic film, membranes, ex-
plosives, textile fibers, water-soluble gums, and organic-solvent-soluble polymers
used in lacquers and varnishes.
The principal cellulose derivative is cellulose acetate, which is used to make
photographic film, acetate rayon, a variety of thermoplastic products, and lac-
quers. The world’s annual consumption of cellulose acetate is about 750,000
tons. Cellulose acetate products are biodegradable. Commercial production of
lyocell, a cellulosic fiber made from a solvent spinning process, has also started
recently. Lyocell, which, unlike rayon, does not require dry cleaning but is wash-
able and very strong, is the first new textile fiber to be introduced in 30 years.
Cotton is currently the most important non-wood fiber crop. It is mainly used
for weaving and spinning into cloth. Advances in biotechnology and genetic en-
gineering are now enabling development of cotton cultivars with improved pest
resistance, yield, and quality, thereby potentially reducing production costs and
better matching cotton characteristics to specific applications. Natural fibers
other than cotton occupy a variety of niche markets, for example specialty fab-
rics, fiber-reinforced composites, papers, cordage, and horticultural mulches and
mixes.
Heightened environmental concerns are also helping jute, hemp, flax, sisal,
abaca, coir fibers, and products derived from these fibers to find their way into
new markets. The use of natural fibers in fiber-reinforced composites, especially,
has seen tremendous growth in Europe in recent years (van Dam et al. 2004).
4.2.3.3 Other
Terpenes, derived from woody materials, also give rise to a variety of chemicals
and products. Crude turpentine, isolated from the pulping industry, may be
used to isolate “pine oil” commonly used in cleaning products, alternatively its
components may be isolated and chemically transformed to materials such as
dipentene, which can be polymerized to prepare tacky polymers and used in
chewing gum and food packaging coatings.
Although not widespread in Western Europe and North America, several East-
ern European, Asian, and South American countries use carbohydrate-contain-
ing agricultural residues as a raw material in the chemical industry. For exam-
ple, hydrolysis of starchy materials to glucose with concomitant severe acid-cata-
lyzed degradation can result in oxalic acid, which is used in the leather industry.
Alternatively, pentoses, found in bagasse and corncobs, for example, readily un-
dergo acid-catalyzed dehydration to furfural. Furfural is a flexible chemical raw
material which can be used as a solvent itself in several applications or can be
used to prepare furfuryl alcohol used in resin materials, and tetrahydrofuran, a
common organic solvent. Although many other chemical transformations are
possible, their current commercial status is unclear.
Carbohydrates remain a flexible raw material, and beside “classical” chemical
transformations, biotechnological transformations have also been explored. For
example lactic acid can be used to prepare a biodegradable polymer with inter-
esting properties and has a wide range of potential applications including fibers
and packaging materials (Sreenath et al. 2001). Other biotech products include
citrates to prepare additive chemicals (dyeing, cleaning, and polymer) and fuma-
ric acid in preserving agents and as a component of unsaturated polyesters.
Specialty chemicals can be made using fermentation and enzymatic processes
or directly extracted from plants (or aquatic biomass). It has been shown that
plants can be altered to produce molecules with functionality and properties not
present in existing compounds (e.g. chiral chemicals). Examples of bio-based
specialty chemicals include bioherbicides and biopesticides, bulking and thick-
ening agents for food and pharmaceutical products, flavors and fragrances, nu-
traceuticals (e.g. antioxidants, noncalorific fat replacements, cholesterol-reducing
agents, and salt replacements), chiral chemicals, pharmaceuticals (e.g. Taxol),
plant-growth promoters, essential amino acids, vitamins, industrial biopolymers
such as xanthan gum, and enzymes. Specialty chemical markets currently repre-
sent a wide range of high-value products. These chemicals usually sell for more
than 4 1 kg–1. Although the worldwide market for these chemicals is smaller
than for bulk and intermediate chemicals, the specialty chemicals market now
exceeds $ 3 billion.
It is expected that advances in biotechnologies will have significant impacts
on the growth of the specialty chemicals market.
92 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
4.2.4
International Perspectives
In several industrialized countries (i.e. USA, UK, and the Netherlands) govern-
ment, business, society, and science have been engaged in outlining future de-
velopments in the material and chemical industry (American Chemical Society
1996; Molendijk et al. 2004; National Research Council 2000; Okkerse and van
Bekkum 1997; Parris 2004; Sims 2004; UK Foresight program Chemicals Panel
2000; US Department of Energy 1998, 1999; Weaver 2000). Most of these fore-
sight exercises are led by the view that an increased demand for chemicals and
materials will place additional pressure on the use of resources and on the envi-
ronment. Accordingly, the thrust is in finding new technologies and creating
novel materials, processes, and capabilities to bring this growth in line with so-
ciety’s demand for sustainability.
The perspectives indicate a shared interest in shifting from sole dependence on
fossil resources to a chemical and material industry founded on the application of
plant-based resources, derived either from secondary streams (i.e. waste and recy-
cling) or from primary streams (i.e. dedicated production). The discussion sug-
gests that changing the resource base of the chemical and material industries will
induce cleaner processes, safer products and a more effective use of scarce re-
sources. The shift to a bio-based chemical and material industry will alter the tech-
nological basis of the industry quite radically. To substantiate the sustainable cre-
dentials of new products and processes, further research and actual implementa-
tion will indicate what specific technological routes in fact contribute to sustain-
ability. This will be necessary for communication with NGO, the general public,
regulators, and policy makers about, for example, CO2 emissions.
From the perspective of the chemical industry striving for sustainability with
sound economic foundations draws the attention to three key areas.
4.2.4.1 Production
The actual production process has a major environmental impact both on efficient
use of energy and resources and on emission and waste production; this is especially
so in bulk industries. This links the provision of multi-quality biomass and the in-
dustrial production process. Because of the large volumes used, it may have a far-
reaching impact on the environment. Cost reduction, because of cheaper raw ma-
terials or processes with less extreme conditions, will be an important consideration.
4.2.4.2 Integration
Implementing a strategy for sustainability requires coordination between differ-
ent levels of a supply chain, product portfolio, and fine-tuning between distrib-
uted technological capabilities. Key technologies in conversion, extraction, and
separation will lay the foundation for further improvement in bulk production
and the development of products with well defined functionality.
4.3 Biomass: Technology and Sustainability 93
This requires an integrated view on resource use and a strategic view on tech-
nology development. Linking of life sciences, chemistry, energy technology, and
process engineering is required for taking up such a challenge.
4.3
Biomass: Technology and Sustainability
The chemical industry undergoes rapid and important changes inherent to the
turmoil resulting from transitions at the end of an industry’s current lifecycle.
These changes require new technological, organizational, and commercial an-
swers from the industry. Moreover, the business strategy of the chemical indus-
try will become increasingly dependent on the acceptance or rejection by society
and consumers of its activities and its conduct. This section introduces a per-
spective on a chemical industry that combines technological innovation with a
socially acceptable business strategy.
4.3.1
Transition to a Bio-based Industry: Sectoral Integration in the Netherlands
Products from the chemical, material, and power industries have become an in-
tegral part of our daily lives and demand for these products is projected to in-
crease. A general concern is the intensive use of finite resources, in particular
fossil resources, and, consequently, the industry is in the midst of reconsidering
its current resource use. Two major Dutch companies communicated its transi-
tion to the general public – the chemical company DSM advertised its transition
process to a specialty company while building an image of sustainability and, in
2002, Shell, the energy company, launched a nation-wide advertisement cam-
paign highlighting the future of natural and renewable resources. In this pro-
94 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
Most likely vertically integrated companies, including Sabic and Shell, will tend
to stick to the first strategy, whereas companies not involved in exploration, e.g.
Dow, DSM, might tend to follow the second strategy. The selling of the polyole-
fins division of DSM to Sabic and the acquisition of part of Roche can be seen
as an example of this strategy. These scenarios (represented in Fig. 4.2), dis-
cussed on a number of occasions in the Netherlands, draw the attention to the
linking of the agro-sector and the food and feed-processing industry with the
chemicals and materials industry (de Klerk et al. 2002).
Although the Dutch economy still has a strong base in manufacturing, both
of food and non-food products, the agro-sector and the chemicals sector operate
remotely and lack of synergy between these two sectors may hinder progress in
4.3 Biomass: Technology and Sustainability 95
dustry, including starch, sugar, and vegetable oils, results in a high “biomass in-
tensity”. A related factor is the opportunity to direct secondary flows, side, and
waste streams, to other industries; without the absorption of these secondary
flows, mainly by the feed and alcohol producers, the continuity of the process-
ing industry would be in danger (Rabobank International 2001). This sketches a
landscape wherein a new synthesis between sectors is possible. This contrasts,
however, with the current low-value use of renewable resources, mainly in the
feed and power industry. A driver for change in the feed industry might origi-
nate in recent scares about the use of slaughter residues and of potentially haz-
ardous fats and oils in feed, bringing these undesired components in the cycle
for human consumption. The European debate on genetically modified crops
might also result in stricter regulation of the use of these crops in feed and
food. Consequently, the composition of feed is affected by public pressures and
stricter regulation which, in combination with the tendency to reduce the inten-
sive livestock industry in the Netherlands, might lead to the disappearance of
existing markets for secondary flows. This will place high pressure on the food
processing industry, because secondary or waste streams will become a cost
rather than an income generator (Rabobank International 2001).
The short-term question is where the food processing industry and the agro-
sector can market their secondary resource flows and/or plant-based resources;
this is an environmental and economic problem. Therefore, companies, re-
search institutes, and government try to address the issue of creating new
chances for biomass, which includes finding alternative markets for residues
and waste streams. A related question is how to find high-value utilization and
application of these renewable resources, in addition to low-value energy and
bulk products. This will require fine-tuning of the quality, price, and quantity of
renewable resources with demand in the end-user market and functionality re-
quirements of new products. We must, therefore, turn round and move from
demand and functionality to processing and, eventually, to the production or
supply of the raw material.
The next section briefly identifies how different social actors perceive healthy
and sustainable products and processes, to provide a guide for formulating tech-
nology agendas for the chemicals and materials industry.
4.3.2
Can Sustainability Drive Technology?
One of the more important societal driving forces is the drive for sustainability.
Directing innovation and technology development from the perspective of a sus-
tainable, bio-based society is one of the major challenges for the chemicals and
materials industries. In response to this widely conceived public concern, com-
panies try to focus their business strategies both on sustainability, including en-
vironmental concerns, and on consumer demands for safe products. Most com-
panies trying to address the three Ps (planet, people, profit) are, however, well
aware that profit is always the ultimate driving force.
4.4 The Chemical Industry: Biomass Opportunities – Biorefineries 97
4.4
The Chemical Industry: Biomass Opportunities – Biorefineries
The preceding paragraphs have shown the scope of chemical products that are cur-
rently produced and therefore the targeted product portfolio of biomass-based chem-
ical products. It was also shown that drivers for a transition to a bio-based economy
lie not in technological opportunities alone but are a complex combination of so-
cietal, economic, and technological opportunities, challenges, and constraints. This
section will focus in more detail on the main technological opportunities to transfer
biomass, either directly or via chemical intermediates, into chemical products.
4.4.1
Biomass Opportunities
The second approach, the integrated process chain approach, follows the analog
of the petrochemical industry. In this scheme a “universal” substrate is first
transformed into universal building blocks, based on which chemical products
are produced. In this approach it is thought that it is economically and techno-
logically beneficial to build chemicals in highly integrated production facilities.
The main technological challenges for this approach lie in the high-efficiency
transformation of biomass into commonly known building blocks for the petro-
chemical industry (van Tuil 2002).
The main technologies producing chemicals from biomass are:
· biomass refining or pretreatment;
· thermochemical conversion (gasification, pyrolysis, hydrothermal upgrading
(HTU));
· fermentation and bioconversion; and
· product separation and upgrading.
4.4.2
Biorefinery Concept
4.4.3
Biomass Availability
The Netherlands is a small country where land is scarce. Although the options for
primary crop production are limited, the biomass flux of utilized biomass (organic
material) is very high (partially imported). An estimated 42 million dry tons of bio-
mass (13 ton ha–1) (van Dam et al., in preparation) are used and produced in dif-
ferent sectors of the economy (compare with a biomass flux some 5 tonnes for
Germany). As markets change this high turnover of biomass does generate many
opportunities for reallocating streams toward biorefinery feedstocks.
One of the largest biomass streams is produced in the agri-industrial com-
plex. Many of these streams can be regarded as byproducts. Approximately
10 million tonnes (as received) of byproducts are currently mostly (90%) used
for animal feed (Vis 2002; Elbersen et al. 2002). These byproducts vary from
slaughterhouse wastes to discarded frying oil, potato peel, etc. As traditional
markets change (diminish) and markets for biobased energy and products in-
crease, a large part of these streams can become partially available for biorefi-
nery. This change in market demand for feed is already apparent from the de-
cline in livestock (from 4.6 in 1995 to 3.6 million in 2003), and pigs (14.5 mil-
lion in 1995 to 10.7 million in 2003), which leads to a smaller demand for feed.
Another estimate has been made of the potentially available (ligno)cellulose
biomass feedstocks in The Netherlands that could be used for ethanol produc-
tion (de Jong et al. 2003). The total amount of these technically suitable feed-
stocks is approximately 12 million tons (dry weight) per year (about 220 PJth an-
num–1), excluding import and biomass energy crops. The potential feedstocks
are highly variable, however, and include a range of agro-industrial residues,
agricultural wastes, forestry residues, and household organic waste, etc.
4.4 The Chemical Industry: Biomass Opportunities – Biorefineries 101
4.4.4
Primary Refinery
Deriving a raw material stream with desired specifications (i.e. amount of ash,
fermentable sugars, lignin) while simultaneously extracting valuable compo-
nents from the heterogeneous biomass streams is one of the major biorefinery
research and development issues. The main research and development areas
which must be addressed before an efficient biomass pretreatment chain can be
established are:
· characterization and standardization of raw materials and products;
· development of a cost-effective infrastructure for production, collection, char-
acterization, storage, identity preservation, pre-processing activities, import
102 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
4.4.5
Secondary Thermochemical Refinery
Within the sixth Framework Program of the EU, ECN et al. are currently (Oc-
tober 2004) preparing a large STREP proposal concerning the modification of
existing coal-based slagging oxygen-blown entrained-flow-based gasification tech-
nology for 100% biomass use. Main research areas are biomass feeding, gasifi-
cation/slag behavior, product gas cooling, and the commercial applicability of
produced solid waste streams. The final goal is to design, build, and operate
several MWth pilot plants within 4 years, so that large commercial implementa-
tion can become feasible around 2010. The gasification processes mentioned all
require size-reduced and relatively dry (about 15–20% moisture maximum) bio-
mass fuels. “Wet” biomass fuels require rigorous drying before they can be
used.
Alternatively these fuels can potentially be converted by means of sub/super-
critical gasification processes (or fermentation processes, see Section 4.4.6).
Supercritical biomass gasification is performed at conditions above the critical
point of water (374 8C, 221 bar), mostly in the temperature range 500–700 8C.
Under these conditions an H2-rich product gas is produced. Under subcritical
conditions (temperature range approx. 350–400 8C) a methane-rich gas will be
produced. Under these conditions for full carbon conversion very low dry matter
concentrations and a catalyst are required. Although bench/pilot facilities are
available – FZK (D) 100 L h–1 (since 2003), University of Twente (NL) 5–30 L h–1
(since 1998) – the ECN opinion is that some years of laboratory-scale PhD
work will be required before the potential commercial implementation of
this technology. The technology is expected to be developed for “green natural
gas” (SNG) production; for the production of hydrogen, ECN has the opinion
that this technology will not become financially competitive in the longer
term. Some main research items are: feeding, heat exchange and catalyst be-
havior.
Within the framework of the biorefinery concept, two gasification-based path-
ways can be distinguished.
· Application of the biorefinery concept to increase the financial yield of “con-
ventional” gasification processes. By separating highly added-value compo-
nents from raw biomass fuels before conversion, or afterwards from the raw
“products” in product gas clean-up/conditioning, the overall plant economics
could be improved, simplifying market implementation (Fig. 4.5).
· Development of highly efficient advanced gasification-based thermochemical
secondary biorefining processes. By developing advanced catalyst-supported
staged or subcritical gasification processes it is expected that a variety of
“products” could be separated from biomass in such a way that the overall
process will be market competitive, without the need for substantial govern-
mental support.
104 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
4.4.6
Secondary Biochemical Refinery – Fermentative Processes
· The costs of fermentation processes for bulk processes are higher than those
for the corresponding chemical process.
· The natural product spectrum of microorganisms is limited.
· In fermentation processes several side streams are formed which can be coped
with on the small scale but will cause a severe burden on the bulk scale.
4.4.6.1 Feedstocks
Most feedstocks currently used for fermentation processes are based on sugar
beet, sugar cane, and corn. To reduce feedstock costs other substrates must be
used. Several alternative feedstocks are being considered, for example fruit
waste, wood, straw, agricultural waste streams, dung, oils, and fatty acids, etc.
Among these the lignocellulosic materials are the most abundant polysaccha-
ride-containing biomass available in the world and are therefore an extensively
studied feedstock for fermentation processes. For almost all microorganisms
this lignocellulosic material must be hydrolyzed into its component saccharides
by mechanical pretreatment, followed by acid, base, or heat treatment, use of or-
ganic solvents or wet-oxidation to open the matrix, and, usually, enzymatic hy-
drolysis of the cellulose. The costs of the hydrolytic enzymes are the main ex-
pense in feedstock pretreatment and hydrolysis.
Hydrolysates from lignocellulosic materials contain, beside C6 sugars such as
glucose, also C5 sugars, for example xylose, and inhibitors. The relative amount
depends on the type of feedstock and the process used. Bakers’ yeast, used in
the production of ethanol, cannot use these C5 sugars. It has been calculated
that for a competitive process these C5 sugars also must be converted into etha-
nol. This is probably also true for other, future, processes.
4.5
Conclusions, Outlook, and Perspectives
4.5.1
Biomass – Sustainability
A transition towards increased use of biomass originates from its possible con-
tribution to sustainable production of energy, fuels, chemicals, and materials.
Several chemicals can, moreover, be more easily or energy-efficiently produced
from biomass than from other feedstock. Many of these products can be ex-
tracted directly from the biomass.
The importance of biomass use towards the sustainability of the production
of chemicals is directly linked to the scale of production. It is, moreover, often
questioned whether the use of biomass for energy, fuels, and chemicals can
form a symbiosis with the use of the same biomass for the production of food,
feed, and materials, for example paper and wood. Also mentioned is the uncer-
tainty of the implication of a change in the main feedstock for energy and fuels
industry on the chemical industry.
4.5 Conclusions, Outlook, and Perspectives 107
What will be the main feedstock for energy and fuels in 50 years time –
water, sunlight, natural gas, or biomass? Are the conversion technologies men-
tioned in this study elegant ways of waste disposal in the food, feed, and cellu-
lose/paper industry? Is biomass mainly of interest for extraction of valuable che-
micals? What will be the impact of a biotechnological revolution on the opportu-
nities and pitfalls of biomass?
Some of these questions have been introduced in this paper. It is, however,
suggested that further insight into the role of biomass in chemicals production
in the Netherlands will be obtained by scenario evaluation. The result of this
evaluation will make it possible to choose feedstock/conversion technology com-
binations that maximize the potential of biomass use for chemicals and chemi-
cal products.
4.5.2
Biomass Refining and Pretreatment
4.5.3
Conversion Technology
4.5.4
Chemicals and Materials Design
4.5.5
Dutch Energy Research Strategy (“EOS”)
References
Ahmed, I. and Morris, D. J. (1994) Replac- fuels, and products from biomass, 2nd
ing Petrochemicals with Biochemicals: A World Conference and Technology Exhibi-
Pollution Prevention Strategy for the Great tion on Biomass for Energy, Industry and
Lakes. Minneapolis: Institute for Local Climate Protection, Rome, Italy, 10–14
Self-Reliance. May 2004.
American Chemical Society, American Insti- Chotani, G., Dodge, T., Hsu, A., Kumar, M.,
tute of Chemical Engineers, Chemical LaDuca, R., Trimbur, D., Weyler, W. and
Manufacturers Association, Council for Sanford, K. (2000) The commercial pro-
Chemical Research, Synthetic Organic duction of chemicals using pathway engi-
Chemical Manufacturers Association neering. Biochim Biophys Acta, 1543 (2):
(1996) Technology vision 2020; the U.S. 434–455.
chemical industry (downloaded at http:// Coombs, R. (1995) Firm strategies and
www.acs.org) technological choices. In: Rip et al. (eds)
Biebl, H., Menzel, K., Zeng, A. P., and Managing technology in society: the approach
Deckwer, W. D. (1999) Microbial produc- of constructive technology assessment.
tion of 1,3-propanediol, Appl. Microbiol. Pinter Publishers: London, New York,
Biotechnol., 52, 289–297. 331–345.
Boerrigter H. et al. (2004). Thermal Biore- Dam, J. E. G. van, de Klerk-Engels, B.,
finery; high-efficient integrated production Struik, P. C. and Rabbinge, R. (2004) Sec-
of renewable chemicals, (transportation) uring renewable resources supplies for
110 4 Biorefineries for the Chemical Industry – A Dutch Point of View
Workshop on Biomass and Agriculture: for fulfilling a vision to enhance U.S. eco-
10–13 June 2003, Vienna, Austria. OECD nomic security through renewable plant/crop-
Code 512004011P1, pp 37–62. based resource use (available at http://
Sreenath, H. K., Moldes, A. B., Koegel, R. G. www.oit.doe.gov/agriculture/).
and Straub, R. J. (2001) Lactic acid produc- Vis, M. (2002) Beschikbaarheid van reststro-
tion from agriculture residues. Biotechnol. men uit de voedings – en enotmiddelenin-
Lett. 23:179–184. dustrie voor energieproductie. A report for
UK Foresight Programme Chemicals Panel Novem, Utrecht. DEN nr 2020-01-23-03-
(2000) A chemicals renaissance (available at 0003/4700001071 (in Dutch).
(http://www.foresight.gov.uk) Weaver, P., Jansen, L., van Grootveld, G.,
US Department of Energy (1998) Plant/ van Spiegel, E. and Vergragt, Ph. (2000)
Crop-based Renewable Resources 2020: A vi- Sustainable technology development. Green-
sion to enhance U.S. economic security leaf Publishing: Sheffield.
through renewable plant/crop-based resource Zeikus, J. G., Jain, M. K. and Elankovan, P.
use (available at http://www.oit.doe.gov/ (1999) Biotechnology of succinic acid pro-
agriculture/). duction and markets for derived industrial
US Department of Energy (1999) The Tech- products. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 51,
nology Roadmap for Plant/Crop-based Re- 545–552.
newable Resources 2020: research priorities
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part II
Biorefinery Systems
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
115
5
The Lignocellulosic Biorefinery –
A Strategy for Returning to a Sustainable Source of Fuels
and Industrial Organic Chemicals
L. Davis Clements and Donald L. Van Dyne
5.1
The Situation
The current, historically high, prices of crude oil are causing economic hardship
for families and businesses worldwide, because of the resulting high energy
prices. The estimated impacts of increasing energy costs for farmers, truckers,
and airlines exceed US $ 13 billion per year for the United States alone. At the
same time, it is clear that increasing demand and a finite supply of petroleum
will sustain the rising prices and increase competition for secure petroleum
supplies.
The strategy outlined here not only addresses these issues, but also provides
major benefits to the environment and to farm incomes. This is all accom-
plished by using known, proven chemical processes (no new research needed)
and at very attractive rates of return on investment (ROI) that will not require
long-term government subsidies when this new industry is established.
5.2
The Strategy
At the most basic level, the strategy is to reduce then, essentially, eliminate de-
pendence on petroleum as the primary source of liquid fuels and industrial or-
ganic chemicals (where “industrial organic chemicals” includes those made
from both petroleum and biological resources). This is accomplished by replac-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
116 5 The Lignocellulosic Biorefinery
5.2.1
A Strategy Within a Strategy
5.2.2
Environmental Benefits
5.2.3
The Business Structure
Because a major source of the biomass needed for this transition is “2nd use”,
this provides a unique opportunity for new business partnerships. Municipal
solid wastes (MSW), agricultural crop residues, and forestry residues comprise
the bulk of the 2nd-use sources.
The biomass input resources are the major component of the operating cost
of production of liquid fuels and industrial organic chemicals for the biorefi-
nery. Because these inputs are now considered to be of low or even negative val-
ue, the owners of these 2nd-use resources can very profitably move these bio-
118 5 The Lignocellulosic Biorefinery
mass materials into the refining process, but delay taking their share of the
profit until the final products are produced and sold. Thus, the 2nd-use produc-
ers would receive their fair share of the generated profits after the increased val-
ue has been added. This provides a considerably better return than the current
negative, zero, or near zero waste value.
The 2nd-use strategy leads directly to the concept of a business partnership
comprising the biorefinery owner(s) and the biomass production owner(s). For
agricultural wastes and residues, assembly of these inputs could be achieved by
use of already existing cooperatives and/or farmer organizations. Similarly,
MSW inputs could be supplied through existing waste-management companies
or municipal waste-management operations.
It is envisaged that the biomass suppliers would participate equally with the
biorefinery companies in the direction and operation of the partnership. Essen-
tially, the business model is one of vertical integration through a collaborative
partnership or a joint venture business.
5.2.4
Cost Estimates
5.3
Comparison of Petroleum and Biomass Chemistry
5.3.1
Petroleum Resources
Utilization of petroleum for the production of liquid fuels and organic chemi-
cals involves both physical separation of the numerous different compounds
and chemical synthesis. Fuels production is primarily a separation process, with
additional synthesis needed for higher-quality products, for example reformu-
lated gasoline, and for removal of sulfur and nitrogen. Crude petroleum is sepa-
rated into different fractions according to molecular size by distillation. Distilla-
tion processes account for approximately three percent of the US total energy
budget.
The largest-volume fuel produced from petroleum is gasoline. Gasoline is a
mixture of smaller (four to eight carbon) straight-chain hydrocarbons recovered
by distillation and synthetically created branched chain hydrocarbons with a
similar number of carbon atoms. Diesel fuel consists of larger (nine to fifteen
carbon) hydrocarbons that are recovered largely by distillation.
Nitrogen, sulfur, and phosphorus are elements that occur naturally in petro-
leum and must be removed from liquid fuels, largely because of the detrimental
environmental effects of their combustion products. The removal processes typi-
cally involve catalytic reactions under extreme operating conditions.
Petrochemical products are, in general, based on chemical addition of organic
functional groups such as hydroxyl, aldehyde, acid, ester, etc., or other elements,
such as oxygen, nitrogen, and halides. Much of the synthetic chemistry used is
based on addition of functional groups to olefin hydrocarbons such as ethylene,
propylene, and butylenes. Ethylene, propylene, and butylene are derived by
high-temperature processing of ethane, propane, and butane recovered from
petroleum crude oil by distillation. Benzene occurs naturally in petroleum, but
most of the benzene family of hydrocarbons is produced synthetically by catalyt-
ic reforming of hexane and/or alkylation reactions. A representation of the pet-
rochemical products families is given in Fig. 5.1.
5.3.2
Biomass Resources
In addition to these basic structural resources, there are hundreds of specific or-
ganic compounds of biomass origin that have commercial uses ranging from
medicinal materials, nutrients and natural products, to industrial products.
120 5 The Lignocellulosic Biorefinery
5.3.3
Saccharides and Polysaccharides
5.3.4
Lignin
5.3.5
Triacylglycerides (or Triglycerides)
glyceride looks like a comb with three long tines. The backbone of the comb is
a three-carbon hydroxycarbon, dehydrated glycerol, with three medium to long-
chain fatty acids attached. The fatty acid part of the molecule is a 7 to 31-carbon
hydrocarbon chain with an organic acid group at one end. Triglycerides are rela-
tively easily reacted with water or alcohols to form free fatty acids or fatty acid
esters, respectively, with glycerol as co-product.
Vegetable oils and animal fats are an essential part of our diet. As such, they
are available as recyclable materials in the form of recycled cooking oils and as
the “float-grease” fraction recovered in municipal water treatment plants. In the
United States an average of 10 kg of “waste” triglyceride materials is produced
per person annually [2].
Derivatives of fats and oils have extensive use in non-food/feed applications.
Current uses of triglyceride derivatives range from latex paints, high perfor-
mance lubricants and polymers, to biodiesel fuel and personal care products.
The hydrocarbon structure of the fatty acid chain has facilitated the accep-
tance and use of triglycerides and their esters in conjunction with traditional
petrochemical products. In fact, use of fats and oils for the production of indus-
trial chemical products (oleochemical industry) is the largest contribution to the
current industrial chemical industry made by biomass resources today.
5.3.6
Proteins
Proteins are long-chain polyamides based solely upon amino acid units. The
–(NH)– (peptide) bonds characteristic of proteins are the same bonds found in
industrial Nylons. The primary non-food/feed uses for proteins currently are as
leather products, protein glues, and personal-care products. There are opportu-
nities for the creation of “designer proteins”, for example synthetic spider silk
for light-weight, high strength cables or for polymer films and adhesives, but
progress in this area has been somewhat slow.
5.4
The Chemistry of the Lignocellulosic Biorefinery
The production of liquid fuels and industrial chemicals from biomass will rely
most heavily on the utilization of polysaccharide, lignocellulosic, and triacylgly-
ceride feedstocks. These materials are available, easily assembled, and storable
in the large quantities. In addition, these materials may be converted into prod-
ucts that are identical, or functionally equivalent, to current petroleum-based liq-
uid fuels and industrial chemicals.
Petroleum is predominantly a liquid resource, with some gases and a small
fraction of solid materials (waxes and asphalts). As such, every petroleum refi-
nery begins with a massive distillation system to separate the crude oil into a
large number of “cuts” that are further manipulated into the desired products.
5.4 The Chemistry of the Lignocellulosic Biorefinery 123
make furfural. Furfural is the starting point for a large family of derivative
chemical and polymer products. The adipic acid and the hexamethylene dia-
mine used in the original synthesis of Nylon-6,6 were made by acid hydrolytic
depolymerization of hemicellulose from oat hulls, followed by chemical synthe-
sis of the monomers and condensation polymerization to form the Nylon-6,6.
There are several possible ways of using lignocellulosic and other categories of
biomass for production of fuels and chemicals. Because the initial production
steps involve solid materials, preparation and handling of the raw materials is
more complicated and costly than using petroleum liquids. Also, as noted
5.5 Examples of Integrated Biorefinery Applications 125
above, biomass materials are more disperse and less dense than petroleum.
This means that assembly and storage of the raw materials is more complicated
than for petroleum.
Finally, some of the biomass resources, notably crops and crop residues, are
cyclical in production. This means that storage and integration with other re-
sources are necessary in the design and management of a biorefinery complex.
5.5
Examples of Integrated Biorefinery Applications
5.5.1
Production of Ethanol and Furfural from Lignocellulosic Feedstocks
5.5.2
Management of Municipal Solid Waste
Municipal solid wastes (MSW) are the largest single source of lignocellulosic
materials available for utilization in modern society. Most localities have sys-
tems for collection and “disposal” of these materials. Too often the “disposal”
consists of burial of the materials. Typically approximately 25% of the waste is
126 5 The Lignocellulosic Biorefinery
5.5.3
Coupling MSW Management, Ethanol, and Biodiesel
5.6
Summary
References
10 Lowenstein, M. Z., Energy Applications New Crops, New Uses, New Markets –
of Biomass, Elsevier Applied Sciences 1992 Yearbook of Agriculture, US De-
Publishers, New York, 1985. partment of Agriculture, Washington,
11 Thames, S., R. Kleiman and L. D. Clem- D.C., 1992.
ents, “How Crops Can Provide Raw Ma-
terials for the Chemical Industry,” in
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
129
6
Lignocellulosic Feedstock Biorefinery:
History and Plant Development for Biomass Hydrolysis
Raphael Katzen and Daniel J. Schell
6.1
Introduction
6.2
Hydrolysis of Biomass Materials
6.2.1
Acid Conversion
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
130 6 Lignocellulosic Feedstock Biorefinery: History and Plant Development for Biomass Hydrolysis
6.2.2
Enzymatic Conversion
Sugar yields are limited during acid hydrolysis because sugars are also con-
verted to degradation products. Cellulase, a multi-component enzyme system,
catalyzes cellulose hydrolysis and is 100% selective for conversion of cellulose to
glucose; high yields are, therefore, possible. This enzyme is produced by a vari-
ety of microorganisms, most commonly, the fungus Trichoderma reesei.
Cellulose conversion rates are limited by the ability of the enzyme to access
the cellulosic substrate. To increase accessibility, biomass is subjected to physi-
cal and chemical treatments that disrupt the biomass structure, usually by re-
moving a fraction of the hemicellulose and/or lignin. Effective pretreatment is
necessary to achieve good cellulose-to-glucose conversion yields.
6.3
Acid Hydrolysis Processes
6.3.1
Early Efforts to Produce Ethanol
Before World War II, research was conducted in the United States on hydrolysis
of biomass to produce sugars for production of ethanol with emphasis on the
use of forest and wood-processing wastes; no operation achieved true commer-
cial success, however. Sherrard and Kressman [1] highlight developments in
acid-based hydrolysis technology before World War II. In the early 1900s, a
6.3 Acid Hydrolysis Processes 131
plant was built in Hattiesburg, MS, USA, to process wood waste using sulfur-
ous acid, but never operated successfully [2]. A commercial operation was also
set up in Georgetown, SC, USA in the 1910s to process wood waste using dilute
sulfuric acid, but eventually failed because of low ethanol yields [3].
Process development was being investigated in Germany at the same time.
One process used concentrated hydrochloric acid [4] to hydrolyze the carbohy-
drate fraction of wood waste. The treated material was then neutralized with
caustic soda to yield a mixture of wood-based sugars and salt (sodium chloride),
used primarily as cattle feed. In another process, a 7300 dry metric ton year–1
plant hydrolyzed wood chips in countercurrent diffusers by contact with 42%
(w/w) HCl to produce a concentrated sugar solution [5]. After World War II the
plant was extensively rebuilt to use a modified process known as the Udic–Rhei-
nau process [6].
Work on sulfuric acid processes was also conducted in Germany at the same
time, leading to the development of the Scholler process [7]. The Scholler pro-
cess used a percolation reactor to hydrolyze wood waste, producing glucose as
the primary product; this was then fermented to ethanol. Many such plants
were built in Germany and Russia before World War II. The extensive use of
water required for this process, however, produced a rather dilute (4%) sugar
stream that was more costly to process.
In the late 1930s, a continuous wood-hydrolysis pilot plant was built in the
United States to produce lignocellulosic plastics, and wood sugars, furfural, and
acetic acid as by-products [3]. The plant was designed to hydrolyze wood slurries
continuously with dilute sulfuric acid by pumping the mixture through heated
hydrolysis tubes and then recovering the solid product. The plant produced
180–260 kg day–1 hydrolyzed product.
At the beginning of World War II molasses was fermented to ethanol as a
raw material for synthesis of butanediol, which in turn was polymerized to pro-
duce synthetic rubber. Because German submarines were sinking transports
from Cuba containing shipments of molasses and ethanol, the US government
made the decision to develop technology for producing ethanol from wood
waste for the synthetic rubber program. The Defense Plant Corporation, an or-
ganization of the US Government, awarded a contract to the Vulcan Copper
and Supply Company (later known as Vulcan Cincinnati) to design and to con-
struct a facility to produce ethanol. The author (Raphael Katzen) was involved
as the senior process engineer and later as the project manager for design and
construction of this facility in Springfield, OR, USA. The plant was designed to
process 270 metric tons (dry basis) day–1 of softwood sawdust trucked from saw-
mills in the area, with the goal of producing 208 L/dry metric ton (50 gal/dry
ton) ethanol.
This plant was based on modifications to the Scholler process, as a result of
work at the Forest Products Laboratory (FPL) of the US Department of Agricul-
ture in Madison, Wisconsin, USA. Based on early work by Ritter [8] and Sher-
rard [9], FPL built a pilot facility that improved upon the Scholler technology,
yielding the Madison-Scholler process [10, 11].
132 6 Lignocellulosic Feedstock Biorefinery: History and Plant Development for Biomass Hydrolysis
Vulcan Cincinnati’s design for their plant was based on the Madison-Scholler
process and used information and data produced during test runs of the FPL pi-
lot plant. Equipment was designed and fabricated at Vulcan’s shops in Cincinna-
ti, OH, USA, and construction was carried out in Springfield, OR, USA, with
the assistance of contractors. Although construction was stopped at the end of
World War II, the Defense Plant Corporation decided to complete the facility
and test the technology.
Plant construction was completed in 1946 and the plant was started up under
management of the Willamette Valley Wood Chemical Company, a group of in-
dividuals in the local forest products industry. Test runs were then initiated with
Vulcan providing technical management under Raphael Katzen’s supervision.
Despite problems with tar formation and calcium sulfate deposits from neutrali-
zation of sulfuric acid used to hydrolyze the cellulose, the design production
rate was achieved. The process proved too costly to compete with petroleum-de-
rived synthetic ethanol which appeared on the scene at the end of World War
II, however. Efforts were made to utilize the Springfield facility for production
of waxy products, but it was not designed for this operation and the plant was
shut down and dismantled.
With the prevalence of cheap petroleum-derived ethanol and other petrochem-
ical products after World War II, there was little economic incentive to pursue
cellulose hydrolysis technology further. In Germany many of the plants shut
down and most of the Scholler process plants in Russia were converted to sin-
gle-cell yeast production, because it was a more profitable product than ethanol.
Research did continue, however, in various laboratories and pilot plants in dif-
ferent parts of the world. In the 1950s the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA)
built a dilute-sulfuric-acid-hydrolysis-based pilot plant using percolation reactors
at Muscle Shoals, AL, USA [12]. The New Zealand Forest Products Laboratory
built a similar plant in the 1980s [13]. Several pilot facilities were also built in
the 1980s that performed continuous dilute-sulfuric-acid hydrolysis of cellulose
and hemicellulose and were able to process 1–2 metric dry tons of biomass per
day. Plug-flow reactor systems processing dilute biomass streams were con-
structed by the American Can Company [14] and at the Solar Energy Research
Institute (SERI), now the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), in
Golden, CO, USA [15]. Systems for processing high-solids biomass streams
were constructed using twin-screw extruders at New York University [16] and in
Canada by Bio-hol/St Lawrence Reactor [17], and TVA installed a new system
using a modified pulp digester [18]. Except for the new reactor at TVA and a
new but similar reactor recently installed at the NREL [19], none of these sys-
tems is currently operational.
In the mid-1980s researchers at the SERI proposed a “progressing batch reac-
tor system” [20] that retained the simplicity of percolation reactors but achieved
countercurrent flow of liquors to reduce sugar losses due to degradation reac-
tions even further compared with percolation reactors. Further testing of the
system, however, did not produce substantial sugar yield improvements [21]. In
the late 1990s, the idea of a countercurrent shrinking bed reactor was also pro-
6.3 Acid Hydrolysis Processes 133
posed for dilute-acid total cellulose hydrolysis [22], but operational difficulties
limited the effectiveness of this system.
Several economic studies performed by engineering companies in the early
1980s to evaluate dilute-acid total hydrolysis processes for production of ethanol
[23, 24] showed the economics to be favorable. The potential of enzymatic cellu-
lose hydrolysis to achieve better yields was shifting emphasis away from acid
hydrolysis to enzymatic-based processing, however [25].
Although there is no current active effort to build dilute-acid based cellulose
plants, two companies are pursuing concentrated acid hydrolysis processing. Ar-
kenol has examined the ability of using recombinant Z. mobilis to ferment acid
hydrolysates produced by its concentrated-acid hydrolysis process [26] and is
pursuing international opportunities to build a large-scale plant. Masada Re-
sources Group plans to build a waste-handling facility in Middetown, NY, USA,
that will use its patented OxyNol process to recycle or convert municipal solid
waste. Profitable economics for both companies rely on achieving cost-effective
recovery of the acid catalyst.
6.3.2
Other Products
6.4
Enzymatic Hydrolysis Process
6.4.1
Early History
6.4.2
Enzyme-Based Plant Development
University of Arkansas and Procter and Gamble, erected a pilot plant at a pulp
mill in Pennsylvania, USA, to process pulp mill waste through disc refiners fol-
lowed by SSF in a 9500-L fermentor [30]. In 1987, a 3000 kg day–1 pilot plant
that processed wheat straw through a batch digester (no catalyst) and used the
washed pretreated solids to produce cellulase that was subsequently used to sac-
charify the remaining washed solids was constructed in the Voest-Alpine Bio-
mass Technology Center [41]. Two pilot plants were also constructed in Japan.
One operated from 1983 to 1987 and processed 500 kg day–1 bagasse or rice
straw. It used mild alkaline pretreatment then enzymatic saccharification of the
pretreated biomass with cellulase produced on Avicel as the carbon source, fol-
lowed by sugar concentration using reverse osmosis and subsequent fermenta-
tion to produce ethanol [42]. The other plant operated from 1986 to 1990 and
processed 1000 kg day–1 cedar wood or white birch chips. It used steam explo-
sion to treat the wood that was then fermented with a strain of Clostridium [43].
In the early 1990s, the US Department of Energy (DOE) and NREL con-
structed a fully integrated 900 kg day–1 pilot plant to produce ethanol from a
variety of lignocellulosic biomass sources [19] that used a modified pulp digester
for pretreatment that has already been discussed. The plant includes unit opera-
tions for feedstock handling, pretreatment in a modified pulp digester, seed cul-
ture production, SSF in 9000-L fermentors, feed tanks for enzyme and nutrient
addition, ethanol stripping in a sieve-tray distillation column, and solid–liquid
separation. The plant has also extensive instrumentation for process control and
data collection. The plant was operated on a corn fiber feedstock during a 15-
day run [44] and was later operated continuously for up to six weeks [45].
The Iogen Company of Ottawa, Canada, recently built a 983,000-L-ethanol-per-
year demonstration-scale plant processing nearly 5 metric tons day–1 agricultural
residue. Because Iogen is a cellulase producer, they can supply the cellulase for
the plant from an adjacent enzyme-production facility. Although little has been
publicly disclosed about this facility and its performance, it has been reported to
produce a 4% alcohol stream from conversion of lignocellulosic biomass [46].
6.4.3
Technology Development
Advances in all three areas will be required to achieve economic viability and
thus success in the marketplace. The Consortium for Advanced Fundamentals
and Innovation (CAFI), a group of independent academic researchers, is colla-
borating in an effort to identify and develop new pretreatment technology. The
most promising technology is uncatalyzed steam explosion, liquid hot water,
pH controlled hot water, flow-through liquid hot water, dilute acid, flow-through
acid, lime, and ammonia-based processing [48].
Development of new and improved enzymes for biomass conversion has been
a focus of the US DOE for the last few years. They have funded cost-shared ef-
forts with the two largest cellulase producers, Genencor International and Novo-
zymes, to produce cost-effective enzymes with a goal of achieving a tenfold cost
reduction that would bring cost down to an estimated $ 0.50 gallon–1 ethanol.
Both companies report success in reaching this goal, but further cost reduction
is required and the DOE’s goal is to achieve an effective enzyme cost of
$ 0.10 gallon–1 ethanol.
Efficient conversion of all sugars derived from biomass to desired products is
required for this technology to become economically viable. Development of ge-
netically modified microorganisms able to utilize other sugars beside glucose
has been an ongoing effort in many laboratories [49, 50]. As also emphasized
by the last recommendation above, the ability to tolerate inhibitory substances
is also a highly desirable characteristic. Currently, however, no microorganisms
can tolerate inhibitory substances in dilute-acid pretreated biomass substrates
without some type of conditioning process that removes inhibitors.
6.5
Conclusion
References
139
7
The Biofine Process – Production of Levulinic Acid, Furfural,
and Formic Acid from Lignocellulosic Feedstocks
Daniel J. Hayes, Steve Fitzpatrick, Michael H. B. Hayes, and Julian R. H. Ross
7.1
Introduction
The energy needs of the developed world are currently over-dependent on the
utilization of finite mineral resources. Although renewable-power technologies,
for example wind and photovoltaics, may, in the future, have major roles in the
production of electricity, provision must still be made for the supply of indus-
trial chemicals and motor fuels that are currently produced predominately from
oil. In fact, of the approximately 170 chemical compounds produced annually in
the US in volumes exceeding 4.5 ´ 106 kg, 98% are derived from oil and natural
gas [1]. The vast majority of modern synthetic products are also derived from
oil. Emerging biorefinery technologies offer a sustainable alternative by utiliza-
tion of carbohydrates, the most abundant organic chemicals on the surface of
the earth. This chapter will focus on the Biofine Process [2, 3], biorefinery tech-
nology that transforms carbohydrate feedstocks into products that include the
platform chemicals levulinic acid, furfural, and formic acid in high yields. The
process involves high-temperature acid-hydrolysis in two reactors and is one of
the most advanced and commercially viable lignocellulosic-fractionating technol-
ogies currently available. The process involves the hydrolysis of polysaccharides
to their monomeric constituents, and these are then in turn continuously con-
verted into valuable platform chemicals.
7.2
Lignocellulosic Fractionation
The major polysaccharides of importance in biomass are the glucans and hemi-
celluloses. Of the glucans (carbohydrate homopolysaccharides consisting of re-
peating d-glucopyranose units), starch and cellulose are the most abundant.
Technologies utilizing starchy feedstocks (e.g. maize) for production of ethanol,
by fermentation of the liberated glucose monomers, are well-established and
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
140 7 The Biofine Process
Fig. 7.1 Physical structures of cellulose and of starch amylose and amylopectin.
7.2.1
Acid Hydrolysis of Polysaccharides
The ash content of feedstocks is important because ash tends to lower the
acidity of the mixture – the catalytic hydrogen ion is a function of the concen-
tration of the acidic solution applied and the neutralizing power of the ash [9].
It is therefore useful to measure the titratable alkalinity of feedstocks to ascer-
tain what acid levels may be necessary for their hydrolysis.
7.2.2
Production of Levulinic Acid, Formic Acid and Furfural
The Biofine Process involves the use of dilute sulfuric acid as a catalyst but dif-
fers from other dilute-acid lignocellulosic-fractionating technologies in that free
monomeric sugars are not the product. Instead, the 6-carbon and 5-carbon
monosaccharides undergo multiple acid-catalyzed reactions to give the platform
chemicals levulinic acid (C5H8O3) and furfural (C5H4O2) as the final products.
Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) is an intermediate in the production of levulin-
ic acid (4-oxopentanoic acid) from 6-carbon sugars in the Biofine Process. The
series of consecutive reactions involved in its production are illustrated in
Figs 7.3 and 7.4. These reactions have been established by numerous studies
aimed at identification of intermediate products and analyses of pathways for
their further transformation [10]. The enediol (1), obtained by enolization of d-
glucose, d-mannose, or d-fructose, is the key compound in the formation of
HMF. Further dehydration of the enediol (1) yields the product (2); which is
Fig. 7.3 Dehydration of the enediol (1) of D-glucose, D-mannose and D-fructose.
7.2 Lignocellulosic Fractionation 143
Furfural
13
mediates were proposed by Horvat et al. [12, 13] based on analysis of C NMR
spectra of the reaction mixture formed in the hydration of HMF.
7.3
The Biofine Process
Feedstock materials for a Biofine plant must be of appropriate particle size (ca
0.5 to 1 cm) to ensure efficient hydrolysis and optimum yields. The feedstock is
therefore initially shredded before the biomass particulates are conveyed by
high-pressure air injection system to a mixing tank. Here the feedstock is mixed
with recycled dilute sulfuric acid (1.5–3%, depending on feedstock and titratable
alkalinity). The Biofine Process then consists of two distinct acid-catalyzed
stages (Fig. 7.6) that are operated to give optimum yields with a minimum of
degradation products and tar formation.
The objective in the first reactor is the dominant, first-order, acid hydrolysis
of the carbohydrate polysaccharides to their soluble intermediates (e.g. HMF).
This reaction is favored by the use of a plug-flow reactor, at a temperature of
210–220 8C and a pressure of 25 bar. The rapid nature of the hydrolysis reaction
means that a residence time of only 12 s is required. Given that the products
are removed continuously, such a small residence time requires that the diame-
ter of the reactor is kept small.
The completely mixed conditions of the second reactor favor the first-order re-
action sequence leading to LA (Fig. 7.5) rather than higher-order tar-forming
condensation reactions. Although the acid concentration remains the same as
in the first reactor, operating conditions are less severe (190–200 8C, 14 bar).
This reactor is considerably larger than the first, however, because of the need
for a residence time of approximately 20 min. Furfural and other volatile prod-
ucts tend to be removed at this stage while the tarry mixture of LA and residues
are passed to a gravity separator. From here the insoluble mixture goes to a de-
hydration unit where the water and volatiles are boiled off. The heating of the
mixture to boil off the LA is conducted under reduced pressure and results in
the tarry material being “cracked”, to give a bone-dry powdery substance
(“char”). The crude 75% LA product can be purified up to a purity of 98%. The
acid is recovered in the final recycle stage, enabling it to be re-used in the sys-
tem.
In a complete Biofine plant, additional processing may then occur, depending
on the final products required. For example, syngas production from the Biofine
char (a dry, powdery material of calorific value comparable with that of bitumi-
nous coal, and composed of the residual materials in the Biofine Process which
has value as a fuel and as a soil additive) can be conducted in a gasification unit
or the LA can be esterified with ethanol to produce ethyl levulinate. The down-
stream conversions will be discussed further below.
7.3.1
Yields and Efficiencies of the Biofine Process
The maximum theoretical yield of LA from a hexose is 71.6% w/w and formic
acid makes up the remainder [14]. How close to this theoretical yield is achieved
in the conversion process will depend on the degradation reactions involved. In
addition to cellulose and LA there are likely to be many intermediates other
than those presented above. Some authors [12] have estimated there are over
100. These intermediates tend to cross-react and coalesce to form an acid-resis-
tant tar which incorporates many insoluble residues such as humins. Previously
developed technologies that attempted to produce LA from lignocellulosics were
expensive because of low LA yields (approx. 3% by mass) and significant tar for-
mation. The Biofine Process, because of its efficient reactor system and the use
of polymerization inhibitors that reduce excessive char formation [2, 3], achieves
from cellulose LA yields of 70–80% of the theoretical maximum. This translates
to conversion of approximately 50% of the mass of 6-carbon sugars to LA, with
20% being converted to formic acid and 30% to tars. The mass yield of furfural
from 5-carbon sugars is also approximately 70% of the theoretical value of
72.7%, equivalent to 50% of the mass, the remainder being incorporated in the
Biofine char. These claims have been supported by process data from a pilot
plant located in Glens Falls, New York State. This processes one dry tonne of
feedstock per day and has been operational for several test-run periods since
1996. Its construction followed successful laboratory-scale demonstrations of the
viability of the process at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden,
Colorado. In the latter experiments, paper sludges from nearby paper mills were
initially used as pilot plant feedstocks and gave LA yields ranging from 0.42 to
146 7 The Biofine Process
0.595 kg per kilo of cellulose (between 59 and 83% of the theoretical maximum
yield).
The acid-insoluble ligneous and ash components of the feedstock become in-
corporated in the Biofine char with 100% mass conversion, although the proper-
ties of the resulting materials are likely to be altered under the “cracking” condi-
tions of high-temperature and pressure. For most lignocellulosic feedstocks that
may be processed in a Biofine unit, the dry mass balance of structural polysac-
charides, lignin, and ash is likely to be close to 100%. Some feedstocks may
have a relatively high proportion of extractives (extraneous components that
may be separated from the insoluble cell wall material as a result of their solu-
bility in water or neutral organic solvents). Bark, for example, may contain up
to 25% by mass of extractives (predominately fats, waxes and terpenes) [15]
whereas some grasses may contain a significant proportion (e.g. 20%) of water-
soluble carbohydrates (WSC), depending on the time of year and environmental
conditions. Although these WSC are also potential LA precursors, their fate in
the Biofine process (as with other acid-hydrolysis schemes [16]) is likely to tend
towards tar/residue formation because the process conditions are geared to-
wards the conversion of cellulose and hence may be too strong to give LA as an
end-product from WSC. Other extractive components are also likely to be incor-
porated in the Biofine char. That may be advantageous in instances where the
char is to be combusted, given the relatively high heating values of these impu-
rities [17].
7.3.2
Advantages over Conventional Lignocellulosic Technology
The Biofine Process is entirely chemical and does not rely on the use of any
form of microorganism, as in enzymatic hydrolysis and in conventional dilute/
concentrated acid hydrolysis technologies. The use of biological agents is often
responsible for poor yields and a lower range of feasible feedstocks.
Most dilute acid hydrolysis technologies utilize microorganisms in the fer-
mentation of the fully hydrolyzed monomers (e.g. Saccharomyces cerevisiae [18]).
Some of the more recently developed schemes also utilize microorganisms in
the hydrolysis of cellulose after hemicellulose extraction (simultaneous sac-
charification and fermentation, SSF). Even in the most advanced SSF technol-
ogy the fermentation process takes a substantial time. After pretreatment, the
cellulase enzyme and fermentation organisms require about 7 days to bring
about the conversion to ethanol, compared with approximately 2 days for conver-
sion of starch and approximately 30 min for conversion of cellulose to levulinic
acid in the Biofine Process. Ethanol yields are also reduced as a result of the
formation of sugar degradation products that inhibit the organisms/enzymes
used for fermentation [19].
There are also significant problems associated with the fermentation of non-
glucose sugars, particularly xylose. Although these sugars can be converted to
ethanol by the genetically engineered yeasts that are currently available, for ex-
7.3 The Biofine Process 147
ample Pachysolen tannophilus [20], ethanol yields are not sufficient to make the
process economically attractive. It also remains to be seen whether the yeasts
can be made “hardy” enough for production of ethanol on a commercial scale
[21]. The inefficient utilization of nonglucose monosaccharide residues is a ma-
jor disadvantage in fermentation schemes because these residues may be a sig-
nificant proportion of the total polysaccharide mass (e.g. xylose makes up ap-
proximately 20% of the total dry mass in much woody and herbaceous bio-
mass). The 50% (by mass) conversion of C5 sugars to furfural in the Biofine
Process looks particularly attractive in such instances.
In avoiding the use of microorganisms, Biofine also enables use of a wider
range of heterogeneous lignocellulosic feedstocks, including those (e.g. cellulo-
sic municipal solid waste, sewage) that contain contaminants that might inhibit
fermentation. The flexibility of the technology for a variety of feedstocks has
been demonstrated over a four-month evaluation period during which the
highly heterogeneous organic fraction of municipal solid waste (from the Bronx
district of New York City) was successfully fractionated [22]. Furthermore, the
lignin content of biomass has no inhibiting effect on the Biofine Process and
this contrasts with enzymatic hydrolysis in which steric hindrance, caused by
lignin–polysaccharide linkages, limits access of fibrolytic enzymes to specific
carbohydrate moieties, this resulting in lower yields or the need for steam-explo-
sion pretreatment [23].
7.3.3
Products of the Biofine Process
Fig. 7.7 Possible markets and saleable products from the Biofine process.
Diphenolic acid (DPA) was used commercially in various resin formulations be-
fore it was replaced by the petrochemically-derived BPA which could be sup-
plied at a lower price. The reduced cost of LA production made possible with
the Biofine Process may enable DPA to recapture some market share. Extensive
research into near-term applications of DPA, particularly those that displace cur-
rently marketed BPA products, has been conducted at the Rensselaer Polytech-
nic Institute in New York State [29]. In the longer term DPA could be a viable
alternative to oil in the production of plastics.
The cost of LA produced by other technologies is the principle reason for the
high price of DPA (approx. $\phi 6 kg–1). On the basis of Biofine estimates, the
production of DPA from LA from the Biofine Process could result in a market
price of $ 2.40 kg–1. That price, based on Biofine estimates, could result in DPA
capturing 20% of the US market (2.5 ´ 108 kg year–1 for BPA). It may also result
in DPA recapturing some of the 2.5 ´ 106 kg year–1 market it held for its old use
as a coating material.
7.3 The Biofine Process 149
7.3.3.2
Succinic Acid and Derivatives
Oxidation of levulinic acid can lead to the production of succinic acid (Fig. 7.8).
Currently, succinic acid is produced using a hydrocarbon-based process. A fer-
mentation process using glucose derived from corn syrup can also produce suc-
cinic acid but this is not economically competitive. The most important uses of
succinic acid are in food additives, soldering fluxes, and pharmaceutical prod-
ucts. The US market for succinic acid is approximately 4.50 ´ 108 kg year–1, with
a market price of approximately $ 2.8 kg–1.
Succinic acid can be used to produce tetrahydrofuran (THF), 1,4-butanediol,
and c-butyrolactone (GBL). THF is formed by cyclization of succinic acid to give
succinic anhydride which is then reduced and dehydrated to provide tetrahydro-
furan. THF is a cyclic ether whose major use is as a monomer in the produc-
tion of poly(tetramethylene ether glycol) (PTMEG), a component of, among
other things, polyurethane stretch fibers (Spandex). A smaller amount of THF
is used as a solvent in poly(vinyl chloride) (PVC) cements, pharmaceuticals, and
coatings and as a reaction solvent. The Western European market for tetrahy-
drofuran is estimated to be approximately 7.5 ´ 107 kg, valued at $ 2.6 kg–1. Al-
most 80% of production is used captively, mostly for PTMEG [30].
c-Butyrolactone (C4H6O2) is used as a chemical intermediate in the manufac-
ture of the pyrrolidone solvents. It can be used in the production of pesticides,
herbicides, and plant-growth regulators. Mechanisms for the production of GBL
are currently being refined – catalysts have been identified for the selective re-
duction of succinic acid to GBL in the presence of acetic acid [31]. Although
high GBL yields have been successfully demonstrated, catalyst productivities are
currently still below commercially attractive rates [31]. The market price for 1,4-
butanediol, another possible derivative of succinic acid, is approximately
$2.30 kg–1 [30].
DALA
7.3.3.4 Methyltetrahydrofuran
The production of fuel additives via renewable feedstocks offers perhaps the
greatest potential for mass-market penetration of LA. Methyltetrahydrofuran
(MTHF) can be added to petroleum in amounts up to 30% by volume with no
adverse effects on performance, and engine modifications are not required.
Some important properties of MTHF are listed in Table 7.1. Although it has a
lower heating value than regular petroleum, it has a higher specific gravity and
hence mileage from MTHF blended fuel would be competitive. MTHF substan-
tially reduces the vapor pressure of ethanol when coblended in gasoline. This
has led to the development of “P-Series” fuels, i.e. fuels miscible with petroleum
designed for vehicles with flexible-fuel engines and containing “pentanes-plus”
hydrocarbons from natural gas, ethanol (preferably from biomass), and methyl-
tetrahydrofuran as a co-solvent for ethyl alcohol (high-octane) [40]. P-Series fuels
can be used alone or may be mixed in any proportions with petroleum. Vehicle
tailpipe and evaporative emissions tests have been conducted on three P-Series
formulations by the Environmental Protection Agency [41] and the results have
been compared with those obtained from reformulated gasoline (RFG). It was
found that the formulations had a reduced ozone-forming potential (OFP) and
resulted in reduced emissions of nonmethane hydrocarbons and total hydrocar-
bons – approximately a third of that formed with Phase 2 RFG. It has been esti-
mated that when the MTHF and ethanol are derived from biological materials,
the full fuel-cycle greenhouse gas emissions will be between 45 and 50% below
those of reformulated gasoline [41]. These successful emission and performance
tests have recently resulted in the P-Series formulations being approved by the
US Department of Energy as an alternative gasoline, meeting the requirements
of the Energy Policy Act for automobile fleet usage. It should be noted, however,
that P-Series fuels can only be used in “flexible fuel engines” and have to be
distributed at gasoline stations supplied with pumps specially modified for alco-
hol-based fuels. Their short-term markets may therefore be limited to captive
fleets (e.g. city buses).
Direct conversion of LA to MTHF occurs in low yield, hence indirect routes
are utilized (Fig. 7.10). One possible mechanism involves the catalytic hydroge-
nation of LA to c-valerolactone (GVL) which, on further hydrogenation, yields
1,4-pentanediol and, finally, MTHF [28]. An efficient application of this mecha-
nism was devised by scientists at the Pacific Northwest Laboratory (PNL) in the
US [45]. The process is conducted at elevated temperatures and pressures using
a continuous-flow catalytic reactor. Levulinic acid is pumped into a tube where
it is warmed to approximately 40 8C, then mixed with hydrogen. Both com-
152 7 The Biofine Process
pounds are then pumped through a reactor filled with a catalyst in which a se-
ries of chemical reactions occurs at approximately 240 8C and 100 atmospheres
pressure to create MTHF. The procedure requires three moles of hydrogen per
mole LA. Laboratory tests indicated the yield was 83% on a theoretical (molar)
basis [45]. This would be equivalent to a yield of approximately 63 kg (71 L)
MTHF for every 100 kg of LA, or 81 L of MTHF for every 100 L of LA. The yield
of the PNL process is significantly greater than that of other processes. These
usually used mechanisms in which MTHF was a merely a byproduct, with final
yields of approximately only 3%.
The extra costs involved in producing MTHF from LA are minimal – for a
Biofine plant processing 1000 dry tonnes of biomass per day, the estimated ex-
tra capital cost for an MTHF production facility would be $ 10 Mio. The re-
quired 6 kg of hydrogen for every 100 kg of LA could be supplied from the resi-
dual process char (via a syngas production unit, see below) with an estimated
cost of hydrogen production of 5 c kg–1.
In addition to transport, MTHF has value in other markets – it is, for exam-
ple, an excellent general solvent that is, in many regards, superior to tetrahydro-
furan. It should also be noted that catalytic production of MTHF from furfuryl
alcohol is possible, as is the production of dimethyltetrahydrofuran (DMTHF)
from hydroxymethylfurfural (the product of the first Biofine reactor). It is hy-
pothesized that the additional methyl group in DMTHF may afford superior
performance and mileage over MTHF, although vehicle tests have yet to be car-
ried out.
erties and gum formation [46]). Addition of ethyl or methyl levulinate to FAME
would be expected to alleviate both these problems.
The most studied of the LA esters is a low-smoke diesel formulation devel-
oped by Biofine and Texaco that uses ethyl levulinate (made by esterifying LA
with fuel-grade ethanol) as an oxygenate additive. The 21 : 79 formulation con-
sists of 20% ethyl levulinate, 1% co-additive, and 79% diesel and can be used in
regular diesel engines. The oxygen content of ethyl levulinate (EL) is 33%, w/w,
giving a 6.9%, w/w, oxygen content in the blend, resulting in a significantly
cleaner burning diesel fuel [44].
The ethyl levulinate blend gives lower sulfur emissions than does regular die-
sel. This is because ethyl levulinate contains no sulfur. Lower sulfur emissions
can also be attributed to the high lubricity of EL blends. Fuel lubricity is used to
determine the amount of wear that occurs between two metal parts covered
with the fuel as they come into contact. Fuels of higher lubricity result in less
wear and prolong engine component life. The sulfur level of diesel is reduced
in the refinery using a hydro-treating process; this results in undesirable re-
moval of some of the lubricity components from the fuel and hence a decrease
in diesel lubricity. Addition of EL, with high lubricity, will therefore mean that
diesel blend-stocks of low lubricity, and hence lower S content, can be used
without reducing the all-over lubricity of the end product. In Europe lubricity is
measured by use of the high frequency reciprocating rig (HFRR) test with lower
values indicating higher fuel lubricity. Biofine has shown that addition of 20%
EL to a standard No 2 base fuel improves the HFRR from 410 to 275 [44]. Im-
portantly, the significant losses of engine efficiency (a decrease of up to 15% in
the distance driven per unit volume is found with other diesel oxygenates, for
example ethanol) do not occur with ethyl levulinate. This is because of the high
energy content of the 21 : 79 formulation (selected properties of EL are listed in
Table 7.1).
The levulinate esters also have potential as replacements of kerosene as a
home heating oil and as a fuel for the direct firing of gas turbines for electrical
generation [47]. The production of levulinic acid esters from LA formed in the
Biofine Process has the added advantage over conventional bioesters that there
is no coproduction of glycerol which would have to be disposed of.
the AMASIL additive produced by BASF Ireland contains 85% formic acid
which is bought at a price of 1 1.35 per liter.
The catalyst-preparation sector is a very large potential future market for for-
mic acid. As well as being used in the manufacture of many catalysts, formic
acid is also used in the regeneration of catalyst metals poisoned with sulfur.
The increasing demand for low-sulfur fuels will result in increased demand for
the catalysts produced using the formates and, consequently, will require formic
acid. Additionally, esters of formic acid (e.g. methyl and ethyl formate) may also
have value as fuel components and as platform chemicals.
In 2000, world consumption of formic acid amounted to approximately
4.15 ´ 108 kg [48], roughly half of which was consumed in Europe. A Biofine
plant processing 300 dry tonnes of feedstock per day would produce approxi-
mately 9 ´ 106 kg formic acid per year (assuming a cellulose content of 40%).
Where supply of formic acid exceeds demand for its conventional uses, the mer-
chant market price may fall to around $ 0.16 per liter, which is the price needed
to open up other markets such as its use as a road salt or for formaldehyde pro-
duction [49]. If even these markets are not available, the formic acid byproduct
still has value, because it can provide energy via gasification or anaerobic diges-
tion.
7.3.3.7 Furfural
Furfural is produced from the hemicellulosic pentose fractions of biomass. Xy-
lose is the predominant pentose in most feedstocks, with hemicellulosic arabi-
nose found to a lesser extent. Furfural can be sold as a solvent or used in the
production of furfuryl alcohol, tetrahydrofuran (THF), and LA. Furfuryl alcohol
(Fig. 7.11) is a monomer for furan resins, these being used mainly as foundry
binders. It is prepared by hydrogenation of furfural. THF is produced by decar-
bonylation of furfural to furan, then catalytic hydrogenation [50]. LA is produced
by first converting furfural to furfuryl alcohol. Figure 7.11 shows the mecha-
nism involved – furfuryl alcohol, when boiled in ethyl methyl ketone in the
presence of HCl, gives rise to 90–93% levulinic acid, the reaction occurring via
hydroxy derivatives [11].
Global production of furfural in 2001 amounted to 22.5 ´ 107 kg year–1 [51].
Approximately 4 ´ 107 kg furfural was consumed in Europe in 2000, furfuryl al-
cohol being the major market. Most furfural is now produced in China, whose
total capacity is 15–20 ´ 107 kg year–1 [51]. Low labor and feedstock prices in Chi-
na, coupled with increasing Chinese capacity, have resulted in prices falling over
the last decade – the current market price of furfural is approximately $ 1 kg–1
compared with prices in 1990 of $ 1.74 kg–1 for furfural and $ 1.76 kg–1 for fur-
furyl alcohol [50]. EU and US import tariffs are placed on furfural from China,
these being designed to lessen this effect of this price differential, but market
prices are still highly dependent on Chinese supply. (A significant rise in price
between 1995 and 1998 was attributed to a drought in China during that peri-
od).
A Biofine plant processing 300 dry tonnes of feedstock per day would pro-
duce, from hemicelluloses, approximately 1.3 ´ 107 kg furfural per year (assum-
ing 25% pentosans by mass). This represents 32.5% of the total consumption of
furfural/furfuryl alcohol in Europe in 2000. Furfural conversion products,
whether THF or LA and their subsequent downstream products, may therefore
be more marketable final products than furfural itself in large biorefinery
schemes, especially if the fuel additive market is explored.
7.3.4
Biofine Char
The quantity of residual char from the Biofine process and its calorific value
will depend on the acid-insoluble lignin content of the biomass, the ash con-
tent, any insoluble proteins present, and the amount of degradation and rever-
sion products formed from the cellulose and hemicellulose fractions. The boil-
ing off from the char of volatiles and LA gives rise to a “cracking” of the char. It
is, therefore, difficult to predict the final composition of the char from the mass
compositions of virgin biomass. The composition would be predictable with
greater certainty if each potential feedstock was tested in the Biofine Process.
Biofine char has much promise as a fuel. Residual char from the processing
of paper sludge in the Biofine pilot plant was found to have a heating value of
approximately 25.6 MJ kg–1 (with 15% ash content), a value that was signifi-
cantly larger than that of the original feedstock (18.6 MJ kg–1). It was found that
combustion of the dry Biofine char (the mass of which was 15% of that of the
original paper sludge) yielded more energy than combustion of the entire feed-
stock (at its initial 50% moisture content).
It has been estimated that the energy provided by the residual char is greater
than that needed to completely fuel the steam and electric power needs of the
biorefinery when the scale of operation is equal to or greater than approximately
270 dry tonnes of feedstock per day (assuming a feedstock lignin content of
approximately 25%). Appropriately sized plants may therefore expect to gain
significant revenue from the marketing of surplus electricity.
Research is ongoing for alternative uses and markets for Biofine char. It is be-
lieved it may have value as a soil conditioner. Figure 7.12 compares the FTIR
spectra of lignin with those of chars obtained from paper sludge and straw feed-
stocks. It can be seen that straw char retains many of the functionalities of lig-
nin, characterized by absorbance in the 1000–1800 cm–1 region of the spectrum.
156 7 The Biofine Process
Fig. 7.12 FTIR spectra for lignin and Biofine chars from paper
sludge and straw feedstocks.
The chars from straw and from paper have significant carbonyl/carboxyl func-
tionality and the presence of significant acidic functionality was confirmed by ti-
tration data. Solid-state NMR will indicate the nature of the aromatic functional-
ity and whether or not the Biofine chars have the fused aromatic structures
characteristic of charcoals.
We have performed thermogravimetric analyses on several feedstocks and on
the chars from straw and paper. In thermogravimetry, sample weight loss is
monitored as a function of increasing temperature. Thermograms, and their
first derivatives (rate of weight loss with respect to temperature) for the renew-
able energy crop Miscanthus, for a lignin extract, and for the Biofine chars from
paper sludge, and straw feedstocks are shown in Fig. 7.13. Weight loss in the
range 50–120 8C is associated with volatilization of water whereas that resulting
from loss of low-molecular-weight compounds and other volatile organic com-
pounds (extractives in woods/grasses) occurs from 120–250 8C; degradation of
hemicelluloses occurs in the 250–300 8C range, and cellulose degrades very
sharp at approximately 300–340 8C in air (higher in nitrogen). The thermogram
for Miscanthus is strong evidence for hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin com-
ponents. The two thermograms for the chars are similar and clearly show that
the hemicellulose and cellulose components are greatly diminished – indicated
by a significant shift of the peaks to the right compared with the Miscanthus
thermogram. This shift reflects a predominance of the ligneous type compo-
nents, this being indicated by a similarity between the char thermograms and
those of the lignin extract.
Another possible use of the char is steam gasification (thermochemical pro-
duction of hydrogen from a feedstock, for example biomass materials, or, in this
context, Biofine char) followed by upgrading of the synthesis gas produced.
Although little work has yet been done along these lines using the Biofine char,
7.3 The Biofine Process 157
there has been much work over the years on the gasification of equivalent mate-
rials, for example peat or coal [52, 53]. Coal gasification was originally used for
the production of syngas for use in, for example, the Fischer-Tropsch Process.
More recently, interest in connection with that process has shifted to the re-
forming of natural gas as a source of the syngas for the process (e.g. Ref. [54]
and other articles in the same volume). The steam gasification of carbon can be
represented simply by a combination of the gasification reaction:
C + H2O ? CO + H2
followed by the water-gas shift reaction:
CO + H2O = CO2 + H2
The exothermic water-gas shift reaction is favored by operation at low tempera-
tures whereas high temperatures favor the reverse reaction. Hence, a product
gas containing largely hydrogen is produced if the temperature is low and a
syngas with a CO/H2 ratio of 1 is obtained if the temperature is high. The syn-
gas can be used as a fuel (e.g. to give the energy needed for the Biofine process)
but it can also be used in a variety of reactions such as methanol synthesis:
158 7 The Biofine Process
CO + 2H2 ? CH3OH
Alternatively, it can be used in the Fischer–Tropsch process mentioned above;
this can be depicted simplistically as:
nCO + mH2 CnH2m
in which the product hydrocarbons are usually aliphatic in nature and can be
used as diesel substitutes. Much work has recently been performed on so-called
GTL technology (GTL = Gas to Liquids – technology that converts synthesis gas
(from gasification of biomass or biorefinery process chars, for example) into liq-
uid fuels), and many of these developments have been summarized recently
[55].
7.3.5
Economics of the Biofine Process
tonnes per day. Indeed, the Biofine process is extremely compact – a feasibility
study conducted by a marine architectural company concluded that a self-con-
tained 1000 tonne per day facility could be accommodated on an ocean-going
“Panamax” barge [56].
Significant economies of scale can accrue with increasing plant size, as
shown in Fig. 7.15 a and b. Figure 7.15 c shows, for various plant sizes, the trend
in the cost of ethyl levulinate production with feedstock cost. Table 7.2 shows a
detailed breakdown of these costs and of byproduct revenues for a plant proces-
sing 1000 dry tonnes of feedstock per day. It is assumed that the feedstock is of
composition, by mass, 50% cellulose, 20% hemicellulose, 20% lignin, and 5%
ash (comparable with many woody and herbaceous energy crops). It is also as-
sumed that the plant is operational for 350 days per year, that all of the furfural
Scale of Operation – 1000 dry tonnes per day (350 000 dry tonnes/year)
Capital Cost – $ 150 million (Grassroots, fully self-contained and integrated)
Production Output – 133 000 tonnes per year ethyl levulinate
Raw materials:
Feedstock 350,000 dt/y @$ 40/t $ 14,000,000/y
Sulfuric acid 3,500 t/y @$ 100/t $ 350,000/y
Caustic soda 500 t/y @$ 120/t $ 60,000/y
Ethanol 35,000 t/y @$ 350/t $ 12,250,000/y
Hydrogen 120 t/y @$ 1,500/t $ 180,000/y
Others allow. $ 160,000/y
Subtotal $ 27,000,000/r
Utilities:
Steam 250,000 lb/h gen. on-site 0
Electric 14.4 MW gen. on-site 0
Electric usage 11.3 MW 0
Electric sold 3.1 MW
Water 250 gpm $ 500,000/y
Gas (boiler) 294 m BTU/h gen. on-site 0
Subtotal $ 500,000/y
Labor and Maintenance:
Operators 17 per shift @$ 20 per hr $ 2,800,000/y
Supervision 2 per shift @$ 24 per hr $ 400,000/y
Maintenance @4% of cap cost/yr $ 6,000,000/y
Subtotal $ 9,200,000/y
Overheads
Direct @30% of labor $ 1,000,000/y
General @25% of Lab. & Maintenance $ 2,300,000/y
Taxes and Insurance allow. $ 3,700,000/y
Subtotal $ 7,000,000/y
Disposal Costs:
Ash: 17,500 t/y @$ 35/t $ 600,000/y
Subtotal $ 600,000
Gross Production costs $ 44,300,000
Byproducts: Formic acid 38,500 t/y @$ 110/t $ 4,200,000
Electric sold 26,000 MWhr/y @$ 60/MWhr $ 1,500,000
Subtotal $ 5,700,000
NET PRODUCTION COST $ 38,600,000
Production cost per to Ethyl Levulinate (no capital charges) $ 291 per tonne
Equivalent Energy price 12 per GJ
7.4 Conclusion 161
is converted to LA, and that formic acid is sold for 10 c kg–1 and electrical power
for 6 c kw h–1. It can be seen that ash is the only waste product, incurring a dis-
posal charge ($ 35/tonne). Disposal need not be a problem, however. The Case-
rta plant will supply an adjacent tile factory with the ash, avoiding such costs.
The ash can also be used as a fertilizer on agricultural land. The ethyl levulinate
production cost of $ 291 tonne–1 is equivalent to a price of $ 12 GJ–1, competi-
tive with the $ 16 GJ–1 of gasoline at $ 2 gallon–1 or $ 10 GJ–1 for crude oil at
$ 50 per barrel.
7.4
Conclusion
References
49 Idriss, H., Lusvardi, V. S. and Barteau, 53 Sutton, D., Kelleher, B. P. and Ross,
M. A. (1996), Two routes to formaldehyde J. R. H. (2001), Review of Literature on
from formic acid on TiO2(001) surface. Catalysts for Biomass Gasification. Fuel
Surface Science 348(1/2): 39–48. Processing Technology 73(3): 155–173.
50 Gravitis, J., Vedernikov, N., Zandersons, 54 Bakkerud, P. K., Gol, J. N., Aasberg-Peter-
J. and Kokorevics, A. (2001), Furfural sen, K. and Dybkjaer, I. (2004), Preferred
and levoglucosan production from decid- Synthesis Gas Production Routes for
uous wood and agricultural wastes. In: GTL. (eds), Studies in Surface Science and
J. J. Bozell (eds), Chemicals and Materials Catalysis. Elsevier, New York, 147: 13–18.
from Renewable Resources. American 55 Bao, X. and Xu, Y. (2004), Natural Gas
Chemical Society, Washington DC, 110– Conversion VII, Studies in Surface
122. Science and Catalysis, 147. Elsevier, New
51 Levy, J. and Sakuma, Y. (2001), CEH Re- York.
port: Furfural. SRI, Menlo Park, CA. 56 Seaworthy Systems Inc. (1997), SSI Re-
52 Rieche, A. (1964), Outline of Industrial port #403-01-01.
Organic Chemistry. Butterworths, London.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
165
8
A Whole Crop Biorefinery System:
A Closed System for the Manufacture of Non-food Products
from Cereals
Apostolis A. Koutinas, Rouhang Wang, Grant M. Campbell, and Colin Webb
8.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
166 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
eal grain there is approximately another tonne of rather less accessible lignocel-
lulosic material such as straw and other residues. How to deal with this
material is one of the prime challenges of the whole crop biorefinery. Not only
is there less to be had from the straw component of the crop than from the
grain but it is also more difficult to get at; requiring tedious and often costly
preprocessing. In addition, there is a major impediment to transportation of
this fraction of the crop because it has a bulk density of only about a fifteenth
of that of the grain, thereby requiring vastly more voluminous vehicles to move
it around.
Ideally, of course, the whole crop biorefinery would involve harvesting the
whole of the crop and transporting it directly to the refinery where fractionation
would begin. Unfortunately, this is unlikely to be the reality and the more prag-
matic approach of separation in the field followed by utilization of the straw as
a primary energy source, through combustion, or incorporation into building
composites, is more likely to prevail for some time to come. It must also be
conceded that traditional outlets for straw such as re-incorporation into the soil,
animal feed, and animal bedding, will continue to be “first call” uses in the fore-
seeable future [1]. Thus one of the principal conclusions of a European study to
determine the profitability of a wholecrop biorefinery [2] was that “Combine har-
vesting with grain processing in a biorefinery is more profitable than wholecrop.” In
view of these observations, this chapter will consider the biorefinery concept as
one in which on-site separation of grain is carried out prior to fractionation and
conversion of the whole grains at a remote site. Should it become feasible to
process straw and other residues alongside the grain, such processing could
readily be integrated within the biorefinery.
Current cereal fractionation processes (CFP) break down the grain into macro
and micro components that are used either as end-products (e.g. gluten, oil) or
as raw materials (e.g. starch) for secondary processing in many industries (e.g.
food, pharmaceuticals, textiles, cosmetics, fermentation). The term macro com-
ponent incorporates any high molecular weight compound (e.g. starch, protein,
cellulose, hemicellulose, oil, gums), while micro components are defined as rel-
atively low molecular weight molecules (e.g. lipids, vitamins, minerals). Tradi-
tional CFP can be categorized into dry and wet milling operations. Dry milling
involves the use of successive grinding and sieving steps aiming at the maxi-
mum economic separation of bran from endosperm. Dry milling operations are
relatively inexpensive and result in incomplete macro component separation.
Wet CFP can be generally categorized into wet–aqueous and wet–nonaqueous
processes resulting in selective separation of one or more cereal components.
Wet fractionation processes could be applied to the end-products of a primary
dry milling operation.
Traditional CFP have been developed to suit the needs of the food industry
and do not exploit the potential of cereal grains for non-food applications. The
development of viable whole-crop biorefineries depends on the constructive inte-
gration of physical, chemical, thermal and biological processing resulting in var-
ious products, such as functional proteins, oils, antioxidants, polysaccharides,
8.2 Biorefineries Based on Wheat 167
fine and bulk chemicals, biofuels and biodegradable plastics. Novel cereal frac-
tionation plants could be of three kinds depending on their production capacity:
· Small-scale plants that will not focus directly on the market outlets of the tra-
ditional cereal processing plants but will target specialty industries (e.g. cos-
metics, pharmaceuticals) by extracting value-added minor constituents (e.g.
antioxidants). Such plants will utilize only one cereal grain and will leave the
majority of the raw material unprocessed, creating the need to find market
outlets for this bulk quantity of material. The use of the remaining material
for the production of fine or platform chemicals through microbial bioconver-
sion would be an attractive option.
· Intermediate-scale plants may have wider flexibility in terms of the cereal
grains that they can process. They will be able to market more end-products.
Their commercial survival though will be dependent on continuous research
and development and process improvements.
· Large-scale plants would be able to utilize any cereal grain for the simulta-
neous commercialization of traditional end-products, value-added minor com-
ponents as well as biofuels and biodegradable plastics. Extensive technical
and market research should certify high efficiency, cost-competitiveness and
customer demand for all the end-products.
In this chapter, potential whole-crop biorefineries based on wheat and oats are
presented. Future biorefineries based on cereals should aim to exploit the vast
complexity of cereal grains by extracting valuable macro and micro components
and converting the starch fraction into platform chemicals, biodegradable plas-
tics and biofuels via microbial bioconversions. This approach targets waste and
cost reductions and the creation of more market outlets.
8.2
Biorefineries Based on Wheat
8.2.1
Wheat Structure and Composition
The structure of the wheat grain consists of several layers with varying composi-
tion and functions (Fig. 8.1 and Table 8.1). The two main parts of the kernel are
the pericarp and the seed. The pericarp covers the entire wheat kernel and is di-
vided into the outer and the inner pericarp. Beneath the inner pericarp, the
seed coat and the pigment strand provide a complete covering around the seed.
The nucellar epidermis and the nucellar projection are located underneath the
seed coat and surround the endosperm and embryo. One of the most nutrition-
ally important wheat layers, the aleurone layer, is situated below the nucellar tis-
sues. This is a one-cell-thick layer that encompasses the entire endosperm and
part of the embryo. The embryo lies on the lower dorsal side of the wheat ker-
nel and its two major components are the embryonic axis and the scutellum.
168 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
Pericarp
) 5
Seed coat, pigment Protect the grain 3 Fiber, K, P, Mg, Ca
strand and nucellus Bran
Aleurone layer Encases endosperm 7 Niacin, phytic acid, minerals (especially P)
Endosperm Stores food 82 Starch, protein, pantothenic acid, B2, minerals
a) Mass fraction of the constituent within the kernel as % on a dry basis (db)
8.2 Biorefineries Based on Wheat 169
8.2.2
Secondary Processing of Wheat Flour Milling Byproducts
In the traditional wheat flour milling process, wheat is milled into various flour
fractions involving a large number of milling and sifting operations developed
originally to serve the needs of the food industry. In particular, wheat grains are
initially cleaned from impurities and tempered with water for an average of 12
hours to detach the outer bran layers from the endosperm, facilitating their sep-
aration. The tempered grains are subsequently processed through a series of
break and reduction roller mills and sifting stages. The main aim of the conven-
170 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
tional dry milling process is to produce flour fractions with the lowest possible
bran impurities. However, the nature of this process will never produce any
flour fraction 100% free from germ and bran. Current wheat flour mills operate
at 70–80% grain to flour conversion efficiency where the remaining 20–30%
constitutes various byproduct streams that contain predominantly bran as well
as lower amounts of germ and flour. The byproduct streams are mixtures of all
coarse streams from each break and reduction roll and are usually used as ani-
mal feeds or commercial bran.
As a whole, the dry milling process of wheat produces many flour streams of
varying particle sizes and compositions in endosperm, bran and germ. This
means that the separation of certain wheat layers enriched in specific value-
added chemical components is not possible. This way of processing results in
high capital investment, high operating costs for milling, conveying and sifting,
and products of low purity. Thus, traditional dry milling of wheat cannot be
considered as the basis for the development of a viable biorefinery for non-food
applications.
The most realistic option to use traditional mills for non-food applications is
through bioconversion of the significant amounts of byproduct produced. In
1999/2000, 5624 ´ 103 tonnes of wheat (83% of which was home grown) was
processed by UK flour millers resulting in 4481 ´ 103 tonnes of flour and
1148 ´ 103 tonnes of byproducts. The majority of this byproduct stream, known
as wheatfeed or middlings, contains 15–19% protein (75% of which is degrad-
able), 20–35% starch and around 1% phosphorus. However, the high crude fiber
content (7–11%), low essential amino acid content (0.6% Lys, 0.5% Thr, 0.2%
Try, 0.4% Met) and the presence of phytic acid (containing about 60–80% of the
total phosphorus) reduce its nutritional value. Consequently, its use as animal
feed is restricted only to pigs and cattle. Phytic acid, in particular, has been
identified as a certain antinutritional compound that forms complexes with iron
and zinc ions and makes these metal ions less accessible for assimilation by hu-
mans and other monogastric animals [11]. Nonruminants excrete most of it as
they do not have an efficient system for making phosphate available from phy-
tate. This forces producers to add inorganic phosphate to animal feed as a sup-
plement, leading to excessive phosphate excretion, which worsens water pollu-
tion and eutrophication [12]. The addition of enzyme preparations such as phy-
tase, xylanase and protease could increase the overall digestibility of flour
milling byproducts, allowing animals to consume phosphorus from the phytic
acid and better assimilate the iron and zinc ions. For this reason, the animal
feed industry is currently developing large-scale enzyme applications [12].
The development of an integrated biorefinery that leads to the production of
high quality wheat flour and upgrades the byproduct stream into a nutrient-en-
riched animal feed and value-added chemicals through microbial bioconversions
is an attractive option. Figure 8.2 shows such a process based around the bio-
production of succinic acid as a major potential platform chemical. The byprod-
ucts from a traditional wheat flour mill could be treated with successive wash-
ing and screening stages to separate the majority of starch and some of the pro-
Fig. 8.2 Schematic diagram of a possible biorefinery utilizing traditional wheat flour milling byproducts.
8.2 Biorefineries Based on Wheat
171
172 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
The total amount of wheat flour milling byproducts (1.1 ´ 106 tonnes) available
per annum in the UK contains on average 30% starch, i.e. equivalent to
3.66 ´ 105 tonnes of glucose (eq. 1). The theoretical yield from glucose to succin-
ic acid is 1.31 kg acid kg–1 glucose (eq. 2), giving a theoretical maximum of
4.8 ´ 105 tonnes succinic acid per annum for the UK. This is far greater than
the current world production of 1.5 ´ 104 tonnes. At the same time, succinic acid
production would result in 1.8 ´ 105 tonnes per annum CO2 sequestration (eq. 2)
because mass production of the acid requires CO2 fixation in the metabolism of
the microorganism involved. This is equivalent to the CO2 released from the
production of 2.4 ´ 105 tonnes of bioethanol (eq. 3). In addition, current biopro-
cessing practices could reduce the succinic acid production cost to lower than
$ 0.6 kg–1 [17]. Thus, by utilizing a low-cost agro-industrial raw material succinic
acid could be transformed into a low-cost platform intermediate. Such alterna-
tive use of wheat flour milling byproducts would also give flexibility to farmers
and industrialists in exploring new market opportunities.
8.2.3
Advanced Wheat Separation Processes for Food and Non-food Applications
Traditional wheat processing for food (excluding breadmaking) and non-food ap-
plications concentrates mainly on the extraction of the bulk macromolecules,
starch and gluten. However, the extraction of a number of value-added compo-
nents from individual wheat layers could upgrade wheat processing into a novel
whole-crop biorefinery producing both low-volume, high-value and high-volume,
low-value products. In recent years, there has been a growing interest in the uti-
lization of advanced cereal fractionation technologies to reduce operating/capital
costs and to separate/purify value-added macro and micro components from
cereal grains. The desired functional component may be concentrated in a par-
ticular layer in the cereal grain (e.g. aleurone layer, pericarp, germ). For this rea-
son, novel CFP involve the selective separation of the outer bran layers includ-
ing the aleurone layer and the germ.
layer has been disrupted during the abrasion stage. The bran separated during
the friction stage is removed through the screen by an air stream blown into
the center of the chamber via a perforated main shaft.
Research and commercial implementation of pearling has revealed the nu-
merous potential uses of this advanced CFP. When pearling is used prior to
conventional milling, it can improve flour quality and reduce operating costs
[24]. The application of pearling can lead to the production of bran-rich streams
that can be used as food ingredients. Cui et al. [19] reported that non-starch
polysaccharides (NSP) from a wheat bran fraction produced by the Tkac and
Timm pearling technology exhibited novel rheological properties. The NSP ex-
tracted from a pearling fraction that contained 13.4% starch, 29.2% insoluble
dietary fiber, 8.5% soluble dietary fiber and 2.6% b-glucan, exhibited shear-thin-
ning flow behavior at low concentrations in water (0.5%, 25 8C) and formed a
thermally reversible gel upon cooling at 4 8C [19].
The bran-rich fractions produced by pearling are also rich in value-added
components (e.g. antioxidants, b-glucan) in comparison to the bran-rich frac-
tions produced from conventional milling operations. This occurs because the
latter contain higher quantities of starchy endosperm, diluting the overall
amounts of added-value components [25]. In the case of wheat, Dexter and
Wood [18] used the Tkac debranning system, which produced friction fractions
rich in pericarp and enriched in dietary fiber, while the abrasion fractions were
rich in aleurone cells and enriched in protein, b-glucan and soluble fiber in
comparison to whole wheat. Marconi et al. [26] used barley pearlings enriched
in b-glucan and dietary fiber for the production of functional pastas with the
aim of meeting the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requirements of 5 g
of dietary fiber and 0.75 g of b-glucan per serving (56 g in the US and 80 g in
Italy). It has been reported that pearling fractions from oats may contain signifi-
cant quantities of specific antioxidants [27]. It has also been reported that by-
products that are produced from the pearling stage prior to dry milling of barley
are enriched in b-glucans, tocopherols, and tocotrienols [28]. Cereal constituents
with antioxidant properties can be used in pharmaceutical and cosmetic applica-
tions.
Using pearling before wheat milling could also lead to increased gluten ex-
traction yield from pearled wheat grains [29]. The gluten extraction yield from
ground, pearled wheat (11.4% of bran and germ was removed during pearling)
was 20–25% higher than from conventionally milled flour in a process achiev-
ing 70% extraction of flour from wheat.
Apart from milling operations that produce flour streams for food, pharma-
ceutical and cosmetic purposes, the usefulness of pearling has also been recog-
nized in the case of non-food applications. Wang et al. [30] used whole grain
flour and pearled grain flour as fermentation medium for bioethanol production
and the latter increased ethanol yields by 6.5–22.5%. This occurred because the
use of pearling reduced the bran content in the fermentation feedstock, while at
the same time the starch throughput per batch increased by an average of
12% (w/v, db). By integrating the grain pearling technology in rye and triticale
176 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
with very high gravity fermentations (0.30 g solids mL–1 supernatant) the etha-
nol concentration was increased to around 16% (v/v) [31]. Partial removal of out-
er grain solids in an alcohol plant would also improve plant efficiency and de-
crease energy requirements for mash heating, mash cooling and ethanol distil-
lation. In addition, the bran byproduct fractions containing pure grain layers or
mixtures of them may be used as functional food ingredients or as raw materi-
als to extract value-added products (e.g. enzymes, phytic acid, tocopherols, oil,
proteins, wheat germ glycerides, agglutinin, arabinoxylans, b-glucan), contribut-
ing significant revenue for the development of cost-competitive biorefineries.
8.2.4
Biorefinery Based on Novel Dry Fractionation Processes of Wheat
Fig. 8.4 Schematic diagram of a wheat-based biorefinery employing pearling and air classification.
177
178 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
Arabinoxylans Wheat bran and especially the aleurone layer contain high
amounts of arabinoxylans and lower quantities of b-glucans. Arabinoxylan is a
polysaccharide comprised of a backbone formed by xylose residues connected
together with b-(1 ? 4) bonds. The xylose residues are highly substituted with
primarily single a-(1 ? 3) and/or a-(1 ? 2)-linked l-arabinose residues as well as
short arabinooligosaccharides, d-galactose, d-4-O-methylglucuronic acid and
ferulic acid residues.
Phenolic acids, such as ferulic acid, play a significant role in the linkage of
hemicelluloses with other cell wall components, especially lignin, through ester
and ether bonds [37]. In addition, ferulic acid assists in the formation of cova-
lently crosslinked arabinoxylans with well developed networks that exert an in-
teresting water-holding capacity [38]. Different concentrations of ferulic acids
would correspond to varying gelling potential of arabinoxylans. Arabinoxylan
properties in solution are also dependent on the degree of polymerization of the
xylan backbone.
The use of enzymatic oxidizing systems such as laccase, horseradish peroxi-
dase or manganese peroxidase could dimerize the esterified ferulic acids caus-
ing gelation of the water-extractable arabinoxylans from wheat flour [39]. The
high viscosity of aqueous solutions containing water-extractable arabinoxylans
that have undergone oxidative gelation after they were treated with laccase and/
or manganese peroxidase has a positive effect in breadmaking [40]. In particular,
water-soluble arabinoxylans can absorb water, influence dough rheology and af-
fect such bread characteristics as loaf volume, crumb firmness and staling
events [41]. Arabinoxylans could also be potential ingredients for wound-care ap-
plications [42]. Sterigel is an arabinoxylan-based product that is used as wound
management aid.
Ferulic Acid Ferulic acid could be released from bran-rich fractions by the sy-
nergistic action of various enzymes, such as esterase and xylanase [43]. Extrac-
8.2 Biorefineries Based on Wheat 179
tion of arabinoxylans located at the outer bran layers, seed coat and pericarp,
may be more difficult than the ones located in the aleurone and nucellar layers
[44]. The aleurone-free wheat bran is more resistant to enzymatic hydrolysis be-
cause it contains higher amounts of lignin, cellulose and glucuronoarabinoxy-
lans than the aleurone layer. Increased crosslinking among cell wall compo-
nents creates a rigid cell wall network and decreases the effectiveness of enzy-
matic hydrolysis.
Ferulic acid could be used as a natural food preservative due to its ability to
inhibit peroxidation of fatty acids. The acid and its derivatives, steryl ferulates,
have antioxidant properties. A commercial product, c-oryzanol, with cholesterol
lowering properties containing steryl ferulates has been extracted from rice bran
[45]. Wheat bran fractions may contain up to 0.34 mg g–1 total steryl ferulates,
which is significantly higher that the 0.063 mg g–1 content in the whole wheat
grain [45]. Ferulic acid is currently used as an ingredient in many skin lotions,
sunscreens and wound dressings [43]. The antioxidant potential of ferulic acid
could be enhanced by converting it enzymatically into cafeic acid by using a mi-
crobial cell extract from the anaerobic bacterium Clostridium methoxybenzovorans
SR3 [46]. Another commercial option is the bioconversion of ferulic acid into va-
nillin by Streptomyces setonii. Muheim and Lerch [47] reported that shake flask
cultures of S. setonii resulted in the production of 6 g L–1 vanillin at a molar
conversion yield from ferulic acid to vanillin of 68%.
Hwang et al. [48] patented a process separating ferulic acid and arabinoxylan
from cereal brans by extrusion and subsequent treatment with plant cell wall
hydrolyzing enzymes.
Wheat Germ Most wheat germ currently produced by flour mills is used as an-
imal feed contributing a very low revenue. Wheat germ could be upgraded into
a useful byproduct if it is used for the extraction of various value-added materi-
als, such as proteins, oils, vitamins and enzymes [24]. Oil extraction could be
achieved simply by mechanical pressure or solvent extraction. The germ oil
could be used as a specialty food or gourmet cooking oil. A commercial applica-
tion of oil extracts has been introduced by the French company Bertin, which
extracts these oils by cold pressing at 4,000 bars in sunflower oil as solvent [49].
The purified wheat germ oil (104 kg year–1) is called heliogerme and is sold as
an ingredient in cosmetics at a price ranging between £ 5–8 kg–1. In the case
that wheat germ is processed by solvent extraction, the functional properties of
germ protein are retained enabling its commercialization as food grade protein.
The extraction of micro components (e.g. enzymes, vitamins, flavonoids) from
wheat germ may open additional market opportunities but additional research
and market/process evaluation is required [24].
The bran-rich fraction produced by wheat pearling would contain a large
amount, if not all, of the wheat germ. Thus, the utilization of the pearling tech-
nology in a wheat biorefinery may decrease the cost currently required by tradi-
tional flour mills to isolate the wheat germ fraction.
180 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
Functional Foods Supplementation of human diets with wheat bran may en-
hance the prevention of a range of cancers due to the presence of various func-
tional components, such as dietary fiber, phytic acid, lignans, oligosaccharides,
antioxidants, phytoestrogens [50]. Reddy et al. [51] reported that the lipid frac-
tion of wheat bran has strong colon tumor inhibitory properties and further
studies are required to identify biologically active constituents of wheat bran lip-
id fractions and their relative role in colon tumor inhibition. The insoluble diet-
ary fiber content of wheat bran may be responsible for their significant bile acid
binding properties that cause decrease in the plasma cholesterol level in hu-
mans [52]. In turn, Cui et al. [19] reported that bran-rich fractions enriched in
soluble fiber could be superior to AACC standard wheat bran, which contains
46.85% insoluble fiber and 2.8% soluble fiber [19]. Pearling may be employed to
produce bran-rich fractions enriched in either soluble or insoluble dietary fiber
depending on the requirements of end-product composition.
Pearling could be exploited for the sequential removal of individual wheat
layers. Fenech et al. [53] reported that pearling could lead to the production of
an aleurone-rich fraction that contains high amounts (5 lg g–1) of folate. Bran-
and germ-rich fractions produced by pearling could potentially be used to en-
rich the mineral content of pan breads [54]. In addition, the quality of wheat
bread, in terms of loaf volume, crumb structure, shelf life, starch structure and
flavor, can be significantly improved when it is supplemented with wheat bran
pre-fermented with yeast and/or lactic acid bacteria [55].
Vital Wheat Gluten Pearled wheat kernels could be used for the extraction of vi-
tal wheat gluten as a valuable co-product. Gluten can be separated from wheat
flour by mixing endosperm particles with water that initiates the formation of
protein microfibrils. The formation of dough from the mixture of flour and
water is dependent on the water to flour ratio used and mixing. The main pro-
cesses for the separation of vital wheat gluten from flour (e.g. Posner, Alfa-La-
val/Raisio, Hydrocyclone, Pillsbury Hydromilling, Far-Mar-Co., High-Pressure
Disintegration) could be categorized into those based on either the Martin or
8.2 Biorefineries Based on Wheat 181
the Batter process [56, 57]. Such processes utilize a spectrum of raw materials
(e.g. wheat, flour), solvents, equipments and wheat flour to water ratio. Weight
for weight, gluten is more valuable than starch and could therefore improve the
economics of biorefineries based on wheat. In general, 10 tonnes of wheat will
give 6–7 tonnes of starch and 1–1.5 tonnes of gluten. The major impediments
in gluten separation processes are the operational effectiveness of processing,
the high cost required for drying vital gluten and waste treatment costs.
Gluten has many applications particularly in the food industry, such as in bread-
making, specialty baked goods, pet foods, breakfast cereals, meat and cheese sub-
stitutes and pizza [57]. Other industrial uses include production of hydrolysates,
wheat protein isolate and deaminated gluten. The gradual decrease of gluten price
in the last 10 years has shown that a potential large-scale utilization of wheat for
non-food applications will saturate the current gluten market reducing its current
price even lower. Identifying novel uses for gluten could provide more commercial
outlets and higher revenue for this value-added co-product. Gluten could be used
for the production of biodegradable or edible films and packaging materials [58]. It
could also be used for the manufacture of biodegradable high-performance engi-
neering plastics and composites when thiol-terminated, star-branched molecules
are incorporated directly into the protein structure [59].
generates a generic microbial feedstock from whole wheat is described and cost
evaluated in previous publications [60–62].
The generic microbial feedstock can be used for the bioproduction of several
organic chemicals, including platform intermediates for chemical synthesis, in-
gredients for a spectrum of commercial products, biofuels, biodegradable plas-
tics and solvents. This process could lead to the production of both commodities
and specialties depending on market outlets and cost competitiveness. Potential
bioconversion products, the large-scale bioproduction of which have or will in-
cur low environmental and high societal and industrial impacts are [16]:
1. lactic acid, succinic acid and 3-hydroxypropionic acid as platform molecules
and industrial ingredients;
2. 1,3-propanediol as a monomer for the production of novel plastics;
3. butanol as platform molecule, solvent, industrial ingredient and biobased
transport fuel;
4. PHA as biodegradable plastics;
5. bioethanol as a platform intermediate and biofuel;
6. l-lysine as animal feed additive and industrial ingredient.
Remaining solids from fungal fermentation could also be used as animal feed or
for the extraction of value-added coproducts, such as glucosamine and N-acetyl-d-
glucosamine. The fungal cell walls contain chitin, which is an unbranched homo-
polymer of N-acetyl-d-glucosamine. Bohlmann et al. [63] used enzymatic and
chemical methods for the recovery of N-acetyl-d-glucosamine from fungal bio-
mass (A. niger) that was produced from a citric acid fermentation. The efficient
degradation of chitin and glucan required the synergistic action of chitinases, b-
N-acetylglucosaminidases and glucanases. Fan et al. [64] have also used various
fungal species (Aspergillus, Penicillium, Mucor) for the production of glucosamine.
Fungal autolysis might evolve into an effective and economic processing route for
releasing glucosamine or/and N-acetyl-d-glucosamine from fungal cell walls.
It is strongly believed that glucosamine provides joint health benefits and
pain relief. The US National Institute of Health is currently conducting research
in order to assess the effectiveness of glucosamine on patients with osteoarthri-
tis. The US retail market for nutritional supplements containing glucosamine is
more that $ 109/year [65]. Demand for bulk glucosamine has been growing in
excess of 20% annually and global consumption exceeds 5 ´ 106 kg [65]. Apart
from glucosamine, N-acetylglucosamine is used as health supplement as well as
in cosmetic and pharmaceutical applications.
