Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BELCOR®
BELLACIDE®
LASOL®
BROMICIDE®
BELCLENE®
BELSPERSE®
BELGARD®
BELCOR®
BELLASOL®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
BELCOR®
BELLACIDE®
BROMICIDE®
BELGARD®
BELSPERSE®
BELGARD®
BELLACIDE®
BELCOR®
BELLASOL®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
BROMICIDE®
BELLACIDE®
BELGARD®
BELSPERSE®
BELLASOL®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
)LSSHZVS(U[PZJHSHU[Z
BELLACIDE®
BELLASOL®
BELCOR®
)LSSHJPKL)PVJPKLZ
BELSPERSE®
BROMICIDE®
:\Z[HPUHISL:VS\[PVUZMVY
:L]LYL:LY]PJL*VUKP[PVUZ
BELGARD®
BELSPERSE®
BELLASOL®
BROMICIDE®
BELCOR®
FLOCON®
BELLACIDE®
BELSPERSE®
BROMICIDE®
BELGARD®
BELCLENE®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
)>(>H[LY(KKP[P]LZPZ[OLNSVIHSSLHKLYPUZ\Z[HPUHISL
BELLASOL®
^H[LY[YLH[TLU[ZVS\[PVUZMVY[VWZPKLVYKV^UOVSL
BELLACIDE®
BROMICIDE®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
BELCOR®
WYVK\J[PVUZLH^H[LYPUQLJ[PVUVYZX\LLaL[YLH[TLU[
)LSSHZVSZJHSLPUOPIP[VYZHYLLU]PYVUTLU[HSS`
BELSPERSE®
BELGARD®
BELLASOL®
BELCOR®
MYPLUKS`OPNOWLYMVYTHUJLHU[PZJHSHU[WVS`TLYZ
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
5L^)LSSHJPKL¶OPNOS`LMMLJ[P]LUVUV_PKPaPUN
BELCOR®
BROMICIDE®
IPVJPKL[OH[PTWYV]LZOLHS[OHUKZHML[`>PKLS`\ZLK
BELGARD®
BELLACIDE®
BELSPERSE®
PUO`KYH\SPJMYHJRPUN
BELGARD®
)>(Z\WWVY[ZVPSHUKNHZZLY]PJLJVTWHUPLZ
BELLACIDE®
BELCOR®
FLOCON® BELCLENE®
BELLASOL®
PUV]LYJV\U[YPLZ
BROMICIDE®
BELLACIDE®
BELGARD®
*VU[HJ[\Z[VKH`!HTLYPJHZ'^H[LYHKKP[P]LZJVT
BELLASOL®
HZPHWHJPÄJ'^H[LYHKKP[P]LZJVT
BELSPERSE®
TPKKSLLHZ['^H[LYHKKP[P]LZJVT
FLOCON®
L\YVWL'^H[LYHKKP[P]LZJVT
BELLASOL
^^^^H[LYHKKP[P]LZJVT
BELLACID
BELCOR®
BELSP
BELC
BRO
July 2013 Volume 06 Issue 07
contents
ISSN 1757-2134
18
A pipeline under repair bleeds money with every passing hour. SmartPlug® isolation technology by T.D. Williamson,
operated by topside remote control, provides ‘double-block and monitor’ isolation capabilities, and makes it possible
to safely and reliably isolate pipelines at high operating pressures. This means that maintenance and repairs can be
conducted quickly, without bleeding down the entire system.
Copyright © Palladian Publications Ltd 2013. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner.
All views expressed in this journal are those of the respective contributors and are not necessarily the opinions of the publisher, neither do the publishers
endorse any of the claims made in the articles or the advertisements. Printed in the UK. Images courtesy of www.bigstockphoto.com.
Powerful. Proven. Dyna-Drill.
Rotor Elastomer Stator
Chromed, or HR 4140/4142 QT
Carbon Coated NBR-HR P530 Non Mag SS
HSN
HT- HR
For over 50 years, Dyna-Drill has offered operators the most technologically
advanced and efficient downhole motor equipment in the oil and gas industry.
www.dyna-drill.com/powersection.asp
© 2013 Dyna-Drill
comment
Anna Scordos
Editor
I
n the world of international business dealings, the newly deposits, is the subject of a territorial clash between China and
emerging relationship between China and Iceland seems to the Philippines, with China consistently claiming that it has,
be flourishing. China’s state-owned oil company, CNOOC, “Indisputable sovereignty over the West Philippine Sea islands
has been progressing its interest in exploration in the Arctic and their surrounding waters.” China is currently favouring
region, and has recently joined with Eykon Energy, a young investment into gas resources and moving away from more
Icelandic company, in a bid for an offshore exploration licence polluting resources like coal, as the country endures domestic
in Northeast Iceland. If the partnership qualifies for the round, and international pressure to clean up air pollution problems
the licence is expected to be awarded this Autumn. Earlier and diversify its energy mix.
this year, Iceland became the first European country to sign CNOOC’s multi-billion dollar takeover of Canadian oil firm
a free-trade agreement with China, and China has since Nexen, approved late last year, marked another movement by
become a permanent Observer at the Arctic Council; an China into Canada’s oil reserves and China’s biggest overseas
intergovernmental forum for Arctic governments and peoples, acquisition to date. However, Canadian Prime Minister
which currently only admits 12 non-Arctic countries as Stephen Harper intimated that the deal was done with some
‘Observers’. Observers may propose projects through an Arctic reluctance on behalf of his Administration. When announcing
State or a permanent participant, but financial contributions the outcome of the deal, he said, “This is not the beginning of
from Observers to any given project may not exceed the a trend, this is the end of a trend […] to be blunt, Canadians
financing from Arctic States. have not spent years reducing ownership of sectors of the
China is certainly making proactive efforts to find partners economy by our own governments only to see them bought
in O&G ventures around the world. CNOOC and other Chinese and controlled by foreign governments instead.” Investment
oil companies held meetings with Russia’s state-controlled by China, on a large scale, into the Canadian O&G industry
OAO Rosneft head, Igor Sechin, during his visit to China earlier is still an unknown undertaking for both parties, and future
this year about potential offshore projects in the Russian Arctic. investment possibilities rely on the skilful management of
In addition, Philippines-based company Philex Petroleum Corp. existing deals.
has said it has been holding discussions with CNOOC to form China does seem to be making some moves towards
a partnership to explore and develop the gas-rich Recto Bank increased transparency in its international business dealings,
(80 miles from Palawan in the Philippines) although these talks although it will continue to come up against oil producing
remain preliminary, and any agreement formed between the nations suspicious of its motivations and reluctant to cede too
two companies would have to respect the laws and regulations much control to China. This will undoubtedly change in time,
set by their respective nations. Unfortunately, the target with the ebbs and flows of the global political and economic
exploration area, which contains a large amount of gas-rich composition. Some things just need a little getting used to.
es Little
Managing Editor: Jam
nology.com
james.little@oilfieldtech
Editor: Anna Scordos
echnology.com
anna.scordos@oilfieldt
nt: Dav id Bizley
Editorial Assista
echnology.com
david.bizley@oilfieldt
: Rod Hardy
Advertisement Director Contact information >>
nology.com
rod.hardy@oilfieldtech
Executive: Ben Macleod Oilfield Technology subscription rates: Annual subscription £80 UK including postage/£95/e130 overseas (postage
Advertisement Sales
echnology.com
ben.macleod@oilfieldt airmail)/US$ 130 USA/Canada (postage airmail). Two year discounted rate £128 UK including postage/£152/e208 overseas
elop men t Man age r: Chris Lethbridge (postage airmail)/US$ 208 USA/Canada (postage airmail).
Business Dev
s.lethbr idge @oi lfieldtechnology.com Subscription claims: Claims for non receipt of issues must be made within three months of publication of the issue or they
chri
ow
Production: Natalie Call will not be honoured without charge.
echnology.com Applicable only to USA & Canada: Oilfield Technology Magazine (ISSN No: 1757-2134, USPS: 025-171) is published
natalie.callow@oilfieldt
Fullerton
Website Manager: Tom monthly by Palladian Publications Ltd GBR and distributed in the USA by SPP, 17B S Middlesex Ave, Monroe NJ 08831.
echnology.com
tom.fullerton@oilfieldt Periodicals postage paid at New Brunswick, NJ.
O’Reilly Postmaster: Send address changes to Palladian Publications, 17B S Middlesex Ave, Monroe NJ 08831.
Website Editor: Callum
lobal.com
callum.oreilly@energyg
Victoria McConnell Palladian Publications Ltd, 15 South Street, Farnham, Surrey GU9 7QU, UK
Circulation Manager:
lfieldtechnology.com Tel: +44 (0) 1252 718 999 Fax: +44 (0) 1252 718 992
victoria.mcconnell@oi
Subscriptions: Laura
Cowell Website: www.energyglobal.com
echnology.com
laura.cowell@oilfieldt
er
istant: Catherine Gow
Reprint/Marketing Ass echnology.com
lfi eldt
catherin e.go wer @oi
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
Publisher: Nigel Hardy July 2013
MULTI-STAGE FRACTURING
“Imitation is the
sincerest form of
flattery… or is it?”
Only Packers Plus delivers proven, reliable
and repeatable results. We have extensive
experience to run your jobs efficiently and
effectively. Contact us today and let us
help you maximize your assets.
DO IT ONCE. DO IT RIGHT.
www.packersplus.com
world news
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
05
world news
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
06 July 2013
POWER OF INNOVATION / ENHANCE PRODUCTIVITY
EXTEND
PRODUCTION AND MAXIMIZE ROI WITH INTERVENTIONS
Volume
Oilproduction volume
INTERVENTIONS
ENHANCE PRODUCTIVITY...
Cleaning, removal of debris & deposits
Milling of hydrates, wax & completion hardware
Mechanical manipulation
Conveyance of logging & perforation
Non-ballistic tubular cutting
Time
Improved recovery rates
... AND EXTEND ASSET VALUE
Welltec’s innovative intervention solutions allow The tools are designed to be light, agile, reliable and
operators to pursue fields that previously weren’t tough, and apply to both standard and tailored inter-
economically viable as well as enable increased cash ventions, offering inherently safer operations.
flows from existing assets.
world news
// Gazprom Neft//
// BP // Asks court to review Macondo compensation Arctic oil ready by Q4
BP is currently in the process of the US in future. The financial implications Gazprom Neft has announced that its
asking a US court to reject a specific are also massive, with a ruling against BP initial oil production from the Arctic
interpretation of a partial settlement over costing the company billions of dollars in Prirazlomnoye field will begin in Q4 this
the oil spill caused as a result of the additional claims. year after delays.
Deepwater Horizon disaster in 2010. A spokesman for BP, Geoff Morrell Start-up of the field had been
BP’s argument is that Claims was quoted as saying, “We are asking delayed over safety fears after the rig was
Administrator, Patrick Juneau has the Fifth Circuit to follow established legal boarded by Greenpeace activists last
approved millions of dollars worth of false principles of contract law and interpret year. The development of Arctic oil and
claims made by businesses as a result of the agreement as written and intended: gas reserves remains highly controversial,
working to an incorrect interpretation of paying only those claimants who suffered with many claiming that risks posed by
the agreement BP reached with lawyers actual losses.” adverse weather conditions and icebergs
in 2012. Not only is the Claims Administrator’s are simply too great to ensure safe
If the judgement goes against BP, misinterpretation contrary to the plain production; Shell’s recent difficulties with
it could have significant long-term language of the settlement agreement its Kulluk drilling rig offshore Alaska have
repercussions for the company in the and the intent of the parties, but it has done little to help sway public opinion.
region; some analysts have pointed out ignited a feeding frenzy among trial Prirazlomnoye is Russia’s first
that if BP feels it was treated unfairly and lawyers attempting to secure money for offshore Arctic oil development and is
not subject to due process then it is likely themselves and their clients that neither expected to reach a peak production
to be less confident about operating in deserves.” level of 19 000 bpd by 2019.
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
08 July 2013
CASING DESIGN FOR EXCEL
"Ã
ÀiÊUÊ-
>ÜÊ7>ÌiÀÊ"vvÃ
ÀiÊUÊii«Ê7>ÌiÀÊ"vvÃ
Ài
>Ãi`ÊÊ-Ì>`>À`Ê*Ê Ý>Ê
>VÕ>ÌÃ
Keri Leicher,
Consultancy
Africa Intelligence,
South Africa, takes a
look at West Africa’s
slippery oil future.
T
OL.\SMVM.\PULHOHZSVUNILLUHJRUV^SLKNLKHZHU VM.OHUH0]VY`*VHZ[:PLYYH3LVULHUK3PILYPHHZYLUL^LKHUK
VPSOV[ZWV[I`PUK\Z[Y`WSH`LYZMVSSV^PUN[OLKPZJV]LY`VM PTWVY[HU[LULYN`O\IZ^PSSYLTHPUHWPWLKYLHT
JVTTLYJPHSX\HU[P[PLZVMVPSPU[OL5PNLY+LS[HPU[OL Z
4HQVYPU[LYUH[PVUHSLULYN`ÄYTZOH]LZPUJLÅVJRLK[V>LZ[(MYPJH West Africa’s new oil province
[VL_WSVYL[OL^H[LYZVMTHQVYWYVK\JLYJV\U[YPLZZ\JOHZ(UNVSH ;OL>LZ[(MYPJHUVPSZJLULPZKVTPUH[LKI`THQVYHUKQ\UPVY
*HTLYVVU,X\H[VYPHS.\PULHHUK.HIVU:VZ[YH[LNPJHSS` L_[YHJ[PVUÄYTZ¶V]LYVM[OLT*OL]YVUMVYL_HTWSLOHZSVUN
PTWVY[HU[PZ[OPZYLNPVU[OH[^OPSL[OLJVU[PULU[PZLZ[PTH[LK[VOH]L KLJSHYLK[OH[>LZ[(MYPJHPZHRL`Z[YH[LNPJHYLH^P[OL_WSVYH[PVU
Q\Z[ VM[OL^VYSK»ZVPSYLZLY]LZP[J\YYLU[S`WYVK\JLZ HUKWYVK\J[PVUHJ[P]P[PLZPU(UNVSH*OHK[OL+LTVJYH[PJ9LW\ISPJ
¶VM[OLWYVK\J[PVU]VS\TLZ0[OHZILLUM\Y[OLYLZ[PTH[LK VM*VUNV+9*3PILYPH5PNLYPHHUK[OL9LW\ISPJVM*VUNV
[OH[[OL.\SMVM.\PULHZOPWZTPSSPVUIISZVMVPS[V[OL ,__VU4VIPSPZHSZVWYLZLU[PU[OLYLNPVUHZHYL9V`HS+\[JO:OLSS
<UP[LK:[H[LZTPSSPVUIISZ[V,\YVWL[V*OPUHHUK )YP[PZO7L[YVSL\T)7HUK[OL-YLUJOLULYN`NPHU[;V[HS1\UPVYZ
[V0UKPHLHJOKH` PUJS\KL[OLSPRLZVM4PYH9LZV\YJLZ*HUHKPHU6]LYZLHZ7L[YVSL\T
6]LY[OLJV\YZLVM[OLWHZ[KLJHKLT\JOH[[LU[PVUOHZILLU *673HUK:PTIH,ULYN`HTVUNV[OLYZ;OLYLNPVU»ZVPSM\[\YLPZ
NP]LU[VV\[S`PUNZ[H[LZM\Y[OLYYLTV]LKMYVT[OLRUV^UVYNHUPJ ZVIYPNO[[OH[(MYPJH»ZSLHKPUNLULYN`L_WLY[+Y+\UJHU*SHYRLVM
ZLKPTLU[ZKLWVZP[LKPU[V[OL.\SMI`[OL5PNLY9P]LY:VWYVTPZPUN .SVIHS7HJPÄJHUK7HY[ULYZYLJLU[S`KLJSHYLK[OH[¸UVNSVIHSWSH`LY
HYL[OLZLUL^WYVZWLJ[Z[OH[HUHS`Z[ZOH]LILN\U[V[HSRVMHU VYLTLYNPUN0UKLWLUKLU[^P[OHUPU[LYUH[PVUHSMVV[WYPU[VYL]LUMHZ[
VPSWYV]PUJL[OH[O\NZ[OLJVHZ[VM.OHUH0]VY`*VHZ[3PILYPH NYV^PUNZ[H[LVPSJVTWHU`JHUHMMVYK[V\UKLYYH[L[OPZ^VYSKJSHZZ
HUK:PLYYH3LVUL>OPSL[OLZLKPZJV]LYPLZOH]LNLULYH[LKT\JO >LZ[LYU(MYPJHUWSH`¹:\JOL_JP[LTLU[OHZILLUKYP]LUI`[OL
L_JP[LTLU[HTVUNLULYN`L_[YHJ[PVUÄYTZHUK(MYPJHUNV]LYUTLU[Z J\YYLU[VPSY\ZOL_[LUKPUNHSVUNHSTVZ[[OLLU[PYL^LZ[JVHZ[VM(MYPJH
HSPRL[OLYLHSPZH[PVUVM[OPZO`KYVJHYIVUYPJOM\[\YLMHJLZU\TLYV\Z HZHYLZ\S[VMHK]HUJLZPUVMMZOVYLL_WSVYH[PVU[LJOUVSVN`
ZLJ\YP[`YPZRZ[OH[[OYLH[LU[VKLYHPS\WZ[YLHTPUP[PH[P]LZ5V[HIS` 6ULVM[OLÄYZ[ZPNUPÄJHU[KPZJV]LYPLZ[OH[[VVRWSHJLV\[ZPKL
[OLZLUL^WYVK\JLYZYLTHPUM\UKHTLU[HSS`PSSLX\PWWLK[VJ\YI VM[OL[YHKP[PVUHS^H[LYZVM[OL.\SMVM.\PULH^HZTHKLI`
NYV^PUNZLJ\YP[`JOHSSLUNLZPU>LZ[(MYPJHWHY[PJ\SHYS`^OLU 2VZTVZ,ULYN`PU^OH[^HZILSPL]LK[VILHU¸\UWYVTPZPUN
JVTWHYLK[VYLNPVUHSJV\U[LYWHY[ZZ\JOHZ5PNLYPHHUK(UNVSH KLLW^H[LYHYLHVMM^LZ[LYU.OHUH¹PU1\UL.OHUH»Z
4HQVY>LZ[(MYPJHUZLJ\YP[`PZZ\LZVMWPYHJ`HUK[LYYVYPZTTH` 1\IPSLLVPSÄLSKZ\IZLX\LU[S`ILJHTLVULVM>LZ[(MYPJH»ZSHYNLZ[
[OLYLMVYLZ[\U[[OLYPZLVM[OPZUL^VPSWYV]PUJLILMVYLYL]LU\LZ KPZJV]LYPLZVM[OLWHZ[[^VKLJHKLZM\Y[OLYILPUNJSHZZPÄLKHZ
OH]LL]LUZ[HY[LK[VÅV^<U[PS[OLZL[OYLH[ZHYLHKKYLZZLK[OLYPZL H^VYSKJSHZZSVUNSPMLWYVK\J[PVUHZZL[;^V`LHYZSH[LYHZTHSS
(TLYPJHUÄYT(UHKHYRV7L[YVSL\TKPZJV]LYLKVPSHUKNHZ JV\U[Y`RUV^U[VIL[OLºJYV^UQL^LS»VM[OLYLNPVU(JYVZZ[OL
YLZLY]LZ^P[O[OLÄYZ[KLLW^H[LY^LSSKYPSSLKPU^OH[^HZZHPK[V IVYKLY[OL9\ZZPHUV^ULK3\RVPSPZYLWVY[LKS`WSHUUPUN[VPU]LZ[
ILLX\HSS`\UWYVTPZPUN:PLYYH3LVUL;OPZÄUK^HZZVTLRT <:TPSSPVUPUL_WSVYH[PVUHJ[P]P[PLZVMM[OL0]VY`*VHZ[^OPSZ[
^LZ[VM2VZTVZ»1\IPSLLÄLSKHUKZV\USVJRLKHUL^^H`VM 9LHS[V,ULYN`^PSSZ[HY[KYPSSPUNSH[LY[OPZ`LHY0U:PLYYH3LVUL
[OPURPUNHIV\[[OLYLNPVU»ZWL[YVSL\TWV[LU[PHS L]LUSVJHS56*ZOH]L[OYV^U[OLPYOH[ZPUHZ[OL.OHUH5H[PVUHS
)`JVUULJ[PUN[OLKV[ZIL[^LLU[OLZL[^VKPZJV]LYPLZ 7L[YVSL\T*VYWVYH[PVUPZJ\YYLU[S`L_WSVYPUNMVYVPSPUP[Z^H[LYZ
PU[LYUH[PVUHSTHQVYZHUKZTHSSLYÄYTZOH]LILN\U[V[YHJLH -PUHSS`PU(MYPJHU7L[YVSL\THUUV\UJLKHKKP[PVUHSVPSÄUKZVMM
UL^VPSWYV]PUJLPU^OH[PZRUV^UHZ[OL>LZ[(MYPJHU;YHUZMVYT [OLJVHZ[VM3PILYPH^OPSL,__VU4VIPSPZHSYLHK`OLH]PS`PU]LZ[LKPU
4HYNPUHUHYLHIL[^LLU[^V[LJ[VUPJWSH[LZWHYHSSLS[V)YHaPS [OLJV\U[Y`
L_[LUKPUNULHYS`RTHSVUN[OLJVHZ[SPULIL[^LLU.OHUHHUK
:PLYYH3LVUL;OLYLPZUV^HNYV^PUNYLHSPZH[PVUHTVUNPUK\Z[Y` Security risks in the Gulf of Guinea
Z[HRLOVSKLYZ[OH[KLZWP[L>LZ[(MYPJHOH]PUNILLUHWYVK\JPUN .P]LU[OH[TVZ[VM[OLZLKPZJV]LYPLZPU[OLUL^VPSWYV]PUJLOH]L
YLNPVUMVYZVTL`LHYZ[OLLU[PYLYLNPVUTH`HJ[\HSS`MVYT ILLUTHKLVMMZOVYL[OLIPNNLZ[ZLJ\YP[`YPZRMHJPUN[OLZLJV\U[YPLZ
WHY[VMHUL^WYLZHS[WYV]PUJL*VIHS[0U[LYUH[PVUHS,ULYN`MVY PZ[OLNYV^PUN[OYLH[VMWPYHJ`(JJVYKPUN[V[OL([SHU[PJ*V\UJPS[OL
L_HTWSLOHZWVPU[LKV\[[OH[HWWYV_PTH[LS`TPSSPVU`LHYZ PUJPKLUJLZVMWPYHJ`HZ^LSSHZRPKUHWWPUNHUK]PVSLUJLH[ZLHPU
HNV"P[Z2^HUaHIHZPUISVJRZVMM[OLJVHZ[VM(UNVSH^V\SKOH]L >LZ[(MYPJHL_JLLKHSSV[OLYHYLHZHJYVZZ[OLJVU[PULU[L]LU^OLU
ILLUHYV\UKRTMYVT[OL>OHSL7HYR*VTWSL_PU)YHaPS»Z JVTWHYLK[V:VTHSPH;OL0U[LYUH[PVUHS4HYP[PTL)\YLH\OHZM\Y[OLY
*HTWVZ)HZPUHUKPU[OLZHTLKLWVZP[PVUHSIHZPU*VTWHUPLZ PUKPJH[LK[OH[WPYH[LH[[HJRZ^LYLYLJVYKLKPU[OL.\SMVM.\PULH
PUJS\KPUN(UHKHYRV2VZTVZHUK;\SSV^6PSHYLUV^^VYRPUN[V PULPNO[VM^OPJOVJJ\YYLKPU-LIY\HY`HSVUL;OLHJ[\HS
LZ[HISPZO[OPZWYLZHS[[YLUKMH[OLYUVY[O:\JOHJ[P]P[`Z\NNLZ[Z ÄN\YLZHYLWYVIHIS`T\JOOPNOLYHZP[PZILSPL]LK[OH[[OLV^ULYZ
[OH[[OLWV[LU[PHSMVY>LZ[(MYPJHUVPSPZUV^WYHJ[PJHSS`SPTP[SLZZ VMHIV\[VM[OL]LZZLSZ[OH[HYLH[[HJRLKPU>LZ[(MYPJHKV
HZTHQVYZHUKQ\UPVYZHYLKYPSSPUNHSS[OL^H`MYVT5HTPIPH[V UV[YLWVY[Z\JOPUJPKLU[Z[VH]VPKOPNOPUZ\YHUJLWYLTP\TZ4VYL
:LULNHS PTWVY[HU[S`^OPSLULHYS`OHSMVM[OLZLH[[HJRZVJJ\YYLKVMM[OLJVHZ[
6MWHY[PJ\SHYPU[LYLZ[PZ[OLUL^VPSWYV]PUJLZ[YL[JOPUNMYVT VM5PNLYPH[OLV[OLYOHSM[VVRWSHJLM\Y[OLY^LZ[VMM[OLJVHZ[ZVM
.OHUH[V3PILYPH>P[OPU[OPZL_WSVYH[PVUaVUL.OHUH»Z1\IPSLL-PLSK )LUPU0]VY`*VHZ[HUKULHYI`JV\U[YPLZ
PZILSPL]LK[VOH]LHYLZLY]LWV[LU[PHSVMHYV\UKÄ]LIPSSPVUIISZ 7PYHJ`PZUV[HUL^ZLJ\YP[`[OYLH[PU>LZ[(MYPJHHZSVJHS
VMVPSHS[OV\NOTHQVYZJVU[PU\L[VTHRLKPZJV]LYPLZPU[OL IHUKP[ZILNHU[HYNL[PUNZOPWZPU[OL5PNLY+LS[HPU[OL Z
;OLZLH[[HJRZ^LYLJSVZL[VZOVYLHUKPU[OLMVYTVMHYTLK 0ZSHTPJL_[YLTPZT7HY[VM[OLYLHZVU^O`[OLYLOH]LILLUTHU`
YVIILYPLZ^P[O[OLM[VMUV[VUS`VPSI\[VM]HS\HISLZHUKJHZOHZ VPSHUKNHZKPZJV]LYPLZ^P[OPU[OL.\SMV]LY[OLWHZ[KLJHKLSPLZ
^LSS:PUJLOV^L]LY[OLZLH[[HJRZOH]LNYV^UTVYLMYLX\LU[ ^P[OHZOPM[PU(TLYPJHULULYN`WVSPJ`WVZ[ ^OLU[OL<:
HUKTVYL]PVSLU[^OLYLI`TPK[OL5PNLYPHUNV]LYUTLU[ VW[LK[VKP]LYZPM`P[ZLULYN`PTWVY[ZH^H`MYVT[OL4PKKSL,HZ[
LZ[PTH[LK[OH[HZTHU`HZIISZVMVPS^LYLILPUNZ[VSLU ILJH\ZLVMHNYV^PUNHU[P^LZ[LYUZ[HUJL>LZ[(MYPJH^HZ
LHJOKH`0UYLZWVUZL[VZ\JOH[[HJRZ5PNLYPHPUJVSSHIVYH[PVU Z\IZLX\LU[S`NP]LUWYPVYP[`K\L[VP[ZHI\UKHUJLVMSPNO[Z^LL[
^P[OP[ZULPNOIV\YZOHZSH\UJOLKTHZZP]LHU[PWPYH[LVWLYH[PVUZ[V JY\KLHUKP[ZNLVNYHWOPJWYV_PTP[`6]LY[OLWHZ[KLJHKL
WH[YVSP[Z^H[LYZ>OPSL[OLZLVWLYH[PVUZOH]LJ\YILK[OLNYV^[OVM OV^L]LYYLSPNPV\ZM\UKHTLU[HSPZ[ZOH]LLU[YLUJOLK[OLTZLS]LZPU
WPYHJ`PU[OL[YHKP[PVUHS^H[LYZVM[OL.\SMVM.\PULH[OL`OH]LOHK [OPZJVYULYVM(MYPJH[OYLH[LUPUN>LZ[LYUPU[LYLZ[ZVUJLHNHPU
[OL\UPU[LUKLKJVUZLX\LUJLVMW\ZOPUNNHUNZM\Y[OLYHSVUN[OL >OPSLUVRUV^U(S8HLKHSPURLKVYNHUPZH[PVUZOH]LHU`
>LZ[(MYPJHUJVHZ[[V^HYKZºWVVYLY»Z[H[LZ¶HZL]PKLUJLKI`UL^ J\YYLU[Z[YVUNOVSKZPU[OLUL^VPSWYV]PUJLHS[OV\NOP[PZ^LSS
WPYHJ`H[[HJRZULHY[OL0]VY`*VHZ[ZPUJL KVJ\TLU[LK[OH[[OL[LYYVYPZ[NYV\W^HZPU]VS]LKPUZVJHSSLK
<USPRL[OLYLNPVUHSOLNLTVU5PNLYPH[OLZLWVVYLYZ[H[LZPU ISVVKKPHTVUKZPU:PLYYH3LVULHUK3PILYPHPU[OL Z[OL
HUKHYV\UK[OLUL^VPSWYV]PUJLPUUV^H`ILHY[OLJHWHJP[`[V >LZ[(MYPJHUYLNPVUH[SHYNLPZRUV^U[VWHZZYLILSNYV\WZ
LMMLJ[P]LS`[HRLVUWPYH[LZ4VZ[VM[OLZLZ[H[LZHYLKLZWLYH[LS` HYV\UKSPRL^PU[LYÅ\HUK[OLIPNNLZ[JHYYPLYPZVMJV\YZL4HSP
WVVYHUKLUNHNLKPUWVZ[^HYYLJVUZ[Y\J[PVULMMVY[ZSLH]PUN[OLT (YLJLU[<UP[LK5H[PVUZ<5YLWVY[OHZM\LSSLKZ\JOJVUJLYUZ
^P[OSP[[SLZWHYLJHZO[VKLWSV`HUH]`[VWH[YVSHUKZLJ\YL[OLPY HZP[OHZYL]LHSLK[OH[YLILSNYV\WZPU.OHUH0]VY`*VHZ[HUK
^H[LYZ+LMLUJLL_WLUKP[\YLPU>LZ[(MYPJHPZSV^LY[OHUPU 3PILYPHHYLJ\YYLU[S`PUJVU[HJ[^P[O[OL0ZSHTPJTPSP[HU[Z[OH[^LYL
,HZ[(MYPJHMVYL_HTWSL;OPZPZPUKPJH[P]LPU[OLZPaLVM[OLPYUH]PLZ PU]VS]LKPU[OLJV\W^OPJO[VWWSLK[OL4HSPHUWYLZPKLU[PU
^OLYL0]VY`*VHZ[OHZQ\Z[[OYLLWH[YVSHUKJVHZ[HSJVTIH[HU[Z ;OLZLMVYJLZOH]LM\Y[OLYL_WYLZZLKHUPU[LYLZ[PUZ\WWVY[PUN
:PLYYH3LVULVULHUK3PILYPHUVUL0UJVTWHYPZVU5PNLYPH»Z KLZ[HIPSPZH[PVUVWLYH[PVUZ[OYV\NOV\[^LZ[LYU(MYPJH;OLYLJLU[
UH]`JVUZPZ[ZVMV]LYZHPSVYZKLWSV`LKHJYVZZWH[YVSHUK H[[HJRVU[OL0U(TLUHZNHZWSHU[PU(SNLYPHLHYSPLY[OPZ`LHYPZH
JVHZ[HSJVTIH[HU[ZHUKHOVZ[VMV[OLYZOPWZYLUKLYPUNP[T\JO JSLHYL_HTWSL[OH[4HSPPZUV^HZV\YJLVMJYVZZIVYKLYYPZRNP]LU
TVYLJHWHISLVMZLJ\YPUNP[Z^H[LYZ9LJLU[HJX\PZP[PVUZI`[OL P[ZYVSLHZHIHZLMVY0ZSHTPJPUZ\YNLU[Z
5PNLYPHU5H]`PUPUKPJH[LHUPUJYLHZPUNJVTTP[TLU[[V^HYKZ ;OLSHJRVMNVVKNV]LYUHUJLHUK[OLZOLLYJHWHJP[`VM[OL
JVTIH[PUNTHYP[PTLHUKYP]LYPULWPYHJ`HZ^LSS UL^VPSWYV]PUJLTHRLZP[HULHZ`[HYNL[MVYZ\JOYLILSZ^OLYL
>P[OTVYLHUKTVYLTHQVYZHUKQ\UPVYZÅVJRPUN[V[OLYLNPVU [OLIPNNLZ[[OYLH[PZHUH[[HJRVUYLNPVUHSPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YLWYVQLJ[Z
[VM\Y[OLY[YHJLV\[[OPZUL^VPSWYV]PUJL[OLPUJPKLUJLVMWPYHJ` (S[OV\NO\WZ[YLHTPUP[PH[P]LZVJJ\YVMMZOVYLSVJHSTPSP[HU[ZOH]L
^PSSJVU[PU\L[VJSPTIPU>LZ[(MYPJH4VYLV]LYILJH\ZLSVJHS KLTVUZ[YH[LK[OLJHWHJP[`[VL_[LUKIL`VUK[OLPYYLHJO[HYNL[PUN
NV]LYUTLU[ZYLTHPUM\UKHTLU[HSS`PSSLX\PWWLK[VJVTIH[[OPZ VPSYLÄULYPLZWPWLSPULZYPNZHUK[HURLYZ
NYV^PUN[OYLH[L_[YHJ[PVUÄYTZ^PSSILL_WLJ[LK[VLUZ\YL[OLPYV^U
ZLJ\YP[`NVPUNMVY^HYKM\Y[OLYKYP]PUN\W[OLWYPJLVMVPS Investment considerations
;OLZLJVUKZLJ\YP[`[OYLH[MHJPUNUL^VPSWSH`LYZHUK (K]HUJLZPUVMMZOVYL[LJOUVSVN`JV\WSLK^P[OHZOPM[PU<:LULYN`
LULYN`ÄYTZVWLYH[PUNPU[OLYLNPVUPZ[LYYVYPZTWHY[PJ\SHYS` WVSPJ`V]LY[OLWHZ[KLJHKLOH]LYHPZLK[OLWYVÄSLVM>LZ[(MYPJH
HZHUVPSWYVK\JPUNYLNPVU
>OPSLKPZJV]LYPLZPU
[OLUL^VPSWYV]PUJLVMM
[OLJVHZ[ZVM.OHUH
0]VY`*VHZ[3PILYPHHUK
:PLYYH3LVULTH`IL
WYVTPZPUN[OLZLZ[H[LZHYL
MHJPUNU\TLYV\ZZLJ\YP[`
YPZRZMYVT[OLV\[ZL[
:\JOYPZRZHYLILJVTPUN
TVYLHWWHYLU[L]LY`KH`
HZ>LZ[(MYPJHPZX\PJRS`
ILJVTPUNHZPUMHTV\ZHZ
,HZ[(MYPJHHUKL]LU[OL
Figure 1. The West African transform margin. 4PKKSL,HZ[.VPUNMVY^HYK
P[^PSSIL\W[VTHQVYZ
HUKQ\UPVYZ[VJVTIH[
[OLZL[OYLH[Z\UPSH[LYHSS`
WLYOHWZ^P[O[OL
HZZPZ[HUJLVM[OLPYV^U
NV]LYUTLU[ZPUJS\KPUN
-YHUJLHUK[OL<:¶VY
YPZRMHJPUN[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VM
\WZ[YLHTPUP[PH[P]LZILPUN
KLYHPSLKILMVYLYL]LU\LZ
Figure 2. Nigerian pirates expand in the region. Figure 3. Attacks in the Gulf of Guinea in 2012. Source: OH]LL]LUZ[HY[LK[VÅV^
www.ics-ccs.org/piracy-reporting-centre/live-piracy-map.
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
9:25AM
:C?DN>C<I=:7:C:;>IHD;6K6HI!
=N9GD86G7DC"G>8=:CK>GDCB:CI
5:25PM
:MEADG>C<I=:I:GG6>CL>I=6
8GDHH"8DJCIGN7>@:G>9:
JcXdckZci^dcVaD^a<VhEgd[Zhh^dcVah
HVjY^6gVbXd^hWgdVYZc^c\^ihedgi[da^dWnkZcijg^c\^cidjcXdckZci^dcVah#
HZ^oZi]Zdeedgijc^inidldg`dc[gdci^ZgWVh^chl^i]hdjgXZgdX`hVcY
i^\]igZhZgkd^ghVhhdX^ViZYl^i]i]ZaVg\Zhid^aVcY\VhÒZaYh^ci]Z
ldgaY#8daaVWdgViZl^i]i]ZaZVY^c\hX^Zci^hih^cHVjY^6gVbXdÉh6YkVcXZY
GZhZVgX]8ZciZgVcYVgdjcYi]ZldgaYi]gdj\]^ih\adWVaG9cZildg`#
:meZg^ZcXZigjangZlVgY^c\YVn"id"YVnX]VaaZc\Zh#7ZndcYldg`ndj]VkZ
Va^[ZhinaZi]Vid[[Zghi]ZX]VcXZidZmeadgZVlZVai]d[VXi^k^i^Zh#
9G:6B7><Villl#6gVbXd#?dWh$DI
Didier Lluch, Repsol, Spain, explains the importance of
supercomputers in the analysis of seismic imaging data as the global
oil and gas industry turns its focus towards offshore West Africa.
