You are on page 1of 7

A Survey of Reservation Based Smart Parking System

Darman1, Andri Purnomo2, Fauzi Yuniary Rachman3


123
Graduate Program of Electrical Engineering Department,
Mercu Buana University, Jakarta
Email: darmandarsosumarto@gmail.com1, andrimte30@gmail.com2, fauzistruggle@gmail.com3

Abstract— Nowadays with the increasing number of vehicles in In this paper, firstly we give an overview about the concept of
big cities and more decreasing of parking space, many driver smart parking system, their categories and different
cars are difficult to get the parking lots especially during peak functionalities. Then we make a survey of the Smart parking
hours. When driver car go to somewhere or building, they do not research and implementations. We describe the technologies
know whether there is an empty parking slot or not at their around parking availability monitoring, parking
destination. It can be problem when driver car arrive at any reservation and dynamic pricing and see how they are utilized
destination but the parking slot not available. Previously, a lot of
in different settings. Finally a theoretical comparison is
research has been done to find out the availability of parking
presented to show advantages and disadvantages of each
space to overcome the problem of limited parking area. In this
paper we provide an overview the concept of smart parking different smart parking systems and a comparison of
technology with different approaches. Then we dedicate the latest technologies used in every system.
development about smart parking infrastructure. We describe
technologies around monitoring the availability of parking lots,
parking reservations. The parking system handles various
technologies, and the categories of those techniques are given.
II. SMART PARKING SYSTEM
Additionally we propose smart parking system with reservation
based on camera analytic approach to recognize the unauthorized
reserved car in the future research. Smart Parking systems typically obtains information about
available parking spaces in a particular geographic area and
process is real-time to place vehicles at available positions .It
Keywords— Smart parking Systems, Smart parking involves using low-cost sensors, real-time data collection, and
Technologies, Sensors, Smart parking services. mobile-phone-enabled automated payment systems that allow
people to reserve parking in advance or very accurately
predict where they will likely find a spot. When deployed as a
system, smart parking thus reduces car emissions in urban
I. INTRODUCTION centers by reducing the need for people to needlessly circle
city blocks searching for parking. It also permits cities to
Traffic congestion caused by vehicle is an alarming problem carefully manage their parking supply. Smart parking helps
at a global scale and it has been growing exponentially. The one of the biggest problems on driving in urban areas; finding
parking problem in big cities, especially the mega-cities, has empty parking spaces and controlling illegal parking. This
become one of the key causes of the city traffic implies M2M technologies aims rightness/safety as well as
congestion, driver frustration and air pollution. Searching for convenience.
a parking space is a routine (and often frustrating) activity for The numbers of vehicles on the road are increasing
many people in cities around the world. This search burns tremendously [1]. Smart parking is a parking garage system
about one million barrels of the world’s oil every day. As the that utilizes various technologies to efficiently manage
global population continues to urbanize, without a well- the garage [2]. Many cities have been starting smart
planned, convenience-driven retreat from the car these parking projects. Smart parking is a way to help drivers find
problems will worsen. So researchers are recently turned to satisfied parking places efficiently through
applying technologies for management of parking area by information and communications technology, especially for
designing and implementation of a prototype system of on-street parking. Smart parking can also be defined as a
smart parking that allows vehicle drivers to effectively find parking system that helps drivers find a vacant spot using
the free parking places. In the future the demand for the sensors that detect the presence or absence of a vehicle, and
intelligent parking service will increase because the rapid finally direct incoming drivers to available locations.
growth in the automotive industries. An effective solution to
this service can be provided by many new technologies.
Smart parking systems can be categorized into many systems:
Smart parking, allowing drivers to access parking
parking guidance and information system (PGIS), transit
information through their smartphones. Many cities have
based information system, smart payment system, E-parking
been launching their smart parking projects and apps, yet still
and automated parking [2]. Every System uses different
very few drivers can really benefit from them. That is because
Technologies to detect the presence of car in the slot, the
this technology still has to be improved from different
author in [3] divided vehicle sensors and detector system into
perspectives: the robustness of sensor devices, the stability
two main categories: intrusive and non-intrusive sensors.
and timeliness of sensor networks, the quality and agility of
urban service.
• Intrusive sensors are sensors which are installed in the image of parking lot and produces the information of the
holes on the road surface, by tunneling under the road empty car parking spaces.
which leads to invasive procedures of installation.
Examples of intrusive sensors: Active infrared Drivers in big cities wasted time searching for the available
sensors, Inductive loops, Magnetometers, Magneto- parking spaces which increase traffic and pollution. To resolve
resistive sensors. this problem Yee H.C & al [8] have proposed a smart and secure
• Non-intrusive sensors can easily be installed and parking reservation system based on GSM technology.
maintained and does not affect the surface in the This system is divided on two modules parking lot monitoring
process. Non-intrusive sensors encompass microwave and security reservation module. The contribution of this work is
radar, passive acoustic array sensors, passive infrared the use of password in and out. The main hardware and software
sensor, RFID, ultrasonic and video image processing. functions in this system are Pic Microcontroller, Visual Basic,
LCD to inform the driver if the password is wrong, motor driver
which control the barrier gate it is active when the password is
wright, and finally the GSM which play the role of interface
III. SURVEY ON PARKING SYSTEMS between the user and PC.

