. : phe ay COOLIDGE ARCHIBALD © C CAABHOE 0603 COJEPAKABIE: L—CAOB O BhICOKOMPEOCBAMEHHALO AMMUTPIA, : CEKOMA HPOC.-IABCKALO Ml POCTOBCKALO, Bb CKOH HA K-LAABUUICE IEPKBI M—HANYTCTBEHHOE Ci0v0 Kb ORONYNRAW IM BOCHHTAHHUILAMS WHCTUTYTH. Coam WK. Mp HL—HO’OMEHIE BOMOCAOBCKOM HAYRI BT PEPM! YHHBEPCHTETAX®. llpor. 8. il. /|—aro. IV.-KH3Hb H VUEHIE BOTOMMIOBE MO MAHOU 3HTABEHA H J.PYTUMD UCTOYHNKAMD. Ip. V.-KHHIH CEKKE ,E(MNCTBO @13H4ECKIXD OM JEHDUM BATCKATO W3 Aart BA MA PYoCKOM! A @. PoayGuncnaro- YL—10 HOBOLY MUCCIOHEPCTRA HA ONY. A. th i ¥—COBPEMBHHOE ObO3PSHIE: ona cenie ney cen: pone MX SAK OWN MA MPOTECTAUTORDXY yoL—usBECTIA 3 AMBTEH. 1X_3ATHCKA ATAHHAA Bb OBIMEMD COBPAHIN BEPCKATO OBMUIECTBA 11 MAM 1875 10,LA. BD -UPUIOREATH: A =CBATON RocTOUHO NEPRBIE yworort T if NEPRBI | eae AAEE CABDPIIICKIA: raana IV, ¥. MOOKRA eo BFESTCEOR ronorpapin (KATKORS it pr yuu? 8 Crpactnows Gyiovaph, BeO DPOLOJIKEHIM HW3 AHI IPABOCAABHATO Ob0SP BHU ae Bb 1875 TOL nods pedaxuieo ceay. I. Ilpeotpaacexcrai. «fIpasocaasnoe OGospbuie» ue 1875 roxy wuagaerca uo opexueii nporpamwb, wb Tomb Me Hanpasaenin, Kawkb Masa- BaOCh LOCeAG Bb TeveHin HATHAANATH AST, nH npn coxbiicTRin ThXb MC COTPYAVUKOBS, UMeHA KOTOPHIX BCTPHiaanch Ba CTpa- HniaXb aToro ®ypuasa. Bb 1875 roay «Uparocaasnoe Oooapbuie» BbixonTh exe- “mbequmo, KoAKAMN Orb 12 HeyaTanIXb ancToBD u 6o.Tbe. lloqunenan whna: 6 p. 50 kK. BH POAs,—a Cb JOCTABKOIO Ha AOMD Bb Mocks’ w uepectiaxoi Ww apyrie ropoga 7 p. ¢. Moguucnaa hua Ch «YRasarereuby 3a OANMHAMNATh ABTS 8 p. C. OMMNCKA UpHuNMaerca: Bb Mockeb, Bb peqakuin aYpHaaa, up Wepkem Oeogopa Cryquta y UuKurcKuxe soporb, jom> CRAM. Tl. HpeoOpancneraro,—u yy BCBND. N3BBCTHHIXD KHNTONPOLABLERS Bb Mocks’ u Uerep6yprs. Huoropoguue CaarososaTb agpecopatsca Ch cBouMH TpeGonaniavn ucKaONNTeADHO TaKS: Bs pegaKnito ypasocaasuaro OGosphuin* wp Mocks. floanbie oxsemnanppi «[Mpasocaasnaro OGoapbuia» 3a npemnie TOA MOMUO HOAYIATH UO CABAYIONNUMS COMMANDING Whuaws; 1861, 1862, 1863 2 1864 rogbi—no 2 py6. Geab nepecpiaKn, 1865, 1866 1 1869—no 3 py6. Gea uepectisku, 1867, 1868 u 1871 no 4 py6. 6ea% nepectiaxu, 1870, 1872, 1873 1 1874— no 3 py6. Gea nopectiakn, a 3a 4eTbIpHadnaTh aba 1861— 1874—copows nam pyGaeii. Wbua Yeasateaa «b «lI pasocaas- Bomy Ooospbuiw» 3a oxmadnaT abib 1860—1870 rr., Gesp Hepecbiakn 75 &., cb uepechiaKoii 1 p. Bsinmuctipaionee «flpa- pocaasnoe O6oapbaie» 3a Bch npemuie ros! noayaaoTh Yra- satoab Cesnsatno. Ha nepecbiaky opaaaraerca 3a Kawi ro- Losoii 9x3. 3a 6 ©., a. 3a 14 bre ch YRazateanwb—aa 80 oyn- TOBb—NO0 pascronnito. Ome Mockew sa xancdud giynms nocviaors co Kuuiamu \ esumaemcn: AGo 12 x. Anwoam 18 18 mss; Acxpharaain ad cx. ee ae TO terete: IeeeCAOBO BHCOKODPEOCBAMEHHSHIIATO AUMHTPIZ, APXIEDHCKONA SPO- CLABCKATO H POCTOBCRATO, IPOH3HECEHHOE 23 MAA CETO roa, Bb AEHb UAMATH CBATHTEIA POCTOBCKATO 4EOHTI4, B'b APO- CAABCROM JEOHTIEBCKON, ITO HA KIAIBUINS, EPRBH. Kags 8a yxazeno 970 MBCTO DOKOM ymepWHXD OTb AANIa EBBIXS, HO OHO LOMMHO OBITh OaMsKO CepANy KawAaro wsb Jace, Gpatie won. He y kamyaro aH SABCh OTe HAR MATE, Gpars BAm CeCTpa, ChIAS HH Low, CpoxAMAD HIB Apyrs? Aras B® moGos, DA0TCKas, TAME DaGe AiOOOBS AYXOBHAS HEBOALHO BAC- YOTS KABTO BE 9TO MBCTO NOKOA BAMIARS NPHCHBIXD HW CpOX- Sinoss. Ms me opaGasHs &B ceMy, 370 nocbmenie cero mE- AuTya WeptsHxs opavecers cyrySyi ooOsbsy AyOTAMD BAMTBMS. BxBCb BSI MOMeTS MOABTBEHAO GSOChAOBATS Cb CBOWMA UPNCHBTAM, w6o xora ofm Moptes! nAdtiw, HO RAELI XyXoMs, oTOMy “tO apers Botows mtd sch mubb!, H-ROCLA Me Moaniicd O Bux @&bcb, ORB ome yceprate m ropavfe ‘MOARYCA © Hach TaMD. S3xbep Me WoMeTS CABIMATS A NOYIATeABADHInie ypoRW 144 MABHH, &6o Kaxb HB GesMossHsi, NOBAIHMOMy, MepTBbIe, HO OBB TOBO- paTS spachophiashe a yOngnTeabASe, HeKen MOMEMD CEa- BaTh BAS MBI CAa6bIe H CRYAHbIC CAOBOMb—NPONOBSAGHRA. Grows rosopits vams ymepmie? Tosopars ycrama Amoctosa: Ke MOOUME Mipa, HU ROWE os Mipm: awe KmO antume mips, wneme s066e Omi os nem. Hxo ece exce 60 Mipn—noxom naomenan, nocdmr ovecs u ropdocmd weumeticnan: u mips 22338 S * * TIPABOCYABHOEOUBOSPMIRE. © TT npexodums % noxoms evo, a meopait Goa Booctw npebusaems eo enxs. [ocmorpate Ha nach. Manie 13% Hacb 064a401n MyApO- cio D03HaHiaMA: YMBAH HBMBpaATh Teyenie sBb3I% H ABARe- Hie BSTPOBS, H3CABOBAAH BCe OTS HCCONA NO KeApa AHBAHCKAO, 3HaIA BCO, ITO He TOABKO Ha 3eMIb, HO A DOAb seMselo BH BO rayOHHaX’ MOpA, ITO ObIAO H 3TO eCH Bb Mipb.—Cupocute me Xb: ITO DpHHeCla BMD BCA HXD wyapocts? Samutaza AH BXB ors cmepTH? Mocrasaza 18 peas Boroms? Onpapaaza aH Ha cyx Ero? Cauckara 15 WM Rub BEIByIO? Hraxb n MyApOCTS H nosHania—Geas Bbptl auBOH HM ChacaTesbHO, Geb Cxaro- yectia HCKPeCHHALQ, 6e3b xHBHH Soroyroqnoi—cyera cyerctBili. Maorie oTangaaach HOVCCTAMA, 3aHHMaIH BaRAbIA MBbCTA Bb O6- Wectsb, oOreIeHbI 6bIAH HeMaOO BAACTiN, BMBAH Binnie Ha HeMaabili Epyrb CBOHX® coOpaTiil; cnpocute Re KOTO yTOAHO H3B HEXB: YTO DOMOrsa HMB BCA BXB wipcraa BaRHOCTS UPH cmepTa? SamuTHsa aH OTS Ooxbsnel w CTpadanii ThaecHbIXt, OTS yma- cosh mw TOMAeHIA Ayxa? [parotopaaa 1m BM XpuCTiaHCEYy!0 KOB- "RHY ®HBOTA, CesGoxbsHenHy, HeNOCTAIARY, MAPHY # AOGpbIit OTBBTB Ha CYA’. XpHCTOBOMB? — H OHH CRAMYTb Rab: yBBI, CMepTh He yBamexa Balle sHaTHOCTH, cpaBaadaa HaCb, Ch Ca- MBIMH DOCXSABHMH H3% DOAYHHCHEBIXD HAM, H eCABGLI He Ba- Koii-1860 KaMeHb, BbI HO OTAHSHAR Obl Hae MOTHAD OTS EXD woraxs. Hrasp novecta # oramuia wipcria — Geass cuupenia & ctpaxa Bomia, 6e35 Gaarovectia m A06poabrTesH, Ges Oxaro- Teopwaro caymenia 6aHmRwMb—cyeTA CyeTcTBii.—Muorie 06za- 348 OOAMINMH CTAMAHIGMH, AAA Bb NPOCTPAHABIXS # GoraTo YEPAMOHBEIXG WadaTAXd, HACLAMARANCh BCMS, ITO MOMETD-LATb HACTOaMad MH3Hb AAA HacaamAenia yexoBhEA. Cupocute me H BX: 310 B3AXH OHH Cb CO6OW B3b BCBXS CBOMXS CORPOBHMTE? Yro NOAbsbI AyMaMb HXb OT BCBXS yAOBOABCTBIH H YTBXB DAOTCERXE? VW oBW CRaRYT BAM: HATH MBI BHIMAH H3b YTPOO MatepHeil, Hara H BOBBpaTHAHCh BS YTPOOy BeMIH; CMepTb OT- Haxa y HACb BCe, W Telleph KOCTH WalIH TakRe TOA Bb MO- THX, RAKB H KOCTH NocabAnaro ObxuaKa. Yama yxosoasctoill MipCRAXS DpespaTHAach Lid Bach BB Yallly Topectn H CTpata-COBO HA RAAABROIS. 3a AyXB cumpenis a opesannocta goss Bomiell, ws ayxs epotocts § TepHbais; KTO, OTBEpraach BETXALO IeAOBSEA Cb ABABHMB CFO, HOUApaeTh # yrauiaeTs Bb CeOB DACTCKIa BORACASHIa H CTpACTU: toTh BoHgeTs 2a Xpacrows a Bs Ero caapy: awe 60 cs Huns « pass Ero cmpaacdems, cs Hums w npocaacumca, ropopats cB. ADOCTOAs; ame xmo HM Cayscums, roBOpuTS cams Toc- DO, xm Ja nocandcmeyems, u udnace ecms Ass, my % cay~a mot Cydems. Kto saupoTaBh HAeTS DYTeMS CaMoyromse- ais, 000saRaeTs CBORMG CTpaCTAM H OOXOTAMS, RABETE DI0- Tito, @ HC AYXOMS: TOT Oms nAomuU noacHEms UCmanHie H HA- cxbayeTb axs. Kro ne aapnipacTh Bb seMal0 AanHaro eMy Bo- Tomb Talauta, HO TPYAHTCA HW ROBABARIBACTE eFO BO CAaBy Ho- wil, 448 Oxara CBOWXS OABMBHXS; ETO CTapaeTca O6oraTHTb ce6a OsarHMA XbAQMH BBP! H Ozarovectia, 100BA M MBAOCEP- Xid, DPaBABI H AOGPOABTeAM, TOTS YCANMIRTh B3b YCTb CBOeTO Toenoga: do6pn, pave Orarit u enpuei, 0 Maan OGuas ecu empens, nads MHOWMU mA NoCMasaH;, EHUdG 6% padocms I'oc- noda ceoero. Kro alpOTHBS DPOBOARTS MasHb CBOIO Bb Npasi- WocTa, 8b HeOpemenin 0 AbAAXD CROeTO BBaHid H BEIBOMS Cla- ceHim AyMH; RTO yootpeOaaeTs, xaBAbla emy Boroms, cuabl A CpegcTBa TOABKO Ha TO, YTOOBI NOLOGHO yooMMAAeMOMY BD EBan- Tesiu Gorasy, BCTb, OTh H BECeAWTBCE, TOMY HapeieHs yRe tpoamwil oparosops Cyzia mipa: wexmowmaro paba seepsume 60 muy KpOMMUHIO; my Cydems naate u cKpeacems ay6o62, Korza soiljems pb xpaMs cel mu cTaHem cpexd ero, Ha- HOMES, BOStOGAeRHEIH, CaMOMy CeOB: BOTS COA BPHHECYT) H @AbCb MOCTABATD w MOH TpO6s, Bb KOTOPOM® OyxeTh ACHATh GeaAsixanHoe Moe TAO, KOrMa AyOla MOM GyseTS ye Bb Apy- toms mips w opeactaners cyay Xpacropy. Caataa nepxoss upu- ¥erp HB MeHA BD OCpsTIA watepHelt 41068q cRoel: pd ysHaeTD 4M 08a RO MBS CBOerO ChIBa, KOTOPATO Oba OMA, OCRATHIA H oupasAasa Bb TaHCTBS cB. Kpemenia, KoToparo m no naxeuia TpBxosgoM MBOTORpaTAO OOHORAGIA mM NpHMBpSsxa Cb UpaBocy- ews Bominws 5p tadgcres ce. noxaania, poToparo uutasa Gea- cMepraowm UANeO maBoTRopamaro saa u Kposm Xpactosol,342 HPABOCIABHOE O603PSHIE. cna6rbpasa Xapawa Ceataro Jlyxa Bowia, roroppili nocemy 201~ Reus Oblth GCTS, CBAT u HenOporeHs npexs Boroms? Ona UpAaOBeTS BCSXS OPHCYTCTBYIOMUXS BS Xpaw'S Eb UpAzemuol MOANTBS O [ym MoH: HO GyAyTb Opatia MoM, CpexH KOTOPEIX®. MpOReIS A KUBHb CBOW, OYAYTS JH OHH BMBTS BRYTpPeHHee N0- Symaeuie BosHeCTH O MHS ycepguyo MosHTBy KO Orny HeGec- HoMy, CorpBrylo TenA0K BO MHS s1GoBil0o? He GyxyTb aM Ha- UpoTHeD HMBTb OPWIHHI CBTOBATL WH OAAKATbCA Ha MeHA OpPerb Boroms? Oua, cpataa MaTepb Mog, H CaMa COTBOPHTS 0 MES UpH- 4A@#®HOC MOACHIG CBOe Kb Bory AYXOBb H Bcakig DAOTH, a MH- JocTaBs OyleTs Oab Eb CMBpeHHOM Ayorb Moe Ha CyAB-cBO- eM}; HO GyLy JH A JOCTOHHS aTOH MHAOCTH; He OKARYCh AW’ 10- CTOHSEIMS OAHOTO THBBA HW OCymAeRIa?—ITO GyneTS He CyB eAOBBICCEIH, NPeAS KOTOPBIMS MHOTO@ MOMHO CKPbITS H YTAHTb, a cyab Bora—cepanestana, KoTopbiii BAJHTS He TOABKO 151A, Q H MBICAH, H ®esania Hw AaMbpenia MoH, KOTOpBIH useedems Ha Conms matinaA mMb uw OBsasUms coemmu cepdernue. Bce, Bb TOMB HA COPpSIIHAS A HE TOABEO ABAOM HAH CAOBOMS, HO H YMOMS H CepANeM CBOHMS, OTS AbaBia NOpowaro XO caoBa Opasqaaro H OTS MOMBICAA AYKABarO 10 yeaamaenia w BomIerb- Bia BeqACTaro,—BCe GyxeTb OOABYEHO H OCYRACHO CYAOMS Upa- BeAHbIMD H HeAMNenpiaTALIMS. He SamlaTHTD MeHA OTB cTporocry Cyla cero HHRaKOe HaBHHenie, He UPHRPOeTS BHKAKAM AHIHHA anqembpis; upeas ovamn Beesagamaro oca na1a Ww OOsAsaeHa; Dpexs cyxoms scessrymaro Cysim aHnTO @ HMGTO He yRPOeTB BuHoBHaro. Tedeps, i0Ka anepm MOKaAaHia OTBEpCTEI, OOpaTicE, ayme Mod, E> DoRaauilo; Tenepb, NoKa BpeMa Aoaroteprbuia Bo- wig He npeRpaTaaocs, NocuSmB ABMBITS H YOBABTS PHabl CBOW cxesama cospymenia cepxesnaro, aa Bansenta BB septors Xpa— cross. Aye ‘ Moa, ayiue “Mos, socraHH, 470 comme? Koxené. UpuOaWmaeTca WH BMAIIH cuyturaca; Bocupaau y6o, aa noma aur ta Xpdcrocs Bors. Koraa Syxere xoqnTs Mexty MOrHzaua YCOUMEX®' Spartit » Ba- TIRX, BenloManTe 0 tom, 410 BxBCb norpesbani ‘Oyxems' @ Hanis rpo6s onyctars ‘Bb Mormay W' 3dcbIUAIOTS seme, &GJORO BA BEAIBEOES. Bad Waxb way BOSBEICATCA seMASHO XOsMb—ZOCTOHADH naMaTAAES yesosbyeckoH Gpeanecta. [payers 18 neckruTs Hemly MotEry MWoOanyiit Hach VeAOBbES HW NOMAHOTE 1H HACh Cb GOI BB moms cBoe# npeas Boros? Ham tomsco npsaxani noctra- TeXb KAAOWM[A PABHOAYOMHO . OpOHAeTS -MAMO 04, He ANGOMMT- Crs0RaBB Jame ySHaTb, KTO Uorpedent sb Hel? isn me Ho-DpE- ACTS H HHETO, 1 Mby OYAOMS AOMATS BABCh OAUH 10 LBA CTpAMe waro cyxa Bomia, u camaa uaMatTh 0 HAC WOrAalRTCA MERAY EBYOAMH, H CaMAH MOTHAA “HAMla, CPOBBRBINHCK Ch BeMzeN, CKBAAGTCA COSbUNEHHO Bh PRY APYCHXS GOSLAMOHBLING MOTHRE? Ho sbrs, wbI de Gyxemb 3a0bITH! cBATOIO TepROBIW, ROTOPAR 6y+ AeTb XO KORUA BRA MOIHTECK HO HAC BMBCTS CO BCBME SAB xemammuue.:Hact we eadyaers ackyuusnrii Hact Cece -KpOBilN Tocnoas wanrs Incycs Xpuerocs: opixxers act, KOr,a H MBI CO BCBME CYHIHMM BO-Fpo6Bxs ycabimuyS raace Craa Boia H YCALIMaBmH omBReNS. Torga mannioe cie absevemcn 68 HE- mannie % chepmuoe cic obscvemca 6 Cescmepmic. Torla-TO orepoetes BO BCeM> BemBTiA H CxaBb cBoel napeTsio’ Bora # o6mcth Xpacra Ero; roraa pce 320e, Hempiasmensoe, BpamAcd- Hoe Baws GyJeTb M3THAHO: H YOpaseMeHO B DOCASABiH Bpars Hall} ECHPASHHICH—CMEPTL; morda npascdnuHu NpPOCERMAR- CA AKO coaHYye.eo Yapcmeiu Omya urs B omumems Focnods ScaKy CAcsy OMS ONO -—BXS, BEB CHOPS SéMHBIA HE TOMEBYTOR Me TOMY, A ONNA sriMHaA PadocmM-nads Ieacanu urs bydems. Ke COMY-10 CEBTACMY)::BHTHO palocTHoMy,: ABWHO . OAAMCHHOMY. TOP- BOCTBY 38 YETPAMASOTCA. BEC YH’ H CepANO: BABS OTL CyeTe Bcero BeMHard'H Bpemesmaro. Tals SOTBAHOe OTeNeC7EO BANE, TAN BCG CORPOBHMIG.cepAGA BAMCFO, TAMS..BECh’ REBOTS Hats coxposes .co:'X pucromh..Bb Boss: eeepc Moe ~ Korga waxonent»6yzeve ‘nepspamathos eteloxa Bb C8OH som, Tak pasmbimxsiize . ch CaMHME ¢o6ew:) J0ar0.:an:ome Tocnor, HOUYCTETS. ‘HANS.XOAATH:DONVTOMY ‘NYT W DOSBPAMPATLCA HAsoKS BS Pb OPOHBRS RABEL)! COTOPLIA: MEL HASHIM CBOWME.(20- 3AM, 2 KOTOPLIN B4.COMOME: ABIES CYTE TORLKU BPOMCEABLA IPR Cranehgas ie. OYTH sweeornat? |‘cRoper AM HavtaBeT :70TS TemeSk DPABOGHABMOR OSOGPRILE. ROrka Mbl He OoMem> yms CaMH, @ DOHCCYTh MCh OAH H ocyasatb 3X%cb Hasceria? Ho ators, wems6bmanli jaa sact, xeub Tocnoss cORpslId OTS Hach Bb Tall’ csoero Bomectsea- HALO BCORSABAIS, 2 HAMS SaMOBhAaTd OBITS FOTORAME Bb STOTS Rocasyaii ny Hams coxa Ha Bcakoe Bpewa. Bors noveny OBSTAA HepEORb BaOBbAasa HaMb KARIN Beeps MOSETECE Tocnozy: Baaatizo sesopbrosm6se, neymeau MAS OApD cel TpoOb GyzeTb? HAW CMe OnAgBHyIO OW AyHy OpOcesTamE Xmema? Ce Mu rpe6b hpekiemarb, ce MA CMePTh UPeACTOETS. Towno mpeactonrs, Gpatie MoH, a60,. Kaxb HH OpoAoAmaiire Bb MBICAMXS RHBAE CBOlO, HO 608% CoMmbEiA yHe BLIPOCAR ApeRa, 48% KOTOPSIXD CADAAOTS HAMD [pods, B 4aCh CMepTH—OIBBKO 4H, HAIOHO AH OH—HOCTHTHETS BACB, KOTRA HO ORMAACME: He oncme 60 dHE NM YaCa, 63 Ons awe Coins YeAoeRuECKI® npiu- dems; cero padu u ew Oydume y6o rwomocu Ha scaKs %a08, TARR yOmgaeTS Hach caw Tocnogs. Bysews rorophi BO Bca- ROO BPM OCYAaBUTL BCE SOMHOe H BPeMeHHOS, PABAYIATECA CO BCBMb, ITO 88 AOPOTOe NOAMTAWTS JKT, TEMS YCAAMAAWTCA H Yrsmawrca Bo spema seunol csoell musHH; 1a He DPMCTPACTHY- Ch Cepage Halle BA ES Tomy TABHBOMY, ITOOD m CAMO He Ha- Oxhyonas0 tabuis. Busnaume ove cefm, rosopurs Tocuoss, 0a Ne KoLdG OmAIWaIOms copdua eau ObsRdenieNs 1% BiAKCMGONE U MetaAMe sUMetCKUNU, U eNesaNy Hatidems na ov dexd 10%; CyXeMS BCerka TOTOR aBETLCA’ Ha HeGh, BE Codops AE- ¥OROBE H BCBKD CBATHIXS, A AI CeO HYRHO Bapawbe UpmBbI- HAT, BOIROCHTECA ‘YHOMD H CepaneMs cBomme roph—eb Bory, BTS AYXONS Bb OOHTeARXt Oma HeSecwaro, HCRATh setururs, udnace ecms Xpucmocs, odecuyw Bora ends, ropmas MYAPSTBO- Bath, a He 3eMBaa. Byzem> roross! wa Bcaxiit sach mpexcraTs ¢spamuony cyzy Bomiw # xatb orsers scessaymemy Cyain BO BObXD DOMBUTTACHig1S, C2ODAXE H AHAB HAMIRX;.A AAA COLO HOROOMO XPAHBTS COSRCTS CBOKO. YHCTONW OTS ASEb HOUPABAW H SessaKodiA WAH HO OWMMEATL W DPOCBDTAAT eC NCRPSHHNMS O- aashiows, yObaaTs pH3y AyOIE cBoed 8% KposH Arana, BanAae- wero Upexaze czomenia mipa. Korga ranues o6pasows-6yxeusCXOBO HA KYATSUIMS. 348 SeupecTaHHO DpWroToBAATs ceOA Kb HCXOLY, TO CMepTb, KOrAa i Oa HH OPHIsa Kb HAMS, He MOHETS yCTPAMINTS HACB; MBI Gyxews OMWAATE Os, KAT BOACABAHATO TOCTA, H CPBTHMS ce Kakb 1aBHO OMBAABHATO Apyra. [pagers au OHA Kb ROMY Bb crapocrs HAH By} gpanozgnonie qyel Hap H BS caMoll 1oHOCTH, OF} Cb Gxarogapedieys BOCHOOT cb spaperebyys Cumeonoms: nee omnyuwaemu pata Teoero, Baaduxo. Hens ocso6ox- MeHIb MCHA OTB 3% DACTH, BB EOTOpOH BO ABRATS £06N0e, #0 KERCTL WHS 3AK0Hs, NpOMUCYEOIOOUYS SaKONY YMG €MOEIO u RARKAINGS MA IGKOHOMS ADPROSHLMS, HBOABAREIIb MOHA OTS camo BosMomHOCTH ocKop6aaTs 1106085 Tsow rpSxame. Hen ACXNUMAeMIb MeHA B35 Mipa, BO BXB seRaMaro; waCasasellb OTS coOaasowb H NCHYMeHi#, OTS MipcKoi cyeTH # DOneveHiM mB- TOHCERXD, CPOAM KOTOPHIXS BAACTCA AYX’S MOH, FARE AAAbA, OCy- pesaemaz BosHama. HiinS npeBo_ums Mona 8b THXO@ DpACTA- mime sBaBnaro Teoero napcersa. Bossecy Ts, Bowe moi, api vol, 8 Oaaroczoba0 mua Ts0e 80 BLES H Bb BSE BhRa!— Crpamua pomcranny # y#acna CMepTb HCaMad MbICSS oO cMepTH TOMLEO Lis PPbUIEWKA HepacnasHHaro, AAA MipostoGna, OpHcTpa- CTmBmaroca Bcef AyOlelO H CepAleMs Kb BeMHLIMG CONPOBAMAMS 1B OXOTCKANS HACAAMAeHiNWS, yBaymarO BB ThM’ OOXoTeH H erpacreil. Paso xa mosqHo 1H Boszoners ero Tocnoab Ha cyAb cso, cueprs yxa Hero Bcerza 410Ta. AMBEB.