S
PUJL[OLÄYZ[VPSHUKNHZL_WSVYH[PVUZJHYYPLKV\[PU[OL
*VUNV)HZPUPU KLLW^H[LYVPSL_WSVYH[PVUVMMZOVYL
>LZ[(MYPJHOHZÅV\YPZOLKHUK[OLYLNPVUOHZILJVTLVUL
VM[OLTVZ[PTWVY[HU[HYLHZPU[OL^VYSKMVYVPSHUKUH[\YHSNHZ
L_WSVYH[PVUHUKWYVK\J[PVU+LLW^H[LYVPSHUKNHZHJ[P]P[`PU>LZ[
(MYPJHL_[LUKZMYVT[OLJV\U[YPLZVM4H\YP[HUPH[V(UNVSHHUK[OL
YLNPVUOHZ^P[ULZZLKVMMZOVYLWYVK\J[PVUOVSKPUNHUPUJYLHZPUN
ZOHYLPU[V[HSVPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVUNYV^PUNMYVT PU[V
I`6MMZOVYLVPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVUPU[OL>LZ[(MYPJHU
YLNPVUPUJYLHZLKMYVTTPSSPVUIVLPU[VTPSSPVUIVL
PUH[HUHUU\HSH]LYHNLNYV^[OYH[L((.9VMHUKPZ
L_WLJ[LK[VPUJYLHZLM\Y[OLY[VTPSSPVUIVLPUH[HU
((.9VMHZHYLZ\S[VMHU[PJPWH[LKWYVQLJ[Z
5PNLYPHHUK(UNVSHHYL[OLSHYNLZ[WYVK\JLYZVMVPSHUKNHZ
PU>LZ[(MYPJHHJJV\U[PUNMVYHYV\UKVM[OLYLNPVU»Z[V[HS
VMMZOVYLVPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVUK\YPUN¶5PNLYPHOHZ
ILLUHU67,*6YNHUPaH[PVUVM[OL7L[YVSL\T,_WVY[PUN*V\U[YPLZ
TLTILYZPUJL HUKPZHTHQVYWYVK\JLYVMVPSPU(MYPJHOVSKPUN
[OLZLJVUKOPNOLZ[HTV\U[VMVPSYLZLY]LZPU[OLJVU[PULU[(UNVSH
OHZILLUHU67,*TLTILYZPUJLVUS`HUKPZH[[OLMVYLMYVU[
VM>LZ[(MYPJHUVMMZOVYLVPSHUKNHZL_WSVYH[PVUHUKWYVK\J[PVU
YLJVYKPUN[OLOPNOLZ[U\TILYVMKPZJV]LYPLZPU[OLYLNPVUK\YPUN
L_[YLTLS`WV^LYM\SHSNVYP[OT^OPJOOHZHKKYLZZLK[OLSPTP[H[PVUZ
VMJ\YYLU[TPNYH[PVUTL[OVKZ[VPTHNLHUKKLSPULH[LJVTWSL_
NLVSVNPJZ[Y\J[\YLZZ\JOHZ[OVZLPU>LZ[(MYPJHHUK(UNVSHPU
WHY[PJ\SHY<U[PSYLJLU[S`[OLWYPTHY`VIZ[HJSL[V[OLSHYNLZJHSL
YV\[PULKLWSV`TLU[VM9;4OHZILLUHSHJRVMJVTW\[LYWV^LY
9;4ULLKZ[PTLZ[OLJVTW\[PUNWV^LY[`WPJHSS`\ZLKPU
L_WSVYH[PVU[LJOUPX\LZ[VILJVUZPKLYLKJVTTLYJPHSS`]PHISL
9LWZVSPZVULZ\JOJVTWHU`[VOH]LPU]LZ[LKPUHUL^ZLPZTPJ
PTHNPUNJVTW\[PUNPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YL[VNHPUHUHS`[PJHSPUZPNO[PU[V
9;4;OLJVTWHU`JVSSHIVYH[LK^P[OZVTLVM[OL^VYSK»ZTVZ[
L_WLYPLUJLK[LJOUVSVN`WHY[ULYZPUJS\KPUN0)4[OL)HYJLSVUH
:\WLYJVTW\[LY*LU[LY):*+.LVHUK:[HUMVYK<UP]LYZP[`»Z
:[HUMVYK,_WSVYH[PVU7YVQLJ[:,7;OLWYVQLJ[SH\UJOLKPU
RUV^UHZ7YVQLJ[2HSLPKVZJVWL\ZLZUL^TVKLSZHSNVYP[OTZ
Figure 1. The MareNostrum supercomputer. HUKVULVM[OL^VYSK»ZTVZ[WV^LYM\SZ\WLYJVTW\[LYZJHSSLK
[OL4HYL5VZ[Y\TVWLYH[LKI`[OL)HYJLSVUH):*+LWSV`LK
YLJLU[`LHYZ+\YPUN1HU\HY` 1\UL(UNVSHHJJV\U[LK I`0)4SVJH[LKPU/V\Z[VU;L_HZ[OL7YVQLJ[2HSLPKVZJVWL
MVYVMH[V[HSKLLW^H[LYVMMZOVYLVPSHUKNHZKPZJV]LYPLZ PUMYHZ[Y\J[\YLPZJVTWYPZLKVM0)4)SHKL*LU[LY8:ISHKL
THKLPU>LZ[(MYPJHLTLYNPUNHZHÅV\YPZOPUNKLLW^H[LYMYVU[PLY ZLY]LYZZ\WWVY[LKI`HSHYNLUL[^VYRVM0)4;V[HS:[VYHNLZ[VYHNL
OHYK^HYL0UWHYHSSLS^P[O[OPZKLWSV`TLU[Z[HMMMYVT0)4:;.*LSS
The super continent ,JVZ`Z[LT
:VS\[PVUZ,UHISLTLU[.YV\WHUK[OL0)4;1>H[ZVU
0U[LYLZ[PU[OL>LZ[(MYPJHUYLNPVUZOV^UI`VPSHUKNHZJVTWHUPLZ 9LZLHYJO*LU[LY»Z4\S[PJVYL*VTW\[PUN.YV\W^VYRLKJSVZLS`^P[O
^VYSK^PKLOHZOPNOSPNO[LK[OLNYV^PUNMVJ\ZVUWYLZHS[WSH`Z WHYHSSLSPZH[PVUL_WLY[ZMYVT[OL)HYJLSVUH):*[VVW[PTPZL[OL9;4
^OPJOOH]LLTLYNLKPUYLJLU[`LHYZHZVULVM[OLTVZ[WYVTPZPUN HSNVYP[OTZMVYWLHRWYVJLZZPUNVU[OL7V^LY?*LSS;LZ[PUNVM[OL
MYVU[PLYZVMVPSL_WSVYH[PVU0UMHJ[L]PKLUJLZOV^Z[OH[[OLYLPZHU Z`Z[LTVU)*:»Z4HYL5VZ[Y\TZ\WLYJVTW\[LY·I\PS[I`0)4·
HSTVZ[WLYMLJ[Z`TTL[Y`IL[^LLULSLTLU[ZZ\JOHZZV\YJLYVJRZ ZOV^LK[OH[[OL0)47V^LY?*LSSPWYVJLZZVYYHU[OLZLHSNVYP[OTZ
YLZLY]VPYZZLHSZHUK[YHWZHUKVPS[`WLZVM[OLWYLZHS[NLVSVN`VM HZT\JOHZZP_[PTLZMHZ[LY[OHUL_PZ[PUNZLPZTPJHUHS`ZPZWSH[MVYTZ
)YHaPS^OLUJVTWHYLK^P[O[OH[VM>LZ[(MYPJH(YV\UKTPSSPVU
`LHYZHNVIV[OJVU[PULU[Z^LYLWHY[VMHZ\WLYJVU[PULU[RUV^U Lending expertise
[OLUHZ.VUK^HUH^OPJO^HZZWSP[I`[OL([SHU[PJ6JLHUHUKSLM[ 9LJLU[S`9LWZVSLU[LYLKPU[VHWHY[ULYZOPW^P[O:VUHUNVS[OL
]LY`ZPTPSHYJVHZ[HSZLKPTLU[VUIV[OZPKLZVM[OLVJLHU;OPZOHZ (UNVSHUUH[PVUHSVPSJVTWHU`^OPJO^PSSPU]VS]L[OL\ZLVM[OL
SLKNLVSVNPZ[Z[VILSPL]L[OH[[OLVPSKLWVZP[ZMV\UKPU[OL)YHaPSPHU JVTWHU`»Z7YVQLJ[2HSLPKVZJVWL[LJOUVSVN`^OPJOOHZHSZV
WYLZHS[SH`LYJV\SKILTPYYVYLKVU[OLV[OLYZPKLVM[OLVJLHUPU ILLU\ZLK[VTHRLYLJLU[KPZJV]LYPLZPU)YHaPSHUK[OL<:.\SMVM
>LZ[(MYPJH.LVSVNPZ[ZOH]LWYV]LU[OH[(UNVSHUHUK)YHaPSPHU 4L_PJV;^LU[`ZL]LU:VUHUNVSLUNPULLYZ^PSSIL[YHPULK[V\ZL[OL
JVU[PULU[HSZOLS]LZZOHYL[OLTVZ[ZPTPSHYP[PLZHZ[OL`OH]LILLU [LJOUVSVN`H[9LWZVS»Z[LJOUVSVN`JLU[YLPU4HKYPK^P[O[OLHPTVM
QVPULKMVYHJLY[HPUNLVSVNPJHSWLYPVK OLSWPUN[OLT[VTVKLS[OL2^HUaHIHZPUHUHYLHVMMZOVYL(UNVSH
^OPJOOHZILJVTLHOV[HYLHMVYL_WSVYH[PVUPUYLJLU[`LHYZHUK
Applying seismic imaging ‘know how’ ^OPJONLVSVNPZ[ZZLLHZHUHSVNV\Z[V[OL:HU[VZIHZPUPU)YHaPS
*VUZLX\LU[S`VPSJVTWHUPLZ^VYSK^PKLHYLUV^HWWS`PUN[OLPY
\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVMVPSÄLSKZVMMZOVYL)YHaPS[V[OVZLVMMZOVYL Drilling deeper with better technology
>LZ[(MYPJH\ZPUNZVWOPZ[PJH[LKZLPZTPJPTHNPUN[LJOUVSVN`[V 0U[OLSVUN[LYT[OLLTIYHJPUNVMUL^HWWYVHJOLZ[VWYVJLZZPUN
YLHJOVPSSVJH[LKH[^H[LYKLW[OZVMTVYL[OHUTM[ HUKSVVRPUNKLLWLYPU[VZLPZTPJKH[H^PSSW\[,
7JVTWHUPLZPU
/V^L]LY[OL\ZLVM[YHKP[PVUHSZLPZTPJPTHNPUNPUHUHS`ZPUN[OL Z[YVUNLYTVYLJVTWL[P[P]LWVZP[PVUZ^P[OV\[OH]PUN[VJVTWYVTPZL
NLVSVNPJHSZ`Z[LTZPU(UNVSHU^H[LYZOHZVM[LUWYV]LKKPMÄJ\S[ [OL[PTPUNHUKX\HSP[`VM[OLPYZ[YH[LNPJKLJPZPVUZ0U[OPZ^H`P[
;OPZPZK\LPUSHYNLWHY[[V[OLL_PZ[LUJLVM[OPJRZHS[KVTLZ PZ[OLWPVULLYPUNÄYTZ[OH[OH]LILLUHISL[VIYLHR[OYV\NO[OL
T\ZOYVVTZOHWLKZ[Y\J[\YLZ[OH[WYV]LPKLHSMVY[YHWWPUNVPS ºHJJ\YHJ`]LYZ\ZZWLLK»[YHKLVMMZ[OH[OH]LKLÄULKZLPZTPJ
KLWVZP[ZI\[^OPJOHYLUV[VYPV\ZS`KPMÄJ\S[[VZLLILULH[OHUK L_WSVYH[PVU\U[PS[VKH`0U[OLM\[\YLHJJLZZ[VTVYLKL[HPSLKZLPZTPJ
THRLZLPZTPJPTHNPUNWYLJPZPVUKPMÄJ\S[[VHJOPL]L+\L[V[OL PTHNLZHUK[LJOUPX\LZ^PSSHSSV^JVTWHUPLZ[VTHRLTVYLHJJ\YH[L
JY`Z[HSSPUL[`WLZ[Y\J[\YL^OPJOJYLH[LZºUVPZL»PU[OLZLPZTPJ HUKKH[HKYP]LUKYPSSPUNKLJPZPVUZZ\IZ[HU[PHSS`TP[PNH[PUN[OLYPZRVM
KH[HHUKIS\YZPTHNLZSPRLHZT\KNLVUHJHTLYHSLUZL_[YLTLS` KY`OVSLZHZZVJPH[LK^P[OKLLW^H[LYWYLZHS[KYPSSPUN-\Y[OLYTVYL
JVTWSL_HSNVYP[OTZHYLULLKLK[VHJOPL]L[OLHJJ\YHJ`[OH[VPS HULUOHUJLK]PL^VMWVZZPISLWL[YVSL\TKLWVZP[Z^PSSWYV]PKL[OLZL
JVTWHUPLZULLK[VKYPSSL_HJ[S`PU[OLYPNO[SVJH[PVUHUKH]VPK JVTWHUPLZ^P[OHUHK]HU[HNLPU[LUKLYPUNHUKIPKKPUNMVYVMMZOVYL
[OLYPZRVMKYPSSPUNºKY`OVSLZ»^OVZLJVZ[ZJHUVM[LUL_JLLK KLLW^H[LYVPSÄLSKZ(ZJVTWHUPLZJVU[PU\L[VPU]LZ[HUKHWWS`
TPSSPVU [OLPYWPVULLYPUNL_WSVYH[PVUZ[YH[LNPLZ[OYV\NO[OL\ZLVMHK]HUJLK
ZLPZTPJPTHNPUN[LJOUPX\LZ[VZ\Y]L`KLLW^H[LYVMMZOVYLIHZPUZ
Achieving ever greater accuracy >LZ[(MYPJHHWWLHYZ[VILVULVM[OLTVZ[WYVTPZPUNYLNPVUZPU[LYTZ
;VV]LYJVTL[OLZLJOHSSLUNLZPUYLJLU[`LHYZZL]LYHSVPSHUK VMM\[\YLKL]LSVWTLU[VWWVY[\UP[PLZ
NHZJVTWHUPLZOH]LHKHW[LK[OLPYZLPZTPJPTHNPUNTL[OVKZHUK
[LJOUPX\LZ[VHSSV^[OLT[VTHRLIL[[LYPUMVYTLKKLJPZPVUZHIV\[ References
+LLW6MMZOVYL6PS
.HZ,_WSVYH[PVUHUK7YVK\J[PVU,
7PU>LZ[(MYPJH
^OLYLL_HJ[S`[VKYPSSMVYVPS(K]HUJLKZLPZTPJPTHNPUN[LJOUPX\LZ
4HYRL[(UHS`ZPZ*VTWL[P[P]L3HUKZJHWLHUK-VYLJHZ[Z[V
OH]LPUJS\KLK[OLKL]LSVWTLU[VMYL]LYZL[PTLTPNYH[PVU9;4HU
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Edward Tovar & Nelbett Marfisi,
Ecopetrol, and Elizabeth Diaz &
Joel Walls, Ingrain Inc, use digital
rock physics (DRP) for reservoir
characterisation in the La Luna
formation.
Technology and methods
T
OL3H3\UHMVYTH[PVUOHZILLUH
^VYSKJSHZZZV\YJLYVJRI\[P[Z +PNP[HSYVJRWO`ZPJZ+97KL]LSVWLKI`
WV[LU[PHSHZHU\UJVU]LU[PVUHS 0UNYHPU^HZHWWSPLKPU[OL3H3\UH^LSS
YLZLY]VPYYVJRPZQ\Z[Z[HY[PUN[VIL MVSSV^PUNHKL[HPSLK^VYRÅV^LZWLJPHSS`
YLJVNUPZLK,JVWL[YVSKYPSSLK[OL KLZPNULKMVY[OLJOHYHJ[LYPZH[PVUVM
3H3\UH^LSSPU^P[O^OVSL ZOHSLZ+\YPUN7OHZL*VYL/+K\HS
JVYLVI[HPULKV]LY[OLLU[PYL3H3\UH LULYN`?YH`*;PTHNPUN^HZJHYYPLKV\[
MVYTH[PVU;OLJVYL^HZ?YH`*;PTHNLK ^P[OH]V_LSYLZVS\[PVUVMHWWYV_PTH[LS`
H[[OL^LSSZP[L^OPJOJVUZ[P[\[LZH TT-YVT[OPZPTHNPUNHJVU[PU\V\Z
TPSLZ[VULPU[OLOPZ[VY`VMJVYLHUHS`ZPZ SVNVMOPNOYLZVS\[PVUYVJRI\SRKLUZP[`
5VWYL]PV\ZJVYLPTHNPUNVWLYH[PVUVM 9/6)HUKWOV[VLSLJ[YPJMHJ[VY7,-^HZ
[OPZUH[\YLHUKTHNUP[\KLOHZL]LYILLU JVTW\[LK)\SRKLUZP[`PZHUPUKPJH[VYVM
H[[LTW[LKPU[OLMPLSK(KKP[PVUHSKL[HPSLK WVYVZP[`HUKVYNHUPJTH[[LYJVU[LU[^OPSL
HUHS`ZPZ^HZJVUK\J[LKVUTHU`ZHTWSLZ 7,-PZHUPUKPJH[VYVMTPULYHSVN`;OL
[VX\PJRS`KLMPULHUKX\HU[PM`[OLRL` KLUZP[`HUKTPULYHSVN`PUMVYTH[PVUJHUIL
ZOHSLYLZLY]VPYWYVWLY[PLZ \ZLK[VKLÄULZOHSLMHJPLZ;OPZWYVJLZZ
ZLWHYH[LZ[OLKH[HPU[VMV\YVYTVYLMHJPLZJSHZZLZHUK (IZVS\[LWLYTLHIPSP[`^HZJHSJ\SH[LKPULHJO]9VJR\ZPUNH
^HZ\ZLK[VJOHYHJ[LYPZLHUKPKLU[PM`[OLNYLH[LZ[YLZLY]VPY U\TLYPJHSTL[OVKRUV^UHZ3H[[PJL)VS[aTHUU
WV[LU[PHSPU[OL3H3\UHMVYTH[PVU0U-PN\YL[OLMV\Y[O[YHJR
MYVT[OLSLM[ZOV^Z[OLMHJPLZ9LKHUKNYLLUJVSV\YLKMHJPLZ Results and findings
YLWYLZLU[OPNOLYWVYVZP[`HUKVYNHUPJJVU[LU[;OLYPNO[ZPKL (WWYV_PTH[LS`ZHTWSLZ^LYLHUHS`ZLK\ZPUN[OPZ
[YHJRZOV^ZHJVTW\[H[PVUVMIYP[[SLULZZPUKL_VYºMYHJHIPSP[`» +97^VYRMSV^HUK[OLMVSSV^PUNWYVWLY[PLZ^LYL
;OPZKH[HJHUILNLULYH[LKPUHTH[[LYVMOV\YZVYHML^KH`Z VI[HPULK![V[HSWVYVZP[`JVUULJ[LKWVYVZP[`VYNHUPJ
HM[LY[OLJVYLOHZILLUYLJV]LYLK[OLYLI`HPKPUNPUOVYPaVU[HS TH[[LYWVYVZP[`HZZVJPH[LK^P[OVYNHUPJTH[[LY7(F64
^LSSIVYLWSHJLTLU[HUKZ[PT\SH[PVUKLZPNU ]LY[PJHSWLYTLHIPSP[`OVYPaVU[HSWLYTLHIPSP[`HUKWVYLZPaL
0U7OHZLVM[OPZZOHSLJVYLWYVNYHTTLWS\NZ^LYL KPZ[YPI\[PVU9LZ\S[ZVM[OLZL[LZ[ZZOV^[OH[[OL3H3\UH
ZLSLJ[LKMVYNYLH[LYHUHS`[PJHSKL[HPS0UP[PHSS`[OL`^LYL MVYTH[PVUOHZOPNOLYH]LYHNLWVYVZP[`[OHULP[OLY[OL3V^LY
?YH`*;PTHNLKH[HYLZVS\[PVUVMTPJYVUZ]V_LS;OLZL*; ,HNSL-VYKVY>VSMJHTWMVYTH[PVUZPU[OL<:(]LYHNL
]VS\TLZUV[VUS`^LYL\ZLK[VN\PKL[OLZLSLJ[PVUVM TH[YP_WLYTLHIPSP[`PZPU[OLZHTLYHUNLHZ[OLZLWYVSPMPJ
Z\IZHTWSLZI\[HSZVHYLWHY[VM 5VY[O(TLYPJHUZOHSLZ-PN\YLZOV^Z
H]LY`PTWVY[HU[]PZ\HSJH[HSVN\L [OL[V[HSWVYVZP[`]LYZ\ZOVYPaVU[HS
+\YPUN[OPZZLJVUKWOHZL WLYTLHIPSP[`[YLUKMVY[OL
ZJHUUPUNLSLJ[YVUTPJYVZJVWL Digital rock physics 3H3\UHMVYTH[PVUJVTWHYLK
:,4HUHS`ZLZ^LYLHSZV
JVUK\J[LKVUPVUTPSSLKZHTWSLZ
(DRP) was applied in [V[OL[YLUKZMVY[OLVPS
HUKNHZ^PUKV^PU[OL
:JHUUPUNLSLJ[YVUPJTPJYVZJVWLZ the La Luna-1 well ,HNSL-VYKMVYTH[PVU
LX\PWWLK^P[OZL]LYHSZLUZVYZ
HSSV^OPNOYLZVS\[PVUPTHNLZVM[OL
following a detailed 0UHKKP[PVUHU
PTWVY[HU[WYVWLY[`^HZ
ZOHSLTPULYHSNYHPUZZVSPKVYNHUPJ
TH[LYPHSHUKWVYLZWHJL[VIL
workflow especially VI[HPULK[OH[JHUVUS`IL
KPYLJ[S`X\HU[PÄLK\ZPUN
VI[HPULK;OLZLPTHNLZHZZOV^U designed for the KPNP[HSYVJRWO`ZPJZ;OL
PU-PN\YL^LYLKPNP[HSS`HUHS`ZLK[V
X\HU[PM`[OLHTV\U[VMVYNHUPJTH[[LY
characterisation of HWWHYLU[ºJVU]LYZPVU
YH[PV»VMZVSPKVYNHUPJ
WVYVZP[`HUKOPNOKLUZP[`TPULYHSZ shales. TH[[LYPU[VVYNHUPJTH[[LY
WYLZLU[PU[OLZHTWSLZ WVYLZ^HZJVTW\[LKMVY
+\YPUN7OHZLVM[OPZWYVQLJ[ HSSZHTWSLZ;OPZ]HS\L
[OYLLKPTLUZPVUHS]VS\TLZVMKPNP[HSYVJRPTHNLZ^LYL TH`HSZVILYLMLYYLK[VHZºWVYVZP[`VM[OLRLYVNLU»;OLZL
VI[HPULKMYVT-0):,4MVJ\ZLKPVUILHTJVTIPULK^P[O ]HS\LZ.HSLTIV$ 7\QHTHUH$:HSHKH$
ZJHUUPUNLSLJ[YVUTPJYVZJVW`;OLZLPTHNL]VS\TLZOH]LH HUK;HISHaV$JHUILJVTWHYLK^P[OYLJVNUPZLKZOHSL
]V_LSYLZVS\[PVUVMHWWYV_PTH[LS`UTHUKMVYTHKPNP[HS WSH`Z,HNSL-VYK$ MVYPUZ[HUJL(SZV7(F64JHUIL
YVJR]VS\TL]9VJR^OPJOPZ\ZLKMVYM\Y[OLYHUHS`ZPZHUK \ZLK[VNL[HUPKLHVM[OLL_WLJ[LKO`KYVJHYIVUZH[\YH[PVU
JVTW\[PUNVMWLYTLHIPSP[`HUKV[OLY[`WLZVMZWLJPHSJVYL ZPUJL64WVYVZP[`PZUVYTHSS`HZZ\TLK[VILÄSSLK^P[O
HUHS`ZPZ:*(3-PN\YLZOV^ZHUL_HTWSL:LNTLU[H[PVU O`KYVJHYIVUZ
HUKPTHNLWYVJLZZPUNHSSV^Z[OLZLWHYH[PVUVM[OLZVSPK +\YPUN7OHZLVM[OLWYVQLJ[ZVTLZ\IZHTWSLZ
TPULYHSVYNHUPJTH[[LYHUKWVYLZWHJLVM[OLZL+VIQLJ[Z ^LYLZLSLJ[LKMVYHKKP[PVUHSZWLJPHSJVYLHUHS`ZPZ:*(3
Figure 1. A 20 ft depth interval of CoreHD data (RhoB, PEF, images) Figure 2. A high resolution SEM image from the La Luna formation
combined with core gamma ray and other data to compute brittleness clearly shows porosity inside organic material. Before SEM imaging,
or fracability (La Luna-1 well). The vertical resolution of CoreHD these samples were polished flat using an argon-ion beam milling
is more than 100 times higher than well log data, which greatly process.
improves sample selection and net pay estimation.
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Leading Through Innovation –
World’s Most Trusted Hardbanding
Supported by almost 200 applicators worldwide – on every continent
100% CRACK-FREE & REBUILDABLE
Duraband®NC
Decreases Downtime & Increases Productivity!
Exceptional Reliability
Excellent Casing & Tool Joint Protection
No need to remove existing hardbanding
Re-application costs up to 75% lower than competitive cracking
hardband products
Cuts NPT & Maintenance Cycles
)HDUQOH\3URFWHU16&HUWL¿HG3URGXFWIRUQHZDSSOLFDWLRQ
re-application over other competitive hardbands
Ultraband™NM
Patent Pending
Improves Wear Resistance
In Non-Mag Applications!
Up to 500% Improved Wear Resistance
Over Ordinary Non-Mag Welding Alloys
Up to 500% Better Abrasion Resistance
Than Drill Collar Base Materials
Apply directly to non-mag tools & over
PERFECT FOR ALL previous layers of stainless
HARDBANDING CONDITIONS Meets API Spec. 7 – Relative permeability
Highly Deviated Wells • Sour Gas Well less than 1.01
Geothermal Wells • HPHT Wells No spalling in multiple layers
Available from drill pipe manufacturers and rental companies
Duraband® NC
Hardbanding
Uses: New Application
and Re-Application to
www.hardbandingsolutions.com Tool Joints
Figure 3. A high resolution FIB-SEM image volume is shown from the
La Luna-1 well. Left is the outer surface of the volume and right is a
transparency volume in which green is solid organic material, blue
is connected porosity, red is isolated porosity and the solid mineral
grains are transparent.
-VY[OLZHTWSLZVM.HSLTIVHUK:HSHKH^H[LYVPSYLSH[P]L
WLYTLHIPSP[`^HZJVTW\[LKPU[OLOVYPaVU[HSKPYLJ[PVU0U
HKKP[PVU[V[OLIHZLSPULZJLUHYPVZZLUZP[P]P[`HUHS`ZPZ^HZ
WLYMVYTLKPU^OPJOZVTLVM[OLPUP[PHSWHYHTL[LYZ(70.69
JVU[HJ[HUNSLHUK^L[[HIPSP[`^LYLJOHUNLKHUKUL^]HS\LZ
VMYLSH[P]LWLYTLHIPSP[`^LYLJVTW\[LK
+97PZJ\YYLU[S`[OLVUS`^H`[VNL[]HS\LZVMYLSH[P]L
WLYTLHIPSP[`PUZOHSLZ;OLTL[OVK\ZLKI`0UNYHPUIHZLK
VU3H[[PJL)VS[aTHUUHPKZPU\UKLYZ[HUKPUN[OLYLSH[PVUZOPW
IL[^LLU[OLÅV^VM[^VPTTPZJPISLÅ\PKZHUK[OLJVTWSL_
Figure 4. These trend lines show how La Luna shale compares to WVYLNLVTL[Y`-PN\YLZOV^Z[OLNHZHUKVPSYLSH[P]L
the oil window and gas window of the Eagle Ford formation in south WLYTLHIPSP[`J\Y]LZMVY[^V3H3\UHMVYTH[PVUZHTWSLZ;OLZL
Texas, USA. Permeability from digital rock samples is computed in the J\Y]LZHYL[`WPJHSVMV[OLYZPU[OPZMVYTH[PVUHUKZOV^OV^
horizontal plane, parallel to shale laminations. VPSWLYTLHIPSP[`JOHUNLZHZNHZJVTLZV\[VMZVS\[PVU;OLZL
J\Y]LZHSSV^YLZLY]VPYLUNPULLYZ[VLZ[PTH[LVPSYLJV]LY`
MHJ[VYZHUKWYLKPJ[OV^WYVK\J[PVUVMSPX\PKO`KYVJHYIVUZ^PSS
KYVWVMMHZ[OLYLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLPZKLWSL[LK
Summary
;OLHWWSPJH[PVUHUKPU[LNYH[PVUVM[OLKH[HVI[HPULKMYVT[OPZ
Z[\K`VM+97OHZHSSV^LK,JVWL[YVS[VHJOPL]LHWHY[PJ\SHYS`
MHZ[HUKLMÄJPLU[\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVM[OLTHQVYMVYTH[PVUZJVYLK
PU[OL3H3\UH^LSS(RL`ÄUKPUNVM[OLWYVQLJ[PZ[OH[
ZOHSLZMV\UKPU3H3\UH^LSSL_OPIP[JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ[OH[
HYLZPTPSHY[VRUV^UL_WSVYH[VY`[HYNL[ZPU5VY[O(TLYPJH
-VYL_HTWSLZVTL\UP[ZVM[OL3H3\UHMVYTH[PVUJV\SK
ILHUHUHSVN\LVM[OL>VSMJHTWMVYTH[PVUVM>LZ[ ;L_HZ
6[OLY\UP[ZHYLZPTPSHY[V[OLWYVSPÄJSV^LY,HNSL-VYK
MVYTH[PVUVMZV\[O;L_HZ.HSLTIV:HSHKHHUK;HISHaVHYL
LZWLJPHSS`H[[YHJ[P]LL_WSVYH[VY`[HYNL[ZHZZ\TPUN[OH[[OL
Å\PKWYVWLY[PLZHUKYLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLZHYLHSZVMH]V\YHISL
Figure 5. Gas-oil relative permeability curves for two samples of
0[ZOV\SKHSZVILUV[LK[OH[[OLZOHSL[OPJRULZZMV\UKPU[OL
La Luna shale. These samples have absolute permeability of a few
hundred nanodarcies, making it impossible to obtain this data from 3H3\UH^LSSZPNUPÄJHU[S`L_JLLKZ[OVZLMV\UKPUTHU`VM
traditional physical core analysis methods. [OLZOHSLZPU5VY[O(TLYPJH
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Exceed
Expectations
Alexander Darishchev,* Pierre Lemouzy and
Patrick Rouvroy, Beicip-Franlab, France, outline
some of the practical aspects of modelling
and flow simulation in the context of tight and
shale gas reservoirs.
U
UJVU]LU[PVUHSO`KYVJHYIVUYLZV\YJLZZ\JOHZ[PNO[HUK PU[LNYH[LKZPT\SH[PVUZVM[^HYLWHJRHNLZHUKTVK\SLZ;OPZLUHISLZ
ZOHSLNHZWSH`HZPNUPÄJHU[YVSLPUV]LYHSSWYVK\J[PVU!V]LY NLVZJPLU[PZ[ZHUKLUNPULLYZ[VOHUKSLHO\NLYHUNLVMYLZLY]VPY
VMJ\YYLU[<:UH[\YHSNHZWYVK\J[PVUHUKHIV\[ KH[HHUKJVUZPKLYKPMMLYLU[ZJLUHYPVZPUVYKLY[VÄUK[OLTVZ[
VMNSVIHSUH[\YHSNHZJVTLZMYVT[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZYLZLY]VPYZ WSH\ZPISLZ[YH[LNPLZMVYYLJV]LY`VW[PTPZH[PVUHUKTH[LYPHSHUK
^P[OLZ[PTH[LKWV[LU[PHS[VYPZLV]LY[PTL;OPZNHZVJJ\YZPU ÄUHUJPHSYLZV\YJLHSSVJH[PVU;OLNH[L^H`[VZ\JJLZZM\SI\ZPULZZ
L_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`YLZLY]VPYZ9LJLU[HK]HUJLZPUOVYPaVU[HS KL]LSVWTLU[PU[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZPZ[OYV\NOZTHY[LY[LJOUVSVNPLZ
KYPSSPUNHUKT\S[PZ[HNLO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUN-PN\YLHUKHIL[[LY HUL^JVTTP[TLU[[V9
+HUKVMJV\YZLJSVZLYJVSSHIVYH[PVU
\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVMYLZLY]VPYÅV^HUKWYVK\J[PVUTLJOHUPZTZOH]L IL[^LLUKPMMLYLU[ZWLJPHSPZ[Z^P[OLTWOHZPZVUT\S[PKPZJPWSPUHY`
THKL[OLZVJHSSLKº\UJVU]LU[PVUHS»NHZYLJV]LYHISLPU[OLJ\YYLU[ HWWYVHJOLZHUKHJVSSHIVYH[P]LLU]PYVUTLU[;OLTHYNPUHS
OPNOWYPJLJSPTH[L:\JJLZZM\SYLZLY]VPYTHUHNLTLU[YLX\PYLZ LJVUVTPJZVM\UJVU]LU[PVUHSYLZLY]VPYZYLX\PYLTVYLPTWYV]LTLU[Z
JSVZLJVSSHIVYH[PVUIL[^LLUKPMMLYLU[ZWLJPHSPZ[Z^P[OLTWOHZPZVU PUÄLSKKH[HHJX\PZP[PVUYLZLY]VPYJOHYHJ[LYPZH[PVUTVKLSSPUNHUK
T\S[PKPZJPWSPUHY`HWWYVHJOLZUV[VUS`PUH[LJOUPJHSJVU[L_[I\[HSZV ZPT\SH[PVUHIPSP[PLZ;LJOUVSVNPJHSLMMLJ[P]LULZZHUKLJVUVTPJ
PULJVUVTPJSLNHSHUKLU]PYVUTLU[HSHYLHZ;OLMVJ\ZVM[OPZZ[\K` Z\JJLZZHYLL_[YLTLS`ZLUZP[P]L[VHUV]LYHSSHIPSP[`[VHJOPL]L
PZVUYLZLY]VPYLUNPULLYPUN;OPZPZHJOHSSLUNPUN[PTL[VYLJVUZPKLY L_WLJ[LKNHZWYVK\J[PVUMYVTZ\JOSV^WLYTLHIPSP[`YLZLY]VPYZ
ZVTLVM[OLPZZ\LZHYV\UKTVKLSSPUNHUKÅV^ZPT\SH[PVUPU[OL (UV[OLYPTWVY[HU[PZZ\LPZ[OLHIPSP[`[VKLZJYPIL[OLYLZLY]VPYPU
JVU[L_[VM[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZYLZLY]VPYZHUK[VL_JLLKJVTTVU [LYTZVMWLYMVYTHUJLX\HU[PM`[OLLMMLJ[P]LULZZVMZ[PT\SH[PVU
L_WLJ[H[PVUZ [YLH[TLU[ZHUK[VMVYLJHZ[WYVK\J[PVUHUKWYV]PKLLJVUVTPZ[Z^P[O
J\Y]LWSV[ZYPZRHUK\UJLY[HPU[`HUHS`ZPZ[VVSZ7YVK\J[PVUWYVÄSLZ
Simulation of flow in tight and shale gas HYL[OLRL`ºPUW\[»KH[HMVYPU]LZ[TLU[Z[\KPLZYL]LU\LLZ[PTH[PVU
reservoirs HUKLJVUVTPJWLYMVYTHUJLL]HS\H[PVU>P[OV\[[OLYLJVNUP[PVUVM
9LZLY]VPYKH[HJVSSLJ[PVUHUKTHUHNLTLU[PZVMJLU[YHSPTWVY[HUJL [OLJYP[PJHSLSLTLU[ZJVU[YPI\[PUNJVTWVULU[ZNLVSVNPJHSMLH[\YLZ
7SHUUPUNQ\Z[PÄJH[PVUWYPVYP[`[PTLSPULZZX\HSP[`JVZ[LMMLJ[P]LULZZ WO`ZPJHSHUKJOLTPJHSWOLUVTLUH^OPJOVJJ\YPUWVYV\ZTLKPH[OL
HUK[OLYVI\Z[ULZZVM[LJOUVSVNPLZHWWSPLKHYL[OLN\PKPUNMHJ[VYZ HWWSPJH[PVUVMWYVK\J[PVUWYVÄSLZHUKMVYLJHZ[ZPZX\LZ[PVUHISLHUK
[OH[ZOV\SKUV^ILYLJVUZPKLYLK,HY[OZJPLU[PZ[ZLUNPULLYZHUK JHUUV[ILWYVWLYS`\ZLKPUKLJPZPVUTHRPUN
ZVM[^HYLKL]LSVWLYZOH]LTHKLJVUZPKLYHISLWYVNYLZZPU[OL ;OLYLZLY]VPYZVM[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZ[LUK[VOH]LSV^LY
PU[LNYH[PVUVMIV[ONLVZJPLUJLHUKLUNPULLYPUNKH[H!NLVSVNPJHS WLYTLHIPSP[`HUKOPNOLYOL[LYVNLULP[`[OLWHYHTL[LYZ[OH[NV]LYU
NLVWO`ZPJHSNLVTLJOHUPJHSHUKYLZLY]VPYWYVK\J[PVUKH[HJHUIL Å\PKÅV^HYLU\TLYV\ZHUK\UJLY[HPU;OLMVJHSSPTP[PUNMHJ[VYZRL`
WYVJLZZLK[VNL[OLY]PHHWSH[MVYTVM+TVKLSSPUN^VYRÅV^HUK YVHKTHWJVTWVULU[ZUH[\YHSNHZJVTWVZP[PVUHUKZOHSLHUK[PNO[
YVJRWYVWLY[PLZOH]LILLUZ\TTHYPZLKILMVYL*VTWSL_
WO`ZPJZHUKUVUSPULHYO`KYVK`UHTPJILOH]PV\YVMÅV^THRL
P[KPMÄJ\S[[VMVYLJHZ[WYVK\J[PVUHUKL]HS\H[LHZZVJPH[LKYPZR
HUK\UJLY[HPU[PLZI`HWWS`PUNL_PZ[PUNHUHS`[PJHSHWWYVHJOLZ
[OH[HYLIHZLKVUZVS\[PVUZVU[OLKPMM\ZPVULX\H[PVUHUK
HZZ\TL[OLMVSSV^PUN!
Ì ;OLYLZLY]VPYPZOVTVNLULV\ZJVUZ[HU[WVYVZP[`HUK
WLYTLHIPSP[`^P[OH\UPMVYT[OPJRULZZ
Ì -S\PKMSV^PZ\UPMVYTV]LY[OLLU[PYL[OPJRULZZVM[OLWH`
ZLJ[PVUYHKPHSVYSPULHY
Ì :PUNSLWOHZLMSV^JVUZ[HU[]PZJVZP[`VM[OLMSV^PUNWOHZL
Ì .YH]P[H[PVUHSMVYJLZHYLULNSLJ[LK
;OLTHPUPUJLU[P]LZMVY\ZPUNHU\TLYPJHSYLZLY]VPY
ZPT\SH[VYHYL[OLHIPSP[`[VTVKLSOPNOOL[LYVNLULP[`YLZLY]VPYZ
[OLT\S[PWOHZLÅV^VMJVTWSL_Å\PKZKPMMLYLU[KYP]PUNMVYJLZ
HUKPU[LYMLYLUJLIL[^LLUWYVK\J[PVUHUKPUQLJ[PVU^LSSZ
;OLHIPSP[`[VOHUKSLJVTWSL_NLVSVNPJHSTVKLSZHUKTVZ[
Figure 1. A horizontal well with hydraulic fractured stages (multi-stage WHY[PJ\SHYS`[VMVYLJHZ[WYVK\J[PVUI`JVUZPKLYPUNKPMMLYLU[
fracturing).** ZJLUHYPVZVMKL]LSVWTLU[HUK[O\ZTHRLIL[[LYI\ZPULZZ
KLJPZPVUZHOLHKVM[PTLPZ[OLTHPUVIQLJ[P]LHUKHK]HU[HNL
VMU\TLYPJHSZPT\SH[PVUZ]LYZ\ZHUHS`[PJHSHWWYVHJOLZ
+\L[VZPNUPÄJHU[JOHUNLZPUZOHSLHUK[PNO[NHZ^LSS
WYVK\J[P]P[`HUKYLZLY]VPYWLYMVYTHUJLPU[OLZHTLSVJHSPZLKHYLHZ
PUHZLLTPUNS`YHUKVTTHUULY[OLKLJPZPVU^HZTHKL[V\ZL
[OL6WLU-SV^:\P[L;4WSH[MVYT^OPJOPZKLZPNULK[VPU[LNYH[L
H]HPSHISLÄLSKKH[HWLYMVYTYLZLY]VPYJOHYHJ[LYPZH[PVUTVKLSSPUNHUK
U\TLYPJHSZPT\SH[PVUHUK[VZWLLK\W[OLKLJPZPVUTHRPUNWYVJLZZ
;OPZZVM[^HYLHSZVLUHISLZ[OLHJJ\YH[LWYLKPJ[PVUVMPUZP[\YLZLY]LZ
HUKZPT\SH[LZWYVK\J[PVUWYVÄSLZ*VUZPZ[PUNVMHJVTWSL[LZ\P[LVM
WS\NPUTVK\SLZ[OLWVY[MVSPVVM[OPZZVM[^HYLLUOHUJLZIV[OZ`ULYN`
HUKJVTT\UPJH[PVUIL[^LLUÅL_PISL^VYRÅV^ZHUKHSZVOVUV\YZ
[OLOPNOX\HSP[`YLX\PYLTLU[ZVM[OLPUK\Z[Y`HUK9
+(M\Y[OLY
Figure 2. A quarter section of a fractured stage: SRV is represented
WHY[VM[OPZZVM[^HYL7\TH-SV^;49LZLY]VPY:PT\SH[VYPZIHZLK
by a simplified discrete fracture network with spatially variable
permeability, unSRV (red). VUYPNVYV\ZWO`ZPJHSMVYT\SH[PVUZHUKWYV]PKLZOPNOWLYMVYTHUJL
JVTW\[PUN\ZLYVYPLU[LKPU[LYMHJLHUK^VYRLU]PYVUTLU[;OL
HZZVJPH[LKMYHJ[\YLTVKLSSPUNZVM[^HYL-YHJH-SV^;4HZZPZ[LKOPZ[VY`
TH[JOPUNHUK\UJLY[HPU[`THUHNLTLU[^OPSZ[*V\NHY-SV^;4HSSV^LK
[OLYLZLY]VPYLUNPULLY[VTHRLYLSPHISLWYVK\J[PVUMVYLJHZ[ZMVYOPNOS`
OL[LYVNLULV\ZYLZLY]VPYZHUK[VIL[[LY\UKLYZ[HUK[OLPTWHJ[VM
KPMMLYLU[WHYHTL[LYZHUKHZZVJPH[LK\UJLY[HPU[PLZ
:VTLWVPU[ZJVUJLYUPUNÅV^TLJOHUPZTZHUK[YHUZWVY[
PUOLYLU[PU[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZYLZLY]VPYZJV\SKILOPNOSPNO[LKHZ
MVSSV^Z!