The author proposes [9] a monitoring parking space system


Cities noticed that their drivers had real problems to find a using wireless technologies. The system is divided on two
parking space easily especially during peak hours, the modules: monitoring and master modules in order to help drivers
difficulty roots from not knowing where the parking spaces finding vacant parking slot. The presence of vehicles is detected
are available at the given time. Even if this is known, many by the use of digital infrared sensors which is interfaced with
vehicles may pursue a small number of parking spaces which the microcontroller. The ZigBee will receive the status
in turn leads to traffic congestion. Various approaches and information and master module will check for the vacant places
researches are made to overcome the difficulties of parking in parking.
Area. As a result, many systems and technologies are
developed for parking. Every day vehicle drivers have to find a vacant parking space
especially during the rush hours. It is time-consuming and it is
The author in [4] present the design and implementation of a leading to more traffic, and air pollution. Singh, H. & al [10]
smart parking system based on wireless sensor networks that presented a solution based on secure vehicle parking
allow vehicle drivers to find the free parking places. The management and reservation scheme using wireless
scheme is based on WSNs, Embedded Web-Server, Central technology. The system is divided on three modules: monitoring
Web-Server and Mobile phone application. The driver can module, parking lot reservation module, and security module.
detect the state of the parking slot using mobile devices thanks
to sensor node in each parking slot which detect the state of In [11], the authors proposed an automated parking system using
this one and report it to embedded web-server and finally the Bluetooth as a means of access which is a wireless technology
information is sent to central web-server using Wi-Fi networks standard for exchanging data over short distances. This system
in real time. uses a mechanical system that transports vehicles to and from
parking lots without intervention of the driver. When the driver
This paper [5] present an invention that could be applied to enter to the parking the vehicle is placed on a movable platform
monitor and manage vehicles in a parking garage by he starts his Bluetooth and start the parking process, the
informing drivers about the number of available parking Bluetooth reader fetches the user’s Bluetooth id and stores it in
spaces and in which area should they be directed to. The scheme database, the ARM microcontroller compares the ID with
is based on the modification of the original WSN and use of numbers stored. In the case of new vehicle the parking process is
RFID and ZigBee technology. To evaluate other meaningful initiated in the other case the vehicle which has already been
metrics such as time etc. The information obtained from each parked needs to be retrieved and the retrieving process is
sensing node is processed collaboratively in two manners either started.
in distributed or centralized manner.
The integration of networked sensors and RFID technologies
[12] is considered in an automatic car park management.
The objective in [6] is to design an intelligent parking
Authors proposed a scalable and low cost car parking
guidance and information system with ARM8 microcontroller
framework (CFP). These include driver guidance, automatic
which can run on an embedded system. The author also
introduce an important feature like fetching the above said payment, parking lot retrieval, security and vandalism detection.
status of the parking slot on the web or internet and status can In this paper the author proposes the clustering of a bunch of
update particular time. The webcam finds the free slots for sensors and the use of hybrid wireless communications instead
parking. It can capture slots at a time and display it on touch of mote in every spot which have a lot of drawbacks in
screen LCD. It will display red color box on LCD if any car is terms of cost and energy consumption. The implementation
present in the slot. If the slot is free it will display empty slot of CPF includes 3 parts: parking manager, gate manager
number on the LCD. If any person wants to book the slot, send and parking spots manager.
slot number through SMS. The controller receives the slot
number information through GSM. After receiving the
information the controller keeps the slot free.

