Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Labour

    Uploaded by

    mbeverinotti
    2 views11 pages
    labour

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    labour

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    2 views11 pages

    Labour

    Uploaded by

    mbeverinotti
    labour

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 11
    20 ey ey Ma Dita «gency pontantroolegia theory of orga echaicky~ oi See gos human sujet sl summoned node to pes ve ‘wn tecnologia! deme? 5 In Origin Tene The Thy of Tc fm Maret Deda then seek ofr one version the ast preset and tre af the ‘eco tra within cantata pxapy. I prc to ‘erin ind Hom the ous, however that stasis ara was aay Seay there Soi 8 by no means ‘ve =e, ia hae ee ‘nming ite ica never end. To oer ne lst cnet ble ‘Sttaing Us opening shapes then shout hat wes the thcont of teenies dumbrated i ths book sacl 2 com ‘on conceptual phosptieal or even methologe apa thn ican wetino to dn Wht oat ean peak ‘wing? wc wl it go nthe ats? How desea the way me {in abot le (nes) rare ey at Dg and he ‘ing that we ousles ate Zen ptr Homo pins at fate ee ‘pts Das ene cae; portnmnan cyborg) And wf anyone = ‘al cum out bee hiner =the cgi at hough Labour iret eng Ntetngagmonchisher Bxson) Up cqes Dera hinsel, Kat Mare ning es than the et thinker of techooogy~ te pony pos de acm 18 wth Nan ther wor, hat te pllosophy of echalogy deemed to move deitalyteyond the Arion Isomerase account of ‘ee tat ad donated thoght wt the ween mesa tion, As we have os Sen in Caper, APSoes Pps se Tec [rere ab nothing mote than ath’ = tooo ntument = that rege wnat has tecomne known 35 an eet use ans of Sn) oc i motos ted si a coat and sting te ft Som Insofar a they ae products of at (cd have no tne Input change (pss, 1921890 Heres pete hs Anclent ea of een 36 an ine, neta istraent depoyed Sor Sone end that preenis that hata staan sok cha Teng, lm the posopical anthologies of the ety Mans whe tua thnks cig finda cata, Sach why Mae Ph toy of wl the Sting pa foro om eee oF Tors we ca 0 fonge spy opps many and technology as tthe wee ene separate ontological ets: oc acon to 1 proce tat wil ave Wo be deh early) comes into entnce trough, and asthe other If Maran psopty i amos wives Iekotiedged ody to vepresent eek th the Atte isi ‘morals acount of techy, Noweve 1 Fevelng tat 5 80 22 meray oho Deis romtnaly convict of not ok ge a gle Remar Seger for ‘anlage that nol terion eh al cones {ote thoughtsrs means nen prodicton tthe extent where he Ieapyses underage whi ot questioned, tl om {tater ha plop of techni er Top a oma pp 138-0) eape the mon fu sdex of Mam aged sat Cink ttc a anything othe han an Arslan means t= nx techn end bi cou of the mace stage of captain he ‘Gnd whey an apstenlypretechnoog] cote nan ‘ject cam oan feo fem the aeration iced BF the ft {hal abuapon of our under isan. th wy, he Imac i eso to ng places he stement ot mas ‘dation o hrsl and is wrk. “Tis chpter explores Mares phsopy of tehoaogy rom the anthnpoogy ticle ine woe ke the Eamon an Pop Mans othe tory of tabu popu the Cap tele ‘onchfng with te famous estga of machines inthe Orbis ‘Torment the mr oer dee nga ab the et te ‘tot Dee call igi echt? Inthe opening pages of is La hoped Mar (1995) ene Ratat ‘este following say seat lc hee no an hee newer fri bea Manos pion One might add ht fhe sae Boks {ru for Maria toy ecology Ae Ale Shi observes ‘Marc theory of he Telsionstipteeen a, trea eho gy ates out oan exceptional vse and raked ef Sures— {fom German ides tagh plc cosom oes materia {sm and seve aco the phish eatear* rus of al he ‘Soung Mars post of echo ema recog Hegeon In outline: i theory bout Me Sarat pesapposs cP ‘eto a unique una ssc op seling tetany Shaping the atherwze net mater oat” Hs oe age ‘eh residual humans never entirely sappeas in theater Mars 4 numberof r= mo mea, of cours Lals Ase — ave ued iat igual (or abot sperseed bya lett oF technol mater forAhuner heater Mase the tout Proceso sb the expesion of beo-Hepln Numan esence so Ich of + materi mechani’ ttt dominated bythe pst. ‘alle fate at techcogy Pehap the mos important tr cing Mare’ s-alled ‘epistencogal beak Anson Rbiaach and Ito's Tener extent) Any E Wendling arg the emerging thery fa themes which ally oestoyed any spcuatve oppostion Tater ma and natre by acing al oc of ate = whether a. Ua naman o technoigat =a ons oa style universal energy oF sf tte youn Mare emai commited toa theory of aur the creo of ha in oi 0 tr Rb (eater between human nour and other noganic pote oxen nature oteehlog: the human bd ss one ope thero= ‘yaar energy producing machine nthe univese (The Humor Ser, 1.7 Bema Sigler sconerton to the recptlon story whieh Ts tease out treater gt tls = Nar Eng the ty of hbour moves beyond oth the man-sersachine hams Syma theory by acting new and dymamie str coupling Fl of Eten 2). Te ith the young Mar’ theory of lou, though that we wll gin Accoeding to Deed of cours, te founder onto ‘ln’ was no ean thinker fing 30m al: ei hiner of tangas mark” Dest being thoroughly nese ne ‘ew cence ofthe 384 Lay etch Job Mole Lat ‘cer et a= the plosopher enained cept boat ed of “wuga eaters tht Sought fo echanise and hes deste ‘he elton betaen san sod atte ahr what put the ry {nto sonal metas (The Cont of Nate Mar. 85, 92 ‘othe Mare of he 1644 Pars Mamuri, fortance ay ‘Siti haar ot sneing ae Pa i of 0 {51 man He For the young plsepey, man is undoubtedly & “ving otra ing endowed wh val per and nets tp ‘ey because ena sing he ao feng, conditioned Sd lintel eau’ who Is Uety dependent on ene beets 0 ‘That toy the act of is ince ouside i a ate Independent of yet these objets ae bes tate mcs = ‘ena ac,nipesablet the manfeston sp conemston {tts esta power: on nd Psp Mami, 81, Mares emphases 24 e he oem Sew Dee By changing moran natin aesondance wth his needs = uig rata resent fod, eating, thes and eng pace = the natal wor becomes the bjetieton (eerste of ‘msn powers 8 othing estan mans gen Pay p11) Sich le proactive ie = in whieh man ata or externas hs owe nto the nrc meld nd opie et win, fay tht worl Ite tai of a the young Mar sy ‘oto calls human spesevexistence (tangent In his woek upon the ote wort hetelor, thot man rt really proves ins to bea sce eg” fp. 11). In thls ma, the Young Nak tec anhopologses egal plosophy of nature nan is countrpare {Gael Le, he Noto RI wi nate "is Maes phesepy develope trough the 180 howere he the ‘ayy of abo bcomes (ora tay of posible rewsons wn wich there il remalay Ite arent Incesnay dethuaniss ‘hat begs as the neo Heelan actasaton ofthe man ence ugh natre tra ot by the tne of Cape? othe Cap = toe no longer singly funky human proces. Wha re he ‘omptome af th famous epstmslogal best? Tosa wt Ks ‘ing tate mature Mat ow defines te bow proc an ‘ler istonsip between man, ate snd one her itera sce) ‘Tesi ements of he about proces ae (1) purpose att, ‘nats woe se the ton wich hat work peered and {Gy the intents cf a wrk (app 280) the two facto tht proces =the tl ne of mana the esourss of notre wich wil fl therm ~ ae wey fai fo om the Pare Mauri, the ncn the tame of cat ‘rte thin element nthe Sefton of abr sino ee aon ‘Sinot poceed with! te nstsuments of abou for Ma that Instrument repent te sential pnt afitrtacebermes the oer ‘tina sd the subject is abou what whieh po bo ke ce ‘An instrument of abour thing or complex of thing which the [Shou interpoerbewcen hime an the bjt his abou an tech Serves conduto cecting acy ont that jc (Capital p288) haps we can sesdy begin Yo tect Man’ break seth he lsopher ls the instunent ef out no me rote at ‘he mare meio (The Compo Nate in ar. 108) ‘hich te dleicofman and tre anak place ares ce, ‘Stato ean say cease ‘jugs ate, oe nqursomahing atthe mek {Capt p08. ‘we ate no nearer €o