Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Archdischild 2017 312697 PDF
Archdischild 2017 312697 PDF
Drug therapy
Nottingham, Royal Derby dexamethasone sodium phosphate oral solution. In significantly less nausea and vomiting than
Hospital Centre, Derby DE22 both countries, dexamethasone had the highest prednisolone base and is rated more palatable.
3DT, UK; palatability scores (SA mean: 1.97; UK mean: 3) and ►► Experienced patients gave better taste scores
sharon.conroy@nottingham. prednisolone base tablets had the lowest (SA mean: for all formulations compared with naive
ac.uk
1.12; UK mean: 1.39). Palatability scores improved for patients.
Received 12 January 2017 all formulations of prednisolone with each subsequent
Revised 1 April 2017 daily dose. In SA, prednisolone base tablets were
Accepted 15 April 2017 associated with more nausea (24vs7 patients) and Tolerability relates to several factors including taste
Published Online First and adverse symptoms such as vomiting, nausea
22 July 2017
vomiting (5vs0 patients) than sodium phosphate syrup
(p=0.008 and p=0.073, respectively). In the UK, vomiting and abdominal pain that can affect quality of life
occurred more frequently with prednisolone base (8 and willingness to continue treatment.3
patients) than sodium phosphate soluble tablets (2 A recent systematic review found that gastroin-
patients) (p=0.041). In both centres, dexamethasone testinal disorders including vomiting, nausea and
was associated with less side effects. Vomiting (1vs0 abdominal pain were the most common side effects
patients), nausea (7vs3 patients) and abdominal pain of oral corticosteroids given in short courses.4 In
(10vs8 patients) occurred more with dexamethasone the studies where formulation was discussed, pred-
sodium phosphate solution than dexamethasone elixir. nisolone sodium phosphate solution had a lower
Conclusions Dexamethasone sodium phosphate risk of vomiting than both prednisolone (base)
solution was the most palatable preparation. solution and oral dexamethasone.4 Only one study
Prednisolone base tablets were rated least palatable and compared both the palatability and tolerability of
were least well tolerated. Palatability scores improved oral prednisolone and dexamethasone. This study
with each dose taken. found that dexamethasone was more likely to cause
vomiting than prednisolone.5
We describe a prospective observational study in
the paediatric wards of Gurayat General Hospital
Introduction (GGH) in Saudi Arabia (SA) and Derbyshire Chil-
Corticosteroids are widely used to treat a variety dren's Hospital in the UK to evaluate and compare
of medical conditions. The palatability and toler- the tolerability and palatability of routinely used
ability of medication is an important factor influ- preparations of oral prednisolone for patients with
encing adherence to medication particularly in asthma and oral dexamethasone for patients with
children. The European Medicines Agency advises croup.
To cite: Aljebab F, Alanazi M, that medicinal products should be made in formu-
Choonara I, et al. lations with an acceptable taste for children.1 Oral Methods
Arch Dis Child corticosteroids often have a bitter taste and are also The study was conducted in the children's emer-
2018;103:83–88. associated with a wide variety of adverse effects.2 gency department (ED) of the two hospitals.
Aljebab F, et al. Arch Dis Child 2018;103:83–88. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2017-312697 83
Original article
Drug therapy
Children suffering from asthma or croup, prescribed oral pred- phosphate 15 mg/5 mL syrup (Predo, Jazeera Pharmaceu-
nisolone or dexamethasone and able to understand the study’s tical Industries, SA) and dexamethasone 0.5 mg/5 mL elixir
palatability scale and communicate their response were (Decadron, Algorithm Pharmaceutical Manufacturers,
approached for consent. The drugs and products administered Lebanon). The study was conducted for 3 months between 1
were in accordance with standard practice in each department. February and 30 April 2015 in GGH. It included only chil-
Choice of product and routine care of the patients were unaf- dren ≤12 years of age as paediatric admissions in SA are
fected by the study. limited to this age.