| HANYTCTBEBHOR CHOBO. KB OKOHSHBAIOUIHMS KYPCh eee HMACTATYTA *). Yero, cxamute, yams nomeaate BaMb—Bb BUY xray, ommRaomed. teneps? Tomesaens, ecru yrogso, Baus apeuse cyactia Bb RU3EE, Bb TOMS YHCTOMS, XOTS BEMHUM®, CMBICAS, KAKOH MBI COCKHBACMS Cb cxoRoN> — cyactje. Ho mul Toro yObmxeRis, TO, npemAe H BEE BCCTO, MbI NOMA! MOMELATb BAM Bb ITY MAHYTY—CBATO HOHCCTH H COBCPINBTL Bb, RABHM TOTS BeaHRid H HEOTAOMApH AOATS Of, KAKOH Ha BCBXD..WACh BOBFATAeTS MESH! W6o sto takoe masse? Ha gto ona Jana YexOBbAy? d MbI BCS 3HaeMb, STO MABHb He CCT WSAb CaMa JAG COOd, HO 4TO, OBA @CTS CpeACTBO, LAHHOS HAM AAd JOCTAReHIA BHOL, BEIM €f DOAOMRCHHOH, WAH, ITO HO AAA TOTO MBBEMD MBI BCS, ITOOBI METS TOSDEO, HO ITOObI CBepHlaTh KAKLOMY Halle HAsHAqeHic Bb muaun. VM ato nasnaienie — MOReM> 3H MbI He aHaTb ero? He 4yBCTBYeMD AH MbI BS COB, BB aTOH ThaAccHOH xpaMHHh, HOCH- moi HaMH, OpHcytcrBie Ayxa, oOaTawmaro Bb Hacs? Mi Bp ray- OmHS cero AYXa He CBBTNTCA IH Bb RARAOMD H3b HACh CBATAT HCKpa A100BH EB AOAAMS, DHTAOMad H OCAaropoRuBaloMad AyXB? Yro CxBAOBATCABHO MBI JOAMAN ABAATS Bb RUBE, UPORAC W aCe *) Cuasago 3s nepxe MOCKOBCRATO BOCKNTATCIbHArO AOMA KS BOCEETAHEE- nams II negarormsecaro xzacca Huxoxaesckaro CEPOTCKArO HNCTETYTA, BS ACHE Bunycka mx3, 1875 roxa Maa 27 xBA.CIOBO RB BOCHBTABHATAMS. 347 Goxse cero? Bawcta a yconepmat, Bb ce6’ wamy xymy 6e3- cMepTHy!o, O6pass w nogoie Bb nach Bora, a BMBCTB CXY METS 6aary H caactiio Apyraxt aloset! Bors o6mee Bcbxb Hac, Be- Augoe i HeOTAOMAOe, HasHadeHie Bb RABHH! Bet ckakete, ITV OBO 1a8HO 3HaKOMO BAM, ITO HOYTH Cb TBXS MOPb, Kak BEI 3anOMeBTe ce6a, Bach BCerqa YEH 3HaTb CFO BH MOCTYHaTh 00 HeMy, H 9TO, CCAH BCO ABAO AASHH Bb TOMB, ITOOBI s;Cumd . do6po 8 Omaame dopo, To cxaBa Bory! ®msab ke Tak TpyAHa, KaKb ONMYTS HW TOBOPATS 06% Heil! Ho sbi eme we 3HaeTe, He HCObITAMH wmusHA. Mmoroe, BecbMa MHOFOe H3b TOPO, 170 CCT BB Hell, 3KBCb ObIAO CRPBITO OTD BACD. HKuswb, cuawy A BaMS, NOARA HCKyMeni#f wu coOsasHoBD! Bp RBBHA KAWMATS BW OyMywTs ctpacta aoe! Ber ysuquTe yacTO— TaMb, Kyla DoHyeTe CROPO OTb HaCb—H CyeTHOCTE, He 3HaNMy!0 rpanend, 8 Ce6aaloOie, He Hoxraratomee ce6b upexbsa,—yBalETS HEDOMBPBY!O POCKOM Cb OsHOH cTopouti, H BOiOMia HY RAB Cb Apyro#,—ropAOcTb H AWKOBaBie OABAXS, BCerAauAIOW CKOp6S H DpHBamenio ApyrAxs,—ysusuTe AOAeH, y KOTOPEIXD OAHa, HO SHalOMlad YCTAIB, 8a00TA BD RASHH, TOOK! KAKb MORHO Combine B TayORe YepnaTs Aad ceOA Ws MUSH OS BEMBLIXD YTBXB H Hacaamaenii, Bcerga 60 epéds CeO H APYCHN, H YACTO Ha cxems ceOa H APYrHXb, B BCE 9T0, KB TOMY Ke, BEI YBAATC Bb OOmM- mei yactn cBoed BCAYeCKH UpHKPAMeHHOe H HaMBpeHHO yEpEt~ T0e COA pashbiMH OxATOBABBINA HMeHAMB, RAKOBbI: CBOGOIA, Uporpeccs, CoppemennocTs H T. 0. Borb ma3Hb, KARb OA CCTS soo6me! Coraacutect Bb BHAY Cero, ITO MHOrO NOTpPeOyeTCa BaMS Bb AUSAW OUbItA H MYAPOCTH Aad TOrO, ITOOKI CoxpanuTh cobs 4HCTBINN CpéAR B8TOTO MOpA Ama BH COOrABHA, ‘o6ypepaiomaro MUBHD TOAOBBICCKY!O, ITO MHOTO TAS DOHAXOORTCA BalD ‘Tpyza, Gops6ni, Teprbaia 144 TOrO, ITOGI YCTOATE Bb STOMb BOXOBO- porB crpacteHl AIOACKAXS, MYTAINHXS Mm GaCTO BREpPXS HOMd CLABAIIAXS HAMTY AWSHS, KOLA BCC UPHTOMS BORPYb Bach Cy- Jerb crpemraasy ‘fecTach m uasaTS Bb Hero, Heme ObITS MO KCTS, naiiiyrca AOU, KOTOPHIG H BAC CaMHX% DOReAaWTS CTOAK- BYTS Bb Hero, M He' tio 3x06, a Tax, wyrs, A1a Badaper...348 OPABOCIABROE OBOSPSHIE. He ockopOutech, 470 4 rosoplo BaMb BCe aT0. A He Mors Te- eps ymoasats o cems. Kro cosopurs? ects 8% BEER, BOUPPRE BCeMy, 9TO MYTATS H DOPTATD e2, MHOTO M MHOTO cBBTAarO H otpagsaro! Ects TaMb, sya BbI DoliseTe OTE HaCb, AIOAE HCTHBEO MyApsie @ AOOpbie, A, YOOBACMS, HXD He Mad0, CMBAO MW HEYEAOH- HO wAyiyie Bb RAIHH NYTeM’ AoATa H YeCTH H BCWAY, Ha CeuS DYTH CBOeMb, asHaMesyomie ce6a AbsaMH UpaBAb! W MuxXOCepaial Ect, rogopw, 8% M3HM, KyAa Bl BAeTe, MBOTO Operpacubi- IIHXS H DOYIATEASESAMIAXS NpHMSPORD W aBseHi, KOTOPLIX>, GeschopHo, Me AACTD, RAM H He DOKAMCTS BaM> BAEAKAA MEOAA, 4 MUSH BS CoM OTHOMeHIN ECT, CaMad BBICMad M AyIMAG peBxt mgozal Ects gecomabago 8b KB3BH BCE ATO, M TbMS, CEa- BY, Obiaa Obl HASH, ecaa6s Bb sell we Ooizo coro? H mst me- #aeM_ H MOAHMD Bora, st06b1 Onb UpEBexb BACh BHAT H BE- AaTb BABE HMEHAO Cb STOM CTOPOb! e4,— AAT A BpaMaTeca Bb EPyry HMCHSO TARHXS AjoAe, ANSI A BALSTS Opexd COCOIO WaeCHHO Takie OPHMBpes, ITOCKI RHBHD Bb ABHCTBATCABHOCTH ObI- 4a J4a Bach He BanyraBaome wu MepTBAMel AyXt mMeoxoH, HO AYXOBHO BOSBbIMaloMelo H OCsaropomasaiomen Bach! Mbt mexar @M% H MOABME Bora, yT06bI BaMD He AOBEAOC YBUABTH Bb BUIET M coToH 4048 TOTO 34a, Kakoe eCTb Bb Hel, HOO B BUABTS TOALKO 340 — BOSMyTBTesbHO Aaa qHcTOM xAyma! Ho, noRtopato, « 104- HONS OHNE BAM CRAGATL BCO TO, ITO CRAsaXb, ITOOM He OCTA- BHTb BAC BATH TeDepb Cb SAKPLITLIMA TxasaMe W RARS Ob! Ba yaauy Ba BCTpbay sty Bb MASHB, ITOGEI Bel 3HasH Aanepers, fa GTO HHOrAa MOMCTS BATOARAYTS BaCh WBA, W MOA BA cayiad DpwroroBAybca & TOMY, NOTOMy TO BCE MOMETS Cay- SUTLCA Bb BASHA M EO BCEMY BAN BYRGO OBIT TOTOBLING BB Rell, 170Gb! sa6zarospewenHO Upanacats ce6% ouopy Bb Hell # YMBTb 8a NYTH ed BcerAa BOBpeMa H TREpAOO PykO! OTPAasBTe yaaps! roms gama xbsaT&, ChaMeTe Bb, KAR Obits? Mei 204HH6I HATH... 8 BA HATH Bb BEY cero? [as saath cHsy, ITOOH YeTOsTh 6b aTod wepocmabHol Goph6b, EoTOpad, Fake Hab fO- BOPATh BS OTY MUBYTY, MACTE HACb, HOCOMABHHO, TANG, EYAA MACAOBO BA KJAXBHUIS. 339 ‘aid: vbw Goxbe yTbMasHch MBI TAM, TBM Opie H TARCABE wams anbcb. Htaxs a Oorarctsa a yTbxH Mipa—6esb aACTOTHI cepata H COBSCTH, Geab Cramania TOro, ITO ecTb exMHOe Bi Horpe6y, 6e3b Tbab 306BH B MasOCepAia XpHCTianCRaro—cyeTa cyercraii.—Maomxatimie 43% Bach DPOBeAH AABHb CBOIO Bb ObI- HOCTH H yOomeCTBS, CpeAw HeXOCTaTKOBS wu AMMeHii, TpyAoBD H 3a60Tb, Heqaxei a ckopGe. Copocute uM AX: ANMIMARCh AR O88 YeCO-4H6O 3pesb TO, 3TO He -ObIaH 3HaTHbI AW Oorathi, He HacdawlasWCh POCKOMbIO H yAOBOAbCTBiAMA? T'opye aM Gbiaa Jaa HuXb céepTs? Hanpotwes, ckaxyTb OBB: CMepTh UPHAa Bb ‘HaMb Ea APyrh H HaGaBHTeAb, TOOK! OpekpaTATh 3eMubIA Hama CKOp6H, 17063 Ha6aBHTb HaCb OTS BCSXE TarocTe ne- waabnol MA3HH Hamel. A oo cMepTH EbI OaarogapaMs Tocnoga, g1o Oat 836aBHAb HaCb OTB ACKyHIeni H COOAasHOBS BemMBarO cyacrid B OpoBexb HAaCb y3KHM H NpPHCKOPONEIMD HyTeMs y6o- WectBa: 64020 nae, ako chupuass ecu nace, Focnoga! Mragb n ObAHOCTS B yOoRecTBO,—cb BBpOWW Hw Oaarovectiemb, cb Tep- UbHiews HoKOpHoctii Boas bomie#,—ne aaujeta, a opiodps- Teie, He Hakasanie, a 3namenie sto6sa Bomiedl. rasp sors atu 2aBbOaewb Bab H BOT 0 eM MOJHMS BaCb: ITOOBI BEI, He UpwabnsasCh AYMOW HW CepAKOMS Hb seMHBIM COKPOBRMAMS DOVCTAMD, Eb UAOTCKHMD YAOBOABCTBIAM H HaCAamAeHiaM, HCKaam Dpewxe Bcero Napctsia Bomia a opaban ero, crapaagch OREBETS AyX> cBoi Bbpow H ynoBasiems wa Bora, corpbtb 4 YeaaquTb cepane cBoe w06osi &B bory # OAWRBRME CBOEND, Gaaroyromaats bory acnoaseniems Ero 3avosbye, o6oramats ce6a XbAaMH OAaTHMH H GOTOYrOABEIME. Cie ove eames 14010- 4ems, Spamie, Axo epema npexpaweno ecmr npovee, dau uMy- Ui aents AKO He uMYUiN CYydyms, % nLaxyUiucA AKO HE naauywUiu, U padyousiuca akooce He padyroweca, u KYNYyI0- Wit AKO HE COdepacame, U mpebywuUsiNn Mipa cero AKO HE mpe- Gye: npecodums 60 o6pass mipa cero, Bawdume y6o, xaxo nacho Lodwme, He AKOoCe He MYOPU, HO AKOMCE npeMyOpU, acnynyrowme apema, AKO Onie syxacu cymb. ecmoxo ecm caoeo cie, OOxyMaeTb KTO-xH60, CAyMaa BTO 22"340 fIPABOCIABHOE OBO3PSHIE. Hoysenie yMepmmxs, oGansalomee cyeTy M HUITORecTRO BCero, Bb YaNb OpABLIEAM MBI DOsATaTS cBOe cyacTie, cBoH pagocta, coe yTbmenie a GaakencTs0 wasHE,—HavOMHHAWMee 0 CMepTA 4 BSag0cTa, Oo cyzs Bomiews u yaacra Hamel 3a rpoGoms. Ho, Opatie Bosa61eHain, MOryTb 4H yMepmlie ABCTATS HAM, OCMa- HbIBaTS HACb AOMHLIMA HalemAaMa’ Hrs, OHH TOBOpATS TOAL- KO HCTHHY, Bb KOTOpOH yAOCTOBSpHANCh COOCTBCHEBIMG CBOBMS ontitows. Hi msi, cb cBoel cropoasl, He MoReMb HAYETO AyT- Maro HoReATh BAW}, RAK TOTO, ITOOb! BbI OCTABAAAM UO Bpe- MeHaMS CBOH JOMBI, Bb KOTOPEIXS MBI CBAAHBI H OOpeMeHeHE! SCMABIMA BA60TAME H 3eMABIMH OPBCTpacTiaMA, H UpHXOAHAB cola GechgobaTb cb yMepmiuua. Kamioe taxoe nytemectsie, €CAH OHO COBepMaeTca BS CrarorosbuHOM HacTpoeHin AyXxa, He- Upembaso yaeceTs Hab Aya Hamel aro-HWOyAb nHeqHCTOe B 340e, OcideTS ee CBBTOMD GaarogatH Bomieil, corpBerb ee 4yB- CTBOBAgiaMH BOSBbIMICHHBIMH HW CBATEIMA. Jaa cero, Korga myeTe cloda, pasubmmagiite 0 TOMS, 90 BCH HABHb Hala CCTh OABA, He CAHMKOMb OPOAOAMBTCABHAR, Jopora KO rpo6y H Kb MOTHAS, ITO 8a TpOOOMD OMBaeTS HAC HAH BBIHOCTS OAameHCTBA HAW BSYBOCTS MydeHii, CMoTpa 00 TOMY, Kyla # Kakb Mbl HaupassdeMs nyTb wame# musaH. Kro BleTS nyTews sadophge Tocnoxaaxs, &10 ctpamatca nase cMepTH OpectyouTs xoTa eluAy 3an0Bb%s Tsopna cBoero # co- TpbmaATb upexd Boroms, Tors upeiaet> OTb cMepTH Bb MA- BoTb, HOO Takb ckasars cama Tocnoab: awe xowemu exumu 6s acusoms, cobswdu sanosndu. Kro naupoTas AersouBicaeH- HO Upectynaers ceatiia sanossqu Tocooaa Bora cpoero, Toro OmBAaeTS OO cMepTA rabss Bomiti w wakasagia: omxpueaemca 60 wines Goowits cs weSece na ecanoe nexecmie u nenpasdy ue- 06rK06s; cKophs u mncKoma Ha ecAKY Oymy YeAOEmKA, mEo- pawaro sace. Kro agers Bo cabys Tocnoga Incyca Xpacta y3- KHMb H OPHCKOPGHEIMD DyTeMD KpecTOROMeHia, KTO OTBepracTca cBoel BoaH H HOKopaetca Bcemba0 Bors Bomieii, nepenocuTs BOB, DODyCKaeMBId UpoMbIcioMs Homies, ackywenia, nagacta, oropsenia # CkOp6B—Bb AyXS BSpbi w ynoBania Ha Bora, BbCOBO Rb BOCONTABSSQAMS. . 340 Biew>,—H Kab wgems? Osan, ne AwbA Cane coOm Goaxbe yume BEROPO H3b TSXD, ETO 6b! MOT HAND DOAATL COBBTE RAB ORA~ BaTb BAMATY,—MpefOCcTasAcBHbie CAMB BS CEG OAHOMY COBSY- BEKY—HalleMy pasyMy, eme He yMYAPeHHOMY ODBITONS MASE; oxnol samATb—coGcrseanomy cepAgy, elle He BaKaxeHBOMY Bb Gow mx3HR! Tx 33a caay, ToBOpHTe BH, 44a TOW GophOel masaA? Ora casa... Ho Bawt He HYMAO AaseKO BCHATb Cf, RAKb A MES Bawb nagBaTh ee. CRamRATC: AAA YeEFO, OTb CAMbIXG pawHEXb YSTD, BaCb yIHIH SABCb NOMBATS, 3HATh H AOGATS Bora, soqwaw He- OnycTHTeabHO, BCanif BOCKpeCHBIH A UPAsAAAIELI# Lew, Bb Xpaws Bomii, crporo cabya ByScrb H 3a Bate AoMamueH BceAneBEON MOAHTBOH, B 3CTABASH BACh MOABTBCS: WH YTPOMD A Ha COBB FpA- Aymi#, nepexb cToAOM> BH NOCIB cToza, Opa HayaAB mw NO CO- Bepmenin ABAa ysenia? Axa vero TaRRe wMBAAAOCL Bab SABC Bb Henpewbanylo o6asaHsOcTh KAMAL rors HeyKOCHETeILBO ACHOABATS AOATD ACOOBSAR B UpHIaMenis cB. XpucTosLixs Tases, Opa yew, emte BHyMaxOCch BCerga, |T06b1 BbI copepmlasa ato CBaToe AAO He BAK, CoXpanH Bors, mpocryw oOpaqaocts mas BU, BO Rak nepBbimit a seamvaimiti xoars ea? Hi aaa yere BoosMe 3ABCb SOPKO CMOTPBAOCH 8A BCAKAMD Bal MaroNs w xbilctBiews, STOObI BAND He NOBEAOCh, KAKB-1HOO Have yaanis, oeropOats Bexnsia Bowmia naknMS-1H00 HEOCTOPORABIMS, ABTCER- HepascyABbiMs CAOBOMS, BBOpoMD, ABAMeBieME? Jaa yero, ena- MHTe, B HOWEMy BCO STO ThAAIOCH BIBCH LAM BAC, KAKD POBAd Mbraerea HW OyxeTs AbaaTCa DOCAB BACh—AAA APYCHXs, BOCHHH THBACHBIXS H BMBNMAXD GbIT BOCHHTAGHLINA saben? Ho aan ¥eru APYTOrO, eCAH HE JAA TOTO, YTOOHI XaTh BAMS MMERHO TO Camoe, 370 BAM BCeTO HYMAE Telepb,—cHry Aaa Gops6s Cb 34084 BS AMABHH, Bb KOTOPyW BbI BCTYMAeTE Telepb, H Kb BO- Topo Bach TOTOBBAN BIBCh, MOMHO CkasATS, OTS KOAtIOerA? [To- TOMY STO MBI BCerJa 8Ha7H B BHAeMB N10 ODBITy, ITO He OBa- Gorbca MbI fats Baws, cb Bomiero momomifio, sto cual sa6xzaro- EpeMeHHO, TOFkA BCB OCTAAHOE, ITO BEI NOAyGHAH HAN COXxpa- BHAN B PasBHAB BL CeO 3XBCb, RAK TO: CHALI, MOAOAOCTH, BAO-850 " BPABOCAABHOE OBO3PSHIE. poRbe, sHaHie, TaIaWTN, ObAO Obl. HANpPACHbIMS, B He COCAYRBIO Obl HCTHHHO HH Kb YeMy AA BaCh BD RBSAH, a TOAPEO Bosrop; 3a40. O61 H BCHOpTHAO Bace!... Ita cuaa... Bor yme HaaBaan ee Bd AYMIb, H A MOLY TeDeph BO BCeycablMagie CkagzaTb HMA eA. Ora cuza—cpataa Bbpa XpHcTOBa, BROPenseMaA MW BOspamacuad Bb Bach 3XKCb OTS ABTS AbTcTBa! Bepa Xpactopa—ata eawaag DOMOMBANA HW YTBUATCAHHNA BCEXE BaCb IpBOMEIXS, HeNOI- HBIXS, BO HMA Cf OOPIOMAXCA Cb 310M Bb RAZHH, NO W YyBbI!— YaCTO HaHeMOFaONjaXd Bb HenOcHABHOH Gopb6s! Bspa: Xpucto- Ba—2TO CORPOBAMC MHBHH, BTOTS CBLTb, BOSBeHHMI ANA HACD BB He Ha BbYHOe Opocebmenie w cnacesie name! Yhus Obiad 61 Mipb, CCAHO® He BB HeMS He CBBTHIO coanne? Ho whup Opiga Obl H AABEb BE Mipb, eCaHOD ee He OBapArA A He OyAHAA BTa Bbpa, CBBTaMad BB Heil! Miraxp, Bor Hams nocabanitt copbrb w OpABSTS BaMb BD ITY MUHYTY: “Xpanute Bb ce6b cB. BBpy XpwcroBy, aXbcb Bacam- ROBBY Bb Bach!» ByxeTh BS BACb OHA, H BBI OykeTe CHALHDI TOTAa UPOTHBOCTAT BCAKOMY 34y Bb RASHB, TX Obl H RaKb-OBO BH Upexctaso opexs sama! Bysers Bb Bach Bbpa, B BAC’ He BOeperd Bb CeOs, KaKb APYTAXS, AC camosaGnenia, cyeta mipa, He OOOABCTHTS BHA POCKOMA H OoratcTBa, He OTBEACTS OTS Absa cuacenia Ayma cBoei B caymenia CABRBRMD Mala 3OMALIXD YTBXb B HacaamAeni, He UPCACTATS H He DOKOACGATS Opaar- BIg M IpbmMabia pbIa soseH cyerbl A DOpoka, # BOOOMe HE OCEBINTS H He BapasHTs COGoW HBEAKAT 1OKb Bb Mipb, VME Obl H BaRb OHA BH OPREPEIAach upexs Bama! Bygzets Bb Bach Bbpa, H BRI Gy_eTe Cb OOABLIAMD OPHBBTOMD H AN0COBIIO BCTPS- ¥aTb Bb RAGAN BCC HCTAHHOC, CBSTACG H OTPaLHOe BD Heli, La- Bath AYWHy~ Way Bb He a AOGPLIMS AlOLAMD H AOGPLIMD AB- 1aM> H DPHMBpaMs, Came OPBBEMATh Kb CepANy BAYS AYWH cpoeH w HYMALI H CKOPOH ApyrHXb, H HAXOAWTh OTPaly Bb Ca- MbIXS AEPTBAXh AAZHB, OPHHOCHMBIXD BaMH BO BMA Bora # 6amx- © uuxt! Byers Bb BACB Ba, H 3X0 HC BACTHTHETS BACB Bpac- DAOXb, HO HaAeTS BACS OOACTCHENXS Bb EPBURYHO H HeCORPy- AMY! GpoHto, A OTpasHTCs OT Bace! ByleTs Bb BACb Bbpa,CIORO Eb BOCOBTABHBNAMS. 3b1 H BH CMBXO, HOYRAOHHO CyAeTO MATH Bb MHBEN, HO BABpaa HE Ba 9T0, HYTOM) AOSTA H GCTH, OPMRLENA Ha COGA ACWHY HA TyTE cpocms Gaarecsosenie Bora w. axel, wehecuoe # sexsoe! Bers yro 310 38 cHAa Bb HACb. ITO Bhpa CBATAS, AApOBaHmad naa! Hi mocemy ona—tanas onaa Bb Hace? Horosy, yo TomEO Oua, OTEPMBAA Haw) RCO HeHSMBPAMYIO BBHHOCTD AyMH YeRO- wbyecsol, Kasb RCKyOAeHHOH CesmbanoI xposo Xpscra, may- ‘GaeTh HACh UPHABasaTh B BBETS ee HCTHERO Bb CeOB H py- raxs! Tloromy, 970 TOAbKO OHa, YRa3ya HANS Ha He6O, EARS Ba Hamte BEIHOC KAHAN BOTURAY, J2CTh MAM BUTTS Bb RUGEN Ba 3eNX6 TOMKO DYT Kb HeOy, A TSME NOGymAACTD Hach, MUBA Ha 3emxb, ucsat, Heda! [loromy, 3T0 TOAbRO OMA, NOKABya Has bo Xpmeré aw6ops, Bosnecmiyi Ce6a-Ha KpecTh 9a aboqai CamopacnssInyWca WA HOM, 1aeTS HAM DONATE Ipess TO H wa- wbpaTs pew rayOeny ceOaseOis, MAByMaro BS MaCb, M THMD WAIBYRAACTS Hach, OTPEKAsch Ce6s, MeptBopars cocoi Saary apyruxs! Doeromy, 310 TObKO OBS CXBAORATCALHO BMBCTB BOR- BMMIACTL EH CMNPSCTS HaCh, COFATHTS B YGORBTS, TROPA Bb HACb HOBy!O CHIY, AACTh Bab YYBCTBORATL 4POas TO H BUBCTS Cb hey © name opmpomaemioe Gescesie! Caosows, moToMy 9T0 TOALRO OHA OCT TA CHAa, KOTOPA cosepmaemca 6s NeNotyans! Haim, nary Bhi OyxeTe yX@RRTS OTOIONA, BbI BOYINTe OTS EaCh Bb BEXS HallytcTsia Kamjad OO cBRrs cB. Esanresis. Bors EpPMMNTe DOTY CBATY KHBIY H COXpAaBUTe ee He KARL TOIBKO 3uakb DaMATH 0 HaCb, BCeTa KelaBMGXs Baws A06pa H 00 BOB- MOMBOCTH XbLABMEXD CFO, 06> ITOMD MBCTS, TXB BbI BOSPOCAH @ BOCHRTAINCL, 060 BCeEMS AOOPOMD BH XOPOMIOM, ITO AAA Bach TSCHO CBa3aHO Ch HENS; HO UPHMHTe HB COXpaHHTe ce B KAKS ¢paToe, Ha BCIO RUSH, Hae HANOMMHAHie Bawh O TOMS, 97d OXHO JOAMHO COCTABASTS BCOrAA BAY CHAY Bb TON MaSHA, KYLA Bi Hodaete teneps! M60, upeaynpexazato, Bbpa — aTO CBBTHAL- ENKS, BOSMeHHBIH BL BACB, H Tpedyiomill, KakB w BCARIM CBB- THIBEEKS, THATexbHarO DaMATOBaHia 0 Ce6S, w MOrymii yrac- 2YT B% BAC, CCAH BbI OCTABHTe ero Bb HeGpemenin BL ce6s. Crapattrecs #0 bosrpheats A yunomats Bb CeO Bhpy cBaTyO—532 HPABOCSABHOE O503PSHIE. MoanTEOW H CaBmalinaMS OSmeniens cs Borows Bs Ero cea ‘TbIXS TawucTBaxs, steniem> Cxosa Bomia, Gaaroropditubms pas- meintaenions 0 Bors, cOammeniew cb MOAbMH BCTHRHO BBpyO- DyWNH H HpaBcTBeHHbMA. CxOBOMS Bce TO, ITO opiysaaw baci ataatb Jan Bora axhcb, opoxormaitte OTAbIED ABAQTS H TOMS (XB Bb GyAeTe Teleph, HO yRe 86 TAKS, KARS OBITS NORE! HHOG HBB TOTO XBAAAOCL BAM BABCL: NO AbTCKH, GesorqeTAO 1 00 4yBCTBY Crpaxa HepeXb AIOAbMH WAH H3b DOBMHOBCHIA BMS BO CBOGOAHO, CO3HaTeIbHO, H 0 SyBCTBY HCKPeHHSTO BaCTeHI! ap Bory @ w3> massimaro mexania opaSansatsca Kb Hemy! Byaete Bcayecka O110CTH Bb ceOB aTy CBaTyIO CHAY AyOlG, | MbI CoOKOHHBI 3a Bact. H6o snaewb, 5TO JOKOeB .ofa Oyxen’ KUT Bb BACh, BI CyAeTe CHABBHI Ha ACHPO M BeyAsBAMET Li 348 Bb Mipd, H TaXHMS OOpasoMD, pyKOvOAWMDIA B YEP bOAdewE €10, CBATO HOHeCeTe A COBepilATe Ha Hy?H CBOeMS BesmEiW ZOmM EBHH; a PH Ce, EARS Oes CONNBHIG, H BL CaMOMD Cont HatgeTe RARAaA AAA COOK BL MUBEH W TY LOMO paXocT# W C4 crid ef, Kakad HeCOMEBEHO OTwbpera BB Ke Boroms kamyol wap Bact! M6o, cabimute x#, 970 ropopats Causa Bomecrsor aii Hacrasnaxs a Yantes, atx Xpaoroes? Hegume, rose pars Ons, npsoede yapomeia Bonein u mpasdw eo, ucta ech T €. M paxeeTh w Cyactie musaA HBOS XoOpOHFee BS BCH, mpu aoocamen eames! Aunt. Osamennuns H. Trotorososs.XN NOTOMEHIE BOTOCAOBCKOM HAYKH Bb TEPMAWCKHX’b YHHBEPCH- TETAXD ‘). CombAccaTS Mecth ABTS OPOMAO Cb TBXb DOpb, Kakb NO- semz0ch Bb novaTH couRHeRie Ranta 0 «6opb68 @akyabTOTOBS Memay co6oio». Bs revenie nara x61> 10 TOTO BPeMeHA OHS HE magasaxh amsero, kacalomaroca peanriosasixs Boupocoss. Ko- posescRHNS ykasoM> ors 1-ro oxTadpa 1794 roxa, emy cxS- 348} OLLID YUPCKS, ITO OHS Bb CBOHMS COURHeRIM «peAuTi« BD mpexbaaxs aEcTaro pasyma» sasoynorpedasers @na0cooien Eb MMCOpoBepKeniw # YARIAMeHiN0 TAaBABIXS H OCHOBHEIXS BCTRES es. Iucasia » xpactiancrsa. Jaa opexorspamesia aa Oyaymee Spema camo soswomHoctH go06HEIXS yupeross, Ranrs Aarb TOPMEcTBeHH0e OFABATLABCTBO BOPeAL COBePMeHSO BOsKepAA- BAIBCR OTS BCAKBXS DYCAWIHEIXG PascyRACHill KACATCABHO OCTO- crsesuo wan OorooTsposenso peauria H Bb CBORXS seRTiaXS ® 8% cosmpeniaxs. Koneqo, 08% cxbaaab Takoe saabavnic BB EaveCTES BHPHOUOMAHHArO; HO HO BMBAD HaMbpenia waBcerga OTBasaTsca OTS CBOCOALI MBICAH, T.