Ì ;PNO[NHZVJJ\YZPUZHUKZHUKJHYIVUH[LZZOHSLNHZVJJ\YZ
PUVYNHUPJYPJOMVYTH[PVUZHUKZV\YJLYVJRHZ^LSSHZ
YLZLY]VPYZ;OYLL[`WLZVMNHZZ[VYLKPUZOHSLMVYTH[PVUZJHUIL
KPZ[PUN\PZOLK!ºMYLLNHZ»PUUH[\YHSMYHJ[\YLZHUKWVYLZºHKZVYILK
NHZ»HUKºNHZKPZZVS]LKPURLYVNLUHUKIP[\TLU»;OLHTV\U[
VMHKZVYILKNHZPUZOHSLZ]HYPLZMYVT)HYUL[[:OHSL
<:([VHTH_PT\TVMVMVYPNPUHSNHZPUWSHJL6.07
3L^PZ:OHSL<:(;OLJVU[YPI\[PVUVM[OLHKZVYILKNHZ[V
WYVK\J[PVUJHUOH]LHZPNUPMPJHU[PTWHJ[K\YPUN[OLSHZ[WOHZL
VMMPLSKL_WSVP[H[PVU^OLU[OLYLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLPZSLZZ[OHU[OL
JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJHKZVYW[PVUWYLZZ\YL;OLHIPSP[`[VWYVK\JL[OL
HIZVYILKNHZPZSPTP[LKILJH\ZLVM[OL\S[YH[PNO[TH[YP_YVJR
YLSH[P]LS`OPNOIV[[VTOVSLWYLZZ\YL)/7HUK[OLKLZVYW[PVU
WYVMPSL^OPJOYLX\PYLZ]LY`SV^YLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLZ[VSPILYH[L[OL
HKZVYILKNHZ+\L[VKPMMLYLU[HKZVYW[PVUWYVWLY[PLZVMUH[\YHS
NHZJVTWVULU[Z[OLJVTWVZP[PVUVMNHZWYVK\JLKJHU]HY`
Figure 3. Quarter sector model of a fractured stage. Vertical scale ZPNUPMPJHU[S`K\YPUN[OLKLZVYW[PVUWOHZLVMNHZWYVK\J[PVU
reduced by two. Variable SRV represented by a simplified fracture .LULYHSS`MPLSKPZV[VWPJKH[HZOV^[OH[[OLYLSH[P]LJVTWVZP[PVUHS
network (f-SRV) and matrix medium (m-SRV), unSRV contains only KLJSPULVMOLH]PLYTVSLJ\SHYZWLJPLZVM[OLNHZPZNYLH[LY[OHU
matrix medium (m-unSRV). [OH[VMSPNO[LYVULZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Ì -S\PKMSV^YLNPTLZJHUILKPMMLYLU[PH[LKI`[OL2U\KZLUU\TILY HUL[^VYRVMMYHJ[\YLZTH[YP_ISVJRZZ[PT\SH[LKHUK\UZ[PT\SH[LK
HUVUKPTLUZPVUHSWHYHTL[LYKLMPULKHZ[OLYH[PVVM[OLTLHU KVTHPUZ^OPJOOH]LZPNUPÄJHU[PTWHJ[PU[LYTZVMYLZLY]VPY
MYLLWH[OVMNHZTVSLJ\SLZ[V[OLJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZPaLVMWVYV\Z
WLYMVYTHUJLHUKYLJV]LY`(ZZ[H[LKHIV]LP[OHZILLUHZZ\TLK
TLKP\T;OLMVSSV^PUNYLNPTLZJHUILKPZ[PUN\PZOLK!JVU[PU\\T
[OH[[OLWOLUVTLUVUVMZSPWOHZHZLJVUKVYKLYLMMLJ[H[OPNO
MS\PKMSV^¶ZSPW¶[YHUZP[PVU¶
MYLLTVSLJ\SHY%,]LUPM[OLJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZPaLVMWVYLZPZ YLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLHUK[OL+HYJ`ÅV^HZZ\TW[PVUOHZILLUHWWSPLK
YLSH[P]LS`]LY`ZTHSS!LNMYVT[VUT)HYUL[[:OHSL[OL
YLNPTLVMNHZMSV^JHUILJVUZPKLYLKHZHJVU[PU\\TMS\PKMSV^
5L]LY[OLSLZZ[OLWOLUVTLUVUVMZSPWJHUUV[ILULNSLJ[LK
PUZWLJPMPJYLZLY]VPYJVUKP[PVUZ0MSHIVYH[VY`TLHZ\YLTLU[Z
VMWLYTLHIPSP[`HYLWLYMVYTLK\UKLYYLZLY]VPYJVUKP[PVUZ[OL
2SPURLUILYNLMMLJ[^PSSILVMZLJVUKVYKLY
Ì ;OLJVUZPKLYH[PVUVMUVU+HYJ`MSV^PUJYLHZLZ[OLJVTWSL_P[`
VMHTVKLS[OH[HSYLHK`OHZOPNO\UJLY[HPU[PLZL]LUMVY[OL Ì 7¶7YLZZ\YL
RL`WHYHTL[LYZZ\JOHZTH[YP_HUKMYHJ[\YLWVYVZP[PLZHUK Ì P¶(_PZPUKL_
WLYTLHIPSP[PLZZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TL:9=L[J;OL+HYJ`
MSV^HZZ\TW[PVUJHUILHWWSPLKHZ[OLMPYZ[HWWYVHJO
Ì _P¶*VVYKPUH[LZ___MVY_`a
Ì RP¶+PYLJ[PVUHSWLYTLHIPSP[`
/`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNKLZPNUHPTLKH[[OLJYLH[PVUVMLMMLJ[P]L Ì ȝ¶-S\PK]PZJVZP[`
MYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRZPZH^PKLS`\ZLK[LJOUPX\LMVYPU[LUZP]LZ[PT\SH[PVU Ì ȡ¶-S\PKKLUZP[`
VMVPSHUKNHZ^LSSZLZWLJPHSS`PUJHZLZVML_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[` Ì N¶.YH]P[`
MVYTH[PVUZWHY[PJ\SHYS`[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZYLZLY]VPYZ-PN\YL0[ Ì a¶,SL]H[PVU
PUJS\KLZ\W[VZ[HNLZVMMYHJ[\YPUNHUK[OL:9=[`WPJHSS`]HY` Ì ij¶7VYVZP[`
MYVT_7 ¶_7M[^LSS\W[V_M[^LSS
Ì J[¶;V[HSYVJRHUKMS\PKJVTWYLZZPIPSP[`
;OLUL[^VYRVMWYVWWLKO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLZWYV]PKLZ[OLJY\JPHSÅV^
WH[OZMYVT[OLZOHSLTH[YP_[V[OLOVYPaVU[HS^LSSIVYL)LZPKLZ[OL
Ì X¶:PUR[LYT
O`KYH\SPJHSS`PUK\JLKMYHJ[\YLZUH[\YHSS`VJJ\YYPUNMYHJ[\YLZHUK ;OLZLSLJ[PVUVMZPT\SH[PVU[PTLZ[LWZYLX\PYLZJHYLM\S
ÄZZ\YLZJVU[YPI\[L[VYLZLY]VPYÅV^HZHKKP[PVUHSTPJYVÅV^WH[OZHUK JVUZPKLYH[PVUVMKPMMLYLU[SPTP[H[PVUZK\L[V[OLHZZ\TW[PVUZ
PUJYLHZLTH[YP_MYHJ[\YLL_JOHUNL THKLHUKU\TLYPJHSTL[OVKZ\ZLK(ZYLMLYLUJLK[OLMVSSV^PUN
SPTP[H[PVUZZOV\SKILJVUZPKLYLKPUYLZLY]VPYÅV^ZPT\SH[PVU!Z[HIPSP[`
Adjustment of gridblock size and simulation time JVU[YVSVMVZJPSSH[PVUZJHSJ\SH[PVUVMYLSH[P]LWLYTLHIPSP[`HUK
step JHWPSSHY`WYLZZ\YLJVU[YVSVMV]LYZOVV[[OH[VJJ\YZTVZ[MYLX\LU[S`
(ZOHZILLUWYL]PV\ZS`Z\TTHYPZLKKPMMLYLU[H\[OVYZOH]L ^P[O[OLNHZWOHZLHUKJVU[YVSVM[Y\UJH[PVULYYVYSPTP[H[PVU
HK]VJH[LK[OLIYLHR\WVM[OLO`WV[OLZPZVM[OLJVU[PU\V\Z VMTH_PT\TWYLZZ\YLHUKZH[\YH[PVUJOHUNLZK\L[VKPZJYL[L
YLZLY]VPY![OLKYHPUHNLHYLHHUK[OLH]HPSHIPSP[`VMYLZLY]LZPU HWWYV_PTH[PVUZ
\UJVU]LU[PVUHSYLZLY]VPYZ^P[OL_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`HYLIHZLK ;OLTH_PT\TNYPKISVJRZPaL[VIL\ZLKPZHSZVSPTP[LKI`
VUHZPUNSL^LSSVYL]LUHZPUNSLMYHJ[\YLKZ[HNLJVUZPKLYH[PVU6UL ºWZL\KVZ[LHK`»Z[H[LHZZ\TW[PVUZ"^LSSISVJRZ[VYHNLLMMLJ[ZJHUIL
VM[OLTVZ[KPMÄJ\S[WHYHTL[LYZ[VL]HS\H[LPU[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZ LYHZLKJVUZPKLYPUNHÄULYLZLY]VPYNYPK+LJYLHZPUN[OLTLZOZPaL
YLZLY]VPYZPZ[OLZPaLHUKZOHWLVM[OLKYHPUHNLHYLH4VU[OZVY SLHKZ[VIL[[LYJHW[\YLLHYS`[PTLWOLUVTLUHZ\JOHZ^LSSISVJR
L]LU`LHYZVMWYVK\J[PVUHYLYLX\PYLKMVYJVU]LU[PVUHS^LSS[LZ[Z Z[VYHNLHUKWYVWHNH[PVUVMWYLZZ\YLWLY[\YIH[PVU0UMHJ[K\L[V]LY`
(ZHYLZ\S[VMPUJYLHZPUNOHYK^HYLLMÄJPLUJ`HUKHK]HUJLTLU[ZPU SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`[OLTH_PT\TNYPKISVJRZPaLPZSPTP[LKI`[YHUZPLU[
U\TLYPJHSTL[OVKZYLZLY]VPYZPT\SH[PVUPZTV]PUN[V^HYKZÄULYNYPK ÅV^HWWLHYHUJLHUK^LSSISVJRZ[VYHNLLMMLJ[Z(ZOHZILLU
TVKLSZVMYLZLY]VPYHUKILJVTPUNHUPUKPZWLUZHISL[VVS/V^L]LY TLU[PVULKILMVYL^OLU;K%[OLKLYP]H[P]LPZÅH[HZL_WLJ[LK
KLZWP[L[OLYLJLU[KL]LSVWTLU[ZPUJVTW\[H[PVUHSZWLLK[LJOUPX\LZ I`[OLHUHS`[PJHSZVS\[PVUVM[OLÅ\PKÅV^LX\H[PVU;OPZ[PTL^HZ
P[PZUV[MLHZPISL[VZPT\SH[LYLZLY]VPYÅV^ILOH]PV\Y^P[OHU\S[YHÄUL KL[LYTPULKHZ[OLVULMYVT^OPJO[OLHWWHYLU[^LSSISVJRZ[VYHNL
NLVSVNPJHSºZ[H[PZ[PJHSS`HUKWO`ZPJHSS`YLHSPZ[PJ»ZJHSL(ZLJ[VYTVKLS LMMLJ[LUKZP[SLHKZ[V[OLMVSSV^PUNPULX\HSP[`!
ZJOLTL^P[OL_WSPJP[MYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRPZ[OLYLMVYLYLX\PYLKPUJHZLZ
VML_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`;OLJVTWSL_P[`VM[OLWO`ZPJZHUK
[OLTHNUP[\KLVMNV]LYUPUNWHYHTL[LYZHUKYLSH[LK\UJLY[HPU[PLZPU
MYHJ[\YLKYLZLY]VPYZJHUHSZVILPU[YVK\JLK^P[OºJSHZZPJHS»TL[OVKZ!
ºK\HSWVYVZP[`¶ZPUNSLWLYTLHIPSP[`»HUKºK\HSWVYVZP[`¶K\HS
WLYTLHIPSP[`»RUV^UHZºĭ2»HUKºĭ2»YLZWLJ[P]LS`^OPJO Ì [¶[PTL
HSSV^ÅV^ZPT\SH[PVUZ[VZWLLK\W^OPSZ[WYV]PKPUNZH[PZMHJ[VY` Ì ¬3¶JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJNYPKISVJRZPaL
YLZ\S[Z ;OLTH_PT\TZPaLVMHNYPKISVJRZOV\SKILHKQ\Z[LKHML^MLL[
+\L[V[OLSVUN[YHUZP[PVUWLYPVKPUSV^HUKL_[YLTLS`SV^ ^P[OZPT\SH[PVU[PTLZ[LWHJJVYKPUN[V[OLPULX\HSP[`Z[H[LKHIV]L
WLYTLHIPSP[`YLZLY]VPYZHWWSPJHIPSP[`VM[OLºWZL\KVZ[LHK`Z[H[L» PUVYKLY[VH]VPKHWWHYLU[^LSSISVJRZ[VYHNLLMMLJ[ZWHY[PJ\SHYS`PU
HZZ\TW[PVUPZX\LZ[PVUHISLWHY[PJ\SHYS`MVY[OLPUP[PHSYLZLY]VPY [OLJHZLVMSV^HUKL_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`
ZPT\SH[PVUHZSVUNHZ[OLWYLZZ\YLWLY[\YIH[PVUOHZUV[YLHJOLK
ZL]LYHSNYPKISVJRZPU[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OL^LSS:L]LYHSHWWYVHJOLZ A study on the simulation of flow in an extremely
^LYLHKHW[LK[VPTWYV]L[OLY\U[PTLVMYLZLY]VPYÅV^ZPT\SH[PVU low permeability reservoir
I\[[OLZLSHJR[OLHIPSP[`[VTVKLS[YHUZPLU[ILOH]PV\Y6ULVM[OL 0U[OLZ[\K`WYLZLU[LKILSV^[OLYLZLY]VPYWYVWLY[PLZOH]LILLU
TVZ[YPNVYV\ZTL[OVKZMVYTVKLSSPUNZ\JOYLZLY]VPYZ^P[OPUK\JLK ZLSLJ[LKHJJVYKPUN[VYLMLYLUJLÄLSKKH[H^P[OOPNOZWH[PHSHUK
O`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLZPZ[V\ZLHSVNHYP[OTPJHSS`YLÄULKNYPKPUJS\KPUN [LTWVYHS]HYPHIPSP[`HUK\UJLY[HPU[PLZ+L[LYTPUPZ[PJHWWYVHJOLZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
With more than 50 facilities on six continents,
TDW is there from planning to project management
(and every step in between).
We are partners.
At TDW, we work with our customers to be operationally
ready for the unexpected. Our emergency pipeline
repair programs combine planning, preparation and
project management with industry-leading products and
services to assist our business partners in preparing
for and responding to pipeline emergencies.
www.tdwilliamson.com
Asia/Pacific: 65-6364-8520
©
® Registered trademark of T.D. Williamson, Inc. in the United States and other countries. ™ Trademark of T.D. Williamson, Inc. in the United States and other counrtries. Copyright 2013 All right reserved. T.D. Williamson, Inc.
[OLYLMVYLOH]LUV[ILLU\ZLK-P]LRL`YLZLY]VPYWHYHTL[LYZHYL NLVTL[Y`VMMYHJ[\YLKISVJRZVMM[_M[_M[MYHJ[\YLHUK
[OV\NO[[VHMMLJ[NHZYLJV]LY`![OLWVYVZP[`HUKWLYTLHIPSP[`VM TH[YP_WLYTLHIPSP[PLZHUK2Y7JWYVWLY[PLZOH]LILLUYL[HPULKMYVT
IV[OTH[YP_HUKMYHJ[\YLTLKPHHZ^LSSHZ:9=;OLW\YWVZLVM[OPZ [OLYLMLYLUJLTVKLSWYL]PV\ZS`KLZJYPILK;OLPUZP[\]VS\TLZVM
YLZLY]VPYZPT\SH[PVUZ[\K`^HZ[VWYV]PKLHYLWYLZLU[H[P]LYLZLY]VPY Å\PKZOH]LILLUHKQ\Z[LK]PHºMYHJ[\YL»HUKºTH[YP_»WVYVZP[PLZ^OPJO
TVKLSJHWHISLVMJHW[\YPUNKPMMLYLU[WOLUVTLUHPUOLYLU[PUL_[YLTLS` YLMLYPU[OLZLJHZLZ[V[OL^OVSLMYHJ[\YLKZLJ[VYUV[[VHKPZJYL[L
SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`YLZLY]VPYZZ\JOHZ[PNO[HUKZOHSLNHZHUKVI[HPU MYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRHUKTH[YP_TLKP\THZPU[OLYLMLYLUJLJHZL;OL
WSH\ZPISLHUKYLSPHISLWYVK\J[PVUWYVÄSLZ MVYTH[PVUWHYHTL[LYZ^LYLPUP[PHSPZLKHZILMVYL!YLMLYLUJLKLW[O
(YLZLY]VPYTVKLSIHZLKVUÄLSKKH[HOHZILLUJVUZPKLYLKHZH M[TWYLZZ\YLWZPIHYHUK[LTWLYH[\YL
TL[OVKVML]HS\H[PUN[OLPTWHJ[VMO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUN:9=TH[YP_ á-á*
HUKWYVWWLKMYHJ[\YLWLYTLHIPSP[`^OPJO^LYLZWH[PHSS`]HYPLKHZVUL (ZZ\TPUNZ`TTL[Y`VM[OLKYHPUHNLHYLHHUKUVPU[LYMLYLUJL
VM[OLTVZ[YLHSPZ[PJHWWYVHJOLZHUK[OLIV[[VTOVSLWYLZZ\YLHZ IL[^LLUNHZ^LSSZHUKMYHJ[\YLKZ[HNLZPU[OLJHZLVMHUL_[YLTLS`
H[LJOUVSVNPJHSWHYHTL[LYVML_WSVP[H[PVU+\L[V[OLSVUN[YHUZPLU[ SV^WLYTLHIPSP[`YLZLY]VPYHX\HY[LYZLJ[PVUVMHMYHJ[\YLKZ[HNLOHZ
WLYPVKZPT\SH[PVUVMZ\JONHZYLZLY]VPYZYLX\PYLZJHYLM\SJVUZPKLYH[PVU ILLUJVUZPKLYLK0[HSSV^LK[OLNYPK[VILSVNHYP[OTPJHSS`YLÄULKHUK
VM[OLZPT\SH[PVU[PTLZ[LWHUKNYPKISVJRZPaL!HUHKQ\Z[TLU[PZ [VL_WSPJP[S`YLWYLZLU[HO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLUL[^VYR^OPJOPZ[OLTHQVY
YLX\PYLKWZL\KVZ[LHK`Z[H[LHZZ\TW[PVU(X\HY[LYZLJ[PVUVMH JVU[YPI\[VYPU[LYTZVMÅV^(YLÄULKX\HY[LYZLJ[PVUPZWLUL[YH[LK
MYHJ[\YLKZ[HNLM[_ M[_M[OHZILLUKPZJYL[PZLKHUK[OL I`HPUOVYPaVU[HS^LSS[OLMVSSV^PUN:9=Z[HNL]VS\TLZOH]LILLU
NYPKOHZILLUSVNHYP[OTPJHSS`YLÄULKNYPKISVJRZ[OLMYHJ[\YL JVUZPKLYLK-PN\YL!
UL[^VYR^HZYLWYLZLU[LKI`ÄULNYPKISVJRZ[OPZHSSV^Z[OL[OYLL Ì M[_M[_M[_$_M[
THPUYLNPVUZ[VILYLNPVUHSPZLKHUK[O\ZKPZ[PUN\PZOLK!º»¶TH[YP_ Ì M[_M[_M[_$_M[
TLKP\TVM\UZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TLT\U:9=º»¶TH[YP_ Ì M[_M[_M[_$_M[
TLKP\TVMZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TLT:9=HUKº»¶MYHJ[\YL
TLKP\TVMZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TLM:9=-PN\YL;OPZHSSV^Z <ZPUNÄLSKYLMLYLUJLZHUKHUHS`[PJHSKH[H-PN\YL;HISL
MYHJ[\YLHUKTH[YP_TLKPH[VILYLWYLZLU[LKPUKLWLUKLU[S`HUK[V NLVTVKLSSPUNZVM[^HYLHUK[OL7\TH-SV^YLZLY]VPYZPT\SH[VYH
ºWVW\SH[L»[OLNYPK^P[OZWH[PHSS`]HYPLKWYVWLY[PLZ!YVJR[`WLWVYVZP[` ZLUZP[P]P[`Z[\K`VM[OLKPTLUZPVUVM:9=TH[YP_HUKWYVWWLKMYHJ[\YL
WLYTLHIPSP[`YLSH[P]LWLYTLHIPSP[`JHWPSSHY`WYLZZ\YLJ\Y]LZ2Y7J WLYTLHIPSP[`^OPJOHYLZWH[PHSS`]HYPLK-PN\YLHUKVM[OLIV[[VTOVSL
HUKLUKWVPU[ZJVTWYLZZPIPSP[`WOHZLZH[\YH[PVU7=;KH[HL[J WYLZZ\YLHZH[LJOUVSVNPJHSWHYHTL[LYVML_WSVP[H[PVU^HZWLYMVYTLK
;OPZHWWYVHJOLUHISLZPU[LNYH[PVUVMKPMMLYLU[KH[HLNWVYVZP[`HUK (ZZ\TPUNHWZL\KVZ[LHK`Z[H[LÅV^[OLZPT\SH[PVU[PTLZ[LWHUK[OL
WLYTLHIPSP[`KPZ[YPI\[PVUPU[OLMYHJ[\YLZHJJVYKPUN[VTPJYVZLPZTPJ NYPKISVJRZPaL^LYLHKQ\Z[LK(ZVIZLY]LKPU[OLÄLSKHUKSHIVYH[VY`
PTHNPUNZH[\YH[PVUVMÅ\PKZL[JHUK[V[YLH[[OLTHZOPZ[VY` WYHJ[PJL[OLMYHJ[\YLHWLY[\YLHUKLMMLJ[P]LWLYTLHIPSP[`KLWLUKVU[OL
TH[JOPUNWHYHTL[LYZ+\L[V[OLJVTWSL_P[`VM[OLYLMLYLUJLTVKLS KPZ[HUJLIL[^LLU[OL^LSSIVYLHUKNYPKISVJRZTVKLSSLKHUKZV[OPZ
^P[OHUL_WSPJP[MYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRHUKYLSH[P]LS`SVUN*7<ZPT\SH[PVU HWWYVHJOOHZHSZVILLUHWWSPLK-PN\YL
[PTL[^VZPTWSPÄLKLX\P]HSLU[YLZLY]VPYTVKLSZOH]LHSZVILLU ;OLZPT\SH[PVUZVMÅV^[OH[^LYLWLYMVYTLKMVYHYLMLYLUJL
Z[\KPLK]PH[OLºJSHZZPJHS»K\HSTLKP\THWWYVHJOLZ!ºK\HSWVYVZP[` X\HY[LYZLJ[VY[VZ[\K`WYLZZ\YLÄLSKPUTH[YP_HUKMYHJ[\YL
¶ZPUNSLWLYTLHIPSP[`»HUKºK\HSWVYVZP[`¶K\HSWLYTLHIPSP[`»ĭ2 TLKPH-PN\YLZHUK;OL`ZOV^LK[OH[[OLJVU[YPI\[PVUVM[OL
HUKĭ2YLZWLJ[P]LS`[VZWLLK\WÅV^ZPT\SH[PVUZ;OLZPTWSPÄLK \UZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TLPU[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OL:9=^OLYL[OLYL
HYLUVO`KYH\SPJHSS`PUK\JLKMYHJ[\YLZ[V[OLNHZWYVK\J[PVUPZ
UVUULNSPNPISL9H[OLYP[JHUILHZPNUPÄJHU[WHY[VMNHZWYVK\J[PVU
Table 1. Selected parameters for sensitivity study
HUKZOV\SKIL[HRLUPU[VHJJV\U[!\W[VKLWLUKPUNVU[OL
Parameter Variables
NLVTL[Y`HUKZOHWLVM[OL:9=[OLMYHJ[\YLHUKTH[YP_
No. Description Min Mode Max Unit WLYTLHIPSP[PLZHUKWVYVZP[PLZHUKVU[OL[LJOUVSVNPJHSWHYHTL[LYZ
1 SRV per stage 12.1 16.2 24.3 106 ft3 VM^LSSL_WSVP[H[PVUZ\JOHZ[OLÅV^YH[LHUKIV[[VTOVSLWYLZZ\YL
5VKL^H[LYPUNWLYPVKOHZILLUJVUZPKLYLK"[OLNHZÅV^YH[L
2 Matrix permeability 10 100 1000 nD
^HZJVUZ[YHPULKMVY[OLLHYS`Z[HNLZPUVYKLY[VOH]LWO`ZPJHS
Propped fracture
3 1 2 10 D HUKJVUZPZ[LU[ZPT\SH[PVUYLZ\S[Z;OLYLZLY]VPYÅV^ZPT\SH[PVUZ
permeability
^LYLWLYMVYTLK^P[O[OLHZZ\TW[PVUVMHULNSPNPISLHTV\U[VM
4 Min BHP 500 1000 1500 psi HKZVYILKNHZ^OPJOOHZUVZPNUPÄJHU[PTWHJ[K\YPUN[OLÄYZ[
WOHZLVMWYVK\J[PVUHUKWYLZZ\YLKLWSL[PVU5L]LY[OLSLZZ
T\S[PJVTWVULU[NHZKLZVYW[PVUJHUIL[HRLUPU[VHJJV\U[
I`WLYMVYTPUNHKKP[PVUHSZ[\KPLZ
;OLJVTWHYPZVUIL[^LLU[OLYLZLY]VPYZPT\SH[PVUYLZ\S[Z
MVY[OLYLMLYLUJLX\HY[LYZLJ[VYTVKLSHUK[OLºĭ2»
ºĭ2»TVKLSZ¶^P[O[OLPKLU[PJHSTH[YP_TLKP\THUK
O`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRWYVWLY[PLZPUZP[\]VS\TLVMÅ\PKZ
HUKÅ\PK7=;¶ZOV^ZV]LYLZ[PTH[PVUHUK\UKLYLZ[PTH[PVU
VMNHZWYVK\J[PVUMVY[OLJVUZPKLYLKWLYPVK!HIV\[¶
-PN\YL;OLºJSHZZPJHS»K\HSTLKP\THWWYVHJOHWWLHYZ
[VWYV]PKLZH[PZMHJ[VY`YLZ\S[Z^P[OHZPNUPÄJHU[NHPUPU
JVTW\[H[PVU[PTLTPU]LYZ\ZTPUPU[LYTZVM*7<
WYVJLZZPUN[PTL;OPZLUHISLZKLJPZPVUTHRPUN[VILZWLK
Figure 4. Relative permeability curves: fracture medium (left), matrix medium (right), \WHUKWYV]PKLZYLHZVUHISLHWWYV_PTH[PVUZHUKMVYLJHZ[Z
two different rock-types, analytical formulae and empirical data used. MVYZJLUHYPVHUK\UJLY[HPU[`HUHS`ZLZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Tilted Orthorhombic RTM
Solving subsalt challenges
TTI RTM TOR RTM
TTI RTM is a widely used technology, but it struggles to The velocity model produced by TOR tomography, with
reconcile azimuthal velocity variations in the presence more accurate descriptions of overburden velocities, is
of fractured, tilted overburdens. then utilized by TOR RTM to provide significant subsalt
imaging improvements.
Hence CGG has developed a suite of Tilted
Orthorhombic (TOR) algorithms. TOR tomography
resolves inconsistent residual moveout among azimuths,
caused by uneven stress and fractures within the
overburden.
cgg.com/SI
Conclusions Ì 0U[LNYH[PVUVMZWH[PHSS`KPZ[YPI\[LKMYHJ[\YLZHUKVM[OLPY
Ì ;OLWYVWLY[PLZVMTH[YP_HUKMYHJ[\YLTLKPHNLVTL[Y` WYVWLY[PLZWHY[PJ\SHYS`WVYVZP[`HUKWLYTLHIPSP[`ZLLTZ[VIL
VULVM[OLTVZ[YLHSPZ[PJHWWYVHJOLZLNMYHJ[\YLWLYTLHIPSP[`
PU[LYJVUULJ[LKULZZWVYVZP[`WLYTLHIPSP[`OH]LHZPNUPMPJHU[
PTWHJ[VUWYVK\JPIPSP[`!^OLU[OLMSV^JHWHJP[`VMHMYHJ[\YL JHUILZWH[PHSS`]HYPHISLKLWLUKPUNVU[OLKPZ[HUJLIL[^LLU
UL[^VYRPZYLHJOLKHKKP[PVUHSWYVK\J[PVUMYVT[OL\U:9=PU [OL^LSSIVYLHUK[OLNYPKISVJRZ[VTVKLS0UJVTWHYPZVU^P[O
[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OL:9=K\L[VWYLZZ\YLKLJSPULHUKL_JOHUNL WYL]PV\ZZ[\KPLZP[OHZILLUZ[H[LK[OH[[OLWYVWVZLKHWWYVHJO
Z\YMHJLJHUWYLZLU[HUVUULNSPNPISLHTV\U[VMNHZ[VIL[HRLU VMTVKLSSPUNJHUIL\ZLKPUJHZLZ^OLYL[OLK\HSTLKP\T
PU[VHJJV\U[4H[YP_WYVWLY[PLZWSH`HRL`YVSLPUYLJV]LY` HWWYVHJOPZX\LZ[PVUHISLVYPUHWWYVWYPH[L
-YHJ[\YLUL[^VYRZLUOHUJLMSV^JHWHJP[` Ì ;OLJVTWHYPZVUIL[^LLU[OLYLMLYLUJLZLJ[VYTVKLSHUKĭ2
Ì ;OLYLMLYLUJLZLJ[VYTVKLSYLWYLZLU[LKI`HSVNHYP[OTPJHSS` HUKĭ2TVKLSZ¶^P[O[OLPKLU[PJHSTH[YP_TLKP\THUK
O`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLUL[^VYRWYVWLY[PLZZPaLVMMYHJ[\YLISVJRZ
YLMPULKNYPK^P[OHZPTWSPMPLKUL[^VYRVMKPZJYL[LMYHJ[\YLZ
OHZHSSV^LKMVYHIL[[LY\UKLYZ[HUKPUNVMMSV^ILOH]PV\YHUK WLYTLHIPSP[PLZL[JPUZP[\]VS\TLVMMS\PKZHUK7=;¶ZOV^Z
[OLWYVK\J[PVUTLJOHUPZTPUHUL_[YLTLS`SV^WLYTLHIPSP[` V]LYLZ[PTH[PVUHUK\UKLYLZ[PTH[PVUVMNHZWYVK\J[PVUMVY[OL
YLZLY]VPY JVUZPKLYLKWLYPVK!IL[^LLUHUK;OLZLTVKLSZWYV]PKL
ZH[PZMHJ[VY`YLZ\S[Z^P[OHZPNUPMPJHU[NHPUPUJVTW\[H[PVU[PTL
TPU]LYZ\ZTPUPU[LYTZVM*7<WYVJLZZPUN[PTL
Disclaimer
;OL]PL^ZL_WYLZZLKPU[OPZHY[PJSLHYL[OVZLVM[OLH\[OVYZ
HUKKVUV[ULJLZZHYPS`YLWYLZLU[[OVZLVM)LPJPW-YHUSHIHUK
0-7,ULYNPLZ5V\]LSSLZ
References
5L^3LUZ:JLUHYPVZ(:OPM[PU7LYZWLJ[P]LMVYH>VYSKPU;YHUZP[PVU
9V`HS+\[JO:OLSS4HYJO
+HYPZOJOL](3LTV\a`79V\]YV`76U:PT\SH[PVUVM-SV^PU
;PNO[HUK:OHSL.HZ9LZLY]VPYZ7HWLY:7, WYLZLU[LKH[[OL:7,
4PKKSL,HZ[<UJVU]LU[PVUHS.HZ*VUMLYLUJLHUK,_OPIP[PVU4\ZJH[
6THU¶1HU
4H`LYOVMLY41L[HS0U[LNYH[PVUVM4PJYVZLPZTPJ-YHJ[\YL
4HWWPUN9LZ\S[Z>P[O5\TLYPJHS-YHJ[\YL5L[^VYR7YVK\J[PVU4VKLSPUN
PU)HYUL[[:OHSL7HWLY:7,WYLZLU[LKH[[OL:7,(UU\HS
;LJOUPJHS*VUMLYLUJLHUK,_OPIP[PVU:HU(U[VUPV;L_HZ<:(¶
:LW[
)SHUJ.L[HS ;YHUZPLU[7YVK\J[P]P[`0UKL_MVY5\TLYPJHS>LSS;LZ[
:PT\SH[PVUZ7\ISPJ+VJ\TLU[0UZ[P[\[-YHUsHPZK\7t[YVSL7H\-YHUJL
;VKK496»+LSS74/PYHZHRP.1 4L[OVKZMVY0UJYLHZLK
(JJ\YHJ`PU5\TLYPJHS9LZLY]VPY:PT\SH[VYZ:7,;YHUZHJ[PVUZ1V\YUHS
7HWLY:7,
Notes
5V^H[0-7,ULYNPLZ5V\]LSSLZ
:V\YJL!^^^H[LYYHL_WSVYH[PVUJVT
Figure 6. Cumulative gas production and BHP: reference model ([SLHZ[ VMZOHSLNHZ^LSSZOH]L:9=VM_M[^LSSHUK
(green curve) versus 2ĭ-1K model (blue curve), 2ĭ-2K (brown curve). V]LY
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
I
[PZVM[LUZHPKOHSMPUQLZ[[OH[[OLWL[YVSL\T
PUK\Z[Y`PZHJ[\HSS`H^H[LYPUK\Z[Y`^P[OVPSHZH
I`WYVK\J[>LSSZWYVK\JLMHYTVYL^H[LY[OHU
JY\KL"PU5VY[O(TLYPJH[OLH]LYHNLUV^L_JLLKZ
IISZVM^H[LYMVYLHJOIHYYLSVMVPSVYHWWYV_PTH[LS`
TPSSPVUIWKPU[OL<:HSVUL>H[LYPZHSZVULLKLK
[VJYLH[LHUKZ[PT\SH[L^LSSZ;OL0U[LYUH[PVUHS,ULYN`
(NLUJ`0,(YLJLU[S`LZ[PTH[LK[OH[[OLHTV\U[
VM^H[LYJVUZ\TLKHUU\HSS`I`6
.L_WSVYH[PVUPZ
HYV\UKIPSSPVUTVY[OLHTV\U[\ZLKI`[OLLU[PYL
WVW\SH[PVUVM[OL<:PUKH`Z(UKZPNUPÄJHU[S`[OL
0,(L_WLJ[Z[OH[]VS\TL[VKV\ISLPU[OLUL_[`LHYZ
MVYP[[VÅV^[VZ\YMHJLIISZVM^H[LYHYL\ZLK[VJVH_
Water management in Western Colorado LHJOIHYYLSVMVPS;OL*HUHKPHU,ULYN`9LZLHYJO0UZ[P[\[L
Western Colorado is one of the most scenic places on *,90YLJLU[S`WYVQLJ[LK[OH[IP[\TLUWYVK\J[PVUMYVTTPUPUN
Earth, home to the breathtaking Rocky Mountain range, HUKPUZP[\WYVQLJ[Z^PSSPUJYLHZL[VTPSSPVUIWKI`HUK
Colorado National Monument and Dinosaur National TPSSPVUIWKI`/LH]`VPSHUKIP[\TLUWYVK\J[PVUPZ
Monument. But the area is also extremely parched, and HSZVL_WHUKPUNYHWPKS`PU=LULa\LSHHUK*OPUHOVWLZ[VHWWS`
the modern stimulation techniques needed to produce [OLYTHS[LJOUVSVNPLZ[VP[ZPTTLUZLKLWVZP[Z^P[OPU[OLKLJHKL
the prolific shale gas reservoirs that lie beneath western /`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNPZHSZVYHWPKS`NYV^PUNPU\ZHNL-PYZ[
Colorado require a lot of water. A single hydraulic KL]LSVWLKHKLJHKLHNV[VYLSLHZL[YHWWLKNHZMYVT[OL;L_HZ
fracture, or frac, can use over 1 million gal. of water, and )HYUL[[ZOHSL[OL[LJOUVSVN`YLSPLZVUMVYJPUN^H[LY\UKLY
each well can contain up to 10 frac stages. Competition OPNOWYLZZ\YLPU[V[OLSV^WLYTLHIPSP[`YVJRPUVYKLY[VMYHJ[\YL
is already fierce for water rights from the nearby P[Z\MÄJPLU[S`MVYNHZ[VÅV^PUJVTTLYJPHSX\HU[P[PLZ¸(MYHJ
Colorado River; public opinion can be critical. JHU\ZLTPSSPVUNHSPUHZPUNSLZ[HNL"Z[HNLZWLY^LSS\ZLZ
WPX Energy operates more than 4000 natural H[V[HSVMTPSSPVUNHS¹ZH`Z+H]PK)\YUL[[H7YVMLZZVYVM
gas wells in western Colorado with an average of 7L[YVSL\T,UNPULLYPUNH[;L_HZ(
4<UP]LYZP[`HUK+PYLJ[VYVM
712 million ft3/d production. ;LJOUVSVN`MVY[OL.SVIHS7L[YVSL\T9LZV\YJLZ0UZ[P[\[L.790
Several years earlier, the company was facing ¸6ULTPSSPVUNHSPZ[OLLX\P]HSLU[VMHJYLMLL[^OPJOPZ^OH[
opposition. “Back in 2008, we were drilling in residential HMHTPS`MHYT\ZLZPUH`LHY0M`V\OH]L^LSSZPUHJV\U[`P[
areas and there was a lot of truck traffic, and it upset THRLZHKPMMLYLUJL¹
the local residents,” says Tyler Bittner, WPX Energy.
The company decided to optimise its completion Problems
strategy through the centralisation of the fracturing ;OLYLPZNYV^PUNWYLZZ\YL[VTHUHNL^H[LY\ZHNL0UYLNPVUZ
crew. For example, on the Hays Gulch project, 97 new ^OLYLO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNPZJVTTVU^H[LYZJHYJP[`PZH
wells were drilled from 14 pads in one central location. THQVYJVUJLYU¸0U;L_HZPM`V\V^U[OLSHUK`V\V^U[OL
495 frac stages were then conducted from that central YPNO[[VJHW[\YL^OH[»Z\UKLYP[ZV`V\JHUZLSSHZT\JOHZ
location. This resulted in a significant reduction in moves `V\W\TWV\[¹ZH`Z)\YUL[[¸)\[[OPZJHUSLHK[VZLYPV\Z
and saved 12 000 water trips. There was also a 95% KYH^KV^UVMHUHX\PMLYZVZVTLJV\U[PLZHYLMVYTPUNJVVW
reduction in truck traffic, and a 60% reduction in water KPZ[YPJ[ZHUK\UP[PZPUN[OLYLZV\YJLZPTPSHY[VOV^HUVPSÄLSKPZ
costs. \UP[PZLK[VVW[PTPZLWYVK\J[PVU¹
Public reaction was favourable, and the company 9LN\SH[PVUZNV]LYUPUN[OLJHW[\YLHUKYL\ZLVM^H[LY
began to look for other ways to reduce its environmental HYLL_WLJ[LK[VILJVTLTVYLJVTTVU¸0U(SILY[HVPSZHUKZ
footprint, mainly through water recycling. The company KL]LSVWTLU[OHZILLUHYV\UKMVYTHU``LHYZHUK[OLYL
produces approximtely 29 000 bpd of water, and needs HYLYLN\SH[PVUZ^OPJOLMMLJ[P]LS`SPTP[[OL\ZLVMMYLZO^H[LY
between 15 000 - 40 000 bpd for completions. The HUKLUJV\YHNLPUJYLHZLKYL\ZLVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY¹ZH`Z
company invested in the construction of two water )PSS/LPUZNLULYHSTHUHNLY[OLYTHSWYVK\J[ZMVY.,7V^LY
treatment facilities and 1.4 million bbl water-storage pits. HUK>H[LY¸;OLYLN\SH[PVUZHUKLJVUVTPJZMVYO`KYH\SPJ
As a result, the company can now recycle virtually all of MYHJ[\YPUNVWLYH[PVUZHZZVJPH[LK^P[OZOHSLNHZHUKZOHSLVPS
its production and frac flow water. HYLZ[PSSYHWPKS`L]VS]PUNHUKHYLUV[`L[^LSSKLÄULKPUTHU`
The water is first treated in the field at a 4-phase YLNPVUZ¹
separator. Some of the water can be used directly on (ZHUL_HTWSL/LPUZJP[LZ[OL4HYJLSS\Z:OHSLPU
site, but most is piped to one of the treatment facilities. 7LUUZ`S]HUPHPU^OPJOMYHJ[\YPUN^H[LY[OH[JVTLZIHJR[V
There, the water first goes into a covered tank to capture Z\YMHJLJHUOH]L]LY`OPNOZHSPUP[`¸(IV\[[OYLL`LHYZHNV
volatile compounds. It is then sent to a second tank for [OLZ[H[LPTWVZLKYLN\SH[PVUZ[OH[SPTP[LK[OLKPZJOHYNL
gravity separation of oil. The water is then subjected to VM^HZ[L^H[LY[VZ\YMHJL^H[LYZPM[OLZHSPUP[`L_JLLKLK
dissolved air flotation (DAF) where bubbles of air float WWT;VKH`[OLYLHYLHKKP[PVUHSYLZ[YPJ[PVUZ^OPJOW\[
solids, hydrocarbons, biomass and silts to the surface [PNO[LYYLX\PYLTLU[ZVU[YLH[LKVPSHUKNHZ^HZ[L^H[LYZ
for skimming. By this time, the water has 100 ppm of ;OH[TLHUZ[OH[VWLYH[VYZOH]L[V[Y\JRP[V\[VMZ[H[LMVY
residual hydrocarbons. It is placed in a water storage pit KPZWVZHS]PHKLLW^LSSPUQLJ[PVU^OPJOPZJVZ[S`HUKPUJYLHZLZ
and injected with algae. The biomass growth is indicative [OLLU]PYVUTLU[HSMVV[WYPU[VM[OLPYVWLYH[PVUZVYYL\ZLHUK
of the health of the water. YLJV]LY[OLWYVK\JLK^H[LY¹
Most of the water contains between )\[HTHQVYMHJ[VYPUKLLK[OLTVZ[PTWVY[HU[[VHU
12 000 - 20 000 ppm of salt, but since a slick water VWLYH[VYPZ[OH[^H[LYPZKYP]PUN\W[OLJVZ[VMKYPSSPUNHUK
frac is used, hardness does not adversely affect the frac JVTWSL[PUN^LSSZH[HUHSHYTPUNYH[L¸@V\OH]L[VÄUK[OL
stimulation process. However, the company is looking ^H[LYI\`P[NL[P[[V[OL^LSSHUKKPZWVZLVMP[HM[LY¹ZH`Z
at RO systems that would clean up minerals in surplus )\YUL[[¸>H[LYTHUHNLTLU[JHUILVM[OL[V[HS
water and provide fresh water to local users. ^LSSJVZ[¹
The company is also mindful of potentially
substantial operating savings. “In all, we reduced our Solutions
AFEs (approvals for expenditure) by 20%, which, when -VYZL]LYHSKLJHKLZVPSZHUKZTPULZOH]LILLU^VYRPUN[V
you consider the low price environment for gas, is a YLJSHPT^H[LYMYVT[OLPYWYVJLZZLZ6M[OLIISZVM^H[LY
huge amount,” says Bittner. \ZLK[VWYVK\JLVULIHYYLSVMTPULKIP[\TLUVWLYH[VYZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Figure 1. GE’s mobile frack water treatment module. Image courtesy of GE Power and Water.