understanding what historically and materially ‘eh an lstament eight look Uke, and Mare’ examples are eves Ing Fay and most ely, Mars oats the portant eso which ‘ve lear eat mas ow oy = ads ad fee =f lt “Instant "uns body orga aloe seve ste istuments of Ii abou when gathering ach rene mean of abe’ ax Fras p16) atervars though, the psosoper uly pats is les to one sid naar of he theory ft ae nthe Mase that he nar! word ems nd of ior ran struments rare 'sman’ ‘orginal those he aus proving him with "ones for towing, ging resin, Cating et (117) or Mart Iowever, it isuinaty ter man's ow Boy no the ar word The we and onsrction of stamens of about hough present ‘thespectcaly human abou proces and Manin therfore eines ‘manasa Yoong sal p12)" Jt a ou the natal contin f ham ensenc, 0 his ‘acon express tel ough he eof stamens and lls fom the vey sta, through nonsatural of abeeted tok eine lege oped ar an elecfay Econ he aber ren ed i ope um eye aro ‘hat human spcereistence ls dfined tog elton to etna man fa ol rama ths sere, mgt be pte 6 enelade ht Maes at singly a thier of ngs works Dea 25, ery of Tats fom Ma rie segue) bat of beng techs: the prom pnd ect aso ‘Miner of eee rs psp. ‘To be sue: Manes deition of an a hm ae i an nd Import sep nis Niel aster enteopaoy, bat we are {tony balay twats undetanding wet happen ia the out proces fs not gut enough fo sty that ma acunies i ot ta exence o spt by wing tose t tanslonn the natura mors, rota are ey la ttm as no essence Pe sprees ‘lactation According to ale tht antes Dea ad. stom of Leo Goutans theory of exteoesaton (swe Wl Sen {Chapter the Bsomingactal of the tence through the ose of tool i what reactnely cies that essence ga eee the fia plac, Not only does Mare’ snthropslgy consiery tle the Itanfntre or ptmateroppoton to tear ere Dut trio characters the han od nis account at es es fo pate the hn of extend! or bot” quay hath pe tng tet otro Hs noe enenment, on the de ha {euincorortng ht envionment int al town a bs, fm theater = a comtemporary cognitive pos now replay ‘site mind” Tor Marea he plleoper goes onto make ‘ear famous psig on Copter 7 the Cp tout Hl ‘othing oe than hi proces of oncogene owing st work Labour a ol proses Between man adnate, 2 proces byw man rough as ow cons, mediate, es, a onto the metaotsa (Secs between sel and Nature ie confront the mates nate ae Yr fate: He es ‘tian ams, eg, heads and ha, ter 1 appropriate te ‘ater of nate na form apt to sew aed. Tag hs ‘movement he acs spn eternal atte ad ange ann thie trey hesitancy changes om ate Unk earch ese ewe trea i unde vert, ven egh sins ape Non} He Sevsop the potent amber ‘nh mate ad sabes dhe play of sacs tS On SO power (Capt p 115) ‘nat being desc in he dat ofthe tour proces? Fy, Its important to ore that = singe te legedbumanim of the Naame dagosed So unbentaly by Altus ~ te psion of -nbouritMare nay ha undergo seething of tot an formation bout Hu notte abou, has Peso the man ‘qatyat sujet that conver: man and nature into one acter ‘rise suonomo stances fn and nate span mater =n "he young Mars o the Manas the mature Mar of Catal ses to we nto mame amore dam recursive and mutually eonsttve ‘ache offset betwen ogi a elonmen" Deas he ‘ow important index of abou consti rl a is eltonhip "ough te tal partion in the abou process. what Sars ‘ut ith an traning naar in acorns with io ned sing tot, ends up eth man om natr isl beg vanstored By changing nate wth tools man changes ison nate, ter ‘ord, bt nat want to ss yon in Wha allows the oo “alter tan meay poset oatmeal that elo” corn at thay abou a he mabe of ote abe {pe made by those os or Marto respite, human spcesasece i we can sti se sch mo ame someting in which oe human el only one Slement oth praacte of sd profes ech secon tre envionment: man and tater invent ene anther thro the medium ofthe tot tees posi athe of sca enluson to lane + Marian mater genealogy