nejtp7,,l1 f it bet.

rayed when
N

h0
th M SI(,loll°,
rev led my name
N Family said life `intolerable'
Scientist slashed his wrist
'6AVID KC7 LY fc ,etrnyed by
,e and w Nicholas Hufford
pw Under mtolenble pressure b7
I'll pla.ed ei rhe cenlre of the Ill I,^'n it,,( he wouid be idem,ticd
low bet"c" the
,he suit tile lollowlng day ' I ael shcrked "
BBC he said "I wes,nld do- whnle Ill, .,
The guvunn,eln suenost who wouldbc,.onlldenUal'
n toll 'it dcad ,n a field wvh a 19o sera of betrayol waa palpable
da5hed wnst near to, hame on and he felt pocuordly Iv do, .
rnaay olso ,aid he waa p,it by the MoD Kelly s nine wa,
through the wnvl;er' during meeo puhb,lmd m newspapns days an,,
rog, with Munslry uf Ddence lelmr nanllng hnn wa senl
lMoUl oilusats and spaf.e oi 'rnan7 b, Geolf Billion, the defrns,a scell-
th ick acwa plryvmg games' I ., m Gasyn Davie, chaunian ef
the EHt'
Isst nlght n elneroed that Kelly s
, u,nfim,ed lo at Irast
die, newspapers b, 11,un Tsar, be
MaD s dne, .rorol nncs, un lnly 9
cidw"e .,osh' . ., it to lie,
Postal defended his actions it
pas"mg Kelly's nmne su the BBC
IIe lied he hod wunen an "calm,-l,
cwMdenUal leud' m d,e 6nC chmr
man He el"u cited tile MoD hld
Imked Kelly', it'mox saymg r'w
nut awnre that III s Inme wi, leaked'
Ken, hunselL bete,e hc gave
cu,denueloaparhamemaryu nnut-
tce aald he tvaa COineed he w
the mtclhgence,o,n,.e yated by the
BBC In us Iluw canw,¢rsml repott
e,tdclme If Imi wwpohe of
s, destrucUon bruxdcast un May
22 "11 ,s I'll, ob,ion, I was ft
OF ]9i'! 107NbdI16a s,vrce " he caid
III 'couters, li on, of which be
OR KELLY asked to be off the re<ord Kelly
,old he ,,, K,lot,, he slain of
FocussNages 13-16 w eek, of ,ococrs, a, the low iii
tens,ful owr Ihc idenlll) of die Kelly's widow Janme and one of their daughters emerge near tile family home m Southmoor. Oxfordshire, yesterdav as the Political ramitlcahons al his death nrnw
BBC's source
1 he d
.,
.
,
 11-run nrade In an lot" - "it has been a dilhcull one, as armed basics cerise, cicilicogsd Polite e, .l,fomled yaterday list cod C,u,h,1I o,ld fn,nds thia It. K, ii.a ., ti, o, will boq In no c old Iile end ol the week befure J
aud r-inal6, "on, as cnbmrt yoo no ,magme Cc said it, avd she 89C tn "it, cut the salenost 1 hc . .... of kally's death was l, 1 snk' whu, he head ef Kelll s e ,ad sent to so Amencan 7uor~eb ludgmv mecpon to III tesl,lon 7 2
.to .. . . ... pr,vn,ely ,'dnnlUd 7ester for she record' , lie had ,tot been as (lie ,ovre, saying Hopelully Meet ., Iron, e wuund ,,, I . . . I'll dcarnla,rerpenadtnleasr[Mwn- ntonlhcdaybedied Kelly refured /
da, Ihal do, i ,na,l.ed the "'roc,u ded , ssured by the dill wnnd all .. 1), Kelly In c arrl xnv A i te~ paotrode~ m°, Slre,a Ill's yeaf, bill q~16 stey lo "many dark actors P1c~m8
Inanother ht5ald 'Hopefully it r~
will soon p ass and I will get back lu "t
a,~,e .t ohce,l crisis It For) MnD, w hl,h 11e d barn qulN ood on will Ius cue,, In Ule MuD We load 111,ur I, J,odv "old lielndnlall",11In.. . . . unit, , hord gamcs
by Ill, e-Innd we, , ntten Baghdad and gel nn with tha)oh"
Bu, s premlcr,hlp aboul u I3e1 liters are suggeatmns Seecral ,,k, xo MoD I{unon is rompleted llours Woo, he lold hls wife hc was A stelanent from Aellu c Ivmd,
In wha,  bebe,ed t', be his that Kelly (eared he imghl to,, hs ce hed ,aid rlrne aa, n deternu- ,,I, oc,t di, it,,, .1cold lead 1. Thcic uio nule.ns'e Kelll gmng for a wel6 on Moist, released }esterdev sa,d 'E,em ~
I~ISt inles" iew hefnrc lie died belly pn,ao  u his lob d he did nahon [it Wrnofy Me BHt s Inol, he ef sls,ui, Ca,,i,b,ll, l ell¢m;hl mr d,chaulebeinswaged Inothermes,a¢esbeveernedtobe mer rc.enl pceks he,, mtdc r7
I,dd Tile snnday To. ., he had not co-operele en and nan,e Nov, m ,n nooapt to tm Te,lowi . .... . sit ..... tla. Mo0
11 and thc BBC loukm4forwudsa,ctum,netoIraq Desut,jtfc tolerahk m,d all sitGGG~~'
been wlephaned by tile Moll Ascot Last week ANm Ing,am the a apolowiromthecmpnrnnou Is, ~,cl ocacrouu,-Inc~ .. . I lo, week- overthegmenm,entsyosnh-ahon` Inone,Kellvwroscliewould in, Irzrzbrit,nlp,lg¢7
N

4J

Police forensLC experts search a path near Me home of Kelly In Southmoor, Oxfordshire, yesterday A full examination of the family home and gardens was also conducted
Hoon denies MoD
leaked Tidentity
6onnrnrred frvrn pu I°~
those mvalved v'htaLi ilect
loug and hard on this fact"
One family t mntber x
,pored as sayLng he would be
looking fur "someone who w
going to pay for this~ bcoouse
somewhetealong theline somc-
on neods m pal tar this
Derek Vuwdrey, he soen-
LLa > broLher at law, rnd
Da,cd par If,, herd above the
parepct and promptly got ft
,han of The .,,,a cat on,
IookLng In, someone ro nor
the otle of mole on and DavLd
and me wnrnaLe price for dua
Ho simply couldn't ukc the
pressnre'
lhegcnrmcntsaWap omt-
mg fnanq a law had, reflected
the senousness of its deareto
,l to the bottom of the aric.
A key iauc will be how Kelly s
name wu> made puhlu. It is
expected Campbell and ode,
senlorzoreinmcnt firm . ,,It
be c .rued to gr, e .rdeaee
Ru.hard Sambmak thc head
of BBC news, has also been
aacu.edurdiopping'pretly htg
hint, abort the Wcnuty af
tire BBC v source to bolster din
mrporauon s clnims that (In,
sulhnently senior
to u[one wMrn involved ft Lhe
preparabnn of the government s
nrtollmence dossmr
] .day, however, Vmcent
Ntd,ol4 the Borneo Catholic
Amhbishop ol BIrrLmgWlq
.Al mrphc0y cunnse life
BBC ~a a servnc in Lshbcld
Cathedral lie iv expected to
say It dLStresses me deeply to
Lhmk Ihere cm, pcople m pu+i-
(,air, nfenmmntpubberespon-
>ibd`ywholarow_Lbesnswcn
- `t'°(a,juTfi""' .,-_
;~~t ~ dn3^u': W
m the questions Dr Kelly was pats o( Gdbgao s n~Wctm In
being askcd Yen thcy remanr the ComvmLS foreLgn anarrs
sdenp behevmg the canGdenu- commntee - to whsh the
alloy of thcn sonrces Ls moee BBC reponer drscusaed what
LmporteLn More importantmnn his source told him - bore
one man's life? drink not" clrrce sundanltes to Kelly's
Kelly's initial mdLCsuon that own'turns of phrase"
he was the source ,s said to Preasure or Kelly trteresaed
have wntmn m conndcnce to funher when he was told he
his line monager oif June 30, wuuldhavetoappcw beforethe
toy announce and the Imus,
atlans committee On successive
days (nlleagues bJLevnl he
bought he had a it" with the
MoD In go hefore the mlnlh-
gence ccannotwe or raw. for
xnouvmny Ile was auxtous at
the prospen M a telcvrsed
appeorance m front of the for-
e,grr effavs commmeo
Andrew Mackrnlay, n Labour
'David Kelly's face was member nf Um forelgn .([ms
an open confession . ' commute, apoloStsed yester-
r'I feel as though I hue tlay or In, harsh questronmg of
Kelly darn, Tuesday's Ireanng
been through the Mackmlay had been oL.cused
STATEMENT ISSUED BY THE FAMILY OP DAVID KELLY
wringer," he said : by fom Mangold a honor,
BBC colrespondent and (vend
Nicholas R.1ford, the last of Kelly, of }eenng' at him
journalist to intennew, the dunog quesuorung when he "We are utterly devastated and heartbroken by pndeto a Events over recent weeks made,
weapotts expert, deecnbes dLSmrssed him as "chafl' be death of our husband, father and brother David's life intolerable and all of those
how an honest man was As prarsonc roomed it the
We loved him very much and will miss his mvoNed shauld reflect long and hard on the;
gotemnLCUq Blau yesterday
driven to kill himself warmth, humour and humanity Those who fact
urged pcople to wait for it,, m-I
knew him will remember him for ha devotion "We have been deeply moved by the many
Focus, pages 1&18 qmry to report hefore reaching
Leader, page 18 yodgn ents In W, mesnteme , to his home, family and the community and expressions of support from friends, family
they 'should show respect and counhysde in which he lived A wing, private and the local cdmmunity We would also like
resonant"
and di®ttfled man has been taken from us all lo pay tribute to the professionalism and
roluntecnng thnt he had met Glenda Jackson the Labour
Andrew Cilia., u BBt, MP, catied to, Bit,. Campbell "Damd's professional life was charactensed compassion of the ofllcpls of the Thames
delencetolLespondent and lluonturesrgn4hevLqamry by his integrity, honour and dedlcahon to Valley police force
It was said yesterday that mm Kelly s death would part- finding the truth, often in the most difficult of "It is hard lo comprehend Die enormity of
Kelly waspromptedtnwamby lyse [lie ooremment whrle circumstances His experlse was unique and this hagedy We appeal now lo everyone to
. cnlleague who wniked for tire an, remained, she smd universally respected, and his life and afford us the privacy to grieve m peace and,
Roydl ilmted 5eceres instltute Addmnrm1 reparnqc
If, colleague had drawn UeudCtvcknelt Jmirtrhan achievements will always be a source of great come to terms wtth on, lass "
Kelly 'sauenuonmLhefastgrant Car, UronnovdMmsCo6nr
jT ~1I
r_ u(;r~t_