The implemented prototype model is based on image processing


technique [7]. The system captures and processes
The author in [13] presents a wireless system for locating
parking spots remotely via smartphone. This system automates The system is fully automated with the use of the Peripheral
the process of locating an available parking spot and paying Interface Controller (PIC). This microcontroller is capable in
for it. The sensors detect if there is a car in the parking spot, if storing information of empty parking spaces, provide
the car is located no action occurs but if the spot is available passwords as well as allowing or denying access to the parking
the wireless sensor node transmits the location to the servers at area.
each parking area. The servers send the details to the back-
end. Once user is within 2 km of the parking the server In study [19] author investigates the problems of car parking
determines the closest available parking spot and sends system in Malaysia and proposed a Wireless Mobile-based Car
location to the user. Parking System using low cost SMS service. The
implementation of SMS service into the car parking system
An agent based coordination network between drivers and car enable drivers to receive information regarding the availability
parks is proposed [14]. .the prototype is designed through the of car parking spaces. In this system, the drivers can resend
MaSE methodology. The system considers 3 criteria for driver SMS to request for new assignment of car parking spaces if
demand: negotiation of parking fees, the distance from the they fail to get the previous assigned destination. This paper
current location to the chosen car park and finally park’s demonstrates the design and implementation of Wireless
booking and reservation. The negotiation algorithms are Mobile-based Car Parking System (WMCPS) using SMS
employed to bargain on parking prices and to calculate the services by Breadth First Search (BFS) algorithm in finding the
shortest path for driver. nearest parking space for drivers

