Professional Documents
Culture Documents
One of the major players on this inflammatory and immunologic battleground is the
polymorphonuclear leukocyte (PMN) or neutrophil. Hart et al 1994, reviewed evidence placing
the neutrophil in a central host response role against invading periodontal pathogens.
4. Adherence to microorganisms.
6. Intracellular killing.
Defects in any of these function or marked decrease in the number of neutrophils may result in
varying degree of susceptibility to infection. These qualitative or quantitative defects may
be inherited, acquired or drug-induced.
Diagnosis of neutropenia is based on clinical signs and symptoms as well as absolute neutrophil
counts.
Qualitative disorders of neutrophil function also increase the host’s susceptibility to infection.
Classification of neutrophil disorders corresponds with the major neutrophil processes:
Defects in the process of margination can occur at two levels. The first is a defect in a specific
neutrophil ligand called the Sialy-Lewis x protein (CD15s). A defect in this glycoprotein will
result in the loss of the neutrophil’s ability to ‘‘roll’’ along the endothelial lining of venules.
Alterations in the selectin-mediated rolling function prevent the neutrophil’s egress from the
venules. The defect is detected through flow cytometry using a commercially available
monoclonal antibody directed against the membrane surface antigens associated with CD15s.
The disease associated with this deficit is leukocyte adhesion deficiency type 2 (LAD-II).
The second neutrophil defect involving margination is at the level of neutrophil adhesion to the
endothelial cell. Defects in neutrophil surface integrins CD18/CD11a, CD18/CD11b, and
CD18/CD11c prevent the neutrophil from adhering to the endothelium. Inability to adhere to
endothelial cells prevents the migration of neutrophils to the site of infection. In addition, since
these integrins are also responsible for neutrophil adhesion to opsonized bacteria, the
neutrophil’s ability to phagocytize bacteria is compromised (Malech HL et al 1997).
Defects on CD18 and CD11 peptides are also identified by flow cytometry. Deficiency of
these intergrins is termed Leucocyte adhesion deficiency type-I (LAD-I)
These defects are very rare defect. Impairment of phagocytic function is usually caused by
deficiencies in certain immunoglobulin isotypes and other opsonization factors rather than
intrinsic defects in the neutrophil (Lakshman R et al,2001). Assays of phagocytosis utilize
either inert particles (stained oil droplets, fluorescent microspheres, latex beads) or radiolabeled
microorganisms (bacteria, yeast) that are detectable within the cell after phagocytosis.
Following incubation, the ingested particles are quantified to determine if phagocytosis is
impaired.
Defects in intracellular killing can be divided into those disorders affecting the oxidative or
non-oxidative pathways. Degranulation within the neutrophil is a non-oxidative function.
There are two main conditions with defects in degranulation – Chediak- Higashi syndrome
and specific granule deficiency.
Chediak-Higashi syndrome is characterized by fusion of cytoplasmic granules forming large
but defective granules. Degranulation is either delayed or incomplete, leading to impaired
intracellular killing. This neutrophil disorder is diagnosed with peripheral blood smears to
identify the large azurphilic cytoplasmic granules.
Specific granule deficiency manifests in the absence of secondary or specific granules. In this
disease, there is decreased availability of specific enzymes and adhesion molecules normally
present in secondary granules. Diagnosis of specific granule deficiency is through the use of
Wright stain confirming the absence of secondary granules. Assays for constituent proteins of
these granules should also demonstrate a reduction or absence compared to normally
functioning neutrophils.
The neutrophil’s oxidative killing mechanism involves two main enzymes that, in rare
instances, can be dysfunctional such enzymes are NADPH oxidase and Myeloperoxidase.
The first involves defects in the five components of the complex enzyme NADPH oxidase.
NADPH oxidase catalyzes the respiratory burst with the production of microbicidal superoxide
anion, hydrogen peroxide and hydroxyl radical. Without this oxidative reaction, bacterial
killing is greatly impaired. This neutrophil defect is responsible for the life threatening
recurrent infections found in chronic granulomatous disease.
Diagnostic tests for oxidative metabolism include the nitroblue tetrazolium test. In this test,
neutrophils are stimulated and incubated with the colorless nitroblue tetrazolium. If NADPH
oxidase is functioning, the nitroblue tetrazolium is reduced, leaving a blue black formazan
precipitate. If the oxidative burst is defective, no precipitate is formed. A more sensitive test to
measure the respiratory burst involves flow cytometry. Hydrogen peroxide converts
dihydrorhodamine to rhodamine and this is detected using a florescent label.