e [),,,it Kelly among
a nu. In the ILrvew.ly
I III, Oelnrd,hne
boom Ii day, ego was
art hl,normalself Gmlewe,e
theu,nalmulcandlinnhand-
,hake H'ornodaadeUawn,he
rod Ihom nsik,,Irdly

'I ha,r Irecn tald by do,
MoD IVllnlslp of Delencel
not In w, anylhlng ' he said
1 a,ked h,nl why
'llhlnkyoualrcadyknnw"
Heloolasi,hel.pwh
A few days evhet I had sug-
ge,l .d m hum rbin he u,  Ill,
Look who had epalkul .I re
port on (ill BItC him the goo-
anmenthad",rxcdup " rnlelh
__ e on Iraq a weapon, W
n .u+ dc,trawun m help to
sell till warmareluclantpull
he . qe had dcmed n, but now
his faxe wms an open ennles
n Ho looked pale and In,
Jntht, hung bagglly off ho,
ulY Inlm .
no nInelly sprightly
" t ba, been a stay dd hcult
mine er son s,III Ilnagmc" Ite
urlnwrd
I~IDIIhtulIlnJeed Honevtand
Aerent kelly x a, nn peacend.
whretleblawer He knew
that Saddam Iloem had' fnr
ny year, punaed terrible
weapuns and hl had had " Ihcy
me In cmnpllmg one of the
go, . .. .. . ran " Jo r sr,rs about
III,,,
Howl-L, r Ibt ,etieu
Inu, s.,entl,l he frll alhad'ex -
egetau.d soine a,pctt, m ,1,
",rn,cnlallun P'hen .,I, tied by
il,e BBC s Andrew Gdhgah lu
omnmnt on it,, do,slcr he
bill done III In lonfillimiLl Laid
soherly he waa rlot a Loan ill
ar e word, like 'select up"
R kill Gllhgan s nutbsequenl
report had pn,voked open
adate he .twcen the BBC and
Dowmug Sttcet-a rlmh Id
hchen,nlh, than urat m if,,
hcev of a gleaner , I. . . had
tile plm,e 1nml,hr
. Ld
.', this
Learn, lo wen on ('he p¢.
Ifaco' -kehyIlad In"(")
umles,td Bus lolc to the
Nhnl K3eof Dalcnee
A, ,food Ilrerc In his
dnueway m the erenmg sun-
,hare 1 d,ked Kelly how the
MoD hall Irlaild into
'11), tire InLmdL the, hall,
feel, qmte good about It ""
Thea he mltlul Bar 1 hel m
tlmlrvh I has, been througll
Ilte xnngei
Ills ordeal was aholl6 to
hecanu .larunrse Hehed)mt
rece,ved a call from the MoD
press ol6,e ,ellmg hun than
his n .ln,c or, about m be
made publn Ile .11 going to
,m,, the Blatr govemmenl
czme tn power He had been
betrayed by ,hose he thought
he,.ouW tru,t
'Flaw did they know," I
,,Led
" They wnulrhll sa) 71,,
.I, aid it is ., going I. be I,,
tomnrrnwb pape,s'
'Wllodoyonw,pu.tleaked
your aan,em
"I don't know I was told
the whole thing would b
con6de,mal
Next day he was Ihmst
unpspared non Ill, full glare
af u,cdla auen,lon and pubhn
eraas exammauan b7 III, rna,-
lots m Whitehall -and kh
Iwsmlg n, the wfelt by file
insertion,nf,heBBC
7o them, pelhaps, Kelly
mood, a pawn n, the rat
and thrnst of politics lony
Scientist whose first loyalty was to seeking truth
fast n,rt Dovld Kelly v,
years ago m III Ins
finapert to,, In Iraq as
a Junked NatI ... I, ,,,
Los Inspectar Ile could took
stern whcn he shook yen,
hand Led looked at yen like I
arch ,c,aurst swdyln~
afurry laboratory antmal Bul
,hem w as a 'm-mill I, le,
,aaI, .mdhl,pLa,mmEIoy that
mmcd
mcdlz,ely
lz,e engegu, ""
w He , to mcly,ud "Su, whet
do you want 1. know atasal
Bowllnum loxmv AnthraJ
VXS Sm all ]here ,,, ,
Iwmkle m luc eye said enall
,mrlh u, Ins volm, and 1 was
,.apuvated straight away by
la, enthosrasm
Flc was an aeademn who
honaed he told n ","d ,he
means confines of acadogna
ht the ,km Elfin, teeth 1 rom
a msenrch pu,t at Oxford
Un rvc ay he Jenard proton
Dawn brain, s b,o-we .y,on,
defence eskWhOingent, here
he b.. .me head of nucmblol
ogy Il,e Gulf war m 1991
uas to cho,l ;e cverylhn,K
'when Carl ,,,,Idd
Kuwmt in August 1990 little
did 1 leallse Ow SadJmn
Hu,s would delate ill,
III,( IO )ems efen, ]if, 'he
sand 61om 1991 Imlrl 1998
Ix mxtle 37 nips to firaq,
many us Bnlaln s chlef weap
on spector with Oil UN
He was as delightful ill
em, ersnllon a, he uas
, ._ ._ III u  , """ ,,1., . " , .
-- = _ Si (J'hLU1
`_ Dr David Kell y al T y s wanted to do the right thin g" He al""I)` knew 'ller' 11'"' we' 'r'"11°lal ;aBoa` of gr°w°I
hm~orco,ennguplhclruth c medunn atqmred by Iraq,
°
`~sp`(3_fC~~~~0-j~1Yr ISts and was not afraid to admit it. But
~ When Oencrel 4m .r ,0
S,,ad, Saddam, eluef It
eml,r, and whluh sommrc,
had sold the n,alenal
umad,lsrl .drel,utnalhwr- 4lthoughflehaJofficeJ35
politicians and BBC powerbrokers failed him. Nicholas Ielnlerrll it) the American
m the Prnllfemhan and Arm,
lor r, n Ba^luled al ,he r,ad
Cnntlrd Seerol .u,,n m Lotukrn,
1 r ,11l "erond rnrlf war he kept n,osl of hn lap",
RufiFord reports on the tragedy of a personal friend `
Ktll,wa,ccalladoulolda,uf) .Ind archl,e malennl m In,
mlcrrogauon 11, ,,aid rally 1,11 on, ILE
Bla,rhad In, cyn on if,, ,, a id gatne ba,rog led to dm rr r¢u , qalckly . rnud<d tn ill, Imenlexcd doll-as of 91d If, ua, IIf, man who hlc .. . . .. if a pJe of paper ,oil[
eweepofhtstop mlltllapetty sun Ide of an honnumblc ulan United Nauons term ol Ilt- dare's olfiuals and mtlaary advsed Sndd" nn on what he dte .,amid tor a few sectxlds
details of a d .... . . Alas, in Kelly was a capom m- specrots wnked wllh smppnlg ullil.crs Involued ,I has , renal! all awry xltl, ' h, aid befell, producmg w,ill a floor-
rarupbdl Ble,rsurlnmuruca- spectoq a job be relished If, Saddam nt us neapnm it e,pln, p,og,amme, Ile ' ii, Law. where I]) the bodies In alt nb,ema Joe. lot that
w ,t as welcome esclpc ,ade,tru,. aalletoakmit kept meuculoos nau,v and buued "
uo .n dnecmr, m hn b-aally w ould grve hill the p,easc
pedantic wa) w,, se, t fern aoldanua won e,nu, He made "i"7 ,np, Oradually ,nrhdKelly fir,
prefe. L ong detailed fill, ,vn mnwerhewarned
vmd,c.nmn Jhe BB(_ wa, too it eserl aciwn to do ,, b. ...III ,I ,o Iraq mer e,~ll ,ear+ untrl he had au.e  lo the world ,slants lal the UN detailed Moor ol tla ,mpmlant
,elf-obscsaed to send, hle hnc hbrarte, Ilehadbxvnm¢m Ilre In,pectors in n, recnllrd 'It lop 1-111 Ille-flao,11- Fe t,,, nJ ,o: In, Lot 1a lt, . - ,.d w n hl, dc .ktap
to an om,ldcr blologlst al Osfnnl tlnlvclsrty front Iraq aIII, Saddnm .,if, knew and bad spa6en u, ,111 of oo'anrs,n,, uund,on 'If 'bell' compulel, mcladmp bandied,
Within Hills Only would all Wool he roared to Perron Jlewhute-opereonn SadJam, t erm, sracnnhc and aulal bonrb, tried with of phowgreph, he had taAi n
lose blood on ill ... hand, as Down Hnlam's main bln O,cr those yea . Kelly ad .me,s They we,b to. . . hnmlmunl ,o,ll, manufaqur it e.aporn larlanen Iraql
Ear n, the puhbu was Lease, - weeponse,mblnhn,em Aide, carr,bed 111111111 hlaurapon, me . and winner, bill Kelly , of eqlupmen, u,ed lor d,, off,uals and milk clumn
ed - their bullying and ar,o- cnd of Ihe bulf wur m 19a1 ho ,nanufactw,n" plains and had then n,easmc and ahnosl pradustlon of hlnweapnn flla,g nwrhmes that hill
been adapa .d by the irayls
to load shell cosmgs wlot
broweapon,
17 . . III ill, "nouse, film
h  garden wa, m bloom he
neuerfmgolthat mhall de,ctn
arnand Baghdad Slddam',
"'LI we along [bell
fauounte slone, were foil ta o,nrJnng aMmt the lend- died tlln, he had Irern cIlk- Ile tu,ed n,r c,ymg I b lm In Qamr m ow, rentral knowledge to cre.rte Exert, I . ..
me in die bar of file V,aggon saape and culture that drew, ,ng to the pres, lol 10 years had ,,led I,) do,tranne in camlnm,d fitl cnehunn lanes weapms
& 11 .... , pub opposite h [air, back 111, banned fell nndhadncverhadab,ulr,pe- engmecnng by becnnung a ,a bar, where he was plepar- ' " 1 someunrm lu .l lockad n,
Joum,ll , ' You could sv.uch Ing to Intel Gay for file lost a battle of n,tnds,' ho n
home in Slrwhu,oor near when de, low broke mu Ille uence if somzrrnr abu,e,
Oalord He had , good hall BBC Lotion was that he ylmr uml youluu don t deal ern ,in(] he a UN m,pcc- lion, snce 19" Inateld of ,eld 'Ihey atl, 1111o . adc I
In anecdnm, about S,ddam s ould not be allowed to w,it, ,hem agall ' he said Inr, hr lold n,e ' It ,s nol Inn ,onndlng exc,ted be wa,,nu- Will to be
lop "'I mists, many of whom resnmn In, work at hall ""I 10, [Losses al the NIL it, ol Ian, Make all Im .11 those n IILflew toB,ghded .md pelllapv a, a Ica.lwn --
stud,eJ In Bntmn lus, hope they it.,, , F. n .,nJ Delel and III, lare,gn , , yaa cqrundeleit " Iran, aaV.lns al,hnurh some thought It on
'9hey me dnarmmgly nlemdehnaely"hesaid Mirec w,,rcu,ed(nlnsunar eHer eluded me ome or wnb the Iraq Sul veY G,nup, d usual tnr a man so se pueal
polne;' he used to Ill) in, Kelly spoke ill lot, of thodo, xay, he a,vnrW me [,I,, for wining I,, groornt tcaln of moll Ills . I OW ,u- and I lgorouv - he lmd "are
'"Thcy love England and talk reporter, Judith Miller or lie I,ahe,ed he 1 ., per- ese ,.hen he slant I ,holdd h rrn  t, uleluNng IBO or so to hehl .,c In a better Imid
about their alma mmera m lLeNew York 9lme,allied fanninaaaenmebyfon>e,- ,mg nn,ple aleuam Ian Bn,nn, scounnu for wclpnnn and had adnp,cd the Baha,
a way that make, )on tolget on for hugely for the book Ill, compl nuenuGc sat,- guage ' Don 1 in Ins, to the ul Inas, dovtruanan Ilhglan, %lIi,h seeks into,
it ., w r . de, oi,mg aeapan Ocnn she animated aboot feel, m srmple, cnmprr.heu,r- dark ,{v, he Is .. . . . . I 1 relled hm, again when hr natlan .d mulclnandmg nnd
to wrpe ear tlmuds of hloweapun,co lom Mangald, lo, lanonaec Be used to 1 ~nnPd hln, roast oNlo In remrned to bad out abna, to' lerourlllauan
pcnple' the fnmlol BBC correvpond- palaploose Emaem (et bast file ,umly,eq III"' Ill galden nosann tiewasLimb nracler lhn wa, the cit man
Kelly would mterv,ew enl, board Earn a Iran, of (hit', uhat he mld nlrl who n blomu I would find r,mally tuulvrn "I nLed to vho was as,lgned early lax
if ... nor, and ,,or again, hlm in ha, tudy, Fxa ner ker.p ,oj ,all,, out of ,he ye.u ta Ilclp lo preq re a ¢ov
ratully tralucnbmF It,,, ,ome ncw document Ilp,omed pap", t the momen, ' he enlmem do  ler ou Iraq
an,welsendgnngbarkforen- 1 n2 be9de'IEcn 6rE lYFdy; pL'SErJBt]'1 . ",1- ,J m bun by M161 Ill, boys nt ,aid B ua, mm herd to put Downulg Street asked the
o,e,  ,1 . . . . . . o .- . . - .  ., - , . .  ,. . .- . .., Joint uaelhgane con,nunc
loch<ck lnr wnslslcnc) 1111 52:EIC9~aViiD~3'1°',.'7i,1;f:Cr213~? ;Sq ;~u"1`7°f ;. relerre,l~w I'll,) whu ." h hr uhcu I ."nkerl ""l. . . n . ... . at (11tJ for d properly reseal eb-
fa,nunte toe was far R,hab q " -, wnuld Icastnely rdu,e to blank he demcd h,rvln. ,po- rd unup,chen,tscanaly,lsol
laha ill, head it Saturn, s 5_i,F1jL'~liiS VTd CL,li~fd b :9e Y3oi ziP ik-, :y,' nL I cbna me Gr ehc he u .,,]it ken lo Andicv Gdlluan Ilay s I,capan, capabdun .
to o-ueapons Programme II bc nllsgvdenlnnvnlnalhe Ile a,md, .d III, nnuauoll Kell} waI asked la plcpme a
was K, Ily wbo rubbed her - - erlge of ht, lawn, ocs ulon- to lan d, wbl,h ha oarm,ais report maxhm weapon and
'Do Oer,n ally n,oppulg hn IoreheaJ ,ould hne au. .p,cd uad, .bar weapon, n,akm9 cqmp-
Her responw Ia Kelly', Information an Saddam's said 'Alg~ suenll,l who Wall wlpmg ho specleele, ruslo Itihen Idnuc told Ile ment or materials Iraq Lorild
an csoom wa, to Inunrh into nrsenel Lao tep n lalltthcn,o,tmnII Jam" hr, uif, » mld hs had paal mnu.d hls nua,l still be from,
n air-,, shouting mild, Ilr For n a,rl sets ent he was cntcd Eli to an elshl sea, hurl, tee or lenmnede I Ell, W Ir.l,l ,tlleduled lor Call, " ' My . oloemcut 'a,
mbwstinto aa¢ Other UK remarkable open Illonghhe ridtJnrtll,ochnllanvl' ,laaghlcls (Ill had does, July I arse doxn m III, . e hstonoll acconnl of
"nun
,r,sperlnr, were Jwarn,ed by always te,nted pubbuly To But his opeuncn, a" ,d,o Loan and Loans It.alrel and house and [. .ad bun In Ihe Unscnln nl,heclmna and
Or, r actlon and fraud her uuensw hml on the reu,nl III, ,ullluablllly II ysnulJ I ]fell) old ,I,, or In, g,of ,a ,o) ding unfair 1111 . Ir,,I
mlposstble ,o d,al wall Imwouldreqncetthat youa,A ha,cbcene, IQlul,thn ,ill he, IncnJ, or girl He hadlu,lhcultoltlbrlho coocealment and deuylum
Kelly With the pabenio al tire Porelen Othc,, press mold, He ,n as~uol a ,,, on, Inends u u a, e Ireppv home- MoD pre,s file, .,,I to [Ak K,11) [old the Countion,
al luant . . . 111[1111 allicc wlnJl Invultebly crl,l.nlployee a Nhuchell halJ 1 Mr,, u Ga,c inn bw hc,pake u, Ill l~wa, lorelgn .,llmn >eleU Loan
ms~long
r espenlnenl would dedlned Bill one ., In a whdc ollluel' or a menlber nf Ihc ,Iloup n,al, la do brale and Laid told nu, he 111d been
novel, last , IeA twa duy,
wall for the lanlrwo m slit, Ilr done , . . . d fixing bunted nuelhgenrc cenue, though aurtlme, Jangemu, ,hl,, Iblong11 the nnger I IL bcloie ho killed hareeff
J, then Ic,un,equucuonmg d vnu told hlm you needed n he did work _101111 11th in 1,,q looked 'aunt and III, eye, lie s,,it that hc I'dbmler.J
admweJ to me he had named source for file story ,hem tie o r, nor 1n reram week, he trader had For their spari.l. II a hl, work foil, Before the final
-ell in lose with Iraq For 7ust don~ltget me into troll xho,e Inyal,yu , also .wem a hlmge u,ldu leek e the lau u me I,nx hum alne, o .,1 the dasecr n n, puS
all the hear, grime and dls- ble lie would say he heheveJ we, light or while for me 1o weak oat Issued 111 $eplelnl,er and u,l,
Ih,aldnlem  before he v.rmtelnrnrL~1 " h, I a" , . . .. . .. (1, Ipboned Nicholas RuROfd 'nnl . . . . . . hed a, all In aa,
 JULY 20, 2003 THE SUNDAY TIMES

