Customer: TOYO ENGINEERING

Project: Chambal fertilisers and chemicals limited

Doc. Name: Comment response Sheet
Job No.: pv-501 (top platform)

PAGE NO.
S. No. (REPORT) comments received

one load is missing in calculation , please refer comments on

1 1 drawing VD-M-A06-STA-DWG-AYDA002-130D-0031
reaction of top platform & load applied on circular platform is
not matching &needs to update after application of missing
2 1 pipe load

in current staad file reaction of top platform is applied on

circular platform in a single load case , it is advisable to vendor
3 1 that apply reaction as per load case
load combinations:- pipe operation load shall be combine with
wind load and seismic load. Currently this combination is
4 1 missing
separate parameter & load factor for serviceability &strength
5 1 design shall be apply as per is 800 2007 LSD

6 1 in circular platform staad file load combinations are missing

calculation sheet, analysis method is shown as LRFD but actual
analysis done by ASD method. It is requested that anlaysis shall
7 1 be done as per indian code IS 800 LSD
 knee bracing work point needs to be updated in staad file as
8 1 per shown in vendor drawings 1)18 deg 2)135 deg
 AEPL REPLY

comment is incorporated

comment will be incorporated on circular platform report

in current stadd file maximum load reaction of top platform is applied on

circular platform which is more conservative ,but applying reaction as per your
comments will consider only one load case of top platform at one time which is
not safe . i.e. when live load case is applied in circular platform,load reaction of
pipe load which are actually acting in top platform cannot be applied

no such case is given in IS 800 2007 LSD

comment is incorporated

comment will be incorporated on circular platform report

comment is incorporated
both the work point in staad file matches as shown in drawing,but in report all
the views are shown in isometric so both degrees shown here seems to be
reversed.