Unhydrolyzed solids from the fungal autolysis stage and solids from the mi-
crobial bioconversion could be gasified at various combinations of high tem-
peratures, pressures and oxygen for the production of synthesis gas that is con-
stituted of various compositions of CO, CO2, H2 and CH4 depending on the
conditions applied. Synthesis gas can be subsequently used either for energy
generation or biological/chemical conversion into a spectrum of chemicals. Po-
tential bioderived products from synthesis gas are bioethanol [66], biodegradable
plastics [67], acetic acid and methanol [16].
8.3 A Biorefinery Based on Oats 183
8.3
A Biorefinery Based on Oats
8.3.1
Oat Structure and Composition
Like all cereal grains, oats have a complex structure and constitution (Table 8.2).
The oat groat, consisting of endosperm, germ and bran, is encompassed in a fi-
brous hull structure that contains approximately 50% hemicellulose, 40% crude
cellulose and 10% crude lignin. The main sections of oat groats are the tri-
chomes (hairs), pericarp, nucellar tissues, aleurone, endosperm, embryo and
scutellum. The composition of each layer varies significantly. In addition, the lo-
cation and concentration of components in oats depend upon cultivar and envi-
ronmental conditions. The chemical composition of oat groats and respective
layers has been given by Webster [68] and Wood [69].
8.3.2
Layout of a Potential Oat-based Fractionation Process
The high value of oat bran necessitates its separation prior to further processing
of the rest of the grain. Figure 8.5 presents a schematic diagram of a proposed
biorefinery based on oat groats, employing pearling and air classification. Signif-
icant information in the formulation of this processing scheme was taken from
Paton et al. [70] who used pearling to remove outer oat layers (1–15% of the oat
kernel). Pearlings were used to produce the following products:
1. a highly concentrated anti-irritant and a light oat oil extracted successively by
a volatile aqueous polar solvent and a nonpolar solvent;
2. a dark high quality oil and a highly stable lipase-active powder extracted by a
nonpolar solvent;
Hull
) Encases oat groat 30 b) Fiber, some protein, some antioxidants
Pericarp Protect the grain – Fiber, protein, antioxidants, K, P, Mg, Ca
Seed coat and nucellus Bran –
Aleurone layer Encases endosperm – Protein, b-glucan, niacin, antioxidants, lipids,
phytin, aromatic amines, minerals (especially
P)
Endosperm Stores food 55–70 c) Starch, protein, b-glucan, lipids, minerals
Embryo Root and shoot 2.8–3.7 c) Similar to bran excluding niacin and aromatic
Scutellum Stores food amines
a) Mass fraction of the constituent within the kernel as % on a dry basis (db)
b) Content as related to dry weight of the complete oat kernel (hulls plus groat)
c) Content as related to the dry weight of the oat groat
184
8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
Fig. 8.5 Schematic diagram of a biorefinery based on oat groats employing pearling and air classification.
8.3 A Biorefinery Based on Oats 185
Pearled oat kernels could be either converted into a feedstock for subsequent
microbial bioconversions or fractionated into various coproducts. Steeping the
pearled oat groats in water would facilitate the maceration of bran and flour
fractions accomplished by aqueous ethanol extraction. The bran fraction is used
for the extraction of b-glucan, while the flour fraction is divided into starch and
protein. From the remaining pearled oat groat extract, an oat anti-irritant can be
recovered. Flour from pearled oat kernels or starch could be used in some fun-
gal bioconversions for the production of chemicals without hydrolysis. For in-
stance, Rhizopus oryzae can utilize starch for the production of lactic acid [71].
in order to provide consumers with the daily requirements for b-glucan. The
presence of b-glucan in the pericarp, aleurone and sub-aleurone layers indicates
that the application of a pearling technology would be ideal for the separation
of b-glucan rich fractions [24]. However, distribution of b-glucan in the oat ker-
nel is dependent on the oat cultivar used. Thus, oat cultivars should be screened
so as to identify the ones that will provide b-glucan enriched fractions through
pearling.
The market price, functional properties and concentration of b-glucan com-
mercial preparations will be dependent on the final application and the fraction-
ation process employed. For instance, purified b-glucan could reach a value of
$ 55 kg–1, while its use as thickening agent would compete with guar and
xanthan gums, the market price of which is $ 0.78 kg–1 and $ 12 kg–1, respec-
tively [24].
times as more endosperm tissue was included. The results reported by Peterson
et al. [27] about pearling fractions were reinforced by two other studies [79, 80].
The numerous functionalities of oat antioxidants including growth regulation,
good emulsifying properties, defense against parasites, inhibition of oxidative
degradation of unsaturated fatty acids, prevention of cardiovascular diseases,
cholesterol lowering capabilities, prevention of specific cancers, and provision of
color/aroma/stability/nutritional value in cereal food products, can impact many
industries [27, 78]. Oil-rich fractions extracted from groats or oat bran could be
used as emulsifiers or as ingredients in health foods, skin-care preparations,
specialized food oils and pharmaceuticals [81].
8.4
Summary
This chapter presents some potential cereal-based biorefineries that can be em-
ployed for the production of fuels, chemicals and plastics, as well as many val-
ue-added byproducts derived from cereal bran. Cereals are complex biological
entities and will represent a major category of the core photosynthetic raw ma-
terials that will replace petroleum in the production of commodities as well as
specialties. The creation of viable biorefineries based on cereals will require the
exploitation of all the botanical constituents of the grain as well as, if possible,
the non-grain components such as straw, stalks and hulls. Novel processing
routes for starch and protein in the production of a generic feedstock for micro-
bial bioconversions have been presented and various products that could be de-
rived from wheat and oats have been identified. The cost-competitiveness of
such cereal-based biorefineries will depend on the range of high value end prod-
ucts and their integration with the much larger volume low to mid-value prod-
ucts, and could be further improved by exploiting straw, hulls and other non-
grain components of the crop, either for the production of more value-added by-
products or simply for the generation of energy.
References
1 Morrison, R., Policy alternatives for the 3 Dobraszczyk, B. J. Wheat and flour. In
development of the cereal processing in- D. A. V. Dendy and B. J. Dobraszczyk
dustry, A report issued from Winnipeg (Eds.), Cereals and cereal products:
by Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada’s Chemistry and technology. Gaithersburg,
Policy Branch under the Grains 2000 MD: Aspen Publishers Inc. (1994) 100–
program, November, 1995. 139.
2 Audsley, E. and Sells, J. E. Determining 4 Pomeranz, Y. Chemical composition of
the profitability of a wholecrop biorefi- kernel structures. In: Wheat: Chemistry
nery. In: Campbell GM, Webb C, McKee and Technology. Vol. I. Pomeranz, Y. ed.
SL (eds) Cereals: Novel Uses and Pro- AACC: St. Paul, Minnesota, USA (1988)
cesses, Plenum press, New York, pp pp. 97–158.
191–204.
188 8 A Whole Crop Biorefinery System
48 Hwang, J., Park, B. and Yun, J. Biologi- J. J. Modified wheat glutens for use in
cally active materials such as ferulic acid fabrication of films. (1999) US Patent
and arabinoxylan obtained from cereal 5,747,648.
bran by extrusion and enzyme treat- 59 Woerdeman, D. L., Veraverbeke, W. S.,
ment. (2001) PCT International Applica- Parnas, R. S., Johnson, D., Delcour, J. A.,
tions WO 01/67891 A1. Verpoest, I., Plummer, C. J. G. Designing
49 Anonymous. Report from the state of new materials from wheat protein. Bio-
France forming part of the IENICA pro- macromolecules 5 (2004) 1262–1269.
ject. Interactive European Network for 60 Webb C., and Wang R. (1997) Develop-
Industrial Crops and their Applications ment of a generic fermentation feedstock
(IENICA). Agency for Environment and from whole wheat flour. In: Campbell
Energy Management (ADEME) (1999). GM, Webb C, McKee SL (eds) Cereals:
50 Ferguson, L. R. and Harris, P. J. Protec- Novel Uses and Processes, Plenum
tion against cancer by wheat bran: role press, New York, pp 205–218
of dietary fibre and phytochemicals. Eu- 61 Koutinas, A. A., Wang, R.–H. and Webb,
ropean Journal of Cancer Prevention 8 C. Restructuring upstream bioprocess-
(1999) 17–25. ing: Technological and economical as-
51 Reddy, B.S., Hirose, Y., Cohen, L.A., pects for the production of a generic mi-
Simi, B., Cooma, I. and Rao, C.V. Pre- crobial feedstock from wheat. Biotechnol-
ventive potential of wheat bran fractions ogy and Bioengineering 85 (2004) 524–
against experimental colon carcinogen- 538.
esis: implications for human colon can- 62 Webb, C., Koutinas, A. A. and Wang, R.-
cer prevention. Cancer Research 60 (2000) H. Developing a sustainable bioprocess-
4792–4797. ing strategy based on a generic feed-
52 Kahlon, T. S. and Woodruff, C. L. In vitro stock. In: Scheper T (Series ed), Zhong
binding of bile acids by rice bran, oat J-J (volume ed) Biomanufacturing. Ad-
bran, barley and b-glucan enriched bar- vances in Biochemical Engineering/Bio-
ley. Cereal Chemistry 80 (2003) 260–263. technology. Springer–Verlag Berlin 87
53 Fenech, M., Noakes, M., Clifton, P. and (2004) 196–268
Topping, D. Aleurone flour is a rich 63 Bohlmann, J. A., Schisler, D. O., Hwang,
source of bioavailable folate in humans. K.-O., Henning, J. P., Trinkle, J. R., An-
Journal of Nutrition 129 (1999) 1114– derson, T. B., Steinke, J. D. and Vander-
1119. hoff, A. Enzymic process for producing
54 Sidbu, J. S., Al-Saqer, J. M. and Al-Hooti, N-acetyl-d-glucosamine from spent fun-
S. N. Mineral composition of high-fiber gal biomass. (2003) PCT International
pan bread formulations containing bran Applications WO 03/13435 A2.
and germ fractions. AFS, Advances in 64 Ian, W., Bohlmann, J. A., Trinkle, J. R.,
Food Sciences 23 (2001) 108–112. Steinke, J. D., Hwang, K.-O. and Hen-
55 Salmenkallio-Marttila, M., Katina, K. and ning, J. P. Glucosamine from microbial
Autio, K. Effects of bran fermentation on biomass. (2002) US Patent 2002115639.
quality and microstructure of high-fiber 65 McCoy, M. Betting on glucosamine.
wheat bread. Cereal Chemistry 78 (2001) Chemical and Engineering News 81 (No 7)
429–435. (2003) 27–28.
56 Czuchajowska, Z. and Pomeranz, Y. Pro- 66 Datar, R. P., Shenkman, R. M., Cateni,
cess for fractionating wheat flours to ob- B. G., Huhnke, R. L., Lewis R. S. Fermen-
tain protein concentrates and prime tation of biomass-generated producer gas
starch. (1995) US Patent 5,439,526. to ethanol. Biotechnology and Bioengineer-
57 Sayaslan, A. Wet-milling of wheat flour: ing 86 (2004) 587–594
industrial processes and small-scale test 67 Weaver, P. F. and Maness P.-C. Photo-
methods. Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft und conversion of gasified organic materials
-Technologie 37 (2004) 499–515. into biologically-degradable plastics
58 Bassi, S., Maningat, C. C., Chinnaswamy, (1993) US Patent 5,250,427
R., Nie, L., Weibel, M. K. and Watson,
References 191
68 Webster, F. H. Oats: Chemistry and tech- tracted from oat, enhances disease resis-
nology. (1986) AACC, St Paul, Minneso- tance against bacterial and parasitic in-
ta, USA fections. FEMS Immunology and Medical
69 Wood, P. J. Oat bran. (1993) AACC, St Microbiology 35 (2003) 67–75.
Paul, Minnesota, USA. 76 Jenkins, A. L., Jenkins, D. J. A., Zdravko-
70 Paton, D., Reaney, M. J. T. and Tyler, N. J. vic, U., Wursch, P. and Vuksan, V. De-
Methods for processing oat groats and pression of the glycemic index by high
products thereof. (2000) US patent levels of b-glucan fiber in two functional
6,113,908. foods tested in type 2 diabetes. European
71 Tay, A. and Yang, S.-T. Production of Journal of Clinical Nutrition 56 (2002)
L(+)-lactic acid from glucose and starch 622–628.
by immobilized cells of Rhizopus oryzae 77 Malkki, Y. and Virtanen, E. Gastrointesti-
in a rotating fibrous bed reactor. Biotech- nal effects of oat bran and oat gum: A
nology and Bioengineering 80 (2002) review. Lebensmittel-Wissenschaft und -
pp. 1–12. Technologie 34 (2001) 337–347.
72 Maki, K. C., Shinnick, F. S., Marlyn, A., 78 Peterson, D. M. Oat Antioxidants. Journal
Veith, P. E., Quinn, L. C., Hallissey, P. J., of Cereal Science 33 (2001) 115–129.
Temer, A. and Davidson, M.H. Food 79 Emmons, C. L., Peterson, D. M. and
products containing free tall oil-based Paul, G. L. Antioxidant capacity of oat
phytosterols and oat b-glucan lower se- (Avena sativa L.) extracts. 2. In vitro anti-
rum total and LDL cholesterol in hy- oxidant activity and contents of phenolic
percholesterolemic adults. Journal of Nu- and tocol antioxidants. Journal of Agricul-
trition 133 (2003) 808–813. tural and Food Chemistry 47 (1999) 4894–
73 Colleoni-Sirghie, M., Kovalenko, I. V., 4898.
Briggs, J. L., Fulton, B. and White, P. J. 80 Gray, D. A., Auerbach, R. H., Hill, S.,
Rheological and molecular properties of Wang, R., Campbell, G. M., Webb C. and
water soluble (1,3) (1,4)-b-b-glucans from South, J. B. Enrichment of oat antioxi-
high-b-glucan and traditional oat lines. dant activity by dry milling and sieving.
Carbohydrate Polymers 52 (2003) 439–447. Journal of Cereal Science 32 (2000) 89–98.
74 Wursch, P. and Pi-Sunyer, E. X. The role 81 Peterson, D. M. Composition, separation
of viscous soluble fiber in the metabolic and applications. Lipid Technology 14
control of diabetes. Diabetes Care 20 (2002) 56–59
(1997) 1774–1780.
75 Yun, C.-H., Estrada, A., Van Kessel, A.,
Park, B.-C. and Laarveld, B. b-Glucan, ex-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
193
Fuel-oriented Biorefineries
9
Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol
from Cellulosic Biomass
Jeffrey S. Tolan
9.1
Introduction
9.2
Process Overview
The basic process steps of Iogen’s Ottawa plant are shown in Fig. 9.1. This is a
demonstration plant that produces up to 2000 gallons day–1 of ethanol from
wheat straw. A full scale plant would produce about 170 000 gallons of ethanol
per day (60 million gallons year–1).
A cellulosic feedstock material such as wheat straw or other straws, corn
stover, or grass is subjected to pretreatment, that is, cooked in the presence of
acid to break down its fibrous structure. After pretreatment, the material has a
muddy texture. Cellulase enzymes are added to the pretreated material to hydro-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
194 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
lyze the cellulose to the simple sugar glucose; this is known as cellulose hydroly-
sis. The cellulase enzymes are made at the plant site by using a wood-rotting
fungus in large fermentation vessels. This is known as cellulase enzyme produc-
tion. After cellulose hydrolysis, the sugars are separated from the unhydrolyzed
solids, which include lignin and residual cellulose. These solids are burned to
provide energy for the entire process (lignin processing). The sugars are ferment-
ed (sugar fermentation) to ethanol using recently developed recombinant Sacchar-
omyces yeast from Purdue University to ferment the glucose and the more diffi-
cult sugar to ferment, xylose. In ethanol recovery, the ethanol is recovered by con-
ventional distillation, denatured, and blended into gasoline.
The remainder of this chapter describes the process steps and related technol-
ogies in more detail.
9.3
Feedstock Selection
9.3.1
Feedstock Composition
The term “cellulosic biomass” refers to potential feedstocks that have cellulose as
a primary constituent. Other major constituents of these materials include hemi-
cellulose and lignin. Minor constituents include proteins, ash, starch, and various
other organic compounds that are not carbohydrates.
9.3 Feedstock Selection 195
Table 9.1 Feedstock composition (mg g–1 total solids) (from Foody et al. 1999 [1]).
ethanol yield. Table 9.1 shows the composition of several typical lignocellulosic
materials.
9.3.2
Feedstock Selection
The scope of feedstocks considered by Iogen for ethanol production are listed in
Table 9.2.
These potential feedstocks are evaluated based on the desired feedstock prop-
erties. The desired qualities of a feedstock are:
1. Low cost. Naturally, the cost of the feedstock is an important part of the over-
all cost. A desired feedstock can be obtained and transported to the plant at
low cost. This rules out primary and secondary tree growth, sawdust, and
waste paper, all of which have existing markets and high cost.
2. Availability. A feedstock must be in sufficient quantity to supply a commercial
plant. This requires perhaps 800 000 tons year–1, which is not available from
bagasse in many locations.
3. Uniformity. For a high-speed production process, foreign matter present in
municipal waste is unacceptable.
4. Cleanliness. High levels of silica can abrade equipment, as stated above. A
high degree of microbial contamination is unacceptable. High levels of toxic
or inhibitory materials are not acceptable.
5. High potential ethanol yield. The main constituents, cellulose and hemicellu-
lose, must be present in high enough levels to produce ethanol. This is a dis-
advantage of forestry waste, which is high in bark that is mostly lignin and
phenolic acids.
6. High efficiency of conversion. The efficiency of conversion to glucose (follow-
ing Iogen’s pretreatment process) is proportional to the arabino-xylan content
of the feedstock [1]. The arabino-xylan content is roughly the sum of the ara-
binan and xylan content listed in Table 9.1. Feedstocks with a low arabino-xy-
lan content, such as softwood, demand unacceptably high levels of enzyme
for conversion to cellulose.
Matching the feedstock list with the desired properties results in the feedstocks
used by Iogen, which are agricultural residues such as straws and stover and
energy crops such as grasses. The energy crops, such as grass, are not currently
harvested in a large scale, as this will require large scale demonstration of the
technology before people commit to these as crops. The grasses are therefore
second-generation feedstocks.
9.3.3
Ethanol from Starch or Sucrose
9.3.4
Advantages of Making Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
The conversion of cellulosic biomass to ethanol is more difficult than starch or su-
crose, and this has limited commercialization of the technology. However, cellulo-
sic biomass is available in much greater quantity and offers the potential for much
greater ethanol production than the other feedstocks. In addition, ethanol produc-
tion from starch and sucrose faces competition for the feedstock from the food
and cattle feed industries, which exerts pressure on the price of the ethanol. Most
cellulosic biomass is free of competition from other uses. Cellulosic biomass can
be grown in a wider variety of climates and soils than starch and sucrose and
therefore represent a potential new agricultural opportunity in many areas.
The most important advantage of making ethanol from cellulosic biomass is
that the production and use of the ethanol does not add to the emission of green-
house gases. Producing ethanol from corn, sugar cane, or sugar beets requires
198 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
9.4
Pretreatment
9.4.1
Process
9.4.2
Chemical Reactions
Of the major components, the first to react is the hemicellulose. The xylan por-
tion is depolymerized and solubilized, and then hydrolyzed to xylose by the re-
action:
mers are formed. Further, the added acid improves the uniformity of the pro-
cess, because natural acid levels vary considerably among feedstocks or batches
of a given feedstock.
If the pretreatment reaction proceeds further, the xylose is dewatered to pro-
duce furfural (Eq. 2), which is undesirable.
Arabinose undergoes analogous reactions, but more slowly than xylose. Acetic
acid is released from the hydrolysis of acetyl groups attached to the xylan.
Removing hemicellulose from the feedstock accomplishes two objectives.
First, it makes the simple sugars that can potentially be fermented to ethanol.
Second and more importantly, it opens up surface area on the feedstock, there-
by allowing the cellulase enzyme to digest the cellulose more efficiently.
A small amount of cellulose reacts to form glucose, which is degraded to hy-
droxymethylfurfural, by Eqs (3) and (4):
Only a small amount of cellulose hydrolysis (< 20%) is desired in the pretreat-
ment. More than this results in a decrease in glucose yield and accessibility of
the enzyme to the cellulose. The older acid hydrolysis process carried out a
much harsher acid hydrolysis and will be described below.
The lignin undergoes a depolymerization during pretreatment, but remains
insoluble in water or acid. Protein is destroyed and starch is hydrolyzed to glu-
cose in the pretreatment.
One can draw an analogy to cooking a turkey to describe the trade-off be-
tween time and temperature in the pretreatment: the longer the time, the lower
the temperature. Acid also acts to decrease the temperature or time required for
pretreatment.
The choice of reactor for this pretreatment is only important insofar as the
desired chemistry must be delivered to the system. Numerous guns, vessels,
and tubes have been proposed and built to carry this out.
9.4.3
Other Pretreatment Processes
Katzen et al. [4] published a detailed review of pretreatment that will only be
summarized here. Pretreatment processes may be divided into (1) those that
produce a stream directly for fermentation to ethanol and (2) those that are fol-
lowed by enzymatic hydrolysis. The former are necessarily harsher and have a
longer history.
Direct sugar production in pretreatment has been carried out using concen-
trated chemicals and dilute acid.
200 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
9.5
Cellulase Enzyme Production
9.5.1
Production of Cellulase Enzymes
9.5.2
Enzyme Production on the Ethanol Plant Site
9.5.3
Commercial Status of Cellulase
There is an ongoing business in cellulase enzymes besides that used for cellu-
lose hydrolysis. Cellulase sales are roughly $ 100 million annually to the textiles,
detergent, animal feed, beverage, and pulp and paper industries [5].
These commercial cellulase enzymes are made by several microbes, including
Humicola, Aspergillus, and Penicillium fungi, and Bacillus bacteria in addition to
Trichoderma. Ethanol production requires aggressive action of cellulase to de-
stroy cellulose, for which Trichoderma cellulase is superior. The other industries
often require milder action and/or specific conditions better suited to other cel-
lulases. For example, the textile industry uses cellulase to soften denim blue
jeans. Humicola cellulases can be less aggressive in this application than Tricho-
derma cellulases, though Trichoderma cellulases can be modified to improve
their performance. Detergents require alkaline conditions that are not easily ac-
cessible to Trichoderma enzymes.
9.6
Cellulose Hydrolysis
9.6.1
Process Description
The hydrolysis proceeds for 5–7 days. As it proceeds, the viscosity of the slur-
ry drops, and the remaining insoluble particles, which are lignin in increasing
proportion, diminish in size. At the end of the hydrolysis, 90% to 98% of the
cellulose is converted to glucose. The remainder is insoluble and contained
within the unhydrolyzed particles, which are mostly lignin.
9.6.2
Kinetics of Cellulose Hydrolysis
Eq. (5) depicts the hydrolysis of cellulose to its soluble dimer, cellobiose. This re-
action is catalyzed by the CBH and EG enzymes. The CBH and EG enzymes
work synergistically to hydrolyze cellulose. Reaction (6) is the hydrolysis of cello-
biose to glucose. This reaction is catalyzed by the soluble enzyme beta-glucosi-
dase and proceeds according to standard Michaelis-Menten kinetics. BG ac-
counts for less than 1% of the total cellulase protein. Hydrolysis of the cello-
biose is important because glucose can be readily fermented to ethanol while
cellobiose is not. In addition, cellobiose is a potent inhibitor of CBH and EG, so
the accumulation of even 5 g L–1 cellobiose slows down the hydrolysis signifi-
cantly.
The properties of the Trichoderma cellulase enzymes are summarized in Ta-
ble 9.3.
There are several inherent difficulties in cellulose hydrolysis that have been
the focus of much research. The first is the inherent shortage of BG, both be-
cause of its low concentration and because it is inhibited by its product glucose.
With a shortage of BG, cellobiose accumulates, thereby inhibiting the action of
CBH and EG in hydrolyzing cellulose.
Three approaches have been proposed to overcoming the shortage of BG. The
first is to produce BG in a separate fermentation by Aspergillus spp. The disad-
vantage of this is the added process cost of a second fermentation.
The second and most widely discussed approach is to carry out a simulta-
neous saccharification and fermentation (SSF) process. In SSF, the enzymatic
204 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
hydrolysis and glucose fermentation are run simultaneously, with the notion
that the yeast consumes the glucose to prevent inhibition of BG, which can
then hydrolyze cellobiose and lift the inhibition of CBH/EG. In Iogen’s re-
search, SSF systems have achieved poor results, because the enzyme’s optimum
temperature is 50 8C and the yeast runs best at 28 8C, so a compromise tempera-
ture of 37 8C is used. In addition to the loss of rate, microbial contamination is
observed at 37 8C. We have put this approach aside.
The third option is to develop Trichoderma strains with high beta-glucosidase
production included in the CBH/EG. This has been carried out at Iogen [12]
and has largely overcome the shortage of BG.
Other important difficulties in the hydrolysis are the decrease in rate as hy-
drolysis proceeds and the diminishing returns with enzyme dosage, i.e. dou-
bling the amount of enzyme does not double the extent of conversion achieved.
These issues, which are probably linked, are not well understood and differ sub-
stantially from Michaelis-Menten kinetics. These effects can, however, be charac-
terized empirically.
The enzyme components initially must adsorb to the surface of the insoluble
substrate cellulose. An equilibrium corresponding roughly to a Langmuir ad-
sorption isotherm is reached within a few minutes. The adsorbed enzyme then
acts on the cellulose at a rapid initial rate. The rate declines significantly after
the first few minutes of hydrolysis, and after 24 h is less than 2% of the initial
rate. The hydrolysis continues over several days at ever decreasing rates. De-
pending on the enzyme dosage used and the duration of the hydrolysis, the fi-
nal cellulose conversion is 90% to 98%.
The reason the rate slows down is not fully known. Speculation in the litera-
ture has centered on: end-product inhibition; an increasingly difficulty in hydro-
lyzing the substrate (substrate recalcitrance); and denaturation of the cellulase
protein over time. However, straightforward experiments demonstrate that none
of these factors account for more than a small fraction of the drop in rate.
Further research continues in this area.
9.7 Lignin Processing 205
9.6.3
Improvements in Enzymatic Hydrolysis
Despite many years of research, cellulose hydrolysis remains the least efficient
part of the process. To illustrate the problem, hydrolysis of pretreated cellulose
requires 100-fold more enzyme than hydrolysis of starch. The enzyme manufac-
turing cost is still sufficiently high that the trade-off between enzyme dosage
and hydrolysis time favors longer times and lower dosages.
One approach to potentially decrease the cost of enzymatic hydrolysis is to recycle
enzyme and/or substrate. These ideas have not been fully explored. The cellulase
enzyme adsorbs to the substrate, so recycle of unconsumed cellulose would be one
way to reuse the enzyme. Reuse of the enzyme in solution is also a possibility. The
current configuration of Iogen’s plant does not carry out these recycles, but up-
grades are under way to allow the demonstration plant to evaluate these options.
Another approach to reducing the cost of hydrolysis is to use fed-batch of sub-
strate or of enzyme. Again, these are ideas with a sound basis that have not
been explored. Fed batch systems are especially interesting because they might
allow high cellulose concentrations to be maintained at all times.
The development of superior cellulase enzymes has been explored extensively
at several research labs, with as yet no cellulases found that are superior to Tri-
choderma cellulase. However, the new tools of molecular biology, such as protein
engineering, can be brought to bear on this problem and might lead to success.
Large development efforts are under way at Iogen and at Genencor Interna-
tional, Novozym Biotech, and Diversa to address this area.
Another area that has been widely explored is novel hydrolysis reactors, such
as trickling bed, high shear, etc. Some improvements in efficiency have been re-
ported, but not easily generalized across feedstocks and enzymes. A better un-
derstanding of the nature of the enzyme’s action will be helpful in evaluating
these reactors.
Taking a wider point of view, better hydrolysis would be a direct benefit of
better pretreatment. Pretreatment has been widely studied, but there are always
new ideas on the horizon.
9.7
Lignin Processing
9.7.1
Process Description
The hydrolysis slurry contains glucose, xylose, arabinose, and other compounds
dissolved in the aqueous phase, and insoluble lignin and unconsumed cellulose.
The insoluble particles are separated by a plate and frame filter, with the cake
washed with water to obtain a high sugar recovery. The sugar stream is pumped
to the fermentation tanks. The lignin cake is disposed of. In a full-scale ethanol
206 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
plant, the lignin would be burned on site to generate power and steam to run
the plant, with excess electricity sold to the power grid.
9.7.2
Alternative Uses for Lignin
Lignin is a lattice of phenolic propane units. Lignin has been the object of
much study, and a good review of applications of lignin is provided by Chum et
al. [13]. The potential applications of lignin fall into the broad categories of in-
soluble and chemically modified. Insoluble lignin is limited to high-volume,
low value applications such as an ingredient in roads or cement. In these appli-
cations, lignin is a filler and competes with corn cobs, gravel, and ground bark.
Chemically modified lignin has a much wider variety of potential markets.
The major types of chemical modifications are to solubilize the lignin, by reac-
tion with i.e. sulfurous acid, or to crosslink the lignin, by reaction with i.e. phe-
nol. Crosslinked lignin is suitable for resins, glues, and other such materials,
where it competes with phenol–formaldehyde resins. Solubilized lignin, i.e. so-
dium lignosulfonate, is used in surfactants, detergents, and biocides.
9.8
Sugar Fermentation and Ethanol Recovery
The hydrolysis sugars, which consist of glucose, xylose, arabinose, and various
organic impurities in aqueous solution, are pumped to the sugar fermenters for
ethanol production. The fermenters are large tanks with gentle agitation, suffi-
cient to keep the contents moving. The fermenters are inoculated with Saccharo-
myces yeast, which readily ferment the glucose to ethanol, and have been geneti-
cally modified for metabolism and fermentation of xylose. These yeast strains
have been developed at Purdue University [14]. The advantage of these strains
over others is that the plant operations (contamination control, cell recycle, and
markets for spent cells) involving Saccharomyces yeast are well developed, and
the ethanol tolerance of the strains are good. The areas for further improvement
include developing the inability to ferment arabinose to ethanol and increasing
the yields and rates of xylose fermentation.
In addition to Saccharomyces yeast, other microbes are under development to
ferment xylose to ethanol, which is not carried out naturally in high efficiency.
Pichia yeast have a natural ability for xylose uptake, but require genetic modifi-
cation to ferment the xylose to ethanol. This strategy is carried out at the Uni-
versity of Wisconsin [15]. In addition, Zymomonas bacteria have been genetically
modified for xylose uptake and metabolism. This strategy is carried out by the
National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Boulder, Colorado [16]. Two other
strategies for pentose fermentation include genetically modified enteric bacteria
such as E. coli and Klebsiella, carried out at the University of Florida [17–19],
and thermostable Bacillus strains developed at Imperial College.
References 207
References
1 Foody, B., Tolan, J. S., Bernstein, J., Pre- 10 Ward, M., Clarkson, K. A., Larenas, E. A.,
treatment process for conversion of cellulose Lorch, J. D., Weiss, G. L., DNA Sequence
to fuel ethanol, US Patent 5,916,780 is- Encoding Endoglucanase III Cellulase, US
sued June 29, 1999. patent 5,475,101 issued Dec. 12, 1995.
2 Singh, L., Scenarios of U.S. Carbon Re- 11 Saloheimo et al., A novel, small endogluca-
ductions: Potential Impacts of Energy Tech- nase gene, egl5, from Trichoderma reesei iso-
nologies by 2010 and Beyond, Interlabora- lated by expression in yeast, Molecular Mi-
tory Working Group on Energy Efficient crobiology, 1993, 61, 1090–1097.
and Low-Carbon Technologies (ORNL, 12 White, T. C., Hindle, C., Genetic constructs
LBNL, PNNL, NREL, ANL), 1997. and genetically modified microbes for en-
3 Foody, P., Method for Increasing the acces- hanced production of beta-glucosidase. US
sibility of cellulose in lignocellulosic materi- patent 6,015,703 issued January 18,
als, particularly hardwoods, agricultural res- 2000.
idues, and the like, US patent 4,461,648 13 Chum, H. L., Parker, S. K., Feinberg,
issued July 24, 1984. D. A., Wright, J. D., Rice, P. A., Sinclair,
4 Katzen, R., Madsen, P. W., Monceaux, S. A., Glasser, W. G., The Economic Con-
D. A., Bevernitz, K., Use of Cellulosic Feed- tribution of Lignins to Ethanol Production
stocks for Alcohol Production, Chapter 5 of from Biomass, National Renewable En-
The Alcohol Textbook, edited by T. P. ergy Lab, Golden, Colo., 1985.
Lyons, D. R. Kelsall, and J. E. Murtagh, 14 Ho, N. W. Y., Chen, Z.-D., Stable Recombi-
1990. nant Yeasts for Fermenting Xylose to Etha-
5 Godfrey, T., Industrial Enzymology, nol, PCT patent application WO 97/
Chapter 1, 1996. 42307, 1997.
6 Shoemaker et al., Molecular cloning of 15 Cho, J., Jeffries, T. J., Pichia stipitis Genes
exo-cellobiohydrolase I derived from Tricho- for Alcohol Dehydrogenase with Fermenta-
derma reesei strain L27, Bio/technology, tive and Respirative Functions, Appl. Envi-
1983, 1, 691–696. ron. Microbiol., 1998, 64(4), 1350–1358.
7 Chen et al., Nucleotide sequence and de- 16 Mohagheghi, A., Evans, K., Finkelstein,
duced primary structure of cellobiohydrolase M., Zhang, M., Cofermentation of Glucose,
II from Trichoderma reesei, Bio/technol- Xylose, and Arabinose by Mixed Cultures of
ogy, 1987, 5, 274–278. Two Genetically Engineered Zymomonas
8 Penttila et al., Homology between cellulase mobilis Strains, Applied Biochem. Bio-
genes of Trichoderma reesei: complete nu- technol., 1998, 70–72, 285.
cleotide sequence of the endoglucanase I 17 Ingram, L. O., Conway, T., Clark, D. P.,
gene, Gene, 1986, 45, 253–263. Sewall, G. W., Preston, J. F., Genetic Engi-
9 Saloheimo et al., EGIII, a new endogluca- neering of Ethanol Production in Escheri-
nase from Trichoderma reesei: the character- chia coli, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 1987,
ization of both gene and enzyme, Gene, 53(10), 2420–2425.
1988, 63, 11–21. 18 Ohta, K., Alterthum, F., Ingram, L.O.,
Effects of Environmental Conditions on Xy-
208 9 Iogen’s Demonstration Process for Producing Ethanol from Cellulosic Biomass
209
10
Sugar-based Biorefinery –
Technology for Integrated Production
of Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate), Sugar, and Ethanol
Carlos Eduardo Vaz Rossell, Paulo E. Mantelatto, José A. M. Agnelli,
and Jefter Nascimento
10.1
Introduction
10.2
Sugar Cane Agro Industry in Brazil – Historical Outline
10.2.1
Sugar and Ethanol Production
During the last quarter of the 20th century, Brazil’s sugar cane agroindustry un-
derwent major changes. This initially traditional sector, previously devoted spe-
cifically to the production of sugar and occasionally to by-products, recovering
or producing very few new products from available sugar or molasses, shifted
its scope to diversify its production lines. In 1975, after the international oil cri-
sis and the rise of oil prices, the Brazilian government launched the National
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
210 10 Sugar-based Biorefinery
Fuel Ethanol Program, with the objective of replacing oil imports with sugar
cane-based ethanol as an alternative fuel. Many mills began to produce aqueous
ethanol, for direct use in converted car engines, or anhydrous ethanol to add to
gasoline as a fuel enhancer. The scale of production increased substantially,
agricultural and industrial productivity grew, and production costs dropped.
This new situation, which led to a favorable change in the country’s energy
balance, caused the production of an excess of bagasse, which has been used as
primary fuel by the mills or has been sold to third parties. Today, Brazil is the
largest worldwide producer of sugar and sugar cane-based ethanol and, on the
basis of cultivated area and income, sugar cane is one of the most important
agricultural activities. This statement is confirmed by figures from the 2003/
2004 season – sugar cane production was 338 316 619. metric tons. Ethanol pro-
duction was 14 107 873 m3, 8 577 410 m3 of which was anhydrous fuel grade and
the remaining 5 530 468 m3 aqueous fuel grade. Sugar production rose to
23 404 703 tons, of which 12 914 468 tons were exported, accounting for revenues
of US $ 2 140 002 217 [1].
10.2.2
The Sugar Cane Agroindustry and the Green Cycle
The modern sugar agroindustry, which tends to operate as a “green cycle”, can
achieve a unique condition as a source of renewable raw materials if a continu-
ous effort is made to keep its production practices environmentally friendly.
The basis of this sector is sugar cane (Saccharum officinarum), a subtropical gra-
mineous plant cultivated on a large scale in Brazil’s south central region with
productivity averaging 85 tonnes per hectare per year and for which production
costs are low. Sugar cane captures solar energy and converts atmospheric carbon
dioxide into biomass. Macedo [2] produced an inventory of carbon dioxide re-
leased during sugar cane processing into final products and, after fuel ethanol
combustion, concluded that the net balance was positive and that atmospheric
carbon dioxide is effectively removed by cane crops. Macedo also demonstrated
that the balance between energy available from final products such as fuel etha-
nol, bagasse and electrical power generated versus energy consumption during
cane culture and industrial processing is positive [3, 4].
The sugar mills operating in Brazil today are very large units functioning as
autonomous industrial complexes. Their main products are sugar and fuel etha-
nol, and bagasse – the fibrous fraction of sugar cane – is the primary fuel. Ba-
gasse burned in high-pressure boilers provides mechanical power for driving
mill tandems, electrical power to meet the requirements of sugar and ethanol
production, and the heat demand involved in processing cane into final prod-
ucts. Mills whose energy production is well planned and optimized exceed their
energy requirements, generating excess electrical power and bagasse. Modern
mills have large facilities for processing and cooling water, and systems for recy-
cling liquid and effluent to irrigate and/or fertilize crops. Vinasse from ethanol
distillation, condensed water from sugar processing, filter sludge resulting from
10.2 Sugar Cane Agro Industry in Brazil – Historical Outline 211
Fig. 10.1 Sugar cane processing to sucrose, ethanol, by-products, and new products.
juice treatment, and ashes and carbon residue captured in the treatment of boil-
er exhaust gases are disposed of in this way.
The idea of integrating the production of new products with that of sugar is
not new. Sugar cane is a renewable agricultural resource and its processing
yields sugar, cane juice, syrup, and molasses, a very rich substrate that is con-
vertible by fermentation into higher value chemicals such as organic acids, ami-
no acids, and biopolymers, etc. Sugar, a highly reactive molecule, can be chemi-
cally converted into valuable products, as indicated by Kahn [5]. Ethanol, the
other main product of Brazilian sugar mills, is the starting molecule of ethanol
chemistry, whereby important basic chemicals such as aldehyde, acetic acid, and
acetates are produced. Paturau [6] describes some successful examples of inte-
gration at sugar mills whose processing involves products such as citric acid,
fodder yeast and yeast products, acetic acid, vinegar and cellulose, paper, and ba-
gasse-based fiberboard.
The block diagram in Fig. 10.1 illustrates the context of green cycle produc-
tion from renewable agricultural raw materials.
212 10 Sugar-based Biorefinery
10.3
Biodegradable Plastics from Sugar Cane
10.3.1
Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid)
10.3.2
Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Polymer
Mean weighted molar mass Dalton (Da) 200 000 to 600 000
Crystalline melting temperature (Tm) 8C 165 to 175
Vitreous transition temperature (Tg) 8C 0 to 5
Theoretical density of 100% crystalline PHB kg m–3 1260
Density of amorphous PHB kg m–3 1180
10.3 Biodegradable Plastics from Sugar Cane 215
The processibility, high crystallinity, and high Tm value of PHB can be altered by
bacterial fermentation or use of polymer blends. The various copolyesters (PHBV)
include random copolyester (R)-3-hydroxybutyrate with (R)-3-hydroxyvalerate,
P(3HB-co-3HV), and random copolyester (R)-3-hydroxybutyrate with (R)-4-hydro-
xybutyrate, P(3HB-co-4HB). The copolyesters are characterized by their lower crys-
talline melting point, hardness, tensile strength, and crystallinity (hence, greater
ductility and elasticity) than pure PHB. Their physical and thermal properties
can be adjusted by varying the HV content of P(3HB-co-3HV) and the 4-HB con-
tent of P(3HB-co-4HB). Simply varying the copolymer content [15, 21] enables pro-
duction of a material with elastomeric characteristics from one which is rigid and
highly crystalline. For P(3HB-co-3HV) the crystallinity usually decreases with in-
creasing HV content. The Tm of PHB of approximately 175 8C drops to 71 8C for
P(3HB-co-3HV) with a 3HV molar mass of 40%. The Tg of P(3HV) varies from
–10 to –12 8C and the Tm varies from 107 to 112 8C [14].
Although copolymers such as PHBV can be used to prevent thermal degrada-
tion (lower melting point), the comonomer must be inserted homogeneously
into the polymeric chains. For example, for a comonomer content of 16 mol%
HV inserted homogeneously into the polymeric chains the corresponding Tm is
approximately 140 8C and a single melting peak is obtained for the copolymer
in differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) thermal curves. If the comonomer is
not inserted uniformly into the PHB chains, however, multiple melting peaks
will appear, and the highest-melting peak among these multiple peaks will be
located at a temperature exceeding that at which the material is thermally stable
(below 160 8C). The HV content is therefore important for the reduction of the
system’s Tm; equally important is reduction of the heterogeneity of the HV con-
tent in the copolymer [23].
The physical properties of copolymers can be altered by varying the comonomer
content, but the use of polymeric blends and incorporation of plasticizers are pre-
ferable alternatives, because they enable greater versatility in the modification of
properties. The synthesis of copolymers is also a more complex process.
150 8C), and the screw speed must be appropriate. Because of the need for strict
control, the processing window of PHB is narrow in comparison with that of
conventional plastics. It should be pointed out that virgin PHB is supplied in
the powder form, requiring an appropriate screw profile to enable it to be pro-
cessed efficaciously.
Poly(hydroxybutyrate) is highly versatile when used in the injection process
and is easily molded into pieces of varying shapes and sizes, which may range
from a few grams to several kilograms. The main uses of this material include
injectable packaging for cosmetics and food, agrotoxic packaging and tubettes,
and medical and veterinary implants. As in extrusion, injection of poly(hydroxy-
butyrate) should be conducted with a nonaggressive temperature profile and a
low injection pressure to prevent the appearance of burrs.
PHB can also be thermopressed into sheets or other flat shapes. Because
characteristics that affect the speed of biodegradation (for example crystallinity,
physical shape, molar mass distribution, and compaction of the material) can
be altered during processing, PHB samples that have undergone different types
of processing may not biodegrade at the same rate. When using most types of
conventional equipment, without inclusion of special modifications such as
screws or matrixes with specific designs, several operating procedures must be
observed if products with satisfactory end quality are to be obtained. Extrusion
or injection processes can use typical polyolefin processing screws (L/D 20 : 1)
designed to minimize the exposure time of the melted biopolymer. After use
the equipment can be purged using low-density polyethylene resin as vehicle.
To prevent marked thermal degradation poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) should not
be exposed to temperatures exceeding 160 to 170 8C for more than 5 min. The
polymer’s “window of processibility” is relatively narrow compared with that of
olefinic polymers, so precise control of the processing temperature is required
to prevent temperature peaks in the heating resistances, which would lead to
rapid degradation of the material. The “window of processibility” can be moni-
tored by observation of the surface characteristics of the molded component, for
example rugosity and shine, which are highly indicative for this polymer.
When using multistage injection equipment, it is advisable to fill the mold
cavity rapidly, using high injection velocities combined with high pressures, and
ensuring that the injection pressure applied does not lead to the appearance of
defects such as burrs and rugosity, because the fluidity index of poly(3-hydroxy-
butyric acid) drops rapidly when the mass is subjected to high shearing rates.
Poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) does not usually require long cooling times in the
mold in comparison with polyolefins. To minimize PHB-molding “cycle times”
it is advisable to use injection molds heated to approximately 50 8C rather than
injection molds with cold water systems at approximately 10 8C; this enables
faster crystallization, with direct consequences on the thermomechanical proper-
ties of the molded component. This mold temperature is appropriate, because it
is approximately 50 8C higher than the polymer’s vitreous transition tempera-
ture. The use of this procedure improves the characteristics of ejectability of the
molded component, resulting in a gain in “cycle times”.
10.4 Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Production Process 217
10.4
Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Production Process
10.4.1
Sugar Fermentation to Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric acid) by Ralstonia eutropha
The fermentation process follows the procedure described by Bueno et al. [26].
A strain of Ralstonia eutropha is grown under aerobic conditions to furnish a
high-cell-density culture. After this step the culture conditions are altered and
the metabolic pathway is shifted to biosynthesis and intracellular storage of
poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid). The block diagram in Fig. 10.3 illustrates the fer-
mentation process; its main characteristics are listed in Table 10.2.
Industrial strains of the Ralstonia genus, for example those described by Brau-
negg [25], are employed in fermentation. Some varieties are highly productive
and can store up to 80% of their dry weight as biopolymer. When cultured in a
medium containing sugar, ammonium, phosphorus, and salts with a low car-
bon-to-nitrogen ratio they produce mainly biomass; when cultured with a high
carbon to nitrogen ratio, however, their growth phase stops and they begin
synthesizing biopolymer.
10.4.2
Downstream Processing for Recovery and Purification
of Intracellular Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid)
ric acid) is washed, dewatered, and carefully dried to avoid thermal breakage of
the polymer. The moisture content after drying and cooling is less than 0.3%. A
white powder of 100 to 200 mesh size and 500 to 800 kDa molecular weight is
obtained. The fraction of degraded polymer of molecular weight < 300 kDa is
less than 3%.
This procedure yields a highly pure polymer by solvent extraction, avoiding
the negative environmental impacts of other processes.
10.4.3
Integration of Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) Production in a Sugar Mill
Fig. 10.5 Mass and energy balance for sugar, ethanol, and PHB.
222 10 Sugar-based Biorefinery
Sugar cane processing begins with extraction of cane juice by mill tandems,
leaving behind bagasse, the fibrous material that is sent to the boiler house and
to storage. The cane juice is treated physically and chemically to purify it. Most
of this juice is used for production of sugar and the rest goes to the fermenta-
tion plant to produce ethanol. In the sugar-processing sector, this juice is con-
centrated in multiple effect evaporators, yielding thick syrup consisting of nearly
65% soluble solids. The syrup is then boiled in vacuum pans until sugar crys-
tals are produced by evaporation–crystallization, which is usually performed in
two stages. White sugar of various standards is recovered in this step; the mo-
lasses by-product, left over noncrystallizable thick impure sugar syrup, is nor-
mally fermented and converted into ethanol.
Part of the sugar production will be used to produce PHB, and sent to the
PHB plant for direct use or stored for use during the off-season. At the cane
juice fermentation plant, the molasses and sugar syrup are blended to formulate
the fermenting must. The must then undergoes ethanol fermentation, yielding
the final liquor, which is distilled into aqueous and anhydrous fuel ethanol. By-
products such as fusel oil and yeast are recovered in the ethanol production sec-
tor. Meanwhile, at the PHB production facility, medium quality standard sugar
is processed into PHB by the aforementioned procedure.
Sugar cane milling and ethanol and PHB processing are energy-intensive pro-
cesses that require mechanical and electrical power and thermal energy in the
form of low-pressure steam. Recovered bagasse is burned in a high-pressure
boiler, producing superheated steam at 60 bar and 450 8C. This primary steam
is expanded in high efficiency multistage turbines equipped with electricity gen-
erators, providing the electricity consumed by the manufacturing complex. Me-
dium pressure steam at 20 bar is extracted from multistage turbines and used
as the primary mover for mechanical power generation in the milling step in-
volving cane cutters, defibrators, and extraction tandems. Low-pressure steam
extracted from the turbines is used as the source of thermal energy for sugar,
ethanol, and PHB processing.
The solid effluents from the PHB process will be composted and spread over
sugar cane fields as filtering mud from the juice treatment. Liquid effluents, for
example the final fermentation liquor and the washing water left behind after
removal of microorganism cells containing PHB, will be sprayed on the cane
crops like vinasse from ethanol distillation.
10.4.4
Investment and Production Cost of Poly(3-Hydroxybutyric Acid) in a Sugar Mill
A preliminary analysis has been made of the investments required for, and the
production costs involved in, sugar-derived PHB. The purpose of the work was
to determine the economical feasibility of biodegradable production integrated
with an existing sugar mill. The analysis was based on two scenarios – an
autonomous unit producing 10 000 tons of PHB per year, located outside the
mill site, and an integrated unit having the same production capacity. Construc-
10.5 Outlook and Perspectives 223
Investment in US $ %
tion of a manufacturing unit for a production capacity of 10 000 tons per year
requires a large investment. Table 10.3 gives a breakdown of investments and
costs, with installed equipment totaling US $ 38 000 000. The production cost of
PHB is highly dependent on the price of sugar, which is the major factor, ac-
counting for almost 29% of the final cost.
The production cost for a basic 99% pure poly(3-hydroxybutyrate) chemical is
estimated at US $ 2.25 to 2.75 kg–1, depending on the price of sugar, other chemi-
cals, and bagasse. It is worth noting that a similar calculation for an autonomous
PHB unit shows the production cost rises to US $ 2.50 to 3.00 kg–1, indicating the
advantages of integrating PHB production with an existing mill. Comparing our
cost data with Lee’s [51] estimate of $US 2.65 kg–1 and Bertrand’s [52] of
US $ 5.85 kg–1, we conclude that our proposed scenario is feasible.
10.5
Outlook and Perspectives
tion at higher temperatures and lower medium pH will also affect the fermenta-
tion technology favorably.
Steinbuchel [53] reviewed bacterial strains and possible genetically modified
organisms to improve PHB production. Vicente [54, 55] gave examples of the
construction of genetically modified bacteria for poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) bio-
synthesis. Poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) production costs could be significantly re-
duced by optimizing production processes. Moreover, fermentation could be im-
proved to increase the PHB content of the cells to 80%. There is also a margin
for increasing the concentration of biomass in the final liquor to 200 kg m–3, as-
suming the oxygen transfer rate in fomenters is improved. The technology avail-
able today limits fermenter capacity to less than 500 m–3; overcoming this obsta-
cle will lead to increasing gains resulting from scale. The fermentation cycle
can be optimized by reducing the content of reducing sugars in the final liquor
from the current 1 to 0.2%.
There is a broad range of possibilities for optimizing and reducing the cost of
technology available for the extraction and purification of poly(3-hydroxybutyrate).
The consumption of thermal energy and the power requirements in downstream
processing could be reduced. Polymer extraction and purification should be re-
viewed to improve the processing stages and to obtain a purer product of higher
molecular weight and a lower poly dispersion index. A survey of new extraction
solvents is required to identify nontoxic and environmentally friendly solvents that
can dissolve more polymer and less undesirable impurities.
A milestone in poly(hydroxyalkanoate) production will be reached when it be-
comes possible to replace sucrose with carbohydrates contained in the lignin–
cellulose biomass component of sugar cane. The bagasse or trash left behind
after cane harvesting are lower-cost substrates than sugar and, according to Ma-
cedo [3], will be available in large quantities. Depending on the extent of optimi-
zation of energy production and available consumption cycles, the amount of
bagasse will range from 39 to 67 kg ton–1 sugar cane. Biomass availability in
trash is estimated to be 56 to 98 kg ton–1 cane, depending on the harvesting
method employed. In the near future, when the hydrolytic process is commer-
cially ready, this lignin cellulose-based material will be transformed into hexose
and pentose sugars, replacing sucrose in PHB fermentation. Da Silva [56] re-
ports on the biosynthesis of poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) by strains of Bhukolderia
Spp, using hydrolysis liquor from an organosolve process that yields 65 to 75%
total reducing sugars from bagasse. The Bhukolderia strain can ferment the pen-
tose and hexose sugar contained in bagasse.
Other poly(hydroxyalkanoates) unlike poly(3-hydroxybutyric acid) and with su-
perior functional properties will lead to improvement of biodegradable plastics.
Long chain hydroxyacids and heteropolymer alkanoates can be produced by dos-
ing specific carbon substrates in the polymer-biosynthesis step. Thus, the bio-
logical process could be engineered to produce new polymers with desirable
properties.
References 225
References
227
11
Biomass Refineries Based on Hybrid
Thermochemical-Biological Processing – An Overview
Robert C. Brown
11.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
228 11 Biomass Refineries Based on Hybrid Thermochemical-Biological Processing – An Overview
11.2
Historical Outline
11.2.1
Origins of Biorefineries Based on Syngas Fermentation
11.2.2
Origins of Biorefineries Based on Fermentation of Bio-oils
11.3
Gasification-Based Systems
11.3.1
Fundamentals of Gasification
1
C O2 $ CO DHR 110:5 MJ kmol 1
2
Boudouard reaction:
Carbon-water reaction:
Hydrogenation reaction:
Two important gas-phase reactions also influence the overall gasification pro-
cess:
Water-gas shift reaction:
Methanation:
The final gas composition is highly dependent on the amount of oxygen and
steam admitted to the reactor and the time and temperature of reaction. For
sufficiently long reaction times chemical equilibrium is achieved and the prod-
ucts are essentially limited to the light gases CO, CO2, H2, and CH4 (and nitro-
gen if air was used as a source of oxygen).
Gasifiers are usually classified according to the method of contacting fuel and
gas. The three main types suitable for biomass gasification are illustrated in
Fig. 11.1 (Brown 2003). Updraft gasifiers are the simplest, consisting of little
more than a grate with chipped fuel admitted from above and insufficient air
for complete combustion entering from below. This countercurrent flow of fuel
and air results in producer gas with large quantities of undesirable tars. In
downdraft gasifiers, fuel and gas move in the same direction with contemporary
designs usually adding an arrangement of tuyeres that admit air or oxygen di-
rectly into a region known as the throat where combustion forms a bed of hot
char. This design assures that condensable gases released during pyrolysis are
forced to flow through the hot char bed, where tars are cracked. A disadvantage
is the need for tightly controlled fuel properties (particles sizes between 1 and
30 cm, low ash content, and moisture less than 30%) and an upper bound on
gasifier size of approximately 2 MW thermal. In fluidized bed gasifiers a gas
Table 11.1 Syngas composition from various kinds of gasifiers (Brown 2003).
11.3.2
Fermentation of Syngas
Fig. 11.2 Metabolic pathways for acetogenic following enzymic activities: 1, hydrogenase;
bacteria that synthesize acetate or butyrate 2, CO dehydrogenase; 3, formate dehydro-
during growth on C1 substrates or H2 and genase; 4, formyl-THF synthetase; 5, other
CO2. The symbols [CH3OH] and [HCOOH] THF enzymes; and 6, one or more enzymes
represent two oxidation states of C1 units required for the synthesis of acetyl-CoA from
bound to tetrahydrofolate (THF) carriers [CO] and a methyl-corrinoid (Zeikus et al.
whereas the chemical nature of [CO] remains 1985).
undetermined. Numbers indicate the
where Cell indicates C-moles (carbon equivalents) in the cell mass produced. At
least half of the CO must be oxidized to CO2 to provide enough electrons to re-
duce the remaining CO to acetate and cell mass. For CO2 and H2 substrate and
acetate production, the molar stoichiometry is:
Worden et al. (1991) noted that acetone, butanol, and ethanol were once pro-
duced commercially from glucose by use of a biphasic process consisting of an
acidogenic phase, which produced organic acids and H2, followed by a solvento-
genic phase, in which the organic acids were reduced to alcohols. In this pro-
cess acid production generates ATP but consumes no electrons while alcohol
production consumes electrons but produces no ATP. They propose a similar
scheme for syngas fermentation, with the first phase producing acetate and bu-
tyrate from CO (acidogenic phase) followed by alcohol production in a second
phase, with reducing equivalents to convert the acids to alcohols coming from
hydrogen in the syngas.
Fig. 11.5 Metabolic pathways to PHB reductase; (5), (6) enolases; (7) depoly-
synthesis and degradation (1) ketothiolase; merize; (8) D-(–)-3-hydroxybutyrate dehyro-
(2) NADPH-dependent acetoacetyl-CoA genase; (9) acetoacetyl-CoA synthetase;
reductase; (3) poly(3HB) synthase; (10) succinyl-CoA transferase; (11) citrate
(4) NADH-dependent acetoacetyl-CoA synthase (Babel et al. 2001).
Yields of PHB and cell biomass from a given substrate can be determined by
experiment or by calculation based on the known metabolic pathways involved.
Recovery of this water-insoluble polymer can proceed by one of several methods.
Solvent extraction gives high recovery but requires high capital investment and
large quantities of solvent. Non-solvent alternatives disintegrate cells by heat
shock followed by enzymatic and detergent digestive processes to solubilize the
non-PHA components (Anderson and Dawes 1990).
PHB is structurally similar to polypropylene and has similar crystallinity and
glass transition temperature. Their chemical properties are completely different,
however, and PHB is stiffer and more brittle than polypropylene. These physical
properties can be changed by forming copolymers from monomeric units of
PHB and PHV. Thus, a range of properties can be engineered from copolymers,
ranging from hard and brittle to soft and tough (Anderson and Dawes 1990).
Polyhydroxyalkanoates are attractive as biobased and biodegradable polymers.
Specialty applications of PHA include hydrophobic coatings, specialty elasto-
mers, medical implants, functionalized polymers for chromatography, microgra-
nules for use as binders in paints or in blends that incorporate latexes, and as
sources of chiral monomers (Kessler et al. 2001).
11.3 Gasification-Based Systems 239
11.3.3
Biorefinery Based on Syngas Fermentation
$ 2.60 kg–1, which is based on a US Department of Energy target price for this
fuel. The cost of producing PHA through syngas fermentation is estimated to
be $ 1.24 kg–1, which is in the range of many petroleum-derived polymers and
considerably cheaper than the production cost of PHA from glucose, which
may be as much as $ 5–7 kg–1. Until more complete information is available on
yields of H2 and PHA from syngas, however, this cost of production should be
considered an approximate estimate.
11.3.4
Enabling Technology
11.4
Fast Pyrolysis-based Systems
11.4.1
Fundamentals of Fast Pyrolysis
Fast pyrolysis is the rapid thermal decomposition of organic compounds in the ab-
sence of oxygen to produce liquids, gases, and char (Bridgwater and Peacocke
2000). The distribution of products depends on the biomass composition and
the rate and duration of heating. The yield of pyrolytic liquid, also known as
bio-oil, depends on pyrolysis conditions, including relatively short residence times
(0.5–2 s), moderate temperatures (400–600 8C), and rapid quenching at the end of
the process. Rapid quenching is essential if high-molecular-weight liquids are to
be condensed rather than further decomposed to low molecular weight gases. Typ-
ical product yields for two kinds of wood are given in Table 11.4.
Bio-oil from fast pyrolysis is a low viscosity, dark-brown fluid containing up to
15 to 20% water, which contrasts with the black, tarry liquid resulting from slow
pyrolysis or gasification (Piskorz et al. 1988). As indicated by Table 11.4, the bio-
oil is a mixture of many compounds although most can be classified as acids,
aldehydes, sugars, and furans, derived from the carbohydrate fraction, and phe-
nolic compounds, aromatic acids, and aldehydes, derived from the lignin frac-
tion. The liquid is highly oxygenated, approximating the elemental composition
of the feedstock, which makes it highly unstable.
Despite the high water content of bio-oil, no appreciable phase separation is
apparent (Scott et al. 1999). If an equal volume of water is added to the liquid,
however, the high-molecular-weight, largely aromatic compounds, are precipi-
tated. Because most of the aromatic compounds can be traced to the lignin con-
tent of the biomass, this precipitate is widely known as “pyrolytic lignin”.
242 11 Biomass Refineries Based on Hybrid Thermochemical-Biological Processing – An Overview
Table 11.4 Analysis of products from fast pyrolysis (Piskorz et al. 1988).
11.4.2
Fermentation of Bio-oils
gars at very high yields. Anhydrosugar is a sugar from which one or more mol-
ecules of water have been removed, resulting in the formation of an internal
acetal structure. The prevalent anhydrosugar from the fast pyrolysis of biomass
is 1,6-Anhydro-beta-d-glucose. The chemical structure of this compound, com-
monly known as levoglucosan, is illustrated in Fig. 11.9. A dimer of levogluco-
san, cellobiose, is also produced during fast pyrolysis, but in much lower con-
centrations. Anhydrosugar has prospects as a platform for chemical synthesis or
as a substrate for fermentation.
In studies on woody biomass with and without cation removal Piskorz et al.
(1997) found that levoglucosan increased from 3.04% in pyrolysis liquid from
untreated poplar wood to 30.42% in bio-oil from pretreated poplar wood. In-
creases were more modest for cellobiose.
Brown and his collaborators (2001) evaluated the effect of alkali removal on
the pyrolytic products of cornstover, an important herbaceous biomass. Three
pretreatments were evaluated: acid hydrolysis, washing in dilute nitric acid, and
washing in dilute nitric acid with addition of (NH4)2SO4 as a pyrolytic catalyst.
Although alkali compounds in plant materials are generally water-soluble, at-
tempts to remove alkali by water washing did not prove effective in this study.
On the other hand, all three acid treatments were able to substantially increase
the yield of anhydrosugars, as shown in Table 11.5. Acid hydrolysis of this anhy-
drosugar yielded 5% solutions of glucose and other simple sugars.
The resulting glucose solutions can be fermented, as demonstrated by Prosen
et al. (1993). However, the substrate derived from the bio-oil contains fermenta-
tion inhibitors that must be removed or neutralized by chemical or biological
methods. Chemical methods that have been evaluated on bio-oil-derived sub-
strate include solvent extraction, hydrophilic extraction, and adsorption extrac-
tion (Brown et al. 2000). The most effective of the chemical methods employed
activated carbon. As a less expensive alternative, Khiyami (2003) explored biolog-
ical treatments. He found that biofilms of Pseudomonas putida and Streptomyces
setonii were able to remove toxins from substrates derived from bio-oil.
As an alternative to hydrolyzing levoglucosan to glucose, several microorgan-
isms have been identified that directly ferment levoglucosan (Kitamura et al.
1991; Nakahara et al. 1994; Zhuang et al. 2001 a, b). This would eliminate the
hydrolysis step and probably improve the economics of producing fermentation
products from bio-oil.
246 11 Biomass Refineries Based on Hybrid Thermochemical-Biological Processing – An Overview
11.4.3
Biorefineries Based on Fast Pyrolysis
reactors; reduces the strong coupling between fuel processing and power genera-
tion typical of integrated power systems; and provides opportunities for recovering
value-added products. The proposed IPCC system is estimated to have a total pro-
ject cost of between $ 2300 and $ 2500 kW–1 based on a net combined cycle output
of 7655 kW. This cost does not include the additional equipment required for pro-
duction of value-added chemicals. This capital cost compares favorably with that of
conventional biomass power systems in this range, which cost around $ 2000 for
basic systems to over $ 3000 kW–1 for systems designed for higher efficiency and
reliability. The cost of electricity for the IPCC plant is projected to be similar to the
costs for conventional biomass power systems, approximately $ 0.02 kWh–1.
11.4.4
Enabling Technologies
When Scott and coworkers (1989) first proposed a pyrolytic route to cellulosic
ethanol, it was offered as a way of leapfrogging the barriers to fractionating bio-
mass. In a simple, rapid process, fast pyrolysis was able to separate lignocellu-
11.5 Outlook and Perspectives 249
lose into a pyrolytic lignin and a carbohydrate-rich aqueous phase. The process
introduces its own set of technical barriers that have yet to be fully solved, how-
ever.
Fast pyrolysis of pure cellulose produces, in principle, levoglucosan as its sole
reaction product. In practice, the presence of lignin and a variety of inorganic
compounds in fibrous biomass results in more than a hundred chemical prod-
ucts, many of which are not only unsuitable as a carbon and energy source for
fermentation but are actually toxic to the microorganisms to be cultivated. Im-
proved selectivity of pyrolytic reactions will be important to achieving high
yields of fermentable carbohydrate. Understanding reaction pathways will be
the key to success in this endeavor.
Like many of the pre-treatment processes used to facilitate fractionation by
acid or enzymatic hydrolysis, fast pyrolysis generates biological inhibitors that
must be removed before the bio-oil is used as a fermentation substrate. Meth-
ods that are more cost-effective than adsorption with activated carbon must be
developed.
Like any process for the production of ethanol from biomass, efficient use of
the hemicellulosic and lignin fractions of the lignocellulose will be essential to
economic viability. In principle, the pentoses released during demineralization
of the biomass can be fermented and the pyrolytic lignin can be used in the
production of process steam. Effective use of these coproducts will require more
attention to integrating the individual processes making up a system for pyrolyt-
ic production of cellulosic ethanol.
11.5
Outlook and Perspectives
References
Anderson, A. J. and E. A. Dawes (1990). “Oc- Brown, R. C., D. Radlein and J. Piskorz
currence, Metabolism, Metabolic Role, and (2001). Pretreatment Processes to Increase
Industrial Uses of Bacterial Polyhydroxy- Pyrolytic Yield of Levoglucosan from Her-
alkanoates.” Microbiological Reviews 54: baceous Feedstocks. Chemicals and Materi-
450–472. als from Renewable Resources: ACS Sympo-
Babel, W., J. Ackermann and U. Breuer sium Series No. 784. Washington, D.C.,
(2001). “Regulation, and Limits of the Syn- American Chemical Society: 123–132.
thesis of Poly(3HB) Physiology.” Advances Datar, R. P., R. M. Shenkman, B. G. Cateni,
in Biochemical Engineering/Biotechnology R. L. Huhnke and R. S. Lewis (2004). “Fer-
71. mentation of biomass-generated producer
Biomass Research and Development Techni- gas to ethanol.” Biotechnology and Bioengi-
cal Advisory Committee of the US Depart- neering 86(5): 587–594.
ments of Energy and Agriculture (2002). Daugaard, D. E. and R. C. Brown (2004). The
Roadmap for Biomass Technologies in the transport phase of pyrolytic oil exiting a fluid-
United States, Biomass Research and De- ized bed reactor. Science in Thermal and
velopment Technical Advisory Committee. Chemical Biomass Conversion Confer-
Bredwell, M. D., P. Srivastava and R. M. ence, Victoria, British Columbia, Canada.
Worden (1999). “Reactor design issues for Dispirito, A. (2004). Personal communica-
synthesis-gas fermentations.” Biotechnology tion.
Progress 15(5): 834–844. Evans, R. J. and T. A. Milne (1987). “Molecu-
Bridgwater, A. V. (1995). “The technical and lar characterization of the pyrolysis of bio-
economic feasibility of biomass gasifica- mass.” Energy and Fuels 1: 123–137.
tion for power generation.” Fuel 74: 631– Ferry, J. G. (1995). “CO dehydrogenase.” An-
653. nual Review of Microbiology 49: 305–333.
Bridgwater, A. V. and G. V. C. Peacocke Grethlein, A. J. and M. K. Jain (1993). “Bio-
(2000). “Fast pyrolysis processes for bio- processing of coal-derived synthesis gases
mass.” Renewable and Sustainable Energy by anaerobic bacteria.” Trends in Biotech-
Reviews 4: 1–73. nology 10: 418–423.
Brown, R. C. (2003). Biorenewable Resources: Grethlein, A. J., R. M. Worden, M. K. Jain
Engineering New Products from Agriculture. and R. Datta (1990). Applied Biochemistry
Ames, IA, Blackwell Publishing. and Biotechnology 24/25: 875.
Brown, R. C., T. Heindel, A. Dispirito and B. Kerby, R. L., P. W. Ludden and G. P. Roberts
Nikolau (2003). Production of biopolymers (1995). “Carbon monoxide-dependent
and hydrogen via syngas fermentation. Na- growth of Rhodospirillum rubrum.” J.
tional ACS Meeting, Anaheim, California. Bacteriology 177: 2241–2244.
Brown, R. C., A. L. Pometto, T. L. Peeples, M. Kessler, B., R. Weusthuis, B. Witholt and G.
Khiyami, B. Voss, J. W. Kim and S. Fischer Eggink (2001). “Production of Microbial
(2000). “Strategies for pyrolytic conversion Polyesters: Fermentation and Downstream
of herbaceous biomass to fermentation Processes.” Advances in Biochemical Engi-
products.” Proceedings of the Ninth Biennial neering/Biotechnology and Bioengineering
Bioenergy Conference, Buffalo, New York. 71: 159–182.
References 251
port NREL/TP-510-34929, Golden, CO, sis gas.” Applied Biochemistry and Biotech-
USA. nology 20/21: 781–797.
Steinbuchel, A. (2001). “Perspectives for bio- Wallen, L. L. and W. K. Rohwedder (1974).
technological production and utilization of “Poly-beta-hydroxyalkanoate from activated
biopolymers: metabolic engineering of sludge.” Environ Sci Technol 8: 576–579.
polyhydroxyalkanoate biosynthesis path- Worden, R. M., M. D. Bredwell and A. J.
ways as a successful example.” Macro- Grethlein (1997). Engineering Issues in
molecular Bioscience 1: 1–14. Synthesis-Gas Fermentations. Fuels and
Tobler, C. (1994). Genesis gives Birth to Chemicals from Biomass. Washington,
another company. Arkansas Business, D. C., American Chemical Society. ACS
February 28. Symposium Series No. 666: 320–336.
Uffen, R. L. (1983). “Metabolism of carbon Worden, R. M., A. J. Grethlein, M. K. Jain
monoxide by Rhodopseudomonas gelatinosa: and R. Datta (1991). “Production of buta-
cell growth and properties of the oxidation nol and ethanol from synthesis gas via fer-
system.” J. Bacteriology 155: 956–965. mentation.” Fuel 70(5): 615–619.
Vega, J. L., G. M. Antorrena and E. C. Clausen Worden, R. M., A. J. Grethlein, J. G. Zeikus
(1989 a). “Study of gaseous substrate fer- and R. Datta (1989). Applied Biochemistry
mentations: Carbon monoxide conversion and Biotechnology 20/21: 687.
to acetate. 2. Continuous culture.” Biotech- Zeikus, J. G., R. Kerby and J. A. Krzycki
nology and Bioengineering 34: 785–793. (1985). “Single-carbon chemistry of aceto-
Vega, J. L., E. C. Clausen and J. L. Gaddy genic and methanogenic bacteria.” Science
(1989 b). “Study of gaseous substrate fer- 227: 1167–1173.
mentations: Carbon monoxide conversion Zhuang, X. L., H. X. Zhang and J. J. Tang
to acetate. 1. Batch culture.” Biotechnology (2001 a). “Levoglucosan kinase involved in
and Bioengineering 34(6): 774–784. citric acid fermentation by Aspergillus ni-
Vega, J. L., V. L. Holmberg, E. C. Clausen ger CBX-209 using levoglucosan as sole
and J. L. Gaddy (1989 c). “Fermentation pa- carbon and energy source.” Biomass and
rameters of peptostreptococcus-productus Bioenergy 21: 53–60.
on gaseous substrates (CO, H2/CO2).” Ar- Zhuang, X. L., H. X. Zhang, J. Z. Yang and
chives of Microbiology 151(1): 65–70. H. Y. Qi (2001 b). “Preparation of levoglu-
Vega, J. L., S. Prieto, B. B. Elmore, E. C. cosan by pyrolysis of cellulose and its cit-
Clausen and J. L. Gaddy (1989 d). “The bio- ric acid fermentation.” Bioresource Technol-
logical production of ethanol from synthe- ogy 79(1): 63–66.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
253
Green Biorefineries
12
The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Stefan Kromus, Birgit Kamm, Michael Kamm, Paul Fowler,
and Michael Narodoslawsky
12.1
Introduction
Green biorefineries are integrated technologies and technology systems for pro-
duction of materials and energy processing of green plants and parts of green
plants. Above all, green biorefinery technologies are based on traditional tech-
nologies of green forage preservation, leaf-protein extraction, chlorophyll pro-
duction, and modern biotechnological and chemical conversion methods.
The main raw material of green biorefineries are green plants, for example
grass, alfalfa, and immature (green) grain or green plant parts, for example
leaves. Green plant parts are a virtually inexhaustible raw material reservoir,
which is fast-growing, available world-wide, and may have ecological advantages.
Considering alfalfa alone, 32 million hectares are currently cultivated and con-
verted into green pellets or forage flour worldwide.
By means of primary photosynthesis green C3 plants can yield up to 20 tons
dry matter with up to four tons of proteins in temperate climates each year. C4
plants in tropical zones can, however, produce up to 80 tons dry matter with six
tons of proteins per hectare per year. Green plants are, moreover, rich in carbo-
hydrates, proteins, lipids, lignin, and a group of secondary plant substances and
phytochemicals. Green plants and green plant parts may therefore be seen as a
chemical plant with a huge potential. In comparison with other vegetable bio-
mass green plants are characterized by a high content of aqueous cell juice with
carbohydrates of low molecular weight, a large amount of enzymes (proteins)
for photosynthesis and a relatively low content of lignin in the cell walls.
For these reasons all technological concepts of green biorefineries include the
separation of the cell juice from the plant framework. Both fractions, the cell
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
254 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
juice and the cellulose-containing leaf cells are subjected to different biotechno-
logical and physicochemical conversion methods.
12.2
Historical Outline
12.2.1
The Inceptions
The green parts of plants have been used by the human being for ages. Primar-
ily ruminants use green plants as fodder. The relevance of green crop cultiva-
tion was already apparent from the occupation of the sons of Adam and Eve,
Cain and Abel – Abel became a shepherd, Cain a farmer [1]. The direct use of
green plants in the diet of humans is ancient. We are able to distinguish be-
tween use as nutrition or for salvation or as a natural stimulant. In Europe the
consumption of spinach (Spinacia oleracea), stinging-nettle (Urtica), sorrels (Ru-
mex acetosa), curly kale (Brassica oleraceae var. Sabellica), and leek (Allium ampe-
lobrasum) is very common.
The chemical and biochemical scientific exploration of green plant leaves can
be traced back to the 18th century. The French chemists G. F. and H. M. Roulle
reported obtaining protein extracts from alfalfa leaves in 1773. Hillaire Marin
Roulle in particular, a demonstrator at the royal garden in Paris since 1770,
proved that the juices obtained by pressing the vegetable alfalfa contain a sub-
stance which coagulated when heated into a “cheesy” substance similar to ani-
mal material. The new coagulate, found by Roulle in the heated juice obtained
by pressing different plants, was therefore called “vegato-animale” substance (to-
day it is called leaf protein) [2].
Mild warming yielded a green colored fraction, further heating delivered an
almost colorless precipitate. Chemical analysis of the colorless substance re-
vealed it contained a larger amount of that new substance than the green coagu-
late. Also, by extraction of the green pigments with alcohol the green precipitate
could be removed [2]. It is impressive that key procedures of modern protein
separation of green biomass in green biorefineries were researched as early as
1773 [3–7]. The functional characteristic of thermal coagulation of proteins was,
moreover, the first criterion for later definition of proteins as a class of sub-
stance [3].
12.2.2
First Production of Leaf Protein Concentrate
In the 20th century research on leaf protein concentrate (LPC) focused on use
of the proteins for human nutrition [4–6], because of the widespread availability,
high nutritional value, and high protein productivity in green plants, with its
valuable spectrum of essential amino acids and the intensive growth of green
12.2 Historical Outline 255
12.2.3
First Production of Leaf Dyes
Chlorophylls, often termed the “pigments of life”, are green colored macrocyclic
pigments which are the primary photosynthetic pigments in nature. The term
chlorophyll, coined by Berzelius in 1838, is derived from Greek roots and indi-
cates the green of leaves [24]. In fact, as green pigments they are responsible
for the primary biochemical energy generation in nature and give the only indi-
cations of life on earth visible from outer space. Reduction of the chlorophyll
(leaf green) gives the xanthophylls (leaf yellow) and carotenes that are not dis-
solved and remain in the leaf, resulting in showy yellow and orange tinges. The
red color pigments are derived from anthocyan, created by metabolic alteration
of the leaves [25].
Although scientists had previously studied the green plant pigment it was
only in 1913 that the first significant research on its structure, separation, and
properties was reported. This work, which won the 1915 Nobel Prize for the
German chemist Willstätter, serves as the basis for subsequent production of
chlorophyll [26, 27].
In the United States, commercial production of chlorophyll and carotene by ex-
traction from alfalfa leaf meal has conducted since 1930 [28, 29]. Chlorophyll, in
various forms, was reported to be present in 1000 products that consumed 10 000
pounds of the green material per month in 1952, with a market value of 50 Million
USD [30]. For example, Strong, Cobb and Company obtained 0.5 ton of chloro-
phyll per day from alfalfa in 1952. The water-soluble chlorophyll, or chlorophyllin,
found use as a deodorizing agent in toothpastes, soaps, mouthwashes, shampoos,
chewing gums, candies, deodorants, and pharmaceuticals [31].
258 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Since 1990 chlorophyll has also been used for conversion of light energy into
electric energy. Electrochemical solar cells, e.g. the Graetzel cell a TiO2–chloro-
phyll-SnO2 solar cell, use organic dyes (not a semiconductor material), for ex-
ample the leaf dye chlorophyll, for absorption of light [32].
12.3
Green Biorefinery Raw Materials
12.3.1
Raw Materials
The major raw material of green biorefineries is “green biomass”, including the
large group of green plant materials (green grass from meadows, willow, exten-
sive willow management, other natural resources), wild fruit and crops, alfalfa
and clover, and immature cereals and plant shoots. The green plant material
contains complex natural and valuable materials in the form of carbohydrates,
proteins, fibers, fragrances, dyes, fats, hormones, amino acids, enzymes, and
other important substances [5, 7, 33, 34].
Ecologically friendly agriculture is based on primary production by photo-
synthesis in green plants during the whole growth season. During a vegetation
period successive harvest and re-growth of one and the same crop can give a
maximum yield of dry matter and protein per area. Green grasses and imma-
ture cereals are excellent for this purpose. Especially, grasses can be grown on
most types of soil in most types of climate, on both normal agricultural land
and marginal land. Thus C3 species in temperate climates can yield up to 20
tonnes of dry matter and 4 tons of protein per ha (hectare = 10 000 m2) per year
whereas C4 species in tropical climates can produce 80 tonnes of dry matter
and 6 tonnes of protein [33, 34].
The yield of dry matter and protein from grass and the quality of the leaf pro-
tein concentrate (LPC) obtained is affected by the type of photosynthesis [35].
Leaf anatomy and cell structure are different for the two types of plant adapted
to different climates. The C4 species have a more efficient carbon dioxide fixa-
tion mechanism and are grown on soils poor in nitrogen. Thus C4 species have
a very high dry-matter production per soil area, but have a low protein content
of the dry matter. The C3 species lose fixed carbon dioxide by a process called
photorespiration. Thus C3 plants produce less dry matter per unit area. In C3
species more leaf cells are rich in protein (FI protein/rubisco protein). There-
fore, a relatively high proportion of the dry matter of C3 species consists of pro-
tein. Subsequently, LPC from C3 species is rich in protein. Both temperate
grass species, including green cereals [34, 35] and tropical grasses [36], have
been investigated for LPC production (Table 12.1).
The second important raw material source is the green harvesting residue
material from agricultural cultivated crops. In particular the vegetables of im-
portance are those with green foliage. This includes, e.g., not insignificant
12.3 Green Biorefinery Raw Materials 259
amounts of sugar beet leaves (sugar beet for the sugar industry), hemp scrapes
and leaves (hemp for fiber production), residues from flax processing, and resi-
dues from the fresh vegetable production.
Further potential refinery raw materials are the little standardized juice-rich
waste biomass. This should contain moisture and mainly natural and valuable
materials or have a substantial conversion grade. According to coupling effects
of material and energy use, the constitution can strongly vary. Such waste bio-
mass is not yet standardized, but is a renewable natural waste resource that
must be managed. Such biomass can be residues from plant production (mixed
and ripe harvest residuals), potato juice, hydroxycarboxylic acid-rich waste as si-
lage seepage, juices from the canned food industry, or residues from the sugar
industry or animal production.
The fourth large group is the little standardized dried biomass and waste bio-
mass. These often contain a large amount of plant cellulose and will therefore
be supplied as raw material to press-cake-using production lines. This can be re-
sidual straw, hay, and all kinds of dried foliage (e.g. maize hay). Residues from
in-plant waste paper and wood, e.g. for energy production or cardboard produc-
tion, are also included in this category. This group also includes modern con-
cepts of dry crop fractionation, for example immature cereals [37].
It should be mentioned that transitions between raw material types will and
should be fluid [38].
12.3.2
Availability of Grassland Feedstocks for Large-scale Green Biorefineries
Country Amount dry matter (t a–1) Country Amount dry matter (t a–1)
fore be found, for example the supply of raw material for the bio-industry. This
trend is apparent throughout Europe [40].
Because of its ability to fix nitrogen from the air and enrich the soil with this
element, alfalfa is the most important forage crop in the world, cultivated on ap-
proximately 32 million hectares. The plant contains the protein rubisco as ap-
proximately 20% of the total dry matter [41].
Green forage drying plants, especially, offer a very good possibility for use in
biorefinery systems. These plants can be seen as agro–industrial knots in grass-
land farming. More than 300 green forage drying plants are used to produce
over 5 Mio tons of dried pellets and powder (Table 12.2) [42].
In the USA the Alfalfa New Products Initiative (ANPI) has the objective of ex-
tending the cultivation and utilization of alfalfa. The ANPI consists of five
states: North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan.
Prominent technology in this context is dehydration and fractionation (dry or
wet) [43].
12.3.3
Key Components of Green and Forage Grasses
The research literature on forage grasses is mainly concerned with their nutri-
tive aspects as fodder grass, hay, or silage. From a biochemical perspective the
composition of forage grasses is well described. Thus, a comprehensive inven-
tory of forage grass chemical/material constituents is available in the literature.
The components can be conveniently categorized according to their location
within the grass, either as a cell wall constituent or as a component within the
cell.
effect on the digestibility of the hemicellulose moiety. In this study, ten varieties
of temperate grass were studied by harvesting at five stages of maturity, taking
only a first cut. The lignin and hemicellulose content were measured, with the
hemicellulose being further fractionated into linear and branched hemicellulose
by iodine treatment. The hemicelluloses were analyzed for the neutral sugars l-
arabinose, d-xylose, d-galactose and d-glucose. The results are shown in Ta-
ble 12.5.
Lignin–carbohydrate complexes from Lolium perenne contained high propor-
tions of d-glucose residues (ca 50%). Leaf tissue complexes had the highest d-
glucose content, whereas stem and leaf sheath were very similar. The other neu-
tral sugar residues present in these complexes were mainly l-arabinose and d-
xylose. The polysaccharide components of the lignin-hemicellulose complexes
contained mainly d-xylose (63–77%) and l-arabinose (19–28%) [50].
Forage grass lignin was more extensively solubilized by acid detergent than
forage legume lignin. Forage plant lignins were characterized by guaiacyl–syrin-
gyl lignin with p-hydroxyphenylpropane units. The number of ferulic acid cross-
linkages in the cell wall matrices of forage grasses increased with plant matura-
tion [51].
Two classes of phenolic–carbohydrate complexes were purified from the water-
soluble products obtained from digestion of Lolium perenne cell walls with a cellu-
lase preparation [52]. They contained d-glucose, d-xylose, l-arabinose, d- galactose,
and d-mannose in the ratios 3.6 : 10 : 6.3 : 1.4 : 2.3 and 5.3 : 10 : 3.0 : 1.1 : 2.1, respec-
tively. The complexes were based on (1 ? 4)-b-d-xylan chains to which were
attached residues of l-arabinofuranose and d-galactopyranose. Mixed linkage
(1 ? 3),(1 ? 4)-b-d-glucan chains also seemed to be integral components of these
complexes.
The principle outcomes of these studies were:
1. The quantities of hemicellulose increased with increasing maturity with the
increase being larger in stem tissue compared with leaf tissue. For example,
the hemicellulose content of Lolium perenne leaf tissue increased from 7.6 to
Leaf Stem
Cut no. 1 2 3 4 5 1 2 3 4 5
21.1% of dry matter over the study period. The d-xylose content of the linear
hemicellulose increased concomitantly from 69 to 85%.
2. The hemicellulose content of stem tissue increased from 9.9 to 29.1% with
the linear hemicellulose increasing from 74 to 91%.
3. The linearity of hemicelluloses tended to increase with crop age.
4. Higher lignin content was associated with hemicellulose of a higher linear:
branched ratio.
5. Hemicellulose also had higher d-xylose : l-arabinose ratios.
In summary:
1. Time of harvesting has a significant effect on the sugar composition.
2. Hemicellulose sugars increase during the growth season.
3. Stem tissue contains greater amounts of hemicellulose (xylans) than leaf tis-
sue.
4. Digestibility of grasses decreases with age, which may affect yields of fermen-
tation-derived products such as xylitol and lactic acid.
Pectin Substances Extraction of mesophyll cell walls from the leaves of Lolium per-
enne afforded 25 mg of a uronic acid polymer per gram of material [53]. The poly-
mer was identified as a 1,4-linked homogalacturonan, essentially free from neutral
sugar residues, with a low degree of acetylation (3.6%) and methyl esterification
(3.3%). Thus, the pectin was similar to the pectins of dicotyledons but the amounts
found were substantially lower than in most dicotyledonous plants. On that basis
there seems little scope for industrial end uses of forage grass pectins.
Sugars d-Glucose, d-fructose, d-sucrose, and fructans are the main nonstruc-
tural carbohydrates in Lolium perenne tissues [55]. The d-glucose, d-fructose, d-
sucrose, and d-xylose, d-mannitol, d-sorbitol, glycerol, and d-maltose content of
Dactylis glomerata, Lolium perenne, and Festuca pratensis cut three times on differ-
ent dates without interim harvesting have been recorded [56]. The results are re-
ported in Table 12.6. Significant findings were:
266 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Lolium perenne
June 6 3.11 5.43 0.00 0.05 0.05 0.24 0.15 0.10 9.12 27.0
June 21 3.82 4.62 0.05 0.00 0.00 0.24 0.14 0.14 9.02 16.1
July 6 2.89 3.92 0.08 0.04 0.04 0.20 0.12 0.16 7.45 18.1
Aug 6 4.36 6.25 0.26 0.13 0.00 0.46 0.26 0.26 11.98 9.2
Aug 21 2.43 5.10 0.23 0.08 0.00 0.32 0.00 0.16 8.32 9.8
Sep 3 1.46 1.87 0.11 0.00 0.00 0.19 0.11 0.08 3.83 7.8
Sep 30 5.00 7.47 0.14 0.07 0.00 0.40 0.27 0.20 13.53 16.0
Festuca pratensis
June 6 2.38 4.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.24 1.42 0.10 9.04 13.8
June 21 2.93 3.48 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.19 0.12 0.12 6.85 9.0
July 6 2.13 3.33 0.07 0.00 0.00 0.18 0.00 0.21 5.95 12.5
Aug 6 2.07 3.30 0.15 0.25 0.00 0.20 0.30 0.40 6.66 4.9
Aug 21 1.74 2.8 1 0.07 0.07 0.00 0.34 0.00 0.20 5.22 7.6
Sep 3 1.53 0.47 1.80 0.19 0.12 0.19 0.19 0.27 4.78 6.6
Sep 30 4.56 6.56 0.13 0.13 0.06 0.44 0.19 0.19 12.25 10.3
In analogous work, Fales and colleagues [57] reported results for stems of Festu-
ca arundinacea. The stems were extracted with 95% ethanol and water to afford
d-glucose, d-fructose, d-sucrose, and fructans. The fructan extract was hydro-
lyzed with sulfuric acid and shown to contain d-glucose and d-fructose. A hemi-
cellulose fraction was hydrolyzed and found to contain d-xylose, l-arabinose and
small amounts of d-glucose.
12.3 Green Biorefinery Raw Materials 267
Fructans In grasses, fructan reserves are mobilized from vegetative plant parts
during seasonal growth, after defoliation during grazing. In expanding leaves,
fructans are accumulated in cells of the elongation zone [58]. Fructan structures
have been characterized in Lolium perenne as belonging to essentially three se-
ries: the inulin series, the inulin neoseries, and the levan neoseries [59]. Festuca
arundinacea contains an inulin and neokestose based series of oligosaccharides
[60].
Fructans are an important class of carbohydrate of substantial biotechnologi-
cal importance [61]. First, they are a potential source of d-fructose, for which
there is a growing market in the food industry as a sweetener. The use of fruc-
tans has been reviewed by Fuchs [62]. Fructans are mainly used in the food sec-
tor. More pertinently, fructans could be chemical feedstocks from which a vari-
ety of chemicals can be produced. Hydrolysis to d-fructose and subsequent de-
hydration leads to hydroxymethyl furfural which, like lactic acid, is regarded as
key chemical intermediate for chemistry based on renewable raw materials.
Similarly, hydrolysis of inulin to d-fructose followed by catalytic hydrogenation
yields d-mannitol/d-sorbitol mixtures from which d-mannitol can be easily crys-
tallized. d-Mannitol, like xylitol, is a valuable, non-cariogenic low-calorie sweet-
ener. Other chemicals that could be derived from fructans include ethanol,
other organic solvents, and chemicals such as furans [63].
Inulin is the best known sub-class of the fructans. Inulin is colorless and
odorless, and has a pleasant slightly sweet taste; it is moderately soluble in
water and acts as a gel-forming agent at concentrations > 30%; it is also a foam
stabilizer and texturing agent. Its calorific value is 4 kJ g–1, but it acts as dietary
fiber. It suppresses putrefying bacteria and selectively supports bifidobacteria
and lactobacilli in the colon. In food applications its main functions are to re-
place fat and sugar, to enrich with dietary fiber, to activate bifidobacteria, and to
reduce cariogenicity. It is classified as a foodstuff [64].
Amino Acids The amino acid composition of Festuca pratensis, Dactylis glomera-
ta and Lolium perenne has been studied. There were no significant differences
between the species. As the grasses aged, amounts of aspartic acid, glutamic
acid, alanine, tyrosine, and phenylalanine decreased and amounts of threonine,
serine, and proline increased. Lysine, histidine, arginine, glycine, valine, methio-
nine, isoleucine, and leucine did not change with plant age nor did the total
amino acid content [65].
In amino acid analysis of six crops and the corresponding juice, the amino
acid composition of the juice deviated only slightly from that of the crop but
the amounts of glutamic acid and aspartic acids were somewhat higher and cor-
respondingly the amounts of other amino acids, particularly arginine, glycine,
alanine, tyrosine, and phenylalanine were somewhat lower [66].
Degradation of protein and amino acids in juice extracted from ryegrass can
be reduced by adding hydrochloric acid. For complete preservation, the pH
must be less than 3. Heating to 80 8C also has a preservative effect [67].
268 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Minerals The dry matter of extracted juice of Lolium perenne has a high
mineral content [66] that may be exploitable as plant fertilizer.
Alkaloids Perloline, perlolidine, and loline are alkaloids of the Lolium spp. The
toxicity of lolium species is because of to a symbiotic fungal infection of the
plants [79].
12.4 Green Biorefinery Concept 269
Antifreeze Protein A plant antifreeze protein from Lolium perenne has been re-
ported [80]. Present in organisms enduring freezing environments, antifreeze pro-
teins have the ability to inhibit damaging ice-crystal growth. The macromolecular
antifreeze protein present in Lolium perenne has superior ice recrystallization inhi-
bition activity compared with fish and insect antifreeze proteins [81].
12.4
Green Biorefinery Concept
12.4.1
Fundamentals and Status Quo
The technical specifications of the product and, especially, its high xanthophyll
content make it very useful in poultry farming for egg yolk and broilers (Ta-
ble 12.7) [91].
12.4 Green Biorefinery Concept 271
PX 1 1977 1300 T 50% crude protein and 1.000 ppm of total xanthophylls
PX 1 1980 6200 T 50% crude protein and 1.000 ppm of total xanthophylls
PX Super 1997 13000 T 52% crude protein and 1.250 ppm of total xanthophylls
12.4.2
Wet Fractionation and Primary Refinery
The special first feature of the green biorefinery is the wet fractionation of
green biomass (Fig. 12.3 A).
This is also called first fractionation step or primary refinery step. (It includes,
for example, the harvest, fractionation, conservation, and storage of the primary
fraction.) Here, fresh harvest and waste goods are treated. Thus, the plant com-
pounds are mostly unadulterated; the green goods should, in any case, be
treated immediately, however. This processing step, usually performed by means
of an industrial press, produces a fiber-rich, water-insoluble, solid material,
press cake (PC), and a nutrient-rich green juice (GJ) or brown juice (BJ). The
wet fractionation is based on soft separation of water-soluble and water-insoluble
components of the green biomass.
The silage wet-fractionation is a form of the primary refinery technology
(Fig. 12.3 C). The green goods are conserved by organic acids or fermentation
processes before treatment by the procedure shown. Treatment of silage from
green resources has many advantages (decentralized raw material preparation,
simple and low price conservation and storage, reasonable whole year operation
of the biorefinery, etc.) [92]. The end products of silage are different from that
of the substances in the green juice, because silage fermentation degrades the
cell walls and modifies or converts substances because of the biotechnological
processes involved.
The so called “decomposition” methods are the third category of primary refin-
ery technology (Fig. 12.3 B). “Decomposition” methods are mainly applied to the
humid or dry whole plant. The processes work with enzymatic, fermentative, hy-
drolytic, chemical, thermal, or combined thermal and fractionation methods. The
strength (depth of operation) of the decomposition varies, and ranges from low
(enzymatic, fermentative) to high intensity (chemical, hydrolytic). For every step
classification is needed to check if it belongs to green biorefinery technology. A
high single yield of products can be achieved if the complete plant decomposition
occurs at the primary refinery step (e.g. saccharification, which increases the total
amount of sugars in the raw charge). But these procedures reduce the level of na-
tive product diversity. Nevertheless decomposition methods have been regarded as
feasible technologically and economically. This is also true for the secondary prod-
272 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Fig. 12.3 The green biorefinery – primary refinery. Methods for fractionation of green crops [7].
uct lines. Problems with the green biorefinery system may be solved by further
development of new biotechnological decomposition methods.
All primary fractionations after the secondary refinery steps contain processes
for substantial and energy utilization of the fractionation products. The kind
and number of the secondary fractionation steps are determined by the compo-
sition and energy potential of the input green biomass and waste biomass, the
type of technology, and the marketability of potential products of the refinery.
The company Avebe operates a pilot plant at Veendam (The Netherlands) and
has formed a consortium with other partners to explore the potential of grass to
supply a range of fiber, protein, and nutraceutical products. The current pilot
plant processes 3 tons of fresh grass per hour. Depending on the outcome, a
full-scale (200 tons per hour, 50 000 tons per year) factory may be commis-
sioned. The intended full-scale plant requires 1000 ha per annum of mixed
grass sources harvested from a radius of up to 50 km [93].
12.5 Processes and Products 273
12.5
Processes and Products
The kind and number of products from a green biorefinery is nearly unlimited,
if the fractal character of the biosynthesis and biochemistry of green plant mate-
rials is considered [96]. Characterization of a plant by a new analytical method
usually discovers, in addition to the main components, innumerable new side
products. Not all substances have been discovered and technologically obtained
from natural products even from plants with great trading importance, e.g. al-
falfa [97]. For the green biorefinery the main products, side-products and im-
purities are of interest [98]. Economic aspects reduce the diversity of products of
interest, however. Soft technology such as biotechnology is used to reduce the
complex molecules of natural materials. Nevertheless, the scientific field of eco-
technology develops new methods, preferring a reduction of technological
strength (depth of operation). This can be done by using, e.g., biodiversity be-
fore molecular modification or applying less intensive methods, etc. [99].
12.5.1
The Juice Fraction
tion, centrifugation, and gel filtration into a leaf nutrient concentrate (LNC) and
a brown juice (BJ). The LNC consists of a mixture of chloroplast and other orga-
nell membranes plus denatured soluble plant-cell proteins. The composition of
a LNC is: true protein (60–70%); lipid (especially palmitic acid, linoleic acid,
and linolenic acid) (20–30%), starch (5–10%), ash (1–10%), carotenoide/polyene
dyes: b-carotene (1–2 g kg–1), and xanthophyll [6, 100]. The LNC is mainly used
for nonruminant feed to enhance the color (red b-carotene, or lutein) of chicken
skin or egg yolk. It also produces tender meat in chickens, ducks, and pigs.
Feeding pigs with LNC results in pork with an increased content of healthy
oleic and linoleic fatty acids in the fat [101].
Sugars (in Particular Glucose, Fructose, and Fructans) GJ and BJ contains valu-
able special sugars and have highly valuable and sometimes expensive applica-
tions. Other sugars in GJ are erythrose, rhamnose, xylose, galactose, mannose,
mannitol, maltose, and derivatives, for example myoinositol and glycerin. Before
these compounds are fermented they are studied with regard to their potential
characterization, and isolation [98, 102].
Dyes and Vitamins Green leaf nutrient concentrate (GLNC) enriched in b-caro-
tene may have anti-cancer effects. b-Carotene (provitamin A) and xanthophyll
are used in cosmetic drugs and as food, textiles, and toy-coloring agents (see
also chlorophyll) [28, 29, 31]. Green juice contains further vitamins, for example
vitamin B1, vitamin B2, and vitamin E [103].
Fatty Acids GLNC is also rich in oleic and linoleic fatty acids, especially palmit-
ic acid, linoleic acid, and linolenic acid. The lipids provide good health value.
The lipids can be separated by steam distillation. They are also of interest to the
cosmetic industry [100].
Proteins The proteins in the green juice can be fractionated by advanced tech-
nology, in a second step, into a green leaf nutrient concentrate GLNC. The
main protein is the enzyme ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase,
also known as fraction-I (F-I) protein (rubisco EC 4.1.1.39). In alfalfa leaves pro-
teins account for 30 to 70% of total nitrogen, depending on the physiological
stage or genotype [106]. Rubisco has a molecular weight (MW) between 500 000
and 600 000 Daltons and is composed of eight large and eight small subunits
with MW of approximately 55 000 and 12 500, respectively. The sedimentation
coefficient is close to 18.5 S. Rubisco has a compact, tightly folded three-dimen-
sional structure typical of globular proteins. Because of its amino acid composi-
tion Rubisco is mildly acidic and is negatively charged at neutral pH (isoelectric
12.5 Processes and Products 275
point pH 4.4–4.7) [107]. It also has a relatively high average hydrophobic value
of 1275 cal/residue, calculated according to Bigelow [108]. Native Rubisco from
alfalfa contains 90 sulfhydryl groups, of which eight are “free” (one per proto-
mer), 36 are exposed after denaturation by SDS, and 46 are involved in the for-
mation of disulfide bonds within the Rubisco subunits [109]. The denaturation
temperature of alfalfa rubisco varies between 70 (pH 7.5) and 61 8C (pH 10.3)
[110]. More details about Rubisco are available in reviews [106, 111].
Fraction-II protein consists of a mixture of proteins originating from the
chloroplasts and cytoplasm with molecular weights from 10 000 to 300 000 Dal-
tons and sedimentation constants from 4 S to 10 S [112]. On the basis of amino
acid composition, Rubisco and the green and white fraction of leaf proteins are
regarded as hydrophobic (Table 12.8).
The F I protein can be used in medical diets to enhance recovery from brain
damage, where a high calorie/high protein diet is needed. People with kidney
problems can easily digest F I protein with no negative effects on body metabo-
lism. Both F I and F II proteins are advocated for solid foods and drinks as a
supplement. The nutritive value and functional properties of LNC and white
leaf protein isolated for incorporation in human diets have been reviewed [68,
69, 115–118].
12.5.2
GJ Drinks/Alternative Life
Young green cereal leaves are used for production of health food grass juices and
cosmetics. Dried, finely ground, and resolved young leaves are used as “green tea”
and added to health-food drinks [119, 120]. Those familiar with folk medicine also
know much about the effects of wild mixed grasses, herbs, and herb teas [97].
276 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Property Value
The silage juice (Fig. 12.3 C) contains a relatively high concentration of lactic
acid, amino acids, sugars, and inorganic salts. Protein and peptide degradation
occurs during ensiling. In silage juices only 5 to 10% of the crude proteins (or-
ganic nitrogen compounds) are peptides > 1.2 kD (*15 amino acids). At least
18 amino acids are found in the juice with a total amino acid content of
26.13 g L–1. Among the most important are alanine, leucine, lysine, GABA (c-
aminobutyric acid), aspartic acid, and isoleucine (all in the l form) [122, 123]
(Table 12.9).
12.5.3
Ingredients and Specialities
12.5.3.1 Proteins/Polysaccharides
The polysaccharide and protein components of Festuca spp cell walls have been
transformed into emulsifiers by extraction and treatment with xylan-hydrolyzing
enzyme preparations. The emulsifiers are useful, for example, for food, cos-
metics, pharmaceuticals, and industrial chemicals applications [125].
12.5.3.3 Antifeedants
Festuca arundinacea and Lolium perenne can become infected with fungal endo-
phytes (Neotyphodium spp). The symbiosis between plant and fungus leads to
the synthesis of alkaloids that have been shown to be either toxic or act as feed-
ing detergents against insect pests. Alkaloid production/accumulation in Festuca
arundinacea and Lolium perenne is enhanced by reduced mowing frequency
[132]. Such alkaloids may have a role as insecticides for agrochemical use [104,
105] or in the clinic as a result of their pharmacology [79].
12.5.3.4 Silica
A process has been described for manufacture of high-purity amorphous silica
from biogenic materials [127]. Rice hulls are given as the example. The hulls
are finely divided, screened, subjected to a surfactant wash, rinsed, and soaked
in water to accelerate and enhance penetration of an oxidizing solution. The oxi-
dizing solution removes organic compounds, and volatile impurities are re-
moved by heated oxidation to leave silica. The remaining silica may be rinsed
with water, acid solution, or other solution to remove even trace impurities. At
278 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
the end of the process, a fine white amorphous silica of extremely high purity
is produced.