DTHE TORMENT OF
Cnnmuuedlrampo,¢c 13
restslnns In fact he was on
leave or worlung abroad when
the haul drafhng was lakmg
place
That document was unique
As Hla¢ boasted, no govem-
meet had ever before pub-
Itehed such a detailed tnlel-
hgence assessment- It pushed
Kelly', work anto a new
dimension, however H
careful, scmnnfic conmbllonnas
was in a dossier designed for
propagdnda And when dl,
da was eventually
exposeA, Kelly would be the
casualty

ANDREW GIfl .14AN, a

portly, baldmg reporter in ]as
Unit es, is kuown as ntmdy
svngle-mrnded m the pursuit
of a slrrry Four years ago he
was ocaraled by BBC R.1111,
4's'1'oday proinuman, which
hoped to bring an edge to Its
)uwnahsm by breaking raw,
rather Ilmn ).St commenting
an it
Gdhgvl went undercover to
buy anti-pcrsnnnel iandrmnes,
` he exposed hew easy n was to
J use dead people's postal voles
and obtmned a sales of leaked
MoD rcports about Burma's
, performance in me Kosovo
J war
Kevin Marsh, Today', edl-
- lor, gave lum freedum to
e nnuble" and rmse thc
` progrxrnne's profile with
cont roversial stories
Like othepoumahsu,Gdh-
) gan knew that when handling
, a Story on Iraq's weapons of
J ass desnucuon (WMD),
Kelly was be expert to lum
? lo Despite his duty of confi-
denuahty, to it,. MoD, Kelly
had a mission to explain
Gdhgan met him m SepterlF
ber last year and spoke to him
on several occasions abse-
quenlly, by telephone
As the question of Iraq's
WMD - or lack of Ihero -- In the Ilon's den Kelly, aantre, fee" the foreign effars select aarnminee fm a no-hotds-barred Inqukroon Hart shook hen and cunidbuled to the despalr he felt
as e pawn in a pohtleal game
grew more mmgumg after the
Iraq war, Kelly was an,ubvl-
ous pan of call m building uP pubb non, to make n sex- Whttehali, flu, hunt for the nr rat he was the figure was precisely what Kelly had Intensely mnrai nran~ a Boon took charge but n ts
e story Gdhgan artangeA to lee' Asanexample ofgus,he mole was well under way GJllban was talking about told thereponer desrnpmn mat titsK...ry's r
For the first nme a etfie
nvablometmelldolma- . .me had teen par to;nb-
meet ban a1 the Channg Cress cited the cimms that chemical Within the MoD the mood He was a senmr officlal According m Adam Ingrain, decision lo clear the ar m~n did nnt pass swiftly on to gads rrmle, hot the BBC
holrl m cenlml I nmlon o weaoaas could be reads at 45 waaunconmn,unane Arrnra- ,r,h., k, .( r nr.~b~a ..n r 0,, Ihr "m,nlln.me nnn,ar " nnr !)n 1'- aO K~IIV mnr n 11 u n.nn C-r r'nmnMll nn.,F... .a .. ., I a 11 - n _
Flat u r I,J6 w, no ,"' .
".It~~ of o,it in nnlldln ~ un
Ousrory Gllhg.m errane" rl ul
"I'll Inner al If" Charlie, C fe,5
food In "noel Londdo or,
Ma) 22
Thry chaued 'it tire hotel
sanon "I'll
1,11 NIy 1
hua was pumanly ulow Iraq
of Ill,
de,
aro,h 'a, it" fallen, I,
a,e weJpani 'If in", it,-
,Itu,aon claims Ile ,, and
,lie Iallule by ND, 22 a Poll
.IICJ, wcapun, ' krll} lold Ihl.
Jonah, ail .", xl"tt cI'll,
nuueelea week
Cmaall7, in,, aho dl,
,a .. . If tire clalnl no 81", 5
do',elir Flat Iraq had pro ,,
led Ill wsapon, call-
blc at hour, .,ad 1 45 Iran
ates nouce lhey lal6ed
KeII) old Miss of why hal
d . . . .. .itght It,,, I ..I, or the
do,,m, Tile 111m, of C,oup
bell room into IF . . . . .. . . . . .a-
con K,11, ari
k how ]a,, late,. Donald
Romweld, the Am . .. . . . sull-
~aay made fisi
,a, ad I'llon For w"pml
of mass deamomm, anglu
o"m be found all ha, Tile
apon, ." 'addirmily For ogain
This a,lgued in no at,
d,...... . . .. .. I Tedas beween
offlCor old John ilann'l
, ,, "le'r It ,, (It,
~!~oan,aaoj del"malln't ur far
g."'cal'at BBC raw
G fligan damed flat a Bru-
I'll Iofili . ..I ml.bed in tit,
,,cp,z,,oa of the VVIAD
rb~o~m, bad ,aid that di,
.. . grant draft hall be, . bland
Tanenall; Street' hed und . ...I
to he 'sated orr'
In her en,uulg uproar GlIll
gal, hloadcucd Jlc cbacgev
Igauut DOwnlllu Street Ile
,roe n lewsplner aalele
r lalnlllle lll n a soo n., had told
I,nn Ill, do ", wo, 'air,

