You are on page 1of 66

CREATING AN INCLUSIVE SOCIETY :

MAINSTREAMING DISABILITY
based on the Social Economy example

European Standing Conference


of Co-operatives, Mutual Societies, Associations and Foundations (CEP-CMAF)

in cooperation with With the support of

EFCCover3_CS3.indd 1 11/09/07 8:14:18


Contents

I. Foreword...................................................................................................... 3

II. Introduction................................................................................................. 5

III. Practical guidelines and examples........................................................... 5

3.1. Employment............................................................................................ 7
3.2. Education and training..........................................................................18
3.3. Goods and services............................................................................. 23
3.4. Health care........................................................................................... 27
3.5. Leisure activities................................................................................... 30
3.6. Financial services and funding............................................................. 33
3.7. Housing................................................................................................ 38
3.8. Horizontal issues.................................................................................. 42

IV. Conclusions............................................................................................... 46

REFERENCE DOCUMENTS .................................................................................................... 50

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int21 1 10/09/07 13:04:07


EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int22 2 10/09/07 13:04:07
I. Foreword

For the past few years, the European Standing Conference of Co-operatives, Mutual
Societies, Associations and Foundations ( CEP-CMAF ), through its group on disability issues,
has promoted the inclusion of the disability perspective in Social Economy enterprises and
organisations at all levels of their work.
As a part of this work, and as a small contribution to the 2007 European Year of Equal
Opportunities for All, we have decided to create this guide to share our expertise in the
field. We have tried to develop a practical tool that can be useful for any type of enterprise.
Although the cases selected to illustrate the guidelines provided are from the Social Economy
sector, the proposals included can be followed by any type of enterprise, regardless of the
sector they operate in.
Disability can be horizontalised in any organisation, structure, policy, or activity undertaken
by public or private actors, active or not in the disability field. Often these actors overlook how
simple measures can improve the quality of life of persons with disabilities, or they are just
not aware of the various ways their actions can impact on disabled people. For them, we have
collected illustrative examples and simple guidelines that will help them to easily include a
disability perspective in their work.
With the aim of ensuring maximum accuracy and usefulness of this guide, we have benefited from
the invaluable cooperation of the European Disability Forum (EDF) and have involved a number of
experts from the various Social Economy families .
(Co-operatives, Mutual Societies, Associations and Foundations). All of this cooperation has been
efficiently coordinated by Marta Hernández and Ana Mohedano of the European Foundation
Centre (EFC). I would like to thank them all for their efforts to make this project a reality.
I would also like to thank all the organisations, institutions and individuals that contributed
to this publication after the presentation of its preliminary version at the Seminar on Social
Economy and Equal Opportunities held at the EU Economic and Social Committee (EESC) on
April 17th 2007, which was organised by the CEP-CMAF and the EDF.
Nevertheless, this Guide is not an end in itself, but just one more step forward on the long
road to full integration of persons with disabilities into society, and, we, as CEP-CMAF, are
committed to continuing to promote the active contribution of Social Economy enterprises to
this integration.

Madrid, August 2007

Miguel Ángel Cabra de Luna,


CEP-CMAF Disability Interest Group Chair

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int23 3 10/09/07 13:04:07




EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int24 4 10/09/07 13:04:08


II. Introduction

This guide, drafted in cooperation with and equal opportunities, with a particular
the European Disability Forum ( EDF ), is focus on disability.
one of several initiatives undertaken by the
With the presentation of the publication
Disability Working Group of the European
at the event a broad consultation process
Standing Conference of Co-operatives,
was launched in which interested parties
Mutual Societies, Associations and
were invited to read the guide carefully and
Foundations ( CEP-CMAF ) aimed at raising
provide their comments and opinion on the
awareness and promoting the integration of
practical tips and ideas outlined as well as
people with disabilities and disability issues
further case study examples that could be
in society as a whole and in Social Economy used to illustrate these practical guidelines.
enterprises and organisations in particular.
Mindful of the complexity of the disability
The guide is published within the framework field and given that people with disabilities
of the 2007 European Year of Equal are not a homogeneous group, we
Opportunities for All ( EYEO ) in order to believe that this consultation of relevant
take full advantage of the opportunities stakeholders, in particular people
that the Year offers to raise awareness and with disabilities and the organisations
give visibility to these issues. However, its representing them, was essential to ensure
relevance and use will extend beyond the the maximum added value of this guide.
European Year.
We are aware that there is still room for
Drafting methodology further development of this publication, of its
contents and examples, in order to make it a
The content of this guide is based on comprehensive tool. This is why we consider
the information and expertise provided this publication to be a first step that we
and gathered by members of the CEP- hope serves to raise awareness on the issue,
CMAF Disability Working Group and the encourage reflection and set up the basis for
EDF through consultation with the CEP- further action.
CMAF and EDF member organisations
and partners, as well as other relevant Aim of the Guide
stakeholders in the field.
This guide has been produced with a
The preliminary version of this publication threefold objective in mind :
was presented at the European Seminar on
Social Economy and Equal Opportunities, • To provide practical guidelines and
which was held on April 17th 2007 at the illustrative case study examples of how
European Economic and Social Committee organisations, regardless of whether
( EESC ) in Brussels ( Belgium ), in order to they work directly in the disability
solicit participant opinion and feedback. field or not, can integrate people with
disabilities and disability issues into their
This one-day event, jointly organised by the
organisations and activities. This action
CEP-CMAF and the EDF, with the support
will hereafter be referred to as ‘disability
of the EESC Social Economy Category,
mainstreaming’ ;
brought together representatives from
Social Economy organisations, European • To present examples of Social Economy
institutions and other key public and private enterprises and organisations, as well as
stakeholders to explore the current and partnerships between these organisations
potential role of Social Economy and its and other stakeholders, which are already
partners in the areas of non-discrimination promoting this approach ; and

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int25 5 10/09/07 13:04:08


• To promote a disability mainstreaming What is “Disability Mainstreaming”?
approach, in addition to disability-
In its document “Disability Mainstreaming
specific initiatives, in society as a whole
in the Employment Strategy” ( 2005 ), the
and in Social Economy enterprises and
European Commission defines the principle
organisations in particular.
of mainstreaming as follows : “Mainstreaming
means that the needs of disadvantaged
Who is it for? people need to be taken into account in the
The guide is addressed to every type of design of all policies and measures, and that
organisation, active in the disability field or action for disadvantaged people is not limited
not, interested in learning about integrating to those policies and measures which are
and/or willing to integrate people with specifically addressing their needs”.
disabilities and disability-related issues According to the definition of the Disability
into its structure and its activities. It is also Knowledge and Research Organisation
a useful reference document for society at ( Disability KaR ), Disability Mainstreaming is
large. “the process of assessing the implications
It is also important to highlight that the for disabled people of any planned
promotion of mainstreaming initiatives action, including legislation, policies and
should be combined with disability-specific programmes, in all areas and at all levels. It
initiatives. is a strategy for making disabled people’s
concerns, experiences an integral dimension
European Year of Equal Opportunities of the design, implementation, monitoring,
for All and evaluation of policies, and programmes
in all political, economic, and societal
The European Year is the centrepiece of a spheres so that disabled people benefit
framework strategy on non-discrimination equally and inequality is not perpetuated. The
and equal opportunities presented by the ultimate goal is to achieve disability equality.’
European Commission in June 2005, aimed
at providing a new drive towards ensuring the Social Economy and its contribution
full implementation of EU anti-discrimination to Equal Opportunities
legislation, which has witnessed much
progress in recent years but has also What is Social Economy?
encountered many obstacles and delays. Social Economy enterprises and
In particular, the European Year aims to organisations are economic and social
stimulate the debate and exchange of good actors characterised by doing business
practice ; raise public awareness of citizens’ differently, in a way which continuously
rights to non-discrimination and equal associates general interest, economic
treatment ; promote equal opportunities for performance and democratic operations, as
all ; and celebrate diversity as an asset for the well as the primacy of individual and social
European Union. objectives over capital and management
The Year focuses on the discrimination that autonomy. Social Economy includes co-
individuals or groups suffer based on their race operatives, mutual societies, associations
and foundations, as well as new forms of
or ethnic origin, religion or belief, age, gender,
businesses.
sexual orientation or disability. It also seeks to
address the issue of multiple discrimination. Social Economy enterprises and
For more information on the 2007 European organisations are present in all sectors
Year, please visit http ://ec.europa.eu/ of society and at all levels, but their roots
employment_social/eyeq/index.cfm remain local. Social Economy organisations

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int26 6 10/09/07 13:04:08


II. Introduction

are particularly active in the fields of The Social Economy’s efforts against
social protection, social services, health, discrimination
banking, insurance, agriculture, consumer
Social Economy, founded on the principles
organisations, handicrafts, housing, supply,
of solidarity and individual involvement in
neighbourhood services, education and
a process of active citizenship, is already
training, culture, sport, and leisure activities.
contributing to creating a diverse society
Social Economy represents 10 % of all that includes all persons, and in particular
European businesses, a percentage the most vulnerable such as those with
amounting to around two million businesses. disabilities.
They employ more than nine million workers,
It is doing so by developing and supporting
that is to say, they are responsible for
activities that directly address this group,
creating 10 % of all jobs in Europe. For
e.g. through employment and training
example in France, 760,000 Social Economy
opportunities, provision of goods and
businesses employ almost two million
services, legal support, defence of rights,
remunerated employees ; in Spain, they
etc. Nevertheless, it is also contributing
make up 5 % of the GDP ( Gross Domestic
by taking into account the needs and
Product ) and 10 % of employment, which is
requirements of people with disabilities in
about 1.2 million people ; and in Belgium, the
relation to other initiatives it may develop,
sector represents 13.37 % of jobs in more
even if these initiatives do not directly target
than 17,000 businesses, making up 5 % of
people with disabilities e.g. banking, culture,
the GDP.
provision of goods and services.
The European Standing Conference of Co-
It is also important to highlight that given
operatives, Mutual Societies, Associations
that Social Economy organisations are active
and Foundations ( CEP-CMAF ) represents
in all areas of society, they are in a perfect
key Social Economy organisations
position to promote full integration of people
at European level. The CEP-CMAF
with disabilities and disability issues in
represents co-operatives, mutual societies,
society as a whole.
associations, foundations, and various other
forms of enterprises that share the values
defined in the Social Economy Charter.

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int27 7 10/09/07 13:04:09




EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int28 8 10/09/07 13:04:09


1. Employment

III. Practical guidelines and examples

Disability issues are acquiring a growing partnerships between these organisations


importance in today’s world for several and others, to illustrate them. These
reasons. First, the percentage of people guidelines seek to :
with disabilities, although already high, is • Encourage an approach that
increasing continuously, in particular in encompasses action to prevent
Europe, as part of the continent’s overall discrimination against people with
ageing population – according to the latest disabilities ( users, customers, employees
EU and World Health Organization ( WHO ) and others ) ;
data, there are currently around 50 million
• Accommodate the diversity of this group ;
people with disabilities in Europe and around
and
600 million worldwide.Secondly, disability
is a cross-cutting issue that affects • Promote equality through positive action
all sectors of society. On the one hand, to address disadvantage or cater for
members of all groups can have a disability special needs.
and / or might acquire it at some point in It is important to highlight that the
life, whether through an illness, accident, promotion of the mainstreaming
or ageing. On the other hand, disability of disability should not exclude the
can affect all of areas of life, ranging from development of disability-specific
employment and training to leisure time, actions, which are also necessary and, for
technologies and so on. certain persons with disabilities, essential.
However, there are still many barriers to Disability mainstreaming and disability-
the achievement of equal opportunities specific actions should go hand in hand and
for people with disabilities. Many continue complement each other.The importance
to experience discrimination in areas such as of the implementing the “Design-for-All”
access to resources, power and employment methodology in all fields, should also be
– people with disabilities are still two to three emphasised. This methodology stresses
times more likely to be unemployed and often the need to take all users into consideration
for long periods of time. In most cases, this from the outset of the process. It deals with
is due to the fact that society as a whole is the process of decision-making within an
designed to meet the needs of the “standard organisation and not just at the level of the
person” and not those of people with special specific operative department that has the
needs, including people with disabilities, responsibility for ensuring accessibility.
elderly people or others.Organisations, Design for All aims to achieve the recognition
regardless of whether they are active of the enabling interface that a person
in the disability field or not, could help uses to function within life. This enabling
to change the situation significantly interface calls for an enabling environment,
by including people with disabilities and enabling society and enabling processes.
disability issues from the outset, into their The implementation of “Design-for-All”
structures and at every level and stage would enable to create a society that meets
of their activities. In addition, many of the everybody’s needs and not only those of the
measures undertaken could benefit other “standard person”
groups such as elderly people or people with
These guidelines aim to consider all types
temporary impairments.
of disabilities, including physical, psychic,.
This section provides practical guidelines sensory and intellectual or mental,
on how to include disability issues and psychological and mental, and a wide array
people with disabilities in organisations of issues of importance for everyday life.
and organisational activities, and gives However, given that it is impossible to take
examples taken from a range of Social into account all the specificities of any type of
Economy enterprises and organisations, or disability and to anticipate every eventuality,

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int29 9 10/09/07 13:04:09


we are aware that these guidelines are equal opportunities for training and
not fully exhaustive : they do not cover all access to career opportunities within the
possible situations and not all guidelines will organisation for all staff members ?
be applicable to every type of disability. It is
Ë Consideration of disability issues in
also important to take into account that some
the bids for goods and services : Do
types of disabilities are less visible than
you ensure that the organisations from
others and require special attention on our
part.Disability mainstreaming : Where does which / to which you buy or sell goods and
your organisation fit in ? services respect and address diversity
and disability issues ?
People with disabilities and disability issues
can be integrated into YOUR organisation, Ë Consideration of disability issues in the
areas of work, policies and practices even provision of support : Do you require that
if it is not directly working in this field. The organisations take into account equality
key is to try to look at each of the different and / or disability issues when providing
elements of the organisation and the them with support ?
activities it carries out and / or supports from Ë Partnerships with organisations active
the disability standpoint, and from the outset
in the disability field : Are you involved in
whenever possible. Check if all elements
partnerships with organisations of people
recognise, respect and meet the needs of
with disabilities and / or representing them,
people with disabilities – whether employees,
or others active in this area, in order to gain
customers or users – and if they provide the
a better knowledge of the disability field ?
same opportunities to all citizens. This is
essential as often citizens, including those Ë Services for all : Do people with disabilities
with disabilities, face discrimination and benefit from the activities and services
social exclusion because of an environment of your organisation ? If not, why ? What
which is not suitably adapted to their needs measures could be taken to ensure they do ?
rather than because of their disability or
specific characteristic. The challenge is to Step 2 : Strategy
remember to be inclusive!
Following an analysis of the current situation
in your organisation regarding equality and
Step 1 : Evaluation
disability issues, you could consider the
To start the refection process and try to following steps :
understand where you are, look at areas
such as the following : Ë Define a strategy of action in this field.
This strategy could be reflected in a
Ë Staff composition : How many people simple statement of organisational
with disabilities work at your organisation ? commitment to promoting equal
At what levels are they employed ? What opportunities for all people, and in
are their main areas of responsibility ? particular people with disabilities – be
Ë Understanding of disability issues : they staff, users or customers – or a more
Is your organisation’s staff aware of the formal disability / equality plan, including
importance of disability issues ? Is there objectives and targets, a code of practice.
any training organised about this ? Ë Promote measures to enhance non-
Ë Flexible work options for people with discrimination and equal opportunities
disabilities and staff members that are for people with disabilities among staff
responsible for taking care of people and partners and involve the relevant
with disabilities : Do they exist ? How stakeholders in their definition and
many people take advantage of them ? implementation.

Ë Provision of equal opportunities : Ë Appoint a disability champion to help


Is there equal pay as well as fair and manage diversity and to provide other

10

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int210 10 10/09/07 13:04:10


members with relevant information It also includes a section on horizontal
such as articles, policy developments, issues that apply to all areas. Horizontal
guidebooks, and so on. issues analysed include the promotion of
access and accessibility for all as well as
Step 3 : Implementation the consultation and involvement of people
with disabilities and the organisations
Below you will find some more practical
representing them in all activities and at all
ideas to help you to take into consideration
stages.Some of the practical tips and ideas
and integrate people with disabilities and
proposed are easy to implement ; others may
disability-related issues in the following
require further efforts and more time. Should
areas :
it be necessary, do not hesitate to phase in
Ë Employment the changes and proceed step by step. We
are convinced that many of these guidelines
Ë Education and Training
could also benefit other groups that often
Ë Goods and Services face discrimination such as elderly people or
people with temporary impairments, e.g. a
Ë Health care person with a broken leg.
Ë Leisure activities

Ë Financial services and funding

Ë Housing

11

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int211 11 10/09/07 13:04:11


3.1. Employment

Participation in employment is crucial not only adequate education and training, workplaces
for earning an income, but more importantly not adapted to the needs of people with
because it enables active participation in disabilities, employer and colleagues’
society.For people with disabilities, this is a prejudices and a lack of support and
challenge as they face significant barriers guidance for employers, disabled employees
with regard to both job seeking and and other staff members.
job retention. According to the European
Community Household Panel, a person within Some practical ideas to overcome
the active age range ( 16-64 years ) has a these challenges
66 % probability of finding a job or developing
A growing number of organisations are
a business. For a person with a moderate
realising that there are several ethical,
disability this probability falls to 47 %, and for a
economic, legal and business reasons to
person with a severe disability the probability
address diversity and disability issues in their
is reduced to a mere 25 %. In addition,
activities and are choosing to adopt strategies
employment opportunities are even lower for in the area, in many cases incorporating them
certain groups of disabled people, for example into their global diversity strategies. Benefits
women. The equivalent statistics are 44 % for include an improved corporate image and
females with a moderate disability and 25 % reputation ; enhanced employee recruitment
for those with a severe disability.In addition and retention, through access to a wider pool
to these worrying trends, a high proportion of highly skilled and motivated workers that
of disabled workers also belong to the low- otherwise would not be attracted ; creation
paid jobs category, and disabled workers of environments that promote inclusion and
are discriminated when it comes to gaining respect ; and the promotion of a highly skilled,
promotion and accessing further training. innovative and diverse workforce.
The situation of those people that become Sometimes, the integration of disability
disabled during their career should also issues into the mainstream processes
be considered. Another target group that will be easy. In other cases, some further
we should take into consideration are the changes and reasonable accommodations
often forgotten family members that are will be needed. For the purpose of this
responsible for taking care of people publication, we understand by reasonable
with disabilities, in particular parents accommodation any change or adjustment
( mostly mothers ) of moderately and severely to a job, the work environment or the way
disabled children, who often have to leave things usually are done that would allow a
the labour market in order to care for their person with a special need / requirement to
children because existing care and support apply for a job, perform job functions, or
services inadequately meet their needs. enjoy equal access to benefits available to
Policies that take into account the specific other individuals in the workplace.
needs of these groups must be put in place.
Social Economy constitutes one of the
most active employment generators in
Challenges
Europe, combining quality employment
In many cases the unemployment or and inclusive employment that includes
inactivity of people with disabilities does the most vulnerable people, such as those
not relate to the impossibility of people with disabilities. Therefore, the provision
with disabilities to work but to other issues of employment for people with disabilities
related to their personal background or to the in Social Economy enterprises and
work environment. These include the lack of organisations is, of course, a major issue.