tbe than 2 “inle antroplog) ofthe human seer. a Any Wendling ote, ‘the enbodimest of dent fom o ols produces sees (pet ‘tama ing (ars Teco an nation, p34 As Mae Timely tin he Gaon, Nt only do the jcive conditions honge the acto epoducon ~ as wastelands become clad ‘un and vilage tom = "bt the produce change to, that Uy tring out new quits in erste, develop thensles in prod ‘on, safer themselves, develop new powers andes new modes oF discouse, em needs and ew langage What exact though fa a psa - hi 5 95 Boy ee: nour bes ot merely ‘obie the nara forces othe Body = mean lege, as a ‘sds ut atoms pis erm, pom ad capac. BY ben hing to lout manly tn te ft pac he man body expends "ais men nerves, ea et (apap 137 a a he dou ee es ety epee cng ey physiological wansformation of the body through the labour process 25 Te of at fo ats manufactrng stage of inte tain and stengthen the Body the ‘machine sage of apa otros masses fee andi ‘ies the mate abou by $15, pp 192-569) Pep the lsc Ss ow ap cna hi ng ‘min thatthe arm othe ee rot ofr Mar sas {ut om he neo Astotelan postin hat human spe bring make ‘Sane tlm order ofall pesos nthe pees i ‘erence ete bua abr he ae band, andthe labor bet ‘espe onthe oer (pp. 281-4) ~ endo aging ta he ‘nen generates ne ends ne eed et ines, eet tht fd at preext esethe stiacton ofthe ks sete on of Sasi al he samen stn wc her a, est ‘orn heed emphasis ae" The pecnceied ae hema In en ot hen ay re generate yi hough 90h Insrament of satsocton. hss why Maan phtosopy af echinal ogy tren so vay with the tylomorpism of Aston thn ofc Ma acu, a ape mo a tea pry eo he pt of ee ees Tethape we can eso the Matsa asciuntof the mutually co statin ao Heteen man and fol by tuning 10 ech Engels tscintng thought expesinent The Par Daye by Labour in the Marlon re Ape to Ma inthe Da of Nate.” Engel objective om the ery outset of hs lee wo radealae Mar aot ff lsbour atthe ‘natural conaton of human existe tothe pt ‘ete what we d= ut cmt tat existence in tea pce Tsetse that bur eet an hime (Dist Nat p27) ‘ecoraingf the tony proba tty of te Dati "onary cog ite a tooughgeing nat ater we mst ‘entend ths elsm tow toa le in forming te bi pels In Darwinian, atmos austen, tems: occu elton une “longue, and ultimately oveaes, slopes! eoton, Dept the fact hat mocha the Dats belongs tothe aim of oreo ‘today, iisremsrablethat Engel alot entirely speculative) tes ‘of he cigs of man il manages to atlate many ofthe tore: ‘tao pls antropeogy pater ao-counan gument ‘Shout he vote of too we a utanevtton "To stat whe Engel sue hat the ith ofthe hua 1s an be Mast the moment ‘en reo ated an upright posture and ts Deane {Ne tous ape lin or purposes the han sae fe aed ‘ould honceto ata ver restr eae a slp. 263)" What ‘eet thoughy makes he human hae 30 haps? For Engel the answer to hs question is nsurpesingy, toobmanuactare and use "The specalon of te hand pbs he nad the ol ysis ‘perf heman ni the tansorming eaten of man on ate, Prodan) Weeything bess with te Mbration ofthe and Fertontase then the elton of the ean of te cal ote onscouness othe capacity fer symbole hough neces comes [oer what well mind the stereo he soy ht marl ‘Shou imme ental gp 2845). Paps mos important Naw ‘er Eel ges with Ma hit the tanner imal) pysealy ‘onslormed tog wo ecology = tnd oes this more ‘nor ha nthe ce ote hand: One the one ie, te han the “Sean of labour ste metal ve it gpper with opp ‘thst enables man ae tot the nt plas On te ote Side, though te ana as he pdf abt hassel evar $n i ra cg og po pent ipating Steir in Chapter a tsbook we might alla enon of Mhman tot ong an nrg mater he aE, Pine COniy by Isbou By adaptation to ever ne operon, by Inher: ‘ce ofthe reiting peal develope of muses Heats Sd oer longer peo of Une ones 35 wel and by the ee ‘ened employment of hse ners proven new Dd Inorecompcted operations ha he aan hand ated te high ‘egeofperction at hs