Italnlea in me .,kk fir-lee
fex,ls 15200 S 1
EVERYTHING COMES AS STANDARD
INCLUDING SECOND GLANCES
FROM ONLY f299 A MONTH ;;C',_
. ;I_pM .e.
15200 9- a [,lie strarghtsrx VVT-l engme . 6 speed rnanu al
transmaslon is g speaker
. dash 6 dlsc CD autochangef
In,PI+ .aemdAm.dIOre.er .ndasswolozoo3Vscuenrm9.e,r,monvmdr
I, APR Typlralexamplebased Onlexuscontraclpurchase
I 8.6% Cash pnce
' ..w .wl,.r.rra^s  r-ne.l,a . .mp..r  Le,erurl .a~aso . .,.n . . ...a,r.
uoed .,a~a .ern~lr..,x. .al .. ..r,.aa .lo, . .oxe .uamazro .e.+ee
~r n. .ele .au r
s . ., ." r.rr . ... .e,c~. .lv-,. .e .,e - ii, ,-.
puMu.allon lo make II ,r
1 A . "nlr,euII,IcOf it,,,, h,
.ncdlhcclmnl,Ihal .hl.nucal
ould be lead, a, 35
mumlrs~nuuce
t nllrg .m wrole . that hn
somce h Id Intned are pcr,lrn
rupvlla'de to, no, tr" III,-
tumlauon <anhell
I ,vameA
tirrrr apeple .y
DVUnuI¢ Strut - .md
although lhel.h .uqelladb,eu
lead, nl a n,.-pep,, Today
bcl. "mre Ibetaryel In, acnge
Nel wa,dcdamJ
idler lisL tile rat lllrl
blnl,cr v.a,n oo Ihc pre-
;ranlme altemplrdta,"IeJge
Jl.otned
Ilumphrys end
logo, clv"mcmJ m rfar scio-
my scn u.e, ul tq n® lo nnder
mlnat the " .",no"T Blalr, ,
spoAe,ma 1 al No 10 atlacAed
9 nd.n Un man' l dl nnn,
rcpon lal poled "'oh '-I n '
MP, were loulv I, `ol`
enl so, men qacleA up
to go oil the .ulwa,cs »I
bludgwll the BBC
The lorcent atNur, ,elcl.l
,in live saluncd Gdll-
gea to cxplmhnl,al and
ul s111 [(I mtenlce B Iau nnd
Campbell, (no J, I,alt UI all
e.u+auon 'on' the ca ' et
Inalhgemc here, Ill, 'an
Blmr n1u,1.J m apvnd brJ
to tire mew - ad 11,
BBC san,111 to 11 elannup 1111
appl .r Iran,] -- ca bdt
"Ipla .ucd ['I'll' tllc cornnm
re IF 11 trial r
leeunJunc^S
fill Now
lnlbgan hell Ilcd ii, Ihun-
derul Hr lahhed de I end
Ixlllgrrenll} d1.nlandeJ a .nr-
futon end nn 1,1111"I TJlonl omc
I wo J . p , I at~r
'1,1 .
(it, Bl,
bcc re", ,n .IVUntcJ that
vomlcd onmnnwsr.d 1 1 or
Channd d News to ulake ha,
pomt S»ole nb,ervel, homed
I In, late of mood
in Ire seuel ralche, of
- -- [x-, ;6oc
e~lixrusssea .~,ve "era ;,., . .,me
oe,ve,r, .  r . .l .lr,. ,rrze ..al .. . . . ..ir .lm. .nrl . .~r w.a, --to " . . " . . . . . . . . . . "dm .,de..  .,I(, r ~ .r . .. . rr,.,e . .e .ara,oa.. ,e .l .lla,ele .e.r v,yrr " =r ,
F hllchall the intol In, rhe
w "n well Ilnalcl u
n Ihe slid) [I . . uror . J
rllnhlnanionic .ew,rd
mglnlalnlrvldla tire Jeu,wn
, leken if, 1111 lie mole w o
wnhcd Ilc svoulJ be ""I"'
and Icid up1op11bilt ..... . . .
Thlrrwoahll+l" noeru
m Luarly acruntr I,1 Its wuld
kell7 w ,I lr "rG To, nn
q.
a
he Ielumedlul hle fine lie
,obccarneawalcullhcell-
denzc that Gdlman hall gncn
m Ihe,elel.t cumrnnlcc
TIIeBBCrepurlerh "Ilimade
II cell that he had ollc APV
Sow+e fn l hls or purt IL .n iha
Suptembrrdn,slerwas sevoll
. . . . ", Wit . . . h 1111, w , Imt hn
lanmlage. hell, ber .lme wm
HbW-THE DUSS[ER: RdW DESGEND AlNTO PERSONAL TRAGEDY
9ePfember2002 Doss,er
entitled Iraq's Weapons of
Mass Deslrutbnn pcallshed
It includes claims of weapons
ready at-05mlnules'notice
and uranmm from Africa
January 2003 A forcing
paper Is published Soon
shown to be largely
plaglansed frOm tire mile at
March 7 Documents
alleging Iraq sought uranmm
from Africa are shown to be
larcenies
May 22 Kelly meef, Cdllgan
In tire Cl anng Ctnss holel
hr
May 79 GIIAgan c[arms nn
the Today urog2mme that a
senior ottlaalln charge of
vyl7~iJi1~'"~~ISaaouolc-~,w, .qrw.rr^emro,anm~nszur,nrn.zw7
Deposit
5 ronthly paymems
Iq, .a.~seeuroe,v-rma,p,<veqi .,.e«,eem.r,~nna .,~ee, .nl<me,rawlloe, .nsaoarl^J .m.m,smarae~ea .amumlle .e~=uno " , .,.rea~ .. I
wd, pi alml KClly had mtcn,cly moral man' It I, a Ho on look Ibalqe for( It I, For Ihc but role a 'Ill
vnccd that hc la, the ligull.
Odlle .ln a, 1 "dkuc ,),,all lot,] lherlpnrter dc,a,puon the( fits Kelly , meoace, able I .,( Ila, all name bad been Fiat I,, Will
Hr n . . . . . .. . olhuel AuoldmeloAd ram bon not not pa" swJtly on lo ronls mule her [he BBC
de6,fa111U tICar tire all
who haJ ` conlllbulell
l lo t he Ihe. armed to,"' m, On June 71J Kelly ,ua a Downm,¢ Sheer C'norphi'll ,,eitheradnllned Kell, ran tire
one
dl»,ICr-JOS1asGJhganhad ot JceID" s cullcaque, aho Iole nionaing tire Mot) that 11 )it and udler, ,elned a e nor firateded ],to, by
allp 1 n", e,c, wrre nol on denyng n
Ill, nolrd That b. had bcen expre,a- he had spoken lo Glillpen
Je Lnned
AhIIVrnh kclly fell tllcel u - - Imdar lo-' , lo those ,hOrtly before, helo de, dlU,pured pren,eh ,bar ree Kelly ma, Now camc the rno,t c,nmal
Ilcncc In fill tlV,+a.r had bccll .redhy I ` 011"'a P.... 1 po,ts lie bche+ell rhe mat hl oreyell In IF, aliur bma bcrrey .,l of Ktlly Doulnng
p linhir" nl hnweser was 3 tercuuldNcle,oheJhquietly
"I", anoar,lnlplcohlar.trvc bluw- street end [lie MoD (]city Ihnl
,- I»g the BBC out of (lie water C .rlm,nell ,r HI*In Laked
_ h, d,d teal n 11,111 brrll krlh frllealhep¢Inre heJld 1,01,
ovcnold m J, Iae .enlallull uoltctallanmgmfare,Ollh- ,Llrnfr . . . .it ,,it Ill his lu re Tile lost day K,Ib ,,, hrllv', morc 1. it. media
'air damled his s0ulce ),ad manager that he n,ay hme hauhd Ir aad -,111 .J try h ba,my talked 1. lon-a ,I,
IrdelnPha,l,
adnus,mn tl om rhe BBC Thl,
To cep n ell hell y ns-., Nor 111d It, recnll, he true To, solrse Ingrem true manager and the surveyor
n td a line III Gdhaau s I.Ui Lie, old MP, duec0, blanl- mmmanted her week 11, of por, unnel "~I lhe MoD Thal v, , fig to,]
By releasulg II, u,lgue
den,,, lo if), ,atllllllll .e h,. Inp Campbell inl ,e,lnp up ucws went up tire tood chain lwakend hl . w,u do, I,mA In
dr.,cnpuon ol Kell7 the MoD
'aid I11, , 1 ca IhIJ red Innl Ihe das5lC f end by Thuradav Jet, i It had Fit, m work will (lie Iraq
Ihefe was~aall'7 r rJlenle ul ar.hedkevln lebbn plrma- Survey Group In tire Inner flo had already var a hare stamina
It Jy pOS,c Ine chemlcnl Khl .l .Yrsdescribed Nysend nenl selrelJry at the MaD He wClponS of 111aS9 dc4lnllllap Information was to
1+a pnn , II, Ihc ,n or unlhc Filter tlthec 4nlen~ an In o ncr prompdy obtained aeotl thejoh be loved JounuWs in 7,e,tlmn,ler
those
Ixlore tile war slanrd "RII, weapan, Inspcctpr, m on ]face the del .e ,urctery Instead he . .is ordered to p,nuudarly tho,e to
alas in Britain and orninioned Campbell
bod, to it,, M .D nor the It Devious Sir,,, bra,q
mg f01 poi lu.al journalist, on
following Mooda, rn lund",
afteilicAl luh 9 a spokesman gale
oe loas eon,~ I . 'a, InaedelJded clonalLron that
"e"ar"ed and I "u'ri"Ib pnrmsd at Kelly
ul Kelly's "fall guy" He goes home
d,a,,,,g up J, classic, had ad . .. . Soon ! abut. . . .. . feet runkrue, [flat The olfiual note of the Ii
sald d was "sexed up" exhausled and turl0ln MoD threal, were nu me to minor, Ig h" n Blau r,puke,mon say-
July 4 and 7 Kclly Lonllnues To insist he was with his pension in pro,eLliv in, that tire .,,vuled uncle
I I
Gllllgan's source BqC fine m ak, if,, official Semen, dld a. ; work for (lie MuD
Iwle 1 Newspaper article interviewed t,y Mot)
Act nnle,a I,e arrived to go se d , flat 1 . 11 a leciuucai cxpert
by Gilligial identifies places lo comment.' he In Jclnolld,lug Olihgan s ,It,, had wurAed in,, a r,au,
Campbell as responsible for July 8 MoD puts out a
Ilaons In dcp "ullneule IncluJlng If,,