12

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int212 12 10/09/07 13:04:11


1. Employment

The following guidelines and tips are


• Provision of contracts of fixed duration
addressed to managers and staff members
for adults coming from sheltered
of organisations as well as persons interested
environments ;
in starting their own business. They will also
be useful for external stakeholders such as • Provision of services and
employment policy-makers and trade unions. entrepreneurial spirit awareness
Here are some actions that organisations raising for disabled adults looking for
can undertake to mainstream disability into employment in the regular workforce ;
their structures and activities. Similar actions and
could also be undertaken for ensuring equal • Analysis of employment possibilities
opportunities for other groups that often for people with disabilities within some
suffer discrimination. enterprises previously selected.
• Review organisational employment Contact person : Jean-Louis Garcia,
policies and practices to ensure that National Delegate for Social and Health
people with disabilities encounter no Action ;Mutualité Générale de l’Education
direct or indirect discrimination or barriers Nationale ( MGEN ) ( France )
in relation to recruitment, job retention E-mail : groux@mgen.fr
and career development. Website : www.mfp.fr
• If necessary, set up a concrete plan
and clear procedures regarding the
employment of people with disabilities, The National Council of Voluntary
including objectives, targets, monitoring Organisations ( NCVO ) in United
and evaluation. A similar exercise Kingdom promotes the respect of diversity
can be carried out for ensuring equal and equal opportunities in the voluntary
opportunities for other groups that often sector. They have developed a policy
suffer discrimination. statement on equal opportunities that
guides all its actions, and which ensures
The Mutualité Générale de l’Education that they apply objectives criteria to
Nationale ( MGEN ) ( France ) has put in assess potential suitability for jobs, that
place at its health centre in Sainte Feyre no applicant or employee receives less
a policy for professional recruitment favourable treatment on the ground of
of people with disabilities, which has race, colour, nationality, religion, ethnic or
been developed and implemented in national origin, age, gender, marital status,
consultation with relevant partners and sexual orientation or disability. NCVO also
stakeholders in the field.The policy aims provides, when necessary, special training
to create a sensitised environment for to enable workers to progress both within
people with disabilities, as well as to and without the organisation.
implement measures that allow them to NCVO has also been awarded the
grow and develop professionally within the Positive about Disabled People symbol,
organisation by developing and launching a recognition given to employers
a variety of professional projects. Services who have agreed to make certain
such as career placement, implementation positive commitments regarding the
of professional objectives, training and employment, retention, training, and
evaluation are made available to individuals career development of persons with
with disabilities. Four main activities are disabilities. These commitments are,
carried out within this framework, namely : among others, to interview all applicants
• Putting in place a rotating educational with a disability who meet the minimum
service for youth with intellectual criteria for a job vacancy and consider
disabilities, providing them with access them on their abilities ; to ensure that
to learning ; there is a mechanism in place to discuss

13

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int213 13 10/09/07 13:04:12


with employees with disabilities what can • Raising awareness and perceptions
be done to ensure that they can develop of employers in the agricultural sector
their abilities ; to make every effort when about workers with disabilities ; and
employees become disabled to make sure
• Supporting implementation of innovative
they stay in employment, etc.
strategies and structures to engage
They are currently working towards disabled individuals in the sector.
Investors in Diversity accreditation and
This is part of the global strategy of the MSA
hope to achieve this by March 2008.
to promote access and equal opportunities
Contact person : Barbara Waugh, Head of people with disabilities in the agricultural
of Human Resources ; National Council of sector. Actions undertaken to achieve
Voluntary Organisations ( NCVO ), United this goal include raising awareness about
Kingdom. disability issues, in particular intellectual
Email : Barbara.Waugh@ncvo-vol.org.uk disability, through information campaigns
Webpage : www.ncvo-vol.org.uk and strategies ; supporting independence
of individuals with disabilities ; promoting
the adaptation of ordinary services such
• Find out about the policies for facilitating as health and education to give access
employment for people with disabilities to people with disabilities ; promoting the
available in the region and the country implementation of local policy adapted to
in which your organisation is based the needs of individuals with disabilities and
by contacting the public authorities or taking into account the difference in nature
organisations active in the disability and needs of different disabilities.
field. In some cases, financial support
schemes or other types of support exist Contact : Franck Darty, Sanitarian & Social
to facilitate employment of people with Action Department ; Caisse Centrale de la
disabilities, e.g. in the United Kingdom, Mutualité Sociale Agricole ( CCMSA )
the government supports the hiring of Email : darty.franck@ccmsa.msa.fr
persons with disabilities by awarding Website : www.msa.fr
grants to cover the ICT-adapted
equipment required for these persons’ • Do not limit diversity and inclusion
work ( “Access to Work” scheme ). issues and measures to the human
resources section of your organisation
• Where possible, ensure that people and to staff members working in this
with disabilities have access to quality department. Make them applicable to all
employment and to high-level positions. areas and levels of your organisation and
• Help to break down job segregation by communicate these principles to staff,
opening up sectors that are normally customers, and other stakeholders.
closed to people with disabilities. • G
 iven that the lack of information and
awareness of diversity issues has proven to be
The Mutualité Sociale Agricole ( MSA ) the biggest challenge for workplace diversity,
( France ) develops innovative strategies to provide information and, where necessary,
meet the needs of people with disabilities equality and diversity training for senior
working in the agricultural sector by managers and staff to increase their insight
promoting employment and reinsertion into and awareness of disability issues and
of these individuals through the following help them to understand the requirements and
three objectives : benefits of a diverse workforce..
• Actively supporting and engaging in You can also provide managers with a series
employment and training of disabled of tools and resources such as performance
individuals under equal conditions in planning frameworks, diversity checklists,
the agricultural sector ; and toolkits to support them in policy
implementation.

14

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int214 14 10/09/07 13:04:12


3.1. Employment

academic training. This strategy allows


Access Ability ( Ireland ) is a unique one-
you to test a person’s skills and ability
stop-shop where employers can benefit
before committing yourself to employing
from a comprehensive package of services
him / her permanently and allows disabled
that enables them to take on a person with
people to have their first experience in the
a disability without any attendant concerns
labour market, an opportunity that it is
or administrative inconveniences by
often difficult to obtain.
providing a complete package of training
and consultancy services. They include : • Introduce measures that reconcile
• Disability-related training sessions for professional and family life in order
people involved in the recruitment process to support parents of children with
in particular as well as for staff in general ; disabilities. The possibility of taking
parental leave should be extended to
• Support, advice and expertise for
cover all disabled children. Furthermore,
employers regarding government grants
social partners should include in their plan
and schemes available, the creation of
of action the development of a common
accessible environments ( buildings,
EU framework agreement on carers.
workstations, external environments, etc. ),
recruitment of suitably qualified people with
The vast majority of the Fédérations du
disabilities ( highlighting any barriers that
Crédit Mutuel ( France ) have recently
may exist in the recruitment process ) ; and
initiated a reflection process on the
• A ‘Work Path’ service available on-site integration of employees with disabilities
and on a continuing basis to deal with in their organisations. Several initiatives
support issues and needs as they arise. have been undertaken in this respect
Access Ability was an EQUAL EU Project and organisations have even decided to
involving organisations from Ireland, the integrate a non-discrimination approach
Netherlands, Portugal and the United into their future strategic plans. This has
Kingdom, with the mission to maximise been translated into growing cooperation
employment opportunities for people and development of partnerships with key
with disabilities by addressing the stakeholders in the area of employment of
structural, attitudinal and policy issues people with disabilities in order to translate
which currently prevent employers from ideas into concrete actions.One such
recognising the abilities of disabled example is that of the Crédit Mutuel de
individuals. It has become a unique Bretagne, which in 2005 signed a second
Disability Management Consultancy. three-year agreement, in the framework
of a general policy of equal opportunities,
Contact person : Louise Milicevic,
to promote access to and retention of
Contact Person ; Access Ability ( Ireland )
employment for people with disabilities.
E-mail : louise.milicevic@accessability.ie
This agreement focuses its actions on
Website : www.accessability.ie
access to employment and measures
• Use positive images showing people to improve the skills and qualifications
with disabilities in active roles in your of people with disabilities. Initiatives
publications ( newsletters, brochures on developed by the organisation are aimed
good practice, reports / studies, websites ) at contributing to creating a favourable
and in interviews, documentaries, and welcoming environment, training and
editorials, opinion pieces, etc. Always reorganising people with disabilities, as
include news items on equal opportunities well as raising awareness about disability-
in your publications. issues among the workforce. In this
context, the recruitment and selection
• Offer work placements for people with
procedure is the same for all persons
disabilities who have just finished their
and reasonable accommodation is made
studies or have not had an opportunity
where necessary. People with disabilities
to gain work experience during their

15

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int215 15 10/09/07 13:04:13


the job and must not place people
are hired according to their professional
with a disability or long-term health
and personal abilities not their disability
condition at a disadvantage in the
status. In addition, there is no minimum selection process. For this purpose,
level of initial training required and skills make the distinction between essential
are enhanced before or after a specific and minor requirements that could
training and the type of impairments be reassigned to another person ;
are made compatible with the positions do not include blanket requirements
available. or exclusions related to health or
disability ; and request qualifications
Crédit Mutuel de Bretagne also gives
only where there is a genuine
employees who have a close relative
occupational requirement and there is
with disabilities ( child, partner, etc. ) the no other way to meet the criteria.
support that allows them to have the
needed flexibility to take care of such a • Make sure that the advertisement
relative and does not penalise his / her reaches people with disabilities. To
this end, you can consider sending it
career advancement.
to organisations helping people with
Contact person : Yves Sanquer ; disabilities to look for employment or
Responsible for Sustainable Development ; those representing and / or offering
Crédit Mutuel de Bretagne ( France ) services to them ; publishing it in
E-mail : yves.sanquer@arkea.com specialist disability publications
Website : www.cmb.fr or those often read by people with
disabilities ; sending it to specific e-
recruitment websites that link people
with disabilities with employers.
v Make recruitment advertising disability-
friendly in the following ways ( for further • Make sure that your job advertising
information, see also section 3.8. ) : scheme is designed to attract people
with disabilities. Consider including a
• When disseminating information, ensure welcoming and encouraging statement
that it is fully accessible : disseminate for people with disabilities in your
it by various means and in various advertisements. If you have specific
formats, including where possible policies regarding the recruitment and
easy-to-read format ; use legible and employment of people with disabilities,
understandable language ; if internally e.g. a specific interview scheme for
you pin details onto notice boards, pin people with disabilities, include a
them at a height where they can be reference to it.
seen by wheelchair users and people of
less than average height, etc. The Carnegie United Kingdom Trust
( United Kingdom ) has set up various
• When advertising the position by e-mail
mechanisms to put in place a specific
or via a website, make sure that the
diversity policy regarding staff and
website or e-mails used are accessible.
Research suggests that, although trustees as well as to ensure its respect
these methods of communication and implementation :
are acceptable for some people with • In the case of staff recruitment, the
disabilities, many are excluded because Trust states in all its job adverts that
of inaccessible and / or badly designed
it is an equal opportunities employer.
e-recruitment tools.
Adverts are communicated across a
• Be careful with wording : ensure that it series of networks that cater to different
is not discriminatory or inadvertently communities, increasing their visibility,
discouraging. particularly among diverse groups ;
• Consider the specifications and criteria • A number of its offices, including
that you are asking for. They must be
its future headquarters, have been
relevant and essential for performing

16

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int216 16 10/09/07 13:04:13


1. Employment

are not accessible and providing


made fully accessible to facilitate the
accessible car parking, and secondly
inclusion of people with disabilities ;
take steps to adapt the interview
• A Staff and Trustee Development itself to the disabled persons’ needs,
Group has been set up to deal e.g. by using an induction loop or
with the monitoring of equal sign language /  oral interpreters if
opportunities / diversity issues as well as an interview is to be carried out with
staff and trustee training and support ; and a person with hearing impairment,
• The Trust has adopted a diversity policy allowing extra time for the candidate
with regard to the Board of Trustees, to complete the test, accepting a
programme committees and advisory lower pass rate for a person whose
panels, by taking positive action impairment inhibits performance in
measures to encourage recruitment of such a test where this is unlikely to
traditionally excluded groups, such as harm performance in the actual job.
people with disabilities. • If that is not possible, as a last resort,
Contact person : Charlie McConnell, put in place a recruitment competition
Chief Executive ; Carnegie United Kingdom for people with disabilities, as a
Trust ( United Kingdom ) positive action measure. Organisations
E-mail : charlie@carnegieuk.org might consider undertaking such
Website : www.carnegieuktrust.org.uk a competition in partnership with
other organisations in the same
sector or geographical area so as to
• Application forms should be made share the additional recruitment and
available in alternative formats and related costs involved and to secure
reference should be made to this in a sufficient public profile for the
the advertisement. Required formats initiative to attract as broad a field of
will depend on the individual’s needs, candidates as possible.
personal preferences and access to
technology. Stipulating that applications • To know whether special arrangements
can only be accepted in handwriting are needed, in all application forms and
would discriminate against some people. letters of invitation to interviews, ask
Make sure applicants are given space candidates if they have any specific
to provide information about alternative needs that should be met to allow them
work-related experiences as some may to attend and take part in the interview.
not have the possibility to follow strictly It might be useful to inform applicants
traditional paths in terms of academic about the types of test that will be
and professional training.
carried out so that they can tell you
v With regard to the selection process, the whether adjustments are necessary.
following should be considered : For example, if applicants have to use
any ICT during the selection procedure,
• Mainstream selection processes
make sure you have the appropriate
should be adapted so that people with
equipment or software.
disabilities can participate in them
equally. In order to do so, ensure that • When evaluating a person with
the whole recruitment process can be disabilities, consider how reasonable
adapted to meet the needs of people adjustments could enable the person
with disabilities ( see also section 3.8. ). to meet the requirements of the job.
Also bear in mind that making a
• The main types of arrangements
decision based on a person’s sickness
will involve overcoming problems
record can discriminate unfairly.
associated with physical features of
the premises, e.g. by using the ground • Keep in mind that some frequently
floor for the interview if other floors used criteria may be discriminatory.

17

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int217 17 10/09/07 13:04:14


3.1. Employment

For example, asking for experience


their entry into the mainstream labour
in the use of a particular type of
market. The initiative will contribute to
computer software can exclude
enhancing opportunities for people with
some people. Many people with
intellectual disabilities, who face many
disabilities use adapted technology
barriers in the current employment market.
with specifically tailored software. It
may have a different name but could This project is undertaken in partnership
carry out the same function as more with the Ateliers du Parc de Claye,
common software packages. the College Coopératif de Paris, the
College Coopératif de Bretagne, the
• During the interview, provide as much
Groupement Français des Personnes
visual information as possible for those
Handicapées and the Institut de
persons with hearing impairments or
Coopération Sociale Internationale.
intellectual disabilities, keep eye-to-
eye contact, have appropriate lighting Contact person : Bernadette Grosyeux,
and have paper and pencil near in case General Director ; Centre de la Gabrielle
it is necessary to write things down. ( France )
E-mail : bernadette.grosyeux@mfp.fr
• Do not ask for qualifications that are
Website : www.mfp.fr
not relevant to or significant for a
particular job. In many cases, people
with disabilities do not have general
qualifications, if for example they v Do not make a decision based on
attended a special school where assumptions. People involved in the
the opportunity to attain a particular selection process should be aware ( and
qualification was not available. They ideally be trained ) about equality and
may, nevertheless, have equivalent disability-related issues and policies.
competence derived from work or life • In terms of job development and
experiences. retention ( training and career
development ), the following
People with intellectual disabilities often considerations should be kept in mind :
underestimate their own abilities and so
accreditation appears to be a good tool to • Some of the key elements for achieving
empower them and promote their access effective job development and
to regular jobs.In this sense, the Mutualité retention are the following : individual
Fonction Publique ( France ) through one of follow-up ; employer-employee
its social structures, Centre de la Gabrielle, dialogue ; and job description revision
near Paris, is undertaking actions aimed at or job reassignment.
the validation of life experience of people • Make reasonable modifications for
with learning disabilities. employees with disabilities in order to
Within the framework of the EU initiative meet their needs and to ensure that
EQUAL, the Centre de la Gabrielle, they are not excluded by physical,
coordinates the ECLAS project, which systemic, attitudinal or communication
seeks to ensure the validation of existing barriers ( e.g. ICT support, sign
skills, including both formal and non- language support, interpretation,
formal experience, so that workers and use of vibrating or light signals to
employees with intellectual disabilities can warn workers, telephone signals that
see their working experience recognised flash a light when it sounds, flashing
and valued. This helps them to obtain a doorbell signals, physical obstacles
diploma or a professional title - especially signals, noise reduction for workers
in the areas of gardening, commercial with hearing difficulties, adaptation of
washing and catering- or even to facilitate intercom systems ).There are easy ways
to do this. For example : improvements