enbled if cone into Being the le teres of Hapoel the states of Toews the msi o aga (p20) ‘What provisional concasonscan we din fom Mars stor mate ‘lis anthropology aboat hi plsopy of technology ore gener sy is wellknown tat the posers cous ited wth 2 Tweiering numberof eerencs-ontlgil athropaogal stor Ie pole and purey spate to something cae ecole ‘put wate much moe fiat lates content poston ‘or stance spon Hs ani As easy teating othe Story of 2 Tere of ay fo ar erie Marx catia reves te piosphe as routine Ben dept 3s ‘ring om a throug ein dtrat wo a a. cmolgkal oman an inthe ese of Ahaser~ even Ho ferent ster of cree" Yet as Kh Ansell ean has ate, Shar atest bite stele toy that he erent postions Teanlogea or mani te ten ust oes of he same at cenit ther he cols human sje east potion Ihetruc agent aif tory orisercal ageny ewe purely lh seaenly ono tse” For Narsian plop of technology ‘tht agisbly romans to Be haut wel hs teary abou ee ot he fae cain hunans or technocets agency oF ete isn case oft nd 0.0m ba rather wat me Have led the ‘ay itig tof hm on, Ot ote tists by extern et ioe inorganic enone, adapting Ihatervironmeat to Reeds On te theron we undead have tninowancenvicnment~-but en evonment tat contin inn hc al nt tat boy, Inventing the fos aman species eg ‘wl tke. To understand a rgnry humane felon 2 the rotor fre of history Is to explode the ampli ontology of = n= {We auoncmous agent = whether you cal nan otc’ males fo atta ference tht fb onan end of sor a Ieplace It wth 3 more complex ad dynam el offre Maes ‘om phikwphy des not sway do eonepaa ase fo thi force fie we ll sein the acon halo hs chapter ow hs pat {alee of cpt zs remo the buon over and gant {he techie does ep to map het undetermined eck nop between organi and enone ht al be explored athe pfu ther of onary tect rom Sond to Seer Teachcae we move om sol n which the human ad miles estas autonomous ete or eins and ony enter into mation ‘hough the lan instant of hylomorphie production = Cowaes 9 Isopid yterof til exchange 2 ln Mar oof boas then the pilsopher acter new ate Finis anroplogy: ham spies exsence te eof dame Inverse between the eae and the Iota out of whch the form ofthe tama i reduced” thes tery ea hat = coy the ig fies ke tier (Le Temps i lon pp. 1850) = tec cannot he rested tthe etapa category of pare ‘et of podson a e Mane io ig es an tre wl ee, human tine concours Accodingy, man o pore ‘hie nagh int the gay technic fhe uma oH en ‘ploig now Hanson te other majo denson of Mae ph Jovy of ecology same ature or acne ‘age capita be sue, Mats sry of the progres anton ‘Gruso of man about under caplet pins whee he oltart becomes dominated by the vey teinalgy wet ct Tote amar nde arto all tle: ehape iss hy as th proved to bean sy (and gain parapet ey) tag o cone tempopy continental pilomphy of ecole Timothy Cl, for ‘rumpie, argucs that Mar ther of anation presupposes thee of Suntrsmmetie uman exencetht il emai within he bi of "he Atel instrument theory of ecaaogy(Deonstration nd Technolgy p29), Fr Rema Slr, tho, sca. ‘Rat upon uf sinters res etagu of ache geet In ight of he act tat he abourng sue ali aleaton has way ae happen: mectannton comes afer humans {toleration onto eho aati sens oie "ony tha Max does nde appeal hey moments hougioat his ‘tought wo teioe ofa te, caletve and unaiate hua abou ‘eich ones ecology ander contol ap well om gs = oeverteess want to wager tat is concep of an unammeled human een ahich has been lost and may be rgnned cannot Seay spe, be ound anyone are oe work ater te Pats ‘Manure Sac the exe to wich the fin hiker of tsi ogy might be ead the gal he of egnay tect. What happens, then, men we rev the Marsan erga of the machine Inthe tasty ee ecole conto he man Te mpotnt to bein by caifying exactly what Mas mas ty ‘ne machine tn the indus paseo atl because ifs om Inert aes scanty sch gure ae anal or abe Ase ‘haks clear