transforming" the classic, slatemanl that someone has July 17 Kelly goes for walk 7hn rhlmr, w,If, Ih lJy , MoD wnh whunl he 'a,
pawning Sheet attacks BBC come forward as the nlalr form hume I l 45pn1 his loso ,nlrmenl rn n. a III It, Loo med, working lfi,
MoD h .ld hccn quite good ,alao as paud by another
Hour solids letter to Gavyll family alert police
about It But tile menstly dcpannunl
June 18 Gillipin interviewed Devles, chairman of BBC,
, pcpanntt lo dc, mrne- 'The role eOmlll»e, 'The
by per' Wright affair, stood namrng Kelly July 18 Body found at
Ulm^ that would ulllmatch, matun, of to, work meant shot
committee (FAC) about 930am Campbell hllehe desa,tallau far ~a Im w. more of a cumultant
July 9 DpwttnlR Street gives arrives back from inan who had cover ,ou,hl the that] J 1CCVIIIICe'
June 25 Campbell journalists more details Washington Friends say he ,polllghl
fin, Journalists ballifial ",III
interviewed by FACT calls the describing mole Kelly told by "felt sick" at hearing about On Tllevalay fill) 8 it issued Kelly it % as not difficult to
cnnfiml by, already by a pm-
allegations lies and demands MoD that ha name is going Kelly BBC Issues blanket I or . .. ..
. .me . .. . . ..len,ord no
callngIIIalauvli,cn am thad he  of chatunlmorl Whe,l
a BBC relracbon to conte out MID confirms ban on slalf talking about
conlcs,ed to an nnaalbon,cA the, omg the MoD and sme-
hun as Tole to reporters Kelly Blau elders ammay
mca.ung vial Ollllgun Is did geeled he was rise mote, tire
June 30 Kelly allots to
her n,une tire man hot ,aid he department crifirreand It it
Me[) he spnke to Gllllgan July 15 Kelly interviewed by July 19 Marn figures In the
,as an e,poll ul "MID w e, htgldy Imu,val, nonnully
admits
Mps' connndfee He dlama deny putting pressure Too day, to,, Hun .. . Is roll. Ilredepanmenrwouldlwlcom-
talking to GIIilgan, but is on Kelly pr leaking his name IOGasynDailies tire ch.ur ela . . . ,uchanoihuel
July 3 Geoff I loon,
ruull of tire BBC, aaklng hurt nl None of do" would base
defence secretary, learns dunuxed as "chafP'and a to the media
la ,.onlinn that Kelly wa` happened snldonesenlorgo,-
Wigan , sounc emonsoon otflclel, wrthuut the
fq,6pg Optional finalpayment _ {g,g-ooo formore information onallFinance offers THE 15200
- L990o fotalarnuunt payable° - .f,656 g
;
! call o84g hot 9977 or visit wwwlexus co uk
I's tee Feeling Insole
.ooo. e.e ... n...,~r.u . .n+ "-.- - nf sslw " r"n .a".ts. . . " ,er . . .," n.tr . . .sr. ., a<s...rm
 16
In search of the source of a political crisis
Who was the real
Whitehall mole?.
David Kelly-or
somebody else?
Jonathon
Can'-Brown looks
at th e evidence
angmal bmadcast in,
' Ihc Today programme, -he
reponer Andrew Gdhgnn
ass responding to stories
wzs
m the medla thn no weepuns
of rates destm,.uon were
likely m be found m Iraq
The piece look the forat of a
canversauon wait John Hum-
pltrys, the BBC Radio 4 pre-
senter, done, which Gdhgan
mfened m ,nfunnauou Pro-
, ;tied by a single suurce who
clanmted that tl,e September
dome, On V, MD was "sused
p" by the governaust a week
~~efoue it was published m
n,ekc n more exerting
The dz,m spadccd n furore,
uuplytng that lon, night . .I
have postal as unrmnent a
threat as the government had
been Suggesting
Gdhgml lurked the allega-
uau to n single vaurce and
has guarded tire peon-'s
rdenuty clasely ever su,ce He
Is believed to have revealed
Ihe name of We snuree In only
one other person his b,,,,,
Richard San,brook. head of
BBC News
But m The broadcasts,
newspeper articles and overall
mw between Downing Street
and the BBC, many clues to
the source', idenuty have
emerged What do they
mdeate'
nre ILantrig point I,
'an" own desenpnan of his
suume IIe described on
today obtaining inhorination
from "onn of the senior ofB-
nala am cha,ge of dmw,ng up"
die i;Eptembey dossier
That description could fit
4113 JULY 20, 2003 ~ THE SUNDAY TIMES
Last week Gdhgan was
quesuaned in pnsale by a
en
aumttee of Mps and, they
say, appr~rcd to backtmck cu
[us clnuns Commrtteesources
claim that he altered his ev,
dence and suggested the key
allegations led he made about
Campbell "sexmg up" the
dossier was based on -me,
a.&' not "evidence'
Accordn,g to on, member,
halfway through the session
on Thursday he sa,d "I never
made da, allegation Hurt
Alastmr Campbell sexed up
die dossier nor that Campbell
hml tnsened the 45-mmute
charts Ilesmdnwasanmfer-
ence that could be made"
D,roald Anderson, it,. com-
nutlee chauman, said "ish
Gdbgan appeared to change
his round on the very grave
alleged.. an qutle a fundn-
memal way"
At one point Gisel. Show,
the Labour MP, accused him
of "net being a very accurate
reparter"
Gdhgan fatuously chnic .
tit . aBegauons He fell he
had been set up he alleged
that every member of the
comm i ttee had a blue dossier
with notes on previous stones
he had done that the gov-
emmenf bad demed
i Downing Street, our source says, It,c north may or may not
emerge thls week when a van-
acnpt of ma latest gnIhag by
ordered a week before publication MPs ,s lasued But die affau is
now so convoluted that We pre-
for it to be sexed up, to be made
cse details may reas tamusimax,
s,ble to ascenmn And Kelly,
a key uvmess, rs dead
more exciting, and ordered more
Thu weekend Gdltgan kept
a low pmfde at his house ,n
GleenwlcFS south London . tie
facts to be discovered 9 was hired by the Today pro-
gramme as IN diplomatic ard
Andrew G~T y programme, May 29 defence correspondent to ,et,
ends headline grabbing news
Ife has eertmNy done that
Claims of the Iraq dossier being 'Sexed up' first emerged when John Humphrys, above, questioned GiIlIgan on Today. Kelly, an expert on losers arms, visited the country as an Inspeclor Rod Liddl ., former editor, of
Today, has descnbed Glltgan
as "one of the most smgle-
cnbe his a.. . to NTP, ., ,aid he had met his source et a that his source thought there that could be ready lot use at Again nscenes that hecould although he could not recall m,nded reporters I base ever
"one of tire senior offieuds in centml London hotel and that, was a 30% chmn.e that Iraq 45 intrudes' nouke be the source But Kelly was the date worked with", but admid, has
charge of drawmg up the  they dtsenssed who had had a cheaueal programme um he correctly suggested fli,it rmnwe lie fold MPS that he Where m,ght Gdhgan have aggressive story-gettmg style
dossier and I van 01 you it,., formedthedacumenCthe the sramunthsbeforttl,ewar this Intomrouts based had uor known all the details had another source? Some was "a bit of a call . shoek
he Is a so. . of long stand- . ..ne of Alastau Campbell This pludse was closely con- on intelligence ho, oalgle, revealedbyGdhganabeat We loumahstswhoknew GWgan for the BBC'
Ing, well known to me, closely had been menhoned aected with Kelly, who was souae and lu'Id been included 45-minute claims Therefore n believe he has at least on .-, BBC collenguce h=
An,
--- . . , , .,. . . , . . .. .r " , .1"n, "< woh III, ac6nnnledeed e'tpeq ~+n nnlsshn,ll ;hrlo,elhellossier seemed he could not base good contact in the Defence has a repulabon as a Usable,
. , .  - _ e-rn  ,cr ~ ,bm,us wnrkzinrhc At the
 , , wa, "I'd
,eu cal nut I " nown ell The details had ,inother ,ultrc<^ Snme waa "a let Of + rultarc ehack