18

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int218 18 10/09/07 13:04:14


1. Employment

in decoration and signage on premises


as well as through organised sport and
that could help people with sensory
cultural activities. UCECOM currently
impairments or learning difficulties.
comprises over 26,000 co-operative
These changes are beneficial to all
members, belonging to more than 560
staff, not only to those with disabilities.
co-operatives and offers employment to
• Make sure that workers with disabilities about 600 people with various disabilities,
can enjoy the same benefits that within about 30 co-operatives.
other workers have, such as health Another key initiative to promote the
programmes, recreational and social economic and social interest of disabled
activities, etc. persons is the partnership between
• Whenever necessary, adopt support UCECOM and the National League of
measures to accompany people with the Organisations with Personnel with
disabilities in their working life, e.g. Disabilities within the Handicraft Co-
personalised plans, appointing a staff operatives – LNOPHCM, whose main role
member to support the new employee, is to secure salaried jobs for people with
and offering flexible working hours. disabilities. In order to truly meet the needs
of this disadvantaged group, LNOPHCM
• Bear in mind that some people with has even amended its own statute to allow
disabilities may take longer to settle other kinds of organisations to become
into a job than other employees, even members, even if they do not belong to the
when reasonable efforts have been co-operative system.
made to accommodate them.
Contact person : Cristian Mateescu, Vice-
• Ask the worker how she / he prefers President ; National Union of Handicraft
to communicate and what measures and Production Co-operatives of Romania
could ease their work – some people ( UCECOM ), Romania
with hearing difficulties would prefer E-mail : ucecom@ucecom.ro
written communication, while others Website : www.ucecom.ro
would rather use visual signs.
• Encourage persons with disabilities • Facilitate the retention of existing
to be independent and confident, employees who acquire a disability
and develop measures that prevent during their working life.
resentment by other colleagues.
• Make sure that the same career The main institutional aim of Fundación
opportunities and possibilities of ONCE ( Spain ), as an expression of solidarity
having a stable job are available to both of the Organización Nacional de Ciegos
disabled and non-disabled persons. Españoles ( ONCE ) in the development
of active policies to train persons with
disabilities in Spain, is to support the
The handicraft co-operatives of principle of equal opportunities for people
Romania, mainly specialised in with disabilities. This commitment is fulfilled
manufacturing goods and providing through a framework for mainstreaming
services and represented at the national equal opportunities and non-discrimination
level by their Union UCECOM, play a within the organisation, developed
significant role in the social inclusion of within two action plans : a Training and
people with disabilities in the country. They Employment Plan and an Accessibility Plan.
do so through education and vocational
Through the former, Fundación ONCE
training, employment in co-operative
advocates for quality employment for
organisations specially established for this
groups that experience greater difficulties
purpose, or by protected working places
in accessing and retaining employment,
secured within the ordinary co-operatives,
also by focusing on double vulnerability of

19

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int219 19 10/09/07 13:04:14


3.1. Employment

the potential of people with disabilities to


disabled individuals. Through the latter, the
become entrepreneurs :
Foundation promotes an autonomous life for
people with disabilities and seeks to break • The provision of financial assistance
down physical, intellectual, communication and other aid to avoid the current
and digital barriers by creating globally difficulties in the transition from public
accessible products and services. administration financial support to self-
employment.
The Foundation makes sure that its
recruitment and selection processes are • The promotion of access to training
adopted so that people with disabilities and support in this field. Currently,
can participate on equal terms, for access is difficult due to, for example,
example by ensuring : the lack of advertising about available
services ; a lack of accessible
• Accessibility of the entire recruitment
transport / funding for transport to and
process ( physical environment,
from advice centres ; training provided
materials, etc ) ; and
in inaccessible venues or not tailored
• Adjustments in the interview process, to meet individual needs.
where necessary. Fundación ONCE’s
• The development of initiatives to
Human Resources Department also
promotion entrepreneurship such as
produces a series of handbooks,
mentoring and peer support networks
made available to employees, which
or incubation support services to
are aimed at raising awareness of
support start-up businesses.
selected employees and producing a
favourable environment conducive to • The promotion of positive role
team building.Specifically for gender, models of entrepreneurship among
Fundación ONCE has instituted a disadvantaged social groups.
mentoring programme for women,
which aims to enhance the managerial The Government of Flanders ( Belgium )
skills and abilities of female workers. funded a project entitled “Developing
Contact person : Silvia Mestres Mateo, entrepreneurship among women
European Programmes Unit ; Fundación with disabilities in the Baltic States”,
ONCE ( Spain ) which aimed to promote the economic
E-mail : smestres@fundaciononce.es empowerment of women with disabilities
Website : www.fundaciononce.es in the Baltic States ( Estonia, Latvia and
Lithuania ) through the development of
a small enterprise development strategy
v Considerations for self-employment and which specifically targeted this group.
business start-ups : This technical cooperation project
The tools which service and finance was coordinated by the International
providers rely on to assess business start- Labour Organisation ( ILO ) Skills and
ups and their needs do not reflect the Employability Department in partnership
present diversity of potential entrepreneurs with various organisations in the targeted
because they are based on traditional countries : in Estonia with the Estonian
profiles and outdated criteria. Union of Disabled Women, in Latvia with
the Latvian Association of Disabled
However, according to several recent studies, Women and in Lithuania with the
the number of people with disabilities in Lithuanian Disability Information and
self-employment is higher than that of the Consultation Bureau.
general public. In addition, self-employment
is a viable option for many people with The preliminary phase of the project
disabilities who require more flexible involved the commissioning of a situation
working arrangements. Below are some analysis of women with disabilities in small
measures that could be taken to help unlock enterprises or those wishing to enter small

20

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int220 20 10/09/07 13:04:15


1. Employment

enterprises in the selected countries. that need to be adapted in order to


Women with disabilities have been trained accommodate persons with disabilities
as interviewers in each country. In addition and disability issues :
to the situation analysis, case studies of
a. Loans : the maximum amount of the
successful women entrepreneurs with
loans ranges between 30,000 and
disabilities will be compiled.
60,000 euros, depending on the
Following the accession of the purpose, at an interest rate of 1.8 %
participating countries to the European with the first year interest-free in all
Union, it was not possible to arrange cases.
for donor funding of the implementation
b. Subsidies : These subsidies are
phase of this project.
granted alongside loans, up to
Contact person : Barbara Murray, 50 % of the loan amount, for those
Senior Specialist on Disability ; Skills initiatives creating a job besides that
and Employability Department of the of the entrepreneur.
International Labour Organisation ( ILO )
Contact person : Bárbara Martín, Director
Email : disability@ilo.org
European Affaire Office ; Organización
Website : www.ilo.org
Nacional de Ciegos Españoles ( ONCE )
( Spain )
Email : otae@once.es
The Organización Nacional de Ciegos Webpage : www.once.es
Españoles ( ONCE ) supports self-
employment initiatives as an alternative
v Work in partnership with civil society
that allows entrepreneurs to start a project
organisations to develop innovative ways
in the sector for which they are best
to promote the integration of people with
prepared, according to their interests,
disabilities into mainstream employment.
aptitudes, and personal abilities.
Project analysis is carried out jointly by
The Association of the Councils of
professionals of the different management
Treviso Province, the Treviso Local NHS
areas of ONCE and its Foundation
Units, the Local Labour Unions, the
( Fundación ONCE ), which facilitates
Social Co-operatives Consortium, the
a greater level of support ( financial,
Regional Business Support Structure,
commercial, advisory, etc. ).
the UNICREDIT Bank and the Provincial
The support to self-employment Business Association are the main
initiatives is given through the following actors in social-economic agreements for
mechanisms : work integration of people with disabilities.
1. Orientation and information on different In Italy, the law obliges all companies
aspects of setting up companies ; with more than 15 employees to provide
jobs to people with disabilities. In order
2. Training in development of self-
to facilitate its application, the law allows
employment initiatives, with the
private companies to sign agreements with
organisation of different courses and
social enterprises to meet this obligation.
follow-up support ;
These agreements provide for an
3. Support for marketing of services / 
exchange between work contracts and
products ; and
work integration. Private companies
4. Loans and subsidies to professionals, outsource the task of preparing people
aimed at making possible low-interest with disabilities for work to social
financial support, both for start-up enterprises that employ them. These
businesses and for those businesses disabled workers then move to those

21

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int221 21 10/09/07 13:04:15


3.1. Employment

private companies and in exchange In addition, partnerships are being


receive adequate work contracts. At the established with open-market companies
end of the work integration period, the to second MLV’s workers to these
people with disabilities are permanently companies. This gives workers an
integrated into the companies. opportunity to work in a mainstream open-
Considerable experience has been built up market workplace with the continuous
at local level through agreements involving support of MLV.
private companies, social enterprises,
Contact person : Daniel Masià, Director ;
public administrations, trade unions, and
Modular Logística Valenciana ( MLV )
umbrella organisations of the disabled.
( Spain )
Contact person : Flaviano Zandonai, E-mail : dmasia1@mlvalenciana.com
Responsible for the CGM Research
Centre ; Gruppo Cooperativo Cgm ( Italy )
E-mail : flaviano.zandonai@consorziocgm.it Labour enclaves are a new legal way,
Website : www.cgm.coop developed in a number of countries,
including Spain, to facilitate access
for people with disabilities to ordinary
Modular Logística Valenciana S.L. employment. In addition, it is a mechanism
( MLV ) ( Spain ) is a company established ensuring that a nexus is created between
as a public-private partnership between ordinary companies and special
Grupo Fundosa, the business branch of employment centres, with mutually
Fundación ONCE, Ford España and the beneficial results.The labour enclaves
Generalitat Valenciana, the government work in the form of a subcontract drawn
of the region of Valencia. MLV aims to up between a company in the ordinary
provide quality services to companies as labour market and a special employment
well as to create stable employment for centre through which a disabled person is
people with disabilities and, in particular, to temporarily employed by the company to
facilitate their transition to the open labour carry out work or services related directly
market. The use of private and public funds, to its main activity. The only difference
including EU funds, has been crucial to the with the rest of the employees is that the
success of the company and has shown disabled workers depend contractually on
that commercial and social objectives can the special employment centre.
be combined while making a profit. Thanks to this scheme, disabled workers
For this purpose, mechanisms inside can integrate into the normal working
and outside the company have been environment and acquire the requisite
developed. Each stage of the production skills. This is a significant improvement
process is adapted to accommodate for target groups who are especially
people with disabilities. The company vulnerable to unemployment such as
employs people with all types of people with mental illness, people with
disabilities who work at all levels of the cerebral palsy, people with intellectual
company. The company also tries to disability and disabled women.
overcome stereotypes regarding the
gender dimension of jobs. In addition,
employees are provided ongoing in-house
training to perform various tasks in order
to become as versatile as possible. This is
an attempt to show that disabled people
are able to do any type of job when they
have the necessary support and are in the
right environment.

22

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int222 22 10/09/07 13:04:16


1. Employment

develop their abilities and increase


Supported employment, a formula that
their overall self-confidence.
shares some elements with mentoring. This
formula enables people with disabilities • Employers can to get to know
to access and maintain employment in persons with disabilities and observe
the mainstream labour market through a good practices and techniques that
number of supportive measures. These compensate for possible shortcomings
supportive measures include training and caused by the disabilities.
guidance at the job site which is provided
• Staff can overcome prejudice and
by a labour trainer according to the
reservations towards people with
worker’s needs. This formula is mostly used
disabilities and develop a more
by persons with intellectual disabilities.
positive attitude towards them.
Labour insertion through supported
employment is a process with the
following stages : The Equal Employment Opportunities
Project, financially supported by the EU
• Evaluation, guidance and selection Leonardo da Vinci Programme and run by
aimed at determining the employability the Marie Curie Association ( Bulgaria ) in
levels of candidates as well as their cooperation with other stakeholders from
need for support ; Bulgaria, Greece, and the United Kingdom,
• Training for employment ; is an example of a mentoring scheme.

• Specific training at the job site provided The project focuses on students and
by a trainer who accompanies the graduates with physical, intellectual and
worker and trains him / her on the sensory disabilities, organisations of
specific tasks of the position ; this people with disabilities, their employers,
support is progressively reduced as well as employers’ organisations,
according to the worker’s needs ; and intermediaries and policymakers. It is
aimed at improving the professional skills
• Long-term follow-up ; the trainer
and abilities of final-year disabled students
periodically monitors the worker’s
as well as providing them with the
accomplishments.
opportunity to gain work experience. As
part of the project, a six-month mentoring
programme is being developed to bring
v Get involved in schemes that help people together these students and employers
with disabilities to get integrated into the interested in working with them.
ordinary work environment. An example
of these mechanisms are the mentoring As a follow-up to this project and given
schemes. Mentoring is the process by the importance of having the mentoring
which a more experienced person ( a process certified, another EU Leonardo
mentor ) provides guidance in the form of Da Vinci project has been launched.
training and support to a less experienced Entitled “Validation of Mentoring”, the
person ( a mentee ). Mentoring has proven main purpose is to create procedures
to be a successful mechanism for achieving and frameworks for validating mentoring
better integration of people with disabilities programmes.
in many fields, and particularly in the labour Contact person : Petya Grudeva, Public
market. Mentoring schemes have a wide Relations ; Marie Curie Association
range of benefits for all parties : ( Bulgaria )
• Mentees with disabilities can obtain E-mail : petia@marie-curie-bg.org
practical skills and knowledge in a Website : www.mentoring-validation.org ;
real working atmosphere. They can www.validation-mentoring.org ; .
www.marie-curie-bg.org / mentoring

23

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int223 23 10/09/07 13:04:16


3.1. Employment

The VOCA2 Project is coordinated


by Grenaa Handelsskole ( Denmark )
and has partners from seven countries
( Czech Republic, Denmark, Greece, Italy,
Lithuania, Portugal, and Spain ). It aims
to facilitate a structured assessment of
potential employees, the tasks they will
be required to do, and their intended
workplace, so that any difficulties can
be foreseen and overcome, in order to
help them secure employment. This is
done by a mentor who will support both
the mentee – the person with disabilities
– and the employer in order to assess the
needs and find solutions to anticipated
problems. VOCA2 lies both in the mentor
training approach and in the competence
assessment tools, which the mentors are
trained to apply to the job placements of
their mentees.
The initiative is based on existing
mentoring courses to develop a specific
“template course” tailored to this
framework. The course will be adapted
to cater for the different legal and cultural
backgrounds of each of the seven partner
countries and then implemented. VOCA2
will then work to make the resultant mentor
training course officially recognised by the
authorities in these countries.
The project builds on the VOCA Europe
project, which developed flexible
vocational training materials to allow
people with disabilities to acquire
vocational qualifications in a manner
and at a pace that suits them and their
circumstances.
Contact person : Anne Fox, Project
Coordinator ; Grenaa Handelsskole
( Denmark )
E-mail : af@cv2.dk
Website : www.voca.dk

24

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int224 24 10/09/07 13:04:16


3.2. Education and training

3.2. Education and training

Education is widely recognised as a means to • Teaching methods and materialsnot


develop human capital, to improve economic adapted to the needs of students with
performance and to enhance people’s special needs.
capabilities and choices. Equipping people
• Lack of support tools.
with the necessary skills and qualifications is
a key prerequisite for full inclusion in society. • Lack of awareness, knowledge and
Thus the importance of ensuring education understanding among teachers and
for all people, including people with students regarding disability issues and
disabilities. This goes from basic education how to deal with disabled students.
to life-long learning opportunities and for
all ages. Some practical ideas to overcome
these challenges
On the other hand, it is proven that a system
where priority is given to inclusive education In this context, it is of key importance to
at all ages, in which both disabled and promote and implement the necessary
non-disabled people can benefit from the measures to enable all students, including
same educational environment, is the most those with special educational needs, to
effective means of combating discriminatory benefit from equal access to and enjoyment
attitudes, creating welcoming communities of education, either general or specifically
and building an inclusive society. tailored, within inclusive settings. Although
priority should be given to inclusion in the
However, despite increased efforts in recent
mainstream education system, special
years, people with disabilities do not have equal
education schemes should be used when
access to education and training opportunities.
skills cannot be acquired through the
Significant numbers of disabled children mainstream system or when it is the decision
and youth are still largely excluded from of the person with disabilities, supported if
educational opportunities at the primary and necessary by his / her family.
secondary school levels or lag behind their
It has been proven that most disabled
non-disabled peers in high school completion
persons could have equal access to
and higher education. Consequently, they find
education, be it general or specialised, if they
it more difficult to have access to employment
are provided with the necessary support.
opportunities later in life, and therefore also to
become financially and socially independent, The following guidelines are addressed to any
which in turn prevents them from participating person or public / private organisation involved
fully in society. in the promotion, support or development
of training opportunities for people with
Disabled adults do not have the same
disabilities or those directly involved in their
access to lifelong learning opportunities
implementation ( such as teaching staff ). They
( programmes ranging from short courses to
will also be of interest for stakeholders in
advanced or further education to continued
charge of making decisions in this field as well
training ), which are key to continued
as for students interested in knowing more
enhancement of their skills and abilities and
about how to better deal with their disabled
therefore their career prospects.
colleagues. The following list is an outline of
suggestions for change :
Challenges
v In your activities, promote the rights of
Key challenges include :
all persons with disabilities to education,
• Accessibility of the environmentwhere irrespective of the nature of their
the education / training takes place. impairment.

25

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int225 25 10/09/07 13:04:17


ECOLE+ Platform for a school without • To identify successful models and
exclusions ( Belgium ) supports school challenges in the integration process
initiatives in Belgium aimed at creating and assess whether successful models
a teaching environment that is more can be replicated and how.
accessible to socially disadvantaged
As part of its activities, the project will
groups. It is a joint initiative of four Belgian
develop and test a methodology to
organisations : Cera, Porticus, the
evaluate the efficiency and quality of
Fondation Reine Paola and the Institut
education services provided to children
Supérieur du Travail ( HIVA ).The initiative
with special educational needs ; tools for
carries out four main areas of activity as
monitoring and supervision of integrated
follows :
education ; as well as practical and
• Organising specialised / targeted efficient tools to evaluate the children’s
training sessions and meetings ; performance. Basic outputs will include :
• Developing and putting into practice a • The tool “Chart for primary assessment
strategic and scientific vision of equal of general development of child /pupil
opportunities in teaching ; with special educational needs”, which
aims to help experts to document
• Providing schools with information
the process of child assessment and
needed to put this approach into practice,
thus collect the needed information
including didactic material, examples of
for concrete actions to be undertaken.
good practice as well as information on
Based on this assessment, decisions
funding opportunities ; and
will be made on what is the most
• Offering advice and support as needed. appropriate educational option that
To contribute to the creation of a real corresponds to a given child’s capacity
platform of knowledge and expertise, the and wishes as well as to the opinion of
Ecole+ website includes relevant information his /  her family. This tool is addressed
and resources for interested parties. to the teams engaging in complex
pedagogical assessment at regional
Contact person : Lies Daenen, Project educational inspectorates of the
Coordinator ; Cera ( Belgium ) Ministry of Education and Science.
E-mail : lies.daenen@cera.be
Website : www.school-ecole-plus.be • The instrument “Assessment of social
development and learning abilities”,
which aims to support the effective
work of the multidisciplinary teams
working with children with special
The Open Society Institute Sofia is
educational needs at mainstream
undertaking a project to promote the
schools. The instrument’s basic goal is
integration of children with intellectual
to provide a realistic evaluation of the
disabilities into the mainstream education
skills, strong points and developmental
system. To achieve this goal, the project
priorities of a child / pupil as well as to
has three key objectives :
serve as a methodological guide for
• To assess the quality and effectiveness systematic planning of the teaching
of the integrated education of children programme in accordance with the
and youths with intellectual difficulties child’s individual pace, needs and
in the general education schools ; capacity. Based on the information
• To propose measures for improving collected through this instrument,
the integration process, focusing on individual educational programmes
the content and implementation of are designed for children with special
individual teaching plans ; and educational needs.