In SA, patients were treated with prednisolone base 5 mg In the UK, children (2–18 years) were treated with pred-
tablets (Gupisone, Julphar, UAE), prednisolone sodium nisolone base 5 mg tablets (prednisolone, Actavis UK, UK),
84 Aljebab F, et al. Arch Dis Child 2018;103:83–88. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2017-312697
Original article
prednisolone sodium phosphate 5 mg soluble tablets (soluble their parents were asked if they had observed any change in
prednisolone, Amdipharm UK, UK) and dexamethasone sodium their child’s well-being which suggested them to be experiencing
phosphate 2 mg/5 mL solution (dexamethasone, Focus Pharma- nausea including dizziness, lethargy or being cold and clammy.
ceuticals, UK). The study was conducted in the children’s acci- Palatability and tolerability ratings were obtained from
dent & emergency (A&E) department and hospital wards, for patients after each dose of medication until the course ended.
3 months between 15 September and 21 December 2015. The researcher contacted the parents by telephone if the patient
We used a 5-point facial Hedonic Scale to assess palatability in had been discharged, alternatively parents were given the option
both countries, as used previously in studies comparing the taste to complete the data collection form themselves and return it by
Drug therapy
of analgesic and corticosteroid preparations in children.6 7 The post using a prepaid envelope.
scale was explained to the patient and parent by the researcher The data collection form (DCF) used for each patient was a
who were then asked to rate the palatability of the medication modification of questions used in two previous studies of accept-
within 10 min of taking the drug where possible, by pointing to ability and/or side effects in children receiving short course pred-
the appropriate face. To evaluate taste in younger patients who nisolone for the treatment of acute asthma8 9 (figure 1).
were unable to self-report, parents were asked to help in inter- Percentages and χ2 testing were used for categorical vari-
preting what their child thought of the taste of the medication. ables to compare between tastes of different dosage forms and
Tolerability (nausea, vomiting and abdominal pain) as reported the tolerability of each drug. Categorical data were compared
by the parent/patients in response to direct questions was docu- using the χ2 or Fisher’s exact test where appropriate. The McNe-
mented 30–60 min after each drug administration. To evaluate mar-Bowker test was used to compare among the same group of
nausea in younger patients unable to self-report this symptom, patients how the taste score changed between different days. A
Figure 2 Mean taste scores of prednisolone base and prednisolone sodium phosphate according to drug history in SA and in the UK. Pred. Base,
prednisolone base; Pred. Na3PO4, prednisolone sodium phosphate; E, experienced patients; N, naive patients; SA, Saudi Arabia.
significance level of p<0.05 was accepted as significant for all when offered this by a nurse. Only five patients received solid
the tests. prednisolone base tablets. Most patients were aged between 2
In SA, ethical approval (Ref: 620/13/54) was obtained from and 5 years old in all corticosteroid groups. The dose between
the hospital Quality and Patient Safety Committee (QPSC) on prednisolone groups was almost the same. Most patients in the
23 December 2014. In the UK, ethical approval (REC Ref: 15/ prednisolone groups had received oral steroids previously, while
in the dexamethasone group most patients had not received oral
Drug therapy
Results Palatability
Overview In SA, the majority of the children on the first day disliked the
In SA, 141 children were approached for the study. Nineteen taste of the medicines (100% of prednisolone base tablet group,
children were not recruited: 11 because the parents refused 89% of prednisolone sodium phosphate group and 76% of
to take part and 8 children were missed for observation dexamethasone group) and no patients stated that they liked the
(see online supplementary figure 1). One hundred and twen- taste on any day (table 2). Prednisolone base was disliked the
ty-two children were enrolled to the study (table 1). Most of most (89%), and dexamethasone was disliked the least (27%)
them were with asthma (89) aged 2–10 years, and the others had (p<0.0001). Both prednisolone base tablets and prednisolone
croup (33) aged 2–5.5 years. The patients with asthma received sodium phosphate syrup were rated significantly more palatable
two formulations of prednisolone (52 received prednisolone day by day (see online supplementary table 1).
base soluble tablets and 37 received prednisolone sodium phos- The children who had received oral corticosteroids before
phate syrup). The croup patients all received oral dexametha- (experienced patients) reported different palatability scores
sone elixir. Prednisolone base tablets were crushed and dispersed compared with the children who received the medicine for the
in water in all cases. Most patients were aged between 2 and 5 first time (naive patients). These differences in taste scores were
years old. The dose between prednisolone groups was almost statistically significant on the first 3 days (figure 2).