Ihr Seplembar dnICi - '
[hn dav.nnn,at "'old fu
r 1 l ~~ I,~ - .Ily the .le~inl
I unIetl edaIdttite qne,uolt r,t
,br kill,'[ hurnelf last
w,rl Ik .ue, t, n ofh~ul
ill xeipnos mspewon, ul
lim~ ,,ail and he pla,eel
inl nnent . ..I, w &.-la,
lo, ta hntonc.tl ,eclwn ul
d .edo,rter
1 mer, (IJb ;au nas W des
hL , .t source cl long slmid-
a .llknnwnwn,r Jo,eh
ct
Iraq' v wcapom of ma  Kelly
dos«urtum sandy ,ufbu .nll}
,emor and uWlble w he
uonh reporitttg Again Kelly
OR the bill well
In a wsptpa ortmle tso
dav,after thebroadcast Gtlh
pn g "ne traffic, clue He
11,11 Ale,taa-Campbell Iht .phie,r.wsJo, .JSUr n uellie..lncc rl hotn a~1"^le cdrdbyGilbganehnutlhc laurnelishwhoAnowGJhgnn forIheBBC"
Iwc III, nonned nu,red all, 6elly alt, w~as ,rowee 'and ha,l been in I d5-mmule rturn Thele lure it Mime he has ~it least one Anion, BBC calicagu6a he
the e.knu.,ledeed ~,y, u r only ,Itottl, Petorn o" r ,d he could nut h . e ood conlnr.t in do Defence ha, a npularmu a a hkeobL .
1. In,, ahu" n, x,It
11, over al Iety,bndogtcalandJsmnal wae puhh,heJ ruuld mal heui Ihe sole ,otuce Inelt- Inh.IItgenCCstall IDtS) ntbmouawtntalmhe At the
zenuel L mJur, at Ihe Chantt" weap,nn pn,_eeuunte, mP vmaltan hate oan, Innn oune-1 m 11, hmadca,l In tlu. lia,t thin somec has Mmislrv ol LRfeucelsreputa-
So let au siniplc In [[III Kcllv, TI®re n set anmher c - IenACd turn lup-,,, act «on u teptmer ta mtx ed
Cm  hotel and m Ihcu
d,thtulne, a l l In Gtlbga,t s Kells wa, kuoan In di,mlss ph-auon Lacl week Gdhrgan document explicitly dtvmns- One source s,.it "We neser
cnn.enauonI [It, I'-!, 'If
rediobrnradcd be made,Pcrt- the 45mmuteJatm ., l ed arWby,orneslP,mline mg .u terttunbemcen refuse to talk I. hun Some-
CemPlrull I'd ait,r
Annual, telhng detaa emer, hr .t, nmts ebrmt a , i .um in later suenusts and untold wdJrcd hr, elainn about
on V,nma ButiAen utth ,aid Suit- times he s .In plain u rang
ged whea t 61iluder .n but, theSeptember er do,ster [felt eenre arc,,, Hr had ptevt- III, point of wrations being data Hnssetn " R a time when but he does have sources Ihm
,,,,,d by ll lie told direct Imq had chenncal "face" imdy told Iran RlangulJ a read, ~a 45 muuncd notice Tony LOU, ,ad George Bush talk m In . and he has to Go
InenJ end former 13BC lour Illat mfunnalton may nor he wcrede,petacn,link Saddam taken sommal
Fruits[ dwl n w 'laughabir . n,ell to ,ay, ba,e r,un,c to AI Vaeda DIS members Ke11yrentautsOteprlme,us-
lo []link you could deploq frnmlu,keysaune would hase been Imolved pect as his Notice What does
dtemnal ucapons in IJ man- On,, .tpam Velly Is back m In Jmwmg up It,, Scplember sccm carrot. .. 1, dial unle,s the
ml, vi s nn that pan the pnuue do BBC forces Glhgen w tame
Ihesu einarded win, Gllhg,m's lhcte nacodterd,screp,ul- Tile ploblem,stied Odligan his wurrc card he might pro-
broadcast Alto he told MPs ca,, (no Gdhgen told the Idenufied oac primary snurce [or u, rcstgn, Coward; Street
that 1n (he cons elsavon I had MPs select commtuee Ihet he hut admitted trial he had three will never t,onclustvely ptoee
Iwith rJJhaanl their w - laid not seen the cource for a other sr urtes who had also or JsVoo,oe that Kelly was the
mto¢entent of some of the year Yet Kelly said he had IaILadtohtmonlhesubycotot mad behind the day, that
lot . he ],as Put forward' duct fair, suite receney, Iraq, vv. . . .. . . nd Ihe dossier ended m his death

