Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Development of An Indoor Radon Risk Map of The Walloon Region PDF
Development of An Indoor Radon Risk Map of The Walloon Region PDF
DOI 10.1007/s12665-010-0568-5
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
123
Environ Earth Sci
selection of levels displayed for the variables (Bossew and of indoor radon concentrations is predicted by smoothing
Dubois 2006). the data associated with the same geological unit. Exam-
The regional variation of radon availability from ground ining the variograms, a constant variogram model can be
is multifactorial and therefore generalizations are not easy used, which means that the moving average is the adequate
to obtain. Two factor groups are known which predispose smoothing method. A preliminary study has shown that the
houses to elevated indoor radon levels. They consist of the data belonging to one geological unit can reasonably be
territorial situation characterized by regional geology, described by a log-normal distribution (Cinelli et al. 2009).
geomorphology and soil type, and the regionally co-located A constant average logarithmic standard deviation for each
building and housing conditions like foundation and con- geological unit, which allows calculating immediately the
struction type, local building materials, water supply, percentage above the action level can be assumed.
quality of fabric an age of house, window glazing, etc.
Some European countries built maps of indoor radon levels
giving estimates of the mean radon levels in buildings by Instruments and method
area. Other countries instead used indirect indicators of
indoor radon to derive maps of radon prone areas (Kemski Database
et al. 2009; Mikšová and Barnet 2002). The indicators
include parameters such as concentration of radium or Two databases of indoor radon measurements coming from
radon in the ground, and soil permeability. the South of Belgium, the Walloon region, are used. About
The choice of the risk indicator is largely related to the the north of Belgium it is supposed, on the basis of the few
availability of the relevant data. Only few countries have available data and of geological information, that no sig-
systematically collected soil radon data, but many more nificant radon risk exists (Gerardy and Tondeur 2002).
have organized indoor measurement campaigns and are The two data sets used have been collected by the fed-
thus naturally led to use these data as the basis of their eral agency for nuclear control (FANC) on the one hand
radon risk maps. Even then, it is useful to include some and by the Institut Supérieur Industriel de Bruxelles (ISIB)
information on the soil and subsoil properties. In the on the other hand. The ISIB data, about 5,000, are short-
absence of measured data, the information can be derived term (ST) measurements collected between 1990 and 2004
from existing geological, lithological, or pedological maps. in houses with charcoal canisters exposed (Cohen and
This is the methodology adopted to establish the map of Nason 1986) during 3–4 days in every season except
radon potential in the United Kingdom, which has drawn summer; radon is measured in equilibrium with its short-
on the methodology described in this paper. For the lived progeny by gamma-spectrometry with NaI(Tl)
430,000 indoor data collected in UK, an analysis of vari- detector. Only ground floor data will be analyzed hereafter
ance has demonstrated that geological unit, house type, (Tondeur 2005). The FANC data, about 7500, are long-
double-glazing, floor level of bedroom, living area, and term (LT) indoor radon data collected using track-etch
date of building year explain 29% of the total variation. Makrofol detectors (Urban and Piesch 1981), exposed
The analysis of the effects of geology (geological unit) and 3 months, from 1995 to 2000 on ground floor levels
of house-specific factors showed that the geological unit (Dehandschutter et al. 2009).
explains about 20% of the variation in logged radon levels Long-term measurements were gathered by several
in a data set for around 400,000 dwellings (Miles and Belgian laboratories. The calibration of the detectors was
Appleton 2005). controlled by using two small radon reference chambers at
The goal of the present paper is to produce a map of the ISIB and at the Ghent university (Tondeur 1998) as well as
indoor radon risk in the Walloon region (Belgium). The through the participation to European intercomparisons
map will display the predicted percentage of dwellings that (Howarth and Miles 2000). For ST detectors, the calibration
have a radon concentration above the action level (400 Bq/ factors provided by the manufacturer were used (Canberra
m3), in agreement with the definition of radon-prone areas 1987). The consistency between the calibrations of LT and
recommended by ICRP (1990), and with the mapping ST measurements was indirectly established by the statistical
categories adopted in Belgium by the federal agency of analysis of data obtained for the same administrative units
nuclear control (FANC 2009). (Tondeur 2005) or for the same geological units (Cinelli et al.