12.5.3.7 Zeolites
Artificial zeolites are manufactured by heating a mixture of grass husks and
plants with aqueous alkali solutions to elute silicic components. These are
mixed with aluminum-enriching agents and treated under heat and pressure.
The zeolites have high cation-exchange properties and are be useful as fertiliz-
ers [131].
12.5.4
The Press-Cake (Fiber) Fraction
The products and product groups described below are technologically possible
after fractionation in accordance with Fig. 12.3 A and C. Use of the PC as feed
(silage, bale press food, green pellets) is well known [133]. Furthermore, extrac-
tion of plant dyes (chlorophyll, carotenes, xanthophyll) [25, 28] and applications
in the food and candle industry [31], in environmental analysis [134] or, after re-
fining, in cosmetics, medicine, biochemistry [135], electronics (nematic liquid
crystals) [136], and photovoltaics (organic dyes [32]) have also been described in
the literature.
Because of the structural similarity of chlorophyll and blood hemoglobin one
can expect interesting developments in the field of plant dyes and colorants.
The resulting fraction will, substantially, be thermally treated analogous to unex-
12.5 Processes and Products 279
tracted PC. The suitability (and applicability) as feed depends mainly on the cor-
responding extraction compounds and has to be tested.
The PC fraction can be separated by analogy with wood raw materials into its
main components (Fig. 12.4). On the one hand, this green plant fractionation
does not seem to make much economic sense today (because of wood competi-
tion). There are, on the other hand, interesting applications for special vegetable
celluloses, hemicelluloses, and lignin. The “green plant” polyoses (hemicellu-
loses) are nutrient-physiologically valuable [137]. Furthermore, they can be used
(similarly to plant rubber) as protecting colloids, emulsifiers in cosmetics, thick-
eners in the food industry [138 a], adhesives, additives in the pulp and paper in-
dustry, stabilizers for environmentally friendly inks and dyes [138 b], or as thick-
eners for crude oil drilling [139].
Lignin is one component of press cake. Isolated lignin can be used as a dis-
persant in the food industry, as stabilizer for foams and bitumen, or as an envi-
ronmental friendly adhesive [140–142].
280 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
12.5.4.1 Fibers
Non-wood fibers have been used to manufacture all kinds of paper, including
printing, writing, and packaging. Such feedstock is expected to play an impor-
tant role in improving the sustainability of the pulp and paper industry [144],
by enabling more rational utilization of forest resources. Non-wood fiber pulps
can be used effectively in combination with recycled papers, improving many of
their attributes and enabling overall cost reduction because of a decrease in the
use of starch [145].
Downstream Processing of the Grass Fiber Fraction (PC) The biorefinery primary
process generates a fibrous press cake (Fig. 12.3 A and C). This fraction can
either be further processed while wet – by applying technology used in the pulp
und paper industry – or it can be dried. After mechanical fractionation grass
and silage press cake particles are typically less than 3 cm in length. The struc-
ture of grass stems and leaves is mostly eliminated and the bulk has a fibrous
appearance.
Basic Properties of Grass Fibers Sfiligoj et al. [150] evaluated the fundamental
physical properties of press cake fibers (from Ryegrass (Lolium hybridum), wheat
(Triticum aestivum L.), red clover (Trifolium pratense), and lucerne (Medicago sati-
va L.) after mechanical separation. Investigation involved isolation of elementary
fibers or fiber bundles from the press cake fraction using chemical or biological
retting. For the resulting samples density, size, and strain-stress-behavior were
analyzed in wet conditions (Table 12.10).
There are no significant differences between mechanical properties of fiber
bundles of different origin (green or ensiled grass). For the press cake of trefoil,
ryegrass and alfalfa tenacity values of stem fiber bundles were measured in the
range 11.4 to 21.4 cN/tex, leaf fiber bundles reached 6.8 to 13.1 cN/tex [150].
The geometrical properties (length and diameter) of press cake fibers were simi-
lar to those of soft wood fibers and the mechanical properties (e.g. tenacity and
elongation) of elementary fibers were comparable with those of bast fibers (jute,
hemp). Grass fibers, especially the dry fibers, have poor bending strength and
are characterized by brittleness. They are, therefore, used for non-woven textiles,
preferably for technical applications. Chemical analysis of different press cake
fractions gave the average results (% dry matter content): *5.8–7.6% cellulose,
14.7–28.7% hemicellulose, and 27.5–31.6% lignin. Crude fiber was 29.1–32.9%
and crude ash 6.3–9.1%. These values are for the first cut of grass and may alter
for later harvests.
Table 12.10 Basic properties of grass fibers from press cake – green and ensiled.
a) Elementary fibers
b) Fiber bundles (technical fiber)
c) Coir 15 cN/tex; jute 23–31 cN/tex; hemp 29–47 cN/tex
282 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
Products From Grass Fiber (PC) Generally speaking, the grass and silage fibers
fraction of the green biorefinery may be used as raw material for:
· insulation material (mats, boards, loose fill material)
· building panels (fiber and chip boards)
· products used in horticulture and landscaping (mulch fleece, erosion-control,
peat substitution)
· bio-composites
· packaging material
· pore forming additives (e.g. brick and tile industry)
· gypsum boards
· pulp and paper [151]
· thermoplastics [156].
Paper and Cardboard Paper has been manufactured from PC of lucerne [152,
153] and from reed canary grass, wild mix grass, and Cock’s foot [7, 154]. It has
also been shown that the quality of grass cardboards is the same or even better
(for the paper re-working industry) than analog waste paper and that they are
also less expensive [7, 155].
Thermoplastics Adhesive films have been produced from grass fiber by prepa-
ration of alkali cellulose and then film-forming. The adhesive film can be used
as agricultural mulching film or packing material [156]. Grass fiber has been
proposed as a component of a biodegradable protein/starch-based thermoplastic
composition. The grass fibers function as reinforcement filler. The composition
is processed by conventional methods, for example extrusion and injection
molding, into packaging material or articles that are low density and have high
compressive strength and tensile strength and good resilience [157].
12.5.4.2 Chemicals
It is reasonable to combine the primary refining of green biomass with fermenta-
tion processes for production of chemicals. This assumption is based on the high
water content of the raw material and the occurrence of many different substances
in green biomass, important for biotechnological processes. Green juice, brown
juice, and silage juice (Fig. 12.3 A and C) contain all the necessary macroelements
(minerals, peptides, amino acids, sugar) for making fermentation products [103,
123, 158–160, 168, 170]. After enrichment with further sources of carbohydrates
(sugars from lignocellulosic feedstock, for example press cake) it should be possi-
ble to produce a variety of biotechnologically basic chemicals [7]. Chemicals which
provide two or three functional groups and can be integrated into the product trees
of the chemical industry are of most interest [162, 163]. An assortment of indus-
trial biotechnologically produced chemicals are:
· (C2) chemicals such as ethanol [160, 161, 166, 167] and acetic acid,
· (C3) chemicals such as lactic acid [48, 159, 164, 165], acetone [167], and 1,3-
propandiol [171],
12.6 Green Biorefinery – Economic and Ecological Aspects 283
Products from lactic acid include, e.g., polylactic acid and ethyl lactate [83, 164,
172]. The biotechnological production of polyhydroxybutyrate from switchgrass
is currently in a stage of industrial development, and chemical or combined
chemical/biotechnological decomposition of lignocellulosic press cake or switch-
grass can be used to produce basic chemicals [169].
Basic chemicals which can be used as precursors in genealogical trees are fur-
fural [174] and xylitol [175, 176] from the hemicellulose line and hydroxymethyl-
furfural [177] and levulinic acid [178] from the cellulose line. Esparto grass is a
particularly important source of xylitol [179], and grasses with a high concentra-
tion of fructan, for example Lolium perenne are a source of hydroxymethylfur-
fural. The same is true of chicory roots [180].
12.6
Green Biorefinery – Economic and Ecological Aspects
Plant biomass is the only foreseeable sustainable source of organic fuels, chemi-
cals, and other materials. A variety of forms of biomass, notably many ligno-cel-
lulosic feedstocks, are potentially available on a large scale and are cost-competi-
tive with low-cost petroleum whether considered on a mass or energy basis, in
284 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
terms of price defined on a purchase or net basis for both current and projected
mature technologies, or on a transfer basis for mature technology [185]. Green
plant biomass and lignocellulosic feedstocks are the dominant source of feed-
stocks for biotechnological processes for production of chemicals and materials
[7, 158, 162, 163, 173]. The development of integrated technology for conversion
of biomass is essential for the economic and ecological production of products.
The biomass industry or bio-industry produces basis chemicals such as ethanol
(15 Mio tons per year), amino acids (1.5 Mio tons a year of which l-lysine
amounts to 500 000 tons per year [186]), and lactic acid (200 000 tons per year).
The target of a biorefinery is to establish a combination of a biomass–feedstock
mix with a process and product mix [162, 163]. A life cycle assessment (LCA) is
available for production of polylactic acid (capacity 140 000 tons per year) [187].
In total assessment of the utilization of biomass one must consider that plant
cultivation must fulfill economic and ecological criteria. Agriculture both creates
pressure on the environment and plays an important role in maintaining many
cultural landscapes and semi-natural habitats [188]. Green crops, especially, are
available in large quantities. Additionally, grassland can be cultivated sustainably
[92]. European grassland experiments have shown that species-rich grassland
cultivation has both ecological and economic advantages. With plant diversity
grassland is more productive and protects the soil against nitrate leaching.
Seventy-one species have been examined, of which 29 had significant influ-
ence on productivity. In particular, Trifolium pratense has an important function
with regard to productivity. On sites where this species occurs more than 50%
of the total biomass has been used. Legumes, like clover and herbs, also play an
important role, as do fast-growing grasses [189]. An initial assessment of the
concept of a green biorefinery was performed by S. Schidler et al. for the Aus-
trian system approach [190]. An Austria-wide concept for use of biomass and
cultivable land for renewable resources has yet to be developed; the same is true
for Europe [191]. The size of such plants depends on the rural structures of the
different regions. Concepts with more decentralized units would have a size of
about 35 000 tons raw material per year [192] and central plants could have sizes
of approximately 300 000 to 600 000 tons per year [174].
The synthetic method used for modeling biorefinery systems [192] is based
on combinatorial acceleration of separable concave programming developed by
Nagy et al. [193].
Cost calculation for raw materials in the green biorefinery are based on the
supply of agricultural products. For late-cut grass and straw the costs of cultiva-
tion, harvest, and intermediate storage have been calculated for Germany (Ta-
ble 12.11 [194]).
Currently, the costs are US $ 30 per ton for corn stover or straw [196]. The
prices for green pellets are also available and range from 80 1 per ton in Ger-
many to 160 1 per ton in Sweden [42]. Production of pellets from silage has
been calculated to be approximately 110 to 155 Euro per ton in Austria [190].
12.7
Outlook and Perspectives
Acknowledgment
The authors thank Michael Mandl and Niv Graf, Joanneum Research, Graz, Aus-
tria, for investigations silage fibers, and Werner Koschuh, University of Natural
Resources and Applied Life Sciences, Vienna, for investigations of silage juice.
References
1 The Bible – Old Testament, First Book 5 Pirie, N. W. (ed.). Leaf Protein: its agron-
Moses, Genesis 4.2 omy, preparation, quality and use. IBP
2 Roulle, H. M.; J. Med. Chirurg. Pharm., Handbook 20 [Blackwell, Oxford, 1971]
40 (1773) 59–67 6 Pirie, N. W.; Leaf protein: a beneficiary of
3 Schwenke, K. D.; Leaf Proteins in the tribulation. Nature, 253 (1975) 239–241
history of Protein research. Ernährungs- 7 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; The green biore-
forschung, 37 (1993) 1–11 (germ.) finery – Principles, Technologies and
4 Pirie, N. W.; Leaf protein as human food. Products, 2nd International Symposium
Science, 152 (1966) 1701–1705. Green Biorefinery, October, 13–14, 1999,
SUSTAIN, Verein zur Koordination von
286 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
60 Spollen, W. G.; Fructan composition and 72 Parry, D., Hodson, M. J. and Sangster,
physiological roles in wheat, tall fescue, A. G.; Some recent advances in studies
and timothy. Dissertation Abstracts Inter- of silicon in higher plants. Philosophical
national B, Sciences and Engineering, 51, Transactions of the Royal Society of Lon-
(1990) 523. don, B, 304, (1984) 537–549.
61 Azis, B. H., Chin, B., Deacon, M. P., 73 Dinsdale, D., Gordon, A. H. and George,
Harding, S. E. and Pavlov, G. M.; Size S.; Silica in mesophyll cell walls of Ita-
and shape of inulin in dimethyl sulphox- lian ryegrass (Lolium multiflorum Lam.
ide solution. Carbohydrate Polymers, 38, Cv. RvP). Annals of Botany, 44, (1979)
(1999) 231–234. 73–77.
62 Fuchs, A., In M. Suzuki and N. J. Chat- 74 Bode, E., Kozik, S., Kunz, U. and Leh-
terton, Science and technology of fructans. mann, H.; Comparative electron micro-
N. J. Boca Raton, Florida: CRC Press, scopic studies for the localization of sili-
p. 319 (1993). ca in leaves of two different grass spe-
63 Pontis, H. G.; Fructans. Methods in Plant cies. Deutsche Tierärztliche Wochenschrift,
Biochemistry, 2, (1990) 353–369. 101, (1994) 367–372.
64 Teeuwen, H., Thoné, M. and Vandorpe, 75 Moore, D.; The distribution of silica
J.; Inulin – From traditional food source bodies in leaf sheaths of two perennial
to an all-round raw material. ZFL, Inter- ryegrass cultivars differing in their sus-
nationale Zeitschrift für Lebensmittel-Tech- ceptibility to attack by dipterous stem-
nik, Marketing, Verpackung und Analytik, borers. Grass and Forage Science, 39,
43, (1992) 732, 734, 737–738. (1984) 205–208.
65 Mela, T. and Rand, H.; Amino acid com- 76 Puffe, D., Morgner, F. and Zerr, W.; In-
position of timothy, meadow fescue, vestigations on the contents of different
cocksfoot and perennial ryegrass at two constituents in important forage plants.
levels of nitrogen fertilisation and at suc- 2. Mineral and silicic acid contents.
cessive cuttings. Annales Agriculturae Wirtschaftseigene Futter, 30, (1984) 52–70.
Fenniae, 18, (1979) 246–251. 77 Malossini, F., Piasentier, E. and Bovolen-
66 Pedersen, E. J. N., Witt, N. and Morten- ta, S.; n-Alkane content of some forages.
sen, J.; Fractionation of green crops with Journal of the Science of Food and Agricul-
expression of juice and preservation of ture, 53, (1990) 405–409.
pressed crop and juice. 3. Relationship 78 Jones, D. I. H. and Hayward, M. V.;
between chemical composition of the Starches in forages. UK, Welsh Plant
crop and that of the juice. Tidsskrift for Breeding Station: Report for 1977, (1990)
Planteavl, 88, (1984) 25–36. 109–110.
67 Pedersen, E. J. N., Witt, N., Mortensen, J. 79 Rizk, A. F. M. and Hussiney, H. A.;
and Soerensen, C. Fractionation of green Chemistry and toxicity of Lolium spe-
crops and preservation of pressed crop cies. In A. F. M. Rizk, Poisonous plant con-
and juice. 2. Preservation of juice. Tids- tamination of edible plants (pp. 95–106),
skrift for Planteavl, 85, (1981) 13–30. (1991) Boca Raton: CRC Press Inc.
68 McDougall, V. D. Support energy and 80 Sidebottom, C., Buckley, S., Pudney, P.,
green crop fractionation in the United Twigg, S., Jarman, C., Holt, C., Telford,
Kingdom. Agricultural Systems, 5, (1980) J., McArthur, A., Worrall, D., Hubbard,
251–266. R. and Lillford, P. Heat-stable antifreeze
69 Lesnitski, V. R. High-protein feeds from protein from grass. Nature, 406 (2000)
green mass. Kormoproizvodstvo, 1/2, 256.
(1997) 61–62. 81 Kuiper, M. J., Davies, P. L. and Walk-
70 Rabovsky, J. Biogenic amorphous silica. er, V. K. A theoretical model of a plant
Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environ- antifreeze protein from Lolium perenne.
ment and Health, 21 (1995) 108–110. Biophysical Journal, 81, (2001) 3560–
71 Sangster, A. G., Hodson, M. B. and Tubb, 3565.
H. J.; Silicon deposits in higher plants. 82 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Principles of
Studies in Plant Science, 8, (2001)85–113. biorefineries, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechn.
64 (2004) 137–145
References 289
103 Keller, K.; Technology for two-steps 112 Jones, W. T., Mangan, J. L. Large-scale
conservation of green biomass, In: The isolation of fraction 1 leaf protein (18S)
Green biorefinery, Kamm B, Kamm M, from lucerne (Medicago sativa L). J.
Soyez K (eds); The Green Biorefinery, Agr. Sci. 86 (1976) 495–501.
Concept of technology, 1st Interna- 113 Hatch, F. T., Bruce, A. L.; Amino acid
tional Symposium Green Biorefinery, composition of soluble and membra-
Oct. 1997, Neuruppin, Society of eco- nous lipoproteins. Nature 218 (1968)
logical technology and system analysis, 1166–1168.
Berlin, 1998, 120–125 114 Douillard, R.; Biochemical and physico-
104 Simmonds, M. S. J.; Molecular- and chemical properties of leaf proteins. In
chemo-systematics: do they have a role Proteines Veg, Publisher Tech. Doc. La-
in agrochemical discovery? Crop Protec- voisier, Paris, France, (1985) 211–244.
tion, 19, (2000) 591–596. 115 Betschart, A. A.; The incorporation of
105 Wang, Y. R. and Li, Q.; Investigation leaf protein concentrates and isolates
and evaluation of native plant re- in human diets, In “Green Crop Frac-
sources in Loess Plateau of Gansu Pro- tionation” [Ed. R. J. Wilkins (ed.) The
vince. In J. Z. Ren, Proceedings of the In- British Grassland Society, c/o Grass-
ternational Conference on Farming Sys- land Research Institute, Hurley, Mai-
tems on the Loess Plateau of China denhead, SL6 5LR, UK, 1977] pp. 83–
(1992) (pp. 246–250). Lanzhou: Gansu 96.
Science and Technology Press 116 Carlsson, R.; White leaf protein prod-
106 Douillard, R., de Mathan, O.; Leaf pro- ucts for human consumption. A global
tein for food use: potential of Rubisco. review on plants and processing meth-
In New and developing sources of food ods. In “Tobacco Protein Utilization
proteins (Ed. Hudson BJF), Publisher Perspectives”, Proc. Round Table Conf.
Chapman and Hall, London, UK, At 1st Int. Congr. Food and Health
(1994) 307–342. [(P. Fantozzi (ed.), CNR/Italian Na-
107 Bahr, J. T., Bourque, D. P., Smith, H. J.; tional Res. Council, Special Project
Solubility properties of fraction I pro- IPBR, Subproject L. EEC Agrimed Pro-
teins of maize, cotton, spinach, and to- ject, 1985] pp. 125–145
bacco. J. Agric. Food. Chem. 25 (1977) 117 Kung, S. D.; Saunders, J. A.; Tso, T. C.;
783–789. Vaughan, D. A.; Womack, M.; Staples,
108 Bigelow, C. C. On the average hydro- R. C.; Beechers, G. R.; Tobacco as a po-
phobicity of proteins and the relation tential food sources and smoke materi-
between it and protein structure. J. al: Nutritional evaluation of tobacco
Theor. Biol. 16 (1967) 187–211. leaf protein. J. Food Sci., 45 (1980)
109 Hood, L. L.; Cheng S. G.; Koch, U.; 320–332, 327.
Brunner, J. R.; Alfalfa proteins: Isola- 118 Linnemann, A. R. and Dijkstra, D. S.
tion and partial characterization of the Toward sustainable production of pro-
major component – fraction I protein. tein-rich foods: appraisal of eight crops
J Food Sci 46 (1981) 1843–1850. for Western Europe. Part 1. Analysis of
110 Burova, T. V.; Soshinskii, A. A.; Danilen- the primary links of the production
ko, A. N.; Antonov, YuA; Grinberg, Vya; chain. Critical Reviews in Food Science
Tolstoguzov, V.B.; Conformation stabili- and Nutrition, 42 (2002) 377–401.
ty of ribulose diphosphate carboxylase 119 Wolfrum, C.; Wheat grass – The power
of alfalfa green leaves according to the in the green Juice [Gräfe und Unzer
data of differential scanning microca- Verlag GmbH, München, 1998, ISBN:
lorimetry, Biofizika 34 (1989) 545–549. 3-7742-4072-8] (German)
111 Barbeau, W. E.; Kinsella, J. E.; Ribulose 120 Gaynor, M. L. and Hickey, G. P.; Green
bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase nutritional powder composition con-
(Rubisco) from green leaves – potential taining natural food and herbal prod-
as a food protein, Food. Rev. Int. 41 ucts. US Patent Application 5904924
(1988) 93–127. (1999).
References 291
121 Messman, M. A., Weiss, W. P., and 130 Palm, S. K., Smith, T. R., Shiuh, J. C.
Koch, M. E.; Changes in total and indi- and Roulston, J. S.; Filterable compo-
vidual protein during drying, ensiling site adsorbents with adsorptive and fil-
and ruminal fermentation of forages. J. terable components as filter aids suit-
Dairy Sci. 77 (1994) 492–500. able for beer chillproofing. PCT Inter-
122 Koschuh, W., Povoden, G., Vu Hong, national Application, 9830324 (1998).
T., Kromus, S., Kulbe, K. D., Novalin, 131 Itsumi, A., Sakagami, E.; Manufacture
S., Krotscheck, C.; Production of leaf of artificial zeolites from grass. Japa-
protein concentrate from ryegrass (Lo- nese Patent Application, 2001323109
lium perenne ´ multiflorum) and alfalfa (2001).
(Medicago sativa subsp. Sativa). Compar- 132 Salminen, S. O. and Grewal, P. S.; Does
ison between heat coagulation/centrifu- decreased mowing frequency enhance
gation and ultrafiltration. Desalination alkaloid production in endophytic tall
163 (2004) 253–259. fescue and perennial ryegrass? Journal
123 Vu Hong, T., Koschuh, W., Kulbe, of Chemical Ecology, 28 (2002) 939–950.
K. D., Kromus, S., Krotscheck, C., No- 133 Fechner, M.; Grassland economy in
valin, S. Desalination of high salt con- Brandenburg. In: Proceedings of the
tent mixture by two-stage electrodialy- 1st. Int. Symposium on Green Biore-
sis as the first step of separating valu- finery, Neuruppin, Germany 1997
able substances from grass silage. De- [K. Soyez, B. Kamm, M. Kamm (eds.),
salination 162 (2004) 343–353 Berlin, Germany, 1998, ISBN 3-929672-
124 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Scherze, I.; 06-5] (German) 47–52
Muschiolik, G.; Bindrich, U.; Biobased 134 Wantanabe, T.; Fujishima, A.; Honda,
polymers by chemical valorization of K.; Dye-sensitive electrodes. In: Energy
biomass components, In: Vasile, C.; Resour. Photochem. Cat. [M. Grätzel
Zaikov (Eds.) Polymer reactions and (ed.), Academic Press, 1983] 359
properties, Publishing House Nova 135 Cohen, B. S., et al.; J. Agric. Food
Science – New York (in press) Chem. 32 (1984) 516
125 Oyama, K., Kobayashi, T., Imazato, Y.; 136 Leblanc, R. M., et al.; Photobiochem.
Kumasawa, Y.; Polysaccharides from Photobiophys. 7 (1984) 41
fescue plant cell walls, emulsifiers con- 137 Girio, F. M. F. Development of xylo-oli-
taining them, and method for emulsifi- gosaccharides and xylitol for use in
cation. Japanese Patent Application, pharmaceutical and food industries
10237107 (1998). (XYLOPHONE) (1997) FAIR-CT97-
126 Cherno, N. K., Adamovskaya, K. D. and 3811.
Lobotskaya, L. L.; Polysaccharide–lignin 138 Aspinall (ed.); The polysaccharides.
complexes of raw materials not tradi- Vol. 2 [Academic Press, New York,
tional for the food industry, and their 1983] (a) p. 98–193, (b) p. 411–490
properties. Khimiya Drevesiny, 3 (1991) 139 Davidson (ed.); Handbook of Water sol-
95–98. uble Gums and Resins. [McGraw-Hill,
127 Shipley, L. W. Manufacture of high pur- New York, 1980]
ity amorphous silica from biogenic ma- 140 Perl (ed.); The Chemistry of Lignin
terial. US Patent Application, 6406678 [Dekker, New York, 1967]
(2002). 141 Crawford (ed.); Lignin Biodegradation
128 Noeske, R. and Horn, I. Procedure for and Transformation. [John Wiley and
the production of silicon carbide from Sons, New York, 1981]
renewable raw materials. German Pat- 142 Hofrichter, M.; Steinbüchel, A.; (ed.)
ent Application, 10020626 (2001). Biopolymers: Lignin, humic substances
129 Shiuh, J. C., Palm, S. K., Nyamekye, and coal; 2001, Wiley-VCH, ISBN 3-
G. A., Smith, T. R., Taniguchi, J. D. and 527-30220-4
Wang, Q. Highly purified biogenic sili- 143 Nay, W. H. and Fuller, W. S.; Method
ca product and its preparation. Europe- for processing straw into pulp and ani-
an Patent Application, 758560 (1997). mal feed byproduct and paper product
292 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
165 Neureiter, M.; Danner, H.; Madzingaid- tives on new crops and new uses.
zo, L.; Miyafuji, H.; Thomasser, C.; ASHS Press, Alexandria, VA, USA,
Bvochora, J.; Bamusi, S.; Braun, R.; 1999, 114–123
Lignocellulose Feedstocks for the pro- 175 Jiang, Z., Chen, R. and Wu, P.; Hydro-
duction of lactic acid, Chem. Biochem. genation of xylose to xylitol in trickle-
Eng. Q. (CABEQ) 18(1) (2004) 55–63 bed reactor. Riyong Huaxue Gongye, 6,
166 McGrath, D.; Italian ryegrass as a (1998) 6–8.
source of fermentable sugars and pro- 176 Nigam, P. and Singh, D.; Processes for
tein feedstuff. Luxembourg: Commis- fermentative production of xylitol – a
sion of the European Communities, sugar substitute. Process Biochemistry,
(1990). 30, (1995) 124–124.
167 Quereshi, N. and Blaschek, H. P.; ABE 177 Bhatt, S. and Shukla, R. P. HMF – a
production from corn: a recent eco- new route to industrial chemicals from
nomic evaluation. Journal of Industrial sugars. Taiwan Sugar, 48, (2001) 4–15.
Microbiology and Biotechnology, 27, 178 Elliott, D. C.; Fitzpatrick, S. W.; Bozell,
(2001) 292–297. J. J.; Jarnefeld, J. L.; Bilski, R. J.; Moens,
168 Starke, I.; Kamm, B.; Kleinpeter, E.; L.; Frye, Jr. J. G.; Wang, Y.; Neuen-
Separation, identification and quantifi- schwander, G. G.; Production of levuli-
cation of amino acids in l-lysine fer- nic acid and use as a platform chemi-
mentation potato juices by gas chroma- cal for derived products; In: Proceed-
tography/ mass spectrometry, Fresenius ings of the fourth biomass conference
J. Anal. Chem., 371 (2001) 380–384 of Americas, Biomass, A Growths Op-
169 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Schmidt, M.; portunity in Green Energy and Value
Starke, I.; Kleinpeter, E.; Chemical and added Products, Vol. 1, Overend, R. P.;
biochemical generation of carbohy- Chornet, E. (ed.); Elsevier Science Ltd.,
drates from lignocellulose-feedstock 1999, 911–914, ISBN 008 0430198
(Lupinus nootkatensis), Quantification of 179 Rothschild, Z., Silva, H. C., Braga,
glucose, Chemosphere (in press) G. L., Carlomagno, D. N., Prado,
170 Kiel, P.; Thomsen, M. H.; Andersen, I. M. R., de Carvalho, R., Polizello,
M.; Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – A. C. M. and Spadaro, A. C. C.; Xylitol a
Use of plant juice as fermentation me- non-cariogenic sugar obtained from
dium, In this book grasses of the genus Aristida and re-
171 Vorlop, K. D.; Willke, Th.; Prüße, U.; lated species. Arquivos de Biologica e
Biocatalytic and catalytic routes for the Tecnologia, 34, (1991) 61–71.
production of bulk and fine chemicals 180 de Baynast, R. and Renard, C.; Pro-
from renewable resources, In this book cesses for extraction and transforma-
172 Datta, R.; Tsai, S.-P.; Lactic acid Pro- tion of products with high fructose
duction and potential uses: A Technol- content from chicory roots (Cichorium
ogy and Economics Assessment. In: intybus). Comptes Rendus de l’Académie
Fuels and chemicals from biomass, d’Agriculture de France, 80, (1994) 31–
B. C. Sara, J. Woodward (ed.), ACS 46.
Symposium series, ISSN 0097- 181 Fischer, K., Bipp, H.-P., Riemschneider,
6156 666, ACS, Washington D. C., P., Leidmann, P., Bienek, D. and Ket-
1997, pp. 224–236 trup, A.; Utilization of biomass resi-
173 Tullo, A.; Renewable Materials, Two dues for the remediation of metal-pol-
Pacts May Help Spur Biomass Plastics; luted soils. Environmental Science and
Chemical and Engineering News, Technology, 32, (1998) 2154–2231.
March 28, 2005, www.CEN- 182 Kato, H.; Porous carbon fibers from
ONLINE.org plant waste materials manufactured by
174 Van Dyne, D. L.; Blasé, M. G.; Clem- baking the waste materials in an oven
ents, L. D.; A Strategy for returning in the roped form for formation of
agriculture and rural America to long- coiled carbonized fibers and reuse of
term full employment using biomass plant waste materials therefor. Japanese
refineries. In: J. Janeck (ed.) Perspec- Patent Application, 2000303266 (2000).
294 12 The Green Biorefinery Concept – Fundamentals and Potential
183 Linke, B.; Schelle, H.; Anaerobe Ver- Kromus, S., Will, M., 2003, Technikfol-
fahren zur Reststoffbehandlung, In: gen-Abschätzung der Grünen Bioraf-
The Green biorefinery, Kamm B, finerie, Teil II: Materialsammlung, In-
Kamm M, Soyez K (eds) The Green stitut für Technikfolgen-Abschätzung,
Biorefinery, Concept of technology, 1st Österreichische Akademie der Wis-
International Symposium Green Biore- senschaften, 2003 (German)
finery, Oct. 1997, Neuruppin, Society 191 Narodoslawsky, M.; Kromus, S.; Devel-
of ecological technology and system opment of decentral green biorefinery
analysis, Berlin, (1998) 196–207 in Austria; In: biorefinica 2004, Pro-
184 Verstrate, W.; Debeer, D.; Pena, M.; Let- ceedings and Papers, October, 27–28,
tinga, G.; Lens, P.; Anaerobic Biopro- Osnabrück, Eds.: Kamm, B.; Hempel,
cessing of Organic Wastes, World Jour- M.; Kamm, M; biopos e.V., Teltow
nal of Microbiology and Biotechnology, 2004, p. 24; ISBN 3-00-015166-4
12 (1996) 221–223 192 Halasz L., G. Povoden, M. Narodo-
185 Fowler, P. A.; McLaughlin, A. R.; Hall, slawsky: Process Synthesis for Renewable
L. M.; The potential industrial uses of Resources, presented at the PRES 03,
forage grasses including miscanthus; Hamilton, Canada, 2003
BioComposites Centre, University of 193 Nagy, A. B., F. Friedler, and L. T. Fan,
Wales, Bangor, Gwynedd 2003; Combinatorial Acceleration of Separ-
www.nnfcc.co.uk/library/reports/ able Concave Programming for Process
download.cfm?id=60 Synthesis, presented at the AIChE An-
186 Elements, Degussa Science Newsletter nual Meeting, Miami Beach, FL, USA,
7 (2005) 35 November 15–20, 1998.
187 Vink, E. T. H.; Rabago, K. R.; Glassner, 194 Fechner, M.; Hertwig, F.; Nachwach-
D. A.; Gruber, P. R.; Applications of life sende Rohstoffe auch vom Grünland,
cycle assessment to NatureWorks poly- Neue Landwirtschaft 11, (1994) 29–31
lactide (PLA) production, Polymer deg- 195 Dale, B.; Encyclopedia of physical
radation and stability 80 (2003) 403– sciences and technology, vol 2, 3rd
419 edn. McGraw-Hill, New York, 2002,
188 IEEP, Contribution to the background pp. 141–157
study agriculture, The Institute for Eu- 196 (a) Lynd, L. R., Wyman, C. E. and Gern-
ropean Environmental Policy, 2004. gross, T. U.; Biocommodity engineer-
189 Hector, A.; et al.; Plant Diversity and ing. Biotechnology Progress, 15, (1999)
Productivity Experiments in European 777–793. (b) Lynd, L. R.; Biomass Pro-
Grasslands, Science, 286 (1999) 1123– cessing in Response to sustainability
1127 and Security Challenges – A Vision for
190 (a) Schidler, S., Technikfolgenabschät- What is possible, In: biorefinica 2004,
zung der Grünen Bioraffinerie, Teil I: Proceedings and Papers, October, 27–
Endbericht, Institut für Technikfolgen- 28, Osnabrück, Eds.: Kamm, B.; Hem-
Abschätzung, Österreichische Akade- pel, M.; Kamm, M.; biopos e.V., Teltow
mie der Wissenschaften, 2003; Schid- 2004, p. 20; ISBN 3-00-015166-4
ler, S., Adensam, H., Hofmann, R.,
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
295
13
Plant Juice in the Biorefinery –
Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
Mette Hedegaard Thomsen, Margrethe Andersen, and Pauli Kiel
13.1
Introduction
Biotechnological utilization of waste and residues from agriculture and the agri-
cultural industry has been the common goal for AgroFerm A/S and University
of Southern Denmark. The concept of the green biorefinery has been described
elsewhere [8]. Additionally, much experimental work has been performed on re-
alizing these ideas for industrial purposes. This paper describes the possibility
of using brown juice from the green crop-drying industry and potato juice from
the potato starch industry as raw materials in Danish lactic acid production, as
a basis for the production of bio-based polylactate to be used as packaging mate-
rials for fruit and vegetables. One single green crop-drying factory producing
50 000 tons of fodder pellets a year has enough brown juice to supply a 6 000
ton lactic acid factory with fermentation medium, and a 50 000 ton potato starch
factory produces enough potato juice to supply a 35 000 ton lactic acid factory.
13.2
Historical Outline
Since 1997 work has been performed on a research project on the production
and testing of bio-based packaging materials for food. The work has been per-
formed as co-operation between The Technical University of Denmark, The
Danish Technological Institute, The Royal Danish Veterinary and Agricultural
University, Risø National Laboratory, The University of Aarhus, and The Univer-
sity of Southern Denmark. Bio-based materials are defined as materials originat-
ing from agricultural sources, i.e. produced from renewable and biological raw
materials. The advantages of such materials are that they are CO2-neutral and
biodegradable.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
296 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
13.3
Biobased Poly(lactic Acid)
13.3.1
Fermentation Processes
13.3.2
The Green Biorefinery
The crops are separated in a liquid fraction – the juice containing the soluble
compounds and the press cake containing particles and insoluble high-molecu-
lar-weight compounds. Vitamins, colors, enzymes, and other phytochemicals
can be isolated directly from the juice or press cake. The press cake can be used
as animal feed or, after drying, as solid fuel.
After extraction of the high-value compounds from the juice, it can be used
as a substrate for fermentation [4]. The fermentation products can be any organ-
ic compounds, for example enzymes, antibiotics, biodegradable plastics, organic
acids, alcohols and amino acids.
298 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
13.3.3
Lactic Acid Fermentation
13.3.4
Brown Juice as a Fermentation Medium
The green crop-drying industry in Denmark uses Italian rye grass, clover, and
alfalfa as raw materials for production of green pellets. Approximately 300 000
tons of green pellets are produced in Denmark each year. The green crop-drying
industry solves its energy-economical problems by pressing the green crop be-
fore drying. The by-product produced, green juice, typically has a dry-matter
content of 3 to 8%. At some factories the green biomass is heated to 80 8C by
steam before pressing, this causes the plant cells to burst and the protein to
coagulate. The by-product produced is called brown juice. Typically brown juice
has a dry-matter content of 4 to 8%. Approximately 200 000 m3 of brown juice
is produced each year in Denmark. Although the green and brown juice are
spread on the fields as fertilizer, pollution of ground water, particularly with ni-
trate, in the late autumn has led to stringent regulations on the use of plant
juice as a fertilizer. In Denmark plant juice can be spread on green fields only
in the autumn and not in the period between October 1st and February 1st [5].
The problem with the plant juice can be solved by storing the juice in large la-
goons from October 1st. Because storage can easily result in foul-smelling waste
products, we have studied other possibilities.
It is common knowledge that grass and almost all kinds of crop decay if
stored inappropriately, but it can be conserved by ensiling either by a sponta-
neous process in which the microorganisms present in the crops convert the
carbohydrates to acid, or by adding a culture of lactic acid bacteria. Therefore
the obvious solution is to use the brown juice as a fermentation medium for
lactic acid fermentation [6].
13.4 Materials and Methods 299
13.4
Materials and Methods
13.4.1
Analytical Methods
13.4.2
Fed Batch Fermentation of Brown Juice with Lb. salivarius BC 1001
A 2-L continuously stirred tank reactor containing 1.5 L fresh (non-heat treated)
brown juice (2% DM) was used for the fed-batch experiment. The bioreactor
was equipped with a Mettler Toledo pH meter, heat sensor (pT100, MJK auto-
300 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
mation) and a heating element (50 W, 220 V), to keep pH and temperature con-
stant. pH was controlled automatically by addition of 4 m NaOH by a peristaltic
pump, the computer program used for control and regulation of pH and tem-
perature was Genesis 4.2.
Growth of the strain was followed by measurement of the dry cell mass. This
was achieved by centrifuging samples and washing twice with saline water
(0.9%) before drying the samples in an oven at 190 8C overnight. During fer-
mentation 2% glucose (40% solution) was added successively.
13.4.3
Pilot Scale Continuous Fermentation with Lb. salivarius BC 1001
The pilot scale experiment with continuous lactic acid fermentation of brown juice
was performed at the green crop-drying factory – Dangrønt Products, Ringkøbing,
Denmark. The brown juice produced from the pressing of the crops was cooled to
30 to 40 8C and fed into an 8 m3 tank and the tank was inoculated with 4 m3 bac-
terial culture (Lb. salivarius BC 1001). Fermentation was initiated as batch fermen-
tation, and after the pH in the tank had dropped to approximately 4.5, substrate
flow was started. The initial flow rate was 3.5 m3 h–1. The acidified BJ was led
to a sedimentation tank from where the supernatant was pumped to a storage/buf-
fer tank before evaporation to approximately 40% DM.
13.4.4
Study of Potato Juice Quality During Aerobic and Anaerobic Storage
Experiments were performed to investigate the quality of potato juice stored un-
der aerobic and anaerobic conditions. The investigations were carried out in
plastic containers with a volume of 25 L. The containers were filled with 10 L
fresh potato juice from the Karup, Denmark, potato starch factory. For anaerobic
storage the surface was covered with 1 to 2 cm corn oil. Containers were kept at
a temperature between 15 and 20 8C.
13.5
Brown Juice
13.5.1
Chemical Composition
The chemical composition of the green and brown juice was analyzed to investi-
gate the suitability of the brown juice as fermentation medium. The average
composition of evaporated fresh brown juice determined from 42 different
batches collected from June 9th 1998 to November 11th 2000 is shown in Ta-
ble 13.1.
13.5 Brown Juice 301
Vitamins
Pantothenic acid 0.060 0.101 0.035 27.139 0.023 0.003
Niacin 0.133 0.190 0.068 17.676 0.050 0.006
Thiamin 0.015 0.028 0.011 23.158 0.006 0.001
Total 0.209 0.276 0.154 14.865 0.078 0.010
Amino acids
Lysine 5.0 7.2 3.2 17.5 1.9 0.2
Serine 6.3 12.1 4.2 25.8 2.4 0.3
Glutamine 17.2 27.2 2.9 24.8 6.4 0.8
Glycine 6.2 16.4 4.0 33.8 2.3 0.3
Alanine 13.1 21.8 8.3 20.5 4.9 0.6
Asparagine 20.9 51.7 10.3 42.1 7.8 1.0
Methionine 1.2 1.8 0.6 22.5 0.4 0.1
Cystine 1.3 1.9 0.8 24.0 0.5 0.1
Threonine 6.0 7.9 3.8 18.0 2.2 0.3
Valine 7.3 10.4 4.6 19.7 2.7 0.3
iso-Leucine 4.6 6.6 2.6 20.7 1.7 0.2
Leucine 7.0 9.6 4.2 20.7 2.6 0.3
Tyrosine 2.3 5.9 0.0 70.6 0.9 0.1
Phenylalanine 4.4 6.8 2.3 24.7 1.6 0.2
Histidine 2.9 5.0 0.5 28.1 1.1 0.1
Arginine 4.0 8.8 0.5 32.5 1.5 0.2
Total 124.0 19.1 167.5 20.7 46.3 5.7
Crude protein 203.0 279.1 133.2 18.3 75.9 9.4
Mono-, di-, and trisaccharides are called free carbohydrates because they can
be metabolized by most lactic acid bacteria. Fructans (including 1-ketose) are
polymeric carbohydrates consisting of variable numbers of fructose molecules
and terminal sucrose. Fructans can be decomposed to free carbohydrates both
by enzymes in the crops, fructan fructohydrolases, and by some strains of lactic
acid bacteria, especially in the genera Lactobacillus plantarum and Lactobacillus
paracasei subspecies paracasei [7]. The enzymes in the crops are activated after
harvesting, carving, and pressing. Alfalfa does not contain fructans.
13.5.2
Seasonal Variations
Table 13.1 also shows the highest and the lowest value for a component found
in the 42 different batches of brown juice and the standard deviation. For most
compounds there are very high deviations between batches. The composition of
13.5 Brown Juice 303
13.5.3
Lactic Acid Fermentation of Brown Juice
Different lactic acid bacteria have been tested for their ability to utilize the most
common carbohydrates. Several strains have been found suitable, but despite
the fact that Lactobacillus salivarius is unable to metabolize fructan, it has been
chosen for lactic acid fermentation of brown juice because of its high growth
rate. This high growth rate makes L. salivarius BC 1001 robust and capable of
competing with other microorganisms for an unsterile substrate [6]. By choos-
ing a robust, fast-growing microorganism that can compete with unwanted mi-
croorganisms in the brown juice, sterilization of the substrate can be avoided.
The brown juice contains both carbohydrates and amino acids, which in combi-
nation can form Maillard compounds during heat sterilization. This will cause a
decrease in the nutrient-content and reduce the quality of the juice, because of
the toxicity of some Maillard compounds.
Fermentation experiments with fresh non-heat-sterilized brown juice have
shown that fructan is used in fermentations with L. salivarius even though this
strain is unable to produce fructan-degrading enzymes. This is probably because
of the activity of plant enzymes in the brown juice. Under monoseptic fermen-
tation conditions fructan is not metabolized because enzymes in the juice are
destroyed by heat sterilization [8].
Fed batch fermentation of fresh brown juice (2% DM) has shown that brown
juice with only 2% DM contains enough nutrients in the substrate to achieve
high lactic acid production. In this experiment the specific growth rate of Lb.
306 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
Fig. 13.6 Growth and titration curve for fed batch fermenta-
tion with L. salivarius BC 1001 in fresh non-heat-sterilized
brown juice with 2% DM, to which glucose syrup, 40%, was
added successively.
salivarius BC 1001 was 0.9 h–1 and a cell mass concentration of approximately
3 g L–1 was achieved (Fig. 13.6).
The composition of nutrients in the brown juice causes the growth of cell mass to
stop at a certain concentration, whereupon the energy in the substrate is used ex-
clusively for maintenance and production of lactic acid. This characteristic makes
the brown juice suitable as a substrate for continuous lactic acid fermentation.
It has been shown that the growth rate of L. salivarius BC 1001 is higher in
brown juice than in MRS-bouillon, which is a substrate commonly used for
lactic acid fermentation [8].
13.5.4
The Green Crop-drying Industry as a Lactic Acid Producer
The green crop-drying industry in Denmark is located in Jutland. There are five
factories with a total production of approximately 200 000 m3 green and brown
juice 5% DM. It is shown in Fig. 13.6 that 2% DM is enough to achieve good
conversion of carbohydrates to lactic acid. A single green crop-drying factory
produces enough juice for lactic acid production of approximately 8000 tons per
year if a carbohydrate source is added to achieve a lactic acid concentration of
8% in the fermentation broth.
Experiments with continuous lactic acid fermentation of brown juice have
been performed at the green crop-drying factory: Dangrønt Products, Ringkø-
bing, Denmark. Figure 13.7 shows the process.
This pilot scale continuous lactic acid fermentation of brown juice was suc-
cessful. The pH of brown juice was reduced to 4.7 and much of the sugar in
the brown juice was converted to lactic acid. Table 13.2 shows the dry-matter
content, density, and pH of the brown juice after the process. Table 13.3 shows
results from analysis of the lactic acid fermented brown juice.
13.5 Brown Juice 307
Fig. 13.7 The brown juice produced from the mately 4.5, substrate flow was started. The
pressing of the crops was cooled to initial flow rate was 3.5 m3 h–1. The acidified
35 8C ± 5 8C and fed into a 8 m3 tank. The BJ was fed into a sedimentation tank, from
tank was inoculated with 4 m3 bacterial where the supernatant was pumped to a
culture (Lb. salivarius BC 1001). Fermentation storage/buffer tank before evaporation to
was initiated as batch fermentation, and approximately 40% DM.
after pH in the tank had dropped to approxi-
The analysis of the lactic acid fermented brown juice shows that efficient lac-
tic acid fermentation has occurred. The amount of lactic acid produced is
280 g kg–1 DM, leaving only small amounts of sugar in the medium. The strain
used for this fermentation (Lb. salivarius BC 1001) is a homofermentative strain,
and only small amount of acetic acid and succinic acid is present in the fermen-
308
Table 13.3 Composition of lactic acid fermented and evaporated brown juice (45.3% DM) produced in pilot scale continuous
fermentation at Dangrønt Products, Ringkøbing 16/10 2001.
Crude Cations Anions Trace Free sugars Fructan Total sugars Succinic- Lactic- Acetic- Total Amino acids
protein minerals acid acid acid org. acids
(g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM) (g kg–1 DM)
245.2 143.4 103.5 0.818 12.5 3.4 16.0 33.5 280.8 23.5 337.8 117.3
Crude Cations Anions Trace Free sugars Fructan Total sugars Succinic Lactic Acetic Organic Amino acids
protein minerals acids
(g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1) (g L–1)
132.0 77.2 55.7 0.440 6.8 1.8 8.6 18.0 151.2 12.7 181.9 63.2
13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
13.6 Potato Juice 309
tation product. Substantial amounts of nutrients (minerals and amino acids) re-
main in the brown juice after lactic acid fermentation, indicating that adding
more carbohydrate could increase the yield of lactic acid. This would be neces-
sary in the production of PLA to make the process feasible. This will be dis-
cussed in Section 13.7.
13.6
Potato Juice
13.6.1
Potato Juice as Fermentation Medium
At potato starch factories the potatoes are sorted, washed, and grated. After grat-
ing, the potato pulp is centrifuged and the starch, pulp, and potato juice are
separated. Two waste products are produced: potato pulp and potato juice. The
pulp is sold for animal feed and the juice is spread on fields as fertilizer. The
potato starch industry thus faces the same problem as the green crop-drying in-
dustry – a waste product that must be stored in large lagoons from October 1st
or be used for other purposes.
Experiments have been performed to investigate the quality of potato juice
with regard to pH, lactic acid, and acetic acid formation, when stored under
aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Figures 13.8 and 13.9 show the results of
these experiments.
The figures show that aerobic and anaerobic storage of the juice causes a con-
spicuous drop in the pH of the juice within the first 7 days. This is because of
lactic acid and acetic acid fermentation of the carbohydrates and some organic
Fig. 13.8 pH, lactic acid and acetic acid during aerobic stor-
age of potato juice at a temperature between 15 and 20 8C.
310 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
Fig. 13.9 pH, lactic acid and acetic acid during anaerobic
storage of potato juice at a temperature between 15 and
20 8C.
13.6.2
The Potato Starch Industry as Lactic Acid Producer
There are four potato starch factories in Denmark situated in Northern Jutland,
Karup, Brande, and Toftlund, manufacturing a total of approximately 1 million
tons of potatoes each year. This gives a total of approximately 200 000 tons of
potato starch, 150 000 tons of potato pulp (12 to 13% DM) and between 1 and
1.5 million tons of potato juice (2 to 4% DM) depending on the production
methods. At the factory in Karup 300 000 tons of potato juice (2% DM) are pro-
duced each year. On that basis Karup potato starch factory could produce ap-
proximately 35 000 tons of lactic acid a year if a sufficient amount of carbohy-
drate is added to the juice.
13.7 Carbohydrate Source 311
13.7
Carbohydrate Source
To profitably utilize brown juice from the green crop-drying industry or potato
juice from the potato starch industry, a carbohydrate source must be added. The
carbohydrate source could be another waste product from the agricultural indus-
try such as molasses from beet sugar production, whey from the dairy industry,
or soy meal extract from the production of soy protein. It could also be refined
sugar (white sugar), hydrolyzed straw, or hydrolyzed cereal grains, e.g. wheat.
Wheat has advantages over other carbohydrate sources. Cereals, being much
lower in moisture than molasses, are more energy intensive and have the ad-
vantage that they can be stored and transported easily. The sugar is in the form
of starch and in addition cereal grains contain nutrients which can be separated
easily from the grain and sold as lucrative by-products – bran, gluten, and A-
Wet separation
(pressing)
starch. Gluten – a protein used in the baking industry – is the most profitable
of these by-products.
Webb and Wang describe a process for utilization of wheat as a carbohydrate
source for lactic acid fermentation in which gluten is separated from the grain
before hydrolysis of the starch. The filamentous fungus Aspergillus awamori is
capable of producing enzymes to break down the starch to glucose [9].
As shown in Fig. 13.10, there are many possibilities of producing fermenta-
tion products on the basis of on green crops and potatoes and thereby changing
the green crop-drying factories and potato starch factories to green biorefineries.
13.8
Purification of Lactic Acid
The lactic acid must be recovered and purified from the fermentation broth.
The classical method is the calcium lactate process in which the lactic acid is
precipitated as calcium lactate and treated with sulfuric acid. The resulting cal-
cium sulfate is separated from the lactic acid solution by filtration and the liq-
uid is evaporated. The process gives residual amounts of gypsum, and waste
gypsum disposal can be a problem.
The latest developments in lactic acid purification have been towards mem-
brane processes such as ultrafiltration and electrodialysis. Other methods such
as ion-exchange and solvent extraction involve heavy initial costs and operating
costs; they are, therefore, not very suitable for low-cost production of lactic acid.
Electrodialysis is a membrane process in which the membranes allow passage
only of either anions or cations (ion-exchange membranes), the driving force
being potential difference. Because the membranes are easily fouled if the fer-
mentation broth contains large impurities and particles, these are removed by
ultrafiltration before electrodialysis. Problems with membrane processes arise if
the fermentation broth contains large amounts of organic particles and in-
organic ions such as calcium and magnesium, which damage the membrane.
Birgit and Michael Kamm use ultrafiltration, nanofiltration, and electrodialy-
sis for purification of lactic acid from fermentation broth. They have developed
a process whereby lactic acid is neutralized with piperazine, an amine that com-
bined with two molecules of lactic acid makes piperazinium dilactate. The pi-
perazinium dilactate can be converted to dilactid (a building block in the pro-
duction of polylactate) without the production of undesired by-products. Birgit
and Michael Kamm did not experience problems with fouling of the ultrafiltra-
tion membrane but some optimization of the nanofiltration and electrodialysis
processes is still needed [10].
At the Technical University of Denmark a process has been developed in
which the lactic acid is continuously removed and purified from the fermenta-
tion broth using various membrane processes (Donnan dialysis, electrodialysis
with bi-polar membranes, and electrodialysis). In this process problems with
fouling of the membranes are minimized or avoided [11].
References 313
13.9
Conclusion and Outlook
Waste products from the green crop-drying industry and the potato starch in-
dustry, brown juice and potato juice, contain all the nutrients necessary for lac-
tic acid bacteria to convert carbohydrates to lactic acid. Brown juice 2% DM in a
substrate contains enough nutrients to achieve good lactic acid production in
continuous fermentation by addition of a carbohydrate source.
It is possible to use other cheap waste products from the agricultural industry,
for example molasses or hydrolyzed straw, or purer products such as refined su-
gar or hydrolyzed starch, as a carbohydrate source. Hydrolyzed B-starch from
wheat has several advantages compared with other carbohydrate sources. The
most important is that the grain contains nutrients, for example bran, gluten
and A-starch, which can be separated easily from the grain and sold as lucrative
by-products.
At the Technical University of Denmark a very promising process has been
developed for purification of lactic acid produced from agricultural waste prod-
ucts. This process can substantially reduce the cost of lactic acid production.
The experiments reported in this article show it is possible to produce lactic
acid from brown juice or potato juice on an industrial scale using non-sterile
brown juice or potato juice for fermentation. The fermented juice can be stored
under anaerobic conditions and used as a substrate for all-year round produc-
tion of lactic acid, lysine, and many other fermentation products.
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the Danish Ministry of Food, Agriculture and Fish-
eries under the program “Increased Utilization of Renewable Resources for In-
dustrial Non-food Purposes” (1997–2001). We thank Vagn Hundelbøll, Agro-
Ferm A/S, and Jens Mikkelsen, the potato starch factory in Karup for the inter-
esting co-operation.
References
1 Shogren, R., 1997, Water Vapour Perme- 3 Petersen, K. et al., 1999, Potential of Bio-
ability of Biodegradable Polymers, J. En- based Materials for Food Packaging,
viron. Polym. Degrad. 5(2). Trends Food Sci. Tech. 10, 52–68.
2 Weber, C. J., Biobased Packaging Materials 4 Andersen, M., Kiel, P., 1999, Method for
for the Food Industry Status and Perspec- Treating Organic Waste Materials, Euro-
tives – A European Concerted Action, KVL pean Patent Application, 19 March 1999,
Department of Dairy and Food Science, WO 00156912.
Frederiksberg, Denmark. Trio Design, 5 The Danish Ministry of Environment
Copenhagen and Energy’s order no. 823 of 16 Sep-
314 13 Plant Juice in the Biorefinery – Use of Plant Juice as Fermentation Medium
tember 1996. Order of the use of waste 9 Webb, C., Wang, R., 1997, Development
products for agricultural purpose. of a Generic Fermentation Feedstock
6 Thomsen, M. H., Bech, D., Kiel, P., from Whole Wheat Flour. In: Campel,
2004, Manufacturing of Stabilized Brown G. M., Webb, C., McKee, S. L. (Eds) Cer-
Juice for l-lysine production – from Uni- eals: Novel Uses and Processes, Plenum
versity Lab Scale over Pilot Scale to In- Press, New York, pp. 205–218.
dustrial Production. Chem. Biochem. Eng. 10 Kamm, B., Kamm, M., Richter, K., Rei-
Q. 18, 37–46. mann, W., Siebert, A., 2000, Formation
7 Müller, M., Steller, J., 1995, Comparative of Aminium Lactates in Lactic Acid Fer-
Studies of the Degradation of Grass mentation. Acta Biotechnol. 20(3/4), 289–
Fructans and Inulin by Strains of Lacto- 304.
bacillus paracasei subsp. paracasei and 11 Garde, A., Rype, J. U., Jonsson, G., 2000,
Lactobacillus plantarum. J. Appl. Bacteriol. A Method and Apparatus for Isolation of
78, 229–236. Ionic Species from a Liquid. Not yet pub-
8 Andersen, M., Kiel, P., 2000, Integrated lished patent. Application no. PA 2000
Utilisation of Green Biomass in the 01862.
Green Biorefinery, Ind. Crops Prod. 11,
129–137.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part III
Biomass Production and Primary Biorefineries
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
317
14
Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
James Hettenhaus
14.1
Introduction
In the next ten year biorefineries may be processing 100 million metric dry tons
(dt) biomass annually for production of fuels and chemicals if a stretch goal set
by the US Department of Energy is met [1–3]. Initially, feedstocks with no col-
lection cost like paper mill sludge, bagasse, and rice hulls may be used to vali-
date the conversion technology. They have no associated transport cost. Their
quantities may also serve niche markets for high-value chemicals [4]. For larger
markets like transportation fuels, their conversion is too small and costly to
compete. The biorefining industry’s growth is predicated mostly on corn stover,
supplemented with straw and grasses with a delivered price of $ 30 to $ 35 dt–1
[5, 6]. The quantity and ready availability makes stover an early feedstock choice
for initial biorefineries (Table 14.1), US Ag residue feedstock availability.
When the feedstock market is established with stover, other biomass feed-
stock, prairie grasses and energy crops, from wide geographic areas will emerge
to supply biorefineries.
While great strides have been made in improving the conversion process,
there remains much uncertainty regarding the feedstock supply. Economies of
scale require a biorefinery size of 500 to 2000 dt feedstock per day. Supplying
these large quantities raises major issues including:
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
318 14 Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
More information is needed for the farmer to assess the opportunity for supply-
ing the emerging biorefinery market for biomass feedstock. What is the value
of the biomass to the soil and to the farmer? What cropping practice is needed
for sustainable removal, balancing environmental and economic requirements?
Previous studies of crop residue removal on soil quality are limited to small re-
search plots that often do not align with current best practice. Although existing
models provide guidelines for residue management to limit soil erosion, robust
models that address soil quality and residue removal are just emerging.
Bulky crop residues are collected to meet small needs, mostly for local farm
use–bales for animal bedding. There is negligible collection infrastructure to serve
large markets like biorefineries. Sizable investment – $ 50 to $ 100 million – is
probably needed in the supply systems for biomass harvesting, collection, storage
and transport to supply a 1 million dt year–1 to a biorefinery [1]. Who will make
these investments – the farmer, the potential processor, or a biomass supplier that
aggregates individual growers? Current supply systems for grain like corn and
wheat are highly evolved and efficient infrastructures and may provide valuable
extensions. Existing grain elevators may serve as collection points for biomass.
Local conditions determine the potential feedstock quantities. Areas capable
of providing large supplies have been identified – but like commercializing an
idea, much work remains between knowing the location of promising biorefin-
ery sites and reliably supplying them with economic, sustainable feedstock.
14.2
Historical Outline
Commercial ventures that require large quantities of crop residues have a mixed
history of success. Collected material has found more use as co-products than
those that remain in the field after harvest. For example, corn fiber is mixed
with steepwater and sold as corn gluten feed with a nutrient value 1.1 times
cracked corn for ruminant animals [8]. Bagasse has a long history and is dis-
cussed in Case Study 2.2. Small quantities like rice hulls offer little economic
incentive to develop markets, therefore most remains to be disposed of, often
by burning as a fuel or simply land applied [9].
For biomass left in the field – stover, straw and grasses – collection and trans-
portation cost increases the economic hurdle. In areas of the world lacking
trees, non wood fiber is pulped, producing quality papers [10]. They make a rel-
atively poor animal feed because of low protein content [8] and their use as a
fuel is limited by their composition, especially the low thermal content com-
pared with coal and natural gas.
14.2 Historical Outline 319
During the last decade the list of unsuccessful ventures using bagasse, grass,
straw, and stover for particle board has grown by more than a dozen [11, 12].
This mixed record hinders enthusiasm among many growers and others to con-
sider feedstock collection as a viable route for biomass commercialization.
14.2.1
Case Study: Harlan, Iowa Corn Stover Collection Project
The largest recent corn stover collection project was undertaken in Harlan, Iowa
in 1996 by Great Lakes Chemical. Modern collection methods – self loading and
unloading wagons and high speed, over the road tractors – were used to reduce
feedstock cost for the production of furfural [13, 14]. The stover revenue to the
farmer was $ 3 to $ 12 dt–1, depending on the hauling distance (Table 14.2).
Total feedstock requirements were approximately 100 000 dt per year. A collec-
tion center for approximately 50% of the total was constructed in Harlan, Iowa,
USA, in 1996. The facility sampled and weighed all deliveries, then stacked
bales for storage. During the year bales were removed from storage, milled, pel-
letized, and loaded into trailers and trucked 90 km to the furfural plant.
The first year was a learning experience for all. Meetings with local producers
were held, and many showed interest in collecting stover for added income, and
as a way to remove most of it so the soil would warm in the spring for seed ger-
mination without having to plow. The amount collected complied with soil ero-
sion guidelines. But at the conclusion little stover was delivered. Great Lakes
had left the collection with the farmers who mostly used their resources for har-
vesting the corn grain, not baling.
The second year Great Lakes employed contract balers and haulers, matching
them up with the farmers and the result was an overwhelming collection suc-
cess. More than 400 farmers committed 20 000 ha of their corn fields. Thirty
plus custom harvesters were contracted to perform the baling.
Self loading and unloading wagons pulled by high speed tractors were used
for bale transport (Fig. 14.1). The bales were collected in the field – 17 round
bales, approximately 9.5 dt – in less than 20 min. The wagon traveled at high-
way speeds, up to 90 km h–1, en route to the collection center. At the collection
center the load was weighed, sampled for moisture, and unloaded. In less than
10 min the driver was on the way to the next field.
a)
b)
Fig. 14. 2 Corn stover bale storage.
14.2 Historical Outline 321
14.2.2
Case Study: Bagasse Storage – Dry or Wet?
Bagasse, the biomass remaining from sugar cane after the sucrose-containing
juice has been extracted, has been used by the pulp and paper industry for
more than a century [10]. It incurs no collection cost and competes favorably
with wood pulp in a global market. The bagasse exits the mill with about 50%
moisture. For stable storage it must be below 20% or above 60%.
In the early 1920s the sugar cane industry investigated ways to store bagasse
for processing to particleboard and pulp. Particleboard processors preferred dry
material. Pulp mills readily accepted wet material.
Although this dry storage method was used for more than 40 years [17], a
change to wet storage occurred in the 1960s because of increasing recognition
of its advantages:
· The bales were relatively small, weighing 115 kg “as is”.
· Mechanical handling was slow and costly.
· The bales had to be precisely stacked to vent fumes and dissipate heat.
· Procedures were labor-intensive.
· Several months were required to dry bales from 50 to 20% moisture.
· Fire loss and increasing fire insurance costs.
14.2 Historical Outline 323
14.3
Biomass Value
Lacking large uses of crop residues, studies have not addressed the impact of re-
moval of stover [21] and straw [22] on soil quality, although several implications
can be drawn [23]. An environmental and economic balance is required for suf-
ficient retention of residues to avoid erosion losses and maintain soil quality,
while economically removing excess residue as biomass feedstocks. The impact
of different levels of surface removal depends on local conditions and practices.
Maintaining this balance is key for success.
14.3.1
Soil Quality
Agricultural residues provide a key role in maintaining soil quality. Surface cov-
er is needed to prevent wind and water erosion, retain soil moisture, recycle nu-
trients from the plant back to the soil, and support assorted life. When residue
is removed, reduced inputs from the residue to the soil can result in a negative
flux from the soil and a loss of soil organic matter, SOM, and other nutrients
leading to a breakdown of soil structure.
The amount of excess is a complex question. It depends on local factors like
soil type, cropping practice, weather, and topography. For example, in some dry
areas surface cover is required to retain moisture, mostly in western areas of
the grain belt [24]. Further east, surface cover is given as a major reason for til-
ling, because the cover prevents the cold, wet soils from warming in the spring,
delaying planting and reducing yield [25]. Recycling nutrients from the plant,
especially P and K, back to the soil reduces the need for replacement. Converse-
ly, in areas where manure is used, the P contained in the soil may already be
too high, resulting in excessive run-off that contributes to algae formation in
ponds and streams [26]. Surface cover provides shelter and food for many or-
ganisms – microbial and larger. Their contribution to the humic pool is impor-
tant, but they also shelter destructive weed seeds, pests, and toxins that can
harm the next crop [27].
Models are under development to better measure soil quality. For example,
agricultural ecosystem models like Century, DayCent, and Cstore show some
beneficial effects of removing residue while still meeting constraints of soil and
wind erosion. Namely, nitrate leaching decreases tenfold in some situations and
nitrous oxide emissions (a potent greenhouse gas) are also significantly reduced.
These models can be used with actual field measurements for guidance in se-
lecting among alternatives that best balance economic and environmental bene-
fits [28]. Using field measurements with the soil conditioning index will show if
the crop practice is correctly managing soil carbon and is recommended [29].
14.3 Biomass Value 325
14.3.2
Farmer Value
Most farmers are forced to manage crop residues in place. Present markets are
negligible for straw and corn stover. Less than 5% is used for animal bedding
and feed, with the major portion used on the site and then recycled as soiled
bedding or manure. Some growers have historically rented harvested corn fields
for grazing, charging $ 12 to $ 25 ha–1. This practice is declining as combines
have become more efficient, lodging is less with Bt corn, and cattle ranching
has grown more “factory-like” with heavy dependence on large feedlots.
If residue were removed, the phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) content in
straw and stover will eventually need to be replaced. The composition is typical-
ly 0.1% P and 1% K, valued at $ 3.50 dt–1 [6]. The N fertilizer value is more
complex, and depends on crop rotation and local conditions. Reduced field
operations are estimated to reduce inputs $ 24 ha–1 for preparation of the seed
bed [30].
Carbon credits are likely to add additional economic incentive for US farmers.
Reducing tillage or no-till sequesters about 0.3 to 0.5 metric tons C equiv ha–1.
The increased soil carbon improves yields, and this benefit continues with each
crop year. Eventually, over decades, soil carbon equilibrium is achieved. In the
European Union, carbon is currently trading for about $ 35 per ton C equiv. A
small, voluntary greenhouse gas trading market has been established for agri-
cultural carbon sequestration as part of the Chicago Board of Trade, the Chicago
Climate Exchange [31]. Recent efforts to move US policy in this direction call
for a $ 26 per ton of C-equivalent credit that would fund renewable fuels re-
search and development [32].
Reducing N fertilizer use is also possible, depending on crop rotation. Mi-
crobes desire a 10 : 1 ratio of C/N for breaking down residue. Because the C/N
ratio of straw and stover is 40 to 70 : 1 , 10 kg N fertilizer addition per ton of re-
sidue is typically recommended to avoid denitrification of the next crop. For
250 ha of 9 dt ha–1 corn (170 bu acre–1), 30 to 40 tons of N fertilizer may be
avoided. In addition to the out-of-pocket costs, environmental benefits include
reducing N run-off to streams and groundwater, and reducing greenhouse gas –
0.17 to 3.5 tons of N2O/100 tonnes applied – 5 to 100 tonnes C equiv ha–1 [33].
The economic benefit from selling stover to the farmer is summarized for
three production yields – 6.9 dt ha–1, 9.9 dt ha–1, and 10.6 dt ha–1 (130, 170, and
200 bu acre–1) in Table 14.3. More details are presented in Section 14.5. The ex-
ample uses the following values:
· delivered sale price is $ 33 dt–1
· moisture is 15% to adjust to dry basis
· harvest index of 0.5, a 1 : 1 ratio of grain to stover
· surface cover of 2.2 dt ha–1 left in the field,
· P and K fertilizer value of $ 3.50 dt–1 removed with the stover
· reduced field operations, $ 24 ha–1
· no credit for carbon sequestration or other inputs like N fertilizer.
326 14 Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
Table 14.3 Stover field value before transportation and collection cost, $ ha–1.
Production case 1 2 3
The net value in the field is $ 163 to $ 273 ha–1 before collection and transporta-
tion cost.
The net margin after Collection and transportation costs are determined is
given for two examples – typical baled stover collection (Table 14.4), and one-
pass collection (Table 14.5). Other costs like shrinkage or change in properties
of the feedstock in storage, storage investment, and operation, and relative qual-
ity of final feedstock processed are not included in the examples. There is a
large variation in these factors depending on the local situation.
Baled stover, Table 14.4, is trucked within a 50 km radius – an average 70 km
round trip using high speed tractors and “load and go wagons” as in Harlan,
IA. Baling and transport cost adds $ 25 dt–1, leaving the farmer a net margin of
$ 41 to $ 54 ha–1. A minimum $ 50 ha–1 return is most often cited to raise
grower interest [34, 35].
Table 14.4 Stover sale net to farmer, $ ha–1 W/custom bale and 50 km radius collection site.
Table 14.5 Sale net to farmer, $ ha–1, W/one-pass harvest and 3–25 km radius collection sites.
One pass collection of grain and stover, with stover trucked from field to one
of three collection centers within a 25 km radius – 35 km average round trip,
stored above 60% moisture, then transported via rail to the biorefinery – offers
more opportunity to reduce cost and reduce harvest risk [36]. Even with higher
transport cost, $ 13.50 vs $ 9.90 dt–1, the farmer’s net margin after delivery
ranges from $ 59 to $ 119 ha–1 (Table 14.5). The difference is greatest for fields
with high yields, with nearly twice the margin compared with baling.
One-pass harvest prototypes are under development, and further discussed in
Section 14.5.
14.3.3
Processor Value
Clean feedstock with consistent composition and properties are desired, but
more information remains to be provided by the processors. Because dirt, inorgan-
ics and ash add to the processing cost, and higher cellulose and hemicellulose con-
tent can increase yields, feedstock pricing based on composition and ease of pro-
cessing is expected to emerge, not paying just per dry ton. Rapid analytical meth-
ods for compositional analysis are under development and are expected to be va-
lidated and available for incorporating in a feedstock payment program [39].
14.4
Sustainable Removal
Removing residues from the soil depletes the amount available for replenish-
ment for nutrients and increases the possibility of erosion. Compensating for
this will probably require revising some present agronomic practices. For exam-
ple, leaving anchored stubble, 20 cm or more above the crown may suffice in
some areas to control erosion, especially with narrow planting rows, e.g. 40 cm
compared with 80 cm, the most prevalent practice for corn rows. This and other
contemplated needs are discussed in this section.
With a biorefinery, the excess is removed, processed into fuels – and “di-
gested” by the autos – the CO2 exits from the auto’s exhaust, instead of being
exuded from microbes in the field. The benefits are huge, BUT only when this
is conducted in a sustainable manner by controlling erosion and maintaining
soil quality, especially soil organic material (SOM).
14.4.1
Soil Organic Material
Tilling causes loss of SOM, an important measure of soil quality. If too much
stover is removed or a cover crop is not planted that adds to the biomass, SOM
can be depleted. SOM is more strongly affected by below-ground residues (i.e.
roots), with above-ground residue contributing less to SOM formation. Studies
at the National Soil Tilth Laboratory shows 80% or more of the surface material
is lost as CO2 within months, and three times the amount of SOM comes from
roots compared with surface material [40].
The tillage effect on soil carbon loss after corn harvest is shown for various
field operations in Fig. 14.6 [41].
The CO2 flux emitted from the soil is shown for various cases over time. The
amount of loss depends on the amount of disturbance – more exposure, more
oxidation of the organic material and more lost soil carbon. The bottom line in
the figure shows normal soil respiration as microbes and other organisms in
the soil and on the soil surface emit CO2 as they digest biomass carbohydrates
and lignin. The top line shows the highest loss when plowing the soil – an ini-
tial burst of CO2 occurs as the plow rips open the soil and the anaerobic soil en-
vironment is exposed to oxygen in the air.
14.4 Sustainable Removal 329
14.4.2
Soil Erosion Control
For example, using the USDA water-erosion model, revised universal loss
equation (RUSLE), and wind erosion equation (WEQ), the variation in required
erosion cover for selected counties in the top corn-producing states – Illinois,
Iowa, and Nebraska – are shown in Table 14.6. Wheat is included, because irri-
gated wheat yields enough to warrant straw collection in Peoria County, IL, Jas-
per County, IA, and Rock County, NE [43]. Unless wheat is irrigated, much of
the wheat yield on dry land is below 2.2 dt ha–1, negating any straw removal.
Even with no till, economic quantities are difficult unless yields approach corn,
8 to 10 dt ha–1.
The historic tillage practices for corn and wheat for the US are summarized
in Tables 14.7 and 14.8. The values are based on a nationwide survey conducted
by the Conservation Technology Information Center (CTIC) [44]. Table 14.7
shows about 20% of corn is no-tilled or ridge-tilled, enabling efficient collection.
More than 80% of farmers employ some form of tillage to manage surface
residues, with 60% of corn fields conventionally tilled. This has become a larger
task as yields have increased. In 1960, corn belt states averaged 3.6 tons ha–1. In
2003 the yield had increased to 10.0 tons ha–1.
Adapting to no-till corn will be easier in many areas when some of the stover
is economically collected, especially in the northern parts of the corn belt where
cold moist soils can delay germination in the spring. Each day delayed is 25 kg
corn grain lost according to local lore. Most corn growers till for removing, i.e.,
burying, corn stover to induce spring soil warming.
Table 14.6 County-level stover and straw cover required for water and wind erosion.
No till 18 17 16 18 19
Mulch 22 23 23 19 16
Ridge till 3 3 3 2 2
Conventional 60 60 61 63 64
14.4 Sustainable Removal 331
No till 5 7 9 10 11
Mulch 25 24 23 20 16
Conventional 69 69 68 70 73
For wheat, less than 10% of the acres are no-till (Table 14.8). Weed control of
wheat is the primary reason for tillage. Changing to no-till wheat is slowly gain-
ing favor, increasing from 5% in 1994 to 11% in 2002. But conventional till has
increased 4% over the same period, despite higher fuel costs for field opera-
tions. Evidently, the new investment in no-till equipment, $ 70 000 to $ 150 000,
coupled with low commodity prices is a significant obstacle to changing.
14.4.3
Cover Crops
Cover crops can offset the erosion effect from collecting residues by restoring
the surface cover, reducing wind and water erosion. Cover crops can also im-
prove soil quality: their additional biomass builds SOM, especially from their
roots. Cover crops also choke out weeds and may retain N in its root system
over the winter, thereby reducing N2O emissions and nitrate leaching [45].
Cover crops require a higher level of management. Important factors for con-
sideration include:
· Selecting appropriate cover crops to fit in the rotation to avoid allelopathic ef-
fects, inhibition of growth in one species of plants by chemicals produced by
other species
· Planning to ensure enough growth occurs to provide the above benefits.
Broadcast seeding may be used for the current crop to give it a timely start,
and care must be taken not to hinder its growth during that crop’s harvest
· Cover crop harvesting or killing growth needs to consider soil moisture condi-
tions. It can deplete needed soil moisture in a dry spring, or if left to grow
longer in a wet spring, deplete excess soil moisture
· Growth must be stopped for some cover crops like rye before it goes to seed
or it will interfere with future cash crops.
Establishing local, credible test plots to investigate the impact of residue re-
moval for various cropping practices is important to provide information to both
the grower and the processor.
332 14 Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
14.5
Innovative Methods for Collection, Storage and Transport
Most previous studies focus on collecting and baling dry material after the grain
harvest. Grain is the cash crop and is at risk until safely collected and stored.
Collecting, storing, and transporting bulky straw and stover is secondary. Addi-
tional field operations add cost and increase risk.
Straw is normally dry enough to bale, but corn stover must dry from 30–50%
moisture to less than 20%. Feedstock drying and densification methods can re-
duce collection delays and increase density. These approaches may be appropri-
ate when a dry, compacted material is desired for co-firing or for thermo-chemi-
cal processes. These operations increase cost to $ 50 dt–1 or more, however [46].
Densification inhibits wet processing and pellets need to be “reconstituted” by
soaking in water to shorten digestion time for hydrolysis.
One-pass harvest of corn grain and stover, wet storage, and transport to the
processor seem to be advantageous where wet feedstock is acceptable, as already
shown in Tables 14.4 and 14.5. Custom bailing and transporting bales from the
field to a processing point within a 50 km has a relative return of $ 41–$ 54 ha–1
depending on the production. One-pass harvest and transport to 3–25 km collec-
tion centers for storage and then supplying the processing plant from these
sites is estimated to increase margins to $ 59–$119 ha–1, a 44 to 118% im-
provement. The relative difference between custom baling and one-pass harvest
with wet storage and transport for the farmer is shown in Table 14.9.
These cost comparisons are relative. Other costs like shrinkage or change in
properties of the feedstock in storage, storage investment and operation, and
relative quality of final feedstock processed are not included. There is a large
variation in these factors depending on the local situation. These are addressed
in the following sub-sections.
14.5.1
Collection
Collection choices are divided into two general categories, baling the residue fol-
lowing harvest or one-pass collection of both grain and residue.
Case 1 2 3
14.5.1.1 Baling
Many studies have been made of baling biomass on a large scale. For straw, bal-
ing is an option. Cereal grains, like winter wheat, are grown in dryer areas and
mature earlier than corn, enabling a longer harvest window. When cereal grain
is ready to harvest, straw moisture is usually suitable for collection. In contrast,
stover is typically too high in moisture, 30 to 50%. It must remain in the field
to dry and be collected later. To speed drying, some flail the stalk. Raking is
then required before baling, adding more cost, increasing the foreign matter,
especially dirt, in the bales and compacting the soil. A wet harvest season can
prevent its collection entirely, because of wet residue [13].
For industrial feedstock, baling only adds cost, $ 15 dt–1 or more at the field
[30]. Bales also add cost at the processor for additional equipment and disposal
of twine, wrap and foreign contamination [38].
Local requirements will vary. In areas where soybeans and corn rotate, the needs
are different from wheat and corn or other crop rotations. For wheat, stripper
headers work well now, leaving a standing stalk that is clean and readily harvested.
334 14 Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
ha Hours Fixed Direct Total cost Case 4.1, Case 4.2, Case 4.3,
1.8 ha h–1 cost cost +15% 7 dt ha–1 9 t ha–1 11 dt ha–1
Some areas may be satisfied with one take off, separating the grain and other
components of the field. Others may desire to use existing equipment, but at
the same speed, separating the grain from the stover in the field. One design of-
fers three field separation possibilities as cobs offer commercial value as a car-
rier for herbicides and other chemicals, cat litter, and metal-polishing applica-
tions.
Development cost for a new design is $ 2 million or more for prototypes, with
millions more required to bring to market. The definition of the customer’s
needs, regional differences, market size uncertainty and the cyclical economic
performance of this industry makes significant up-front development beyond
paper studies difficult to justify until the market for machine sales exist. With-
out subsidizing development, a “chicken and egg” dilemma exists.
14.5.2
Storage
14.5.2.1 Density
The dry density of bales is about half that of wet stored material, ranging be-
tween 112 kg m3 for round bales to 160 kg m–3 for square bales. Wet storage
density depends on the stack height, with 40 meters achieving 200 kg m–3 aver-
age pile density [52].
storage period. The loss in solubles during storage is shown in Fig. 14.7, declin-
ing from 10 to 3% within weeks, and fresh bagasse having 7% less solubles for
the five trials.
The pentosans and holocellulose, which consists of the alpha-cellulose plus the
hemicelluloses, continue to increase over a longer period (Figs. 14.8 and 14.9).
14.5.3
Transport
During harvest, existing resources are stretched just collecting and transporting
the grain in the field while keeping the combines operating continuously. In-
creasing the resources to accommodate up to 2.5 to 3 times that quantity from
the filed is a serious increase.
338 14 Biomass Commercialization and Agriculture Residue Collection
Truck Transport Truck transport has long been favored for both wet and dry ma-
terials for short distances. Dry material is bulky and flammable. Flaming trailers
in transit are a serious hazard, especially in populated areas. Depending on bio-
mass density and local regulations, the dimensional limits for road transport
may be exceeded before the weight limit is reached. Because trucking cost is based
on distance, $ 1.00 to $ 1.50 km–1, less than a full weight load results in higher
cost. For example, round bale transport using load-and-go wagons was just 9 dt
per trailer load, a transport cost twice that of a full load, normally 18.2 tons.
Wet material from storage can be passed through a dewatering press and re-
duced to 50% moisture before transporting. It is perishable with this moisture
content and requires timely delivery. Full truck loads are readily achieved, but
14.6 Establishing Feedstock Supply 339
50% water results in the same pay load as the load-and-go wagon. The water
volume requires management.
Rail Transport Rail shipments for short distances have become feasible as a result
of improved practices, especially when shipments remain on the same line of a
regional railroad. With multiple collection points along the rail line, the collection
area for the biorefinery can be more than doubled. Moving a rail car 100 to 300
miles is $ 150 to $ 250 with little regard to weight [57]. The cost of rail transit
was estimated to be $ 3.00 to $ 5.00 dt–1 for transporting feedstock several hundred
miles. Modeling shows conversion costs drop 30% for a 4 million dt plant.
Rail shipment of dry material has the associated fire liability issue. The high-
er weight limits make wet feedstock shipments possible at lower cost. Maxi-
mum load per car is usually 114 tonnes, 91 tonnes net, to accommodate grain
shipments.
Truck traffic increases with increased plant size while rail car shipments are
more manageable. Assuming 50 car unit trains traveling at 50 km h–1 (off the
main line), approximately 1.5 min is required for the train to pass a road cross-
ing. In contrast, when the truck delivery is limited to just 10 hours each day
and 6 days per week, the truck traffic just from feedstock delivery is 50 to 60
trucks in and out every hour for a 1 million dt plant. Storing 1/3 of the feedstock
on site reduces the value accordingly, but the disruption is still substantial.
Trucks are assumed to carry maximum loads (Table 14.12).
14.6
Establishing Feedstock Supply
At the present time in the US, the dairy herd feed lots in Jerome County Idaho
purchase about 1 million dt of straw from the surrounding irrigated barley and
wheat fields with yields often exceeding 10 dt grain ha–1. Grower participation
and infrastructure evolved over years. It is 20 times the largest corn stover col-
lection effort in Harlan, IA. Establishing a reliable feedstock supply system re-
quires substantial investment, planning and outreach to the growers and other
stakeholders.
14.6.1
Infrastructure
model. Local growers already deal with them for their grain business [14]. Ac-
counts are in place, and their managers are skilled in logistics issues. Feedstock
from other areas could also be sourced.
14.7
Perspectives and Outlook
References
1 J. DiPardo, Outlook for Biomass Ethanol Number: 01-16075, 2001 ASAE Annual
Production and Demand, DOE EIA, International Meeting, http://www.mea-
2002,http://www.eia.doe.gov/oiaf/analy- dowoodindustries.com/asae_paper.htm
sispaper/biomass.html 12 D. Lengel, Ag-Fiber Dot Gone: A Litany
2 The Vision for Bioenergy and Biobased of Failure. Panel World July 2001: 8–9,
Products in the United States, October 34–38.
2002, http://www.bioproducts-bioenergy.- 13 D. Glassner, David, James Hettenhaus,
gov/pdfs/BioVision_03_Web.pdf Tom Schechinger, Corn Stover Collection
3 USDA National Agriculture Statistics Project, Bioenergy ’98, Expanding Bioe-
Service nergy Partnerships, Madison, WI, 1998
4 S.W. Fitzpatrick, Commercialization of 14 J. Hettenhaus, T. Schechinger, Corn
the Biofine technology for levulinic acid Stover Harvest: Grower, Custom Opera-
production from paper sludge, DOE/CE/ tor and Processor Issues and Answers,
41178, April 2002 www.osti.gov/gpo/serv- Oak Ridge National Laboratory Contract
lets/purl/771246-zVDe5D/native/ 4500008274, 1999.
5 M. E. Walsh, R. L. Perlack, A. Turhollow, 15 J. Hettenhaus, T. Schechinger, Improved
D. de la Torre Ugarte, D. A. Becker, R. L. Corn Stover Harvest & Collection Meth-
Graham, S. E. Slinsky, and D. E. Ray, Bio- ods, 3rd Annual AgFiber Technology
mass Feedstock Availability in the Unit- Showcase, Memphis, TN, October 2000
ed States: 1999 State Level Analysis, Jan- 16 E. Lathrop, C. Elbert and B. Treadway,
uary, 2000 Ind. Eng. Chem. 26:594–598, 1934.
6 Biobased Industrial Products: Priorities 17 H. Hay and Lathrop, E. C. Storage of
for Research and Commercialization, Crop Fibers and Preservation of their
National Research Council, National Properties. TAPPI Technical Association
Academy Press, Washington, D.C. 1999 Papers, Series XXIV. P 412–418, 1941.
7 A. Aden, A., M. Ruth, K. Ibsen, J. Je- 18 J. Salaber and Maza. Ritter Biological
chura, K. Neeves, J. Sheehan, B. Wallace, Treatment Process for Bagasse Bulk Stor-
L. Montague, A. Slayton, J. Lukas, Ligno- age. TAPPI Non-wood Plant Fiber Pulp-
cellulosic Biomass to Ethanol Process ing Progress Report, No 2, October
Design and Economics Utilizing Co-Cur- 1971.
rent Dilute Acid Prehydrolysis and Enzy- 19 J. Moebius, The Storage and Preserva-
matic Hydrolysis for Corn Stover, Na- tion of Bagasse in Bulk Form, Without
tional Renewable Energy Laboratory, Baling. Pulp and Paper Development in
NREL/TP-510-324328, June 2002. Africa and Near East, United Nations,
8 T. Klopfenstein (1996) Crop residue as N.Y. Volume II, 1966.
an animal feed. p. 315–340. In: P. Unger 20 J. Bruin, Gonin, C., McMaster, L., and
(ed.), Managing agricultural residues. Morgan, R., Wet Bulk Storage of Ba-
Lewis Pub., Boca Raton, FL gasse. Proc. Intern, Soc. of Sugar Cane
9 Cooperative Research Centre for Sustain- Tech. (ISSCT) XV Congress: 1793–1820,
able Rice Production Annual Report, 1974.
2004 21 L. Mann, Tolbert, V. and Cushman, J.
10 J. Atchison, Review of Progress with Ba- (2002) Potential environmental effects of
gasse for Use In Industry (A review of corn (Zea mays L.) stover removal with
progress in purchasing, handling, stor- emphasis on soil organic matter and ero-
age and preservation of bagasse). J. E. sion. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Envi-
Proc. Intern. Soc. Sugar Cane Technolo- ronment 89:149–166.
gists 14:1202–1217 (1971) 22 M. Stumborg, L. Townley-Smith, and E.
11 K. E. Gorzell, Finding an Economic and Coxworth (1995) Crop residue export-
Environmental Balance to the Technol- issues and concerns. Innovations in
ogy of Producing Building Materials Straw Utilization Symp, Oct 23–25.
from Agricultural Crop Residue, Paper 1995, Winnipeg, Manitoba. Agriculture
References 343
345
15
The Corn Wet Milling and Corn Dry Milling Industry –
A Base for Biorefinery Technology Developments
Donald L. Johnson
15.1
Introduction
15.1.1
Corn – Wet and Dry Milling – Existing Biorefineries
Corn dry milling has existed for hundreds of years – maize was ground with
stones into flour for food consumption by early American populations. Modern
corn refining, however, began in the mid 1800s when Thomas Kingsford started
up his corn refining plant in Oswego, New York [1].
Corn refining is distinguished from corn milling in that the refining process
separates the corn grain into its components, starch, fiber, protein, and oil, and
further processes the starch into a substantial number of products. Corn “wet
milling” is the aqueous slurry process by which the corn grain is separated into
its component parts. Corn “dry milling”, in contrast, physically alters moist corn
granules into composite products such as flakes, grits, meal, flour, and hominy
feed, although some operations do separate germ and recover oil. The dry
milling process produces food and industrial products based on flakes, meal,
and flour, and also fermentation ethanol.
Specialty products such as white corn flour for food uses and yellow corn
flour-based adhesives, produced by what are termed the flour millers, are a
small part, less than ten percent, of the industrial market [2] and will not be dis-
cussed further here. Those interested in the topic are referred to texts available
on the subject [3].
Corn refining has been the fastest growing market for US agriculture over
the past 25 years. This is attributed to the burgeoning high-fructose corn sweet-
ener market early in the period, followed by rapid growth in fuel alcohol, and,
more recently, by fermentation products. Corn refiners now use over 14% of
the annual corn crop [4], exceeding 39 million metric tons (MT) of corn refined
each year.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
346 15 The Corn Wet Milling and Corn Dry Milling Industry
15.2
The Corn Refinery
15.2.1
Wet Mill Refinery
A corn refinery can be described succinctly in five process steps, but is substan-
tially more complicated in operation. Corn grain that has been received by truck
and/or rail is inspected for moisture content and debris, passed through clean-
ers to remove foreign material and steeped in large tanks. Steeped corn is
coarsely ground to loosen and free the low-density germ which is removed by
centrifugation from the starch and fiber slurry. A second grind releases starch
and gluten from the fibrous hulls, the fiber is further washed to remove resid-
ual starch and sent to a feedhouse. The low-density gluten is removed by centri-
fugation and a battery of cyclone cleaners washes residual protein from the
starch. The 99.5+ percent pure “refined” starch is ready for further processing.
Germ, which was removed early in the process, is subjected to further proces-
sing to remove the oil, which can be refined or sold as crude corn oil. The spent
germ is combined with the fiber from the second grind, dried, and sold as corn
gluten feed. The gluten is dried and sold as a 60% protein-feed supplement.
“Wet milling” is so named because the corn is steeped in slightly acidic warm
water and is processed as an aqueous slurry until dried or solubilized in down-
stream processing.
15.2.2
Dry Mill Refinery
A dry mill, or “mash,” ethanol plant, is a simpler process. Corn is received and
cleaned as in the wet mill, but the clean corn is tempered with steam, ground,
and wetted to a free flowing “mash,” from which the name is derived. The
mash is superheated in a continuous cooker, to which acid and/or enzymes are
added to solubilize the starch in the corn meal. Additional water is added to ad-
just the solids and temperature, and saccharifying enzymes are added. This
mash is added to a fermenter, adjusted to appropriate solids and temperature,
and yeasts are added to convert the sugars to alcohol. When the fermentation is
complete, alcohol is removed by distillation and the residual “still bottoms” are
recovered for animal feed. In such a plant, the only two products are ethanol
and distillers dried grains and solubles (DDGS). Some plants now separate the
germ before “mashing” – the added cost is justified by the value of the oil recov-
ered.
A wet mill corn refinery and a dry mill ethanol plant are compared in a pro-
cess flow schematic diagram of Fig. 15.1. As might be expected, the capital in-
vestment for a mash ethanol plant is significantly lower than that of a corn re-
finery. The operating profits from the multitude of products normally oversha-
dow the investment cost differences, however; this will be discussed later.
15.2 The Corn Refinery 347
15.2.3
Waste Water Treatment
Another common feature of wet and dry mills is, as indicated in Fig. 15.1, the
waste water treatment required. Both operations, but especially wet milling, are
water-intensive processes. A corn refinery may require two hundred to two hun-
dred fifty gallons per bushel of corn (a bushel is defined as 56 pounds (25.45
kilograms) of corn at 15.5 percent moisture) processed, most of it as process
water that is vaporized, condensed, heated, and cooled needing very little treat-
ment before being returned to its source. But five to ten percent contains organ-
ic material which must be treated before discharge into the environment. Meet-
ing local, state and federal regulations for liquid wastes may add more than
10% to the total plant investment [5]. The corn milling industry and its equip-
ment suppliers work diligently to minimize water usage.
348 15 The Corn Wet Milling and Corn Dry Milling Industry
15.3
The Modern Corn Refinery
15.3.1
Background and Definition
The modern corn refinery is a model for developing future biorefineries. Corn
refining has been compared with petroleum refining wherein flexibility of
downstream processing is used to maximize profitability [6]. Thus the focus of
this chapter is on wet milling, with some reference for comparative purposes to
mash ethanol plants.
Corn refining produces several products in large volume. As already men-
tioned, wet milling refines the corn into four components, starch (carbohy-
drate), gluten (protein), hull (fiber), and germ (corn oil). Moreover, the carbohy-
drate fraction, which is nearly 70 percent of the corn composition, is further
processed and refined into products such a native starch, modified starch, dex-
trose, high fructose corn sweetener (HFCS), ethanol, glucose syrup, and special
hydrolyzates.
15.3.2
Technologies and Products
In the United States, the largest producer and miller of corn in the world, plant
capacities are rated in bushels per day. Refineries in the US range in grind ca-
pacity from 55 000 bushels/day (14 000 MT/day) to more than 550 000 bushels/
day (14 000 MT/day) [6]. A metric ton of corn grain yields, on average, 684 kg
starch, 237 kg corn gluten feed (CGF), 45 kg gluten meal (60% protein) and
34 kg corn oil in a typical wet milling operation. Thus the largest corn refinery
produces more than 5 million metric tons of pure carbohydrate per year to be
sold as such and further processed into a myriad of refined products.
The wet milling process, as alluded to earlier, is a countercurrent aqueous
slurry process. The aqueous stream, called mill water, begins as fresh water en-
tering the final washing step of the pure granular starch stream, flows backward
through several recycle loops in intermediate processes, and exits from the
freshest corn steeping tank as heavy steep water. The solid phase, beginning as
corn kernels, flows from a steep tank forward through the separation processes
as components are removed and exits the final washing step as a pure granular
starch slurry.
Steeping is accomplished by conveying corn grain into large steep tanks
where it is exposed to warm water (circa 122 8F, 50 8C) for 30 to 40 h. A small
amount of sulfur dioxide is added to maintain approximately 0.2% concentra-
tion to control bacterial growth. The corn kernels soften, loosening the hulls
and disrupting gluten–starch bonds as the slightly acidic water diffuses into the
swelling kernels. Steeping is currently a semi-continuous countercurrent pro-
cess. Process water to which sulfur dioxide is added enters the first of a train of
15.3 The Modern Corn Refinery 349
steep tanks, each holding as much as 3000 to 5000 bushels (76 to 127 MT) of
corn kernels. The steepwater flows continuously through the train while tanks
of steeped corn are sequentially removed from the front end and fresh corn
tanks added at the back. Flow rates are adjusted to provide the appropriate
steeping time. Water exiting the final tank has been exposed to the corn the
longest whereas the corn in that tank has been exposed to the steepwater the
shortest time. The fully steeped tanks are drained and the kernels are sluiced to
the first, or coarse, grind.
Steeping process improvements have been proposed with the objective of
shortening steeping time, eliminating sulfur dioxide, and other cost reductions
[7] but none has yet been incorporated to any extent.
Steeping yields an additional product, corn-steep liquor (CSL). This nutrient
rich product can be concentrated for sale as condensed fermented corn extractives,
more commonly called concentrated steep liquor. Steep liquor that is not used
internally (called thin steep liquor if it has not been concentrated) as a fermen-
tation nutrient or sold to other users as CSL, is combined with corn germ meal
(germ from which the oil has been extracted) and hulls, the composite consti-
tuting CGF.
Hydrocyclones remove the low-density corn germ from the coarsely ground
slurry in the germ separation process. The germ of each kernel contains about
85% of the kernels’ oil. Germ is thoroughly washed over bent screens to remove
residual starch, then dried and subjected to mechanical and chemical proces-
sing to remove the oil. The oil is further processed into either crude or refined
corn oil, and the spent germ combined with hulls and steep liquor as described
above.
The degermed slurry is subjected to more extensive grinding in attrition mills
to free the starch and gluten from the fibrous hull of the kernels. Slurry from
the grinding mills flows over concave “bent” screens. The slotted screens enable
starch and gluten particles to flow through, but not the fiber, effectively separat-
ing the fiber from the starch–gluten slurry. The fiber is rewashed to optimize
starch–gluten recovery and combined with spent germ and CSL as already de-
scribed.
The starch–gluten slurry is centrifuged to remove the gluten (light phase)
from the starch water slurry. Gluten, containing 60% protein is dried, and mar-
keted primarily as a premium animal feed ingredient. The starch is subjected to
exhaustive countercurrent washing to remove protein to less than 0.5% in the
starch, commonly approximately 0.3% range. The last stage, in which the starch
is washed to 99.5% purity (some oil and trace minerals also remain), is the only
point in the milling process where fresh water is added. This essentially pure
carbohydrate stream is ready for further processing into starch products, syrups,
or fermentation products.
350 15 The Corn Wet Milling and Corn Dry Milling Industry
15.3.3
Refinery Economy
15.4
Carbohydrate Refining
15.5
Outlook and Perspectives
The modern corn refinery is a model for the application of biotechnology to the
production of fuels, chemicals, and materials from abundantly available natural
resources in a sustainable, environmentally acceptable manner. New commodity
chemicals and materials, capable of replacing non-renewable petroleum-derived
products are being developed and manufactured now from corn-derived glucose
in such refineries. Other biomass sources of glucose that are equally or more
abundantly available and potentially less expensive than corn can readily be in-
corporated into such a process environment as the technology for such utiliza-
tion is developed.
References
1 B. W. Peckham 2000, The First Hundred 3 See for example, P. White and L. A.
Years of Corn Refining in the United Johnson (eds.) 2004, Corn: Chemistry and
States, in Corn Annual 2000, Corn Refin- Technology, 2nd edn, American Associa-
ers Association, Washington, DC. tion of Cereal Chemists, Eagan Press.
2 United States Department of Agriculture 4 Corn Refiners Association 2003, Corn
2003, Economic Research Service, Feed Annual 2003, Washington, DC.
Outlook, January 2003 5 P. W. Madson, and J. E. Murtagh 1991,
Fuel Ethanol in USA: Review of Reasons
References 353
for 75% Failure Rate of Plants Built, In- ics, National Corn Growers Association
ternational Symposium on Alcohol Fuels, Corn Utilization Conference V, June
Firenze, 1991, available from Katzen In- 1994, unpublished.
ternational, Cincinnati, Ohio. 9 US Department of Agriculture, NASS,
6 L. R. Lynd 2002, Principal Investigator, Agricultural statistics board.
Strategic Biorefinery Analysis, NREL 10 US Department of Agriculture, Econom-
Subcontract ADZ-2-31086-01. ic Research Service.
7 J. Randall et al. 1978, USP 4,106,487.
8 R. Katzen et al. 1994, Ethanol from Corn
– State of the Art Technology and Econom-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part IV
Biomass Conversion: Processes and Technologies
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
357
16
Enzymes for Biorefineries
Sarah A. Teter, Feng Xu, Glenn E. Nedwin, and Joel R. Cherry
16.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
358 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
16.2
Biomass as a Substrate
16.2.1
Composition of Biomass
A vast carbon source for biobased products is locked up in plant matter, the
most abundant source of biomass on earth. The principal components of bio-
mass are cellulose (30–50%), hemicellulose (20–30%), and lignin (20–30%);
with starch, protein, and oils as minor components. The exact composition of
each biomass varies depending both on the plant and on the residue collected
(Table 16.1). The composition, in turn, determines the ease with which the bio-
mass can be converted to useful products and/or intermediates and affects the
functionality of the final product.
The complex polymeric structure of crystalline bundles of cellulose embedded
in a covalently linked matrix of hemicellulose and lignin poses a formidable
challenge for solubilization and conversion to monomeric sugars. As can be
seen in Table 16.1, the relative lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose content of a
variety of potential feedstocks is quite similar, yet even a 5% increase in lignin
or hemicellulose content can significantly alter accessibility to enzymatic attack.
Thus, the variation in the composition of a given biomass requires some tailor-
ing of the conversion method.
16.2.1.1 Cellulose
Cellulose is abundant in plant cell walls and comprises a linear beta-(1 ? 4) an-
hydroglucopyranose polymer (six-carbon sugars). The molecular weights of dif-
ferent celluloses can range from 200–2 000 kDa where the number of glucose
Source: http://www.eere.energy.gov/biomass/feedstock_databases.html
360 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
residues can exceed 15 000 per polymer molecule. Cellulose has such extensive
hydrogen bonding, because of the formation of overlapping, staggered flat
sheets, that it is a highly recalcitrant and water-insoluble crystalline material.
Within a cellulose chain, each d-glucosyl residue is rotated by approximately
1808 relative to its nearest neighbor residue, making cellobiose the repeating
unit present in cellulose. Only agents that can attack the glycosidic linkages
between the glucose residues or which can disrupt the hydrogen bonding can
solubilize cellulose.
16.2.1.2 Hemicellulose
Hemicelluloses are plant cell wall heteropolymeric sugars and sugar acids with
a backbone of 1,4-linked b-d-pyranosyls in which O4 is in the equatorial orienta-
tion. They are usually shorter than celluloses, typically containing fewer than
200 1,4 linkages, highly branched, and easily hydrolyzed by strong acid or base.
Hemicellulose serves as an interface between cellulose and lignin in plant cell
walls, and may form covalent and non-covalent linkages with other cell-wall
constituents, for example pectin, glucans and proteins. One major hemicellu-
lose is xyloglucan, a beta-(1 ? 4) linked polymer of xylose with mono-, di-, or tri-
glycosyl side-chains, via O6, composed of a variety of substituents, for example
acetyl, arabinosyl, or glucuronosyl units. Other hemicelluloses include xylan,
glucuronoxylan, arabinoxylan, mannan, glucomannan, and galactoglucoman-
nan.
16.2.1.3 Lignin
Lignin is a highly complex, amorphous and heterogeneous complex of substi-
tuted phenolic compounds, often comprising syringyl, guaiacyl, and p-hydroxy-
phenol components. It binds to hemicellulose and cellulose. Lignin is highly re-
sistant to enzymatic, chemical, and microbial hydrolysis because of its extensive
cross linking. It can, however, be pyrolyzed to form oil for fuel and resins.
16.2.1.4 Starch
Starch is composed of glucose, as a mixture of amylose and amylopectin in
varying ratios. Amylose is a linear alpha-(1 ? 4) d-glucopyranose polymer
whereas amylopectin has a similar structure but with additional side branches
of more than 20 glucose residues with alpha-(1 ? 6) linkages. Currently, corn
starch is the primary raw material of several major grain-based products, for ex-
ample ethanol, polylactide, plastics, some packing materials, and adhesives.
16.2 Biomass as a Substrate 361
16.2.1.5 Protein
Proteins are polymers of amino acids. In plants, proteins serve as structural,
functional, and regulatory agents. Catalytic proteins, the enzymes, are essential
for a variety of plant physiological activity.