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
PZVMMLYPUN[OLILZ[^H[LYYLJ`JSPUNZLY]PJL;L_HZ(
4 5,?;3LNHJ`;LJOUVSVN`HU(SILY[HIHZLKZLY]PJL
<UP]LYZP[`»Z.SVIHS7L[YVSL\T9LZV\YJLZ0UZ[P[\[L[OLYLMVYL JVTWHU`OHZJVTL\W^P[OHZ`Z[LT[OH[\ZLZVUS`H[PU`
JVUZ[Y\J[LKHTVIPSLSHI[OH[JHUJVUK\J[MPLSK[YPHSZVM HTV\U[VM^H[LYHUKILUPNUVYNHUPJJVTWV\UKZ+\YPUN
^H[LY[YLH[TLU[ZLY]PJLZPUVYKLY[V]L[[OLTPUHMHPY [OLMYHJVWLYH[PVU[OLJVTWHU`KLWSV`ZHZPUNSLJVPSLK
\UIPHZLKTHUULY;OLSHIPZI\PS[PU[VH5(:*(9JSHZZ [\IPUNYPNZ[HMMLKI`[^VJYL^TLTILYZ(WWYV_PTH[LS`VUL
[YHPSLYHUKYPNNLKPUHTHUULY[OH[HSSV^Z[OLZJPLU[PZ[Z[V IHYYLSVMVYNHUPJJVTWV\UKPZTP_LK^P[OSVM^H[LY;OL
WYVJLZZNWTVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY0[PZKLZPNULKZV[OH[ TP_PZ[OLUPUQLJ[LKPU[V[OLYLZLY]VPYaVULH[SV^WYLZZ\YL
H^PKL]HYPL[`VMWYVJLZZLZHUK[LZ[ZJHUILJVUK\J[LK ;OLJVTWV\UKYLHJ[Z^P[O[OLYLZLY]VPYYVJRPUJYLHZPUN
KLWLUKPUNVU[OL[YPHS¸;OLTVIPSLSHIPZ]HS\HISL[V WLYTLHIPSP[`[OYV\NOL_V[OLYTPJOLH[PUNHUKRPUL[PJ
JSPLU[ZILJH\ZL[OLHUHS`[PJHS^VYRJHUILWLYMVYTLKYPNO[ TLJOHUPJHSHJ[PVU(JJVYKPUN[V[OLJVTWHU`KLWLUKPUN
VUZP[LLMMPJPLU[S`HUKX\PJRS`¶`V\KVUV[OH]L[V^HP[H VU[OLTP_\ZLK[OLMYHJJHUYHKPHSS`WLUL[YH[LM\Y[OLY[OHU
TVU[OMVY[OLYLZ\S[Z¹ZH`Z)\YUL[[¸>LJHUZOV^OV^ TPU[V[OLYLZLY]VPY;LZ[ZWYV]LK[OH[[OL[LJOUVSVN`
^LSSHMPS[LYVYZ`Z[LTPZ^VYRPUNHUK^LJHUHSZVTLHZ\YL JV\SKPUJYLHZLWYVK\J[PVUMYVT\UKLYIWK[VV]LY
HPYLTPZZPVUZHUKV[OLY]HYPHISLZ[OH[ML^JHYLHIV\[I\[ IWK([LZ[WHY[ULY^HZZ\MÄJPLU[S`PTWYLZZLK^P[O[OL
HYLJYP[PJHS[V[OLLU]PYVUTLU[HSMVV[WYPU[¹ WYVJLZZ[VHNYLL[VHT\S[P`LHYT\S[PIPSSPVUKVSSHYJVU[YHJ[
5,?;YLJLU[S`JVUZ[Y\J[LKHWSHU[PUJLU[YHS(SILY[HHUKPZPU
The future [OLWYVJLZZVMHJX\PYPUNJVPSLK[\IPUNYPNZ
;OL0,(LZ[PTH[LZ[OH[6
.^H[LYKLTHUKPZL_WLJ[LK 9LNHYKSLZZVM[LJOUVSVNPJHSPUUV]H[PVUZTVZ[PUK\Z[Y`
[VKV\ISLPU[OLUL_[`LHYZ[VV]LYIPSSPVUT WHY[PJPWHU[ZL_WLJ[Z[YPJ[LY^H[LYTHUHNLTLU[YLN\SH[PVUZ
4PUKM\S[OH[O`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNPZHZPNUPÄJHU[WVY[PVUVM ¸0U*HSPMVYUPHHSSWV^LYWSHU[ZHYLHSYLHK`YLX\PYLK[V\ZL
[OH[PUJYLHZLYLZLHYJOLYZHYLUV^MVJ\ZPUNVUYLK\JPUN ALYV3PX\PK+PZJOHYNLA3+¹ZH`Z/LPUZ¸;OLYLHYLKYV\NO[
¶HUKLSPTPUH[PUN¶^H[LYMYVT[OLWYVJLZZ/HSSPI\Y[VU JVUKP[PVUZHUK^H[LYZOVY[HNLZ[OYV\NOV\[T\JOVM[OL
YLJLU[S`SH\UJOLK[OL9HWPK-YHJZ`Z[LT+\YPUNHMYHJ ZV\[O^LZ[<:HUK[OL[YLUKPZ[V^HYKH[PNO[LUPUNVMMYLZO
HZPUNSLIHSSVWLUZT\S[PWSLZSLL]LZPZVSH[LK^P[OPUHU ^H[LY\ZHNLHUKYLJ`JSPUNPUV[OLYZLJ[VYZ¹
PU[LY]HSI`Z^LSSHISLWHJRLYZ<W[V ZSLL]LZJHUIL ;OLNVVKUL^ZPZ[OH[YLJ`JSPUN^H[LYJHUPTWYV]L[OL
PUJVYWVYH[LKPU[VHU`VULOVYPaVU[HSJVTWSL[PVULUZ\YPUN ZLJ[VYZ»WYVÄSLHUKL]LUZH]LTVUL`¸0^V\SKZH`[OH[VUS`
TH_PTPZLKZ[PT\SH[LKYLZLY]VPY]VS\TL;OLZ`Z[LTJ\[Z VM[OL\S[PTH[LWV[LU[PHSPZILPUNHJOPL]LK¹ZH`Z
KV^U[YHKP[PVUHSWLYMHUKMYHJWYVJLK\YL[PTLI`HUK /LPUZ¸>LÄYZ[OH]L[VZLLZVS\[PVUZYLN\SH[PVUZHUK[OL
YLK\JLZ^H[LYJVUZ\TW[PVU[VHZTHSSMYHJ[PVUVM^OH[PZ PUK\Z[Y`JVTL[VLX\PSPIYP\T(M[LY[OH[[OLYLPZHMHJ[VYVM
UVYTHSS`\ZLK PUWV[LU[PHSNYV^[O¹
Figure 1. Typical configurations involving membranes, ion exchange or chemical additions; and Ì .YLH[LYMYLX\LUJ`VM^LSSHUK
YLZLY]VPYWS\NNPUNYLX\PYPUN
how granular micro media filtration (Spectrum™) improves performance.
^VYRV]LYZHJPK[YLH[TLU[ZHUKUL^
^LSSZ^P[O[OLHZZVJPH[LKWYVK\J[PVU
SVZZ
Ì 9LK\J[PVUPUWYVK\J[PVUVYPU[OL[V[HSYLJV]LYHISL
WV[LU[PHSVM[OLYLZLY]VPY
Ì :V\YPUNVM^LSSZ[OYV\NOPU[YVK\J[PVUVMZ\SM\YYLK\JPUN
IHJ[LYPH:9)Z]PH[OL^H[LYPUQLJ[PVU
0UYLZWVUZL[V[OLJVUJLYUZ[OH[ZVSPKZPUQLJ[LKPU[V^LSSZJHU
YHPZLZWLJPÄJH[PVUZMVY[OL^H[LYX\HSP[`ILPUNPUQLJ[LKPU[V
Z\JO^LSSZHYLPUJYLHZPUNS`ILPUNKLÄULKI`HWHY[PJSLZPaL
J\[VMMH[HIV\[TPJYVUZ^P[OTHU`ZWLJPÄJH[PVUZYLX\PYPUN
[OH[ VM[OLWHY[PJSLZNYLH[LY[OHUTPJYVUZIL
YLTV]LK
Figure 2.Comparing granular (Spectrum) micro media to conventional :VTLV[OLYUL^WYVK\J[PVUWYHJ[PJLZPU]VS]LV[OLY^H[LY
media. The lower layer of micro media features a very small particle JVUKP[PVUPUNWYVJLZZLX\PWTLU[^OPJOPU[\YUYLX\PYLZ
size and acts as a barrier to small suspended solids. L_JLSSLU[ÄS[YH[PVUMVYP[[VWLYMVYTWYVWLYS`-PN\YLPSS\Z[YH[LZ
HU\TILYVM[OLZLWYVJLZZLZ^OPJOPU]VS]L[OL\ZLVM
TLTIYHULZPVUL_JOHUNLYLZPUZVYJOLTPJHSHKKP[PVUZHSSVM
^OPJO^PSSILHMMLJ[LKPM[OL^H[LYMLK[VP[PZUV[^LSSJSLHULK
VMZVSPKZHUKVPS;OLÄN\YLHSZVZOV^ZOV^NYHU\SHYTPJYV
TLKPHÄS[YH[PVUJHUPTWYV]LWLYMVYTHUJL
Membrane filters
>OLUHS[LYUH[P]LÄS[YH[PVU[LJOUVSVNPLZHYLJVUZPKLYLK[OL
KPZJ\ZZPVUTH`[\YU[VTLTIYHULÄS[YH[PVU\ZPUNWVS`TLYPJ
VYTVYLYLJLU[S`JLYHTPJVYTL[HSSPJTLTIYHULZ^OPJOHYL
YH[LKHZTPJYVÄS[LYZVY\S[YHÄS[LYZKLWLUKPUNVU[OLWVYLZPaL
Figure 3. A 330 m3/hr (50 000 bpd) Spectrum micro media filtration VM[OLTLTIYHUL>OPSLZ\JOÄS[LYZOH]LOHKZVTLTLHZ\YL
system. VMZ\JJLZZPUPUK\Z[YPHSHWWSPJH[PVUZ[OL`OH]LUV[ILLU
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
^PKLS`KLWSV`LKPU[OLÄS[YH[PVUVM
WYVK\JLK^H[LY;OPZPZHWWHYLU[S`[OL
JHZLMVYHU\TILYVMYLHZVUZZ\JOHZ!
Ì *HWL_![OLPUP[PHSJVZ[VMZ\JO
MPS[LYZPZJVUZPKLYHIS`TVYL[OHU
[OL[YHKP[PVUHS^H[LYMPS[YH[PVU
Z`Z[LTZ
Ì 6WL_!TLTIYHULZHYL
THU\MHJ[\YLK[VOH]L]LY`ZTHSS
WVYLZ[VHSSV^^H[LY[VWHZZ
I\[UV[Z\ZWLUKLKZVSPKZVYVPS
KYVWSL[Z0UVYKLY[VRLLW[OL
WVYLZVWLU[OLMSV^[OYV\NOZ\JO
MPS[LYZPZ[HUNLU[PHS[V[OLMS\_
HJYVZZ[OLTLTIYHULPL
JYVZZMSV^;OPZVM[LUYLX\PYLZ
W\TWPUNT\JOTVYLMS\PKPU
HYLJPYJ\SH[PVUSVVW[OHUPZ
HJ[\HSS`MPS[LYLK-\Y[OLYYLN\SHY
IHJRW\SZPUNVM[OLMSV^PZYLX\PYLK
[VRLLW[OLWVYLZJSLHU;OPZ
YLX\PYLZ]HS]LZJVU[YVSZHUK
H\_PSPHY`LX\PWTLU[7LYPVKPJHSS`
[OLTLTIYHULZYLX\PYLJOLTPJHS
Figure 4. An 18 000 bpd (2860 M3/day) Spectrum micro media filter.
JSLHUPUN[VKPZZVS]LTH[LYPHS
^OPJOOHZILLUPTILKKLKPU[OL
WVYLZ;OPZYLX\PYLZJOLTPJHSZ
HUKTVYLH\_PSPHY`LX\PWTLU[<S[PTH[LS`[OL
TLTIYHULZOH]LHSPTP[LKSPMLHUKT\Z[ILYLWSHJLK
H[JVUZPKLYHISLJVZ[
Ì 0UJVTWH[PIPSP[`!ZVTLWVS`TLYPJTLTIYHULZHYL
PUJVTWH[PISL^P[OO`KYVJHYIVUZ^OPSLZVTLHYLHSZV
[LTWLYH[\YLZLUZP[P]LHUKJHUUV[IL\ZLK^OLU[OL
WYVK\JLK^H[LYPZ^HYT[`WPJHSS`SPTP[LK[V#á*
Ì 7YVUL[VMV\SPUN!THU`WPSV[[LZ[ZOH]LILLU
JVUK\J[LK\ZPUNTLTIYHULZMVYMPS[LYPUNWYVK\JLK
^H[LYI\[^P[OSPTP[LKZ\JJLZZK\L[V[OLPYWYVWLUZP[`
[VMV\SPYYL]LYZPIS`^P[OVPSHUKKPY[0M[OLVWLYH[PUN
JVUKP[PVUZHUKJSLHUPUNYLNPTLZHYLUV[WYVWLYS`
THPU[HPULK[OLSPMLVM[OLTLTIYHULZTH`IL
ZPNUPMPJHU[S`JVTWYPZLKHUK[OL`TH`YLX\PYL
WYLTH[\YLYLWSHJLTLU[0UZVTLJHZLZTLTIYHUL
MPS[LYZHYLWYVWVZLKKV^UZ[YLHTVMJVU]LU[PVUHSMPS[LYZ
Figure 5. Granular micro media filter vs. conventional filter performance:
^P[O[OLPU[LU[PVU[OH[[OPZ^PSSWYV[LJ[[OLTLTIYHULZ
averaged site results collected from field study.
HUKYLK\JL[OLKPY[SVHKHUKMV\SPUNYH[L/V^L]LY[OPZ
PUJYLHZLZ[OLJVZ[VM[OLV]LYHSSMPS[YH[PVUWYVJLZZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
HM[LYIHJR^HZOPUNK\YPUN^OPJOIV[OTLKPHHYLÅ\PKPZLK \ZPUNÄULTLZOYLZPU9LJVÅVZ`Z[LTZOH]LHK]HU[HNLZ
ZPT\S[HULV\ZS`[OLKLUZLTPJYVTLKPHX\PJRS`ZL[[SLZ[V V]LYJVU]LU[PVUHSPVUL_JOHUNLMVYHWWSPJH[PVUZZ\JOHZ
MVYTHKPZ[PUJ[SH`LYILSV^[OLJVHYZL\WWLYTLKPHSH`LY ^H[LYKLTPULYHSPZH[PVUVYZVM[LUPUNHUKJOLTPJHSWYVJLZZ
;OPZHSSV^ZP[[VHJ[HZHUPU[LNYHSWVSPZOPUNÄS[LYJHWHISLVM ZLWHYH[PVUZ/V^L]LYZPUJL[OLYLZPUILKZHYLWHJRLKHUK
YLTV]HSVMT\JOZTHSSLYZVSPKWHY[PJSLZHUKVPSKYVWSL[Z^OPJO KVUV[NL[IHJR^HZOLK[OL`YLX\PYLYLTV]HSVMHSSZVSPKZ
UVYTHSS`WHZZ[OYV\NOHJVU]LU[PVUHSTLKPHÄS[LY [OH[TH`JH\ZLWS\NNPUN0[OHZILLUKL[LYTPULK[OH[[OPZ
JVYYLZWVUKZ[VHMLLKZ\ZWLUKLKZVSPKZZWLJPÄJH[PVUVM
Development and industrial experience of #WWT;::^P[OUVTPUHSWHY[PJSLYLTV]HS#TPJYVU
granular micro media technology .YHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPHÄS[LYZOH]LILLUPUVWLYH[PVU
.YHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPHÄS[LYZ^LYLKL]LSVWLKPUP[PHSS`HZH MVYTVYL[OHU`LHYZPUH]HYPL[`VMWYVJLZZHWWSPJH[PVUZ
WYLÄS[LYMVY,JV;LJ»Z9LJVÅVWHJRLKPVUL_JOHUNLZ`Z[LTZ PUJS\KPUNWYLÄS[YH[PVUVMZ\YMHJLHUK^LSS^H[LYZMVY
KLTPULYHSPZH[PVUWYVJLZZLZ
-VY[OLWHZ[`LHYZNYHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPHÄS[YH[PVUOHZ
ILLU\ZLKHZWYL[YLH[TLU[MVYYL]LYZLVZTVZPZTLTIYHULZ
^OPJOHSZVYLX\PYL]LY`ÄULÄS[YH[PVUPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[
TLTIYHULMV\SPUN-PN\YLPZHWOV[VNYHWOVMH
TOYIWKNYHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPHÄS[YH[PVUZ`Z[LT
PUVWLYH[PVUMVY`LHYZPU^OPJOYH^SHRL^H[LYPZÄS[LYLK
ILMVYLYL]LYZLVZTVZPZHUKM\Y[OLYKV^UZ[YLHTWVSPZOPUN[V
WYVK\JL\S[YHW\YL^H[LYMVYHU\JSLHYWV^LYZ[H[PVU
0U[^VNYHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPHÄS[YH[PVUZ`Z[LTZ
^LYLZ\WWSPLKMVYÄS[YH[PVUVMWYVK\JLK^H[LYPUOLH]`VPS
WYVK\J[PVUPUUVY[OLYU*OPUH
:PUJL [LUZ`Z[LTZOH]LILLUW\[PU[VVWLYH[PVU
H[ZP_KPMMLYLU[ZP[LZ[VÄS[LYWYVK\JLK^H[LYMYVTOLH]`VPS
WYVK\J[PVUPU[OL)HRLYZÄLSK*HSPMVYUPHHYLH;OLZLÄS[LYZ
OH]LHSSILLUPUZ[HSSLKHZWYLÄS[LYZILMVYLHK]HUJLKPVU
Figure 7. Granular micro media filter oil droplet removal by size (as
measured by Canty Instruments). L_JOHUNL^H[LYZVM[LULYZ[OH[JVUKP[PVU[OLWYVK\JLK^H[LY
[VILMLK[VVUJL[OYV\NOZ[LHTNLULYH[VYZ
;VKH[L[OLÄS[LYZOH]LILLUWLYMVYTPUN]LY`^LSSVUH
X\HSP[H[P]LIHZPZZPUJL[OLYLOHZILLU]PY[\HSS`UVMV\SPUNVM
[OLWHJRLKILKPVUL_JOHUNLYZK\L[VZVSPKZVYVPSWHZZPUN
[OYV\NO[OLÄS[LYZ
(SVUN^P[OX\HSP[H[P]LYLZ\S[ZP[^HZHSZVYLJLU[S`KLJPKLK
[VTLHZ\YL[OLWLYMVYTHUJLVM[OLNYHU\SHYTPJYVTLKPH
ÄS[LYZX\HU[P[H[P]LS`HUKJVTWHYL[OLPYWLYMVYTHUJL^P[O
JVU]LU[PVUHSÄS[LYZPLU\[ZOLSSHUKVYZHUKÄS[LYZVWLYH[PUN
H[V[OLYZP[LZPU[OLHYLH
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
SPE OFFSHORE CONNECT
EUROPE THE
NEXT 50 YEARS
SPE Offshore Europe is where the E&P community meets to find the REGISTER
solutions required to keep up with an accelerating technology race,
and understand the demands of a changing industry committed to NOW
WWW.OF
ensuring security of supply in an increasingly complex world. FSH
EUROPE.C ORE-
O.UK
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Jay Keener,
Produced Water Absorbents,
USA, reveals the
development of a new
water treatment technology
designed to help ‘clean up’
the hydrocarbon industry.
T
OL[YLH[TLU[VMWYVK\JLK^H[LYMVY
LU]PYVUTLU[HSKPZJOHYNLMVYTH[PVUYLPUQLJ[PVU
HUKILULMPJPHSYL\ZLPZHUL]LYNYV^PUN
JOHSSLUNLPUHSSO`KYVJHYIVUWYVK\JPUNYLNPVUZ
(Z[OLSHYNLZ[I`WYVK\J[Z[YLHTHZZVJPH[LK^P[O
VPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVUWYVK\JLK^H[LYTH`
PUJS\KLO`KYVJHYIVUZMYVT[OLYLZLY]VPYJOLTPJHSZ
PUQLJ[LKPU[V[OLMVYTH[PVUHUKHU`JOLTPJHSZ
HKKLKK\YPUN[OLWYVK\J[PVUHUK[YLH[TLU[
WYVJLZZLZ
A pertinent problem
(S[OV\NOLZ[PTH[LZVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY]VS\TLZ
]HY`[OLNSVIHSX\HU[P[`^PSSSPRLS`JVU[PU\L[V
PUJYLHZLPU[V[OLO\UKYLKZVMIPSSPVUZVMIISZ
WLY`LHY(ZHUVPSÄLSKTH[\YLZVPSWYVK\J[PVU
KLJYLHZLZ^OPSL^H[LYWYVK\J[PVUPUJYLHZLZ;OL
J\YYLU[H]LYHNL^H[LY!VPSYH[PVPZLZ[PTH[LKH[
!!^VYSK^PKL^OPJOLX\H[LZ[VH^H[LY
J\[VM;OLZLSLJ[PVUVM[YLH[TLU[
[LJOUVSVNPLZ[OLYLMVYLYLX\PYLZRUV^SLKNLVM
[OL^H[LY[VIL[YLH[LKHUK[OLJVU[HTPUHU[Z[V
ILYLTV]LKHJYVZZ[OLYLZLY]VPY
;OPZ^H[LYNLULYHSS`JVUZPKLYLKH
UVUYL]LU\LWYVK\J[HUKZPNUPMPJHU[
JVU[YPI\[VY[VWYVK\J[PVU*HWL_JHUOH]L
]HS\LPULUOHUJLKVPSYLJV]LY`,69HUK
ILULMPJPHSYL\ZLHWWSPJH[PVUZPMP[JHUIL[YLH[LK[VTLL[VY HUK[YLH[TLU[Z`Z[LTZ:LSLJ[PVUVM[OLILZ[H]HPSHISL
L_JLLKKPZJOHYNLVYYLPUQLJ[PVUYLX\PYLTLU[Z*HWL_JHU [LJOUVSVNPLZPZKL[LYTPULKI`T\S[PWSLMHJ[VYZPUJS\KPUN[OL
ILYLK\JLKI`PUJ\YYPUNSV^LYKPZWVZHSJVZ[ZMVYPUQLJ[PVUVM JVUZ[P[\LU[ZVM[OLJVU[YPI\[PUNZV\YJLZVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY
JSLHULY^H[LYVYI`LUHISPUN[OLLU]PYVUTLU[HSKPZJOHYNLVM KYPSSPUNHUKJVTWSL[PVUIYPULZZVSPKZJVU[LU[HUKZHUK
[OL^H[LYYH[OLY[OHUYLX\PYPUN[YHUZWVY[H[PVUHUKKPZWVZHS WYVK\J[PVUUVUYLZLY]VPYMS\PKZWYVK\J[PVUJOLTPJHSZHUK
;OLYLPZHSZVPUJYLHZPUNPU[LYLZ[PU[OLILULMPJPHSYL\ZLVM WYVJLZZPUNZ`Z[LTJVUMPN\YH[PVU
WYVK\JLK^H[LYPUHNYPJ\S[\YHSHUKPUK\Z[YPHSHWWSPJH[PVUZ 0[PZ[OLYLMVYLPTWVY[HU[[V\UKLYZ[HUK[OLPU[LYHJ[P]L
HZWLJ[ZVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY[YLH[TLU[PUJS\KPUN[OL
Technology selection JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZVM[OLJY\KLVPSHUKJVUKLUZH[LILPUN
;OLJVTWSL_P[`VMWYVK\JLK^H[LYHUK[OLKLZPYLKLUK\ZL WYVK\JLKJOLTPZ[Y`VM[OLWYVK\JLK^H[LYWYVJLZZ
KYP]L[OLWSHUUPUNHUKKLZPNUVM[OLYLSL]HU[WYVJLZZPUN OHYK^HYLHUKJOLTPJHS[YLH[TLU[
7YVK\JLK>H[LY(IZVYILU[Z0UJ\ZLZ6ZVYI TLKPH
[LJOUVSVN`^OPJOPZHUVYNHUPJHSS`TVKPMPLKZPSPJHMVY
[OL[YLH[TLU[VMVPSHUKNHZ^HZ[L^H[LYZ[YLHTZ0[PZ
O`KYVWOVIPJHUKKVLZUV[HIZVYI^H[LYI\[JHUYLTV]L
\W[V VMMYLLKPZWLYZLKHUKZVS\ISLO`KYVJHYIVUZ
HUKVPSMPLSKJOLTPJHSZMYVT^H[LY0[OHZ[OLHIPSP[`[V
L_WHUK^OPSLHIZVYIPUN[OLZLJVU[HTPUHU[ZMYVTWYVK\JLK
^H[LY^OPJOSLHKZ[VPUJYLHZLKJHWHJP[`HUKILKSPML
;OL[LJOUVSVN`PZHWWSPLKPUIV[OVUZOVYLHUKVMMZOVYL
HWWSPJH[PVUZMVY[OLW\YWVZLZVMKPZJOHYNLJOLTPJHS,69
YLPUQLJ[PVUILULMPJPHSYL\ZLWYL]LU[PVUVMTLTIYHULMV\SPUN
HPYLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZHUKVMMZOVYLL_J\YZPVUZ
;OLTLJOHUPZTI`^OPJO[OPZTLKPHYLTV]LZ
O`KYVJHYIVUZHUKVPSMPLSKJOLTPJHSZMYVTJVU[HTPUH[LK
^H[LYPZKPMMLYLU[[VV[OLYTLKPH[LJOUVSVNPLZ;OLTLKPH
PZIV[OHUHKZVYILU[HUKHUHIZVYILU[HUKUVWLYTHULU[
Figure 1. The Osorb media can remove dispersed, emulsified and JOLTPJHSIVUKZHYLMVYTLKIL[^LLU[OLTLKPHHUK[OL
soluble hydrocarbons and oilfield chemicals from produced water.
ZVYIH[LZ;OPZSHJRVMWLYTHULU[IVUKPUNLUHISLZ[OL
YLWLH[LKYLNLULYH[PVUHUKYL\ZLVM[OLTLKPH^OPSLHSZV
YLJV]LYPUN[OLJVU[HTPUHU[Z[OH[^LYLJHW[\YLKMYVT[OL
^H[LY;OLYLNLULYH[PVUJHWHIPSP[`ZL[Z[OLTLKPHHWHY[MYVT
V[OLY^H[LY[YLH[TLU[[LJOUPX\LZI`KYHZ[PJHSS`YLK\JPUN[OL
JVZ[ZVMTLKPHYLWSHJLTLU[HUK^HZ[L[YHUZWVY[H[PVUHUK
KPZWVZHS
;OLOPNOS`]HYPHISLJVU[HTPUHU[WYVMPSLVMWYVK\JLK
^H[LYYLX\PYLZ[LJOUVSVNPLZ[OH[JHU[YLH[H^PKLYHUNLVM
ZWLJPLZ^OPSL^P[OZ[HUKPUN[OLOHYZOJOLTPJHSLU]PYVUTLU[
;OL6ZVYITLKPHOHZHOPNOHMMPUP[`MVYVYNHUPJJVTWV\UKZ
SPRLKPZWLYZLKHUKLT\SZPMPLKVPSZ^H[LYZVS\ISLVYNHUPJZ
]VSH[PSLVYNHUPJJVTWV\UKZ=6*ZHUKZVTLVPSMPLSK
JOLTPJHSZ;OLTLKPH!THPU[HPUZ[YLH[TLU[WLYMVYTHUJL
PU[OLWYLZLUJLVMTHU`VPSMPLSKJOLTPJHSZ[OH[HYLUV[
LMMPJPLU[S`JHW[\YLKTHPU[HPUZZ[HIPSP[`PU[`WPJHS[LTWLYH[\YL
Figure 2. Osorb media floating in a flask after absorbing >99% of all HUKW/LU]PYVUTLU[ZHUKPZUV[ULNH[P]LS`HMMLJ[LKI`HU`
dispersed oil in a produced water sample. JVUJLU[YH[PVUVMZHSPUP[`VY[V[HSKPZZVS]LKZVSPKZ;+:PU[OL
^H[LY
*\YYLU[S`YLN\SH[PVUZMVYVMMZOVYLVPSHUK
NHZVWLYH[VYZPU[OL.\SMVM4L_PJVYLZ[YPJ[
[OLSL]LSVMVPSHUKNYLHZL[OH[JHUIL
KPZJOHYNLKV]LYIVHYKPUHU`WYVK\JLK^H[LY
VYHS[LYUH[P]L^H[LYZ[YLHT;OLZLSL]LSZHYL
ZL[H[ TNSTH_PT\TH]LYHNLMVYTVU[OS`
KPZJOHYNLHUKTNSTH_PT\TH]LYHNL
KHPS`KPZJOHYNL
=HYPV\ZVMMZOVYL[LJOUVSVNPLZL_PZ[[V
LSPTPUH[LT\JOVM[OLMYLLVPSHUKNYLHZL
MYVT[OLZLV]LYIVHYKKPZJOHYNLZI\[
TVKLYU[LJOUVSVN`J\YYLU[S`SHJRZ[OLHIPSP[`
[VJVUZPZ[LU[S`KLJYLHZLVPSHUKNYLHZL
Figure 3. OIW reduction in offshore produced water with 6 in. media test column. JVUJLU[YH[PVUZ[VSLZZ[OHUTNS^OPSL
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
42nd Turbomachinery
29th Pump SYMPOSIA
9.30 – 10.3.2013
turbolab.tamu.edu
/TurbolabatTAMU @PumpTurbo
HUK[VWYV]PKL[OLMPUHSO`KYVJHYIVUHUKJOLTPJHSYLTV]HS
Z[LWK\YPUNJVU[PU\V\ZVYJVU[PUNLUJ`V]LYIVHYKKPZJOHYNL
VMWYVK\JLK^H[LY4LJOHUPJHSZ`Z[LTZHYLVM[LU\UHISL[V
JVUZPZ[LU[S`THPU[HPUVPSHUKNYLHZLJVUJLU[YH[PVUZILSV^
[OLKPZJOHYNLYLN\SH[PVUI\[[OPZJOHSSLUNLJHUILHSSL]PH[LK
I`\ZPUN[OL6ZVYI[LJOUVSVN`HZHZ[HUKI`ºL_J\YZPVU»
Z`Z[LT[VWYV]PKLHZULLKLKVYJVU[PU\V\ZºWVSPZOPUN»VM
VPSHUKNYLHZLMYVT[OL^H[LY
(UL^WYVJLZZPZHSZVILPUNKL]LSVWLK[OH[JHUHSSV^H
ZPTWSLJOHUNLV\[VM[OLTLKPHPUHJHY[YPKNLIHZLKZ`Z[LT
;OPZ^PSSLUHISL[OLTLKPH[VILX\PJRS`HUKLMMPJPLU[S`
YLTV]LKMYVT[OL]LZZLSILMVYLILPUNYLNLULYH[LKHUK
YLSVHKLKPU[V[OL]LZZLS:LJVUKNLULYH[PVUZRPK]LZZLSZHYL
HSZVILPUNKLZPNULK[OH[^PSSHSSV^MVYPUZP[\YLNLULYH[PVU
HUK^H[LY[YLH[TLU[
Regeneration
6ULVM[OLWYPTHY`KPMMLYLU[PH[VYZVM[OPZ[LJOUVSVN`PZP[Z
HIPSP[`[VILYLWLH[LKS`YLNLULYH[LKHUKYL\ZLKMVY^H[LY
Figure 4. The OBV-036 System. [YLH[TLU[;OPZPZILJH\ZLP[KVLZUV[JOLTPJHSS`YLHJ[^P[O
HU`JVU[HTPUHU[ZI\[YH[OLYOHZHWO`ZPJHSYLHJ[PVU^OLU
YLTV]PUN[OL^H[LYZVS\ISLVYNHUPJZ>:6ZHUK]VSH[PSL JVSSLJ[PUNO`KYVJHYIVUZMYVT^H[LYVYNHZZ[YLHTZ6UJL
VYNHUPJJVTWV\UKZ=6*Z [OLTLKPH»ZWO`ZPVH[[YHJ[PVUHKZVYW[PVUHUK]VS\TL[YPJ
L_WHUZPVUHIZVYW[PVUWYVJLZZLZOH]L[HRLUWSHJLP[JHU
Field trials ILYL[\YULK[VP[ZVYPNPUHSZ[H[L[OYV\NOZL]LYHSWYVJLZZLZ
+\YPUN[OLWHZ[[^V`LHYZ[OLJVTWHU`OHZJHYYPLKV\[H 7YHJ[PJHSTL[OVKZMVYKLZVYW[PVUVMJVTWVULU[Z^OL[OLY
U\TILYVMZ\JJLZZM\SMPLSK[YPHSZPU[OL<:(HUKYLJLU[S` HKZVYILKVYHIZVYILKPUJS\KL[OLMVSSV^PUN!
YHU[OYLLPU[LYUH[PVUHS[YPHSZIV[OVUZOVYLHUKVMMZOVYLPU Ì ;OLYTHSZ^PUN!PUJYLHZLZPU[LTWLYH[\YL[VL]HWVYH[L
[OL-HY,HZ[;OLZLMLHZPIPSP[`[LZ[Z\ZLKHPU[LZ[JVS\TU JHW[\YLKZWLJPLZ
[PLKPU[VHZHTWSLWVPU[VM[OLL_PZ[PUNWYVK\JLK^H[LY Ì 7\YNPUN!\ZLVMPULY[MS\PKZ[VYLTV]LJHW[\YLKZWLJPLZ
[YLH[TLU[Z`Z[LT[VNLULYH[LWLYMVYTHUJLKH[HVU[YLH[PUN Ì +PZWSHJLTLU[!\ZLVMHOPNOS`HKZVYILKMS\PK[VYLTV]L
SP]LWYVK\JLK^H[LY [OLJHW[\YLKZWLJPLZ
6ULVMMZOVYL[YPHSKLTVUZ[YH[LKHUH]LYHNLVM Ì 7YLZZ\YLZ^PUN!KLJYLHZLZPUWYLZZ\YL[VL]HWVYH[L
VPSPU^H[LY60>YLK\J[PVUMYVTWWTWHY[ZWLYTPSSPVU JHW[\YLKZWLJPLZ
[VWWTILMVYLIYLHR[OYV\NO^HZL]LU[\HSS`VIZLY]LK ;OLYLJV]LYLKHKZVYILKZWLJPLZJVSSLJ[LKMYVT[OL
;OL[^VVUZOVYL[YPHSZPU0UKVULZPHWYVK\JLKYLZ\S[Z^P[OHU YLNLULYH[PVUWYVJLZZVM[LU[OLUJYLH[LHWYVK\J[^P[Oº]HS\L»
H]LYHNL 60>YLK\J[PVUMYVTWWT[VWWT YH[OLY[OHUHJVUZ\THISL^HZ[LZ[YLHTLZWLJPHSS`^OLU
>P[ONYV^PUNWYLZZ\YLMYVTSLNPZSH[VYZ[VYLK\JL[OL [OLO`KYVJHYIVUZHUKVYNHUPJZJHUILMLKIHJRPU[V[OL
LU]PYVUTLU[HSPTWHJ[MHJ[VY[OPZNHTLJOHUNPUN[LJOUVSVN` WYVJLZZVYKPZ[YPI\[LKMVYHUHS[LYUH[P]L\ZL6UJL[OLTLKPH
NP]LZVWLYH[VYZ[OLHIPSP[`[VTLL[HUKZ\YWHZZZ[YPUNLU[ OHZILLUYLNLULYH[LK[VP[ZVYPNPUHS\UZWLU[JVUKP[PVUP[JHU
UL^LU]PYVUTLU[HSHUKKPZJOHYNLYLN\SH[PVUZIL`VUK[OL ILYL\ZLKT\S[PWSL[PTLZMVYZ\IZLX\LU[^H[LY[YLH[TLU[
ZPTWSLNSVIHSH]LYHNLVMWWT60>(U\TILYVM[LZ[ZHYL VWLYH[PVUZ^P[OV\[HU`SVZZPUWLYMVYTHUJL
ILPUNJVUK\J[LKVU[OLILUJOZJHSL[VM\Y[OLY\UKLYZ[HUK
[OLJHWHIPSP[PLZVML_[YHJ[PUN]HYPV\ZVPSMPLSKJOLTPJHSZMYVT Conclusion
ZPUNSLJVTWVULU[HUKT\S[PJVTWVULU[WYVK\JLK^H[LY >P[OJVUZ[HU[S`PUJYLHZPUN^H[LYJ\[ZHUK\[PSPZH[PVUVM
Z[YLHTZ LUOHUJLKVPSYLJV]LY`[LJOUPX\LZSLHKPUN[VHUHUU\HSYPZL
;OPZTLKPHWYPTHYPS`ZL[ZP[ZLSMHWHY[MYVTJVTWL[P[P]L PU[OLNSVIHS]VS\TLVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY[OLTHUHNLTLU[
[LJOUVSVNPLZI`P[ZWLYMVYTHUJLMSL_PIPSP[`VMHWWSPJH[PVU VMWYVK\JLK^H[LY[VTHPU[HPULU]PYVUTLU[HSWYV[LJ[PVU
HUKYLNLULYHIPSP[`^P[OV\[HU`^HZ[LNLULYH[PVU(ZH HUKLJVUVTPJLMMPJPLUJ`PZVULVM[OLVPSHUKNHZPUK\Z[Y`»Z
T\S[PMHJL[LKHUKT\S[PWSL\ZL[LJOUVSVN`[OLWV[LU[PHS NYLH[LZ[JOHSSLUNLZ;OLHIPSP[`[VTPUPTPZL[OLZLJVZ[Z
MVYP[Z\ZLPUV[OLYTHYRL[HYLHZZ\JOHZJVTWSL[PVUHUK HUKTH_PTPZL^H[LYYL\ZLYLTHPUZHOPNOWYPVYP[`JVUJLYU
Z[PT\SH[PVUMSV^IHJRZKLS\NL^H[LYVPSZWPSSYLJV]LY`HPY MVYVWLYH[VYZ[OH[HYLHPTPUN[VVW[PTPZLYLJV]LY`MYVT
LTPZZPVUZJVU[YVSHUKUH[\YHSNHZJVUKP[PVUPUNJHUUV[IL YLZLY]VPYZL_[LUKMPLSKSPMLHUKTLL[Z[YPUNLU[LU]PYVUTLU[HS
\UKLYLZ[PTH[LK [HYNL[Z[VTH_PTPZL[OLPYYL[\YUZ
;OLNSVIHS]VS\TLVMWYVK\JLK^H[LY^PSSJVU[PU\L[V
Flexible packaging NYV^PU[V[OLMVYLZLLHISLM\[\YLHUKVPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVU
;OLTLKPHJHUILWHJRHNLKPUI\SRTLKPHJHY[YPKNLVY ^PSSPUJYLHZPUNS`YLX\PYL[LJOUPX\LZ[OH[NLULYH[LOPNOS`
PUQLJ[PVUKVZPUNWYVJLZZLZ[VYLTV]LKPZWLYZLKLT\SZPMPLK JVU[HTPUH[LKWYVK\JLK^H[LY(ZHYLZ\S[[OLPUK\Z[Y`
HUKZVS\ISLVYNHUPJZMYVTWYVK\JLK^H[LYZHUKMSV^IHJR ^PSSILJVTLTVYLKLWLUKLU[VUUL^[LJOUVSVNPLZ[OH[HYL
^H[LYZ)\SRTLKPHZRPKZ6)=ZRPKZOH]LILLU KLZPNULK[VKLHS^P[O[OLPUJYLHZLKJOHSSLUNLVMTLL[PUN
KL]LSVWLK[VOV\ZL[OLTLKPH^P[OPUPUKPHTL[LY]LZZLSZ 60>HUKVPSMPLSKJOLTPJHSKPZJOHYNLYLN\SH[PVUZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
Dr Frances Metcalfe, Cambridge Consultants, UK, looks at the range of
automatic leak detection techniques currently in use and points out some
key opportunities for improvement.