There are numerous diseases related to deficiencies in both neutrophil number and function,
only a few have been specifically related to periodontal disease in the medical and dental
literature. The following conditions were systemic conditions with neutrophil dysfunction in
which periodontal disease manifested as oral manifestations.
Systemic disease Neutrophil deficit Clinical manifestations
The earliest pioneering work on neutrophil functions and periodontal diseases in general and
aggressive periodontitis in particular indicated an impairment of neutrophil functions
responsible for host protection.
For the next decade, the prevailing view was that impaired neutrophil functions, as well as
impaired functions of other cells of the host response, were a central mechanism in the
progression of chronic and aggressive forms of periodontitis.
However, in subsequent decades, the concept of a “primed” or hyperactive neutrophil,
particularly in aggressive periodontitis, began to emerge (21, 29, 43, 56), leading to a new
perspective on the role of neutrophils in aggressive periodontitis, as well as the destructive role
of inflammatory cytokines from the cell-mediated response.
In the absence of a specific stimulus such as microbial colonization in the gingival crevice ⁄
periodontal pocket, neutrophils flow within the terminal circulation system in the periodontal
tissue, with a proportion of these neutrophils rolling along the endothelial lining. This rolling
motion along the endothelial lining is facilitated through weaker binding of selectins on the
neutrophil surface to lectins on the endothelial lining.
One of the first responses to such binding is shedding of the selectins on the neutrophil surface,
with a concomitant increased expression of integrins of the CD11 ⁄ CD18 (cluster determinant
11 ⁄ 18) family on the neutrophil cell surface.
These integrins enable the neutrophil to adhere more tightly to intercellular adhesion molecules
on the surface of endothelial cells, and facilitate migration of neutrophils through the
endothelial lining and into the lamina propria of the periodontal tissues. The actual movement
of neutrophils into the tissue is driven by an actin filament motor through polymerization and
depolymerization of intracellular actin filaments. Neutrophils then move out of the lamina
propria into the gingival crevice ⁄ periodontal pocket, where they attempt to engulf ⁄
phagocytose and kill the bacteria on the tooth surface.
This process of engulfing the bacteria via phagocytosis and eliminating them by intracellular
killing is facilitated by two neutrophil processes:
(i) Release of enzymes such as myeloperoxidase and a variety of proteolytic enzymes
from lysosomal granules, and
(ii) The oxidative burst, which entails the synthesis and release of superoxide and
hydroxyl radicals, and subsequent conversion of these products to hydrogen
peroxide.
Neutrophils secrete other bactericidal substances such as calprotectins and cathelicidins as part
of the innate immune system.
Both impaired neutrophils and primed ⁄ hyperactive neutrophils may play a role in the
pathogenesis of aggressive and chronic periodontitis.
Impaired chemotaxis in aggressive but not in chronic forms of periodontitis, the consensus is
that the chemotaxis defect may involve faulty surface receptors for chemotactic stimulants.
This could be due to
(i) A reduction in the number of receptors on the neutrophil cell membrane,
(ii) An inherent or acquired defect in the f-Met-Leu-Phe membrane receptor itself and
⁄ or coreceptors for the f-Met-Leu-Phe receptor such as GP110 (glycoprotein 110)
or CD38 that facilitate and enhance the chemotatic response (Van Dyke TE et al )
(iii) A combination of both.
Early indications supported a decrease in the number of neutrophil receptors for both f-Met-
Leu-Phe and the GP110 co-receptor.
Fuji et al in their studies there was a significant decrease of CD38 expression in f-Met-Leu-
Phe-stimulated neutrophils in localized aggressive periodontitis patients compared to normal
individuals.
However, these membrane receptor defects do not appear to influence the function of the
“motor”of neutrophil motility, the actin cytoskeleton,as the patterns of actin polymerization
and depolymerisation were normal.
In addition to impaired chemotaxis, some early studies demonstrated impaired phagocytosis
and killing in patients with localized or generalized aggressive periodontitis compared to
individuals with chronic periodontits.
Kimura et al studies showed that consistently lower percentages of neutrophils with
phagocytosed particles and lower numbers of phagocytosed particles per neutrophil in localized
aggressive periodontitis and generalized aggressive periodontitis compared to chronic
periodontitis patients.