-€. LOABe TOTO BpeMeHH, 00- ka Geixb KaSb KOposs. Bs noa6ps 1797 roza Opaapaxs Buss- rexsun II] wacabgosars caoemy OTHy, # DepBBIMb akTOM ero ero mapcteosania 66110 yaaxtomenie peadriosnaro aganta, OTS $ro inaa 1788 roaa, Ha OcHOBania KOTOparo H3AaH0 Ob120 yuO- %) Theolog. Studion u. Kritiken. 1975.2 Heft. 23384 WPABOCIABHOE OBOPTHTE. MaHyTOe KOposeBcKoe nOBexbHie, HaDpaBsennoe OpoTHss Kasra. Kanth o0crBMast, Kakb OND TOBOPHTS, «BbIPAsHTb CaMbIMS XB- XOMb DOAOGaMee UPOCRBMCHHOMY, CHAMAIONIeMY HaxOReHebIA Ha AYXb YEAOBSRA ORGBEI UPABHTeALCTBY NOBHHOBeHIe» yme BO- COMBSHHO HCEPCHHO B CIBACTBIe NPOXOCTABIeHHOW CBOGOAI MBI- CAH H OTEPOBCHHO BbICKABATS CBO BETAAXS Ha MBCTO, UPHHALAema- Mee @HA0COSIN Bb HAYSHOMS OpranAMs, WAH, 970 TORe—wa Bsa- MMHOe OTHOMeHIe GAakYALTETOBS, TAKE KaKb YHRBEPCRTCTS eCTb yueHoe oSmectso, cooTesrcrByromee aToMy opranasmy. TpH B84a~ BHa CyMecTBYWMEX SakyabTeTa—Oorocaoncsii, opaguieckili # MOANQHHCKIM uMBIOTL, 10 Kanty, TO MexAy coGo1o o6maro, 370 MpenoxapaeMbla Bb BUX HAYKA AOMMHB! OPOHSBOAHTE COOTBST- CTBCHHOe BAigHie HA HBBBCTHBIA COepbl IeAOBS1eCKOH RaSHA, B Tab Kak} UpaBATeAbCTBO, OCHOBBIBAd YHEBEPCRTeTH H labad HMB Coxepmanie, ocoGeHHO STHMS BHTepecyeTCa, TO OHO CIH- Ta0Tb 9TH TPH @aKYAbTeTAa CTapWMAMH. TacxO HX COOTBBICTBYETA TpeMb TAaBHBUMEMS NPyRHHANS, HANpavasiOMHMS HapoAnyto HEB OpewAe BCCO Kb BIHOMY Oxary KaRLATO yAOBbKA, 0O- TOM Kb eTO rpawAaackoMy GOraroctoanit, Kakb WeHa o6me- qzBa, BH HagOBeHD EB ThxecHoMy sgoponbio. Ho Aaa yHuBepcH- TeTCKaro yaeHxaro oOMectTBa CyMecTBeHHO HEOOXOARM eme IeT- RoptThit @akyabTeTS, «KOTOpHIN Obl, 00 XapakTepy cBoeH HayaE, HeSaBHCHMO OTS UpaBATOALCTBCHBLIXD DpBKasanil, NOAbsO0BaACT CROOOAOW BCe NoABeprath OGcymACHiIO BE YNCTO HayIHOM BATC- pecs, T.-c. Bb HATepech o_HoK MCTHADI, TABOIO CBOGOAOI, Ha OCHOBaHIA KOTOPOH MOBO ObIA0 ObI TOBOPHTL HCTRBY OTEPEITO, HOTOMY, ¥TO Cb OHO CTOPOHLI, Gesb aTOi cBOGOAL HCTHHA (Bb yolep6e jaa camaro npaBATesbcTBa) He MOMCTb CLbAATbCA H3BB~ CTHOIO, a Cb Apyroti pasyMs, cBOCoxmDIH nO cROel opApoA, He MOMCTh UPHBBMATS HAEAKHX OPRKABaKii, ITOGbI CIHTATh ITO- an60 3a HCTHHY (BHKAaKOrO crede, HO TOsbKO BpocToe credo). OtTorb serseptEit @akyabTeTS oHAocoecKiii. Ecan 6b1 octaab- HbIG @ABYALTOTSI BCTYOHAH Bb OOps6y Cb OTHMS YeTBEPTLIM’, CCbIAAMCh Ha 3afOHOHOAOMCHia, W3AAHHbIA MAH TOALRO yTBEpHK- ACHHBIA OpaBNTCALCTBOMS AAA YBAREPGRTCTORD, 70: 37a GapL6aBOTOCAOBIE BL YERBECCRTETAXS. 388 aa 663 DPOTWBYSAKOHBAs; OHA CYPOMMAACD Obl BAaepMaTL cpo+ 6ommoe ybUMoHie HaykH BOOtMe. Mexanic onx0COOCRATO oanyab- Teta DO_Beprats cBoeMy oOcymAcHilO H ONBHES 3aKOnn # yue- Hit APYTHXS OaKyALTETOBS BOOABS BaKOHHO BS BHTepeC’ WCTAH- Karo 3nagia Ww OaaroTBopHo Aas GyaymHxt Abatexeli BB paa- AWSHBIXS OOAACTAXD YoAOBbIecKOM masaA. Ke TOMy xe H BsiA- Wie @NAOCO®CKATO GARyABTETA Ha 3THXS DOCKSAUHAD CTS TOA- KO GOCPeACTBEHHOS, YPe3b Th OAKYALTETM, KOTOPHIC PYROBOAATS IXB OGpasoBani7us; a HelocpercTBeHHO ABUCTByeTS Ha HHXS STOT GaKYABTCTS BMSCYS CB BCHMH APYTEMH GanyAbTeTAMG, COCTABAMONINNH akakemmueckii oprasnams. Daxocoocsili oa- AVIBTCTS DOCTYORID Ot OpOTHByaakouHoO B Hepemexb Obl 3a SOrpanwIBY!O TepTy cBOerO UpBIBAHis, ecaH OBI BSAYMaID He- DOCpeACTBEHHO YEASbIBATS TEOAOTAHS, WOPHCTAND wW Bpataies Dpegwert! As BX} Tou, BMBCTO TSXS, KOTOPHIe NOpysenB mrs spasstescrsoms. Yro Kanrs canmsoms ysko nonmMaers Upuseawie APYTHXS GakyALTeTORL Bb CpaBneHin Cb oRAOCOO- CEEWL GABYISTCTONS, EOTOPAO 3akasy, BAUPOTNBS, CTABNTD CAMTIEOWD BXOAILAO, YCROGA DepBLINS ONCHS Mat THOTO Ha- yuwaro WHTepeca W OTHOCH eFO ACKNIOGHTCALHO KB TOCKbE- BeBY, 310 OOsacaAéTCA BBL ero OOmaTO BOaDpbais, NO. KOH TepoMy oTxbasasil cyOLerTh EPHTAYOCKW OTROCHTCS Kb ORPY- wawmei ero Goraroi azn. Ho Kaers patyers ToxbKo 3a apase enzocooia na cao6ornce macrbyzoBawie B matOmenie ACYH- . NM; HOTOMY OBS BECLMA Jase OTS MbICAN OCIAPHBATL y APy- THXS eaxysbteTons coemiasbAyl ceepy: HX DpHeBania w DOI DOPTaTs COMESHIO AXE DOsHOUpABie, KAKS HEOOXOABMMXD WC- BOBE Bb HayIHONS oprasueMb. Gro enrocoeckid eaxyabTeTs, HG CHOTPA Ha CBOe NpeMyMecTBeHHOe NpPaBo cBOGoAb, CmATAeT- ca msagmams, Kanth maxoauTs sTOMy OOvaCHeHIG Bb TOM, ITO sosexbsanmid, xOTa 651 Obi JbUMb-AH6O CHEPCHELIND CAy~ mETexeM’, BCe Tae coHTaeTS ce6a BEING HeKerS cBOGoRHETH, BO Be eMbomid BAacTH. DOBeXbBath. Ba yacTHocTH OTHOCRTeIE- yo Gorocsoscraro @axysbreta Kanrs saxogaTs pasyMubms, IT0+ Gi TOT @akyAbreTb, KOTOps. uMbeTS mbaiO BbIBeO rar Ie 23°356 MPABOCLABHOER OBQ3PDRLE. SORBRA, BAHHMAND NepBoe MBCTO BS PEAY OCTASHHMIXS, 32 HENS fopusayeckili, a makoHen® Meuqunckii, xoTd 00 BECTHNETY Bpays Bamase APYTWXD AAA GeAOBBEA, DOTOMY TO COXpanser’ eMy HSEb. Kaxaws xe o6pasom Oorocsosckaa aayka, 9Ta qapHna Mex- AY APYTHMH HAyKaMM, CXBAAAACS TAKOIO YHHIBMeRHOIO Bb Ha- croamee spema? Ona oTHwas ge UpeneOperasa ooysatsca y @naocosin, ofa, HyHAO CkasaTb, MAOrO Dopadoraza Hays Kas- tomb & @uxte, Mlessanroms # Teresemb, Dpasons a lep6ap- Tob, Tak> ITO Kametca, #6 Ob40 BH OAHOH saMbaaTesbHO @B.10CO@cKOH cHCTeMBI, KOTOPad Obl Opomza MBO GorocaoBia, Ke DposmeHyss ero wackBoab. Ce apyro# cropoas! Gorocacsie AQBHO PaByIHIOCh B3bIBATh Eb CBBICKRMS BAACTAMB XAG orpa~ mmyeHis ODACHATO Aad HOO SUACCO@CKATO yMOapbais, HW AOHOCS, exbaananiit Bb 1853 roay na Kyno-Damepe 8p FeiisoasGeprs, AOLHOCHS OCTABATLCA COBOPMICHHO OAMHOWRRMS Bb Hopbimes uctopia ysabepcatetoss opotecrantcKod Tepwasia. Daaocosia, roropod Kanrs nagmazaat takoe cepomnoe noxomenie HOAs es- CTaPWIAXS CeCTeph, B TeMeph UpexocrassaeTs Corocaosiw ero- Bpemaes wécTO. OAHAKOMS CCAM BL OCOSPbaiaXt AmgMarO ana~ AOMHIeCKATO COCTaBa B Openosanawia Bayed, a pabHO W BS aKa- AOMHTOCKAXD TOPMOCTRCHABIX® COOpaniaxt Gorocxosito eile ycTy— @TCH MEpBEHCTBO; TO STO MPONCXOANTS, KaweTCs, Coabmew ya- CTH OTS TOTO, 470 CMOTPATh Ha HETO, KAEB wa yMEpAwOmlaro,. gawbaaa Ba Hews facies hippocratica # Aymas, 170 BOOGMe eMy He KOATO OCTAeTCA MATb; BL CaMOMS AIG MHOTHMD CABIMBTCA Ba ABOPAMA yKe H MACH CTO MOTHALIMKOB}, OPRTOTOBRAMBXCE ero norpedars. Moat xe-Jarapas, cams goeTops orocsosia, HaXOAMTb, ITO Cymectsywmie aba’ GorocaoBcKie akyabTeThl we BB CocTOaHin ACpMaTbca; Opwcara, jaBaeMas Opo@eccopaMy Gorocaosia ps Hoayvenia cretionn ammenniata, 10 taxol cre- WHE CBASHIBACTS HX, YTO AABaA Ge, OHH TBME CaMbIM HCRAIO- saoTs Gorocaosie H3b pala Bayqabixd suanill. Jaseqs UItpayce as 1840 roxy ye AyMaat, 470 cymectBeaaoe coAepmanie BB— PH, Xpanuaoe mAioTcRAMD COsHaHieNs Bs opm’ UeACTasacHia,BOFOCIOBIE BS FHEBEPCHTETAXS. 387 WhaaeTCa AOCTOAHieMS yveHarO BS SOPNS MBICAN; HO yRe H YOTAA OH, RABE RABALOCL CMY, MOT SACBAABTENLCTBORATS COO. — CYROHSLIMS HPHMBPONS, 4x0 Baysenie Gorocaosia, BSKOAA eper- CTBO CHOCOSHOS NPSTOTOBATS Eb CAyMCHi HEPEBH, TeMeph CTAAO CaMbIN> BPAMIM DYTEMS Hb TOMY, ITOOB CABAaTL Aaa HOTO WeCBOCOORLIMD; HADPOTHRS CANOMBBICCKAd CRAMbS, DBCApCRAs KOMBaTa H Npowee, STO OpemAe CAMLIMD HAaleRALIME OGpasoMs UpeAOXpab#AO OTS BTOPMOHis wayKA, BL HACTOAMee BPOMA CXB- JAs0Ch MECTOMD UpeAsapRTeAbHOH NOATOTOREH KB NPODOSBARE- Secko# AOXHHOCTA AYIEMS, REReAR YBRBEPCHTETH! BH COMMBA- pis. Peawriosaie waiorn, Gorocaoscsie camoyaen, wieTacTCEIc BowaKH H FOROPYEN, BOTS AyXOBHOe cocsoBie Gyxymaro! Heazas- BO Mpoe@eccops Sorocsosia Bb Basexs @panns Ovep6exs 10- sropaxs 3a Ulrpaycous noxpaiinell wpb nepsoe ero nos0me- Bie, yTRepM AAs, ITO OPOTABONOAOMAOCTS MORAY BbpOIW H BHA- HieMS NCNPEMEPHMA, H ITO MOTOMY, HAYA MOMCTS TOUBKO pas- PYMSTOABEHMS O6pasoNs AdiicTBOBaTL ma pesarin. Hexonens CCTCCTBCHRAd HAYEA, SLICTYNAMAd Bb HAMM ABA Bb IexB Ba- YI8aTO ABNReHiA, CHABTCH OCTABATh CorocacBie 6esb BCAKarO peaabuaro mpeamera, ycrpauaa Aame anqnaro mBBaro Bora, Ko- Yophii Aas ectectsesnoM wayxe He Coxbe, Kakb 7, HAYIAbI 30853, BhIpaMelomill HewaBCTHYI BeAHINEY, M BEICTABIAS BO- Ome pesurito, 2% DPOAYKTE YoxoRBaecKaro caMoo6osbmoHia. Taxews o6pasom> semwSuie Upapa ObT> MHTerpasbHwNd 129- HOM DayoHaro OpramssMa,—HecnoeoGHOCTh O6cabALIBATE CBO BpeAMeTh HalsemaneM> OGpasons, Aame Beawbuic gbiicrsaTesb- HO CyMectsyioMaro UpexMeTa,—sOTS Tpolldas DpAMBTa, ROTOPOIO oOosnaqsetca Npeacueptaoe cocroanié Gorocsoscrod nayKe, BS- Pylomew Bb CBOIO OCHORATEALNOCTE, CTPOTOCTS A DOCABAOBATEAL- aocts. Borocaosie merao 6s! ycwoxonpath ce6s TBNb OScTOaTeab- CTBOMS, TO, He CMOTPa Ha aTO, OHO BCe-TAEN UPOLOAmacTE KUT, ITO CUO HE PaSb BEIXOAHAO HBb DOLOGHOH CopL6s! Do- MOLOLBBMGND 4 OKDBOMAMS. He sa6oTacs 0 Hanageniaxt, OBO Wors0 Gel HAXOANTS BL EXD wOAEpBoAeHic Aaa Ce6a, T7068),338 HPABOCSABHOE OBOSPSRLE. KaRb H OPERAS, AbAATE CROC TSAO Bb TAMIA HYyTSMarbca 6xa- rocaoBeHieM>, KOTOpoe Bcergza conpoBomaaeTs ero. Ho ecan On0- pag BHIBBAHO BCTYOATS Bb Oopb6y 3a cBoe CymectBoBanie, TO yme Bb HOpAAKB Bemel Jats ceGB OTIETh BL CBOE UpABs Ha cyMectBoBanie MpOTABb TSX, KOTOPbIe OCHOPABAIOTS ero. Ecau pasb BBIBYIBAH CTaTb Bb anlosoTeTAYeCKOe MOAOMeLie, TO Obia0 Gbl HeOAAropasyMHO AONYCTATb, YTOGbI ero sdMATABRE goxBepraaHch HacMBOkaMb CO CTOPOHb! BbISBABIUHXS BXb Dpo- TUBHEOBD; Bb CaMOM ABA CyMecTByeTs MBbRIe, ITO samIAT~ HEH Gorocazosia AyYMe Obl CABAAIH, CCAM Obl OTKASAIHCh OTL Gesnaxemnoh Oopp6n HH 6esb AasbABMMAXD Ba60T CKAOHHIN CB0e 3HaMA NpeA OPeCBOCXOABLIMS BE CHAAXS HeNpiaTexeMD. HawHews cb NOCABARAO H8b BbINeYKAsAHELIX® BONPOCOBS, KaE Cb TakOrO, KOTOpAaro pasphmMenie opexpSMaeTs OTBETLI H Ha OCTAIbHBIC BODPOCKI, HMeHHO Cb BONPOCA: BMBETS IH BOOOME Gorocaosie peaabubili opexueTs. Cospemennoe ecrecrsoananie, Bb OOABMIAHCTBS CBORXS BpeActasuTereH, pbmMaeTL STOTS BO- Dpoch OTpHyareabHO, yTBepmAad, 970 Bbpa BB Bora ects ny- ctaa MeqTa Boo6pamenis, A ¥TO DOHATIe O Borb ect TOAbRO BCTABKa, KOTOPYH AYXOBHAd OFpaaHIeHHOCT # TYNOCTE noMb- MalwTb Taub, TAS AAYKA BATAXKMBASTCA Ha KAakyH-«a60 TpanE- ay. Ectectsosaasie B3aaBARCTb, ITO Bb AOKASATOALCTBO 93TOTO TOTOBO DpeACTaBHTh HayIHO KOHCTATAPOBaHEble, HeOCHOPHMbIC @aktTbl. Hitpaycs, BOpOWeMb, O46Hb MBTRO UpOTaBOnOCTaBAgeTS ato Mipocosepnanie, eB KOTOpoMy oOpaTHaca BB HOCKbAUeH Ma- Tepiaamcrayeckod a3b cBoero passatis, crapod Bbpb, Rakb BBpy Sosylo. Towo aH oTa BBpa-ABHCTSHTCABHO HOBAA, aTO ee BOUPOCE; HO ITO Ona XbiicTBHTeAabHO BBpa, KOTOPy! NPHARMANTS HAW OTBOPFalTS, CMOTPA 10 CyODERTHBEBING yCAOBiaMS H f0- TpeOHOCTaMs, a OTHIOAS He 3HaHie, HeoTpasHMO XbicTByWOIee Ba yObmaenic CB0c OOBCETHBHOIO CHAQW, BB STOMB HE MO- ers ObiTh u comabaia. Momems yeasaTs ga ieTbIpe NyHeTA, 00 OTHOMeHiO KE KOTOPLING [1a HeBSpylome waysH OGpLiBactca HUTS AORAGATCALCTES, H ITOO CHOBA CBABATS STyY HBTS, OBA Osipaer sbiuymlena yxsaTateca 3a BBpy. Wyant: sta o6osBa-BOFOCAOBIE 3% YAUBEPCRTETAXS. ee ‘sanrca BOOpOCaMA: KakAMD o6pas0m> 8b HEOpraHMdecKarc BBI- HOMETS OpranAecKkoe, H3b OescosHaTesbaaro COBHATCABHOC, USB ectecTBeaHO-HeOOxolNMarO CBOCONHOe CaNoonpeAbaeRig mM RSD cxbnoxbiicrsyiomed atepin mbxecoopasnee Miposoe mBaA0e. OruoceteabHo 9THXb DYHRTOBS HayKa, He BHalOMad ABRAKON Apyroi xblctsatexbHocts#, KPOMb BeMecTsa, MPBHSHACTCH, ITO ex aossphuie Ha MpOBCXOmAeHie Bcero NYTeM> ecTeCTBeHHArO pas- Beria MaTepi# Bb HACTOAMee BpeMa He HMBET HAKAXS AOKABA- TeAbCTBS; HO OHA 3apanbe BPHT HW yTSMACTS CeOx HALeRAOW, ‘TO HeJOCTaWMMie Tenepb HocpegcTBylomie IAeHL KOTAa BWOYAB 6ysxyT naifzeast. Dosspun # M6, 970 RwBOTHOM DapoBOH Ma- WES cooOmaers xeAReHie upocToH XHMHYeCKO-MexaHAecHiMt QkTS rophHig, HO TOABKO TOrAa, KOTAA XaMin He UPOCTO pasxo- ‘ATS MUBOTHRIM OpranAsMs, HO NO penenty HaBBcTHaro Barwe- pa chywSers ero oponssecTH Bb peroprh. Papas o6pasoms ne YélicrByeTs Ha HAC OAHO-NpOcToe 3aBbpenie, ito KAMBIO caolictsen HBKOTOPLIM pOXb yBCTBA, CMBAO BLICKABLIBACNOE Cb WhsiO YCTpAaAHTh BaTPYABATeABHOe paasHyie MeMAY CescosMa- TCABHLIMG H COBHaTeABEBIMS. He Goabmee Take BNBOTS SHA- seuie a yrasanie fa saMbaaeMsle y BBKOTOPHIX ®MABOTABIXD CHBAbI YyBCTBA YECTA H AOsLA, HORA HE CTABYTS OPHBACKATS Eb cyay coOaky waH JA0MIa\b 8a Bapymienie AOATa, Rakb REAWBH- AYMOB>, DOAemaMaXt BMbusemocta. Kaks BaKoneNb WhxeCO- O6pasHocTh Morsza Obr cTaTs UpHCymen CxbooH # GescosHaTert~ Bow Matepiv, eCaH Obl ee Be BHOCHAa TYAA MBICID YOAOBBIC- Cag, WAH CCAM Obl TEOPECKAA MEICAb, COBLABMAA MiP, HE BAO- HAA ce BHATANS, OTO COBepMIEAHO AXA HACb HeMbICAHMO. Ka- noe Me paso wMbets Takak Hayka UpesEpaTs GorocaoBcky 38 TO, STO BTa Bhpyers, HO Bb MuBaro, AngHaro Bora, KOTO- paro Gsitie oGycaosansaeTb BCAKOe ycaoRROe cymectsoBanie, YorOppld OTAHIHAS VeAOBBRA OT NPOUAX seMuEIND TBapel, DAOXHYBIMA Bb HeTO AYXS OTS COOCTBeHHArO AYXAa, 1aBb BS ero cepane 3axont Csoei crathimeli noan a KoToppill, Bb CRAY Cscero scemorymectsa H opemyxpocTa Bce BanpaBasdeTs Kb Ceoelt wisn? [Ipososebcrinsa Hosoi BBpEI cb ropaBIM® CosHaBiews To-860 DPABOCEAREGE ObOSPSHIE. BOPATS: «Mble CABAQIA TARie H3YMHTCALHbIC YCUSXH, KAS OyATO BTO “My BE CaMOMD AAG COLCPRATS BL COOL DEBTS YMCTBOR- Hol apacroxpatig, IT06bI CBBICOKa CMOTPBTb Ha APYTHXb, Kakb Ba aujembposs w wzioToss. Ho Ms, Kametca, TpyAHO Upeacta- BETb Bb UOAbsy cBOeH BOBOH BbpE oakTHaeCKia JOKABaTOAB~ CTBa, Bb EOTOPSIXS OBH NOCTABASWTS CYMECTBCHHY! BARHOCTh. One He 3aMBIAOTb, ITO Eb BX TOPAOMY “Mbin UPWMBIRAIOTS BEChMa COMHBTCABANA OUCYpbI COBCBMS He apwcTORpaTBseCcEOw BSIACPHEH, ITO HOBAs BPA BabwpaeTD CeOb HeMBIECAAMOe MHO- WeCTBO HocabAopaTerell u3b rpyOoH MacctiI, KOTOpas He pacuo- 40KeHa UYTATS CB MaTepiasHCTHeCKOIO Teopiew, MIMBINIAAEMOIO BS KACWHOTAXS, HO CTPCMATCA NPOROAUTL Bb MUBHL waBICKAC- MBA HED Hea OpaRTuyeckia oocabactBis. Ogu He XOTATS Cay- math, 97) ropopaTs we Téte, KoTopsil uWbs OCTpoe spbHie © ToaKili cuuicrs 10 OTHOMeRI0 KO BCOMy UPARTHICCKOMy H Ha ROTOparo OH OXOTHO Hoa pasb CCBiaatoTca. «EAMHCcTBeHHad r caMag ray6ogaa Tema BCemipnol uCTOpia yexOBbyecTBay, TOBO- PST. ONS, «TeMa, KOTOPOH NOAWMHEHLI BCS Apyrig, ecTb BS CO6- CTBCHHOM CMBICAS cTOaKsoBeHie HeBbpia cb BEpOW. TS 900XxB, BS KOTOPHIXE TOCHOACTBYeTS Bbpa, BE KAKO Obi BH ObIAO oOp- wb, Bcersa OxeCTANIE, BOSBHMIEHE! # SxarOTBOPALI AsG COBpe- MOBHEKOBS A AAd DOTOMCTBAa. Haupotaes, TS SU0XB, Bb KOTO- PUXS TOpRecTeyeTs ceolo MaskyO noobsy Hesbpie, By To MAB Apyrod @opwS, eCAH H MOTYTS NOXBACTATL HA MrHOREBIC AOMEBIMG CACCKOMS, TO 148 HOTOMCTBA KpooaZawth 6esb cab- 48, WOTOMy ITO HH y KOTO HBTS OXOTHM MYIHTBCA HaXb 10- apaniows Geanxoggaro.» G76 copabexanso no otsomenio Eb MCTOPHICCEENS BUOKAMS, TO BOOAHS CABAYOTS CKABITh HO TROPNAXS dTOXU, BbIAAIOMAXCA MCTOPHIOCKUXS ABIHOCTAXS, Has caamjeaso ray6mabi Bbpbi oovepaase Onw TS TBOpiecEia MBCAH 8 CHAY BOAH, KOTOPHIG ABAAAN HXS CHOCOOHLIME KB NpoOLOAWATeALHO ABUCTByMOMeMy H DOCKS BAX OsaroTeop- Bomy Brisni Ha sesopbuecki’ port. He Gyzems rosopays © TBXS, KOTOPbIXS Upespanion> Gtiso caymenie a cuocTbme- cTsosagie Bbpb,— apepocxoxctso Jlapte He TOsbEO Bb Cpa-BOTOCHOME BL YHRBEPCETETAIS. 