R
LJLU[L]LU[ZOH]LZOV^UOV^KYHTH[PJ[OLPTWHJ[VMH ^P[OSVUN[PLIHJRZ:VTLKL]LSVWTLU[ZWHY[PJ\SHYS`PU[OL
THYPULVPSZWPSSJHUILHUKOV^T\JOSPHIPSP[`^PSSLUZ\L 5VY^LNPHUZLJ[VYOH]LUVZ\YMHJLWYLZLUJLH[HSS^P[O[OL
0UJYLHZPUNLU]PYVUTLU[HSYLN\SH[PVUHUK[OLULLK[VTLL[ [LTWSH[LZILPUN[PLKIHJRHSS[OL^H`[VSHUK;OPZTLHUZ[OH[[OLYL
OPNOLYZ[HUKHYKZOHZJYLH[LKHUPUK\Z[Y`ULLKMVYHYHUNLVM PZHSHYNLHTV\U[VMLX\PWTLU[[OH[OHZ[VILWYV[LJ[LK
WYVK\J[Z[VTVUP[VYPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YLHUKLX\PWTLU[ 3LHRZMYVTÄZZ\YLZOH]LHSZVILLURUV^U[VVJJ\Y!HS[OV\NO
(U\TILYVMZ`Z[LTZOH]LILLUKL]LSVWLK[VKL[LJ[ [OLZLJHUILJH\ZLKI`\UKLYNYV\UKISV^V\[ZHZHYLZ\S[VM
SLHRZPUTHU`KPMMLYLU[ZP[\H[PVUZ\ZPUN]HYPV\Z[LJOUPX\LZ JHZPUNMHPS\YLSLHRZJH\ZLKI`HUHWWYHPZHS^LSSOH]LVJJ\YYLKPU
HUK[LJOUVSVNPLZ^P[O]HY`PUNKLNYLLZVMZ\JJLZZ@L[TVZ[ )YHaPS7YV[LJ[PUNHNHPUZ[HUKTVUP[VYPUNZ\JOSLHRZWYLZLU[ZH
ZPNUPÄJHU[SLHRZHYLZ[PSSMV\UKPU[OLÄYZ[PUZ[HUJLI`O\THUL`L [LJOUVSVNPJHSJOHSSLUNLZPUJLH^PKLHYLHT\Z[ILTVUP[VYLK@L[
^OLU[OLVPSOHZYLHJOLK[OLZLHZ\YMHJLMHYPU[PTLHUKKPZ[HUJL [OLHTV\U[VMVPS[OH[TH`ILWYLZLU[PZZTHSS
MYVT[OLVYPNPUVM[OLSLHR:V^OLYLKVL_PZ[PUN[LJOUPX\LZ (WHY[PJ\SHYS`ZLUZP[P]LHYLHVMHWPWLSPULJHUILTVUP[VYLKI`H
^VYR^LSSHUK^OH[VWWVY[\UP[PLZL_PZ[[VTHRLH\[VTH[PJSLHR KPZ[YPI\[LKÄIYLVW[PJZLUZVY;OPZ[`WLVMZ`Z[LTOHZILLU\UKLY
KL[LJ[PVULMMLJ[P]LHUK[OLJVTTLYJPHSILULÄ[ZP[VMMLYZHYLHSP[`& KL]LSVWTLU[MVYZVTL`LHYZ^P[OZL]LYHSJVTWL[PUNZVS\[PVUZ
H]HPSHISL;OLLHYS`Z`Z[LTZYLX\PYLKNYH[PUNZ¶ZWLJPHSHYLHZVM
“Most significant leaks are still found in the first [OLÄIYL¶[VIL^YP[[LUPU[V[OLNSHZZILMVYLWHJRHNPUNP[:`Z[LTZ
instance by human eye” [OH[HYLJ\YYLU[S`ILPUNKL]LSVWLK\ZLHZ[HUKHYKÄIYL^P[OUV
4VYLHUKTVYLÄLSKKL]LSVWTLU[ZHYLZ\IZLHVM[LUPU ZWLJPHSMLH[\YLZ0ULP[OLYJHZL[OLWYPUJPWSLPZ[OLZHTL![OLÄIYLPZ
\S[YHKLLW^H[LY;OLYLTH`ILVUS`VULWSH[MVYTVU[OLZ\YMHJL JVUULJ[LK[VHUVW[PJHSPU[LYYVNH[VY^OPJOWYV]PKLZHSPNO[ZV\YJL
^P[O[OL^LSSOLHKZHUKWYVK\J[PVULX\PWTLU[ILPUNJVUULJ[LK ;OPZSHZLYSPNO[PZ[YHUZTP[[LKKV^U[OLÄIYL^OLYLP[PZZJH[[LYLK
LP[OLYI`KLSPILYH[LS`PUK\JLKMLH[\YLZPTWLYMLJ[PVUZPU[OLNSHZZVY TLHZ\YLKI`Z[HUKHYKPZLK[LZ[Z^OPJOYLS`VUHZHTWSL
L]LUHJV\Z[PJ^H]LZWYVWHNH[PUNPU[OLTH[LYPHS;OLPU[LYYVNH[VY ILPUN[HRLUHUK[OLUH]LYHNLKPU[OLSHI;OPZX\HU[P[H[P]L
TLHZ\YLZ[OLHTWSP[\KLHUKYLSH[P]LWOHZLVM[OPZYL[\YULKSPNO[ HUHS`ZPZPZ\Z\HSS`JHYYPLKV\[I`09ZWLJ[YVZJVW`HS[OV\NONHZ
HUKHUHS`ZLZP[[VLMMLJ[P]LS`MVYTHSVUNZL]LYHSTPSLZHYYH`VM JOYVTH[VNYHWO`OHZHSZVILLU\ZLK
TPJYVWOVULZ 09ZWLJ[YVZJVW`PU]HYPV\ZMVYTZKL[LJ[Z[OLJOLTPJHS
-\Y[OLYKL]LSVWTLU[ZVM[OPZ[LJOUVSVN`OH]LHSSV^LKP[ O`KYVJHYIVUIVUKI`TLHUZVMP[ZHIZVYIHUJLVMSPNO[H[
[VTLHZ\YL[LTWLYH[\YL)V[O]PIYH[PVUHUKSVJHSS`PUJYLHZLK JLY[HPUMYLX\LUJPLZ/V^L]LY^H[LYHSZVZ[YVUNS`HIZVYIZZVTL
[LTWLYH[\YLJHUILZPNUZVMSLHRZ(S[OV\NO[OPZ[LJOUVSVN`PZ MYLX\LUJPLZVMSPNO[PU[OL09IHUK*OLTPJHSZWLJPLZV[OLY[OHU
ILJVTPUNTVYLWYVTPULU[P[JHUVUS`TVUP[VY]LY`SVJHSS`HUKZV VPSZ\JOHZWYVK\J[PVUJOLTPJHSZJHUHSZVWYLZLU[HZPTPSHY
^V\SKOH]L[VILKLWSV`LKVUHSS[OLWPWLSPULZ[OH[^V\SKULLK[V ZPNUH[\YL[VVPS-VY[OPZYLHZVU[OL09ZWLJ[YVTL[LYPZ[`WPJHSS`
ILWYV[LJ[LK JHSPIYH[LK^P[OHZHTWSLVM[OLVPS[OH[P[PZZ\WWVZLK[VKL[LJ[
:PUJL[OLZLUZP[P]P[`VM[OLV]LYHSSWYVJLK\YLPZX\P[LSV^H
The consequences of a leak will be serious JVUJLU[YH[PVUZ[LWPZYLX\PYLK[VYLTV]L[OLVPSMYVT[OL^H[LY
7HY[PJ\SHYS`^OLUWPWLSPULZ[YH]LYZLSHUK[OLYLPZHO\NLSLUN[OVM HUKWYLZLU[P[[V[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[
WPWLSPUL[OH[OHZ[VILTVUP[VYLK;OLJVUZLX\LUJLZVMHSLHR^PSS ;OPZZ`Z[LTPZJSLHYS`MHYMYVTHºZTVRLHSHYT»^OPJO
ILZLYPV\ZHZ[OL`JV\SKJH\ZLWLYTHULU[KHTHNL[VMHYTSHUKVY JHUKL[LJ[PUJYLHZPUNJVUJLU[YH[PVUZVMVPSHUKHSLY[WYVJLZZ
WVSS\[L^H[LYJV\YZLZ;OLZLWPWLSPULZHYLZVTL[PTLZTVUP[VYLKI` LUNPULLYZ[OH[HUPSSLNHSKPZJOHYNLPZVJJ\YYPUN>H[LYX\HSP[`
HKPZ[YPI\[LKZ`Z[LTPU^OPJOWYLZZ\YL[LTWLYH[\YLHUKÅV^HYL Z`Z[LTZ[OH[\ZL\S[YH]PVSL[<=Å\VYLZJLU[HYLZVTL[PTLZ
TLHZ\YLKHUK[OLUHUHS`ZLKH[HJVU[YVSJLU[YL;OLZ`Z[LTJHU \ZLKPU[OPZZP[\H[PVU;OLZL[`WPJHSS`OH]LH<=SHTW[OH[
KL[LJ[SLHRZKV^U[VHIV\[VMÅV^ L_JP[LZHU`VPSWYLZLU[PU[OL^H[LY;OLVPS[OLULTP[Z]PZPISL
/V^L]LYMVYHPUWPWLSPUL[OPZSLHRYH[LYLWYLZLU[ZHSHYNL SPNO[^OPJOPZKL[LJ[LKI`HWOV[VT\S[PWSPLY
X\HU[P[`VMVPS0M[OLSLHRPZSLHRPUNH[HSV^ÅV^YH[LP[JV\SKIL (THQVYWYVISLT^P[OTHRPUNVW[PJHSTLHZ\YLTLU[ZPU
THU`TVU[OZILMVYL[OLWYVISLTPZKPZJV]LYLK0U[OPZ[PTLHU WYVK\JLK^H[LYPZ[OH[P[[LUKZ[VMV\SHU`VW[PJHS^PUKV^Z[OH[
LUVYTV\ZHTV\U[VMKHTHNLJV\SKILKVULWHY[PJ\SHYS`PM[OLWPWL HYLWYLZLU[0M[OL^H[LYJVU[HPUZZHUKP[JHUL]LULYVKL[OLT
PZ\UKLYNYV\UK 0UHU`JHZL[OL^PUKV^Z^PSSZVVUILJVTLJV]LYLK^P[OH
(KPZ[YPI\[LKSLHRKL[LJ[PVUZ`Z[LT^V\SKHWWLHY[VIL[OLVUS` SH`LYVMTPULYHSZJHSLZ;VHKKYLZZ[OPZTVZ[Z`Z[LTZTLHZ\YL
ZVS\[PVU/V^L]LYJVZ[HWWLHYZ[VOH]LWYL]LU[LKKLWSV`TLU[ZV HZ[YLHTVMSPX\PKMHSSPUN[OYV\NO[OLIVK`VM[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[VY
MHY ÅV^PUNHJYVZZH[PS[LKWSH[L;OPZTHRLZ[OLKL[LJ[PVULZZLU[PHSS`
0[OHZSVUNILLURUV^U[OH[VPSVU[OLZ\YMHJLVM[OLZLH^PSS UVUJVU[HJ[I\[[OLZLPUZ[Y\TLU[ZHYLUV[H]HPSHISLMVYZ\IZLH
KHTWKV^U^H]LZ;OLZLNYH]P[`JHWPSSHY`^H]LZHYLYLZWVUZPISL \ZL
MVYIHJRZJH[[LYVMYHKHYZPNUHSZHUKNP]LYPZL[V[OLIHJRNYV\UK ;OLWYPUJPWSLVM<=Å\VYLZJLUJLJHUILL_WSVP[LKPUTHU`
PTHNLJS\[[LYVUHYHKHYZJYLLU0ML]LUH[OPUÄSTVMVPSPZWYLZLU[ ^H`ZMVYSLHRKL[LJ[PVU0[OHZ[OLHK]HU[HNLVMILPUNOPNOS`
P[^PSSYLZ\S[PUHYLK\JLKZJH[[LYPUN^OPJO^PSSYLZ\S[PUHKHYRLY ZWLJPÄJ[VÅ\VYLZJLU[Z\IZ[HUJLZ*Y\KLVPSPZUH[\YHSS`
PTHNL(Z[HUKHYK?VY*IHUKTHYPULYHKHYJHUKL[LJ[ZWPSSZPU[OPZ Å\VYLZJLU[HUKNLULYHSS`[OLSV^LY[OL(70PUKL_SPNO[LY[OL
^H`^OLU[OLPTHNLPZJVYYLJ[S`WYVJLZZLK;OLZ`Z[LTJHUOH]LH Z[YVUNLY[OLYL[\YUZPNUHS;OLHWWSPJH[PVUHUKPTWSLTLU[H[PVUVM
YHUNLVMTPSLZVYZVI\[P[PZHSZVHWWSPJHISL[V\ZLMYVTZWHJL [OPZ[LJOUPX\LOHZILLUZ[\KPLKPUKL[HPS;OPZ^VYROHZZOV^U
(UPTWVY[HU[SPTP[H[PVUPZ[OH[HSNHSISVVTZVYL]LUSHYNL [OH[HZ[YVUNZPNUHSPZLTP[[LKMYVTÄSTZVMVPSVUS`TPU
WH[JOLZVMZLH^LLKJHUOH]LHZPTPSHYKHTWLUPUNLMMLJ[[OH[ [OPJRULZZHUK[OH[[OPZZPNUHSJHUILZLWHYH[LKMYVT[OL<=
YLZ\S[ZPUHKHYRPTHNL+L[LYTPUPUN^OH[HKHYRWH[JOHJ[\HSS` L_JP[H[PVUNP]PUNL_JLSSLU[ZLUZP[P]P[`(SZV\ZPUNZVSPKZ[H[L
PZNLULYHSS`YLX\PYLZ[OH[HWH[YVSIVH[NVLZV\[[VKYH^HZHTWSL SPNO[ZV\YJLZHUKKL[LJ[VYZP[^HZWVZZPISL[VYLK\JL[OLWV^LY
MYVT[OLZ\YMHJLVM[OLZLHHUKZLLPMP[JVU[HPUZVPS;OLIVH[ZHYL JVUZ\TW[PVUVM[OLZ`Z[LTHUKYLTV]L[OLULLKMVYYLN\SHY
ZVTL[PTLZLX\PWWLK^P[O<=SPNO[Z^OPJOTHRL[OLVPSÅ\VYLZJL! SHTWYLWSHJLTLU[
[OPZ[LJOUPX\LPZ\ZLM\SI\[H[WYLZLU[P[JHUVUS`IL\ZLKH[ZOVY[ -VYPUZ[HUJLHÅ\VYLZJLUJLKL[LJ[VYJV\SKTHRLH
YHUNLZ JVU]LUPLU[ºZTVRLHSHYT»[OH[JV\SKILÄ[[LKVUH^LH[OLYI\V`
6PSOHZHKPMMLYLU[LTPZZP]P[`[V^H[LYHUK^PSSWYLZLU[H H[ZLH:PUJL[OL[LJOUPX\LJHUILVW[PTPZLK[V^VYRH[YHUNLP[
KPMMLYLU[PUMYHYLK09ZWLJ[Y\T-\Y[OLYVPS^PSSHIZVYITVYL JV\SKRLLWHU`Z\ZJLW[PISLJVTWVULU[ZH^H`MYVT[OLZ\YMHJL
LULYN`MYVT[OLZ\UHUKILJVTLOV[[LY[OHU[OL^H[LYK\YPUN[OL VM[OL^H[LY0[^V\SK[OLUJVUZ[HU[S`TVUP[VYMVYVPSHWWLHYPUN
KH`;OPZTLHUZ[OH[[OPJRULZZLZVMVPSMYVT[VT^PSSIL (UL[^VYRVM[OLZLKL]PJLZJV\SK[OLUZLY]LHZHULHYS`^HYUPUN
KL[LJ[HISLI`[OLYTHS09PTHNPUN Z`Z[LT[VHSLY[^OLUVPSPZTV]PUNHZOVYLHUK[OYLH[LUPUN
9LTV[L[OLYTHSPTHNPUNMYVTHPYJYHM[OHZILLUVMPU[LYLZ[ ILHJOLZHUKZLHIPYKZ
WHY[PJ\SHYS`K\YPUNJSLHU\WVWLYH[PVUZ([OLYTHSJHTLYHPZLHZ` ;OPZZHTLJVUÄN\YH[PVUJV\SKHSZVILHWWSPLK[VH
[VWYVJ\YLHUK\ZL/V^L]LYP[ZZ\JJLZZ^PSSKLWLUKVU[OL WYVK\J[PVUWSH[MVYT3LHRZVJJ\YYPUNZ\IZLHHYLZVTL[PTLZ
^LH[OLYHUKSVJHSJVUKP[PVUZ(SZVIV[OWHY[PJ\SHYS`[OPUHUK[OPJR VUS`ZWV[[LK^OLUH]PZPISLZSPJRHWWLHYZVU[OLZ\YMHJL;OPZ
ZSPJRZ^PSSILKPMÄJ\S[[VKL[LJ[ZPUJL[OL`WYLZLU[SP[[SLJVU[YHZ[ TH`UV[VJJ\YH[UPNO[VYPUYV\NOJVUKP[PVUZJVUZLX\LU[S`HU
-\Y[OLY[OLYLHYLV[OLYZ\IZ[HUJLZZ\JOHZHSNHSISVVTZ[OH[JHU H\[VTH[PJKL[LJ[VYJHUVUS`ILOLSWM\SOLYL
NP]LHZPTPSHYZPNUH[\YL
Ideally, problems with subsea infrastructure would
A fluorescence detector could make a be found at source
convenient smoke alarm :WV[[PUNSLHRZH[[OLZ\YMHJLPZOLSWM\SI\[PKLHSS`WYVISLTZ^P[O
<UKLY6:7(9VWLYH[VYZHYLUV[HSSV^LK[VKPZJOHYNL^H[LY Z\IZLHPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YL^V\SKILMV\UKH[ZV\YJL0UMHJ[Z\JO
JVU[HPUPUNTVYL[OHUWWTVMVPSVUH]LYHNL;OPZPZ[`WPJHSS` KL[LJ[PVUZ`Z[LTZHYLYLJVTTLUKLKPU[OL5VY^LNPHUZLJ[VY
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
ENGINEERED
PREVENTION AND INTERVENTION
A recognized leader in well control, Cudd Well Control
SURYLGHV¿UVWFODVVHQJLQHHULQJDQGFULWLFDOZHOOLQWHUYHQWLRQ
services to identify risks and design solutions that reduce
QRQSURGXFWLYHWLPHVDYLQJ\RXYDOXDEOHWLPHDQGUHVRXUFHV
Blowout Specialists
+LJK3UHVVXUH6QXEELQJDQG&RLOHG7XELQJ
Freeze Operations
Engineering Services
Rig Inspections
5HOLHI:HOO3ODQQLQJ
Kick Modeling
'ULOOLQJ3ODQ5HYLHZV
%ORZRXW&RQWLQJHQF\3ODQV
5HJXODWRU\&RPSOLDQFH9HULILFDWLRQ
www.cuddwellcontrol.com
+1.713.849.2769
/V^L]LYHYLJLU[YLWVY[Z\NNLZ[LK[OH[[OLJ\YYLU[S`L_PZ[PUN
Z`Z[LTZ^LYLUV[YLSPHISLLUV\NOMVYZ\IZLHKLWSV`TLU[
Join us!
0UWHY[PJ\SHYYLWVY[LK[YPNNLYPUNVMMHSZLHSHYTZ^HZWHY[PJ\SHYS`
WYVISLTH[PJHZP[SLHKZ[V[OLVWLYH[VYZPNUVYPUNM\Y[OLY
^HYUPUNZ
;OPZWYVISLTOHZILLUHKKYLZZLKPUZL]LYHS^H`ZILMVYL
*HWHJP[P]LNH\NLZSVVRMVY[OLKPMMLYLUJLPU[OLKPLSLJ[YPJ
JVUZ[HU[IL[^LLUVPSHUK^H[LY^OPJOTHRLZHJOHUNLPU
JHWHJP[HUJL^OLUVPSLU[LYZ[OLZLUZVY;OLJOLTPJHSWYVWLY[PLZ
VMVPSOH]LHSZVILLUZLUZLKI`THZZZWLJ[YVTL[Y`HUK09
HIZVYIHUJLTLHZ\YLTLU[Z/V^L]LYIV[OJOLTPJHS[LJOUPX\LZ
YLS`VUHºKY`»ZLUZVYPU[OH[[OLO`KYVJHYIVUZOH]L[VKPMM\ZL
[OYV\NOHTLTIYHUL[VILZLUZLK;OL[LJOUVSVN`[VWYVK\JL
follow HWLYTLHISLTLTIYHUL[OH[JHU^P[OZ[HUK[OLO`KYVZ[H[PJ
WYLZZ\YLPZUV[JVTTVUWSHJLI\[OHZILLUKL]LSVWLK;OLZL
us on twitter WYVK\J[ZHYLJOHYHJ[LYPZLKI`HZSV^YLZWVUZL[PTLHUK[OL`
OH]L[V^HP[MVYVPSTVSLJ\SLZ[VYLHJO[OLZLUZVY;OPZTLHUZ
[OH[[OL`JHUVUS`ZLUZLSVJHSS`
0[^V\SKILPU[LYLZ[PUN[V[Y`HUKHWWS`09TLHZ\YLTLU[Z
V]LYHSVUNLYZJHSL[OH[^H`HKL[LJ[VYJV\SKZ\Y]L`H^PKL
HYLH/V^L]LY[OL^H]LSLUN[OZULJLZZHY`[VKL[LJ[HUVPS^LSS
KVUV[WHZZ[OYV\NO^H[LYMVYTVYL[OHUHML^TPSSPTL[YLZ
(NHPUÅ\VYLZJLUJL[LJOUVSVN`PZHWWYVWYPH[LOLYL3PNO[H[[OL
@energy_global IS\LLUKVM[OL]PZPISLZWLJ[Y\TWHZZLZ^LSS[OYV\NOZLH^H[LY
[OLYL[\YULKZPNUHSH[SVUNLY^H]LSLUN[OZPZHSZV^P[OPU[OL
^LSSRUV^U[YHUZTPZZPVU^PUKV^PU[OLNYLLU;\YIPKP[`TH`IL
HJOHSSLUNLHZP[^PSSJH\ZL[OLL_JP[H[PVUSPNO[[VILYL[\YULK[V
[OLZLUZVY;OPZSPNO[ULLKZ[VILYLQLJ[LKI`HZ\P[HISLÄS[LY!
like [OLZLKLZPNUZOH]LILLUZ\JJLZZM\SS`VW[PTPZLKHJYVZZZL]LYHS
THYRL[ZHUKOH]LZOV^U^OH[JHUILHJOPL]LK
us on facebook Conclusions
;OLÄLSKVMTHYPULSLHRKL[LJ[PVUPZJVTWSL_^P[OJVTWL[PUN
WYHJ[PJHSZJPLU[PÄJHUKSLNHSJVUZ[YHPU[Z;OLYLPZH]HYPL[`VM
[LJOUPX\LZHWWSPJHISL[V[OPZYHUNLVMWYVISLTZ/V^L]LY[OL
ILZ[[LJOUPX\LMVYHSHIVYH[VY`^PSSUV[ILZ\P[HISLMVYHOHYZO
LU]PYVUTLU[VYHSVUN[LYTKLWSV`TLU[¶VYP[TH`UV[L]LU
Energy Global THRLHUHWWYVWYPH[LTLHZ\YLTLU[
-S\VYLZJLUJLKL[LJ[PVUPZHWV^LYM\SWLYOHWZ
\UKLYL_WSVP[LK[LJOUPX\LPU[OH[P[PZZWLJPÄJHUKJHUILTHKL
ZLUZP[P]LLUV\NO[VIL\ZLM\S/V^L]LYMVYYLHS^VYSKWYVISLTZ
P[^PSSOH]L[VILJVTIPULK^P[OV[OLY[LJOUPX\LZ(JVTIPUH[PVU
join VMTLHZ\YLTLU[WYPUJPWSLZJHUUV[VUS`THRL[OLZ`Z[LTTVYL
YVI\Z[HNHPUZ[MHPS\YLI\[HSZVNP]LHYLK\JLKU\TILYVMMHSZL
HSHYTZ*HTIYPKNL*VUZ\S[HU[ZOH]L\ZLKHYHUNLVM[LJOUPX\LZ
us on LinkedIn
™
MVYJVTIPUPUNT\S[PWSLTLHZ\YLTLU[Z[VKLSP]LYYVI\Z[ZVS\[PVUZ
MVYZPTPSHYJOHSSLUNLZHJYVZZTHU`KPMMLYLU[PUK\Z[YPLZ
;OLPUJYLHZLPUYLN\SH[PVUJVTIPULK^P[O[OL[LJOUVSVN`
[VNHPUUL^SPMLMYVTVSKÄLSKZ^PSSVUS`PUJYLHZL[OLULLKMVY
HKL[LJ[PVUZ`Z[LT[OH[PZYVI\Z[ZLUZP[P]LHUKJVZ[LMMLJ[P]L
;OLYLPZOV^L]LYWV[LU[PHS[VVW[PTPZL[OLZLSLJ[PVUHUK
References
0UZPKL*SPTH[L5L^Zº-L^6PS7PWLSPUL:WPSSZ+L[LJ[LKI`4\JO;V\[LK
;LJOUVSVN`»:LW[
+5=9LJVTTLUKLK7YHJ[PJL+5=97-º0U[LNYP[`4HUHNLTLU[VM
:\IZLH7PWLSPULZ»
+5=9LJVTTLUKLK7YHJ[PJL+5=97-º:LSLJ[PVUHUK<ZLVM
:\IZLH3LHR+L[LJ[PVU:`Z[LTZ»
6PS:WPSS9LTV[L:LUZPUN¶H9L]PL^4LY]-PUNHZ
S
PUJL[OL ZWYVK\J[PVUVMTL[OHULMYVTJVHSILKZ [OH[VULVM[OLJOHSSLUNLZVM*)4PZ[VKL]LSVW[OLYLZV\YJL
OHZILJVTLHUPUJYLHZPUNS`ZV\NO[HM[LYYL]LU\LMVYNHZ ^P[OPU[OLKLTHUKZVM]LY`TVKLZ[LJVUVTPJZ(STVZ[HSS
JVTWHUPLZK\L[V[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMWYVÄ[HISLWYVK\J[PVU UH[\YHSS`VJJ\YYPUNJVHSZLHTZHYL^H[LY^L[>P[OUH[\YHSSV^
L]LUH[SV^YLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLZ;OLZLWYLZZ\YLZHYL YLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLZHY[PÄJPHSSPM[PZULJLZZHY`[VYLTV]L[OL
ZVTL[PTLZZPNUPÄJHU[S`SV^LY[OHU[OLLJVUVTPJHIHUKVUTLU[ ^H[LYMYVT[OL^LSSHUKHSSV^TL[OHUL[VÅV^[V[OLZ\YMHJL
WYLZZ\YLMVYHJVU]LU[PVUHSNHZYLZLY]VPY*VHSILKTL[OHUL ;OLM\UKHTLU[HSPZZ\LYL]VS]LZHYV\UKOV^[V\USVHK[OL
*)4PZYLJV]LYLKMYVTJVHSZLHTZHUKPZJVTWVZLKVM ^H[LYHUKKPZWVZLVMP[PUHULJVUVTPJHSTHUULY;OLZL^LSSZ
]PY[\HSS`TL[OHUL^OPJOPZHJSLHULYI\YUPUNNHZ[OHU OH]LWYV]LKHI\UKHU[PU5VY[OHUK:V\[O(TLYPJH(ZPH(MYPJH
JVU]LU[PVUHSNHZ;OYV\NOL_WLYPLUJL2<+<OHZKPZJV]LYLK HUK(\Z[YHSPH;OPZHY[PJSL^PSSKL[HPS[OL\ZLVM7*7\TWZPU
*)4HWWSPJH[PVUZI`L_WSHPUPUN[OLSHYNLYHUNLVMW\TWPUN LUZ\YLZ[OH[HM[LYHWYLKL[LYTPULKKL^H[LYPUNWLYPVKTL[OHUL
JHWHJP[PLZHIPSP[`[VOHUKSLZVSPKZJVHSÄULZHUKZHUKHZ^LSS ^PSSMYLLS`ÅV^[V[OLZ\YMHJL\U[PSPUP[PHSYLJV]LYHISLYLZLY]LZ
HZNHZLV\ZÅ\PKZHUK[OLSV^LYL_WLJ[LKJVZ[Z HYLKLWSL[LK(Z*)4PZJVTWYPZLKTHPUS`VM*/[OLYLZ\S[Z
HYLJSLHULYO`KYVJHYIVUJVTI\Z[PVU[OHUJVU]LU[PVUHSUH[\YHS
Advantages of CBM NHZ^OPJOJHUJVU[HPUHZ\IZ[HU[PHSWLYJLU[HNLVMPTW\YP[PLZ
>OLU^H[LYPZYLSLHZLKMYVT[OLJVHS[OLWYLZZ\YLPZYLK\JLK ;OLYLMVYL\ZPUNTL[OHULMVYM\LSNHZ^PSSYLZ\S[PUTVYLLMÄJPLU[
HUKNHZÅV^Z[OV\NO[OLJSLH[Z>OLUH^LSSPZÄYZ[KYPSSLK O`KYVJHYIVUJVTI\Z[PVUHUKSLZZJHYIVUI\PSK\WPULUNPULZ
PU[VHJVHSZLHTNHZKVLZUV[UVYTHSS`ÅV^[V[OLZ\YMHJL
>H[LYPZW\TWLKMYVT[OL^LSSKL^H[LYPUN^P[ONHZÅV^PUN Difficulties
HM[LY^HYK0[OHZILLUMV\UK[OH[^H[LYWYVK\J[PVUKLJSPULZHZ *)4^LSSZULLK[VILTLJOHUPJHSS`MYHJ[\YLKPUVYKLY[VJYLH[L
NHZWYVK\J[PVUPUJYLHZLZ([`WPJHSWYVK\J[PVUJ\Y]LMVYH*)4 HWLYTLHIPSP[`JOHUULSIL[^LLU[OLJSLH[Z;OLWYVWWHU[
^LSSPZZOV^UPU-PN\YL TH[LYPHS\ZLKPU[OLZLMYHJ[\YLZPZTVZ[VM[LUZHUK6]LY[PTL
;VZ\TTHYPZLPUH*)4^LSS\USPRL[OH[VMHJVU]LU[PVUHS HWVY[PVUVM[OPZZHUK^PSSÅV^IHJRPU[V[OL^LSSHUKVM[LUNL[
NHZ^LSS[OL^H[LYWYVK\J[PVUKLJYLHZLZV]LY[PTL;OPZY\SL W\SSLKPU[V[OLW\TWPUNZ`Z[LT*VHSÄULZMYVT[OLMVYTH[PVU
TH`HSZVHMMLJ[[OL7*7\TWZ`Z[LT0UHKKP[PVU[OLYLPZ
VM[LUHWYLZLUJLVMPYVUZ\SÄKLZ-L:6HSVUN^P[O[OLJVHS
7\TWPUNSV^]VS\TLZTHRLZP[KPMÄJ\S[[VHJOPL]LHUHKLX\H[L
Å\PK]LSVJP[`[VIYPUN[OLZLZVSPKZ[VZ\YMHJL^OPJO^PSSJH\ZL
[OLZVSPKZ[VI\PSK\WPUVYHIV]L[OL7*7\TWHUKTH`YLZ\S[
PU[VYX\LPZZ\LZ
4VZ[VM[LUSV^NHZWYLZZ\YLPZWYLZLU[PU*)4^LSSZ"
[OLYLMVYLP[PZLZZLU[PHS[VTHPU[HPUHÅ\PKSL]LSH[ULHYW\TWLK
VMMJVUKP[PVUZ^P[OV\[Z[HY]PUN[OLW\TW4L[OHUL^PSS[OLUIL
HSSV^LK[VLZJHWLV\[VM[OLMVYTH[PVUHUK\W[OL^LSSIVYL
0M[OLWLYMVYH[PVUZHYLL_WVZLK[OLYLPZHSZVHKHUNLYVMZJHSL
MVYTH[PVUHUKKLZ[HIPSPZH[PVUVMMYHNPSLJVHSZLHTZ4VYLV]LY
^P[O[OLWYLZLUJLVMNHZHKKP[PVUHSMYPJ[PVUPZJYLH[LKK\L[V
[OLSHJRVMS\IYPJH[PVU.HZPUZPKL[OLW\TW^PSSHSZVJVTWYLZZ
Figure 1. Generalised production profile. HUKJH\ZLHKKP[PVUHSOLH[^OPJOJHUSLHK[V[OLW\TW»Z
WYLTH[\YLMHPS\YL
-\Y[OLYTVYLJVYYVZPVUVMKV^UOVSLHUKZ\YMHJLLX\PWTLU[
Table 1. Trouble shooting PZHJOHSSLUNL*VTWH[PIPSP[`[LZ[Z^P[OJVYYVZPVUPUOPIP[PUN
The following table details some general problems related to PCPs in JOLTPJHSZT\Z[ILJVTWSL[LKPUVYKLY[VH]VPKKHTHNL[V[OL
CBM applications. W\TWMVYTH[PVUVYJVTWVULU[Z)H[JOTP_PUNIHJ[LYPJPKLZHYL
Problem Possible Causes Suggested Solutions HSZVULJLZZHY`PM[OLYLPZ^H[LYWYLZLU[PU[OL^LSS6UJL[OL
Production ^H[LYPZIYV\NO[[VZ\YMHJLP[PZKPZWVZLKVMPUHTHUULYÄ[[PUN
Low fluid level
productivity
Reduce pumping speed.
[OL^H[LYX\HSP[`PUJS\KPUNHNYPJ\S[\YL\ZLZPYYPNH[PVUHUKMVY
estimates
^H[LYPUNZ[VJRYP]LYZHUKJYLLRZVYPUQLJ[LKPU[VHKPZWVZHS
incorrect.
^LSS
Inspect tubing lin for gas
Gas through
Low efficiency with fluid. Lower intake of
pump.
pump if possible. Design recommendations
Plugged pump
Low efficiency Flush-by.
intake. Well equipment selection
Close the tubing valve on 0U*)4^LSSZP[PZJY\JPHS[VKYPSS[VHKLW[OILULH[O[OLWH`
surface. If pressure does aVULPUVYKLY[VPUZ[HSS[OLW\TWILSV^[OLWLYMVYH[PVUZ;OPZ
Low efficiency Hole in tubing. not increase. Pull tubing,
WVZP[PVUPUNLUHISLZMYLLNHZ[VIYLHRV\[VM[OLZVS\[PVUHUK
inspect, replace damaged
portion, rerun pump. [YH]LS\W[OL[\IPUNJHZPUNHUU\S\Z^OPSL[OLÅ\PKPZSPM[LK
Take fluid level. If low
I`[OLW\TW-VYZTHSS]VS\TLZP[PZYLJVTTLUKLK[V\ZL
fluid level, reduce pump PUJHZPUN^OPJOHSSV^ZMVYHKP]LYZLW\TWZLSLJ[PVUHUK
Low efficiency Well pumped off.
speed, downsize pump if SHYNLY[\IPUNJHZPUNHUU\S\Z[VHPKPUNHZZLWHYH[PVU6USHYNLY
needed.
]VS\TL^LSSZHPUJHZPUNZOV\SKIL\ZLK-VYZTHSS]VS\TL
Gas through Lower PCP intake or add
High GLR W\TWPUNILSV^TKH`\ZPUNPUYVKZHUKPU[\IPUN
pump. gas anchor.
PZZ\NNLZ[LK
Lower PCP intake or add
Uneven flow High GLR.
gas anchor.
;OLZLYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZHSSV^HZTHSSJYVZZZLJ[PVUHS
HYLH[VWYVK\JLHOPNOHTV\U[VMÅ\PK]LSVJP[`;OLOPNOLY[OL
Rotor contacting Lift up rod string 6 in.
Torque fluctuations
tag bar. with crane of flush-by rig.