16.2.2
Biomass Pretreatment
This usually means modifying or removing lignin, which not only acts as a
block to enzyme action by coating cellulose microfibrils in untreated biomass,
but also interferes with enzymatic hydrolysis by directly absorbing some cellu-
lose-active enzymes. The result of pretreatment is a cellulose with both im-
proved solvent accessibility and reduced lignin interference with enzyme action.
Numerous methods of biomass pretreatment have been described in the litera-
ture and are summarized below.
rates and temperatures, the lignin content is reduced by as much as 46% and
the process produces no significant amounts of compounds inhibitory to fer-
mentation [7, 8]. Although the hydrothermal process does not require the acid-
resistant reactor materials of acid pretreatment, this advantage may be offset by
increased water use and recovery costs.
16.3
Enzymes Involved in Biomass Biodegradation
16.3.1
Glucanases or Cellulases
16.3.2
Hemicellulases
On the basis of the products they form xylanases can be classified as endoxy-
lanases (EC 3.2.1.8) and b-xylosidases (EC 3.2.1.37). On the basis of sequence,
endoxylanases belong to the GH10 and GH11 families whereas b-xylosidases be-
long to GH3. Galacto/glucomannan-active mannanases can also be classified as
endomannanases (EC 3.2.1.78) and b-mannosidases (EC 3.2.1.25). Other hydro-
lases are active on other polysaccharides commonly found in biomass, for exam-
ple pectinase/polygalacturonase, arabinofuranohydrolase, arabinase, galactanase,
glucoronidase, and acetylesterase [21].
16.3.3
Nonhydrolytic Biomass-active Enzymes
16.3.4
Synergism of Biomass-degrading Enzymes
12]. Cellulosomes range from 0.5 to 50 megadaltons, and many cellulosomes can
further aggregate into polycellulosomes. The catalytic domains of cellulosomic en-
zymes are very similar to those of their non-complexed counterparts. Co-localiza-
tion of enzymes in a cellulosome may improve synergism by bringing necessary
components together within the same vicinity, but the organization gives the hy-
drolases limited mobility in comparison with the non-complexed cellulases. Never-
theless, the cellulolytic activity of the supramolecular cellulosome is comparable
with that of the multi-component, non-complexed fungal cellulase system [10].
An effective industrial cellulase preparation should include enzymes that can
“multi-task”, and the enzyme function should be collaborative and synergistic.
Several fungal cellulase preparations are available commercially but no bacterial
cellulase preparation has yet been produced industrially. Available cellulase
products, developed for detergent, textile, and other industries, are too expensive
for a viable biorefinery. The economic considerations of protein production led
us to choose Novozymes’s Celluclast 1.5L, produced by large scale batch fermen-
tation of T. reesei, as a starting point for developing the next generation of bio-
mass-targeting cellulase product. We focused on improving the activity of the T.
reesei cellulase system while maintaining its already high protein productivity
during fermentation. All studies were performed using acid-pretreated corn
stover (PCS) as the substrate.
16.4
Cellulase Development for Biomass Conversion
16.4.1
Optimization of the CBH-EG-BG System
16.4.1.1 BG Supplement
A “complete” cellulase system requires BG to hydrolyze cellobiose, a potent in-
hibitor of CBH and a precursor of fermentable glucose. Balancing the ratio of
CBH, EG, and BG is vital for improved cellulose hydrolysis. T. reesei secretes at
least two enzymes with BG activity at a very low level during normal cellulose-
induced growth. We observed that Celluclast hydrolyzed cellulose with improved
performance when assayed in a diafiltration–saccharification device which en-
ables continuous removal of small sugars by filtration, compared with a closed
vessel. Accumulation of CBH-inhibiting cellobiose in a closed vessel resulted in
a slowing down of the overall reaction [25]. We exogenously supplemented Cel-
luclast with an Aspergillus oryzae BG (belonging to the GH3 family). Addition of
small amounts of BG, present as a few percent of total protein, enabled us to
achieve equivalent conversion of cellulose in PCS with half the enzyme dosage
of the unsupplemented Cellulase mix (Fig. 16.1). By expressing the A. oryzae
BG in the T. reesei strain used to produce Celluclast 1.5L we were able to elimi-
nate the need to ferment BG separately.
16.4 Cellulase Development for Biomass Conversion 367
Fig. 16.3 Improved CBH I (Cel7A) variants the wild type (wt) is marked as a triangle
with enhanced activity at high temperatures. (s). The open circle (*) marks the position
Activity at moderate temperature (at which of a variant obtained by protein design.
the wild-type enzyme is stable) is plotted Closed diamonds (^) denote variants
against the ratio of activity at a thermally obtained from primary screens whereas open
challenging temperatures (at which the wild- squares (`) show variants obtained by
type is unstable) divided by activity at the rounds of shuffling from pools of primary
moderate temperature. The performance of variants.
16.4 Cellulase Development for Biomass Conversion 369
Because T. reesei CBH I has high specific activity on PCS at moderate tem-
perature, we tried to improve its thermal stability, using structure-based design
and directed molecular evolution. For structure-based rational design, we com-
pared the coding sequences of thermostable CBH with their less stable counter-
parts and modeled their structures, informed by the published structures of gly-
cosyl hydrolase domains [28–31]. This comparison revealed specific residues
that could be mutated to enhance thermostability, and several of these muta-
tions were created by site-directed mutagenesis. In addition, we generated ran-
dom mutations in the CBH I gene and identified variants with improved activ-
ity at elevated temperature. As a result of both approaches we identified several
substitutions in the CBH I gene that led to enhanced performance in hydrolyz-
ing a soluble cellulase substrate at high temperature. DNA shuffling, the pro-
cess of using recombination between genes with partial sequence identity, was
used to find favorable combinations of the identified substitutions and to elimi-
nate detrimental mutations [32] (Fig. 16.3).
We expressed several of our thermally improved CBH I variants in Trichoder-
ma host strains that lacked the native CBH I gene. Expression of the improved
variants was achieved at levels that approximated those found in the wild-type
parent strain, and their expression did not noticeably alter the levels of other
proteins in the T. reesei secretome. We assayed complete broths containing vari-
ant CBH I enzymes for hydrolysis of PCS at temperatures higher than the opti-
mal temperature for T. reesei native cellulases. Figure 16.4 shows that the pres-
ence of the variant CBH I improved the high-temperature saccharification of
Fig. 16.4 High-temperature hydrolysis by cel- lines, 55 8C hydrolysis; dotted lines, 60 8C hy-
lulase mix including variant CBH I. Sacchari- drolysis. Cellulases were used at equivalent
fication of pretreated corn stover by two Tri- protein loadings. Cellulose conversion was
choderma broths, one expressing the wild determined by measurement of reducing su-
type CBH I (“WT CBH I”) and one express- gars.
ing a CBH I variant (“Variant CBH I”). Solid
370 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
PCS over the wt strain. The selected variants failed to surpass wt T. reesei cellu-
lase mix at its optimum temperature (50 8C), however (data not shown).
In addition to CBH I, we also improved the thermal stability of A. oryzae BG
by directed molecular evolution. We screened for stabilized variants by measur-
ing enzyme residual activity after brief thermal denaturation at temperatures
that partially denature the wt enzyme. Several improved variants had better ther-
mal stability, as measured by assessing residual activity after a ten-minute ther-
mal challenge at 68 8C (Fig. 16.5).
16.4.2
Other Proteins Potentially Beneficial for Biomass Conversion
16.4.2.2 Hydrolases
The two CBH, six EG, and one BG known to be secreted by T. reesei belong to
eight GH families, representing approximately half of the GH families known
to include cellulases. It is possible that cellulases from other GH families could
be beneficial to T. reesei cellulolytic system, by providing either complementary
specificity, stronger synergism, reduced inhibition, enhanced reactivity, or in-
16.4 Cellulase Development for Biomass Conversion 373
16.5
Expression of Cellulases
Fig. 16.10 Signal peptide effect on BG secre- secreted fraction, using 4-nitrophenyl b-D-
tion in T. reesei. T. reesei strains were geneti- glucopyranoside at pH 5. B. SDS–PAGE of
cally modified to heterologously express A. secreted proteins from the two T. reesei
oryzae BG, either behind the native A. oryzae strains. The positions of molecular weight
BG signal peptide, or behind a signal markers are labeled; the position of A. oryzae
peptide from the H. insolens Cel45A. BG is marked with an arrow. The gels were
A. Relative BG activity measured in the stained with Coomassie Brilliant Blue.
16.6
Range of Biobased Products
16.6.1
Fuels
In the US, fuels make up approximately 70% of the carbon consumed annually
(more than 1.8 billion tons). Biobased ethanol and biodiesel are currently pro-
duced at higher cost than gasoline, and these renewable fuels account for less
than 2% of total liquid fuel consumption. Developing biobased liquid fuels will
require production cost reduction, including use of low-cost carbon sources, for
example agricultural/forestry byproducts and urban wastes.
As a direct result of research and development programs worldwide, fuel
ethanol production from sugarcane/beet (direct fermentation of material ob-
tained by crushing) and corn/wheat starch (by starch saccharification) has be-
come a viable industry. Yeast-fermentation of simple sugars, particularly sucrose
and glucose, has been used economically to produce ethanol, in amounts of
more than 20 million tons per year [36]. In Brazil, fermentable sugars are ob-
tained from mechanically processed sugar canes. In the US the sugars come
mainly from enzyme-degraded corn and wheat starch. To extend this industry
by tapping into inexpensive, readily available biomass materials such as corn
stover, wheat straw, and other agro/forestry byproducts as sources for ferment-
able sugars, intensive research is being conducted to develop enzymes which
convert lignocellulosics and other polysaccharides to simple sugars. In addition,
research efforts are being focused on obtaining and improving microbes for fer-
menting diverse sugars [37, 38].
Production of fermentable sugars from cellulose is currently more expensive
than their production from amylose (starch). This can partly be explained by
the relative recalcitrance of cellulose – amylase hydrolysis is intrinsically faster
and the kinetics of cellulase action require relatively higher loadings of enzyme.
As a result of significant funding by the US Department of Energy and col-
laboration between Novozymes and the US National Renewable Energy Labora-
tory (NREL), however, substantial progress has been made toward reducing en-
zyme cost for conversion of cellulose to fermentable sugars. After the research
16.6 Range of Biobased Products 377
EtOH)
and development advances mentioned above, more than 20-fold cost reduction
has been achieved (Fig. 16.11).
Importantly, the reduction of enzyme cost achieved in the last few years has
had a major affect on the estimated cost of producing fuel ethanol from corn
stover in a biorefinery. In 1999, the total expected cost for producing bioethanol
was dominated by enzyme cost; today enzyme cost is comparable with the esti-
mated costs of biomass feedstock collection or depreciation of capital. Using a
2004 “state of the technology” process cost estimate supplied by NREL, and an
enzyme cost of $0.50 per gallon ethanol produced, ethanol derived from bio-
mass has a total cost of about $2.50 per gallon [39]. Comparing costs for pro-
ducing ethanol from corn starch saccharification (by amylase) and fermentation
to projected costs for lignocellulosic-rich biomass-based ethanol production indi-
cates that the biomass based industry is becoming economically viable.
In addition to fuel ethanol, biomass-derived sugars can be fermented into
combustible “biogas.” Mainly methane, the fermentation is accomplished by
anaerobic bacteria, a technology already developed on small to medium-scale.
Fuel ethanol seems to be the future for a biomass-based energy industry, how-
ever. Future research and development effort will probably be focused on cellu-
lases with improved reactivity and stability, and on microbes with expanded su-
gar specificity (e.g. novel yeasts or pathway-engineered microbes capable of fer-
menting a variety of pentoses, hexoses, or oligomeric sugars).
378 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
16.6.2
Fine/Specialty Chemicals
16.6.3
Fuel Cells
A clean, efficient, and easily rechargeable energy source, fuel cells have been ac-
tively studied in the past few decades. In fuel cells, chemical energy is converted
into electricity by electrochemistry rather than combustion. Biofuel cells, in
which enzymes or entire microbial cells serve as electron-transfer catalysts, use
Sugar Lactic acid (currently biobased) Acidulant (food, drink), electroplating bath
fermentation additive, mordant, textile/leather auxiliary
Polylactide (currently biobased) Film and thermoformed packaging, fiber,
fiberfill
Ethyl lactate (currently Solvent, chemical intermediate
biobased)
1,3-Propanediol Apparel, upholstery, specialty resins, other
applications
Succinic acid Surfactants/detergents, ion chelators, food,
pharmaceuticals, antibiotics, amino acids,
vitamins
Succinic acid derivatives Surfactants, adhesives, printing inks,
magnetic tapes, coating resins, plasticizer/
emulsifiers, deicing compounds, herbicide
ingredients, chemical and pharmaceutical
intermediates
Bionolle 4,4 polyester Thermoplastic polymer applications
3-Hydroxypropionic acid Acrylates, acrylic fibers, polymers, resins
n-Butanol Solvent, plasticizers, polymers, resins
Itaconic acid Aluminum anodizing reagent, methyl acryl
relatively inexpensive, safe, and available “feeds”, for example alcohol or sugar,
instead of hydrogen gas or its volatile derivatives used in conventional fuel cells
[41]. Because of the safety and cost issues of conventional fuel cells, biofuel cells
are quickly emerging; in the near future, mini and micro-scale biofuel cells
could replace conventional batteries that power a variety of consumer and medi-
cal-implant devices. In the more distant future, scaled-up biofuel cells could
serve as a major industrial energy source.
Current research on biofuel cells focuses on how to improve performance in
terms of speed, output, reliability and durability. Enzyme-mediated electron-
transfer between feeds and electrodes is a focus of research and development.
For example, alcohol dehydrogenase and sugar oxidase are being studied as fa-
cilitators for electron-donation from alcohols or sugars (e.g. glucose) to an an-
ode, and laccase is being studied to facilitate the electron-accepting of O2 (air)
from a cathode. In the future, the focus of biofuel cell research may shift to
cheaper, more readily available feedstocks. Because both ethanol and glucose
can be generated from biorefineries, we may envisage a next-generation biofuel
cell that is powered by biomass. In such a fuel cell, biomass would be enzymati-
cally converted into glucose (e.g. by cellulase), which would then be enzymati-
cally oxidized on an electrode (e.g. by glucose oxidase). The extracted electrons
would run through a wire, perform electric work, and then be used to enzymati-
cally reduce O2 (e.g. by laccase). Biofuel cells may be set up as part of a biore-
380 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
finery plant that generates electric power from biomass, or be used for wilder-
ness exploration or military operations where fuel transport is logistically costly.
16.7
Biorefineries: Outlook and Perspectives
16.7.1
Potential of Biomass-based Material/Energy Sources
16.7.2
Economic Drivers Toward Sustainability
Efficient enzyme catalysis is one of the primary economic barriers in the chal-
lenge to design an overall cost-effective process for converting biomass into fer-
mentable sugars. The research efforts described here, and research efforts in
similar work performed at Genencor International, have specifically focused on
improving the efficiency of enzymatic hydrolysis, and progress thus far looks
quite promising. Further work on metabolic engineering of microbial produc-
tion strains should continue, as should efforts to better integrate biomass pre-
treatment, enzyme hydrolysis, and fermentation to avoid complications result-
ing from isolated efforts.
Several major problems must be solved to enable commercialization of var-
ious biorefineries. To satisfy the optimum operating conditions of enzymes and
microbes, raw biomass materials collected from diverse regions under diverse
climates must be examined to assess the impact of biomass feedstock variability
on pretreatment, enzymatic conversion, and fermentation. Optimizing these
steps and integrating them into a robust, low cost, efficient, sustainable, and
value-generating material–energy cycle is highly challenging, yet offers great so-
cial, economic, and environmental promise.
382 16 Enzymes for Biorefineries
References
1 Finlay, M. Old Efforts at New Uses: A lulosomes. Curr Opin Struct Biol 8, 548–
Brief History of Chemurgy and the 57 (1998).
American Search for Biobased Materials. 13 Mosier, N. S., Hall, P., Ladisch, C. M. and
J. Ind. Ecology 7, 33–46 (2004). Ladisch, M. R. Reaction kinetics, molecu-
2 Rooney, T. Lignocellulosic Feedstock Re- lar action, and mechanisms of cellulolyt-
source Assessment. (National Renewable ic proteins. Adv Biochem Eng Biotechnol
Energy Laboratory, Golden, CO, 1998). 65, 23–40 (1999).
3 Lee, Y. Y., Lyer, P. and Torget, R. W. Di- 14 Maheshwari, R., Bharadwaj, G. and
lute-Acid hydrolysis of Lignocellulosic Bhat, M. K. Thermophilic fungi: their
Biomass. Advances in Biochemical Engi- physiology and enzymes. Microbiol Mol
neering and Biotechnology 65, 93–115 Biol Rev 64, 461–88 (2000).
(1999). 15 Schulein, M. Protein engineering of cel-
4 Zaldivar, J., Nielsen, J. and Olsson, L. lulases. Biochim Biophys Acta 1543, 239–
Fuel ethanol production from lignocellu- 252 (2000).
lose: a challenge for metabolic engineer- 16 Lynd, L. R., Weimer, P. J., van Zyl, W. H.
ing and process integration. Appl Micro- and Pretorius, I. S. Microbial cellulose
biol Biotechnol 56, 17–34 (2001). utilization: fundamentals and biotechnol-
5 Teymouri, F., Laureano-Perez, L., Aliza- ogy. Microbiol Mol Biol Rev 66, 506–77
deh, H. and Dale, B.E. Ammonia fiber (2002).
explosion treatment of corn stover. Appl 17 Bourne, Y. and Henrissat, B. Glycoside
Biochem Biotechnol 113–116, 951–63 hydrolases and glycosyltransferases: fam-
(2004). ilies and functional modules. Curr Opin
6 Allen, S. G., Kam, L. C., Zemann, A. J. Struct Biol 11, 593–600 (2001).
and Antal, M. J. J. Fractionation of Sugar 18 Davies, G. J. Structural studies on cellu-
Cane with Hot, Compressed, Liquid lases. Biochem Soc Trans 26, 167–73
Water. Ind Eng Chem Res 35, 2709–2715 (1998).
(1996). 19 Shimon, L. J. et al. Structure of a family
7 Liu, C. and Wyman, C. E. Impact of fluid IIIa scaffoldin CBD from the cellulo-
velocity on hot water only pretreatment some of Clostridium cellulolyticum at 2.2
of corn stover in a flowthrough reactor. A resolution. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crys-
Appl Biochem Biotechnol 113–116, 977–87 tallogr 56 Pt 12, 1560–8 (2000).
(2004). 20 Zhang, Y. H. and Lynd, L. R. Kinetics and
8 Nagle, N. J. et al. Efficacy of a hot wash- relative importance of phosphorolytic
ing process for pretreated yellow poplar and hydrolytic cleavage of cellodextrins
to enhance bioethanol production. Bio- and cellobiose in cell extracts of Clostri-
technol Prog 18, 734–8 (2002). dium thermocellum. Appl Environ Micro-
9 Varga, E., Schmidt, A. S., Reczey, K. and biol 70, 1563–9 (2004).
Thomsen, A. B. Pretreatment of corn 21 de Vries, R. P. and Visser, J. Aspergillus
stover using wet oxidation to enhance enzymes involved in degradation of
enzymatic digestibility. Appl Biochem Bio- plant cell wall polysaccharides. Microbiol
technol 104, 37–50 (2003). Mol Biol Rev 65, 497–522 (2001).
10 Wilson, D. and Irwin, D. Genetics and 22 Kirk, T. K. and Farrell, R. L. Enzymatic
properties of cellulases. Adv Biochem Eng “combustion“: the microbial degradation
Biotechnol 65, 1–21 (1999). of lignin. Annu Rev Microbiol 41, 465–
11 Tomme, P., Warren, R. A. and Gilkes, 505 (1987).
N. R. Cellulose hydrolysis by bacteria and 23 Gronqvist, S. et al. Lignocellulose proces-
fungi. Adv Microb Physiol 37, 1–81 sing with oxidative enzymes. in Applied
(1995). Enzymology to Lignocellulosics (eds. Mans-
12 Bayer, E. A., Chanzy, H., Lamed, R. and field, S.D. and Saddler, J.N.) 46–65 (Am.
Shoham, Y. Cellulose, cellulases and cel- Chem. Soc, Washington, DC, 2002).
References 383
385
17
Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk
and Fine Chemicals from Renewable Resources
Thomas Willke, Ulf Prüße, and Klaus-Dieter Vorlop
17.1
Introduction
17.1.1
Renewable Resources
The most important sources of renewable resources for industry are oil plants,
starch plants, sugar plants, energy plants, and wood, but also waste and resi-
dues from agriculture and industry. The corresponding substrates for conver-
sion processes are manifold and belong to such heterogeneous substance
classes as oils, fats, glycerol, lignocellulose, cellulose, starch, inulin, sugar, com-
plex biomass, etc. Fats and oils are already being used as feedstock in industry
at a level of 15 million t a–1. The corresponding products are mainly applied in
plastics, paints, lacquers, biotensides, and energy (as biodiesel). The potential of
carbohydrates (starch, sugar, cellulose) is far from being fully exploited. In the
year 2002/2003, approximately 143 million tons of sugar were produced world-
wide (Germany 4 million tons). Of these, only 70 000 t (1.7%) were industrially
employed as renewable resources in the pharmaceutical and chemical sector in
Germany [1].
Because of the substantial quantities of (ligno)cellulose available, utilization
of the material of biomass (wood, straw, waste, and residues) has huge poten-
tial. Countries with large amounts of wood, for example Canada, the USA,
Scandinavia, or Austria, invest much effort to utilize this potential. There is
much need for research. If it were possible to establish highly efficient enzy-
matic pulping processes, numerous bulk products (ethanol, butanol, lactic acid,
etc.) could be produced at competitive prices.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 1
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
386 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
17.1.2
Products
17.2
Historical Outline
Until 1930 many important bulk products, for example fuels (ethanol, butanol),
organic acids (acetic acid, citric acid, lactic acid), and other basic chemicals, were
mainly produced from renewable resources. Process engineering was limited to
fermentation by use of fungi or bacteria. In the past some basic chemicals (for ex-
ample butanol and acetone) were produced exclusively by fermentation. With the
development of petroleum chemistry, however, they were replaced by chemical–
technical products. In the production of other chemicals (ethanol, citric acid, lactic
acid, and acetic acid), biotechnological techniques have always been predominant,
because the chemical–technical alternatives are not economical.
There are several prognoses of the amount and range of worldwide petroleum
reserves. Most of the experts predict that maximum production will be achieved
in the next few decades [2] (Fig. 17.1). Countries with high energy demands and
limited resources, for example the USA, have already realized this and are in-
vesting much effort in appropriate research [3]. In the USA, for example, substi-
tution of fossil fuel with renewable resources in the production of liquid fuels
and organic chemicals is envisaged to be 50% and 90%, respectively, by 2090
[4]. More realistic prognoses expect an increase to 25% in the next 30 years [5].
Shell Oil, for example, intends to provide 30% of the world‘s chemical and en-
ergy needs by use of biomass by 2050, corresponding to nearly US$ 150 billion
[6]. DuPont, one of the largest manufacturers of plastics, intends to produce
25% of its products from renewable resources by the year 2010 [7]. Figure 17.2
summarizes several prognoses for the USA.
Fig. 17.1 Prognoses of crude oil production and estimated ultimate recovery (EUR) [2].
388 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
17.3
Processes
Problem Solution
ways, especially in the fine and specialty segment, are less efficient and less en-
vironmental friendly. In this segment more classic organic chemistry is used
than catalytic processes, resulting in significant waste generation, emissions,
and energy consumption.
Biotechnological processes usually occur under mild conditions. Biocatalysts,
substrates, intermediates, and by-products, and the product itself, are biodegrad-
able. Water is usually used as a solvent. There are also frequent disadvantages,
however, including low product concentration, low productivity and, hence, high
recovery costs. Table 17.1 lists some problems and possible solutions. Some
products are only accessible chemically, whereas biotechnology is more appro-
priate for others (chiral substances, some vitamins and amino acids, highly se-
lective transformations with polyfunctional substrates, such as sugars). Numer-
ous syntheses are conducted exclusively using enzymes (lipases, amylases, pro-
teases, and, also, increasing in the future, cellulases). To establish a large-scale
process based on a biochemical reaction it is preferable to have means available
to hold back the catalyst (i.e. enzyme) in the bioreaction vessel. By immobilizing
catalysts, for example growing, resting, or dead cells or enzymes, it is possible
to retard them.
17.3.1
Immobilization
Different types of immobilization procedure have been developed for this pur-
pose, as is shown in Fig. 17.3 [8]. Besides the advantage of easy retention, im-
mobilized catalysts are also often more stable with regard to, for example, pH
and temperature. When entrapped the catalysts are, moreover, protected against
other bacteria and thus processes can run under non-sterile conditions, because
potential contamination is washed out while the favored catalyst is specifically
protected.
Encapsulation of catalysts also has disadvantages, however: during the immo-
bilization process the catalyst may be inactivated by physicochemical or physio-
logical effects. Even if this does not happen, the overall activity of the immobi-
lized system could be lower than that of the free catalyst, because of diffusion
limitations. To minimize this effect the particles should be small and applicable
for the later application.
Examples of processes developed, investigated, and optimized at the Institute
of Technology and Biosystems Engineering are discussed in the sections below.
17.3.2
Biocatalytic Routes from Renewable Resources to Solvents or Fuels
Introduction Ethanol can be used as a liquid energy carrier, fuel additive, and
feedstock in the chemical industry. Because of the costs – except for use in
foods or stimulants – biotechnological production in Europe has not yet been
profitable. In May 2003 an EU directive on the use of biofuels set a minimum
level of 5.75% bio-fuels (including bioethanol) for all transport fuels sold by
2010 [9]. Thus ethanol will be more highly in demand in the future. The bio-
technological production of ethanol – at the beginning of the 20th century
mainly for fuel – is currently experiencing a renaissance.
In the year 2001, worldwide annual ethanol production amounted to more
than 30 billion liters. The leading role played by Brazil, where bioethanol from
sugar cane has been used for more than 25 years, has currently been taken over
by the USA, which will probably continue to occupy first place. In the USA,
mainly corn or wheat starch is used. In the EU, with a total of approximately
2 billion liters, France (approx. 0.8 billion liters) is the largest producer; Ger-
many produces only approximately 0.3 billion liters [10].
Fig. 17.4 Process scheme for the production of ethanol from renewable resources.
[18]. The process uses genetically modified Zymomonas mobilis, which was
given the ability to use pentoses (xylose) in addition to hexoses (glucose, fruc-
tose). This enables inexpensive substances which could not previously be
used, for example, rice straw, to be transformed into ethanol with high yields
[19].
Reduction of the process costs can be achieved by several methods:
· Screening or genetic engineering of microorganisms with the goal of increas-
ing productivity, ethanol tolerance (and hence achievable final product concen-
tration), and yield. For example, use of the bacterium Zymomonas mobilis in-
stead of conventional yeasts (Saccharomyces spp.) also results in increased
product yields, besides the fivefold higher productivity. In addition, immobili-
zation boosts volumetric productivity and, again, product yield. Furthermore,
product tolerance, and with it the final ethanol concentration, is enhanced.
Essential data for the process are listed in Table 17.2.
Fig. 17.6 Pilot plant for the continuous ethanol production with immobilized cells.
17.3 Processes 393
17.3.3
Biocatalytic Route from Glycerol to 1,3-Propanediol
17.3.3.1 Introduction
One of the applications of 1,3-propanediol (PD) is its use as a diol component
in the plastic polytrimethyleneterephthalate (PTT), a new polymer with proper-
ties comparable with those of Nylon. It is preferably used for carpets (Corterra
by Shell) or special textile fibers (Sorona by DuPont). Further applications are
appearing in polyester resins, mainly in the paint industry.
394 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
(Fig. 17.12). Further on, use of immobilized cells (LentiKats; Section 17.3.2.1,
above) rather than freely suspended cells, enables productivity to be increase
from approximately 2 to 30 gPD L–1 h–1.
Comparison of current (chemical) techniques with the new biotechnical tech-
niques based on different substrates and glycerol qualities (= raw glycerol costs)
396 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
17.3.4
Biocatalytic Route from Inulin to Difructose Anhydride
17.3.4.1 Introduction
Inulin is a linear b-2,1-linked polyfructane terminated with a glucose residue.
Large amounts of inulin are contained in the roots and tubers of crops like dah-
lia, chicory, and Jerusalem artichoke. Inulins have a very limited market thus
far, mainly because of the high cost of expensive separation and purification
steps. For 1.5 to 2 1 kg–1 it is approximately four times as costly as competing
glucose, starch, or sucrose. This also explains why short oligofructoses are
synthesized enzymatically from sucrose for probiotic products rather than by
partial hydrolysis of inulins. Future use of inulin-derived products is thus either
in high-value markets, for example the functional food segment, or by convert-
ing inulin into intermediates which can be separated and purified at lower cost.
One promising compound derived from inulin for this purpose is difructose an-
hydride (DFA III, Fig. 17.13).
DFA III can be the basis for plastics and tensides. It can be crystallized as
easily as sucrose after an ion-exchange step and hence can be produced at a
price well below that of inulin. So far DFA III has not been introduced to the
market, because no efficient enzyme and biotechnical process was available for
the necessary bioconversion of inulin.
To produce DFA III on a technical and industrial scale, large amounts of en-
zyme are needed. The following sections introduce a strategy showing how this
problem can be solved [23, 24].
Chicory
Chemical feedstock
Fig. 17.16 Fermentation of the redombinant E. coli pMSiftOptR for production of inulinase II.
400 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
a)
b)
Fig. 17.19 Principle of JetCutting, and high-speed-motion pic-
ture of the cutting process showing the effect of correct ad-
justment.
To accomplish the task of producing the desired small droplets from the very
viscous alginate–enzyme solution, a novel JetCutter technology was used. In
comparison with other techniques, for example blow-off devices, vibrating noz-
zles or electrostatic forces, the JetCutter uses mechanical cutting of a continu-
ous jet of liquid to produce small droplets; this is shown in Fig. 17.19 [25].
17.3.4.6 Summary
Complete process development has been shown, starting from screening for an
enzyme with the desired properties – an inulase II converting inulin to DFA III
at elevated temperatures (60 8C). After screening and successful optimization of
the enzyme by genetic engineering and construction of a genetically modified
organism which expresses the enzyme in very high numbers, this strain was
fermented to furnish large amounts of enzyme for immobilization. After immo-
bilization by entrapment of the enzyme in hydrogel particles, an industrially
402 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
applicable enzyme formulation with an activity of 196 U g–1 (wet matter) is ob-
tained.
17.3.5
Chemical Route from Sugars to Sugar Acids
17.3.5.1 Introduction
The increasing use of low-molecular-mass carbohydrates (sugars) for production
of chemical building blocks is of great interest both economically and ecologically.
Besides the biotechnological routes presented above, chemical catalysis has great
potential for functionalization of sugars to furnish fine chemicals or building
blocks for the chemical industry. Sugar oxidation in the presence of supported no-
ble metal catalysts has always been an attractive subject. The products are biode-
gradable compounds and have many potential applications. Gluconic acid, for ex-
ample, is of great industrial interest. Annual production amounts to nearly
80 000 t; this is used as a noncorrosive and biologically degradable complexing
agent in industry, and in numerous applications in food, pharmaceuticals, and
cosmetics. Lactobionic acid and maltobionic acids – the oxidation products of
the corresponding sugar monomers lactose and maltose, respectively – can be
used in the detergent and pharmaceutical and food industries.
Gluconic acid is mainly produced biotechnologically, because chemical cata-
lysts are inadequate. With gold catalysts, this could be changed in the future
(Fig. 17.20).
Table 17.3 gives an overview of some important milestones in chemical cata-
lytic glucose oxidation. The work of Prati and Rossi describes an charcoal-sup-
ported gold catalyst for glucose oxidation, which exceeds the previous Pt- and
Fig. 17.21 Catalytic oxidation of glucose: screening of catalysts and selectivity proven by HPLC.
17.3.5.3 Summary
The newly developed Au/TiO2 catalysts have outstanding properties, including
pronounced substrate selectivity and extremely high product selectivity. Combi-
nation of these with very high activity and excellent long-term stability results
in catalysts that meet all the requirements demanded from a “Synzyme” (syn-
thetic enzyme). In the future, gold catalysts may be an alternative to the bio-
technological process for industrial production of gluconic acid.
References
1 WVZ, Wirtschaftliche Vereinigung Zu- 5 BRDTAC, Vision for Bioenergy and Bio-
cker, Informationen zum Zuckermarkt based Products in the United States.
Stand 12/2003. 2003, http://www.zucker- 2002, Biomass R&D Technical Advisory
wirtschaft.de Committee.
2 K. Hiller and P. Kehrer, Erdöl Erdgas 6 OECD, Biotechnology for clean indus-
Kohle, 2000, 116, 9, 427. trial products and processes, p. 30. 1998,
3 BRDTAC, Roadmap for Biomass Tech- OECD Publications, Paris Cedex.
nologies in the United States. 2002, Bio- 7 Dupont, Press release: Genencor Inter-
mass R&D Technical Advisory Commit- national and Dupont expand R&D colla-
tee. boration to make key biobased polymer.
4 NRC, Biobased industrial products: pri- 2001, http://www1.dupont.com/NA-
orities for research and commercializa- SApp/dupontglobal/corp/index.jsp?-
tion. In: National Research Council (ed.), page=/content/US/en_US/news/product/
2000, Washington, DC. 2001/pn03_12_01.ht ml
406 17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine Chemicals
Edited by
Birgit Kamm,
Patrick R. Gruber,
and Michael Kamm
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
Related Titles
Elvers, B. (Ed.)
Handbook of Fuels
Energy Sources for Transportation
2006
ISBN 3-527-30740-0
Shahidi, F. (Ed.)
Ocic, O.
Volume 2
Edited by
Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, and Michael Kamm
The Editors n All books published by Wiley-VCH are carefully
produced. Nevertheless, authors, editors, and
Dr. Birgit Kamm publisher do not warrant the information contained
Research Institute in these books, including this book, to be free of
Bioactive Polymer Systems errors. Readers are advised to keep in mind that
biopos e.V. statements, data, illustrations, procedural details or
Kantstr. 55 other items may inadvertently be inaccurate.
14513 Teltow
Germany
ISBN-13: 978-3-527-31027-2
ISBN-10: 3-527-31027-4
V
Contents
Volume 1
3 Development of Biorefineries –
Technical and Economic Considerations 67
Bill Dean, Tim Dodge, Fernando Valle, and Gopal Chotani
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
VI Contents
Fuel-oriented Biorefineries
10 Sugar-based Biorefinery –
Technology for Integrated Production
of Poly(3-hydroxybutyrate), Sugar, and Ethanol 209
Carlos Eduardo Vaz Rossell, Paulo E. Mantelatto, José A. M. Agnelli,
and Jefter Nascimento
Green Biorefineries
17 Biocatalytic and Catalytic Routes for the Production of Bulk and Fine
Chemicals from Renewable Resources 385
Thomas Willke, Ulf Prüße, and Klaus-Dieter Vorlop
Volume 2
Foreword XXV
Henning Hopf
Foreword XXVII
Paul T. Anastas
7 Protein-based Polymers:
Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering 217
Dan W. Urry
7.1 Introduction 217
7.1.1 Definitions 217
7.1.1.1 Proteins and Protein-based Polymers 217
7.1.1.2 Two Basic Principles for Protein-based Polymer Engineering 217
7.1.2 Proteins in Aqueous Media 218
7.1.3 Thermodynamics of Proteins in Water 218
7.1.3.1 Exothermic Hydration of Apolar Groups 218
7.1.3.2 The Change in Gibbs Free Energy of Hydrophobic Association 218
7.1.3.3 The Apolar–Polar Repulsive Free Energy of Hydration, DG8ap 218
7.1.4 The Inverse Temperature Transition for Hydrophobic
Association 219
7.1.5 The Role of Elasticity in the Engineering of Protein-based
Polymers 219
7.1.5.1 Near Ideal Elasticity Provides for Efficient Energy Conversion 219
7.1.5.2 Mechanism of Near Ideal Elasticity 220
7.1.6 Many of the Advantages of Protein-based Polymeric Materials 220
7.2 Historical Outline 221
7.2.1 Historical Beginnings of (Elastic) Protein-based Polymer
Development 221
7.2.2 Mechanistic Foundations: Fundamental Engineering Principles 222
7.2.2.1 The Hydrophobic Consilient Mechanism 222
7.2.2.2 The Elastic Consilient Mechanism 223
7.2.3 Highlights of Bioproduction 223
7.3 Bioproduction 224
7.3.1 Gene Construction using Recombinant DNA Technology 225
7.3.1.1 Preparation of Monomer Genes and the PCR Technique 225
7.3.1.2 Transformation, Monomer Gene Production and Sequence
Verification 226
7.3.1.3 Monomer Gene Concatenation Produces Multimer Genes
of Monomer 226
7.3.2 E. coli Transformation for Protein-based Polymer Expression 227
7.3.3 Fermentation using Transformed E. coli 227
7.4 Purification of Protein-based Polymers 227
XIV Contents
16 Industrial Biotech –
Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential 445
Rolf Bachmann and Jens Riese
16.1 Introduction 445
16.2 Time to Exploit the Potential 446
16.2.1 How Far Can it Go? 446
16.2.2 Better Technology, Faster Results 447
16.2.3 Environmentally and Balance-sheet Friendly 448
16.2.4 Rekindling Chemicals Innovation 450
16.2.5 Increasing Corporate Action in all Segments 451
16.3 The Importance of Residual Biomass 452
16.3.1 Why Waste Biomass Works 452
16.3.2 Economic Benefits and Regulation 452
16.3.3 Still a Long Way to Go 454
16.3.4 Collaboration Will Push Biomass Conversion Forward 454
16.4 Overcoming the Challenges Ahead 455
16.4.1 Internal Obstacles 455
16.4.2 External Challenges 456
16.5 Overcoming Challenges 457
16.5.1 Case 1: Building a Biotech Strategy 457
16.5.2 Case 2: Identifying the Right Opportunities 458
16.5.3 Case 3: Managing Uncertainties 459
16.5.4 Case 4: Preparing the Launch and Market Development 460
16.5.5 Case 5: Building a Favorable External Environment 461
16.6 More Needs to be Done 461
Editor’s Preface
In the year 2003 when the idea for this set of books “Biorefineries, Biobased In-
dustrial Processes, and Products” arose, the topic of biorefineries as means of
processing industrial material and efficient utilization of renewable products
had been primarily a side issue beyond the borders of the United States of
America. This situation has changed dramatically over the last two years. Today
in almost every developed and emerging nation much work is being conducted
on biorefinery systems, driven by the rising cost of oil and the desire of to move
away from petrochemical-based systems.
In these books we do not claim to describe and discuss everything that be-
longs or even might belong to the topic of biorefineries – that would be impos-
sible. There are many types of biorefinery, and the state of the technology is
changing very rapidly as new and focused effort is directed toward making bio-
refineries a commercial reality. It is a very exciting time for those interested in
biorefineries – technologies for bio-conversion have advanced to a state in which
they are becoming practical on a large scale, economics are leaning more fa-
vourably to the direction of renewable feedstocks, and chemical process knowl-
edge is being applied to biobased systems.
As the editors of the first comprehensive biorefinery book we saw it as our
duty to provide, first of all, a general framework for the subject – addressing
the main issues associated with biorefineries, the principles and basics of biore-
finery systems, the basic technology, industrial products which fall within the
scope of biorefineries, and, finally, technology and products that will fall within
the scope of biorefineries in the future.
To provide a reliable description of the state of biorefinery research and devel-
opment and of industrial implementations, strategies, and future developments
we asked eighty-five experts from universities, research and development insti-
tutes, and industry and commerce to present their views, their results, their im-
plementations, and their ideas on the topic. The results of their contributions
are thirty-three articles organized into seven sections. Our very special thanks
go to all the authors.
We are especially indebted to Dr. Hubert Pelc from Wiley-VCH publishing,
who worked with us on the concept and then, later, on the development and
implementation of the book. Thanks go also to Dr. Bettina Bems from Wiley-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXIV Editor’s Preface
VCH publishing, who managed with admirable professionalism and very much
patience, and to the three editors and eighty-five authors from three different
continents. We are also indebted to Hans-Jochen Schmitt, also of Wiley-VCH
publishing, who had the not always easy task of arranging the manuscripts in a
form ready for publication.
Maybe in 2030, when a biobased economy utilizing biorefinery technology
has become a fundamental part of national and globally connected economies,
someone will wonder what had been thought and written about the subject of
biorefineries at the beginning of the 21st century. Hopefully this book will be
highly representative. Until then we hope it will contribute to the promotion of
international biorefinery developments.
November 2005
XXV
Foreword
One-hundred-and-fifty years after the beginning of coal-based chemistry and 50
years after the beginning of petroleum-based chemistry industrial chemistry is
now entering a new era. In the twenty-first century utilization of renewable raw
materials will gain importance in the chemical conversion of substances in in-
dustry. Partial or even complete re-adjustment of whole economies to renewable
raw materials will require completely new approaches in research, development,
and production. Chemical and biological sciences will play a leading role in the
building of future industries. New synergies between biological, physical, chem-
ical, and technical sciences must be elaborated and established and special re-
quirements will be placed on raw material and on product-line efficiency and
sustainability. The necessary change from chemistry based on a fossil raw mate-
rial to biology-based modern science and technology is an intellectual challenge
for both researchers and engineers. Chemists should support this change and
collaborate closely with their colleagues in adjoining disciplines, for example
biotechnology, agriculture, forestry, and the material sciences.
The German Chemical Society will help direct this necessary development by
supporting within its structure new kinds of organization for chemists to work
on this subject in universities, research institutes, and industry.
This two-volume book is based on the approach developed by biorefinery-sys-
tems – transfer of the logic and efficiency of today’s petrochemical product lines
and product family trees into manipulation of biomass. Raw biomass materials
are mechanically separated into substances for chemical conversion into other
products by different methods, which may be biotechnological, thermochemical,
and thermal. Review of biomass processes and products developed in the past
but widely forgotten in the petroleum age will be as important as the presenta-
tion of new methods, processes, and products that still require an enormous
amount of research and development today.
Henning Hopf
President of the German Chemical Society
Frankfurt (Germany)
November 2005
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXVII
Foreword
On October 5, 2005, the Nobel Prize Committee made an interesting and im-
portant statement with regard to the prize in chemistry. It said, “This represents
a great step forward for ‘green chemistry’, reducing potentially hazardous waste
through smarter production. [This research] is an example of how important ba-
sic science has been applied for the benefit of man, society and the environ-
ment.” By making this statement, the Nobel committee recognized what a new
generation of scientists has known for quite some time, that by working at the
most fundamental level – the molecular level – we are able to design our prod-
ucts, processes, and systems in ways that are sustainable.
There is general recognition that the current system by which we produce the
goods and services needed by society is not sustainable. This unsustainability
takes many forms. It would be legitimate to note that in our current system of
production we rely largely on finite feedstocks extracted from the Earth that are
being depleted at a rate that cannot be sustained indefinitely. It is equally legiti-
mate to recognize that our current production efficiency results in more than
90% of the material used in the production process ending up as waste, i.e. less
than 10% of the material ends up in the desired product. Yet another condition
of unsustainability is in our current energy use; this not only relies largely on fi-
nite energy sources but also results in degradation of the environment that can-
not be continued as the growing population and demands of the developing
world emerge over the course of the twenty-first century. Finally, the products
and processes we have designed since the industrial revolution have accom-
plished their goals without full consideration of their impact and consequence
on humans and the biosphere, with many examples of toxic and hazardous sub-
stances being distributed throughout the globe and into our bodies.
If we are to change this unsustainable path, it will need the direct and com-
mitted engagement of our best scientists and engineers to design the future dif-
ferently from the past. We will need to proceed with a broader perspective such
that when we design for efficiency, effectiveness, and performance, we now
must recognize that these terms include sustainability – a minimized impact
on humans and the environment.
An essential part of meeting the challenge of designing for sustainability will
be based on the nature of the materials we use as starting materials and feed-
stocks. Any sustainable future must ensure that the materials on which we base
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXVIII Foreword
our economic infrastructure are renewable rather than depleting. The rate of re-
newability is also important because certainly one could argue that petroleum is
renewable if you have a few million years to wait. Serious analysis would, how-
ever, necessitate that the rate of renewability is connected to the rate of use.
There are options for how to approach this technological challenge, for example
using waste products from one process as a feedstock for another, that are well
thought through in industrial ecology models. There is, however, recognition
that an essential part of a sustainable future will be based on appropriate and
innovative uses of our biologically-based feedstocks.
This book addresses the essential questions and challenges of moving toward
a sustainable society in which bio-based feedstocks, processes, and products are
fundamental pillars of the economy. The authors discuss not only the important
scientific and technical issues surrounding this transition but also the necessary
topics of economics, infrastructure, and policy. It is only by means of this type
of holistic approach that movement toward genuine sustainability will be able
to occur where the societal, economic, and environmental needs are met for the
current generation while preserving the ability of future generations to meet
their needs.
While it will be clear to the reader that the topics presented in this book are
important, it is at least as important that the reader understand that these topics
– and the transition to a sustainable path that they address – are urgent. At this
point in history it is necessary that all who are capable of advancing the transi-
tion to a more sustainable society, engage in doing so with the level of energy,
innovation, and creativity that is required to meet the challenge.
Paul T. Anastas
Director of the Green Chemistry Institute
Washington, D.C.
November, 2005
XXIX
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
XXX List of Contributors
Seungdo Kim
Department of Chemical Engineering
and Materials Science
Michigan State University
East Lansing, MI 48824
USA
List of Contributors XXXIII
Todd Werpy
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
P.O. Box 999/K2-12
Richland, WA 99352
USA
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part I
Biobased Product Family Trees
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
3
1
The Key Sugars of Biomass: Availability, Present Non-Food
Uses and Potential Future Development Lines
Frieder W. Lichtenthaler
1.1
Introduction
Because our fossil raw materials derived from prehistoric organic matter are ir-
revocably decreasing – the end of cheap oil is realistically predicted to occur in
the next 2–3 decades, i.e. 2040 at the latest [1–3] – and because pressure on our
environment is building up, the progressive change-over of chemical industry to
renewable feedstocks emerges as an inevitable necessity [3–5].
The terrestrial biomass which Nature graciously provides us on an annual ba-
sis is considerably more complex than fossil raw materials, constituting a multi-
faceted accumulation of low- and high-molecular-weight products, exemplified
by sugars, hydroxy and amino acids, lipids, and biopolymers such as cellulose,
hemicelluloses, chitin, starch, lignin, and proteins. By far the most important
class of organic material in terms of volume produced is carbohydrates, which
represent approximately 75% of the annually renewable biomass of about 180
billion tons (Fig. 1.1). Of these, only a minor fraction (ca. 5%) is used by man,
the rest decays and recycles along natural pathways.
Thus, carbohydrates, a single class of natural products are – aside from their tradi-
tional uses for food, lumber, paper, and heat – the major biofeedstocks from which to
develop industrially and economically viable organic chemicals and materials to re-
place those derived from petrochemical sources.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
4 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
1.2
Availability of Mono- and Disaccharides
their parent aldoses, are mainly used as food ingredients, because of their
sweetening properties, yet also have potential as inexpensive raw materials for
broad-scale preparative purposes. The same holds for d-gluconic acid [15] and
the other sugar-derived acids listed.
Despite their large-scale accessibility at comparatively low cost, it must seem
surprising that the chemical industry currently utilizes these mono- and disac-
charides to a minor extent only as feedstock for organic chemicals – a state of
affairs amply documented by the fact that of the 100 major organic chemicals
manufactured in the US in 1995 [16], only seven were derived from biofeed-
stocks, and five of these – ethanol, sorbitol, citric acid, lysine and glutamic acid
– used carbohydrates as the raw material source. Intense efforts within the last
decade [17–26] to boost the acquisition of organic chemicals from the sugars in
Table 1.1 have not basically changed this picture.
There are a variety of reasons for this. Current use of fossil raw materials is
more economic and, as important, the process technology for conversion of pet-
rochemical raw materials into organic chemicals is exceedingly well developed
and basically different from that required for transforming carbohydrates into
products with industrial application profiles. This situation originates from the
inherently different chemical structures of the two types of raw material, of
which the essence is manifested in their structure-based names (Fig. 1.2). Our
fossil resources are hydrocarbons, distinctly hydrophobic, oxygen-free and devoid
of functionality, thus, organic functional groups such as hydroxyl, amino, alde-
hyde, acid, ester or halo functionalities have to be introduced – usually into ole-
finic hydrocarbons such as ethylene, propylene, and butane – to obtain the in-
dustrially important intermediate chemicals. In contrast, annually renewables
are carbohydrates, overfunctionalized with hydroxyl groups and pronouncedly hy-
drophilic. Needless to say, that the methods required for converting carbohy-
drates into viable industrial chemicals – reduction of oxygen content with intro-
duction of C = C and C = O unsaturation – are diametrically opposed to those
prevalent in petrochemical industry.
As higher oil prices, environmental issues, and regulations begin to adversely
affect the manufacture of chemicals from fossil raw materials, the transition to
a biobased production system is unavoidable, strongly emphasizing the need for
systematically elaborating appropriate chemical and microbial process methods
to convert carbohydrates – they are the major biofeedstocks to fill the gap be-
tween dwindling oil supply and demand – into industrially useful products, be
it bulk, intermediate, and fine chemicals, pharmaceuticals, agrochemicals, high-
value-added specialty chemicals, or simply enantiomerically pure building
blocks for organic synthesis.
1.3
Current Non-Food Industrial Uses of Sugars
1.3.1
Ethanol
With production of about 24 million tons in 2004 (300 mill hL [27]), fermenta-
tion ethanol (“bioethanol”) is the largest-volume biobased chemical today. The
principal organism for fermentation is Saccharomyces cerevisiae, an ascomycetous
yeast that can grow on a wide variety carbohydrate feedstocks – sugar crops,
and sugar-containing by-products such as sugar cane, sugar beet, sorghum, mo-
lasses, and – after hydrolysis to glucose – starchy crops such as corn, potatoes,
and grain, or cellulosic materials, e.g. wood pulping sludges from pulp and pa-
per mills [28 a]. Recent developments [28 b] replace the conventional yeast by
bacteria (Zymomonas nobilis) and/or genetically engineered organisms, which
seems to improve productivity significantly.
The manufacturing costs are said to be approximately the same as those for
its production from ethylene in a plant of comparable size [28 c]. The large
growth in production of industrial-grade fermentation ethanol within recent
years is less because of its use as a solvent and starting material for follow-up
chemicals such as acetaldehyde, ethyl esters (e.g. EtOAc) and ethers (Et2O) –
these mostly result from ethylene-based processing lines – but because of its
high potential as a fuel additive. It is either directly mixed with standard gaso-
line at a level of 5%, or indirectly in the form of ETBE (ethyl t-butyl ether) in
proportions of up to 15%; a hefty government subsidy is, however, required (re-
8 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
1.3.2
Furfural
Most of the furfural currently produced is used as a selective solvent in the re-
fining of lubricating oil and, with furfuryl alcohol in condensations with formal-
dehyde, phenol, acetone, or urea, to yield resins with complex, ill-defined struc-
tures, yet excellent thermosetting properties, most notably high corrosion resis-
tance, low fire hazard, and extreme physical strength [29]; they are extensively
used in the foundry industry as cores for high-quality castings.
1.3.3
D-Sorbitol (: D-Glucitol)
Although the main consumer of its sizable annual production (Table 1.1) is the
food industry, primarily as a non-calorific sweetening agent and as a key inter-
mediate in the production of ascorbic acid (vitamin C) [12], it has important
non-food applications, because of its moisture conditioning, softening, and plas-
tifying properties. These result in its use in adhesives, paper, printing, textiles,
cellulose-based foil, and pharmaceutical formulations. Other non-food applica-
tions of d-sorbitol result from etherification and polycondensation reactions
which provide biodegradable polyetherpolyols used for soft polyurethane foams
and melamine–formaldehyde or phenol resins [34]. Sizable amounts of d-sorbi-
tol are also used for production of the sorbitan ester surfactants (cf. below).
10 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
1.3.4
Lactic Acid ? Polylactic Acid (PLA)
Large amounts of d-glucose – in the crude form as obtainable from corn, pota-
toes, or molasses by acid hydrolysis – are used in industrial fermentation pro-
cesses for production of lactic acid (Scheme 1.2), citric acid, and different amino
acids, for example l-lysine or l-glutamic acid. Although the major use of these
products is in food and related industries, recent non-food exploitation of lactic
acid have made it a large-scale, organic commodity chemical. Most of it is sub-
sequently polymerized via its cyclic dimer (lactide) to polylactic acid [36, 37], a
high molecular weight polyester.
Because of its high strength, PLA can be fabricated into fibers, films, and
rods that are fully biodegradable (? lactic acid, CO2) and compostable, having
degraded within 45–60 days. Accordingly, PLA and copolymers of lactic and gly-
colic acid are of particular significance for food packaging and in agricultural or
gardening applications, but are highly suitable materials for surgical implants
and sutures, because they are bioresorbable.
Cargill, since 1989, has invested some $ 750 million to develop and commer-
cialize polylactic acid (tradename “NatureWorks”), its Nebraska plant with an
annual capacity of 140 000 metric tons opened in 2002 [36, 37]. Thus, polylac-
tides, because they combine favorable economics with green sustainability, are
poised to compete in large-volume markets that are now the domain of thermo-
plastic polymers derived from petrochemical sources.
Another green development based on lactic acid is its ethyl ester (“Vertec”)
that has been marketed for applications in specialty coatings, inks, and directly
for cleaning because of its high performance and versatility [38]. As a most be-
nign solvent – green, readily biodegradable, and excellent toxicology – it has the
potential to displace a variety of petrochemically based solvents such as acetone,
DMF, toluene or N-methylpyrrolidone in industrial processes.
1.3.5
Sugar-based Surfactants
1.3.6
‘Sorbitan’ Esters
tions [34]. Having been commercially available since the 1940s, they de facto
constitute one of the first fully green synthetic surfactants, presently produced
at an estimated 20 000 t a–1.
1.3.7
N-Methyl-N-acyl-glucamides (NMGA)
1.3.8
Alkylpolyglucosides (APG)
1.3.9
Sucrose Fatty Acid Monoesters
These are currently produced at an approximate 5000 t · a–1 only, and are mostly
used in cosmetic and personal care formulations because of their attractive der-
matological properties. Produced by transesterification of fatty acid methyl es-
ters or fats, the resulting sucrose monoester (if 1 : 1 molar ratios have been used
in the process) is not a defined product acylated exclusively at the primary glu-
cose-6-OH, as indicated in the formula, but at the other primary and some sec-
ondary OH groups also [41]:
14 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
1.3.10
Pharmaceuticals and Vitamins
Aside the enormous amount of sugars, mostly glucose and sucrose, that flows into
the fermentative production of amino and hydroxy acids (cf. Table 1.1), of which a
substantial part is for food use, a significant volume of these sugars is used in fer-
mentation processes furnishing high-value-added products – antibiotics and vita-
mins, much too complex in their structures as to be generated by chemical synthe-
sis. Figure 1.3 lists several representative examples – penicillins and cephalospor-
ins with an estimated world production in the 70 000 t a–1 range, the aminogly-
coside antibiotics of the kanamycin and spectinomycin type, or the recently
optimized bioprocesses for bulk-scale production of vitamin C and B6.
Some sugar-derived drugs obtained by chemical means have also reached
some importance, e.g. ranitidine (Zantac), an inhibitor of gastric acid secretion
– one of the top 30 drugs based on sales [42] – isosorbide dinitrate, a coronary
vasodilatator [43], or topiramate, a fructose-derived anticonvulsant drug with
high antiepileptic efficacy [44].
1.4
Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines
6)
1.4.1
Furan Compounds
1.4.1.1
5-Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF)
Like many petroleum-derived basic chemicals, e.g. adipic acid or hexamethyl-
enediamine, HMF is a six-carbon compound with broad application potential,
inasmuch it is readily accessible from fructose or inulin hydrolysates by acid-in-
duced elimination of three moles of water [45]. Even a pilot-plant-size process
has been elaborated [46].
HMF has been used for the manufacture of special phenolic resins of type
12, because acid catalysis induces its aldehyde and hydroxymethyl group to react
with phenol [47].
12
ated [56]. Both of these reactions proceed in excellent yield. Aldol-type condensa-
tions deliver derivatives with polymerizable double bonds, most notably the
methylenation product 24, which polymerizes spontaneously, and the acrylic
acid 25 [55], expected to yield novel, hydrophilic polymers with interesting per-
formance profiles. Reductive amination provides GMF-amine; N-acylation of
this with fatty acid chlorides gives compounds of type 26, non-ionic surface-ac-
tive agents in which hydrophobic fat-alkyl residue and hydrophilic glucose part
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 19
into the area of C-glycosides, which, as stable “mimics” of the usual O-glyco-
sides, command major interest as glycosidase inhibitors [62].
1.4.2
Pyrones and Dihydropyranones
for the synthesis of non-carbohydrate natural products [65, 69] or for agrochem-
icals and/or high-value-added pharmaceuticals, a particularly versatile array of
six-carbon dihydropyranones is listed in Fig. 1.4; all are accessible from d-glucose
(via the glucal and hydroxyglucal esters) in no more than three to five straight-
forward steps.
All these pyran building blocks are enantiomerically pure and have a unique,
highly diverse array of functional groups to which the armory of preparative or-
ganic methodology can directly be applied. The enolone esters in Fig. 1.4, for ex-
ample, have three differently functionalized carbonyl groups, one being free,
the other two masked in enol ester and acetal form. In addition, the enolone
structural unit is flanked by chiral centers, so any addition reaction to either car-
bonyl or enolic double bond proceeds with high stereoselectivity. As for the dis-
accharide-derived building blocks 36–38, they feature functionality in one of the
24 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
units and – in the form of the intact glycosyl moiety – a cheap acid-sensitive
protecting group in the other.
In addition to their extensive use in the total synthesis of enantiomerically
pure non-carbohydrate natural products [65, 69] these pyran building blocks
have found little use as high-value-added chemicals. If suitable targets and ap-
propriate preparative outlets are found, however, particularly toward pharmaceu-
tically promising compound libraries via combinatorial techniques, these pyran
building blocks are likely to become a plethora of attractive, industrially relevant
specialty chemicals.
1.4.3
Sugar-derived Unsaturated N-Heterocycles
1.4.3.1 Pyrroles
The generation of pyrroles by heating a glycerol solution of lactose-derived am-
monium salt of galactaric acid over a free flame [84] seems to be the highest-
yielding acquisition (40%) from a carbohydrate source – a process that, in this
or a modified form, does not seem to be utilized industrially.
1.4.3.2 Pyrazoles
Expeditious four-step approaches to 1-phenylpyrazol-3-carboxaldehydes with 5-
hydroxymethyl, 5-dihydroxyethyl, or 5-glucosyloxymethyl substituents has been
elaborated starting from d-xylose [88], d-glucose, and isomaltulose [89], respec-
tively.
1.4.3.3 Imidazoles
A variety of imidazoles carrying hydrophilic substituents in the 4-position
are readily accessible in one-pot procedures from standard monosaccharides.
Of those, the formation of 4-hydroxymethylimidazole by Cu(II)-promoted reac-
tion with formaldehyde and conc. ammonia [90] is rather unique, because ob-
viously retroaldolization to glyceraldehyde and dihydroxyacetone is involved
(Scheme 1.10). The retroaldol fission can be partially suppressed, however, on
heating d-fructose with formamidinium acetate in liquid ammonia in a pres-
sure vessel [91] or with formamidinium acetate in the presence of boric acid
and hydrazine, obviously proceeding via a boric acid complex of the bishydra-
zone of d-glucosone [56].
1.4.3.4 3-Pyridinols
The conversion of pentosans or pentoses into 3-pyridinol can be effected in a
practical three-step sequence, involving acid-induced dehydration to furfural,
reductive amination to furfurylamine, and subsequent oxidation with hydrogen
peroxide [51, 92], the last step conceivably proceeding through the stage of a
2,5-dihydroxy-2,5-dihydrofurfurylamine, which forms the pyridine nucleus by
dehydration to a 5-aminopentenal intermediate and intramolecular aldimine for-
mation. The pyridinol is a prominent intermediate chemical for the preparation
of herbicides and insecticides [93], and cholinergic drugs of the pyridostigmine
type.
1.4.3.5 Quinoxalines
Useful one-pot procedures are also available for the conversion of various mono-
saccharides into tetrahydroxybutyl-substituted quinoxalines, the preparatively
most favorable conditions seem to be reaction of fructose with hydrazine, o-phe-
nylenediamine, and boric acid in dilute acetic acid by bubbling oxygen through
the solution [95], the decisive intermediate being the bis-hydrazone of d-gluco-
sone:
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 29
On briefly heating the quinoxaline under reflux in aqueous acid with excess
hydrazine or phenylhydrazine, a surprising oxidative cyclization occurs with for-
mation of the trihydroxypropyl-substituted flavazols [96].
1.4.4
Toward Sugar-based Aromatic Chemicals
On the basis of a 1995 compilation [16], twenty of the 100 major organic chemi-
cals in the US were aromatic compounds, invariably manufactured from fossil
raw materials, mostly from the BTX (benzene–toluene–xylene) fraction derived
from naphthas in refineries. There are very few alternatives. The direct thermo-
chemical conversion of biomass to an equivalent BTX product is not realistically
feasible, because only small amounts of monocyclic aromatic hydrocarbons –
phenols of the catechol and pyrogallol series – are formed on pyrolysis or ther-
mal cracking of woody feedstocks. The same is true for exposure of simple
sugars, for example d-xylose, d-glucose, or d-fructose, to either basic or slightly
acidic aqueous conditions at 100–160 8C [97]. Vanillin, however, is a by-product
of the manufacture of cellulose pulp by the action of alkali on basic calcium
lignosulfonate and may be isolated in yields of up to 25%.
30 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
Scheme 1.11 Metabolic engineering of the (c) E. coli KL3/pWL2.46B [101], (d) E. coli
shikimic acid pathway intermediates toward KL7/pSK6.161 [102]. Abbreviations: PEP = -
aromatic chemicals: chemical phosphoenolpyruvic acid, EHP = erythrose-4-
transformations; ? bioconversions with phosphate, DAHP = 3-deoxy-D-arabino-heptu-
biocatalysts. (a) E. coli QP1.1/pKD12.138 losonic acid 7-phosphate, DHQ = 3-dehydro-
[98], (b) E. coli SP1.1PTS–/pSC6.090B [99], quinic acid, DHS = 3-dehydroshikimic acid.
32 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
Whereas protocatechuic and gallic acid are generated via the shikimic acid
pathway, other C7 plant acids of c-pyrone structure are biosynthesized from
d-glucose via 3-deoxy-manno-octulosonate 8-phosphate (KDO 8-P), as a result of
aldol-type addition of PEP to d-arabino-5-phosphate (Scheme 1.12) [107].
Although widespread throughout the plant kingdom, daucic, chelidonic, and
meconic acids are of limited availability because of their capricious isolation
from the individual plants. Given their utility for industrial purposes when read-
ily accessible, metabolic engineering of the genes involved in the respective en-
zymes is likely to be the proper approach to their large-scale acquisition.
1.4.5
Microbial Conversion of Six-carbon Sugars
into Simple Carboxylic Acids and Alcohols
Some experts predict that biotechnology will produce up to 20% of the indus-
trial chemicals by 2010 – from the current level of 5% [108, 109]. Undoubtedly,
such an increase will receive its major thrust from the various genetically engi-
neered bioprocesses currently under industrial investigation, most notably those
that involve bioconversion of sugars into industrially relevant bio-alcohols other
than ethanol and into simple C3–C5 carboxylic acids other than those already
exploited (i.e. lactic, citric, and tartaric acids, and a variety of amino acids – cf.
Table 1.1). Table 1.2 lists a variety of acids and alcohols that can be obtained by
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 33
Each of these are considered to have high “building block potential”, either as
monomers for the production of novel polyesters and polyamides [112] or as a
starting material for a variety of commodity chemicals, currently produced pet-
rochemically. Accordingly, these five carboxylic acids are to become economically
viable products if low-cost fermentation routes can be developed and implemen-
ted on an industrial level. Even for glutamic acid – for which several fermenta-
tion processes have been industrially realized to meet the need for its sodium
salt as a flavor enhancer – the productivity of the organism and the final fer-
mentation titer must be improved if it is to become an attractive candidate for
chemical and microbial follow-up transformations [111 a]. The same is true for
aspartic acid, for which Krebs cycle pathway engineering of biocatalytic organ-
isms to overproduce oxaloacetate (cf. Scheme 1.13) are required to provide a
Scheme 1.13 Glycolytic pathway leading to the L-malic, fumaric, and succinic acids [114].
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 35
product competitive with the (racemic) one obtained currently from petrochem-
ical-derived fumaric acid by amination [111 b].
Unlike a product such as lactic acid, one of the attractions of 3-HPA is that it is
not manufactured commercially, either by chemical or biological means.
Fumaric Acid Fumaric acid, a metabolite of many fungi, lichens, mosses and
some plants, which is mainly used as the diacid component in alkyd resins
[115], is produced commercially to some extent by fermentation of glucose with
Rhizopus arrhizus [116], yet productivity improvements seem essential for the
product to be an option for replacing its petrochemical production by catalytic
isomerization of maleic acid.
Malic Acid Most of the malic acid produced, approximately 10 000 t a–1, is race-
mic, because it is derived from petrochemically produced fumaric acid. The L-
form can also be produced from fumaric acid by hydration with immobilized
cells of Brevibacterium or Corynebacterium species.
Succinic Acid Succinic acid is used to produce food and pharmaceutical prod-
ucts, surfactants and detergents, biodegradable solvents and plastics, and ingre-
dients to stimulate animal and plant growth. Although it is a common metabo-
lite formed by plants, animals, and microorganisms, its current commercial pro-
duction of 15 000 tons per year is from petroleum, i.e. by hydrogenation of
malic acid. The major technical hurdles for succinic acid as green, renewable
bulk scale commodity chemical – 1,4-butanediol, THF, c-butyrolactone, or pyrro-
lidones are industrially relevant products – entail the development of very low-
cost fermentation routes from sugar feedstocks. Currently available anaerobic
fermentations of glucose include use of an organism genetically cloned from As-
pergillus succinoproducens, an engineered E. coli strain developed by DOE labora-
tories [111 d], and several others [117]. The processes are currently under active
36 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
1,3-Propanediol Both the diol and the dicarboxylic acid components of poly(tri-
methylene terephthalate), a high performance polyester fiber with extensive ap-
plications in clothing textiles and carpeting, are currently manufactured from
petrochemical raw materials.
For the diol portion of the polyester, 1,3-propanediol, however, biobased alterna-
tives have been developed which rely on microbial conversion of glycerol [122],
a by-product of biodiesel production, or of corn-derived glucose [123]. For the
latter conversion, DuPont has developed a biocatalyst, engineered by incorporat-
ing genes from bakers’ yeast and Klebsiella pneumoniae into E. coli, which effi-
ciently converts corn-derived glucose in 1,3-propanediol [120, 123]. The biopro-
cess, currently being implemented on an industrial scale in a Tennessee manu-
facturing plant by a DuPont/Tate & Lyle joint venture will be providing bulk
quantities from 2006 [124].
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 37
1.4.6
Chemical Conversion of Sugars into Carboxylic Acids
The sugar-derived carboxylic acids mentioned in Table 1.1, i.e. gluconic, citric,
lactic, tartaric, and ascorbic acid, are accessible in bulk by fermentation pro-
cesses and may be considered (and used as) commodity chemicals despite being
mostly used for food purposes. In addition to these, however, there are several
industrially attractive carboxylic acids obtainable from sugars by chemical
means which have high potential as versatile building blocks.
38 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
In the 2004 DOE report [111], four of these sugar-derived carboxylic acids
have already been singled out as suitable candidates for further development:
· furan-2,5-dicarboxylic acid
· glucaric acid
· levulinic acid, and
· 3-hydroxybutyrolactone
yet there are many others that equally merit the development and implementa-
tion of low-cost preparative procedures to become competitive products. They
are addressed briefly here.
The high industrial potential of furan-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (19) (cf. Scheme 1.5),
accessible from fructose or fructosans (inulin) via HMF [45], has already been
emphasized, because it could replace petroleum-derived diacids such as adipic
or terephthalic acid in the production of polyesters and polyamides. The aldaric
acids of the key hexoses and pentoses as highly hydrophilic diacids also have
much potential, similar to that of the sugar platform – d-glucaric acid, a direct
nitric acid oxidation product of glucose or starch [128], usually isolated as its
1,4-lactone, galactaric and xylaric acid, accessible from lactose [129] and from d-
xylose or hemicellulosic xylans. The technical barriers to their large-scale pro-
duction are mainly development of efficient and selective oxidation technology
for these sugars to eliminate the need for nitric acid as oxidant. Investment in
Pt-catalyzed oxidation with oxygen seems to be a promising approach.
Because sucrose is cheaper than its component sugars d-glucose and d-fructose,
and available in unprecedented quantities (cf. Table 1.1) and exceptional purity,
carboxylic acids resulting from selective oxidation of its primary hydroxyl groups
are likely of even higher industrial relevance. Because of the persistence of an
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 39
1.4.7
Biopolymers from Polymerizable Sugar Derivatives
mers are non-toxic and biodegradable and, hence, have minimal impact on
waste management. They can be safely incinerated and, by composting, can be
returned to the ecosystem harmlessly in a carbon dioxide-neutral process.
Compound Derivation
1,2-Propanediol D-Glucose
1,3-Propanediol D-Glucose
2,5-Bis(hydroxymethyl)furan D-Fructose
1,6-Dianhydro-D-sorbitol D-Glucose
3,5-Bis(hydroxymethyl)pyrazole D-Xylose
Xylitol D-Xylose
D-Sorbitol D-Glucose
1,6-Diamino-1,6-dideoxy-D-glucitol D-Glucose
2,5-Bis(aminomethyl)furan D-Fructose
1.4 Toward Further Sugar-based Chemicals: Potential Development Lines 43
Compound Derivation
1.4.7.3 Polyamides
More than 90% of the polyamides produced worldwide, amounting to approxi-
mately 5.8 million tons in 1998 [146], are based on six-carbon monomers, i.e.
caprolactam (Nylon-6), and adipic acid/hexamethylenediamine (Nylon-66), the
manufacture of which is based exclusively in petroleum-based pathways [146].
Despite of the impressive array of highly useful products – their application profiles
compare favorably with those of well known commercial polyamides – none of these
sugar-derived polyamides is currently produced on an industrial scale; the reasons
are purely economic, because the products derived from fossil raw material sources
are still cheaper, on average by a factor of five. Eventually, however, with the end of
cheap oil predicted for 2040 [1], and the pressure on our environment increasing,
this untoward situation for products from carbohydrate feedstocks will change.
Because the sugar groups along the carbon chain may be freed from their O-
protection by smooth simple reactions, highly hydrophilic, in most cases water-
soluble polymers are obtained. These are not accessible from the respective
monomers with free OH groups, because these usually give polymers of low
molecular weight only, due to the increasing insolubility of oligomers.
48 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
Sucrose, the most readily accessible bulk-scale sugar, has received particular
attention in this context. A large variety of mono- and disubstituted ethers and
esters have been prepared – mostly not clearly defined with respect to attach-
ment of the residues to one or two of the eight OH groups – and subjected to
radical or ionic homo- and co-polymerizations – acryloyl, and methacryloyl es-
ters, styryl ethers, ethers with primary amino groups, etc. [162–165]. Some of
the respective polymers are depicted schematically in Fig. 1.8.
1.5 Conclusion 49
Despite the broad and versatile application profiles of these polymers, mainly
because of their enhanced hydrophilicity (compared with their hydrophobic pet-
roleum-derived counterparts), none seems to be produced commercially; one
reason is that only the sugar portion of these polymers is biodegradable, leaving
an extended carbon chain. Because biodegradability is currently a major issue
[137], these polyvinylsaccharides are unlikely to become petrochemical substitu-
tion options in the near future.
1.5
Conclusion
Materials Association [167] – play a substantially more dynamic role than hither-
to, e.g. by the elaboration of a conclusive funding strategy for the material utili-
zation of biorenewables rather than for biofuels and bioenergy only – a funding
strategy capable of providing and maintaining a judicious balance between applied
and basic research.
Applied research ordinarily has predefined goals usually applying known scien-
tific facts to the solution of practical problems, and has constraints that require
results in a short time. It certainly should be funded and implemented on a
broad basis, yet its short-term pressures, e.g. the expectation of obtaining mar-
ketable products within a three-year time frame, are often counter-innovative
and tend to dodge research projects too complex to be solved in a few years.
Basic (fundamental) research, in contrast, is driven by the interest and curiosity
of an investigator usually following his intuition, be it an unresolved phenome-
non, conflicting literature data, or the unconstrained exploration of a new inter-
face between existing methods; it frequently creates its aims and specific targets
along the way. Basic research of this sort inspires project proposals “for which
it is infeasible or impractical to express a performance goal in an objective,
quantifiable, and measurable form” [168]. Because Europe’s national granting
agencies, e.g. the FNR [169] or AGRICE [170], do not have provisions enabling
funding for such proposals, they have no chance of being supported [171].
Nevertheless, it is the author’s firm conviction that new, industrially viable, su-
gar-based chemicals and materials are likely to emerge as much from basic re-
search as from mission-oriented applied investigations. Thus, there is an urgent
need to create an instrument in our granting agency system that gives innova-
tive basic research projects an equal chance of support.
In this context, a pertinent cartoon (Fig. 1.9) seems to catch the essence of
the present scenario – “biogold”-bearing seams are not only to be found along
the common, much (re)searched main roads with conventional, generally ap-
plied means, but also – maybe even more likely – in remote, virgin, basic terri-
tory with unconventional, innovative methodology, and a healthy measure of in-
tuition and serendipity.
For full utilization of the “biogold” lying in carbohydrates – widely available
from the plant kingdom and easily recovered at low cost – any promising, inno-
vative research project, irrespective of involving mission-oriented, applied inves-
tigations or non-predefined basic explorations, should receive generous support
either by funding institutions or by the chemical industry and/or both. Econom-
ically sound biobased alternatives to petrochemicals – various potential exam-
ples are contained in this review – will then become available as a matter of
course.
References
115 K. Lohbeck, H. Haferkorn, W. Fuhr- duction and new trends”, Adv. Biochem.
mann, “Maleic and fumaric acids”, Ull- Engineering/Biotechn. 2002, 74, 239–
manńs Encyclopedia Industrial Chem., 259.
Wiley–VCH, 2000; http://www.mrw.in- 124 DuPont 2004, press release: http://
terscience.wiley.com/ueic/articles/ www.dupont.com/sorona/news/
a16_053/frame.html 052604.html
116 F. S. Carta, C. R. Soccol, L. P. Ramos, 125 (a) N. E. Altaras, D. C. Cameron, “Meta-
J. D. Fontana, “Production of fumaric bolic engineering of a 1,2-propanediol
acid by fermentation of enzymic hydro- pathway in E. coli”, Appl. Environ. Micro-
lyzates derived from cassava bagasse”, biol. 1999, 65, 1180–1185. (b) “En-
Bioresour. Technol. 1999, 68, 23–28. hanced production of (R)-1,2-propane-
117 (a) G. N. Vemuri, M. A. Eiteman, E. Alt- diol by metabolically engineered
man, “Succinate production in dual- E. coli”, Biotechnol. Progr. 2000, 16, 940–
phase E. coli fermentations depends on 946. (c) N. E. Altaras, M. R. Etzel, D. C.
the time of transition from aerobic to Cameron, “Conversion of sugars to 1,2-
anaerobic conditions”, J. Ind. Microbiol. propanediol by Thermoanaerobacterium
Biotechnol. 2002, 28, 325–332. (b) “Ef- thermosaccharolyticum”, Biotechnol.
fects of growth mode and pyruvate car- Progr. 2001, 17, 52–56.
boxylase on succinic acid production 126 N. Nishino, M. Yochida, H. Shiota, E.
by metabolically engineered E. coli Sakaguchi, “Accommodation of 1,2-pro-
strains”, Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 2002, panediol and enhancement of aerobic
68, 1715–1727. (c) R. R. Gokarn, M. A. stability in whole crop maize silage in-
Eiteman, J. Sridhar, “Production of suc- oculated with Lactobacillus buchneri”,
cinate by anaerobic microorganisms”, J. Appl. Microbiol. 2003, 94, 800–807.
in Fuels and Chemicals from Biomass, 127 W. Niu, M. N. Molefe, J. W. Frost, “Mi-
B. D. Saha, J. Woodard, eds., ACS crobial synthesis of the energetic mate-
Symp. Series 666, 1997, pp. 237–279. rial precursor 1,2,4-butanetriol”, J. Am.
118 J. H. Kane, A. Finlay, P. F. Amann Chem. Soc. 2003, 125, 12998–12999.
(Chas. Pfizer, Merck), “Itaconic acid”. 128 C. L. Mehltretter, “d-Glucaric acid”,
US Pat. 2 385–283 (1945); Chem. Abstr. Methods Carbohydr. Chem. 1963, 2, 46–
1946, 40, 995. 48.
119 (a) C. S. Reddy, R. P. Singh, “Enhanced 129 B. A. Lewis, F. Smith, A. M. Stephen,
production of itaconic acid from corn “Galactaric acid and its derivatives”,
starch and market refuse fruits by ge- Methods Carbohydr. Chem. 1963, 2, 38–
netically manipulated Aspergillus terreus 46.
SKR 10”, Bioresour. Technol. 2002, 85, 130 S. Immel, F. W. Lichtenthaler, “The
69–71. (b) T. Willke, K. Welter, K. D. conformation of sucrose in water: A
Vorlop, “Biotechnical production of ita- molecular dynamics approach”, Liebigs
conic acid from sugar”, Appl. Microbiol. Ann. Chem. 1995, 1938–1947.
Biotechnol. 2001, 56, 289–295. 131 M. Kunz, H. Puke, C. Recker, L.
120 DuPont 2004: http://www.dupont/soro- Scheiwe, J. Kowalczyk (Südzucker AG),
na/biobasedinitiative.html “Process and apparatus for the prepara-
121 SHELL 2004: http://www.shellchem- tion of mono-oxidized products from
icals.com/corterra/1,1098,280,00.html carbohydrates”, Ger. Offen. DE 4 307 388
122 M. M. Zhu, P. D. Lawman, D. C. Ca- (1994); Chem. Abstr. 1995, 122, 56411.
meron, “Improving 1,3-propanediol 132 L. A. Edye, G. V. Meehan, G. N. Ri-
production from glycerol in a metaboli- chards, “Platinum-catalyzed oxidation
cally engineered E. coli by reducing ac- of sucrose”, J. Carbohydr. Chem. 1991,
cumulation of glycerol-3-phosphate”, 10, 11–23; 1994, 13, 273–283.
Biotechnol. Prog. 2002, 18, 694–699. 133 M. Kunz, A. Schwarz, J. Kowalczyk
123 For an informative review, see: A. N. (Südzucker AG), “Process for continu-
Zeng, H. Biebl, “Bulk chemicals from ous manufacture of di- and higher-oxi-
biomass: Ease of 1,3-propanediol pro- dized carboxylic acids from carbohy-
58 1 The Key Sugars of Biomass
61
2
Industrial Starch Platform – Status quo of Production,
Modification and Application
Dietmar R. Grüll, Franz Jetzinger, Martin Kozich, Marnik M. Wastyn,
and Robert Wittenberger
2.1
Introduction
2.1.1
History of Starch
Although the early history of starch use is mainly unrecorded, some interesting
examples of its industrial uses are known. Starch paste was used by the ancient
Egyptians to cement strips of papyrus stem together for use as writing paper as
early as 4000 B.C. In a treatise Cato described a process used by the Romans
for separating starch from grain in 170 B.C., and 300 years later Celsus, a Greek
physician, described starch as a wholesome dietary product. Pliny the Elder (23–
74 A.D.) stated that the Romans used wheat starch to make papyrus documents,
to stiffen and whiten cloth and to powder their hair. In his Greek Herbal,
Dioscorides (1st century A.D.) recommended the use of wheat starch for the
treatment of ulcers, sores and eye inflammations. Around 312 A.D. starch was
shown to provide resistance to ink penetration in Chinese paper, so starches
from rice, wheat and barley came to be commonly used at that time. In 975
A.D. Abu Mansur, an Arab pharmacologist, described a method to treat wounds
with an artificial honey made by mixing starch with saliva. Starch was used in
northern Europe to stiffen linen, possibly as early as in the 13th to 14th centu-
ries. Colored starches were used as cosmetics, and uncolored starches were pri-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
62 2 Industrial Starch Platform – Status quo of Production, Modification and Application
marily used as hair powder. The Puritans used blue starch until it was banned
by Queen Elizabeth in 1596.
2.1.2
History of Industrial Starch Production
The most common sources of starch are maize, potato, wheat, tapioca, and rice.
Starches are isolated by wet grinding of the grain or tuber, followed by wet sift-
ing, centrifugation, and drying. Wheat starch is an exception in that it may also
be extracted from flour. These steps remove most of the other plant compo-
nents, for example proteins, oil, and fiber. Because of their availability, wheat
and barley were the first sources of starch to be commercially wet-milled. The
first American wheat starch plant was founded in Utica, New York, in 1807.
Wet milling of potato starch began in Hillsborough County, New Hampshire, in
1824, and in Europe at about the same time in Foxhol, The Netherlands, where
Willem Albert Scholten founded his first potato-starch mill. Wet milling of corn
began in 1844, when the Colgate wheat starch mill in Jersey City, New Jersey,
was converted to processing corn using Thomas Kingford’s alkaline purification.
2.1.3
History of Starch Modification
2.2
Raw Material for Starch Production
starch industries elsewhere. The different raw materials each supply a large
share of total starch output, as shown in Fig. 2.2.
In 2000, the world starch market was estimated to be approximately 48.5 mil-
lion tons, of which the EU holds a share of approximately 17% or 8.5 million
tons (Fig. 2.3). During the past 20 years the quantities of starch produced and
the demand in food and non-food areas have increased continually. Whereas the
increase worldwide was about threefold (Fig. 2.5) in the past 20 years, the in-
crease in the EU was some 2.5-fold (Fig. 2.4); this was mainly based on an in-
crease in maize and wheat-starch production capacity.
2.3 Industrial Production of Starch 65
2.3
Industrial Production of Starch
Moisture (%) 16 75 70 13 14
Starch (%) 62 19 24 60 77
Protein (%) 8.2 2 1.5 13 7
Minerals/Ash (%) 1.2 1.2 2 1.7 0.5
Sugars (%) 2.2 1.1 0.5 8 0.3
Fiber (%) 2.2 1.6 0.7 1.3 0.3
Fat (%) 4.2 0.1 0.5 3 0.4
66 2 Industrial Starch Platform – Status quo of Production, Modification and Application
2.3.1
Maize and Waxy Maize
As starch has been produced industrially from yellow maize for more than a
century, the process is technically well developed. Typically maize starch fac-
tories have a daily processing capacity of 500–2000 tons of maize. The produc-
tion of maize starch (Fig. 2.6) starts with steeping purified maize kernels. This
means that maize is not just swelling in water, which has a temperature of
about 50 8C and a pH of 3.8–4.2, but these conditions cause a controlled lactic
acid fermentation and loosen the protein matrix. Steeping is an important step,
because the maize kernels absorb up to 45% (wet basis) of water, release solu-
bles, absorb sulfur dioxide (0.2–0.4 g per kg) and become soft enough to be suit-
able for separation of its components.
After steeping, the grains are coarsely ground in an attrition mill, and then
the germs are separated in special hydrocyclones. The grinding and separation
processes must be performed twice for complete removal of the germs. This is
followed by fine grinding in a pin mill or impact mill in order to completely
disrupt the cells. At this stage the starch is freely in suspension and is led over
bend screen cascades for separation from fiber and other maize components.
The separated residues are dehydrated and dried for use as an animal feed com-
ponent referred to as maize feed.
The crude starch milk still contains all the dissolved proteins. This fraction is
called gluten, and most of it is separated off by means of two successive nozzle
type continuous centrifugal separators. The gluten is dehydrated by means of a
rotary vacuum filter, then dried and used as a feed additive similar to maize
feed. The starch milk, which still contains approximately 2% of protein after
separation, is then refined in a multi-step cyclone plant. The refined starch
milk, having a residual protein content of approximately 0.3%, is dehydrated in
peeler centrifuges and dried by means of a flash dryer. The residual water con-
tent of the starch at this stage is less than 14%, and the product is storable.
In some cases the starch production plant is connected with saccharification
and ethanol production plants.
Waxy maize is a special form of yellow maize. Its starch contains more than
99% amylopectin. The production of waxy maize starch is similar to normal yel-
low maize starch.
2.3.2
Wheat
Wheat starch can be produced either from wheat flour or by wet milling of
wheat grain. Industrial production of wheat starch is almost exclusively from
wheat flour. There are a large number of processes which are basically similar
but differ in the means of producing and further processing the wheat dough.
In the first step the wheat flour is stirred with water in special mixing machines
to form a dough or a suspension (Fig. 2.7). Then the wheat paste is separated
2.3 Industrial Production of Starch 67
2.3.3
Potato
Potato is the most important tuber used for industrial isolation of starch. It has the
advantage that the extraction process is simpler than that used for cereals, because
it is not necessary to swell or mill them or prepare a dough. The disadvantages are
the lower starch content of tubers and the large quantity of fruit water produced,
which is the main cause of sewage problems arising from potato starch plants.
Processing (Fig. 2.8) starts after purification of the tubers by rasping by
means of a rotary saw blade rasp, in which potatoes are converted into a mash.
This process results in a nearly complete disruption of the potato cells, which
therefore release the starch. Because of this disruption technique, starch yields
in modern potato starch plants are in excess of 97%. Sulfur dioxide is added to
the rasped potatoes to avoid discoloration, which is a result of the action of phe-
nol oxidases.
In modern plants the high protein fruit water is separated off by means of de-
canters before the starch is extracted. This reduces the problem of sewage, and
the valuable potato protein may be separated. The soluble proteins are coagu-
lated by treatment with acid and heat and then separated in decanters. The
starch in the rasped potatoes is isolated by means of centrisieves, yielding 99%
of pure starch. The remaining pulp is drained or pressed off and used directly
as feed while still damp or dried in flash dryers. The dilute starch milk had to
be concentrated in separators or multi cyclone units prior to the next step of
processing. Potato starch is refined in several steps in hydro cyclone plants. The
starch is dewatered by rotary vacuum filtration and subsequently dried in a
flash dryer.
2.3.4
Tapioca
Tapioca starch is a root starch which is produced from the roots of manioc or
cassava plants. Its starch content is about as low as that of potato. One disad-
vantage is that the roots are not storable. Therefore they have to be processed
within 24 h of harvesting. Another problem is that the roots contain the glyco-
side linamarin, from which prussic acid may emerge during decomposition.
Most of the steps of industrial tapioca starch production are similar to those
of potato starch production (Fig. 2.9). After purification the roots are first cut
into potato-size pieces with a crusher and then rubbed with a rotary saw blade
rasp, which is the same as that used for potato rasping. The starch is extracted
in centrisieves. The steps of concentration and refining correspond to those in
potato-starch production. The only difference is that finer sieves are used be-
cause the starch granules are smaller in size. Like maize starch, tapioca starch
is dewatered with peeler centrifuges and subsequently dried.
2.3.5
Other Starches
Apart from the main starch sources described above, there are a number of
starch containing plants of less importance for industrial application. They are,
however, worth mentioning because of their often very interesting properties.
Sweet potatoes, for example, are used for starch production in Japan and are
processed in the same way as normal potatoes.
In the field of cereal starches, rice and millet are used regionally for industrial
starch production, whereas rye and barley are rarely utilized because of their
lower availability, their low starch content and their difficult production. Rice
starch is usually produced from broken rice. Rice is first steeped under alkaline
conditions and then ground and washed through a sieve. The separated fiber
fraction is used as feed. The starch milk is separated from the paste by means
of separators, dewatered in centrifuges and subsequently dried. Millet starch
production is similar to the maize starch process. Therefore, it can be produced
in maize starch plants, although an adaptation of the plant is necessary, because
the millet starch granules are smaller and therefore require the use of smaller
sieves and some changes in the milling process.
The starch from different kinds of peas, beans and tropical plants such as ba-
nana, shoti roots and curcuma has been investigated because of its scientifically
interesting properties. The production of so-called “tropical starch” is still in the
experimental stage although it has been ascribed great potential in the future.
2.4
Properties of Commercial Starches
in most kinds of starches. Amylose is a largely linear molecule built from 1,4
linked a-D-glucopyranosyl units having an average molecular mass of 1 ´ 105 to
1 ´ 106. Amylopectin is different from amylose in that it has both a-1,4 and a-
1,6 bonds and a higher molecular mass of 1 ´ 107 to 1 ´ 108. The molecular mass
varies substantially, depending on the method of isolation and determination. A
method for the determination of the molecular mass of the polymers is a liquid
chromatographic method called size-exclusion chromatography (SEC), in which
the molecules are separated according to their hydrodynamic volume. Figure
2.10 shows the molecular mass distributions of six different types of starch.
Because of these different structures, the two fractions of starch have different
specific properties. Amylopectin is responsible for the partial crystallinity of
starch, with the crystalline properties resulting from clusters of layers of the
amylopectin molecules. The crystalline units are separated by amorphous layers.
When studied by light microscopy with polarized light, these layers appear as
Maltese crosses because of the optical properties of the starch granules
(Fig. 2.11). These optical properties enable assessment of whether or not the
starch granules are intact, because they are lost after e.g. thermal treatment.
The shape and size of starch granules can be measured microscopically,
which allows identification of the origin of the starch. The shape of the gran-
ules is difficult to describe, because it is never uniform. The shapes often range
from round to oval, oblong, kidney-shaped, edged, polyhedral, and rosette-
shaped. The size of the granules is between 1 lm and approximately 100 lm,
and each type of starch usually contains a broad distribution (Table 2.2). Ama-
2.4 Properties of Commercial Starches 73
ranth and rice starch are examples of starches having small granules, potato
starch is an example of a large granule starch.
Diffraction patterns obtained by X-ray irradiation of starch allow identification
of different types of starch and further classification of the material. Cereal
starches have been assigned to type A, root and tuber starches to type B, and
mixed forms (e.g. legume starch) to type C. The diffraction patterns result from
different degrees of polymerization of the amylopectin side chains, resulting in
double helix chains of different pack density. In type B, the double helices are
less closely packed than in type A, in which more water can be stored, giving a
different diffraction pattern.
Commercially produced starch contains several contaminants, the amounts
and types of which are generally dependent on the type of starch plant but also
on the quality of the production process. Because the properties and quality of
the starch can be severely affected by these substances, attempts are being made
to reduce the total amount to less than 1%. This is usually achieved in a mod-
ern production plant. Typical accompanying substances are proteins, lipids, and
salts. Phosphorus is especially important, because it is bonded to starch in the
form of a salt of phosphoric acid or, in potato starch, an ester. This bonding to
the hydroxyl groups of starch strongly affects the properties of the starch, partic-
ularly potato starch. Potato starch has greater swelling properties, stronger an-
ionic character and forms a paste of clearly higher viscosity stability. The main
minerals in starch are sodium, potassium, calcium, and magnesium.
74
MS WMS PS TS WS RS
Brabender peak viscosity [BU] 870 2800 2010 540 300 680
(concentration) (6.25%) (6.25%) (4%) (5%) (6.25%) (6.25%)
Gelatinization temperature [8C] 62–80 63–72 56–66 52–65 52–85 61–78
a) Bimodal distribution
b) Resulting mainly from salt
2 Industrial Starch Platform – Status quo of Production, Modification and Application
which can lead to the formation of gels. Retrogradation may be substantially re-
duced by different methods, for example by chemical modification.
2.5
Modification of Starch
2.5.1
Modification Technology
Native starch has a granular structure and is used in this form in only a few specific
applications. For normal applications starch is converted into a hydrated or gela-
tinized form, either by the user or the producer. In any case, any change of the
original starch means a modification. Natural starch can be modified by chemical,
physical, enzymatic treatment or by a combination of these methods (Fig. 2.13).
(e.g. sodium sulfate) are often used, which allow the application of more intensive
and therefore more efficient reaction conditions. The slurry concentration is
usually 30–40% of dry matter, and the reaction temperature is usually from 25
to 50 8C. Under these conditions starch is often modified by treatment with dilute
acids or alkalis (pH 1– pH 12). This treatment results in only minor substitution
and limited degradation. More substitution leads to undesired swelling of the
starch, which makes further processing more complicated.
These modified starches are usually washed free from salt, drained and dried
in a flash dryer. The advantages of this process are that it yields almost pure
starch derivatives without any side-products, and that energy costs are low.
These starches are normally sold as products that are insoluble in cold water
(cook up starches). In special cases the starches may be modified by extrusion,
drum drying, or spray cooking to make them cold-water soluble according to
consumers’ needs.
2.5.2
Types of Starch Modification
it does not form a real solution but a colloid dispersed gel. The addition of
chemicals such as alkalis influences the swelling properties as well as the solu-
tion conditions. Swelling starches for non-food applications are mostly produced
by drum drying, extrusion, or spray cooking.
tutes. Ionic groups may also be introduced into starch by etherification. Starch
is carboxymethylated by reaction with chloroacetic acid, chloroacetic acid salts or
esters. Anionic starches are used in construction, sizing and textile printing.
The solubility of carboxymethylated starch in non-aqueous solvents increases
with increasing substitution. Therefore, the most highly substituted products
are optimally produced by reaction in alcohol solutions. Cationic starch ethers,
i.e. polysaccharides which become positively charged in acid as a result of proto-
nation, are as industrially important as anionic starches, the most important
ones being the tertiary and quaternary ammonium alkyl ethers. Quaternary am-
monium alkyl ethers are produced by reacting starch with appropriate epoxides
or the corresponding chlorohydroxy compounds. Cationic starches have a spe-
cial affinity to negatively charged celluloses, fibers, sludges, etc. They are pro-
duced by slurry reaction, paste reaction, extrusion, and by semi dry technology.
They are predominantly applied in the paper industry and as flocculants. One
example of a Michael addition is the preparation of cyanoethylated starch by re-
action with acrylonitrile. Depending on the strength of the base, the product
may be further hydrolyzed to the amide or the carboxylic acid. Carbamoyl ethyl
starch ethers are used in the cement and textile industries. Another important
modification of starch is cross-linking. Reaction with a variety of polyfunctional
reagents, e.g. phosphorus oxychloride, epichlorhydrin, adipic acid, vinylsulfones,
or aldehydes, e.g. propionaldehyde, allows construction of a three-dimensional
network in the starch. Cross-linking may proceed both on the intramolecular
and on the intermolecular levels. Pure cross-linking may be used to reduce the
extent of swelling of the starch. Usually, however, cross-linking is carried out in
combination with further modification steps, resulting in increased shear stabil-
ity and better thickening properties. Such materials are used as textile print
thickeners.
The types of modification described in this section lead to different classes of
products summed up in Fig. 2.14. This figure is not just an overview of these
products, but it also shows how modification of starch varies depending on the
chosen application.
2.6
Application of Starch and Starch Derivatives
Starch and modified starches or starch derivatives have a broad range of applica-
tions both in the food and non-food sectors. A comparison of the compositions
of the two largest markets, the US and the EU, shows how starches are used
differently (Table 2.3). While in the US production of isoglucose, high-fructose
corn syrup (HFCS), and ethanol are the most important uses of starch, these
are of secondary importance in the European Union.
EU US
In Europe in 2002, the total consumption of starch and starch derivatives was
approximately 7.9 million tons, of which 54% or 4.3 million tons were used in
food applications and 46% in non-food applications. By far the largest user of
starch and starch derivatives in the EU (29%) is in the paper, board, and corru-
gating industries. Other important fields are textiles, adhesives, cosmetics, phar-
maceuticals, construction, paints, and agrochemicals. The use of starches in the
manufacture of detergents and biodegradable plastics has become of increasing
interest in recent years (Fig. 2.15).
2.6.1
The Paper and Corrugating Industries
also dewatering and retention of fiber and filling materials. The industry also
uses amphoteric starch and, in special applications, anionic starches. Combina-
tions of native starches and cationic polymers, e.g. polyvinylamines, are only
used to a limited extent.
Addition and retention of starch in the paper pulp by electrostatic interaction
between starch and fibers is quantitatively limited to 1–2% of starch per paper
and depends on the type of fiber and starch. Higher additions of starch to paper
to obtain greater strengths are achieved by sizing paper with starch solutions in
a size press. Usually, degraded starches are used in this application. The degra-
dation is usually a depolymerization carried out either in the starch factory (oxi-
dized starches, dextrin) or in the paper factory directly before use (thermochem-
ical or enzymatic degradation). The method of production and the type of starch
allows control of the strengths of the paper (dry strength, bursting strength, sur-
face strength) as well as other quality features, for example smoothness, print-
ability, and stiffness. In addition to degraded native starches, degraded slightly
modified starches (cationized or acetylated) may be used as well.
A fundamental disadvantage of paper sizing with starch solutions is that the
dampening of the paper means that the machine speed must be reduced, which
affects the output. Therefore, size presses have been mostly replaced by film
presses, which allow less penetration of the paper. In addition to this global trend,
efforts are being made to replace paper sizing with starch by increasing the addi-
tion of starch to the pulp. This requires dual technologies that permit an increased
use of cationic starch (>1.5%) through the addition of an anionic component (e.g.
silicic acid, bentonite, polyaluminum oxide, alum, anionic starch). Many systems
are now being tested in an experimental stage wherein the starch is not in a sol-
uble state but in a more or less particulate state and is retained mechanically in the
paper sheet. Hopefully, this will include significantly more starch (> 2%) in the pa-
per. As of now, however, these new systems are still not economical.
In paper coating, starch is mainly employed as a binder or as a co-binder in coat-
ing colors. Degraded starch products are usually used to bind the pigments to the
paper fibers. The starch also controls water retention and rheology of the coating
colors. Starch as a co-binder is in widespread use for precoating, usually in com-
bination with latex as the binder in the top coat. Coating starches are usually oxi-
datively degraded starches, dextrin, or enzymatically degraded starches, which are
used in highly concentrated solutions. Modified, e.g. acetylated, ethoxylated, and
propoxylated starches are also commonly used in this field.
Spray starch is mainly used in carton production. The different paper layers
are stuck together by spraying starch on them. The starch becomes gelatinized
in the drying section of the paper machine, and thus the paper layers stick
together. Usually, native starches are used in this application, but modified
starches having a reduced gelatinization temperature, and some cold-water solu-
ble starches may be used as well.
2.6 Application of Starch and Starch Derivatives 85
2.6.2
The Textile Industry
Large quantities of starch are used in the textile industry. Usually, the products
are used to facilitate textile treatment and are removed from the product after
the process. Here it is an advantage that starch degrades naturally. The starches
used are native, modified or even highly modified, predominantly starch ethers.
In this application starch has to compete against synthetic polymers.
a tough, abrasion-resistant and elastic film and good desizing. With the develop-
ment of high-performance weaving machines achieving high weft insertion
rates, it has become necessary to modify the starches accordingly. Originally, na-
tive products were used for sizing; nowadays, degraded modified starch esters
and starch ethers are used. The starch may be degraded under oxidizing or ther-
mal conditions by use of an extruder. Modifications include propoxylation, car-
boxymethylation, acetylation and carbamate production by the Noredux process.
These products have to compete against synthetic polymers, for example poly-
acrylates and polyvinyl alcohols, as well as against semi-natural carboxymethyl
celluloses. Mixtures of starch and synthetic sizing agents are used for fine cot-
ton products and semi-synthetic materials (e.g. mixtures of cotton and poly-
ester), again competing with synthetic products.
In countries where potato and tapioca starches are available, these are usually
favored as raw materials. If such starches are not available, maize and wheat
starches are used, but mostly in combination with synthetic products. Cooking
starches and cold-water soluble starches are used as well. The great advantage
of starch products is their still low costs and their sustainability because they
are biodegradable.
2.6.3
Adhesives
2.6.4
Building Chemistry
tives. The systems in which starches are used range from a wide variety of
structural materials, e.g. mortars and concretes, to surface-applied plaster, etc.
Cold-water soluble starch derivatives, i.e. highly modified so-called starch ethers
of substantially modified starch grains, are usually produced by drum drying.
The extent of modification is very important for special applications. In the field
of plastering, highly propoxylated starch ethers based on potato starch are used.
Such starch ethers are used for both hand plasters and machine plasters based
on gypsum and cement. In these plasters the starch acts as a synergistic addi-
tive to highly modified cellulose, which is also responsible for water retention.
The starch improves the stability of the plaster, making it easier to handle. The
use of starch increases productivity and stand-up quality. Starch ethers are only
applied in very small quantities of up to 0.1%, depending on the formulation.
In fillers, the amount of modified celluloses is higher. Starch ethers are used
to reduce the stickiness and to slow down the formation of a film on material
which may be exposed to the atmosphere for a long time.
Another important field of application is tile cement, which also exploits the
synergistic effects of highly modified celluloses and starch ethers, like plaster.
For tile cement, however, the important properties are workable time, ease of
application, and setting time.
Another application of starch products which has come up in recent years is
self-levelling concrete, a self-compacting concrete that gives a very flat surface
without requiring vibration. Starch ethers are used as new viscosity-modifying
agents that help reduce bleed and improve the stability of the concrete mixtures.
A new field of application for starch was recently found in the dry-jet process for
conventional tunnelling. Tunnelling not only requires economic efficiency, but
ecological considerations and working conditions are important, too. Dust forma-
tion may be reduced, thus improving work hygiene and mitigating the effect of
dust on the environment. A clear reduction of rebound may be achieved by using
a highly hydroxypropylated cold-water soluble starch ether based on maize starch.
If it is possible to pre-moisturize dry spray concrete, starch ether will have even
more favorable properties. Depending on the starch ether used, less than 0.20%
is usually required in the cement to give the spray concrete the desired properties.
The starch must not negatively affect the early strength of the fresh sprayed con-
crete, but the required concrete strength must still be achieved with aging.
Hydrolyzed wheat or maize starches are used in the manufacturing of plaster-
boards. The starches are responsible for binding the gypsum core to the card-
board. The starch is believed to migrate into the surface of the gypsum core
and act as a glue between gypsum and cardboard.