the same. Around half of the patients in the prednisolone groups In the UK, the majority of the children on the first day disliked
had received oral steroids in previous disease episodes, while in the taste of the medicines (90% of prednisolone base tablet
the dexamethasone group no patients had oral steroids before. group, 62% of prednisolone sodium phosphate group and 34%
In the UK, a total of 147 children were approached. Four- of dexamethasone group) (table 3). On day 1, most patients
teen children were not recruited: 6 because the parents refused that received prednisolone base (77%) disliked the medication
to take part and 8 children were missed for observation very much as did 36% of the prednisolone sodium phosphate
(see online supplementary figure 2). One hundred and thir- group. Only 6% of patients disliked dexamethasone very much
ty-three children were enrolled to the study (table 1). Most of (p<0.0001). Both prednisolone base tablets and prednisolone
them were with asthma (80) aged 2–16 years and the others had sodium phosphate soluble tablets were rated significantly more
croup (53) aged 2–10 years. The patients with asthma received palatable day by day (see online supplementary table 1).
two formulations of prednisolone (38 received prednisolone base The children who had received oral corticosteroids before
tablets and 42 received prednisolone sodium phosphate soluble (experienced patients) reported different palatability scores
tablets), and all patients with croup received oral dexametha- compared with the children receiving the medicine for the first
sone sodium phosphate solution. Crushed prednisolone base time (naive patients). These differences in taste scores were statis-
tablets and prednisolone sodium phosphate soluble tablets were tically significant on day 3 only (figure 2). Most treatment naive
dispersed/dissolved in water and a few patients followed admin- croup patients disliked the taste a little (40%) or were neutral
istration by a drink of blackcurrant juice if the patient chose to (40%), while 33.3% of experienced patients were neutral,
86 Aljebab F, et al. Arch Dis Child 2018;103:83–88. doi:10.1136/archdischild-2017-312697
Original article
33.3% liked the taste a little and 17% liked the taste very much.
The differences were statistically significant (p=0.021).
<0.0001†
95% CI for mean p-Value
0.009†
0.019†
0.131
0.131
Tolerability
In SA, five patients in the prednisolone base group experienced
vomiting, while no patients experienced vomiting in the pred-
(1.12 to 1.67)
(1.84 to 2.54)
(1.29 to 1.94)
(1.61 to 2.33)
(2.71 to 2.91)
(0.67 to 3.33)
(0.67 to 3.33)
nisolone sodium phosphate group (p=0.073). Nausea was
(1.81 to 2.6)
(2.7 to 3.3) reported among almost half of the patients taking the pred-
nisolone base formulation (24 patients). This was significantly
–
more frequent than with the prednisolone sodium phosphate
formulation (OR=3.67; 95% CI 1.26 to 11.58, p=0.008).
Abdominal pain, however, was reported more frequently in
patients taking the prednisolone sodium phosphate formulation
0.82
0.88
0.93
0.98
0.88
1.27
(n=13) than in patients taking the prednisolone base formu-
1.27
1.1
1.1
SD
–
lation (n=8) (OR=2.9; 95% CI 1.1 to 8.1, p=0.031). The
patients who received dexamethasone experienced nausea and
Mean of taste
score (1–5)*
1.61
2.21
1.97
2.54
2
2
2
2
bance were the most common side effects. They occurred much
Like very much
1 (4)
1 (4)
(%)
0
0
0
0
9 (17)
1 (17)
1 (17)
2 (5)
1 (3)
1 (4)
2 (6)
2 (8)
Drug therapy
0
20 (38)
8 (26)
7 (30)
1 (17)
1 (17)
2 (5)
15 (28)
14 (58)
13 (54)
3 (100)
3 (100)
6 (20)
8 (26)
1 (17)
1 (17)
(%)
bance were the most common side effects. They occurred more
Taste of medication
19 (61)
13 (42)
3 (49)
3 (49)
3 (6)
1 (4)
*1=dislike very much, 2=dislike a little, 3=not sure, 4=like a little, 5=like very much.