361 soesia ct Borsasio, x0 w cs Derpaprow raapuuns o6pasoms @CROBLIBACTCA BA CepLOsHOCTR H BCKPeHBOCTN ero BSpb. ToS tame = [lexcosps ceoew siicotow Bb cpabnenia Cb Coppemen- muse emy Mapso, Bowonrous # Dactsepoms o6acaas cpooll ray- Goxoll B&PS Bb rposHyH, HO COKPOREHMYHO NpavocyAByW Cuay, Koropol abiictsia On yMbAS HI06pAMatTs DOTPACAWMUN o6pa- years. Bepyiomii Musstous cBOwM Ha Mipd, BCOBLID- sews Cymectst, a spess sbpy 3% Hero apio6phraers cpoeo ayuryto caxy? Camp samstaaen marepiasmama He MOryTE OTAB- zaTees Ob aToro eanta copaania. Msi He cranews uopmuarb #Xb 3a 970 B 6esb WX BSAOMA CTPOUTS DOCKBAOBATOADEBIA 3AEAUCHIS OTb HX TeoperAiecHaro MaTepiaANsMa E> BpaKeE- SeceoMy; Mb CKOpbe vOpaayeMcs MXb CuacTampol menOcréLO- DATCALBOCTH, TOMY UPOTHROPSsiD, BS HOTOPOM CTOATL HX% HUBBb362 HPABOCEABROE OB0aPSmE. H HONOCPOACTBOHHBIA BHpAReHia HX COBHAHIA Kb NOAOMONISME iNXS CHCTOMBI; STAM OHH LOKABLIBANTE, TO OUN CaM AYTUTE, HemesW BX cactema. [loca oepBsixh MBCANeBS e@panReypT- ckaro Hagiouaabuaro coOpania 5% 1848 roay, Koraa HaxemAa MHOTHXS Ha CkOpOe BOSCTaHOBAeHie eXHHOK repMaHCKOH BwnepiN BHAIATOABHO OCAAGbAa BH HeBECeAoCe pacnoaomenie AyXa CKAaBbE- BasOCh Bb PBIaXs OpaToposs, Kakb 3aMbias> Mow TorAanrBill tosapums Kapas @orrs, Bb TO BpeMa nO pB4a raMGyprcaro AelyTata 3aMbIaaH, ITO OAD AOATO ee He GyACTS BCTB BEYC- HO® MACO CBOerO poAHArO ropoka. ITO cKasado COBepmMesHO BB AYXB Matepiaaw3ma: scanit HpaBcTBeHEH HeAOCTATORS, NOCat- AOBATGABHO 1A MaTepiasH3Ma, KAMeTCH eMy HEAOCTATOWMEMS Datadiows, Wexaroraka W 9TAKA AMA BELO TOABKO AiAACKTWER. Ho gags coraacyetca Bb «HoBod Bp» Iiltpayca cp marepi- asmctayeceow teopied nepsol 4yacta tpeGosasie Hakasasia w ake cMepTHol KasHa BO Bropol aacTH, Koraa BakasaBie onpe- ABAMOTCA BB cxrBAcTBie TipascTBeaaaro BM bueuia, H BHRARR BO BITCKACTS H3b OHO GopbObs1 3a cymecTsOBanie, Bb KOTOPOH ecuababimit ycobsaers ocBoGomjatbca OTs GesnoKolinaro Aaa wero caaGBilmaro, noka ators nocabaaiii cams He OpBoHeTS qTo6tI OOpaTATS HAaDpassensoe UpoTAB Hero opymie. Camoe Ha- 440 KBETH, 8b KOTOpoM® IlItpayccs Bipamaers cBoe acteTa- ¥eCKOe BOCXBMeHic XyROMecTBeHALIMA Opowsseeniaua Tatiqna, Monapta a Borxosesa, fére a Iilassepa, ects seansaiimill opo- TeCTb UPOTMBb MatepiaamcTayeckaro MipocosepHadia, CBHABYEAL- -CTBYA O6% OCTATES CORPOBMMa, COepeReHHOME BARA OTb POAN- abl, Bb GessAnOw H GesoTpaqHow DycTHIBS. YReaw TaKOM ocrpo- Yuabri MbICAHTeAL HO 3aMBTHAS OPOTHROPS is, Bb KOTOPOC OND “9pe3b JTO CTABNTS Cea TO OTHOMeHI Kb MaTepiaINcTHyeCKO teopia? BSxL HcTERHOe HCKYCCTBO, 3a KOTOpOe cToETS IiTpa- Yes, HaxOAnTCa Bb Camo TBcHOM CBagA Cb peARTictO, OTS KO- Topol onb OTpeKca, To, 9TO ACKYCCTBO OOKASHBACTL HONS BS ABANIHON OGpash, BOSBLIMAd OTABRBALIA ABACHiA EE OOMEMY HX% 3HaMeHOBAHIM, UpeACTABAde BBYBOe AYXOBHOe CORepmManid 3} KOHeTHOH syBCTBeaHOH @0pES, 70 camce HOCpeACTROMS pexa-BOFOCIOBIE Bb YARBEPCETETAXS. 363 Tis 1OAMWO CTAHOBNTACA ABAOMb HB ACTHOW BS pacuozomeniy m5 muaznn. Tlotomy-1o peanriosnoe mcKyecTs0 opexcTabasers Deamsaiimia opomssexenia BO BCBXD O6saCTaXs XyOMecTBeE- waro TeopuectBa. 3awbratessao, ato [lrpayccs supamaers ae- Tpmtsepsoe yAOBOACTBIC, HCULITABHOe BMD OTS «TsOpeRia wipar Taiiaga, koToparo tema: ne6eca noendawme caasy Boaciwo, meo- penie ace pyxy Exo cosenuaems meepdr. Cabionas0 661 OmE- 4aT, STO HACAAMAeHie TAKHM XYAOMCCTRCHBLING OpOMBBexeHi- wb cxbsaeTs jaa Lltpaycca opespsausms mipocosepnanie, Ko- Topoe oTBepracTs Douatie TBOpeni#, EOTOPCe OAWHAKOBO He MO- BeTh YMBBATECA KARE Ch pPerMTiewW, Cb ApPABCTBeEHROW CBOGO- 400, Tab PaBHO H Cb HCEYCCTBOMD, OTHMD cMbabIND Bropme- Biew> camOcosHaTesbaaro, cBobognaro AYX& FesOBBIeCKATO Bb OnE X0Ab ecTecTBeMHaro pasBatia Bemeli. Jaa nocxbyoBa- Teabharo MaTepiaaBaMa HCKYCCTBO AOIMHO ObITE He Goxbe, KaEb DYCTHMb OPHIPAakOMd, KOTOPLIM MOMETE OOOABMATS TOALKO Ab- tell M raynnoss, Bo KoTOpil cepsosabill YeAOBbab AOAMCHD Fes - WasocTso paspymars opysiews cepbosHok saysHoM KpETAKE BuscTS Cb NpHspakous peanria. Ho atH aenopATBOpHbIA BLIpPAme- Bis HEMOCpeACTBeAHaTO 4yBCTBA HCTMHBI, OCTABIMaroca HeTpORY- ThIM} OAHOCTOPOUHElO Topic, BMBCTS CS TOI DOXBAALHOW OCTO- PomBocTiwo, Cb KaKOO TeopeTMIecKie MaTepiaaMcTH! OXpaHawTb AyMesai Map> KeagwAs # AbTeH OTE CBOero COOcTBeHHATO y1e- Bia = Ba UpagTHEes YSOpawTD ero BO SHU,—O0pPRHAAACKATh Kb TOMY OCHOBania BCTO- pasecric @AKTLI,OBb CMOTPSAD KAKS HA 170-70 TakCe, Ges Ter0 @a- COO MOMOTS OOKOANTECA, HB IT) ORAMCTCA HOCTHHHBING, eel CFO MCTOPHICCKOMY DOSOMBTCALUOMY COLCPRAiN UPOTADO- aecrasats ydenie ezocoeckod pesurin. Kauts, oymanox, BO 10TSAL COBEPMIEHHO PasAbsareca Cb XpHCTiaWCTBOM; HO CIM- TaXb CTO, BE OCOGCHHOCTH CFO CBAMIOHALIA KHHIM, ee Halos TOC BPOMs HCOOXOAMMBIMD CPOACTROMD ASA TOFO, IT06% CABAATE Baw6orbe AOCTYOGhIMG HapOABOMy COsBaBiln COgepmanio ont0- coecxo-pesmriosgo% wopase. Bs arom cMbCAS 08} OOBACHRET CyuyecTRemHble eakth g AOrMATH xpHctiagcTBa, HO OObaCcHoRia 0 CBBABTESRCTBYWOTS, ITO Cogepmanic Xpuctianctea BLIXOANTS 3a Upexbabl EPATHIECKOH e@NsOCOein, B yOBRAMOTS, YTO Xpu- CTIARCTBO, OTS KOTOPArO OMS AYMAXD TEOPCTRICCRM YRAOBRTLCA, MRA0 BAX} HEM COSBC BAACTH, HOMCAR CKOADKO OHS COBHA~ saxs. Ho ero posapbait, oTAbabatiil cyGbexTs AUAMeHD KPETE- ‘SOCKE OTHOCHTLCS KB OspyMalome ero MHsBA, A wayIBOG wumazemic HavuRaeTCR Cb waCabAoBAaBia Toro, 476 BBs CoORep- AMATO HAMH CO DPRBLIIKS AVAMGO Obit yAepRano wa GyAy- mee spema m0 3akonaMs Mbicau. Ho cb Teveniews spemena Opam- 40cb yOBANTBCA, 470 Ha0AHposasie OTAbsLHOH AMYBOCTH OTS HCTOpssecKaro pasBaTia deaxoBbyectBa ecth oaKgia. Teaosses, cramems cb Cegekow, ecth RBBOTHOe OOMeCTBEBHOe; OS KA- NTS CBOCW COGCTBERHOW MmsAil0 TOALEHO KAKS IACHb YEAOB- secxaro oOmectsa. Kagb ToabKO OH HATHHACTS MBICAUTb, Ob YRC BXOANT Bb AYXOBHOG HACABACTBO, KOTOPoe ero NoKOAbUiE Bb CROW OFEPEAL DOIYINAO OT DPCMGWX POAOBS, H OTb KO- Toparo ofS Be MOMETS OTKABATECA. ITO CABAYeTS CRASATS KARE % orgomesi# efo ©> pesnriosHod musen sOBBICCTBA, TAED366 HPABOCIABAOE ObO3PSHIE. pasHo 06% oTHOMmenin kb HAaMleMy BpeMeHH # ero ycaoBiawS, Bb OcoSeHHOCTA 06% ero OTHOMeHiA Eb xXpuctiancrBy. Ons mu- BeTb H AbIMETS Bb TOH AyXOBHOH aTMOC@eps, BOTOpAd BB Te- senic BBROBD HANOAHAAACh XPBCTIAHCEAMN MBICIAMR; H CAH OB AyMaeTs, 970 pesaria MOMETS ObITb NOCTpoena wBB IACTArO pa- ByMa CTO MB0KHPOBAHHOK AWTHOCTA, TO 8TO KOHETHO OGoALHE- nie. H eb caMoms xbaB BceoOmia noxomenia TON peauriu, FO- Topylo Teneph HasbIBawTS oHAOcoe@cKoro (Vernunftsreligion), na- Kopi: ysenie o Bors, 0 cBoGoxt w Geacueptin, cb AOcTaTOIBONO ACHOCTiIO CBHABTCABCTBYIOTS, ITO OHH BbIPOCAH Ba HOWWS XpH- criancrsa. Bas xpuctiancrsa pa3ym> Daaroaa ne Bosebicaaca XO DoxHarO HOHATiA Oo AWGHOMS Borb w cocTosmaro ch BUMS BB CBAs DORSTiS 0 TREpYeCTBS, paseo KaKb pasyws MaroMeTad— CBUXD YICHLIXE 20 DOHATIA 0 CBOGOAB, H pPAasyM eBpeeBt NO Towero HosATIA o GescMepTi, KAXS OpOxOAmenin sBTHATO Cy- Mecrsosania, cad3agHOM Cb yIeHiews O BOBAagHIA. ITO CoAb- maa sacayra Hisetepmaxepa, 470 08% PHAITOMHAS oasbutEBGe pasybxenie Memy OTABABHEIMG CyOBeHTOME H OKPyMatonyer ero Cpexoi0, B% OcOGeHHOCTH Cpexolo peanTiosHOH musaa, OODACHHED, 4To Baxava xpucTiaucnaro cosHagia we 3B TOMS, ITOOKI CrpORTE HCTHAAYD peanriio, HO Bb TOM, ITOGbI crath BB ASHCTBHTEXB- HB; COWS Cb HCTHHHOIO pesnriew, OCyMecTBHBGEWCA- BY xpscriancrss. Ho pb cawom> x8 BAG XpuctiaHcTBO ects ACTHH- Wad pesnria? ITorTs BOUpOCs OTHIONE He MOMETS Guth pPbmMeHs EPHTREOW orabasnolt ARQHOCTH, @ TOTbRO ®AKTHIECROI BpHTA> BO cosepmMasmewca Bb teveuin BhROBD. Heassa He UpHBHaTS ‘BH 3acayrn Tereaa Bb TOMB, ITO OND NOKAZAND, KAS ITOTR 06b- ORTHBEBIH KpHTATeCKI Mponecch cymecTBeAHO CHocobcTROBaIS EB DO3HaBilO ACTHHLI BO BCBXS O61aCTAXd 3HaHia, —XoTA BL cBoeli oHACcooin peanriv ORD BB06pamaeTs Nnocabsopareapacitl XOAb pasBatian peanrin HECOOTBSTCTBeHHO HCTOpHYeCKOl ABACTER- teabuocta. HoTereas cmotpbab Ba pexBTilo OAHOCTOPOBHE, KakB Ha ABAO TOABKO HETOAACRTYaAbHOe; y HeTO HW Tpxonagenie ecTb HEOOXOAMMBIH MOMCBTE Bb OTOMB BHTEAICRTYAIDHOMD passaTin, Wcnosuaceili lars, sagt waspaxt ero [essepb, — roToppMy. BOTOCAOBIE Bb YHHBEPCETETAXS. 367 Sesosbes Hepemer> OT Gescosuaresbuaro e_MHenia cb Boroms > cosHanilO CRoeM OTABABHOCTH, 1a6bI GAKOHETS BOBBPATBTLCA 3 cosnaTessuomy cxunoniio cs Haws. Taxaus o6pasoms aca wcropia cnacenia npespamaetca Bb sormyeckili oponeccs: co- commie BeBNHHOCTA eCTb HepasBAToe foHaTie, rpbxonageuie peaxbasiomee cymzenie, a npAMApenie — ymosaKsyenie, BHOBE HpHBOAATCe KB CAHACTBY TO, ITO ObiA0 pasaxbseno. Jaa ypasy- Whais CyOyHOCTH # HCTOpMuecKaro paaBatia peautia BBNerO Be Guo H BSTS ONACHBe, KARD HOYMBALE ONBABTS OTOTS ymacabiit ears rpbxonagenia. OGnacuats rpbxb, opatos oGsacnats, EAE> HOOOXOABMEIN MOMCHTS BB BCTOPIA UeAOBBIecTBAa, 3HAqETB mm Goxbe, HH MeHbe, KAKb YHAITOMATS caMoe nonAtie rpBXxa, ROTOMY {TO HeOSXOAEMOe—TO, ITO BB DOCABIHEME OCHOBAHIB pospernrca KE Box Bomie#i; a Bb nonatia rpsxa cymectsen- Boe HNCHHO 70, ITO Ha Hero HBTS BOAR Bomiel. Bs caoews pascymacnin 0 KOpeHHOMS 3x5 BB YexOBEYeCKOH OpHpOrS, Bb RepsoMs OTABAeAIA @MxXOCO@CKaro yseHia o peanrin, Kanrs Gnapymesacts Coxke Tpessni BBTARIb Ha STOTS SAaKTS H Tsy6- Me BUBKACTL Bb CFO UPHIBEB, H UOTOMy Opawo upHanaerca: “MAG BAL AST AUGErO HEUOCTAMAMGE NPAINALI, OODACHAPHOH, HAK@WS 06paz0Mb BPaBCTBeHHOe 810 Morao BOUTA Bb Bact. Ho TOMY HOHOHSTHOMY, XOTA A HEOUPOBePMAMOMY OaKTy rpBxona~ Ronis yo10sbEa OpoTHBODOCTAaBAAeTCA TAKRe HCOOBSCHEMLIH Hob CCPECYBEHHATO pasBATiA YEAOBEICCTBA H CTOABKO We AOCTOBSP- mut ‘eanTs Comecrsenuaro Oreposenis, a OTHIOTL He NpuspaKy xaxol-10, upmpaysemilica yeaowboecTBy Bb OLAS NpeKRpacusill XOHb of020 30-ro roxa Hamero FSTOCIRCACHIA A BAYMMBMIt my, 37O OHO BOBCe He OTUAaIO oTb Bora, Kakb AOTOAS eMy Wasas0cbh, HO HaXOABTCH Bb OAMHCHIM H Name COCTABAACTS OLEO cs Boroms. Passutie peanrifi npowexognz0 He Bb ORHOMS Ha-~ BpaBEeHi, 2 Bb ABYX%; OLHO OpeAcTaBAReT HCTOPia ecTeCTREH- SWXB pesnrill, aApyroe npoTaBorosomHOe—HCTOpiA SorooTEpO~ Dennoi peanrin. Draws pasanseniems, AyMalo, yeTpanAeTca CHOPS 6a oTgomenin MemAy pasyMom> m Orxposeniens; on0 ocHoBLI- BOTCH HA SAKTARY, EWSIONIAXD DpPaBO Ha BCeObMee UpH3HaHie,368 WPaBOCHABHOE O603PSHiB. Takb KAR AXb 4CPKO UPOBBpATb, BMeHHO: ecTeCTReuBHIA pesa- tid — TB, KOTOPbIa COCTABIAWOTS OABY H3b CTOPOHD ecTecTBeH-, Hod gaqionasbHol MasaH TOTO HAH Apyraro Bapoga, M Kab OO cuoco6y cBoero Opoucxomgenis, Tak H 00 opeAMetams secTRO- BaHid BAagbIBAIOTCA @CTECTBEHBSIMH; DOTOMY HW CaMM GORYBHOMbI ecTeCTReBHOMY XOAY pasButis, H Hapods, CaMbi AapoBHTH Bed BCBXD BYAbTYPHbIXS HapoOaowd, we MOTAM OPeAOXpaRMTb OTS. MOAIHeHiA TOMY Ke XOAy, ROTOPLIH Be_eTh OTS BOSAWEHORCRIS qpest sospactanie w oponsbranie xb yoaaey # TH6edR, T. @,. ecTeCTReHBOMy pasBATilo rpSxXOsHaro DOBpemAeHia, KOTOPbIM cama oH# 3apamenbi. Hanpotass Oorootgpopensaa peauria He OCTh UPOAYETS eCTecTseHHaro yeAOBSiecsaro pasBHTia, eo MOM- RO OOBACHBTS TUABEO A3b BbICMArO ApRAQNOA, sKOTOpLIH OpiaD BEOPCHCAS Bb CCTOCTBOBHYW MA3Hb OAHOLO MaBBCTBALO Baposa M BCerO TeAOBHYeCTBA, XOTA 4pesb DOCpeACTBO AOCTOCAABHHIXS mye, Coabe BCelO UPOHBKAYTbIXD UM Bb CabACTBIG OCO6ERr garo Bomecrsesuaro sgoxsosenia. [lo atowy aonati, soro-- OTEPOBCHHAS PesHria CCTb TOADEO PeAUFiH BOTXOZABBTAAM, KAR. OpexbyroToenTeabHad, # XpHCTianCKad, RAK coBepmenabimee- oTepopunie, a He CYAAMSMb, HAQpAMBpd, KOTophili 00 BEANMOMY.. MubeTb Ha 9TO Opetensi0. ExanoGomie serxosasbruod posarie: Be CCTs, KAD YTBepwlaeTs Peuans w NoJ., ecrecrsesswii Opo~ AYRTD COMHTHICCKOH pach; OBO UpiOOpBao cusy H ORPBOAO BS Gops6s cb ecrectseaHow pesnriew ato pack — asbisecTsOwh. Mo xpactiancrsb rakb xe OTHIOAD HOAbBA CAGBATh, ITOOH ONO: CBOBMS DoaBsepienb sakagIABAIO MBCCilo DETXOZABSTEOH pea rin, KAKb TOADKO opoxoamenie aToM nocabagel; OHV OCHORABO Ha Gesyca0BHO HOBOMS Aaya’, KOTOPOe COCTORTS GH Kak Be 8b ysenin, HO BB AnaHOCTH Iucyca, GesycaoBRO OTANHOH OTB sctxs. Bs Ero swmé sagaiowerca fia ectectsensold mane qesobka ChMa HOBO AyXOBHOH MUsHH, KOTOPOe OGAaAaeTS CH 401 UOpenoObmsaTs ecTecTseauylo HOpyy rpbxa BCwAY, FAB TOAb— KO OBO ycBOgeTCA BOCcopieMaWwmaNs ero AyXoMs. NoctouHctBo- S89H0CTH Tucyca, MCEAIOUNTCALHO Euy cBoHctBeHHOe, COCTONT®. Bb TOMb, IT0 6s Hems ofumaems oca nosnoma Boasecmea mn—BOTOCHOBE B% YERSEPCHTETAXS. 369 secno (Kos. 2, 3), m ro, BODTOMY ANNE BOBXD BpeMORS A0I- encTsylorh covepsaTs BCTWRyY H mwBHE aa> Ero noagoty. Passer, pesmriso ome jarbe camaro Xpwera, Hak ITO Tome, pesphmars xpuctiaucrso, aty adcoatTayio peamrilo, Bb yuospH- temsuee spanie adcomoTHol enz0coeim,—9T0 3naduTS DORHAATS Raunhil mers 00 Gsarogate Bomie# epepxci nawest cnacenia, yeGn cuoBa Opocntca Bb pacTabsawimil noTow, ecTecTBeHHa- Fo passsyia yexopbvecnol muaHN, yOpaBiaewaro rpbXow> w saxymxeuiows. [Ipaptows, Ges comusuis, ocraetca HeusMBE- Mb, TO KAMCUb TOTS AAN OLX — KAMENb CHacenia, 134 IPYTexd — npersmagia « coGaasua; woTOMY ITO yObmacHie BD poTaHS xpuctiagcTsa He MoRerb GbITS AORAsHBAENO HO Obme- DpswaroMy cuOCOSy; ero HY MAO OpiodpdraTs ABTHO HEpeREBae- Mim onbaroms. OuaROTL Tb, KoTOpbie ACDORDAyOTE cb fler- POMS: «Kb ROMY Ham BATH? TH wMBeMIE rxarosbl BBYHOM mw3- Nes! KpowS AORAGATOABCTBA BUYTPCHHATO HOUbITAHiA WACTaB.AMIO- mye mA BOSKY HCTHHY w CzameHBOTSOpHON: cHaLl Oaarospetia Hipucrosa, MOryTs CCbINaTSC# HMA AOKAZATeADOTBO BHBATWATO owsiTa u earvons. Bt upexucaonin KS cpoeH xpactiagcHoM 20r- marevs (Glaubenstehre) Lilvpaycs ceasarb oven xopotio: eoyOvenrapwad EPHTAKA OTEBALHAO ARHA-D0A00HA OONTAHY, EO- Toped sca MaxbqHHD MOMETS sANepeTh wAXOCYTS; BO EPUTY- Ka, OOSONTUBHO COBCpIAleMancd BD TOYeRIN BBRUBE, HeTerCE, nexeGuo Sypnot pSeb, Dporass KOTOpON CescmabAt! BCaKia HIO- ou © BaoTeHes. By. comacnia ceoes Wirpaycy aywaary wa~ UpeweTy aTy YHRUTOMalOMylo OOSeKTHHHYW EPwTURY npoTHED xpworiancrsa, H eMy YAQXOCh pasChaTh HBWOTOPbIA BEUpABAAL- Weld: Boswuania B OpeactaBzeuia: xpHctiancxow acta. Ho ca- Nowy XpECTINHCTSY 08% BAYT He MOTS NOBPEAHTS Bb CBOIO xacut. Xpscrianctso cb ropasi0 GommAMS NpasoN wORETS so Tamecyb aTol OSsenTADAOH KPATHKW O6paTHTs Ha CBORXD Dporesewnoss. xd BeioKasbisaan npoTHBS RETO NOCADAOBATeA Jove cropousi eusocoein Tereag, x0rayeckH norows nepemer- mio 5% Matepiaamany, B Apytie, COMBELIC Ch BHM, DOKpalnell wops, 3b ouHOGHMIN NpoTAsS xpectiancTsa, BE CymaocTA ToRe : 24370 UPABOGAABHOR ORUGPRER, camoe, aT) roBopaan QUnKypelin .& CTOHEM Ha AeHmcEDH Bx0- magu, 9d rosopaxb ooroms Iesson, std Bb anOXy BOspOMREY Hid POBOPHAD FeCROMAICAcRANY ryManAsMD, coOcrseRHO, B& Hra- Aig, @ ITO BB DPOMAOMD CTOABTIA TOBOPHAR SANUEAQDAAROTES so Dpannia. OGpexTusnad Kpituea GesbocraHoBoqHO mAyulel HcTopid JO08B04SeTS TOPMecTRoBaTh, cHamema cyonaun Téze, TOABEO Ha MrHOBeHie Maakylo0 NOOSA 9THMS CaaIOABLAMs, YaR- GTOMAWMAM BCAKYIO BBICIIYO AYXOBAYO Meseb BosapBaisM, KOTOPHXS AOMHDIND CACCKOME XBACTAeTh Hesbpywomad Hayka. Bo scB speMena 31a KpaTHRA. HaXOAHIa ACOOABBTANGH en DpE- TOBOPOBb HAXS TAKUMH BOS3PDHIGMM BL CAMONd Zareph BAyEE. Hanpotass, XpucriagcTso BO BCBXD TRKOTO pOAA EPASRCAKD HwBi0 UpasO Ba AWSHb, AOKASbIBAIO, ITO OBO Onto MALO A npokoamaso ObITS Ada slozell HCTOSBREOM eae BoaBh- mesia # Oxarocacsenia. Vraxb Msi MOKeMD ObITs copepmeHHO, cuOROHEL oTwocaremsao. wataia 0 Geanpeametaocts. Sorocaosis. Bos -actopia se10Bt- YOCTBA CBAXBTCALCTRYCTS, ITO POAMFis, HOXb BOTOPA CABLYET pasyMBTb coGctaesHO XpEcriancTao, ecTs.cakTs, KorOppiil,BcerAa. EMBAD Jpeavsliaiao BamAOe, a TacrO Opepdsaraomee aaisnip. Ba TOsQRBIGGRYO .RUBHb, Tro KacaeTca HAMALO: BPAMAAM, BS. KOTOPOC M PEABTiOZAbIC H HEPKOPAKS .BOUPACH OBATh BHLARBY- auch Ha Depshli oxam> HyGauqso MMsHA, TO He CABAYOTh. 3a- GuiBaTb, ITO Gopp6a OpoTass peruria, NpPOTAR® KPMCTIABOTAA WepEBH, Aame OpOTHsS aputasani paMcKpM nepaA, BO RCEr KOMB CAYIAS CRUABTOARCTAYCTS 0 ABACTBNTAABBONS CYMAGERO- Bawif AKT, NPOTABR KOTOPATO paTylOTh, H ITO BOOPOCH, :aat- POnyTHe 97010 Gope6ow, noBamAbe Bogpoca: Oo. oympcrsoRagim, DpotonaasMsl HO eg CnocoGHocTH K% pasBETiN,. Ho taRoH sBa-. GHTeAbHbIA HCTOPHICCHIN OaRTb, KAR PeAHTia, ObIAD Obl HAOKe-. ACHEMS, CCAH ObI He HMBAS OCHOBaMIH BL CYNICCTES 1OL0BB-, gacearo Ayxa. A c% ApyroH croponsl, BceoOmaoct peamria, 0, KoTOpol UpoTBb CBOE SOAH CBHABTCASGTBYOTS M UPOTHBURKA, pesaria, 6b14a Ob1 HeMbICANMa, ecan Obi eH we cOpTBHTCTBOBA-; 4a OObenTHBHad ABACTSHTeAbHOCT, T.,¢. Obitia Rowie. Tanams«BOTOCHOSIE B% YHWEEPONTATAXS. st 06paz0Nb SASTE CyMecTSyeTs, B BOMPOCS TOABKO BS TOMS, IT0- 6u Bpaswabeo Momwuats ero. Tosopath, sto Gorocaosie cab- 30Th BTO He BS CcoctoaHi#.