2.6.5
Pharmaceuticals and Cosmetics
Many pharmaceutical products such as tablets etc. are taken orally, but not as
nutrients, so they are not classified as food. Starches act as excipients and must
fulfill special requirements. Specially modified products are used as binding
2.6 Application of Starch and Starch Derivatives 89
agents to give tablets high strength, low abrasion loss, and stable consistency.
Starch is also used in products which are solid when dry but swell when wet
(oral administration), and it is also used to accelerate the breakdown of the ta-
blet to release the drug. Such products are based either on swelled, spray-cooked
starches or, if the grain structure has to be preserved on in organic solvent, on
highly modified starches, which can develop an enormous swelling capacity.
The opposite effect is required for tablet coatings. In this case, the starch has to
make the tablets stable enough for handling and trading, and it has to prevent
the release of the drug before the moment of oral administration.
A new application of starches is hard or soft capsules. So far, gelatin products
have usually been used, but these are now out of favor because of BSE (bovine
spongiform encephalopathy). In the production of capsules, gelatin may be suc-
cessfully substituted by specially modified starches.
Hydroxyethylated, highly degraded starches which may be obtained in high
purity and toxin-free may be used as blood plasma substitutes.
Starch products are also used in cosmetics, for example in toothpastes, pow-
ders, and shampoos. They often contain crosslinked waxy maize and rice
starches which support the active ingredient and are responsible for the soft,
velvety feeling of the pastes on the skin. Such starch derivatives are also found
in baby powder, eye shadow, and face powder. Highly crosslinked sterilisation
stable cooking starches are used as separating agents and lubricants in the pro-
duction of condoms and surgical gloves. Acylated products are used as emulsi-
fiers in pastes, and propoxylated phosphate ester starches are used in shampoos
to give them a soft feeling on the skin. An essential requirement for all these
products is high purity and non-toxicity.
2.6.6
Laundry Starches
Native starch is widely used for washing bed sheets and table cloths to extend
the lifetime of the fabric and to impart stiffness and finish to the material. Mod-
ern laundries often use soluble starches packaged with a suitable propellant in
aerosol cans for starching garments during steam ironing.
As an alternative to non-biodegradable co-builders, graft copolymers of starch
having a high carboxylate content are often used as ion-exchange materials in
water softeners.
2.6.7
Bioconversion of Starch
taining raw materials, e.g. wheat, maize, and rye, is booming. Usually, starch is
saccharified enzymatically (by a-amylase and amyloglucosidase), and the organic
hydrolysate is fermented to alcohol by means of yeast. “Bioethanol” thus pro-
duced is mostly used as an admixture to mineral fuels, but it is also used as a
raw material for the synthesis of ethyl tertiary butyl ether (ETBE). The residues
from fermentation may be made into highly nutritious animal feed.
In addition to the production of ethanol, starch hydrolysate also serves as a
carbon source in many other fermentations. For example, many organic acids
such as citric acid, acetic acid, gluconic acid, 2-ketogluconic acid (the first step
in the production of erythorbic acid), and itaconic acid are produced from starch
syrups. Other organic acids, e.g. maleic acid, fumaric acid, and l-tartaric acid,
are produced biotechnically from glucose syrup in an economical process. As-
corbic acid (vitamin C) may also be produced from starch syrup.
Enzymes are widely used in food and non-food applications. Most of the en-
zymes are produced in bio-technical processes using glucose of starch as the
source of carbon. The production of many hydrolytic enzymes, e.g. amylases,
proteases, and cellulases, is catabolically inhibited by glucose, and therefore it is
advisable to use only slowly metabolized substrates such as starch or partly hy-
drolyzed starch. a-Amylases and amyloglucosidases are produced on an indus-
trial scale by fermenting hydrolyzed maize starches (with bacillus and aspergil-
lum). Many amino acids, e.g. arginine, lysine, glutamic acid, glutamine, histi-
dine, threonine, and valine, may be produced biotechnically from starch glu-
cose. Antibiotics such as penicillin G and V, cephalosporin, and oxytetracycline
are also obtained by fermentation of substrates containing hydrolyzed starches
as essential nutrient components.
Many other industrial chemicals are produced by fermentation of glucose
syrups, and because of the permanent shortage and increase in price of fossil
resources there is a growing interest in alternative economical processes for pro-
ducing organic chemicals such as propanediol, glycerin, butanediol, 2-propanol,
polyalkonates, polyhydroxybutanoic acid, and polylactic acid. Other products that
may be obtained by fermentation of glucose or glucose syrups include alginate,
dextran, and xanthan.
Starch hydrolysates and starch syrups are used as starting materials for the
industrial production of iso-syrups on a large scale. Fructose syrups are pro-
duced by enzymatic transformation from glucose to fructose (iso-glucose) using
so-called glucose isomerase. Iso-syrups are often used as sweetening agents and
sugar substitutes in pharmaceuticals and dietary products.
Cyclodextrins a, b and c are water-soluble cyclic non-reducing oligosaccharides
produced by liquefaction of starch with special enzymes, the so-called CGT-ases
(cyclomaltodextrin glycosyl transferases). The special complex forming proper-
ties of the cyclodextrins make them successfully applicable in many fields in-
cluding cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, analytical chemistry, textile production, etc.
2.6 Application of Starch and Starch Derivatives 91
2.6.8
Other Applications of Starch
sand grains with a fine-grained, fire-proof filler and act as a separating agent al-
lowing ready detachment of the cast from the mold. They also have a positive
effect on the surface of the casts so that they may be used without much addi-
tional treatment. In this field, starch derivatives compete with celluloses, poly-
saccharides, acrylate dispersions, and alkyd emulsions.
A growing field of application of starches is the textile glass-fiber industry.
Glass-fiber weavings are coated with a complex dressing and dried to produce
glass-fiber wallpaper. Such dressings usually contain dispersing and crosslink-
ing agents, a paraffin emulsion, and a number of starch derivatives, which are
responsible for the good wet strength and elasticity of the wallpaper. Usually,
phosphorized carbamate starches or propoxylated oxidized cold-water soluble
starches based on potato starch are used.
2.7
Future Trends and Developments
In recent years, the demand for starch has grown constantly, and this develop-
ment is expected to continue during the next decade. If growth continues ac-
cording to recent trends, starch production in 2010 is estimated to be more than
70 million tons. This growth scenario will be boosted by the development of
new application areas, new technologies in starch modification resulting in new
properties, and tailor-made starches produced mainly by applying biotechnologi-
cal processes.
The increasing need for crude oil a basis for petrochemicals leading to high
prices will trigger starch use in new application areas. New product properties,
e.g. biodegradability and compatibility with the “bio–energy” market, will be
based on starch-producing plants. In recent years increasing efforts have been
made to investigate new modification technologies, for example high-pressure
treatment, low-temperature modification, pulsed high electric field treatment,
and ultrasonic treatment, resulting in starches having new properties. The in-
corporation of new functionalities by chemoenzymatic derivatization or biotrans-
formation will also open new markets for starch-based products. Transgenic
plants produced by new biotechnological tools are expected to produce new tai-
lor-made starches.
2.7.1
Tailor-made Starches made by using Biotechnological Tools
The property profiles of starch products for a variety of food and non-food appli-
cations require complex physical, chemical, or enzymatic modifications of the
starches. Therefore, growers try to breed varieties of starch-producing plants of
higher agricultural performance, e.g. higher yield per hectare, better resistance
against diseases and pests etc., as well as plants that grow to produce starch
having the required polymer characteristics. These efforts have not only been
2.7 Future Trends and Developments 93
made by conventional breeding methods, but also, for some 20 years, by genetic
modification of the plants. A classical example from the past is the development
of mutants of yellow maize, so-called waxy maize species, that produce a starch
made up of pure amylopectin. This provided a qualitatively and economically
superior alternative to the complicated fractionation of conventional starch for
the production of pure amylopectin. Similar procedures for obtaining amylopec-
tin starches have been applied to other starch-producing plants. Mutants or
genetically modified potatoes, tapioca, wheat, sweet potato and rice, etc., which
are now available and have, to a certain extent, already found their ways into in-
dustrial uses. Plant species which produce starches having a high amylose con-
tent have been bred in a conventional way. Especially famous are, e.g., mutants
of maize (amylomaize) and different types of rice, rye, and pea species. Cur-
rently, potatoes are being developed which produce high-amylose starch.
Beside the required amylose or amylopectin content, further attempts have
been made to develop plants which grow to produce new starches having specif-
ic properties. Examples already developed or under development include
starches having an increased phosphor content, altered particle size distribution,
different branching degree or amylopectin-sidechain length, higher viscosity,
special rheology and retrogradation properties, or combinations thereof. It is to
be expected that in the very near future an increasing number of starches hav-
ing special functions, obtained from new plant species, will be introduced to
the market.
2.7.2
New Modification Technologies for New Properties
The permanent need for starch products having better or different properties
leads to the development and use of new technologies for the production and
modification of starch products. For example, pulsed high electric field or ultra-
sonic treatment have been shown to be useful for extracting starch from e.g. po-
tatoes or maize. The use of these new technologies reduces the amount of en-
ergy needed to extract the starch, resulting not only in higher yields but also in
starch and starch derivatives of higher purity.
New ways of modifying starch, e.g. high-pressure or cryo treatment, are the
subject of very intensive research. These new treatment methods furnish
starches e.g. with special rheology characteristics. Wide-spread application of
these new technologies will depend on whether the higher costs of the pro-
cesses can be justified by better performance of the modified starches. These
new technologies may become very important in the production of organic
starches having improved properties. Another important topic of high interest
is the further development or combination of current technologies. For example,
the combination of spray-drying technology and gelatinization of starch using
steam directly in the spray drier (spray cooking) has led to many new starches
having special viscosity characteristics. Similar developments are now being in-
vestigated e.g. in the field of reactive extrusion processing.
94 2 Industrial Starch Platform – Status quo of Production, Modification and Application
2.7.3
New Fields of Application
While in the 2nd half of the 20th century petrochemical products boomed and
put some applications of starch under pressure (e.g. in the field of textiles and
adhesives), this trend is expected to reverse in the 21st century. A number of ap-
plications of classical petrochemical products are criticized for their lack of sus-
tainability, and the demand for sustainable alternatives is increasing. A typical
example is biodegradable packaging material. Highly intensive research has
been done in recent years in the field of thermoplastic starches, and it is just a
matter of time until new products enter this huge market.
In this general trend, in many fields of application new solutions are being
investigated that are based on starch. Intensive work is done in the field of
application of specially modified starches for inks, coatings, and paints, and
new products are expected to be launched very soon.
The type-dependant, particular granular structure of starches allows use of
these starches in special applications, e.g. as a pigment in paper coatings.
Recently, hydrophobized starch derivatives have been described for use in de-
tergents in a number of applications. Considering the polyalkyl glycosides,
which are already known, a wide range of new starch based detergents is ex-
pected to hit the market in the near future.
The use of special starch derivatives in construction applications is gaining
importance. While application in plasters, mortars, and tile cements have long
been known, new products for new applications have been developed in recent
years, particularly in the field of conventional concrete and spray concrete.
These new products are starch-based anti-blocking agents and so-called rebound
minimizers. It is to be expected that further new applications of special starches
will be developed in the future.
Bibliography
H. Röper: Renewable Raw Materials in Eu- “Corn: Chemistry and technology”, Stanley
rope – Industrial Utilisation of Starch and A. Watson, Paul E. Ramstad (eds.), Ameri-
Sugar [1], Starch/Stärke 54 (2002) 89–99 can Association of Cereal Chemists, Inc.,
H. Röper: Starch: present use and future St. Paul, Minnesota, USA
utilisation, in Carbohydrates as Organic Otto B. Würzburg (ed.), Modified Starches:
Raw Materials III (Eds. H. van Bekkum, Properties and Uses, CRC Press Boca Ra-
H. Röper, F. Voragen), VCH Verlagsge- ton, 1986
sellschaft Weinheim, 1996, 17–35 “Starch and its Modifications”, M. V. Ruten-
Otto B. Würzburg (ed., Modified Starches: berg
Properties and Uses, CRC Press Boca Ra- “Handbook of Water-Soluble Gums and
ton, 1986 Resins”, R. L. Davidson (ed.), McGraw-Hill
Book Co (1980)
Section 2.6 Lorenz, A., Beiträge zur Anwendung von
Stärkeveredelungsprodukten auf dem Ge-
biet der Tablettierung in der pharmazeu-
“Applications of Wet-End Paper Chemistry”,
tischen Technologie. Dissertation, Martin-
Che On Au, Ian Thorn (eds.), Blackie Aca-
Luther-Universität Halle-Wittenberg, 1986
demic and Professional, 1995
Colloidal silica/polyelectrolyte blends for
“Paper Chemistry”, J. C. Roberts (ed.),
natural water clarification, Kristine S.
Blackie Academic and Professional, 1996
Slmen, Pek Lee Choo, David A. Picco, Mi-
“Stärkeeinsatz in der Papierindustrie”; PTS-
chio Kobayashi, Nalco Chemical Company,
IZP-Seminar, SE-SE 358 HEI, 1993
(1997); Naperville (US)
“An overview of developments in starch ad-
“Industrial Starches”, Roland W. James,
ditives and starch kitchens for corrugated
Noyes Data Corporation (1974); New Jer-
board”, Bob Boades, International Paper
sey (US)
Board Industry, January 1996, 59–66
Ullmanns: Encyklopädie der technischen
Chemie, 4., neubearb u erw Aufl. Verlag Section 2.7
Chemie, Weinheim (D)
“Handbuch der Textilhilfsmittel”, A. Chwa- “Gentechnik in der Stärkeforschung”,
la, V. Anger, C. Chwala, Verlag Chemie, J. Koßmann, M. Emmermann, R. Lorberth,
Weinheim, 1977 F. Springer, L. Willmitzer, G. Abel, V.
“Grundlagen der Textilveredelung”, M. Pe- Büttcher, E. Duwenig, T. Welsh, Getreide
ter, H. K. Rouette; 13. überarb Aufl. Mehl und Brot 51 (1997) 5, 259–262
Deutscher Fachverlag, Frankfurt am Main, “Approaches to influence starch quantity
1989 and starch quality in transgenic plants”,
EP 1232189 Emulsionspolymerisationsver- B. Müller-Röber, J. Koßmann, Plant, Cell
fahren; M. Pfalz, M. Wastyn, D. Grüll and Environment (1994) 17, 601–613
(2003); Südzucker AG Mannheim (D) “Towards modifying plants for altered starch
EP 1075839 Plasmaexpander, Blutverdün- content and composition” R. G. F. Visser,
nungsmittel und Kryoprotektor, hergestellt E. Jacobsen, TIBTECH February 1993
unter Verwendung von Amylopektin-Kar- (Vol 11), 63–68
toffelstärke; D. Grüll, U. Stifter (2001); Mutation: Modified Starch Metabolism in
Südzucker AG Mannheim Mutant and Transgenic Plants, P. Sathish,
EP 1313682 Flockungs- bzw. Bindemittel C. Sun, A. Lönneberg, C. Jansson in Pro-
für den keramischen Bereich; D. Grüll, M. gress in Botany, Vol. 56, Springer, Berlin,
Wastyn, M. Kozich (2003); Südzucker AG (1995), 301–318.
Mannheim (D)
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
97
3
Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products
and Product Family Trees
Birgit Kamm, Michael Kamm, Matthias Schmidt, Thomas Hirth, and Margit Schulze
3.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
98 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
3.2
Historical Outline of Chemical and Technical Aspects of Utilization Lignocellulose
in the 19th and 20th Century
3.2.1
From the Beginnings of Lignocellulose Chemistry Until 1800
disaccharide
3.2.2
Lignocellulose Chemistry in the Nineteenth Century
Fig. 3.2 Oxalic acid synthesis by Scheele 1776. *Today catalyzed with HNO3 and V2O5.
100 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
drates” [14]. Prout also classified organic food for the first time into the three
groups – proteins, fats, and carbohydrates, a classification still used today. Even
so, he called the carbohydrates the “saccharine class”. The current name carbo-
hydrates instead of “saccharine class” was introduced in 1844 by Carl Schmidt
(1822–1894), Professor of Medical Chemistry at the University of Dorpat/Tartu,
formerly Ostpreußen, today Estonia [15].
3.2.2.4 Cellulose
In 1839, Anselme Payen, a French manager of a sugar refinery, later an univer-
sity lecturer, reported the generation of a substance called les cellules (France
Cellule = cell) [16] formed after treatment of wood with nitric acid and subse-
quently with sodium hydroxide solution. The name was recommended by his
scientific friend Jean-Baptiste André Dumas who developed the hydrogen–halo-
gen substitution theory and discovered trichloroacetic acid, propionic acid, fatty
acids, and anthracene from tar [17 a].
In 1839, cellulose was converted into dextrose (d-glucose) for the first time by
Payen, by treatment with concentrated sulfuric acid. Payen discovered that cellu-
lose, starch, and sugar all have the same chemical composition. He also found
cellulose in cotton and recognized that wood is not a uniform substance. By
treatment of wood with nitric acid he obtained a carbon-like substance he, how-
ever, believed to be a mixture of different compounds. He called it “incorporated
substance”; today it is known as lignin [17 a/18].
3.2.2.6 Lignin
In 1856, Franz Ferdinand Schulze (1815–1873), chemist at the agricultural faculty
of the University of Greifswald, reported the isolation of cellulose by treatment of
wood with a mixture of nitric acid and potassium chlorate (KClO3) (see also Payen,
1839 [16]). For the first time, F. F. Schulze called the solved part lignin (Latin lig-
num, wood) [21, 22]. Schulz’s “Contributions to the knowledge of lignins” [23]
was the beginning of intensive investigation of lignin [17 b, 24 ].
It was still many years, however, before the chemical structure of lignin was
described. F. Bente (1868) [25] reported the aromatic character of alkaline lignin
melts. In 1897 the Swedish scientist P. Klasen described the “non-cellulosic”
aromatic character of lignin. Klason assumed coniferyl alcohol (4-hydroxy-3-
methoxycinnamyl alcohol) to be the central building block of lignin cellulose
biosynthesis [26, 27]; in 1919, W. Fuchs described a phenol nucleus [28].
Karl Freudenberg (1886–1983), Professor of Wood Chemistry at Karlsruhe
and Heidelberg, discovered in 1927 that lignin is built of phenylpropane deriva-
tives [29]. In addition, lignin can be described as a product of a continuous
etherification of those building blocks [30–33]. In the 1940s, systematic investi-
gation of a variety of lignin-containing plants and wood species started on an in-
ternational scale. The results were published in a review in 1960 by Friedrich
and Dorothy Brauns [34].
a) H2SO4
3.2.2.8 Lignocellulose
The term lignocellulose was introduced by Edward John Bevan (1856–1921) and
Charles Frederick Cross (1855–1935), the two British discoverers of the “Cellu-
lose–Xanthogenate Process” (also called the Viskose process) [42]. In 1903 they
described lignocellulose as one of five natural cellulose types, assuming a chem-
ical bond between lignin and cellulose [43]. There is some controversy about the
first use of the term lignocellulose in the current meaning as a type of biogenic
feedstock. It is assumed that the “lignocellulose feedstock” term was first intro-
duced at the end of the first third of the 20th century. Until that time, raw ma-
terials such as cotton or wood were mainly evaluated with regard to the techni-
cal utilizability of the corresponding cellulose. In the American literature, the
term lignocellulose has been used since 1942, for example by Raphael Katzen
and Donald F. Othmer (co-editor of the Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia for Technical
Chemistry) [44].
3.2.3
Industrial Lignocellulose Utilization in the 19th and Beginning of the 20th Century
In the 19th century and the first third of the 20th, technical and industrial utili-
zation of lignocellulose-containing raw materials was mainly focused on:
· paper and pulp production from wood,
· soluble cellulose derivatives, viscose and other cellulose-based synthetic fibers,
· wood-based sugar production and wood liquification,
· vanillin production from lignin,
· nitration of cellulose (guncotton and nitro rayon),
· furfural and nylon.
3.3 Lignocellulosic Raw Material 103
This topic will not be discussed more in detail at this point because the histori-
cal and technological aspects are discussed several times from different points
of view in different chapters of this monograph [45–47].
3.3
Lignocellulosic Raw Material
3.3.1
Definition
3.3.2
Sources and Composition
3.3.2.1 Sources
After green biomass, lignocellulose feedstock is the most common raw material
for continental biorefinery processes. In addition, LCF are least regulated by fed-
eral law and exclusively reserved for food applications. The best known re-
sources are wood, fast-growing lumber, old forest and timber, recovered paper,
Group 1 Existing landscape species Softwood, hardwood, reed, reed grass, switch
grass, dry grasses
Group 2 Fast-growing plantations Poplar, willow, wood grass, eucalyptus, Sudan
grass
Group 3 Landscape conservation Old forest, residual wood and under-wood from
forestry, switch grass, dry grasses, hay, straw
Group 4 Process lignocelluloses Straw, corn stover, press cake from crop drying
plant, ethanol plants and oil mills, by-products
from cereal mills, whole crop refineries, paper
mill and pulp industry
Group 5 Used materials and waste Timber, used wood, recovered paper, cellulosic
municipal solid wastes
106 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
and straw. In Table 3.2, lignocellulosic sources are summarized and placed into
five different groups.
All five source groups will play an important role in the supply of LCF,
although there will be significant regional differences. Groups 2 (fast-growing
plantations) and 4 (process lignocelluloses) will grow the fastest, because of the
significant resources (e.g. fast-growing woods and straw). In Europe, Group 3
will attract more attention because of substantial changes in agricultural poli-
tics.
Name (raw material) Latin name Lignin (%) Alpha- Hemicellulose (%) Extractives c) Ash
cellulose b) (%) (%)
% Pentosans Other
Table 3.3 presents the compositions of different types of straw. Straw species are
more uniform in composition than wood species. Straw usually has a lower cel-
lulose content than wood, but despite this it has a total carbohydrate fraction
(holocellulose) approximately equal to that of wood. This is because of its high
hemicellulose and low lignin content compared with wood. The ash content of
straw is higher than that of wood [57].
Differences also arise as a result of different investigation and pulping meth-
ods [58, 59]; because of this complexity, it is still difficult to determine specific
group composition. The data shown in Tables 3.3 to 3.6 are collected from dif-
ferent sources.
White wood fir, 46.5 11.6 6.8 1.2 1.6 67.70 26.7
Abies alba
Douglas fir, 43.46 10.76 2.77 4.66 2.67 64.32 31.30
Pseudotsuga
menziesiicaesia
Oak, Quercus 40.63 1.97 19.19 1.22 0.36 63.37 23.91
Aspen, Populus 45.97 2.10 17.74 7.9 1.23 67.83 20.30
tremula
Maize cob 34.0 0.5 14.0 1.0 1.7 51.20 13.1
Wheat straw 37.0 0.3 18.9 6.5 5.6 62.30 13.6
3.4
Lignocelluloses in Biorefineries
3.4.1
Background
3.4.1.1 Example 1
Is an entire tree (from roots to treetop) as biomass is processed into pulp a sig-
nificant weight loss is observed. After pre-treatment and pulping more than
70% of the original mass is lost. Before arrival at the plant the “biomass tree”
will already have lost 40% of its original mass; a further 30% will be lost during
the pulping process [65].
3.4.1.2 Example 2
Table 3.3 shows the composition of wheat straw [52]; none of the three main
components cellulose, hemicellulose, or lignin is dominant. So, economically all
three components must be processed to be efficient.
The following conclusions could therefore be drawn.
· Every plant, every feedstock, is a raw material that must be converted entirely.
· All components of such a raw material are of special value and therefore
must be treated within a complex integrated process.
There are still many problems to be solved, e.g. with regard to conversion of LCF
into precursors. It is still the problem that one or more components may be de-
stroyed or changed in structure during conversion. Another unsolved problem
is that lignin still is not really used but regarded as waste. To solve the problem
completely it will be necessary to learn from more than 100 years experience with
and efficiency of petroleum-based chemistry. Petroleum refineries deliver well-de-
fined, chemically-pure basic chemicals (building blocks) that are easily handled.
On the basis of these simple building blocks, more complex intermediates can
be generated in a controlled manner by chemical reactions. Because of an almost
countless number of combinations, those intermediates then can be converted into
a broad variety of even more complex intermediates and/or final products.
The principles of the highly efficient fossil-based chemical industry – specific
product lines, building blocks, product family trees, commodity chemicals, so-
3.4 Lignocelluloses in Biorefineries 111
3.4.2
LCF Biorefinery
A general equation for the conversion of LCF precursors into “intermediate plat-
forms” sugar (xylose, glucose) and lignin is given in Fig. 3.11 [7, 68, 71, 87] and an
overview of the potential products of an LCF biorefinery is shown in Fig. 3.12.
3.4.3
LCF Conversion Methods
strength, etc.). Therefore, all processes are a compromise focused on the final
product.
3.5
Lignin-based Product Lines
3.5.1
Isolation and Application Areas
Current and future application of lignin are a broad field of increasing impor-
tance, as demonstrated during the last 20 years by an increasing number of
worldwide scientific publications and patents on basic scientific knowledge and
technological aspects. One reason for this development is an increasing appre-
ciation of lignocelluloses as a renewable resource. Lignin as a raw material is
still very far from intensive utilization, however, despite its high potential for
several applications with regard to its chemistry, properties, and the large
amounts available from pulp production or LCF biorefinery processes.
During lignin isolation, there are mainly two problems to be solved – main-
taining the natural lignin structure and achieving high yields. Usually, however,
the chemical structure of the isolated lignin is changed to some extent. The
principal isolation methods are shown Fig. 3.15 [34, 48, 54, 109 , 110–114].
Today, approximately 50 Mio tons alkalignin- and lignosulfonic acids are pro-
duced per year during pulp production, although only a very few percent of these
acids are used. Combustion combined with recycling of chemicals is still the most
efficient process (economically). Both sulfate and (increasingly) sulfite pulping
processes include combustion (in combination with recycling). The heat gener-
ated covers 80 to 100% of the energy demand of the pulping factories (except
bleaching processes). Although, there are several application areas for lignin
Fig. 3.16 Areas of application of different insulated and modified lignins [48].
and modified lignins; their market potentials would significantly increase in a bio-
based economy [34, 48, 50, 54, 110–118] (Fig. 3.16).
3.5.2
A Lignin-based Product Family Tree
Processes for substantial utilization of lignin can be divided into four groups:
· utilization in polymeric forms: e.g. as adhesives for wood materials, cement
additive for enhanced low-temperature durability and low-temperature resis-
tance etc.;
· utilization as polymer component: co-reactant for polymers and resins;
· fractionation into low-molecular-mass particles and monomers: e.g. genera-
tion of vanillin from softwood lignosulfonates; production of dimethyl sulfox-
ide (an important solvent); and
· complete degradation to gas, oil and coal by pyrolysis.
Figure 3.17 shows a potential chemical lignin-based product family tree. Alka-
line hydrolysis/oxidation is already technically established, e.g. vanillin produc-
tion; residues are used as dispersants. Alkaline demethylation via sulfide is used
for DMS production, which later could be used for DMSO solvent production
[50, 119]. Up to 33% phenolic substances can be obtained by addition of NaS
and NaOH at temperatures of 250 to 290 8C [120].
118 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
3.6
Hemicellulose-based Product Lines
3.6.1
Isolation and Application Areas
3.6.2
A Hemicellulose-based Product Family Tree
3.6.3
Furfural and Furfural-based Products
3.6.3.1 Furfural
Furfural (the structural formula is given in Fig. 3.18) is the oldest and most im-
portant substance industrially produced from hemicellulose [141, 142]. In 1998,
approximately 142,000 t a1 furfural were been produced worldwide, mainly in
China, the Dominican Republic, South Africa, and the USA [41]. Industrially
used raw materials are: corn cobs (23.4%), oat hulls (22.3%), cottonseed hull
bran (18.6%), cane trash (17.4%), and rice hulls (11.4%) – the numbers given
in parentheses are potential furfural yields [143]. Synthesis of furfural on the
basis of fossil raw materials (e.g. catalytic oxidation of 1,3-dienes) is economical-
ly not competitive. Because of the acidic hydrolysis, the biobased synthesis of
furfural can be combined with alcohol production based on lignocellulose. Fur-
fural is a liquid with a boiling point of 161.7 8C that is almost infinitely miscible
with all solvents except saturated aliphatic compounds. Freshly distilled, furfural
is a colorless, temperature-stable liquid with a very high durability under anae-
robic conditions. All technically established processes start with pentosan-con-
taining raw materials. The primary reaction is acidic hydrolysis (1). Kinetically,
this reaction depends on proton concentration and temperature [144]. The sec-
ond step is a dehydration of pentoses to furfural (2) (Fig. 3.19). Finally, furfural
is obtained by steam distillation, another time-determining reaction step [145].
The following processes are known for preparation of furfural; except for (9) and
(10) all are used industrially applied [147] (1–4, 6, 8, 12 [41]; 5, 7, 9, [50 c]; 10 [146,
147]; 11 [143]).
3.6 Hemicellulose-based Product Lines 123
"
Legend Fig. 3.21 (continued) anhydride from (56) c-valerolactone from d-valerolactone:
THF: cat. airborne oxidation [196]. (35) isomerization, a) H2SO4-cat. in H2O [215],
maleic acid from THF: cat. airborne oxida- b) with J2 [216]. (57) d-cyanovaleric acid from
tion in gas phase [197]. (36) maleic acid d-valerolactone: NaCN, H2O [192 c, 215].
from maleic anhydride: [198]. (37) fumaric (58) e-caprolactam from d-cyanovaleric acid:
acid from maleic acid: (a) cis-trans isomer- hydrogenation, (+ 4H, – H2O) [192 c, 215].
ism by heating with HCl solution [199], (59) 1,5-dichloropentane from THP: acidoly-
(b) cis-trans isomerism with H2O2, thiourea, sis with 2 HCl [208]. (60) 1,5-dicyanopentane
and ammonium persulfate by 100 8C [198]. from 1,5-dichloropentane: + KCN in Metha-
(38) DL-malic acid from fumaric acid: cat. or nol, 130 8C [217]. (61) 1,7-diaminoheptane
thermal hydration [54, 200]. (39) DL-malic from 1,5-dicyanopentane: cat. hydrogenation,
acid from maleic acid: thermal hydration Ni-cat. [218]. (62) 1,5-dicyanopentane from
[201]. (40) DL-tartaric acid from maleic acid: 2-cyano-THP: acidolysis [192 b]. (63) pimelic
Oxidation with H2O2 or KClO4 [202]. (41) acid from 1,5-dicyanopentane: hydration
maleic acid from furoic acid: oxidation with [219, 220]. (64) butanol from THF: cat. or
ClO–2 (by-product 2-furancarboic acid) [203, acid hydration [221, 222 a]. (65) d-valerolac-
204]. (42) tetrahydrofuroic acid from furoic tone from THF: + CO, cat. carbonylation
acid: cat. Hydrogenation [150]. (43) 2,5-fur- [223, 224]. (66) c-valerolactone from THF:
andicarboxylic acid (FDCA) from furoic acid: cat. methylation [216, 225]. (67) 1,3-buta-
react. of potassium salt of furoic acid over diene from THF: -H2O, cat. Dehydration
CdI2-cat [205]. (44) 5-nitrofurancarboxylic [222 b]. (68) c-butyrolactone from THF:
acid from furoic acid: Nitration with HNO3 a) oxidation with O2 [223]; b) oxidation by
[109 c, 166]. (45) a-ketoglutaric acid from bromate and lactonization [226]. (69) c-valer-
furoic acid: oxidation under esterification olactone from c-butyrolactone: cat. oxidation
and ether forming, then oxid. ring open./ and methylation [227]. (70) pyrrolidone from
hydrolysis [109 c, 206]. (46) 1,2,5-trihydroxy- c-butyrolactone: reaction with NH3 [228].
butane from tetrahydrofuranyl alcohol: with (71) N-vinylpyrrolidone from pyrrolidone:
(CH3CO)2O/ZnCl2 to 1,2,5-triacetyl-butane N-alkylation [228]. (72) adipic acid from
and then KOH/CH3OH [192 a]. (47) 2,3-dihy- THF: 2 CO + 2 H2O, cat. (Ni(CO)4 and
dropyran (DHP) from tetrahydrofuranyl NiCl2 [229]. (73) 1,4-dichlorobutane from
alcohol: cat, (alumina-cont. cat.) dehydration THF: (a) with HCl and higher pressure
and ring expansion at 200–500 8C [152 b, [152 a, 222 c] (b) in presence of water re-
207]. (48) acrolein + ethylene from DHP: by moval agents H2SO4/ZnCl2/SOCl2 [230].
thermolysis [41, 192 b]. (49) 2-hydroxytetrahy- (74) poly(THF) from THF: polymeris. in
dropyran (R=H) and tetrahydropyran (THP) pres. of oxonium salts, chlorosulfonic acid,
ethers from DHP: ethers by addition of ROH or phosphor(V)-chloride [231]. (75) 4,4'-di-
[41, 208]. (50) 2-cyano-THP from DHP: addi- chlorodibutyl ether from THF: + HCl, cat.
tion of cyanide [208]. (51) tetrahydropyran [222 b]. (76) poly(THF) from 4,4'-dichlorodi-
(THP) from DHP: cat. hydrogenation [152 b, butyl ether: + KOH, 1,4-butanediol [222 b].
207]. (52) 1,5-pentanediol] from DHP: cat. (77) adiponitrile from 4,4-dichlorodibutyl
Hydrogenation in presence of Raney-Ni [209, ether: KCN and normal pressure, or NaCN
210]. (53) d-valerolactone from DHP: cat. and higher pressure [222 d, 232]. (78) 1,6-
Hydrogenation [41, 208]. (54) d-valerolactone diaminohexane from adiponitrile: hydrogena-
from 1,5-pentanediol: select. oxidation and tion under higher pressure over Ni- or Co-
lactonization [211]. (55) glutaric acid from cat. [222 d, 233]. (79) adipic acid from adipo-
d-valerolactone: cat. oxidation [212–214]. nitrile: + 4 H2O, hydrolysis [234].
3.7 Cellulose-based Product Lines 127
3.7
Cellulose-based Product Lines
3.7.1
Isolation, Fractionation and Application Areas
Cellulose is by far the most frequent organic compound. Cotton and other cellu-
lose-rich fibers (ramie, flax, cannabis) release their cellulose rather easily; in cel-
lulose production from lignocellulose (wood, reed, straw, cane strash, cornstalks,
or sunflower stalks, and others) special pulping processes must be performed to
separate lignin and other polyoses and to obtain cellulose of uniform molecular
weight. The most important chemical pulping processes are discussed in Sec-
tion 3.4.3 (see also Fig. 3.13), the generated cellulose is called pulp. The corre-
sponding pulping process can often be identified by the prefix of the pulp, e.g.
sulfite-pulp, sulfate-pulp, sodium hydroxide-pulp etc.
Cellulose is one of the most important raw materials for a variety of branches of
industry. By far the largest amounts of cellulose are used in the paper and textile
industries. In addition, cellulose is used in medicine and pharmacy. Cellulose is
also a raw material for many plastics, fibers, rayon (viscose silk), vulcanized fiber,
and cellophane. Further cellulose derivatives are cellulose wadding (batting), gun
cotton, cellulose-based varnishes, and adsorbent materials for chromatographic
use and other applications. Several cellulose derivatives are used in ion-exchange
chromatography. Microcrystalline cellulose and cellulose powder are used as fillers
or binders in tablets, as sedimentation delayers in tooth pastes and creams, in ci-
garettes as tobacco substitutes, and as filter materials, emulsifiers, dispersants, and
filtration additives in the food industry, etc. Another application is bacterial trans-
formation of cellulose into so-called single-cell protein (SCP) [54].
Use of cellulose while maintaining its original structure is discussed in detail
in Ref. [48]. In the following text “cellulose chemistry” describes the chemistry
of the corresponding cellulose conversion products, e.g. glucose, the major hex-
ose of lignocellulose sugars, and its derivatives, for example fructose, polyalco-
hol, methylglucoside, hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF), and levulinic acid.
When using cellulose prepared from lignocellulose feedstocks for conversion
processes, it should always be checked in advance if the pure isolated and thus ex-
128 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
3.7.2
Cellulose-based Key Chemicals
3.7.2.1 Glucose
Glucose, a hexose (d-glucose, dextrose, grape-sugar, IUPAC/IUB abbreviation d-
Glc, acyclic aldose, monosaccharide) is the most important cellulose derivative
of lignocellulose. The importance of glucose is primarily a result of the fre-
quency of the molecule (Section 3.3.1). Glucose also plays an outstanding role
as so-called “intermediate platform” or “key chemical” within the concept of bio-
based products [75]. For biotechnical conversion, in particular, glucose is of spe-
cial significance [128].
d-Glucose or dextrose occurs as a pure crystalline material; for medical appli-
cations, glucose is available as 5 to 50% aqueous solution. Most glucose is cur-
rently produced by hydrolysis of starch [235]. Most is used as glucose syrup for
candy production; for this application an increasing amount of enzymatically
isomerized glucose syrup, so-called “isosyrup”, is used. In the chemical industry,
large amounts of glucose are used for chemical synthesis, e.g. of sorbit, glucon-
ic acid, ascorbinic acid, glutaminic acid, and glutamates or methylglycoside and
for technical application, for example fermentation into ethanol, acetic acid and
lactic acid [236]. In recent years production of d-glucose and glucose syrups, re-
spectively, starting from cellulose and lignocellulose, has attrached increasing
interest, especially ethanol production from lignocellulose [90 d]. Industrial
chemical processes of lignocellulose saccharification are mainly based on acid
hydrolysis in so-called wood saccharification by the Bergius (Bergius-Rheinau
process) [237] and Scholler (Scholler-Tornisch process) [238, 239], processes that
were industrially used between 1930 and 1960 [240]. After World War II crystal-
line glucose was also successfully manufactured in the so-called New Rheinau
process [241].
In recent times, enzymatic methods have been increasingly used for extrac-
tion of cellulose degradation products, e.g. saccharification of cellulose (see also
Fig. 3.14). Although this degradation works successfully when applied to pure
cellulose, it is still a problem to use lignocelluloses, particularly non-uniform
lignocelluloses. Here, pretreatment and prepulping of lignocellulose are neces-
sary to end up with economically efficient saccharification. Nevertheless, the
first success has been obtained in enzymatic saccharification [90 e, 91].
Fig. 3.22 shows a chemical industrial cellulose-derived product family tree
based on glucose as so-called “intermediate platform”. This does not mean, how-
ever, that crystalline cellulose or cellulose syrup is necessary as starting material
for all the processes and product lines listed.
3.7 Cellulose-based Product Lines 129
3.7.2.2 Sorbitol
d-Sorbitol (d-glucitol according to IUPAC/IUB; glucit, C6H14O6) is a crystalline su-
gar with approximately 50% of the sweetening efficiency of saccharose. d-Sorbitol
belongs to the hexite group; it is a hexa-alcohol (sugar alcohol, polyalcohol, polyol)
which can intramolecularly split off one or two molecules water and can form cyclic
ethers (e.g. sorbitan and sorbit) (Fig. 3.23) [243]. Sorbitol is obtained when a glucose
130 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
Fig. 3.23 Synthesis of cyclic ether based on sorbitol and glycose [243].
3.7.2.3 Glucosides
Glucosides are the glycosides of glucose. “Glycosides” is a collective term for an
extensive group of plant substances and synthetic compounds that – by boiling
in water or dilute acids or by treatment with glycosidases – can be fractionated
into one or more carbohydrates (mono- or oligosaccharides) or into one or more
aglycones (or non-sugars). The chemistry and biochemistry of glycosides is
therefore very extensive [248]. In the following text glucosides are discussed as
compounds in which the reducing group of sugar is condensed with an alcohol
or phenol to form acetals. Among different types of glucosides the methygluco-
sides (formula in Fig. 3.24) are commercially important. A simple methylgluco-
3.7 Cellulose-based Product Lines 131
3.7.2.4 Fructose
d-Fructose (levulose, fruit sugar) is the sweetest of the sugars. On a relative scale
with sucrose taken as 100 the sweetness of fructose is 173. The molecular weight
and the elemental composition of glucose and fructose are exactly the same. The
only difference is that glucose is of the aldehyde type whereas fructose is of the
keto type (ketohexoses). The most important natural sources are saccharose and
inulin. A variety of methods have been proposed for converting glucose into fruc-
tose by isomerization. In general, these can be divided into chemical and enzy-
matic methods. Until 1970 chemical isomerization in alkaline solution with alka-
line catalysts such as ammonia, slaked lime, lime water, sodium carbonate, potas-
sium carbonate, or caustic soda via d-glucose-1,2-enediol was preferred [254–256];
today enzymatic and mixed enzymatic/chemical catalysis methods are of advan-
tage. Under optimum conditions the enzyme glucose-2-oxidase converts > 99%
of the glucose into glucosone, which can subsequently be transformed into d-fruc-
tose by use of a metal catalyst, e.g. Pd or Raney Ni, and hydrogen at elevated tem-
perature and pressure, or by homogenous NaBH4 reduction [242, 257] (Fig. 3.25).
d-Fructose is used as sugar substitute in the pharmaceutical and dietetics in-
dustries, particularly in cases of diabetes. For the biobased chemical industry,
fructose is an outstanding starting material for manufacture of 5-hydroxy-
methylfurfural (HMF) and levulinic acid [175]. Nevertheless, both these impor-
tant building blocks are also available from non-specific hexoses (Section 3.7.2).
Utilization of natural fructose raw material, for example inulin (polyfructosan)
from special cultures such as artichoke and topinambur (Jerusalem artichoke)
or saccharose (sucrose) from sugar cane and sugar beet, and utilization of semi-
132 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
synthetic d-fructose for HMF and levulinic acid, will both be exposed to signifi-
cant economic pressure.
3.7.2.5 Ethanol
The significance of ethanol as an important bulk product from lignocellulose con-
version and from the different processes of utilization of lignocellulose-based
hexoses and pentoses has already been discussed. In this section the importance
of ethanol among biobased products as a C2 building-block chemical is reviewed.
Most currently produced ethanol is used in beverage industry. Technically, ethanol
is a valuable solvent for fats, oils, and resins, particularly in lacquer and varnish
manufacture and also for production of essences. Ethanol is the most important
solvent for scents and perfumes and cosmetics (aftershaves, hair tonic, etc.). Be-
cause of its germicidal effect, ethanol is used as a preservative and a disinfectant.
As substrate for protein generation (SCP), ethanol can replace petroleum. Because
of its high calorific value (29 kJ g–1 or 7 kcal g–1), ethanol in the form of denatured
alcohol or so-called solid alcohol is used for combustion or (mixed with gasoline)
as a fuel (gasohol, E10- or E85-biofuel etc.).
Use of ethanol as raw material for synthesis of important industrial chemicals
is most promising for those countries that decided to use ethanol for fuel pro-
duction. Changing the raw material basis from cost-intensive agricultural prod-
ucts (e.g. grain, corn) to lignocelluloses (e.g. straw) and introducing energy-sav-
ing biotechnological processing steps could further improve the competitiveness
of bio-based versus fossil-based ethanol. Ethanol is the starting material for
many chemicals, for example diethyl ether, chloroform, ethyl chloride, dyes, and
pharmaceutical compounds [258]. Fig. 3.26 shows an industrial chemical prod-
uct family tree. The product lines for ethyl lactate and ethylene, and the corre-
sponding derivatives are of particular interest in chemical industry [259].
3.7.2.6 Hydroxymethylfurfural
Two very important biobased building blocks, 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF)
and levulinic acid, are available via acid-catalyzed dehydration of hexoses. For-
mally, elimination of one molecule of water leads to a mixture of levulinic acid
and formic acid. It is assumed that during degradation HMF is formed as an
intermediate which is not stable in acids and degrades into levulinic and formic
acids. This means that three molecules water are eliminated to form HMF,
which then reacts with two molecules of water in a kind of “re-hydration” to
form levulinic acid and formic acid [260, 261] (Fig. 3.3). To achieve high yields
in the isolation of HMF, it is essential to suppress HMF hydrolysis, which is
most successful in non-aqueous systems [20].
5-Hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) is a versatile sugar derivative which can be
regarded as a key intermediate between bio-based carbohydrate chemistry and
mineral oil-based industrial organic chemistry. HMF is a common dehydration
product of all hexoses and thus is an aldehyde, an alcohol, an aromatic com-
pound, a cis diene, and a difunctional diene. HMF is available from biomass
in a simple dehydration reaction and is convertible into di- and tetrahydro-
furan derivatives and also benzene, pyridazine, pyridine, and other derivatives
[262. 263]. Some possible reactions and applications are shown in Figs. 3.27 and
3.29.
Starting with HMF, furan-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (FDCA) is available in an one-
step reaction [264, 265]. Terephthalic acid or isophthalic acid are bulk products
which could be replaced by furan-2,5-dicarboxylic acid (FDCA) (Fig. 3.27). Cur-
rently, fossil-based terephthalic acid is the most important dicarbonic acid, pro-
duced on the million ton scale and mainly used for polyester production, e.g.
poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) and polycondensation products of terephthal-
ic acid (TPA) and ethylene glycol (EG) for packaging, beverage bottles, foil, etc.
[266]. Polymers, especially polyesters and polyamides have been prepared using
FDCA and other HMF derivatives instead of terephthalic acid [267, 268].
134 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
and in the manufacture of nylon and rubber. Use of the sodium salt of levulinic
acid as a replacement for ethylene glycols as an antifreeze has also been pro-
posed [81].
3.7.3
An HMF and Levulinic Acid-based Family Tree
HMF and levulinic acid both are multifunctional compounds with a very broad
reaction and application potential. Figure 3.29 shows a chemical family tree
with HMF- and levulinic-based products that already have or might achieve
technical importance. Today, some of these products are as economically effi-
cient as levulinic acid itself, others were of economic significance years ago and
were then replaced by fossil-based products, e.g. several hydroxymethylfuranyl
derivatives. Several others could gain importance in the future, for example 2,5-
furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) as a monomer for polymer synthesis and methyl-
tetrahydrofuran (MTHF) as a fuel additive. In a biobased economy, market de-
mand and economic efficiency of all the products discussed will develop ex-
tremely positively.
136 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
3.7 Cellulose-based Product Lines 137
Fig. 3.29 An HMF and levulinic acid-based acetic acid: electrochemical oxidation at a
chemical product family tree: (1) 5-hydroxy- Ni-oxide-hydroxide anode [298]. (24) 2,5-
methylfurfural (HMF) from hexosic material: bis(hydroxymethyl)tetrahydrofuran from
acid hydrolysis [20, 274]. (2) levulinic acid HMF: cat. hydrogenation, Raney Ni, 90%
(LEVA) direct from biomass or over HMF: [283, 290, 292]. (25) 1,2,5-trihydroxyhexane
acid hydrolysis [81, 272, 275, 276]. (3) levu- from HMF: cat. hydrogenation, cat: Ru/C,
linic acid (LEVA) from HMF: cleavage in 96% [290]. (26) 1,2,5-trihydroxyhex-3-ene
acidic medium [277]. (4) levulinate esters from HMF: cat. hydrogenation, cat: Pt or Ru
from cellulose: acid cat. + alcohol, + higher [290]. (27) 2,5-bis(hydroxymethyl)tetrahydro-
temp. [278]. (5) levulinate esters from HMF: furan from FDCA: cat. reduction, cat: Raney-
acid. cat. + ROH [278]. (6) levulinate esters Ni [292]. (28) 2,5-bis(hydroxymethyl)-
from LEVA: + ROH [279, 280]. (7) aldaric tetrahydrofuran from BHMF: cat. hydrogena-
acids from hexoses: oxidation of glucose (or tion, cat: Ru/C, T. neutral med. [283, 290].
hexoses): (a) acid oxid. HNO3; (b) cat. oxid. (29) 2,5-bis(aminomethyl) tetrahydrofuran
O2, Pt on C; (c) biotechn. by Aspergillus niger from FDCA: cat. hydrogen, NH3 [290]. (30)
[242]. (8) 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) succinic acid from FDCA: (a) Potassium Salt
from aldaric acids: (a) with dehydrating of FDCA and Brom to dibromosuccinic acid
agents, e.g. HBr [281, 282]; (b) by cyclodehy- and then hydrogenation [299 a]; (b) FDCA
dration of mucic acid with p-TsOH at 140 8C and Brom in heat water to fumaric acid and
[283]; (c) esters, from d-glucaric acid, alcs. then hydrogenation [299 b]. (31) succinic
and acids by using microwave radiation acid from LEVA: (a) cat. oxidation, O2/V2O5
[284]. (9) 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) [272, 300]; (b) H2O2 on Cu-cat. [81].
from hydroxymethyl furoic acid: by cat. oxyd. (32) 2-oxoglutaric acid from LEVA: cat. oxi-
with charcoal-on-Pt-cat. [285]. (10) 2,5-furan- dation (Riley reaction) SeO2 [272, 301].
dicarboxylic acid (FDCA) from HMF: cat. (33) 5-methyl-2-pyrrolidone deriv. from LEVA:
oxydat. different cat. methods [286–289]. + R-NH2, reductive amination over Co-,
(11) 2,5-bis(hydroxymethyl)furan (BHMF) Raney Ni, Pt or Pd-catalysts [302–305].
from HMF: (a) by cat. hydrogenation [290]; (34) 5-furfurylidenelevulinic acid from LEVA:
(b) by Cannizzaro [291]. (12) 2,5-bis(hydroxy- + furfural [306–308]. (35) dilevulinic acid
methyl)furan (BHMF) from FDCA: cat. hy- from 5-furfurylidenelevulinic acid: acids treat-
drogenation [292]. (13) 2,5-furandicarbalde- ment [272, 309]. (36) sebacic acid from dile-
hyde (FDC) from HMF: cat. oxyd. BaMnO4, vulinic acid: cat. hydrogenation, H2/Ni [272,
93% [289, 293]. (14) 2,5-furandicarbaldehyde 309]. (37) 4,4-diaryl subst. valeric acids (di-
(FDC) from BHMF: cat. hydrogenation [292]. phenolic acid) from LEVA: acid-cat. conden-
(15) 2,5-furandicarbaldehyde (FDC) from sation with phenols or naphthols [310–312].
FDCA: cat. hydrogenation [292]. (16) 2,5-fur- (38) 1-keto-non-6-en from LEVA, + hex-3-
andicarboxylic acid (FDCA) from FDC: cat. enoic acid [313]. (39) acrylic acid from LEVA:
oxid. AgO2, 80% [289]. (17) 5-hydroxymethyl- condensat. with aldehydes and ketone split-
furoic acid from HMF: (a) cat. with Ag2O, ting [80]. (40) b-acetylacrylic acid from LEVA-
100 8C, 75% [289] ; (b) by Cannizzaro [291]. esters: oxidation of levulinic acid esters with
(18) methyl malonate from HMF: electro-oxi- SeO2 [314]. (41) a-angelica lactone from
dation on platinum anode in methanol, LEVA, cat. dehydration, cat e.g. phosphoric
LiClO4 electrolyte [294]. (19) bis(5-methylfur- acid, [81, 315]. (42) b-angelica lactone from
furyl)ether from HMF: TsOH, 89% [295, a-angelica lactone: base cat. (cat. e.g. tert.
296]. (20) 2-aminomethyl-5-hydroxymethylfur- Amine) isomerization [81]. (43) c-valerolac-
an from HMF: reductive amination, Ni/H2, tone from a-angelica lactone: reduction
NH3, 72% [297]. (21) 2,5-bis(aminomethyl)- [316]. (44) c-subst.-b-acetyl-c-butyrolactones
furan from HMF: + NH2OH, then Ni/H2 from a-angelica lactone: rect. with aldehydes
[289]. (22) 5-hydroxymethyl-furylideneacetic in presence of BF3-O(C2H5) [317].
acid from HMF: + malonic acid, cat. react in (45) 4-hydroxypentanoic acid from LEVA: cat.
pyridine [298]. (23) 5-carboxy-2-furylideneace- hydrogenation or reduction with diluted HCl
tic acid from 5-hydroxmethyl-furylidene- [318].
138 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
Legend 3.29 (continued) (46) c-valerolac- tenol (oxymethyl thiophene) from LEVA,
tone from hydroxypentanoic acid: acidic de- heating with P4S10 [80, 324]. (56) [5-methyl-
hydration [318, 319]. (47) c-valerolactone 5-fluoro-c-butyrolactone] from LEVA, fluori-
from LEVA: (a) cat. hydrogenation, cat: Ra- nating with SF4 (over-5-hydroxy-c-valerolac-
ney-Ni on Pt [273, 320]; (b) Platinum-Group tone) [326]. (57) dihydropyridazinones from
metal catalyst (e.g. Rh/C) in the presence of LEVA: + hydrazine or derivatives [327, 328].
hydrogen [321]. (48) 1,4-pentanediol from (58) pyridazinones from dihydropyridazi-
c-valerolactone: cat. hydrogenation [316]. nones: oxidation with Br2 or SeO2 [327, 328].
(49) 1,4-pentanediol from LEVA: cat. hydro- (59) dihydropyridazinone-3-carboxylic acid
genation, cat: Raney-Ni on Pt [320]. from dihydropyridazinones: oxid. w. 10%
(50) 2-methyl-THF (MTHF) from 1,4-penta- HNO3 [329]. (60) glutamic acid from dihy-
nediol: dehydration [316]. (51) 1,4-penta- dropyridazinone-3-carboxylic acid: cat. hydro-
diene from 1,4-pentanediol: cat. dehydration genation, H2/Ni [329]. (61) brominating le-
[322]. (52) 2-methyl-THF (MTHF) from vulinic acids from LEVA: + Br2 in different
LEVA: cat. hydrogenation, 240 8C, 100 atm solv. [272, 330]. (62) d-aminolevulinic acid,
(ca. 101 bar) [47, 316, 323]. (53) 5-cyano-4- (5-aminolevulinic acid) from LEVA or LEVA-
methylpent-4-enoic acid from LEVA: Knoeve- esters: (a) regioselect. Bromination to 5-bro-
nagel condensation with cyanoacetic acid molevulinic acid and then react. w. alkali
[324]. (54) 3-methyladipic acid from 5-cyano- metal diformylamide [331]; (b) fermentation
4-methylpent-4-enoic acid: reduction of dou- by photosynthetic bacterium (Rhodobacter
ble bond and acid hydrolysis [324]. (55) thio- sphaeroides IFO 12203) [332].
3.8
Outlook and Perspectives
References
24 Brunow, G.; Methods to Reveal the 41 McKillip, W. J.; Furan and Derivatives.
Structure of Lignin. In: Biopolymers In: Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Indus-
Vol. 1 [M. Hofrichter, A. Steinbüchel trial Chemistry. 6th Ed., Vol. 15 [Wiley-
(eds.), Wiley–VCH, Weinheim, New VCH, Weinheim, 2003] 187–206
York et al, 2001, ISBN 3-527-30220-4] 42 Cross, C. F., Bevan, E. J., Beadle, C.
90 (Viscose Syndicate); British Patent
25 Bente F.; Über die Konstitution des 8,700, (1892/1893)
Tannen- und Pappelholzes. Chem. Ber., 43 Bevan, J. E; Cross, C. F.; Cellulose (an
8 (1868) 476–479 Outline of the Chemistry of the Struc-
26 Klason, P.; Ber. dt. chem. Ges. (B.), 53 tural Elements of Plants), 2. Ed. [Lon-
(1920) 1864 don, 1903]
27 Klason, P.; Berichte der Deutschen Che- 44 Katzen, R.; Othmer, D. F.; Ind. Eng.
mischen Gesellschaft (B.), 69 (1936) 676 Chem., 34 (1942) 314.
28 Fuchs, W.; Berichte der Deutschen Che- 45 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Gruber, P. R.;
mischen Gesellschaft (B.), 54 (1921) 484 Kromus, S.: Biorefinery Systems – An
29 Freudenberg, K.; Zur Konstitution des Overview, In this book, 2005
Lignins. II. Mittl., B., 60 (1927) 581 46 Katzen, R.; Schell, D. J.; Lignocellulosic
30 Freudenberg, K.; Polysaccharides and Feedstock Biorefinery: History and
Lignin Annual Rev. Biochem., 8 (1943) Plant Development for Biomass Hydro-
81 lysis. In this book, 2005
31 Freudenberg, K.; Neish, A. C. (eds.); 47 Hayes, Daniel, J.; Fitzpatrick, Steve;
Constitution and Biosynthesis of Lig- Hayes, M. H. B.; Ross, J. R. H.; The Bio-
nin [Springer, Berlin, 1968] fine Process: Production of Levulinic
32 Freudenberg, K.; Ploetz, Th., Dumpert, Acid, Furfural and Formic Acid from
G.; Stufenweise Hydrolyse von Fichten- Lignocellulosic Feedstocks. In this
holz. Cellulosechem., 19 (1941) 89. book, 2005
33 Freudenberg, K.; Lautsch, W.; Engler, 48 Fengel, D.; Wegener, G.; Wood, Chem-
K.; Zur Konstitution des Lignins. istry, Ultrastructure, Reactions [Walter
XXXIV. Mittl., B., 73 (1940), 167 de Gruyter, Berlin, New York, 1984]
34 Brauns, F. E., Brauns D. A.; The Chem- 49 Bikales, N.M.; Segal, L.; Cellulose and
istry of Lignin. Supplement Volume cellulose derivatives [Wiley, New York,
[Academic press, New York and Lon- 1971]
don, 1960, LCCCN: 60-9065] 50 Schliephake, D. et al.; Nachwachsende
35 Schulze, E.; Zur Kenntnis der chemi- Rohstoffe, Teil I Holz und Stroh [Land-
schen Zusammensetzung der pflanzli- wirtschaft-Industrie e.V. (ed.), Verlag J.
chen Zellmembranen. Ber. Deutsch. Kordt, Bochum, 1986] a) I3–I226,
Chem. Gesell., (B.), XXIV (1891) 2277 b) I–160, c) I–166
36 Sandermann, W.; Grundlagen der Che- 51 Gruber, E.; Krause, Th.; Schurz, J.: Cel-
mie und chemischen Technologie des lulose. In: Ullmann, Enzyklopädie der
Holzes [Akademische Verlagsge- technischen Chemie, 4. Aufl. Bd. 9
sellschaft, Leipzig, 1956] a) 97 ff b) 147 [Bartolomé, E. et al (Hrsg), Verlag Che-
37 Staudinger, H.; Reinecke, F.; Holz, mie, Weinheim, 1975] 184 ff
Roh- und Werkstoff, 2 (1939) 321 52 Lengyel, P.; Morvay, S.; Chemie und
38 Staudinger, H.; Makromolekulare Che- Technologie der Cellulose-Herstellung
mie und Biologie [Wepf & Co., Basel, [Akadémia Kiadó, Budapest, 1973]
1947] 53 Hägglund, E.; Chemistry of Wood.
39 Pringsheim, H.; Cellulosechemie, 2 [Academic press Inc., New York, 1952]
(1921) 123 54 Römpp Chemie Lexikon – CD Version
40 Ullmann, F.; Enzyklopädie der Tech- 2.0 [Georg Thieme Verlag, Stuttgart/
nischen Chemie. 2. Aufl., 5. Bd. New York, 1999]
[Urban & Schwarzenberg, Berlin und 55 Brauns, F. E., The Chemistry of Lignin.
Wien, 1930] 442 ff [Academic press, New York and Lon-
don, 1952]
References 141
81 Leonard, R. H.; Levulinic acid as a Ba- 95 Ander, P.; Ericksson, K.E.; Progress in
sic Chemical Raw Material. Ind. Eng. ind. Microbial. Vol. 14 [M. J. Bull (ed.),
Chem., 48 (1956) 1331–1341 Elsevier, New York, 1978] 1
82 Timell, T. E.; Tappi, 44 (1961) 99 96 Schurz, J.; Bioconversion of Cellulosic
83 James, R. L.; In: The pulping of wood, Substances into Energy, Chemicals and
2nd edn., vol. 1 [McGraw-Hill, New Microbiol. Protein. Symp. Proc. BERC
York, 1969] p 34 IIT Delhi [T.K. Ghose (ed.), New Delhi,
84 Brink, D. L.; Pohlmann, A. A.; Tappi, 55 1978]
(1972) 381 ff. 97 Scott, G. M.; Akhtar, M.; Biotechnologi-
85 Puls, J.; Dietrichs, H. H.; Energy from cal Applications of Lignin-Degrading
Biomass. Proceed. EC-Conference Fungi. In: Biopolymers Vol. 1 [M. Hof-
Brighton 1980 [1980] 348 richter, A. Steinbüchel (eds.), Wiley-
86 Shen, S.; Biological Engineering for VCH, Weinheim, New York et al, 2001,
Sustainable Biomass Production. ISBN 3-527-30220-4] 181
In: Biodiversity [E. O. Wilson, Harvard 98 Dunlap, C. E. et al; AIChE Symp. Ser.
University, ed.; National Academy of 72/158 (1976) 58
Sciences/Smithsonian Institution, 99 Fan, L. T. et al; In: Biotechnol., Bioeng.
Washington DC, 1988, German Symp. no. 11 [C.D. Scott (ed.), Wiley,
Edition: “Ende der biologischen Viel- New York, 1981]
falt?”, 1992, ISBN 3-89330-661-7] 404– 100 Gharpuray, M. M.; Biotechnol. Bioeng.,
416 25 (1983) 157
87 Van Dyne, D. L. et al.; Estimating the 101 Reese, E. T.; Sinn, R. G. H.; Levinson,
Economic Feasibility of Converting Lig- H. S.; J. Bacterial., 59 (1950) 485
no-Cellulosic Feedstocks to Ethanol 102 Reese, E. T.; Recent Adv. Phytochem., 11
and Higher Value Chemicals under the (1977) 311
refinery concept: A Phase II Study 103 Ghose, T. K.; Ghosh, P.; J. Appl. Chem.
[University of Missouri, 1999, Biotechnol., 28 (1978) 1489
OR22072-58] 104 Wood, T. M.; 6th Int. Ferment. Symp.
88 Fan, L. T.; Adv. Biochem. Eng. Vol. 23 London, Canada, 1980, p 87
[A. Fiechter (ed.), Springer, Berlin-Hei- 105 Chang, M. M.; Chou, T. Y. C.; Tsao,
delberg New York, 1982] G. T.; Adv. Biochem. Eng., 20 (1981) 15
89 Fan, L. T. et al.; Biotechnol. Bioeng., 23 106 Keller, F. A.; Integrated bioprocess de-
(1981) 419 velopment for bioethanol production.
90 Kosaric, N.; Vardar-Sukan, F.; Potential In: Handbook of bioethanol: production
Sources of Energy and Chemical Prod- and utilization. [C. E. Wyman (ed), Tay-
ucts. In: The Biotechnology of Ethanol lor & Francis, Bristol, Pa. 1996] 351–379
[M. Roehr (ed.), Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 107 Wolley, B. R.; Ruth, M.; Sheehan, J.;
et al, 2001, ISBN 3-527-30199-2] a) 89 ff Ibsen, K.; Majdeski, H.; Galvez, A.;
b) 131, c) 132 d) 125 e) 137 Lignocellulosic Biomass to Ethanol
91 Kamm, B.; Kamm, M.; Schmidt, M.; Process Design and Economic Utilizing
Starke, I.; Kleinpeter, E.; Chemical and Co-Current Dilute Acid Prehydrolysis
biochemical generation of carbohy- and Enzymatic Hydrolysis Current and
drates from lignocellulose-feedstock Futuristic Scenarios. [National Renew-
(Lupinus nootkatensis), Quantification of able Energy Laboratory (NERL), Golden,
glucose, Chemosphere, (in press), DOI Co, USA, 1999, NREL/TP-580-26157]
information: 10.1016/j.chemosphere. 108 Galbe, M.; Zacci, G.; A review of the
2005.03.073 production of ethanol from softwood.
92 Han, Y. W.; Callihan, C. D.; Appl. Micro- Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 59 (2002)
biol., 27 (1974) 159 618–628
93 Turbak, A. F. et al.; Chemtech, Jan. 1980 109 Oshima, M.; Wood Chemistry – Pro-
94 Warwicker, J. O.; In: Shirley Institute cess Engineering Aspects [Noyes Devel-
Pamp No. 93 (1966) opment Corp. New York, 1965, No.
10965] a) 121 b) 88 ff c) 109–119
References 143
110 Freudenberg, K.; Vorträge über Bio- 123 Groheen, D. W.; Lignin, Structures and
chemie. Vergleichende Untersuchung Reactions. [American Chemical Society,
des natürlichen und biosynthetischen Washington DC, 1966] 205
Lignins. J. Prakt. Chemie, 10 (1960) 124 Goheen, D. W.; Henderson, J.; The
220–238 Preparation of Unsaturated Hydrocar-
111 Sarkanen, K. V.; Ludwig, C. H. (eds.); bons from Lignocelluloses Materials.
Lignins: Occurrence, Formation, Struc- Cellul. Chem. Tech., 12 (1978) 363
ture and Reactions [Wiley-Interscience, 125 Lora, J. H.; C. F. Wu; Pye, E. K.; Balati-
New York, 1971] necz, J. J.; In: Lignin: Properties and
112 Adler, E.; Lignin chemistry – Past, Materials. American Chemical Society
Present and Future, Wood Sci. Technol., Symposium Series 397 [W.G. Glasser
11 (1977) 169–218 and S. Sarkanen (eds.)]. Washington,
113 Hofrichter, M.; Steinbüchel, A. (eds.); DC, USA 1989, p. 312–324
Lignin, Humic Substances and Coal. 126 Lawford, H. G.; Rosseau, J.D.; 16th IGT
Biopolymers Vol. 1 [Wiley-VCH, Wein- Conf. Energy from Biomass and Wastes,
heim, New York et al, 2001, [IGT, Washington DC, 1991] 583
ISBN 3-527-30220-4] 127 Goldstein, I. S.; Organic Chemicals
114 Brunow, G.; Lignin chemistry and the from Biomass [CRC press, Florida,
role in biomass conversion. In this USA, 1981].
book, 2005 128 Lichtenthaler, F. W.; The Key Sugars of
115 Northey, R. A.; Low-Cost Uses of Lig- Biomass: Availability, Present Non-
nin, Emerging Technology if Materials Food Uses and Potential Industrial De-
and Chemicals from Biomass, ACS velopment Lines. In this book, 2005
Symposium Series 476, Washington, 129 Schuster, L.; Saccharide Selektive Hy-
D.C., 1992 drogenolyse zu Polyalkoholen. In:
116 Lin, S. Y.; Lebo, S. E. Jr., Lignin, Kirk- Nachwachsende Rohstoffe – Perspekti-
Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical ven für die Chemie [M. Eggersdorfer,
Technology, Fourth Edition, Volume S. Warwel, G. Wullf (eds.), VCH, Wein-
15, 268–289, 1995 heim New York Basel Cambridge
117 Lignin Institute; http://www.lignin.info Tokyo, 1993, ISBN 3-527-29019-2] 211
118 Pye, E. K.; Industrial Lignin Production 130 Van Bekkum, H.; Verrast, D. L.; New
and Applications. In this book, 2005 Starch and Inulin Derived Products
119 Hearon, W.; Macgregor, W. et al; Sulfur with potential Applications. In: Per-
Chemicals from Lignin. Tappi, 45 (1962) spektiven nachwachsender Rohstoffe in
120 Enquist, F. et al; Tappi, 45 (1962) 128 der Chemie [E. Eierdanz (ed.) VCH,
121 Taraban’ko, V. E.; Ivancehneko, N. M., Weinheim New York Basel Cambridge
Koropatchinskaya, N. V., Kuznetsov, Tokyo, 1996, ISBN 3-527-29417-1] 200
B. N.; Study of wood and lignosulfonate 131 Van Bekkum, H.; Studies on Selective
processing into fine chemicals. Chem. Carbohydrate Oxidation IN: Carbohy-
for sustainable development, 4–5 (1996) drates as Organic Raw Materials [F. W.
391–402 Lichtenthaler (ed.), VCH, Weinheim
122 Taraban’ko, V. E.; Kuznetsov, B. N.; New York Basel Cambridge Tokyo,
Chernyak, M.; Yu., Pervyshina, E. P., 1991, ISBN 3-527-28280-7] 289
Swistek, M.; The production of fine 132 Defay, J., Pedersen, C.; Hydrogen
chemicals from hard wood. In: Catalytic Fluoride, Solvents and Reagent for car-
and Thermochemical Conversion of bohydrate Conversion Technology. In:
Natural Organic Polymers. Proc. Fourth Carbohydrates as Organic Raw Materi-
Intern. Sym., 2000, Krasnoyarsk, Russia als [F.W. Lichtenthaler (ed.), VCH,
[B. N. Kuznetsov; R. Gruber (eds.), Rus- Weinheim New York Basel Cambridge
sian Academy of Science, Russia and Tokyo, 1991, ISBN 3-527-28280-7] 47
University of Metz, France, 2000] 77 133 Hosaka, H.; Suzuki, H.; In: Wood Hy-
drolysis, FAO Technical panel on Wood
144 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
sis. Russ. Chem. Rev., 68 (1999) 73–84, lin, 1965, ger.] a) 1402 ff, b) 1542 ff, c)
75 [see there also Ref. [33] US Patent 3 1535
752 849 and [34] Jpn. Patent 5 139 205 193 Reppe, W.; Chemie und Technik der
171 Kenkyujo, Z. H. R.; English patent, E.P. Acetylen-Druck-Reaktionen [Verlag
253 877 (1926) Chemie, 1952] 118 (Beilstein XVII, 27
172 Nielson, R. E.; Vapor Phase Oxidation and XVII(2), 15),
of Furfural. Ind. Eng. Chem., 41 (1949) 194 Schmoyer and Case; Nature, 187 (1960)
365 592
173 Milas, N. A.; Walsh, W. L.; J. Am. Chem. 195 Reppe, W., et al; Bernsteinsäure aus
Soc., 57 (1935) 1389 Tetrahydrofuran. In: Äthinylierung V.
174 Milas, N. A.; Fumaric Acid. Org. Syn., Liebigs Ann. Chem., 596 (1955) 156
Coll. Vol. II (1943) 302 196 Reppe, W., et al; Oxydation von Tetra-
175 Lichtenthaler, F. W., Peters, S.; C.R. hydrofuran IN: Äthinylierung V. Liebigs
Chimie, 7 (2004) a) 80, b) 65–90 Ann. Chem., 596 (1955) 107
176 McKillip, W. J.; Furan and Derivatives. 197 Reppe, W., et al; Maleinsäure aus Tetra-
In: Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia Chem. hydrofuran. In: Äthinylierung V. Liebigs
Technol. 11, 1981, 501–527 Ann. Chem., 596 (1955) 157
177 Rajagopalan, S.; Raman, P. V. A.; Org. 198 Weissermel, K., Arpe, H.-J.; Maleic An-
Syn., 25 (1945) 51 hydride. In: Industrial Organic Chem-
178 Rice, C. C.; Dudley, E. A.; J. Am. Chem. istry. Fourth, Rev. Ed. [Wiley-VCH
Soc., 78 (1956) 68 GmbH Co. KGaA, 2003] 367 ff
179 Johnson, J. R.; 2-Furanacrylic acid. Org. 199 Dobratz, E. H. (Monsanto); Patent AP.
Synth., 20 (1940) 55 2.704.296 (1951)
180 Patterson, J. M.; 2-Furanacrylonitrile. 200 Saito, K. et al (Nippon Chem. Ind.);
Org. Synth., 40 (1960) 46 Patent JP 4360(50), 1950
181 Hinz, A., Meyer, G.; Schlucking, G.; 201 Takashi, Y.; Hibino, O.; Morita, S.; Syn-
Ber. (Chem. Ber.), 76 B (1943) 676 thesis of malic acid from maleic acid.
182 Starr, D.; Hixon, R. M.; Org. Syn., Coll. J. Chem. Soc. Japan, Ind. Chem. Sec., 53
Vol. II (1943) 566 (1950) 361
183 DuPont; Deutsches Bundespatent 202 Milas, N. A.; Tery, E. M.; J. Am. Chem.
(DBP), 106872 (1958) Soc., 47 (1925) 1412
184 Bandford & Manes; U.S. pat. 2.846.449 203 Schmidt, E.; Haag, W., Sperling, L.;
(1959 to DuPont), Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges. (B.), 58 (1925)
185 Manly; U.S. pat. 3.021.342 (1962 to 1400
Quaker Oats) 204 Session, W. V.; J. Am. Chem. Soc., 50
186 Pinkos, R.; Fischer, R. (BASF AG); Pro- (1928) 1696
cess for preparation of 1,4-butanediol 205 Andrisano, R.; Angelori, A. S.; Prepara-
and tetrahydrofuran from furan. Ger. tion of 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid from
Patent; Ger. Offen., DE 19510438 A1 furoic acid. Ann. Chim. (Rome), 53
(1996) (1963) 1658–1664
187 Yur’ev, Y. K.; Tranova, V. A.; J. Gen. 206 Bottorff, Moore; Org. Syn. Coll. vol. V,
Chem., USSR Engl. Tranl., 18 (1940) 31 (1973) 687
[CA: 34, 4733] 207 Paul, R.; Bull. Soc. Chim. France, 53
188 Yur’ev, Y. K.; Org. Khim., 175 (1956) (1933) 1489
159 [CA: 51, 10470b] 208 Houben–Weyl, Methods in Organic
189 Cass, O. W.; Chemurgic Digest, 8 (1949) Chemistry. Bd. 6/4 [E. Müller (ed.),
3 Georg Thieme Verlag Stuttgart, 1965,
190 E. I. DuPont; Patent US 2.600.289 ger.] a)12–70, b) 286–300
(1952) 209 Sharples Chem Inc.; AP 2.516.337
191 Boesken, M. J.; Receuil Trav. chim. Pays- (1946)
Bas., 24 (1915) 100 210 Ritter, H.; Dihydropyran. In: Ullmann’s
192 Fodor, G.; Organic Chemistry Enzyklopädie der technischen Chemie.
[Deutscher Verlag Wissenschaften, Ber- Bd. 14, 1966, 456
146 3 Lignocellulose-based Chemical Products and Product Family Trees
211 Kaufmann, D.; Reeve, W.; Org. Syn. 231 Meerwein, H.; Delfs, D.; Morschel, H.;
Coll. vol. III, (1955) 693 Die Polymerisation des Tetrahydrofu-
212 Paris et al.; Org. Syn. Coll. vol. IV, rans; Angew Chem., 72 (1960) 927–1006
(1963) 496 232 Scott, L. T.; Roelofs, N. H.; Tsang, T.-H.;
213 English, Dayan; Org. Syn. Coll. vol. IV, Automerization of Benzene. J. Am.
(1963) 499 Chem. Soc., 109 (1987) 5456–5461
214 Gordon, D.; Kline, M.; Modern Plas- 233 DuPont; Patent AP. 2.284.525 (1942)
tics, 23 (1946) 174 234 Danly, D. E.; Campell, C. R.; In: Kirk-
215 Hopff, H.; Caprolactam. In: Ullmann’s Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical
Encyklopedia Chemie. 3. Aufl., Bd 5, Technology vol. 1, 3rd. [Wiley-Inter-
1954, 68 ff science, New York, 1978] 510–531
216 Jenner, G., Kheradman, H., Kienne- 235 Grüll, D.; Jetzinger, F.; Kozich, M.;
mann, A.; Journal of Organometallic Wastyn, M.M.; Wittenberger, R.; Starch
Chemistry, 277 (1984) 427–438 Product family trees Starch / Starch
217 Beilstein; Handbook of Organic Chem- Platform, Products. In this book, 2005
istry; 4. Aufl., Vol. I. 131, Vol. I1 43, 236 Schenk, F.W.; Hebeda, R.W. (eds.);
Vol. I2 95 Starch Hydrolysis Products, Worldwide
218 Houben-Weyl Methods in Organic technology, production and Applica-
Chemistry. Polyamide, Vol. E20/2 tions [VCH Publishers, Inc., NY/Wein-
[E. Müller (ed.), Georg Thieme Verlag heim/Cambridge, 1992]
Stuttgart, 1965, ger.]1497–1560 237 Bergius, F.; Trans. Inst. Chem. Eng.
219 Beilstein, Handbook of Organic Chem- (London), 11 (1933) 162
istry; Beilstein EIV 2, 2003 238 Scholler, H.; Dissertation, Technical
220 Cornils, B.; Lappe, P.; Dicarboxylic University of Munich, Germany 1923
acid, Aliphatic. In: Ullmann’s Encyklo- 239 Scholler, H.; French Patent, F.P.
pedia, 5. Ed., Vol A (1987) 531 777,824 (1935)
221 Grimm, A.; Schimpf, H.U.; Patent 240 Conrad, T. F.; Holzzuckerbrennerei. In:
DWP 7259 (1953) Die Hefen, Vol. II 8 F. Reiff, R. Kautz-
222 Reppe, W., et al; Äthinylierung V. Lie- mann, H. Lüers, M. Lindemann (eds.)
bigs Ann. Chem., 596 (1955) a) 89 b) [Verlag Hans Carl, Nürnberg, 1962]
80 ff c) 120 d) 127 437–444
223 Flickinger, E.; Tetrahydrofuran. In: Ull- 241 Gläzer, H.; Flügge, F.; Scholler, H.;
mann’s 3. Aufl. Bd. 17 (1966) 72 Praetorius; Chemische Technologie des
224 Ullmann’s Encyclopedia Chemistry, Holzes [Carl Hanser Verlag, 1954]
Bd. 13, p. 82 242 Röper, H.; Selective Oxidation of d-
225 Patai, S. (ed); The chemistry of acid de- Glucose; Chiral Intermediates for In-
rivatives (2 vol.). In: Chemistry of func- dustrial Utilization. In: Carbohydrates
tional groups series [Chichester, Wiley as Organic Raw Materials [F.W. Lich-
& Sons, 1979] tenthaler (ed.), VCH, Weinheim New
226 Metsger, L.; Bittner, S.; Autocatalytic York Basel Cambridge Tokyo, 1991,
Oxidation of Ethers with Sodium Bro- ISBN 3-527-28280-7] 267–288
mate. Tetrahedron, 56 (2000) 1905–1910 243 Wulff. G.; Übersicht über neue poly-
227 Ullmann’s Encyclopedia Chemistry; Bu- mere Materialien auf Basis nachwach-
tyrolactone, Bd. 4, p. 802 sender Rohstoffe IN: Nachwachsende
228 Ullmanns Encyclopedia Chemistry, Pyr- Rohstoffe – Perspektiven für die Che-
role and Derivatives, Bd. 14 (1966) mie [M. Eggersdorfer, S. Warwel, G.
507 ff Wulff (eds.), VCH, Weinheim New
229 Reppe, W.: Neue Entwicklungen auf York Basel Cambridge Tokyo, 1993,
dem Gebiet des Acetylens und Kohlen- ISBN 3-527-29019-2] 291
oxyds [Springer, Heidelberg, 1949] 47 ff 244 Kirk-Othmer Encyclopedia of Chemical
230 Treischmann, H. G.; Manchen, F. Technology. Vol. 1 [R. E. Kirk, D. F. Oth-
(BASF); DBP 859 734 (1939) mer (eds.) The Interscience Encyclope-
dia Inc., 1947] 329
References 147
300 US patent: USP 2 676 186 [ref. Zh. 317 Mukaiyama, T.; Hanna, J.; Inoue, T.;
Khim. (20) 47161P (1955)] Sato, T.; A Convenient method for the
301 Japan patent: Jpn. P. 4513 [ref. Zh. synthesis of c-substituted-b-acetyl-c-bu-
Khim. 16N 34P (1961)] tyrolactones. Chem. Lett. (1974), 381–
302 Frank, R. L.; Schmitz, W. R.; 1,5-Di- 382
methyl-2-Pyrrolidone. Org. Synth. Coll. 318 Erdmann, H.; Ueber Abkömmlinge
Vol. 3 (1954) 328 und Umwandlungen der Benzallävu-
303 US patent: US P. 4 389 531 [ref. C.A. linsäure. Ann. d. Chem. (Annalen), 254
99, 89 638 (1983)] (1889) 213 [see also Wolff, L.; Annalen
304 Moffett, R. B.; Pyrrolidyl Alkanols. 208 (1881) 106]
J. Org. Chem., 14 (1949) 862 319 Rosenmund, K. W.; Zymalkowski, F. et
305 Manzer, L. E. (E. I. Dupont); PCT Int. al; Chem. Ber., 84 (1951) 711
Appl: WO 2004084888, A1 20041007 320 Delpine, M.; Horena, A.; Bull. Soc.
(2004) Chim, Fr., Hem [5], 4 (1937) 32
306 Kumashiro, G.; Hatikava, E.; J. Chem. 321 Manzer, L. E. (E. I. DuPont); PCT Int.
Soc. Jpn., Chem. Ind. Chem., 57 (1954) Appl.: WO 2002074760, A1 20020926
299 (2002)
307 Joda, N.; Macromol. Chem., 55 (1962) 174 322 Houben-Weyl – Methods in Organic
308 Fetizon, M.; Montanfirer, M.; Rens, J.; Chemistry; Bd 5/1c [E. Müller (ed.),
J. Chem. Res. (S), 9 (1982) Georg Thieme Verlag Stuttgart, 1965,
309 US patent: US P. 2 815 375 [ref. Zh. ger.] 1–975
Khim. (12) 2072P (1960)] 323 Elliott, D. C., U.S. Patent 5,883,266
310 Bader, A. A.; Kontowic, A. D.; J. Am. (1999)
Chem. Soc., 76 (1954) 4465 324 Stevens, R.; Laevulinic acid. Part I.
311 Japan patent: Jpn. P. 6 270 338 [ref. J. Chem. Soc. (1960) 1118
Chem. Abstr., 107, 154 076 (1987)] 325 Kues, W.; Paal, C.; Synthese des Thio-
312 Zhang, R.; Moore, J. A.; Polymer Pre- tenols und des Thiolens. Ber. Deutsch.
prints, 43 (2002) 1007–1008 Chem. Ges. (Ber.), 19 (1886) 555
313 Knole, J.; Schaefer, H.; Angew. Chem., 326 Larsson, V.; Carlson, R.; Leroy, J.; Acta
87 (1975) 777 Chem. Scand., Ser. A, 47 (1993) 380
314 Raymond, S.; J. Am. Chem. Soc., 72 327 Stevens, F. J.; Griffin, T. D.; Fields, T. L.;
(1950) 3296 J. Am. Chem. Soc., 77 (1955) 42
315 Leonard, R. H.; Conversion of levulinic 328 Lepangol, A.; Deprey, J.; Bull. Soc.
acid into alpha-angelicalactone. US pat- Chim. Fr., 606 (1961)
ent: US P. 2 809 203 [ref., Chem. 329 Fudzise, M.; Nacamura, F.; J. Chem.
Abstr. 52 2819b] Soc. Jpn., Pure Chem., 75 (1954) 348
316 Bozell, J. J., Moens, L., Elliott, D. C., 330 Ha, H.-J.; Lee, S.-K., Ha, J.-L.; Synth.
Wang, Y., Neuenschwander, G. G., Fitz- Commun., 24 (1994) 10945
patrick, S. W., Bilski, R. J. and Jarnefeld, 331 Moens; Luc (Midwest Research Insti-
J. L. (2000), Production of levulinic acid tute) US patent: US P. 5,907,058, May
and use as a platform chemical for de- 25, 1999
rived products. Resources, Conservation 332 Matsuda, S.; Yunoue, M.; Appl. Microb.
and Recycling, 28 (2000) 227–239. Eng. Div., 24 (1998) 197–202
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
151
4
Lignin Chemistry and its Role in Biomass Conversion
Gösta Brunow
4.1
Introduction
Lignin is among the most abundant biopolymers on earth and, being renew-
able, it has attracted much effort to make use of lignin as feedstock in biomass
conversion processes. Lignins are an essential component of the woody stems
of arborescent gymnosperms and angiosperms in which amounts range from
15 to 36%. Lignins are not restricted to arborescent plants, they are found as in-
tegral cell wall constituents in all vascular plants including the herbaceous vari-
eties. The lignin in the cell walls is intimately mixed with the carbohydrate
components. The structure of the polymer is complex and irregular and isola-
tion of lignin from other plant constituents is not easy. Lignin is an essential
component of higher plants, giving them rigidity, water-impermeability, and re-
sistance against microbial decay. In the pulp and paper industry, lignin is re-
moved chemically and residual lignin in pulp is removed or degraded using
bleaching agents, e.g. chlorine dioxide, oxygen, or ozone. In mechanical pulping
much energy is needed to eliminate the cementing effect of lignin. Vast
amounts of lignin derivatives from pulp and paper industry are created and
these compounds are a threat to the environment if not detoxified or otherwise
treated in effluent treatment plants. White-rot fungi are the only organisms able
to mineralize lignin efficiently to carbon dioxide and water by processes initially
catalyzed by extracellular enzymes. Biotechnological applications of these fungi
and their lignin-modifying enzymes are being developed as alternative methods
for pulping and bleaching and for bioremediation, i.e. removal of toxic pollu-
tants from soil, groundwater, and effluents.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
152 4 Lignin Chemistry and its Role in Biomass Conversion
4.2
Historical Overview
4.3
The Structure of Lignin
4.3.1
Definition
The term “lignin” is often loosely used both for the lignin in the intact wood
and for preparations obtained from diverse procedures with the objective of sep-
arating the lignin from other cell-wall constituents. To be precise, the lignin in
the cell wall should be termed “protolignin”, and all other preparations “lignin
products” with a clear declaration of what procedure was used to obtain the lig-
nin. A published description (Brunow et al. 1998) gives an useful overview of
our present knowledge about the chemical composition of protolignin:
This description is not a chemical definition of protolignins, but summarizes
the main structural features based on knowledge available today. Protolignins
are biopolymers consisting of phenylpropane units with an oxygen atom at the
p-position (as OH or O–C) and with none, one, or two methoxy groups in the
positions ortho to this oxygen atom. These ortho positions may alternatively be
C-substituted or O-substituted with substituents other than methoxy. Only a few
of the aromatic units are substituted in other ring positions. A few percent of
the building blocks in protolignins are not phenylpropane units. The side chain
is missing or shortened, or the unit is replaced by a quinoid group. The phenyl-
propane units are attached to one another by a series of characteristic linkages
4.3 The Structure of Lignin 153
(b-O-4, b-5, b-b, etc.) or, alternatively, exist as members of a series of characteris-
tic end groups (e.g. cinnamaldehyde units). Practically all the types of structural
element detected in protolignins have been demonstrated to be formed on oxi-
dation of the p-hydroxycinnamyl alcohols in vitro (Freudenberg 1968; Adler
1977). The structural elements in protolignins are not linked to one another in
any particular order. Protolignins are not optically active. The polymer is
branched and cross-linking occurs. In addition, the following facts should be
noted: (1) there are strong indications of the occurrence of linkages between
protolignin and carbohydrates, (2) some types of protolignin are esterified with
phenolic acids (grass lignins with p-coumaric acid and other lignins, for exam-
ple aspen lignin, with p-hydroxybenzoic acid), and (3) scattered observations
suggest that there are some units, for example, dihydroconiferyl alcohol units,
that cannot be thought to have been produced by oxidation of p-hydroxycinna-
myl alcohols.
4.3.2
The Bonding of the Phenylpropane Units
1 2 3
4.3.3
Bonding Patterns and Functional Groups
4.3.3.1 General
Biosynthetic considerations are often used among the arguments for the exis-
tence of particular structural units in lignins. Biosynthetic arguments are only
pointed out occasionally in the discussion below. Each one of the types of unit
discussed below can be expected to be present in all the different classes of lig-
nin listed in Table 4.1. For simplicity the lignin units are usually depicted as non-
condensed guaiacylpropane units (1) but when applicable the formulas also represent
the other types of phenylpropane unit. Data given for hardwood lignins refer to such
lignins composed of similar amounts of units of types 1 and 2.
(Lapierre et al. 1991; Nimz 1974; Sakakibara 1992) degradation studies provide
evidence for the occurrence of different types of pinoresinol structure in lignins.
Both pinoresinol and syringaresinol structures have been detected in lignins by
a variety of NMR spectroscopic techniques (Lundquist 1991; Kilpeläinen et al.
1994). Ogiyama and Kondo determined the abundance of b-b units in a soft-
wood lignin to be 5–10% (Ogiyama and Kondo 1968). NMR spectral studies
suggest somewhat lower values (Lundquist and Stomberg 1988).
The formation of 3,4-divanillyltetrahydrofuran on acidolysis (Lundquist and
Stomberg 1988; see also references cited therein dealing with the formation of
2,3-divanillyl-1,4-butanediol from lignin) or thioacidolysis of softwood lignin (La-
pierre and Lundquist 1999) suggests the occurrence of b-b-linked units with re-
duced side-chains. These structures cannot be formed by oxidation of coniferyl
alcohol.
Biphenyl Units, Dibenzodioxocin Structures and Diaryl Ether Structures The oc-
currence of biphenyl units in lignins has been demonstrated in studies of lignin
degradation products. Methylation then permanganate oxidation gives dehydro-
diveratric acid (Erickson et al. 1973). Degradation by reductive methods gives
dehydrodicoerulignol (Lapierre et al. 1991; Nimz 1974; Sakakibara 1992). This
provides unambiguous proof of the occurrence of phenylpropane units in lig-
nins attached to each other by a biphenyl linkage. Pew (1963) attempted to esti-
mate the number of biphenyl units in softwood lignin by a UV spectrometric
method. He concluded that “coniferous lignin may well contain 25% or more
biphenyl-linked units.” Permanganate oxidation studies suggested that 19% of
the lignin units are of the biphenyl type in softwood lignin (Erickson et al.
1973). This estimate is based on results obtained by permanganate oxidation of
lignin pre-treated by cupric oxide oxidation. Model compound studies (Pearl
and Beyer 1954; Bose et al. 1998) show that biphenyl coupling occurs to some
extent on cupric oxide oxidation. This indicates that the value derived from per-
manganate oxidation studies is slightly too high. On the basis 13C NMR exami-
nations Drumond et al. (1989) arrived at a higher value for the frequency of bi-
phenyl units (24–26%). The accuracy of this estimate can be questioned, be-
cause no separate signals from biphenyl units can be discerned in the spectra.
In view of the many sources of error the results obtained by different methods
are not directly incompatible. Estimation of biphenyl units is complicated by
the recent finding (Karhunen et al. 1995) that there are significant amounts of
dibenzodioxocin structures in lignins. Conclusive evidence of the occurrence of
units of this type (Scheme 4.1, units C–D) has been obtained by NMR spectral
studies (Karhunen et al. 1995). Tentative estimates suggest there are approxi-
mately 6% such units in softwood lignin (Sipilä and Brunow, unpublished re-
sults). This implies that approximately 12% biphenyl units may be present in
dibenzodioxocin structures. From model compound studies (Karhunen et al.
1999) it can be concluded that the biphenyl units in dibenzodioxocin structures
are included in the estimates of biphenyl units by NMR spectroscopy and per-
manganate oxidation. The number of biphenyl units is smaller in hardwood lig-
4.4 Role of Lignin in Biomass Conversion 159
nins. Permanganate oxidation suggests there are 9% such units in birch lignin
(Larsson and Miksche 1971).
The occurrence of diaryl ether structures in lignin was concluded on the basis
of permanganate oxidation (Freudenberg 1968) and was later confirmed in stud-
ies of lignin degradation by reductive methods (Lapierre et al. 1991; Nimz 1974;
Sakakibara 1992).
Permanganate oxidation studies suggest 3.5% of such units in softwood lig-
nin (Erickson et al. 1973) and significantly larger amounts (6.5%) in hardwood
lignin (Larsson and Miksche 1971).
4.4
Role of Lignin in Biomass Conversion
4.4.1
Introduction
Because of the very nature of this complex organic polymer and its derivatives,
there has been rather slow development towards an increasing number of uses
and products. Improved understanding of the structure of lignins and their de-
rivatives will help researchers to relate their experimentation to a fundamentally
sound framework of ideas.
160 4 Lignin Chemistry and its Role in Biomass Conversion
4.4.2
Low-molecular-weight Chemicals from Lignin
4.4.3
Polymeric Products
The uses to which polymeric lignin products can be put may be broadly sepa-
rated into three classes: (1) combustion, (2) utilization of the surface active
properties of salts of a lignin derivative, and (3) condensation of lignin so that it
becomes an integral part of the product. A useful review of the utilization of
polymeric lignin products is found in Hoyt and Goheen (1971).
4.4.4
Biodegradation
References
Adler, E., JM Pepper, E Eriksoo. (1957) Ac- Adler, E., K Lundquist. (1963) Spectrochemi-
tion of mineral acid on lignin and model cal estimation of phenylcoumaran ele-
substances of guaiacylglycerol-beta-aryl ments in lignin. Acta Chem Scand 17:13–
ether type. Ind Eng Chem 49:1391–1392, 26, 1963.
1957.
References 161
Adler, E. (1977) Lignin chemistry – past, Freudenberg, K. (1968) The constitution and
present and future. Wood Sci Technol biosynthesis of lignin. In: K Freudenberg,
11:169–218, 1977. AC Neish, eds. Constitution and Biosyn-
Argyropoulos, DS. (1994) Quantitative phos- thesis of Lignin. Berlin–Heidelberg:
phorus-31 NMR analysis of six soluble lig- Springer, 1968, pp 47–122.
nins. J Wood Chem Technol 14:65–82, Funaoka, M., I Abe, VI Chiang. (1992) Nu-
1994. cleus exchange reaction. In: SY Lin, CW
Bardet, M., D Robert, K Lundquist, S von Dence, eds. Methods in Lignin Chemistry.
Unge. (1998) Distribution of erythro and Berlin: Springer, 1992, pp 369–386.
threo forms of different types of b-O-4 Habu, N., Y Matsumoto, A Ishizu, J Naka-
structures in aspen lignin by 13C NMR no. (1990) The role of the diarylpropane
using the 2D INADEQUATE experiment. structure as a minor constituent in spruce
Magn Reson Chem 36:597–600, 1998. lignin. Holzforschung 44:67–71, 1990.
Björkman, A. (1956) Studies on finely di- Hauteville, M., K Lundquist, S von Unge.
vided wood. Part I. Extraction of lignin (1986) NMR studies of lignins. 7. 1H
with neutral solvents. Sven Papperstidn NMR spectroscopic investigation of the
59:477–485, 1956. distribution of erythro and threo forms of
Bose, SK., KL Wilson, RC Francis, M Aoya- b-O-4 structures in lignins. Acta Chem
ma. (1998) Lignin analysis by permanga- Scand B40:31–35, 1986.
nate oxidation. I. Native spruce lignin. Higuchi, T. (1990) Lignin biochemistry: Bio-
Holzforschung 52:297–303, 1998. synthesis and biodegradation, Wood Sci.
Brunow, G., K Lundquist, G Gellerstedt. and Technol. 24, 23–63.
(1998) Lignin. In: E Sjöström, R Alén, eds. Hoyt, CH., DW Goheen. (1971) Polymeric
Analytical Methods in Wood Chemistry, Products. In: KV Sarkanen, CH Ludwig,
Pulping and Papermaking. Berlin: Sprin- eds. Lignins – Occurrence, Formation,
ger, 1998, pp 77–124. Structure and Reactions. New York: Wiley-
Brunow, G., K Lundquist. (1991) On the Interscience, 1971, pp 833–865.
acid-catalysed alkylation of lignins. Holz- Jiang, Z-H., DS Argyropoulos. (1994) The
forschung 45:37–40. stereoselective degradation of arylglycerol-
Chan, FD., KL Nguyen, AFA Wallis. (1995) beta-aryl ethers during kraft pulping.
Estimation of the aromatic units in lignin J Pulp Pap Sci 20:J183–J188, 1994.
by nucleus exchange – a reassessment of Karhunen, P., J Mikkola, A Pajunen, G Bru-
the method. J Wood Chem Technol now. (1999) The behaviour of dibenzodiox-
15:473–491, 1995. ocin structures in lignin during alkaline
Drumond, M., M Aoyama, C-L Chen, D Ro- pulping processes. Nord Pulp Pap Res J
bert. (1989) Substituent effects on C-13 14:123–128, 1999.
chemical shifts of aromatic carbons in Karhunen, P., P Rummakko, A Pajunen,
biphenyl type lignin model compounds. G Brunow. (1996) Synthesis and crystal
J Wood Chem Technol 9:421–441, 1989. structure determination of model com-
Ede, RM., J Ralph, KM Torr, BSW Dawson. pounds for the dibenzodioxocine structure
(1996) A 2D NMR Investigation of the het- occurring in wood lignins. J Chem Soc,
erogeneity of distribution of diarylpropane Perkin Trans 1 1996:2303–2308, 1996.
structures in extracted Pinus radiata lig- Karhunen, P., P Rummakko, J Sipilä, Bru-
nins. Holzforschung 50:161–164. now G. (1995) Dibenzodioxocins; a novel
Ede, RM., J Ralph. (1996) Assignment of type of linkage in softwood lignins. Tetra-
2D TOCSY spectra of lignins: the role of hedron Lett 36:169–170, 1995.
lignin model compounds. Magn Reson Kilpeläinen, I., E Ämmälahti, G Brunow, D
Chem 34:261–268, 1996. Robert. (1994) Application of three-dimen-
Erickson, M., S Larsson, GE Miksche. sional HMQC–HOHAHA NMR spectros-
(1973) Gaschromatographische Analyse copy to wood lignin, a natural polymer.
von Ligninoxydationsprodukten. VIII. Zur Tetrahedron Lett 35:9267–9270, 1994.
Struktur des Lignins der Fichte. Acta Kilpeläinen, I., J Sipilä, G Brunow, K Lund-
Chem Scand 27:903–914, 1973. quist, RM Ede. (1994) Application of two-
162 4 Lignin Chemistry and its Role in Biomass Conversion
165
5
Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
E. Kendall Pye
5.1
Introduction
As one of the three major polymers always present in woody biomass, lignin
represents a considerable proportion of the structural components of plants. It
can account for approximately 10–12% of the aerial portion of some short an-
nual plants and up to 30% or more for some coniferous trees [1]. As such it is
claimed to be the second most abundant organic chemical on earth [2] and is
therefore a major renewable chemical that should not be overlooked, either in
volume or value. Significant commercial markets, totaling over one million tons
per year, already exist for lignins that have been recovered from chemical pulp
mills [3]. The value of lignin in these markets is generally an order of magni-
tude higher than its fuel value. With the anticipated future construction of bio-
refineries processing lignocellulosic feedstocks, the amount of lignin potentially
available for marketing for its chemical value, rather than its fuel value, is likely
to be enormous. Furthermore, lignin from some types of biorefineries will most
probably have better performance characteristics and be of greater commercial
value for its chemical properties than lignins from existing chemical pulping
operations. The availability of these “new” lignins with enhanced physical and
chemical properties will no doubt stimulate major new markets for this renew-
able material. However, it is likely that these materials will find their initial mar-
kets in the same sectors as the current lignin products. A review of the manu-
facturing, properties and present markets for lignins from pulping operations is
therefore instructive in assessing the potential economic value of lignin that
might be recovered from biorefineries processing lignocellulosic materials.
Presently lignin is separated on an industrial scale from wood and from some
annual plants, such as straw, bagasse and flax, by the chemical pulping indus-
try, using primarily the kraft, sulfite and soda pulping processes [4]. The vast
majority of this lignin is not isolated and recovered but is burned in chemical
recovery boilers as components of the concentrated black liquor feed. As such it
provides low value fuel to the pulp mill for the production of steam and power
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
166 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
[4]. A small number of companies have, on the other hand, introduced systems
for the partial recovery and purification of lignin and have developed significant
businesses that market these materials to a large number of different industries
for diverse applications [3].
In future, biorefineries processing lignocellulosic materials with the primary pur-
pose of producing fermentable sugars from cellulose and hemicellulose, will gen-
erate lignin in very substantial quantities. The lignin produced by these operations
will almost certainly be chemically different from the presently available industrial
lignins and they will most probably be closer to the chemical structure of the native
material. Consequently, new applications will arise for these more versatile prod-
ucts, but they will also be capable of competing in the existing lignin markets, re-
presenting strong competition to the presently available lignin products.
The lignins that are currently produced and marketed today are recovered
from the cooking liquors of the chemical pulping industry. They are, however,
chemically modified to a greater or lesser extent by the chemistry of the specific
chemical pulping process from which they are derived [1]. In the sulfite pulping
process, for example, sulfonic acid groups are introduced into partially hydro-
lyzed lignin in the wood converting it into a fully water-soluble lignosulfonate.
This becomes a major component, together with the hemicellulose sugars, of
the spent sulfite liquors. In the kraft pulping process the native lignin is con-
verted into lower molecular weight fragments of thiolignin by the introduction
of thiol groups through the action of the sodium sulfide employed in the pro-
cess. This thiolignin is soluble in the strong alkali present in the cooking liquor,
but can be precipitated and recovered by acidification of the kraft black liquor
[1]. Soda pulping causes a hydrolytic cleavage of the native lignin into smaller
fragments that are soluble in the strongly alkaline cooking liquors, but the re-
sultant lignin is otherwise relatively unmodified chemically.
The markets and the applications of the various forms of lignin presently re-
covered from commercial chemical pulping operations are therefore determined
by the nature of the lignin that is produced by each process. As mentioned pre-
viously, when compared with the total amounts that are separated from wood
and woody fibers by the chemical pulping industry, the amounts of the various
forms of lignin that are presently recovered and sold commercially are very
small, representing a few percent of all that is extracted by that industry. World-
wide, almost all of the lignin separated from woody feedstocks by the pulping
industry is burned in chemical recovery furnaces because of the need to recover
and recycle the inorganic cooking chemicals. An exception to this is in some
lesser developed countries where many small soda pulp mills that process an-
nual fibers cannot afford chemical recovery boilers and therefore dispose of
their cook liquors into the environment, either directly or following minimal
treatment. This latter activity is now being actively discouraged by almost all
governments, with one result being the closure over the last decade of many
small chemical pulp mills, especially in China [5]. In the larger chemical pulp
mills, where chemical recovery boilers are an economic necessity, the lignin is
part of a low value fuel that provides steam and power to the pulp mill.