nquiry to focus on ministry role

Conanurdfintn page 15
the puhacai cmb .um,atnenl a
man pu« ued 6y C vnpbell his
duse aule hnd mtmmued sm-
etdu He u,uttedtalely not;
dir e I,,], I .. .. Including
Beer and I .,it F .k .'e" his
old friend and do, lord chen-
Celebrate the launch of cc0or As tire plane land, .d m
Tokyo, his spokesman amid .,.
Alliance & Leicester Commercial Bank ore than there would he a yudt-
cmi ntqmry - since dawn-
D) ke had to pondcr ,u,cral
questions, mcludmg whelher
the I3BC should own up .,ad
,drat the name of Gllhgali s
seurce He mmoral late thal
evemne lot a patty he had
been due to host at the Proms,
whete the him [led two
rows or seats m ,he suits
ln,tders say he was m s bull
tsh muod red III, mu,n was
largely tgaoted m e,eryone
discussed the Kelly alfati'
The BBC, they fell, Bad
acted propedy 11 had nphtly
held a debate about it,, caltses
nl the w .u They talked alhom
whether m nan,e kelly d he
was rldbg.,ti s suutce
Yeverdav the cumporahon s
gorcmots were still grvtag
Dyke, Santbtuukand Glhgan
thin, lull ,appear 'we dl
think theBBC,houldnamens
noire, load can, rwcowar
Howe,eqm,taI18BCItaen
,, add ve,wn, or indeed
nv sfair - were so 'can; I,
Andrew Manor ,, elhor-A
editor c .needed that n laid
mchy que,nans lo
nmuer In the letlut and
e-m+tlssiololtheToday pnr
pan me yesterday, hsicners
acidic theu teehngs known
One accused it,, BBC .1

with our new business savings account. graded and A less far reaching being Inased and defensive
"utymry, by a yudpr and tn Its own propaganda t

THE GILLIGAN MEE~ING

expre ,cd Blmr s dtshcss and
11 A market-leading introductory ratel guaranteed for sotrow, it the death
111I floury around, irre,
six months when you apply before 31st August 2003 D)ke, dnector-geneml of the
BBC was .,,,it. ..g down art,,
® Only £30,000 minimum deposit a busy week aad looking to,
ward to lonadam it,, first
,ld of III, limits at in,
Take a look how our rate compares .. .
Albert Hall m London
When he hand that Kelly
wu~ tossing, Dyke callerl
GROSS P-A BALANCE GROSS AER Richard Szmbtook, head of
PROVIDER
BBC News and apparent) (lie
only person othe, than (All-
- 6 1 too was adamant that
can lu know (it, curve of his
se,ed tip" source Alter
NatWest 2 60"/a 25ok 2 63°/a
helb w .rt cntdinncd dead,
D}ke held , t eeltug w tth
HSBC 2 33"h Lml6on 2 16% Semhmok and nthen called
(,"'n [Moh, It.. . . con of
Lloyds I58 2 75'Yo 1lndhan 2 78%
[he fill( eovemon
sowre eunr2sr noneyrnna has, 95 Julr ZW7 In It,, mw .,III Dnwnmg
Street the public ],ad been
After six months the rate will revert to our base -0 2% gross, currently 3,33% gross AER largely supprailic of (tic
BBC Now it looked as d tire
.orporauall s refusal lo own
The BBC reporter Andrew
Gilligan described
meatlng h6 source at a
London hotel m an
account in The Mall on
Sunday on June 1
The source agreed with
Blan about one thing He,
Iraq had had weapons of
mass deabut bon
programme in the recent
past But he knew, buffer
Bear anyone, poll it didn't
,mount to the "I. ... . intent
threat" touted by ministers
And he was gently
despairing about the way
No 10 had spralt Its case by
So what, I asked [am now,
had changed' "Nothurg
changed "Hard the week
before, It was lust like I told
you It was transformed the
week before publication, to
make it sexier '
What do you meanr Can I
lake notes, "The classic,"
be sad, "was the statement
that WMD were ready for
use in 45 minutes, One
source said it took 45
minutes to launch a missile
and that was misinterpreted
to mean that AMID could be
deployed in 45 minutes
There was no evlden(e that
they had loaded
conventional nal with
defence of Gibbon," One
was far itud, bid .( It . .it
"Odhgma Sombnrok and the
BBC cocnions ne w have
blood on then Itands '
CHB speed with which Liao
,ninedKed a. inquiry mw
Kelly s death left his officials
turning to -atelt up Initial
ttnlicuhe,ls Are that n wdl
fee,,, narrowly on whether
any Jeclstotn wolon tire Men
may have played a pan m
Kelly's death
The Inquiry is to be headed
by Lord trillion, 72 the sixth
al semor law lord, re-
Berong it,, sennusness war,
whtch tire gosernment views
dte allmr
The amount . .. . is to,, a satft
onesm,antar perhaps Using
no more 11 . . . six wea,ks But
yesterday lain Dimedull South,
the Tory leader, celled for a

Apply today!
up to GJltgaa s source, evcn far wtde, mqulry vat . Imw it,,
exaggeration "Typical WMD, or could do so
when Kelle was ulentthed gollmament ],ad lateral it,
Dihoung Street" he said, anything like that quickly
r had contributed lu in, w11-
half smiling, half annoyed I asked him how [his
case for war taerint Iraq

V 0800 195 61 72 enpteref.aD0te6 flat I count Had III,, These ,re naportanl ques

Alliance hecd ,I mal'u nt noun f .. tire We'd discussed the transformation happened lona, But for the mends and
aake of a stop aa id the /an,ous Blair dossier on Inc answer K5 a single to it, of Kelly Ihere are oll,er

: t.,l www.alliance-leicestetco .uk Leicester 813(' s reptn toon tot accttnfo

icpunmgir
let's weapons al our wad "Campbell"Whap mavers Was Kelly hundred
and used crucial, by Dawning
previous meeting, a few Catnpball made it up' "No .
~ . Visit your local branch COMMERCIAL BANK III, BBC nsaed a brief sLate-
of syntpal' then months before d was it was real information But
Street and the MOM Did
GIIhgan and the BBC treat
oNcred a blanket , us published last September it was included against Our ban in., ly, Adl Any of draw
staff discussant, tt ., . Kqly- ' It's realty not very exulmg wishes because It was, t .ale -,,r be Is b, .n mnMe
,
,qrcee "t~rmMeNe rW 6nv.naiN79AY^e"aauart1ateMweaeaurtwndianntx1rllii qa.kMpn a,rv
.Ir.aNm~wx+hlexiry.xtevA,8,qa7ttanr+r#It , rn, " i~rv .,olfo-6n .sm.a,nw., affen Gdh^an r .as Bid you know ." he'd told me reliable " as a man who view no way out
him death I
 pursuit of the BBC tvcausc I
police search the farmland near oxford where the body of David Kelly was found on Friday The scientist's Whitehall office hasalso been sealed off by Special Branch officers Its report embarrassed Blatr?

nnaatoan appioval of HcwnsIsraeli lospeul.up I he i dte day oi Kelly a 9nday programme he 'Last m,her gnlhng, , , pa,".er-by nut whet wus
t'empbJl Kelly had be,,, MP, c,an tun,ed 11® eit- end, .nec Blair held a small that the BHC ,huuld come floor the Commom,, ,III goal, .,I inside [flat (,led,
elean d Kelly oas nut r7ilb getrne and vecunty cumnmtce angry aid brilliant asura ll
huuI goullodty
hat muht when Kelly [ .fit
condnmnmgollsothat eey
III, con sul hear hun
pady in the love
bell. . .6 No 10
juden
s nurce and sa5 w By III, ome lie ,earned m his Nobody teally knows Gmh7
ANDREW GIWGAN
awliewlnddbees»r.dmvuu- Kelly his answer, It w ,, mlly affair ,,it -a°Ilnpeully that cold home tn Southnnxr Uxfotd- Dntllu,tun' Desperabanr Or
lu. p ,us ~< the foumsmg d+y und refined e, Iii [it could Campbrll, who behr,ul Is, ellmv Dr Kclly m c,un o n ,hne in oas I n, IrIf, James, c a destve for pencev Rule: BBC reporter who met
I asked ruse Munhndotterrd But It was .