0
Discussion
Taste affects the acceptability of medication and may affect
Table 3 Palatability of oral corticosteroids in the UK
53
Prednisolone base 31
24
Prednisolone base 31
24
Prednisolone base 6
3
Prednisolone base 6
3
sodium phosphate
sodium phosphate
sodium phosphate
sodium phosphate
Dexamethasone
Prednisolone
Prednisolone
Prednisolone
Prednisolone
n=55
n=55
n=9
n=9
Day 2
Day 3
Day 4
Day 5
the medicine for the first time (naive patients) in both countries CHMP/PEG/194810/2005. London, 2006. http://www.ema.europa.eu/docs/en_GB/
studied. Research suggests that the physiology and neurobio- document_library/Scientific_guideline/2009/09/WC500003782.pdf (accessed 27 Aug
logical mechanisms underlying the taste function mean that the 2016).
4 Aljebab F, Choonara I, Conroy S. Systematic review of the toxicity of short-course oral
impression of taste changes with time and experience and leads
corticosteroids in children. Arch Dis Child 2016;101:365–70.
to adaptation of taste perception.16 The experienced patient who 5 Ailakis JG, Hope ME, Stafford L, et al. Comparison of paediatric steroid mixtures. Aust
is familiar with the medication taste may therefore have adapted J Hosp Pharm 1998;28:246–9.
and started to accept it. This may also explain our findings that 6 Hames H, Seabrook JA, Matsui D, et al. A palatability study of a flavored
the taste ratings of all medications improved in both countries dexamethasone preparation versus prednisolone liquid in children. Can J Clin
Pharmacol 2008;15:e95–8.
day by day. It is also possible that as treatment becomes effective 7 Smith CJ, Sammons HM, Fakis A, et al. A prospective study to assess
and children start to feel better, they become more cooperative the palatability of analgesic medicines in children. J Adv Nurs 2013;69:655–63.
and tolerant. No other studies identified, however, have made 8 Dawson KP, Penna C, Penna AC. Tolerance and compliance of oral prednisolone
this observation of increased tolerability with time or with expe- therapy during acute childhood asthma. Aust J Hosp Pharm 1992;22:278–82.
9 Dawson KP, Sharpe C. A comparison of the acceptability of prednisolone tablets and
rience for these drugs.
prednisolone sodium phosphate solution in childhood acute asthma. Aust J Hosp
In conclusion, dexamethasone was rated more palatable than Pharm 1993;23:320–3.
prednisolone. For patients with asthma, prednisolone base tablets 10 Kim MK, Yen K, Redman RL, et al. Vomiting of liquid corticosteroids in children with
were rated the least palatable preparation and were also the least asthma. Pediatr Emerg Care 2006;22:397–401.
well tolerated. Prednisolone sodium phosphate was associated 11 Mitchell JC, Counselman FL. A taste comparison of three different liquid steroid
preparations: prednisone, prednisolone, and dexamethasone. Acad Emerg Med
with a significantly lower incidence of nausea and vomiting and 2003;10:400–3.
better taste score, compared with prednisolone base. Best practice 12 Meyer JS, Riese J, Biondi E. Is dexamethasone an effective alternative to oral
suggests that prednisolone sodium phosphate or dexamethasone prednisone in the treatment of pediatric asthma exacerbations? Hosp Pediatr
should be used. 2014;4:172–80.
13 Keeney GE, Gray MP, Morrison AK, et al. Dexamethasone for acute asthma
exacerbations in children: a meta-analysis. Pediatrics 2014;133:493–9.
Study coordinating centre 14 Medicines Complete. BNF for children. https://www.medicinescomplete.com/mc/bnfc/
Paediatric Medicines Research Group, Division of Medical current/index.htm (accessed 20 Sep 2016).
15 Li G, Almossawi O, Dulfeker H, et al. A really wheezy way to save money. Arch Dis
Sciences & Graduate EntryMedicine, School of Medicine, Child 2016;101:e2.28–e2.
Faculty of Medicine & Health Sciences, University ofNot- 16 Mennella JA, Spector AC, Reed DR, et al. The bad taste of medicines: overview of basic
tingham, Royal Derby Hospital Centre (RDH). research on bitter taste. Clin Ther 2013;35:1225–46.