Å\PK]LSVJP[`[OLTVYLZVSPKZHYLIYV\NO[[VZ\YMHJLPUZ[LHK
VMZL[[SPUNVU[OLW\TW»ZKPZJOHYNL:WPU[OYV\NOJLU[YHSPZLYZ
Gas through Lower PCP intake or add
Torque fluctuations
pump. gas anchor. HYLULJLZZHY`MVY[OLYVKZ[VYLK\JL[\IPUN^LHY^P[O[^V
WLYYVKILPUN[OLZ[HUKHYKWYHJ[PJL-VYOPNOLY]VS\TL
Reduce pump speed,
Well pumping W\TWPUNPU[VPU[\IPUNHUKPU[VPUYVKZHYL
Torque fluctuations downsize pump if
off.
needed. YLJVTTLUKLK
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
;VYLK\JL[OLJOHUJLVMY\UUPUN[OLW\TWKY`THU` LJJLU[YPJTV[PVUH[[OLYV[VYOLHK>P[O[OLWYLZLUJLVMNHZ
JVTWHUPLZOH]LOHKZ\JJLZZ^P[OKV^UOVSLWYLZZ\YLZLUZVYZ PU[OL^LSSIVYLP[PZJY\JPHS[VSHUK[OLPU[HRLVM[OLW\TW
)`TVUP[VYPUNWYLZZ\YLP[PZWVZZPISL[VKL[LYTPULPM[OLYLPZH ILSV^[OLWLYMVYH[PVUZ;OPZWYVJLZZHSSV^ZNHZ[VIYLHRV\[VM
SVZZVMPUÅV^[V[OLW\TW;OLZLZLUZVYZHYLPUZ[HSSLKVU[OL [OLMVYTH[PVUHUK[YH]LS\W[OL[\IPUNJHZPUNHUU\S\ZHUKUV[
LUKVM[OL[\IPUN [OYV\NO[OLW\TW0[PZHSZVULJLZZHY`[VSLH]LLUV\NOJLSSHY[V
HSSV^MVY[OLJVSSLJ[PVUVMZVSPKZ
Pump selection (M[WVU`YVKPZPUZ[HSSLKHIV]L[OLYV[VY7VU`YVKZSLZZ
7*7\TWZ`Z[LTZSPM[HYHUNLVM]VS\TLZ\W[VTKH` [OHUM[SVUNHYLTVYLYPNPKHUKJH\ZLHKKP[PVUHSZ[YLZZ[V
=VS\TLZVMÅ\PKPU[OLJVHSILK^LSSZHYL]HYPLK[OYV\NOV\[ [OLYV[VYOLHK^OPJOJHUSLHK[VIYVRLUYV[VYZ<ZPUNHM[
[OLPUK\Z[Y`0[PZLZZLU[PHS[VJVTWSL[LWYVWLY[LZ[PUNVM^H[LY YVKHIV]L[OLYV[VYLUHISLZTVYLTV]LTLU[PU[OLZ\JRLYYVK
WYVK\J[PVU]VS\TLZI`^H`VMZ^HIIPUNVYKYPSSZ[LT[LZ[PUN Z[YPUNYLZ\S[PUNPUH^OPWWPUNTV[PVU;OPZTV[PVUPZYLMLYYLK
PUVYKLY[VHJJ\YH[LS`Ä[LHJOW\TW[V[OL^LSS;OPZWYVJLZZ [VHZHºZRPWWPUNYVWLLMMLJ[»ILJH\ZLVM[OLTV]LTLU[VM[OL
HPKZPUTHPU[HPUPUNHÅ\PKSL]LSZSPNO[S`HIV]L[OLPU[HRLVM[OL Z\JRLYYVK
W\TW0M[OLW\TW»ZKPZWSHJLTLU[PZ[VVOPNO[OLYLPZHKHUNLY
VMW\TWPUNVMM[OL^LSS*VU]LYZLS`PM[OLW\TW»ZKPZWSHJLTLU[ Operation practices
PZ[VVSV^Å\PKSL]LS^PSSYLTHPUOPNOTHRPUN[OLNHZWYLZZ\YL <WVUZ[HY[\WVMHUL^^LSSHZ[HY[PUNYH[LZWLLKVM
PUJHWHISLVMV]LYJVTPUN[OLO`KYVZ[H[PJWYLZZ\YLL_LY[LKI` HWWYV_PTH[LS`974PZZ\NNLZ[LK\U[PSL_HJ[^H[LYPUÅV^
[OL^H[LYJVS\TU"[OLYLMVYLUV[HSSV^PUN[OLTL[OHUL[VJVTL HTV\U[ZHYLKL[LYTPULK;OLPKLHS974YHUNLVMH*)4
[VZ\YMHJL(ZVM[LSHZ[VTLYZOV\SKIL\ZLK^OPJONYLH[S` HWWSPJH[PVUPZ[V9740M[OLÅ\PKSL]LSPZUV[KYVWWPUN
YLK\JLZYV[VY^LHYHUKZOV^ZSP[[SLKLMVYTH[PVUHZHYLZ\S[VM HUPUJYLHZLVMUVTVYL[OHU974WLYKH`PZYLJVTTLUKLK
[OLNHZ ;OPZYHUNLHSZVZSV^Z[OLWYLZZ\YLKYVWHJYVZZ[OLMVYTH[PVU
0M[OLWYLZZ\YLKYVWZ[VVX\PJRS`JVHSHUKZHUKJV\SKIL
Surface equipment WYLTH[\YLS`IYV\NO[PU[V[OL^LSSIVYLHUKKHTHNL[OL
MVYTH[PVUJH\ZPUN\UULJLZZHY`^LHYVU[OLW\TW9LJVYKPUN
Electric [OLÅ\PKSL]LS\WVUZ[HY[\WHUKL]LY`Z\IZLX\LU[OYWLYPVK
,SLJ[YPJWV^LYPZ\ZLK^OLUHKPYLJ[KYP]LZOLH]LVYZOLH]L ^PSSHPKPU[OLKL[LYTPUH[PVUVM[OLYLX\PYLK974VM[OLW\TW
Z`Z[LTPZPUZ[HSSLK(TV[VYZOLH]L^PSSULLK[VILJOHUNLK >OLUY\UUPUN[OL^LSSH[ULHYW\TWLKVMMJVUKP[PVUZP[PZ
[VZSV^KV^UVYZWLLK\W[OL^LSS(KPYLJ[KYP]LZ`Z[LTPZ LZZLU[PHS[VÄUK[OLLX\PSPIYP\TWVPU[IL[^LLU[OLPUÅV^VM[OL
\ZLK^P[OH=-+HSSV^PUN[OLVWLYH[VYVM[OL^LSS[VHKQ\Z[[OL YLZLY]VPYHUKW\TWPUNYH[LVM[OL7*7\TW0MHM[LY[OLPUP[PHS
974VM[OLKYP]LZ[YPUN^P[OV\[JOHUNPUN[OLTV[VYZOLH]L OYZP[PZKPZJV]LYLK[OH[[OL^LSSPZW\TWLKVMM[OLW\TW
-YVT[OLVUZL[KH[HSVNNPUNLZWLJPHSS`VM[OL[VYX\LPZOPNOS` ZOV\SKILZSV^LKPTTLKPH[LS`+\L[VHSHJRVMS\IYPJH[PVU^P[O
YLJVTTLUKLKPUVYKLY[VKL[LYTPULHU`WYVISLTZLHYS`VUPU [OLWYLZLUJLVM^H[LYHUKNHZP[PZNLULYHSS`UV[YLJVTTLUKLK
[OLVWLYH[PVU [VZSV^H7*7\TWZ`Z[LTILSV^¶974([YH[LZ
ILSV^[OPZ[OLMYPJ[PVUPU[OLW\TWPZ[VVOPNOHUKHºZSPWZ[PJR»
Hydraulic LMMLJ[TH`VJJ\YWVZZPIS`YLZ\S[PUNPUHIYVRLUYV[VY0MP[PZ
0UHO`KYH\SPJHSS`KYP]LUZ`Z[LT[OLZWLLKVM[OLKYP]LOLHK ULJLZZHY`[VY\UH[HYH[LILSV^¶974KV^UZPaPUN
PZJVU[YVSSLKI`[OLÅV^VMO`KYH\SPJÅ\PK0[PZJVTTVUS` [OLW\TWPZYLX\PYLK
JVU[YVSSLKI`HUHKQ\Z[TLU[ZJYL^VU[OLZ^HZOWSH[LVYI`H
JVU[YVS]HS]LVUHSVHKZLUZPUNZ`Z[LT(KH[HSVNNLYTH`HSZV Note
ILPUZ[HSSLKVUHO`KYH\SPJ\UP[[VYLJVYKPUMVYTH[PVUHUKZLY]L 7SLHZLUV[L[OPZ[YV\ISLZOVV[PUNN\PKLZOV^JHZLZWV[LU[PHS
HZHW\TWVMMJVU[YVSSLY WYVISLTZ^P[ONLULYHSZVS\[PVUZ[OH[TPNO[UV[ILJVYYLJ[MVY
ZWLJPÄJHWWSPJH[PVUZ;VWYVWLYS`L]HS\H[L`V\Y\UPX\L^LSS
Installation recommendations ZP[\H[PVUWSLHZLZLLRN\PKHUJLMYVTHWYVMLZZPVUHS7*7\TW
;OLZ[H[VYY\UZVU[OLIV[[VTVM[OL[\IPUN6U[OL[VWVM[OL [LJOUPJHSZWLJPHSPZ[;V]PL^[OLJVTWSL[L[YV\ISLZOVV[PUNJOHY[
Z[H[VYHSHYNLY[YHUZP[PVUVYW\WQVPU[PZPUZ[HSSLK[VHSSV^MVY ]PZP[^^^R\K\W\TWJVTYLZV\YJLZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
w w w . e n e r g y g l o b a l . c o m / e v eJulyn 2013
ts
Evan Sheline,
ESP Completion Technologies,
USA, shows how a new
approach helps solve
the problems caused by
weaknesses in the standard
ESP bypass system (Y-tool)
design.
A
Y[PMPJPHSSPM[OHZILJVTLVULVM[OLMHZ[LZ[
NYV^PUNZLNTLU[ZVM[OLVPSPUK\Z[Y`HZMSV^PUN
^LSSZSVZLYLZLY]VPYWYLZZ\YLHUKVWLYH[VYZ
VW[[VPUZ[HSS]HYPV\ZHY[PMPJPHSSPM[TL[OVKZ[VTHPU[HPU
VYPUJYLHZLWYVK\J[PVU6WLYH[VYZ[`WPJHSS`ZLSLJ[
LSLJ[YPJHSZ\ITLYZPISLW\TWZ,:7MVYOPNOMSV^YH[L
^LSSZILJH\ZL[OPZTL[OVKWYV]PKLZMSL_PIPSP[`HUK
YLSPHIPSP[`PU[OLTVZ[JOHSSLUNPUN^LSSLU]PYVUTLU[Z
*\YYLU[S`[OLYLHYLTVYL[OHU,:7ZPUZ[HSSLK
^VYSK^PKLHUKHS[OV\NO[OLTHQVYP[`HYLZPTWSL
VULW\TWPUZ[HSSH[PVUZ[OLYLPZHNYV^PUNULLK[V
PUZ[HSS[HUKLTW\TWZVY[VHJJLZZ[OL^LSSIVYLILSV^
[OL,:7;OLSH[[LYYLX\PYLHU,:7I`WHZZZ`Z[LT"
HWWYV_PTH[LS`VM[OLPUZ[HSSLKWVW\SH[PVU\[PSPZL
[OPZHWWYVHJO
,:7I`WHZZZ`Z[LTZVY@[VVSZHYL [OPZKYHTH[PJHSS`PUJYLHZLZ[OLJVZ[V]LY[YHKP[PVUHS
X\PJRS`ILJVTPUNHULZZLU[PHSWPLJL JHZ[PUNVYMVYNPUN;OLTVS[LUTL[HS\ZLKPUJHZ[PUNMVYTZ
VMLX\PWTLU[PU,:7PUZ[HSSZ)LPUN ºNYHPUZ»K\YPUN[OLJVVSPUNWYVJLZZ:VSPKPMPJH[PVUVM[OPZ
HISL[VHJJLZZ[OLYLZLY]VPYILSV^ TVS[LUTL[HSVJJ\YZPU[^VZ[LWZ!U\JSLH[PVUHUKJY`Z[HS
[OL,:7^P[OV\[[OLHKKLKJVZ[VMH NYV^[O+\YPUNU\JSLH[PVUZVSPKWHY[PJSLZMVYTPU[OL
^VYRV]LYZH]LZ[PTLHUKYLK\JLZ[OL SPX\PKTL[HS;OLUMYVT[OLZLU\JSLPHJY`Z[HSZ[Y\J[\YL
YPZRVMYLZLY]VPYMVYTH[PVUKHTHNL NYV^Z[OYV\NOV\[[OLTV\SKLKWHY[;OLWYVJLZZJHUIL
HZZVJPH[LK^P[ORPSSPUN[OL^LSSK\YPUN PTWYV]LKI`JVU[YVSSPUNJVVSPUNYH[LZVYI`PUVJ\SH[PVU
^VYRV]LYVWLYH[PVUZ;OLHIPSP[`[V HKKPUNPTW\YP[PLZ[VPUK\JLU\JSLH[PVUI\[[OPZVUS`
VI[HPUK`UHTPJWYVK\JPUNWYLZZ\YL PTWYV]LZJVHYZLNYHPULKJHZ[PUNZ[VMPULNYHPULK
HUKMSV^YH[LYLZLY]VPYKH[H^OPSL[OL JHZ[PUNZ
,:7PZWYVK\JPUNHSZVHSSV^ZLUNPULLYZ ;OLJHZ[TL[HSP[ZLSMPZZ[PSSZ[YVUNI\[[OLWYLZLUJL
[VPUJYLHZLYLZLY]VPYWLYMVYTHUJL0M VM[OLZLNYHPUZTLHUZ[OH[[OLYLPZZVTLWVYVZP[`PU[OL
ULLKLKHU,:7I`WHZZZ`Z[LTJHUHSZV TL[HS^OPJOKLJYLHZLZ[OLZ[YLUN[OVM[OLWHY[HZH
IL\ZLK[VPUZ[HSS[^V,:7ZPU[OLZHTL ^OVSL(UV[OLYKHUNLYVMJHZ[PUNPZOV[[LHYPUNVYOV[
^LSSIVYLMVYWYVK\J[PVUYLK\UKHUJ`VY JYHJRPUN;OPZWOLUVTLUVUVJJ\YZ^OLUHUPYYL]LYZPISL
[VHSSV^ZLWHYH[LW\TWPUNMSV^YLNPTLZ MHPS\YLJYHJRMVYTZPU[OLZ[PSSZLTPZVSPKJHZ[PUNVM[LU
^OLUSVJHSYLN\SH[PVUZYLX\PYLP[ JH\ZLKI`[OLPUHKLX\H[LJVTWLUZH[PVUVMZVSPKPMPJH[PVU
ZOYPURHNLI`TLS[MSV^PU[OLWYLZLUJLVM[OLYTHS
Improving a classic Z[YLZZLZ
;OL@[VVS,:7I`WHZZZ`Z[LTPZHZHML ;OLPTHNLZPU-PN\YL^LYL[HRLUK\YPUNH[LHYKV^U
HUKWYV]LU[LJOUVSVN`I\[JHUP[IL VMHMHPSLKZ`Z[LT;OLJHZ[PUNOHK^LHRZWV[Z[OH[
PTWYV]LK& JYHJRLK^OLUW\[PU[V^LSSJVUKP[PVUZ:PUJL[OLLU[PYL
:PUJLILPUNPU[YVK\JLKPU [VVSPZJHZ[HZHZPUNSLWHY[WYVWLYPUZWLJ[PVUVU[OL
]LY`ML^HK]HUJLZOH]LILLUTHKL PUZPKLPZL_[YLTLS`KPMMPJ\S[HUK[PTLJVUZ\TPUN6UJL
[V[OL@[VVSI`WHZZZ`Z[LT;OL V\[PU[OLMPLSKPUZWLJ[PVULZJHSH[LZMYVTKPMMPJ\S[[V
Z[HUKHYKKLZPNUPZ^PKLS`H]HPSHISLHUK ULHYS`PTWVZZPISL0UZWLJ[PVUVMJHZ[WHY[ZPZ\Z\HSS`KVUL
PZHJJLW[LKºHZPZ»I`TVZ[)\[[OLYL ]PHUVUKLZ[Y\J[P]L[LZ[PUNTL[OVKZZ\JOHZTHNUL[PJ
HYLMYLX\LU[WYVISLTZ[OH[VJJ\YK\YPUN WHY[PJSLVYSPX\PKK`LWLUL[YHU[+\YPUNTHNUL[PJWHY[PJSL
[OLTHU\MHJ[\YPUNWYVJLZZ)LJH\ZL[OL PUZWLJ[PVUH[YHPULK[LJOUPJPHUW\[ZHTHNUL[PJMPLSK
[VVSZHYLJHZ[PUTL[HSMSH^ZHYLVM[LU PU[V[OLWHY[HUKZ\YMHJLVYZ\IZ\YMHJLKPZJVU[PU\P[`
KPMMPJ\S[[VMPUKHUKPUTHU`JHZLZ[OLZL PU[OLTH[LYPHSHSSV^ZTHNUL[PJMS\_[VSLHR-LYYV\Z
OPKKLUMSH^ZHYLVUS`MV\UKHZHYLZ\S[ PYVUPZ[OLUHWWSPLK[V[OLWHY[HUKPMHUHYLHVMMS\_
VMMHPS\YL SLHRHNLPZWYLZLU[[OLU[OLWHY[PJSLZ^PSSILH[[YHJ[LK
0U]LZ[TLU[JHZ[PUNVYºSVZ[^H_» [V[OPZHYLHHUKWHY[PJSLZ^PSSI\PSK\W3PX\PKK`L
JHZ[PUNOHZ[VIL\ZLK^P[O@[VVSZ WLUL[YHU[PUZWLJ[PVU^PSSPKLU[PM`[OLWYLZLUJLVMJYHJRZ
ILJH\ZL[YHKP[PVUHSJHZ[PUN^V\SK VYPTWLYMLJ[PVUZ^OLUZ\IQLJ[LK[VZWLJPHSSPNO[PUNHZ
Figure 1.
Standard Y-tool JH\ZLHUVYTHSTV\SK[VIYLHRK\YPUN ZOV^UPU-PN\YL
deployed with [OLYLTV]HSWYVJLZZ:PUNSL\ZL ;OPZ[LZ[Z[HY[ZV\[^P[O!
ESP system and TV\SKZJHUILIYVRLUHWHY[[VMYLL[OL Ì 4H[LYPHS^P[OHZ\YMHJLIYLHRPUNJYHJR[OH[PZUV[
bypass tubing. JHZ[WHY[MYVT[OLTV\SK"\UMVY[\UH[LS` ]PZPISL[V[OLUHRLKL`L
Ì 7LUL[YHU[PZHWWSPLK[V[OLZ\YMHJL
Ì ,_JLZZWLUL[YHU[PZYLTV]LK
Ì +L]LSVWLYPZHWWSPLKYLUKLYPUN[OLJYHJR]PZPISL
;OLZLTL[OVKZVMPUZWLJ[PVUHYLVM[LUZ\JJLZZM\S
H[MPUKPUNZ\YMHJLVYL]LUZ\IZ\YMHJLMSH^ZI\[KVUV[
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
HSSV^LUNPULLYZ[VWYVWLYS`L]HS\H[LWHY[Z(ZHYLZ\S[
PMHU`MSH^ZHYLMV\UKPUZ[LHKVMYLWHPYZILPUNTHKL
[OLLU[PYLWHY[TPNO[OH]L[VILZJYHWWLK-YLX\LU[S`
OPKKLUMSH^ZSH`ZKLLWPU[OLMSV^WHZZHNL^OLYL
\UL]LUMSV^VYHI\IISLMVYTLK;OLZL^LHRZWV[ZJHU
NYV^HUKL_WHUK^OLUKLWSV`LKHUKL]LU[\HSS`JH\ZL
MHPS\YL
+\L[V[OLJHZ[PUNWYVJLZZP[ZLSM[OLTH[LYPHSZ
H]HPSHISLHYL]LY`SPTP[LKWYPTHYPS`JOYVTL
JOYVTLHUKJHYIVUZ[LLS;OLTHU`HK]HUJLZPU
VPSMPLSKTH[LYPHSZZ\JOHZ7/::K\WSL_
Z[HPUSLZZPUJVULSTVULSHYLUV[]PHISLMVYJHZ[[VVSZ
;OLULLK[VJHZ[J\YYLU[@[VVSZHSZVZL]LYLS`SPTP[Z
[OLKLZPNUZWVZZPISL*HZ[PUNPZI`P[ZUH[\YLHU
PTWYLJPZLTL[OVKVMZJ\SW[PUNTL[HS;PNO[[VSLYHUJLZ
HYLPTWVZZPISL^P[OV\[NVPUNIHJR^P[OTHJOPUL^VYR Figure 5. A CMM machine at ESPCT.
(UKZPUJL[OLPUZPKLVM[OL@[VVSPZPUHJJLZZPISL[OL`
JHUUV[ILTVKPMPLKHM[LY[OL`OH]LILLUJHZ[
3LHK[PTLZHYLHSZVHTHQVYSPTP[PUNMHJ[VY^P[O[OL
J\YYLU[TL[OVKVMWYVK\JPUN@[VVSZ0UK\Z[Y`Z[HUKHYK
SLHK[PTLZMVYJHZ[PUNZHYLHYV\UKZP_[LLU^LLRZ;OPZ
PU[YVK\JLZHSVUNKLSH`PUYL]PZPVUZHUKHSSV^ZMVY]LY`
SP[[SLMSL_PIPSP[`*\Z[VT@[VVSZHYLPTWYHJ[PJHSK\L
[V[OLOPNOJVZ[VMY\UUPUNSV^]VS\TLJHZ[PUNZHUK
J\YYLU[S`VUS`THZZWYVK\JLK]HYPL[PLZHYLH]HPSHISL
;OLZL^LHRULZZLZHYLSPZ[LKUV[ILJH\ZL[OL
@[VVSJVUJLW[P[ZLSMPZMSH^LKI\[ILJH\ZL[OLYLHYL
^LHRULZZLZ[OH[HYPZLMYVTP[ZTHU\MHJ[\YPUN;OLZL
^LHRULZZLZULLK[VILL_HTPULK[VPKLU[PM`[OLHYLHZ
[OH[JHUILPTWYV]LK0[PZ[PTLMVY[OLUL_[NLULYH[PVU Figure 6. Dye penetrant inspection steps.
VM@[VVS[LJOUVSVN`
,:7*VTWSL[PVU;LJOUVSVNPLZ,:7*;KLZPNULKH
TVK\SHY@[VVS[VHKKYLZZ[OLPZZ\LZ[YHKP[PVUHS@[VVSZ
OH]L^P[OOPKKLUMSH^ZSHJRVMWYVWLYPUZWLJ[PVU
PUMSL_PISLKLZPNUHUKSVUNSLHK[PTLZ([YLTLUKV\Z
HTV\U[VMMSL_PIPSP[`HUKZHML[`PZHKKLKI`THJOPUPUN
[OLTL[HSPUZ[LHKVMJHZ[PUN
;OLSLHK[PTLMVYTHJOPULKWHY[ZPZHMYHJ[PVUVM[OL
SLHK[PTLMVYJHZ[WHY[Z^OPJOHZTLU[PVULKLHYSPLY
PZHWWYV_PTH[LS`ZP_[LLU^LLRZ(UVYTHS@[VVSJHU
ILWYVK\JLKPU[^V^LLRZVYMV\Y^LLRZPMZWLJPHS
TL[HSS\YN`VYJ\Z[VTPZH[PVUPZULLKLK;OPZHSSV^ZMVY
NYLH[MSL_PIPSP[`VMKLZPNUHUKHSSV^Z[OLTHU\MHJ[\YLVM
J\Z[VT@[VVSZ0[HSZVHSSV^ZMVYYLWHPYZ[VILKVUL0M
[OL[VW[OYLHKPZKHTHNLKMVYL_HTWSL[OH[JVTWVULU[
VM[OL@[VVSJHUILYLWSHJLKMVYHMYHJ[PVUVM[OLJVZ[VM
HUL^VUL;OLWYVJLZZVMJYLH[PUNHTV\SKHUKTHZZ
WYVK\JPUNMYVT[OH[TV\SKPZVM[LU^OH[[HRLZSVUNLZ[
PU[OLJHZ[PUNWYVJLZZI\[THJOPULKWHY[ZJHUIL
J\Z[VTPZLKVUHWLYWYVK\J[PVUIHZPZZPUJLUVTV\SKPZ Solutions That Fit SM
888.448.6825 | TotalSafety.com
^P[OHIYHZP]L^LHY4HU`JVH[PUNZOH]LILLUKL]LSVWLK HK]HUJLKJVH[PUNZ[VILHWWSPLKZPUJL[OLMSV^WHZZHNLPZ
[OH[^PSSPUJYLHZLOHYKULZZJVYYVZPVUYLZPZ[HUJLHUK HJJLZZPISL
WHY[SPML[PTLSPRLJHYIPKLZJLYHTPJZHUK878<U[PS (UHKKP[PVUHSILULMP[VM[OLTVK\SHYKLZPNUHUK
UV^THU`VM[OLZL[YLH[TLU[Z^LYL\UH]HPSHISLMVY H]HPSHIPSP[`VMJVH[PUNZPZPUJYLHZLKMSV^[OYV\NO[OL@[VVS
\ZLPU[YHKP[PVUHS@[VVSZ4VZ[[YLH[TLU[ZULLKKPYLJ[ *HZ[WHY[ZHYLYV\NO^OLU[OL`JVTLV\[VM[OLTV\SK
HJJLZZ[V[OLZ\YMHJLILPUN[YLH[LKHUK[OH[MSV^HYLH HUK[OLMSV^WH[OZPUZPKLHYLPUHJJLZZPISLMVYZTVV[OPUN
PZJSVZLKVMMHUKPUHJJLZZPISLPU[YHKP[PVUHS@[VVSZ;OPZ 4HJOPULKMSV^WH[OZHYLZTVV[OLYTVYLHJJ\YH[L[OHU
PZILJH\ZL[OL`HYLJHZ[HZHJVTWSL[LJSVZLKVMMWHY[ JHZ[VULZHUKTHU`JVH[PUN[`WLZPUJYLHZL[OLS\IYPJP[`
;OLUL^TVK\SHYKLZPNUVM[OL@[VVSHSSV^ZMVY[OLZL TLHZ\YLVM[OLYLK\J[PVUPUMYPJ[PVUVMZ\YMHJLZ^OPJO
M\Y[OLYPUJYLHZLZMSV^
;OL[PNO[LY[VSLYHUJLZ[OH[THJOPULKWHY[ZJHUOVSK
THRLZTHSSLY@[VVSZWVZZPISL;OL`JHUILKLZPNULK^P[O
[OL,:7HUKI`WHZZ[\IPUNJSVZLY[VNL[OLYHUK[OL6+
VMLHJOJSVZLY[V[OL6+VM[OL@[VVSIVK`P[ZLSM>OLU
[Y`PUN[VMP[Z`Z[LTZPU[V^LSSZMYHJ[PVUZVMHUPUJOJHU
THRL[OLKPMMLYLUJLIL[^LLUHKLZPNU^VYRPUNVYMHPSPUN
;OL[VSLYHUJLZPUJHZ[PUNVM[LUZVM[OV\ZHUK[OZVMHU
PUJOJHUUV[TH[JO[OL[VSLYHUJLZ[OH[THJOPULZJHUOVSK
HU`^OLYLKV^U[V[^V[OV\ZHUK[OZVMHUPUJO
Conclusion
;YHKP[PVUHS@[VVS[LJOUVSVN`OHZILLUWYV]LU[VILLMMLJ[P]L
HUKZHMLV]LYP[ZL_PZ[LUJLI\[OHZ\UKLYNVUL]LY`ML^
PTWYV]LTLU[ZZPUJLP[ZPU[YVK\J[PVU;OPZUL^TVK\SHY
KLZPNUNVLZHSVUN^H`[VHKKYLZZ[OL^LHRULZZLZWYLZLU[
PUJ\YYLU[KLZPNUZ;OLHYN\TLU[MVY[OPZKLZPNUPZ[VH]VPK
[OLVSKPKPVTVMILPUNºWLUU`^PZLWV\UKMVVSPZO»(]LY`
ZTHSSWLYJLU[VM@[VVSZMHPSHZKLZJYPILKHIV]LI\[LHJO
Figure 7. ESPCT modular Y-tool (Patent Pending). [PTL[OL`KV[OLJVZ[JHUILPU[OLTPSSPVUZ
NEED A
REPRINT?
WE CAN TAILOR
TO YOUR
REQUIREMENTS,
PRODUCE 1-12
PAGE FORMATS,
PRINT COLOUR OR
MONO AND MORE!
*VU[HJ[*H[OLYPUL.V^LY
VYLTHPS!
JH[OLYPULNV^LY'WHSSHKPHUW\ISPJH[PVUZJVT
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
T
OLHK]LU[VML_[LUKLKYLHJOOVYPaVU[HSKYPSSPUNHUK
T\S[PZ[HNLO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNOHZSLK[VHIVVT
PUVUZOVYLVPSHUKNHZWYVK\J[PVUMYVTZOHSL
YLZLY]VPYZ;OLOVYPaVU[HSSLUN[OVM[OLZL^LSSZHUK[OL
U\TILYVMMYHJZ[HNLZOHZILLUZ[LHKPS`PUJYLHZPUN
;VKH`VWLYH[VYZHYLKYPSSPUNOVYPaVU[HS^LSSZ^P[OH
SH[LYHSSLUN[OVMM[-PN\YL^P[OV]LY
MYHJZ[HNLZ;OLKPHTL[LYVM[OLZLJVTWSL[PVUZ
PZHSZVPUJYLHZPUNHZVWLYH[VYZMVJ\ZVUVPS
WYVK\JPUNMVYTH[PVUZ
([`WPJHSOVYPaVU[HS^LSSPZJVTWSL[LK
^P[OT\S[PWSLO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YLZ[HNLZ;OL
MYHJZ[HNLZHYLPZVSH[LK\ZPUNJVTWVZP[L Jack Kolle,
IYPKNLWS\NZ*)7IHSSHJ[\H[LKMYHJ Oil States Energy Services/
ZSLL]LZVY^P[OHJVTIPUH[PVUVM[OL Tempress, USA, provides an
[^V*VPSLK[\IPUN*;KLWSV`LKWVZP[P]L
KPZWSHJLTLU[TV[VYZ7+4HUKTPSSZ
overview of some extended
HYL[OLMH]V\YLKTL[OVKVMTPSSPUNV\[ reach well intervention
IHSSZLH[ZHUKIYPKNLWS\NZILJH\ZLVM tools.
[OLZWLLKVMZLY]PJLHUKHIPSP[`[VTHPU[HPU
JVU[YVSVM[OL^LSSWYLZZ\YLHZP[ILNPUZ
[VWYVK\JL>VYRV]LYYPNZVMMLYHSV^LY
JVZ[HS[LYUH[P]L[VJVPS;OPZVWLYH[PVUJHU
ILHJJVTWSPZOLKHM[LY[OLO`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUN
PZJVTWSL[L*;PZIYV\NO[[VSVJH[PVUHM[LY[OL
O`KYH\SPJMYHJ[\YPUNPZJVTWSL[LHUK[OLWS\NZHUK
ZLH[ZHYLTPSSLKV\[MYVTHSS[OL^LSSZVU[OLWHKPUH
JVU[PU\V\ZVWLYH[PVU
;OLHIPSP[`[VKYPSSL_[LUKLKYLHJOOVYPaVU[HS^LSSZOHZV\[WHJLK
[OLHIPSP[`[VYLLU[LY[OL^LSSZ^P[OJVPSLK[\IPUNVY^VYRV]LYYPNZ+YPSSPUNYPNZOH]L
[OLHIPSP[`[VYV[H[L[OLKYPSSZ[YPUN^OPJORLLWZJ\[[PUNZPUZ\ZWLUZPVUHUKYLK\JLZ
MYPJ[PVUMVYJLZ*VPSLK[\IPUNZ[YPUNZHYLZTHSSLYKPHTL[LYHUKL]LU[\HSS`L_WLYPLUJL
OLSPJHSI\JRSPUNHUKSVJR\WPUL_[LUKLKYLHJO^LSSZ:THSSLYKPHTL[LY^VYRZ[YPUNZHUKSHYNLY
JHZPUNZYLK\JL[OLSH[LYHSYLHJOH[^OPJOSVJR\WVJJ\YZ6UJL[OL^LSSPZJVTWSL[LK[OL^LSS
PU[LY]LU[PVU^VYRZ[YPUNT\Z[LU[LY[OYV\NO[OLWYVK\J[PVU[\IPUNM\Y[OLYYLK\JPUN[OLZPaL
*;OHZHSPTP[LKÅV^JHWHJP[`^OPJOSPTP[ZP[ZHIPSP[`[VYLTV]LMYHJ
ZHUKHUKWS\NKLIYPZMYVT[OL^LSS+LWLUKPUNVU[OLYLZLY]VPY^LSSZ
TH`OH]L[VL\WJVUÄN\YH[PVUVYH[VY[\V\Z^LSSWH[O^OPJOM\Y[OLY
JVTWSPJH[LZ^LSSLU[Y`
0UHKKP[PVU[V[OLL_[LUKLKYLHJOJOHSSLUNLZTHU`^LSSZTH`UV[
OH]LZ\MÄJPLU[WYLZZ\YL[VJPYJ\SH[LJVTWSL[PVUÅ\PKZHUKJ\[[PUNZV\[
VM[OL^LSS0UZVTLHYLHZP[PZULJLZZHY`[VW\TWUP[YVNLU[V\USVHK
[OL^LSS^OPSLTPSSPUNWS\NZVYWLYMVYTPUNZHUKJSLHUV\[ZHUKV[OLY
^LSSPU[LY]LU[PVUZLY]PJLZ;OLUP[YVNLUYH[LYLX\PYLK[V\USVHK[OL^LSS
TH`L_JLLK[OLÅV^JHWHJP[`VM[OL7+4
:L]LYHS[OYV\NO[\IPUN[VVSZOH]LILLUKLZPNULK[VHKKYLZZ[OL
JOHSSLUNLZVML_[LUKLKYLHJOTPSSPUNHUK^LSSPU[LY]LU[PVU^P[O*;VY
Figure 1. The length of horizontal well completions is increasing. QVPU[LK^VYRZ[YPUNZ
Source: KeyBanc Capital Markets Equity research. ;OL/`KYV7\SS^H[LYOHTTLYPZWYPTHYPS`\ZLK[VL_[LUK[OL
YLHJOVM[OL^VYRZ[YPUNI`HWWS`PUNWLYJ\ZZP]L^H[LYOHTTLYPTWHJ[Z
[V[OLIV[[VTOVSLHZZLTIS`;OLPTWHJ[MVYJLZW\SS[OL^VYRZ[YPUN
M\Y[OLYPU[V[OL^LSS[OHUPZWVZZPISLI`W\ZOPUNVU[OLJVPSHUKLUZ\YLZ
LMMLJ[P]L^LPNO[[YHUZMLY[VTV[VYZHUKTPSSZ;OLÅV^W\SZH[PVUZ
WYVK\JLKI`[OL[VVSHSZVLUOHUJL[OL[YHUZWVY[VMKLIYPZPUOVYPaVU[HS
^LSSZHUKJHUIL\ZLK[VJSLHUZHUKZJYLLUZHUKNYH]LSWHJRZ;OL
[VVSZHYLHSZV\ZLKMVYÄZOPUNVWLYH[PVUZPUOVYPaVU[HS^LSSZHUKHZHU
HS[LYUH[P]L[VHJ[\H[PUNHQHY[VMYLLHZ[\JR^VYRZ[YPUN
;OLTV[VYNHZZLWHYH[VY4.:-PN\YLI`WHZZLZNHZHIV]L
[OLTV[VY[VWYV]PKLYLSPHISLJPYJ\SH[PVUHUKTV[VYVWLYH[PVU^OLUSV^
Figure 2. HydroPull water-hammer tool equipped with a blast nozzle.
WYLZZ\YLZHYLLUJV\U[LYLK;OLZL[VVSZJHUILY\UPU[HUKLT^P[O
/`KYV7\SS^H[LYOHTTLYZMVYL_[LUKLKYLHJOPU[LY]LU[PVUPU
SV^WYLZZ\YL^LSSZ
)V[O[VVSZHYLOPNO[LTWLYH[\YLJVTWH[PISL[VV]LYá-á*
;OL/`KYV7\SSJHUILY\UVU[^VWOHZLZI\[HNHZZLWHYH[VYPZ
YLJVTTLUKLKPMHWVZP[P]LKPZWSHJLTLU[TV[VY7+4PZY\U;OLZL
[VVSZHYLH]HPSHISLPUZPaLZMYVTPUMVY[OYV\NO[\IPUN^LSS
PU[LY]LU[PVUZ[VñPUMVY^LSSJVTWSL[PVUZ;OLTVZ[JVTTVUZPaL
PZPU;OLVWLYH[PUNWYPUJPWSLZQVIWSHUUPUNHUKJHZLOPZ[VYPLZVM
[OLZL[VVSZHYLKPZJ\ZZLKOLYL
Tripping in
>OLU[YPWWPUN[OL)/(PU[V[OL^LSS[OLWLYJ\ZZP]L
^H[LYOHTTLYMVYJLW\SSZHUKZ[YL[JOLZ[OLLUKVM
[OL[\IPUNHIV\[PU;OLZWLLKVMZV\UKPUZ[LLSPZ
TZZVHZLJW\SZLZ[YL[JOLZ[OLIV[[VT
TM[VM[\IPUN;OPZZ[YL[JOWYVWHNH[LZHZH
Figure 4. HydroPull job planning software including CT circulation, cuttings transport Z[YLZZ^H]L\W[OYV\NO[OLJVPSH[[OLZWLLKVMZV\UK\U[PS
and extended reach estimates. P[YLHJOLZ[OL*;YLLSVUZ\YMHJL(U`NP]LUZWV[VU[OL
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
*;TV]LZMVY^HYKH[M[TPUMVYZLJ[OLUZ[VWZMVYZLJHUK
[OLUTV]LZHNHPUHZPSS\Z[YH[LKPU-PN\YL;OLZLZ[YLZZ^H]LZJH\ZL
[OL*;YPN[VZOHRL^OPJOPZUV[PJLHISLVUZ\YMHJLL]LU^OLU[OLJVPSPZ
KLLWPU[OL[VLVM[OL^LSS
*;PZZ\IQLJ[[VOLSPJHSI\JRPUNHUKSVJR\WK\L[VMYPJ[PVUMVYJLZ
^OLU[OLSLUN[OVMJVPSPU[OLOVYPaVU[HSZLJ[PVUL_JLLKZHJYP[PJHS]HS\L
:VM[^HYLPZH]HPSHISL[OH[JHUIL\ZLK[VJHSJ\SH[L[OLSLUN[OH[^OPJO
JVPS^PSSSVJR\WPUZPKLVMHZ[YHPNO[ZLJ[PVUVMOVYPaVU[HSJHZPUN;OL
ZVM[^HYLHSZVLZ[PTH[LZ[OLHKKP[PVUHSYLHJO[OH[[OL^H[LYOHTTLY^PSS
LUHISL;OLTVKLSJHSJ\SH[LZ[OLLUKMVYJLWYV]PKLKI`[OL[VVSHUK
Figure 5. Sequential stills from HydroPull sand transport video inside
HZZ\TLZHYLK\J[PVUPUMYPJ[PVUIL[^LLU[OLJVPSHUKJHZPUNK\L
of a transparent test section at 100 fpm (0.5 m/s) average flow
[V[OLJVPS]PIYH[PVU;OLTVKLSHSZVJHSJ\SH[LZ[OLYH[LH[^OPJO[OL*; velocity.
PZW\SSLKPU[V[OL^LSSI`[OL^H[LYOHTTLY<ZLYZJHUHSZVJHSJ\SH[L
SVJR\WKLW[O^P[OTVYLJVTWYLOLUZP]LWYVNYHTZ[OH[HJJV\U[MVY^LSS
[VY[\VZP[`6UJL[OLJVU]LU[PVUHSSVJR\WKLW[OPZYLHJOLK[OL*;MLLK
YH[LZOV\SKILYLK\JLK[VTH[JO[OLYLJVTTLUKLK/`KYV7\SSMLLK
YH[L^OPJOPZ[`WPJHSS`HYV\UKM[TPU
:\IZ[HU[PHSPUJYLHZLZPUSH[LYHSYHUNLHYLWVZZPISLKLWLUKPUNVU
[OLVWLYH[PUNWHYHTL[LYZ(S[OV\NO[OL^H[LYOHTTLYMVYJLPZZTHSSLY
[OHU[OL[V[HSMYPJ[PVUMVYJLZVU[\IPUNPUHSVUN^LSS[OL[\IPUNTV]LZPU
^H]LZ[OH[HYLVUS`M[SVUN;OLZL^H]LZKPZZPWH[LZSV^S`K\L[V Figure 6. Motor gas separator (MGS).
MYPJ[PVU\USLZZ[OL^LSSPZOPNOS`[VY[\V\Z6UPUJVPS[OLYHUNLJHUIL
L_[LUKLKI`V]LYM[
Milling
>OLU[OLTV[VYHUKTPSSLUJV\U[LYHUVIZ[Y\J[PVUZ\JOHZHIYPKNL
WS\N[OLWLYJ\ZZP]LPTWHJ[MVYJLZHYLWHY[PHSS`HIZVYILKI`[OLWS\N
HZP[PZTPSSLKV\[)LZ[WYHJ[PJLZMVYWS\NTPSSPUNHYL[V[HN[OLWS\N
HUKTPSS^P[OTPUPT\TJVPS^LPNO[(Z^P[OHWLYJ\ZZP]LOHTTLY[OL
^H[LYOHTTLYWYV]PKLZ[OL^LPNO[YLX\PYLK[VYLTV]L[OLWS\N7S\NZ
JHUILTPSSLKPUHML^TPU\[LZI\[TPSSPUN[PTLZVMTPUHYL
YLJVTTLUKLK[VYLK\JL[OLZPaLVMJ\[[PUNZNLULYH[LK;OLJVPS^PSS
MLLKPUZTVV[OS`HUKHUL_WLYPLUJLK[VVSVWLYH[VY^PSSYHYLS`Z[HSS[OL
TV[VY-P_LKJ\[[LYTPSSPUNIP[ZVY[YPJVULIP[ZJHUIL\ZLK^P[OLX\HS
Z\JJLZZ
Short trips
7S\NKLIYPZHUKJVUZPKLYHISLHTV\U[ZVMZHUKT\Z[IL[YHUZWVY[LKV\[
VM[OL^LSSVUJLHWS\NPZTPSSLK[OYV\NO:OVY[[YPWZHJJVTWHUPLKI`
HWVS`TLYWPSS[VOLSWZ\ZWLUKJ\[[PUNZHYLYLJVTTLUKLKHM[LYL]LY`
Figure 7. Extreme reach CT sand cleanout well profile.