-ITO sTOpMit OYHETS, BOTOPOMy DO- ceamactca Hamia acoxoris. TOMS 83% HaMEXS UpOTHBEHEOBS, HOTOPHE HACTOATEADRO SBICKAILIBANWTE, ITO GorocaoBic, Kany Bayka, AOAKHA YHRITORNTE permit W HOAOMATEABHOO-XpucTian- C180, HW MORES OTSBIATS UpocTo, vo xpHCTiagcKoE Corocao- sie He MexacTs atoro. Ho ecth uw MeKAY Sorocaobauu takie, corpse Ob COmarSHioND ropopaTb, ITO HAyWBde Goroczopie NO BCOOXOAWMOCTA AOFMHO YHHITORATE BBPY; DOTOMY Npexsa- FAOTS MOMAY BTUMA," BS CYMIHOCTA HOCPHMUPENEIMM, 10 AXD unbaiio, cTOponaMs, sauzovTs TaKOM KOMMpOMACCS, YOO) BEpA We Bpensrcrsosaxa cpoboxuomy AvMKeHiO Haye B 4T06% Ba- yauoe Gorocscsiec, Bb coom ONepexs, He paspymaro mpostecep~ xecis Wo waEpa, caoitcTReHEbIXD BAph. Hpa atoms. paoxabeoms xosaiictss acée-rasw ‘Bbpb ayane ocraparhca G6es> Goroesosia, Homers Gorocaocsin Oesb ‘PBpEI, nOTOMy FTO OTABAGHDIZ GotocxoReRig HayER, COOARBACMBIA BB’ ono mbsce marepecoms sfpsr a pésmriosmeti axnena, TOTIaCT! HPS STOW, pacmagaw7ca H NOATAAaOTS ssinniw omxcroTia, BC mipmoll acropia, enxocovin ‘poxmrin # SnxOCOeCHOH STHeS, fe-! Topexd u DORATOTAES, U Goroca0Es, KOTOPOMY MosdveLeWs BO 206m EOMMPONACCS, xyTE Ob1 ‘CAbAATL, ecHHOE “sAdzaro>. DPeMeNHO BNGpOmS COMIESHCTEYOMeC CROHMS saHaTiAh'y” wBCTO' Bb SS10COSCHONS Saryabters: PavsHibnoe. Xosdiidiso.we opm mecse Chi BbITOM!'-'HA ODOM Hab OObHXD. CTYpORS. ‘Kawoo. ae! BD Cawows XbES ADAMHG ObITs ‘OTHOMERIe MERAY: BEPOW:! Go-| rocsosions? He toqzexinys' COMBBHIIO, YTO- DepBORaYadsHO Cys SyeCTRYTL BBO; a DOCKS Hea BOABAACTCA GorocavBic, HwbiOMeE: BSpy cCsoswL DppAMetom’s.' A saanie-cBoero npeaMeTa yReau- 2OaHHO YHUITOMATE Camel npeawers? O Gorocacsia woRWO OKA’ wave TOMe, $70 WO SHBHEB, KoTOpad' He -yHRITOMALTS CcBOEFO Bpeamera, OOTOMy “10-HScrSAyeTs BaKvmi ero-rvaeRis. Ho UPOTBS TOTO MOTYTS BOsPasHTb: «ROHETHO, ECAH Oo? BEPE OeiAa TAEAMG 26 OLTYTHMBIMS A TeeplO CroamuwL spenMaTows. Ho: 2aama BRAD@CIAREOR OLDRPREIS. Bhpa eC TORO oOpma Hamel AyAOBNOM AbaTembBOCTE, Re- HOcpeacTaenGO YCBOAIOMASs AyXoBHOe COACpmaHic, a ecaH HAYKA BOBBOARTS BTO COACPBanie wa CTeHEAb BHawia NOOPeACTBOME BbIACHOHIA GFO OCHOBABIN, 70 ymRe HeN@cpeACTROBHOH BSP KO— mens. Kpomb roro, mSpa OMMpaeTcs: Ba MCTOPRICCREXD CBHAB— TeALCTRARS H BABACHTS OTS aBTOPHTeTOBS, KeTOpble He MOLyTS- YCTORTh OPeAb HaYIHOW KpATREOIOy. Tro Racaetca uepBaro BOs pamenia, T.e, ITO BEHOCPOACTBCHBAd BPA LOARPA YARITOMETH— CA, EOTAA HAYEA, HOCPOACTBOMS BhidcHeBis ea OCHOBaHiA, ROZRO- AUTD 00 Ha CTeleHb BHabis; TO 90 MOTAO ObI CAyWNTECA TOAL- KO TOTAa, CCW Obl HAYKA MOFAA KOTAR HWGYAL DORORIETA Cb ATAMS CBORM OPRACHRTCALELING DpoReccous. Ilaxxeps, same- mapa KBTCROe Bpocrocepsedie NPOTMBL pAveveTaNsarO Gaaro— pasysis, ABsACTS COpaBenamBee HaAnOMMBABIe CaNoyAsSpenHol, DOCUSMHOM Bb CBOBXS OPHLOSOPAXD HAYKS; COCZORTS 3a1a5a Bale HAyTHO#-NBICANPEsDHON ASATOA,HOCTA? Be TOM, IPAS ACO, Gogh Bamera ysacria, B@DOCPOACTROBHO-AaBHOe COXepmaAnic REMAre, AYAA. PARBaTh BD ONPEABACHEWA OONATIS, Bb. COSBATEADEO 06 CHOBAHHIA, WOCASZORATCALESIA mM CZpONO CRARGHBAA MOMAY ceGow mbican. Ho Mbi JOSE COTSACHTEES, ECAR TO4bKO CRPOM- BO .OTAATARBO PABCYHAROMD 0 CBOOMS MEIMZCKIB, ITO BLOFRS. paspMIBTs, Oty BARAT HAM} He YARETCA, B ITO BD Halen He DOCPCACTRGRROME COBGAHIA BCergZa OCTaeTCA RAKOU-T0 OCRATORS, Koraphii He DEpexasaTS Bb auanie, HOQpeACTByaMOe HayKOH.. Sakeb-TO saeHOTAeTCA DPHIBHA, NoveMy He Npexpamaerca no~ Cywrenie, xa Aatbebimemy pageutiio nosHaRili, Kb DORTOpHTeIb- BYMb, DPOLUPRERTiANS ORHOM H TOHMe paGorbi, AAOb! UPEBECTS ©@ Eb YAOBACTBOPETCAbEOMY KOWWY, B NOGeMy KAMAAA Bay IHO-. DPORSROAMTCABHAS ARIHOCT BhIMIe H Goraqe NO coxepmanil, HéRean opewagaemamaa ef cuctewa. Totomy, ecaw GorocsosieBOFOCAOVIE BS YHOBEPCHTETAXS. 373 KOKRBIBACTL, ITO HBBBCTHOY TOAROBaHie TOTO Ban Apyraro On- Gaclicearo TORCTA BOAACKATS COMMEND, BAKAOIACTS BE COOB Mperasophiis, KoTOpata He MOTYTE ObITs ycTpaseaw Gest uace- sosauia ero emcaa, HAH ITO HapogHoe BSposanie opahaMucTS BSKOTOPEIA BHbOaia CCOeNBECTA 8A CYMCCTBORENS OPHESAVOM- HOCTH BEPEI, TO Bbpa OTCTYNACTCA OTS HEXS H TENS CHOphE, ‘tu, ona musde. Ecam xe, nanporess, Gorocxosceas wayEa CrAHeTS BAkS HAGYIE ROKRBHIBATS, ITO ce. Iimcanie cers TOASED sexoebsecroe Oponspesenie, DOMOGHOe APYTEWS ANTePaTyPRMIS RAMATHBEAMS, TOTOMY #6 MOMETS CAYAUTE OPOORTCTEIONS ‘KUT sespatiimaro passutia peanrig, iTo peasriosnce Aswxenic, NBO mmce CBOG Bagas40 BB AEN fncyca, O6xzaN0 CBONED TPSMCKOM-. . Reaiews ecTecTBeauoMy paspaTio YeAeBbIeCTSA, DOTOMY WORETS pacsasarsca saxbe.XKpucra: ro ato, oo pipameain I[[ussepa, Sporssepaars Bceo6mesy tysCrsy scBKS MCKpeNNO SSpyio~ Mux’ ‘xpsctiags. Borocsesckas gaya Totxa YOLEO YCUBEIBO SyAOTS BLIDOSEATS CROW Bamaty, KOTAa, BOBOyaNAeMAd BOROG- Wiles BPOTHPOpTriewb, Choa DPAMETCH GA DOCISMAO RONTCE- ayo paGory a Hyreus Coase ocHopaTeabwaro sacrbacsavia DPERCTL HS Gowbe Gzaronpisresim> AXA BBP pasyaLTaras. Tesoss rors euulexs yacto oxoynorpesasemaro, HO Tsy6OK0- wbpzaro sirpamesia Anvesua: fides quaerens intellooctam, xe- Topee AIlzeliepmaxeps siidrasuxs oURrpacems CBee AOTmATI- 7. ) Bepa. sanaoincts 0b co6s mewcronyemo-rayGonilt pexeass Co&TA, BOD KoTOpare BAYKA MOMETS HOTepnars, BS ROTUpEIH.NO- OTS BPORTKATH Ch CBONNS CESTERENKONS, BBKOTWA 410 Be w@cvepmunes = ne mcromas. Ho stpa se qRMeTS say IEOMy emenia Serocsceid sanakoro Apyraro cvicuesis, xpows Tero, €2K00 MCEDMTSOWTS Beh HAYEH, SATEMADENCS MOC ISROBATEND. oGsacnenions =-sexomesioms sagsero Coxepmagis; > TAeeEre pash GOSRAR .NAyWHbE TeOpis BAXONNTE DE HETOCPEROTRONNUINE eecapietia otoro caxepmauia .# 5% Gadsmgenia ero OpON ‘OCEO- tasig w-epeicrsa uoBhpens costa # BCLpEBANT. - ¥) Neque caim fatelligo, ut credaim, sed credo, ut intelligam. Nam qui ava ‘crediddil, non ‘expetistir etqui expertus non fierit, non intelliget.Bh '\ BPABOOIADBOE OBOBPSEIE. >Boreesosie SMBCTh CBROMMD BOCkMA POaALELIMD. IPOAMDTOMD @ARTh PesAriosHoii BbpL, KOTOParO BhpROCTL BOATBEPMaeTcH -OBUABTOABCTROND ‘BCeH BCTOPIA Fer0BBYecTEA Hw HeOOXOAHMOCTL cosnaniewt BChXS stodeH @ napoxopb. Beam Opi ETO-an60 wy BMAPLG NPOTSRABKOBS CTAAB YTBEPAAATh, ITO y BBROTOPBIXS HeRABHO OTPLITHXS HAPOLOBS HE CyMectsyeTs HH maabimMaro BaMeka #8 pexurito, 10 Mb 6e3b COMAbHIs MMBAR OI ApaBo -yoorpeGa@ 35 opolictienabiii HN CaMHMs Opiews, 00 KOTOpoMy OHE, Bawhaas, ITO Bb UXL THON HeLOCTACTS WBHOTOPHIXS CHOBE, Y¥bmawTs coda BbpOW, YTO BPH ToOInSHmMENS BabicHanin, EO- Hew, Oysyrs.natazcas! a on. Borocaopie, xaxhe, Ho BWheTD BH Hase6nOCTB, HH Merasin YHRITOMBTE DOcpeACTROMS- EPUTE- EH cBoii UPOANeTS, T.-e. Bbpy HIN paspsmuT, ee BE sHaHie; CKOpbe Oba MesaeTh LOCTABATE COGOW CpeACTeO YCBOUTL HAYIHO- sy: cosnagin conepmanie Bbpe BH CAbAaTS ee coAepmaniows Ha -yaHaro acosizania; A 970 BayKa, DOcBNMenHad weexBJoRaniD BpemmeTa cosh rayGoKod m MBOTrocTOponuel BAMAOCTH, AMSETS. -BommOe Dpaso Ha CaMOGLITHOe CymecTBOBAMie, GOsB' SOTOPArO He ‘RoeTanaxO 6b! CyMecTBeABArO TACHA Bb HAYIROMD OprasHsNs,— @70 “Re :HOTPOOYOTS -LAAbARAMIBX AORABATCALCTES, €CAB COrEa~ -eatsva cd: Kantown, ut0 seaonbRy me TYBAD MENEpHCE KB: BB4- -womy Onary, pom BHTepeca ‘kD TexccHOMY Oxary BED Crpol- mb .Ppawegancnees oTaomenians. [lo orspmeain'es oary.Ab- TeTaMs, COCRUINCHAHML STEMS TPeMT GOSACYRWS, @HAOCOOCETT @AKYALPOLH EMBL: MEpBORATAIGGO TOABEO BOHGHOTATEHHHOS BHB~ Hid, ROCTARES. HOOGKONEMLEA Ad HEKS CEBLCHIS ORSOCOONYE- omis, emioz0rmeokis; HCTOpHsetuia, m Tame maTewavagecalt B erréeormenne-sesopuscoris. Ho ob Tewesiems spewena 3teTt @RnpMaETS: SA RNRDUPSBAATE 10..CTEnCAB' CABOCTOTTEALAArS HE Yyreaco QSrr0, .W OTABILESM RAYEH, BLO COETEBAMTTA; CODE ANEAHG: EBAY cO6OwW: BS CTpeMsenin WecmRORATL wCIWHy © Pat AM-@a camoly TORLA SaK OCTAADALIG: CRRPULTOTS! WubaN qBFHP Upaxreueckm coatiowsosaTl: nepxoRnelt MNZEN, TpamnaRcncl RABE, BLOPOBLN. ro 4081 @anyabTeTa, aubionjie saxsTPO cn Gamecrsopath masHE Mepsopnaro oGntecrea, xajore..-OPA-BOTOCHOBIE BS YRHBEPCHTETAXS. 378 Cary Ba PEPHOCTS OCHdBAaMD aTATO OBINeCTEA, TO aTO CaMO nO ce6b OTHIONL HO MOMOTS' GHTS NpexocysuTeAbHO. Aarapaxs, To WOBOAY aTarO OCTosTeALCYBa, BalyMayb OCHepaBaTh y Sorocao~ sia UpaBo 8a AasbMbinies CynecrsoBahic BE KAVeCTES GAeHa BB WAyWOMS OpranHsM’s. «Boroc#ovs!, ropopHrs o#%, BcTyHaomie Bb Kaxia-2M60 OGUGaTCALCTBA OTHOCHTEABHO PesyALTATOBS A Me- YOXA CBONAS BSCABACBANIH, He BWSIOTS HukaKOTO npasa cHO~ ypiTs ma ce6a, Kaks Ha CAyHMTOReH HayaHy. Tro KacaeTca Dpo- TOCTAHTCRUXD GOFOCAOBOBD, 10 STO OGABATCABCTBO OTHIOAL He CORSLIBACTE WXD TAHHNS BEBOEUME OOPAGOWS, KAR HANpAMSpS WPACTORE HO OTHOMeHIIO KS MbCTHOMY MpaBy rocyxapcrsa. Ecan mepsHe He BalyMOTS AbAaTh web Exauresia Hoss saxous, TO BIO -@ORBATCABCTRO HWRARS HE MOMCTE-ObITs OTHOCHMO KB OyE- BB CB. NBCANIS; PABMEINS OOpasoN’s, ECAH ON He COrRACHLI Ipe- XOCTABANTS CROBMD CAMBOAWGOCRUML HHATAwS TOO Opecbsara- lomjaro saateuia OraceMrasuo camate ce. Hncagia, Kakb BS Peuckol nepesm opexoerasxeno npexasiio; To sto oGasaTerb- OTRO HO MCRAWIACTS ANC BUXS CBOSOAG OTCTYNATS OTS BbKO- TOPHX BSPOONPENBACHIN BAHMOYAMIMEXCA BL BX CHMBOANIC- cunxs rowraxs. Coo6era, 933 notopdl Tenrerendeprs crssaxs b% caoeu> yenin 06b oTaomenin wey Bbpow x ACSpLIME Abxa~ WW, TeTOs MUpoKOE M COMBHTeABHOe yHoTpeOscHic, Be MORETE Guiry cBHgaHa BHAI, KAR TOMBRO HAYTHIMH CPeRCTBAWH B fe ABDDOOTS CTO UpaRA OuiYL CrOsDOD mpoTecraRtcROM OpTOAOKom: Ho ccan‘komy ssgyuaetca ovpaiars ‘nocrownorso Xpwcta, ars cammaro‘uemero Honynutats 2 Xonaras, uckmowmressuo ‘Euy BPRBALISRAMes, oTveprans ‘pynopercTBenHVe sHAtHie ‘cB. Hwow- miu, 2am Ho BaNMATS ComecrPCANeS TIpusO NALOTSA, NpPsBO eke+ ‘TpSTs BA: Rom AeCples NOUR, RAKE Ha-Bacayry Upors Borows,-- TOTS tawy uoTE O81 CABTATL, ITO cRBsass Tarapys, spwoneDy) ‘(1O' ONG WOMOMETD UPHWORAERATE KB UpoTEcTadveKo-Carocx0n- cuomy eaxyxsery. Ups umcrocroposaecrs ‘nayienin's « samagitt; Wy MAIS “DO'CaBCMY ByUTECHMy Corenydsoned fayHH, TRROMY JenPeRY AOPRO MabaTaN gaa Cole, CAN BAEC, Xpyroe Bpacvd Hime, hwy OOSB, ITO BB CpeIs ‘HECRATADUMNS COO rT FOlSEOS376 HPABOGAARHOE OBOBPANEE ;.: Bilo RPHHATO 38 DPABAAO RByYATb BCO, IFO ORM BBYWHOTE, HO paid oGasateascrsa, HO 00 CBOGOAgOMy awaywHoMy yOSmucHiD, Haar oquakom> waualaat He Cb TAROIO OAROCTOPOHHOIO HECApa~ BeAAMBOCTIIO TOADKO Ha GorocsoBie; OHD CHOTPEAD Ha O6m—a~ TOALCTBO UPeAUHCABHOG YCTABOM, HARD Ha OGmee, ROTOPOMY NO CROCMY MOATHHAAACS W KOPHCTH M MOAUEY, BMBCTS CB COrocad” BaMH; eC4H Ld Gorocaobons upeAMeTOMD OGazaTeabcTea KaaTe HABbIBACTS TOABES GuCsilo, ASA WPHCTORS MBCTHOS UPAR cROeTO TOCyaapcTea, JAM MeAWEOB) MEAHQRHCHIK ycraBD, 10 Aa Goro- CAOBOBD OGAZATOALCTRO, OVERANHO, MOHE CricauTesbHO. Ce croolt e@uxocoeckol Bucoth! Kanrs cMoTpbab Ha OCTAADEHG #aYJbr TOTH CAUIIKOMS OpeHespeRHAHO A CAMTIROMS PRaKO BMCTAR- AG} HPOTRBODOAOMMOCTS MEMAY HUM R GARYALTCTOMD @EAOr coeckums. Hoaban ceagath, yF00bI TaMe CyMeCTROBAAA TOALRG Wewaywuaa NpakTARa, a aXbcb Oulad ACTABHAA Hayka; OOb crOr POBEI BOCUOABAIOTS BaaMMBO OXHA APZTyYO 8b CTpOMAeNin Kh pasphmesiio wayiHol sazaa. Ecaw eopmyamposarh oty saxagy TANAMD OOPaZOMS, ITO OBA COCTOTS BE HBCABAOBAHIB OCHOBARIN B CaaBH HAMEXD Nosnanil, B COrAACHTHCS UpH 9TOMB, ITO BTOA- WS pBWATE aTy 3aja1y BBROTAA we yaacTca, Do xpatined whps JAM OTASSLMIXD ANN>,—TO BL HAyTBOMS pasphmenia ex yaa- GTBYWTS A oNsOCOoia C> CBOeH CTOpOHEI M Apyrio @KEYAbTOTH ce caoe#. Ta speumymesuo saGoTAtca, ITOGbI BOCTPONTh ODAG- RATCABHYIO M OTPOMAyO CACTeMY, HO AOKO MOMETL sTHOpEpe DATS OTAGALULIO SARTH, HOTOPNE BG YHAQALIBAWTCA. Bb.05 Cie CreHS. ITH WMBIOTS ABAD. Cb GanTaMH mH TacTO Ch pAsy yRAOs maetca OTh HayIHACO H3% OGOCNORAHiA, awha 3a BRX: CBRASH Teascrno outa. Ho Rams @nsocesia OocTOaEAO RanOMmmactE APYTOM CARY AHTETAMD 0.HCOOXOQMENMOCTA COOOMATS BXB HAY IEDRES RacahAOpaHiswy OCHORATERLHOCTD H crpolmOcM, cama soczaRIEe Kb..TOMY .CPOAGTEA; TARE H Th, CB CROed cropousl, Beacil..paay ChHANORA SOBTOPAOTd el BAAALY OPRANMATS Be PANIETS.OTSPM- Beemde RMB @aKth. Oprandeania BALIEXS YERBOPCHTATORS, TARR MBODD ChoCOGorsoRADwAS HSMENAON OCHOBATOALMOCTA M OGMGTPE TOAMHOCTH, AMGOTS TY RONAN. BHTOLY, $70 BD MEXD, BO: SinBOrOCOBIE B% YHUBEPCHTETAXS, 377 cxoxsso rpySomy stipamenin Kanta, sce coxepmanie yqexocTa oOpaCorsipactcs, TAKS CKAZATb, «00 eapmanOMy CHOCOSy, Ipess paaxbaegie rpyxa.» Jaa opotectaatcxaro Gorocaosia 6ba0 OBI Hecaactiom®, 6CAd Obl OHO BRIABIHAOCL ¥3% STOH MBM A OREB- Aswmell cpestl, Bb KOTOpoH coBepmactca OOwbHD wemAY Ay- XOBELML AASHieND M EPRUEMANioNs; Gelso 641 mecvacriens w1Aa Hepeossot H3HE, CCAR Obl OpEsBaHAbIe KB MoteteHin ono AN- Wem OBL YaaCTid BS TONS OCBAAOMEND H MBOTOCTOPOHHEMS wayruoms xBamenin. H rocyzapcreo He AOBOAUTS UpMHEAS ‘cBO- €F0 OTABACHIA OTS HepKBN 10 TOTO, ITOOM BaObITh, KAKS BARHO 4a ero coOcTeenawxs mbze sxpasoe passutie qepsosEot mA- SUN, DOTOMY TpeSyers, T7068 GyxyMie DacTLIpm NOAYWAAR aKane- MEsecKoe O6pasopania Bb OCHOBABHHXS AMS YHNBEPCATETAXS. Hi yameepcuteTn nepectaam 651 ObITh ThMH, Ha ITO YaCRIBACTS MX} ENS, CCAR Obi HAayEA, UOCREMONNAd MeCabORABIO A RODONE- Bim © peamrioguold AMREN, Be BMhsa BD WAXe CROOTO NDELCRRER- WAILCTBd,—Bh STON HO Memes OGuauiasess.O” fesmpRcspacrEes mecuotpureszsce cymgonio. Tanums oSpasoms auc bovevacsten CQEPTIOCHE OGeOMOTEERETON CTO MOTOMOWS RAKS THOVORUARETO “ERORA Bb yHESePCHTOTOKONS Opranmows H Bt nayks. Ornsei YeRLHO HAaTAKOKS, ABAXCMEIX'S fd HAMy Hayky, Mer Oyxews td- Bepiirermo coonolant, scat Ch HCKPOHHAMS pactoxomesion’ Or- necems Bb coh cxob0 Anocroda: sce sawme,—naks NOCTOaaIOG sosbymgonic Kb Hayao xbaTexbHocTH, a Bb ocoGéaHocta qpR- Nome % Cepany,.cagna cHbAyIoMiia Aasbe: ov awe Xpucmogry, a Xpucmocs Boacits (1 Kop. 3, 22—23). \ Ur. B. K—h. Xapsness.HHSHb A YIEHIE BOTOMEIOBS © 1O DAHODJIM EBOUMIA BUrABEHA MW OAPYCHMD HCTOSHHEAMS, > Bs 1872 roay 3 Upanocaaszous OGosphuix Ouxs nanevaTrats pyccxif mepesoxs BuraSenona Tpartara 0 6oromHzaxs cB HeTOpHH ‘weceuun cebybuiaun 06% vrod cerrh, sauMcrBossHEnEA 435 Bu- samvidcnod mecerexbEme, Anan Kowaenoft, nveofainms O..H. ‘Ta- ‘aaysonxs. Bs. nacreaiiet ctarwh 1peXCPABAACTCK MAY UREN pasteps ‘Burehenonwxs weeborit 0. Goremeraxy m opapmeRie HIS ep: ReGke- G@iAME APYTEXS acToTHEROR,. Dp saxgouy BCTOpMYeCKONY SNARE- Rin CorommascKoH ceRTH, UpemMymecTBanpO Bb cpexh cxabap- CEEX, 4eMeHS, WO ea HecoMHbaHOMY BAiasin Ha noszRbimia CeRTH SANAXHWA H BOCTOIBNA, No sHaveniM Bosspbuif cenTH BB Bsyyenin HapoAHOf CxrOBeCHOCTH, MERAY MpOWMS Hames pyccKoH, Bcukaad CepbesHaa NOMWTRa HAyWHO OcBbraTh Maxo eme O6cxrb- XOBaHEYD ‘EcTopin a ceRTH SACXYRHBACTS © aoxuaro ara iat. Ped. “A ra eae Hai Tipu cocraszenin Hacroamaro Tpyx@ COWNHUTesS MOILSOBAICH UpeHMY- MecTBeHHO CABAYOMAMH HCTOWHEKAME H NOCOGiaME: Euthymius Zygabenus: ,Narratio de Bogomills*, titulus XXII, edid. Gieseler. 1842. Gotha. — MavesNea Geqparixy (Bb saTHECKOMS epes.). Maxima Biblioth. vet. patrum, t. XXI. Anna Comnena: Alexias*, L L. XY, ed. Venetiis, 1729. Rosua Upecsuteps: ,Bechyu aa sosoasupmywca epecs Boro- unaiy“, Ipasoca. Co6. 1864, 3. I, II.BOTOMBAL. WI Quzoguxs Goxrapcxaro. naps Bopnce, Bpew, O6m. Hor. « xpena. 1855. xa. wButie upen. Hiapiona Morsencxaro“. Toss. Co6p. axbr. 1. IX, erp. 144—149. Liber s. Ioannis apocryplus, ap. Thilo, codex apocryphus Novi Testa- menti. 1832. p. 884—896. Lipsine. Ceillier: Histoire generale des auteurs sacrés ot ecolesiastiques, tUxxT. @Engelhardt: ,Kirchengeschichtl. Abhandlungen. 1832. Erlangen. p. 153—250. Gieseler: Lehrbuch der Kirch-gesch. I, I. 1844. — ,Uber den Dualismus der Slaven“, Theo? Stud. u Krit. H. 1. Neander, Kirebengeschickte, t. ¥, abt. I. 1845. Ullman: ,Nicol, von Methqne, Euth Zigab“... Stud. u Krit. B, 1868. BRI © : : C. Schmidt: Histoire de la secte des Cathares ou Albigeois, 1849. Paris. Tesunxifi: ,Boromnsscrzo — Gosrapcxas epecs (mcTopHy. ovepEs) Xpucriazce. Tr. 1870. Husaps, despar. Terpanosms: Boros Uprea Bocasscea u Kpetaun. 1967. 8e- 8 Chr. Wolf: Historia Bogomilorum. 