' I'm is,, w ¢ in, but, cars ,,its In, ce r et its, Mol7 aid later ctru~.a, phyalai ly V Across, the wnonq, if the Kelly from ciatmed . senior
bu rn "my help lo cope art thesBBC ~ apf raicd on the hot lie Airfoil rWhal could thn stek and scry, tery angp Baha I cbgoar is die crew ofnclal sald the September
sfill a gap best-is wb,d 11,
bemgthnnt into the qtothght "Id lie ['ad tuld Glltgao and ,on, Inandlshmg v s, t if bag- mean alherlhanthat bcnskcd He had bud lo da Us, sigh, that " drn ,,c ams does act dossier was 'styrad up'
]I'd III, nmusuy adst,rd wfar the repnrler had broad fibres It they wunicd about the,a,kr dungandhadbecnchewe,lup attach him,ell to thx mon.d
fail to [a, .,in his [,rally ,, 1313cmilvoluciris ,hit sn"Id (,,,pa . .. Kelly . Kelly heard tint
Whet ,no,patum life and does not de,end Qllesfiong Was Kelly his
a Imla I unW the hubbab 'had Is" newspaper aroJe tml,ody mowed n in tolankno,ir Ralb, I. . .),I it, esson a[ lialle
On die face of n tier, were lhc naat day, Wedncsdny, is source? If so, did he
duwn, cnunselled turn m how bell he,,,, already [, .[a] of THURSDAY 3 .1, 17 ormacHrI lie lignilly Islic-1
isomerism, day u, the his al
deals (last he any tlWereby be accurately reflect what Kelly
m handle ass-don talls Nlen,d seuerel Iwssbihnrs to ., Inyram slurred that Kelly , 1111, thri he loved
ta send somtrutc learn fla, Kelly w owing backtnrm "I'll, wa, at stake Oil III, the ,amc day he fared Blau s go,emntcnl In Amer-
need from these sorrows send saldP If he was not gte source,
ehalhcbarls.ud IhalOilbgvt in Cnneres, wa, prepanng
aBlsuoud'
pie efface to deal "I'll why did Gilligan nut fray so,
canteia c¢", annmg at his had esay" geraled or that an- u. aaoaa . Wheat hill, speak Itajorat a,-
By maintain he had not ending Kelly's landlord?
other person w ,m fact (I n, reuvned home md III; family
hausel He was ollued notls ,ma of its two losses, an hurt
u ascoNcd m only three
had animated (lie rmluc At
in^ .ad wav antply told' nut ,,at .. . .. . Ihe Miss Ldud
talk In ti e, poss," .It to the last idea ,about Y 20am the next day a
I due, Bids,], III, me island...
I dunk thcy eepocl all They asked Kelly d on the In London, parhameul was poltce assarcl . . . hand his RICHARD SAMBRDDK
m deal .,its d mysJl, h< bass, ol whnt Udltgan had mar, I([, . "rose If ones hteless body lying face duwn
>.d nn today, haesuddlic tire iclmfnnd exhau,uon nfler one m e held neor rame wuadland
told use Rule
:BBC head of news
c Kelly I'll no It was a if [he Insist drvtsrve and bad- lie had taken some ivm-
Keily had stared couldn't, logical answer lie tetnpered sesacms amce new Aillers and had sht his left Said to be the only person m
FOR year,
down,nnle nl Saddata , cmrI- had not satd Al [flat Ofilsom I abour came to va,,o wnst befure lymgdawn lo dlc whom Gilligan confided the
led tough, But re was now had rrparled In Odoubhuc Kelly was in the peace of the English name of his souree,
mvolvt.d In a form of cutnbal However Ilu. Mi never pmpanng to all htmselt countryside
he did rait full) understand broached the goisdalix that That coming he had much The war had clatmed a Que.stians. If Kelly was not
A, a ,))air Is,, felt it we, Is,, Kelly ,a, Indeed tie, .i to .male, [fail I, old the assail casualty after years of
the source, why did he nut
duty to gel things nJn he and (flat his noae had hecume wheit, truth h) the foreign yonsung wills Saddara and tax
affaue select commtlect Was officials, Kelly was a vtchm say sd If Kelly was the
naddy agteed la appcarwihen exaggeraled "sexed up,
the MIN of if . fareitm dllans men -bv 111, rose Gdbgrr tie a "(,it[ guy' s Hail [lie McD of wamng Faults, who were source, did lie check with
,elect comnuue, s,mananed n,ade his bmadcavl and f7RC calloosiy abandunul British Kelly whether GAhgari s report
],,,a as explain himself The Instead the Miss branded him, Had us, government III, family we® devanmtrd was accurater
i,tenn wa t.lfnr Kelly as cholf .,it n 'fall exegFcrated dm Ilue.lt of Iraq t I learnt the news in a role
guy" tie 1,11 on, trat loss Whal was his farurcv phane cell and flit numb that
LISiuesdey
Kelly w clearly a as used ,ad d,,ps,,I,d To oll appemances he was such a decem utan, such a
Ihec are msl,tent fepurls, a, diligent as u,ual He work hi friend had felt that lie
undu presawc as he walked
,d Is,, cash, and, nn a sepaml had no other way out GREG DlflT
tula Ih Hrvve of(:ontmuns m noun ([ruled by it,, Mal) that
b,, fight enhanced .it Is,, III. .. ],all been I'll lri that he owed in die Foreign tire shmake,mis, ,cad
eyes told .,,ad mrad [,limit nmuve befnnd Ilus gnlhng- 011firLe their he 'cut ' .'Is' ,,,,any Campbell was on his Rolin Director-general of the
thal Kelly w s suppo,ed t e-mail, One in u lonmahsl lie way back lo Bnlarn ftom
hl, bases, glaeces BBC Executive ultannatedly in
I he went ptePared ur eduwle confess puhhely to heutg Ih knew said he Issas Waiting Miles,, . When lie heard of charge of whether the BBC
"utml the end of Ilu " week" Kelly s death, In, fnenrts
I,,,] explaus But ]I,, was .11 mole but amuw (bl1qasr suit
ITc befatc taking stack of lus Jann that lie 'Tel, sick ' but should reveal as source
tnymahnn nut oa expoeilion the BBC ol exaggermmn
Kelly faced e bmraee of yvea- rmtlee had tried pumi,ed pmmun Butnnknrelenedlo he usually no stalcmuw or apal-
Is claim a,,.,d.ng 1. ho, "maay dark act.,, playing ugy Instead he dr ;,,,caad Quesfinniz Was he from
oons ralhu 'hall 11-11111 let
theory a,] tire t"mra nnition games; roade ]]III blame concemed with prudecturg
onS oil( m academic admit,
, he math, save pefened, wauld "of us revenge on the He had hands and al about Blmr on a 7et Bymg the reputation at the BBC
,flat he ,, In, it,, evtdenrr BBC If [Is,, aas hour It t,et- 31m went not fad a walk towa,d, Japan on the near than the trNh, Wlry can he
landy faded as 2 vlrategy as
"as h,, usually does "said his lee of his international tour
The reasons, dam"d hete and not now admit whether Kelly
The power simggle mged war tbld the news by salelhte
dicre file Mp, seemed un- was Gdhgaris sourcey
rc ot theu gmund or die tetn- rhc BBC ntamlavmed m laity A whde later he was sees, In plu
,denec Dawnntg Streel slot[ a lam. near his house aid He wa, vwtaady aware of
cmto of event,
An u,ual he ,poke qme0y mv>ted it .,,, a tire Into Kelly was found about three miles from his Southmoor home appr,med to stnilc as usual at a Conru,ued on yage 16

CURRENT ACCOUNT Nationwide

Overdrafts. Save over 50%.

" Overdraft rate 6 75a/o EAR, over ' 'o less than High Street banks " Free access to your mor^,r worldwide " More ways to access your account than any bank

SWITCH YOUR CURRENT ACCOUNT IUDAY.