In this study [15]. The author designs an automatic smart In study [20] Author proposes a vehicle detection algorithm,
parking using internet of things which enables the user to find named Peak-Valley Algorithm (PVA), based on the Wireless
the nearest parking area and the available slot in that area. The Sensor Networks (WSN). By measuring the disturbance of the
architecture of the parking system consists of several Earth’s magnetic field, when a vehicle passes through a
components: centralized server, Raspberry PI, image capture, Honeywell 3-axis sensor, the vehicle can be detected. A large
navigation system, display device and user device. The cloud number of experimental data have been collected and analyzed.
[based IOT architecture contains cloud service to store The system can perform in real-time with detection accuracy as
information about status of parking slots and the centralized high as 98.68% for vehicles. Especially, it can effectively solve
server which stores smart parking system information. The the fluctuation problem caused by temperature drift in the
driver can access and map the status of parking slots from any baseline tracking method.
remote location through web browser. But in [16] the author
introduced a smart parking system using cloud-based In study [21] Author using a WSN to build an efficient and
platforms as a service (Paas). The (Paas) provides the tools and smart parking system for vehicles. The application will use
services needed to create smart parking solution. We distinguish light sensors to automatically determine the use of parking
two types of Paas: IOT middleware platform as back-end data spaces in a parking area and calculate billable parking time
platform and front-end dashboard platform for virtualization and while also providing a useful overview of occupied and free
reporting. The IOT middleware contains 3 modules: data parking spaces to vehicle operators. Such a system can provide
storage module, device management module and processing increased driver comfort and reduce costs in parking space
module. The utilization of Paas has resulted in the creation of operation by allowing drivers to easily decide on where to
faster smart parking system which has a lot of benefits. park, while the used components only generate low costs for
the operator.
The author in [17]designs a prototype for IOT based car parking
In study [22] Author propose system with make the drivers
management system for smart cities using infrared sensors,
easier to park the vehicles and also overcome traffic
RFID and IOT. This prototype offers a lot of services: finding
congestion. Drivers can initiate request using reservation app in
parking space availability, IOT maintains the database
the android mobile to determine the availability of the parking
of parked vehicle through a shared server, booking slots and slot. If the slot is available a driver can reserve a slot through
finally theft management. It has also some advantages: less online payment system. The propose system also enables
human interaction, increases flexibility and security. This drivers to cancel the reserved parking slot. Amount will be
system consists of different modules: online booking, parking refunded after cancellation charges. Thus a low cost prototype
entrance system, parking exit system and parking management. for smart parking with reservation is proposed using sensor,
Arduino and android in cloud platform.
In the study [18] discribe a smart parking system reservation
system is developed in such a way that users book their In study [23] Author proposed smart parking has been focused
parking spots through short message services (SMS). The SMS due to the development of indoor position technology. There
sent will be processed by a wireless communication are several smart parking systems for garage. But there are two
instrumentation device called micro-RTU (Remote Terminal major problems in these systems. The first one is the detection
Unit). This micro-RTU will reply the confirmation of booking of parking space occupation, and the second one is space
by giving the details of reservation like password and lot navigation.To solve these two problems, we propose a smart
number. The password will be used to enter the parking area parking system combining WiFi and wireless sensor network.
and valid for a certain period of time. In this system, geomagnetic sensors are used to detect the
occupation of parking spaces, and WiFi is used for navigation.
A prototype system has been developed.
In study [24] literature review conducted for this paper offers users and the PRS, real time monitoring of the current parking
an in-depth review of the recent advances in sensing and availability, and estimates of the anticipated demand. The
communication technology concerning parking systems. In anticipated demand could be estimated based on the number of
addition, this paper presents a survey and analysis of an people who reserved a space and the expected number of non-
academic, qualitative literature review. It includes an in-depth reserved arrivals during the next few time periods that could be
study of the selected topics and provides a step by step based on historical arrival data. The users would be able to
implementation process. It reviews different smart parking reserve a parking space and receive a response from the PRS
systems used for parking guidance and parking facility through a variety of communication media such as telephone,
management and gives an insight into the technical aspects and fax, or the web.
specifications analysis of such systems that have been
published in academia during the last 15 years. In study [31] author provide classifications of smart parking
system as Intelligent Transport System (ITS). ITS systems are
In study [25] Author provide an example of such opportunity, a set of information, communications and technologies for
by describing Park Here!, a novel mobile application that aims vehicles and infrastructures focused on the transport. The
at mitigating the over- head caused by parking spot seeking information can be offered by an accurate vehicle classification
operations in urban areas. Our solution targets common city using WSNs.
environments, where no per- spot sensors are available, and
there is no remote service allowing the reservation in-advance In study [32] author provide classifications of smart parking
of a parking spot. For this scenario, we propose a novel system as Intelligent Parking Assist System (IPAS). This
algorithm for the automatic detection of parking actions system was designed for reverse parallel parking. It does not
performed by the user, through the analysis of smart- phone require driver's attention, and it can automatically place the car
embedded sensors (accelerometer/gyroscope), and of the by guiding the vehicle appropriately. This system is also
Bluetooth connectivity. Once a parking event has been known as Advanced Parking Guidance System (APGS).
detected, an adaptive strategy allows disseminating the
information over the target scenario, using a combination of In study [33] author provide classifications of smart parking
Internet connection to a remote server, and Device-to-Device system as Agent Based Guiding System (ABGS). An agent can
(D2D) connection over WiFi Direct links. Preliminary be any entity capable of perceiving facts through sensors and
experiments demonstrate the accuracy of the proposed acting upon the environment through effectors or exchanging
algorithm in correctly identifying parking events in an information. It has useful characteristics such as autonomy,
automatic way, and hence in notifying information to other reactivity, adaptability, pro activity, and social ability. Such
potentially interested users. characteristics are very suitable for problems with highly
dynamic and interactive behavior and are thus applied to
In study [26] author provide classifications of smart parking establish the automation mechanism in the parking negotiation
system as centralized assisted parking search (CAPS), non- and guidance system in this study.
assisted parking search (NAPS) and opportunistically assisted
parking search (OAPS). In centralized assisted parking search In (Table 1) we divided the parking system into 5 parts:
(CAPS), the information processing will lay on the central • Collection: relies on sensors to collect the real-time
processor (server). The server will collect information from a parking.
sensor in the parking spot and take decisions respectively. • Deployment: deals with the communication methods.
However, this centralized approach always has some • Urban Services: can be provided to the user once the
challenges. data storage and information monitoring are done.
• Connection: concerns the IOT layer which
In study [27] author provide classifications of smart parking maintains the database of the parked vehicles through
system as transit based information system (TBIS). The a shared server.
Transit based information system (TBIS) provides guidance • IHM: means the technologies used as interface
for park-and-ride facilities. This system succeeds in between human and the parking system.
implementing, and it reduces the inconvenience of the users.