First, the data are organized into geological units, 2009). The geological units considered are shown in Table 1.
grouping formations of similar ages, with the two con- It has been shown that a log-normal distribution provides a
straints (a) to make homogenous groups from the point of reasonable description of the data and that the two data sets
view of the radon risk and (b) to make groups big enough can be merged for the evaluation of the logarithmic mean (or
for better statistics. At any given location, the local geo- the geometrical mean). The composite database represents
logical unit is determined, and the local logarithmic mean an important goal for two reasons: (1) the two databases have
123
Environ Earth Sci
different geographical distributions and can be considered as uncertainty value (1r) is 4% for both LT and ST at the
complementary in this respect, and (2) increasing the number reference level (400 Bq/m3). A large uncertainty, associ-
of data also improves the statistical power of our analysis. ated with the choice of the measurement period, depends
For each house for which a radon measurement is on the building and is usually not known. For LT results,
available, the database includes the geographical coordi- it may be more than 50%, due to the seasonal variability.
nates (Belgian Lambert System 1972), the radon concen- With the aim to reduce it, most of the measurement
tration, and the local geological unit determined with the campaigns were organized during spring or autumn. For
digital geological map (GSB). ST data, the time variability is much higher and much
Loess, a quaternary eolian deposit, here is considered as more stochastic, often reaching a factor 2 with respect to
a separate unit, which is not the case in the Belgian geo- the mean value, a factor 3 being not exceptional. ST
logical map, where loess is presented as a local cover measurements were distributed among all seasons except
above the underlying geological unit, with no indication of summer. Finally, a large stochastic uncertainty, often
the limits of loess-covered areas. However, loess plays a more than a factor 2, is associated with the choice of the
special role in the indoor radon pollution (Tondeur et al. room where the detector is installed. In general, one
1996), which justifies that it is considered apart. As there is single radon data cannot be used as a reliable evaluator of
no easy way to know from the maps if loess is present at a the risk level in the house, but only as a trigger for the
given location, it is chosen to develop two separate maps, decision of additional investigations. Nevertheless, such
one for situations without loess, the other to be used where data make sense when used for statistics with large
loess is present. numbers of cases.
All radon measurements included in the databases
suffer from significant uncertainties. The (systematic) Variability
calibration uncertainty is considered to be \5%, on the
basis of the calibration studies to which we referred Applying the t test (Cinelli et al. 2009), the two databases
above. Counting statistics may vary with the details of the were found to be statistically compatible as far as the
procedure, like the exact time of exposition. A typical geometrical mean is concerned. Instead, short-term data
123
Environ Earth Sci
Mapping method
123
Environ Earth Sci
by averaging the short-term and long-term LSDs as this extension is not sufficient, the node is blanked in the
explained above. map.
123
Environ Earth Sci
Fig. 2 a Oligocene variogram from FANC. b Namurian variogram from ISIB. c Eocene variogram from FANC. d Siegenian variogram from
ISIB. e Famennian variogram from ISIB. f Famennian variogram from FANC
agree with the constant model. The isotropic experimental without loess. A separate map must be established for the
variogram averages the behavior over all directions. But in similar regions where loess cover is present. For a given
general natural phenomena are created by physical pro- location, the user must first determine whether the loess is
cesses that often have preferred orientation. So a possible present, to choose the appropriate map.
anisotropy of our variogram has been studied. Even if a The map of the logarithmic mean for the Walloon region
variation related to the direction is often observable, it is is shown in Fig. 4; it includes also the region of Brussels, in
not important and remains compatible with the constant which only data coming from the ISIB database were used.
model. In Fig. 3 the directional variogram example shows The nodes with uncertain results (\20 data within
big variations but a great distance ([30 km). This variation 20 km) are marked using a cross. Grey color indicates
is not significant if the smoothing of data are restricted to nodes where \10 data in a radius of 50 km have been
an area of radius \30 km. found in the same geological unit.