1712. Wtrtemberg. ” Oeder, Prodromus historiae Bogomiloram criticae, Tarn depx aura: Tfoanoe coOpanie coummeni® 1868 r. toxé I. ; i Osoxso 1111 1. 8% Kosctanraaonoxs voscwxy pacupoczpa- WUACE CAYAD O MOADACHIA HOBEIXD, OUACHSIXS CPOTHKORS, BOTO- PMXb WasBAAN CorowsxaMH H CINTAAA HOCAB_OBATeAAME MaBH- xeexs 8 Meccasian®. Ira epech CyMlecTBOBAAA HB Dpemle, RO He Gsr¥a ome WERECTHA NepkBM: «840 CHPBIBAXOCS DOAD Maurie ¥ gsodyrens.>» Epotann 2b Bhiciiell crenana 0f4a,a4H MCKYCCTBOME Ipwrvopstsc#; xepier, cee creneHHo, Cb Graroropbalewt, Upe- BeGperas cubzcroctiio. Ompaueanoe uevarbio ane, HOWTH BaKpL- Tee KROGYKONS; OMEGA TOROBA; MexteHHAs DOXOAEA # HOCTORE- woe nfmodrsibanto’ kaxdXs-70, woanTB> Op9 ceda—sorp Kaptaza Gorompxa 00 B306paxeuiio Anni Kowaesot), Jame moaaman 4) Adefiar, p. 384.330 MIPABOCEABHOE OBO3PSHIE. Yeuneramecs ytenioms eperaxoss; OHO wanlto 0e6%: MpuBepHeH- Webs HW Bb BHATEBIXD JOMAX (cic cixiac usyiozac), ocoGenHO Uae toxapa weyTommMo# xbateabuocta Monaxa *) Bacnaik. Bctpeso- WEREbI STHMH CAYXAMH, BMDEPATOPS BeXBAS OPEACTABUTL eMy BO ABOPeNS «yGHTEAA W BEPXOBHALO CARBY COTOMEIOBI, ‘RAKE EA- supain Bacssin oxvaienaire 00 OpwrKasanito wutepatopa epe- taxa. Mo onacanito Anati Kousesoii a Evenmia *), oto Onrats“se- AoBBEb BEICoRatO pocta, tmexyuinaro Th«OCSOmeHIA, Cb kAHHO- O6pasHo# Gopogot, 8% oxexA’ Monaxa. [paxasill, BaMOmACHRBI BHAS OOANYAID BS HONS BEChMA DPCKAONTSA ATA; OPH BCOM TOMS OHD COXpa@ens 3awbTHyt0 CoApOCTs Ayxa HW CHOCOOHOCTL XOPKO BiHaxbTS CHOBoMs, Mpic6pbrettyio nis Loxroabteeh ApaR- THEOH BB RanecTBS yawTead cerTH: 00 Eseamito *) Bacwaifl'hat- WaqnaTs ABTS wayyaxb epech m OoxBe copoka AbTS UpomoRs- Abipass ce *). Bacuxia OObIHOReHHO CONPOBOMAAAR ARBHAABATE ADOCTOAOBS BH ABCKOALKO MemMNNS KpMine passparnare na- sozenin. Korga Bacasif apnaca Bo xBopens, AMDepaTops yAocTOwss ero sexmaaiiinel ecin: Axenchi fémaéns ‘ecraap Opn éro apH- BhrcTBiN H OpArAacHAS CBCTS 3a OAANMS CTOJoMD. Munepatops CKOpO 8aMBTHxb, ITO eMy He JerKo BbI3BaTs Bacaaia wa OTEpO- *) Exonwit nassissers Bacuaia ne xonsxows, a spavems, cxbxzyd BL eroms. cayeas, sipostao, cyerspooh moxeh mapoga, roropmd suxiuy: 3p nomaxh Goromms0ns Bhyyna, wapoxba, Saxoqupmaroca BS cHOMeHIN Ch BHCMAMH CHaMH, CHOcOOHArO BpayeBaTh, 10 HOHATIN ApeBhixs cxaBaHt (Mame pycomext, Y RoTOpHXS Yarme spar epavap oOOSHaNALO -KROIXYSA, Bimaro) acaxio wexyra. Koaazyaa, vapoxka Bapoxs BaARIG H B® DpeeK- mugs Bacusia Jusonetps, xoropuit, no cxoBaMs CBOHXS YICHHBOBS BOC ‘epeos Bs tperift xens 10 cHepra m ABHACH HS BS PuXS Somme (Victufmii. 1 Aves. ap. Tolli p. 115)—ore cxapamance Honhpee, Tpeneranagnnye? Woxofannoss-oSoporses umenHo Bs TaKOh hopus (cpavau Mnnuna, crop, “Oxas. Tntep. crp. 74). Bparews, 8s uacrosmieks cunicxd, Bacuaih ne ne, PRATO RAED H WONawONS GOUSPSL 5 THO it #0 couse HA MOHAXS, & 10 Sey catasy (Annales I, XVIII). “Y) Adeues 885, Narrat, de Bogom. p. 6. . . : 4) Nesrat ¢e Bogom, L. i. a tog 5) Somaps rosopats, ,1ro Bacusifi 52 roxa nponoBbawsast HW Bano. kom Bow BcexeHayn.“ (totum fere orbem pestis implevit) Annalei XVI, p. 231. : 4BoromBaw. 381 MSHOCTL, M BOTS OND (UO NpENSpy Daapinaa egackoua aatio~ wilczaro, oTpiismano yseuie Meccasiags) KoBapHO MpeTBOpseToA RoSOpabMG yiesunont Bacesia. «Joctooovreaswii orews! cxa- 3Xb TOCyAaph,—A BECLMA MBOTO yRamalo Te6A W ITy, OABEASCE TROMMR AOOPOABTOAMA, HO ele Soxbe xOuy HayINTECA y Te6a KcTumaNs, Tailso COOOIaeMAINE TO60I0 HEMHOFHWS, Gepers KOTO- PME Hae OOMREODCABWE OGpaybl NOIMTACHS MyctbiMa w Ge8- nopesssime.>» YrToHIeHwasS 40 HOAOGOCTpactia oGxoAHTeARHOCTL MaulepaTopa H AOBKO 3AMACENPORARHOC, UPNTBOPHOE Meaagic ero 1 Gpara Hcaaxa Gsirh yreamxaua Bacusis paspazaas wakonens ¥ela BOCEBAHEMY: OHS CO BCC OTEPOBCMHOCTIO mBxAral® CBOE yseuie, He HoAospizas sacagu. Bapyrs aMnepatops u9% nocAym~ Haro YICHMKA ABAACTCA FPOIHbIMG CyAbOIO. 3a 3anaBBCaMH, pAas- FSASBUINME BXb KOMBATY, CHXSID ONCE, ObICTPO salecHBas- wit psa Bacmasia; yserie ero 65110 sanecano BCe H OpeAcTas- 3em0 Ha CYA, COBBAHBArO No BYOMy caysaw, codopa. Heoworps HA SOOMHOKPATAMA YIpPOshi H ysBMania nMNepaTOpa H EAupa Ba~ Call He AYM4Xb OABAKOR’ OTRABHBATECA OTS CBOETO sabIyHAC- Ma B TOROPHEAh, 170 8a RCTHBY cBeero BSpoyvesia roToBs. nO- Tepmbte cross, Ousesanio H ThCa1y Cueprell. Memxzy Tiwb Goiae DoMManb! ABAMAANATS ANOCTOIOSD BH MHO- wecTso HocsbAoBareaell epecu. Maorie #3% apecToRanaNXh 1O- KasQSE CBON REBUBROCTL; Apylie, HANPOTHBS, Cb paaccTifo ro- TOBNANCh BCTPBINTS ORAAABUIIA AXD MyTeHia. Jaa pacnosHania BEHOBHLIXD OT HOBRHALIXS BMDEPATOPS BeaABAB YCTPOATh 3a KOCTpa M Ha BepXy OAHOTO Hb BAXS BOAPYSHERb, KYeCTs, boro- MEABI, UpesmpaBmie EpecTs no UpBENADY cpoero BbpoyseHia, He YOUYAE Kb HOMY H OTHMD ABHO 3ACBAABTCABCTBOBAAR, CBO OPE- mgaemBccth kb CoaTé. Ouw. Osan OTREAOHI BL TEMHANEI, a Te AOBPAMTIG Kb KOCTPY Cb. KPeCTOMS OCBQGOMACHEI, Korga am yetmjania, Ha yrpoasy.ne xnieTBesasa Ba Bacuaia, cobops ocyauas ero #a céepts. [pa maoroqucaenpoms coGpa- iia, maposa, Bacaaiés, npunexent Obiab HA THNOAPOMS, FAB ObI- ar, soomesubri xocteps. Boromsxs we CMyTHICA: OD Teepl0 Mpomsnecs cxoBa 90-ro NcamMa: anreioms cooums sanoancmr o382 SPaBOCAABHOE OBO8PSEHIE. meOn companwmu ma. Y KOCTpa 08% 8aMBTERE Epects. Crons0 TOABEO OPCKAOAMTSCA OpeAD HaMD w Bacusitt Goias Ou coacens Ore yRacHoH cMepTa, HO OHD OTBepuyacA OTD Kpecta. Bapyrs OHS yaHaeTb, ¥TO CFO POACTROHURKE A ApyBbA, BOUPEER OObMa- Hit0 BMDepaTopa, NOABOPFAYTHI ObITKAMb, THWOTS Bb TIOpLMAXs. Toperia caess! 10404NCb BBb CFO 4asb; OWb POMBO . puAars, BCHOMAHAA O DpomeAmiens, 0 CxsKAXxS ero cepany ‘). Heupe- ksosnocts Bacaaia Bb BEAY UbIZAONaTO KOCTpa, ere oGpamesie Eb AHTedaMh DOCOAHAH Bb TOAUS OGACewie, ITO REMOUL CHACYTS ero Orb cMepTs. Bp Barb onbita. casain Gpocawrs 8 Oronb oxemiy Bacasia W naaMa GbiCTpo ee DORMpaeTs; Ba We! Ba0- Teas Ha gocteps Bacwaill # ero He cTax0. Ito Gsia0' BD 1118 roxy ’). «Paapa Aparona Oplaa oTpyOxena, 80 eke yubebas ero sse- HS, 6 3albTb Oviab xbocTb», ropopars Eseawill ‘). Eaye ge pascbasach «rpossad TYIa epeceli, qopacmiad- wa BasaATiienOMD BeGocgx0n5 *). Mors wmaepaTops, pas'be @ opasowspin:ceonxs DOAAQHBBIXS, AOpORa CxaBOW XOpomaro Gorocxosa ”) cTOABEO Me, CROABKO # CAQBOW BCKYCHAPO NOXWTHEA, HOpywAs Coxbe ostit- HBIMS GorocaoBamb cBoere BPCMGGH 'COCTABHTS ' onweanio pas- HBIX® epecell. Pegarnia aroro rpyaa Gtixa eosxomena wa Keou- wis 3araGena. tte aes - Tors pomgenia a cwepta Esommia ne aastcrens. Moxaranrs, ' *) Narrat. de Bogom. XXII rx 35 p.” 7) Alexias, p. 390. - C A Narrat. de Bogom. LII ra., %) Alexias, 384, peceae ) Tanoe Gamsxoe yuactie 3s xbiaxs sips Bnsantificeaxt auneparo- POBb, HOCHBIIAXS THTYIS , Ayio¢‘—aBIOHie JOBOASHO OOMRHOBERNDE.BE TO Bpeua, Puxcrie uunepatopy, rosopaTs Huxuta Xouiars, ue AOBOALCTRYWTCA TOCHOACTBOMS HAXt CBOCOARHMH, Eakt HaAb padamu; OAR OOumaWTCA, eClH EXD He UPHSHAWTS OpeMYAPHME, UPABOCTABKMMH Coroe¢oBauM, 3akOHOA- TelamH, CHOcOOHHMH OXuHaKOBO pbmats Absa Oomeckia H YerOBbyecria (Neander, V, II, 1043). Asexchi Komaent weoxnogpaTHo cams cuopHab B OGauvars CoromuxoBs, maBausians H Ap. Ho caosaw, Beduvia ero ,u0- pews OWIb HaM0sHeAS AYXOBAMMH sugauH (multitudine Regia semter re- ferta esse solet...), Cb ROTOPHMU MNepaTOps pascyRAasb O Absaxs BEPH (Max. Bibl, Vet. Patr. IXX, 6).ROTO MHA. 39s wo mansanie Susatena OMb HOLyINSS OTL MhCTA CRdCTO pom ysis EAR REPBOHATasbHArO BocMeTanis. Hbxoropwe yrenbie a~ vars Zuyadtvaug—orb Zuyddec, poanun Exommia '. Cobxbaia 0 @f0 WEBER BeChMA CHYAGH. CaM omb HasbIBAeTR CAba MOMa- YOK OLMOLO HOHCTARTHAQHOALCKALO MOHACTRpPA BY yecTs [pe- castoll Abpsi, Aemanmara Ba Gepery .mopa "*). Own nosbaopasca OT COBpeMCHBMEOBD CraBpo ysaTeas wSpe!. Agua Koupeua ga- BMBAETL CTO BPEBOCKOARLIMS CpaMNATRROMD, BACbMA HCHYCHBIME PETOPOM, OFAMTHLING 3HATOKOMS We@pROBHWXD AOTMATOBS (+o oyna we ox GAAog tig ématépevav), Onb Ose HaDCTORD eme aMnepatpao’ Apa a acemy sasanriiicnomy naupy “’). Oxonqenunii Esouiens tpyxy cam EMDepaTops HasBaxs Aoy- panxi, Tavorhia '*). Hoanoe ero saraapie taxoe: Mavordia doy- parc, tis SpFoddYou mioteos, Fro srhodyxy Goypdtwv, ata opymellaaa wasata «A0amBa O511a AOCTABAATS Ha OyAymee BpeMa opyxie gaa XyxosHol Copb6tt cb pasHbiMA O6sapyRuBUIMHCH saGxymaenisua.» Esouniii yebpxers, 3710 «ota pasHooSpasioms Crphxs = opymia MoRHO Cyrers, fasbpHoe, OTpasBTs BCAKOe Ha- Baxenic wa pésurito *). Bopovems’ tania nazemasr Esenmia te Rovorvwo Onpasxersanirca coxepmauioms Magonsin. Ixbcb, nam Gops6s cb HOBEM epecam, ¥OSHHEOTaMa Ha HOBO NOW'S, UH APYTHXS ycsowinxs, ytoTpeOssetce Coaster’ yactho ycraphe- Wee opymie BBxoBs ipeAmectsywmAXs: Bb TPyXs Fiirasena Maso OpEIMHAMHOCTH, ‘CaMOCTONTEABHOCTH; CBNABTCABCTRA OTHOBD HE seerxa yxatHo"ipuebzatcd (Cian, s. 668). Ita rpoansaa Kow-' omxagia yrasemaers ‘a ‘sdbrasii “yoarors rpetécroii “dbpas0- Bansocta. Boas Bacirters, Uparopiess, Saaroyctoss—sBbes cBo- Goxnaro secrbsoranie pasyma, ‘axbdonuaro BB nocaymaite Bh Ullman, Theoiog. Studien x Britiken 1838 r. IIB. exp. 063674, Cp. Cave, Hist. Liter.’t. II, p. 198. Bags roxcosaress Ba6zin Enoweil u. xo raanexs yell, nomsyerca HEMAIOW HSBECTHOCTIN: BUPOVEMS BL TOAROBAHIAXS CFO HO AOCTACTS Iy- MBCA H caMocTOsTeaBHOCTH worbronania (Ullman Theol. St. a Kri- then 1833 r. ore £69). Pee 1 3 mee Max. ‘Bibl. a. Patr. IXX. p. 6,384° UPABOCLABEUE @BOGPSHIE pw—210 Busaatia manosass. [epiogs scoxcnernxd cosopors KOBUNICA @, HOBHANMOMY, BB OOAACTHA perRTiOsHLIKs BOBPOCOB HUGCLO GOAbMIG BE OCTABAIOC ABAATL, KAKb KODEPOBATE CTApO. Y neprovasixt nacatexel swBcto masoH MeCKM cTaaa Hpeod- ZalaTb pHTOpaveckas @pageosoria, crasmaa HaKoHent BCeos~ IUWS YCAOBHEIMY aB5IKONS. Bs oOmecTes, RoTOpoS roBopaaO ma aaixb Apepsell Cpenia, mas0 NOX ThME Me HeGONS, HByIaAO APOPBEXD KASCCHNOBS, BAMBTAL EM CABALI ABbIIECKATO BAinnia= Be Aapoms [agonsia nanagaeTs ch RApOMy wa SRARYpONCNS BL pestesaws ‘). Tazoe cocrosnie oGmjectsa BMb10, KOBE TRO, Bais~ Hie # 8a YCOSMHOS pacnpoctpasenic Goromaspcrsa BD 'penia. IL 23 rsasa QManovsin, sanecanas 41a OGansenia Goromaaoss, CACTaBAMeT HawGorbe CAaMOCTOATeABHYW IaCTb UpoBsBexenia Ke— aumia SaraGeaa. lo nexaBnaro oOwapososania «Copa opecsa— tepa Koss tpyxs Eseuwia octapasca n0aTe eAMBCTBORERIN DaMATHWKOMD JAS HByTeRia AOTMATRICCERX® MESH CoroMBsOBR. Yaeusie, sanuMagmieca aTHM DAMATABROMD, OPRXOAMIH ED pa- ABRAALAO DPOTABONOACMALING BAsAOIOHIAMS KACATeEAbHO AQCTO- BRPUOCTH COOOMACMEIXE AM CBBABGIM. ApHOsnAD Hepepill yTRED~ waar, 70 eppscris, Evguwia 06% yuenin Corommzony—actaa BEyaKa (figmentum), o6maas. nparocaasanixs (fraus orthodo- xorum), MOTOMy 970 ORO He HOATRepAAaATCA wBBSCTIAMA. ERY— TAX DMCATeLOM Hy COMPMATH, HETRULIA HOCALIXAHHWA MBdAIA. (opiniones vix quando auditas) ‘’). Coanreiiws ropopwrs, 170 rpe- KS UpBONCaAn CoroMmsans MHOrO GacmocaoRANXh (fabulosos) wake nid, mau NO Kpailaed Miph, COMBHTOAHBIX®, "*). Ineph BanECarI Whabid TpakTaTb Cb YBAbIO OCAWSHTE «AOMb wouAXa Esounia.» Cs cpoei nierucraveckol rourm spbHia Ixeps yrBepRAAeTS, ITO sb Busaatin, Bo BpeMena OoromMabcTBa, rocnoAcTBywmad Bbpa Gsixa BcHOpieMa: m: ceomniaasatie: Corocsoshi copepmenmo Hesa— 1) Heresiologia I. 356. 1) Max. Bibl. Veter. Patrum, XXI p. 7—10. **) Wolf, Histor. Bogomiloram. p 44.| BOroMBAM. 385 CIYROHHO OOBHHANH BL JOMANXS MEBRIAXD COroMAAOSL — N0- -casgosatexel aucto#, wesaTemHeHaod pasabiMm TpaaMniaNE, BB- Pa—wob HOHABHCTH KS BXt BAianito Ha-Baporb. O cawow> Es- omim Dzeps Bbipamaerca tax: oullam paene auctoritatem Grae- euti bojas agnosco, dum monachum cogito, i.e. hominem su- perstitiosum, credulem. Hyao Obits gpaine serkoBbpHbiNe, ‘10681 DOBSpHTE aTONY Oasarypy (historiolis) ‘*). Boabos nanpo- ‘Ws, DYCKACTH BS OGOPOTh BCH CBOW YeHOCTb, ITO6SI gOKA- 321 cupaBesambocts noxazaniti Eneumia. Taasasims 108010N5 wan Boxboa CAyHATS Up 9TOMS NOTTH OyRKBAAbHOe CXOACTRO nozsebimax, oxcatezet (H. Xoniara, Apmesouyaa a Ap.) cb Ksommiews, KoTopbie, OFeRARHO, NBAMKOMS BLIOHCHIBAIH eFO HO- sazania. Bp caoens oOmApHoMS tpyib (136 crp., in-8°) Boabes, co scew onepricH m TpyxoawGiems cpeaneBbRoBaro reseprepa, BogbicsaBaeTS aTats! 48% [Mxatona, Kcenowonta, Ianepona, aeb PasHBIXS OUIOCOGOBD H OTHORD NOPKBR, Jame YBTATY H3b JHe- 3381 Buprsaiesotl **), 114 Toro, 90681 JOKasaTh UpaBxMBOCTS NO- wazanit Enowmia. Boasmuuctso BORSMMAXD BCTOPEROBD CTORTS Tame 3a DOLIMABOCTE UusBbcTii Esoumia. Oum obinnOBeHHO n0- ‘STH DBAREOMD BEINRCHIBAIOTCA pH BBXOReHA GoroMBABCHArO Yreuia eb THROTOpHIXS MoHOrpaoiaxs *') H BD HBBECTALIXS TPy- 4aXxt 00 yepKosHo acropin, Haina OTS Heasxepa. Jrors yse- weil CORBTYeTL, BIPOIEME, OCMoposcHO OTHOCHTECA Rb DOHABA- Biaws Ksounia **). Docasauiit sorasxs ua Esownia ticraapipaetca W Bb ABYXS HOBSHMNXD wonOrpaciaxs—letpaonuya A Tesun- gato. Depstii rosopats, s70 y Esewmia ecth maoro mexnuas MBCTb, HO BS AOKAVATEALCTRO OPUROARTS TOAGKO OAHHD @AKTS, #0 oro uabHin, HcKameHabI Esoumieus **. Jesnusiti o6smaers TOABEO XOKARATS “Bb NOCABACTBIA, ITO MAbHIA yIeBLIXD Ob HC- Kameniaxt # upmotpacrin Eseamia seGesocnosateabens **). ‘*) Prodromus Hist. Bogomilorum. p. 8. >) Wolf, p. 56, 58, 80 et caet. o Engelhardt, Kirchengeschlliche Ab bead ange Alg. Kirch. V. II, 1086—89. Borousau, Ipxna Bocucna, 64 crp. si pee *) Xpucr. Urewie, 1870 r., anpapy. i,386 UPABOCIABHOR OBO3PSHIE. Ocrapasa Doka Bb CTOpoHh MOpoOsyw onbaRy cabaBsid o CorommanctsS, coodmaessixt Esenuieus SaraGenoms, CRAROMS 06b OTHOMeHIAXE aBTOpa Kb CBOCMY TPyAY: HACKOIKO CHAR -Gxaronpiatas! ycxobia, Bb KOBXD Haxoxsaca Esoumii upe Bh- weagenig Upexzomennod emy sagaia? Anna Kowsena ronopars, 470 Bxepatopb oopyqHss Eseamito a310meTb yienie GOroME- NoBb—xadads 6 doeBi¢ Basidrsiog dpnyfceto *), Ira epaza BO- RagbiBaets, 410 y Esonmis, upH cocrapxeuia tpagtata 0 6or9- WH1aXb, ObIAH DOTS PYKAMH SaNHCRH, BOACHHHS, RAKS MLL BE- xBau sbimie, ckoponucnem co cxoBb Bacesia. Ho Geckaa ch Bacusiems Bo ABopHb He Oblaa vocrbanew. Camb wunepatops H AYXOB@HCTBO HEOAHOKPATHO GecbyoeasH Ch epeTHEONS H, Cesb ComHbaia, xbanaBCch cb Esoumiem HOBbIMH AOORITHIME CBbA‘- giama. Ba cacab AyXOBHEIXD ABD, DOChmasmAxt Bacwaia Bb TOMHBTS, OvlAb W TOT, KOWY ObITO DOpyyeHO COCTAaBATS ONpO- Bepmenie epecu *, H paacyaas> cb epetasoMs. Kpoms toro Esoamit mubat caysait Gechxopats Cb MHOrHMM ApyraMW Goro- MHJQMH, EAKb CaM OBS 06% OTOMD TOROPATD Bb Lvyypagy aty- Acteutixy *7), Tans osnamabl Ha nyT#, Epemmili pcrpbraaca cb Gorommaoms, KoTOpbiii cBOGoAHO roBopass emMy O cBoe BApB. Jha M BS CBOeMS MOHACTEIPS Sura6eHs HepRARO AbIBHIBAAS HA OT- -EPOBOHHEIA OOBACHEHIA epeTHROBb, OpPATBOpPAAch, 10 UpUMbpy muOpaTOpa, HX YIEHRROMS, Cb AIO BLIBBAATS TeMELA CTO- POusI BXD BBpoyienia. Anna Kounena rosopars, 370 MuOrie Heb DOMMaRHLIXS CpeTHKOBS OTKALIBAAHCh OTb CBOMXE BadaAyRACHil. Bo qWcab ax> Oban, Geatb COMAbHIA, H MCTMBHO packaaBiiecg, -ROTOpbIC MOrIH Ges6oRsmeHNO OTKPEIBATD Tallabl epece. Ecrs ocnosanié. yrsepmaats, 910 y Esemmia Oblau coA® py- KAM Jake nuctMenttie ACTOTENER, UpRHasemasilie ConTAHTaM’. Taxb Bb 27-m5 Tu7x% **) SaraGeHs roBopaTs, 370 08D orpanm- SHTCH HBAOMERieMS moskosanitt epeTHROBS TOALEO HA HhROTO- *) Alexias L. XV p. 387. XXII. Ea. Fogginus in Anecdotis literarits, v. IV, ap. Marrat de Bogom. IT. ° Narrat. de Bogom. ra. *) Narrat de Bogom. p. 34, 85.BOroMmse. 