ZP_[V[LUWS\NZ;OLHUU\SHYÅV^]LSVJP[`^OPSLTPSSPUN^P[OIWTVM
^H[LYPUñPUJHZPUNPZVUS`M[TPU^LSSILSV^[OL
M[TPUYLJVTTLUKLKMVYLMMLJ[P]LOVSLJSLHUPUN
;OL^H[LYOHTTLYHSZVNLULYH[LZÅV^W\SZH[PVUZPU
[OLHUU\S\Z^OPJO^OLUHJJVTWHUPLKI`]PIYH[PVUVM
[OL*;OLSWZ[VRLLWJ\[[PUNZPUZ\ZWLUZPVU-PN\YL
ZOV^ZOV^J\[[PUNZHYL[YHUZWVY[LKPU^H]LZ\W[OL
HUU\S\Z;OPZÅV^W\SZH[PVUYLK\JLZ[OLH]LYHNL
]LSVJP[`YLX\PYLK[VJ\[[PUNZ[YHUZWVY[[VM[TPU
;OL^H[LYOHTTLYWLYJ\ZZPVUHSZV]PIYH[LZ[OL
[\IPUN^OPJOYLK\JLZMYPJ[PVUKYHN;OLJVTIPUH[PVU
VM[OLZLLMMLJ[ZL_[LUKZ[OLSH[LYHSYHUNLVM[OL[\IPUN
I`KLSH`PUN[OLVUZL[VMOLSPJHSI\JRSPUNHUKSVJR\W
;OL[VVSPZJVTTVUS`Y\UKPYLJ[S`HIV]LHKV^UOVSL
TV[VYMVYTPSSPUNHWWSPJH[PVUZ;OLWYLZZ\YLW\SZH[PVUZ
PTWYV]L^LPNO[[YHUZMLYZV[OH[WS\NTPSSPUN[PTLZPU[OL
[VLVM[OL^LSSHYL[OLZHTLHZPU[OLOLLS
Well stimulation
;OLZHTLIWTVM^H[LY\ZLKMVYH[`WPJHS^LSS
PU[LY]LU[PVUPUZPKLVMñPUJHZPUNPZTV]PUNIHJR Figure 8. Typical plug milling depth/time profile.
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
\W[OLHUU\S\ZIL[^LLU[OLJVPSHUKJHZPUN;OL^H[LYPZTV]PUN Composite bridge plug milling
H[HUH]LYHNLZWLLKVMMWTTZ:[VWWPUN[OPZÅV^ ;OPZ[`WPJHSQVI\ZLKHPUTT/`KYV7\SS7+4PUPU
NLULYH[LZHZ\J[PVUW\SZLVM\W[VWZP47HV]LYHM[ TTJHZPUN;OPZ^HZVULVM[OYLLQVIZ^P[OHUH]LYHNLWS\N
SVUNZLJ[PVUVM[OLJVTWSL[PVU;OPZWYLZZ\YLJH\ZLZ[OL^LSS TPSSPUN[PTLVMTPU6US`[OYLLZ[HSSZ^LYLVIZLY]LKV\[VM
[VZ\YNLV\[VM[OLMVYTH[PVUYLTV]PUNÄULZHUKKLIYPZMYVT WS\NZTPSSLK[V[HS(IIS SZ^LLW^HZW\TWLKHM[LY
ILOPUKZJYLLUZHUKJVTWSL[PVUZ0M[OL^LSSPZZO\[PU[OLÅV^ LHJOWS\N^HZTPSSLKHUKVULZOVY[[YPW^HZJVTWSL[LKHM[LY
Z\YNLZPU[V[OLMVYTH[PVU;OPZPZHULMMLJ[P]LTLHUZVMKPZWLYZPUN TPSSPUNWS\NZ;OLH]LYHNL[PTL[VJVTWSL[LLHJOQVI^HZVUS`
ZVS]LU[ZZJHSL[YLH[TLU[HUKZ\YMHJ[HU[ZPU[V[OLMVYTH[PVUULHY OYZ
[OL^LSSIVYL
Milling CBPs with a snubbing unit
Optimising motor flow rates ;OPZQVIPU>LZ[=PYNPUPHPU]VS]LKTPSSPUN*)7ZMYVT[V
5P[YVNLUPZVM[LUW\TWLKHSVUN^P[O^H[LY[VLUZ\YLJPYJ\SH[PVU M[\ZPUNHZ[HUKHSVULZU\IIPUN\UP[(/`KYV7\SS[VVS^HZ
VMÅ\PKZHUKJ\[[PUNZ^OLUHSV^WYLZZ\YLaVULPZLUJV\U[LYLK Y\U^P[OH)HRLY?[YLTLTV[VYHUKISHKLQ\URTPSSKYLZZLK
;OL4.:PUJVYWVYH[LZH[\YIPULKYP]LUOPNOLMÄJPLUJ`KY\T ^P[O.S`WOHSSV`;OLQVI^HZJVTWSL[LKPU[^VKH`Z^P[OHU
ZLWHYH[VY*VTPUNSLKUP[YVNLUHUK^H[LYHYLZLWHYH[LKPUZPKL[OL H]LYHNLWS\NTPSSPUN[PTLVMTPU;OL^H[LYOHTTLYHSSV^LK
ZWPUUPUNKY\T;OLNHZL_P[Z[OV\NOHJYVZZV]LYHUKPZI`WHZZLK [OL\ZLVMHSV^LYJVZ[ZU\IIPUN\UP[^P[OUVYV[HY`JHWHIPSP[`[V
HIV]L[OLTV[VY JVTWSL[L[OPZQVI
;OPZ[VVSPZ\ZLK[VHSSV^[OL\ZLVMVW[PT\TÅV^YH[LZMVY
[OLTV[VY^OPSLI`WHZZPUNHU`NHZ[OH[TH`IL\ZLK[VSPM[[OL Milling composite bridge plugs with two-phase flow
^LSS;OL[VVSPUJVYWVYH[LZHÄLSKZLY]PJLHISLNHZWVY[[OH[T\Z[ (PUTT/`KYV7\SS[VVS^HZY\U^P[OHTV[VYHUKTPSS
ILWYVWLYS`ZPaLK[VHJJVTTVKH[L[OLNHZÅV^YH[LH[KV^UOVSL VUPUTTJVPS[VTPSSIYPKNLWS\NZPUZPKLPUTT
WYLZZ\YLHUK[LTWLYH[\YL([^VWOHZLJPYJ\SH[PVUTVKLS^HZ JHZPUNMYVT[VM[[V T4+VUMV\Y
KL]LSVWLKPUVYKLY[VHSSV^\ZLYZ[VJHSJ\SH[L[OLZLWHYHTL[LYZ OVYPaVU[HSNHZ^LSSJVTWSL[PVUZM[TOVYPaVU[HS-VY
HUKZPaL[OLNHZWVY[MVYHNP]LUQVI(S[LYUH[P]LS`[OLVWLYH[VY [OLÄYZ[QVIH4.:[VVS^HZY\UILSV^[OL^H[LYOHTTLYHUK
TH`^PZO[VJOHUNLNHZYH[LZK\YPUN[OLQVIHUK[OLTVKLSHSSV^Z HIV]L[OLTV[VY;OL[VVSZ^LYLVWLYH[LKH[IWTSWT
HJHSJ\SH[PVUVM[OLHWWYVWYPH[L^H[LYYH[L[VH]VPKV]LYZWLLK ^P[OIWTSWTÅ\PKVYNHZLX\P]HSLU[I`WHZZLKI`[OL
^OPSLLUZ\YPUN[OH[[OLTV[VYY\UZH[M\SSWV^LY[OYV\NOV\[[OL ZLWHYH[VY,PNO[IYPKNLWS\NZ^LYLTPSSLKPUHUH]LYHNL[PTL
QVI VMTPULHJO0UVMMZL[QVIZY\UUPUNHJVTWL[P[P]L]PIYH[PUN
[VVSPUZ[LHKVM[OL^H[LYOHTTLY[OLH]LYHNLTPSSPUN[PTL^HZ
Case histories TPUWLYWS\N
;VKH[L[OLWYPTHY`HWWSPJH[PVUOHZILLU[OLTPSSPUNVMJVTWVZP[L -VY[OLUL_[[^V^LSSZ[OLNHZZLWHYH[VY^HZY\UHIV]L[OL
IYPKNLWS\NZHUKMYHJZSLL]LIHSSZLH[Z6[OLYJVTTVU ^H[LYOHTTLYHUKTV[VY[VYLK\JL[OLW\SZLHTWSP[\KL,HJO
HWWSPJH[PVUZHYLÄZOPUNVWLYH[PVUZJLTLU[TPSSPUNHUKZOPM[PUN QVIPU]VS]LKTPSSPUNIYPKNLWS\NZ^P[OÅ\PK;OLH]LYHNLTPSSPUN
KV^UOVSLZSLL]LZ [PTLWLYWS\N^HZTPU
6U[OLSHZ[^LSSUP[YVNLU^HZY\U[VTHPU[HPUJPYJ\SH[PVU
Ball seat milling on jointed tubing ^OPSLKYPSSPUN[OLSHZ[[^VIYPKNLWS\NZ5P[YVNLUKHTWLULK[OL
(UPUKLWLUKLU[VPSHUKNHZJVTWHU`VWLYH[PUNPU[OL W\SZLHTWSP[\KLI\[KPKUV[YLK\JL[OLTPSSPUNZWLLK
>PSSPZ[VU)HZPUULLKLK[VYLTV]LMYHJZLH[ZMYVTHT\S[PZ[HNL
IHSSKYVWZ`Z[LT;OLMYHJZSLL]LZZ[HY[LKPUHOVYPaVU[HSñPU Cement milling
SPULYH[M[THUKJVU[PU\LK[VH[V[HSTLHZ\YLKKLW[O (THQVYVWLYH[VYVU[OL5VY[O:SVWLVM(SHZRH^HZL_WLYPLUJPUN
VMM[ T(PU)/(PUJVYWVYH[PUNH/`KYV7\SS \U^HU[LKNHZWYVK\J[PVUPU[OLOLLSVMH^LSS[OH[^HZYLJLU[S`
[VVS)HRLYT\KTV[VYHUKêPU)HRLY/\NOLZ.S`WOHSSV` ZPKL[YHJRLK;OLJOHSSLUNL^HZZO\[[PUNVMM[OLNHZWYVK\JPUN
TPSS^HZ\ZLKMVY[OPZQVI([V[HSVMMYHJZLH[Z^LYLTPSSLKPU WLYMVYH[PVUZHIV]L^OPSLWYLZLY]PUNHM[ZLJ[PVUVM
VUL[YPW^P[OH[V[HSTPSSPUN[PTLVMOYZ WLYMVYH[PVUZH[[OL[VLVM[OL^LSS;OLZVS\[PVU^HZ[VPZVSH[L[OL
[VLHUKZX\LLaL[OLNHZWYVK\JPUNWLYMVYH[PVUZHUK[OLUTPSS[OL
Extreme-reach CT sand cleanout WS\NHSSV^PUNWYVK\J[PVUMYVT[OL[VL(M[LYKYPM[PUN[OL^LSSIVYL
;OPZQVIPU]VS]LK[OYLL^LSSZ[OH[YLX\PYLKZHUKJSLHUV\[PUPU H*)7^HZZL[HWWYV_PTH[LS`M[HIV]L[OLWLYMVYH[PVUZH[[OL
TTJHZPUNH[HUL_[LUKLKYLHJOVM HUK M[ [VLVM[OL^LSSH[M[4+(NLSHUKJLTLU[[YLH[TLU[^HZ
HUKT(PUTT/`KYV)SHZ[[VVS W\TWLK[VZO\[VMM[OLNHZWYVK\JPUNWLYMVYH[PVUZ(SSMHJL[ZVM
^P[OHTV[VY^HZY\UPU[OLZL^LSSZVUPUTTJVPSH[ [OLWS\NHUKJLTLU[PUNVWLYH[PVUZ^LU[HZWSHUULK"OV^L]LY
IWTSWT;+^HZYLHJOLKVUHSS[OYLL^LSSZ(JVPSLK ^OLUTPSSPUNVWLYH[PVUZLUZ\LKMVSSV^PUN[OLJLTLU[ZX\LLaL
[\IPUNMYPJ[PVUSVJR\WTVKLS^HZY\UMVYLHJO^LSS[YHQLJ[VY`6U [OLYL^LYLUV[PJLHISL^LPNO[[YHUZMLYPZZ\LZ^OPSLH[[LTW[PUN[V
[OLSVUNLZ[^LSS[YHQLJ[VY`ZOV^UILSV^[OLTVKLSWYLKPJ[LK TPSSJLTLU[^P[OQ\Z[[OLPU?[YLTLTV[VY
JVPSSVJR\WH[HTLHZ\YLKKLW[OVMM[ THZZ\TPUN ;OL^H[LYOHTTLY^HZWPJRLK\WHSVUN^P[OHTPSSPUN)/(
HKLMH\S[]HS\LMVY[OLJVPSJHZPUN^HSSMYPJ[PVUJVLMÄJPLU[;OL JVUZPZ[PUNVMHU/**+PHTVUK7HYHIVSPJTPSSPU6+)/0
/`KYV)SHZ[[VVSLUHISLK[OLJVPS[VYLHJO;+H[ M[T ?[YLTLTV[VYJPYJZ\IKPZJVUULJ[QHYZIHJRWYLZZ\YL]HS]L
^OPJOPZ M[ TIL`VUK[OLWYLKPJ[LKSVJR\WWVPU[6U KPTWSLVUJVPS[\IPUNJVUULJ[VYHUKPU6+JVPS[\IPUN6UJL
[OL M[TSH[LYHS[OPZYLWYLZLU[ZHTPUPT\T VUIV[[VTTPSSPUN[OLYLTHPUPUNM[VMJLTLU[^HZTPSSLK\W
PUJYLHZLPUSH[LYHSYLHJO(S[OV\NO[OLH]LYHNLOVYPaVU[HS]LSVJP[` HZ^LSSHZ[OL*)7(S[OV\NOHU\TILYVMZ[HSSZ^LYLLUJV\U[LYLK
PU[OLJHZPUN^HZVUS`M[TPUHSSZHUK^HZYLTV]LKMYVT[OL K\YPUN[OLVWLYH[PVUJVUZPZ[LU[^LPNO[VUIP[^HZHJOPL]LK
^LSSZ [OYV\NOV\[[OLTPSSPUNWYVJLZZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
EXPERIENCE MAT TERS.
TRUST YOUR INVESTMENT TO A PROVEN LEADER.
Cudd Energy Services (CES) approaches each challenge with experience, reliability and a
commitment to helping you achieve the maximum production from your reservoir. We have
extensive experience in conventional and unconventional oil and gas fields, and understand
the challenges that may arise. With CES, you get a partner who works with you to develop the
optimal plan to ensure your investment produces the maximum return, safely and efficiently.
Dr Liane Smith, Wood Group Intetech,* UK, shows how
integrity management and corrosion modelling tools provide
a systemic approach to ensuring the safe and reliable
operation of ageing assets for oil and gas operators looking
to squeeze more from mature reservoirs and facilities.
;OLYLJHUHSZVILHJOHUNLPU[OLWYVK\J[PVUJVUKP[PVUZ Z\YMHJL^OPSLNYHK\HSKL[LYPVYH[PVUVMHJLTLU[ZLHSHYPZPUN
TVKPÄJH[PVUVYPU[YVK\J[PVUVMUL^LX\PWTLU[([[OLZHTL MYVT[OLYTHSHUKWYLZZ\YLJ`JSPUNV]LY[OL`LHYZJHUNLULYH[L
[PTL[OLVWLYH[VYULLKZ[VILZ\YL[OH[THRPUN[OLULJLZZHY` TPJYVHUU\SPPU[OLJLTLU[JOHUULSHYV\UKJHZPUNZ;OPZYLZ\S[Z
PU]LZ[TLU[PZ^VY[O^OPSLPUYLZWLJ[VM[OLHKKP[PVUHSWYVK\J[PVU PUOPNOLYYPZRVMHSLHRWH[O[OYV\NOHUU\SPPUZ[LHKVMJVUÄUPUN
[OH[^PSS\S[PTH[LS`ILYLHSPZLK Å\PKZ[V[OLJVYYLJ[JVUK\P[[\IPUN
([^LSSSL]LS[OLYLHYLTHU`YPZRZ[VJVUZPKLY,_[LYUHS ;OLZLJOHSSLUNLZHYLJVTWV\UKLKI`[OLMHJ[[OH[VWLYH[VYZ
JHZPUNZKL[LYPVYH[LV]LY[PTLH[KPMMLYLU[KLW[OZMVYH VM[LUZ[VYLVYYLWVY[VUHZZL[PUMVYTH[PVUPUKPMMLYLU[Z`Z[LTZ
]HYPL[`VMKPMMLYLU[JVYYVZPVUTLJOHUPZTZHUKJHUYLZ\S[PUH 5V[VUS`KV[OLZLºZPSVZ»VMPUMVYTH[PVUTHRLP[KPMÄJ\S[MVYZLUPVY
SVZZVMZ[Y\J[\YHSPU[LNYP[`;OLYPZRVM^LSSJVSSHWZLPZ[OLYLMVYL L_LJ\[P]LZHUKTHUHNLTLU[[LHTZ[VJVSSH[LJVTWHYLHUK
OPNOLYHZ[OPUULK^LSSJHZPUNZI\JRSL\UKLY[OL^LPNO[VM YLWVY[VUHZZL[PU[LNYP[`KH[HI\[[OLSLUN[OVM[PTL[OPZJHU
[OL^LSS(NLPUN^LSSZHSZV[LUK[VOH]LTVYLHNNYLZZP]L [HRLPTWHJ[ZVU[OLPYHIPSP[`[VPKLU[PM`WV[LU[PHSWYVISLTZTHRL
JVUKP[PVUZUVYTHSS`ILPUNOPNOLY^H[LYJ\[HUKWV[LU[PHSS` PUMVYTLKKLJPZPVUZHUK[HRLYLTLKPHSHJ[PVU
^P[O/:HYPZPUNMYVTYLZLY]VPYJOHUNLZVYTPJYVIPHSHJ[P]P[`
*VUKP[PVUZTH`HJJLSLYH[LH[[HJRVYPU[YVK\JLJVYYVZPVU A unified approach
KHTHNL^OLYLP[^HZJVUZPKLYLKºUV[[VOHWWLU»ILMVYL (K]HUJLKHZZL[PU[LNYP[`THUHNLTLU[Z`Z[LTZPU[LNYH[LKH[H
-\Y[OLYTVYLHNLPUNZHML[`JYP[PJHS]HS]LZ:*::=ZHUK?; [OH[PZV[OLY^PZLOLSKPUZPSVZHUKWYV]PKLHUPUZ[HU[V]LY]PL^
]HS]LZOH]LHOPNOLYYPZRVMKHTHNLPU[LYTZVM[OLZLHS HUKKYPSSKV^UJHWHIPSP[`PUZ[LHKVMVWLYH[VYZOH]PUN[V[YH^S
[OYV\NOTHZZLZVMPUMVYTH[PVUOLSKPUUVUPU[LNYH[LKZ`Z[LTZ 6US`OH]PUNLZ[HISPZOLK[OLJVUKP[PVUVMHUHZZL[PZP[
([[OLZHTL[PTLJVYYVZPVUTVKLSSPUNZVM[^HYLJHUILLTWSV`LK WVZZPISL[VJVUÄYT[OLJ\YYLU[ZHMLVWLYH[PUNLU]LSVWL;OPZPZ
[VLZ[PTH[LJVYYVZPVUYH[LZ^OLUHZZLZZPUN[OLJVUKP[PVUVMHU KVULI`JVTWHYPUN[OLSH[LZ[YLZ\S[ZHNHPUZ[[OLKH[HZWLJPÄLK
HZZL[HUKPUMVYTTH[LYPHSZZLSLJ[PVU^OLUSVVRPUN[VTVKPM`VY PU[OLHZZL[»ZVYPNPUHSKLZPNUKVJ\TLU[2L`PUW\[ZPUJS\KL[OL
L_[LUKP[ZVWLYH[PUNYLTP[;VNL[OLY[OLZLZ`Z[LTZJHUWYV]PKL LZ[PTH[LKHUKVYTLHZ\YLKL_[LU[VMSPML[PTLKHTHNL[VKH[L
[OLMV\UKH[PVUMVYHYVI\Z[HZZL[SPMLL_[LUZPVUZ[YH[LN` JVYYVZPVULYVZPVUMH[PN\LHZ^LSSHZ[OLRUV^UTL[HSS\YN`
;OLÄYZ[Z[LWPZ[VJVUZPKLY[OLJVTTLYJPHSSPMLVM[OLHZZL[ VMJVUZ[Y\J[PVU^OPJOKLÄULZ[OLLU]LSVWLPUYLZWLJ[VM
;OPZTLHUZHZZLZZPUN[OLIHZPJHKLX\HJ`VM[OLPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YL WYLZZ\YL[LTWLYH[\YLÅV^YH[LZHUK[OLYLX\PYLKJOLTPJHS
PUWSHJLSVJHSTHYRL[JVUKP[PVUZHUK[OLJVUKP[PVUVM[OL PUQLJ[PVUULLKLK[VTHPU[HPU[OLZ[H[\ZX\V
YLZLY]VPY;OPZHSZVTLHUZHZZLZZPUN[OLJ\YYLU[JVUKP[PVUVM
[OLHZZL[HUKLZ[HISPZOPUN^OL[OLYVYUV[P[PZÄ[[VJVU[PU\L Actionable information
VWLYH[PVU6WLYH[VYZ^PSSULLK[VL]HS\H[LPUZWLJ[PVUKH[H (NLPUNHZZL[Z^PSSHS^H`ZIL]\SULYHISL[VJOHUNPUNJVUKP[PVUZ
SVNNPUNKH[HMVY^LSSZHUKWLYMVYTHYL]PL^VMHSSTVUP[VYLK ZV[OL`T\Z[ILYLHZZLZZLKH[YLN\SHYPU[LY]HSZHUKJVTWHYLK
WYVK\J[PVUWHYHTL[LYZ;OLSH[[LYPUJS\KLZJOHUNPUN^H[LYJ\[ HNHPUZ[HJVU[YVS[VLUZ\YL[OH[HSSWHYHTL[LYZZ[H`PUZPKL
Å\PKÅV^YH[LZHUKWYLZZ\YLWYVÄSLZV]LY[PTL [OLPYZHMLVWLYH[PUNLU]LSVWL:THSSKL[HPSLKZOPM[ZTH`IL
(JVTWYLOLUZP]L\UKLYZ[HUKPUNPZHSZVYLX\PYLKVMIV[O PUKPJH[VYZVMZVTL[OPUNTVYLKHUNLYV\ZLN/:SPTP[Z
[OLJ\YYLU[HZI\PS[TH[LYPHSZHUK[OH[VM[OLLU]PYVUTLU[PU JYLLWPUNHIV]LH[OYLZOVSKJHUYLZ\S[PUJH[HZ[YVWOPJJYHJRPUN
^OPJO[OL`HYLVWLYH[PUNPU^OLUJVTWHYLK^P[O[OLPYVYPNPUHS MHPS\YL^OPSLP[TH`ILULJLZZHY`[VHKQ\Z[[OLZHMLVWLYH[PUN
KLZPNUJVUKP[PVUZ/LYLJVYYVZPVUTVKLSSPUNZVM[^HYLWYV]PKLZ LU]LSVWLVMHUHZZL[V]LY[PTL
HUPKLHSZ[HY[PUNWVPU[NP]LU[OH[JVSSLJ[PUNPUZWLJ[PVUHUK 9HWPKYLWVY[PUNVUKH[HWYV]PKLZVWLYH[VYZ^P[O[OL
SVNNPUNKH[HPZJVZ[S`:WLJPHSPZ[ZLY]PJLZHYLYLX\PYLK[VSVN JHWHIPSP[`[VTHRLKHPS`HZZLZZTLU[ZVUHZZL[JVUKP[PVUZ
[OL^LSSHUKWYVK\J[PVUOHZ[VILZ[VWWLK^OPSLP[PZHJX\PYLK /H]PUN[OPZULHYYLHS[PTL]PZPIPSP[`HSSV^ZRL`WLYZVUULS[V
;OLYLMVYLP[PZWLYOHWZ\UZ\YWYPZPUNOV^THU`VWLYH[VYZ THRLPUMVYTLKKLJPZPVUZVU[OLULJLZZHY`HJ[PVUZZOV\SKH
JOHUNL[OL\ZLVMHUVSK^LSS^P[OV\[NP]PUN[OVYV\NO WYVISLTILPKLU[PÄLK([[OLZHTL[PTLHUPUZWLJ[PVUYLNPTL
JVUZPKLYH[PVU[V^OL[OLYP[PZZ\P[HISLMVYHUL^WYVK\J[PVU JHUILJSLHYS`KLÄULK^P[OPU[OLZ`Z[LT[VKLZJYPILOV^
JVUKP[PVU YV\[PULJOLJRZHUK[LZ[PUNWYVJLK\YLZHYLWLYMVYTLK^OV
PZYLZWVUZPISLOV^VM[LU[OL`ZOV\SKILWLYMVYTLK^OH[
ZOV\SKILYLWVY[LKHUKUL_[Z[LWZZOV\SKYLZ\S[ZMHSSV\[ZPKL
HJJLW[HUJLJYP[LYPH
>P[O[OL]PZPIPSP[`[OH[HUPU[LNYH[LKHZZL[THUHNLTLU[
Five founding pillars for asset life Z`Z[LTWYV]PKLZVWLYH[VYZHYLHSZVHISL[V[HRLHUPUMVYTLK
extension KLJPZPVUVU[OLHJ[PVUZULJLZZHY`[VWYL]LU[[OLJ\YYLU[
Ageing assets can operate safely and effectively well Z[H[\ZVMHUHZZL[VYHZZL[ZMYVTKL[LYPVYH[PUNM\Y[OLY+PMMLYLU[
beyond their specified design life, provided operators KLJPZPVUZVUTP[PNH[PVUZ`Z[LTZHYLHWWYVWYPH[LMVYKPMMLYLU[
adopt the right management approach. Outlined LX\PWTLU[-VYL_HTWSL[OL\ZLVMJH[OVKPJWYV[LJ[PVUPZH
below are five founding pillars for implementing an JVTTVUWYL]LU[H[P]LTLHZ\YLMVY[OLWYV[LJ[PVUVMJHZPUNZ
asset life extension strategy addressing both surface HUKI\YPLKWPWLSPULZ^OPSLPUOPIP[VYJHUILPUQLJ[LKPU[VIV[O
and subsurface facilities: [OL^LSSHUKZ\YMHJLLX\PWTLU[
1. Consider the potential commercial life: in respect /H]PUNHSS^LSSPU[LNYP[`KH[HH[[OLPYÄUNLY[PWZOLSWZ
of local circumstances such as the remaining VWLYH[VYZ[VTHRL[OLYPNO[KLJPZPVUPU[LYTZVMJHYY`PUNV\[
reserves, market demand and basic adequacy THPU[LUHUJLHUKYLWHPYZPUH[PTLS`MHZOPVUIHZLK\WVUHYPZR
of the infrastructure, and look for possible YHURPUNZ[YH[LN`[OH[UV[VUS`LUZ\YLZZHML[`I\[WYPVYP[PZLZ
bottlenecks. YLZV\YJLZPUHUVW[PT\T^H`[VSV^LY[OLV]LYHSSYPZRSL]LS
2. Evaluate the current condition: assess whether [OH[HUVWLYH[VYPZJHYY`PUN;OPZPZWHY[PJ\SHYS`PTWVY[HU[NP]LU
the asset is fit to continue operation by evaluating [OH[[LZ[PUNHUKWYL]LU[H[P]LYLWHPYZOH]LHUHZZVJPH[LKJVZ[
inspection data, logging data (for wells) and HUKHUPTWHJ[VU[OLVWLYH[VY»ZZOVY[[LYTWYVK\J[P]P[`^OPSZ[
perform a review of all monitored production LX\PWTLU[MHPS\YLZOH]LKPMMLYLU[JVZ[ZHUKWLYOHWZHUPTWHJ[
parameters. VUSVUN[LYTWYVK\J[P]P[`VYWV[LU[PHSZHML[`HUKLU]PYVUTLU[HS
JVUZLX\LUJLZ
3. Establish the current safe operating envelope:
>P[OHUPUJYLHZPUNKLWLUKLUJLVUL_PZ[PUN
compare results of current condition assessment
PUMYHZ[Y\J[\YL[VHJ[HZºO\IZ»PU[OLKL]LSVWTLU[VMUL^
against data specified in original design document.
ÄLSKZVYL_[LUZPVUVMHNLKÄLSKZHUKHMVJ\ZVUPTWYV]PUN
4. Prevent present status from deteriorating further: [OLYLSPHIPSP[`VML_PZ[PUNHZZL[ZJVTIPUPUN^LSSPU[LNYP[`
select appropriate mitigation systems, namely THUHNLTLU[HUKJVYYVZPVUTVKLSSPUN[VVSZWYV]PKLZH
repairs and means of protection (paint, coatings, JVZ[LMMLJ[P]LHUKYVI\Z[HWWYVHJO[VL_[LUKPUN[OL\ZLVM
cathodic protection, protective chemicals injected). LX\PWTLU[HUKPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YLWHZ[[OLVYPNPUHSS`HU[PJPWH[LK
5. Clearly define and document the inspection ZLY]PJLSPML
regime: outline roles and responsibilities, technical
and physical review procedures, instrumentation, Note
data collection and reporting tools, define next 0U[L[LJOOHZYLJLU[S`ILLUHJX\PYLKI`>VVK.YV\WHUK^PSSIL
steps should issues be identified. RUV^UHZ>VVK.YV\W0U[L[LJOWHY[VM>VVK.YV\W2LUU`
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
E
SLJ[YPJP[`PZH]P[HSLSLTLU[PUQ\Z[HIV\[L]LY` WLYMVYTJVTWYLOLUZP]LHYJÅHZOOHaHYKZ[\KPLZPU
VPSHUKNHZWYVJLZZ<WZ[YLHTKV^UZ[YLHT HJJVYKHUJL^P[O5-7(:[HUKHYK,[OL5H[PVUHS
HUKTPKZ[YLHTMHJPSP[PLZHYLWV^LYLKI` ,SLJ[YPJHS*VKLKPYLJ[P]LMVYLSLJ[YPJHSZHML[`PU[OL
LSLJ[YPJP[`+LZWP[LHSS[OLHK]HUJLZPULSLJ[YPJHS ^VYRWSHJL(YTLK^P[O[OPZPUMVYTH[PVUWV^LY
KPZ[YPI\[PVUHUKJVU[YVSTV]PUNLSLJ[YVUZ[OYV\NO Z`Z[LTLUNPULLYZJHU]PZP[VPSHUKNHZMHJPSP[PLZ
Z[YHUKZVMJVWWLYHUKIHURZVMLX\PWTLU[Z[PSS [VHZZLZZHYJÅHZOKHUNLYHUKTPUPTPZLYPZR0[PZ
WVZLZ]LY`YLHSZHML[`KHUNLYZH[VPSÄLSKZ(YJÅHZO YLJVTTLUKLK[OH[JVTWHUPLZHKVW[LUK[VLUK
PZVULVM[OLTVZ[ZLYPV\Z ZHML[`PTWYV]LTLU[Z^P[OPUP[PH[P]LZSPRL!
Ì *YLH[PUNHUKKLWSV`PUNHJVTWSL[LHYJMSHZO
What is an arc flash? Z[YH[LN`
*YLH[LKI`[OLYLSLHZLVMLULYN`MYVTHULSLJ[YPJ Ì *VUK\J[PUNVUNVPUNLTWSV`LL[YHPUPUN
HYJHYJÅHZOPZHUPTTLUZLS`WV^LYM\SI\YZ[VMOLH[ Ì 4H[JOPUNHYJMSHZOWYV[LJ[PVULX\PWTLU[HUK
LULYN`/V^WV^LYM\S&(UHYJÅHZOPUJPKLU[JHU! JSV[OPUN^P[O[OLSL]LSVMYPZR
Ì :L]LYLS`PUQ\YLVYRPSSHWLYZVUMYVTHZMHYH^H` Ì 0KLU[PM`PUNHUKL]HS\H[PUNHYJMSHZOWV[LU[PHS
HZM[VYTVYLPUJLY[HPUZP[\H[PVUZ [OYV\NOV\[HSVJH[PVU
Ì *H\ZLZLYPV\ZI\YUZ!H[á-HYJMSHZO Ì *HSJ\SH[PUNPUJPKLU[LULYN`L_WVZ\YLHUKHYJ
[LTWLYH[\YLZHYLOV[[LY[OHU[OLZ\YMHJLVM[OL MSHZOIV\UKHYPLZ
Z\U Ì 7SHJPUN^HYUPUNSHILSZ[VPUKPJH[LHYJMSHZO
Ì 7YVK\JLWYLZZ\YLHUKZV\UK^H]LZZ[YVUN OHaHYKSL]LSZ
LUV\NO[V[OYV^^VYRLYZHJYVZZHYVVTHUK
[\YU[VVSZHUKLX\PWTLU[PU[VSPML[OYLH[LUPUN
>OPSLLK\JH[PVUHUKWYLJH\[PVUZJHUYLK\JL
ZOYHWULS
HYJÅHZOVJJ\YYLUJLZ[OL`JHUUL]LYIL[V[HSS`
Ì *H\ZL]PZPVUHUKOLHYPUNSVZZMYVTL_[YLTL
LSPTPUH[LK6PSHUKNHZJVTWHUPLZJHUKLWSV`HYJ
SPNO[HUKZV\UKV\[I\YZ[Z
ÅHZOTP[PNH[PVUZ[YH[LNPLZ[VYLK\JL[OLPUJPKLU[
Ì *VZ[\W[V<:TPSSPVUWLYPUJPKLU[PU
LULYN`VM[OVZLL]LU[ZTPUPTPZPUN^VYRLYPUQ\YPLZ
OLHS[OJHYL^VYRLYZJVTWLUZH[PVULX\PWTLU[
YLWSHJLTLU[HUKYLWHPYPUJYLHZLKPUZ\YHUJL HUKLX\PWTLU[KHTHNL
WYLTP\TZHUKSVZ[WYVK\J[PVU[PTLHJJVYKPUN
[VHU,SLJ[YPJ7V^LY9LZLHYJO0UZ[P[\[LZ[\K` Selecting a strategy: mitigation
versus containment
(YJÅHZOKHUNLYPZWYLZLU[[OYV\NOV\[HUVPSÄLSK :L]LYHS]HYPHISLZKL[LYTPUL[OLLULYN`PUHUHYJ
4VZ[MYLX\LU[S`HYJÅHZOPUJPKLU[ZVJJ\Y^OLUHU ÅHZOPUJS\KPUN!]VS[HNLH]HPSHISLIVS[LKMH\S[
LUNPULLYPZZLY]PJPUNLULYNPZLKLSLJ[YPJHSLX\PWTLU[ J\YYLU[LX\PWTLU[KLZPNUHUKHYJK\YH[PVU;OL
(UHJ[PVUHZTPUVYHZKYVWWPUNH^YLUJOJHUJH\ZL LHZPLZ[]HYPHISL[VJVU[YVSPZHSZVVULVM[OLTVZ[
HUHYJÅHZOL]LU[PMP[MHSSZHJYVZZJVUK\J[VYZ PTWVY[HU[MHJ[VYZPULULYN`V\[W\[!HYJK\YH[PVU
,SLJ[YPJHS:HML[`-V\UKH[PVU0U[LYUH[PVUHS 9LK\JL[OLHTV\U[VM[PTLPU[OLHYJÅHZOLX\H[PVU
YLWVY[Z[OH[LHJO`LHYTVYL[OHUWLVWSLZLLR HUK[OLLULYN`PZSV^LYLKSP]LZJHUILZH]LKHUK
[YLH[TLU[MVYZLYPV\ZHYJÅHZOI\YUZ-PN\YLZMYVT LX\PWTLU[VYZ`Z[LTYLSH[LKKV^U[PTLJHUIL
[OL0U[LYUH[PVUHS(ZZVJPH[PVUVM6PS
.HZ7YVK\JLYZ TPUPTPZLK
YLWVY[ZOV^[OH[VMVPSÄLSK^VYRLYZ»KLH[OZHYL 5VZPUNSLK\YH[PVUYLK\JPUNZVS\[PVUÄ[ZL]LY`
KPYLJ[S`YLSH[LK[VHULSLJ[YPJHSHJJPKLU[HUKHYL ZP[\H[PVU,HJOZVS\[PVUNP]LZJVTWHUPLZHKPMMLYLU[
YLSH[LK[VL_WSVZPVUZVYI\YUZ HWWYVHJO[VTH_PTPZL[OLZHML[`PU^VYRHYLHZ^OPSL
0[PZWSHPU[VZLL[OH[HYJÅHZOOHaHYKZKLTHUK KLSP]LYPUNHYLSPHISLLULYN`ZV\YJLMVYYLÄULYPLZYPNZ
[OLPUK\Z[Y`»ZH[[LU[PVUHUKYLX\PYLWSHUZMVY O\IZHUKZ[VYHNLMHJPSP[PLZ
YLK\JPUN[OLYPZRHUKKHUNLY :VTLJVTWHUPLZW\YZ\LZ[YH[LNPLZMVYHYJÅHZO
JVU[HPUTLU[PUZ[LHKVMTP[PNH[PVU*VU[HPUTLU[
Assessing the risk ZLLRZ[VJHW[\YLHUKKPZWLYZL[OLLMMLJ[ZVM
6PSHUKNHZJVTWHUPLZZOV\SKYLHJOV\[[VLSLJ[YPJHS HUHYJÅHZO^P[OPUOHYKLULKLX\PWTLU[>OPSL
KPZ[YPI\[PVUL_WLY[ZMVYOLSWPUJYLH[PUNJVTWSL[L JVU[HPUTLU[OHZTHU`ZPNUPÄJHU[ILULÄ[ZSPRL
WYVNYHTTLZ[OH[SPTP[[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMHUHYJÅHZO JVTWHY[TLU[HSPZH[PVUVM[OLHYJZVHZ[VWYL]LU[
HUKTPUPTPZL[OLLMMLJ[ZVMHUPUJPKLU[-VYL_HTWSL WYVWHNH[PVU[OYV\NOV\[[OLSPUL\WVMLX\PWTLU[
.,[YHPUZHUKJLY[PÄLZP[ZWV^LYZ`Z[LTLUNPULLYZ[V [OLHIPSP[`[VL_OH\Z[[OLOV[NHZLZVM[OLL]LU[
Marty Trivette,
GE, USA, outlines
various strategies
and technologies
that can be deployed
to protect workers and speed
recovery from arc flash incidents in
oil and gas operations.