The map of the logarithmic mean in the areas covered
Map of geometric mean (logarithmic mean) by loess is shown in Fig. 5. Loess is mostly found in the
Northern part of the Walloon region, but even there it is
The map has been constructed separately for each geo- often discontinuous (Tondeur and Gerardy 2004).
logical unit (Table 1) and with the method and parameters Comparing these two maps we can notice that in some
previously described. Since the digital geological map does areas the risk is low in the absence of loess while it becomes
not indicate the limits of loess, it is not possible to include moderately higher in presence of loess. In this case, the risk
it in the general map. It deals exclusively with areas is due to loess, deposited here on a permeable substrate
without loess cover and the map is based solely on the data (chalk or sand), itself producing little radon, but allowing the
123
Environ Earth Sci
123
Environ Earth Sci
123
Environ Earth Sci
evacuation of water from loess and thus increasing its per- the southernmost part: Lorraine). This affected area is
meability (Tondeur 2006). Elsewhere, areas of increased continuous and percentages above the action level as high
risk appear to correlate with those of Fig. 4 where the risk as 40% are predicted. It corresponds to geological units
arises from the formation underlying the loess. from Cambrian to lower Devonian.
A complex pattern is observed in Condroz, South of the
Map of percentage above the action level Meuse river and is associated with the alternating Fame-
nian and Dinantian strips of the Dinant synclinorium. Just
These maps are displayed in the Figs. 6 and 7; the second North of it, affected areas are associated with Dinantian
one considers data coming from areas where loess is and Silurian of the Namur synclinorium.
present. Finally, scattered hot spots are observed in the Northern
Figures 6 and 7 basically display the same features that part of the region, most of them associated with the out-
are directly related to the local geology, which is given in crops of the Brabant massif (Tondeur and Gerardy 2004),
Fig. 8. The main affected area of the Ardenne and Stavelot and the hot spot of Visé where the indoor radon problem
massifs is clearly seen in the South of the region (except was first observed in Belgium.
123
Environ Earth Sci
In the Ardenne massif, the geological determination of European radon risk mapping. Radon investigation in the Czech
the radon risk may probably be amplified by climatic factors republic XI, Czech Geological Survey, Prague
Canberra (1987) Radon analysis CISE 437. Canberra Industries Inc,
related to the altitude (about 400–500 m). Observing the Meriden, CT
rain maps (annual and seasonal mean precipitation), and the Cinelli G, Tondeur F, Dehandschutter B (2009) Statistical analysis of
mean number of days of precipitation in a year, we can see indoor radon data for the Walloon region (Belgium). Radiat Eff
that the Ardenne massif is the area with the highest values Defects Solids 164(5):307–312
Cohen BL, Nason R (1986) A diffusion barrier charcoal absorption
(Tilmont and De Roeck 1980). This area also presents the collector for measuring Rn concentration in indoor air. Health
lowest mean temperature in Belgium, thus a strongest stack Phys 50:457–463
effect in the dwellings, and presents the highest number of Dehandschutter B, Noel E, Pépin S, Poffijn A, Sonck M (2009) The
days in which the ground is frozen. These climatic conse- application of radon measurements in the radon action plan in
Belgium. Annales de l’Association belge de Radioprotection
quences of the altitude do not apply to the hot spots. The fact 34(1):89–110
that the maximum level of risk found in the Brabant hot Dubois G (2005) An overview of radon surveys in Europe.