5.1 Introduction 167
from the kraft pulping process and lignosulfonates from the sulfite pulping pro-
cess. These chemically-modified lignins are presently being marketed primarily
by two major suppliers with roots in the pulp and paper industry, the Specialty
Chemicals division of MeadWestvaco Corporation and Borregaard Lignotech di-
vision of Borregaard Industries [3]. Chemically nonderivatized lignins, of the
type used in many investigative studies and of the type likely to be produced by
biorefineries, have not been available in the quantities required to support a sig-
nificant commercial market.
With the anticipated commercial introduction of biorefineries processing lig-
nocellulosics, this situation is about to change. These biorefineries could pro-
duce large quantities of lignin in a relatively uniform and purified form. Such
lignins can either be used for low value fuel, or they can be used for much
higher value industrial chemical applications, which would substantially im-
prove the economics of the biorefineries producing them. The lignin output
from these future biorefineries could become the raw material for a major new
industry making products that either substitute for chemicals presently made
from crude oil or natural gas, or products that are new to the market place.
Some current and future market and product opportunities are presented in
this chapter.
5.2
Historical Outline of Lignin Production and Applications
An excellent and detailed account of the discovery and history of lignin, as well
as the history of the chemical pulping industry, has recently been provided by
J. L. McCarthy and A. Islam [15]. Starting with the discovery of lignin in 1838
by Payen in France [16], there has been a substantial continuing interest in lig-
nin both at the industrial and the chemical research levels. This interest acceler-
ated with the introduction of a process in 1866 to produce pulp for papermak-
ing from woody materials by chemical pulping (in which the bulk of the lignin
is removed in order to release intact individual fibers) using sulfurous acid [17].
Before this time high quality printing and writing paper had been produced al-
most exclusively from old rags.
5.2.1
Lignosulfonates from the Sulfite Pulping Industry
The first chemical wood pulp mill, using a calcium based sulfite liquor, was
built in Sweden in 1874 followed by a mill in the US in 1882 and a mill in Ca-
nada in 1888 [15]. From that time on the sulfite pulping process became the
dominant chemical pulping process for wood until the kraft process started to
expand in the 1930s following the invention of the Tomlinson recovery furnace.
Prior to this time, the lignin-containing “spent liquors” from the sulfite pulp
mills were discharged into the environment, usually into the nearest waterway.
5.2 Historical Outline of Lignin Production and Applications 169
5.2.2
Lignin from the Kraft Pulping Industry
With the invention of the Tomlinson chemical recovery furnace in the early
1930s the kraft process started to displace the sulfite process as the primary
chemical wood pulping technology, except for the production of some specialty
pulps such as dissolving pulps. Even though a number of specialty sulfite pulp
mills have been constructed in the intervening period, the sulfite pulping indus-
170 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
try has been a steadily declining fraction of the overall chemical pulping indus-
try since that time; a trend that continues today.
In 1942, at Charleston, South Carolina, the Westvaco Company started to pro-
duce lignin products from the black liquors obtained from the kraft pulping of
softwoods and hardwoods. That company, now MeadWestvaco Corporation,
through its Specialty Chemicals division, continues as the dominant supplier of
lignin products obtained from kraft black liquor. While this business appears to
be quite profitable, MeadWestvaco has attracted few competitors for its kraft lig-
nin business, probably because the recovery of kraft lignin from black liquors is
neither simple nor inexpensive. Furthermore, the manufacture and marketing
of lignin products appears as a complicating divergence from their principle
business for most pulp and paper companies. Today, vast quantities of lignin
are produced in the kraft industry worldwide, probably greater than 70 million
tonnes per year, but of this amount more than 99% is burned in chemical re-
covery furnaces and is not recovered for industrial applications. Separation and
recovery of significant quantities of lignin from kraft black liquors changes the
organic to inorganic ratio in the recovery furnace feed and will potentially dis-
rupt operations of those critical pieces of equipment. With the huge scale of
present day chemical pulp mills, any possibility for an expensive disruption of
normal operations is carefully avoided by most company managers.
It is likely that no more than 100 000 tonnes per year of kraft lignin is mar-
keted for its chemical value, worldwide. However, a significant fraction of this
amount is chemically modified to convert it into a water-soluble sulfonated lig-
nin that competes in some applications against lignosulfonates from the sulfite
pulping industry [19].
5.2.3
Lignin from the Soda Pulping Industry
While it is the oldest of the chemical pulping processes, the soda process [4], in
which chemical pulp is produced by the delignifying action of sodium hydrox-
ide, is now almost exclusively used for the production of chemical pulps from
annual plants, such as sugar cane bagasse, flax and cereal straws. Soda pulping
is not as effective a pulping process as kraft or sulfite when applied to either
hardwoods or softwoods. Because of the relatively high ash content of the raw
materials, annual fiber pulp mills usually face the serious problem of a high in-
organic content, particularly silica, in the soda black liquors, which restricts
their ability to use chemical recovery methods similar to the kraft process.
Furthermore, because of the seasonal nature of the availability of the annual fi-
ber feedstock most of these mills are very small and are mostly located in devel-
oping countries. In the past, the standard treatment of the black liquors from
these pulp mills has been to discharge them directly into the environment. Lig-
nin has not been recovered from such sources in the past primarily because of
the relatively unsophisticated nature of the industry in the regions that practice
soda pulping.
5.2 Historical Outline of Lignin Production and Applications 171
However, the lignin produced in the soda pulping of annual fibers is poten-
tially a very useful material. Unlike kraft and sulfite lignins, soda lignins have
not had sulfur introduced into their chemical structure. In addition, they have
interesting thermal and solubility properties that make them especially valuable
in certain commercial applications. One company, Granit S.A., of Lausanne,
Switzerland, is now selling sulfur-free lignin from the soda pulping of annual
fibers for higher value applications [20]. As noted above, most annual fiber pulp
mills are small and located in developing countries, so the availability of this lig-
nin is a concern as the markets for it expand. Granit has addressed this prob-
lem in an innovative way. Recognizing that small annual fiber soda pulp mills
have severe difficulties dealing with their silica-containing pulping liquors,
Granit has developed a technology that allows these mills to solve their liquor
disposal problems while at the same time providing Granit with the lignin prod-
uct it requires for its lignin marketing business [22].
The lignin recovery process developed by Granit, called the Lignin Precipita-
tion System (the LPS process), recovers lignin from the soda black liquor [23].
In this process, the black liquor is first filtered to remove any contaminating
pulp fibers. The filtered liquor is then acidified to create a lignin slurry, which
is conditioned in a maturation step and then filtered to remove the lignin sol-
ids. Following washing, the lignin cake is dried to a powder of high purity lig-
nin containing about 5% moisture. The removal of lignin reduces the COD of
the original black liquor by about 50%, which can then be treated either by
anaerobic digestion or by wet oxidation. The capital cost of the combined sys-
tem would appear to much lower than that of a typical alkali recovery system
used in conventional pulp mills, which in any case would be difficult to scale
down to a size appropriate for the small annual fiber mills. The interesting fea-
ture of this business arrangement is that Granit will purchase the high purity
dried lignin powder from the mill [24]. Thus, installation of the LPS system in-
creases revenues to the mill, solves an environment problem and generates lig-
nin product that is required by the lignin marketing arm of Granit. The first
commercial installation of the LPS technology was undertaken at the flax pulp-
ing mill of Papeteries du Léman in Thonon, France, in 2000 [20]. In this opera-
tion the entire black liquor generated from the soda pulping of flax is fed into
the relatively small LPS lignin recovery unit. After the lignin is filtered from the
slurry and dried, the filtrate is sent presently to a municipal treatment plant,
but soon it will be treated in a Granit wet oxidation reactor that will be part of a
new on-site effluent treatment plant. A second LPS system is under construc-
tion at a mill in India and is anticipated to be operational in 2005. The potential
lignin production is over 10 000 tonne per year of dried high purity lignin pow-
der ready for the market. Interesting alternative uses of the LPS technology are
for the debottlenecking of an existing conventional alkali recovery system, or for
the expansion of pulping capacity in an existing mill.
172 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
5.3
Existing Industrial Lignin Products
5.3.1
Lignosulfonates
As previously stated, the sulfite pulping industry, in its earlier days, simply dis-
charged its spent liquor into the environment. As this practice became less ac-
ceptable and also for economic reasons, some in the industry started to look for
alternative uses for the spent sulfite liquor. Initially, the simplest approach was
to partially evaporate the liquor to reduce its volume and its transportation cost
and then to use the concentrated material as road dust suppressant, or animal
feed supplement [3]. One of the processes used to upgrade the spent liquors in-
volves the fermentation of the sugars in the liquor, which represents close to
50% of the organic material, to produce food and fodder torula yeasts. The re-
maining partially purified lignosulfonates can then be concentrated and modi-
fied to produce a series of industrial products suitable for commercial applica-
tion. Such a plant is operated by Wausau Paper Mills at the Rhinelander sulfite
mill in Wisconsin, but other similar plants have been constructed in the wes-
tern US but are not presently operating. As the sulfite pulp mills that supplied
the spent liquors were closed the fermentation and lignosulfonate plants were
also mostly closed.
birch hardwood pulp per day. These lignosulfonate products are sold in liquid
form having a solids content of between 52% and 62% and a pH as low as 2–3
and as high as pH 7–8, depending on the grade. The more purified grades,
which are used primarily as binders and dispersants, have approximately 5% su-
gars, 4–5% calcium, and 6% sulfur as a percent of dry matter, with up to 80%
of the solids being lignin. The less pure grades would have between 30% and
35% of the solids as sugars and about 55% as lignin.
ment or, in the case of feed pellets, in the animals digestive tract. An added ad-
vantage in pelletizing operations is that the lignosulfonates provide lubrication
for the die of the pellet forming machine, which reduces the energy consump-
tion and increases productivity of the pelletizing equipment.
5.3.2
Kraft Pulping and Kraft Lignin Recovery
The kraft pulping process has now become the dominant chemical pulping process
for making pulp from wood. It uses a combination of sodium hydroxide and sodium
sulfide to delignify the wood by causing thiolysis mostly of the aryl–alkyl ether lin-
kages, which occur predominantly at the b carbon of the phenylpropane unit. This
thiolysis introduces a thiol group into the partially depolymerized lignin, which can
account for about 2–3% by weight of the lignin product. This lignin becomes a
component of the kraft black liquor, which in almost all kraft pulp mills is evapo-
rated to greater than 60% by weight of solids and then burned in an on-site kraft
chemical recovery boiler [4]. The purpose of the recovery boiler is to allow the recover
and recycle of the inorganic cooking chemicals. The burning of the concentrated
black liquor produces steam, which can be used for power production and also pro-
cess steam. To recover kraft lignin it is necessary to remove some lignin from the
black liquor prior to its entry into the recovery boiler. This can be done by acidifying
the black liquor, initially with carbon dioxide from flue gas, and then by addition of
sulfuric acid. A precipitate of sodium lignate is formed, which is coagulated and
filtered and in most circumstances dried. Only a small portion of the lignin in
the black liquor can be recovered otherwise the organic content of the concentrated
liquor becomes too low to support combustion in the recovery boiler.
5.3.3
Lignins Produced from the Soda Process
As stated previously, the Swiss company Granit is now producing and market-
ing annual fiber lignin from the soda pulping process [20]. The markets for this
product are developing rapidly and it is finding applications in many of the
markets currently being exploited by kraft lignin producers. However, with its
particular advantageous properties it is likely to find new markets, especially in
animal nutrition and health, which are not presently being served by other
forms of lignin.
5.3.4
Lignin from Other Biomass Processing Operations
5.3.5
Comparisons of the Physical and Chemical Properties of Commercially Available
Lignins
A general comparison of the chemical and physical properties of the three com-
mercially available lignin is given in Table 5.2. It can be seen that lignin from
the soda process is distinguished from the other two since it contains no mea-
surable sulfur and has a very low water solubility.
5.4 Lignin from Biorefineries 177
Carbon, % 66 53 56
Hydrogen, % 5.9 5.4 7.5
Methoxy, % 14 12.5 N/A
Ash, % 3 2.5 < 2.5
Wood sugars, % Low Up to 50% 2.5–3.5
Sulfur, % 1.6 6–7.9 N/A
Water solubility Low Very high Very low
Tg, 8C 140 Not detected 150
Softening pt. 8C Not detected Not detected N/A
Mol. wt., MN 2000 400–150 000 2300–2900
5.4
Lignin from Biorefineries
5.4.1
Advantages of Lignin and Hemicellulose Removal on Saccharification
and Fermentation of Cellulose
Strong mineral acid can be employed to saccharify cellulose, as was done in the
Scholler process and other processes reviewed by Wenzl [25], to produce ethanol
from wood. However, acid hydrolysis creates a number of significant difficulties.
Strong mineral acid will readily penetrate the walls of the woody material and
quickly initiate both cellulose and hemicellulose saccharification but, being a
rather indiscriminate catalyst, it also induces other less desirable reactions in
wood hydrolysis. These side reactions include the dehydration of pentose and
hexose sugars to form furfural and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural, two potent inhibi-
tors of fermentation organisms. This not only makes it difficult to ferment the
resultant sugars directly, but it also leads to a significant reduction of glucose
yield below the theoretical maximum. Additionally, strong mineral acid, at the
elevated temperatures required for cellulose hydrolysis, induces potentially un-
desirable condensation reactions in the lignin, thus reducing its versatility and
value as a chemical intermediate and product. Consequently, lignin recovered
from acid hydrolysis processes is usually utilized only as a boiler fuel.
Cellulase enzymes are much more specific catalysts that operate closer to am-
bient temperature than do acid hydrolysis systems. They do not catalyze reac-
tions in lignin, although they may have secondary hydrolytic activity on hemi-
cellulose. Neither do they create fermentation inhibitors. As a consequence, they
have the ability to carry out almost complete saccharification of relatively clean
cellulose, when the enzyme profile is appropriately adjusted. The glucose yields
178 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
from cellulose using enzymatic hydrolysis can be greater than 90% of theoreti-
cal [26], compared with acid-catalyzed hydrolysis which may be little better than
70% of theoretical. For these and other reasons the technology focus for future
lignocellulosic biorefineries has now mostly shifted towards enzymatic saccharif-
ication of cellulose, especially with the recent major reductions in the price of
cellulase enzymes [27]. Starch saccharification has moved almost exclusively to-
wards enzymatic systems, for similar reasons. However, enzymes are large
bulky catalysts that cannot readily diffuse through the encrusting hemicellulose
and lignin that surrounds the cellulose in woody materials. Cellulase enzymes
react very slowly with native lignocellulosic materials. For this and other practi-
cal reasons biorefinery technology for lignocellulosic conversion has now found
it essential to include some type of feedstock pretreatment stage.
Such pretreatments must accomplish the physical disruption of the native lig-
nocellulosic biomass sufficiently to allow the diffusion and penetration of the
enzymes into the biomass structure and give ready access to the cellulose mole-
cules in the primary and secondary walls of the woody fiber. Woody biomass
pretreatments that are under investigation include (1) one stage steam explo-
sion, (2) two stage steam explosion in the presence of SO2 or sulfuric acid, (3)
ammonia fiber explosion (AFEX), (4) dilute mineral acid, and (5) organosolv de-
lignification. More exotic pretreatments, such as treatment with super critical
water, are also being investigated. The various fiber explosion processes and di-
lute mineral acid pretreatments have the effect of hydrolyzing and solubilizing
hemicellulose and also of opening up the tight structure of the fiber structure
to expose cellulose more for enzymatic attack. They do not remove lignin from
the pretreated material unless specific extraction steps, usually with hot ethanol
or hot alkali, are included after the initial explosion stage. Recent studies have
indicated that the presence of lignin and even hemicellulose in the pretreated
biomass can reduce the speed and possibly the extent of enzymatic saccharifica-
tion of the cellulose [28]. Partly this is because of nonspecific, and possibly irre-
versible, binding of the cellulase enzymes to the lignin. The effect of this phe-
nomenon, which can be overcome by adding excess enzymes, is to increase the
enzyme requirement and consequently the operating costs of the biorefinery.
Organosolv pretreatment, which involves treating the raw lignocellulosic ma-
terial with an aqueous organic solvent (frequently ethanol) at temperatures in
the range of 180–200 8C, specifically hydrolyzes most of the hemicellulose and
lignin and causes them to dissolve in the liquor [29]. Following washing of the
remaining solid fiber, the residual lignin is a minor part of the finely disrupted
material. Studies have shown that organosolv-pretreated woody biomass is
highly susceptible to cellulase hydrolysis, with the extent of cellulose saccharifi-
cation being greater than 90% of theoretical [26]. Even though dehydration prod-
ucts of the sugars are formed in organosolv processes, they do not contaminate
the saccharification and fermentation stages because the solid fiber is washed
extensively to remove and recover lignin that is dissolved in the liquor retained
in the fibers following the pretreatment. The other advantage of organosolv pre-
treatment is that a relatively pure, partially hydrolyzed lignin product is easily
5.4 Lignin from Biorefineries 179
5.4.2
Lignin from an Organosolv Biorefinery
5.5
Applications and Markets for Lignin
5.5.1
Phenol–Formaldehyde Resin Applications
5.5.2
The Potential Use of Biorefinery Lignin in Phenolic Resins
Fig. 5.2 Some commercial and pre-commer- sections of oriented strand board (OSB) and
cial products made with organosolv lignin other panel boards, while on the right is a
from hardwoods. On the left is an automo- section of rubber belting. In the middle is a
bile brake pad, next to a pot handle made sample of the original organosolv lignin
from a molding compound. To the rear are powder, with a granulated version to its left.
sions of formaldehyde from the press during manufacture [34]. This is a major
advantage to manufacturers because these emissions of a known carcinogen are
being closely monitored and regulated by various governments. An added bene-
fit to OSB manufacturers is that it has been shown that the substitution of up
to 35% of PF resin with an equal weight of organosolv lignin will provide sub-
stantial improvements to the final board properties, especially in reduced swell
of the wet board and a higher modulus of rupture following the boil test [7].
5.5.3
Panelboard Adhesives
Resin binders for exterior grade wood panel production is the largest part of the
market for PF resins, representing over half of the PF resin used today. The
market is divided mostly between plywood (a declining market), waferboard and
oriented strandboard (OSB), and exterior grade granulated wood panels, such as
particleboard. Plywood uses only liquid resins, while waferboard and OSB resins
are divided between dry powder and liquid forms. For a number of technical
and production reasons, isocyanate resins, despite their higher cost, are becom-
ing the favored resins for the core layer of OSB, while PF resins remain the re-
sins of choice for the two face layers. The estimated North American demand
for this market segment is over 550 000 tonnes annually on a solids basis, while
total world demand for this purpose is probably more than 1.1 million tonnes
annually.
184 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
In work conducted in the 1970s it was shown that lignin could replace up to
50% or more of the expensive MDI on an equal weight basis in an isocyanate resin
used in wood binder applications [35]. The properties of the finished board were in
many cases superior to the control board with 100% isocyanate resins. Isocyanate
resins sell for about double the price of PF resins on a solids basis.
5.5.4
Thermoset Resins for Molded Products
5.5.5
Friction Materials
During the manufacture of friction products, such as brake pads, brake shoes
and clutch facings, PF resins are added to the initial mix of components in the
range of 2–5% by weight. They serve as green strength binders to hold the
shape of the final product during molding and while in the bake oven. In the
bake cycle the PF resins are carbonized and form a matrix that supports the
other components. Approximately 27 000 tonnes per year of PF resins are used
in the manufacture of friction materials in the US, while world consumption is
probably in excess of 120 000 tonnes per year. Lignin can substitute for a signifi-
cant amount of this PF resin in friction materials [36].
Before the closing of the Alcell plant in 1996, Repap was regularly selling or-
ganosolv lignin to a commercial brake lining manufacturer who was substitut-
ing lignin for PF resin at a 20% level, but a higher level of substitution was
anticipated following these successful introductory levels (Fig. 5.2). Organosolv
lignin was found to provide some technical advantages to the final product, in
addition to cost advantages.
5.5.6
Foundry Resins
PF resins are used to bind the sand in metal casting molds and core. Mostly
the molds are made of green sand without binders, but the more delicate sand
cores are bonded with PF and other types of resins, such as furan resins. These
5.5 Applications and Markets for Lignin 185
resins have the advantage that they are burned out of the sand, which can then
be recycled. The incorporation of lignin into these resins would have the same
advantage. Phenolics account for slightly more than 50% of the resins used in
the foundry market. In North America approximately 55 000 to 60 000 tonnes of
phenolic resins are used in the foundry mold binder market each year. World-
wide the usage is estimated to be about 150 000 tonnes per year. Alcell organo-
solv lignin was found to effectively displace more than 20% of furan and
phenolic foundry resins without loss of performance.
5.5.7
Insulation Materials
Glass fiber in insulation batting is bonded together using mostly liquid phenolic
resins but some powder resins, about 15–20% of the total, are used in certain
specialty applications. PF resins are used because they are temperature stable
and flame resistant. They are also used in phenolic foams, mineral wool and
waste fiber insulation. In the latter case, waste fiber such as cotton, polyester
and wool is shredded and bonded together with powder resin and molded.
Much of this material is used for acoustical insulation and applications. In
North America over 110 000 tonnes of phenolic resins are used by the insulation
materials market sector each year. The prices are similar to those for resins
used in other applications.
5.5.8
Decorative Laminates
5.5.9
Panel and Door Binders
There is a growing market for PF resins in the production of laminated and ve-
neered doors and certain types of molded fibrous structural panels. While this
is a fast growing business it is relatively small compared to the production of
structural wood panels for roofing, siding and underlaying, such as OSB and
plywood.
186 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
5.5.10
Rubber Processing
Several applications for lignin have been identified in the rubber industry.
These are:
· phenolic tackifiers
· antioxidants
· reinforcers.
Tack is the term given to the resistance to separation of two materials after they
have been brought in contact with each other, under light pressure, for a short
time. One type of tack is classified as autoadhesive tack, where the two materi-
als have the same chemical composition. The other type, adhesive tack, is used
where the two materials are of different composition.
In the production of multi-layered rubber products, such as tires and belting,
tack is needed to hold the components together during manufacture. Various
additives, known as tackifiers, are added to rubber formulations to increase tack
in the compound. Three types of tackifying resins are mostly used – hydrocar-
bon resins, rosin and its derivatives, and phenol–formaldehyde resins. Interest-
ingly, the molecular weight of the typical tackifying resins is around 2000 or
less, a number consistent with the number average weight of several soda and
organosolv lignins.
As a result of recognizing these similarities Repap entered into a collaborative
development program in the early 1990s with two major rubber products manu-
facturers for the evaluation of Alcell lignin as a tackifier in rubber processing.
This program demonstrated the capacity of dry powder Alcell lignin to function
as an effective tackifier in SBR compounds. Initially, lignin was used as a 50%
replacement of PF resin. Because tackifiers also affect the cured physical proper-
ties of rubber, it was necessary to not only test for tack improvement, but also
to test the hardness and tensile strength of the cured rubber as well as other
properties such as cut growth resistance and resistance to oils and solvents. A
patent covering this application was awarded in the US and several other coun-
tries [37].
Reinforcers are additives employed to obtain certain performance properties
in rubber products, such as tires, where abrasion resistance, in particular, is im-
portant. Reinforcing agents are normally carbon blacks, inorganic fillers, or re-
inforcing resins. Kraft lignin powders are also used in this application and it
has been suggested that, because of the specific gravity of organosolv lignin
powders, they should also be effective reinforcers.
A major advantage in this application was that the lignin also acted as an
antioxidant. In the manufacture of rubber products, antioxidants are also added
to the compound. Therefore, lignin acted as a multi-functional additive; a major
advantage, since a single additive could be used in place of the two additives
normally employed.
5.6 Lignin as an Antioxidant 187
5.5.11
The Opportunity for Lignin in Phenol–Formaldehyde Resin Markets
5.6
Lignin as an Antioxidant
Antioxidants are a group of chemicals that inhibit atmospheric oxidation and its
degradative effects on polymer systems, lubricants, foodstuffs and animal feed
additives. They minimize degradation during fabrication, storage and use.
In polymers and long chain molecules, such as fatty acids and polyalkanes,
chemical bonds are broken under the influence of heat, ionizing radiation, me-
chanical stress and chemical reactions to form free radicals. Oxygenation of
these free radicals forms peroxy radicals that initiate a chain reaction, which will
eventually badly degrade the polymer or long chain molecule, frequently intro-
ducing colored compounds into the product.
In order to inhibit oxidation in this chain reaction and to slow polymer degra-
dation, free radical scavengers are introduced into the polymer or foodstuff.
These are known as primary antioxidants, which include hindered phenols and
secondary arylamines. Lignin is a polymeric hindered phenol, a class of com-
pounds known to be effective primary antioxidants. Alcell organosolv lignin was
tested for its antioxidant properties and found to be an effective antioxidant in
grease, rubber and animal vitamin supplements.
Presently, the major antioxidants used in industry include butylated hydroxy-
toluene (BHT), butylated hydroxyanisole (BHA), propyl gallate (PG), natural to-
copherols and polymeric hindered phenols. These are all expensive materials
($ 3.00 per kg) and many of them are petroleum-based. Particularly in food and
188 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
feed applications, they are highly regulated. Some synthetic antioxidants con-
tinue to be under suspicion for adverse health effects. Lignin is a natural prod-
uct, which is ingested daily by both humans and animals. It might therefore be
expected to be a preferred form of natural antioxidant especially in food and
feed since there is a high likelihood that lignin is physiologically benign in hu-
mans.
5.6.1
Antioxidants in Animal Feed Supplements
In 1996 a leading feed vitamin supplier tested Alcell lignin to assess its poten-
tial as a natural antioxidant able to protect the potency of the antioxidant vita-
mins, such as vitamin E in animal feed vitamin supplements. It was reported
that the lignin functioned well in this application. Interestingly, the lignin also
served the added function as a pellet binder.
5.6.2
Antioxidants in the Rubber Industry
5.6.3
Antioxidants in the Lubricants Industry
An area that is very attractive for lignin as an antioxidant is in the field of lubri-
cating greases. In this application the dark color of lignin is not usually impor-
tant and it is not necessary for it to be soluble in the grease. Addition levels to
greases is between 1% and 10% by weight, depending on product and applica-
tion.
Alcell organosolv lignin was marketed in 1996 as a multifunctional grease ad-
ditive (antioxidant and extreme pressure/antiwear additive) through a specialty
lubricants additives company for a price competitive with existing antioxidants.
Lubricating greases represent only 2% of all lubricant sales. Sales of antioxi-
dant/antiwear additives for greases in the US in the late 1990s were approxi-
mately 3.0 million kg with a value in excess of $10 million. Many customers are
looking for “green additives” that are nonmetallic, nonchlorinated, nonsulfur ad-
ditives and also are looking for natural products with low cost relative to the
conventional additives.
5.7 Applications for Water-soluble, Derivatized Lignins 189
5.7
Applications for Water-soluble, Derivatized Lignins
As discussed earlier, lignosulfonates from the sulfite pulping industry and delib-
erately sulfonated kraft lignins represent the largest single form of lignin used
in industrial applications. Together these products account for approximately 1
million tonnes per year, worldwide. They function mostly as dispersants,
emulsifiers and surfactants in numerous commercial applications. Hydrolysis
lignins obtained from future biorefineries will also be capable of being modified
to produce equivalent or, because of their greater purity, improved materials for
these markets.
As the sulfite pulping process has moved from being used to produce com-
modity papermaking pulps to being the source for the manufacture of specialty
dissolving pulps, more sulfite mills have closed over the last fifty years or so,
and continue to close. Most of the recovered lignosulfonates from the remain-
ing mills is going into the surfactants, dispersants and emulsifiers markets.
With the increase in demand for these products and the need for improved per-
formance, some market share has been lost to synthetic products. Sulfonated
kraft lignins are also sold into this market by MeadWestvaco. Methylsulfonated
biorefinery lignins should easily enter this market.
5.7.1
Concrete Admixtures
The first three categories rely upon sulfonic acid groups to impart a negative
charge on the cement particle. The positioning of sulfonic acid groups on ligno-
sulfonates is a direct result of the pulping process chemistry. This may not be
ideal for this application and deliberately sulfonated natural lignins may yield
higher performing products than lignosulfonates. Methyl-sulfonated Alcell lig-
nin was tested as a water reducer in concrete and found to be quite effective.
Figure 5.3 shows a concrete cylinder produced with methyl-sulfonated Alcell lig-
nin that is used for testing of compressive strength.
5.7.2
Dye Dispersants
Before the advent of synthetic fibers, fabrics were made from naturally occur-
ring materials such as wool, cotton, linen etc. These natural fibers were dyed
from solution, in a dye bath. The dissolved, dyestuff molecule chemically
bonded to reactive sites on the fiber surface. Solutions exhibited uniform con-
centration so that the fabric was evenly-colored.
Synthetic fibers have now become equally as important as natural materials
in clothing, furniture coverings, drapes, and carpeting. Since many of the newly
discovered fibers were synthetic polymers, they were chemically unreactive.
5.7 Applications for Water-soluble, Derivatized Lignins 191
It is not easy to meet these demanding requirements. Over the past 30 years,
the dyestuffs industry has found only three dispersants that will perform ade-
quately:
1. Sulfonated kraft lignin
2. Lignosulfonate
3. Condensation products of naphthalene sulfonate.
Sulfonated kraft lignin and lignosulfonates together account for about 90% of
the dispersant market. While they are the best products available, it is generally
admitted that they are far from ideal. The third class of products, the naphtha-
lene sulfonates, account for 5 to 10% of the dispersant market. They exhibit
questionable high-temperature stability – a vital property – and are expensive.
They are seldom used in formulations in North America, but they are often
used in vat dyes for cotton in other countries. The total amount of lignin-based
dye dispersants used worldwide is about 25 000 tonnes annually.
192 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
5.7.3
Asphalt Emulsifiers
The strong move to water-based asphalt emulsions and away from organic sol-
vent-based systems has been driven by environmental concerns about organic
solvent releases into the atmosphere. Asphalt emulsions are now used exten-
sively in a variety of applications including road building, road and driveway
sealing, soil stabilization, surface coating of asphalt pavement and built-up roof-
ing. In these applications the emulsions are formed and stabilized with emulsi-
fiers that are generally used at a level of about 1 to 2% by weight of the emul-
sion.
Pinova, a division of Hercules, of Wilmington, DE, markets a series of asphalt
emulsifiers based on polymerized rosin, Vinsol resin (a “bottoms” fraction from
the refining of rosin) and rosin acids. These materials are obtained from rosins
extracted from Southern Pine stumpwood. For a number of reasons the avail-
ability of these rosins is declining and Hercules has been searching for new
raw materials to support its asphalt emulsifier business.
During discussions with Repap in the mid-1990s Hercules became aware of
the new organosolv lignin product from the Alcell process and tested its perfor-
mance in asphalt emulsifiers. These trials were successful and two US patents
[38, 39] was awarded and assigned to Hercules covering the formulation of lig-
nin-containing asphalt emulsifiers and the asphalt emulsions containing such
emulsifiers. These new emulsifiers were prepared by combining and melting
lignin and polymerized rosin to obtain a homogeneous molten blend, then cool-
ing the blend until it solidified. In a preferred embodiment, the ingredients
further comprise added rosin acids and Vinsol resin, and the lignin is an orga-
nosolv lignin.
The total world output of asphalt is well in excess of one billion tons. It is
stated that 90% of all road networks are asphalt. Lignin-based asphalt emulsi-
fiers should be well received by the industry. There is a continuing public con-
cern about leaching of asphalt components into the surrounding soils and into
ground and surface water. The leaching of lignin would have no negative envi-
ronmental consequences, and may even have positive effects.
5.7.4
Agricultural Applications
Lignin products from conventional chemical pulping operations have for a long
time been used in agriculture. Lignosulfonates from the sulfite pulping industry
have found applications as feed pellet binders, dispersants for insecticides, fun-
gicides and herbicides, and even as dust suppressants on farm roads. Initially
these applications were driven by a need of the sulfite pulping industry to find
uses for its spent sulfite pulping liquors. In these applications there was little
need to purify the spent liquors and so the product was frequently a dried pow-
der of the spent liquor, or even the liquor itself.
5.7 Applications for Water-soluble, Derivatized Lignins 193
Worldwide, agriculture has several emerging needs that can be satisfied by hy-
drolysis lignins, such as organosolv and biorefinery lignins. Among these needs are
· improved environmental performance
· improved animal health without using human applicable antibiotics
· greater efficiency in use of resources
· lower costs of operation
· improved productivity
· insulation from rising energy costs
· lower usage of fossil carbon-based chemicals.
5.7.5
Dispersants for Herbicides, Pesticides and Fungicides
5.8
New and Emerging Markets for Lignin
As can be readily seen from the above descriptions of the present markets for
lignin and its water-soluble derivatives, there is an existing major market oppor-
tunity for hydrolysis lignins that might be obtained from new biorefinery opera-
tions. Not only will the new lignins promise superior performance in many ap-
plications that currently are filled by the lignosulfonates and kraft lignins, but,
because of their anticipated superior purity and functionality, they will open ma-
jor new markets that presently do not exist. Already there are indications of
such future market opportunities that were being developed from the very lim-
ited supply of organosolv lignins generated from Repap and from the limited
work undertaken by Organocell. Some of these exciting opportunities are pre-
sented below.
5.8.1
Printed Circuit Board Resins
A report from the IBM company in 1996 [40] identified a novel application for
lignin in the manufacture of printed circuit boards (PCBs) for the electronics in-
dustry. In the manufacture of PCBs the glass fabric, which is the largest part of
the PCB, is dip coated with a resin. This is usually an epoxy resin, dissolved in
a low boiling solvent, such as methyl ethyl ketone or acetone. The release of
these solvents during resin curing is an undesirable health and environmental
issue.
At that time, IBM was in the process of examining its various production pro-
cesses and operations in order to substitute, where possible, “green” technology.
One area of interest was the use of renewable biopolymers to replace the oil-
based epoxy resins typically used in the industry. Lignin became of interest be-
cause its molecular structure could provide the thermal stability and chemical
resistance that was required for PCBs. It was reported that in initial research,
PCBs produced with an epoxy resin containing 50% lignin showed better ther-
mal and electrical performance than current high volume PCBs and that the re-
sin cost was significantly lower than standard resins. Furthermore, this material
reduced the dependence on fossil fuels.
5.8 New and Emerging Markets for Lignin 195
5.8.2
Animal Health Applications
5.8.3
Animal Feed Supplement
5.8.4
Carbon Fibers for Mass-produced Vehicles
A fascinating and potentially very large new market for lignin is for the produc-
tion of low cost carbon fibers for use in automobile and light truck body compo-
nents.
It is well recognized that major transportation fuel savings, and an equivalent
reduction in the demand for oil, would be achieved if the weight of vehicles
could be reduced. There would also be a beneficial concomitant reduction in
emissions. Today, despite a rising use of lower weight materials, between half
and two thirds of the weight of most vehicles is contributed by ferrous metals.
Much of these could be replaced by components made from lighter weight car-
bon fiber composites, which could reduce the weight of the vehicle by about
one third. Such carbon fiber composite materials are used extensively in the
aerospace industry where they have proven their value and performance. Carbon
fibers for these applications are made mostly from oil-derived pitch and poly-
acrylonitrile (PAN) and in their final form cost in excess of $ 25 per kg.
In order for auto body parts made from carbon fiber composites to be price-
competitive in today’s mass-produced vehicles, it has been determined that the
carbon fibers would need to cost less than half this amount. This price cannot
be achieved using existing feedstocks, especially as oil prices continue to climb.
5.8 New and Emerging Markets for Lignin 197
What is needed to achieve this goal is a high carbon content, relatively low
priced, preferably renewable feedstock that can be produced on a large scale,
the price of which would be relatively independent of the price of oil.
Researchers at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory in Tennessee, USA, are in-
vestigating the use of lignin for this application [46, 47]. Most of their work has
been with kraft lignin, but they have also successfully used organosolv lignin in
this application. This work has produced industrial grade carbon fibers suitable
for use in vehicles from blends of lignin and post-consumer recycled polyester
and other polymers. The commercial kraft lignin that was used had to be
washed free of contaminants and desalted prior to use to avoid the presence of
voids in the fibers, which would significantly reduce their strength and value.
Purer lignins produced from biorefinery processes could eliminate the need for
this processing step. Figure 5.4 shows spools of the melt spun lignin/polymer
fibers containing different amounts of lignin. Figure 5.5 displays microscopic
images of lignin/polyethylene oxide fibers at different stages in the manufacture
of carbon fibers [47].
Once this application becomes fully developed it has been estimated that if
each newly manufactured vehicle in the US used only 10 kg of carbon fiber,
there would be an annual demand for 125 000 tonnes of carbon fiber. With a lig-
nin carbon content of 0.68 and an expected carbon yield of 0.45–0.55, just this
limited consumption could require up to approximately 250 000 tonnes of lignin
annually and could support a lignin price greater than US $ 1.20 per kg. Each
new vehicle could ultimately use many times the 10 kg suggested in this illus-
tration. In fact, it is conceivable that each vehicle could ultimately use up to
500 kg of carbon fiber making the carbon fiber demand for US manufactured
vehicles alone at least 4 million tonnes per year, which in turn would require
up to 8 million tonnes of lignin per year. Today the worldwide demand for car-
bon fiber is approximately 28 000 tonnes per year. Therefore, capacity would
have to increase by close to five times just to satisfy this application at a level of
10 kg per new vehicle in the US alone and a further fifty times to meet the ulti-
mate potential demand.
Fig. 5.4 Spools of melt spun fibers made from blends of kraft lignin and polymer.
198 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
5.9
Conclusions and Perspectives
Lignin that is now being recovered from conventional chemical pulping opera-
tions has established a significant commercial market in numerous industries
and applications. These markets basically employ two different forms of lignin.
The first of these are the water-soluble lignosulfonates recovered from the sulfite
pulping process and the deliberately sulfonated lignins derived from the kraft pro-
cess. The second form of commercial lignin is the thiolignin obtained from the
kraft process. Because of their markedly different physical and chemical proper-
ties, each of these has established its own range of applications, with very little
overlap between them. The combined worldwide market that presently exists
for these two product forms appears to be about one million tonnes per year.
With the increasing cost of crude oil and natural gas and the developing trend
and incentives towards the use of renewable chemicals to replace fossil-carbon-de-
rived materials it can only be anticipated that these traditional markets for lignin
products will expand. At the same time, the number of pulp mills that practice the
sulfite process are slowly declining, which raises the question as to where the sup-
ply to meet this increased demand will come from. An additional trend in the
pulping industry is the ever increasing scale of new kraft mills and the frequent
closure of small kraft mills now regarded as too small to be competitive. It is un-
likely that recovery of lignin will be an attractive option for the very large kraft
mills because of the process integration with large recovery boilers.
This situation can benefit future biorefineries that will be processing lignocel-
lulosic feedstocks. Certain biorefinery pretreatment technologies, such as orga-
nosolv processes, will have the capability to produce a superior form of pure lig-
nin ideal for chemical applications. The marketing of this lignin as a co-product
will add substantial revenues and vastly improve the economics of the biorefin-
ery. The new biorefineries will more than likely be on a considerably smaller
scale than world-scale kraft pulp mills that are now processing 3 000 to 4 000
tonnes of wood on a dry weight basis per day. Consequently biorefineries will
be more flexible and better suited to produce and market some of the special-
ized lignins that will emerge from them.
References 199
The past experience from the production of large volumes of Alcell lignin
shows that the availability of commercial quantities of these improved lignins
will stimulate sizeable new market opportunities that do not presently exist for
lignins from the chemical pulping industry. Some of these new markets are al-
ready clearly visible. What is needed now is the commercial-scale production of
the lignin to service these opportunities.
References
1 R. Alén, Forest Products Chemistry, Fapet 12 R. Alén, Forest Products Chemistry, Fapet
Oy, Helsinki, Finland, 2000. Oy, Helsinki, Finland, 2000, p. 66.
2 W. G. Glasser, R. A. Northey, T. P. 13 W. G. Glasser, Forest Prod. J. 1981, 31,
Schultz, Lignin: Historical, Biological and 24–29.
Materials Perspectives, ACS Symposium 14 Lignin: Properties and Materials, eds.
Series 742, American Chemical Society, W. G. Glasser, S. Sarkanen, American
Washington, DC, 2000. Chemical Society Symposium Series
3 J. D. Gargulak, S. E. Lebo. In Lignin: His- 397. Washington, DC, USA, 1989.
torical, Biological and Materials Perspec- 15 J. L. McCarthy and A. Islam, Lignin: His-
tives, ACS Symposium Series 742, Amer- torical, Biological and Materials Perspec-
ican Chemical Society, Washington, DC, tives, ACS Symposium Series 742, Amer-
2000, p. 304. ican Chemical society, Washington, DC,
4 G. A. Smook, Handbook for Pulp and Pa- 2000, p. 2–99.
per Technologists, 2nd edn., Joint Textbook 16 A. Payen, Compt. Rend. 1838, 7, 1052.
Committee of the Paper Industry, TAP- 17 B. C. Tilghman, British Patent No. 2924,
PI, Atlanta, USA, and CPPA, Montreal, 1866.
Canada. 18 Borregaard LignoTech website. http://
5 X.-J. Zhong, A. Gan, Profit Through Inno- www.ltus.com/about us/history.html.
vation, Pira International, London, UK, 19 Meadwestvaco website, http://
1997, p. 222–224. www.meadwestvaco.com/specialtychem-
6 F. Zimbardi, E. Ricci, G. Braccio. Applied icalshome.nsf
Biochem. Biotechnol. 2002, 18/20, 89–99. 20 Granit S. A. website, http://www.granit.-
7 J. H. Lora, C. F. Wu, E. K. Pye, and J. J. net
Balatinecz, In Lignin: Properties and Ma- 21 Chemical modification, Properties, and
terials. W.G. Glasser and S. Sarkanen Usage of Lignin, 2002, ed. T. Q. Hu,
(Eds.). American Chemical Society Sym- Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers,
posium Series 397. Washington, DC, New York.
USA 1989, p. 312–324. 22 J. H. Lora, A. Abächerli, F. Doppenberg,
8 X. Pan, X. Zhang, D. J. Gregg, J. N. Sad- 2000, Tappi Pulping Conference Proceed-
dler. Applied Biochem. Biotechnol. 2004, ings, Tappi Press, Atlanta, USA.
113/116, 1103–1114. 23 J. H. Lora, Proceedings of the 6th Interna-
9 A. Boussaid, A. R. Esteghlalian, D. J. tional Conference of Pulp and Paper Indus-
Gregg, K. H. Lee, J. N. Saddler, Applied try – Paerex, December 5–7, 2003, New
Biochem. Biotechnol. 2000, 84/86, 693– Delhi, India.
705. 24 J. H. Lora, personal communication, 2004.
10 G. P. van Walsum, Applied Biochem. Bio- 25 H. F. J. Wenzl, The Chemical Technology of
technol. 2001, 91/93, 317–328. Wood, 1970, Academic Press, New York.
11 F. Teymouri, L. Laureano-Perez, H. Ali- 26 X. Pan, C. Arato, N. Gilkes, D. Gregg,
zadeh, B. E. Dale, Applied Biochem. Bio- W. Mabee, K. Pye, Z. Xiao, X. Zhang, J.
technol. 2004, 113/116, 951–963. Saddler, “Biorefining of Softwoods Using
Ethanol Organosolv Pulping – Prelimin-
200 5 Industrial Lignin Production and Applications
201
6
Towards Integration of Biorefinery and Microbial Amino Acid
Production
6.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
202 6 Towards Integration of Biorefinery and Microbial Amino Acid Production
6.2
Present State of the Industry
6.2.1
Microbial Amino Acid Production
6.2.2
Biorefinery and the Building-block Concept
6.2.3
Metabolic Engineering and the Building-block Concept
6.3
Environmental and Commercial Consideration of Microbial Amino Acid Production
Integrated in a Biorefinery
The role of amino acids in world-wide ecology and in relation to the future de-
velopment of the world population has been evaluated recently [22]. Feeding an-
imals in a well balanced manner leads to reduced release of ammonia into the
environment. When methionine instead of soybean meal is given to poultry the
amount of ammonia released to the environment is reduced more than tenfold
206 6 Towards Integration of Biorefinery and Microbial Amino Acid Production
g6p f6p ri5p e4p gap pga pep pyr accoa oaa akg
Ala 606 1
Arg 189 1
Asx 399 1
Cys 87 1
Glx 806 1
Gly 361 1
His 71 1
Ile 202 1 1
Leu 0 2 1
Lys 202 1 1
Met 146 1
Phe 133 1 2
Pro 170 1
Ser 225 1
Thr 275 1
Trp 54 1 1 1
Tyr 81 1 2
Val 284 2
Dmp 146 1 1
Protein 0 0 125 268 0 673 482 1724 0 1370 1165
RNA 630 368 262
DNA 100 50 50
Lipids 129 129 2116
LPS 51 16 24 24 24 329
Peptidoglycan 55 28 83 55 28 28
Glycogen 154
CI units 49
Polyamines 59
Precursor g6p f6p ri5p e4p gap pga pep pyr accoa oaa akg
Total 205 71 879 268 129 1293 534 1807 2500 1710 1252
[22]. In this way surplus nitrogen and especially nitrate can be avoided so that
ground-water quality is improved. The same is true for substitution of soybean
meal by lysine and threonine in low-protein diets.
An ecological balance for the fermentative production of polyhydroxyalkano-
ates revealed that the major burden on the environment was caused upstream
of the fermentation in the supply chain which provides the substrate for the fer-
mentation [23]. Similar results were obtained for the fermentative production of
lysine and threonine [24]. This means that a re-engineering in the sugar-provid-
ing industry could further improve the ecological impact of MAAP. Because the
lignocellulose-based process is significantly less efficient for the preparation of
the monomer carbon source, however, compared with the well established
starch or sucrose-based process there might not be a significant improvement.
Considering the ecological balance the most efficient process will be the prepa-
ration of a sucrose stream from sugar cane and utilization of sugar cane ba-
gasse for energy generation. The utilization of bagasse for energy supply or sup-
ply of lignocellulose-based carbon sources has a significant advantage over corn
stover, because it is already available at the processing site and no costs arise for
collection and transport.
The markets for the amino acids glutamate, lysine, and threonine are charac-
terized by dynamic growth and they are highly competitive. Monosodium gluta-
mate is used in food as a taste enhancer which is added in prepared food at 0.1
to 0.8% or even more in East Asian dishes. Lysine is used as a feed additive
and the addition of 1 kg lysine · HCl increases poultry feed quality to the same
extent as addition of 35 kg soybean meal [22]. Also threonine is used as feed ad-
ditive especially in diets for pig and poultry. Addition of up to 0.75% of threo-
nine to sorghum-peanut meal increases breast meat deposition by more than
15%.
Lysine and monosodium glutamate are the largest products in the category of
MAAP, and the total market value for amino acids including threonine and
tryptophan was estimated to be in the range of 2.5 billion 1 in 2004. A publica-
tion by Ajinomoto illustrates the decrease of manufacturing cost for lysine and
threonine during the last two decades [25]. It becomes obvious that in this
highly competitive market the product price stabilizes on a quite narrow low
price level. Innovative concepts for reduction of production cost are of tremen-
dous importance to stay competitive in MAAP.
The size and location of a MAAP site is affected by the following considera-
tions:
· availability and price of carbon sources as major single cost
· availability and price of electricity, gas, and steam supply
· availability and price of nitrogen source
· equipment prices and prices for engineering and construction driving capital
investment
· proximity to the market and large-scale customers to achieve low transport
and distribution cost
· currency effects in a global market.
208 6 Towards Integration of Biorefinery and Microbial Amino Acid Production
The same considerations are valid if MAAP is evaluated in the context of any
biorefinery operation. MAAP processes consist of four major steps: receiving,
storage and sterile preparation of carbon sources and other raw materials; culti-
vation of the production strain in an aerobic process; downstream of fermenta-
tion broth; and purification of amino acids and waste treatment. Table 6.3 illus-
trates, as an example, that depending on the downstream process the overall
process yield and thus the quantity of waste materials differs significantly [3, 4].
Even though the process flow in the downstream part of the production of a
special lysine sulfate product which contains the whole culture broth was sim-
plified to a minimum number of unit operations, great challenges had to be
overcome to enable good handling properties and variations of lysine content in
the final product. Because, in the feed-additive market, customers require only
a guaranteed minimum content of the active substance and handling properties
suitable for large scale operations (low dustiness, low caking tendency, good
flow ability, high bulk density) there is room for the development of further
low-purity product forms if the savings in manufacturing cost are substantially
higher than the costs of product registration and marketing efforts for a new
product form. Even if a feed mill is integrated into a biorefinery operation and
a liquid, amino acid-enriched product [29] is used directly for the feed prepara-
tion, large variation of the amino acid content will be very problematic for high-
quality feed preparation. This puts significant higher constraints on process
control of MAAP within a biorefinery operation compared with production of
ethanol.
6.4 Technical Constraints for Integration of Microbial Amino Acid Fermentation into a Biorefinery 209
6.4
Technical Constraints for Integration of Microbial Amino Acid Fermentation
into a Biorefinery
6.4.1
Mono-septic Operation
6.4.2
Carbon Sources
6.4.3
Nitrogen Source
Complex nitrogen sources such as corn steep liquor or yeast extract are already
added to MAAP processes to increase productivity and stability of the microbial
fermentations. They do not contribute significantly to the supply of nitrogen
sources. This is achieved with low-cost alternatives, for example ammonium sul-
fate or liquid ammonia. Corn steep liquor is a by-product in the production of
corn starch and contains amino acids, nucleic acids, vitamins, minerals, and a
significant amount of phosphorus. The natural fluctuation in quality of complex
nitrogen sources results in fluctuations of MAAP process performance. Inten-
sive quality monitoring for the raw materials is required. This must be consi-
dered when new nitrogen sources from a biorefinery are to be introduced in
MAAP. The use of high-value amino acid or peptide fractions as nitrogen
source in amino acid fermentation could be an outlet for these components,
however, only if other applications of those amino acids are not successful. This
application would force a biorefinery operation to price those “high-value” nitro-
gen sources at the same level as “low-value” ammonium sulfate or ammonia.
6.4.4
Phosphorus Source
6.4.5
Mixing and Oxygen Supply
Depending on the extent of reduction of the carbon source and on the energetic
efficiency of MAAP processes more or less oxygen is required to produce bio-
mass and amino acids. The fermentation equipment for mixing, oxygen supply,
and heat removal will have to handle a rather large range of requirements, espe-
cially when flexible utilization of carbon sources with different physical proper-
ties (i.e. viscosity) and different reduction state of the carbon atoms are used. If
the carbon sources are less oxidized than sugars, the fermentation will use sig-
nificantly more oxygen and produce more CO2. For E. coli this effect seems to
be uncritical up to a concentration of 30% of carbon dioxide in the exhaust gas
[46].
6.4.6
Toxicity
A major problem of the usage of raw materials from biorefinery in MAAP may
be the toxicity of components which are contained in the raw material. This top-
ic has already been addressed in Section 6.4.2 when the use of lignocellulose
was discussed. Advanced monitoring technologies such as cytometry [47, 48]
and DNA microarray analysis of gene expression [49, 50] might be used to
monitor toxicity effects, to reveal the nature of toxicity, and to search for meta-
bolic engineering or strain breeding strategies to overcome the hurdles caused
by toxic compounds. Recently, metabolic flux analysis has been applied to acid-
tolerant yeast Candida milleri which would be ideal to convert industrial pulp
mill xylose containing waste streams into xylitol [51]. This kind of investigation
is a first step in the direction of a comprehensive understanding of metabolic
network responses to stimuli from substrate streams which originate from bio-
refineries. It is crucial to select robust host strains such as, in this case, C. mill-
eri in advance and afterwards to optimize the metabolic pathways for maximum
product formation. In the field of MAAP this approach is in its infancy, because
metabolic engineering efforts have been focused on well established hosts. Al-
ternatively, before proceeding with further optimization of terminal pathways
for amino acid biosynthesis, metabolic engineering and classical strain breeding
should be initiated for improvement of resistance against toxic effects. A re-
cently described example is the development of a raffinate (ammonium sulfate
rich eluent from ion exchange)-resistant lysine production strain that enables
re-utilization of the ammonium sulfate generated as a waste stream during pur-
ification [52].
6.5 Outlook and Perspectives 213
6.4.7
Cultivation Temperature
6.5
Outlook and Perspectives
Acknowledgment
References
217
7
Protein-based Polymers:
Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
Dan W. Urry
7.1
Introduction
7.1.1
Definitions
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
218 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
7.1.2
Proteins in Aqueous Media
7.1.3
Thermodynamics of Proteins in Water
the shift that occurs in pKa of an ionizable side-chain on changing the hydro-
phobicity of the protein-based polymer. From the standpoint of bioproduction,
ionization can give solubility and neutralization can effect selective phase sepa-
ration for purification.
7.1.4
The Inverse Temperature Transition for Hydrophobic Association
7.1.5
The Role of Elasticity in the Engineering of Protein-based Polymers
fore, without near ideal elasticity, too little energy of deformation becomes avail-
able for the function of producing motion
7.1.6
Many of the Advantages of Protein-based Polymeric Materials
7.2
Historical Outline
7.2.1
Historical Beginnings of (Elastic) Protein-based Polymer Development
lecular weight polypentapeptides, and to find the latter material to be highly elastic
[12]. Then followed the proposal of a new mechanism of elasticity in 1982 [13],
which was supported by test syntheses, by many more physical characterizations
[14, 15], and by calculations using the ECEPP molecular mechanics approach of
Scheraga [13] and the CHARMM molecular dynamics program of Karplus [16].
The development of elastic-contractile model proteins capable of diverse en-
ergy conversions, based on inverse temperature transitions, rapidly ensued for-
mation of crosslinked elastic matrices that contracted either on raising the tem-
perature above Tt, the onset of the transition, or on lowering Tt from above to
below the operating temperature. Five phenomenological Axioms summarize
the use of Tt for design of Tt-type polymers capable of eighteen classes of pair-
wise energy conversions [4]. Development of the mechanistic foundations fol-
lowed enumeration of the Axioms.
7.2.2
Mechanistic Foundations: Fundamental Engineering Principles
7.2.3
Highlights of Bioproduction
Fig. 7.1 A. E. coli transformed to express the of the volume of the transformed E. coli. B.
phase-separated protein-based polymer, The same strain of E. coli before transforma-
(GVGVP)121, with the expression product tion. Reproduced with permission from Ref.
seen as large phase-separated inclusion [28].
bodies which comprise approximately 80%
7.3
Bioproduction
Fig. 7.3 Three thermoplastics (polymer melts isms but of growing interest to society.
pulled into plastic fibers). Two are plastics Furthermore, protein-based polymer thermo-
of our daily experience (B, polypropylene; plastics can be programmed to biodegrade
C, polystyrene) whereas the third, A, is a in a sufficiently wet environment with half-
protein-based plastic that melts at 160 8C lives that could be varied from days to de-
and does not decompose until 250 8C. Thus, cades. It might be said that these protein-
using living organisms, the potential is to based thermoplastics portend food rather
prepare protein-based polymeric materials than death for marine life. From Ref. [1].
with properties inaccessible to living organ-
7.3.1
Gene Construction using Recombinant DNA Technology
molecular weights that would be some 200 kD, whereas the original maximum
size was thought to be 50 kD in E. coli.
7.3.2
E. coli Transformation for Protein-based Polymer Expression
The multimer gene, prepared in pUC-118, is excised and inserted into an expres-
sion vector, such as pET-23d, which is specialized for expression of the designed
protein-based polymer and inserted into a strain of E. coli, selected for the expres-
sion [29]. Figure 7.1 B, above, shows the non-transformed E. coli, whereas Fig. 7.1A
shows the strain of E. coli, transformed to produce (GVGVP)121. This demon-
strates the high production capacity of the chosen expression system, for example,
the BL21(DE3) strain of E. coli, to produce the elastic protein-based polymer.
7.3.3
Fermentation using Transformed E. coli
7.4
Purification of Protein-based Polymers
7.4.1
Use of the Inverse Temperature Transition as a Method of Purification
Fig. 7.5 SDS–PAGE with CuCl2 stain of ex- tion leaving polymer in solution. Lane 3:
pressed (GVGVP)141 demonstrates use of Supernatant of cold spin after heating to
phase transition to separate from E. coli pro- phase separate (GVGVP)141. Lane 4: Phase
teins. Lane 1: Crude lysate of transformed separated elastic protein-based polymer on
E. coli. Lane 2: Precipitate of cold centrifuga- heating. From [30].
7.4 Purification of Protein-based Polymers 229
7.4.2
Physical Characterization and Verification of Product Integrity
Fig. 7.6 A. Phase separated, taffy-like mass cake, which in C. is pulled into a tough band
of (GVGVP)251 produced by a single fermen- of a meter in length. The addition of a single
tation. The mass readily pulls into long, fine CH2 group per pentamer causes this
viscoelastic strands [1]. B. A small amount dramatic change in physical property. Cross-
of the protein-based polymer, (GVGIP)320, linked (GVGVP)251 exhibits reversible stress–
phase separated into the bottom of a strain curves, whereas (GVGIP)320 exhibits a
250 mL centrifugation bottle to form a pan- marked hysteresis. From Ref. [1].
230 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
7.4.3
Biocompatibility
means of Tables 7.3 and 7.4 and Section 7.5 below. It is important to realize,
however, that this level of purification is insufficient when using the protein-
based polymer in vivo, as a biomaterial that can release all of its impurities in a
short time without leaving any trace of its ever having been present.
jected polymer is seen in Fig. 7.7 B to be intact and surrounded by a fine fibrous
capsule [32].
7.5
Mechanistic Foundations for Engineering Protein-based Polymers
7.5.1
Phenomenological Axioms (see Table 7.2)
7.5.2
The Change in Gibbs Free Energy for Hydrophobic Association, DGHA
AXIOM 1: The change in temperature interval, over which occurs the hydrophobic associa-
tion transition of a host protein-based polymer on introduction of different guest substitu-
ents, becomes a practical measure of relative hydrophobic character of the substituents, and
it approximates the change in free energy of the resulting hydrophobically associated state.
This provides the phenomenological data-base for design of protein-based machines.
AXIOM 2: Heating to raise the temperature from below to above the temperature interval
for hydrophobic association of crosslinked elastic protein-based polymers drives contraction
with the performance of mechanical work.
This is thermally driven contraction inherent in inverse temperature transitions.
Example: Thermo « mechanical transduction
AXIOM 3: At constant temperature, any energy input that changes the temperature interval
for hydrophobic association in a protein-based polymer can drive contraction with the perfor-
mance of mechanical work
Examples: Chemo « mechanical transduction Electro « mechanical transduction
Baro « mechanical transduction Photo « mechanical transduction
AXIOM 4: Two or more different functional groups of an amphiphilic macromolecule, each
of which can be acted upon by a different energy input that changes the temperature inter-
val for hydrophobic association, become coupled one to the other by acting upon the same
hydrophobic association domain. In other words, an energy input acts on one functional
constituent to change its hydrophobicity and that change in hydrophobicity becomes an en-
ergy output that changes the other functional constituent due to its dependency on hydro-
phobicity.
This axiom is the fundamental energy-coupling axiom; it utilizes the hydrophobic association
transition common to all energy conversions by the consilient mechanism. Importantly, in
doing so, it involves the performance of kinds of work in addition to mechanical work.
Examples: Electro « chemical transduction Electro « thermal transduction
Baro « electrical transduction Photo « voltaic transduction
Thermo « chemical transduction Photo « thermal transduction
Baro « thermal transduction Baro « chemical transduction
Photo « baric transduction Photo « chemical transduction
Chemo « chemical transduction Electro « electrical transduction
Electromagnetic radiation (1) « electromagnetic radiation (2) transduction
AXIOM 5: More hydrophobic domains make more efficient the energy conversions involving
polar constituents undergoing conversion between more and less hydrophobic functional
states.
This is the efficiency axiom. (Poising or Biasing)
association, DGHA. Because of this and all that has been demonstrated by sim-
ply controlling hydrophobic association, your author believes DGHA to be the
underlying thermodynamic quantity that dictates protein function. Accordingly,
a proper derivation of the quantity, an analysis of its component parts, and reali-
234 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
7.5.2.1 The Change in Gibbs Free Energy Attending a Phase Transition, dDGt(v) [3]
The relationship that the chemical potential for molecules undergoing a phase
transition is the same in solution as in the phase separated state means that
the heat of the transition, DHt, equals TtDSt, which is then written for both a
reference state, ref, and a state resulting from the change in a variable, v. Suit-
able identification of the change in the heat, dDHt, and entropy, dDSt, of the
transition as the result of v allows the statement [3] that,
7.5.2.2 The DGHA-based Hydrophobicity Scale for Amino Acid Residues [3]
Rewriting Eq. (1) for the endothermic inverse temperature transition allows that
dDGt(v) = DGHA(v). When the variable is the amino acid residue, X, within the
pentamer, dDGt(v) = DGHA(GXGVP) where DGHA is written per mole GXGVP. If
the glycine residue (Gly, G) is taken as the zero reference, DG8HA(GGGVP) = 0.
Thus, at the temperature of the inverse temperature transition, Tt(GXGVP), we
can write:
Included in Table 7.4 are reduced and different oxidative states of N-methylni-
cotinamide (NMeN), oxidized and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide
(NAD and NADH), oxidized and reduced flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD and
FADH2), adenosine monophosphate (AMP), sulfated serine, threonine, and
tyrosine (Ser{–O–SO3H}, Thr{–O–SO3H}, and Tyr{–O–SO3H}, respectively), ni-
trated tyrosine (Tyr{–O–NO–2}), and finally phosphorylated serine (Ser{PO2–4 }).
Table 7.4 shows large effects of changing the oxidative states of the most com-
mon redox groups of biology and of changing the state of phosphorylation. The
DGHA on reduction of FAD is about two-thirds that of NAD as might be ex-
pected for their roles in oxidative phosphorylation. On inclusion of the effects
of salt, solvent and ligands on DGHA , one gains a comprehensive understand-
ing of the hydrophobic effect in biology, a universal foundation for protein and
protein-based polymer function.
7.5.3
The Coupling of Hydrophobic and Elastic Mechanisms
7.6
Examples of Applications
7.6.1
Soft Tissue Restoration
Soft tissue restoration can be considered in terms of three categories: (1) pre-
vention of post-surgical adhesions to restore the tissues to a near normal state,
(2) soft tissue augmentation, for example, to support the urinary bladder and
improve body contours, and (3) soft tissue reconstruction where elastic–contrac-
tile materials function as temporary functional scaffoldings that induce normal
cells of the tissue to remodel into a natural tissue.
Fig. 7.8 Outgrowth of human uroepithelial designed to simulate bladder filling and
cells from a ureteral explant (dark area) onto emptying. A. The static case where good
a crosslinked elastic matrix of {(GVGIP)10– outgrowth is seen. B. The dynamic case of
GVGVPGRGDSP–(GVGVP)10}12(GVGVP). filling in three hours and emptying in 25 s
The elastic matrix, with an elastic modulus shows enhanced cellular proliferation and
that closely matches that of the human much greater development of extracellular
urinary bladder, is placed within a chamber matrix. Reproduced from reference [41].
240 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
7.6.2
Controlled Release Devices for Amphiphilic Drugs and Therapeutics
7.6.2.2 Prevention of Pressure Ulcers by Means of Elastic Patches for Drug Delivery
Pressure ulcers appear over bony prominences where the pressure leads to skin
necrosis and ulcers. In the Swaim coaptation cast model for the dog model, even
the elastic patch (Fig. 7.9) made of crosslinked (GVGIP)260 placed over the bony
7.6 Examples of Applications 241
Fig. 7.9 A. Disk-shaped patches of cross- 350%. C. The two polymers, (GVGVPGVG
linked (GVGIP)260 contain Dazmegrel from FPGEGFPGVGV PGVGVPGVGV P)40–
left to right of 0, 0.1, 1.0, and 10 mg cm–2. (GVGVP) and (GVGVP GVGFP GKGFP
B. The two polymers, (GVGVP GVGVP GVGVP GVGVP GVGVP)22(GVGVP), were
GEGVP GVGVP GVGVP GVGVP)36–(GVGVP) similarly treated to obtain fibers with an
and (GVGVP GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP elastic modulus of 6.1 ´ 106 Pa, a break
GVGVP GVGVP)22(GVGVP), were cross- stress of 6.9 ´ 106 Pa and a break strain of
linked by amide linkage to form a fiber with 280%. The bar indicates 100 lm. B and C re-
an elastic modulus of 3.86 ´ 106 Pa, a break produced from Ref. [45].
stress of 1.3 ´ 106 Pa and a break strain of
7.6.3
Fibers of Improved Elastic Moduli and Break Stresses and Strains
The carboxyl and amine functions in the polymers of Fig. 7.9 exhibit hydropho-
bic-induced pKa shifts. Formation of the –COO–···+H3N ion pairs on mixing of
the polymers reduces Tt and DGHA from the values of the individual polymers.
This aligns the polymers for chemical crosslinking and results in improved elas-
tic moduli and break stress values by one to two orders of magnitude (see leg-
end of Fig. 7.9).
7.6.4
Programmably Biodegradable Thermoplastics
Thermoplastics derive from the designed repeat pentamer, (AVGVP)n, that ex-
hibits an inverse temperature transition, but to a plastic rather than elastic-like
state [46]. When the polymer is made more hydrophobic, the dry polymer melts
and can be pulled into the fibers of Fig. 7.3 A. Also, introduction of asparagine
residues allows for timed breakdown to the carboxylate of aspartic acid. This
raises the value of Tt, and in water the plastic surface swells to become bio-
degradable. Since life cannot exist at the 160 8C required to melt the plastic, we
have designed protein-based polymers for functions that go beyond what nature
has had reason to evolve. Nonetheless, society can find uses for such environ-
mentally friendly plastics.
242 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
7.6.5
Acoustic Absorption
7.7
Outlook and Perspectives
7.7.1
List of Gene Constructions and Expressed Protein-based Polymers
Appropriate in considering the list of Table 7.5 is a quotation due to Jacob Bro-
nowski “In effect, the modern problem is no longer to design a structure from
the materials (available) but to design materials for a structure” [48]. Each of the
gene constructs of Table 7.5 was made for a specific purpose, either for elucidat-
ing an understanding of mechanism or for a specific application or for both. In-
deed, no longer is it required to coerce, by physical manipulation, many struc-
ture/function uses out of a single composition of matter. Now, one can design a
specific polymer sequence to be near optimal for the particular application and
then use physical manipulation in the role of fine-tuning the product for its de-
signed application. This is the power of protein-based polymeric materials. Each
transformed E. coli, below, becomes the factory for producing, with extraordi-
nary fidelity, the specific designed protein-based polymer.
7.7.2
Efforts Toward Low-cost Production in other Microbes and in Plants
36 {(GVGVP)10–GVGRGYSLGIP–(GVGIP)10)}n: n = 7*
37 {(GVGIP)10–FPGVGQKRPSKRSKYLIP–(GVGIP)10)}n: n = 11*, 6*
38 {(GVGVP)10–FPGVGQKRPSKRSKYLIP–(GVGVP)10}n(GVGVP): n = 9*, 6*
39 {(GVGVP)10–FPGVGQKRPSKRSKYLIP–(GVGIP)10}n(GVGVP): n = 9*, 7*, 5*
40 GKGKAPGK–(GVGVP GVGVP GEGVP GVGVPGVGVP GVGVP}n(GVGVP): n = 1
41 {(FEGVP)10}n: n = 28*, 15*, 11, 4
42 {(GVGVP)10–GVGVPGRGDSP–(GVGVP GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP GVGFP
GFGFP)2}n(GVGVP): n = 8*, 5
43 GKGKAPGK–{(GVGVP)10–GVGVPGRGDSP–(GVGVP)10}n: n = 7*
44 (FEGFP AFGFP)5: n = 33, 29, 26, 25, 23, 19, 18, 16, 14, 11, 6
45 {(GVGVP GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP GVGFP GFGFP)2–GVGVPGRGDSP–(GVGVP)10
(GVGVAP)8}n: n = 11*, 8*, 4*, 3*
46 {(GVGVP GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP GVGFP GFGFP)2– (GVGVP)10(GVGVAP)8}n:
n = 12*, 8*, 4*
47 {(GVGIP)11–GYGIP–(GVGIP)10}2(GVGIP):Rea): n = 11*, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6*, 5
48 {(FVGEP FVGFP)5}n: n = 18, 17, 12, 2, 1
49 (GIGVP GAGVP GIGVP GIGVP GAGVP GIGVP)n: n =22*, 11*
50 {(GVGIP)11–GYGIP}n(GVGIP):Rea): n = 18*, 17, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11*, 6, 3
51 {(GVGVP)10}n(GVGVP): Rea): n = 28, 26, 18, 17*, 16, 15, 14,13*, 12, 11, 6, 4
52 {(GVGIP)10}n(GVGVP): Rea): n = 32*, 25*, 21*, 15*, 9*, 6*, 4*, 2*
53 [{(GVGIP GEGIP GVGIP)2}2]n: n = 20*, 9*
54 [{GVGIP GEGIP (GVGIP)4}2]n: n = 23*, 10*
55 [(GVGIP GEGIP GVGIP GEGIP GVGIP GVGIP)2]n: n = 26*, 17*, 15*
56 [{(GVGIP GKGIP GVGIP)2}2]n: n = 19, 18, 17, 12
57 [{GVGIP GKGIP (GVGIP)4}2]n: n = 21*, 12*
58 [(GVGIP GKGIP GVGIP GKGIP GVGIP GVGIP)2]n: n = 73, 41, 21, 17, 14, 11
59 [(GVGIP)8(GYGIP]n: n = 32*, 24*, 18*
60 [{(GVGIP)5GYGIP}2]n: n = 20*, 12*, 11*
61 [{(GVGIP)2GYGIP}3]n: n = 26, 15*, 14
62 {(GVGIP)10}n1–c)Fn3–{(GVGIP)10}n2: n1 = 16 and n2 = 6
63 {GVGVP GVGVP GEGVP GVGVP GVGVP GVGVP}n(GVGVP): n = 42*, 23*, 22*, 18*,
16*
64 AKKKKKKG–{(GVGIP)10}n–VCCC: n = 15*
65 AKKKKKKG–{(GVGIP)10}n–VCCC: n = 18*
66 GKGKAPGK–{(GGAP)12}n(GVGVP): n = 1
67 { (GGAP)12}n: n = 1
68 {(FVGVP FEGVP)5}n: n = 1
69 {[(GVGVP)2–GFGVP]3}n: n = 1
70 {(GVGIP)11–GSGIP–(GVGIP)10}n(GVGIP):Rea): n = 1
71 {(GVGIP)11–GTGIP–(GVGIP)10}n(GVGIP):Rea): n = 1
72 {(FFGEP)10}n: n = 1
73 {(GVGIP)11–GSGIP}n(GVGIP):Rea): n = 1
74 {(GVGIP)11–GTGIP}n(GVGIP):Rea): n = 1
75 {(GVGVP GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP GVGFP GFGFP)2–GVGVPGRGDSP–(GVGVP
GVGVP GKGVP GVGVP GVGFP GFGFP)2}n: n = 1
76 (GIGVP GAGVP GKGVP GIGVP GAGVP GIGVP)n: n = 1
77 (GIGVP GAGFP GKGFP GIGVP GAGVP GIGVP)n: n = 1
78 (GIGVP GAGFP GKGFP GIGVP GAGFP GVGFP)n: n = 1
7.8 Patents 245
79 {ACPGCGGVGIPCPGCG–[(GVGIP)26–b)Fn3(RGYSLG)–(GVGIP)6]
CPGCGGVGIPCPGCG}n: n = 1
7.8
Patents
7.8.1
Patents of D. W. Urry on Protein-based Polymers
7.8.2
Result of Ex Parte Patent Reexamination Request to the USPTO
Our routine utilization of GVGVP, or any of the five permutations of this se-
quence, in development of the mechanistic foundations and the applications
considered above is apparent. As noted above in Section 7.2, the efforts, specifi-
cally using GVGVP and VPGVG, date back more than three decades. Nonethe-
less, a patent issued in 1993 that claimed the use of recombinant DNA technol-
ogy to produce GVGVP and VPGVG. Once the patent appeared collaboration/li-
cense agreements between Bioelastics Research (BRL), the entity that held the
246 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
13 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Reversible Mechanochemical Engines Comprised of Bioelastomers Capable of Inter-
conversion of Chemical and Mechanical Work
USA 5,255,518 12/24/91 10/26/93
14 Inventors: D. W. Urry and M. M. Long
Title: Stimulation of Chemotaxis by Chemotactic Peptides
USA 4,976,734 09/19/87 12/11/90
Europe EP 0,366,777 06/13/88 07/20/94
15 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Bioelastomeric Materials Suitable for burn areas or the Protection from Adhesions
USA 5,250,516 04/21/88 10/05/93
Europe EP 0,365,655 09/21/94
Japan 2,820,750 04/14/89 08/28/98
16 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Elastomeric Polypeptides as Vascular Prosthetic Materials
USA 5,336,256 04/22/88 08/09/94
Europe EP 0,365,654 01/12/94
Japan 2,115,962 04/14/89 12/06/96
17 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Polynonapeptide Bioelastomers Having an Increased Elastic Modulus
USA 5,064,430 02/23/89 11/12/91
18 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Polymers Capable of Baromechanical and Barochemical Transduction
USA 5,226,292 04/22/91 07/13/93
19 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Superabsorbent Materials and Uses Thereof
USA 5,393,602 04/19/91 02/28/95
Europe EP 0,580,811 03/10/93 08/04/99
Japan 4,510,189 03/10/92 07/26/02
20 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Superabsorbent Materials and Uses Thereof
USA 5,520,672 02/06/95 05/28/96
21 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Elastomeric Polypeptide Matrices for Preventing Adhesion of Biological Materials
USA 5,527,610 05/20/94 06/18/96
Japan 05/20/95
22 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Elastomeric Polypeptide Matrices for Preventing Adhesion of Biological Materials
USA 5,519,004 06/07/95 05/21/96
23 Inventor: D. W. Urry
Title: Bioelastomeric Drug Delivery System
USA 6,328,996 B1 10/03/94 12/11/01
Europe EP 0,449,592 11/30/94
Japan 1,994,740 11/22/95
248 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
Note added in Proof: Since the completing of the manuscript for this book, I have learned,
following my resignation as General Partner of Bioeleaxtec Research Ltd. that the prosecu-
tion and maintenance of this patent portfolio did not continue.
References 249
Note added in Proof: On August 2005, just prior to receiving these page proofs quite inex-
plicably, your author has learned that the Examiner has allowed amended claims to read on
the other three permutation of the polypentapeptide, namely VGVPG, GVPGV, and PGVGV.
These should be rejected on the same basis as were GVGVP and VPGVG. For example, one
can group the pentameric repeats of figures 7.8 and 7.9 to reach as repeats of any of this five
permutations.
Acknowledgment
References
1 D. W. Urry, What Sustains Life? Consilient 8 D. W. Urry, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA,
Mechanisms for Protein-based Machines 1971, 68, 810–814.
and Materials. Springer, LLC, New York, 9 W. R. Gray, L. B. Sandberg and J. A. Fos-
2006 (in press), ISBN: 0817639101. ter, Nature, 1973, 246, 461–466.
2 J. A. V. Butler, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1937, 10 L. B. Sandberg, N. T. Soskel and J. G.
33, 229–238. Leslie, N. Engl. J. Med., 1981, 304, 561–566.
3 D. W. Urry, Chem. Phys. Letters, 2004, 11 D. W. Urry and M. M. Long, CRC Crit.
399, 177–183. Rev., Biochemistry, 1976, 4, 1–45.
4 D. W. Urry, J. Phys. Chem. B, 1997, 101, 12 D. W. Urry, K. Okamoto, R. D. Harris,
11007–11028. C. F. Hendrix and M.M. Long, Biochemis-
5 E. O. Wilson, Consilience, The Unity of try, 1976, 15, 4083–4089.
Knowledge, A. E. Knopf, New York, 1998, 13 D. W. Urry, C. M. Venkatachalam, M. M.
p. 8. Long and K. U. Prasad, In Conformation
6 D. W. Urry, B. Starcher and S. M. Par- in Biology, (R. Srinivasan and R H. Sar-
tridge, Nature, 1969, 222, 795–796. ma, Eds.) Adenine Press, USA, 1982,
7 B. A. Cox, B. C. Starcher and D. W. Urry, pp. 11–27.
Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1973, 317, 209– 14 D. W. Urry, Methods in Enzymology, 1982,
213. 82, 673–716, (L.W. Cunningham and
250 7 Protein-based Polymers: Mechanistic Foundations for Bioproduction and Engineering
253
8
New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable
Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
Ursula Biermann, Wolfgang Friedt, Siegmund Lang, Wilfried Lühs, Guido Machmüller,
Jürgen O. Metzger, Mark Rüsch gen. Klaas, Hans J. Schäfer, Manfred P. Schneider
This work is dedicated to Professor Siegfried Warwel, Münster, for his impor-
tant contributions to the development of oleochemistry.
8.1
Introduction
Sustainable development had become the key ideal of the 20th century [1]. In
the search for sustainable chemistry, considerable importance is being attached
to renewable raw materials which exploit the synthetic capabilities of nature [2,
3]. Oils and fats of vegetable and animal origin make up the greatest proportion
of the current consumption of renewable raw materials in the chemical indus-
try, since they offer to chemistry a large number of possibilities for applications
which can be rarely met by petrochemistry. The extent of the use of natural oils
and fats in chemistry was summarized in 1988 [4]. It stated that “more than
90% of oleochemical reactions have been those occurring at the fatty acid car-
boxy group, while less than 10% have involved transformations of the alkyl
chain. However, future progress will be along the lines of these latter types of
reactions with their potential for considerably extending the range of com-
pounds obtainable from oils and fats. Such progress is essential for a growth in
the use of oils and fats as renewable raw materials”. For the future, this means
that “oils and fats of vegetable and animal origin offer possibilities for providing
chemistry with a wealth of reaction products which will be of great value in the
future. The chemical possibilities of renewable oils and fats are still very far
from being fully exploited. Interdisciplinary collaboration involving chemistry,
biochemistry, plant breeding, and agriculture is necessary to extend the success-
ful applications of this technology.” A good example of this is the alkyl polygly-
cosides, the use and properties of which have been recently reviewed [5].
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
254 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
We report here the advances made in the chemistry and biotechnology of fatty
materials over the last ten years and include the improvements in natural oils
and fats by plant breeding.
8.2
Reactions of Unsaturated Fatty Compounds
By means of simple industrial reactions, fatty materials are available from vege-
table oils in such purity that they may be used for further chemical conversions
and for the synthesis of chemically pure compounds. Predominantly, oleic acid
1 a and elaidic acid (E)-1 a, petroselinic acid 2 a, erucic acid 3 a, linoleic acid 4 a,
and linolenic acid 5 a have been used in the syntheses described below
(Fig. 8.1). Ricinoleic acid 6 a carries an additional hydroxyl group which is useful
in stereo- and regioselective syntheses. By pyrolysis of 6 b and subsequent hy-
drolysis, 10-undecenoic acid 7 a, a x-unsaturated carboxylic acid, is obtained [4],
which is very useful for selective reactions. Both 9-decenoic acid 8 a and 13-tetra-
decenoic acid 9 a are accessible by the metathesis reaction of ethylene with oleic
acid 1 a and erucic acid 3 a, respectively, thus extending the range of x-unsatu-
rated fatty compounds available (Section 8.2.3). Conjuenic acid 10 a, with conju-
gated double bonds, is obtained as a regio- and stereoisomeric mixture by the
isomerization of linoleic acid 4 a [4]. The alkyne fatty compounds 11–13, with
internal or terminal triple bonds, are readily available on a laboratory scale [6].
The epoxides 14–16, the synthesis of which has been greatly improved re-
cently, are also available as reactive fatty compounds (see Section 8.2.1). Methyl
ricinoleate 6 b may be oxidized to methyl 12-oxooleate 17 which, in turn, may
be readily isomerized to the enone 18 [7]. Similarly, the allyl alcohol 19, ob-
tained by selenium oxidation of methyl 10-undecenoate 7 b (see Section 8.3.2.2),
can be dehydrogenated to the x-unsaturated enone 20 [7 b]. The fatty com-
pounds 17–20 are suitable substrates for interesting follow-up reactions.
8.2.1
Oxidations
Fig. 8.1 Starting materials for the synthesis 9,10-epoxyoctadecanoic acid 14 a, cis-9,10;cis-
of novel fatty acids: Oleic acid 1 a, elaidic 12,13-bisepoxyoctadecanoic acid 15 a, cis-
acid (E)-1 a, petroselinic acid 2 a, erucic acid 9,10;cis-12,13;cis-15,16-trisepoxyoctadecanoic
3 a, linoleic acid 4 a, linolenic acid 5 a, ricino- acid 16 a, 12-oxooleic acid 17 a, 12-oxoocta-
leic acid 6 a, 10-undecenoic acid 7 a, 9-dece- dec-10-enoic acid 18 a, 9-hydroxy-10-undece-
noic acid 8 a, 13-tetradecenoic acid 9 a, con- noic acid 19 a, 9-oxo-10-undecenoic acid
juenoic acid 10 a (regio- and stereoisomeric 20 a, and the respective methyl esters
mixture), stearoleic acid 11 a, 17-octadecy- 1 b–20 b and alcohols 1 c–20 c.
noic acid 12 a, 10-undecynoic acid 13 a, cis-
256 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
acid, such as 21, by a lipase-catalyzed reaction with H2O2 and is then self-epoxi-
dized in an essentially intermolecular reaction (Scheme 8.1) [23]. The second re-
action step occurs without involvement of the enzyme, following the rules of
the Prileshajev epoxidation.
Excellent stability and activity is shown by Novozym 435, a Candida antarctica
lipase B immobilized on polyacryl. This remarkable, readily separable, heteroge-
neous biocatalyst can be used several times without loss of activity; a turnover
of more than 200 000 moles of product per mole of catalyst has been achieved.
If vegetable oils are subjected to perhydrolysis, they are likewise epoxidized by
the peroxy fatty acid formed (Scheme 8.2) [24]. The formation of mono- and di-
glycerides can be fully suppressed by the addition of 5 mol% free fatty acid.
Soybean and other vegetable oils have been oxidized by these methods with con-
versions and selectivities of 90% and above. Even with the highly unsaturated
linseed oil, the selectivity of this reaction is maintained.
Industrially, vegetable oil epoxides are currently used mainly as PVC stabiliz-
ers. New applications have been opened by the possibility of photochemically in-
itiated cationic curing [25].
8.2.2
Transition Metal-Catalyzed Syntheses of Aromatic Compounds
8.2.3
Olefin Metathesis
8.2.4
Pericyclic Reactions
8.2.5
Radical Additions
esters 1 b and 7 b by initiation with manganese(III) acetate [52] to give the re-
spective c-lactones such as 35 (Scheme 8.12) [53–55]. Unfortunately, higher car-
boxylic acids cannot be oxidized to radicals with manganese(III) acetate and
added to alkenes [54, 55]. For this purpose, a new method was developed.
8.2.6
Lewis Acid-Induced Cationic Addition
8.2.7
Nucleophilic Addition to Reversed-Polarity Unsaturated Fatty Acids
Addition to the double bond of unsaturated fatty acids mainly occurs with electro-
philes (Section 8.2.6), radicals (Section 8.2.5), or in pericyclic reactions (Section
8.2.4). Totally new coupling possibilities arise when the polarity of the electron-
266 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
rich double bond is reversed, as in the enone fatty acids 18 and 20. In this way, a
number of nucleophiles may be coupled to the double bond by Michael additions
[78]. Interesting and novel fatty compounds have also been obtained from the en-
ones 18 and 20 in Stetter [7, 78] and Mukaiyama additions [79]. Similarly, methyl
conjuenate 10 b has been treated anodically with numerous alcohols to afford
methyl dialkoxyoctadecanoates, some of which had interesting surfactant proper-
ties [80]. Numerous carbon, oxygen, and nitrogen-based nucleophiles may be in-
serted into fatty allyl carbonates by palladium catalysis (from the corresponding
allyl alcohols; Section 8.3.2.2) in very good yields [79 b, 79 d].
8.3
Reactions of Saturated Fatty Compounds
8.3.1
Radical C–C Coupling
particularly the a-positioned C–H bond of the ester group. The fatty acid methyl
esters 49 were anionized and treated oxidatively with 0.9 equivalents CuBr2. In
this way, the dimers 50 were formed with a (d,l) : meso ratio of about 1.2 : 1
(Scheme 8.21) [81 a]. The dimethyl ester of the tetracarboxylic acid 51 was ob-
tained from 50 c by ozonolysis in 90% yield.
8.3.2
Functionalization of C–H Bonds
Selective reactions at the alkyl chain of fatty acids are still rare but are of great
interest [4].
with triphenylphosphine (Scheme 8.25) [79 b, 79 c]. In the presence of acetic an-
hydride, pyridine, and catalytic amounts of 4-dimethylaminopyridine (DMAP),
the hydroperoxide may converted directly into the regioisomeric mixture of the
enone fatty acids 18 [79 b, 79 c]. Since the photooxidation occurs even in sun-
light, unsaturated fatty acids oxidized in the allylic position are available by a
route which is particularly favorable from both an economical and an ecological
viewpoint.
8.4
Enzymatic Reactions
8.4.1
Lipase-Catalyzed Transformations
Lipases and their applications have been reviewed in this journal in 1998 [92].
We will limit ourselves therefore to a few examples of selective syntheses of
fatty compounds.
able advances have been made here in the last few years but no breakthrough
could yet be considered economic.
Glycerol, protected as the isopropylidene [93] or phenylboroester [94, 95] deri-
vatives, can be converted into pure monoglycerides 68 with interesting surfac-
tant properties in the presence of a lipase from Rhizomucor miehei (lipozyme)
and free fatty acids as acyl donors (Scheme 8.26).
If glycerol is immobilized on silica gel, the esterification runs surprisingly
smoothly in aprotic solvents such as n-hexane or tert-butylmethyl ether in the
presence of different lipases and acyl donors (free fatty acids, fatty acid methyl
esters, vinyl esters, triglycerides, and so forth) [96–98]. Thus, for example, iso-
merically pure (> 98%) 1,3-sn-dilaurin 70 is readily obtained with vinyl laurate
69 in the presence of a “1,3-selective” lipase (Scheme 8.27) [96, 99]. Because of
their ready accessibility, up to the kilogram scale, and their high purity and sta-
bility, these 1,3-sn-diglycerides represent interesting building blocks for further
surfactant compounds (for example, by coupling with amino acids) and for the
preparation of reagents for lipid modification of natural products [100].
If the 1(3)-sn-monoglycerides 68 are prepared by this method, they must be
selectively separated from the reaction mixture, since they are very readily esteri-
fied by the lipases to 1,3-sn-diglycerides. This separation is achieved by exploit-
ing the poor solubility of the monoglycerides 68 at low temperatures in appro-
priate solvent mixtures [97, 98]. The method has proved to be exceptionally suit-
able for the conversion of natural fats and oils from palm kernels, coconuts,
soybeans, sunflowers, and rapeseeds into the respective monoglyceride mix-
tures. Such highest-quality products are particularly well suited for uses in the
cosmetic and pharmaceutical industries.
8.4.2
Microbial Transformations
8.4.3
Microbial Conversion of Oils/Fats and Glucose into Glycolipids
The broad structural palette of biosurfactants, along with their numerous appli-
cations and biosynthetic pathways, were comprehensively reviewed by Kosaric
[116], Ratledge [117], Desai and Banat [118], Banat [119], and Lang and Wagner
[120]. Of particular interest, because of the remarkably high yield, 300–400 g L–
1
, is the sophorose lipid formation with Candida bombolica from glucose and ra-
peseed oil as substrates [121, 122]. Moreover, natural oils, fatty acid methyl es-
ters, and free fatty acids have been converted into glycolipids in the presence of
Ustilago maydis DSM 4500. In comparison with natural oils, the use of free fatty
acids has brought about an increase in yield to 30 g L–1 glycolipid containing 90
wt% of mannosyl erythritolipids [123].
8.5 Improvement in Natural Oils and Fats by Plant Breeding 275
8.5
Improvement in Natural Oils and Fats by Plant Breeding
8.5.1
Gene Technology as an Extension of the Methodological Repertoire
of Plant Breeding
Concurrent with the increasing demand for renewable raw materials, modern
biotechniques, including gene technology, have made enormous steps in extend-
ing the methodological repertoire of plant breeding, so that today’s breeding
procedures are even more efficient and selective. Although classical plant breed-
ing, when combined with experimental mutagenesis (“mutation breeding”) and
modern in vitro cell- and tissue-culture methods, has frequently proved to be
successful in oil plants such as, for example, soybean, rapeseed, sunflower, or
linseed [125, 126], gene technology offers an additional, universal approach for
changing the amount and composition of the stored oil [127, 128].
This development was recently made possible by a series of methodological
improvements. This is illustrated by continued progress both in natural vector-
transformation systems based upon natural infection by the soil-borne bacteri-
um Agrobacterium tumefaciens (or A. rhizogenes) and in a series of vector-free
transformation systems where, for example, the foreign recombinant gene is in-
tegrated into cells lacking a cell wall (protoplasts) or by bombardment of regen-
erable meristems with DNA-loaded particles [129, 130]. In molecular-biological
experiment, the necessary regulatory “gene switches” (promoters) as expression
signals are normally combined (cloned) with structural parts of previously iso-
lated genes (structural genes) to form a new functional unit, a chimeric gene
[131]. Moreover, selection markers, namely, genes which confer antibiotic or her-
bicide resistance and thus permit a selection of successfully transformed plant
cells, are also frequently inserted [129].
A widely used method for the genetic modification of useful plants, which
are used particularly for the prevention of the undesired expression of species-
specific genes, is the “antisense RNA” approach. Although the mode of action
276 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
in transgenic plants is not yet fully understood, the simplest explanation is that
the species-specific sense RNA binds to the transferred, complementary anti-
sense RNA and, thus, the translation and biosynthesis of the relevant protein is
inhibited. The resulting double-stranded RNA hybrid appears to be degraded
very rapidly by nucleic-acid digesting enzymes (the nucleases, in this case
RNAse H) [132]. The extent of the gene expression achieved is dependent to a
significant extent upon the transcriptionally active promoter used. Thus, in the
preparation of the gene constructs that are to be transferred, bacterial or viral
promoters are frequently used. Meanwhile, however, a series of seed-specific
promoter sequences such as those of napin, phaseolin, or oleosin genes have
also been successfully used [131, 133]. Since at present, almost exclusive reli-
ance is placed upon cell cultures or embryonic tissue in vitro for genetic trans-
formation, further improvements are also indispensable for the regeneration to
intact, transgenic plants; this has also been achieved [129].
8.5.2
New Oil Qualities by Oil Designed with Available Agricultural Varieties
implant a specific and desired quality property from distantly related plant species,
from microorganisms (such as bacterial or yeasts), or even from mammals with-
out detrimental effects to the genetic background or yield capabilities of the pro-
ductive species. Numerous genes (cDNA clones) exist for the biosynthesis of un-
usual fatty acids such as ricinoleic, petroselinic, linoleic, vernolic, or crepenynic
acids, which may be cloned and transformed in cultivated plants. With the help
of this material, it should become more possible to optimize genotypes (such as
species) for the production of oleochemical raw materials [127, 137–139].
8.5.3
Overview of Renewable Raw Materials Optimized by Breeding
8.5.3.1 Soybean
As a result of intensive quality breeding, the fatty acid pattern of the soya bean
is remarkably variable. In addition to the low linolenic acid varieties, which
should contribute considerably to the improvement in oxidative stability (mainly
in the food oil area), there are further varieties with modified proportions of in-
dividual saturated fatty acids (Table 8.2) [144–146]. “High oleic” (HO) soybeans
have been produced by routes based on genetic engineering. It has been esti-
mated that 40 000 ha of this variety was planted in the USA in 1998 [138, 147].
8.5.3.2 Rapeseed
For a number of reasons, the intensive, ongoing work inducing alterations in
the oil quality of cultivated plants is currently concentrated on rapeseed (B. na-
pus). Since both summer and winter forms of this species are available, they
can be planted as oil plant in climatically different regions of the world. A
further advantage of rapeseed over other cultivated species is in its accessibility
to biotechnological methods and, in particular, in its capability for transforma-
tion and regeneration [141, 148].
278
Table 8.1 Commercially available fatty acid variants of important oil seeds.
a) 12 : 0 = lauric acid, 14 : 0 = myristic acid, 16 : 0 = palmitic acid, 18 : 0 = stearic acid 60, 18 : 1 = oleic acid 1 a, 18 : 2 = linoleic acid 4 a,
18 : 3 = linolenic acid 5 a, 20 : 1 = eicosenoic acid, 22 : 1 = erucic acid 3 a.
8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
Table 8.2 Extreme fatty acid variants in breeding material from important oil seeds.
soybean low linolenic acid mutagenesis – 10.5 4.6 23.2 59.6 2.0 – – – [144]
low palmitic acid mutagenesis – 3.7 3.7 24.1 58.9 8.9 – – 0.7 [145]
high palmitic acid mutagenesis – 17.3 2.9 16.8 54.5 8.3 – – 0.2 [146]
high stearic acid mutagenesis – 8.4 28.1 19.8 35.5 6.6 – – 1.6 [146]
high oleic acid gene technology – 6.6 3.6 84.9 0.6 1.9 – – 2.4 [147]
(HO)
rapeseed high myristic acid gene technology 17.7 23.1 2.4 33.7 14.8 3.8 – – 4.5 [155]
high stearin gene technology – 4 29 15 19 22 1 – 10 b) [153]
high oleic acid mutagenesis – 4.2 2.2 80.2 4.5 5.2 1.8 – 1.9 [151]
(HO)
high oleic acid gene technology – 4.3 1.4 84.1 5.2 2.9 0.9 – 1.2 [133]
(HO)
low linolen gene technology – 3.8 1.5 68.5 22.1 1.2 1.1 – 1.8 [133]
sunflower high palmitin mutagenesis – 25.2 3.5 11.4 55.1 – – – 4.8 c) [158]
high stearin mutagenesis – 5.1 26.0 13.8 55.1 – – – – [158]
high oleic acid com- mutagenesis – 3.2 2.4 92.1 2.3 – – – – [144]
bined with low satu-
rated fatty acids
linseed high palmitin mutagenesis – 27.8 1.8 17.5 6.0 42.0 – – 4.8 d) [164]
a) 14 : 0 = myristic acid, 16 : 0 = palmitic acid, 18 : 0 = stearic acid 60, 18 : 1 = oleic acid 1 a, 18 : 2 = linoleic acid 4 a, 18 : 3 = linolenic acid
5 a, 20 : 1 = eicosenoic acid, 22 : 1 = erucic acid 3 a;
b) includes 6% arachidic acid (20 : 0), 2% behenic acid (22 : 0), 1% lignoceric acid (24 : 0);
c) includes 3.7% palmitoleic acid (16 : 1);
d) palmitoleic acid (16 : 1).
8.5 Improvement in Natural Oils and Fats by Plant Breeding
279
280 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
Rapeseed oil is very rich in erucic acid (3 a), a widely sought raw material for
many nonfood uses [149, 150]. In the context of improvement in nutritional oil
quality, the low erucic acid varieties – named zero and double zero or canola
types, which exhibit about 60% oleic acid (1 a) – were developed by classical
breeding methods. The breeding of linolenic acid deficient (< 3% 5 a) or high
oleic acid (> 80% 1 a) rapeseed forms has been achieved both by induced muta-
tion [151, 152] and genetically by inhibition of the inherent 12- or 15-desaturase
genes [133] (Table 8.2). Anti-sense inhibition of the desaturation step in Brassica
rapa (a close relative of B. napus) yields up to 40% stearic acid 60 in the seed oil
and has been already tested under field conditions [153]. In approaches which
promise success, special fatty acid variants, which previously could not be real-
ized in rapeseed, have been developed by gene technology. In this way, success
was obtained in establishing the synthesis of short- and medium-chain saturat-
ed fatty acids (chain lengths of 8–14 carbon atoms), which are of special interest
for oleochemistry and which could only be obtained previously from imported
tropical fats (coconut, palm kernels) [154, 155]. Most advanced is the develop-
ment of “high lauric acid rapeseed” with about 40–50% lauric acid by Calgene
(CA, USA), which depends on the transfer of a thioesterase gene from the Cali-
fornian bay (Umbellularia californica) and which has been already commercially
planted [141, 154].
There is a constant demand for high erucic acid rapeseed oil for industrial
use. Here, breeding is devoted to increasing the fraction of this very long chain
fatty acid well above the current maximum of 55–60% 3 a. It has been known
for a long time that, because of the nonoccupation of the middle of the three
triacylglycerol positions by erucic acid 3 a, a (theoretical) maximum of 67% can-
not be exceeded [149]. However, partial success was achieved recently when
transgenic rape forms were developed with varying contents of trierucin (trieru-
coylglycerol) in the seed oil by transfer of the gene for sn-2-acyltransferase (lyso-
phosphatidic acid acyltransferase, LPAAT) from different Limnanthes species
(meadowfoam) and by inhibition of the inherent LPAAT of rapeseed [141, 156].
8.5.3.3 Sunflower
In addition to the conventional sunflower oils, which exhibit a high content of
linoleic acid (4 a), HO types were developed experimentally some time ago by
mutagenesis [126, 157]. Furthermore, forms with increased proportions of satu-
rated fatty acids, which could provide advantages for margarine production (Ta-
ble 8.2), have been produced by mutagenic treatment [158]. However, the indus-
trial use of HO sunflower oil requires that the content of saturated fatty acids
should be as low as possible. Breeding has already reduced the content of stea-
ric acid 60 to 1.5%, which adversely affects the solidification temperature and
the cloud point. Under favorable climatic and cultivation conditions, a stable
proportion of 90% 1 a with a concurrently reduced content of stearic acid 60
could be achieved from current HO sunflower lines or hybrids developed in this
way [144]. In contrast for nonfood purposes in Germany, economic reasons de-
8.5 Improvement in Natural Oils and Fats by Plant Breeding 281
mand at least 83% oleic acid 1 a in the product in order to avoid additional
purification steps and thus increase the advantage to this production, against 1 a
derived from the competing raw material, beef tallow [159].
8.5.3.4 Peanut
In the case of the peanut, an HO mutant (breeding line F435 from the Univer-
sity of Florida) was found in the available varieties which was then used to
breed varieties which provide an oil with high oxidative stability [142, 160].
8.5.3.5 Linseed
If the possibilities for the use of linseed oil in the nonfood areas are considered, its
main uses are in the production of dyes, coatings, and linoleum [135]. On the
other hand, in the oleochemical area, the high reactivity of the polyene structure
of linseed fatty acids results in a pronounced sensitivity towards autoxidation of
products based on linseed oil as well as complex reaction pathways which lead
to poorly defined products [161]. From this point of view, breeding efforts are
being made to improve the variability of linseed oil in respect of its fatty acid
and triglyceride composition in order to provide new, specific oil qualities [162].
Here too, the classical approach of mutagenesis has also been used to breed
new linseed varieties with a linolenic acid 5 a content of less than 5% (linola qual-
ity) [143, 163] or with an increased palmitic acid content in the oil [164].
8.5.4
Concluding Remarks on the Use of Gene Technology
The preceding presentation clearly illustrates that gene technology is a very suit-
able breeding instrument in order to induce new genetic variation. In the ideal
situation, it allows the breeder to introduce totally new qualities into cultivated
plant varieties with greater precision without impairing the performance cap-
abilities of the respective genotype. There are certain barriers to the realization
and use of gene technology because of the poor acceptance by some end users;
this applies especially to the nutritional and feed area (novel food, novel feed).
However, since the novel products do not enter the human food chain directly,
it is not surprising that the initial applications of modern bio- and gene technol-
ogy methods are found in the technical and chemical area, where they provide
vegetable raw materials of improved quality and yield. In this way, important
but limited raw material resources can be saved for future generations. To what
extent these “new” plant types achieve practical relevance depends on economic
factors. Thus, from the viewpoint of industry, demand will only be generated if
new raw materials of vegetable origin are available in sufficient quantities at
competitive prices, economically viable isolation of the relevant components is
possible, and they are held in a higher esteem and preference to alternatives
which come, for example, from the petrochemical industry.
282 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
8.6
Future Prospects
After years of relative stagnation, the synthesis of novel fatty compounds based
on oils and fats has made important advances. With the breeding of new oil
plants – including the use of gene technology – numerous fatty compounds of
adequate purity are now available which makes them attractive for synthesis.
The use of modern synthetic methods together with enzymatic and microbiolog-
ical methods has lead to an extraordinary expansion in the potential for the syn-
thesis of novel fatty compounds, which are selectively modified in the alkyl
chain. These are now being investigated for their action, properties, and possi-
bilities for new applications.
However, numerous synthetic problems remain unsolved and solutions must
be found in the coming years. Chemists, biotechnologists, and plant breeders
are all challenged to continue development of the advances made in recent
years in an integrated, interdisciplinary approach and thus prepare the way for
oils and fats to be increasingly used as renewable raw materials in the chemical
industry.
Acknowledgments
References
299; e) U. Biermann, W. Friedt, S. Lang, 1709; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 1991,
W. Lühs, G. Machmüller, J. O. Metzger, 30, 1638–1641.
M. Rüsch, gen. Klass, H. J. Schäfer, M. P. 16 M. Gerle, PhD thesis, RWTH Aachen
Schneider, Angew. Chem., 2000, 112, (Germany), 1997.
2292–2310; Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2000, 17 W. A. Herrmann, J. D. G. Correia, F. E.
39, 2206–2224; f) J. O. Metzger, R. Mah- Kühn, G. R. J. Artus, C. C. Romao, Chem.
ler, G. Francke, A. Hayen, “Synthesis of Eur. J. 1996, 2, 168–173.
