Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Manalo
Facts:
2. The CA rendered a decision in favor of the Manalo brothers and ordered the current
petitioners to:
To furnish the Manalos and CA of all official and unofficial reports of the
investigation undertaken in connection with their case, except those already
on file.
To confirm in writing the present places of official assignment of M/Sgt
Hilario aka Rollie Castillo and Donald Caigas
To cause to be produced to this Court all medical reports, records and
charts, reports of any treatment given or recommended and medicines
prescribed, if any, to the petitioners, to include a list of medical and (sic)
personnel (military and civilian) who attended to them from February 14,
2006 until August 12, 2007 within five days from notice of this decision.
Ito na talaga
Feb. 14, 2006 - Raymond and Reynaldo Manalo, brothers and herein
respondents, were abducted by elements of the military (AFP and Citizen
Armed Force Geographical Unit or CAFGU) from their house in Buhol na
Mangga, San Ildefonso, Bulacan.
o The abductors were looking for a certain “Bestre”. Manalo brothers were suspected
of being members of the NPA
o The white L300 van was driven by M/Sgt. Rizal Hilario aka Rollie Castillo
o The brothers were repeatedly beaten and tortured and questioned about their
knowledge of the NPA.
Manalo brothers were given medicine named “Alive”. Gen. Palparan said that this
would make them feel better, but the real effect was drowsiness and a heavy feeling
after waking up.
After 3 months in Sapang, Raymond was brought to Camp Tecson. He was ordered
to clean outside the barracks of the Army Rangers.
o Met Sherlyn Cadapan, a UP student who was also abducted, tortured and
raped by the military.
Reynaldo was brought to Camp Tecson a week later. Other captives (Karen Empeño
and Manuel Merino) also arrived.
o All the captives were chained every night. They were told that their families
would be killed if they escaped.
o Cadapan, Empeño and Merino would later on be killed. Merino would even
be burned.
o November 22, 2006 – the captives were transferred to a camp of the 24th
Infantry Battalion in Limay, Bataan. They were continually beaten and made
to do chores.
o Here, respondents witnessed how soldiers killed an old man suspected of
harboring the NPA and also of an Aeta who was subsequently burned.
The captives were then brought to Zambales, in a safehouse near the sea. They were
brought back to Limay on June 2007 by Caigas, the commander of the 24th Infantry
Battalion.
June 13, 2007 – Respondents were brought to Pangasinan to farm the land of Caigas.
Here, they started to save their earnings to aid in their escape. When they saved
1000 pesos, they were able to acquire a cellphone.
August 13, 2007 – Reynaldo and Raymond Manalo were able to escape and board a
bus bound for Manila.
The respondents were able to corroborate each other’s affidavits.
Dr. Benito Molino also corroborated the accounts of the Manalo brothers. He
specializes in forensic medicine. He conducted a medical exam on the respondents
After their escape. The scars and wounds of respondents were consistent with their
account of physical injuries inflicted on them. He followed the Istanbul Protocol in
the medical exam.
Petitioners also submitted affidavits
Gen. Palparan and M/Sgt. Hilario filed their affidavits late.
Lt. Col. Ruben Jimenez, Provost Marshall and witness for the petitioner, conducted
an investigation on May 29, 2006, from 8am to 10pm.
All 6 persons (CAFGU members) implicated in the abduction denied the allegation.
They had alibis (some were building a chapel, some were just at home)
Discovered that “Ka Bestre” is actually Rolando Manalo, elder brother of the
respondents.
Recommendation was for the dismissal of the case.
Issue:
Held:
The adoption of the Amparo Rule is a result of the two-day National Consultative
Summit on Extrajudicial Killings and Enforced Disappearances sponsored by the
Court on July 16-17, 2007.
o It was an exercise for the first time of the Court’s expanded power to
promulgate rules to protect our people’s constitutional rights
The continuing threat on the life of the Manalo brothers is apparent. This threat
vitiates their free will because they are forced to limit their movements and
activities. Threats to liberty, security, and life are actionable through a petition
for a writ of amparo.
The military failed to provide protection for the respondents. They were even the
ones who actually tortured them. The one-day investigation conducted by Jimenez
was limited, superficial and one-sided.
“In sum, we conclude that respondents’ right to security as “freedom from threat” is
violated by the apparent threat to their life, liberty and security of person. Their
right to security as a guarantee of protection by the government is likewise violated
by the ineffective investigation and protection on the part of the military.”