26

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int226 26 10/09/07 13:04:17


3.2. Education and training

with visual impairments, provide as


The instruments were developed by experts
many materials as possible in CD or
of BAPID ( Bulgarian Association of
Braillespeak so that they can read
People with Intellectual Disabilities )
them on their computers ; provide
on the basis of a thorough survey of
easy-to-read materials for people with
needs carried out with the help of all 54
intellectual disabilities.
local BAPID members in the relevant
municipalities. Representatives of all • Lessons / courses : provide support,
involved parties took part in the process such as interpretation facilities and
– parents, children, multidisciplinary teams induction loop systems ; permit entry
from schools, regional inspectorates, of volunteers and guide dogs ; allow
and others.The Ministry of Education and students to record lessons and to
Science is testing and validating both use technical aids ; for the benefit
instruments in three municipalities in of people with visual impairments,
Bulgaria. This has resulted in a proposal whatever you write on the board,
being made to the Minister of Education and also read it orally and when showing
Science to incorporate the tools into relevant pictures, explain what they show, etc.
Bulgarian educational legislation and Exams / tests : where appropriate,
more specifically into Regulation No. 6 for offer people with disabilities and / or
teaching children with special educational special needs the possibility of having
needs and / or chronic diseases. the exam in different formats and give
them the opportunity to be tested in
Contact Persons : Boyan Zahariev,
different ways, e.g. orally, in writing,
Program Director Governance and Public
by computer. Whenever necessary,
Policies Programme ; Open Society
provide them with more time to
Institute Sofia
complete the exam. These exemptions
Email : bzahariev@osf.bg
should not appear on their certificate.
Web page : www.osf.bg
Desislava Sirakova, Coordinator
The Talento Project aims to promote
Governance and Public Policies Program ;
the development of public policies that
Open Society Institute Sofia
provide equal opportunities in access
Email : dsirakova@osf.bg
to education and in particular paths to
Web page : www.osf.bg
employment for people with intellectual
disabilities. Ths project is supported
v When you organise mainstream education, by AFEM ( the Association for the
training and lifelong learning schemes, Employment of People with Intellectual
ensure that, where possible from the Disabilities ), in cooperation with FEAPS
outset, they are designed in a way that ( Spanish Confederation of Organisations
everybody ( disabled and non-disabled ) of People with Intellectual Disabilities ),
can equally participate in and benefit from CEPES ( Spanish Confederation of Social
them ( see section 3.8. ). For example : Economy Enterprises ) and Fundación
Aspanias, and with the sponsorship of
• Physical settings or where activities
Fundación Iberdrola.
take place : make sure that the venues
are fully accessible. The Project, which takes place in 2006-
2007, is organised in 3 phases :
• Information and educational material :
ensure that all relevant information • Phase 1 : Qualitative and quantitative
and materials are accessible by review of the education and training
taking into account the needs context for disabled youth between
of people with different types of the ages of 16 and 23 in 11 Spanish
disabilities. For example : provide regions. A reference to other European
materials beforehand ; for people

27

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int227 27 10/09/07 13:04:18


countries ( France, Germany, and • The Local Scholarship Funds project,
Sweden ) is also made. Result : Green which offers technical and financial
Paper ; assistance to organisations that
undertake to create local scholarship
• Phase 2 : Analysis of the reasons for the
programmes for children and youth ; and
situation. Result : White Paper ;
• The Rainbow Academy project, which
• Phase 3 : Launching, with the support
offers grants for organisations that
of experts, of a debate and reflection at
run integration, educational and art
the political level on an effective model
therapy, programmes to prevent social
for the education of the targeted group,
exclusion of handicapped children.
which can then be implemented as a
pilot phase. Contact person : Ewa Kulik-Bielinska,
Information, and Development Director ;
Contact person : Nuria García Gabaldón,
Stefan Batory Foundation ( Poland )
Director, or Miguel Urra Canales, Project
E-mail : ekulik@batory.org.pl
Officer ; Asociación FEAPS para el Empleo
Website : www.batory.org.
de las Personas con Discapacidad
pl / english / equal / index.htm
Intelectual ( AFEM ) ( Spain )
E-mail : afem@ceeafem.org
Website : www.ceeafem.org / .
v Take the necessary measures to raise
www.ceeafem.org / proyectotalento
awareness among non-disabled peers
about disability issues. This will help to
v Special education should only be organised create an inclusive environment where
when mainstream education is not suitable disabled and non-disabled people are
for people with disabilities to acquire the fully integrated.
necessary skills, or when people with v Encourage and facilitate the participation
disabilities or their families decide to opt for of parents, communities, and
it. The possibility to opt for special education organisations of people with disabilities
is important for some types of disability, i.e. in the planning and decision-making
deaf-blind children, as they could not follow processes concerning the provision of
mainstream education. However, this special special educational needs.
education should aim to compensate for,
v Take the necessary measures to make
reduce, or remedy their disability and should
sure that disabled students can also
always offer them the possibility to move into
participate in the school or institution
mainstream education.
extracurricular activities and social life.
v Consult user organisations active in the
The Stefan Batory Foundation’s
disability field in all matters relating to the
( Poland ) Equal Opportunities Programme
organisation and delivery of provisions.
supports organisations that work to
provide equal access to education for v In the case of disabled people that need
school children and youth from small assistance from their families /  social
towns and low-income families as well environment to take decisions, consult,
as those that strive to counteract the involve and provide support and guidance
social exclusion of disabled children from to parents, and others responsible for both
poor communities and neglected areas disabled and non-disabled children, so
and, through innovative forms of therapy, that they are informed about the process
enhance their life opportunities. of inclusion, its rationale and the potential
In the framework of this Programme, the benefits that will accrue to their child.
Foundation runs two projects : v Take full advantage of technological
developments in your training

28

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int228 28 10/09/07 13:04:18


3.2. Education and training

programmes. They have the potential


social and cultural life, it also includes
for both improving and obstacling the
a wealth of tools that allow people with
opportunities of people with disabilities
disabilities to have access to, and take
for participating in education and training.
advantage of, opportunities offered by the
Therefore, special attention should be
knowledge society regarding employment
given to :
and employability, through education.
• Training in new Information and Fostering employment and employability
Communication Technologies ( ICT ). of people with disabilities by using all
the opportunities that the knowledge
• Use of these technologies for
society offers is one of the main objectives
education and training.
of Discapnet. The website’s section
• Ensuring that ICT and the places on training includes information about
where they are located are designed to courses, scholarships, teletraining
enable people with all sorts of special and other resources to improve the
needs to use them. Attention must be employability of people with disabilities.
paid to the fact that people with certain
Contact person : Maria Tussy, Head of the
disabilities may need special training
European Programmes Unit ; Fundación
software or conversion software that
ONCE ( Spain )
adapts programmes to meet their
E-mail : mtussy@fundaciononce.es
specific needs. They may also need
Website : www.discapnet.es
special training courses in the use of
equipment and software.

v Assist teaching staff to gain the relevant


Created in 2000, the disability-related qualifications, insight and understanding
portal Discapnet aims to improve the on disability issues. Inclusion largely
social and employment integration of depends on teachers’ attitudes and
people with disabilities. The initiative is motivation and on the resources available
co-funded by Fundación ONCE and to them. However, teachers generally lack
the European Regional Development training or any type of preparation for
Fund ( ERDF ) and managed by the social working in an inclusive environment and
enterprise Technosite, a technology lack the necessary resources. As such,
company which forms part of the business in many cases, they do not know how to
branch of Fundación ONCE ( Grupo cope with the presence of people with
Fundosa ). The project has been recently special needs at school.
selected as an example of good practice v Disability equality training should be
in the framework of the Operational integrated into college training and the
Programme for the Fight against continued development of professionals
Discrimination. active in teaching environments. In
The portal, free and accessible to addition, teachers working with students
everybody, is an essential tool for with special needs should acquire
complementing training and employment specific competences in relevant areas.
actions undertaken within the framework This preparation could be completed
of the Operational Programme for in cooperation with disabled learners
the Fight Against Discrimination that themselves.
Fundación ONCE manages. As part of v The role of universities in general and
the wide range of services offered to university foundations in particular,
improve the quality of life of people with with their potential to mainstream
disabilities, in terms of their personal disability-linked issues into their different
autonomy and participation in economic, activities, deserves a special mention.
University foundations contribute to the

29

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int229 29 10/09/07 13:04:19


development of the general goals of the
The Fundación General de la
university by building bridges between the
Universidad Autónoma de Madrid
university and society and ensuring that
( FGUAM ) ( Spain ), through the
the university contributes to the creation
development of its initiatives and its
of a better society through teaching,
continuous cooperation with relevant
research, and innovation programmes.
organisations, tries to integrate
Universities can play an important role by : people with disabilities and disability-
related issues in all the activities of the
• Facilitating and promoting the inclusion
Universidad Autónoma ( UAM ) and thus
of students, teachers and employees
extend UAM’s impact to society as a
with disabilities.
whole. Some of its initiatives include :
• Promoting awareness-raising activities • The drafting of practical reference
for students and staff. material on how to support the
• Including disability-related issues in integration of people with disabilities
education and training programmes into the university environment as well
( theoretical and practical ) of all as in other areas.
relevant professionals that may be • Project “Easy-to-read books”, carried
dealing with people with disabilities in out in cooperation with FEAPS ( Spanish
the future. Confederation of Organisations for
People with Intellectual Disabilities ),
• Increasing research, development which is aimed at developing a
and innovation ( R+D+I ) focused on methodology that allows the adaptation
disability-related issues, as well as of books into easy-to-read format, as
providing new knowledge and carrying well as developing support measures
out studies related to this field. that promote reading access for people
• Promoting Long Life Learning ( LLL ) with intellectual disabilities.
of people with disabilities and The training and volunteering project
professionals who care for them. “Apúntate”, which develops what is
known as ”professional volunteering”, is
• Promoting innovation and collaboration
a key part of a new model of participation
with organisations of people with
of the university in the social field
disabilities, launching collaborative
based on research, training and quality
programmes to drive their proficiency
cooperation, with an ethical commitment
and promoting the innovation of
to disadvantaged groups.
models, products, and services.
The aim of this programme is to improve the
quality of life of people with Autistic Spectrum
Disorders ( ASD ) and their families providing
individual support in their leisure time and
day living activities. Students from the areas
of psychology, pedagogy, psychopedagogy
or teaching ( special education ) are trained to
supply a quality support. The training process
starts with a set of classes and continues
during the entire volunteer’s activity trough
continuous management, workshops and the
support of experts.
Contact person : Bernardo Díaz Salinas, .
Director ; Fundación General de la Universidad
Autónoma de Madrid ( FGUAM ) ( Spain )
E-mail : bdiaz.fguam@uam.es
Website : www.fg.uam.es

30

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int230 30 10/09/07 13:04:19


3.3. Goods and services

The number of users of goods and • Physical accessibility : Lack of


services both with both disabilities accessibility regarding the premises
– lifelong and temporary – or with where goods and services are
impairments, such as the elderly, is provided and the routes leading to
growing rapidly. In many cases, these users them.
have trouble in getting access to and fully • Information : Lack of accessible and
enjoying the goods and services available user-friendly information on goods and
in our society because they are conceived, services.
produced, or provided in a way that is
• Mechanisms and procedures for the
adapted only to the requirements of the so-
provision of goods and services : often
called “standard person” and not adapted to
too rigid and unaccommodating to
society as a whole. people with special needs.
Against this background, and in addition to • Communication : personnel speaking
it being a human rights issue, it is of extreme too quickly or incomprehensibly.
importance for society as a whole to ensure
more inclusive and user-friendly goods and v Attitudes : The attitudes of persons
involved in the design, production and
services that can be used by all people,
provision of goods and services as well as
including people with and without disabilities.
society as a whole lead to the creation of
It is also in the interest of service suppliers unnecessary barriers due to patronising
– anyone providing a service to the public attitudes and assumptions about people’s
in general or to a section of the public abilities and inabilities and the use of
– to take into consideration the needs and inappropriate and disrespectful language,
requirements of people with disabilities among other reasons.
and / or with impairments. They represent an
increasingly significant share of the market Some practical ideas to overcome
in terms of both number -making up more these challenges
than 10 % of the population- and consumer In order to create an inclusive society
influence. Consequently, by ensuring that and ensure that all people can enjoy
these customers can have access and the goods and services offered, the
can use and enjoy any goods and services needs and requirements of people with
offered by society, service suppliers will disabilities and / or with impairments must
be opening up a new market share and be accommodated at all stages of design,
contributing to enhancing their reputation. production and delivery to ensure that they
are not unintentionally discriminated against.
Challenges A number of studies and experiences
The main challenges encountered by show that many of these barriers can be
people with disabilities arise from a lack overcome through simple, practical, and
of knowledge and understanding about reasonable measures. A high percentage
disability issues and the needs of people of the arrangements involve low or no
cost at all. In many cases, solutions can
with disabilities and are in many cases
be included in regular routines. In others,
unintentional. They include :
reasonable accommodation and positive
v A lack of accessibility in the way in action to promote equal opportunities for
which goods and services are designed, the special needs of disabled customers can
produced and provided, for example : help organisations deal with this challenge.

31

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int231 31 10/09/07 13:04:19


The key is not to wait until a person with
disabilities cannot use your service, but After ten years of existence, the European
rather to anticipate the need yourself ! Platform on Design-for-All ( EIDD ) has
The following guidelines and tips are developed external relations and an internal
addressed to stakeholders involved in the structure consisting of national member
design, production and / or provision of organisations and corporate members
established in sixteen European countries.
goods and services, be it at the level of
In order to achieve its mission, the Institute
decision-making or implementation. They will
has developed a strategy whose purpose
also be of interest for stakeholders involve in
is to nurture, develop and propagate the
the development and approval of policies in
theory and practice of Design for All,
this area.
which is defined in the EIDD Stockholm
Here are some practical tips to overcome the Declaration 2004 as “design for human
main barriers : diversity, social inclusion and equality”.
v Apply the Design-for-All methodology to To this end, EIDD has established a series
the design, production and delivery of of annual conferences around a cycle
your goods and services as follows ( see of macrothemes that will be repeated
also section 3.8. ) : on a four-yearly basis. Each of these
• Designing products, services and macrothemes encapsulates an area of
applications that are readily usable by basic human interaction in modern society
most of the potential users without any where the intervention of Design-for-All
modification. can make the difference between sluggish
inertia and vibrant development. The
• Making products, services and macrothemes have been identified as
applications easily adaptable to culture, work, tourism and design.
different users, e.g. by adapting their
user interfaces. Design-for-All is a methodology dealing
with the process of design rather than the
• Having standardised interfaces that product that results from design. Design-
are compatible with special products, for-All seeks to ensure that the issue of
e.g. special interaction devices for social inclusion of people with disabilities
people with disabilities. is taken into account at all levels of
Here are some practical tips to overcome the decision-making within an organised
main barriers : social structure such as the family, a social
organisation, a business enterprise or a
v Apply the Design-for-All methodology to government department. The elements
the design, production and delivery of of the process of decision-making are
your goods and services as follows ( see defined in this approach as “awareness”,
also section 3.8. ) : “audit”, “consultation” and “impact
• Designing products, services and assessment”. Design-for-All aims to enable
applications that are readily usable by all people to have equal opportunities to
most of the potential users without any participate in every aspect of society. This
modification. calls for the built environment, everyday
objects, services, culture and information
• Making products, services and
to be made accessible, convenient for
applications easily adaptable to everyone in society to use and responsive
different users, e.g. by adapting their to evolving human diversity. Design-for-All
user interfaces. enables a person to achieve an effect by
• Having standardised interfaces that employing a tool that interfaces with the
are compatible with special products, sensory / physical / intellectual modality
e.g. special interaction devices for preferred. This enabling interface calls for
people with disabilities.