New Oleochemicals: Functionalization of 18 R. Landau, G. A. Sullivan, D. Brown,
Fatty Compounds Using Radical Reac- CHEMTECH 1979, 602–607.
tions”, Recent Developments in the Synthe- 19 P. J. Martinez de la Cuesta, E. Martinez,
sis of Fatty Acid Derivatives L. M. Cotoluero Minguez, Grasas Aceites
(G. Knothe, J. T. P. Derksen), OCS Press, (Seville) 1985, 36, 181–185, and refer-
1999, ISBN 1-893997-00-6, 90–99; ences therein.
g) U. Biermann, J. O. Metzger, “Synthe- 20 A. Debal, G. Rafaralahitsimba, E. Uccia-
sis of New Oleochemicals: Products of ni, Fat Sci. Technol. 1993, 95, 236–239.
Friedel-Crafts Reactions of Unsaturated 21 a) F. Björkling, S. E. Godtfredsen, O.
Fatty Compounds”, Recent Developments Kirk, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun.
in the Synthesis of Fatty Acid Derivatives 1990, 1302–1303; b) F. Björkling, H.
(G. Knothe, J. T. P. Derksen), AOCS Frykman, S. E. Godtfredsen, O. Kirk, Tet-
Press, 1999, ISBN 1-893997-00-6, 80–89. rahedron 1992, 48, 4587–4592; c) O. Kirk,
5 W. von Rybinski, K. Hill, Angew. Chem. F. Björkling, T. Damhus, S. E. Godtfred-
1998, 110, 1394–1412; Angew. Chem. Int. sen, Biocatalysis 1994, 11, 65–77.
Ed. 1998, 37, 1328–1345. 22 M. Rüsch gen. Klaas, S. Warwel, J. Mol.
6 K. E. Augustin, H. J. Schäfer, Liebigs Ann. Catal. A 1997, 117, 311–319.
Chem. 1991, 1037–1040. 23 S. Warwel, M. Rüsch gen. Klaas, J. Mol.
7 a) L. Hinkamp, PhD thesis, Universität Catal. B 1995, 1, 29–35.
Münster (Germany), 1993; b) H. J. Schä- 24 a) M. Rüsch gen. Klaas, S. Warwel, J.
fer, M. aus dem Kahmen, L. Hinkamp, Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1996, 73, 1453–1457;
R. Maletz in 3. Symposium Nachwach- b) M. Rüsch gen. Klaas, S. Warwel, Ind.
sende Rohstoffe, Perspektiven für die Che- Crops Prod. 1999, 9, 125–132.
mie (Ed.: Bundesministerium für Ernäh- 25 J. V. Crivello, R. Narayan, Chem. Mater.
rung, Landwirtschaft und Forsten), Land- 1992, 4, 692–699.
wirtschaftsverlag, Münster, 1994, pp. 26 M. S. F. Lie Ken Jie, M. S. K. Syed-Rahma-
217–234. tullah, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1992, 69,
8 M. C. Kuo, C. T. Chou, Ind. Eng. Chem. 359–362.
Res. 1987, 26, 277–284. 27 a) J. O. Metzger, S. Fürmeier, Eur. J. Org.
9 W. Adam, J. Bialas, L. Hadjiarapoglou, Chem. 1999, 661–664; b) S. Fürmeier,
Chem. Ber. 1991, 124, 2377. J. O. Metzger, Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2003,
10 P. E. Sonnet, M. E. Lankin, G. P. Lankin, 649–659.
J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1995, 72, 199–204. 28 M. S. F. Lie Ken Jie, Y. F. Zheng, Chem.
11 M. S. F. Lie Ken Jie, M. K. Pasha, Lipids Phys. Lipids 1988, 49, 167–178. For
1998, 33, 633–637. further heterocyclic fatty compounds see:
12 Y. Ishii, K. Yamawaki, T. Ura, H. Yama- a) S. Fürmeier, J. O. Metzger, Eur. J. Org.
da, T. Yoshida, M. Ogawa, J. Org. Chem. Chem. 2003, 885–893; b) S. Fürmeier,
1988, 53, 3587–3593. M. M. L. Lau, M. S. F. Lie Ken Jie, A. Lüt-
13 P. Bavaj, PhD thesis, RWTH Aachen zen; c) J. O. Metzger, Eur. J. Org. Chem.
(Germany), 1995. 2003, 4874–4878.
14 W. A. Herrmann, R. W. Fischer, M. U. 29 B. Dahlke, S. Hellbardt, M. Paetow,
Rauch, W. Scherer, J. Mol. Catal. 1994, W. H. Zech, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1995,
86, 245–266. 72, 349–353.
15 W. A. Herrmann, R. W. Fischer, D. W. 30 “Stets geforscht . . .Chemieforschung im
Matz, Angew. Chem. 1991, 103, 1706– Degussa-Forschungszentrum Wolfgang”:
M. Dankowski, G. Goor, G. Prescher,
284 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
112 a) D. Fabritius, Diploma thesis, Univer- C. Syldatk, Biotechnol. Lett. 1998, 20,
sität Münster (Germany), 1993; b) D. 1153–1156; e) U. Rau, S. Hammen, R.
Fabritius, PhD thesis, Universität Heckmann, V. Wray, S. Lang, Ind.
Münster (Germany), 1996. Crops Products 1999, in press; f) Y. Hu,
113 a) J. Schindler, F. Meussdorfer, H. G. L. K. Ju, Enzyme Microbial Technol.
Bühler, Forum-Biotechnol. 1990, 274– 2001, 29, 593–601; g) V. Guilmanov, A.
281; b) N. Uemura, A. Taoka, M. Taka- Ballistreri, G. Impallomeni, R. A.
gi, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1988, 65, Gross, Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2002, 77,
148–152. 489–494; h) D. A. Cavalero, D. G. Coop-
114 D. Fabritius, H. J. Schäfer, A. Steinbü- er, J. Biotechnol. 2003, 103, 31–41.
chel, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 1996, 123 S. Lang, U. Rau, D. Rasch, S. Spöck-
45, 432–438. ner, E. Vollbrecht in Biokonversion nach-
115 a) D. Fabritius, H. J. Schäfer, A. Stein- wachsender Rohstoffe (Ed.: Fachagentur
büchel, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. Nachwachsende Rohstoffe), Land-
1996, 45, 432–438; b) D. Fabritius, H. J. wirtschaftsverlag, Münster, 1998, pp.
Schäfer, A. Steinbüchel, Appl. Microbiol. 154–164.
Biotechnol. 1998, 50, 573–578; 124 a) T. Voelker, A. J. Kinney, Annu. Rev.
c) D. Fabritius, H. J. Schäfer, Schriften- Plant Physiol. Plant Mol. Biol. 2001, 52,
reihe „Nachwachsende Rohstoffe Bd. 12“, 335–361; b) H. Drexler, P. Spieker-
Chemische Nutzung heimischer Pflan- mann, A. Meyer, F. Domergue, T.
zenöle – Abschlusskolloquium des Zank, P. Sperling, A. Abbadi, E. Heinz,
BML, Landwirtschaftsverlag Münster, J. Plant Physiol. 2003, 160, 779–802.
1998, p. 111–140. 125 A. Thierfelder, W. Lühs, W. Friedt, Ind.
116 N. Kosaric in Biotechnology, Vol. 6 Crops Prod. 1993, 1, 261–271.
(Eds.: H. J. Rehm, G. Reed, A. Pühler, 126 W. Lühs, W. Friedt in Designer Oil
P. Stadler), VCH, Weinheim, 1996, pp. Crops (Ed.: D. J. Murphy), VCH, Wein-
659–717. heim, 1994, pp. 5–71.
117 C. Ratledge in Biotechnology, Vol. 7 127 D. J. Murphy, Lipid Technol. 1994, 6(4),
(Eds.: H. J. Rehm, G. Reed, A. Pühler, 84–91.
P. Stadler), VCH, Weinheim, 1997, pp. 128 a) R. Töpfer, M. Martini, J. Schell,
133–197. Science 1995, 268, 681–686;
118 J. D. Desai, I. M. Banat, Microbiol. Mol. b) W. Friedt, W. Lühs in Perspektiven
Biol. Rev. 1997, 61, 47–64. nachwachsender Rohstoffe in der Chemie
119 I. M. Banat, Acta Biotechnol. 1995, 15, (Ed.: H. Eierdanz), VCH, Weinheim,
251–267. 1996, pp. 11–20; c) S. Weber, M. K.
120 a) S. Lang, F. Wagner, Fat Sci. Technol. Zarhloul, W. Friedt, Progress in Botany
1995, 97, 69–77; b) S. Lang, Curr. Opin. 2000, 62, 140–174; d) W. Friedt, W.
Colloid Interface Sci. 2002, 7, 12–20; c) Lühs in 7. Symp. Nachwachsende Roh-
S. Lang, In Novel Surfactants (Ed.: K. stoffe für die Chemie, Landwirtschafts-
Holmberg), Marcel Dekker, Inc., New verlag Münster, 2001, Schriftenreihe
York, Basel, 2003, pp. 279–315. Nachwachsende Rohstoffe, Bd. 18,
121 A. Albrecht, U. Rau, F. Wagner, Appl. S. 45–75; e) W. Lühs, M. K. Zarhloul,
Microbiol. Biotechnol. 1996, 46, 67–73. S. Weber, W. Friedt in 7. Symp. Nach-
122 a) A.-M. Davila, R. Marchal, J.-P. Van- wachsende Rohstoffe für die Chemie,
decasteele, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. Landwirtschaftsverlag, Münster, 2001,
1992, 38, 6–11; b) Q. H. Zhou, N. Kosa- Schriftenreihe Nachwachsende Roh-
ric, J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1995, 72, 67– stoffe, Bd. 18, S. 750–762; f) W. Friedt,
71; c) L. Fischer, A. Boger, S. Lang, C. W. Lühs, Biol. Unserer Zeit 1999, 29,
Manzke, S.-H. Park, U. Rau, A. Schlot- 142–150.
terbeck, F. Wagner in Perspektiven nach- 129 a) M. De Block, Euphytica 1993, 71,
wachsender Rohstoffe der Chemie (Ed.: 1–14; b) H. J. Fisk, A. M. Dandekar,
H. Eierdanz), VCH, Weinheim, 1996, Sci. Horti. (Amsterdam) 1993, 55,
pp. 250–254; d) H.-J. Daniel, M. Reuss, 5–36.
288 8 New Syntheses with Oils and Fats as Renewable Raw Materials for the Chemical Industry
CAB International, Wallingford, 1995, 157 a) K. I. Soldatov in Proc. 7th Int. Sun-
pp. 339–352; c) K. Coupland, K. B. T. flower Conf., Krasnodar, USSR, Intern.
Hatton in Synthesis in Lipid Chemistry Sunflower Assoc., 1976, pp. 352–357;
(Ed.: J. H. P. Tyman), The Royal Society b) W. Lühs, K. J. Dehmer, R. Berg-
of Chemistry, Cambridge, 1996, pp. mann, W. Friedt in Perspektiven nach-
57–66. wachsender Rohstoffe in der Chemie (Ed.:
151 D. L. Auld, M. K. Heikkinen, D. A. H. Eierdanz), VCH, Weinheim, 1996,
Erickson, J. L. Sernyk, J. E. Romero, pp. 232–238; c) J. M. Martínez-Rivas,
Crop Sci. 1992, 32, 657–662. P. Sperling, W. Lühs, E. Heinz, Mol.
152 B. Rücker, G. Röbbelen in Rapeseed To- Breed. 2001, 8, 159–168.
day and Tomorrow, Vol. 2, Dorset Press, 158 J. Osorio, J. Fernández-Martínez, M.
Dorchester, 1995, pp. 389–391 (Proc. Mancha, R. Garés, Crop Sci. 1995, 35,
9th Int. Rapeseed Congr. (GCIRC)). 739–742.
153 D. S. Knutzon, G. A. Thompson, S. E. 159 a) W. Lühs, W. Friedt, Anbauempfehlun-
Radke, W. B. Johnson, V. C. Knauf, J. C. gen für hochölsäurehaltige Sonnenblumen
Kridl, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1992, (HO-Sonnenblumen) in Deutschland,
89, 2624–2628. 3rd ed., Universität Giessen (Ger-
154 a) T. A. Voelker, A. C. Worrell, L. Ander- many), 1998; b) W. Lühs, W. Friedt in
son, J. Bleibaum, C. Fan, D. J. Haw- Proc. 6th Symp. Renewable Resources
kins, S. E. Radke, H. M. Davies, Science and 4th Eur. Symp. on Ind. Crops Prod.
1992, 257, 72–74; b) A. J. Del Vecchio, (Ed.: Fachagentur Nachwachsende Roh-
INFORM 1996, 7, 230–243; c) D. S. stoffe), Landwirtschaftsverlag Münster,
Knutzon, T. R. Hayes, A. Wyrick, H. 1999, pp. 401–406.
Xiong, H. M. Davies, T. A. Voelker, 160 a) A. J. Norden, D. W. Gorbet, D. A.
Plant Physiol. 1999, 120, 739–746. Knauft, C. T. Young, Peanut Sci. 1987,
155 C. Stoll, W. Lühs, M. K. Zarhloul, W. 14, 7–11; b) T. G. Isleib, C. T. Young,
Friedt, Eur. J. Lipid Sci. Technol. 2005, D. A. Knauft, Crop Sci. 1996, 36, 556–
107, 244–248. 558.
156 a) D. Weier, C. Hanke, A. Eickelkamp, 161 R. Höfer, W. Knörr, A. Westfechtel in
W. Lühs, J. Dettendorfer, E. Schaffert, 3. Symposium Nachwachsende Rohstoffe,
C. Möllers, W. Friedt, F. P. Wolter, M. Perspektiven für die Chemie (Ed.: Bun-
Frentzen, Fett/Lipid 1997, 99, 160–165; desministerium für Ernährung, Land-
b) M. Frentzen, Fett/Lipid 1998, 100, wirtschaft und Forsten), Land-
161–166; c) A. Gräfin zu Münster, W. wirtschaftsverlag, Münster, 1994, pp.
Lühs, D. S. Borchardt, F. P. Wolter, M. 235–256.
Frentzen in Advances in Plant Lipid Re- 162 a) C. Bickert, W. Lühs, W. Friedt, Ind.
search (Eds.: J. Sánchez, E. Cerdá-Ol- Crops Prod. 1994, 2, 229–237; C. Bick-
medo, E. Martinez-Force), Secretariado ert, W. Lühs, W. Friedt, Ind. Crops Prod.
de Publicaciones de la Universidad de 1994, 2, 317; b) R. Steiss, A. Schuster,
Sevilla (Spain), 1998, pp. 671–674; W. Friedt, Ind. Crops Prod. 1998, 7,
d) W. Lühs, A. Voss, J. Han, A. Gräfin 303–309.
zu Münster, D. Weier, F. P. Wolter, 163 a) A. G. Green, Can. J. Plant Sci. 1986,
M. Frentzen, W. Friedt in Genetics and 66, 499–503; b) A. G. Green, Theor.
Breeding for Crop Quality and Resistance Appl. Genet. 1986, 72, 654–661; c) G. G.
(Eds.: G. T. S. Mugnozza, E. Porceddu, Rowland, Can. J. Plant Sci. 1991, 71,
M. A. Pagnotta), Kluwer, Dordrecht, 393–396.
1999, pp. 323–330; e) J. Han, W. Lühs, 164 C. Ntiamoah, G. G. Rowland, D. C. Tay-
K. Sonntag, U. Zähringer, D. S. Bor- lor, Crop Sci. 1995, 35, 148–152.
chardt, F. P. Wolter, E. Heinz, M. Frent-
zen, Plant Mol. Biol. 2001, 46, 229–239.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
291
9
Industrial Development and Application
of Biobased Oleochemicals
Karlheinz Hill
9.1
Introduction
Vegetable oils and fats are important constituents of human and animal food-
stuffs. Some grades are used industrially and, together with carbohydrates and
proteins, are numbered among renewable resources compared with fossil and
mineral raw materials, whose occurrence is limited and finite. For new products
price, performance, and product safety are equally important criteria and have a
correspondingly high importance at the start of product development. To ensure
high product safety for consumers and the environment renewable resources
have often been shown to have advantages compared with petrochemical raw
materials and can, therefore, be regarded as being the ideal raw material. Re-
sults from oleochemistry show that the use of vegetable fats and oils enables
the development of competitive, powerful products which are both consumer-
friendly and environmentally-friendly. Products from recent developments fit
this requirement profile.
In polymer applications derivatives of oils and fats, for example epoxides,
polyols, and dimerization products based on unsaturated fatty acids, are used as
plastic additives or components for composites or for polymers such as poly-
amides and polyurethanes. In the lubricant sector oleochemically-based fatty
acid esters have proved to be powerful alternatives to conventional mineral oil
products. For home and personal care applications a wide range of products, for
example surfactants, emulsifiers, emollients, and waxes based on vegetable oil
derivatives has proved to provide extraordinary performance benefits to the end-
customer. Selected products, for example the anionic surfactant fatty alcohol sul-
fate, have been investigated thoroughly with regard to their environmental im-
pact compared with petrochemical based products, by life-cycle-analysis. Other
product examples include carbohydrate-based surfactants and oleochemical
based emulsifiers, waxes, and emollients.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
292 9 Industrial Development and Application of Biobased Oleochemicals
9.2
The Raw Materials [1–3]
The sources of oils and fats are a variety of vegetable and animal raw materials
(e.g. tallow, lard), with the vegetable raw materials soybean, palm, rapeseed, and
sunflower oil being the most important in terms of the amounts involved
(Fig. 9.1). Of approximately 125 million tonnes of fats and oils produced world-
wide in 2003, by far the largest share was used in human foodstuffs. For oleo-
chemistry 17.4 million tonnes were available. The composition of the fatty acids
contained in the oil (fatty acid spectrum) determines the further use of the oils.
Special attention must be given to coconut oil and palm kernel oil (lauric oils)
because they contain a high proportion of fatty acids of short or medium chain
length (mainly 12 and 14 carbon atoms – C12, C14). For example, these are par-
ticularly suitable for further processing to surfactants, for washing and cleans-
ing agents, and to cosmetics. Palm, soybean, rapeseed, and sunflower, and ani-
mal fats such as tallow contain mainly long-chain fatty acids (C18, saturated and
unsaturated) and are used as raw materials for polymer applications, surfac-
tants, and lubricants. Figure 9.2 shows the composition of a typical lauric oil
(coconut oil) compared with that of sunflower oil.
Fats and oils are available in large amounts. In recent years the amounts pro-
duced have increased continuously by approximately 3% per year. Price develop-
ment – similar to crude oil – has not been constant, but has sometimes under-
gone drastic changes. In parallel with the price increases in crude oil in the
seventies caused by shortage of supply (oil crisis), price jumps in the fats and
oils sector have also occurred; this has been particularly noticeable for coconut
oil which in those days was the most important source of short-chain fatty
acids. In this market palm kernel oil, a second source of short-chain fatty acids,
Fig. 9.1 World production of oils and fats in 2003 (in million
tonnes) and main uses (source: Oil World).
9.3 Ecological Compatibility 293
has had a stabilizing effect on raw material availability and price. In the medi-
um and long term it must be assumed that fats and oils will be offered at com-
petitive prices. The increasing demand will be met by the amounts produced,
which are also increasing [3, 4].
9.3
Ecological Compatibility
On the basis of on results from cycle analyses (see Chapter 9.4.3.1) and selected
ecological and toxicological studies one can assume that products based on
renewable resources are usually more ecologically compatible than petrochem-
ical-based substances – an important criterion in the development of a new
product, just as price and performance are [5]. This general assumption must
be proven for each new product, however, so ecological compatibility plays a de-
cisive role in all research and development projects. Basically, it covers two dif-
ferent aspects – remaining in the environment and the effects on the environ-
ment (Table 9.1). A variety of criteria are used to evaluate these two aspects. By
exposure analysis the expected environmental concentration of a particular sub-
stance (in wastewater, in exhaust gases, or in a sewage treatment plant) is esti-
mated, taking into consideration the amount of the substance produced and its
biodegradation behavior. The effect on the environment, e.g. toxicity to organ-
isms such as fish, algae, or microorganisms, is determined by a series of stan-
dardized testing methods. The two results are compared with each other. If the
expected environmental concentration of a particular substance is less than the
amount at which negative effects can no longer be determined then the product
294 9 Industrial Development and Application of Biobased Oleochemicals
Method Result
Basic information
– Environmental fate Biodegradation tests
– Environmental effect Ecotoxicity tests
Criteria
– Environmental concentration Exposure analysis, PEC: Predicted environmental concentration
– Ecotoxicological concentration Biodegradation PNEC: Predicted no effect concentration
Analysis of effects
Evaluation Comparison PEC vs. PNEC PEC < PNEC: environmentally compatible
9.4
Examples of Products
Oils and fats are triglycerides which typically consist of glycerin and saturated
and unsaturated fatty acids. There are a few exceptions to this rule, for example
castor oil, a glycerol triester of 12-hydroxyoleic acid (ricinoleic acid). Triglycer-
ides have two chemically reactive sites – the double bond in the unsaturated
fatty acid chain and the acid group of the fatty acid chain. In product develop-
ment based on triglycerides most derivatization reactions are performed out at
the carboxyl group (> 90%) whereas oleochemical reactions involving the alkyl
chain or double bond amount to less than 10% (Fig. 9.3).
For most other uses oils and fats must be split into the so-called oleochemical
base materials – fatty acid methyl esters, fatty acids, glycerol, and, as hydrogena-
tion products of the fatty acid methyl esters, fatty alcohols (Fig. 9.4) [1]. In the
Fig. 9.4 Industrial processing of natural oils and fats and se-
lected product derivatives.
text below innovative products derived from glycerides, fatty acids, or fatty alco-
hols are discussed – oleochemicals for polymers, esters for lubricants, and sur-
factants, emulsifiers, and emollients for home and personal care applications.
9.4.1
Oleochemicals for Polymer Applications
The use of oleochemicals in polymers has a long tradition. One can differentiate
between their use as polymer materials, for example linseed oil and soybean oil
as drying oils, polymer stabilizers and additives, for example epoxidized soybean
oil as plasticizer, and building blocks for polymers, for example dicarboxylic
acids for polyesters or polyamides (Table 9.2) [7]. Considering the total market
for polymers of approximately 150 million tonnes in 1997 the share of oleo-
chemical based products is relatively small – or, in other terms, the potential for
these products is very high. Without doubt there is still a trend in the use of
naturally derived materials for polymer applications, especially in niche mar-
kets. As an example, the demand for linseed oil for production of linoleum has
increased from 10,000 tonnes in 1975 to 50,000 tonnes in 1998 (coming from
120,000 tonnes in 1960!) [8 a]. Epoxidized soybean oil (ESO) as a plastic additive
has a relatively stable market of approximately 100,000 tonnes/year [8 b].
A few years ago research was undertaken to use oleochemicals to build up
matrices for natural fiber reinforced plastics [9]. The use of natural fibers, for
example flax, hemp, sisal, and yuca is of increasing interest for a variety of ap-
plications, among them the automotive and public transportation industries, in
which the composites could be used in door pockets, covers, and instrument
panels, and for sound insulation [9 a]. Other applications could be in the manu-
296 9 Industrial Development and Application of Biobased Oleochemicals
Product/use Source
Polymer materials
– polymerized soybean oil, castor oil Drying oils Soybean oil, castor oil
– polymerized linseed oil Linoleum Linseed oil
Polymer additives
– epoxides Stabilizers, plasticizers Soybean oil
– soaps (Ba/Cd, Ca/Zn) Stabilizers Stearic acid
– fatty acid esters, – amides, waxes Lubricants Rapeseed oil
Building blocks for polymers
– dicarboxylic acids Polyamides, polyesters, Tall oil, soybean oil, castor
– ether-/ester polyols alkyd resins, polyur- oil, sun-flower Oil, linseed
ethanes oil, oleic acid
nents for polymers. This is approximately 0.5% of the total dicarboxylic acid
market for this application, in which phthalic and terephthalic acids represent
87%. The chemical nature of these oleochemical derived dicarboxylic acids can
alter or modify condensation polymers, and therefore will remain a special
niche market area. Some of these special properties are elasticity, flexibility, high
impact strength, hydrolytic stability, hydrophobicity, lower glass transition tem-
peratures, and flexibility [10]. The crucial reactions in the development of build-
ing blocks for polymers based on oils and fats are caustic oxidation, ozonolysis,
dimerization, (aut)oxidation, epoxidation, and epoxy ring opening. All of these
reactions except biooxidation [10 b] are performed on the double bond of an un-
saturated fatty acid or glyceride. Figure 9.5 summarizes the end products and
areas of application derived from these reactions. In the following text recent
developments in the field of diols and polyols for polyurethanes will be pre-
sented in more detail [11].
Outer appearance Yellow liquid Colorless liquid White flakes White flakes
Hydroxyl value 180–200 180–210 345–360 625–645
Viscosity (25 8C, mPas) 3500–4300 1800–2800 Solid Solid
Melting Point (8C) – – 61–65 68–73
Composition
– monomer (%) 13 2 – –
– dimer (%) 68 >96 – >98
– trimer (%) 19 2 – –
Trademark Sovermol 650NS Sovermol 908 Sovermol 912 Sovermol 110
9.4.2
Biodegradable Fatty Acid Esters for Lubricants [15]
Apart from being used as “bio-diesel”, fatty acid esters, which are obtained from
fatty acids and alcohols, are becoming increasingly interesting as biodegradable
replacements for mineral oils. In some application areas, for example chain saw
300 9 Industrial Development and Application of Biobased Oleochemicals
oil, gearbox oils, hydraulic oils, and lubricants for crude oil production these
oleochemical products have already proved themselves.
Esters for lubricant applications are divided into five groups: monocarboxylic
acid esters (monoesters), dicarboxylic acid esters (diesters), glycerol esters, polyol
esters, and complex esters.
Monoesters are obtained by reacting carboxylic acids with alkyl chain lengths
from C8 to C22 and branched or linear alcohols. Typical diesters are obtained,
for example, from adipic, sebacic, azelaic, or dimer fatty acids by reaction with
butanol, ethyl hexanol, isodecanol, isotridecanol, or Guerbet alcohol (see Chap-
ter 9.4.4.3). Using renewable resources as a base, sebacic acid is obtained from
castor oil by oxidation with lead(II) oxide as catalyst. Azelaic acid and dimer
fatty acids are obtained from oleic acid by technical processes – the first by
ozone cleavage, with pelargonic acid being formed as a coupling product, the
latter by thermal dimerization (see also previous section). Although the diesters
already have excellent lubricating properties, their thermal stability is surpassed
by the polyol esters. These products are based on polyols with a quaternary car-
bon atom – for this reason glycerol esters form a separate class of products
(Fig. 9.8). Complex esters are formed by esterification of polyols with mixtures
of mono, di, and tricarboxylic acids and are oligomer mixtures; from a technical
application viewpoint they are characterized by their high shear stability [15 a].
The decisive factor is that the specially designed fatty acid esters which are
used as replacements for mineral oil products not only have ecologically com-
patible properties but also comparable or even better performance than that of
conventional products. That this is possible can be demonstrated very clearly by
an example from crude oil production. In coastal drilling (e.g. in the North Sea)
the demands placed on the lubricants (drilling fluids) are particularly high. The
drilling fluid is pumped to the surface together with the drill cuttings and after
coarse separation disposed of directly into the sea. In addition to the good lubri-
cating effect the biodegradability assumes particular importance in this applica-
tion. A specially developed fatty acid ester (Petrofree) not only fulfils the re-
Table 9.4 European potential market for biodegradable lubricants (1000 tonnes year–1) a).
quirement of biodegradability but also has a better lubricating effect than prod-
ucts based on mineral oils [16].
Current developments include the use of specially designed fatty acid esters
in a wide range of applications as biodegradable lubricants, and environmentally
friendly alternatives are available for almost all mineral oil-based products. In
Europe, the long-term potential is estimated to be 10–20% of the total market
(500,000–1,000,000 tonnes/year; Table 9.4) [15 c]. In 1997 40,000 tonnes of biode-
gradable lubricants were sold in Germany alone (4.5% of the total market)
[15 c]. An increase of this share is the objective of a variety of measures taken
by government and other authorities. The success of these efforts will finally
also depend on statutory regulations which should govern the use of environ-
mentally-friendly products [17].
9.4.3
Surfactants and Emulsifiers Derived from Vegetable Oil
Surfactants are used in a wide range of fields. By far the most important
fields of application are the washing and cleansing sectors and in textile treat-
ment and cosmetics; these use more than 50% of the total amount of surfac-
tants. Surfactants are also used in the food sector, in crop protection, in mining,
and in the production of paints, coatings, inks, and adhesives. The basic manu-
facturing routes to important surfactants are listed out in Fig. 9.9. It is true that
the most important surfactant on the basis of the amount produced, apart from
soap, is still the petrochemical-based alkyl benzene sulfonate; in recent years,
however, a continuous trend toward surfactants based on renewable resources
has become apparent. The total worldwide market amounts to approximately
19.2 million tonnes (2000, including soap). The amounts involved, broken down
Soap 8800
Anionic surfactants
– Alkyl benzene sulfonates 3400
– Fatty alcohol ether sulfates 1000
– Fatty alcohol sulfate 500
Nonionic surfactants
– Alcohol ethoxylates 800
– Alkylphenol ethoxylates 700
Cationic surfactants 810
Amphoteric surfactants 180
Others (including carbohydrate-based surfactants) 2900
into the individual surfactant classes, are summarized in Table 9.5; Fig. 9.10
shows the regional distribution [18 b].
based fatty alcohol sulfate the analysis starts with harvesting of the oil fruits
(palm kernels or coconuts) and their processing to isolate the desired plant oil.
Subsequent transesterification and hydrogenation of the methyl ester intermedi-
ates leads to the fatty alcohols, which are finally sulfated to produce the desired
product. On the basis of on this analysis the environmental impact of vegetable
oil-based fatty alcohol sulfate compared with the petrochemical based product
is:
· 70% less use of fossil resources
· 50% less emission to the atmosphere
· 15% less waste
· 50% more emission to water (low toxic waste water from small, decentralized
oil plants)
9.4.3.2 Acylated Proteins and Amino Acids (Protein–Fatty Acid Condensates) [19]
In the development of protein–fatty acid condensates it was possible to combine
the renewable resources fatty acids (from vegetable oil) and protein, which can
be obtained both from animal waste (leather) and from many plants, to con-
struct a surfactant structure with a hydrophobic (fatty acid) and a hydrophilic
(protein) part (Fig. 9.12). This was achieved by reacting protein hydrolyzate with
fatty acid chloride under Schotten–Baumann conditions using water as solvent.
The products obtained have an excellent skin compatibility and also a good
cleaning effect (particularly on the skin) and, in combination with other surfac-
tants, lead to an increase in performance. For instance, even small additions of
the acylated protein hydrolyzate improve the skin compatibility of other prod-
ucts. This protective effect could be because of the amphoteric nature of the
product. There is an interaction between the protein–fatty acid condensate and
skin collagen. This could lead to the formation of a protective layer, which re-
duces excessive attack of surfactants on the upper layers of the skin, their
strong degreasing effect, and the direct interaction of anionic surfactants with
the skin. Comparable reaction conditions have been used to develop acylated
amino acids, and acyl glutamates, in particular, have found broad uses in recent
years (Fig. 9.13).
In the personal care market, fatty acid derivatives of proteins and amino acids
(glutamic acid) are mainly used in mild shower and bath products, mild sham-
poos, surfactant-based face cleansers, cold-wave preparations and fixatives, baby
wash formulations, and special emulsifiers for “leave-on” products.
Unique properties had previously been observed for alkyl polyglycosides, par-
ticularly in combination with other surfactants. For example, use of alkyl poly-
glycosides in light-duty detergent or shampoo formulation means that the total
amount of surfactant can be reduced without sacrificing performance. In other
combinations a particularly stable and fine foam can be produced which pro-
tects sensitive textiles during the washing process. Toxicological and ecological
laboratory investigations have also produced favorable results. Alkyl polyglyco-
sides have a good compatibility with the eyes, skin, and mucous membranes
and even reduce the irritant effects of surfactant combinations. On top of this
they are completely biodegradable, both aerobically and anaerobically. The rela-
tively favorable classification (for surfactants) as class I under the German water
hazard classification (WGK I) is a consequence of this.
Pentaerythritol Esters As for glycerol esters, these esters are produced by esteri-
fication of pentaerythritol with the desired fatty acids. For example, under de-
fined reaction conditions and use of stearic acid at a defined concentration, pen-
taerythritol distearate has been recently developed as an off-white wax with a
very weak odor (Cutina PES). This type of product is offered as co-emulsifier
and consistency factor for cosmetic products with high sensorial elegance and
can be applied in a variety of formulations (Fig. 9.17).
Fig. 9.17 Chemical structure of pentaerythritol distearate (main component in Cutina PES).
9.4 Examples of Products 309
but also compatibility with modern emulsification techniques and balanced sen-
sory feeling. One product which fulfils these requirements is a compound based
on glycerin, alkyl polyglycoside and polyglyceryl-2-dipolyhydroxystearate (Eumul-
gin VL 75). In combination with selected emollients it enables the preparation
of O/W emulsions of high quality and stability (small droplet sizes). In addition,
because of the liquid appearance of the product, and, as a consequence, the pos-
sibility of cold processing, manufacturing time and cost of preparation of emul-
sions are significantly reduced (Fig. 9.18).
tion with wax esters and cationic polymers also has the benefits of silicon-free
body-cleansing preparations with regard to improved sensorial skin properties.
9.4.4
Emollients [24]
9.4.4.1 Introduction
The physicochemical nature of the oil-phase components in a cosmetic emul-
sion, the emollients, determines their skin-care effects, such as smoothing,
spreading, sensorial appearance. Test methods have been developed to character-
ize and classify the numerous emollients available on the market, for example
Chemical structure
products have proven to be efficient emollients, but are also used for other ap-
plications, for example as plasticizers or as components of lubricants (Fig. 9.21).
9.5
Perspectives
9.6
Trademarks
References
315
10
Phytochemicals, Dyes, and Pigments
in the Biorefinery Context
George A. Kraus
10.1
Introduction
The idea of a biorefinery is modeled after the highly successful oil refinery
wherein petroleum is converted into gasoline, oil, and monomers such as ethyl-
ene and propylene. As a result of several decades of improvements, these petro-
leum refineries are flexible and efficient [1–3]. They produce high-volume chem-
icals plus a large number of low volume, high-value materials.
For the biorefinery to be successful, it must produce high-volume fuels such
as ethanol or biodiesel plus monomers and a portfolio of high-value chemicals
for niche markets. An outline of a biorefinery is depicted in Fig. 10.1.
The monomers produced by the biorefinery will probably be diols and acids,
because the feedstocks are more highly oxygenated than petroleum. Among the
high-value products produced by the biorefinery will be phytochemicals, dyes,
and pigments. Occasionally these phytochemicals are foods or drugs. Often (e.g.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
316 10 Phytochemicals, Dyes, and Pigments in the Biorefinery Context
10.2
Historical Outline
The fundamentals of a biorefinery already exist in the corn and soybean indus-
tries. The corn wet milling industry converts approximately two billion bushels
of corn per year into corn oil, starch, corn gluten feed, corn gluten meal, and
corn germ meal plus a variety of sugars and other chemicals [4–6]. The basic
outline of a corn wet milling plant is shown in Fig. 10.2.
In the wet milling process, corn is first soaked in water containing sulfur di-
oxide. It is then ground and the components are physically separated using a
series of centrifuges, screens, and washes. Some of the separated fractions then
undergo additional refining steps.
In a soybean-processing plant, the soy protein is separated from the oil [7–9]
and the crude soybean oil is then purified by degumming to remove lecithin,
by refining to remove fatty acids, by bleaching with clay to remove chlorophylls,
and by deodorization (steam distillation) to remove phytosterols and tocopher-
ols. This process is outlined in Fig. 10.3.
10.3
Phytochemicals from Corn and Soybeans
Corn and soybeans are, at least initially, the most likely feedstocks for a biore-
finery. There is an enormous knowledge base about the fundamental plant
science of corn and soybeans [15]. Additionally, the means of production and
harvesting of these two crops on a million-acre scale is well documented and is
improved each year. I have therefore focused this chapter on describing the phy-
tochemicals, dyes, and pigments from these two crops. Phytochemicals are
chemicals from plants. We will focus on chemicals that are reported to have
beneficial health effects but are not essential for life.
10.3.1
Phytosterols
Phytosterols are present in both corn and soybeans. They are separated from
soybean oil by a steam distillation process and are isolated in the deodorizer dis-
tillate with other organic chemicals. The structures of the major phytosterols
found in corn and soybeans are depicted in Fig. 10.4.
The mixture obtained from soybeans consists of sitosterol (60%), sigmasterol
(20%), and campesterol (20%). These sterols are converted into commercially
important steroids by microbial fermentation [16]. Biotransformation procedures
for the efficient production of androst-4-ene-3,17-dione, androsta-1,4-diene-3,17-
dione, and testosterone have been reported [17, 18].
Sitosterol has recently been shown to reduce plasma VLDL and LDL (“bad”)
cholesterol and increases plasma HDL (“good”) cholesterol [19, 20]. Because ap-
proximately 25% of American adults have high cholesterol, the market for this
high-value phytochemical may soon increase dramatically.
Corn contained dimethyl sterols and monomethyl sterols which amount to
approximately 6% of the total sterol content. In corn and soybeans, sterols are
also present as esters and as glycosides. In Illinois high oil corn, 53% of the
sterols are free sterols, 46% of the sterols are acylated, and 1% of the sterols are
present as glycosides [21]. Most of the acylated sterols are esters of linoleic acid.
318 10 Phytochemicals, Dyes, and Pigments in the Biorefinery Context
10.3.2
Lecithin
10.3.3
Tocopherols
Tocopherols are antioxidants that are present in both corn and soybeans. They
are separated from soybean oil in the deodorizer distillate fraction. The struc-
tures of the tocopherols are shown in Fig. 10.6. In soybeans the major constitu-
ent is c-tocopherol (62%), followed by d-tocopherol (25%), a-tocopherol (12%),
and b-tocopherol (1%) [26]. In corn the major component is c-tocopherol, with
a-tocopherol second. The total tocopherol content of corn varies as a function of
genetics and geography, with a range of 500–1000 mg tocopherols per kilogram
of corn oil [27].
The tocopherols are a source of vitamin E. Natural vitamin E is a-tocopherol
in which each of the three stereogenic centers has the R configuration. The b, c,
10.3.4
Carotenoids
The main pigments in yellow corn are carotenes and xanthophylls. Depending
on the growing conditions, corn contains from 20–80 mg kg–1 carotenes and
xanthophylls [30]. The main carotenes are b-carotene and b-cryptoxanthin. Their
structures are shown in Fig. 10.7. Because of the conjugated polyene structure
of carotenes, they are not as stable as other phytochemicals present in corn.
They can be readily degraded by oxygen in the air, by a combination of oxygen
and sunlight, and also by heat. The time of storage and storage conditions are,
therefore, factors in the yield of carotenoids.
Carotenoids are a significant dietary source of vitamin A for animals. The effi-
ciency of conversion of carotenes into vitamin A varies with the type of animal.
Carotenes are also good antioxidants [31].
Xanthophylls are pigments responsible for color but do not function as pre-
cursors to vitamin A. The principal xanthophylls in corn are lutein and zea-
xanthin. Their structures also are illustrated in Fig. 10.7. Like carotenes, the
xanthophylls are labile in light, heat, and air. They are also good antioxidants.
Chromatography-based detection methods have been developed for the caro-
tenes and xanthophylls [32].
Lutein has recently been recognized as an effective drug for treatment of
macular degeneration, a disease that affects eyesight [33]. Although marigolds
are currently the primary source of lutein, genetic modification of corn may
lead to enhanced levels of the compound.
10.3.5
Phytoestrogens
10.3.6
Saponins
of visceral fat, providing a mechanism for controlling obesity [40]. Saponins also
bind tightly to bile acids, thereby reducing the risk of colon cancer [41]. Sapo-
nins have also been reported to remove toxins and hardened matter from the
intestinal tract [42]. Researchers have recently reported an in-vitro effect of sapo-
nins on the infectivity of the human immunodeficiency virus [43]. Saponins
have also been reported to protect against aflatoxin-induced mutagenicity. They
were ranked as more effective than tocopherol or l-ascorbic acid [44].
10.3.7
Protease Inhibitors
Over the past decade, protease inhibitors, particularly those derived from soy-
beans, have emerged as potential cancer chemopreventive agents. Soybeans con-
tain significant amounts of protease inhibitors – approximately 6% by weight of
total soybean protein is protease inhibitors [45]. Protease inhibitors have also
been found in crops such as corn and rice.
The inhibitor known as the Bowman–Birk inhibitor, more commonly referred
to as BBI, has received the most attention [46]. This inhibitor makes up a signif-
icant fraction of the inhibitors in soy protein and is readily available in commer-
cial tofu. The molecular structure of BBI, a polypeptide of molecular weight
8000, has recently been determined [47]. Extensive experimentation has shown
that BBI is a potent chymotrypsin and trypsin inhibitor.
Although BBI has been effective in animal trials, results of human trials are
not yet known. On the basis of public health records in Asia and the United
States, there certainly seems to be a connection between soybean consumption
and the incidence of breast, colon, and prostate cancers [48]. BBI has been re-
commended as a radioprotector for normal tissue to enhance radiotherapy [49].
The soybean protease inhibitor SBTI has also been characterized.
References 323
10.4
Outlook and Perspectives
References
1 Strachan, J. F. The Petroleum Refinery En- 10 Encinar, J. M.; Gonzalez, J. F.; Rodriguez,
gineer’s Handbook, Philosophical Library, J. J.; Tejedor, A. Energy & Fuels 2002, 16,
New York, 1955. 443–450.
2 Nelson, W. L. Petroleum Refinery Engineer- 11 Zhou, W.; Konar, S. K.; Boocock, D. G. B.
ing. 4th ed. McGraw–Hill, New York J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 2003, 80, 367–371.
1958. 12 Schlaf, M.; Ghosh, P.; Fagan, P. J.;
3 Peterson, D. J. New Forces at Work in Re- Hauptman, E.; Bullock, R. M. Ange-
fining: Industry views of Critical Business wandte Chemie, International Ed. 2001,
and Operation Trends, Rand, Santa Moni- 40, 3887–3890.
ca, CA 2003. 13 Antal Jr, M. J.; Mok, W. S. L.; Richards,
4 Johnson, L. A.; May, J. B. Corn: Chemistry G. N. Carbohydrate Research, 1990, 199,
and Technology, Chapter 12, American 111–115.
Association of Cereal Chemists, USA, 14 Schuster, L.; Eggersdorfer, M. Eur. Pat.
2003. Appl. 1996. EP 713849
5 Blanchard, P. H. Technology of Corn Wet 15 For an excellent overview, see:
Milling and Associated Processes, Elsevier P. J. White, L. A. Johnson Corn: Chemistry
Publishing, Amsterdam, 1992. and Technology, American Association of
6 Brekke, O. L. Corn Culture, Processing, Cereal Chemists, USA, 2003.
Products, AVI Publishing, Westport, CT, 16 Shah, K.; Mehdi, I.; Khan, A. W.; Vora,
1970. V C. European J. Applied Microbiol. Bio-
7 Erickson, D. R. Practical Handbook of technol. 1980, 10, 167–169.
Soybean Processing and Utilization, AOCS 17 Liu, W.-H.; Pan, C.-P.; Lo, C.-K. Food
Press, St. Louis, 1995. Science and Agricultural Chemistry 2001,
8 Friedrich, W. Fette, Seifen, Anstrichmittel 3, 139–142.
1983, 85, 346–355. 18 Lo, C.-K.; Pan, C.-P.; Liu, W.-H. Journal
9 Cowan, J. C. Agronomy 1973, 16, 619– of Industrial Microbiology & Biotechnology
664. 2002, 28, 280–283.
324 10 Phytochemicals, Dyes, and Pigments in the Biorefinery Context
19 Gylling, H., Puska, P., Vartiainen, E. and 36 Lee, H. P., Gourley, L., Duffy, S. W.,
Miettinen, T. A. J Lipid Res 1999, 40, Esteve, J., Lee, J., Day, N. E. Lancet, 1991,
593–600. 337,1197–1200.
20 Gylling, H. and Miettinen, T. A. Diabeto- 37 MerzDemlow, B. E., Duncan, A. M.,
logia 1994, 37, 773–780. Wangen, K. E., Xu, X., Carr, T. P., Phipps,
21 Davis, D. L.; Poneleit, C. G. Phytochemis- W. R., Kurzer, M. S. Am. J. Clin. Nutr.
try, 1975, 14, 1201–1203. 2000, 71, 1462–1469.
22 Grieser, M. D.; Geske, J. N. J. Am. Oil 38 Wanezaki, S.; Tsuzaki, S.; Araki, H. PCT
Chem. Soc. 1989, 66, 1484–1487. Int. Appl. 2003, WO 2003075939 A1
23 Miller, D. L. Cereal Foods World 2002, 47, 20030918 Application: WO 2003-JP2881
178–184 20030311.
24 O’Mullane, J. E.; Hawthorne, J. N. Athero- 39 Arditi, T.; Meredith, T.; Flowerman, P.
sclerosis (Shannon, Ireland) 1982, 45, 81– Cereal Foods World 2000, 45, 414–417.
90. 40 Wanezaki, S.; Fukui, K.; Takamatsu, K.;
25 Ladd, S. L.; Sommer, S. A.; LaBerge, S.; Araki, H. Jpn. Kokai Tokkyo Koho 2003.
Toscano, W. Clin. Neuropharmacol. 1993, 41 Lacaille-Dubois; Wagner Phytomedicine,
16, 540. 1996, 2, 363–386.
26 Clark, J. P. Nutraceuticals: Designer Foods 42 Lipkin, R. Science News, 1995, December
III: Garlic, Soy and Licorice, [Course on 9.
Designer Foods, Proceedings], 3rd, 43 Nakashima, H. AIDS 3, 1989, 655–658.
Washington, D. C., May 23–25, 1994, 44 Jun, H.-S.; Kim, S.-E.; Sung, M.-K.
237–242. Food & Nutrition Press J. Med. Food 2002, 5, 235–240.
27 Weber, E. J. J. Am. Oil Chem. Soc. 1984, 45 Hwang, D. L. R., Davis-Lin, K. T., Yang,
61, 1231–1234. W. K. and Foard, D. T. Biochem. Biophys.
28 Pratt, D. E. AOCS Monograph 1985, 15 Acta 1977, 495, 369–382.
(Flavor Chem. Fats Oils), 145–153. 46 Kennedy, A. R Pharmacol. & Therapeutics
29 Stampfer, M. J.; Hennekens, C. H.; 1998, 78, 167–209.
Manson, J. E.; Colditz, G. A.; Rosner, B.; 47 Odani, S. and Ikenaka, T. J. J. Biochem.
Willett, W. C. N. Engl. J. Med. 1993, 328, (Tokyo) 1973, 74, 857–860.
1444–1449. 48 Dunn, J. E. Cancer Res. 1975, 35, 3240–
30 Weber, E. J. J. Am. Oil Chem Soc. 1987, 3245.
64, 1129–1134. 49 Dittmann, K. H.; Mayer, C.; Rodemann,
31 Burton, G. W.; Ingold, K. U. Science, H. P. Current Med. Chem.: Anti-Cancer
1984, 224, 569–573. Agents 2003, 3, 360–363.
32 Kurilich, A. C.; Juvik, J. A. J. Liquid Chro- 50 Suh, H. J.; Whang, J. H.; Kim, Y. S.; Bae,
matogr. Related Technol. 1999, 22, 2925– S. H.; Noh, D. O. Process Biochem.
2934. (Oxford, United Kingdom) 2003, 38,
33 Krinsky, N. I.; Landrum, J. T.; Bone, R. A. 1239–1244.
Ann. Rev. Nutrition 2003, 23 171–201. 51 Blanco-Labra, A.; Chagolla-Lopez, A.;
34 Dickson, R. A.; Ferreira, D. Phytochemis- Martinez-Gallardo, N.; Valdes-Rodriguez,
try, 2002, 60, 205–211. S. J. Food Biochem. 1995, 19, 27–41.
35 Wang, H.-J.; Murphy, P. A. J. Agric. Food 52 Abe, M.; Arai, S.; Kato, H.; Fujimaki, M.
Chem. 1994, 42, 1666. Agric. and Biol Chem 1980, 44, 685–686.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
325
11
Adding Color to Green Chemistry?
An Overview of the Fundamentals and Potential
of Chlorophylls
Mathias O. Senge and Julia Richter
11.1
Introduction
Chlorophylls, often termed the “pigments of life” are green colored macrocyclic
pigments which are the primary photosynthetic pigments. The term chlorophyll,
coined by Berzelius in 1838, is derived from Greek and indicates the green of
leaves [1]. In fact, as green pigments they are responsible for primary biochem-
ical energy generation in nature and are the only indication of life on earth visi-
ble from outer space. Current efforts to switch chemistry from a system based
on the use of nonrenewable resources (geological organic carbon deposits) to
one based on the utilization of renewable bioresources are one of the corner-
stones of efforts often labeled “green chemistry” [2]. Although “green” is taken
to imply an environmentally friendly approach, chlorophylls in a literal sense
are the green chemical components responsible for beauty in our natural envi-
ronment (vegetation).
If so, is green chemistry really green? At present, no. Even a cursory inspec-
tion reveals that all practical efforts aimed at the use of biological materials in
chemistry rely solely on the use of nongreen materials. This article aims to de-
scribe some of the fundamentals and highlights of chlorophyll chemistry and
gives a preliminary assessment whether chlorophylls might be a useful biore-
source.
11.2
Historical Outline
Chlorophylls have been studied for almost 200 years [1] and, although much of
their basic chemistry was established almost 100 years ago [3], real break-
throughs in their exact biochemical function were only made in recent decades
as a result of X-ray crystallographic analysis both of the reaction center [4] and
of light harvesting complexes [5]. Until WW II most studies were concerned
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
326 11 Adding Color to Green Chemistry?
with their basic structural chemistry. This was followed by elucidation of the ba-
sic anabolic pathways of chlorophyll in the higher plants, photophysical studies
of their function in photosynthesis, and most recently their catabolism. Parallel
to studies on chlorophylls a and b from higher plants, recent decades have seen
many efforts to elucidate the structure, function, and biosynthesis of photosyn-
thetic pigments from unicellular organisms and photosynthetic bacteria [6].
Chlorophylls have never been used as bulk chemicals for transformation into
other compounds on a technical scale. As outlined below, since the middle of
the last century phytochlorin and rhodochlorin derivatives have found some use
as food additives and antiodor compounds, often in the form of simple plant ex-
tracts. During the last twenty years pheophorbide derivatives have been used as
starting materials for the synthesis of novel photosensitizers (vide infra) and are
under active investigation as compounds for solar energy conversion and hydro-
gen production. These efforts are still in a developmental stage, however, and
require only gram-scale amounts of material [7].
11.3
Chlorophyll Fundamentals
11.3.1
Occurrence and Basic Structures
lated chlorins have also been found in many oxidoreductases, marine sponges,
tunicates, and in Bonella viridis. The deep-sea dragon fish Malacosteus niger even
uses a chlorophyll derivative as a visual pigment [10]. Most of these are believed
to be derived from chlorophyll which is processed by the plant or animal.
11.3.2
Principles of Chlorophyll Chemistry
11.3.3
Isolation of Chlorophylls
Because of their prominent biological role, many different methods have been
developed for the qualitative and quantitative extraction of chlorophyll a and b
from plants and algae [15]. All methods require extraction of the pigments with
an organic solvent or boiling water and, despite all efforts, no single solvent or
solvent mixture has been found that will extract the pigments quantitatively and
unaltered. The natural chlorophylls are exceptionally labile compounds that
readily undergo reactions in the macrocycle core, at C20, and at the doubly acti-
vated 132-position [16]. Thus, they rapidly become demetalated and/or lose the
phytyl side-chain to yield pheophorbides 12, or undergo other chemical altera-
tions (Fig. 11.3).
11.3 Chlorophyll Fundamentals 329
Often, this is not only the result of the chemicals added but is promoted by
the plant material itself. For example, plants may have an acidic cytoplasm re-
sulting in the formation of pheophytins, or contain oxidative enzymes that pro-
mote oxidation reactions. The most prominent and most easily formed byprod-
ucts of the extraction process are the allomerization products, notably epimer-
ized 13 or hydroxylated derivatives 14 of chlorophyll [16, 17]. Likewise, chloro-
phyllase often remains active during extraction resulting in the formation of
acidic chlorophyllides 15 or re-esterified derivatives thereof when using alcohols
for extraction. Efforts to denature the enzymes before extraction (e.g. by scald-
ing) will result in the formation of isomerization products. All the different re-
actions described, and many others, can occur concomitantly at different stages,
giving rise to a broad range of extraction artifacts. Thus it is almost impossible
to extract plant materials without concurrent formation of a variety of chloro-
phyll derivatives.
Exceptional precautions must be taken (inert gas, cell break up by liquid ni-
trogen, etc.) to isolate chlorophylls quantitatively and unaltered. This precludes
any large-scale technical use of chlorophyll and any chemical or technical use of
chlorophyll must be based on chemically more stable derivatives thereof.
In practical terms, small-scale extractions (1–5 g plant material) may be per-
formed with almost any “green” organism, usually with chilled acetone as ex-
traction solvent. A typical procedure involves disrupting the material in a blen-
der in the presence of acetone, filtration, re-extraction of plant material, and
concentration of the combined extracts by rotary evaporation. Medium-scale ex-
tractions (up to 1 kg plant material) are best performed using fresh spinach.
The material is first heated in boiling water (1–2 min), filtration followed by ex-
traction with methanol–petroleum ether mixtures then typically yields 2 to 4 g
crude pigment extract. For large-scale extractions (1–5 kg) dried alfalfa meal or
air-dried blue–green algae, notably Spirulina, are the best sources. In our hands
the best results were obtained by freezing Spirulina with liquid nitrogen and ex-
tracting the pigments with acetone to yield approximately 2–5 g chlorophyll a
kg–1 dried algae. Spirulina contains only chlorophyll a, a major benefit which
circumvents the a/b separation problem. Although a variety of chromatographic
330 11 Adding Color to Green Chemistry?
methods have been developed to separate the “a” and “b” series, the best “large-
scale” method utilizes chemical modification of the formyl group in pheophytin
b with Girard’s reagent T [18].
Dried blue-green algae are still the best material for the “large-scale” prepara-
tion of pure chlorophyll derivatives and have served for decades as the source of
starting materials for research groups involved in chlorophyll chemistry. Except
for production of “chlorophyllin” (see below) no attempts have been made to ex-
tract chlorophyll or derivatives thereof on an industrial scale. A “dye fraction” is,
nevertheless, one of the fractions routinely obtained when green materials
(grass, lucerne, alfalfa, etc.) are processed in a green biorefinery [19] and could
serve as a source of chlorophyll derivatives.
11.4
Chlorophyll Breakdown and Chemical Transformations
11.4.1
Biological Chlorophyll Catabolism
Although more than 109 tons of chlorophyll are degraded each year on earth
(and account for the natural beauty of fall vegetation), the biological breakdown
of chlorophyll had remained an enigma until about a decade ago [20]. The only
chemical reactions known to be involved in senescence and natural breakdown
of chlorophyll were similar to those encountered during pigment extraction.
Loss of Mg, dephytylation, and some changes at the isocyclic pentanone ring
seemed to be early steps but nothing was known about the fate of the macro-
cycle and the putative ring-opening reaction.
Work by the groups of Kräutler, Matile, and Gossauer showed that the central
step is a ring-opening reaction at the 5-position [21, 22]. This is in contrast with
the situation encountered for heme, which is oxidatively cleaved at the 20-posi-
tion. As shown in Fig. 11.4, the crucial steps of chlorophyll degradation begin
by conversion of chlorophyll a into pheophorbide a, 12, followed by enzymatic
transformation into the bilinone, 16. During this step the macrocycle undergoes
oxidative C5 ring-opening, incorporates two oxygen atoms (the CHO one from
O2) and is saturated at the 10-position. This reaction is catalyzed by a monooxy-
genase and the red compound 16 is further converted to the still fluorescing
compound 17, and finally into the nonfluorescing derivative 18, along with
some changes in the side chains which increase the hydrophilicity of the break-
down products. Chlorophyll b is first converted into chlorophyll a and then sub-
jected to the same reactions.
11.4 Chlorophyll Breakdown and Chemical Transformations 331
11.4.2
Geological Chlorophyll Degradation – Petroporphyrins
It is known that chlorophyll is not only degraded in living systems but also un-
dergoes degradation in sediments [23]. Up to a few percent of all annual pri-
mary organic production is accumulated in sediments and under appropriate
conditions (low thermal or oxidative stress) significant amounts of organic com-
pounds will remain identifiable in sediments as fossil molecules [24]. These
compounds can serve as geochemical biomarkers as long as they retain enough
structural resemblance to biochemical compounds. Indeed, porphyrins are
found in many deposits and their concentration in sediments can vary from 1
to 3000 ppm. They have been termed geoporphyrins, petroporphyrins, or sedi-
mentary porphyrins. Their concentration in coal is usually below that in crude
oils, and even one porphyrin-based mineral, abelsonite, has been identified [25].
Tetrapyrroles have been isolated with the organic matter from almost all sedi-
ments, and are found at geological ages ranging from the Precambrian to re-
cent. Interest in these pigments is related to two areas of research. In practical
terms, different deposits have different porphyrin compositions, both with re-
gard to type and relative content of pigments. Thus, the petroporphyrins can be
used as a fingerprint for different oil shales. Indeed, HPLC analysis of the pet-
332 11 Adding Color to Green Chemistry?
roporphyrin fraction often serves as an important analytical tool in the oil in-
dustry.
Second, the close structural resemblance between some geoporphyrins and
biochemical pigments (e.g. chlorophyll a) might enable development of a diage-
netic scheme for their formation. Indeed, Treibs’s basic hypothesis [23] that
petroporphyrins are derived from chlorophylls (and porphyrins) has more than
stood the test of time. By now more than 90 different petroporphyrins have
been identified, some with very unusual structures. The classic example is
desoxophylloerythroporphyrin, 20 (a derivative of phytoporphyrin in modern
nomenclature), which clearly bears a close resemblance to chlorophyll a
(Fig. 11.5). Even etioporphyrin, 19, another well-known geoporphyrin, may be
envisaged as being derived from 20 by cleavage of ring V, or from heme-type
pigments [26].
Geoporphyrins are derived from almost all different types of chlorophyll (e.g.,
21, 22). Indeed, even some “petrochlorins” (e.g. phytochlorins 4 and 23) have
been found. Many of these compounds have been prepared by total synthesis,
and for many a chemical rational can be given for their chemical formation.
Their natural formation involves extreme diagenetic conditions (geological time-
scale, heat, pressure, catalysts, . . .). Most of the reactions involving geoporphyr-
in formation are easily identified – loss of magnesium, remetalation with VO,
Ni, or other metals, aromatization of ring IV, vinyl and keto group reduction,
cleavage of the methyl ester, decarboxylation – and are standard reactions of the
porphyrin chemist [24]. Fossils of phytol 26, e.g. phytane 27 and pristine 28, are
prominent constituents of sediments also [27]. Finally, elucidation of the struc-
ture of geoporphyrins with yet unknown diagenetic origin (e.g. 24) might lead
to the identification of yet unknown biochemical pigments (Fig. 11.6).
In the context of this chapter, such pigments can serve as typical examples of
exceptionally stable compounds which can be derived from natural pigments.
Besides their importance in palaeobiology, geochemistry, and as an analytical
tool, however, they are of no industrial importance.
11.4.3
Chemical Degradation of Chlorophylls
11.5
Industrial Uses of Chlorophyll Derivatives
chlorophyll derivatives are currently under active investigation and show great
promise. The current status of this field has been reviewed [37].
The use of chlorophyll derivatives in technical applications is still in the early
developmental stage. Topics of current interest are both solar energy conversion
and hydrogen production [63]. A representative investigation of biohydrogen
evolution uses Zn-chlorophyll a. This is prepared from chlorophyll a derived
from Spirulina and its photostability and photosensitizing activity are superior
to those of the natural magnesium complex. The use of chlorophyll derivatives
is based on their absorption in the visible region. Besides the photosensitizer
the photo-induced hydrogen generation-systems also require an electron donor
(for example nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) regenerated by glu-
cose dehydrogenase (GDH)), an electron relay (Fig. 11.10, MV+/MV2+) and a cat-
alyst (for example colloidal platinum) [64, 65].
Another modern example is the use of chlorin e6, 36, also derived from Spiru-
lina in bio-photovoltaics [66]. Here, the conversion device uses chlorin e6 in a
dye-sensitized solar cell (DSSC) [67] with a nanocrystalline TiO2 film. The green
pigment absorbs visible light (to yield the chromophores in an excited singlet
state). In the next step its emission is quenched by TiO2 with effective electron
injection from 1(chlorin e6)* into the TiO2 conduction band. The final aim is
the production of low-cost solid-state photovoltaic cells. Organometallic com-
pounds such as ruthenium(II) polypyridyl complexes have been used frequently
in this field [68, 69]. Chlorophyll derivatives, however, have a better near-infrared
response and the use of environmentally undesirable heavy metals can be
avoided.
11.6
A Look at “Green” Chlorophyll Chemistry
Currently, the inherent lability of the natural pigments precludes any direct
commercial use. Exceptions are dried algae or plant materials or freeze dried ex-
tracts of these. These are hardly uses in the context of a biorefinery, however
[70], and even if a suitable application would be found, regulatory problems
might arise with regard to GMP standards. Thus, any rational use of the pig-
338 11 Adding Color to Green Chemistry?
ments, i.e. the macrocyclic part of the chlorophylls, must involve a simple and
facile extraction process and some simple chemical transformations that pro-
duce chemically defined materials of high purity and stability. These require-
ments are counteracted by the need to produce chemicals that are still suffi-
ciently reactive (e.g. carry functional groups) that enable transformations into
desirable and marketable target compounds.
A variety of extraction methods have been developed for small-scale extrac-
tion, and it should be possible to transfer these to large-scale systems. Ignoring
the chlorophyll a/b problem for now, there are several possibilities of utilizing
chlorophyll derivatives as starting materials for other fine chemicals. Almost all
start with conversion of the chlorophylls to the respective pheophorbides, i.e. de-
metalation and hydrolysis of the 172-ester. This reaction is preferably performed
in the presence of an alcohol to yield a pheophorbide ester, 34, which can be
handled in organic solvents. Often it is beneficial to hydrogenate the 3-vinyl
group to yield “meso” compounds (35). There are two means of circumventing
allomerization problems. Either the 132 ester can be removed by demethoxycar-
bonylation [18] to yield the “pyro” compounds 37, or ring V can be opened by a
variety of nucleophiles to yield chlorin e6 36 and/or various other derivatives of
rhodochlorin. Naturally, at all stages it is possible to oxidize the chlorins to the
respective porphyrins (e.g. 38). Fig. 11.11 shows a few selected reactions that
can be applied to chlorophylls in different sequences to yield relatively stable de-
rivatives. Rhodochlorin and phytochlorin derivatives, in particular, serve as very
important intermediates in contemporary chlorophyll chemistry [14, 28].
Any use of chlorophylls as fine chemicals will start with these or closely re-
lated compounds [71]. As a result of ongoing studies in PDT (vide supra) and
the photobiological relevance of these pigments, the chemistry of these com-
pounds is well developed and most of the reactions can be performed on a mul-
tigram scale. Note that oxidation of chlorins to the porphyrins typically results
in “red” chemistry, because of a blue shift of the absorption maxima.
All of the compounds outlined in Fig. 11.11 can be prepared from crude chlo-
rophyll a in a few steps with standard chemicals. Porphyrin chemists are conti-
nually adding new and exciting compounds to this field. Current efforts concen-
trate on modeling the bacteriochlorophylls c–e [72], developing new electron-
transfer compounds [73], modeling compounds for photosynthesis [74], and ap-
plications in biomedicine [37]. Thus, no significant efforts in synthetic chloro-
phyll chemistry are necessary in respect of their use from biorefineries. Rather,
the biotechnological side and the technical side of the extraction processes must
be resolved.
One of the most overlooked areas of chlorophyll chemistry is their use as
new materials. For example, significant enhancement of their photochemical
stability is possible by adsorbing them on solid phases (silica or polymer sup-
ports or smectite conjugates) [75–79]. Such silica-adsorbed materials have been
shown to be capable of generating hydrogen gas when coupled with appropriate
electron carriers [76], whereas PEG-coupled chlide could function in the coupled
generation of glutamate [80]. Despite these promising results, very few groups
11.7 Outlook and Perspectives 339
Fig. 11.11 Some chlorophyll transformations and key intermediates of chlorophyll chemistry.
are active in this area. The situation is similar with regard to applications in so-
lar energy conversion. Although this has been the catchword in almost any
modern publication dealing with chlorophyll chemistry, very few recent papers
actually deal with the use of isolated chlorophyll derivatives in photovoltaic cells
[66, 81]. Both areas require major research efforts to yield useful applications. If
successful, however, these would provide the impetus necessary to further stim-
ulate this whole line of research.
11.7
Outlook and Perspectives
applied to the crude chlorophyll fraction to yield homogenous and pure materi-
als for use as fine chemicals. Similarly, use of the “green biomass fraction” must
be compared economically and environmentally with dedicated use of, perhaps,
bioengineered blue green algae as a biological source of tetrapyrroles [85]. Last,
but not least, more industrial applications must be found for natural tetrapyr-
role pigments and developed to provide an economic stimulus for this area.
Only then will “green” be truly a part of green chemistry.
Acknowledgment
Writing of this article and our own research was made possible by generous
funding from the Science Foundation Ireland.
Part II
Biobased Industrial Products,
Materials and Consumer Products
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
347
12
Industrial Chemicals from Biomass – Industrial Concepts
Johan Thoen and Rainer Busch
12.1
Introduction
The era of a chemical industry based on mineral oil, gas and coal has lasted al-
most 150 years, but will gradually come to an end in the course of the next 50
to 75 years. The two main reasons for this development are:
· The stocks of fossil resources are finite. This has generally been accepted
since the Club of Rome published its report “Limits to Growth” in 1972. First,
mineral oil stocks will be exhausted around 2050 if we continue our present
way of life. Times during which more oil was found each year than was con-
sumed are definitely over. Natural gas will last slightly longer (some 75 years),
and coal will last longest (> 200 years).
· Environmental considerations. All kinds of pollution from global warming to
acid rain, from smog to ground water pollution, can be linked to the use of
fossil fuels. Hence we are really living on the threshold of a new era in chem-
istry – and unfortunately in most chemical research and education this has
not yet been sufficiently recognized.
The hypothesis has been formulated that from 2040 onwards we will no longer
use fossil organic raw materials, as a consequence of exhaustion and environ-
mental considerations. The fundamental question, however, is: “Is this techno-
logically feasible while maintaining our present way of life in terms of food, or-
ganic materials and energy consumption?”
12.2
Historical Outline
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
348 12 Industrial Chemicals from Biomass – Industrial Concepts
largely based on the use of renewable resources and this continued until the in-
dustrial revolution.
This means that until 1850, all organic consumer products and industrial raw
materials were plant-based. Within the relatively short period of 150 years so-
ciety changed from a mainly plant-based economy to an economy based on fos-
sil fuels (coal until the end of the 19th century, until 1950 mineral oil, and now,
increasingly, natural gas). Wood supplied 70% of the fuel demand in 1870, in
1920 70% came from coal, in 1970 70% from mineral oil.
The use of renewable materials declined substantially with time, mainly as a
consequence of the extremely low prices of petrochemical resources. Currently,
approximately 96% of all organic chemical substances are based on fossil re-
sources. Nevertheless, several important industries are still based on renewable
raw materials. Half of the fiber used in the textile industry is natural material
(cotton, wool, flax), the oleo-chemical industry supplies society’s daily hygienic
needs for soaps and detergents that are based on vegetable oils. The building in-
dustry continues to use natural fiber for thermal insulation purposes. Petro-
chemistry does not always offer a realistic alternative to the use of renewable
materials. Classic examples are, for example, in the production of antibiotics
and of drugs where fermentation processes play an important role. Moreover,
industrial biotechnology frequently has further significant performance benefits
compared with conventional chemical technology, for example higher reaction
rates, increased conversion efficiency, improved product purity, reduced energy
consumption, and significantly reduced chemical waste generation. This branch
of biotechnology has recently been named “White Biotechnology”.
The penetration of bio-based product today is estimated at 5% with growth po-
tential up to 10–20% by the year 2010. The Vision for Bioenergy and Biobased
Products in the United States and the related Roadmap have established far reach-
ing goals for increasing the role of biobased energy and products in this country.
The oil crisis of the 1970s gave renewed impetus to the use of renewable re-
sources. The worlds increasing dependence on fossil resources, and the finite
availability of these, created serious concern. The concern was, however, largely
channeled in the direction of energy security. Renewable materials were less of
a concern and all attention disappeared when the oil price dropped. With in-
creasing awareness and concern in the 1990s about industrial and consumer
waste, and its effect on the environment, the need arose for better biodegrad-
able intermediates and final end products. Those products can naturally degrade
into components that are absorbed back into the natural cycle. Biodegradability
was the new key property of many new products and they were often based on
renewable resources, in view of their intrinsic biodegradability. With regard to
fossil reserves, the world is now faced with the dilemma that while crude oil is
being consumed faster than ever, “proven oil reserves” have remained mostly
unchanged. The cost of exploration and exploitation of crude oil increases,
which is reflected in increasing oil prices. In contrast with this, agricultural raw
materials such as wheat, corn, sugar, and oil crops are becoming cheaper as a
fundamental consequence of increasing agricultural efficiency and yield. This
12.3 Basic Principles 349
trend will most probably continue for some time to come. This long-term trend
may be perturbed by the transitory effects of market imbalances and politics
but for a growing number of applications the economic balance is tipping to-
ward the use of renewable resources; this is also true of bulk chemicals.
Process and catalysis technology revolutionized the chemical industry in the
20th Century. Now the same thing is happening for the production of industrial
chemicals from biomass. A wave of project initiatives is under way globally; the
objective of these is to convert renewable resources into industrial chemicals.
Industrial biotechnology uses biological systems in conjunction with existing
and new thermochemistry, for production of useful chemical entities. Biotech-
nology is mainly based on biocatalysis and bioprocessing (the use of enzymes
and cells to catalyze chemical reactions) and fermentation technology (directed
use of microorganisms), in combination with recent breakthroughs in the fore-
front of molecular genetics and metabolic engineering.
12.3
Basic Principles
12.3.1
Primary Conversion Technologies of Biomass
12.3.1.1 Gasification
Biomass can be converted into power plant fuel by gasification with high yield
and in an environmentally friendly fashion. Also, in the longer term, the eco-
nomics of this process look good, especially for energy crops. Gasification takes
place with air, at temperatures of approximately 850 8C. The gas consists of 13%
H2, 17% CO, 4% CH4, 12% CO2, 13% H2O, and 40% N2, which has a calorific
value of 6 MJ. In the 2040 scenario, 80 EJ a–1 could be produced from waste
streams and 200 EJ a–1 from energy crops, on a global scale. The removal of sul-
fur-containing components, tar, char, and ash from the gas is critical for use in
gas turbines and for methanol production. The technology is promising. Many
pilot plants are in operation, large installations are in the planning phase. The
gas could presumably also be used in Fischer–Tropsch synthesis.
12.3.1.2 Hydrothermolysis
During the period 1982–1993, the Royal Dutch Shell Laboratory developed a pro-
cess to convert biomass into liquid fuel, so-called bio-crude. This process is called
HTU (hydro-thermal upgrading). First, biomass is treated in an aqueous slurry at
200 8C and 30 bar, followed by a treatment at 330 8C and 200 bar. This process re-
sults in a bio-crude, an oil with a low oxygen content which can be further upgraded
by catalytic hydrodeoxygenation to a high-quality naphtha or diesel oil with very low
oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur content. The oil yield is approximately 40%, on the
basis of the biomass feed stock. Wood, agricultural, and domestic (green) waste
streams have been successfully used as feedstocks. According to Shell, this
HTU process is the cheapest route to liquid biofuels. Its cost price would be ap-
proximately $20–40 per barrel, compared with fossil crude oil today at approxi-
mately $12 per barrel. Hence, the process is not yet economical under the current
tax regime. This HTU process and many variants of this process lead directly to bio-
crude, from which known transport fuels and petrochemicals can be manufactured,
without the extra sulfur-removing steps, etc., which are necessary with fossil fuel.
12.4
Current Status
12.4.1
Europe
Hence, by saving fossil resources the use of RRM in industry directly contrib-
utes to sustainable development, recently endorsed by heads of States and Gov-
ernments at their summit in Gothenburg as one of the Community’s main po-
litical aims for the future.
It is felt that this industrial sector needs a more detailed presentation of its
situation and requirements, with a view to assessing what kind of action could
be taken at a Community level to increase its prospects.
12.4.2
United States
In the United States, strong motivation has developed in the past decade to re-
duce the nation’s dependence on imported oil and to increase its own energy
supplies by using a more diverse mix of domestic resources. In 1999 a presiden-
tial order triggered a series of initiatives for promotion of the use of renewable
12.4 Current Status 353
materials. The Biomass Research and Development Act of 2000 led to the estab-
lishment of the Biomass Research and Development Technical Advisory Com-
mittee, which issued the “Vision for Bioenergy and Biobased Products in the
United States” and the “Roadmap for Biomass Technologies in the United
States”.
Challenging long-term goals have been established that will dramatically
transform the role of biomass in the everyday lives of Americans. For produc-
tion of chemicals and materials from biobased products, these goals predict a
substantial increase from five percent of the current production of target US
chemical commodities in 2001 to 12 percent in 2010, 18 percent in 2020, and
25 percent in 2030. By 2030, a well-established, economically viable, bioenergy
and biobased products industry will create new economic opportunities for rural
America, protect and enhance the environment, strengthen US energy-indepen-
dence, provide economic security, and deliver improved products to consumers.
Biobased products are a major new market opportunity for domestically
grown biomass resources. It will be a new source of revenue not only for those
who produce the feedstocks but also for the farmers and others who are in-
volved in the production of biobased products. Continued research can signifi-
cantly increase opportunities for biobased products, expand existing markets,
and open entirely new markets. Current production of biobased textile fibers,
polymers, adhesives, lubricants, soy-based inks, and other products is estimated
at 12.4 billion pounds per year. Total production (biobased and non-biobased) is,
however, in the hundreds of billions of pounds. The growth opportunities for
biobased products are, therefore, enormous. As a result of advanced research,
new concepts in industrial biorefinery could become a reality. In the industrial
biorefinery, any combination of biofuels, electric power, materials, chemicals,
and other products could be produced from local biomass resources.
12.4.3
Products
new technologies and processes for converting plants into useful industrial in-
puts. For example, DuPont recently developed a biobased method that uses corn
instead of petroleum-based processes to produce a polymer platform for use in
clothing, carpets, and automobile interiors. Similarly, Cargill Dow’s biorefinery
in Blair, Nebraska is producing polylactide (PLA) polymers from corn sugar.
12.5
Industrial Concepts
12.5.1
Introduction
Total annual biomass production on our planet is estimated at 170 billion tons
and consists of approximately 75% carbohydrates (sugars), 20% lignin, and 5%
of other substances, for example oils and fats, proteins, terpenes, alkaloids, etc.
Of this biomass production, 6 billion tons (3.5%) are presently being used for
human needs, distributed as:
· 3.7 billion tons (62%) for human food use, possibly via animal breeding as an
intermediate step;
· 2 billion tons of wood (33%) for energy use, paper, and construction needs;
and
· 300 million tons (5%) to meet the human needs for technical (non food) raw
materials (clothing, detergents, chemicals, . . .).
refining, and energy. The case studies show that biotechnology not only reduces
costs but also reduces the environmental footprint for a given level of produc-
tion. Capital and operating costs are sometimes reduced by 10–50%. In others,
energy and water use were reduced by 10–80% and use of petrochemical sol-
vents was reduced by 90% or eliminated completely. There are several example
in which biotechnology enabled development of new products whose properties,
cost, and environmental performance could not be achieved by use of conven-
tional chemical processes or petroleum as a feedstock.
12.5.2
Biorefinery Concepts
cesses, although having much potential in the future, have been insufficiently con-
sidered. Thermochemical thermolysis, pyrolysis, and gasification are well known
technology for production of char, oil, and gases. Catalytic thermochemical conver-
sions technology is mostly undiscovered for production of complex molecules
from agricultural feedstocks. Fractionation technology is a preparation process in-
tended to separate agricultural materials into separate families using chemical and
physical methods. Industrial biotechnology, enzymatic technology, and thermo-
chemical conversion technology are complementary with each other for full valor-
ization of renewable feedstocks into a portfolio of value-added chemicals and of
energy. The whole chain of different process steps, each using very different tech-
nology can occur within an industrial complex. These are then referred to as “bior-
efineries” analogous to petrochemical crude oil refineries.
12.5.3
Classes of Bioproduct
The many different industrial bioproducts produced today can be divided into
four major categories.
· Sugar and starch bioproducts derived by fermentation and thermochemical
processes include alcohols, acids, starch, xanthum gum, and other products
derived from biomass sugars. Primary feedstocks include sugarcane, sugar
beet, corn, wheat, rice, potatoes, barley, grain. and wood.
· Oil and lipid-based bioproducts including fatty acids, oils, glycerin, and a vari-
ety of vegetable oils derived from soy, canola, sunflower, or other oil seeds.
12.5 Industrial Concepts 357
· Wood chemicals include tall oil, alkyd resins, rosins, pitch, fatty acids, lignin,
turpentine, and other chemicals derived from trees.
· Cellulose derivatives, fibers, and plastics, including products derived from cel-
lulose, including cellulose acetates (cellophane) and other cellulose deriva-
tives.
12.5.4
Opportunities for Industrial Bioproducts
Polyethylene 48
Polypropylene 23
Poly(vinyl chloride) 26
Poly(ethylene terephthalate) 13
Polystyrene 14
Butadiene/co-polymers 8
Phenolic resins 5.5
Polyamides 4
The other major organic chemicals markets for bioproducts include organic
acids, alcohols, and solvents. Biomass-based ethanol is an established industry,
with other emerging markets for other alcohols and bio-derived acids.
Lubricants and greases were originally plant based but are now mostly petro-
leum-based. Increasing energy prices and growing environmental concerns over
the impact of petroleum-based products are supporting the entrance back in the
market of vegetable oil-based lubricants and greases.
12.5.5
Product Categories Based on C6-Carbon Sugars to Bioproducts
Biomass sugars are the most abundant renewable resource available. Many of
the products used today, for example citric acid, ethanol, and lactic acid are pro-
duced by fermentation. With a vast range of microorganisms available and
being discovered and exploited, the fermentation of sugars has great potential
for the future. Two types of sugar are present in biomass – six-carbon sugars or
hexoses, of which glucose is the most common, and five-carbon sugars or pen-
toses, of which xylose is most common. The most promising glucose derivatives
include lactic acid, succinic acid, butanol, 3-hydroxypropionic acid, 1,3-propane-
diol, and polyhydroxyalkanoates. Lactic acidderivatives include poly(lactic acid)
polymer, ethyl lactate solvent, acrylic acid, propylene glycol, and pyruvic acid.
Succinic acid derivatives include tetrahydrofuran (THF), 1,4-butanediol (BDO),
c-butyrolactone (GBL), and N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP). 3-Hydroxypropionic
acid derivatives include acrylic acid, acrylonitrile, and acrylamide.
12.5.6
Product Categories Based on C5-Carbon Sugars to Bioproducts
Pentose sugars such as xylose have thus far been an untapped resource. The
microorganisms currently available prefer glucose to pentose. By developing mi-
croorganisms that convert pentose sugars alone or in combination with glucose,
the overall economics of biobased products can be improved by enabling full
12.5 Industrial Concepts 359
12.5.7
Thermochemical Conversion of Sugars to Bioproducts
per pound) is prohibitive for large-scale applications. Levulinic acid can be pro-
duced from lignocellulose material such as paper mill sludge, paper and wood
solid waste, and agricultural residues applying high temperature dilute-acid hy-
drolysis. The manufacturing cost for levulinic acid using such technology has
the potential to be reduced to below $ 0.50 per pound. Important chemicals de-
rived from levulinic acid include methyltetrahydrofuran (MTHF), d-aminolevuli-
nic acid (DALA), and diphenolic acid (DPA).
MTHF can be blended with gasoline up to 70% by volume without adverse
engine performance or reduced mileage. MTHF will have to complete with bio-
ethanol to penetrate the transportation fuel market. DALA is the active chemical
in a new group of herbicides and pesticides. DPA is an alternative to bisphenol
A which is used in polymers such as polycarbonates and as a comonomer in
phenolic resins. Other potential derivatives of levulinic acid include tetrahydro-
furan, 1,4-butanediol, c-butyrolactone and N-methylpyrrolidone.
Thermochemical xylose derivatives include ethylene glycol, propylene glycol,
and glycerol. High hemicellulose content agricultural fiber waste can be hydro-
lyzed to xylose and other C5 sugars.
12.5.8
Thermochemical Conversion of Oils and Lipid Based Bioproducts
The fatty acid methyl ester of soybean oil is an excellent biobased solvent. It is
produced by transesterification of soy oil with methanol, resulting in a mixture
of soy fatty acid methyl esters. Methyl soyate-based biobase solvents have been
introduced commercially in recent years. They match or even surpass the per-
formance of some conventional solvents while being cost-competitive. Methyl
soyate has superior solvent properties, is readily biodegradable, and has a low
toxicity compared with other common chemicals.
The diversity of structure and inherent functionality of vegetable oils make
them prime candidates for use in polymers and resins. The fatty acid chain in ve-
getable oils, which is hydrocarbon in nature, can be transformed with a spectrum
of traditional and breakthrough chemistries to yield high-performance products
with desirable properties. The chemistry being considered to modify and functio-
nalize vegetable oils includes transesterification, epoxidation, hydroformylation,
and metathesis. Transesterification and epoxidation are already being used to
modify soy oil for use in industrial products. Hydroformylation and metathesis
are well developed for use on petroleum feedstocks. The challenge will be to de-
velop similar catalyst systems that are effective and efficient on vegetable oils.
12.5.9
Bioproducts via Gasification
gen fuel cells. It can also be converted to valuable chemicals and liquid fuels.
Methanol can be produced from syn-gas. Methanol is a versatile and key start-
ing compound for production of several chemicals, for example acetic acid, for-
mic acid, higher alcohols, MTBE, methyl chloride, methylamines, formaldehyde,
or dimethyl ether. The methanol to olefins route (MTO) seems an interesting
future route for production of propylene and ethylene which, in turn, are used
to produce polyethylene, polypropylene, and other bulk components, for exam-
ple propylene oxide and its derivatives. Ethanol can also be produced from syn-
gas and this might become a cost-effective alternative to the sugar fermentation
route. Fischer–Tropsch chemistry is another approach for converting syn-gas to
valuable chemicals and fuels. The chemicals that can be produced include paraf-
fins, monoolefins, aromatics, alcohols, aldehydes, ketones, and fatty acids.
12.5.10
Bioproducts via Pyrolysis
12.5.11
Biocomposites
Over the past few decades, high performance composites have replaced metals
in some applications, and wood in many applications. Biobased materials have
the potential to replace one or both parts of composite systems thereby main-
taining or improving performance. Plant fibers are very ductile and do not
splinter, producing panels that are more shatter-resistant than traditional com-
posites made with wood flour or sawdust. Fibers that could be used include ke-
naf, jute, sisal, coir, flax, and straw.
12.6
Outlook and Perspectives
and societal advantages from the development of this new resource base. The
appropriate mix of research and development and technology development, in
combination with market and public policies, can support the development and
the demonstration of viable chemicals, intermediates, and materials, in combi-
nation with fuels, heat, and power supply. The impetus for new bio-products
will continue to come from favorable government policies, the implementation
of bio-refineries, and the desire to reduce the need for and dependence on im-
ported oil. Perhaps the greatest factor driving the growth of bio-products will be
acceptance by the public, business enterprises, and governments that biomass
can provide a solution to some of the most pressing global resource problems.
The impact of the bio-industry on rural development and economics has not yet
been quantified, but could be impressive. Development of a bio-industry will re-
quire increased production and processing of bio-mass and could provide a
boost to rural areas. It could create new income for farmers and foresters. De-
velopment of a larger bio-industry would require new processing, distribution,
and logistics, and new service industries. This could potentially result in posi-
tive economic impacts on rural economic growth in many parts of the world.
Using plants as feedstock instead of petroleum or natural gas can potentially
reduce the amount of carbon dioxide emitted to the atmosphere. Globally, ap-
proximately 62 Gigatons of carbon are taken-up by plants annually in photo-
synthesis. Producing chemicals and industrial products from biomass directly
reduces the associated carbon released during the production of fossil-based
products.
References
Ashford, Robert D., Ashford’s Dictionary of “Current situation and future prospects of EU
Industrial Chemicals, 2nd Edition, (Wave- industry using renewable raw materials”,
length Publications Ltd., London, 2001) European Renewable Resources and
“Affordable Resins and Adhesives from Opti- Materials Association (EERMA), Brussels,
mised Soybean Varieties”, US Department 2002
of Energy, Industrial Technologies Pro- Deamin, A. L., Small bugs, big business: The
gram Fact Sheet, May 2002 economic power of the microbe, Biotechnol-
ACS Symposium Series 742: Lignin: Histor- ogy Advances 18 (2000) 499–514
ical, Biological, and Materials Perspectives, “Developing and Promoting Biobased Products
W. G. Glasser, R. A. Northey and T. P. and Bioenergy”, ordered by William J. Clin-
Schultz, 1999, ISBN 0-8412-3611-9 ton, U.S. President, August 1999 (White
Barger, Paul. Methanol to olefins (MTO) and House, 1999)
beyond. Catalytic Science Series 2002, 3 M. Sasaki, Z. Fang, Y. Fukushima, T. Ad-
(Zeolites for Cleaner Technologies), 239– schiri, K. Arai, Dissolution and Hydrolysis
260. of Cellulose in Subcritical and Supercritical
Biomass Research and Development Act of Water, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2000, 39,
2000, http://www.bioproducts-bioenergy.- 2883–2890
gov/bio_act.html Eggersdorfer, M.; Meyer, J. Eckes, P.; Use of
Bioprocessing, Reaping the Benefits of Renew- renewable resources for non-food materials;
able Resources, Chemical Week, February FEMS Microbiology Reviews 103 (1992)
11, 2004 355–364.
References 365
367
13
Succinic Acid – A Model Building Block
for Chemical Production from Renewable Resources
Todd Werpy, John Frye, and John Holladay
13.1
Introduction
The U.S. currently produces about 10 billion bushels of corn annually, with
about 20%, or 2 billion bushels, processed by either wet or dry milling. Approxi-
mately 550–600 million bushels of the processed corn are used to produce etha-
nol. The remainder is processed to produce food and non-food products.
While corn wet milling has been practiced since the mid 1800s, significant
technology advancements have continued to improve processing efficiency and
bring about a substantial reduction in water usage and energy requirements.
The corn wet milling process consists of seven major unit operations: 1) corn
cleaning and inspection, 2) steeping, 3) grinding, 4) germ separation, 5) fiber
separation, 6) starch and protein separation, and 7) downstream processing.
The major components from corn wet milling include corn oil (1.5 pounds
per bushel), corn gluten meal (2.6 pounds per bushel 60% protein), corn gluten
feed (13.5 pounds per bushel – 20% protein), and starch (32 pounds per bush-
el). Corn oil is extracted from the germ, refined and used to produce finished
oil. Corn gluten feed is produced from combining the fiber fraction with the
steep water followed by drying, and is sold primarily as animal feed. Corn glu-
ten meal is derived from the protein fraction, and is also sold as animal feed.
The starch is recovered and converted by several processes to produce various
starch products. The starch is also enzymatically hydrolyzed and used as a feed-
stock to produce products such as high fructose corn syrup, ethanol, lactic acid,
lysine, citric acid, and a variety of other fermentation products. However,
through further technology advancements, additional valuable products can be
derived from corn processing operations.
Several new technologies are under development for the production of value
added chemicals from starch. This is driven by the desire to expand the capacity
at existing corn processing facilities and for improving the overall economics of
the integrated biorefinery. The integrated biorefinery is defined here as a facility
producing both fuels and chemicals. Specific products currently under develop-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
368 13 Succinic Acid – A Model Building Block for Chemical Production from Renewable Resources
ment or in various stages of commercialization include lactic acid for the produc-
tion of polylactic acid, direct hydrogenolysis of sorbitol for the production of pro-
pylene glycol and ethylene glycol and the production of polyols for polyurethanes.
The product targets have been established because of the potential economic at-
tractiveness and synergistic fit with the existing corn wet milling infrastructure.
One of the major considerations for the development of new technologies that
can be utilized in a corn wet mill for the production of new chemical products
is the concept of platform building blocks. This concept is based on the fact that
a single building block has the potential to create a significant number of final
products. Succinic acid represents a building block that can be used as a start-
ing material for producing a large number of commodity and specialty chemi-
cals. Succinic acid itself is derived via the fermentation of both C6 and C5 su-
gars. The derivatives of succinic acid can be obtained via a variety of catalytic
processes, primarily hydrogenation. Succinic acid and potential derivatives of
succinic acid are represented in the “starburst” diagram below (Fig. 13.1).
13.2
Economics of Feedstock Supply
The major feedstock from corn wet milling to be utilized for the production of
fuels and chemicals is starch. Starch costs are estimated to be in the range of
$0.05–0.06 per pound. The cost of starch is based on the overall corn wet
milling process and the co-product value associated with the oil, corn gluten
feed, and corn gluten meal. The actual starch cost depends on both the specific
corn wet mill and the size of the mill. Corn pricing has remained essentially
constant over the past several decades. The average annual corn price over the
past 10 years has been $2.37/bushel.
13.3 Succinic Acid Fermentation 369
The fiber fraction of corn (5.5 pounds per bushel) is another feedstock oppor-
tunity that represents a low cost source of five carbon sugars, xylose and arabi-
nose, that could be used as a fermentation feedstock. Corn fiber is currently
sold as part of corn gluten feed, and the value of the feed is on the order of
$0.05 per pound. The real value in corn gluten feed is the protein, and the fiber
is primarily used as a carrier for the protein.
The economics of the fermentation of glucose to succinic acid are driven by a
number of key factors including sugar costs, yield of succinic acid from sugar,
media costs and productivity. Within these technical challenges the two major
issues are the development of an organism that can use a minimal media and
improving the overall productivity. The minimal media requirement is that a
low cost media such as corn steep liquor can be the sole source of nutrients. It
is also essential that the productivity be high enough that the capital costs do
not become dominant in the economics. Initial economic analysis has shown
that the productivity requirements be on the order of 2–3 g L–1 h–1. The chal-
lenge in developing a competitive process for the production of succinic acid
and its derivatives is developing a fermentation process that can produce succin-
ic acid at a cost structure comparable to the cost of maleic anhydride from bu-
tane. This cost structure must allow for purification costs of succinic acid as
well as the overall cost of the fermentation. The economics of the catalytic
transformations are competitive with the catalytic conversion of maleic anhy-
dride.
13.3
Succinic Acid Fermentation
lism, making such organisms unsuitable for industrial use [1 a, 2 a]. This results
in low final titers which adds to production and separation costs.
A second challenge is media cost. Often expensive nutrients found in yeast
extract are required. These might include tryptophan, cysteine, methionine bio-
tin, folic acid, thiamine, riboflavin, and various others [1c]. Niacin may be the
important yeast extract component as the organism must regenerate NAD rap-
idly to achieve the required productivity levels. The cost of fermentation nutri-
ents can have substantial effect on production costs.
A third challenge is production of co-products such as acetic acid or pyruvic
acid [1 c]. These co-products result in lower titers of desired products and must
be removed if additional catalytic upgrading of succinate is to be done.
A fourth challenge is the narrow pH range under which bacterial microorgan-
isms can operate. The required neutral conditions for maintaining succinate
production (usually between pH 5.8–7.2) [1 a], necessitates base neutralization.
Common bases include ammonia or sodium or potassium hydroxide. Thus the
actual fermentation product is not succinic acid but rather the ammonium, so-
dium or potassium salt. Acidification can represent of to 30% of the total cost
of organic acid production.
The patent literature provides examples of relatively high succinate concentra-
tions produced at neutral pH. Examples of three microbial variants developed
by MBI are given in Table 13.1. The data was obtained from shake flask experi-
ments using a peptone, yeast extract, glucose medium [1 b].
The final titer for succinate approached and even surpassed 90 g L–1. How-
ever, substantial amounts of either acetate or pyruvate were co-produced.
Furthermore, the nutrient concentrations, even for the “low nutrient” conditions
were substantial. It is interesting to note that the organism that gave low acetate
had an increased production of pyruvate.
Organism FZ 6 was selected for further evaluation using various nutrient
conditions. Results are shown in Table 13.2. Increasing the corn steep liquor
concentration had a dramatic effect on the final titer, whereas increasing the
yeast extract concentration had only a moderate effect. Examples with lower
yeast extract were not provided.
“Low” 10 5 84.9 92
“Medium” 15 5 93.4 94
“High” 10 15 90.4 82
The high producing succinate strain FZ 21, was also examined in a 1 L fer-
menter using 15 g L–1 yeast extract, corn steep liquor, MgCO3 (for pH control)
and glucose. The succinate yield was 78%. Results are shown in Fig. 13.2.
Other groups have also been involved in strain development. Strains devel-
oped at Argonne have been demonstrated on more complex carbohydrate
streams. For example they have used industrially produced rice straw hydroly-
sate (Arkenol, Inc.) with Difco yeast extract (5 g L–1), tryptone (10 g L–1) as well
as various buffers. Figure 13.3 shows data for the consumption of the two major
Fig. 13.2 Succinate production with time (Reproduced from US Patent 5,573,931).
372 13 Succinic Acid – A Model Building Block for Chemical Production from Renewable Resources
13.4
Succinic Acid Catalytic Transformations
products that can be produced from succinic acid, or more appropriately from dia-
mmonium succinate (DAS) is N-methylpyrrolidinone (NMP).
13.5
Current Petrochemical Technology
13.5.1
1,4-BDO, THF, GBL, and NMP
Several catalytic technologies have been developed in the past for the production
of 1,4-BDO from petroleum based resources. Early technology development in-
cluded a two step process based on Reppe chemistry. The first step in the pro-
cess is the conversion of acetylene and formaldehyde to produce primarily 1,4-
butynediol. The second step is the catalytic hydrogenation of 1,4-butynediol to
1,4-BDO. The 1,4-BDO produced can be dehydrated to produce THF.
A second well know technology is the Lyondell propylene oxide based process.
This process utilizes propylene oxide as the starting material and converts PO
to allyl alcohol via isomerization. The allyl alcohol is converted to 4-hydroxybu-
tyraldehyde via hydroformylation with CO and H2. The final step is the hydro-
genation of the aldehyde to produce 1,4-BDO.
374 13 Succinic Acid – A Model Building Block for Chemical Production from Renewable Resources
A third process utilizes butadiene as the starting material. In this process, buta-
diene is reacted with acetic acid and oxygen to produce the intermediate 1,4-dia-
cetoxy-2-butene and water. The 1,4-diacetoxy-2-butene is then hydrogenated over
a catalyst to form the saturated intermediate which is then hydrolyzed to pro-
duce 1,4-BDO.
The process developed by Huntsman employs a catalyst for the direct oxidation
of butane to maleic anhydride. Maleic anhydride is then reacted with methanol
to produce dimethyl maleate. The dimethyl maleate is hydrogenated to produce
1,4-BDO.
The final process is the process developed by BP Amoco and Lurgi. The process
is also based on the direct oxidation of butane to maleic anhydride. This process
differs from the Huntsman process in that the maleic anhydride is directly re-
duced over a catalyst to produce THF.
It is currently believed that this is the low cost technology for THF production.
All of these technologies are described in more detail in the open literature and
the patent literature [6].
The production of THF can be achieved from any of the technologies that
produce 1,4-BDO. In one form or another BDO or one of its precursors is dehy-
drated to yield THF. The overall yield is generally greater than 90%.
GBL is produced by the cyclic dehydrogenation of 1,4-BDO. The majority of
GBL produced is used for the production of N-methylpyrrolidinone (NMP). In
13.6 Current Biobased Technology 375
the process to produce NMP, GBL is converted in a three stage liquid phase
process. The reaction is carried out by reacting GBL with methylamine and
water. After reaction the final NMP produce is recovered via distillation with
methylamine and water being recycled back to the process.
13.6
Current Biobased Technology
13.6.1
1,4-BDO, GBL, and NMP
There is extensive patent literature regarding the conversion of maleic acid and
succinic acid to produce 1,4-BDO, THF, GBL and NMP, the bulk of this work
has been developed utilizing petrochemical feedstocks as the starting material. There
has been a relatively low level of effort on the direct aqueous phase catalytic con-
version of bio-derived succinic acid to value added products. The remainder of this
chapter will describe work at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory on the cataly-
sis of converting succinic acid and diammonium succinate and describe some of
the unique challenges associated with fermentation derived starting materials.
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory has developed a series of supported
metal catalysts for the highly selective, aqueous phase hydrogenation of succinic
acid to GBL. The basic catalysts materials consist of an active form of palladium
on a specific carbon support. Selection of the carbon support with the appropri-
ate surface chemistry and porosity is critical in achieving highly selective cata-
lysts. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory has demonstrated that an active pal-
ladium on carbon can afford yields of GBL greater than 95%. The reaction is
carried out in either a batch mode or in a continuous mode. Operating tempera-
tures are on the order of 150–175 8C with pressures ranging from 800–2000
psig. The weight percent of succinic acid can range from 5–25%.
An important aspect of this technology development is that during the fer-
mentation of glucose to produce succinic acid, acetic acid is often seen as one
of the co-products. The technology developed at Pacific Northwest National Lab-
oratory is selective in the hydrogenation of succinic acid in the presence of
acetic acid, to the point that none of the acetic acid is hydrogenated to ethanol.
This has important economic implications in that acetic acid could be recovered
as a co-product and that selective reduction of succinic acid without the reduc-
tion of acetic acid reduces the total consumption of hydrogen.
A second element of this work relates to the production of 1,4-BDO. In an at-
tempt to maximize the yields of 1,4-BDO, a process was developed in which
GBL produced by hydrogenation of succinic acid is separated via distillation.
The purified GBL is then catalytically hydrogenated over bimetallic catalysts
supported on carbon. The bimetallic include nickel and palladium coupled with
rhenium. These catalysts have afford selectivity greater than 95% to 1,4-BDO
376 13 Succinic Acid – A Model Building Block for Chemical Production from Renewable Resources
from GBL. Operating temperatures range from 150–200 8C with hydrogen pres-
sures ranging from 1000 to 2000 psig.
13.6.2
Derivatives of Diammonium Succinate
As has been described previously succinic acid from the fermentation is an ex-
cellent building block for the production of industrially important chemical in-
termediates. One of the challenges with the fermentation is that neutralization
is required which leads to significant downstream processing to convert the suc-
cinic acid salt back to the free acid. One strategy for deriving products from suc-
cinic acid fermentations is to identify products that can be obtained directly
from the salts. One route that affords the economical production of chemicals
from diammonium succinate is the formation of 2-pyrrolidone (2P) and N-
methylpyrrolidone (NMP). In addition to 2P and NMP, derivatives such as N-vi-
nyl-2-pyrrolidone can also be produced. The reaction chemistry for these prod-
ucts is shown in Fig. 13.5.
2-Pyrrolidone can be produced by the direct hydrogenation of aqueous diam-
monium succinate with hydrogen in the presence of an active metal catalyst [7].
A mixed product of NMP and 2P can be produced from the conversion of DAS
in the presence of methanol and an active metal catalyst. Figure 13.6 shows the
results of converting aqueous DAS in the presence of methanol and hydrogen
over a supported rhodium catalyst. Conversion for this reaction is near 100%
with a yield of NMP of about 50% and a yield of 2P of about 30%. The remain-
der of the product is a polymer of 2P. It is interesting to note the formation of
N-methylsuccinimide in the early part of the reaction, which converts to NMP
as the reaction proceeds. Once 2P is formed it essentially remains during the
course of the reaction as shown in Fig. 13.6.
13.7
Conclusions
The fermentation of glucose and other sugars derived from biomass for the pro-
duction of succinic acid provides a valuable building block for the production of
industrially important chemicals. There are still several challenges before com-
mercialization will be realized. The first major hurdle is the need for further
cost reductions in the fermentation of glucose to succinic acid. The specific cost
barriers include reducing the media requirements so that a low cost nutrient
source such as corn steep liquor could be used, improving the volumetric pro-
ductivity of the organism and ultimately a low pH fermentation. From a process
perspective, reducing the cost of separation/purification would have a signifi-
cant overall economic impact. With respect to catalysis, the overall yields for the
conversion of succinic acid and diammonium succinate to commercially impor-
tant chemical intermediates needs to be demonstrated on a longer term contin-
uous basis which will prove that the catalyst lifetime is commercially viable.
In general, the potential for biobased products to replace or displace existing
petrochemical routes to value added products continues to move closer to com-
mercialization. Overcoming a broad range of technical barriers in fermentation,
separations and catalysis will be critical to the realization of economically viable
biobased products from renewals.
References
1 (a) Guettler, M. V.; Jain, M. K.; Soni, B. K. methods of obtaining the microorgan-
US Patent 5,723,322; March 3, 1998 isms.” (e) Ponnampalam E. US Patent
(Michigan Biotechnology Institute). “Pro- US Patent 6,284,904; Sep 4, 2001 (Michi-
cess for making succinic acid, microor- gan Biotechnology Institute). “Purifica-
ganisms for use in the process and tion of organic acids using anion ex-
methods of obtaining the microorgan- change chromatography.” (f) Berglund,
isms.” (b) Guettler, M. V.; Jain, M. K.; K. A.; Elankovan P.; Glassner, D. A. US
Rumler, D. US Patent 5,573,931; Nov 12, Patent 5,034,105; July 23, 1991 (Michigan
1996 (Michigan Biotechnology Institute). Biotechnology Institute). “Carboxylic acid
“Method for making succinic acid bacte- purification and crystallization process.”
rial variants for use in the process, and 2 (a) Donnelly, M. I.; Sanville-Millard, C. Y.;
methods for obtaining variants.” (c) Nghiem, N. P. US Patent 6,743,610; June
Guettler, M. V.; Jain, M. K. US Patent 1, 2004 (The University of Chicago).