In study [28] author provide classifications of smart parking IV. DISCUSSION


system as E-Parking System. E-Parking is a system where the
SMS or the internet is used for efficient parking. This system
also includes a smart payment mechanism. For reservation From this two tables shown below (Table I, Table II), we can
mechanism mobile phones or reservation centers are used. see that only one smart parking system has used an intelligent
Wireless Application Protocol (WAP) enabled mobile phones, agent system. For that reason we will propose a multi-agent
and Personal Digital Assistants (PDAs) are also used by this parking system based on expert systems that offers many
system. services for the driver. Agent-based systems technology has
been hailed as a new paradigm for conceptualizing,
In study [29] author provide classifications of smart parking designing, and implementing software systems. Agents are
system as Car Park Occupancy Information System (COINS). sophisticated computer programs that act autonomously on
This system checks the vacancy for parking the car by video behalf of their users, across open and distributed
sensor. The image-processing technique is used, and vacancy environments, to solve a growing number of complex
information is displayed in a display panel. problems. Increasingly, however, applications require
multiple agents that can work together. A multi-agent system
In study [30] author provide classifications of smart parking (MAS) is a loosely coupled network of software agents that
system as Parking Reservation System (PRS). PRS would interact to solve problems that are beyond the individual
require the establishment of parking reservation operations capacities or knowledge of each problem.
information centers, a communication system between the
TABLE I. Matrix Related Research

Collection Deployement Services Connection IHM

Researcher

Type of sensor WSN CON GY PY LR SE RE GM AC PM CC SP WA VICS

Yang, J.,
Portilla, J., & Light sensor WiFi WiFi-3G + + + + +
Riesgo, T.

Patil, M., & Reflection


Bhonge, V. N.
ZigBee + + +
sensor+RFID

P.DharmaReddy,
A.
CMOS
RajeshwarRao, GSM + + + +
Dr. Syed Camera
Musthak Ahmed
Al-Kharusi,
H., & Al- Camera + + +
Bahadly, I.
Rahayu, Y., &
GSM + + + + + +
Mustapa, F. N.

digital
Yee, H. C., &
infrared ZigBee + + + +
Rahayu, Y.
sensor

Infrared
A.Poojaa ZigBee GSM + + + + + +
Sensor

Singh, H.,
Anand, C.,
Bluetooth + + + + +
Kumar, V., &
Sharma, A
Karbab, E.,
Djenouri, D.,
ultrasonic
Boulkaboul, ZigBee Wifi-3G + + + + + + + + +
sensor,+RFID
S., & Bagula,
A
Orrie, O.,
Silva, B., & Sensor+RFID + + + + +
Hancke, G. P.
Chou, S. Y.,
Contract
Lin, S. W., & Agent + + + + + +
net
Li, C. C.

Basavaraju S
Pi camera WiFi + + + +
R.

Suryady, Z.,
Sinniah, G. R.,
Haseeb, S.,
ferromagnetic
Siddique, M. ZigBee + + + +
sensor
T., & Ezani,
M. F.
M.
Gandhi, B. M.
Infrared
K., & Rao, M. + + + + + + + +
sensor+RFID
K.