This reduced function had not altered after treatment, implying an inherent defect that is not
affected by changes in serum factors that could be altered after periodontal treatment.
In the innate immune system, neutrophils are an important source of potent broad-spectrum
antimicrobials such as defensins and LL-37 cathelicidin.
In gingival crevicular fluid from some patients with aggressive periodontitis, LL-37
cathelicidin was reduced or absent, and there were lower levels of human neutrophil peptide
1–3 defensin compared to gingival crevicular fluid and neutrophils obtained from patients with
chronic periodontitis.
However,Fleming TF et al studies demonstrated that the reduction in these defensins was
considered to be minor and not to have a significant impact on the pathogenesis of aggressive
periodontal diseases.
A third area of study of neutrophil function that has involves possible alterations in the initial
adhesion of neutrophils to endothelial cells of capillaries. When stimulation started, this
process involves both shedding of selectins, and increased cell surface expression of CD11 ⁄ 18
integrins, which promote firmer adherence and fixation of the neutrophil to the endothelial
lining and subsequent chemotactic migration into the tissue.
Hurttia HM et al,1998 shown that unstimulated and f-Met-Leu-Phe-stimulated neutrophils
from localized aggressive periodontitis patients demonstrated higher adhesion to culture plates
than did periodontally healthy controls. But Mouynet P et al 1994,Palmer et al 1990 shown that
CD18 ⁄ CD11a and CD18 ⁄ CD11b expression on peripheral and crevicular fluid neutrophils in
localized aggressive and chronic periodontitis patients demonstrated no marked differences in
expression nor a deficiency of these adhesion integrins.
Most data have supported the concept of a hyperactive ⁄ primed neutrophil that leads to
increased tissue destruction in aggressive forms of periodontitis (Kantarci et al ).
Such priming could involve
1. Increased neutrophil adhesion,
2. Increased enzyme release and, perhaps most importantly,
3. An elevated oxidative burst.
For increased enzyme activity is supported by studies of neutrophils from patients with
aggressive forms of periodontitis who have increased intracellular levels of beta-glucuronidase,
an enzyme characteristic of azurophil lysosomes.
Patients with generalized aggressive periodontitis had greater beta-glucuronidase activity in
crevicular fluid than individuals with localized aggressive periodontitis, whose levels were in
turn greater than found in periodontally healthy controls. These higher levels of beta-
glucuronidase could lead to increased periodontal breakdown in aggressive periodontal
diseases (Albandar JM et al 1998).
Myeloperoxidase is another enzyme secreted by neutrophils that may play a central role in the
activation of neutrophil proteases In patients with aggressive periodontitis, baseline levels of
myeloperoxidase were highly correlated with the presence of bleeding and suppurating sites,
although no specific comparisons were made between aggressive and chronic periodontitis
patients (Kaner D et al ,2006).
Neutrophil priming by inflammatory cytokines in serum has also been implicated in aggressive
periodontitis. In one study, increased interleukin-8 plasma levels in aggressive periodontitis
patients were correlated with increased production of hydrogen peroxide by neutrophils, and
decreased L-selectin shedding, implicating interleukin- 8 in serum as a priming factor for the
neutrophil oxidative burst (Gainet J et al ,1999).
Another study found that an increase in expression of genes associated with NADPH
oxidase,which is responsible for the synthesis of oxidative burst products in both chronic and
aggressive forms of periodontitis (Nibali L et al,2006). The authors speculated that this may
also be an explanation for the altered neutrophil response that is characteristic of aggressive
periodontitis.
There are several pathways, substances or nodes in the intracellular scheme that could be
investigated, but this review focuses on the three pathways and nodes that have received the
most attention:
i. Calcium homeostasis,
ii. The phosphorylation of proteins by protein kinase C, and
iii. The central role of diacylglycerol and diacylglycerol kinase.
Calcium homeostasis and alterations of intracellular pH play a critical role in a variety of
neutrophil functions, including the chemotactic response, cell motility in migration and
phagocytosis, and selected intracellular signaling pathways. Several studies have demonstrated
impairment of the initial intracellular release of calcium and the influx of extracellular calcium
into the neutrophil. Although some studies have demonstrated that the release of intracellular
sequestered calcium in the early phase of the calcium response appears to be intact in
neutrophils from localized aggressive periodontal patients (Daniel MA et al,1993), the second
phase of the calcium response, associated with membrane channel activation and influx of
extracellular calcium, appears to be compromised (Daniel MA et al,1993).