32

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int232 32 10/09/07 13:04:20


3.3. Goods and Services

schemes.and.services.accessible,.focusing.
an.enabling.environment,.enabling.society.
fi.rst.on.the.needs.of.deaf.people.using.
and.enabling.processes.
sign.language,.and.then.the.entire.group.of.
Contact person.:.Cearbhall.E..O’Meadhra.;. people.with.hearing.impairments..To.better.
Representative.of.EIDD.–.Design-for-All. understand.the.needs.of.this.group.and.in.
Europe.at.the.European.Disablity.Forum order.to.make.the.necessary.adaptations,.
Email.:.president@idd.ie a.working.group.composed.of.people.with.
Webpage :.www.design-for-all.org hearing.impairments.and.staff.members.
of.MACIF.was.created..Based.on.the.
recommendations.of.the.working.group,.the.
v. .Develop.strategies.to.help.staff.of.the. following.measures.were.introduced.:
organisation.tackle.the.challenge.of. •. A
. .website.adapted.for.people.
dealing.with.people.with.special.needs.. with.hearing.impairments.(.www..
These.could.include.: macifsourds.com.),.which.is.translated.
. •. T
. raining.and.support.for.staff.to.build. into.sign.language.and.accessible.
awareness.and.skills.needed.to.deal. from.the.organisation’s.main.website..
with.this.group.of.customers.in.a. It.includes.information.on.the.services.
confi.dent,.respectful.and.courteous. offered.by.MACIF.as.well.as.other.
manner,.i.e..in.a.way.that.they.are. interesting.facts.for.deaf.people.;
treated.as.equal.citizens.with.the.same. •. A
. n.identity.image.requested.and.
rights.and.obligations.as.everyone.. designed.by.deaf.people.with.a.special.
Training.can.be.provided.by.external. symbol.;
organisations.or.internally.and.can.
consist.of.stimulating.informal.debate.
on.the.issue.and.how.to.address.it.
. •. R
. aising.awareness.about.the.
organisation’s.commitment.to.
persons.with.disabilities.and.about. •. S
. implifi.cation.of.tools.and.mechanisms.
the.disability-friendly.features.of. used.for.daily.services,.e.g..the.
the.premises.and.the.goods.and./.or. availability.of.a.special.fax.number.
services.offered.among.staff.and. and.e-mail.address.for.daily.activities,.
other.members.and.partners.of.the. adapted.forms,.the.possibility.of.
organisation. discussing.a.particular.issue.via.
. •. I.ncluding.in.the.customer.service. webcam.with.specialised.staff,.and.the.
and.safety.plans.a.section.regarding. setting.up.of.pictograms.and.illustrations.
people.with.disabilities. related.to.the.different.terms.;
•. A
. wareness-raising.and.training.
initiatives.for.staff.members.and.
Since.2004,.the.mutual.society MACIF. partners.on.how.to.deal.with.people.
(.France.).has.devoted.a.lot.of.effort. with.hearing.impairments..These.
to.adapting.their.services.in.order.to. included.training.sessions.and.a.
eliminate.and.avoid.the.current.and. subscription.to.specialised.magazines.
potential.barriers.that.people.with. in.the.sector,.among.other.activities.;
disabilities.face.in.relation.to.insurance. •. T
. raining.of.certain.staff.members.to.be.
schemes.and.services. better.able.to.deal.with.disabled.clients.;
In.the.fi.rst.phase.of.this.work.and.as.a.way. •. S
. etting.up.of.reception.points.for.deaf.
of.gaining.experience,.MACIF.initiated.a. people.where.special.technical.aids,.such.
refl.ection.on.how.to.make.its.insurance. as.induction.loops,.are.made.available.;

33

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int233 33 10/09/07 13:04:21


• Development of partnerships and The Belgian socialist mutual insurances
communication with people with facilitate access to people with disabilities
disabilities and their organisations ; and to services through specific projects
as well as general programmes and
• Improvement of protection of
campaigns. One example is the project
people with hearing impairments by
run jointly by the Socialist and Christian
adapting products to their needs and
Mutual Societies in the province of
participation in initiatives relating to
Walloon Brabant. The project has set up a
prevention and detection such as the
transport service adapted to people with
national day of hearing.
disabilities. Transportation is provided for
Following the success of this “trial” period, individuals going to medical appointments,
MACIF extended the same type of process work, visiting family and others for a very
to blind people and is currently working to reasonable and accessible price.
extend it to all types of disabilities.
In addition, the Union National des
Contact person : Jérémie Boroy, . Mutualités Socialistes Francophones
Contact Person ; MACIF ( France ) has set up a specific association
Email : jboroy@macif.fr – the Association Socialiste de la
Website : www.macifsourds.com Personne Handicapée ( ASPH ) that
aims at defending people with any type
of disabilities, severe or incapacitating
v If necessary, request an internal or external
illnesses. The association is in charge
person to undertake an access audit on of developing, among other actions,
elements such as policies and practices, raising public awareness campaigns,
service delivery structures, information interventions and lobby initiatives, notably
material used and the decision-making relating to health care or work-related
processes of your organisation. impairments and health care systems.
v Ask for feedback and ideas and whenever Contact person : Gisèle Marlière, National
appropriate, involve disabled users and Secretary ; Association Socialiste de la
the organisations representing them, at all Personne Handicapée ( ASPH ) of the
stages of the design, production and / or Mutualité Socialiste ( Belgium )
provision process so that they can express E-mail : gisele.marliere@mutsoc.be
what they want from the service provided. Website : www.asph.be ; www.mutsoc.be
This will help to evaluate the extent to
which current schemes are meeting their
needs and preferences and to shape the
design of new ones. This activity could be The project “Design for everyone
done through consultation exercises, focus – development of a teaching model and
methods for more accessible shops”,
groups, comment / suggestion cards / boxes,
which is being currently developed in the
website questionnaires, customer panels,
Swedish region of Västra Götaland, is run
regular meetings with disabled customers
by a partnership consisting of the publicly
or representative organisations or by simply
elected bodies in the region, the Regional
asking your disabled customers. It should be
Development Committee, the Disabilities
a two-way communication process.
Committee, the Swedish Inheritance
v Communicate and raise awareness about Fund, the County Administrative Board
the disability-friendly features included of Halland, the Association for the
in the design, production and delivery Promotion of Village Stores in Sweden,
of goods and services through disability representatives of disability organisations,
organisations, the media, and other and grocers of village shops.
channels.

34

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int234 34 10/09/07 13:04:21


3.3. Goods and Services

This project takes place within the


programme run by the Swedish
Consumer Agency aimed at hindering
the deterioration of services in the
countryside. For many people living in
the countryside access to grocers’ shops
as well as the services they provide is of
great importance. These shops act often
as agents for different services such as
postal and chemist’s. increasing even
more their importance to the consumer.
A set of guidelines and standards of
accessibility for people with disabilities
to shops and information was developed
based on the needs of people with
varying disabilities to get into a shop,
find their way, do the shopping, and pay.
A group of mentors was also trained ;
they then developed a special teaching
model for shopkeepers. These mentors
also performed accessibility inventories
of 90 shops, in cooperation with
disability organisations. According to the
information collected, the mentors and
shopkeepers developed an accessibility
action plan for each shop that was then
put into practice.
Contact person : Marianne Salén, Executive
Officer, Secretariat to the Regional Executive
Board, Region Västra Götaland
Email : marianne.salen@vgregion.se
Webpage : www.vastsverige.com

35

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int235 35 10/09/07 13:04:21


3.4. Health care

The current health care model is primarily children’s health and on the part of
designed for the “average person”, professionals regarding the needs of
and thus presents significant barriers for people with disabilities.
people with disabilities in terms of access to
appropriate services since they do not fully Some practical ideas to overcome
comply with what are considered “normal these challenges
standards”. In addition, although people
These practical suggestions are addressed
with disabilities are not and do not consider
to any individual or organisation active in
themselves unhealthy, in many cases they
the health field, including health policy-
require specific, regular and more intense
makers, health professionals, organisations
health care assistance than other citizens.
supporting or developing health projects, as
The health system does not seem to meet the well as to any other actor in the health field
needs of people with disabilities, which can willing to integrate disability into their work.
vary considerably according to the type of
Key areas of activity that can be taken up to
impairment or severity of disability. In many
overcome these challenges are as follows :
cases, the disability is not even taken into
account because health care professionals v Promotion of research and prevention,
do not know how to deal with it. early detection and early attention. These
actions can lessen, or even remove or
Challenges even prevent the effects of a disability. To
promote this, it is essential to foster and
The following appear to be the greatest
apply research in these areas.
challenges to equal access :
v Implementation of universal accessibility
• Financial : high cost of necessary care.
in health environments, processes, and
• Physical : physical inaccessibility of many procedures. For example :
health services.
• Providing people with disabilities
• Service provision : lack of availability of with all necessary information in
community-based provisions. appropriate formats.
• Barriers to information : lack, or • Full accessibility of all services
inaccessibility, of information about what including emergency services.
is available.
• Provision of services at reasonable
• Attitudinal, communication and social costs.
barriers manifested through, for example,
• Promotion of community-based
attitudes of medical professionals that
provision of information, advice and
may even be discriminatory. For instance,
training.
in many cases, when assisting people
with disabilities, medical personnel talk • Elimination of communication barriers
with their parents or with the persons that currently exist in hospitals and
assisting them rather than with the health care services to ensure that
disabled individuals themselves, who disabled patients can communicate in
as a consequence will find themselves other ways, e.g. sign language or other.
excluded from their own treatment and
• Simplification of paperwork and
unable to express their needs.
ensuring accessibility of administrative
• Knowledge : a lack of knowledge on procedures for gaining access to
the parents’ part of how to protect their health care services.

36

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int236 36 10/09/07 13:04:21


3.4. Health care

• Promote cooperation with other


Aware of the different types of stakeholders.
discrimination that people with disabilities • Provide support to these professionals.
face in their access to health, the French • Carry out these measures in cooperation
Mutuality Federation together with the with people with disabilities.
Fédération Hospitalière de France
• Special training should be provided to the
and other stakeholders has requested
staff at employment and vocational training
( according to the French legal procedure )
centres that are responsible for information,
the High Health Authority in France, in
guidance, and training on the specific needs
charge of monitoring and dealing with
and abilities of disabled persons. Moreover,
medical matters, to look at the specific
the direct involvement of persons with
area of health care and disability. In
disabilities in the management and running
particular, they have asked the Authority
of these centres should be considered.
to analyse the specific needs of people
with disabilities and how to make a high-
quality health service available to them. The In 2006, the Region of Västra Götaland
areas of access to adapted health care, ( Sweden ) started the development of
prevention and cure, and access to specific a project aimed at training health care
treatments should also be looked at. professionals on how to deal with patients
with disabilities.
This project aims to call the attention
of public authorities to the issue and to The “Wasn’t aware” project was run in
improve health care services for people partnership with the health care institutions
with disabilities. In addition, this request is in the region, the Regional Disability
really important : health matters can only Committee and the Västra Götaland
disability organisations. So far, over 12,000
change if the High Authority deals with
health care professionals have been trained
them. If, following an in-depth analysis,
within the framework of this project.
it considers that action is needed, it
will present the issue to the relevant The training provided to professionals
institutions for further action. covered the following areas :
• Overview of the various types of
Contact person : Isabelle Millet-Caurier, disabilities, in order to provide an
Responsible for the Health and Social increased understanding of different
Policy Area ; Fédération Nationale de la disabilities, life conditions and needs ;
Mutualité Française ( FNMF ) ( France ) • How to deal with disabled patients
E-mail : isabelle.millet@mutualite.fr with the purpose of facilitating tips for
Website : www.mutualite.com person-to-person encounters, stressing
the importance of adequate attention
and consideration ; and
v Training of professionals ( medical staff, • Guidelines to make the physical
social assistants, staff at vocational training environment and the information
centres, etc. ) on specific health care and provided more accessible.
assistance needs of people with disabilities : The training was available online or
• Promote and develop training courses so through an interactive CD, and it also takes
that staff is aware of the needs of people into consideration other perspectives such
with disabilities and their typologies as gender, ethnicity and age.
in order to be able to provide a good Contact person : Alexander Riquelme
service. Disability should be integrated Oskarsson, Executive Officer ; Secretariat
into professional health care studies ( both to the Regional Executive Board, Region of
during initial as well as long-life training ). Västra Götaland ( Sweden )
Email : alexander.oskarsson@vgregion.se
• Promote incentives to foster Webpage : www.vgregion.se
professionals’ involvement in the area.

37

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int237 37 10/09/07 13:04:22


v Creation of specialised services for v Promotion of the availability and
persons with disabilities whenever accessibility of technical aids and
necessary. assistive technologies. Currently, most
systems only cover a limited range of
v Consultation and involvement of users, their
technical aids and health products – in
families and the organisations representing
some cases, even the most essential ones
them in the design, management and
are not funded – designed to increase the
assessment of these services.
independence and social participation of
v Setting up of systems to facilitate the people with disabilities. In other cases,
financing of special medical treatments. they are of low or medium quality and in
many cases old-fashioned. In addition,
people with disabilities usually must pay
first to receive these products and are
reimbursed afterwards by the system.
The Belgian mutual insurances,
including the Socialist Mutual Insurance, v Giving a higher visibility to people with
implement a number of projects aimed disabilities by employing them as staff.
at facilitating the financing of the
required medical treatment of vulnerable
populations, making the fee of their
needed treatment affordable and thus
attainable.
Among these are :
• The “Maximum à facturer ( MàF )”
( maximum to be invoiced ) programme,
which provides financial support
to families with disabled members
( children or adults ), ensuring their
medical expenses will not surpass a
maximum amount ;
• The “compensation for chronic
disease”, which provides financial
support to patients who have been
diagnosed with a chronic disease
requiring persistent treatment ; and
• The Service Medi’Kids that the
Socialist Mutual Insurance provides,
which also establishes an expenses
ceiling for children under the age of 19
diagnosed with a disability or severe
illness. This programme also finances
additional expenses of the treatment,
including medicines, special diets, etc.
Contact person : Gisèle Marlière, National
Secretary ; Association Socialiste de la
Personne Handicapée ( ASPH ) of the
Mutualité Socialiste ( Belgium )
E-mail : gisele.marliere@mutsoc.be
Website : www.asph.be ; www.mutsoc.be

38

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int238 38 10/09/07 13:04:22


3.5. Leisure activities

Access to and active involvement in leisure • The personnel working in these


activities, including arts and cultural life, activities / sites are not trained to serve
sports and recreation, and tourism facilities persons with disabilities.
is as important for disabled as for non-disabled
• Persons with disabilities too often face
people. Leisure activities contribute to their
stereotypes about them ; more information
personal development and they are a good
and awareness-raising are needed to
means of getting integrated into society.
stress the importance of leisure for
However, people with disabilities face a persons with disabilities.
number of obstacles to participation in such
activities. In many cases, this prevents them Some practical ideas to overcome
from enjoying leisure activities at all or they these challenges
can only have access to those specifically
There are many ways in which organisations
geared to disabled persons.
can help to promote the participation of all
On the other hand, their participation in citizens in leisure activities. The following
the leisure sector as professionals also ideas are addressed to individuals and
deserves special mention due to their organisations involved in the leisure sector
difficulties. at the level of decision-making, support or
implementation.
Challenges
v When developing or supporting leisure
However, despite of the importance of activities, ensure that they involve fully
leisure, people with disabilities face a wide inclusive infrastructures, materials and
range of barriers : processes so that both disabled and non-
disabled people can participate in them,
• Often they are forced to pay high ticket
whether actively ( taking an active part
prices and sometimes transport companies
in their development ) or passively ( as a
refuse to accept them on board.
spectator ).
• Some transport companies are still not
v Promote the development of activities
accessible for people with disabilities, so
where disabled and non-disabled people
they are forced to look for more expensive
can enjoy leisure activities together.
transportation alternatives.
• Some hotels, hostels, and camping
areas are not accessible for persons with
The Fondation de France and the
physical disabilities.
association Loisirs Pluriel ( France ) joined
• Leisure time sites ( both public and forces to create leisure centres where the
private ) are too often not accessible. disabled and non-disabled children can
meet and get involved in activities together
• Museums, archaeological sites, and
at an early age.
recreational parks are often closed
for those with physical or intellectual Loisirs Pluriels is currently organised
impairments. as a federation of local associations
operating in eight cities in France. Its aim
• The information provided on leisure
is to expand to other regions throughout
activities is not accessible for people
France. Each organisation manages
with disabilities ; so far, there is very little
a leisure time centre that welcomes
information about them in Braille, easy-to-
disabled and non-disabled children up to
read versions, etc.

39

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int239 39 10/09/07 13:04:22


v Develop audience-building efforts such as
the age of 13. In these centres, disabled making available subsidised tickets, large
and non-disabled children have the print programmes, real-time captioning
opportunity to meet and get to know each and other assistive technologies that can
other, which leads to further respect and benefit all audiences.
understanding.
v Regardless of the additional expenditures
Each leisure centre respects the following which may be incurred in putting
criteria to ensure the best conditions and accessible services and facilities in
treatment both for disabled and non- place, such services and facilities should
disabled children : not give rise to an increase in rates for
customers with disabilities.
• Small groups ;
v Create opportunities for networking,
• Equal treatment of disabled and non-
training and exchange of ideas among
disabled children ;
professionals working in leisure and other
• Continuous monitoring by qualified related services, to help them understand
persons ; how to deal with problems facing people
• More supervision and support than in a with disabilities.
traditional leisure centre ;
• Special training for the carers ;
EWORX S.A. ( Greece ), the Hellenic
• Adaptation of the activities ; and Ministry of Tourism ( Greece ), Disability
Now ( Greece ), Fundación ONCE ( Spain ),
• Equal rates for disabled and non-
VisitBritain ( United Kingdom ), the
disabled children.
Association National pour le Logement
Contact person : Laurent Thomas, des Personnes Handicapées asbl
Director ; Loisirs Pluriels ( France ) ( Belgium ), Toegankelijkheidsbureau
E-mail : laurent.thomas@loisirs-pluriel.com ( Belgium ), Turism för alla i Sverige
Website : www.loisirs-pluriels.com ( Sweden ) and the Work Research Centre
( Ireland ) jointly launched the European
Network for Accessible Tourism
v If even by taking all measures at hand, it ( ENAT ). The network was supported by
is not possible for people with disabilities the European Commission for the first
to participate into mainstream activities, two-year period ( 2006-2007 ).
develop specific activities specifically ENAT aims to make European tourism
addressed to them. Bear in mind that this destinations, products and services
should only be done as a last resort. accessible to all travellers by applying the
v Ensure that any documents or concept of “Tourism for All”, that is, making
promotional materials used are fully transport modes, tourism destinations,
accessible and provide clear indications products and information suitable for all
of accessible services and facilities, those who have particular accessibility
preferably, accompanied by easy-to- needs, and for their families and friends.
understand international symbols ( see The network is open to any individual or
section 3.8. ). organisation that supports the goal of
v Make sure that the reservation systems “accessible tourism for all”. It currently
( websites or others ) used for your leisure has over 250 members in more than 30
activity are fully accessible and usable countries, including businesses that serve
by everyone so that disabled tourists can travellers and tourists, tourist boards
interact with them independently. and public authorities, professionals,
researchers and educational institutions,

40

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int240 40 10/09/07 13:04:23


3.5. Leisure activities

and NGOs of disabled people, as well as Landmine Survivors Network ( LSN )


individual members. ( Bosnia and Herzegovina ) believes in the
importance of sports, recreational and
ENAT brings together these actors and
cultural activities for the rehabilitation
stakeholders in the tourism sector to share
and physical well-being of people
their experience, learn from each other
with disabilities but also for promoting
and collaborate in order to :
reconciliation. In this context, it carries out
• Promote wider awareness and activities that contribute to the successful
understanding of the need for social inclusion of people with disabilities,
accessibility in all areas of travel and particularly landmine survivors, while
tourism throughout Europe ; bringing together former confronted
• Support the development and spread parties.
of good policies and practices ; One of these initiatives is the annual
• Develop knowledge and expertise on ‘Princess Diana Memorial’ tournament of
accessibility issues in the European sitting volleyball. In addition to the event’s
tourism field ; positive contribution to the promotion
of skills and capacities of persons with
• Provide a platform for those who disabilities, it offers them socialising and
support accessibility in tourism ; and social networking opportunities. It bridges
• Create a representative voice towards the divides created by years of civil strife
European and national institutions and between different ethnic groups in Bosnia
organisations whose actions have a and Herzegovina.
direct influence on the tourism sector. It also organises art colonies with the aim
In addition to the organisation of events of recognising and developing the different
and the promotion of partnerships, artistic potential and skills of persons with
initiatives include the creation of an disabilities. These activities encourages
“Accessible Tourism on-line Resource social networking of artists with disabilities
Centre”, which includes relevant and promotes their reintegration into
information such as good practices, key society through socialisation with non-
documents and selected links, as well as disabled art students.
the development of studies, including one Contact person : Ramiz Be Irovi, Assistant
on how to address the rights of disabled for Advocacy and Regional Initiatives ;
tourists in Europe. Landmine Survivors Network ( LSN )
Contact person : Ivor Ambrose, ( Bosnia and Herzegovina )
Coordinator ; European Network for E-mail : lsnbih@landminesurvivors.org
Accessible Tourism ( ENAT ) Website : www.landminesurvivors.org
E-mail : enat@accessibletourism.org
Website : www.accessibletourism.org

Cera SCRL ( Belgium ) supports the


“Culture and Democracy” Programme,
which encourages vulnerable populations
in Belgium to become part of their cultural
v Foster the active participation of people environment. Victims of social exclusion
with disabilities as professionals in the are brought together with professional
sector. artists who work with them to conceive
v Use leisure activities as a means and produce an artistic production, while
of promoting mutual respect and working with partners that can assure the
understanding.