athe Grands Mars Ulery spread on tage’ {vson of machinery nt te extgoes = thee that tas pe ‘ting loc he an power or natural power and tow tht produce ther oper p90) = bat of the oI sbeay te pre Stony shat sings fom te andl olor trent ‘a human att tat cance the fevia! ode of rodeo, 52 Te Dyn fom Ma Dee using the Indl Rewltion nan cesses ob the mer oF ca toler of cinoloy and simply becomes what Max els te ower = the fore requred to nly in mani. Ye, the ce of aon ins pce, th el {aie sans pce tte toto of taaiotgy (Cap 497). Now, ‘Ste thi sate of ts os not stifactory Benue nara oc ae ‘bot powetlenough to paduce consistent and eons maton fe wind doce not aay low, the wae lees ea al) 108 ‘pow and more ependbl motive fret be seared or Marthe ‘cet of echo atonomiation ony ese lope on ‘lon when tecnology Has Become independent enough to be ‘en prine move ox mnie fre the Bh ofthe age othe machine {Shs pace en machines and he pragmatic xa or Mar ‘cure Wat seam engine be o power themselves and chet ‘sche (ps6). Seon ad aling om rm hin, ls eget {tat what ake te machine even mot power sis ysanasay of ‘rotation an ndsdual machine sendy a ensemble petting» ‘nunber of operations simtaneousy (p47. there one ahi, ‘mother woes then thslvays mpl te existence of hr maces Sn ltnately of machine stem all working togeer in adem, Ike the factory, Final, and et ratrouy Mar also Gotnes the ‘achine a hela! Conlon ofthe captain of pretation: the machine embodies the rea sabsampten of ving bon about thst has sendy teen fonuly subsumed thug the inpestion of ‘he mage econo) = y deed o een abu Te species of anation Synonpmous with he ach age cally pede mtn el ‘gy =the manuacring woshogs tat dominated production rom ‘he scent century troup othe en of the ghee a aed translorme the abate ito an somai npemet (48) = bak from dee is ony sal tpt replace the umn works with $m al pete at fie se ah Son of the working ay wo acommate the icesed procucety tthe machine In somparion to human bout (2) the apprepta ton of women anderen into the abou proce tthe expe of mena the demand for muscar eng made redundant by the chines (3) We deing do of wages assed bourse eta ‘ant andthe conequent erento ofa vats abou amy an fly, (the ever incteingitesteaton of what human about emas In a9 unvarying, monotonous bau press (pp. 229-58, J hs machin sabsampin fal te abou’ psa and ental ower the fom animal eacrbed in Cape? the Capt nates tote machlne-opttea ol of Chapt 1s In handicrafts and manuacue, the workman mokes we of a 0 In te faci, the machine makes wae of Thee the mone the movement ofthe machine that he mst oon In mane: tre he worker ae the pro vig tans 9 Ue toy tre hive oie mechani which independent he workers (Tho are incorpo nto ving appendage (8 = 40 Gnesi pp. 92-3) neve =i the stoi mates antropology ot the et ‘est ofthis chapter has any force tal tg hay cant te {o snple To pre the evaue question, what xa =i ating ie ‘eng allented nthe machine age of exp? ean some ni ‘onl an eee that ow puss iat Ue machine Beans Mare ky Cape 7 Ca a he ae en ‘ment our essence non-senal om he very sa On the cone Nae nuit emtiey ace wit Ler outro ana ate Sle that the human tives hough a proces of sel-bjectiicton: we Hs By Pting ourtves [our cosiounes cr know’ and ou is) Sukie uae and ita merece eptons at aeeer Simply prostheses Any atenpe to pot a theory of technolo [ienaton the depot a some pmotil metal or pyc ‘acy terry replat the itn ego al et fy puns rom te perspective of tcl mms. Fr “Maen philosopher of eeely the, any spa oa onary Ibuman ene tht ony subequal arated heaven of the {ge the machine mu be ps Int abeyance: Ketan Aacos comes ‘oer ty ove pon ere in speasing ofa ste of “nary Shenton a procs of esti seltexeositon or prone: thn = tht contest ams sl ar psd ig). TE Aon sight ona tt humanity has aay eoed a tate a Sllenation def or eof tchiology, though His esas to ral ‘eis