However, redistribution of the rapidly released calcium and alkalinization of the cytoplasm was
impaired in the neutrophils from aggressive periodontitis patients compared to healthy controls
(Herrmann JM et al,2005).
Calcium influx is a newly described calcium influx factor (Shibata K et al,2000). This calcium
influx factor is hypothesized to be a second messenger for the opening of membrane calcium
channels when intracellular calcium stores are depleted. The activity of this calcium influx
factor is decreased in localized aggressive periodontitis patients compared to patients with
chronic periodontitis or healthy controls.
Alterations in protein kinase C One study reported that the total calcium-dependent protein
kinase C activity of neutrophils from patients with localized aggressive periodontitis and
decreased chemotactic migration to a F-Met-Leu-Phe gradient was lower than in neutrophils
from healthy controls.
Diacylglycerol (DAG) may play a central role in this intracellular signaling process, and the
reported alterations in DAG kinase levels in neutrophils from aggressive periodontitis patients
may have a variety of effects.
Because DAG is an endogenous activator of protein kinase C, increased and prolonged
generation of DAG could lead to an abnormal pattern of protein kinase C-regulated neutrophil
functions, explaining the parallel hypo and hyperactivities (Leino L et al, 1999).
DAG is converted to phosphatidic acid by DAG kinase. Thus reduced DAG kinase levels imply
increases in intracellular DAG levels and subsequent neutrophil priming (Gronert K et al,
2004).
This role for DAG in intracellular signalling in neutrophils from aggressive periodontitis
patients is supported by studies demonstrating that the DAG levels increased by 67 and 111%
from the basal level following stimulation with f-Met-Leu-Phe
Early studies suggested that a reduction of GP110 and f-Met-Leu-Phe receptors on neutrophils
is specific to localized aggressive periodontitis patients who exhibit neutrophil chemotaxis
abnormalities, and may be a useful disease marker for localized aggressive periodontitis (Van
Dyke TE et al,1987). DeNardin E et al 1990 demonstrated that some patients with aggressive
periodontitis exhibit normal chemotaxis, this approach may have limitations in diagnosing
aggressive periodontitis.
Kimura S et al, 1992 study that demonstrated impaired phagocytosis in localized aggressive
periodontitis patients, this reduced function was not changed after treatment, implying an
inherent defect that is not affected by serum.
On the other hand, neutrophil myeloperoxidase levels were decreased in a study on the
treatment of 23 patients with generalized aggressive periodontitis, and were related to reduction
of probing depth (Kaner et al , 2006).
In a recent series of studies on the treatment of patients with aggressive or chronic periodontitis
involving combinations of scaling and root planing, surgery if needed, and amoxicillin 500 mg
three times daily and metronidazole 250 mg three times daily for 7 days, there were reductions
of markers of neutrophil-mediated inflammation such as the enzymes cathepsin D,
myeloperoxidase and beta-glucuronidase in the gingival crevicular fluid in both the aggressive
and chronic periodontitis patients, with greater reductions after surgery. However, the levels
remained higher in the aggressive periodontitis patients (Buchmann R et al.2002).
Low-dose systemic antibiotics of the tetracycline family, such as doxycycline, can inhibit the
activities of some of the proteolytic enzymes released by neutrophils, and can act as scavengers
for products of the oxidative burst. Thus several investigators have suggested the use of low-
dose systemic doxycyclines specifically for the treatment of periodontal diseases (Lee HM et
al,2004), particularly aggressive periodontitis.
More recently, new insights into the role of products of the arachidonic acid pathway have
revealed that, in addition to proinflammatory and tissue-destructive products, such as
prostaglandins and leukotrienes, there are other products that may have anti-inflammatory ⁄
tissue protective effects (V an Dyke TE et al,2008)
These include a variety of arachidonic acid-derived lipoxins, such as lipoxin A4, which is
generated from the interaction of platelets and neutrophils, and an aspirin-generated lipoxin. In
addition, several investigators have identified metabolic modifications of omega-3 fatty acids
called resolvins that have similar structure and activity to these anti-inflammatory lipoxins. In
initial animal studies, administration of metabolically stable analogs of lipoxins and aspirin-
stimulated lipoxins inhibited migration of neutrophils in a mouse dorsal pouch model incubated
with P. gingivalis (Kantarci A et al,2005).These results also identified the neutrophil as a source
of prostaglandins, which are a potent mediator of bone resorption
Conclusion