41

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int241 41 10/09/07 13:04:23


continuity of this project. The aim of the
project is to make the social and cultural
sector aware of the needs of vulnerable
populations as well as to promote mutual
respect and understanding through
culture.
Contact person : Ivo Janssens, .
Severine Monniez and Marie Poncin,
Project Coordinators ;.
Culture et Démocratie / Kunst en
Democratie ( Belgium )
E-mail : ivo.janssens@kend.be /
cultureetdemocracie@scarlet.be
Website : www.cdkd.be

v Develop materials that can be used as


reference, support, and assessment in the
different fields of leisure time activities.

The World Tourism Organisation ( WTO )


publication “Accessible Tourism for All’,
developed with the contribution of experts
from Fundación ONCE ( Spain ), provides
general guidelines for stakeholders
involved in the tourist industry on how to
make tourism accessible for all.
Topics covered include : tourism
information and publicity, staff preparation,
common requirements ( parking areas,
signage, elevators, public telephones,
public toilets, pricing ) and requirements
concerning specific facilities ( terminals,
railway stations and related facilities,
accommodation facilities, catering
facilities, museums and other buildings
of tourist interest, excursions, conference
facilities, major roads ).
Website : www.world-tourism.org

42

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int242 42 10/09/07 13:04:23


3.6. Financial services and funding

People with disabilities systematically have to


face barriers in accessing financial services and Compagnia di San Paolo ( Italy ) launched
funding. This is because people with disabilities its project on social microcredit in 2003
and their specific needs are disregarded or by creating a network of non-profit sector
are treated on an unequal basis ( e.g. when institutions, banks and the Foundation
they are requested to take out extra insurance itself. The project aims to facilitate the
in order to have access to financial services ). granting of loans by Italian banks to Italian
Such restrictions can negatively affect people and foreign individuals or legal entities,
with disabilities by denying them full inclusion in which due to their social conditions and / or
society and causing them financial problems due economic situations, find it difficult to
to their disability.
access the credit market. This scheme
Mainstream financial institutions and aims to increase their chances of gaining
funders may not consciously exclude people sustainable employment and / or carrying
with disabilities, but by not seeing to their out an economic activity.
inclusion, they are failing to tackle the
The network has three types of partners,
challenge of ensuring that financially insecure
each of which undertakes clearly defined
people with disabilities have full and equal
tasks :
access to their services.
• Compagnia di San Paolopromotes,
Challenges coordinates and monitors the project.
The barriers encountered by people with It is also the institution which funds the
disabilities are quite diverse, such as : Guarantee Fund for the loans granted
inaccessibility of information on sources of ( which can be used in the case of
grants and loans or the premises where the default or insolvency ) and the project
information on them can be obtained ; refusal as a whole.
of financial services or exorbitant rates for • Four non-profit institutions : Don Mario
the insurance required by certain financial Operti Foundation ( Turin ), Santa
institutions ; negative attitudes, prejudices Maria del Soccorso Foundation
and a lack of awareness about disabilities ; or ( Genoa ), Risorsa Donna Foundation
simply self-exclusion due to a belief that they ( Rome ), and San Giuseppe Moscati
will not be accepted by financial institutions
Foundation ( Naples ). They act as
when requesting a service.
community points of reference and
carry out very delicate tasks such
Some practical ideas to overcome
as gathering information, evaluating
these challenges
applications, starting bank procedures,
The following recommendations are addressed and mentoring successful applicants.
to decision-makers and staff members of public
• Two banks : Intesa Sanpaolo and
and private financial institutions and funders,
Sanpaolo Banco di Napoli which
including banks, grantmaking foundations and
evaluate the applications and carry out
trusts and other organisations awarding grants
and loans, public administrations, and other the final procedures. Credit is granted
stakeholders in this field. through current accounts offered on
special terms. The banks inform the
Some ideas to ensure their full access : institutions on outstanding credits on a
v Offer innovative finance schemes, e.g. monthly basis.
microcredit or mutual lending groups.

43

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int243 43 10/09/07 13:04:24


Loans are between 1,000 and 35,000 Social co-operatives in Italy fulfil the
euros ( with a maximum of 20,000 euros tasks of social services and within their
for credits to a single person ) and can be range of work, also develop activities
granted for a period of 18 to 60 months to that encourage the integration of
both individuals and organisations. disadvantaged people. In Italy, there are
currently 438 BCCs with more than 3,750
Contact person : Daniela Gregnanin,
branches, 820,000 members and 30,000
Social Policy and Welfare Department ;
employees.
Compagnia di San Paolo ( Italy )
E-mail : daniela.gregnanin@compagnia. Contact person : Sergio Gatti,
torino.it Communications Officer ; Federazione
Website : www.compagnia.torino.it Italiana delle Banche di Credito
Cooperativo, Federcasse ( Italy )
E-mail : sgatti@federcasse.bcc.it
Website : www.creditoccoperativo.it
In May 2006, the Italian Federation
of Credit Cooperative Banks
( Federcasse ), the Federation of v Ensure that people with disabilities are
Social Co-operatives, Mutuals and treated like their non-disabled peers when
Social Enterprises ( Federsolidarietà ), requesting a grant or a loan. For example,
Confcooperative and the Consortium do not ask for additional insurances linked
of Social Co-operatives CGM signed to their disability.
an agreement aimed at enhancing the
development of social co-operatives by
facilitating the creation of patrimonial
capital of any social cooperative Die Zweite Sparkasse ( savings bank )
enterprise and its second level consortia offers bank accounts to people in Austria
( co-operatives formed by smaller co- who have got into financial difficulties
operatives ) through the support of the and no longer have access to banking
Italian Credit Cooperative Banks ( BCCs ). services. The “bank for people without a
bank” was initiated by ERSTE Stiftung
This innovative agreement responds to the
and is operated by voluntary staff
challenges in accessing finance normally
members of Erste Bank and Austrian
faced by small or very small social co-
savings banks in cooperation with social
operatives. It is a very innovative measure
welfare institutions such as Caritas as
in the non-profit field in Italy. It establishes
well as debt counselling services. The
the conditions for the granting of loans at a
main product of Die Zweite Sparkasse is
favourable rate for any member of a social
a limited-duration, interest-bearing credit
cooperative ( aimed at strengthening the
account, i.e. a basic account with a bank
capital of the cooperative ) or directly for
card that does not offer any overdraft
the single social cooperative enterprise
facilities and is available to customers
to strengthen the capital of the second
for three years only. Rather than being a
level consortia they take part in. Through
permanent solution, Die Zweite Sparkasse
a specific product, called “Conto / i tu”
provides a basis for helping people to
( “Account You / You count” ), the BCCs can
open and maintain a regular bank account
grant a loan at very favourable conditions
at a later time. Owing to an initiative by
for the above-mentioned purposes up
Vienna Insurance Group, customers also
to a maximum amount of 3,000 euros
benefit from basic insurance coverage.
for members of a social co-operative
and 20,000 euros for co-operatives The credit account is not the only product
themselves. aimed at people in personal distress ; it is

44

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int244 44 10/09/07 13:04:24


3.6. Financial services and funding

barriers. For this purpose, applicants


one component of a complete package of should be required to provide evidence
counselling and support services provided that they have considered how
by these welfare organisations. In order to equality and diversity, and disability
be entitled to such an account, customers issues in particular, have been taken
must already use the services of one of these into account in the project both in
organisations and be recommended by them. the application, implementation and
evaluation processes. If necessary,
The starting capital for Die Zweite Sparkasse
announce at an early stage to the
has been provided by ERSTE Stiftung, the
beneficiaries of the funds that they will
initiator of this project for social integration.
have to provide this information.
ERSTE Stiftung is active in the Central and
South Eastern European region. Since • Ask applicants to include users in the
starting its work in 2005, it has been running application process to ensure that
projects independently and in collaboration projects meet identified needs. If the
with partners within its Social Affairs, Culture potential users are not already part of
and Europe programmes. the organisation, applicants should
consider consulting or involving specific
Email : info@erstestiftung.org
user groups or the organisations
Webpage : www.erstestiftung.org
representing them, including disability
groups, and where possible use up-to-
v Make sure that the rights and date research on the issue.
requirements of people with disabilities • Make sure that any persons involved
are taken into account at all stages of in assessing, selecting, supporting
the funding process. This is particularly and monitoring projects have an
important in the case of grant-making understanding of disability-related
trusts and foundations and other public issues, including the relevant rules
and private funders and deserves and practices in the field, or that they
particular attention given the enormous have access to disability experts
contribution that these actors could make and resources that could help them
if they respect disability-related issues in this task. For this purpose, in
in their funding processes. It implies a the first stage provide them with
change of approach in which people with the necessary human and material
disabilities are recognised as funding resources and mechanisms to improve
applicants rather than beneficiaries of their understanding of the issue ( e.
project outcomes. Funders should : g. provision of training inside or
• Ensure that the application process is outside the organisation, contact with
fully accessible, clear and transparent, disability-related organisations or
identifying stages and time frames and experts, attendance of seminars on
sticking to them. the issue, information about the latest
developments in the field, etc. ).
• Develop the application process in close
consultation with people with disabilities • Ensure the provision of specialist
and organisations representing them to expertise tailored to applicant needs,
make sure that the selected criteria are either by employing or liaising with
relevant to their rights, requirements and people with disabilities, or people
aspirations. with an in-depth understanding of the
issues facing people with disabilities
• Ensure that the organisations
( individuals and groups ).
and projects supported take into
consideration equality and disability- • Mainstream equality through each
related issues and that with their project in order to ensure that
actions they are not creating new people with disabilities are not

45

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int245 45 10/09/07 13:04:24


simply restricted to disability-related
opportunities ( e.g. by allocating The King’s Fund ( United Kingdom )
responsibility for equality and expects that all grantees will show the
diversity to policy officers within each same commitment to equal opportunities
programme team, providing support for everyone as the Fund and therefore
to meet additional transport costs for request them to demonstrate it through
people with disabilities ). a series of questions and statements
• To ensure that people with disabilities included in the grant-related documents.
are not inadvertently discriminated In the terms and conditions, the grantee
against, increase staff awareness agrees to the following “if the grant has
and understanding of the rights been awarded to pay for a new post for
and requirements of people with our organisation, we undertake to have an
disabilities. This can be done by : open and fair recruitment process which
∙ Recruiting people with disabilities as includes advertising the post”.
employees or volunteers ; One of the questions in the grant
∙ Employing advisors with knowledge application form is “How will you ensure
of issues affecting people with that all possible users of your project can
disabilities ; and access it ?”
∙ Training staff to ensure they understand Contact person : Clare Jacques, Funding
the rights and requirements of all and Development Team Administrator ;
people with disabilities. Staff should King’s Fund ( United Kingdom )
be fully informed and updated about E-mail : mediaoffice@kingsfund.org.uk
disability issues and current legislation. Website : www.kingsfund.org.uk

The Carnegie United Kingdom Trust Lloyds TSB Foundation for England and
( United Kingdom ) has a statement of Wales ( United Kingdom ) asks applicants
values underpinning its work, including a to provide, as part of its assessment
commitment to social justice, equality of process, “a copy of your equal
opportunity and anti-discrimination. opportunities policy or if you do not have
one, information about your commitment
The Trust’s entire portfolio of programmes
to equal opportunities”.
and its five-year strategy are informed by
this statement. In support of this, the Trust In the application form, the Foundation
has also introduced external monitoring asks applicants if they have an equal
and evaluation of all programmes. opportunities policy and how it is
implemented. They are also asked to
This is part of a comprehensive approach
give an estimate of the percentage of
to diversity applied to the organisation
service users based on several categories,
itself and to its programmes .
including ethnicity and disability.
Contact person : Charlie McConnell, .
Contact person : Louise Harley, .
Chief Executive ; Carnegie United Kingdom
Contact Person ; Lloyds TSB Foundation
Trust ( United Kingdom )
( United Kingdom )
E-mail : charlie@carnegieuk.org
Email : Louise.Harley@
Website : www.carnegieuktrust.org.uk
lloydstsbfoundations.org.uk
Website : www.lloydstsbfoundations.org.uk

46

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int246 46 10/09/07 13:04:25


3.6. Financial services and funding

This section analyses in detail the various Application and guidance materials
aspects of the funding process. Although
v Ensure that applications and guidance
the proposals concern people with
materials are accessible by providing
disabilities, they will be of direct interest to
a wide range of sources through which
other groups :
materials can be obtained ( Braille,
audio, large print, easy read, etc. ) and
Marketing and raising awareness
making material available through various
about funding opportunities
channels, e.g. via direct mail, websites,
v Make sure that information on different e-mail. When using websites, make sure
types of funding reaches people with that they meet accessibility requirements
disabilities by adopting tailored marketing ( see section 3.8 ).
strategies and targeting specific applicant
v Be clear and simple. For example, provide
groups, where appropriate. Effective
a checklist of all materials required and
methods include the use of local radio
how to access them, have separate
and press, including articles in specialist
application forms and guidance for each
publications, and disseminating
funding stream, and provide examples on
information through community events
and to local, regional and disability how funding has been used before.
organisations. v Be flexible regarding the requirements
v Ensure that accessibility requirements for awarding a grant, and in particular,
are taken into account in marketing and when making specific statements, ensure
promotional strategies and materials that certain groups are not accidentally
( paper or electronic ) ( see section 3.8 ). or carelessly excluded. For example, if
an educational trust only funds young
v Consider positive action to encourage the people up to the age of 21, its criteria
participation of people with disabilities may exclude some people with learning
and their representative organisations difficulties who develop more slowly than
in funded projects ( both as funding the average person does and who would
applicants and as receivers and not be able to take advantage of a course
beneficiaries of project outcomes ) e.g. until over the age limit.
funding projects that actively seek to
recruit and retain people with disabilities v Accept applications in different formats
or that encourage people with disabilities and through different means.
to apply for grants. v Include an evaluation form focusing on the
v There are however some discussions ease of the application process and the
about the relevance of including specific contents of relevant documentation.
statements in marketing strategies.
One issue is that including such a list Project selection
can be perceived as a catalogue for
v Ensure that applicant organisations are
the disadvantaged elite and therefore
committed to equal opportunities and
anyone not on the list should not apply.
the projects selected contribute to the
At the same time, groups that are often
promotion of non-discrimination and
discriminated against say they prefer
equal opportunities and do not create
to be specifically mentioned because
new barriers. You can do so by asking
their life experience is one of exclusion
applicant organisations during the
unless otherwise positively invited.
application process questions that require
An intermediate option would be to
them to prove their commitment and show
state that “all disadvantaged groups
how they will implement it in practice.
are encouraged to apply” and then, if
considered necessary, mention some of v When disability projects fail, analyse the
them. reasons in order to strengthen guidance

47

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int247 47 10/09/07 13:04:25


and application processes to give v Where matched funding is a requirement,
potential applicants clearer advice. provide a flexible bidding timetable to
v Provide feedback to unsuccessful enable applicants to secure the necessary
applicants. Where possible, feedback funding.
should be made available before the
deadline to enable inexperienced Type of support
applicants to further develop their v Consider extra costs that people with
applications. disabilities might have, e.g. personal
assistance and private transport if public
Application support transport is not adequate or available.
v Provide regular and accessible v Provide a mix of ’core’ and ’project‘
opportunities for potential and current funding to enable organisations to make
applicants to receive free application long-term “service development” plans
support on their project proposals in and retain an appropriate skill level within
ways that meet their needs ( by e-mail, the organisation. If not, they will be forced
telephone and face-to-face meetings ) to constantly chase funding in order to
before and after application forms are maintain their work or may have to make
submitted. In particular, provide additional employees redundant until the next raft of
support to applicants who are unable to funding.
complete their application form due to a
disability. Monitoring and evaluation
v Provide networking opportunities and v Develop effective monitoring of applicant
contacts for additional support directed organisations, types of projects and
at small voluntary and community beneficiaries, in order to assess under-
organisations and user-led groups
representation of applicants, and target
to enable them to link up with larger
your marketing to address this.
organisations and access funds aimed at
strategic partnerships. v Monitor the number of people with
disabilities accessing projects funded and
v Provide a range of project support
break the information down into types
mechanisms ( e.g. seminars, guidance
of impairments ( e.g. visual impairment,
notes, visits ), including support on
hearing impairment, etc. ), including
disability issues and areas where
indicators on those experiencing multiple
appraisal indicates consistent
discrimination, e.g. disabled women,
weaknesses across projects.
and black and other minority people with
v Provide a nominated officer or mentor to disabilities.
support successful applicants through
v Monitor applicants’ compliance with
the process, either through visits or by
equality policies and strategies.
telephone.
v Ensure outputs can be flexible to take
Timelines account of target group needs. Make
greater use of outcome, impact, and soft
v If possible, operate a roll-on-roll-off
indicators to take account of disability
application cycle, with frequent or
target groups and their potential
no deadlines. This is helpful for all
difficulties in achieving outputs over the
applicants and in particular for people
short term. Consider the use of project-
with disabilities if they need more time
determined outputs.
to complete an application. It also helps
to ensure that applications are made in v Ensure that the results of monitoring,
response to service requirements rather consultation, and research are used to
than for chasing funding. change policy and practice.

48

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int248 48 10/09/07 13:04:25


3.6. Financial services and funding

v Undertake an interim and final programme


evaluation to identify what is working
well and what can be improved and if
funding is being accessed by people
with disabilities. Where access audits
and the development of access plans
are required, consider supporting this
requirement with appropriate levels of
funding to enable applicants to undertake
audits and prepare access plans.
v Ensure that people involved in the
monitoring and selection have a
knowledge on diversity and disability
issues.