Darman, Andri
IP Camera WiFi GSM + + + + + + + + +
& Fauzi

GY:GUIDANCE PY:PAYEMENT LR:LOT RETRIEVAL SE:SECURITY


RE:RESERVATION M:GATE MANAGEMENT PM:PARKING MANAGEMENT USING SMARTPHONE
AC: AVAILABILITY CHECKING OVER INTERNET
CC:CLOUD COMPUTING WA:WEB APPLICATION SP:SMARTPHONE VICS:IN-VEHICLE SY (+) : THE TECHNOLOGY OR THE SERVICE IS USED
IN THE PAPER
pp. 4044–4048, 2013.
V. FUTURE WORK [7] H. Al-Kharusi and I. Al-Bahadly, “Intelligent Parking Management
System Based on Image Processing,” World J. Eng. Technol., vol. 2,
no. 2, pp. 55–67, 2014.
In the future work we will propose a dynamic smart parking
[8] Y. Rahayu and F. N. Mustapa, “A Secure Parking Reservation System
architecture based on multi agent systems. Our system will be Using GSM Technology,” Int. J. Comput. Commun. Eng., vol. 2, no.
divided to different process: 4, pp. 518–520, 2013.
• Communication module: It will concern the request [9] H. C. Yee, Y. Rahayu, and S. Member, “Monitoring Parking Space
send by the driver to the system. Availability via Zigbee Technology,” vol. 3, no. 6, pp. 377–380, 2014.
• Coordination module: at this level we find agents [10] E. Science, “WSN BASED SECURE VEHICLE PARKING
which have the role of displaying information to the MANAGEMENT AND RESERVATION SYSTEM,” pp. 1–4, 2015.
user in a suitable manner taking into account [11] H. Singh, C. Anand, V. Kumar, and A. Sharma, “Automated parking
system with bluetooth access,” vol. 3, no. 5, pp. 3–8, 2014.
constraints of the device.
[12] E. Karbab, D. Djenouri, S. Boulkaboul, and A. Bagula, “Car Park
• Processing module: the main role of this module is Management with Networked Wireless Sensors and Active {RFID},”
the processing of different queries sent by the user pp. 373–378, 2015.
e.g.: reservation, payment, check-in, check-out, etc. [13] O. Orrie, B. Silva, and G. P. Hancke, “A Wireless Smart Parking
• Data module: it contains data of the parking saved on System,” pp. 4110–4114, 2015.
real time. [14] S. Y. Chou, S. W. Lin, and C. C. Li, “Dynamic parking negotiation
The contribution of our system will concern the data analysis and guidance using an agent-based platform,” Expert Syst. Appl., vol.
process which is the node of our system .For that reason we 35, no. 3, pp. 805–817, 2008.
will use different modern techniques such as Expert Systems [15] S. R. Basavaraju, “Automatic Smart Parking System using Internet of
and SMA. We should integrate the two different technologies Things (IOT),” Int. J. Sci. Res. Publ., vol. 5, no. 12, pp. 629–632,
2015.
together in order to achieve a system which is the most
[16] Z. Suryady, G. R. Sinniah, S. Haseeb, M. T. Siddique, and M. F. M.
efficient, reliable, secure and inexpensive. Expert systems Ezani, “Rapid Development of Smart Parking System with Cloud-
have a lot of attractive features: based Platforms.”
• Increased availability. [17] B. M. Kumar Gandhi and M. Kameswara Rao, “A prototype for IoT
• Reduced cost based car parking management system for smart cities,” Indian J. Sci.
Technol., vol. 9, no. 17, 2016.
• Reduced danger
[18] N. H. H. M. Hanif, M. H. Badiozaman, and H. Daud, “Smart parking
• Permanence reservation system using short message services (SMS),” 2010 Int.
• Increased reliability Conf. Intell. Adv. Syst. ICIAS 2010, 2010.
• Explanation [19] S. C. Khang, T. J. Hong, T. S. Chin, and S. Wang, “Wireless mobile-
• Fast and complete response at all times based shopping mall car parking system (WMCPS),” Proc. - 2010
IEEE Asia-Pacific Serv. Comput. Conf. APSCC 2010, pp. 573–577,
• Intelligent Database 2010.
• Multiple expertise [20] Xiangke Guan, Zusheng Zhang, Jingquan Zhou, and Fengqi Yu, “A
vehicle detection algorithm based on wireless magnetic sensor
networks,” 2013 8th Int. Conf. Commun. Netw. China, pp. 669–674,
VI. CONCLUSION 2013.
In this paper, we define the concept of the smart parking [21] S. S. Adhatarao, O. Alfandi, A. Bochem, and D. Hogrefe, “Smart
parking system for vehicles,” IEEE Veh. Netw. Conf. VNC, vol. 2015–