spots (more than 30% of the houses above the reference Radioactivity environmental monitoring emissions and health
level) is nearly as high as the maxima of Ardenne (more unit institute for environment and sustainability JRC—European
commission. EUR 21892 EN, EC, pp 168
than 40%) shows that, in our region, geological aspects are Dubois G, Bossew P (2006) The radon ‘‘noise’’ and its geostatistical
dominant in comparison with the climatic ones. implications: risk mapping or mapping at risk? Society for
mathematical geology, XI international congress, Université de
Liège, Belgium
FANC (2009) Federal agency for nuclear control. Available in the
Conclusions web site: http://www.fanc.fgov.be/fr/page/bienvenue-sur-le-site-
radon-de-l-afcn/646.aspx
The maps shown in this article are the first radon maps for Gerardy I, Tondeur F (2002) Radon risk maps obtained from two
the Walloon region that fully take into account the geo- different databases in Southern Belgium, 6th international
worshop on geological aspects of radon risk mapping, Radon
logical information. investigations in the Czech Republic IX. In: Barnet I, Neznal M,
They are based on the separate smoothing of the indoor Miksova J (eds) Czech Geological Survey, Prague, p 44
radon data for each geological unit. As the experimental GSB, Geological Survey of Belgium, http://www.naturalsciences.be/
variograms do not show significant spatial correlations, the institute/structure/geology/gsb_website/products/geolmaps/cdroms
Howarth CB, Miles JCH (2000) Results of the 1999 European
data are smoothed with the moving average method. In this Commission intercomparaison of passive radon detectors,
way we evaluate the logarithmic mean radon concentration EUR [ 19148, European Commission, Directorate-General for
at every node of a 1-km grid. Research
The logarithmic standard deviation is evaluated for each ICRP (1990) ICRP publication 60: recommendations of the interna-
tional commission on radiological protection annals of the ICRP
geological group in two steps: first the logarithmic SD of 21, pp 1–3
short-term measurements is corrected for their higher var- Isaaks EH, Srivastava RM (1989) An introducion to applied
iability and then a weighted mean value of short- and long- geostatistics. Oxford University Press, New York, p 561
term LSDs is calculated. With the LM evaluated at each Kemski J, Klinger R, Siehl A, Valdivia-Manchelo M (2009) From
radon hazard to risk prediction-based on geological maps, soil
point of the map, and the LSD evaluated for each geo- gas and indoor measurements in Germany. Environ Geol
logical group, and assuming a log-normal distribution, we 56:1269–1279
have built a map that shows directly the proportion of the Langley R (1971) Practical statistics. Dover
distribution above the reference level (400 Bq/m3). Mikšová J, Barnet I (2002) Geological support to the national radon
programme (Czech Republic). Bull Czech Geol Surv 77(1):13–
Several nodes of the grid show uncertain results or no 22
result at all, because of the insufficient number of data. Miles JCH, Appleton JD (2005) Mapping variation in radon potential
Future measurement campaigns focused on such zones both between and within geological units. J Radiol Prot 25:256–
should be organized. 276
SURFER (1999) User’s guide, Golden Software
A separate map was established for the areas where a Tilmont J, De Roeck M (1980) Atlas classique, collection Roland
loess cover is present. The limits of these areas are not Tondeur F (1998) Mesures de radon dans les bâtiments par les
specified by the geological map, which only shows the laboratoires belges: résultats d’intercomparaisons et de cam-
presence of loess at the geological sampling points. pagnes de mesures menées depuis 1993. Annales de l’association
belge de radioprotection 23:175–201
Tondeur F (2005) Comparison between long-term and short-term
measurements for indoor radon risk mapping, The Natural
radiation environment VII. In: McLaughlin JP, Simopoulos SE,
Steinhäusler F (eds), Elsevier, p 598
References Tondeur F (2006) Mapping indoor radon in the Walloon region:
kriging vs moving average, international assesment for mathe-
Bossew P, Dubois G (2006) From Babel to the round table of matical geology, XI International Congress, Université de Liège,
Camelot: on setting up a common language and objective for Belgium
123
Environ Earth Sci
Tondeur F, Gerardy I (2004) Search of small radon-prone hot spots in Urban M, Piesch E (1981) Low level environmental radon dosimetry
unaffected areas on geological basis, 7th international workshop with a passive track etch detector device. Radiat Prot Dosim
on geological aspects of radon risk mapping, radon investiga- 1:97–109
tions in the Czech Republic X. In: Barnet I, Neznal M, US EPA (2008) Environmental protection agency. http://www.epa.
Pacherova P (eds), Czech Geological Survey, Prague, p 23 gov/radon/
Tondeur F, Gerardy I, Gerardy N (1996) Indoor radon on loess WHO, World Health Organization (2008) http://www.who.int/ionizing_
deposits in Wallonia, 3rd international worshop on geological radiation/env/radon/en/index.html
aspects of radon risk mapping, radon investigations in the Czech Zhu HC (1997) Geological controls to the radon distribution in the
Republic VI. In: Barnet I, Neznal M (eds), Czech Geological Ardenne Massif, Ph.D. thesis, PMs
Survey, Prague, p 31
ULg (2009) Université de Liège. http://www2.ulg.ac.be/geolsed/
geolwal/geolwal.htm
123