49

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int249 49 10/09/07 13:04:26


3.7. Housing

In spite of the legislative measures and communities if their needs were taken into
practices implemented in recent years, account in mainstream accommodation and,
people with disabilities still face many where necessary, special housing or special
barriers preventing them from having access support schemes were set up. Although
to housing or adapting their houses to meet the priority should be given to mainstream
their needs. housing, special housing may be needed in
certain cases and for certain groups, such
This situation has a direct effect on both
as for people with severe disabilities or with
people with disabilities and their families.
complex dependency needs.
On the one hand, people with disabilities find
it difficult to live independently both because Social Economy organisations and in
they cannot find suitable accommodation particular housing associations and co-
or because they are obliged to live in operatives as well as foundations and
accommodation that effectively imprisons mutual societies, in partnership with public
them at home and makes them dependent and private partners, are developing many
on others in their daily activities. This can innovative ways to break down these
also increase the impact of their impairment barriers.
and even induce further disability. On the The solutions listed below are addressed
other hand, families of the disabled find it to any person or organisation involved in
extremely difficult to find suitable housing, the design, construction or management
in many cases due to a shortage of suitably of housing. They include architects, interior
sized accommodation, whether flats or designers, housing decision-makers, public
houses, which can be adapted to meet administrations, organisations developing
the requirements of a disabled person. or providing financial support for housing
Improving this situation would also be projects, persons with disabilities and their
directly beneficial for elderly people, an families.
important consideration given today’s ageing
population. In general, solutions should all aim to follow
four main objectives in this regard :
Challenges • To respect first and foremost a disabled
Key barriers include : person’s own choices – he / she should
have the opportunity to try different
• Architectural barriers. alternatives ;
• Financial barriers, in particular because • To take into account the perspective of
of the extra costs of acquiring an adapted the family, in cases where a disabled
house or adapting inaccessible dwellings. person needs support in decision-
• Communication barriers and negative making ;
attitudes or prejudices within the • To give greater independence to disabled
community, which make it difficult for people ; and
people with disabilities to integrate into
their environment. • To help them to stay and / or integrate into
the wider community.
Some practical ideas to overcome In line with these objectives, the following
these challenges should be observed :
It is proven that many people with disabilities • Unless they decide otherwise, people
could live independently and / or stay in their with mild disabilities should be given the

50

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int250 50 10/09/07 13:04:26


3.7. Housing

opportunity to move into mainstream · Distance between the house and


housing and should be provided with the car-parking space kept to a
support whenever it is needed ; minimum ;

• For those who cannot manage to live in · Level or gently sloping approach to
mainstream housing, specific schemes the house ;
should be promoted to allow them to · Accessible threshold that is covered
maintain and develop a strong level and well lit ;
of independence. They include small
· Lifts fully wheelchair accessible in
housing schemes in the community, flats. Stairs in flats should provide
where they receive the required support, easy access ;
or, for those who prefer this option,
· Width of door and hall that allow
specific residential centres with close
wheelchair access ;
links to the community ;
· Turning circle for wheelchair in
• For people with severe disabilities
ground-floor living room ;
requiring 24-hour support, special
residential centres may be needed, but · Living room or family room at
efforts should be made to develop strong entrance level ;
links with surrounding communities and to · Identified space for temporary bed at
promote the person’s independence and entrance level ;
empowerment ; and
· Accessible entrance-level WC, plus
• People with disabilities should only be opportunity for the installation of a
placed in residential centres if they so shower later ;
desire or when there is no other option · Walls that can be adapted ;
( e.g. persons with complex dependency
· Provision for a future stair lift ;
needs, etc. ). These institutions should
provide housing and living facilities that · Easy route for a hoist from bedroom
aim to promote disabled persons’ self- to bathroom ;
determination and equal participation · Bathroom planned to give side
in the community. Institutions that do access to bath and WC ;
not respect these principles should be
· Low window sills ; and
replaced by community-based services
that pursue the goals mentioned above. · Sockets, controls, etc. at a
convenient height.
Other practical ideas include :
v When getting involved in the design or The concept of Lifetime Homes was
construction of new mainstream public developed by the Joseph Rowntree
and private housing projects : Foundation ( JRF ) ( United Kingdom ) in
the early 1990s as a result of its concern
• Make sure that the housing is designed
about the bad quality and in particular the
according to inclusive standards such inaccessibility and inconvenience of many
as the barrier-free or Lifetime Homes British houses for large segments of the
standards, using the ‘design for all’ population.
approach. Lifetime Homes include
Lifetime Homes have 16 accessibility
accessibility and design features that
and design features that make the home
make them flexible enough to meet
flexible enough to meet the changing
every type of need. Features include :
needs of most people at all stages of
· Sufficiently wide parking space for a life, including older people, people with
wheelchair user ;

51

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int251 51 10/09/07 13:04:26


temporary or permanent disabilities and Habinteg Housing Association has
families with young children, e.g. people been opening doors for disabled people
carrying in heavy shopping or parents in England for more than thirty years
dealing with a pushchair. They include contributing to the design, building and
level access for wheelchair users and the management of accessible homes.
ability to easily accommodate aids and Together with sister organisations in
adaptations. Ireland, Northern Ireland and Scotland,
the organisation was formed to improve
These standards have been used in public
housing opportunities for disabled people.
and private developments in the field both
in the UK and abroad. They are suitable At a time when institutional care was the
for older people ( whose numbers are predominant solution, the association
increasing rapidly ), for the vast majority established a model of building small
of disabled people and for non-disabled housing schemes where disabled and
people. They are therefore a mainstream non-disabled people can live and enjoy
solution. together. The principles of inclusion and
the opportunities for greater independence
According to research commissioned by
are key features in these housing
the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, the
schemes, facilitated by both the design
additional cost of achieving the standard
and local support arrangements available.
is between 0.5 and 1 % of total building
costs, which is much cheaper than making Habinteg have also campaigned
adaptations after a house has been ceaselessly to improve housing
completed. opportunities for disabled people by :

Contact person : Julia Lewis, Director of • promoting inclusive design including


Communications ( interim ) ; . the Lifetime Homes standard as a
simple set of criteria that can be
Joseph Rowntree Foundation ( JRF )
incorporated within a range of housing
( United Kingdom ) .
types to allow future flexibility and
E mail : julia.lewis@jrf.org.uk
adaptability of use ;
Website : www.jrf.org.uk
• publishing design guidelines for the
development of homes designed
v Whenever possible, and particularly in the for the needs of specific impairment
case of people with severe disabilities or types, such as visual impairment and
with complex dependency needs, design wheelchair users ;
homes that are tailor-made to meet their • conducting research and developing
needs. good practice in the general area of
v Involve people with disabilities as much as housing and disability, including research
into the housing needs of black and
possible in the design and management
minority ethnic disabled people ; and
of their homes.
• working with other disability focused
v Develop systems that allow people with organisations to improve the housing
disabilities to live independently in their sector’s response to disabled customers.
own houses. SMART technologies, offer
many possibilities in this sense. Habinteg remain committed to seeking to
improve housing opportunities for disabled
people, whether in the public or private
sector, and its latest project involved
commissioning an interior designer to
demonstrate that accessible design could
be marketable and attractive.

52

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int252 52 10/09/07 13:04:27


3.7. Housing

The completed inclusively designed Contact person : Felisa Lobato Valcuende ;


bathrooms and kitchens have been Confederación Española de Organizaciones
recognised as class leading designs en favor de las Personas con Retraso
through industry award schemes and Mental ( FEAPS ) Castilla León ( Spain )
Habinteg continues innovating to offer a E-mail : aspanias@feapscyl.org
widest range of choices for all. Website : www.aspaniasburgos.com
Contact person : Mike Donnelly, Chief
Executive ; Habinteg Housing Association
( United Kingdom ) v When developing schemes aimed
E-mail : mdonnelly@habinteg.org.uk at helping disabled people to live
Website : www.habinteg.org.uk independently in the wider community,
consider putting in place support
schemes such as information services,
work and training centres, social facilities
The Fundación ASPANIAS Burgos and good public transport systems.
( Spain ) runs since 2003 a specific scheme
to allow couples of people with intellectual
disabilities, already working in special After the overthrow of the Portuguese
employment centres or in process of dictatorship in 1974, 50 co-operatives
professional inclusion, to live independently were formed across Portugal to provide
in a mainstream environment to fully enjoy care education and training to disabled
their life in couple. children and young people. Today, the co-
operatives work with many thousands of
This programme gives a reduced number
people with disabilities and their families.
of couples, selected through an extensive
and thorough process, the opportunity About a dozen co-operatives provide
of having an adapted housing as well as supported housing that offers them
the necessary support for them and their independent living in the wider community.
environment to adapt to this new life. In addition to a barrier-free housing
scheme, the beneficiaries count on the
Moving to the adapted house is the final
support of specialised personnel including
step of a quarterly training and guidance
psychiatrists, social workers, and teachers,
process during which the selected
supported by volunteers. Health care,
couples acquire some basic skills for
training, and school support are provided.
living autonomously with their couples
All the schemes are embedded in the local
through training sessions and interviews.
community to integrate the disabled young
The guidance and training, which also
people. Among them is the Cercizimbra
involves the couples’ families, starts with
cooperative, located near the small
an interview aimed at finding out the skills
coastal holiday town of Sesimbra, about
that need to reinforced and lasts during
25 kilometres south of Lisbon. It currently
all the process to rent an apartment and
supports 220 disabled children, young
signing the contract, equipping it and
adults and their families, has three centres,
getting adapted to the new environment.
and is the biggest social enterprise in the
The result of this programme can be area apart from the local authority.
considered quite satisfactory, as it has
Contact person : Sorcha Edwards,
enabled couples to continue developing
Communication, and Liaison Officer ;
their personal lives in couple – some
European Liaison Committee for Social
of them have institutionalised their
Housing ( CECODHAS )
relationships – and some others have
E-mail : sorcha.edwards@cecodhas.org
acquired their own homes.
Website : www.cecodhas.org

53

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int253 53 10/09/07 13:04:27


The Association Nationale pour le with disabilities, senior citizens or
Logement des Personnes Handicapées dependent people ; and
( ANLH ) ( Belgium ) aims to ensure the right
• The process of informing and helping
of persons with disabilities to live in an
develop the level of awareness of
autonomous way – to live in a house that
specific target groups ( educators,
responds to their needs, to move freely
health professionals, social workers,
within their city, to use public transportation,
and people working in the field of
etc. The ANMPH seeks to eliminate
housing in its broadest sense ) about
technical and architectural barriers that
these issues related to the living
prevent persons with reduced mobility from
conditions of the most vulnerable.
exercising their fundamental rights.
The creation of the foundation follows
The project “AccesCity – Vis ta Ville”
other initiatives already developed by
( Live your city ) has developed a dynamic
Leroy Merlin in cooperation with civil
interactive database on the accessibility of
society actors. For example, the “Papas
public places ( public sites, transportation,
Bricoleurs” competition, which has
etc. ) in the Belgian Walloon region and
been held since 1997 in partnership with
Brussels, that can be easily consulted by
the NGO Handicap International and
people with disabilities willing to visit them.
rewards parents who develop projects
Contact Person : Stéphanie Herman, which improve the quality of life of their
Responsible for Communication, children with special needs.
Research, Accessibility, Transportation
Contact person : Régis Degelcke,
and Database ; Association Nationale pour
President ; Fondation Leroy Merlin
le Logement des Personnes Handicapées
( France )
( ANLH ) ( Belgium )
E-mail : nlemaire@leroymerlin.fr
Email : accescity@anlh.be
Webpage : www.leroymerlin.fr
Website : www.accescity.be

v When dealing with the provision of v Set up advice, information, and support
financial support, provide financial aid services to help people with disabilities to
for adaptations and acquisition of homes gain access to grants and loans relating to
for disabled homeowners and people with housing.
disabilities living in private rented housing. v Always work closely with social actors
to identify the needs of people with
disabilities.
Created in 2006, the Fondation Leroy
Merlin ( France ) is committed to the v Pay special attention to the situation of
improvement of housing for disabled and families with disabled children, many of
elderly people. The foundation supports whom live in inadequate and overcrowded
projects related to : conditions. More and larger specially
designed houses should be built to satisfy
• Overall considerations regarding their needs.
the evolution of housing ( both on a
practical and an aesthetic level ) ;
• Research into new housing for disabled
and elderly populations ;
• The creation of services related to the
needs and problems encountered in
the improvement of housing by people

54

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int254 54 10/09/07 13:04:28


3.8. Horizontal issues

This section gathers some tips and the responsibility for ensuring accessibility.
recommendations on transversal issues Design-for-All aims to achieve the recognition
that can be applied to any of the already of the Enabling Interface that a person uses
mentioned areas, or they can be used in to function within life. This enabling interface
other fields of daily life. It is addressed to calls for an enabling environment, enabling
any person willing to include a disability society and enabling processes. Design-
dimension in his / her work. for-All breaks the process of such decision-
making into :
Access and accessibility • Awareness
Accessibility is not just about ramps, • Consultation
automatic doors and other physical features,
but refers to any features that make an • Impact assessment
environment accessible. In addition, it not The traditional view of “disability” is the
only benefits people with disabilities ; it medically defined loss of a bodily function.
also makes participation easier and more The Design-for-All methodology defines
effective for other users who are excluded, “disability” as the disablement that such
including young and old alike, people who a person encounters in his / her workplace
speak different languages, etc. Despite this due to the fact that the interface that he / she
thinking, there is a current lack of awareness uses is not enabled by the environment in
and information on the need for accessibility which the person is operating. Therefore, this
among stakeholders, and the lack of methodology focuses on the interfaces and
appropriate technical knowledge. what environmental factors will enable the
For example, large print and audio person with disabilities to function in society.
tapes benefit not only people with visual
impairments but people for whom English is E-Accessibility
not their first language. Likewise, accessible Access to information has become an
environments are convenient for elderly essential need in today’s knowledge society.
people and parents with little children. Overcoming the technical barriers and
Therefore, it is important that you ensure difficulties that people with disabilities and
from the beginning that there are no physical, others experience when trying to participate
attitudinal, or other barriers preventing on equal terms in the Information Society ( IS )
persons with disabilities from having access is known as “eAccessibility.”
to your organisation and the initiatives it This is part of the broader eInclusion
carries and / or supports. This has proven to concept, which also addresses other types
be most effective and avoids costly changes of barriers, such as financial, geographical,
to initiatives, programmes, and venues. or educational.
In addition, the Design-for-All methodology Accessible websites and accessible adapted
gives a new approach, overcoming ICT equipment are essential to ensure equal
accessibility policies. It shifts the focus of opportunities for people with disabilities.
disability from the person to the environment
Some practical ideas to overcome these
in which this person lives and works.
challenges :
Design-for-All is a methodology dealing
Built environment
with the process of decision-making within
an organisation and not just at the level of v For the purpose of this publication, the
the specific operative department that has built environment covers all internal

55

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int255 55 10/09/07 13:04:28


and external buildings and spaces, and that takes place in them. For this
the means of getting to and from these purpose it is important that design,
environments, both in urban and rural the activities taking place at these
contexts, where people participate in environments, and / or staff attitudes do
everyday activities such as going to not prevent people from doing all this ;
shops, offices, sports facilities, parks or
• Be designed to be safe and to inspire a
walking on the streets. The key is to try to
sense of safety. For example, reflective
develop inclusive environments that can
surfaces can be disabling for people
be used equally by everybody.
with visual impairments or learning
v Ensure that the environment takes into disabilities as can steps for wheelchair
account the needs and requirements of users ; and
people with disabilities and is free from
• Be logical and predictable. Elements
barriers.
such as the internal layout, the use of
For new buildings or spaces colour and lighting can help users to
obtain information about the building
v If you are involved in the construction
and how to use it. For example, a
of a new built environment, take into
reception area with seats arranged
consideration at the earliest possible
around or in clearly defined groups
stage the access requirements of most
is a space that a person with a visual
citizens by implementing the so-called
impairment will quickly recognise.
“Inclusive Design” approach, which
goes beyond the minimum technical and
accessibility requirements. This principle
Information and communication
should be applied to the design, building,
materials
and operation of the building or site in In today’s society only a very small portion
question. Any item inside the space of information available, even the most
should also betaken into consideration. essential, is accessible to all citizens. So
as not to fall into this trap, consider the
v If you are supporting the construction,
following :
ensure that accessibility criteria, and
if possible the “Inclusive Design” v Make your information, promotional
principle, are taken into account and fully material, and other materials produced
implemented. by and for the organisation available
in a wide range of accessible formats,
v For existing environments, try to adapt
including text-only format, Braille, audio,
them to make them as accessible as
large print ( font size 16-22 ), easy-to-read
possible by applying the “Design for All”
format, CD-ROM, hard copy.
methodology. Most existing workplaces
can be made accessible with minimum v Provide the information through different
effort and expense. means such as subtitled video, printed
materials and an accessible website.
v Inclusive environments should :
v Accept applications, information requests
• Be easy to use by as many persons
and other documents in different formats ;
as possible without undue effort ( for
example, climbing steps when another v Seek advice and feedback from
solution would be possible ), special disabled users and their representative
treatment or separation ; organisations to ensure compatibility
with current communication / assistive
• Offer people the possibility to
technology.
choose how they access and use
them ( independently or with support v Include evaluation forms focusing on the
and assistance ) and allow them to ease of the application process and the
participate in any mainstream activity contents of relevant documentation.

56

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int256 56 10/09/07 13:04:28


3.8. Horizontal issues

v It is also important to provide terms, do not use elaborated and closely
accessible and affordable equipment spaced fonts.
to workers / members of organisations, v Size : Whenever possible, use font size
adapted to their capacities and needs. 12 as a minimum standard and font
v Access to adapted equipment is as size 14-16 ( large print ) when producing
important as adapted software. For this, documents for visually impaired readers
social prices for ICT-adapted equipment Do not use more than 18-20 points.
should be established in order to v Capitals : Avoid using capital letters for
guarantee accessibility. blocks of text, e.g. more than one or two
Website words They are too similar in size and
shape for readers to be able to easily
v Make sure that your website complies distinguish letters.
with accessibility and usability criteria.
Some features commonly used in v Italics : Avoid italics, they are harder to
websites cause problems for people read.
with disabilities. Some alternatives are v Colour and paper : Be careful before
available to resolve these barriers. For choosing colours so that there is a
example : significant contrast between them.
• Always provide a text-only format as v Graphics and images : The use of
an alternative for people using screen graphics and images can facilitate reading
readers, which “read” text and then for people with intellectual disabilities.
convert it to speech output for people However, ensure that these images can be
with visual impairments. read by the programmes used by people
with visual impairments. In this sense,
• Pay attention to the use of colour
consider including an explanation next to
contrasts so that people with colour
the image.
blindness can easily use the site.
v Whenever possible, develop easy-to-
• Avoid the use of small areas for links
read documents so that people with an
which make it difficult for people with
intellectual disability can have access to
restricted manual dexterity to navigate.
the information.
• Provide mouse-free navigation.
v Avoid splitting up words at the end of a
• Therefore, ensure that your line.
organisation’s or enterprise’s website
v Lighten your pages ( about 150 words per
is accessible, taking into consideration
page A4 ).
the Guidelines included in the Web
Accessibility Initiative ( WAI ), which can v Whenever possible, before publishing the
be downloaded at www.w3.org / WAI / . information, test it with your audience.