Ì 4P[PNH[L^P[OPUZ[HU[HULV\ZaVUL
ZLSLJ[P]LPU[LYSVJRPUN0A:0!0A:0
WYV[LJ[PVUKLSP]LYZJVU[PU\V\ZZHML[`
HUKZLSLJ[P]P[`HNHPUZ[HYJMSHZO
LULYN`;OPZKL]LSVWTLU[PZH[V[HS
Z`Z[LTYL[OPURPUN[OH[WSHJLZ[OL
THPUJPYJ\P[IYLHRLYVUHUHS[LYUH[L
ZL[[PUNPMHMH\S[VJJ\YZILSV^[OL
MLLKLY:VP[ILJVTLZWVZZPISL[V
Z[H`\WHUKY\UUPUNL]LUHM[LYHU
HYJMSHZO;OPZJVUJLW[WYL]PV\ZS`
YLNHYKLKHZ\UVI[HPUHISLWYV]PKLZ
ZPT\S[HULV\ZZLSLJ[P]P[`HUKHYJMSHZO
WYV[LJ[PVUPUVUL[LJOUVSVN`0A:0
JHZLZ[\KPLZYLWVY[HYJMSHZOLULYN`
JHUILYLK\JLK[VQ\Z[¶VM
[OLLULYN`YLSLHZLKK\YPUNL]LU[Z
^P[O[YHKP[PVUHSA:0VYZ[HNNLYLK
WYV[LJ[PVU
Ì 4P[PNH[L^P[OYLK\JLKLULYN`SL[[OY\
Figure 1. Normal operation: sensitive response; short-time protection limits selectivity to less 9,3;!9,3;PZHZHML[`^PUKV^5L^
than 6 kA. As the curve overlap illustrates (see lower right diagram), zone selective interlocking KPNP[HS[YPW\UP[ZVMMLY[^VZLWHYH[L
(ZSI) is effective, but has limitations. With no ZSI, selectivity is limited to < 6 kA. With ZSI, it PUZ[HU[HULV\ZZL[WVPU[Z:V^VYRLYZ
improves to > 10 kA. With instantaneous zone selective interlocking (I-ZSI), shown in the upper JHUSV^LY[OL[YPW[OYLZOVSK^P[O
right diagram, 85 kA selectivity is achieved and instantaneous protection still provides reduced [OLMSPWVMHZ^P[JOILMVYLZLY]PJPUN
arc flash energy to maximise both system reliability and protection. LULYNPZLKLX\PWTLU[;OPZJHU
KYHTH[PJHSS`SV^LYPUJPKLU[LULYN`
WV[LU[PHS
H^H`MYVTWLYZVUULSHUKZLUZP[P]LLX\PWTLU[HUKL]LU[OLPZVSH[PVU
VMSV^]VS[HNLJVU[YVSHUKPUZ[Y\TLU[JVTWHY[TLU[Z.,ILSPL]LZ
Ì 4P[PNH[LI`YL[YVMP[[PUNM\ZL[LJOUVSVN`SVHKPU[LYY\W[LY
Z^P[JOLZ^P[OMHZ[JPYJ\P[IYLHRLYZ!6SKLYLX\PWTLU[PU
TP[PNH[PVUPZMHYZ\WLYPVY[VJVU[HPUTLU[I\[\ZPUNIV[OPZL]LUIL[[LY THU`VPSMPLSKZ\ZLZM\ZLZ[VJ\[WV^LYPUSVHKPU[LYY\W[LY
/LYLPZ^O`! Z^P[JOLZVUKPZ[YPI\[PVU[YHUZMVYTLYWYPTHYPLZ-\ZLZJHU
Ì *VU[HPUTLU[PZHJYHZOHUKI\YUZ[YH[LN`*VU[HPUTLU[ [HRL\W[VOHSMHZLJVUK[VYLZWVUK¶HUL[LYUP[`MVYHU
LX\PWTLU[[OH[JHW[\YLZHYJMSHZOLULYN`PZZ\IZ[HU[PHSS` HYJMSHZOL]LU[9L[YVMP[[PUNM\ZLKPU[LYY\W[LYZ^P[JOLZ^P[O
KLZ[YV`LKK\YPUNHUHYJMSHZOL]LU[0[ULLKZ[VILJVTWSL[LS` TVKLYUJPYJ\P[IYLHRLYZJHUJ\[VMMWV^LYPU[OYLLJ`JSLZ
YLWSHJLK;OH[YLZ\S[ZPUSVUNKV^U[PTLZL_JLZZL_WLUZLHUK VMHZLJVUKKYHTH[PJHSS`SPTP[PUN[OLHYJMSHZO[PTL
SVNPZ[PJHSJOHSSLUNLZ4P[PNH[PVUZH]LZTVZ[LX\PWTLU[HUK HUKZPNUPMPJHU[S`YLK\JPUNP[ZLULYN`
TPUPTPZLZYLJV]LY`[PTL¶VM[LUMHJPSP[H[PUNYLWHPYZ^P[OWHY[ZVU
OHUK
Ì 4P[PNH[L^P[OLULYN`[YHUZMLYHUKJVU[HPUTLU[!(UL^
HYJJVU[HPUTLU[[LJOUVSVN`[OH[\ZLZHYJ[VHYJ[YHUZMLY
Ì *VU[HPUTLU[LX\PWTLU[VUS`WYV[LJ[ZWLVWSL^OLUKVVYZHYL [VRLLWLULYN`SV^HUKHSSV^MHZ[TP[PNH[PVUPZUV^
ZLJ\YLKHUKJV]LYZHYLVU¶[OPZPZUV[HS^H`Z[OLJHZL^OLU H]HPSHISL;OPZO`IYPKZVS\[PVUJHUZ[VWHULSLJ[YPJHSMH\S[
^VYRLYZHYL[YV\ISLZOVV[PUNHMH\S[VUKV^UZ[YLHTSVHKZ PUTPSSPZLJVUKZVYSLZZTP[PNH[PUN[OLMH\S[^OPSLHSZV
Ì *VU[HPUTLU[LX\PWTLU[PZYLSH[P]LS`SHYNLOLH]`HUKOHYK[V^VYR [YHUZMLYYPUN[OLLULYN`PU[VHOHYKLULKJVU[HPUTLU[
^P[O¶PUJYLHZPUNPUP[PHSJVZ[SHIV\YHUKTHPU[LUHUJLOHZZSLZ KVTL:PUJL[OLOHYKLULKZ`Z[LTZO\[ZKV^U[OL
Ì .P]LU[OLSPTP[LKH]HPSHISLMVV[WYPU[ZPUWSHU[ZVUYPNZHUKPU MSHZOHUKP[ZLULYN`ZVX\PJRS`P[Z\Z[HPUZSP[[SLKHTHNL
,/V\ZLZJVU[HPUTLU[LX\PWTLU[HUKHZZVJPH[LKL_OH\Z[ K\YPUNHUL]LU[:V^VYRLYZJHUX\PJRS`PUZ[HSSHZWHYL
WSLU\TZ[HRLZ\WTVYLZWHJL[OHUTH`ILH]HPSHISL JVU[HPUTLU[KVTLHUKOH]L[OLJVTWSL[LZ`Z[LT
Ì *VU[HPUTLU[PZUV[HZ[YH[LN`MVYYL[YVMP[[PUNL_PZ[PUNNLHY¶P[ H]HPSHISLMVYZLY]PJLPUOV\YZPUZ[LHKVM^LLRZ;OPZ
ZVS\[PVUKLSP]LYZHNYLH[LYYL[\YUVUPU]LZ[TLU[[OYV\NO
YLX\PYLZJVTWSL[LYLWSHJLTLU[
YLK\JLKKV^U[PTLLUOHUJLKWYVK\J[P]P[`HUKSV^LYYPZR
VMPUQ\Y`
Deploying arc flash mitigation solutions
0U[OLWHZ[KLJHKLZL]LYHS[LJOUVSVN`IYLHR[OYV\NOZOH]LPTWYV]LK Ì 4P[PNH[LWYVHJ[P]LS`^P[OWYVWLYKLZPNUMVYUL^VPSHUK
NHZMHJPSP[PLZ!;OLHMVYLTLU[PVULKHYJMSHZOTP[PNH[PVU
[OLTHUHNLTLU[VMHUHYJÅHZO»ZWV[LU[PHSKHUNLY.,LUNPULLYZOH]L
[LJOUVSVNPLZHUKZ[YH[LNPLZZOV\SKILWHY[VM[OLKLZPNU
^VYRLKVU^H`Z[VHWWS`[OLZLIYLHR[OYV\NOZ[VPUZ[HSSLKLX\PWTLU[
MVYUL^LSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTZHZ^LSSHZYL[YVMP[Z)LNPUUPUN
YLNHYKSLZZVM[OLTHU\MHJ[\YLY(ZHYLZ\S[VPSHUKNHZJVTWHUPLZJHU ^P[OHWYVWLYWV^LYZ`Z[LTZ[\K`HUK[LJOUVSVN`
YLK\JL[OLHYJÅHZOYPZRPU[OLPYPUZ[HSSLKPUMYHZ[Y\J[\YLPUJYLHZPUN[OL ZLSLJ[PVUJHUZPNUPMPJHU[S`PTWYV]LJVVYKPUH[LK
\ZLHISLSPMLVMJHWP[HSLX\PWTLU[HUKPTWYV]PUNZHML[` WLYMVYTHUJLHUKZHML[`<ZPUNHWYV]LUWV^LYZ`Z[LT
;OLMVSSV^PUNHYLZ[YH[LNPLZMVYJVTWHUPLZ[VKLWSV`PUVYKLY[V KLZPNUZVM[^HYLWHJRHNL[VKLZPNUHUKZPT\SH[L
YLK\JL[OLPYYPZRVMHUHYJÅHZOPUJPKLU[! WLYMVYTHUJLJHUOLSWTPUPTPZL[OLLMMLJ[ZVMHUHYJMSHZO
Ì 4P[PNH[L^P[O[YPW\UP[Z\ZPUNSV^LYZOVY[[PTLKLSH`IHUKZ!/V^
X\PJRS`KVJPYJ\P[IYLHRLYZ[YPWPU[OLL]LU[VMHMH\S[&6SKLY Summary
[YPW\UP[ZPUWVY[HISLWV^LYZ\WWSPLZ\ZLKPUKYPSSPUNVYVSKLY ;OLKHUNLYVMHYJÅHZOJHUUL]LYILJVTWSL[LS`LSPTPUH[LK
Z^P[JONLHYHYLYLSH[P]LS`ZSV^3V^LYPUNZOVY[[PTLKLSH`[PTLZ I\[HMVJ\ZLKZ[YH[LN`HUKVUNVPUN]PNPSHUJLJHUYLK\JLYPZR
JHUYLK\JL[OL[PTLP[[HRLZHJPYJ\P[IYLHRLY[V[YPWI`\W[V HUKTH_PTPZLZHML[`HUKWYVK\J[P]P[`H[VPSÄLSKZHYV\UK[OL
;OPZJHUZSHZO[OLLULYN`VMHUHYJMSHZOL]LU[ NSVIL
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
David Lawler, Forensic Risk Alliance, UK, reveals
everything you wanted to know about whistleblowing,
but were afraid to ask.
W
OPZ[SLISV^PUNPZHISHURL[[LYTMVYHZP[\H[PVU L_[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^LY(ZHYLZ\S[,UYVUZ\MMLYLKHTHQVY
^OLUHTLTILYVMZ[HMMVYV[OLYZ[HRLOVSKLY JVSSHWZLHUKL]LU[\HSIHURY\W[J`"P[ZH\KP[VYHUK*OPLM
WYV]PKLZJVUMPKLU[PHSPUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[Z\ZWLJ[LK -PUHUJPHS6MMPJLY^LYLHSZVPUKPJ[LK0[JV\SKILHYN\LK
^YVUNKVPUNLP[OLY[V[OLPYLTWSV`LYVY[VHYLN\SH[VY [OH[[OL,UYVUZP[\H[PVUJVTIPULK^P[O[OLJVSSHWZLVM
(S[OV\NOIV[OVM[OLZLZP[\H[PVUZHYLJV]LYLKI`[OLZHTL >VYSK*VTHUK[OLZLU[LUJPUNVMP[ZMVYTLY*-6[VMP]L`LHYZ
[LYT[OL`OH]L]LY`KPMMLYLU[YLZ\S[ZHUKJVUZLX\LUJLZHZ PUQHPS[OLMVSSV^PUN`LHYHSZVWYLJPWP[H[LKI`HUL_[LYUHS
MHYHZJVTWHUPLZHYLJVUJLYULK0U[OPZHY[PJSLWYV]PKPUN ^OPZ[SLISV^LYJOHUNLKNSVIHSH[[P[\KLZ[VJVYWVYH[L
PUMVYTH[PVU[VVUL»ZLTWSV`LY^PSSILYLMLYYLK[VHZºPU[LYUHS JVYY\W[PVUHUK^HZ[OLJH[HS`Z[MVY[OLPTWSLTLU[H[PVU
^OPZ[SLISV^PUN»HUKWYV]PKPUNPUMVYTH[PVU[VHYLN\SH[VY^PSS VMUL^HU[PJVYY\W[PVUSH^ZHYV\UK[OL^VYSK0UMHJ[
ILJHSSLKºL_[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^PUN» ^OPZ[SLISV^PUNOHKZ\JOYHTPMPJH[PVUZNSVIHSS`[OH[HSS[OYLL
0U:OLYYVU>H[RPUZH]PJLWYLZPKLU[H[ VM;04,4HNHaPUL»Zº7LYZVUZVM[OL@LHY»PU^LYLTHQVY
,UYVU*VYW\UJV]LYLKL]PKLUJL[OH[ZVTLVM[OL JVYWVYH[L^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ
JVTWHU`»ZHJJV\U[PUNWYHJ[PJLZ^LYL\UL[OPJHS:OL -YVTIV[OHUVWLYH[PVUHSHUKMPUHUJPHSWLYZWLJ[P]L[OL
HWWYVHJOLK[OLIVHYK[VNL[[OLTH[[LYYLZVS]LKHJ[PUN YLSL]HUJLVM^OPZ[SLISV^PUNPU[OLUH[\YHSYLZV\YJLZLJ[VYPZ
MPYZ[HZHUPU[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^LY;OL`KPKUV[SPZ[LU JSLHY¶P[ZLSMOPNOS`YLN\SH[LKHUKVWLYH[PUNPUZVTLVM[OL
HUK>H[RPUZ^HZMVYJLK[VNVW\ISPJILJVTPUNHU TVZ[OPNOYPZRNLVSVNPJHSHUKNLVNYHWOPJHYLHZ
Getting the house in order L_WYLZZJVUJLYUZTHRPUNP[LHZPLYHUKTVYLJVTMVY[HISLMVY
6]LYHKLJHKLSH[LYHUK[OLTHQVYP[`VMJVTWHUPLZHYLTVYL LTWSV`LLZ[VYLWVY[[V[OLPYLTWSV`LYYH[OLY[OHU[VHYLN\SH[VY
H^HYL[OHUL]LY[OH[[VTHPU[HPUYLW\[H[PVUHUKPU[LNYP[`HUK /H]PUNHJSLHYLHZ`[V\ZL^OPZ[SLISV^PUNWYVJLK\YLPUWSHJL
[VJVTWS`^P[OSLNPZSH[PVUZ\JOHZ:HYIHULZ6_SL`[OL`ZOV\SK HUKTHRPUNZ\YL[OH[LTWSV`LLZRUV^HIV\[P[^PSSNVHSVUN
OH]LTLJOHUPZTZPUWSHJL[VH]LY[\UL[OPJHSWYHJ[PJLZ/V^L]LY ^H`[V^HYKZLUJV\YHNPUN[OLT[V[\YU[V[OLPYLTWSV`LYÄYZ[
O\THUUH[\YLILPUN^OH[P[PZL]LU^P[OZ\JOTLJOHUPZTZPU ^OLUZVTL[OPUNPZHTPZZ
WSHJLZVTLWLVWSL^PSSHJ[P]LS`JOVVZL[VIYLHR[OLY\SLZ
\Z\HSS`MVYÄUHUJPHSNHPUVY^PSSWHZZP]LS`WHY[PJPWH[LVYZPTWS` Motivation - morals or money?
ºSVVR[OLV[OLY^H`»^OLUV[OLYZKVZV[OH[[OL`JHURLLW -VYTHU``LHYZ[OL<:OHZOHKHTLJOHUPZTPUWSHJL^OLYLI`
[OLPYOLHKZKV^UHUKUV[H[[YHJ[ULNH[P]LH[[LU[PVU^P[OPU[OLPY ^OPZ[SLISV^LYZJV\SKZOHYLPUHU`M\UKZ[OH[^LYLYLJV]LYLK
VYNHUPZH[PVU-VY[OPZYLHZVUPMJVTWHUPLZYLHSS`^HU[[VKLHS HZHYLZ\S[VM[OLPYPUMVYTH[PVU-VYL_HTWSL[OL09:TH`WH`
^P[OWV[LU[PHSS`\UL[OPJHSILOH]PV\YHUK\ZL[OLPUMVYTH[PVU[OH[ H^HYKZ[VWLVWSL^OVWYV]PKLZWLJPÄJHUKJYLKPISLPUMVYTH[PVU
PU[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^LYZWYV]PKL[V[OLPYHK]HU[HNL[OL`ULLK PM[OLPUMVYTH[PVUYLZ\S[ZPU[OLJVSSLJ[PVUVM[H_LZWLUHS[PLZ
[VNL[PU[VHWVZP[PVU^OLYL[OL`HYLHISL[VKLHS^P[OÅHNNLK PU[LYLZ[VYV[OLYHTV\U[ZMYVTHUVUJVTWSPHU[[H_WH`LY0M
WYVISLTZPUOV\ZL;OPZ^PSSHSSV^[OLT[VOHUKSLZ\JOPZZ\LZ [OLZ\TZPUKPZW\[LL_JLLK<:TPSSPVUHUKJLY[HPUV[OLY
PU[LYUHSS`ILMVYLHULTWSV`LLMLLSZ[OH[[OL`OH]LUVV[OLY X\HSPÄJH[PVUZHYLTL[[OL09:^PSSWH`IL[^LLUHUKVM
JOVPJL[OHU[VºNVW\ISPJ»^P[O[OLPYÄUKPUNZ [OLYLJV]LYLKHTV\U[[V[OL^OPZ[SLISV^LY;OL09:HSZVOHZ
*VTWHUPLZJHUKV[OPZI`HJ[P]LS`WYVTV[PUNPU[LYUHS HUH^HYKWYVNYHTTLMVYV[OLY^OPZ[SLISV^LYZNLULYHSS`[OVZL
^OPZ[SLISV^PUNPU[OLOVWL[OH[L_[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^PUNPZUL]LY ^OVKVUV[TLL[[OLKVSSHY[OYLZOVSKZVM<:TPSSPVUPUKPZW\[L
ULLKLK0UKLLK^OH[KPZ[PUN\PZOLZHNVVKJVTWHU`MYVTH VYJHZLZPU]VS]PUNPUKP]PK\HS[H_WH`LYZ^P[ONYVZZPUJVTLVMSLZZ
WVVYVULVYHNYLH[JVTWHU`MYVTHNVVKVULPZUV[[OLL_[LU[ [OH[<:;OLH^HYKZ[OYV\NO[OPZWYVNYHTTLHYLSLZZ
[V^OPJOP[OHZWYVISLTZI\[P[Z^PSSPUNULZZ[VSLHYUHIV\[[OVZL ^P[OHTH_PT\TH^HYKVM\W[V<:TPSSPVU
WYVISLTZ\UKLYZ[HUK[OLTHUKX\PJRS`W\[[OLTYPNO[;OLYL 0UHKKP[PVUHU`VUL^P[OPUZPKLRUV^SLKNLVMMYH\KILPUN
HYLZVTLL_HTWSLZVMVPSZLY]PJLZJVTWHUPLZ[OH[HJ[P]LS` JVTTP[[LKI`JVU[YHJ[VYZHNHPUZ[[OLNV]LYUTLU[JHUÄSL^OH[
YL^HYK^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ^P[OIVU\ZWH`TLU[Z0UKLLKOH]PUN OHZILJVTLRUV^UHZHºX\P[HTSH^Z\P[»VU[OLNV]LYUTLU[»Z
^P[ULZZLK[OLKL]HZ[H[PVUJH\ZLKI`L_[LYUHS^OPZ[SLISV^PUN ILOHSMYLJLP]PUNHZOHYLVM[OLYLJV]LY`HZ[OLPYYL^HYK:\JO
[VTHQVYJVYWVYH[PVUZZ\JOHZ,UYVUHUK>VYSK*VTHUK JSHPTZOH]LILLUÄSLKI`WLVWSL^P[OPUZPKLRUV^SLKNLVMMHSZL
[OLYHM[VMYLN\SH[PVUZ[OH[^LYLPU[YVK\JLKPU[OLPY^HRLVUL JSHPTZ[OH[OH]L[`WPJHSS`PU]VS]LKOLHS[OJHYLTPSP[HY`VYV[OLY
TPNO[HZZ\TL[OH[PU[OLSHZ[KLJHKLJVTWHUPLZHUKW\ISPJ NV]LYUTLU[ZWLUKPUNWYVNYHTTLZ4VYLYLJLU[S`HZWHY[VM[OL
ZLJ[VYVYNHUPZH[PVUZHSSV]LY[OL^VYSK^V\SKOH]LILLUKVPUN YLN\SH[VY`YLMVYTSLNPZSH[PVUPU[YVK\JLKPUYLZWVUZL[V[OLMYH\K
L]LY`[OPUN[OL`JV\SK[VLUJV\YHNLHULU]PYVUTLU[^OLYL WLYWL[YH[LKI`)LYUPL4HKVMM[OL<::LJ\YP[PLZHUK,_JOHUNL
LTWSV`LLZ^V\SKMLLSZHML[VISV^[OL^OPZ[SLPU[LYUHSS` *VTTPZZPVU»ZSP[[SL\ZLK>OPZ[SLISV^LY)V\U[`7YVNYHT^HZ
JVUÄKLU[[OH[[OLPYJVUJLYUZ^V\SKIL[HRLUZLYPV\ZS`/V^L]LY L_[LUKLK[VJV]LYWLVWSLJVTPUNMVY^HYK^P[OL]PKLUJLVMHU`
VULVUS`OHZ[VSVVRH[[OLU\TILYVMYLJLU[ZJHUKHSZPU[OL [`WLVMZOHYLMYH\K
IHURPUNHUKÄUHUJPHSZLY]PJLZPUK\Z[YPLZPU[OL<:(HUKHJYVZZ :WLJPÄJHSS`[OLUL^º+VKK¶-YHUR>HSS:[YLL[9LMVYTHUK
,\YVWL[VRUV^[OH[[OPZPZUV[OHWWLUPUNL]LY`^OLYL *VUZ\TLY7YV[LJ[PVU(J[»UV^TLHUZ[OH[PUKP]PK\HSZ
;OPZZP[\H[PVUPZPSS\Z[YH[LKPUHYLJLU[,\YV-PUHUJLZ\Y]L` JVTPUNMVY^HYK^P[OPUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[MYH\KZVYIYPILY`Z[HUK
^OPJOZ\NNLZ[ZVUHNSVIHSIHZPZ[OH[HSTVZ[H[OPYKVM [VYLJLP]LIL[^LLUHUKVMHTV\U[ZV]LY<:TPSSPVU
VYNHUPZH[PVUZZ[PSSOH]LUVMVYTHSWYVJLZZMVY[OLPYLTWSV`LLZ[V YLJV]LYLKI`[OL:,*[OYV\NOZ\IZLX\LU[LUMVYJLTLU[HJ[PVUZ
YLWVY[ÄUHUJPHS^YVUNKVPUNVY[OLPYLTWSV`LLZHYL\UH^HYL[OH[ ;OL:,*KLJPKLZ[OLÄUHSHTV\U[IHZLKVU[OLVYPNPUHSP[`HUK
HU`WYVJLZZL_PZ[Z;OLYLWVY[HSZVOPNOSPNO[Z[OH[LTWSV`LLZ ]HS\LVM[OLPUMVYTH[PVUWYV]PKLKHUKOV^KPYLJ[S`P[SLK[V[OL
PUVYNHUPZH[PVUZ^P[OV\[HMVYTHS^OPZ[SLISV^PUNWYVJLZZ ÄUHUJPHSWLUHS[`ILPUNSL]PLKHNHPUZ[[OLKLMLUKHU[
YLWVY[LK^P[ULZZPUNT\JOOPNOLYSL]LSZVM\UKL[LJ[LKZLYPV\Z >P[O[OLPTWSLTLU[H[PVUVM+VKK-YHURºIV\U[PLZ»PU
ÄUHUJPHS^YVUNKVPUN[OHU[OVZLPUVYNHUPZH[PVUZ^P[OH [OL<:P[PZL]LUTVYLPTWVY[HU[[OH[JVTWHUPLZNL[[OL
MVYTHSWYVJLZZPUWSHJL;OPZPTWSPLZ[OH[[OLYLPZHKPYLJ[ TLZZHNLHJYVZZ[OH[[OL`[HRLLTWSV`LLJVUJLYUZZLYPV\ZS`
YLSH[PVUZOPWIL[^LLUJVTWHUPLZLUJV\YHNPUN[OLPYLTWSV`LLZ[V [VLUJV\YHNLHU`^V\SKIL^OPZ[SLISV^LY[VYLWVY[KPYLJ[S`
YLWVY[[OLPYJVUJLYUZHUKYLK\JLKSL]LSZVMTPZJVUK\J[ [V[OLJVTWHU`HUKUV[[V[OLNV]LYUTLU[:VTLHYN\L
[OH[^OPZ[SLISV^LYPUJLU[P]LZYPZRJOHUNPUN[OLK`UHTPJ
An effective internal ‘speaking up’ mechanism VMPU[LYUHSPU]LZ[PNH[PVUZ*VTWSPHUJLWLVWSL^VYY`[OH[
0UKP]PK\HSZHYLTVYLSPRLS`[V[HRLHJ[PVUHUK[LSS[OLPYLTWSV`LYZ IV\U[`WYVNYHTTLZ^PSS\UKLYTPUL[OLPYPU[LYUHSJVTWSPHUJL
HIV\[\UHJJLW[HISLILOH]PV\YPM[OLYLPZHMVYTHSWVSPJ`PUWSHJL WYVNYHTTLZHZLTWSV`LLZ^OV^V\SKVUJLOH]LHWWYVHJOLK
[OH[VMMLYZULHYHIZVS\[LJVUÄKLU[PHSP[`6[OLY^PZLHJ\S[\YLVM [OLTKPYLJ[S`^P[O[OLPYZ\ZWPJPVUZTH`UV^KLJPKLPUZ[LHK[V
MLHYHUKºSVVRPUN[OLV[OLY^H`»^PSSKL]LSVW^P[OWLVWSLHMYHPK NVZ[YHPNO[[V[OLYLN\SH[VYZPU[OLOVWLVMHÄUHUJPHSYL^HYK
[VZWLHRV\[H[[OLYPZRVMPU[PTPKH[PVUHUKILPUNVZ[YHJPZLKI` ;OL:,*NVLZZVTL^H`[VLUJV\YHNPUNPU[LYUHSYLWVY[PUN
[OLPYWLLYZ0[PZPTWVY[HU[IV[O[VZHMLN\HYK[OLJVUÄKLU[PHSP[`VM HZHÄYZ[TLHZ\YLI`Z[H[PUN[OH[H^OPZ[SLISV^LYPZLSPNPISLMVY
[OL^OPZ[SLISV^LYHUK[VWYVWLYS`PU]LZ[PNH[LHSSHSSLNH[PVUZTHKL HYL^HYKPM[OL`YLWVY[PU[LYUHSS`HUK[OLJVTWHU`PUMVYTZ[OL
-VYJVTWHUPLZZ\IQLJ[[V[OL:HYIHULZ6_SL`(J[[OPZ :,*HIV\[[OL]PVSH[PVUZ0[HSZVVMMLYZÄUHUJPHSPUJLU[P]LZMVY
HUVU`TV\ZYLWVY[PUNYLX\PYLTLU[T\Z[HSZVILL_[LUKLK[V[OPYK ^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ[OH[Z\WWVY[HJVTWHU`»ZL_PZ[PUNJVTWSPHUJL
WHY[PLZ(JJVYKPUNS`JVTWHUPLZVM[LULZ[HISPZOHUHUVU`TV\Z HUKYLWVY[PUNZ`Z[LTZHUKKPZPUJLU[P]LZ[V[OVZL[OH[
[LSLWOVULOV[SPULVY\ZLHUPU[LYUL[IHZLKTLJOHUPZTMVY PU[LYMLYL^P[OPU[LYUHSJVTWSPHUJLHUKYLWVY[PUN/V^L]LY
HUVU`TV\ZJVTT\UPJH[PVUZHUK[VLUJV\YHNLLTWSV`LLZ[V ^OPZ[SLISV^LYZHYLUV[KPYLJ[S`YLX\PYLK[VYLWVY[]PVSH[PVUZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
PU[LYUHSS`[VX\HSPM`MVYHUH^HYKZVTHU`JV\SKIL[LTW[LK 0UHUV[OLYYLJLU[[YLUKLTWSV`LLZOH]LHSSLNLK^YVUNM\S
[V[HRL[OLSLHZ[WHPUM\SVW[PVUHUKYLWVY[[V[OL:,*Z[YHPNO[ [LYTPUH[PVUVMLTWSV`TLU[MVYIYPUNPUNIYPILY`JVUJLYUZ[V[OL
H^H`L]LU^OLU[OLYLHYLWYVJLZZLZPUWSHJL[VOLHYHUKHJ[ H[[LU[PVUVM[OLPYTHUHNLYZPM^OPZ[SLISV^PUNOHZYLZ\S[LKPU[OL
VU[OLPYÄUKPUNZ LTWSV`LLILPUNKPZHK]HU[HNLKVYKPZTPZZLK;OL<:JV\Y[Z
.P]LU[OLSHYNLÄULZPUMVYLPNUIYPILY`JHZLZPUYLJLU[ OH]LOLSK[OH[HULTWSV`LLHSSLNLKS`KPZTPZZLKILJH\ZL[OL`
`LHYZ[OLYLJV\SKILZVTLIPNYL^HYKZMVY[OVZLWYLWHYLK LP[OLYYLWVY[LKVYYLM\ZLK[VWHY[PJPWH[LPUJVUK\J[[OH[PUJS\KLZ
[VZWLHRV\[-\Y[OLYP[PZRUV^U[OH[JLY[HPUZLJ[VYZZ\JO ºWYLKPJH[LHJ[Z»Z\JOHZISHJRTHPSHUKL_[VY[PVU\UKLY[OL
HZL_[YHJ[P]LHYLHS^H`ZNVPUN[VIL\UKLYZJY\[PU`MYVT 9HJRL[LLY0UÅ\LUJLKHUK*VYY\W[6YNHUPaH[PVUZ(J[90*6JHU
YLN\SH[VYZHUKWYVUL[VPU]LZ[PNH[PVUZ¶VUL.*PU[OPZZLJ[VY IYPUNHJP]PS90*6Z\P[PM[OL`JHUKLTVUZ[YH[L[OLPYKPZTPZZHS
^HZOLHYKZH`PUN[OH[º[OLYLHYL[^V[`WLZVMVPSZLY]PJLZ ^HZWHY[VMHJVUZWPYHJ`[V]PVSH[L90*6
JVTWHU`![OVZL\UKLYPU]LZ[PNH[PVUHUK[OVZL^HP[PUN[VIL -\Y[OLYHÄLSK0UKPHPZPU[OLWYVJLZZVMWHZZPUNº;OL
PU]LZ[PNH[LKHNHPU»0[PZVI]PV\ZS`UV[Q\Z[UH[\YHSYLZV\YJLZ >OPZ[SLISV^LYZ7YV[LJ[PVU)PSS»[VZHMLN\HYK[OVZLL_WVZPUN
[OH[PZPU[OL^OPZ[SLISV^PUNZ^LL[ZWV[SHZ[:LW[LTILYH JVYY\W[PVUVYTHSWYHJ[PJLI`W\ISPJZLY]HU[Z0MHWWYV]LKP[
MVYTLY<):IHURLY^OVISL^[OL^OPZ[SLVU^PKLZWYLHK[H_ ^V\SKIL0UKPH»ZÄYZ[SH^[VWYV[LJ[^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ0UJPKLU[Z
L]HZPVUI`<:JP[PaLUZ\ZPUN[OLIHUR»ZHJJV\U[ZYLJLP]LKH VMOHYHZZTLU[PU[PTPKH[PVUHUK]PVSLUJLOH]LILLUYLWVY[LK
<:TPSSPVUYL^HYKMYVT[OL<:0U[LYUHS9L]LU\L:LY]PJL I`^OPZ[SLISV^LYZHJYVZZ[OLJV\U[Y`HUKWLVWSLHYLNLU\PULS`
7LYOHWZ[OH[PZ^O`[OL:,*YLJLP]LK[PWZK\YPUNP[Z HMYHPK[VZWLHRV\[HNHPUZ[^YVUNKVPUNPU[OLW\ISPJZLJ[VY
ÄZJHS`LHYHSTVZ[HÄM[OVM^OPJO^LYLYLSH[LK[VJVYWVYH[L ,HYSPLY[OPZ`LHYHZ[H[LVMÄJPHS^HZT\YKLYLKHM[LYISV^PUN
KPZJSVZ\YLHUKÄUHUJPHSZ [OL^OPZ[SLPUHSHUKHSSV[TLU[ZJHUKHSHUKPUHW\ISPJ
(ULJKV[HSS`^OH[PZILPUNOLHYKMYVT[OLLUMVYJLYZPZ[OH[ ZLY]HU[^HZZOV[HUKRPSSLKMVYIYPUNPUN\USH^M\SKLHSPUNZPUH
[OLU\TILYVMHSSLNH[PVUZOHZUV[NVUL\WI\[[OLSL]LSVM UH[PVUHSOPNO^H`ZWYVQLJ[PU[V[OLW\ISPJKVTHPU
KL[HPSHUKZ\WWVY[PUNPUMVYTH[PVUOHZPTWYV]LKZPNUPÄJHU[S` 0[PZHSZVPTWVY[HU[[V\UKLYZ[HUK[OLJ\S[\YHSHZWLJ[Z!PU
;OLZLºIV\U[`»WH`TLU[ZTH`HSZVOH]LOHKHUPTWHJ[VU 1HWHUMVYL_HTWSLP[PZVM[LUMV\UK[OH[LTWSV`LLZHYL]LY`
^OPZ[SLISV^PUNHYV\UK[OL^VYSK0UP[ZÄYZ[YLWVY[[OL:,* JVUZLUZ\ZVYPLU[LKHUKYLS\J[HU[[VISV^[OL^OPZ[SL^OLYLHZ
YLWVY[LKTVYL[OHUMVYLPNU[PWVMMZPU[OLSHZ[ÄUHUJPHS`LHY PU*OPUHLTWSV`LLZZLLTMHYSLZZHMYHPK[V]VPJL[OLPYJYP[PJPZT
^P[OULHYS`VULPUMV\YJVTPUNMYVT[OL<2MYVT*HUHKH (UVU`TV\ZYLWVY[PUNJHUZVTL[PTLZHSZVYHPZLSLNHSPZZ\LZ
HUKMYVT0UKPH;OPZTPNO[ZPTWS`ILYLWYLZLU[H[P]LVM[OL 0U-YHUJLMVYL_HTWSLHJV\U[Y`^P[OHZ[YPJ[ISVJRPUNZ[H[\[L
SHYNLU\TILYVM<:JVTWHUPLZVWLYH[PUNHIYVHKHUKPU[OLZL [OLSH^Z[YVUNS`KPZJV\YHNLZHUVU`TV\Z^OPZ[SLISV^PUN
JV\U[YPLZPUWHY[PJ\SHYVYP[JV\SKILWHY[VMHTVYLNLULYHS YLS`PUNPUZ[LHKVUHZZ\YHUJLZVMJVUÄKLU[PHSP[`
[YLUKPU[OL<2[OH[OHZZLLU[OLU\TILYVM^OPZ[SLISV^PUN
JHZLZYLWVY[LK[V[OL-PUHUJPHS:LY]PJLZ(\[OVYP[`-:(\W Conclusion
PUMV\Y`LHYZ0[JV\SKHSZVWVPU[[V[OLMHJ[[OH[UVUL >OPZ[SLISV^PUNPZUV[NVPUN[VNVH^H`HUKPZHJ[\HSS`VU
VM[OLZLJV\U[YPLZOH]LZPTPSHYWH`V\[ZJOLTLZPUWSHJL [OLPUJYLHZL7LYOHWZ[OPZPZK\L[VPUKP]PK\HSH^HYLULZZ
HS[OV\NOPU[OL<2/49L]LU\LHUK*\Z[VTZ/49* VMJVYWVYH[LJVTWSPHUJLHNYV^PUNJVUÄKLUJLHTVUNZ[
OHZWHPKO\UKYLKZVM[OV\ZHUKZVMWV\UKZ[V^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ LTWSV`LLZ[VºNVW\ISPJ»^P[O[OLPYÄUKPUNZILJH\ZLVM
PUYL[\YUMVYPUMVYTH[PVU[OH[OHZSLK[V[OLYLJV]LY`VM[H_ PUJYLHZPUNS`WVZP[P]LWYLZZJV]LYHNL[OLPUJYLHZPUNS`
YL]LU\LZ0[PZHSZV^VY[OUV[PUN[OH[ULP[OLY*HUHKHUVY0UKPH W\ISPJPZLKÄUHUJPHSPUJLU[P]LZVYILJH\ZLVM[OLMYLLKVT
UVYZL]LYHSVM[OLV[OLYJV\U[YPLZ^OVZLJP[PaLUZOH]L[PWWLK HMMVYKLK[VPUKP]PK\HSZ[VIYLHR^OPZ[SLISV^PUNZ[VYPLZ[OYV\NO
VMM[OL:,*OH]LHU`ZPNUPÄJHU[^OPZ[SLISV^LYWYV[LJ[PVU ZVJPHSTLKPHV\[SL[Z
LUZOYPULKPUSH^HMHJ[[OH[TH`HSZVPUÅ\LUJLWV[LU[PHS 9LNHYKSLZZVM[OLYLHZVU[OLYLPZH]LY`JSLHYTLZZHNL¶
^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ[VKLHSKPYLJ[S`^P[O[OL<: JVTWHUPLZ»MVYTHSWYVJLK\YLZOH]LHKPYLJ[PUÅ\LUJLVU[OL
WLYJLP]LKYPZRVM^OPZ[SLISV^PUNHUKVUZ[HTWPUNV\[IYPILY`
Legal protection for whistleblowers? HUKJVYY\W[PVU(^OPZ[SLISV^PUNWVSPJ`ZOV^ZJVTTP[TLU[
0U[OL<2PMTHSWYHJ[PJLVY^YVUNKVPUNPZOHWWLUPUNPUH [VNVVKNV]LYUHUJLHUKPZHN\PKLMVYLTWSV`LLZMVYYHPZPUN
^VYRWSHJLHUKHULTWSV`LLTHRLZHKPZJSVZ\YLPU[OLW\ISPJ JVUJLYUZYLZWVUZPIS`
PU[LYLZ[[OLUHZSVUNHZ[OL`MVSSV^[OLJVYYLJ[WYVJLK\YLZ -PUHSS`P[PZ^VY[OYLTLTILYPUN[OH[^OPZ[SLISV^PUNPZUV[
[OLPYLTWSV`TLU[YPNO[ZHYLPU[OLVY`WYV[LJ[LK,TWSV`TLU[ LHZ`-VYTVZ[WLVWSLMLHYPZHTVYLJVTTVUJH\ZLVMJVYY\W[
L_WLY[ZKVJH\[PVUOV^L]LY[OH[[OLSH^JHUUV[LU[PYLS` ILOH]PV\Y[OHUNYLLK4VZ[WLVWSL^HU[[VH]VPKJVUÅPJ[HUK
YLTV]L[OLYPZR[VLTWSV`LLZ0UKLLKH[[OLLUKVMSHZ[`LHYH ZWLHRPUN\WJHU[HPU[HJHYLLYVYPUL_[YLTLJHZLZOH]LL]LU
ZLUPVY5/:JVUZ\S[HU[W\ISPJS`Z[H[LK[OH[¸[OL5/:PZZ[PSS ^VYZLJVUZLX\LUJLZZVTHU`PUKP]PK\HSZQ\Z[RLLWX\PL[0[
[VVKHUNLYV\ZMVY^OPZ[SLISV^LYZ¹/LM\Y[OLYJSHPTLK[OH[¸ [HRLZJV\YHNL[VYLWVY[^YVUNKVPUN,]LU[OL[LYTPUVSVN`
^OPZ[SLISV^LYZPU[OLTLKPJHSWYVMLZZPVUJV\SKÄUK[OLTZLS]LZ \ZLKJHUZLUKHUPTWVY[HU[TLZZHNL!ZVWLYOHWZHNVVK
MHJPUN[OLZHJRHUKBOHKDUV^OLYL[VNV^P[OPU[OL5/:[V ÄYZ[Z[LWPZ[VJOHUNL[OLUHTLº:WLHRPUN\W»OHZHMHYTVYL
YLJLP]LHKLX\H[LZ\WWVY[VYWYV[LJ[PVU¹ WVZP[P]LJVUUV[H[PVU[OHUº^OPZ[SLISV^PUN»HUKWLYOHWZ[OH[PZ
;OPZPZL]PKLUJLKHJYVZZ[OL<2PULTWSV`TLU[[YPI\UHS ^OH[ZOV\SKYLHSS`ILLUJV\YHNLKPU[OLM\[\YL
Z[H[PZ[PJZ^OLYL[OLU\TILYVMPUKP]PK\HSZJP[PUN^OPZ[SLISV^PUN
HZHMHJ[VYPU[OLPYKPZW\[LPUJYLHZLKMYVTJHZLZPU References
O[[W!^^^L\YVMPUHUJLJVTYLZLHYJOHUKHUHS`ZPZVWPUPVUFHUKF
[V PU HUKLHJOVM[OLZLJHZLZPZL]PKLUJLVMH
YLZLHYJOHY[PJSLZL\YVMPUHUJLZ\Y]L`YL]LHSZJVTWHUPLZ^P[OV\[MVYTHS
IYLHRKV^UPUYLSH[PVUZIL[^LLULTWSV`LYHUKLTWSV`LL^OLYL WYVJLK\YLZYPZRMYH\KNVPUN\UYLWVY[LK
[OVZLJSHPTPUN[VOH]LZWVRLUV\[OH]LILLU\UKLYTPULKVY O[[W!^^^OZQJV\RUL^Z^OPZ[SLISV^LYOLSWSPULMVYKVJ[VYZ
HY[PJSL
YLTV]LKMYVT[OLPYQVIZ
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
product news
Advertisers Index
BWA WATER ADDITIVES IFC M-I SWACO OBC
CGG 29 OFFSHORE EUROPE 2013 39
CUDD ENERGY SERVICES 61 OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY 56
CUDD WELL CONTROL 47 PACKERS PLUS 04
DRILLING SOFTWARE LLC 09 SAUDI ARAMCO 13
DYNA-DRILL 02 SCIENTIFIC DRILLING LLC 17
ENERGY GLOBAL 48 SUPERIOR ENERGY SERVICES 65
GEFCO 34 T.D. WILLIAMSON OFC, 26, 27
GEODYNAMICS IBC TOTAL SAFETY 55
HARDBANDING SOLUTIONS BY
PUMP/TURBOMACHINERY SYMPOSIA 43
POSTLE INDUSTRIES
21
WELLTEC 07
OILFIELD TECHNOLOGY
July 2013
YEAH,
miswaco.com/deepwater