5,521,075; May 28, 1996 (Michigan Bio- “Method to produce succinic acid from
technology Institute). “Method for mak- raw hydrolysate.” (b) Donnelly, M. I.;
ing succinic acid, Anaerobiospirillum Millard, C. S.; Stols, L. US Patent
succiniciprodens variants for use in pro- RE37,393; Sep. 25, 2001 (The University
cess and methods for obtaining vari- of Chicago). “Mutant E. Coli strain with
ants.” (d) Guettler, M. V.; Jain, M. K.; increased succinic acid production.” (c)
Soni, B. K. US Patent 5,504,004; April 2, Donnelly, M. I.; Sanville-Millard, C.;
1996 (Michigan Biotechnology Institute). Chatterjee, R. US Patent 6,159,738; Dec.
“Process for making succinic acid, mi- 12, 2000 (The University of Chicago).
croorganisms for use in the process and “Method for construction of bacterial
References 379
strains with increased succinic acid pro- 7 Frye Jr., J. G.; Zacher, A. H.; Werpy, T. A.;
duction.” (d) Nghiem, N. P.; Donnelly, Wang, Y. “Catalytic Preparation of Pyrro-
M.; Millard, C. S.; Stols, L. US Patent lidones from Renewable Resources” in
5,869,301; Feb 9, 1999 (Lockhead Martin Catalysis of Organic Reactions, Sowa Jr.,
Energy Research Corporation). “Method J. R. Ed; Taylor and Frances, Boca Raton
for the production of dicarboxylic acids.” 8 Werpy, T. A.; Frye, Jr, J. G.; Wang, Y.; Za-
3 Gorkan, R. R.; Eiteman, E. US Patent cher, A. H. U.S. Patent 6,706,893; March
6,455,284, Sep. 24, 2002. (The University 16, 2004 (Battelle Memorial Institute)
of Georgia Research Foundation). “Meta- “Methods of Making Pyrrolidones”
bolically engineered E. Coli for enhanced 9 Werpy, T. A.; Frye, Jr. J. G,; Wang, Y.; Za-
production of oxaloacetate derived bio- cher, A. H. U.S. Patent 6,670,483; De-
chemicals.” cember 30, 2003 (Battelle Memorial In-
4 Okino, S.; Inui, M.; Yukawa, H. Poster stitute) “Methods of Making Pyrroli-
at the Biotechnology for Fuels and dones”
Chemicals Conference, 2003. 10 Werpy, T. A.; Frye, Jr, J. G.; Wang, Y.; Za-
5 Chang, H. N.; Chang, Y. K.; Kwon, S. H.; cher, A. H. U.S. Patent 6,632,951; Octo-
Lee, W. G.; Lee, P. C.; Yoo, I. K.; Lim, S. J. ber 14, 2003 (Battelle Memorial Insti-
US Patent 6,596,521; July 22, 2003 (Ko- tute) “Methods of Making Pyrrolidones”
rea Advanced Institute of Science and 11 Werpy, T. A.; Frye, Jr, J. G.; Wang, Y.; Za-
Technology). “Method for manufacturing cher, A. H. U.S. Patent 6,603,021; August
organic acid by high efficiency continu- 15, 2004 (Battelle Memorial Institute)
ous fermentation.” “Methods of Making Pyrrolidones”
6 See for example Kirk–Othmer Encyclope-
dia of Chemical Technology, 2005 on-line
edition.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
381
14
Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
Patrick Gruber, David E. Henton, and Jack Starr
14.1
Introduction
In today’s world of green chemistry and concern for the environment, polylactic acid
(PLA) is interesting. One hundred percent of the carbon in PLA originates from
carbon dioxide in the atmosphere. PLA has very versatile properties, giving it
the ability to compete in a wide variety of markets, and it is economical. The types
of lactic acid used to make the polymer combined with the length of polymer chain,
and the extent of branching control the versatility of PLA. The stereoisomers of lactic
acid required for PLA can only be produced economically by bioprocesses. PLA also
rapidly degrades in the environment under composting conditions and the bypro-
ducts are of very low toxicity, eventually being converted to carbon dioxide and water.
PLA is an interesting combination, it performs well, is economical, and it is “green”.
Polylactic acid (PLA) is a rigid thermoplastic polymer that can be semi-crystal-
line or totally amorphous, depending on the stereochemical purity of the poly-
mer backbone. l-(–)-Lactic acid (2-hydroxypropionic acid) is the natural and
most common form of the acid, but d-(+)-lactic acid can also be produced by
microorganisms or by racemization and this “impurity” acts much like co-
monomers in other polymers such as poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) or poly-
ethylene (PE). In PET, diethylene glycol or isophthalic acid is copolymerized
into the backbone at low levels (1–10%) to control the rate of crystallization. In
the same way, d-lactic acid units are incorporated into l-PLA to optimize the
crystallization kinetics for specific fabrication processes and applications.
PLA is a unique polymer that in many ways looks like PET, also a polyester,
but also performs much like polypropylene (PP), a polyolefin. It may eventually
be the polymer with the broadest range of applications because of its ability to
be stress crystallized, thermally crystallized, impact modified, filled, co-polymer-
ized, and processed in most polymer processing equipment. It can be formed
into transparent films or injection molded into blow-moldable preforms for bot-
tles, similar to PET. PLA also has excellent organoleptic characteristics and is ex-
cellent for food contact and related packaging applications.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
382 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
14.2
Lactic Acid
14.2.1
Lactic Acid Production Routes
14.2.1.2 Fermentation
The fermentation of lactic acid by humans is very old, as shown in the produc-
tion of yogurt and other foods. In the last hundred years, people have mastered
the fermentation and purification of lactic acid for food and industrial use. The
anaerobic fermentation of sugars to produce lactic acid is the main commercial
route. Fermentation can provide either l-lactic acid or d-lactic acid with a chiral
purity near 100%. The exact chiral purity if the lactic acid formed depends on
the characteristics of the microorganism used for fermentation. Current lactic
acid production by fermentation is limited to the small number of companies
listed in Table 14.1.
There are numerous other smaller lactic acid manufacturers, particularly in
China, that are not listed here. Virtually all lactic acid manufacturers have some
affiliation with a company that provides the sugar feedstock for the lactic acid
fermentation. There has been a large increase in the worldwide lactic acid ca-
pacity in the last decade as the PGLA-1, B&G, and Cargill Dow plants have all
started up production between 1998 and 2004. All three of these plants have
been the result of joint ventures. Another joint venture between Dupont and
ConAgra, named EcoChem, was established in the early 1990s to produce lactic
acid. EcoChem closed down the manufacturing plant in 1994 because of pro-
duction problems. Cargill Dow has the largest single plant at a declared capacity
of 400 million lbs per year. Virtually all the lactic acid produced at the Cargill
Dow facility is used internally for the production of lactic acid-based polymers.
Cargill Dow does sell lactide, a six-membered ring consisting of two lactic acid
moieties that can be easily converted back to lactic acid, by addition of water, or
to other chemical derivatives. For the other seven manufacturing plants listed in
Table 14.1, for which the main applications are the food and industrial markets,
the declared capacities range from 20 million to 100 million lbs per year.
14.2.2
Production by Fermentation
14.2.2.1 Microorganisms
Several microorganisms are able to produce lactic acid in an economically viable
process. There is probably no perfect microorganism because each company
and geographic location has different sugar sources, nutrient availability, and
separation technology. For instance, a Lactobacillus microorganism needs low-
cost nutrients like corn steep liquor, but this system may result in higher sepa-
ration costs to produce a high purity product. Alternatively, the use of Rhizopus
with a defined medium may produce lower yields, but the lower separation
costs of a relatively clean broth could make it viable.
Although there are numerous microorganisms that can make lactic acid, Ta-
ble 14.3 lists the genus of three microorganisms that have the characteristics of
a commercially viable lactic acid-producing microorganism. The characteristics
listed for each genus are generalizations from the literature. Given the diversity
within each genus, it is likely that a strain exists that is contrary to the general-
ized characterization listed here. Producers regard their specific production
strain as part of their competitive advantage.
Area Purpose
14.2.2.3 Nutrients
The choice of nutrients depends on the production microorganism. Complex
nutrients that are typically used would be corn-steep liquor and yeast extract
paste. These are available commercially from several suppliers. Most microor-
ganisms require various salts, particularly ammonium phosphate, and vitamins.
If a complex nutrient is used, it may provide much of the microorganism’s salt
and vitamin needs. Salt and vitamins may need to be supplemented into the
media as the amount of complex nutrient decreases.
14.2.3
Acidification
The fermentation area produces a lactate salt, because the fermenters operate at
near neutral pH. The acidulation area of the plant needs to convert the lactate
salt to lactic acid. There are two main options for the acidification – strong acid
addition and salt-splitting.
Carbon dioxide is a weak acid when it dissolves into water as carbonic acid. The
carbonic acid can provide a proton to acidify a small fraction of the lactate salt.
This sequence of chemical reactions is shown below.
As the solution becomes acidic, the system reaches an equilibrium. The lactic
acid must be removed from the aqueous phase to achieve high conversion to
lactic acid. Cargill solved this problem by extracting the lactic acid into an
amine-based solvent [6].
14.2.4
Purification
over residual sugars and nutrients, but does not provide good separation from
acidic impurities.
The forward extraction of the lactic acid into the solvent phase is performed at
relatively low temperatures to help increase the distribution of the lactic acid into
the solvent. The lactic acid is released from the amine and the solvent phase by
back extracting the lactic acid into an aqueous solution at high temperatures. A
process flowsheet for this solvent extraction process is shown in Fig. 14.2.
Solvent exchange can be integrated with salt-splitting operations such as those
described above with carbon dioxide. The solvent extraction acts as a second
phase to help drive the salt splitting reaction to high conversion. Solvent extrac-
tion could also be used to sequester the lactic acid when vaporizing the ammo-
nia from ammonium lactate.
Distillation of Lactate Ester The distillation of lactic acid can be difficult, be-
cause it can form lactic acid oligomers, require high temperatures, and low
pressures. By reacting lactic acid with an alcohol, such as ethanol, to form a lac-
tate ester, many of the issues with the distillation of lactic acid can be avoided.
High-purity lactic acid can be obtained by this process as multi-stage distillation
has the potential to separate other carboxylic acids. A simplified process flow-
sheet with ethanol as the alcohol is shown in Fig. 14.3.
The alcohol must be recycled in the process which adds complexity. The water
and the alcohol have higher vapor pressures than ethyl lactate, so they preferen-
tially go into the vapor phase compared with the lactate ester. Thus ethanol
must be recycled back to the esterification reactor and water must be removed
from the system to drive the esterification reaction to high conversions. Re-
390 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
14.3
PLA Production
14.3.1
Polymerization of Lactide
Many catalyst systems have been evaluated for polymerization of lactide, includ-
ing complexes of aluminum, zinc, tin, and lanthanides. Even strong bases such
as metal alkoxides have been used with some success. Depending on the cata-
lyst system and reaction conditions, almost all conceivable mechanisms (cation-
14.3 PLA Production 393
ic [11], anionic [12], coordination [13], etc.) have been proposed to explain the ki-
netics, side reactions, and nature of the end groups observed in lactide polymer-
ization. Tin compounds, especially tin(II) bis-2-ethylhexanoic acid (tin octoate),
are preferred for bulk polymerization of lactide, because of their solubility in
molten lactide, high catalytic activity, and low rate of racemization of the poly-
mer. Conversions > 90% with less than 1% racemization can be achieved while
providing polymer with high molecular weight.
The polymerization of lactide using tin octoate is thought to occur via a coor-
dination–insertion mechanism [13] with ring opening of the lactide to add two
lactyl units (a single lactide unit) to the growing end of the polymer chain, as
shown schematically in Fig. 14.7. The tin catalyst facilitates the polymerization,
but hydroxyl or other nucleophilic species are the actual initiators. There are
usually several hundred ppm of hydroxyl impurities in the lactide from water,
lactic acid, and linear dimers and trimers.
High molecular weight polymer, good reaction rate, and low levels of racemi-
zation are obtained with tin octoate catalyzed polymerization of lactide. Typical
conditions for polymerization are 180–210 8C, tin octoate concentrations of 100–
1000 ppm, and 2–5 h to reach 95% conversion. The polymerization is first-order
in both catalyst and lactide. Hydroxyl-containing initiators such as 1-octanol are
frequently used to both control molecular weight and accelerate the reaction.
In addition to the work performed on catalysts and comonomers, a significant
amount of work has been devoted to designing the optimum polymerization
process from a cost and versatility perspective. Most of this work has used lac-
tide dimer as the starting point. Batch polymerization and continuous processes
can be used. Continuous processes (Fig. 14.6) have a cost and productivity ad-
vantage and thus are the focus of most work. Stirred tank or pipe reactors have
been evaluated alone and in combination. Because of the low energy of the
ring-opening polymerization and the potential to obtain high rates of polymer-
ization, melt extruders have been extensively evaluated as reactors to produce
PLA. Several groups have reported or patented specific aspects of the use of ex-
truders or combinations of several reactor concepts to produce PLA [14–27].
Dupont [15] recognized the importance of high rates of lactide polymerization
on the economic viability of using extruders. They investigated the issues sur-
rounding hydroxyl initiators, catalysts, and acidic impurities. Dupont’s patent
[15] (US 5,310,599) provides examples showing the dramatic (negative) effect of
acidic impurities, such as the linear dimer (DP2), etc., on the rate of lactide po-
lymerization. The acid impurities coordinate with the tin catalyst and render it
ineffective as a ring-opening site of polymerization. As an example, 389,000
MW PLA can be made with a 5-min residence time (6000 : 1 monomer:Sn octo-
ate) at 180 8C in the absence of acidic impurities and 98% conversion is ob-
tained. The conversion in 5 min drops to 50% when the impurty:catalyst ratio is
2:1 and to 12% in 5 min if the ratio is 6:1.
The rate of polymerization of lactide can be accelerated by use of hydroxyl ini-
tiators such as butanol or by higher catalyst loading. Increased initiator levels
will, however, reduce the molecular weight while more catalyst will reduce the
thermal stability and increase the color of the PLA.
14.4
Control of Crystalline Melting Point
PLA is a hard, brittle plastic which can exist in either the amorphous or semi-
crystalline state, depending on the stereochemistry and thermal history. Com-
mon physical properties such as density, heat capacity, and mechanical and rhe-
ological properties are very dependent on its transition temperatures. For amor-
phous PLA, the glass transition (Tg) determines the upper use temperature for
most commercial applications. For semi-crystalline PLA, both the Tg (*58 8C)
and melting point (Tm), 130–230 8C, (depending on structure) are important for
determining the usage temperatures for different applications. Both of these
transitions, Tg and Tm, are highly affected by overall optical composition, pri-
mary structure, thermal history, and molecular weight. Several excellent reviews
have been written which include details of the properties and characteristics of
PLA [28–32].
Having two optical arrangements for lactic acid (l-lactic acid, d-lactic acid),
and three optical arrangements for lactide (l-lactide, d-lactide, meso-lactide), the
variety of primary structures available for PLA is substantial. In addition, many
other monomers have been copolymerized with lactic acid and/or lactide, a top-
ic which will not be covered in this chapter. Techniques for measuring PLA
stereo-sequences by NMR have been published by Thakur et al. [33].
The most common commercial polymers of PLA are optical copolymers of
predominantly l-lactide, with small amounts of d- and meso-lactides, made by
bulk polymerization with tin octoate catalyst by ring-opening polymerization
(ROP). Although these copolymers are usually described as random, there is
evidence of some stereo selectivity. The selectivity of tin octoate is discussed by
Thakur et al. [34]. Condensation polymerization of, mostly, l-lactic acid with
small amounts of d-lactic acid, polymerized in solution, has also been used.
The optical comonomers introduce “kinks” in PLA’s natural helical conforma-
tion and “defects” in the crystal arrangement, which results in depression of the
melting point, reduction in the level of attainable crystallinity, and reduction in
14.4 Control of Crystalline Melting Point 395
the rate of crystallization. Optical purity (OP) is common nomenclature for de-
scribing polymers of this variety. As OP decreases, crystallization eventually be-
comes impossible and the polymer is amorphous (occurring about when OP
<0.78). For the purposes of this chapter, the designation a-PLA will be used for
PLA made with insufficient optical purity to crystallize, and c-PLA will be used
to denote PLA that are crystallizable. Stereo-selective catalysis has been used to
develop optical copolymers with a highly tapered concentration of optical purity
(OP) along the chain [35].
Random copolymers made from meso-lactide result in an atactic primary
structure referred to as poly(meso-lactide) and are amorphous. Random optical
copolymers made from equimolar amounts of d-lactide and l-lactide are com-
monly referred to as PDLLA or poly(rac-lactide). PDLLA is also essentially atac-
tic, but the primary structure is segregated into optical doublets of the lactyl
group, and it is also amorphous.
For l-rich polymers with small amounts of d- and meso-lactides, there is an
observed decrease in the equilibrium melting point with decreasing OP. At least
two possible explanations for this have been considered. In one extreme case it
is assumed that the optically impure units are incorporated into the crystal
structure as defects. This results in a decreasing melting point (Tm), because of
the decrease in the enthalpy of fusion. In the other extreme case it is assumed
that the optically impure units are rejected from the crystal structure, causing a
reduction in Tm because of entropy effects. Runt [36] studied the degree of crys-
tallinity, spherulitic growth rate, lamellar thickness, and melting temperature of
a series of optical copolymers of this variety, comparing the effects of d-lactide
and meso-lactide optical impurities. Small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) results
showed that lamellar thickness decreases with decreasing OP at a given degree
of super cooling. It was proposed that a critical sequence length that is free of
stereo defects is necessary for crystallization, and that the stereo defects are ex-
cluded from the crystalline regions. In a study by Munson et al. [37] it was
shown that, at least for long crystallization times, a certain fraction of optical
impurity (in this case, a small percentage of labeled l-lactide copolymerized into
a polymer of predominantly d-lactide) is incorporated into the crystal lamellae.
Munson went on to develop a model for determining the fraction of crystalliz-
able PLA based upon a critical chain length necessary for crystallization that en-
ables stereo defects to be included in the crystalline region if they are sur-
rounded by a sufficient isotactic run length. The spherulite structure for l-lac-
tide-rich PLA was studied by Pyda et al. [38] using AFM and polarized light mi-
croscopy.
The observed melting point by DSC after isothermal treatment at the crystalli-
zation temperature Tc has been studied as a function of crystallization tempera-
ture for a series of poly(l-lactide-co-d-lactide)s [36]. Experimental equilibrium
melting points for a series of l-lactide-rich polymers are shown in Fig. 14.8.
During normal processing and crystallization procedures, polymers do not
reach their equilibrium melting temperature. A practical equation describing
melting point for PLA of predominantly l-lactide with meso-lactide is simply
396 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
Tm ( 8C) & 175 8C 300wmeso, where wmeso is less than 0.18 [28]. The melting
point is depressed by approximately 3 8C for every 1% initial meso-lactide.
An enthalpy of fusion of 93.1 J g–1 is used for 100% crystalline PLLA or
PDLA homopolymers (i.e. DHm8 = 93.1 J g–1) [39] having infinite crystal thick-
ness. However, because Tm8 decreases with decreasing OP, it is expected that
using a constant value for DHm8 across all optical compositions will introduce
error. It is well known that for PLA of essentially random optical copolymers of
predominantly l-lactide, with small amounts of d- and meso-lactides, the attain-
able percentage crystallinity (xc) decreases with decreasing optical purity (OP),
and crystallization is essentially non-existent about when OP < 0.78.
The crystallization kinetics of PLA are highly dependent on the optical copoly-
mer composition and molecular weight. The degree of crystallinity, nucleation rate,
and spherulite growth rate decrease substantially with decreasing optical purity
(OP). Kolstad showed that under quiescent crystallization conditions the bulk crys-
tallization half-life increases by roughly 40% for every 1% w/w increase in meso-lac-
tide [40]. PLA has the highest rate of crystallization between 100 and 130 8C.
14.5
Rheology Control by Molecular Weight and Branching
thermoforming and foams. The time scales of these processes are very different.
Considerations for material flow characteristics, orientation and crystallization
must be made to gauge and predict the resulting properties of the products
made from these processes. Intrinsic factors affecting the flow characteristics of
PLA are molecular weight distribution, degree and type of branching, optical
composition, optical block length distributions, and melt stability.
14.5.1
Melt Rheology of Linear PLA
14.5.2
Melt Rheology of Branched PLA
14.5.3
Branching Technology
14.6
Melt Stability
Issues related to PLA melt stability during processing and rheological testing
have been cited by Witzke [28], Dorgan [42], Ramkumar [55], and Feng [56]. Re-
actions leading to poor melt stability include chain scission, because of hydroly-
sis, chain scission because of thermal instability, and lactide formation by the
well documented “back biting” mechanism. Hydrolysis can be reduced or essen-
tially eliminated with conventional drying operations in which water is removed
before melting. Recommended drying conditions are available for commercial
PLA. When PLA is exposed to a humid environment after drying, moisture is
quickly absorbed into the polymer up to its equilibrium level of swelling. Ki-
netics for melt hydrolysis depend on water concentration, acid or base catalysis,
and polymerization catalyst concentration.
The proton in the CH group of the main chain of PLA is labile. It has been
suggested that the proximity of this labile proton to the ester group affects the
thermal sensitivity of the polymer [55]. The proton can be abstracted, resulting
in the breakdown of the molecular chain. In practical extrusion processes, ther-
mal stability becomes important at temperatures greater than 250 8C.
Using PLA polymerized with tin octoate catalyst, Cicero, et al. [57] showed
that the melt stability of PLA can be improved by addition of small amounts of
tris(nonylphenyl) phosphite (TNPP), probably as a result of balancing chain ex-
tension with degradation reactions. Addition of TNPP during rheological testing
greatly stabilized the polymer, and increased the time available for testing.
The thermodynamic equilibrium between polylactide and lactide monomer
varies with temperature, and is about 4.3% lactide at 210 8C [28]. Because lactide
imparts undesirable characteristics, for example fuming, during processing, it is
desirable to depress the lactide-formation kinetics and stabilize the polymer.
Gruber et al. [58] showed that lactide formation could be substantially reduced
400 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
14.7
Applications and Performance
PLA resins can be tailor-made for different fabrication processes, including in-
jection molding, sheet extrusion, blow molding, thermoforming, film forming,
or fiber spinning. The key is controlling molecular properties in the process, for
example branching, d isomer content, and molecular-weight distribution. The
ability to selectively incorporate l-, d- or meso-lactide stereoisomers into the poly-
mer backbone enables PLA to be tailored for specific applications. The ease of
incorporation of various defects into PLA enables control of both crystallization
rate and ultimate crystallinity.
Typical properties of NatureWorks PLA from Cargill Dow LLC for injection
molding and extrusion applications are shown in Table 14.4. The various grades
of NatureWorks PLA differ in stereochemical purity, molecular weight and addi-
tive packages. Each grade is optimized for both processing and end-use perfor-
mance in its intended application.
Physical properties
Specific gravity (g cc–1) 1.25 D792 1.21 D792
Melt index, g/10 min (190 8C/ 4–8 D1238 10–30 D1238
2.16 kg)
Clarity Transparent Transparent
Mechanical properties
Tensile strength at break, psig 7700 (53) D882 7000 (48) D638
(MPa)
Tensile yield strength, psig (MPa) 8700 (60) D882
Tensile modulus, kpsig (GPa) 500 (3.5) D882
Tensile elongation (%) 6.0 D882 2.5 D638
Notched izod impact, ft-lb in–1 0.24 (0.33) D256 0.3 (0.16) D256
(J m–1)
Flexural strength, psig (MPa) 12,000 (83) D790
Flexural modulus, kpsig (GPa) 555 (3.8) D790
14.8
PLA Stereocomplex
Blends of PLA optical copolymers also have a variety of new properties. The
most notable is that of the stereocomplex PLA, which is made by solvent or
melt blending PLLA and PDLA and in which the polymers undergo stereocom-
plexation or racemic crystallization. This phenomenon has been an area of in-
tense study since first described by Ikada [60]. PLA stereocomplex is expected to
open markets in consumer electronics, automobile manufacturing, and other
durable goods, because of excellent heat stability combined with relatively low
cost and other benefits such as PLA’s inherent flame retardency and biodegrad-
ability.
PLA stereocomplex occurs when PLLA is mixed with PDLA and the homo-
polymer segments co-crystallize into a new arrangement with a markedly higher
melting point. The interesting features of the stereocomplex crystal will be dis-
cussed later. Tsuji and Ikada [61] reported that the Tg of stereocomplex PLA is
5 8 higher than that of the non-blended components. The equilibrium melting
temperature of PLA stereocomplex has been reported by Tsuji to be 279 oC [62],
a very marked improvement over homocrystals, with the minimum tacticity se-
quencing needed to produce stereocomplex for the l-rich and d-rich PLA to be
15 lactyl (or 7.5 lactide) units [63]. The heat of fusion for pure stereocomplex
has been determined to be 142 J g–1 by Loomis [64]. This was attributed to the
strong interaction between the l-lactyl and d-lactyl unit sequences in the amor-
phous region of the blends, resulting in a more dense chain packing.
Melting points for stereocomplex are dictated by the optical purity (OP) of
both the l-lactide-rich and d-lactide-rich polymers (in terms of optically pure
run lengths) and molecular weight and blend ratio. Maximum regularity is at-
tained with a blend of PLLA and PDLA. The greater the deviation in OP of the
l-rich and/or d-rich chains, the greater the decrease in stereocomplex melting
peak. This follows the equivalent behavior of PLA homocrystals, but is shifted
to higher temperature. A practical upper attainable melting temperature that
would be achievable for commercial resins approaches 230 oC.
Melting point (Tm) and enthalpy of melting (DHm) of the stereo complex de-
pends on the ratio of l-lactide-rich polymer and d-lactide-rich polymer. For a
constant optical purity of racemic polymers, the Tm varies only by a few degrees
across the possible blend ratios, whereas the stereocomplex DHm varies directly
402 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
with the blend ratio with maximum at 1:1. Tsuji et al. have published an excel-
lent series of papers on the crystallization, mechanical behavior and hydrolysis
properties of PLA stereocomplexes [65–76].
14.9
Fossil Resource Use and Green House Gases
PLA made today in Blair, Nebraska, uses corn as the feedstock, natural gas to
heat the manufacturing process, and coal fired electricity. Vink et. al., have pub-
lished a life-cycle inventory (LCI). This LCI indicates that PLA production gener-
ated 56% less greenhouse gas emissions than production of polyester. Yet, even
though PLA uses fixed carbon dioxide from the atmosphere as the carbon
source, it still contributes 1.2 kg CO2 kg–1 PLA to greenhouse gases because of
the use petrochemical energy sources to heat and operate the manufacturing
plant.
Integrated into a lignocellulosic biorefinery PLA production is a carbon diox-
ide sink at –0.3 kg CO2 kg–1 PLA while using traditional sources of electricity.
The advantage of 1.5 kg CO2 kg–1 PLA is because of the displacement of natural
gas by lignin as the fuel source to heat the manufacturing process. With im-
provements in “green” sources of electricity, PLA would even be a greater sink
at –1.7 kg CO2 kg–1 PLA.
14.10
Summary
Because all of the carbon of PLA originates from carbon in the atmosphere, it
is regarded a renewable resource-based material. This, combined with useful
material properties and processability, makes it attractive.
PLA takes advantage of a biological system to perform chemistry that tradi-
tional production techniques cannot perform efficiently. Fermentation of sugar
to lactic acid produces chiral lactic acid in high yield. Not only does bioproces-
sing and fermentation provide chiral lactic acid, it does it inexpensively while
conforming to the principles of Green Chemistry. Control of chirality enables
producers to change the polymer performance by changing the optical activity
of the lactic acid units in the polymer backbone. The result is a family of prod-
ucts, all made from lactic acid, with properties that can reach the wide range of
applications previously discussed. It is not possible, with all the technology
known today, to economically produce commercially useful PLA from petro-
chemical feedstocks. Production of PLA depends on bio-based sources of lactic
acid because the stereo-isomer content must be controlled.
PLA is currently produced using corn as a feedstock. The corn-based sugar
raw material can account for approximately 25–40% of the total cost of PLA. To-
day PLA made from corn is competitive with traditional petrochemical-based
Abbreviations 403
Abbreviations
References
13 Nijenhuis, A. J., Du, Y. J., Van Aert, 32 Hartmann, M. H., High molecular
H. A. M. and Bastiaansen, C., Macromole- weight polylactic acid polymers, in: Bio-
cules, 28, 2124, 1995. H. R. Kricheldorf, I. polymers from Renewable Resources,
Kreiser-Saunders, and C. Boettcher, Poly- Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 367-411.
mer, 36(6), 1253, 1995. 33 Thakur, K. A. M., Kean, R. T., Hall, E. S.,
14 Feijen, J., J. Applied Polymer Science, 62, Doscotch, M. A., Munson, E. J., A quanti-
1295, 1996. tative method for determination of lac-
15 US Patent 5,310,599, 1994. tide composition in poly(lactide) using
16 Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Degee Ph., Du- 1H NMR, Analytical Chemistry, 69, 4303,
bois, Ph. and Jerome, R., Polymer, 41, 1997.
3395, 2000. 34 Thakur, K. M., Kean, R. T., Hall, E. S.,
17 Schmack, G., Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Kolstad, J.J., Munson, E. J., Stereochemi-
Vogel, R., Tandler, B. and Beyreuther, R., cal aspects of lactide stereo-copolymeri-
Journal of Biotechnology, 86, 15, 2001. zation investigated by 1H NMR: A case
18 Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Degee Ph., Du- of changing stereospecificity, Macromole-
bois, Ph., and Jerome, R., Journal of Poly- cules, 31, 1487, 1998.
mer Science, 37, 2413, 1999. 35 Spassky, N., Wisniewski, M., Pluta, C.,
19 Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Degee Ph., Du- Le Borgne, A., Highly stereoselective po-
bois, Ph., and Jerome, R., Industrial lymerization of rac-(d,l)-lactide with a
Crops and Products, 11, 265 2000. chiral Schiff’s base/aluminum alkoxide
20 Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Degee Ph., Du- initiator, Macromolecular Chemistry and
bois, Ph., and Jerome, R., Macromol. Physics, 197, 2627, 1996.
Symp., 144, 289, 1999. 36 Baratian, S., Hall, E. S., Lin, J. S., Xu, R.,
21 Jacobsen, S., Fritz, H. G., Degee Ph., Du- Runt, J., Crystallization and solid-state
bois, Ph., and Jerome, R., Macromol. structure of random polylactide copoly-
Symp., 153, 261, 2000. mers: poly(L-lactide-co-D-lactide)s, Macro-
22 T. Fukushima, Intern. Polymer Processing, molecules, 34, 4857, 2001.
XV, 4,2000. 37 Zell, M. T., Padden, B. E., Paterick, A. J.,
23 R. Miyoshi, Intern. Polymer Processing, Hillmyer, M. A., Kean, R. T., Thakur,
XI, 4, 1996. K. A. M., Munson, E. J., Direct observa-
24 Miyoshi, R., et al., U.S. Patent 5,574,129, tion of stereodefect sites in semicrystal-
1996. line poly(lactide) using 13C solid-state
25 Narayan, R., et al., U.S. Patent 5, NMR, Journal of the American Chemical
906,783, 1999. Society, 120, 12672, 1998.
26 Reichert, D., et al., U.S. Patent 38 Pyda, M., Buzin, A., Wunderlich, B.,
5,378,801, 1995. Bopp, R. C., Morphology of poly(lactic
27 Jansson, K., Koskinen, J., and Selin, J.-F., acid) by AFM and calorimetry, Proceed-
U.S. Patent 6,214,967, 2001. ings of the NATAS Annual Conference on
28 Witzke, D.R. Introduction to Properties, Thermal Analysis and Applications, 30th,
Engineering, and Prospects of Polylactide 463, 2002.
Polymer, Ph.D. thesis, Chemical Engi- 39 Fischer, E. W., Sterzel, H. J., Wegner, G.,
neering, Michigan State University, Investigation of the structure of solution
1997. grown crystals of lactide copolymers by
29 Garlotta, D., A literature review of poly means of chemicals reactions., Kolloid
(lactic acid), J. of Polym. and the Environ- Zeitschrift & Zeitschrift fuer Polymere, 251,
ment, 9, 63, 2002. 980, 1973.
30 Tsuji, H. and Ikada, Y., Physical proper- 40 Kolstad, J. J., Crystallization kinetics of
ties of polylactides,. Current Trends in poly(L-lactide-co-meso-lactide, Journal of
Polymer Science, 4, 27, 1999. Applied Polymer Science, 62, 1079, 1996.
31 Tsuji, H. Polylactides, in: Biopolymers 4 41 Janzen, J., Dorgan, J. R., Knauss, D. M.,
Polyesters III Applications and Commercial Hait, S. B., Limoges, B. R., Fundamental
Products., Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Ger- solution and single-chain properties of
many, 2002, chap. 5.
406 14 Polylactic Acid from Renewable Resources
Macromolecular Chemistry and Physics, 70 Tsuji, H., Hyon, S. H., Ikada, Y., Stereo-
197, 3483, 1996. complex formation between enantio-
63 Tsuji, H. and Ikada, Y., Stereocomplex meric poly(lactic acids). 5. Calorimetric
formation between enantiomeric poly- and morphological studies on the stereo-
(lactic acid)s. XI. Mechanical properties complex formed in acetonitrile solution,
and morphology of solution-cast films, Macromolecules, 25, 2940, 1992.
Polymer, 40, 6699, 1999. 71 Tsuji, H., Horii, F., Nakagawa, M., Ika-
64 Loomis, G. L. and Murdoch, J. R., Poly- da, Y., Odani, H., Kitamaru, R., Stereo-
lactide stereocomplexes, Polymer Prepr. complex formation between enantio-
31, 55, 1990. meric poly(lactic acid)s. 7. Phase struc-
65 Okihara, T., Kawaguchi, A., Tsuji, H., ture of the stereocomplex crystallized
Hyon, S. H., Ikada, Y., Katayama, K., Lat- from a dilute acetonitrile solution as
tice disorders in the stereocomplex of studied by high-resolution solid-state car-
poly(L-lactide) and poly(D-lactide), Bulle- bon-13 NMR spectroscopy, Macromole-
tin of the Institute for Chemical Research, cules, 25, 4114, 1992.
Kyoto University, 66, 271, 1988. 72 Tsuji, H. and Ikada, Y., Stereocomplex
66 Tsuji, H., Horii, F., Hyon, S. H., Ikada, formation between enantiomeric poly-
Y., Stereocomplex formation between en- (lactic acid)s. 6. Binary blends from co-
antiomeric poly(lactic acid)s. 2. Stereo- polymers, Macromolecules, 25, 5719,
complex formation in concentrated solu- 1992.
tions, Macromolecules, 24, 2719, 1991. 73 Tsuji, H. and Ikada, Y., Stereocomplex
67 Okihara, T., Tsuji, M., Kawaguchi, A., formation between enantiomeric poly-
Katayama, K., Tsuji, H., Hyon, S. H., Ika- (lactic acids). 9. Stereocomplexation from
da, Y., Crystal structure of stereocomplex the melt, Macromolecules, 26, 6918, 1993.
of poly(L-lactide) and poly(D-lactide), 74 Tsuji, H., Ikada, Y., Hyon, S. H., Kimura,
Journal of Macromolecular Science, Phys- Y., Kitao, T., Stereocomplex formation
ics, 30, 119, 1991. between enantiomeric poly(lactic acid).
68 Tsuji, H., Hyon, S. H., Ikada, Y., Stereo- VIII. Complex fibers spun from mixed
complex formation between enantio- solution of poly (D-lactic acid) and poly
meric poly(lactic acid)s. 3. Calorimetric (L-lactic acid), Journal of Applied Polymer
studies on blend films cast from dilute Science, 51, 337, 1994.
solution, Macromolecules, 24, 5651, 1991. 75 Tsuji, H., In vitro hydrolysis of blends
69 Tsuji, H., Hyon, S. H., Ikada, Y., Stereo- from enantiomeric poly(lactide)s part 1.
complex formation between enantio- Well-stereocomplexed blend and non-
meric poly(lactic acid)s. 4. Differential blended films, Polymer, 41, 3621, 2000.
scanning calorimetric studies on precipi- 76 Tsuji, H. and Suzuki, M. In vitro hydro-
tates from mixed solutions of poly(D-lac- lysis of blends from enantiomeric poly-
tic acid) and poly(L-lactic acid), Macro- (lactide)s. 2. Well-stereocomplexes fiber
molecules, 24, 5657, 1991. and film, Sen’i Gakkaishi, 57, 198, 2001.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
409
15
Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
Thomas C. Kripp
15.1
Introduction and Historical Outline
15.1.1
Cosmetics Past and Present
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
410 15 Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
15.1.2
Bionics: Learning from Nature
15.2
Betaine, The Conditioner Made from Sugar Beet [3]
15.2.1
Occurrence
Betaine was first discovered as a component of sugar beet (Beta vulgaris) more
than a hundred years ago. Betaine (trimethylglycine) has an important role in
life-sustaining systems in Nature. It is present throughout the ecosystem, in mi-
15.2 Betaine, The Conditioner Made from Sugar Beet 411
15.2.2
Chemical Properties
15.2.3
Production
In the first stage of sugar production, betaine and sugar (saccharose) are ex-
tracted from the crushed beet by dissolution in hot water. Betaine is a white
substance and after physical purification of the sugar up to 5% betaine is pres-
ent in the remaining molasses. Further clean-up, e.g. by chromatographic sepa-
ration on industrial columns, is necessary for separation of the betaine. It is fi-
nally recrystallized repeatedly from pure water.
15.2.4
Use and Fields of Application
Betaine is used in foods, for instance as an additive in energy drinks and food-
stuffs, and as a flavor enhancer in seafood. Many vitamin mixtures for humans
and for animals contain betaine. It is approved as a dietary supplement in a
variety of countries.
In acid solution betaine has a positive charge; in other words it has a cationic
character. In hair care, cationic compounds are used to improve the combability
of damaged hair. The mode of action is as follows. Hair suffers oxidative dam-
age as a result of a variety of effects, for example sun and sea water, e.g. during
a seaside holiday, but also as a result of different kinds of treatment. The result
is accumulation of negatively charged groups on the hair surface. This negative
charge enables deposition of positively charged – i.e. cationic – compounds,
which improve the properties of the hair surface (Fig. 15.3).
Examples of such cationic compounds are long-chain alkyltrimethyl ammo-
nium salts. These so-called cationic surfactants may be replaced by betaine in
special formulations of hair rinses and deep-conditioning products. Because
conventional cationic surfactants also act as emulsifiers, a formulation contain-
ing betaine must also include – in addition to an acid – an emulsifier system to
regulate the viscosity, which fortunately also enhances the conditioning effect of
15.2 Betaine, The Conditioner Made from Sugar Beet 413
the product. Wella has obtained patents [10] for this kind of formulation and
they have been successfully used in hair-care products for many years.
An interesting discovery was made when the skin tolerance of betaine prod-
ucts was investigated. Not only were betaine-containing skin-cleansing lotions
well tolerated by the skin, they even proved to have a smoothing effect on the
skin compared with formulations without betaine.
Proof of the good skin tolerance is provided by the elbow washing test
(Fig. 15.4) according to P. Frosch. The products (one with betaine and one with-
out betaine) were each tested on a person with sensitive skin. The products
were applied one to the right and one to the left arm (crook of the elbow) of
one person twice daily on five consecutive days under standardized conditions.
The results were impressive – see the photos of the test person.
15.2.5
Innovation Through Combination: Betaine Esters
The cationic surfactants mentioned in the previous paragraph are usually also
quaternary ammonium compounds which are known to be biologically “hard”,
that is they do not biodegrade easily. By using betaine derivatives, however, it is
possible to manufacture hair conditioners based on biologically “soft” surfac-
tants [11]. The chemical structure of betaine contains a cationic group and an
anionic acid group, depending on the pH value. The group with a positive
charge, responsible for the excellent substantivity to hair, makes the molecule
readily soluble in water. A surfactant molecule, however, also has a hydrophobic
part to make it “feel at home” in both worlds – those of water and oil – and to
make it able to mediate between them. By applying appropriate methods a so-
called “hydrophobic chain” of any length can be attached to the acid group by
linking the betaine to a fatty alcohol. Chemically speaking, this is an ester bond
that forms when an acid combines with an alcohol with elimination of water.
The structural formulas (Fig. 15.5) of betaine esters and “normal” cationic sur-
factants are very much alike.
There is, however, a difference that has far-reaching consequences. It is pre-
cisely the reaction by which the betaine ester was formed that can – under cer-
tain conditions – take a reverse course to form the original materials. A wel-
come property of this class of substance is the fairly good stability of the ester
bonds in acid media, for example in a hair conditioner, whereas at neutral or,
especially, alkaline pH the bonds are quickly cleaved. Thus it is possible to for-
Fig. 15.5 Structures of a normal cationic surfactant (a) and of a betaine ester (b).
15.3 Chitosan, Hair-setting Agent from the Ocean 415
15.2.6
Summary and Prospects
15.3
Chitosan, Hair-setting Agent from the Ocean [15]
15.3.1
Chitin, a Precursor of Chitosan
Carbohydrates are the most abundant class of organic substance on earth. The
most common carbohydrate is cellulose, a polymer of glucose, and it forms the
skeletal structure of most plants. Among the nitrogenous polysaccharides, chi-
tin, a polymer of acetylglucosamine, is most important (Fig. 15.6). Like cellu-
lose, its role in nature is that of a skeletal and membrane substance. It does,
however, not occur in higher plants but rather in lower plant life and inverte-
brates, the arthropods, in different amounts. The term “chitin” is derived from
the Greek word “chiton” which means “armor” [16].
The properties of chitosan and its production from chitin are described below;
chitosan also occurs in several lower fungi, e.g. Mucor rouxii.
15.3.2
Occurrence of Chitin (Fig. 15.6)
15.3.3
Production
Chitin and cellulose have similar structures, the difference being that in chitin
the hydroxy group on the C-2 atom is replaced by an acetylamino group. The acet-
ylglucosamine units are connected through b-glycoside linkages (Fig. 15.9).
Chitin is insoluble in water, dilute acid, dilute alkalis, alcohol, and other or-
ganic solvents. It dissolves in concentrated hydrochloric acid or methanesulfonic
acid, although with partial cleavage of the biopolymer.
Fig. 15.8 Deacetylation of chitin to chitosan and its protonation by salt formation.
418 15 Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
teins or the hair keratin, are negatively charged, which enables interaction with
the positively charged chitosan.
15.3.4
Chitosan in cosmetic products
The positive charge of chitosan (in an acid solution) is the cause of its substan-
tivity (i.e. its ability to become attached to the hair, especially damaged hair),
which improves the combability, luster, and feel of the hair (Fig. 15.10). Wella
has obtained patents [22] in many countries for use of chitosonium salts in hair
conditioners and special-formulation shampoos.
As early as in 1976, Wella researchers discovered that chitosonium salts were well
suited as film-forming agents in hair-setting products, and chitosan has been suc-
cessfully used in Wella products ever since. The biopolymer has several advantages
over synthetic polymers. It contains no harmful monomers or by-products from
polymerization, the polymer films do not tend to become tacky, even at high relative
humidity, and the concentrations required to achieve a firm hold are relatively low.
These properties are particularly useful in setting mousses. The quality of a
setting product is expressed in terms of its ability to retain curl in hair strands.
An uncomplicated method (hair relaxation or curl retention test, Fig. 15.11) is
used to show that curl retention in hair swatches treated with a chitosan setting
product is significantly better than in swatches treated with other products, and
the more so for untreated hair.
In this test the relaxation of swatches of curled hair, that is the change in
length of the swatches, is measured over a period of time and the results are re-
laxation curves characteristic of the product applied to the wound hair. The
comparison criteria are “no product applied”, “chitosan setting product applied”,
and “non-chitosan setting product applied”. Although after four hours at a rela-
tive humidity of 30% there is not much difference in relaxation, the results vary
widely at 70% relative humidity. Curl retention by swatches treated with a chito-
san setting product is far better than by the other samples.
The water-retentive properties of films based on chitosonium salts depend on
the acid used for neutralization. The so-called water vapor sorption is deter-
mined from the difference in weight of the films at 30% and at 65% relative hu-
midity. Comparison with the results obtained with hyaluronic acid, a moistur-
izer frequently used for skin-care products indicates that some chitosonium
salts have similar effects (Fig. 15.12).
Many other uses of chitosan in cosmetics have been suggested in the relevant
patent literature. The potential uses proposed for chitosan include coating of
cosmetic pigments, and as a skin-protecting agent and moisturizer in cosmetic
products [23–26]. Chitosonium salts have also been proposed for oral hygiene
purposes to prevent dental caries and halitosis [27].
It is also possible to use chitosan as a basis of ingredients of other products.
The free NH2 and OH groups shown in the graphic formula can be derivatized
under suitable conditions, which enables its properties to be tailored to the in-
tended use. Qualities such as solubility, substantivity, conditioning, and film-
forming properties, etc., can be adapted to suit the most diverse needs
(Fig. 15.13). Although such derivatives are no longer pure natural substances (a
definition is given in Section 15.4.1), the fact that most of the molecule has
been “borrowed” from Nature enables their classification as “renewable raw ma-
terials” with all their well-known advantages.
15.3 Chitosan, Hair-setting Agent from the Ocean 421
15.3.5
Summary and Prospect
The natural substances chitin and chitosan have been known for a long time.
Professor Joseph Nagyvary from Texas goes so far as to argue that Stradivari
was the first to discover the biopolymer – he is said to have used chitosan ob-
422 15 Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
tained from crushed dragonfly wings as the varnish for his violins. It is, how-
ever, in the past 25 years that, because of its structure and its properties, chito-
san has proved a versatile raw material.
The polymer is an excellent basis for synthesis of customized materials for
the most diverse applications. Depending on the type and position of substi-
tuents the products may be incorporated into hair and skin-care products. The
growing volume of the patent literature indicates that the number of cosmetic
and non-cosmetic uses of chitosan and its derivatives will continue to increase
in years to come.
15.4
From Energy Reserve to Shampoo Bottle: Biopol [28]
15.4.1
Biodegradable Packages
its origin, this definition only concerns the question of whether the substance
flows through biological metabolism. As an example, salicylic acid is basically
a natural substance, even if a sample of it is produced by synthesis instead of
by extraction from wicker bark. The food industry has coined the term “na-
ture-identical” for synthetically produced natural substances.
· Renewable material. A substance which is obtained fully or at least chiefly
from biomass, including after chemical modification, when the resulting
product is not found in animated nature. Examples include nitrocellulose,
made from cellulose, and fatty acid methyl ester (“biodiesel”), made from veg-
etable oil. The resulting products are not known to be present in animated
nature, but they are based mainly on renewable materials.
15.4.2
What is “Biopol”?
When food is abundant, each living organism uses specific substances as energy
reserves. Whereas humans and animals deposit surplus nutritional energy mostly
in the form of body fat, plants also use carbohydrates, in particular starch. The seed
pods of plants, in particular, are rich in carbohydrates and fats, the energy supply
used by the germinating seedling. Although these two classes of substance are cer-
tainly the most important for energy storage, others are used for the purpose, espe-
cially in microorganisms. Many bacteria form polyhydroxy-b-alkanoate, PHA
(Fig. 15.14), as reserve or food-storage material which provides carbon and energy
when needed. Its monomer constituents include b-hydroxybutyric acid, hydroxyva-
leric acid, and lactic acid. The linear polymer poly-b-hydroxy butyric acid (PHB) is
accumulated within the cell in the form of grains or granules and it plays a pro-
minent part among the polyhydroxyalkanoic acids. It is a chloroform-soluble poly-
ester with an average of 60 (up to 25,000) units of hydroxybutyric acid.
15.4.3
Biodegradability of Biopol
15.4.4
The Long Way to the Shampoo Bottle
Many problems had to be solved on the way from the first discovery of the bio-
polymer to its use as a packaging material. The first PHB samples obtained by
mechanical processing were dirty brown in color, mainly because of impurities
in the biomass. It was, in particular, the vacuole membranes of the bacteria that
impaired the appearance and mechanical properties of the new raw material.
Initially it was not possible to re-melt the biopolymer, although it is a thermo-
plastic, which meant that leftovers from the production of shampoo bottles were
useless waste. The material was very brittle, difficult to print on using commer-
cial processes, was of limited availability, and above all was very expensive.
All these problems, except the high price in comparison with petroleum-
based polymers, were solved within approximately six years. Optimization of the
fermentation conditions and of the isolation and purification methods made the
product increasingly cleaner. The technological features improved with progress
in lightening the color. Specific fermentation conditions were chosen to produce
not pure polyhydroxybutyric acid, but a copolymer of PHB and polyhydroxyva-
leric acid (PHV). This further improved the properties of the material.
The natural brittleness of the PHB-PHV copolymer was reduced by addition
of suitable plasticizers, which were, of course, also required to be readily biode-
gradable. Small amounts of triacetin (glycerol triacetate) enhanced the elasticity
of the material. Printing of the shampoo bottles was facilitated by the use of
special UV-hardening varnishes. Finally the plastic properties of the new materi-
al were largely comparable with those of polyethylene.
There was still one problem to be solved – the plasticizer used for bottle man-
ufacture. Triacetin is also an ester, so decomposition of small amounts of the
material over the course of time cannot be prevented. Although the amounts
are so small that the plasticizing function will not be impaired, the human nose
is extremely sensitive to the smell of acetic acid which is released in the pro-
cess. Consequently every effort was made to find a perfume combination that
optimally masks traces of acetic acid. This was certainly the only example of a
perfume being chosen for its compatibility with the package.
ment to the German bio-waste management ordinance included plans for a nation-
wide collection system for bio-waste [33], there was a good reason for not assigning
Biopol packages to the bio-waste disposal route, despite its high compostability – it
was precisely the result of many years of in-depth research, i.e. making the bacte-
rial energy reserve material look and perform like a “conventional” plastic material,
that made it difficult, not to say impossible, for the average consumer to differenti-
ate between Biopol and other polymers. Mistakes seemed bound to occur and, be-
cause neither the “Duales System” nor biowaste collection provided a practical and
practicable disposal method, the promising approach ended up a blind alley.
15.4.5
Quo vadis, Biopol?
the costly petroleum fuel needed in residual waste combustion plants, because
the waste does not contain enough combustible materials. More than 60 years
elapsed between the discovery of polyhydroxybutyric acid and the first techno-
logical application. Maybe the continuing increase in oil prices and the increas-
ing reluctance to subsidize waste processing will eventually be reason enough
for a breakthrough of biodegradable polymers . . .
15.5
Natural Apple-peel Wax: Protection for Hair and Skin [36]
15.5.1
Raw Material Source
The apple, the epitome of fruit since time immemorial, is still a symbol of
youthfulness, freshness, health, beauty, lushness, naturalness, and vitality. In
the garden of Eden it was the coveted fruit from the tree of knowledge, the
cause of the Fall. In Greek mythology, Paris, prince of Troy, judged Aphrodite,
the goddess of love, to be “the fairest”, preferring her to Hera and Athene, and
awarded her the “apple of discord”. William Tell had to shoot an apple off his
son’s head to save his and his son’s lives.
430 15 Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
The apple appears in proverbs and sayings (“the apple never falls far from the
tree”, “the apple of someone’s eye”), it is a metaphor of love or immortality. Apples
are healthy and rich in vitamins (“an apple a day keeps the doctor away”), they can
be eaten raw, cooked, as juice, or in a fermented form as cider or applejack, and
they are sort of model for other kinds of fruit – pineapple, “love apple” (for toma-
to), “pomegranate” (from the French word “pomme” for apple) and so on.
15.5.2
Apple-peel Wax
Apples are coated by nature with a very thin wax layer (Fig. 15.18) which accounts
for the shine that appears when an apple is wiped with a soft cloth. It is widely
believed that a man-made wax coating is applied to apples before they are mar-
keted, but it is usually the natural wax we see and feel. In many countries, includ-
ing Germany, apple skin waxing is not allowed by law. Pre-sale waxing would, any-
way, be applied only to fruit intended to look “good”. The apple-peel wax we are
dealing with is obtained from juice-making residues that contain apple skin,
and the appearance of apples used for this purpose does not matter at all.
15.5.3
Observations
The valuable ingredients of apples are a rich nourishment not only for humans
but also for microorganisms, especially for mold and yeast (it is the special quality
of apple juice to ferment easily which is exploited in making cider and applejack).
The inside of the apple is highly sensitive to atmospheric oxygen, light, and
drying out but although apples consist of perishable and highly sensitive com-
ponents, if handled carefully they stay in good condition for a surprisingly long
time – quite unlike peaches, apricots, or strawberries, etc. They owe their ro-
bustness partly to the extremely clever composition of their skin, a composite of
mechanically resistant polymers (cutin, cellulose) and hydrophobic waxes pro-
viding effective protection against all types of attack from outside (Fig. 15.19).
That apples, on the one hand, quickly take on an unsightly brownish color,
dry out, and rot when the skin is lacerated but, on the other hand, can be stored
for a long time when their skin is intact, has encouraged investigation of the
natural surface wax of apple peel. It turned out that it is not the skin but the
natural wax coating that accounts for the long-lasting protection of apples
against drying out and microbial attack: In a laboratory-scale test the wax coat-
ing was removed from one half of an apple with an alcohol-soaked cotton pad
without abrading its skin. Within a very short time of storage in a normal office
environment the de-waxed half looked brownish and shriveled, as shows
Fig. 15.20. It seems that without the wax coating the apple skin is porous and
deprived of its protective function.
15.5.4
Production of Apple-peel Wax
It would, of course, be far too labor-intensive and expensive to isolate the wax from
intact apples. Dried apple pomace, a by-product of juice and pectin production,
has proved to be a favorably priced source with guaranteed availability throughout
the year. Depectinized pomace (Fig. 15.21) is a sufficiently enriched raw material
with the additional advantage that the apples being intended for juice-making and
are thus usually smaller than dessert apples (and consequently have a relatively
larger wax-coated surface). They also contain significantly less pesticide residues
(because their appearance does not matter – see above).
Wella has developed a process for isolating the wax from the dried pomace
and for removing chlorophyll and pesticide residues to obtain a rich, yellow, un-
scented raw material. For purification, as for extraction, purely physical pro-
cesses are used (adsorption, filtration, distillation), which means no chemical
change is involved.
Pomace is usually dried and used as a high-nutrition animal feed. Because
ecological aspects are considered throughout the manufacturing process, in par-
ticular with regard to the solvent used, the residual pomace after extraction of
the wax (which has hardly any nutritional value for the animals anyway) can
still be fed to animals. We could say that the pomace is only “borrowed” for wax
extraction. The process is illustrated in Fig. 15.21.
The apple-peel wax is extracted and purified using supercritical carbon diox-
ide, a solvent which is completely harmless and may be employed for food treat-
ment. The yield of apple-peel wax suitable for incorporation in cosmetic formu-
lations is approximately 2%.
15.5.5
Chemical Composition
15.5.6
Mode of Action and Uses
Many measurements were taken to discover whether the natural action of ap-
ple-peel wax could be transferred to cosmetic applications.
Procedure Standardized hair swatches were washed twice with 0.5-mL volumes
of lauryl ether sulfate solution (14%), while being moved to and fro, for one
minute each time. They were then rinsed under running water at 40 8C while
being combed through. The hair conditioner to be tested (0.5 mL) was then
applied to the pre-treated hair swatches – application time 30 s – and left to act
for 5 min. The hair was then rinsed under running water at 40 8C while being
combed. The swatches were then dried with a blow-drier. The reference was a
swatch pre-treated in the same way but without after-treatment.
15.5.7
Market Launch
The first use of apple-peel wax as a natural protection and conditioning princi-
ple was in shampoos, rinses, and hair tip repair fluids of Wella’s hair care
ranges “Sanara”, “Wella Balsam”, and “Wellapon”. According to EU regulations,
the botanical name of the raw material source, “Pyrus malus”, is used for INCI
labeling on the product package.
15.5.8
Summary and Prospects
Apple-peel wax is a natural protective and conditioning agent. Being the chemi-
cally unaltered component of a common staple food, it has no toxic potential
whatsoever. It is a renewable material extracted from waste available in unlim-
ited quantities, throughout the year, from juice and pectin production. Wax es-
15.6 Ilex Resin: From Shiny Leaves to Shiny Hair 437
can be translated to the hair and skin [43]. Potential applications are skin-care
and hair-conditioning products and shampoos. Products containing apple-peel
wax have been marketed nearly everywhere in the world.
15.6
Ilex Resin: From Shiny Leaves to Shiny Hair [44]
15.6.1
Holly
seem to have a highly effective coating that not only imparts the deep green col-
or and brilliant shine, but also protects them against drying out even under ex-
tremely untoward conditions, and against the action of atmospheric oxygen. A
holly leaf torn from the stem can be kept for years before it looks withered, the
(very sensitive) chlorophyll fades, and the leaf’s glossy surface shrivels.
15.6.2
Extraction of a Resin Fraction
The observations described – like those for apple peel [45] – led to closer investi-
gation of ilex leaves. Relatively simple extraction and purification methods were
sufficient for isolation of a hydrophobic, tacky, highly refractive, viscous sub-
stance (Fig. 15.27). Owing to its specific consistency the material is called “re-
sin”.
Because the leaves of the Central European holly (Ilex aquifolium) are difficult
to obtain on an industrial scale (the first holly leaves used for investigation were
from the author’s garden), better sources of the raw material were sought. It
was found that the leaves of the closely related Paraguay tea shrub (Ilex para-
guariensis) furnishes a cosmetic raw material with similar properties. The Para-
guay tea shrub or maté is not a hardy shrub in Central Europe, but the leaves
are commercially available throughout the year. Chemically, ilex resin – the fol-
lowing statements apply to the material derived from maté – is a complex mix-
ture of numerous hydrophobic substances, with a fraction containing hydrocar-
bons, terpenes (for example squalene and amyrin), and terpene esters being the
largest. Figure 15.28 shows the relative amounts of the main ingredients.
The large proportion of high-molecular-weight hydrophobic substances is re-
sponsible for the plant’s enormous water-retaining capacity which accounts for
the extreme protection against drying out.
A new, little-known raw material is always a special (i.e. inverse) challenge –
it may be the answer to a question that has not yet been asked. Ilex resin has
Fig. 15.27 Sample of native (left) and dechlorophyllized (right) ilex resin.
15.6 Ilex Resin: From Shiny Leaves to Shiny Hair 439
proved to have many uses and, depending on the type of product, has a variety
of sometimes quite unexpected effects [46].
15.6.3
Effects in Cosmetics
15.6.3.3 Styling
Styling products are usually “leave-on” products and thus the favorable effect of
the ilex resin in styling formulations is especially conspicuous. Use of hair sprays,
styling gels, and, particularly, shine gels containing the resin resulted in improved
hair luster and color richness which was occasionally noticeable, otherwise often
measurable (Fig. 15.29). It was amazing that in some hair sprays, setting mousses,
and styling gels it also enhanced the elasticity of the hair and the hold of the hair
style. In principle, ilex resin is suitable for all kinds of styling product, except per-
haps hair sprays with a high water content (>10%). It can be used for setting
mousses, hair sprays, gels, and waxes and for hair tip repair fluids, i.e. formula-
tions preventing split ends, and for leave-on conditioners.
15.6.4
Summary and Prospects
Ilex resin is a new natural material with many useful cosmetic properties. As
an active ingredient it enhances the performance of numerous product groups
in hair and skin care and, because it is derived from a very decorative ornamen-
tal and useful plant and has an obvious active principle working in its natural
habitat, its efficacy is readily substantiated.
Ilex resin is extracted from a plant cultivated in many countries as an agricul-
tural crop. There are no supply problems, and being renewable the substance is
available in virtually unlimited amounts. The resin is obtained by a purely phys-
ical solvent-free process with and without undergoing chemical change, simply
by extraction of maté leaves with supercritical carbon dioxide. Because it is non-
toxic, this process has recently largely replaced conventional solvent extraction
for foodstuffs (e.g. decaffeination), spices, and drugs. Biodegradability, climate
Fig. 15.29 Increase of hair luster by application of a product containing an ilex resin.
References 441
safety, and sparing of fossil resources are additional benefits of all chemically
unaltered natural substances.
Ample toxicological testing has shown that ilex resin is not an irritant to the
skin and the eye mucosa, that it is not mutagenic, and has no sensitization po-
tential. The first hair conditioners and shampoos containing ilex resin were
launched under Wella’s “Lifetex” brand in 1998 and hair-care products contain-
ing this natural material are now marketed nearly everywhere in the world. The
trade name is “Ilex Gloss”, and – according to EU legislation – the INCI term is
the botanical name of the raw material source, that is “Ilex paraguariensis”.
References
1 Lang, G., Clausen, T., Chitosan and Be- 16 Römpp Chemie Lexikon, Thieme Verlag
taine, Wella AG Darmstadt, company Stuttgart, Online DE Version (2002–
brochure, revised edition (2004). 2004).
2 Kripp, T. C., Von der Naturstoffisolierung 17 Zechmeister, L.; Toth, G.: Fortschritte
bis zur Trendformulierung. SOeFW-Jour- Chem. Org. Naturstoffe II (1939) p 212.
nal 123, 20–27 (1997). 18 Muzzarelli, R.A.A.: Chitin. Pergamom
3 Lang, G., Clausen, T., Chitosan and Be- Press, New York (1977), p 5 ff.
taine, Wella AG Darmstadt, company 19 “Panzerknacker”, High Tech 7 (1988),
brochure, revised edition (2004). p 29 ff.
4 Imhoff, J. F.; Rodriguez-Valera, F.: Jour- 20 Zikakis, J. P. (Ed.): Chitin, Chitosan and
nal of Bacteriology (1984), pp 478–479. Related Enzymes. Academic Press Inc.
5 Bagnasco, S.; Balaban, R.; Fales, H. M.; (1984), S. XVIII.
Yang, Y.-M.; Burg, M.: The Journal of 21 Sandford, P. A.; Hutchings, G. P.: Prog.
Biological Chemistry, Vol. 261, No. 13 Biotechnol. 3 (1987) p 363.
(1986) pp 5872–5877. 22 Groß, P.; Konrad, E.; Mager, H.: DE PS
6 Grattan, S. R.; Grieve, C. M.: Plant and 26 27 419 (1976).
Soil 85, pp 3–9 (1985). 23 Bernadet, M.: FR 1552076 (1969).
7 Coughlan, S. J.; Heber, U.: Planta (1982), 24 Gleckler, G. C.; Goebel, J. C.: US
156: pp 62– 69. 4035267 (1977).
8 Semmler, F.: Ther. d. Gegenw. 116 25 Yanagida, T.: JP 61/210014 A2 [86/
(1977), pp 2113–2124. 210014] (1986).
9 Babucke, G.; Sarre, H.: Med. Klin. 68 26 Konrad, E.; Gross, P.; Mager, H.: EP PS
(1973), pp 1109–1113. 0 002 506 (1987).
10 Schroeder F., Konrad, E., Lang, G.: Wella 27 Waki, M.; Tsuruta, E.: Jpn. Kokai Tokkyo
AG DE 3527974 (1987). Koho, JP 62/223108 A2 [87/223108]
11 Bimczok, R., Racky, E. D., Lang, G.: (1986).
Wella AG EP 747468 A1 (1996). 28 Kripp, T.: Industrielle Erfahrungen mit
12 Bimczok, R., Lang, G.: Wella AG EP Verpackungen aus Nachwachsenden
0750904 A1 (1997). Rohstoffen. Vortrag und Tagungsband
13 Racky, E.-D.: Wella AG DE19640086 C2 des Zentrums für Europäische
(1998). Wirtschaftsförderung und der IHK
14 Lang, G., Bimczok, R., Czigler, T., Kripp, Karlsruhe, (1994) pp 44–53.
T.: Wella AG EP 826661 A2 (1999). 30 Schlegel, H. G.: Allgemeine Mikrobiolo-
15 Lang, G., Clausen, T., Chitosan and Be- gie, Thieme Stuttgart, New York, 5. Au-
taine, Wella AG Darmstadt, company flage (1981), p 65.
brochure, revised edition (2004). 29 Römpp Chemie Lexikon, Thieme Verlag
Stuttgart, Online DE Version (2002–
2004).
442 15 Biobased Consumer Products for Cosmetics
31 Universität Stuttgart, Institut für Sied- tion and fractionation of cuticular waxes,
lungswasserbau, Wassergüte und Abfall- Ann. Appl. Biol., 53, 43–58 (1964).
wirtschaft. 42 Kaufmann, R., Höcker, H., XPS, eine
32 Nachr. Chem. Techn. Lab. 39 (1991) Methode zur Charakterisierung von Fas-
Nr. 10 p 1112. erveränderungen in der Oberfläche.,
33 www.umweltfibel.de/lexikon/pq/lex_p_ Fachz. Lab. 4, 348–352 GIT-Verlag,
polymilchsaeure.htm. Darmstadt (1994).
34 Danone, personal communication 5 July 43 Lang, G., Hoch, D., Konrad, E., Geibel,
2004. W., Wendel, H., Kripp, T.. EP 0 583 ;438 B1
35 Financial Times 15 February 1994. “Verfahren zur Gewinnung von Apfel-
36 Kripp, T. C., Von der Naturstoffisolierung wachs, durch diese Verfahren erhältliches
bis zur Trendformulierung. SOeFW-Jour- Apfelwachs sowie apfelwachshaltige kos-
nal 123/1 (1997) pp 20–27. metische Mittel” (1993).
37 Kolattukudy, P.E., Cutin, suberin and 44 Kripp, T. C., Ilex Resin, a Novel Renew-
waxes. Comprehensive biochemistry of able Raw Material for Cosmetics.
plants, IV, 571–645, Academic Press, SOeFW-Journal 126, 18-21 (2000).
New York (1980 b). 45 Kripp, T. C., Von der Naturstoffisolierung
38 Herbstreith & Fox, Neuenbürg, Firmen- bis zur Trendformulierung. SOeFW-Jour-
prospekt “Von der Apfelernte zum Pek- nal 123, 20-27 (1997).
tin”. 46 Kripp, T. C., Bormuth, H., Franzke, M.,
39 Sando, C. E., Constituents of the wax-like Baecker, S., Schröder, F. and Kischka,
coating on the surface of the apple, J. K. H., Cosmetic Agent with an Ilex resin
Biol. Chem., 56, 457–468 (1923). content, process for extraction of Ilex re-
40 Chibnall, A. C., Piper, S. H., Pollard, A.., sin and Ilex resin obtained thereby. WO
Smith, J. A. B., Williams, E. F., The wax 97/30680. Wella AG, Berliner Allee 65,
constituents of the apple cuticle, Bio- D-64274 Darmstadt (DE).
chem. J. 25, 2095–2110 (1931).
41 Fernandes, A.., Baker, E., Martin, J.,
Studies on plant cuticle, VI. The isola-
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
Part III
Biobased Industry:
Economy, Commercialization and Sustainability
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
445
16
Industrial Biotech –
Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
Rolf Bachmann and Jens Riese
16.1
Introduction
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
446 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
16.2
Time to Exploit the Potential
For those who remain unconvinced that biotech is more than just a passing
fad, approximately 5% of the estimated US$ 1.2 trillion total chemical sales al-
ready depend on biotech. (Here, “dependency” is defined as at least one produc-
tion step using biotechnology; 100% of the sales of a chemical product were ac-
counted for in a multi-step production process.) The global market for bio-based
ethanol is worth US$ 15 billion alone; other basic organic molecules, for exam-
ple citric acid (US$ 2 billion) and lactic acid, are produced by fermentation, and
so are all but three amino acids (approx. US$ 4 billion). Various basic, advanced,
and active pharmaceutical ingredients produced by the fine chemical industry
are worth US$ 7.5 billion; the attractive enzyme market has reached US$ 2 bil-
lion in sales and is growing by more than 5% per year, and specialty chemicals
for flavors, fragrances, and other applications add several more billion dollars.
Biotech is changing industrial production in three specific ways. First, sugars,
vegetable oils, and ultimately waste biomass are replacing fossil fuel feedstock
(oil and natural gas). Second, bioprocesses such as fermentation, biocatalysis,
and, in the future, plant- and animal-based production may replay chemical syn-
theses. Last, new bioproducts are emerging including bio-based polymers, en-
zymes for use in textiles or feed, and innovative nutritional ingredients.
16.2.1
How Far Can it Go?
McKinsey & Company has analyzed the market potential by looking at the tech-
nological and market trends in the chemical industry, taking an inventory of ex-
isting commercial and research and development biotech activities, estimating
the likely penetration in different chemical market segments, and finally by con-
ducting interviews and discussions with more than 100 industry executives
(Fig. 16.1).
The results suggest that biotech could have an impact on 10% of chemical
sales by 2010, double what it is today. Initial analyses at the beginning of the
decade indicated that 20% might have been achievable in the same timescale.
Today this looks highly unlikely, and even the 10% figure will not be reached
without effort.
One of the most important factors affecting this development is the price dif-
ference between fossil fuel feedstocks and biological carbohydrate feedstocks,
especially for those products with a high relative feedstock cost. Consumer ac-
ceptance is also vital – as we have seen in agricultural biotech with the wide-
spread rejection in Europe of genetically modified foods, despite their accep-
tance in the US. Thus far there is no significant consumer movement against
industrial biotech – indeed, as we show later, it actually has strong environmen-
tal benefits. Consumer and environmental organizations have not actually pub-
licly endorsed industrial biotech, however.
16.2 Time to Exploit the Potential 447
16.2.2
Better Technology, Faster Results
16.2.3
Environmentally and Balance-sheet Friendly
The increased pressure for sustainable production is also helping to spur the in-
dustry’s prospects. Two reports – one authored by the OECD (OECD Report
“The Application of Biotechnology to Industrial Sustainability” (2001), which in-
cludes 21 case studies on the impact of biotechnology on the environment), the
other by a consortium of companies, industry associations, the Öko-Institut,
and McKinsey – clearly demonstrated that industrial biotech can help create
jobs, boost profits, and benefit the environment (Fig. 16.2).
Green Economics
When oil and gas are used as production feedstock, carbon is removed from the
earth and bound into the chemicals that constitute plastics and other materials.
Eventually, the plastic is discarded and burned and CO2 is released into the at-
mosphere – a one-way cycle that produces significant pollution. When biomass
is used, the CO2 released helps provide the raw material for further production,
because it can be absorbed by plants, which can in turn be used as new feed-
stock. This closed cycle theoretically results in a neutral carbon balance, thereby
reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
The increased energy efficiency that comes from replacing fossil fuels has led
McKinsey to estimate that 7% of the Kyoto target on emissions could be
achieved (based on the full range of case studies in the reports mentioned
above, and the figure of 10% of chemical product sales relying on biotech).
When we reach the stage where 20% of chemical products are produced using
biotechnology, the contribution will increase from 7 to 20%.
The economic benefits alone are also driving the adoption of biotechnology.
The case studies for Vitamin B2 and Cephalexin (see box), and dozens of phar-
maceutical intermediates suggest that cost savings of 50% and more are not un-
likely. The savings can come directly from lower variable costs, but also from re-
duced capital expenditure for simpler production assets, or from reduced scale
and therefore lower risk, transportation costs, and/or overcapacity.
450 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
16.2.4
Rekindling Chemicals Innovation
Finally, interest in biotech has increased recently because of its role in product
innovation. At a time of increasing competition from Asia in established prod-
ucts and the subsequent commoditization and strong price decline, chemical
companies are once again looking at innovation as a key source of differentia-
tion. At the 2004 World Economic Forum in Davos, the leaders of the world’s
largest chemical companies generally shared the view that biotechnology will be
the predominant driver of innovation for their organizations, and placed it
among the key drivers of change for the decade ahead.
The importance of stimulating innovation can be seen by looking at the intro-
duction of new polymers. Over the course of the 20th century the development
of fossil-fuel-based polymers increased steadily through to the post-war period,
stimulated by the abundance and low cost of basic petrochemicals. It has, how-
ever, declined dramatically since 1960. Innovation in the traditional polymer in-
dustry today is mainly related to the application and blending of these poly-
mers, rather than the invention of new ones (Fig. 16.3).
Just as low-cost petrochemical building blocks such as ethylene, propylene,
and butadiene became available with the introduction of crackers in the 1930s,
we are seeing the emergence of new bio-based building blocks today. These in-
clude lactic acid, which can be polymerized to the biopolymer PLA. PLA has
started to replace polyester because of its competitive cost and new applications.
Lactic acid can also be processed into chiral drugs, acrylic acid, propylene glycol,
food additives, and more (Fig. 16.4).
16.2.5
Increasing Corporate Action in all Segments
All these economic, regulatory, and environmental factors are encouraging com-
panies in all major chemical market segments to make more definite moves In
fine chemicals, half of all life science chemicals at DSM are based on biotech –
a wolume which is worth US$ 1.5 billion. BASF has committed more than
1 500 million to explore the potential of plant-based biotechnology. DuPont has
invested more than US$ 500 million in the development of Sorona®, and Car-
gill Dow’s investments for PLA are of a similar scale. Ciba Specially Chemicals
has introduced an enzymatic process for acrylic acid, BP is exploring industrial
biotech for oil exploration and basic chemicals, Degussa has recently opened a
second project house dedicated to biotechnology, Givaudan is using biotech ex-
tensively for new flavors and aromas, and Novozymes has an annual research
and development budget of more than 1 100 million for new and enhanced en-
zymes. Finally, dedicated industrial biotechnology companies such as Codexis,
Diversa, and Genencor have established themselves in the market and have en-
couraged a new generation of start-ups to emerge.
452 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
16.3
The Importance of Residual Biomass
Early introductions of bio-based products have shown that the willingness to pay a
high “green” premium is limited to a small portion of the customer base. For broad-
based adoption, new products must be competitive with existing offerings. In this
context, the use of alternative low-cost feedstock could give industrial biotech an-
other boost (as, of course, will the recent increases in the price of natural oil and gas).
16.3.1
Why Waste Biomass Works
Bioethanol is one of the first and the largest markets to profit from cheap bio-
mass feedstock. Ethanol is usually produced from dextrose, which in the US
tends to be derived from corn. The first ethanol biorefinery based on waste bio-
mass is already online. It is a Canadian venture operated by Iogen and receiving
investment from Shell, Petro Canada, and the Canadian government. With an
annual capacity of 700,000 liters it is semi-commercial in scale and too ineffi-
cient to compete on cost with conventional ethanol refineries. The technology is
expected to improve quickly, however.
The process sounds relatively simple. Straw is delivered to the refinery where it is
chemically and/or physically pretreated. Enzymes then decouple the cellulose and
hemicellulose chains, breaking them down into individual sugars. Most of the sugar
yielded will be used as feedstock for fermentation. As bacteria or yeast cells break
down the sugar it is fermented into ethanol. The organisms can also be modified to
produce vitamins, organic acids, and other substances. The primary products that
emerge from the biorefinery are often subject to further downstream processing.
16.3.2
Economic Benefits and Regulation
Biomass-based biorefineries have the potential to reduce sugar costs from about
8 to 9 cents per pound in the US today to approximately 4 cents per pound in
three to four years, and lower still as the biorefineries become more integrated.
It is even possible to see a case where the net cost of producing sugar in an in-
16.3 The Importance of Residual Biomass 453
tegrated biorefinery is zero because by-products such as lignin and proteins gen-
erate the value. It is important to realize that the price of conventionally pro-
duced sugar will also fall as genetic modification makes a variety of productivity
improvements possible.
The technology for the cost-competitive, large-scale application of ethanol
could be ready in the next few years, and the value-creation potential for shift-
ing from corn to biomass for ethanol is estimated to be US$ 10 to 16 billion by
2010 (Fig. 16.5). (This figure is derived from industry estimates for the increas-
ing use of biomass as feedstock. After calculating marginal and overall cost sav-
ings, we multiplied the result by typical profit multiples for the industry. We as-
sumed that the price of ethanol remains stable. The resulting change in market
capitalization is the value creation.)
Legislation is already in place to support production of fuel ethanol in coun-
tries such as Canada and Brazil, and the EU has committed to ensuring that
5.75% of all transportation fuel in the EU will be bio-based – a target that can-
not be achieved by biodiesel alone. Several European companies, for example
Abengoa and Südzucker, have therefore announced aggressive plans for expan-
sion in ethanol in the coming years. Estimates for the US market suggest that
15 billion gallons (57 billion liters) of bioethanol will be produced from a com-
bination of biomass and corn-based feedstock by 2020; and the cost of ethanol
could come down from approximately $ 1.20 per gallon (32 cents per liter) today
to as low as 40 cents per gallon (11 cents per liter) by 2010.
454 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
16.3.3
Still a Long Way to Go
For this to happen, all steps of the process need to undergo major efficiency im-
provements. The cost of enzymes must fall by 90% from its 2003 level. This
might sound unrealistic, but it is not unusual to increase the effectiveness of
enzyme production by factors of 10, 100 or even 1000. By modifying the amino
acid sequences of the cellulase and hemicellulase enzymes, biochemists from
Genencor and Novozymes have been able to make them dramatically more ef-
fective, and recent advances suggest the cost target for the enzymes will be ex-
ceeded in due course.
The US Department of Energy predicts that 2 billion gallons (7.5 billion li-
ters) of ethanol will be derived from biomass by 2010. This figure, depends,
however, on whether companies are willing to invest. Despite major govern-
ment support, especially in the US, no major companies have yet aggressively
pursued this. Cargill, DuPont, Deere, Shell, and others are putting in moderate
investments of US$ 10 to 15 million often related to matching government
grants, thereby reserving an option to play in the future. The competitive threat
is still perceived as low, and companies are afraid to risk being the first mover.
Only the technology companies, in particular Novozymes and Genencor, and
the Spanish pioneer Abengoa have publicly announced aggressive growth plans
and commitments to biomass-based ethanol.
It is not just the chemical or the biotech companies that need to make the in-
vestments; it goes all the way down the value chain. Farmers need the right sort
of equipment, storage facilities for corn stover must be built, pretreatment
needs investment, etc. No one owns the full value chain, so collaborating with
partners is essential. In fact, the value chain does not yet exist, and collabora-
tion between different parties is required if it is to be built.
16.3.4
Collaboration Will Push Biomass Conversion Forward
There are three collaboration models. The first, which prevails today, is where
multiple players are involved in diverse activities with very little explicit collabo-
ration and without enough investment to launch a new value chain. In the sec-
ond, entrepreneurial pioneers invest substantially to bundle research and devel-
opment efforts and build the new value chain. This is a high-risk approach, but
has potentially high rewards. It also enables the company to assume a clear lea-
dership role. The final model is a structured network in which multiple players
from different parts of the value chain cooperate closely. The risks – and there-
fore the returns – are shared out and each company can focus on its core com-
petency. Such networks have yet to emerge. When they do, they will have much
to accomplish, including collecting, warehousing, and treating biomass, and
constructing biorefineries. One possible drawback of this model is the introduc-
tion of governance and interface inefficiency.
16.4 Overcoming the Challenges Ahead 455
It will be interesting to see how governments and the various players along
the value chain will act in the coming years, and whether a real breakthrough
in the broad commercial use of waste biomass will happen. Next to the advan-
tages for the environment, political stability, and jobs in rural areas, it could
give a welcome boost to the broader adoption of industrial biotech.
16.4
Overcoming the Challenges Ahead
The path from awareness to profit for companies engaged in biotech is long
and arduous (Fig. 16.6). Most companies have already taken the first step and
are aware of the opportunities and the threats of biotech. Some have even made
the commitment to invest; but from there onward is a long staircase with many
internal and external challenges to manage.
16.4.1
Internal Obstacles
The first challenge for chemical companies in turning the biotech promise into
reality is to create the awareness of its economic potential and benefits for sus-
tainability. We have already come a long way in achieving this. The next chal-
lenge is to convert the awareness into a commitment to act. Investors and se-
nior managers have recently demonstrated their willingness to act if they are
presented with good opportunities. This has held true particularly for incremen-
tal investments. Those high-risk/high-return areas that require major invest-
ments, for example biomass conversion, still face great skepticism. Further-
more, very few companies have progressed beyond an opportunistic use of bio-
tech and have formulated a true biotech strategy, with a clear focus on where
and how to compete. To execute a strategy, a company needs the right assets,
capabilities, and networks, and no one has all the requirements in-house. Iden-
tifying where the gaps lie and understanding how best to fill them is not easy,
and feedback on partnerships in this field has been mixed.
The next step is to identify and select the right opportunities. There is usually
no shortage of ideas, as illustrated, for example, by the impressive theoretical
product trees rooted in the new bio-based building blocks. The difficulty is se-
lecting the right ones; as mentioned earlier, the list of failed biotech invest-
ments is much longer than the list of successes.
Failure cannot be avoided. The trick – as in the world of venture capital – is
to manage the uncertainty and to build a portfolio of good prospects. And, as
with venture capital, the starting point is a solid business case for the opportu-
nities deemed right for investment. The most common mistakes are overesti-
mating the addressable market size and market uptake (mostly by defining it
too broadly), and underestimating the investments, in particular for ongoing
market development and application development after the initial research and
development investment.
With a portfolio of projects in hand, there remains the challenge of separating
the biotech wheat from the biotech chaff. Companies often hang on to second-
tier projects far too long, rather than focusing their scarce resources on the few
most promising. Investors are also no longer willing to tie their money up in
projects that might take a decade to break even. Research and development
work in biopolymers, for example, began in the 1980s, so we need to find ways
to accelerate the whole process.
The launch and market development might be the last steps, but they are also
the ones that can make all the difference. The art is to focus on the right mar-
ket segments and customers with the right value proposition, to align the value
chain to adopt your innovation, and to use partners appropriately. Indeed, man-
aging partnerships plays a role in several steps of this staircase of success.
Surrounding this set of internal challenges are external pressures that also
need close attention, but which can be met.
16.4.2
External Challenges
be labeled GM. The environmental NGOs and pressure groups have been rel-
atively quiet on industrial biotech so far, but it would only take one of the
more influential groups putting it on the agenda for lengthy delays to be pos-
sible. The industry therefore needs to invest resources in educating people on
the benefits.
· The cost differential between hydrocarbon (oil, natural gas) and carbohydrate
(sugar, biomass) feedstock is clearly a moving target. In a climate of rising oil
prices, carbohydrates look even more appealing but such a situation cannot
be relied upon permanently. Companies need to consider potential price
changes, and analyze the sensitivity of biotech investment cases against var-
ious assumptions on future feedstock costs.
· The regulatory situation is certainly liable to change but is also subject to the
influence of various interest groups. The proponents of industrial biotechnol-
ogy, represented, for example, by the BIO and EuropaBio industry associa-
tions, need to maintain or even increase the level of activity on this front.
This, in turn, requires commitment from their members.
· The success of company strategies and investment decisions ultimately de-
pends on the moves of competitors. Products must be distinctive; intellectual
property must be in place to introduce a new biotech process; and an eye
must be kept out for opportunities to align interests and join forces. It is
therefore essential to watch and anticipate competitor moves as well as possi-
ble.
16.5
Overcoming Challenges
A growing number of case studies demonstrate that all these challenges can be
overcome. Usually, the trick is to tailor well-established good management prac-
tices and problem-solving approaches from comparable situations to the specific
needs of industrial biotech. These approaches do not have to come from the
chemical industry itself. For example, chemical companies have looked at risk
management tools in financial services to learn how to deal with uncertainty.
Here, we set out a number of cases with which McKinsey has been involved,
and in which companies have managed to capture value from industrial bio-
tech.
16.5.1
Case 1: Building a Biotech Strategy
After years of internal discussions, and smaller investments with promising re-
sults, the board of a chemical company decided to take a major step in indus-
trial biotech. It looked at a number of different growth fields and biotech
emerged as the one with the highest innovation potential and a good fit with
the company’s broader capabilities and position in the value chain. There were
458 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
many potential entry points and business opportunities, some of which had in-
ternal champions and others that did not seem worth pursuing, but none had a
clear rationale. The company approached the challenge from two sides. It deter-
mined its distinctive skills and assets through a benchmarking process. At the
same time, it assessed the relevant opportunities and threats – both competitors’
recent or announced moves and the potential for competitors if the company
chose not to enter a specific area.
This produced a list of strategic options – a combination of areas that seemed
most attractive for the client to enter and different business models and value
chain positions that would match these areas. The next step was to assess these
different strategic options along a set of criteria that included economic value,
feasibility, risk, investments, fit with overall strategy, and portfolio of initiatives
(Fig. 16.7). The final decision was made after extensive discussions and inter-
views both within and outside the company. It is too early to determine the fi-
nancial success, but the company has already achieved alignment between the
overall strategy, the level of investment and the organizational setup.
16.5.2
Case 2: Identifying the Right Opportunities
Another chemical company already had a clear biotech strategy in place and
had built the capabilities, assets, and networks required to implement it. Execu-
tion was already successfully underway in several business units and new bio-
based products and processes had started to generate healthy profits. The com-
pany was, however, wondering how best to apply biotechnology to a recently ac-
16.5 Overcoming Challenges 459
quired business. In particular, it was seeking ways to change the old chemical
production processes to new, more competitive synthesis routes.
The project scope expanded to include a complete review of the company’s
core product strategies, which included a detailed assessment of competitor
moves, market trends, etc. This was important because a new biotech process
can easily take five years or more to develop, so it is critical to understand
whether it will result in a distinctive cost position after that time. Regulations
and customer sensitivities also change – would there be a “bio-based” premium
or a “genetically modified” discount for a product produced by fermentation?
The scope was also extended on the technology side. While one team investi-
gated the potential for new biotech routes, a competing team tried to optimize
the existing process, including analyzing different locations, and a third team
searched for the best alternative chemical routes. In the end, biotech was just
one of the solutions. Each potential solution was assessed, and the final one
was chosen based on the basis of the best risk/reward ratio. This led to an im-
plementation roadmap and a decision tree, as further technical feasibility stud-
ies were required to prove the concept and assist in making the final choice.
Of the fifteen products under investigation, biotech was the best solution for
five of them; in four cases a new chemical process was found; incremental im-
provements to the existing chemical process were made in three further cases;
two products were moved to China, one was stopped completely and bought in-
stead from a low-cost producer. So even though the impetus for the project was
to see how biotech might have an impact on the company’s processes, the out-
come was an improvement of every process in a variety of ways. By 2010, it is
predicted that costs will have fallen by 60% on average for these fifteen pro-
cesses.
16.5.3
Case 3: Managing Uncertainties
This company was building a portfolio of industrial biotech projects but it was
difficult to predict the future cost and revenues of each one and to determine
which ran a relatively high risk of failure. The company wanted to make the
risks more transparent and to improve its decision making against a back-
ground of high uncertainty.
The solution was inspired by riskmanagement practices used in the venture
capital and pharmaceutical industries. The basis of many of these tools is a
Monte Carlo simulation, which randomly combines potential parameters to as-
sess the probability of certain resulting values. It was used to estimate the pro-
cess economics of a new biotech process. Instead of using a best guess for yield,
cycle times and other key process characteristics, a best-, base-, and worst-case
scenario were each assigned a certain probability of occurrence. The Monte Car-
lo simulation combined these randomly and generated a graph that showed the
potential total production costs against its probability of occurrence. For exam-
ple, it turned out that there was a 60% chance that a new process was going to
460 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
be at least 30% cheaper than the old one. Based on the investment required,
this was still considered to be too risky and the project was terminated. In an-
other case, the analysis revealed a spread of potential outcomes that did not en-
able any conclusive recommendation. A more detailed assessment showed that
the range of outcomes was extremely broad for one process characteristic, and
the company decided to invest in another six months of laboratory work to un-
derstand this better and then repeat the assessment with a better defined range
of potential outcomes. This is just one example demonstrating that uncertainty
and risk are not reasons to refrain from rational decision making.
16.5.4
Case 4: Preparing the Launch and Market Development
This company was on the very last step of the staircase towards profitability in
industrial biotech. It had a strategy, a highly capable organization, a great prod-
uct, a new production facility, and some funding. Its problem was that the po-
tential market applications for its new bio-product were so numerous that it
was impossible to pursue them all simultaneously with its limited resources. It
was also becoming clear that the product was not equally suited to all applica-
tions and that each market required a different product positioning. The com-
pany was looking for a go-to-market strategy for its new blockbuster.
The full list of potential applications and addressable market segments were
assessed against:
1. the relative strength of the new product’s value proposition to the customer
in terms of price and performance compared with existing offerings;
2. the size and attractiveness of the addressable market; and
3. the ease of capturing the value, i.e. the time and effort it would take to devel-
op the product applications and markets and the hurdles for adoption of the
product along the value chain.
The last point required much attention because consumers had already ex-
pressed considerable interest in some of the applications and the economics
looked attractive. Interviews with companies along the value chain and support-
ing analyses showed, however, that the investment of intermediaries in the val-
ue chain made adoption very unlikely. In other market segments, retailers were
concerned about the brand risk and were not willing to proceed without further
demonstration of fitness-for-use and safety. These segments were therefore put
on the back burner, but will be reignited when results from other segments
support this market case.
In the end, a handful of segments were chosen as top-priority targets for im-
mediate focus and specific targets, marketing strategies, and implementation
plans were put in place. In some other market segments and geographies part-
nering was the preferred strategy, mostly because partners had better customer
access or application technologies than the company. The remaining segments
were put on hold. It is too early to measure the success in financial terms, but
16.6 More Needs to be Done 461
the company now feels it has a clear focus and funding has recently been re-
newed by investors, so the new go-to-market strategy can be implemented.
16.5.5
Case 5: Building a Favorable External Environment
The previous case referred to overcoming internal hurdles, but the final case
study illustrates how companies and industry associations can work together to
tackle external challenges: to educate opinion leaders and decision makers and
avoid a negative atmosphere that could prevent the economic and environmen-
tal potential from being realized.
In 2003, EuropaBio decided to launch a project together with BIO (its Ameri-
can big sister) and some of its most prominent industrial members. BASF, Car-
gill Dow, DSM, DuPont, Genencor, and Novozymes all committed funds, data,
and resources to put together case-studies on recent industrial biotech innova-
tions. The German Öko-Institut, which has a good reputation and credibility
with environmental interest groups, was asked to ensure that the environmental
impact assessment was sound, and McKinsey was brought in to manage the
process and perform the economic analyses. The resulting report included case
studies and high-level recommendations for policy makers. It was presented at
several prestigious conferences, and is still cited regularly in the trade and gen-
eral press. Moreover, it has opened the door for EuropaBio to enter a dialogue
with the key policy makers in the European Commission. One of the outcomes
was to establish round-table discussions with the key stakeholders, including in-
dustry, academia, governments, and consumers. Several consumer interest
groups are meanwhile supporting industrial biotech, and, more importantly,
none is campaigning against it!
16.6
More Needs to be Done
The potential of industrial biotech to benefit the triple P – “profits, planet, and
people” – has been broadly recognized and companies are starting to turn it
into reality. There are significant challenges in making this happen, but the
cases shown here encourage us to think that they can and will be overcome.
Nevertheless, the effort required from chemical companies in terms of making
and managing investments is significant. The speed and extent to which the po-
tential of industrial biotech is realized will largely depend on how determined
and successful chemical companies are in forging ahead. Another part of the
equation is government support. Various US institutions, especially the Depart-
ment of Energy, have supported industrial biotech significantly in the past. It is
important that this level of investment is sustained or even increased. There are
rumors that part of this funding will be redirected towards other technologies,
462 16 Industrial Biotech – Setting Conditions to Capitalize on the Economic Potential
but this would send a negative signal that could have repercussions far beyond
the direct loss of investment.
In contrast to the situation in the US, the EU has yet to implement any ma-
jor initiatives to support industrial biotechnology. Such support would be more
than desirable and should concentrate on three specific areas. First, the EU
should formulate a vision and a long-term strategy for developing the biotech-
nology industry and all the relevant groups should be included in drafting such
a strategy. Second, legislators should be challenged to create a favorable environ-
ment, which can include temporary support for lower prices for carbohydrate
feedstock that Europe is not producing competitively. Third, the EU should pro-
mote research to intensify technological development in Europe.
It feels as if we are teetering on the edge of an economic breakthrough in in-
dustrial biotech. If governments help create a conducive environment and com-
panies understand how to move forward without taking unnecessary risks, this
could be the beginning of a genuine revolution in the application of science. It
is an exciting time to be involved in this industry, but there are still challenges
ahead that we must all rise to meet if industrial biotech is to fulfill its sizeable
potential.
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
© 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.
463
Subject Index
Numbers in front of the page numbers refer to Volume 1 and 2: e.g., 2: 282 refers
to page 282 in volume 2
a
A. niger CBX-209, levoglucosan fermenta- acyclic sugar derivatives 2: 48
tion 1: 229 acyl glutamate, synthesis 2: 305
A. rhizogenes 2: 275 acylated proteins 2: 304
absorption, acoustic 2: 242 addition
acetaldehyde, glucose product family 1: 21 – cationic 2: 264–265
acetate, biorefinery concept 2: 210 – copper-initiated 2: 262–263
acetic acid, glucose product family 1: 21 – perfluoroalkyl iodides 2: 263–264
Acetobacterium woodii 1: 235 additive chemicals 1: 91
acetogenic bacteria, metabolic pathways additive replacement, ethanol 1: 357
1: 234 adhesions prevention, post-surgical 2: 238
acetogens 1: 233 adhesive films 1: 282
acetoin, biomass building blocks 1: 22 adhesive tack 2: 186
acetone, glucose product family 1: 21 adhesives 2: 86
acetyl-CoA 1: 233, 236 advanced materials, protein-based polymeric
acetylated starches 2: 80 materials 2: 220
acid addition, lactic acid 2: 386 aerobic storage, potato juice 1: 300, 309
acid-catalyzed dehydration 1: 91 agarose gel gene ladder 2: 229
acid-catalyzed hydrolysis, cellulose 1: 133 age of sustainability, modeling tools 1: 57–
acid-catalyzed stages, biofine process 60
1: 144 agribusiness, integrated production 1: 8
acid conversion, cellulose 1: 129 agricultural applications, lignin 2: 192
acid cooking, straw 1: 193 agricultural crop residues 1: 117
acid-forming anaerobes 1: 235 agricultural ecosystem modeling 1: 57–60
acid hydrolysis, carbohydrate polysaccha- agricultural land, net requirement 1: 54–55
rides 1: 144 agricultural varieties, oil qualities 2: 276
acid hydrolysis of polysaccharides 1: 140 agricultural waste 1: 68
acid hydrolysis process 1: 130–133, 199 agriculture residue collection 1: 317–344
acid-insoluble ligneous components, feed- agrification 1: 96
stock 1: 146 Agrobacterium tumefaciens 2: 275
acid prehydrolysis 1: 200 agroindustry, sugar 1: 209–211
acidification, lactic acid 2: 386 agrosector, dutch 1: 96
acidogenic anaerobes 1: 235 air-blown gasification 1: 232
acids air classification 1: 176
– dilute 1: 362 – oat grain 1: 183
– sugar-derived 2: 5 Alcaligenes eutrophus, PHB accumulation
aconitic acid, glucose product family 1: 21 2: 424
acoustic absorption, elastic protein-based alcell demonstration plant 2: 180
polymer 2: 242 alcell process 2: 179
acrylic acid, glucose product family 1: 21 alcohol commodities, sugar-based 2: 36–37
Biorefineries – Industrial Processes and Products. Status Quo and Future Directions. Vol. 2
Edited by Birgit Kamm, Patrick R. Gruber, Michael Kamm
Copyright © 2006 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ISBN: 3-527-31027-4
464 Subject Index
alcohols amylose
– microbial conversion 2: 32–34 – physical structure 1: 140
– microbial fermentation 2: 33 – starch synthesis 2: 71
– production 1: 235–236 anaerobe bacteria, lactic acid fermenta-
– sugar-based 2: 42 tion 1: 298
– sugar-derived 2: 5 anaerobes, acidogenic 1: 235
alfalfa 1: 254 anaerobic fermentations, succinic acid
– chlorophyll extraction 2: 329 2: 35
– cultivation 1: 260 anaerobic production, succinic acid 2: 369
Alfalfa New Products Initiative see ANPI anaerobic storage, potato juice 1: 300, 310
alfaprox procedure 1: 257 analytical assays, antioxidant activities
algal fungi, chitin occurrence 2: 415 1: 186
aliphatic diols, high molecular weight analytical methods, lactic acid fermenta-
2: 298 tion 1: 299
alkali pretreatments 1: 200 1,6-anhydro-b-d-glucose, chemical struc-
alkaloids 1: 268 ture 1: 245
alkanes 1: 268 d-anhydroglucopyranose units 1: 140
– thermal addition 2: 264 anhydrosugar 1: 229, 243, 245
alkyl polyglycoside carboxylate 2: 307 animal bedding, stover 1: 325
alkyl polyglycosides 2: 272, 305 animal feed, nutrient-enriched 1: 170
– emulsifiers 2: 308 animal feed supplements
– manufacturing processes 2: 306 – antioxidants 2: 188
– synthesis 2: 306 – lignin 2: 196
– see also APG animal health 2: 195–196
allylic C–H Bonds, oxidation 2: 269–270 anions of fatty acids, oxidative coupling
alternative life, GJ Drinks 1: 275–277 2: 266
American Society for the Testing of Materi- anodic coupling, fatty acids 2: 267–269
als see ASTM ANPI 1: 260
american straw, chemical composition anthracenes 1: 118
2: 107 antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains 2: 195
amino acid-based product family trees antibiotics 2: 15
2: 201–216 antidiarrheic effects, dietary lignin 2: 195
amino acid composition, lucerne 1: 275 antifeedants 1: 277
amino acid production, microbial antifreeze protein 1: 269
2: 201–216 antimutagenic effects, chlorophyll 2: 336
amino acid residues, hydrophobicity antioxidant activity, oat bran-rich frac-
scale 2: 234–235 tions 1: 186
amino acid units, proteins 1: 122 antioxidants 1: 186
amino acids 1: 267, 2: 304 – animal feed supplements 2: 188
– analysis 1: 299 – ferulic acid 1: 179
– brown juice content 1: 305 – lignin 2: 187–189
– fermentation 2: 203 – lubricants industry 2: 188
– markets 2: 207 – rubber industry 2: 188
d-aminolevulinic acid see DALA – synthetic 2: 188
ammonia fiber explosion, pretreatment antisense RNA approach 2: 275
1: 362 APG 2: 11–12, 272
ammonium lactate 2: 387 – synthesis 2: 13
amphiphilic drugs, controlled release apolar groups, exothermic hydration
devices 2: 240 2: 218
amylases 1: 197 apolar–polar repulsive free energy of hydra-
amylopectin tion 2: 218
– physical structure 1: 140 apple-peel wax 2: 430–432
– starch synthesis 2: 71 – components 2: 434
Subject Index 465
syngas 1: 26, 30–31, 46, 98, 126, 157, 2: 361 Thermatoga maritima 1: 80
– composition 1: 232 thermochemical biorefinery concept,
– fermentation 1: 228–229, 233–239, 239– ECN 1: 104
241 thermochemical conversion 1: 31
– platform 1: 31–32 – biomass processing 1: 98
– product family tree 1: 33 – catalytic 2: 356
– technology 1: 240–241 – oils 2: 361
syntheses 1: 123 – optimization 1: 108
– lactic acid 2: 382 – sugars 2: 360
– lipase-catalyzed 2: 270–272 thermochemical liquefaction 1: 123
– petroleum compounds 1: 119 thermochemical processing, biomass 1: 249
– with oils and fats 2: 253–289 thermochemical refinery 1: 101–103
synthesis gas 1: 182 thermogravimetric analyses, feedstock
synthesis of structure, petrochemistry 1: 156
1: 123 Thermoplasma acidophilum, microrgan-
synthetic biofuels 1: 30 isms 1: 80
synthetic biopolyesters 2: 41 thermoplastic polymer, PLA 2: 381
synthetic rubber 1: 131 thermoplastics 2: 225
– adhesive film 1: 282
t – thermoplastic 1: 215
tablet coatings 2: 88 thermoset resins 2: 184
tack 2: 186 THF 1: 149, 2: 373
tall oil fatty acid 2: 297 thickeners, textile-printing 2: 86
Tamiflu, synthesis 2: 30 threonine
tapioca 2: 70–71 – biomass building blocks 1: 22
tapioca starch production 2: 70 – markets 2: 207
tar-formation, acid hydrolysis 1: 144 Tiemann, F. 1: 7
target chemicals, biobased 1: 14, 16 Tilgham, B. C. 1: 6
target crops, feedstock production 1: 15 tillage effect, soil carbon loss 1: 328
tars, undesirable 1: 231 tillage practice 1: 330–331
technical constraints, MAAP 2: 209 tin-catalyzed lactide polymerization 2: 391
technical prerequisite, cellulosic biorefin- tin hydride radical chemistry 2: 261
eries 1: 55–56 tin octoate catalyzed polymerization, lac-
technoeconomic factor, dominant 1: 53–54 tide 2: 393
technological outline, biorefinery sys- TNPP, melt stability improvement 2: 399
tems 1: 4–8 tocopherols 2: 319–320
technological pathways, transformation pro- toxicity 2: 212
cess 1: 87 TPA, synthesis 2: 134
temperature adjustment 1: 79 traffic congestion 1: 338
temperature transition, inverse 2: 219 traffic problems, feedstock 1: 338–339
temporary functional scaffoldings 2: 239 tragacanth, substitute 2: 62
terpenes 1: 91 transepidermal water loss 2: 434
terrestrial biomass, content 2: 3 transesterification, sucrose fatty acid mono-
tetrahydrofuran see THF esters production 2: 13
tetrahydroxybutyl side-chain, furans 2: 19 transition metal-catalyzed syntheses, aro-
tetrapyrrole structures 2: 328 matic compounds 2: 259
TEWL 2: 434 transition metal metathesis, olefins 2: 259
textile-glass-fiber-industry, starch usage transport
2: 91 – baling dry material 1: 332
textile industry, starch usage 2: 85 – crops 1: 337
The Netherlands, bio-based industry transportation fuels, biomass share 1: 14, 16
1: 93–96 Treibs’s scheme, petroporphyrin forma-
thermal addition of alkanes 2: 264 tion 2: 332
496 Subject Index