Printed material Images

v Make printed material legible and v Images can facilitate reading for people
accessible for people with visual with intellectual disabilities. However,
impairments by considering issues such some screen readers used by people with
as print size, weight, font, contrast, case, visual impairments cannot read graphic
colour, etc. This implies no extra cost and information. Therefore, a text description
also makes documents more readable for should be included next to the picture.
other citizens. Oral communication ( in formal
conversations, speeches, etc )
v Font : Use large and clear fonts. Visually
impaired readers may find it easier to read v Keep language simple by avoiding jargon
“sans serif” fonts, such as Arial. In general and using simple words ; explain complex

57

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int257 57 10/09/07 13:04:29


terms whenever it is necessary to use Meetings and events
them.
v Regarding the physical environment,
v Do not speak at a high speed and make check the section “built environment”.
short breaks.
v Regarding speech, check the section
v Facilitate sign language interpretation “oral communication”.
when possible.
v Regarding reference and support
v When talking to persons with hearing documents, provide at least those
difficulties, remove pencils, gum, and which are crucial for understanding and
cigarettes from your mouth ; if you have following an event in different formats
a beard or a moustache, consider the upon request or send them in advance so
fact that they can interfere with their that people with disabilities attending the
ability to speech-read you ; make eye-to- meeting can adapt them to their needs. If
eye contact and use facial expressions there are people with learning disabilities
and body language to communicate the in your audience, consider using easy-to-
emotion of a message. read documents.
v Ensure that only one person speaks at a v Allow for a range of communication
time. formats so that everyone has an
opportunity to communicate in some way.
v Let the person with disabilities choose
the best seating or standing arrangement v Visual aids such as Power Point, slides
to see the speaker and the interpreter, if or flip charts facilitate understanding.
there is one. However, when you use such material,
make sure that whatever is written is easy
v Point to the person you are talking about,
to understand. Use pictures whenever
if you are talking to a person with hearing
appropriate, use concrete symbols
difficulties.
( photos, images, drawings, etc ), and read
v Do not pace while giving a presentation the text and explain the pictures included
and do not speak while you are writing on so that persons with visual impairments
a blackboard, as that will make difficult can follow it.
to read your lips for those with hearing
v Involve your audience in your presentation
problems.
To this end, speak directly and personally
v Incorporate visual aids, demonstrations, to the audience ; create some interaction
flip charts, written agendas and hand- with them ; use examples to make your
outs into your presentations and make presentation more understandable ; leave
sure that minutes or notes are taken to time for questions and discussion.
ensure that your audience gets all the
v Whenever it is possible, use the system
information.
of accessibility cards ( each one with a
v When dealing in particular with people different shape ) to make sure that everyone
with intellectual disabilities, take into understands what the speaker is saying :
account some addition requirements :
• Green card : participants agree with
explain one idea per sentence, use the
what the speaker says.
same term for the same concept ; do not
give too much information on one sheet of • Yellow card : the speaker is speaking
paper or in too short a period of time. too quickly and is requested to slow
down.
v Remember that people with disabilities,
even if they have specific requirements, • Red card : participants do not
are adults and not children, therefore treat understand what the speaker is
them like adults when you speak with saying ; He / she is requested to explain
them. it with easier words.

58

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int258 58 10/09/07 13:04:29


3.8. Horizontal issues

Lack of awareness, prejudices, and


attitudinal barriers opportunities by including as one of the
eligibility criteria to become member of
A lack of awareness, prejudices, and
the organisation the fact that they “have
negative attitudes in most cases give rise
a commitment to equal opportunities”. It
to other types of barriers. This is why it
also promotes equal opportunities among
is important to tackle the root causes its partners by disseminating publicly
of existing and potential problems. The available information on how to apply
following can be taken into account : diversity and equal opportunities to their
v Develop or support formal and informal organisations.
information and awareness-raising Contact person : Barbara Waugh, Head
initiatives both inside and outside your of Human Resources ; National Council of
organisation, possibly with partners, at all Voluntary Organisations ( NCVO ), United
levels and in all areas of activity. Kingdom.
Email : Barbara.Waugh@ncvo-vol.org.uk
v Take advantage of all opportunities to
Webpage : www.ncvo-vol.org.uk
raise awareness among staff members,
colleagues, and partners about the
importance and benefits of diversity.
Use positive images showing people Sharing your values
with disabilities in active roles in your
• Promote your approach among your
publications ( newsletters, brochures
partner organisations and encourage
on good practice, reports / studies, web
them to follow your approach.
page ) and in interviews, documentaries,
editorials, opinion pieces, etc. Always • Ensure that other companies with which
include news items on equal opportunities you work, in particular goods and services
in your various publications and websites. suppliers, are aware that this policy is in
place and that they also respect disability
v Communicate and promote in your
issues.
advertising and marketing material your
commitment to equality and diversity • In the case of grant-making organisations,
among your staff ( including volunteers ), include a horizontal clause in your
partners, customers, as well as other grant-making procedure that obliges
stakeholders. beneficiaries to comply with the different
disability-related aspects, irrespective of
v Organise training sessions whenever it is the area of work / thematic priority.
necessary.
• Whether you are offering grants to new
businesses, dealing with lifelong learning,
The National Council of Voluntary
rehabilitation, assisting ex-offenders or
Organisations ( NCVO ) ( United Kingdom )
ethnic minorities, disability mainstreaming
pays a lot of attention to the promotion
applies to you. This is because your
of the respect of diversity and equal
stakeholders and participants are not a
opportunities within the organisation and
homogeneous group and any of these
in the voluntary sector as a whole. In
activities can also include a disability
addition to measures undertaken internally
based on the organisation’s policy approach.
statement on equal opportunities, several • Ask specifically how equality and diversity
initiatives have been developed to promote issues in general and disability issues in
this approach outside the organisation. particular will be taken into account in
For example, NCVO encourages their projects. This should include the provision
members to respect diversity and equal of a project-specific equality strategy,
evidence of consultation with user groups,

59

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int259 59 10/09/07 13:04:30


and an access policy and audit where
applicable.

Consultation and involvement


of people with disabilities and
organisations representing them
• Consult and involvement of all
stakeholders, and in particular people
with disabilities and the organisations
representing them, in all activities and at
all levels, is a key factor in success.
• Consult and ask for advice and feedback
and cooperate with all actors in the field.
• Consult with and encourage active
participation by organisations
representing people with disabilities
as well as people with disabilities
themselves. This would require a
proactive policy, which would imply
examining consultation mechanisms
to ensure that people with disabilities
can participate and implementing non-
discriminatory practices and affirmative
action, e.g. extra funding to support extra
costs whenever they exist.
Further information on the national councils
on disability as well as other relevant
organisations in the disability field in Europe
is available on the European Disability Forum
( EDF ) website at http : /  / www.edf-feph.
org / en / welcome.htm

60

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int260 60 10/09/07 13:04:30


IV. Conclusions

Is it possible for any organisation to take Secondly, as a result of this lack of


into consideration and integrate people with understanding and awareness, it is difficult
disabilities and disability issues into their for organisations to identify and apply
structures and activities ? The answer is actions that implement the disability
YES. And by doing so, they can enormously mainstreaming approach and it is therefore
contribute to the full integration of people of complicated to document what is being
disability without changing their objectives or done, particularly in certain areas, which is
areas of work. why the information in some sections is more
comprehensive than in others.
This is the key message that we wanted
to transmit through this Guide. We hope Thirdly, mindful of the complexity of the
that the practical guidelines outlined give disability field and the fact that people with
you ideas on how to do so. There are many disabilities are not a homogeneous group,
ways to integrate people with disabilities the definition of guidelines that cover all types
and disability issues into the structures and of disabilities is a key challenge. Therefore,
activities of an organisation. Although some although these guidelines aim to consider all
are more specific and difficult to implement, types of disabilities and a wide array of issues
others can be set up quite easily with of importance for everyday life, it is impossible
minimal cost and effort. If it is not possible to take into account all the specificities of
to implement the most complex changes any type of disability and to anticipate every
or at least not immediately, do not hesitate eventuality. Thus, we are aware that these
to phase in these changes ; you can start guidelines are not fully exhaustive : they do
testing little changes and then move forward. not cover all possible situations and not all
guidelines will be applicable to every type of
Complementing these guidelines, the disability. It is also important to highlight that
case study examples clearly illustrate how some types of disabilities are more difficult to
several Social Economy enterprises and perceive from the outside and should not be
organisations are already promoting this underestimated and further efforts should be
approach, in many cases in partnership with made to take them into account.
other stakeholders. They are developing
and / or supporting initiatives in the areas Finally, we should not forget that an approach
covered in the publication – employment, based on the mainstreaming of disability
should not exclude disability-specific actions,
education and training, goods and services,
which are also necessary and for certain
health care, leisure activities, financial
persons with disabilities, essential.
services and funding and housing – as well
as in other areas, for example in promoting In this context, we consider this publication
mainstreaming of disability issues in policies to be an additional contribution in this
or empowering people with disabilities. process. We hope that it serves to raise
awareness on the issue and to encourage
However, the different challenges
reflection on how to improve the integration
encountered during the development of this
of people with disabilities and disability
publication showed that there is much more
issues in society as a whole. We hope that
room for action and improvement regarding
the guidelines and examples will give ideas
the mainstreaming of disability.
to organisations that have not tried this
Firstly, much more effort is needed to approach yet and will help organisations
raise awareness and understanding of already applying it to better understand what
the definition and implications of the term they are doing and encourage them to share
“mainstreaming”. this with other organisations.

61

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int261 61 10/09/07 13:04:30


The key is to try to look at each of the
different elements of the organisation
( working environment, training policy,
activities, labour relations, etc. ) and the
activities carried out and / or supported
from the disability standpoint, and from
the outset whenever possible. Check if all
elements recognise, respect, and meet the
needs of people with disabilities – whether
employees, customers or users – and if they
provide the same opportunities to all citizens.
It is also essential to consult and involve
people with disabilities and the organisations
representing them at all stages. They are
the real experts in this field and the ones
that can provide you the best support to get
involved in this area. And do not forget, the
challenge is to remember to be inclusive !

62

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int262 62 10/09/07 13:04:30


1. Employment

List of resources

This section includes selected documents con Discapacidad (CERMI), 2006. .


and reference materials consulted in the http://www.cermi.es/
writing of this publication. Space limitations 11. Employment. A practical guide to the
prohibit a full listing of all the valuable law and best practice for employers
resources consulted during the entire – London: United Kingdom Disability
process of drafting this guide. Rights Commission, 2005. .
1. Access for All. Helping to make http://www.drc-gb.org/
participatory processes accessible for 12. European Social Fund in action:
everyone – London: Save the Children success stories – Brussels: European
UK (SC), 2000. http://www.crin.org/ Commission, irectorate-General for
2. Advancing equality: What can Employment, Social Affairs and Equal
foundations do? – A selected overview of Opportunities, 2006. .
equal opportunities actions – Brussels: http://ec.europa.eu/
European Foundation Centre (EFC), 2007. 13. Fairness in Funding – An Equal
http://www.efc.be/ Opportunities Guide for Grant-Makers/
3. Breaking down the barriers. Social Roland Doven and Fiona Ellis. – London:
Housing for People with disabilities – Association of Charitable Foundations
Brussels: European Liaison Committee (ACF), 1995. http://www.acf.org.uk/
for Social Housing (CECODHAS), 2003. 14. Getting there – a practical resource for
http://www.cecodhas.org/ arts venues in Scotland to increase the
4. Combating discrimination, a training inclusion of disabled people/ ADA inc.-
manual – Brussels: European Edinburgh: Scottish Arts Council, 2005.
Commission, Directorate-General for http://www.scottisharts.org.uk/
Employment, Social Affairs and Equal 15. Good Signs- Improving Signs for People
Opportunities, 2005. http://ec.europa.eu/ with a Learning Disability – London:
5. Comunicación para todos – Madrid: United Kingdom Disability Rights
Grupo Telefónica & Comité Español Commission (DRC), 2004. .
de Representantes de Personas con http://www.drc.gov.uk/
Discapacidad (CERMI), 2005.. 16. Guidelines for Equal Status Policies in
http://www.cermi.es/ Enterprises /Turlough O’Sullivan, Niall
6. Cross-Currents in the Mainstream: Crowley, David Begg. – Dublin: The Irish
Including Disability in Foundation Equality Authority, 2005. .
Funding Priorities – Midlothian, Virginia: http://www.equality.ie/
Disability Funders Network (DFN), 2004. 17. Guidelines on Equality and Diversity
http://www.disabilityfunders.org/ Training in Enterprises/Niall Crowley,
7. Disability and Social Exclusion in the David Begg. – Dublin: The Irish Equality
European Union. Time for change, tools Authority, 2004. http://www.equality.ie/
for change. Final study report/Brussels- 18. Hacia un turismo para todos – Madrid:
Consortium led by the European Comité Español de Representantes de
Disability Forum (EDF), 2003. . Personas con Discapacidad (CERMI),
http://www.edf-feph.org/ 2003. http://www.cermi.es/
8. Disability and social participation in 19. Independent Living- choosing where and
Europe/European Communities, 2001. who you live with (Easy Read) – London:
9. Disability, inclusion and development: United Kingdom Disability Rights
key information resources/London: Commission (DRC), 2007. .
Source and Handicap International, http://www.drc-gb.org/
2006. http://www.asksource.info/ 20. La discriminación por razones de
10. Discapacidad y asistencia sanitaria/Luis discapacidad en la contratación de
Cayo Pérez Bueno. – Madrid: Comité seguros/Luis Cayo Pérez Bueno. – Madrid:
Español de Representantes de Personas Comité Español de Representantes de

63

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int263 63 10/09/07 13:04:31


Personas con Discapacidad (CERMI), 2004. . General for Employment, Social Affairs
www.cermi.es and Equal Opportunities, 2005. .
21. Mainstreaming disability within EU http://ec.europa.eu/
employment and social policy. Working 32. The CEP-CMAF and the European Year
paper/Brussels: European Commission, of Equal Opportunities for All – Brussels:
Directorate General Employment, Social European Standing Conference of
Affairs and Equal Opportunities, 2006. Co-operatives, Mutual Societies,
http://ec.europa.eu/ Associations and Foundations (CEP-
22. Making access to goods and services CMAF), 2003. http://www.cepcmaf.org
easier for disabled customers: A practical 33. Time for equality at work. Global
guide – London: United Kingdom report under the follow-up to the ILO
Disability Rights Commission (DRC), Declaration on fundamental principles
2004. http://www.drc-gb.org/ and rights at work – Geneve: International
23. Making Change Possible. A Practical Labour Organization (ILO), 2003. .
Guide to Mainstreaming / Brussels: http://www.ilo.org/a
European Commission, Directorate- 34. United Kingdom Disability Rights
General for Employment, Social Affairs Commission (DRC) – London: United
and Equal Opportunities, 2005. . Kingdom Disability Rights Commission
http://ec.europa.eu/ (DRC), 2003 http://www.drc-gb.org/
24. Manifesto for Inclusion – Edinburgh: 35. We are all unique and yet more alike than
Inclusion Scotland, 2005. . we imagine/ Lena Udd. – Stockholm:
http://www.inclusionscotland.org/ SIOS (Coperation Group for Ethnical
25. Manifiesto por un Ocio Inclusivo – Associations in Sweden), 2005. .
Madrid: Cátedra Ocio y Discapacidad http://www.epda.eu.com/
Estudios de Ocio Deusto, ONCE, 36. Yo también digo 33. Programa para
Fundación ONCE y CERMI, 2003. . el apoyo y la mejora de la atención a
http://www.discapnet.es/ personas con discapacidad intelectual
26. Manual de Trabajo en Equipo – Madrid: en el ámbito de la salud. Project
Fundación ONCE and Fundosa Grupo, final report/Javier Muñoz Bravo and
2002. María Marín Girona. –Madrid: Centro
de Psicología Aplicada, Universidad
27. Manual for Funders- Addressing the Autónoma de Madrid, 2004. .
Rights and Requirements of People http://www.fg.uam.es/
with Disabilities in the Funding Process/
London: United Kingdom Disability 37. You Can Make a Difference: Improving
Rights Commission (DRC), 2001. . hospital services for disabled people –
http://www.drc-gb.org/ London: United Kingdom Disability
Rights Commission (DRC), 2005. .
28. Organising Accessible Events – London: http://www.drc-gb.org/
United Kingdom Disability Rights
Commission (DRC), 2004. . 38. Various resources. European Agency for
http://www.drc-gb.org/library/ Development in Special Needs Education. .
http://www.european-agency.org/
29. Our Rights, Our Choices: meeting the
39. Various resources. European
information needs of black and minority
Commission. http://ec.europa.eu/
ethnic disabled people/London: United
Kingdom Disability Rights Commission 40. Various resources. European Disability
(DRC) and Centre for Education in Racial Forum (EDF). .
Equality in Scotland (CERES), 2004. http://www.edf-feph.org/en/welcome.htm
www.drc-gb.org 41. Various resources. Inclusion Europe
30. Serving the Community/Niall Crowley, practical guidelines. .
Tara Buckley.–Dublin: The Irish Equality http://www.inclusion-europe.org/
Authority and RGDATA, 2004. . 42. Various resources. The Irish Equality
http://www.equality.ie/ Authority. http://www.equality.ie/
31. The business case for diversity. Good 43. Various resources. Employers´ Forum on
practices in the workplace – Brussels: Disability. .
European Commission, Directorate- http://www.employers-forum.co.uk/

64

EFC_MainstreamingDisability_int264 64 10/09/07 13:04:31


Creating an inclusive society:
Mainstreaming disability
based on the Social Economy example
A publication by the European Standing Conference of Co-operatives,
Mutual Societies, Associations and Foundations (CEP-CMAF)
in cooperation with the European Disability Forum (EDF).

The CEP-CMAF is the EU-level representative organisation for the Social Economy.
Social Economy represents 10% of all European businesses, which equals two million
businesses employing more than nine million workers, or in other words, 10% of
all jobs. The CEP-CMAF aims to give Social Economy organisations better visibility
on issues which are common to them at a European level with a view to gaining
recognition for the Social Economy as a sector that produces both economic and
social wealth; promoting the role and values of the social economy actors throughout
Europe; and reinforcing their political and legal recognition at European level. For
further information, please visit www.cepcmaf.org

European Standing Conference of Co-operatives, Mutual Societies,


Associations and Foundations (CEP-CMAF) Copyright © 2007.

Edition : European Foundation Centre (EFC)


Design and printing : Edition & Imprimerie, Brussels, Belgium

EFCCover3_CS3.indd 2 11/09/07 8:14:19

You might also like