ll to tumanstand estes) cm that such onary Slenton i oni 2 necery acts! moment onthe pt fo the ‘eatin ofthe fal man Eee uer communis eat we mst asm calling ‘lento’ = hough extenceaon ght be a eter 34 Te Th Th fe Mar Dei Tepe condition ob lied Ferhap more ding ti tee at ne ica ern ean ct thera age Tope outweighs tate nna self shentos ek petly the progreivecbjectisation extention of owed, memory Sgt Ino aefcs tat nes the eal sunt of labour (Gnateven othe soda Antonia Nee irc pose eae he ‘her owns or cms such anf asaly abo wn he no ‘peek ofthe aman On the one ha, the echt ‘tthe human boy can ese frent inthe seo ve te moet rime toot the aparenysiple ac of sing nae 35 ero ‘Catan ists, the woul a avery compen proce of teqng ‘te aputy af antelpation and reenion tough rope Othe later hand the process oftndstel caption mast bevewed the eatin hs motor capac thin haan ao nora trys Step argucs the generation and nensiaton of 5 ‘mnemotechnologil reproductive capacity ofthe motor behavout a pots In te same way Jeter Bjork concludes thatthe Inds apalstion of abr saga cra of the ey ‘tensor prstedae proactive power thts ls te ib Tabor: sucha cum by no meats dsguaes Marxian ceo Insta cata = eginary extern or postetcaton tae place in diferent stra ons, containing ferent moda and ‘Sseenons of power and capble of ving economia pon des: ‘ty bit tows tid any aga io an unteate uma about the piged eo tha gu eae the most revelling expression ofthe tno a the et ‘arts theory a alenaton can be wits nh athens some ‘tact pilwopy of tne. As ef sleady See In Chapel {he metaphyseal oppostion been thought nd ten sgl 2 tempo one: Patou euamnss election wera po {aru memory Ye, the moder cite of tease dos not So much suspend this oppeation ax esp riley a he fonm of ses of oppontins between a fects ‘pu’ te Dority anda “comtamiaatd” techn! temporality ck ae Po Sus ton (Bergson vlgar stra tse veronica ne (Pedeger tonal ne vers meantime nmi, Levis, Desa amen). To many jes fas own plot o me i ‘no excepto to his ral Peter Osborne shee gern sie ow the foumers thought presuppse at oppeiton betwee the amc quanta tine of capital and teats, quatadve tne oman penis On the ones, or example we Bate the chondlogil doctnw tat saonny pod upon abr "om gute to mesie value product, te Tenth ofthe wok ‘nga ad 0 on Capea Chap 10)" On te the iy oh we tte the immanent me of neat lou whowe reste Pe {ng eannot be maurd according to any predetermine external Sale {Gre p 8) For Otome Mant te of human hein ren ‘Ral existent iat e the en blo he abou they ‘tral ua ide thse ofthe existent ei of er {aly 5 te ol af “vlc” of ie, Osborne ages and ‘hry the onal ound of abou e's Hectoning ‘erat eno ue’ Maryan the Filosphy of Time’ 20 et ‘ne ight wonde whether wean oppose ontological ine the hock tne of apa gltesocsy here og to pu ferent wee ee the tine of mmanence not lo foro extortion. Mare ow indeed pref Heidegger phenomenology of nit, n ther ‘rosie might be publ tole the sue Seton toes tt ‘Sep ( ew Se a Caper eves ase Heeger in he fs ote of Tens and Tims Danes nite hs poly ot “aeting the pt to hie eas teen Ma a I eo Fst it fora into ftir kasi sl nly pale sant Fest hs lye ley era iced or in een sage Pt sstems aso what Hedge eal entokgal ne canon Be Epposed to chronological tine v's metaphyseal edtion =the ale ay the et of wting ad even the ral i an sen of te Sn ae llc’ ant a te (The al of peta 225) 30 te igh wonder whether Mares unliented abort gt al te undesood an eae orm of npn expat) rola alte why ese can the posopher peak of Soeting called the otal working ya opposed fo the working Imposed y ap a heh tet oto the ugh is prs of urls ae = ot 2 nawalsed ut unwell pate sens of cckte? Sch a Poston = whalers mate ments woul ea atone wa ‘eon de tension ten the two competing verso of te set Up Mare al tine = whether ulate or quanta, ontolgel of Salo acid oneal

    You might also like