987 gua mbcta Esagresia Maroes, BODMOMBOD ToqocTio, Camblll TeKcTE tpaxTara o Boromssax3, uo: rwyese- POBCKOMY WBAAwWO, BAAS WHEOTOPLIA OTCTYOXeHia BL DOPSIES H3X0KOHia TOMKO TOTZA, BOTAA BS PAEBIXS MBCTARD FOBOPET- Ca 06% O4HOND HW TOMb Me BPCAMCTS MW DOTTE Be KACHACL 009- powenit Exonuis, wakb MONMSIONIUXS UpsMaro ovnomesia We Bameny opexwety. Ha psay cb weaomeuiems phposasill Goro- MEAOBD MBI OyAenS aratb H OTHOCamieca emga TeHcTE Es. Marees, 00 epermueckOMy TOsKOBARiI0, HOTOPC® CAYMETS DOA- TBepMAcHionh, OObacRenicNS WAN BLIPAMeRICMS TOTO BAB Apyroro uatuia cextantoss. [pa otom> MBI BYTeMS cpabuuTessuaro Me- Toxa woCTapaemca OnpeABAETE, Wa CEOILEKO “OANO H éMPHO De- pexauss astopoms Manousia actopia # yyenie Goromms0nt, co- octabiad Jaa oto NbaH Cb cRasaniaun Esonmia, 00 BOsMOR- HOCTH, BCL HeMHOTOGHCACHHDIA Ckasauid APyrHXs Dacatesell 06% STOMS OpeAMeTS, YKasbIBad, TXB HEOOXOANMO, HCTOPHUeCKIa, OT- worpaendeceis # ApyTia RPHIHEBI, DOBRiasmis Ha OOpasonanie & XapanTep> TOTO HAN Apyraro epeTmuecKaro sa6aymAenia. IV. 23 tatao Dagonsia «opotuss Coromus0Bb» Eseumitl Sarason Hawuaers 3aMBraiemb oO sHayewid CAOBa «GoroMBsS», DPOBSBOAT €F0 OTB ABYXB CAABAHCKEXD CA0Bb «Borb MBAYH>, TAR TO «60roMB.Ab», DO TOAROBaHito Eseumia, sHayuTE—é toU Ocob tdv Fecv émtordpevoc-ycepano Mosamitica. Taxoe Toamopauie Ha- XOAMTCA Bb CBASH CO BaTARIOMS Evenmia a CXOACTBO BW Aame TOMACCTBO MeMAy yueHnieMs COTOMMAOBS, CBXHTOBS, MeCCasianS {gvyitoc-mechlin-moaamitica). Toanopagie 9T0 egba AB BBpHO; aBTops [anonsin ocranopaaca Ha HeMb BSpOATHO 00 HesHanOM- CIBY Cb CaaBaAHCEAM ASbIROMD. Cxoso «Goromaat» 038a4aeTb M0-CAaBAHCRH—EAOBSEA Goroyrolwaro, GaaroyectmBaro, kawb- TO BHAHO HH3% GA0Ba Upecsutepa Kosmsl, Kotopsiit HpoHBuecRE BaMbiaeTs 0 epecenayaAbHAES GOToMBAOBS: a No ACHES pemty— Bory—xe muss», 10-ecTh Heyronen’ *). Yexosses ycepauo MO- ) TIpas. CoGec. 1864 r, I g. 481 erp.390 DPABOCAABEOE OBOSPTHIE Aammilicay NO-CUabaHCKH BepeBOARTCe—6ov0M0s3, KAKE A wasbI~ pares: GOTOMmAB BB OAROM pyxoumcH Kopmye XVI 8. *‘). Ha- POAD BasbiRAsB HXb GOrOMOAAMA, TOTOMY ITO OMM 1aCTO H MBOTO MOSHAHCh—-HA ORAZ HM TOPABAHCL STAMB: «MEI, TOBOPHAN Goro- MBabI TpeBOCAaBHEeNS, Bora opasbiBacws, MOXEMTECH.... MBI TAIe rect Bora MOAMMS H OJHMS H MOSHNCS, a HO MBDEND BE AB- HOCTB, ABOME Ber *'). He sano, 106K CaMH Oorommsbl MABbI- BasH ce6a ores umenems. [p. Koama rosopars, 4T0 onm Ha- BhIBAAH COX “HCTHHNHIME: XpmCTiaHaMM», «EpeCTBAHAMA» **), & Esoumil 8% ogous umchuh 0 SorosHAaXs TOBOpATS, 9TO On HOGbIBARa COOH «xpUCmianGNU, ZpucmosuiMU rpascdanaMy: Aprotiavads Eautods évoutCovtes ol ursoyarctor xal ypictono+ ‘Dirag 7), Bu6sia wea ynotpedaenie y Coroumaons. Ta. I, 27, 30, 41, 36, 20, 21. Kanoas cs. Mncania Gorommast rbaaTs Ha 7 REATE—cably‘O- muxe: 1) feaataps, 2) 16 xaurs Hpopoxoss, Esanreaia, 3) orb Mateea, 4) Mapra, 5) Ayana, 6) Joausa, 7) [sania anoctoas- cwig, BcB nocaadia m Anosaanncuct Ioanna Borocaosa. (Ocao- Baie xBacuia BuGain na 7 gar OHM HaxogaTs BD IX, I cr. Raura opatieli Coromon.). Octasbubia me HcTOpHuecKia REBTH Berxaro 3assra a [atoruamie Movcea oan orpeprawrs, Bagh Dpowssesesia 2iaboaa; He upHsHaioTs uw Bora, yoommaaemaro Bb HEXb BMBCTS cb yrommBMaMa Fay myxamu. Ho ong, aaa oos- TRepmAenia cBoero ysenia UpBBOsaTS MBCTa H H3> HeNpH3Ha- BaeMBIXt WMH CBAMIeHEIXD EHTS **), Coon CeMb KBAIb Goro- MHAbI TOARYIOTS aLLerOpHYeCRHMS CUOCOGOMS, Aad DOATBEpRAe- Big cBonxb MabHi. Boe, cxasannoe Bb busin 0 HeyeCTHBLIXS TpBareaRaxe H BXOAOUORAOHBARAXS, OHH OTHOCATL Rb 0paBo- » Ou. Ounc. Pyu. Mys.—y Jesaugaro 33 czp, Ifpapoca. Co6ec. 1864 r. I vacts, 491 crpan. Tbidem. th, 106. aa] Neander. ¥. . II, 1094, mpumby. 2. ) Narrat. de “Bogom. ulBOTOMEAL. 391 CupRod TepxeH B, BACGOPOTE, BOB, CRAvABHOG 0 BpADEREREAXS, Ons UpwbEawWTL KS CBONMD BOCrSACsaverENS *’). By Boxrpep- xmyenie cpocro seranja Ha sakows Moveer, rags wa npomaperc- Hie AfabOXA, ONE HPBBOARTL arserepsiecKoe TOAKOBaHie TeKCTA: Toanns umause pasy ceo Ooms each semOsyords, NaKds: YOMeNs 0 Lpecanas ceoUss: CHRO oe 680 On npyorie u moda Ousis (Mv. 3, 4). Besoct: sepOoza osbauaors upexoucania zarona Movceesa, KOTOpsid DOXOKH HA WeINCTONJOTHARO Bep~ Gx, NOSBORAL CHONG MecxbAOBaTeATAS yOOTpeOAenie NECA, Opama, EASTSLI, Ropes, cuoeptscll xasae- #7. Dox, Komaniit Boacs oswauacTs cp. Exanresie, GucamuOe Ha CROTLHXS HOMAXS. Hpeauacamia sanona Movcoesa onN BusMBaIOTS Capamiel0, Ko~ Topad He BD CHAAXS PasewwaTS 20Cpoe OFS ypmero H R3bE~ pats sysmee. [wauws monoms Hasuusactcs Esanresic, xoropoe DPOACYABAACTCA HARES MOXL CXOAKEMS LIT CBONXE DOCAbOBATE~ Ae: (yoma meon caauje Meda % Coma), H IAKEMS 148 OTBEP- FAWUAKS CTO, BOSBEMad TEcHUM cKOpOHEI DyTh MESEB, BC- BoxnewEBitt erpagasill ‘*), Ha orsopmenie Berxaro Saxtta ch 3a- WhUOW CFO HOBLING YRISMBACTE, 00 HHSHIO epeTHROBS, CABAYI- Will cTUXs: Cleeuacme, ano pevewn Cecne dpeonune: OKO sa ono, sy6s 3a ay6o (Maps. 5, 38). [sasa ogueveiors x8a sagona— Moveeess Esaureatcei, a sy6si—yea DytH—opoctpanubll w youill. Hracs, orm cxopa CoacuTeid SMBIOTS TOTb CMBICIS, 970 Tecmoas 1a4> saxors (fopbiil) sube70 saxona Movceesa H yerill BYTS swhoto mpoctpanwaro “‘). Macro wes Es. Maroea V, 18, BOBNAMMOMY He NOAXOAAMee MOAB 9TO TOAKOBaMie, CoroMBAM OGLECHIIM TAES: H ioma H Yepima BAKONA O3RATAWTS AeCaTO~ cxosie, WOO GEpTa Bb BOPTNKALsHOND NOAOMeNiN BBOGpamaeTs jory. Hi rams iota, 2.-. xecutocaopie He YHENTOHeTCs, HO 6y+ ACTb BMSTA CHAY Y eBpeess, NOKA we HOTuGueTS nebo w SoMAA. Hotomy-70 » ckasago (5% [imcasia), sro Xpuctocs ne npamers 5°) Tbidem, ra. XXVII. *) Ibidem, ra. XXX. ‘) Ibidem. ra. XLI.32 BPABOCIABROE OfOSPSHIE. P&3pyGIATS BAEOHD, a HaNOAHNTS (DpasexHRKaMB) eGo, ocTas-. xemmoe ESKOTAA HaMeNm auresaua “).—Haerja GoroMmatl CCA~ AAINCh Ha TEKCTH, EOTOPHIXS BOBCe He. OKaBHIBAIOCS Bb _DaGuin;, Haup.: «HomtTaiize JeMOROBL—He NOTOMY, 9T06% OHH MOTH 1O— CTaBAaTs BAM DOAbSY, 2 ITONS we BpexMAM BaMt» (XX); «pca~ KuM oGpasoms cuacenie Bame coxbsaiiter. Bupovent Exouuiil, THatTexbHO DepecMoTphES epautesie Bacuxis, watlert, ITO OBO He OTABTAETCA OTS yoTpeGAseMarO Bb DPAaBOCAaBHOH NepEsH. Hi sorza Exounii sawtraxs ato Bacasito, aocrbgnit cocrasca Wa ABTOPHTeTS KANOTO-TO Crapla, BCTPSIMBMAroca Cb HMMS Bb. HBEOTOPOMS YeAHBCHHOMS -MBCTB. Crapels HAsBaNS erO D0 mMeHH @ Ceasaa% Bacwait, 310 On% UpioOphab BB RYNACHBOMS HM OEBCMOASpS eBanreaia BexHIaliMee CORPOBNEIe, HOTOMy ITO TOIbKO 3Ta KHHTA He OOABepraach WCKAMeRIAMS CO CTOPOHAE Toanwd gupco-ctouia ([paswoycta) @ COLCPRATS ABA BHEIONPR- Begenabia Mocra> ‘*). Ceasanie Exenmia SaraGena 0 Gorommab- CEOMS KaMOHS gHarD CB. [ncaia XoBOabHO TeMHO. Take esTOpE Tanonsin rosopats, yTo Gorommasi OTBepraam BCb ACTOPHIECKIA xaure Berxaro 3aphta, HO ooveMy OBa ApseaMass nEcania Dpopoveckig, Bb RakOMb BELG OH YOOTPeGuaIA OCTAmbALE WearH—OCTACTCA HepasbACHeHHbIND. Mui sHaeMs, ITO COBpeMeH- Mule GOrOMHAaM> Kaeapbl,- -UOCKBAOBaTeAH YCTATO AyarHaMa, DPHEMMAAH KERTH OPOPOKOBs, Kakb CKasanie O HeBSAOMOMS Mips, HpeamectsovabmeMt BULHMOMY, —O MipS xyXOBHOMS. Dpopose- c¥Ba, 00 mHbwilo OTHXD CeRTAHTOBD, Oplaw MpeRCKASARLL, eNTe XO coajanis Mipa, HeCeCubIMH AyXaMB; OBB, NPeABRAT BEbaeHIC es1n08s Bominxt Bb OKOBbI DAOTH, XOTBAH YTBIIBTb.AXD (C8 HOBS) BOCHOMAHaHieMS 0 NPOMeAMeMS H HaXeMAoIO Ba Syky- mee “), Best comptuia 4 OOroMHAbI BHXBIW BB OPOpOIecTBAXS wooOpamenie HSKOTOPEIXE TAMECTBCHELIXD BeMell, MOANSyACh at- ACTOPMIECRHMS TOAKOBAHICMS UPOpOreCtB, ATREIABHIHXS OCRORL ‘*) Tbidem. ra. XXXVI. “) Ibidem. ra. XX, XXII. “) Histoire et Doctrine de la secte des Cathares on Albigeois. par ©. Schmidt t, IL, 23—24,BOTOMBABL. 393 ROBY DSrascy wXS peawriognol cactom. Crom 1as0KH ONT | GAN OTS Hagxemanyaro DOuAMaHiE DPOpOTeCRAXS KBaTS—BE- HO W383 TOFO, Fo Apyrie UNCaTeAH OPWOECHBAITS HHS OTBEp- wewic cceto Kanona Berxosarbramxt Kuers. «I'xb, nagm BONpO- maw Bacs, ropopars Hazapions Morseacuii Goromusaw>, 290- Gpbrocre xyuleryOutemuyw ci assy eme raaroaare, aR0 Ipes- 0G 30x0Hs OTS AYEABATO Obuler (H3% KOBTOKCTA BBAGO, ITO Bx3cb DOTS saKOHOMS pasywherca eccs Berxili 3axtrs) *'). To we camoe rosopuxs 0 Gorommsaxt, ropaszo passme Haapiona, apecpateps Kosma: «Appaama, apyra Bowis, a Xaginza w Asapsa- HM Yale B MpONNas MpopoKoss HO UPiOMAIOTS, HXHO B SPEPN ceupbuia yOosmaca a orab ycyumbca> ‘*), ITo pagworaacic Bs BOKAZaWITXD CAEBAECKNXS ONCaTezel wn Esemmia xacatemzo 60- TOMMILCEATO FAHONS MORHO OPNMEPETE TAKENS OOpazoMD. Boo6pamaa ces Uoxs Heupectanniums BoxETeacTsoms Ayxa ‘omia, OTHOESCh NpespwreabBO 0 BCeMy, ITO BOCHTS neqaTS OcsaemocTm, BemlecrsenBocTa, GoroMmas! He AySAAR OfpaaEqE- 38, ce6d PAMRQMN RAREXS-HROYAL BUBOIERXS DPCAONCaHill, BoD Fatro 6b wcrovawea OmM Hm ucxoxnaH. [pexancania Saxoua Bomy mwham suavenic 18 ZeHORS COBTH (eeorgons) HacTOxSEO, BACKOALEO OHB OTBbIAAN BAYTPORHOMY PachOomenito xamaaro, abMcTBiama KOTOparo yupabaseTs Cams Ayx> Garsit. Bors novemy OBW TakD O6es06pamuBars WHOTAA COOBME yaxosaniawH cubica® cB. IIncania @ cchaaaRch Aame Ha Henpmgapaemsia wun KoATH Berxaro Saphra, eCam BHABAR Bb EX NOATBEPMACHIC CBONXD LOTMATHKO-MHOOAOTHICCKEXS MpexcraBxedi. Takoe cBoGoxHoe, Takb CKagaTb, 9RAeRTAIE- croe “’) oraumenie Kb OpHaRABACMLING H HOUPHBRABACMLIMS KEW- “) I. C. P. J, 7, 9, erp. 146, — Marie Huapiona, euuckoma morsen- ¢zaF0, BEAHEATO TpOTRBOGOPAHES GOrOMAIOES 20 9-f won0uKES XII shxa, ‘BagucanO warpiaprows Esoxwiows topuosckums 3% XIV séxb. Hovops- ‘Yeckaa OCHOBA 9RN0 muTiA Ke HOALeRUTS Mu MaRbimeMy commiain. Cu, coGp. comms. Tuasgepxunre 1. I erp. 132. ‘ “*) Upanocsana. CoGechau. 1864 1. 4. II. 90. “*) Bs cuncrh manuxeens, Roropme BHXOAKIE u9S TOTO OcHOsadia, YTO Toxbgo yuesie Manéaa esyorosmO MCTEHHO M BC6 HECOTIQCHCS Ch BHMS39k DPABOCIABROR OSOSPBHIE. rams B. 3., aBapOAMBINGS WX BS PAX OOINNOBCHAHAD INVO~ PaTypRND DaMATABKOBS, 1abaxo Goanoe oenesanic BamMenpE- BOACAUSING THCATCLAMD OPHONCATE GOroMMAAKS OTBEpRenia acevo B. 3. Taxoe nowamanie Bu6sin ee acabe Bipamaerca Bb OT meni GoremmsoBs &b Esanresio. Ono, 20 caonaus Koswti, n0ab~: BOBAAOCh TARNMS YBARCHIOMS Y CERTABTORS, ITO He CXOANAO Y ERED C3 pyk> “'); ocoOeHHOe HO NpemMymecnrsO OHA OTIABAEE Enanresito Ioagna uo crasagito Esewwia ‘*).-H ato me? TS me: CaMble DBCaTeAw 4aloTb OOHATH, ¥TO A Epanresio opespaTazoce: Y HHXD Bb MHOD—TARD OHH OOez0Opamapeas CNLICID ero! Hanp., BORpeaA DOAOMUTeAHOMY CBBAbreabcTBy eB. loamHa-o abICOKOE uaccin Joanna Kpectatesa, , OSM Hasbibasd efo aBia‘tca TeMHOe Be- Xopaspatoe peauriosHoe vyscmeo, cursHoe BOpogens xy Takol cTenesE,. ¥T0 e0coGHo Omx0 BBOAETS CTO BS caMOOCOALMsnia, TAL ITO OND UPA- HUMANS 6f0 pykopoxcTBO sarosccs ceume (Narrat. de Bogom. ra. XXI} “t) Tpasocs. Co6echyn, 1864 7. Il, 99. , ‘9) Narrat de Bogom. XV1. tH %) Tpanocs, CoGecigu. 1864 r. I, 90. 5!) Thilo, Codex spocryphus N. T. Aeiomurs 1889. p. 883.BOTOMMABI. 395 DRO SACTABARETS HACE UepewATE Wh ANOKPHOANS, KOTOPHE EMS- 4m Tamce rpomassoe Buiamie na OGpasosanio a xapacteps Gore- MELCTSR. ; Basanrilicnas anrepatypa—sslpasatcabRana Cyepbpuaro, Bb OTY Bopy, susastilicsaro o6mectsa—Gniaa OcoGennO Gorasa soacup. ams wusraue. Bs otpeveanoi amtepatypd Olan anoxpaen Bet Xaro Jasbra, orsacra eppeloxaro, oTsacTa go3zadaro xpactian- Cxaro Dponcxomacnis, wb wel pascKasbiparnch opesamia woBO~ sarbTaoH SNOKM HAM MoSTATeCEIA ACCeHE] WAM ROTMATHTECRIA bosbpba A Cyesbphs Apeseuxs xpucriags. Ocobenanl ycrsi5 FS mapoauod MACOS 1aBAA0 VTHKS GAMETRHEAMD TO OGcTOATEAL~ ¢rp0, IT@ OHH YaCTO OfpamAsMch UMEHHO &> TAKAMS BODPO- cam, Ha EOTOPMe BeIbSA 64110 HaATH DOAORUTeADHALO OTBSTA 3 CRajenwoM, DEcauin u yreHin nepxannoms. Onm pascnasn~ BAAN © HOAPOOROCTAXS TeOpeRia,—ITO OhIs0 10 TROpeHia ipa mu std GyxeTD OPH KOBWHAS efo, RaKoe npowcxomzcnie B Mesnasenie sexostea. O60 AceMh aTOMD aDOKpHONTeEKIN CKAse~ Hin TOROPHAN CB TARNME DOAPOOHOCTAMH, M Bb AORABATEALCTRO RAMMAIR TAKIC ABTOPATETSI, ITO HEOUSITALIH YNTATeEAL yBACKAt~ Ci @ sbpaas wus fa caove. [Ipoetota mszomenia cuoco6cTs0- Bala Tsepiomy yAepmasio wXb Bb Damats. CoctasnTeam ano~ MPNO08s, CTPeMaCb AaTb BCeMy OAHOe OODACHERIe, nPHOBraaM KS opomspossuomy campoanowy. [ocabagee kakb weabaa Coxe ylonaersepaao BaTpiapxaspwoe rayCokoMsicsie: HamBHoe CTpeN- Beni OTEPLIBATL sAySOKIN, matinudl CubiCAs NuUCaKin BHABEO CUMBORNYOCEIM CMLICAD JARO Bb TAKWXS PAsCKaBAXd, KOTOPHIE Cano Esamresio na06pamaso OOLOMATOADHLING OAKTOMS, a HE Dparsell # mHoceasaniews **). : Cymectaonanie anokpaooss y SoromHA0Bb HecoMBbaHO. TaRS Y Kaeaposs coxpaswaocs opeaasie, 370 «Bonpocsi loasaa Boro- cxosa> O14 npmueceny av> Boarapin «GoroMmabCKEM> COM> cronoms Hasapiemb», xakb monasbinaeTs MpBOHCKA RA PyXOnWcH 5) Cu. cxas. Esommia o Paxsam (ra. XXIX), 0 rposctowmnol xeub (ra. LI),—Jaa nctoss. orpes. antep. cx. COepauas af6ata Muss (Migne): Dictionaire des apocryphes; raxae Thilo, Codex apocryphus N. T.396 DPABOCIABHOE OBOSPSHIE. sToro namatanca **). Cymectaosanie ero y Gorommsost Becom- BBAHO; OHO NOATBEPMAATCA He TOALEO YKASAHHOW DPRBRCKOI,; HO—TAaBHOG—OAH3EHMS CXOACTBONS Ch CRazaniont Esomwia 3u- TaGeHa, Kakb MBI YBRXEN BARE WIb HAPaLNCALHWIXS COUOCTAB- Xeni Hxb O6onxt. Hcropuiecea AoKasaHEnt oaxTL—CyMeCTBO- Baie y GoromHA0B> # Xpyroro avogpHea: «Baxbaie Dpopoxa Hain» **). O6% Spactc *Hoatov ynomanacts asrops fMauonsinz pp IV anacematasmés “'). Bors raasasimia yeprsi cxoAcreAa epaxsuia Mcaia» cb crasaniews Esouwia Suradena: Yueuia o Becovalimemus Bors, orepxerrévy eEoucia. Carananat, uo Eseu- mito, O6tcveHS Bb Comecnia OACHALI Bb SHAK CBOETO Gome- CTBeHHATO ROCTOHACTRA; BE «BUABHIHD OTA OCHAA CAYRUTS TABME BHaEOMS OCO6aro AocTOMHCTBAa. CaMaHa DOXORS Ba KOMOUpPa- batexa Carawawza; Kak TOTS, TAaES H Apyroi Gopwrca ct n0A- qwneaubimm nub Cuaame. Tab # 3Q5Cb DpHeHaeTcA opuspaq- Hocts Thaa Incyca Xpucta. Croi womameckyio oxemay Soro- MBABI MOTAH CPaBHHBATS Cb acKeTHIecEOH oxemAOW Heaia a ers ApyzeH. Caymesin Manaccin Carant wan Camanay (paantiuxs ipa) HW ero cnzaMa u OGetanie ero Mamaccin Coromuat moraW DpPepasaABath Eb CBOeMY YueHIO O COMATIN XCMOHOBS Cb MOLb-~ un. Bexiaxb, 0040680 Caranamay, mpavuTs mipom> ors azvasa ero coagania °*), Aexaetca BOUpOCS: HMEAB-Ib ANOKPROI FAHOHMGECKOe 3Ha- Yeuie AAG CCRTAHTOBL BAH BTO DPOCTO Oviad HasHAATeABbIA H HOACBHbIA 140 IT6HiA KRATH,—KARb AyMawTS HBKOTOpEIC “). Bo- HPOCb CBOAWTCA Kb TOMY—CyMecTBOBada 3B y COroMMAOBS wa BSCTHAA ONPeNbxeHHAaM CHCTewa BBpPOyeHiA, saKmWIeHHAA Bb DMCbMCHHBIX DaMATHHKAXb, HAM Re STO yoewie OTXAHO Os1z0 53) Cy STUN NAMATHUROMS HaXOAATCA Bb CARSON cBASH, ,BOUpOCH Toanna Borocaosa“, mpunagsemamie pyconok anorpxd. zevepatyps; ost Geass comubuia copemim et Hams na Boarapin. Cu. Taxompasens ,orpet. xnuTHt Ii, 174—192. Hanevarano ws Kirchengeschichtliehe Abhandlungen v. Engethardt. a Ap. Tolli. p. 116, . “) Engethardt 101, 102; 209—250, ‘?) Engelhardt . 161.BOroMulbl. 397 HQ DPOMSBONE OTALALAWAD yOHTeKeH COKTH Hu DepeAasazocs EME yerno? Msi auvero we suaeMS O CymecTBOBaBia y Gorommaons KAKRI}-HROYAS CBMBOABTCCENXD KEATS, COTOCIOBCREXD TPaKTa- rows. epxossad 8 rpaxAAHCKad BAACTS, peBHEBO oGeperaBmas Bpasccsasayh Bbpy, 6eas commbaia, OOpaTHsa ObI Ba HWXD BEN wasie, ec.186% O8R ObINH Ha CAMOMD ABIB: MEI BHAEMD, ITO BE- mHOrO MOCAS TAA pyKOW Uasasa saOAosphAnHA Bb Goro- MNASCKEXD Tesjenniax’ cowHesia Koncrantana Xpmsowaaa **). Cs xpyroii cropoabl, HBCateaH O GoroMBAbCTBS roBopaTs © Kpail- HOM pasworsacia AOrMaTAIeCREXS MBbRIH epeTHROBD ™). TaKoe pasderaacie ykaabiBaeT® Ba OTCyTcTBie y BMX onpexbsensoit CHCTeMBI YIeHiA, H NOTOMY HeYABBHTCALHO, ITO ADOKPHOBI YOrIE C3YHATL AAG HEX kaKe ucmounuxoms Bbpoyvesia, HapapEs > ceameaHtius Macagiows, HCTOUHBEOMD, C% KOTOPHIME OHH, Foues#0, OOpamjaamch Takme CBOGOAHO, RAK HC CBAMCHEHM Tincanions (cu. stime). Esemmift opamo ne ropopsTs 06% aToNs 33 Manonsin, 20 1) on® cBagbreasctsyers, sTo Bacuaiit Gorommas ccpiaaaca Wa WECTA, KOTOPEIXS He OFAAIOCh Bb KAGOHHYECKOMS Esanre- Aim 8 KOTOPbIA OFeBHAHO ObIIH SAaMMCTROBABLI BFE ADOKPHOE- 3ecKNXS ckagauil. Taks AormaTb 0 nouTania OBcoBD **), ecam Bpamo we saswiarca Bb «BoDpocaXs loanHa», TO ecTecTBeHHO Wblrekayb 3b OpeyBeaHIeHHaTO B3raaJa NOCABAGAXS Ha sHave- Bie B cway XemoHOBD ‘'). Bacuaziit snosA Ovla> yBSpOHD BD XBiCTBETeABBOMD CyMeCTBOBAHIA ITBX COBB, XOTA, ObITb MO- Hers, OU OAH 3aMNCTBOBAULI AMG H H3b BCOHCARBATO. HCTOU- HBKA, U3 XOTHBINEXD BE CeETB Upexanil— atoH «acweod xuwrun, 4) Lee Allativs de perp. Eecles, orient et occident consens. L. II c. TI, p 644 509, 59) Kooma ropopurt, u10 ,cxoBeca HxB we cOrzacymTca BKYDS, BO pas- }, ANH TEER cBNTA* (cyRHO) Hpazocs. Codechan. 64 r. 9. II. 100— Anna Komunent rosopurs, yr0 y BEXS Ocypara duspevouv. Pasnorsa- cia uabaift y Gorommz03t mu yeuaTpHBacus w BB [anonsi Suradeta. Narrat. de Bogom. rz XXL *') Thilo, codex apocryphus. p. 887 etc.398 MPABOCIABEOE OFOSPBBIE. H& ROTOPy!O TABS GACTO TOOATS CChzaTSCa WH HAWN CRATOPYC- erie deocecnpre *). 2) Evowmii, Gamme OsHakOMHBHINCS Cb CeRTaNTAaNM, BABIeXS, "fo ORB ABHCTBATeALHO MPHHAMAWTE aDOKPHOS! HApaBeh Ch OnGxsctckHMH KHATaNH H Bb HOBOMG CBOeMS COdHHeHIA O Goro- Mmaaxt °°) DpaMo roBopATS:

You might also like

• Fear: Trump in the White House

  

  From Everand

  Fear: Trump in the White House

  Bob Woodward

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (738)
• Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  

  From Everand

  Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

  Gilbert King

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (266)
• A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  A Man Called Ove: A Novel

  Fredrik Backman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (4610)
• • Magazines
  • Podcasts
  • Sheet music
• A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  

  From Everand

  A Heartbreaking Work Of Staggering Genius: A Memoir Based on a True Story

  Dave Eggers

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (231)
• The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  

  From Everand

  The Sympathizer: A Novel (Pulitzer Prize for Fiction)

  Viet Thanh Nguyen

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (122)
• Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  

  From Everand

  Grit: The Power of Passion and Perseverance

  Angela Duckworth

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (590)
• The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  

  From Everand

  The World Is Flat 3.0: A Brief History of the Twenty-first Century

  Thomas L. Friedman

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2259)
• Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  

  From Everand

  Shoe Dog: A Memoir by the Creator of Nike

  Phil Knight

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (540)
• Principles: Life and Work

  

  From Everand

  Principles: Life and Work

  Ray Dalio

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (608)
• The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  

  From Everand

  The Little Book of Hygge: Danish Secrets to Happy Living

  Meik Wiking

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (401)
• The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  

  From Everand

  The Subtle Art of Not Giving a F*ck: A Counterintuitive Approach to Living a Good Life

  Mark Manson

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (5813)
• Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  

  From Everand

  Never Split the Difference: Negotiating As If Your Life Depended On It

  Chris Voss

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (844)
• Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  

  From Everand

  Her Body and Other Parties: Stories

  Carmen Maria Machado

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (822)
• Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  

  From Everand

  Team of Rivals: The Political Genius of Abraham Lincoln

  Doris Kearns Goodwin

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (234)
• John Adams

  

  From Everand

  John Adams

  David McCullough

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2409)
• The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  

  From Everand

  The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer

  Siddhartha Mukherjee

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (271)
• A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  

  From Everand

  A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

  Betty Smith

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1929)
• The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  The Glass Castle: A Memoir

  Jeannette Walls

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (1716)
• Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  

  From Everand

  Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race

  Margot Lee Shetterly

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (897)
• Yes Please

  

  From Everand

  Yes Please

  Amy Poehler

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1898)
• Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  

  From Everand

  Rise of ISIS: A Threat We Can't Ignore

  Jay Sekulow

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (137)
• Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  

  From Everand

  Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the Quest for a Fantastic Future

  Ashlee Vance

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (474)
• The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  

  From Everand

  The Hard Thing About Hard Things: Building a Business When There Are No Easy Answers

  Ben Horowitz

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (348)
• The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  

  From Everand

  The Gifts of Imperfection: Let Go of Who You Think You're Supposed to Be and Embrace Who You Are

  Brene Brown

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1092)
• Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  

  From Everand

  Angela's Ashes: A Memoir

  Frank McCourt

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (441)
• The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Constant Gardener: A Novel

  John le Carré

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (104)
• The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  

  From Everand

  The Perks of Being a Wallflower

  Stephen Chbosky

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (2104)
• Wolf Hall: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Wolf Hall: A Novel

  Hilary Mantel

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (3811)
• On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  

  From Everand

  On Fire: The (Burning) Case for a Green New Deal

  Naomi Klein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (74)
• The Woman in Cabin 10

  

  From Everand

  The Woman in Cabin 10

  Ruth Ware

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (2521)
• The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Art of Racing in the Rain: A Novel

  Garth Stein

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (4203)
• The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Light Between Oceans: A Novel

  M.L. Stedman

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (789)
• The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  

  From Everand

  The Yellow House: A Memoir (2019 National Book Award Winner)

  Sarah M. Broom

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (98)
• The Outsider: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  The Outsider: A Novel

  Stephen King

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1850)
• Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Sing, Unburied, Sing: A Novel

  Jesmyn Ward

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1104)
• The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  

  From Everand

  The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America

  George Packer

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (45)
• Little Women

  

  From Everand

  Little Women

  Louisa May Alcott

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (104)
• Brooklyn: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Brooklyn: A Novel

  Colm Toibin

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (1947)
• Bad Feminist: Essays

  

  From Everand

  Bad Feminist: Essays

  Roxane Gay

  Rating: 4 out of 5 stars

  4/5 (1018)
• Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  

  From Everand

  Manhattan Beach: A Novel

  Jennifer Egan

  Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars

  3.5/5 (792)
• Steve Jobs

  

  From Everand

  Steve Jobs

  Walter Isaacson

  Rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars

  4.5/5 (807)
• Principles of Social Psychology 1st International H5P Edition 1666999882. Print

  

  Document773 pages

  Principles of Social Psychology 1st International H5P Edition 1666999882. Print

  Nikita

  No ratings yet
• Oldthemesnewdirections

  

  Document23 pages

  Oldthemesnewdirections

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet
• Infant Toddler Preschool Sample

  

  Document2 pages

  Infant Toddler Preschool Sample

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet
• Ideologyof Ed Res

  

  Document27 pages

  Ideologyof Ed Res

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet
• Christians Under Muslim Rule

  

  Document29 pages

  Christians Under Muslim Rule

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet
• Benjamin Graham, Legendary Value Investor

  

  Document5 pages

  Benjamin Graham, Legendary Value Investor

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet
• Bihac I Bihacka Krajina (1890) PDF

  

  Document333 pages

  Bihac I Bihacka Krajina (1890) PDF

  valkyrkia

  No ratings yet