system, their Types and the classification of different Janua, no. January, pp. 189–190, 2015.
technologies. After we give a survey of different parking
[22] M. Karthi and P. Harris, “2016 IEEE International Conference on
systems which was implemented by many researches to resolve Cloud Computing in Emerging Markets SMART PARKING WITH
the growing problem of traffic congestion, wasted time, RESERVATION IN CLOUD BASED ENVIRONMENT I .
wasting money, and help provide better public service , reduce INTRODUCTION II . RELATED WORKS III . SYSTEM
ARCHITECTURE,” pp. 168–171, 2016.
car emissions and pollution, improve city visitor. The table
contains advantages and disadvantages of various parking [23] C. Yuan, L. Fei, C. Jianxin, and J. Wei, “A smart parking system
using WiFi and wireless sensor network,” 2016 IEEE Int. Conf.
systems implemented by researchers. As a future work we will Consum. Electron. ICCE-TW 2016, pp. 7–8, 2016.
propose a dynamic architecture based on multi-agent systems [24] M. Fraifer and M. Fernström, “Investigation of Smart Parking
and expert systems for smart parking management. Systems and their technologies,” pp. 1–14, 2016.
[25] R. Salpietro, L. Bedogni, M. Di Felice, and L. Bononi, “Park Here! a
REFERENCES smart parking system based on smartphones’ embedded sensors and
short range Communication Technologies,” IEEE World Forum
[1] U. Azeem, “Traffic congestion in Indian cities : Challenges of a rising Internet Things, WF-IoT 2015 - Proc., pp. 18–23, 2016.
power,” Kyoto Cities, Naples, Mar 26-28, 2009, no. March, pp. 1–7,
2009. [26] E. Kokolaki, M. Karaliopoulos, I. Starakakis,
"Opportunisticallyassisted parking service discovery: now it helps,
[2] J. C. J. Chinrungrueng, U. S. U. Sunantachaikul, and S. T. S. now it does not," Elseveir Journal of Pervasive and Mobile
Triamlumlerd, “Smart Parking: An Application of Optical Wireless Computing (PMC), (2011 In Press).
Sensor Network,” 2007 Int. Symp. Appl. Internet Work., pp. 66–66,
2007. [27] K. C. Mosques, M. Boil and N. Parker, 2007, “Technical solutions to
overcrowd park and ride facilities,” University Transportation
[3] L. E. Y. Mimbela, “A Summary of Vehicle Detection and Surveillance Research Center-Region 2. Final Report, FHWA-NJ-2007-01.
Technologies used in IN INTELLIGENT TRANSPORTATION Available:
SYSTEMS,” 2000. http://www.nj.gov/transportation/refdata/research/reports/FHWA-
[4] J. Jeffrey, R. G. Patil, S. Kumar, K. Narahari, J. Bapat, and D. Das, NJ2007-011.pdf.
“Smart Parking System using Wireless Sensor Networks,” pp. 306– [28] K. Inaba, M. Shibui, T. Naganawa, M. Ogiwara and N. Yoshikai,
311, 2012. “Intelligent Parking Reservation Service on the internet,” SAINT-W,
[5] M. Patil and V. Bhonge, “Wireless sensor network and RFID for smart Symposium on Applications and the Internet-Workshops (SAINT 2001
parking system,” Int. J. Emerg. Technol. …, vol. 3, no. 4, pp. 188–192, Workshops),Jan 8-12, San Diego, CA, USA., 2001, pp. 159-164.
2013. [29] D.B.L. Bong, K.C. Ting and K.C. Lai, “Integrated approach in the
[6] P. Dharmareddy, A. Rajeshwarrao, and S. M. Ahmed, “An Intelligent design of Car Park Occupancy Information System (COINS),” IAENG
Parking Guidance and Information System by using image processing Int. J. Comput. Sci., 2008, Vol. 35, pp. 7-14
technique,” Int. J. Adv. Res. Comput. Commun. Eng., vol. 10, no. 10,
[30] Kyriacos C. Mouskos, Maria Boile, Neville Parker, “Technical
solutions to overcrowded park and ride facilities,” University
Transportation Research Center-Region 2, May 2007.
[31] Ivan Corredor, Ana-B Garcia, Jose-F Martinez, Pedro Lopez,
“Wireless Sensor Network-based system for measuring and monitoring
road traffic,” CollECTeR Iberoamérica 2008.
[32] Intelligent Parking Assist System
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intelligent_Parking_Assist_System.
[33] Shuo-Yan Chou, Shih-Wei Lin, Chien-Chang Li, “Dynamic parking
negotiation and guidance using an agent-based platform,” Expert
Systems with Applications, 2008,Vol. 34, pp. 805–817.

You might also like