LAW ON SALES

Atty. Relson P. Moral

Nature of the Contract of Sale

Coronel vs. CA 263 SCRA 15
Jovan Land, Inc. vs. CA 268 SCRA 160
Quijada vs. CA 299 SCRA 695
Heirs of San Andres vs. Rodriguez 332 SCRA 769
Pealosa vs. Santos 363 SCRA 545
PUP vs. CA 368 SCRA 545
Katipunan vs. Katipunan 375 SCRA 199
Jimenez vs. Jordana 444 SCRA 250
Dantis vs. Maghinang 695 SCRA 599
Monongsong vs. Estimo 404 SCRA 683
Yason vs. Arciaga 449 SCRA 458
Republic vs. Florendo 549 SCRA 527
Mapalo vs. Mapalo 17 SCRA 114
Cabotaje vs. Pudunan 436 SCRA 423
Bagnas vs. CA 176 SCRA 159
Dizon vs. CA 302 SCRA 288
Manila Metal Container Corp. vs. PNB 511 SCRA 444
Ang Yu Asuncion vs. CA 238 SCRA 602
Toyota Shaw, Inc. vs. CA 244 SCRA 523
Acap vs. Court of Appeals 251 SCRA
Alcantara-Daus vs. de Leon 404 SCRA 74
San Miguel Properties Philippines vs. Huang 336 SCRA 737

Characteristics of a Sale
Santos vs. CA 337 SCRA 67
Lao vs. CA 275 SCRA 237
Buenaventura vs. CA 416 SCRA 263
Fule vs. CA 286 SCRA 698
Bian Steel Corp. vs. CA 391 SCRA 90
National Housing Authority vs. Grace Baptist Church 424 SCRA 147
Congregation of the Religious of the Virgin Mary vs. Orola 553 SCRA 578
Carrascoso vs. CA, 477 SCRA 666
Gaite vs. Fonacier 2 SCRA 838

Sale Distinguished from Other Contracts

Santos vs. CA 337 SCRA 67
Carloz vs. Romil 20 Phil 183
De Santos vs. City of Manila 45 SCRA 409
Vda. De Jayme vs. CA 390 SCRA 380
Dao Heng Bank, Inc. vs. Laigo 571 SCRA 434
Luzon Development Bank vs. Enriquez 639 SCRA 332
SSS vs. Atlantic Gulf and Pacific Company of Manila, Inc. 553 SCRA 677
CIR vs. CA and Ateneo de Manila University 271 SCRA 605
Inchausti & Co. vs. Cromwell 20 Phil 345
Celestino Co. vs. Collector of Internal Revenue 99 Phil 841
CIR vs. Engineering Equipment and Supply Company 64 SCRA 590
Quiroga vs. Parsons 38 Phil 501
Gonzalo Puyat & Sons vs. Arco Amusement Co. 72 Phil 402
Quiroga vs. Parsons 38 Phil 501
Voctorias Milling Co. vs. CA 333 SCRA 663
Filinvest Credit Corp. vs. CA 178 SCRA 188
Contract of Sale vs. Contract to Sell
Coronel vs. CA 263 SCRA 15
PNB vs. CA 262 SCRA 464
David vs. Tiongson 313 SCRA 63
Gomez vs. CA 340 SCRA 720
Carrascoso Jr. vs. CA 477 SCRA 666
Robern Dev. Corp. vs. People’s Landless Association 693 SCRA 24
Heirs of San Andres vs. Rodriguez 332 SCRA 769
Gonzales vs. Heirs of Thomas and Paula Cruz 314 SCRA 585
Romero vs. CA 250 SCRA 223
Heirs of Pedro Escanlar vs. CA 281 SCRA 176
Akang vs. Municipality of Isulan, Sultan Kudarat, 699 SCRA 745
Almira vs. CA 399 SCRA 351
Portic vs. Cristobal 456 SCRA 577
Universal Robina Sugar Milling Corp. vs. Heirs of Angel Teves 389 SCRA 316
Manuel vs. Rodriguez 109 Phil 1
Padilla vs. Spouses Paredes 328 SCRA 434
Adelfa Properties Inc. vs. CA 240 SCRA 575
Babasa vs. CA 290 SCRA 532
Chua vs. CA 401 SCRA 54
Dignos vs. CA 158 SCRA 375
Topacio vs. CA 211 SCRA 291

Parties to the Contract of Sale

Labagala vs. Santiago 371 SCRA 360
Domingo vs. CA 367 SCRA 368
Paragas vs. Heirs of Dominador Balacano 468 SCRA 717
Guiang vs. CA 291 SCRA 372
Abalos vs. Macatangay 439 SCRA 64
Medina vs. Collector of Internal Revenue 1 SCRA 302
Matabuena vs. Cervantes 38 SCRA 284
Cruz vs. CA 281 SCRA 491
Olaguer vs. Purngganan 515 SCRA 460
Rubias vs. Batiller 51 SCRA 120
Schmid & Oberly vs. RJL Martinez Fishing Corp. 166 SCRA 493
Phil. Trust Co. vs. Roldan 99 Phil 392
Macariola vs. Asuncion 114 SCRA 77
Valencia vs. Cabanting 196 SCRA 302
Gregorio Araneta, Inc. vs, Tuason de Paterno GR No. L-2866
Del Rosario vs. Millado 26 SCRA 700
Daroy vs. Abecia 298 SCRA 172
Director of Lands vs. Ababa 88 SCRA 513
Johannes Schuback & Sons Phil. Trading Corp. vs. CA 227 SCRA 719 722

Subject Matter of the Contract of Sale

Sibal vs. Valdez 50 Phil 512
Pichel vs. Alonzo 11 SCRA 34
Mananzala vs. CA 286 SCRA 722
Gaite vs. Fonacier 2 SCRA 830
PUP vs. CA 368 SCRA 691
Tanedo vs. CA 252 SCRA 80
ACap vs. CA 251 SCRA 30
Alonso vs. Cebu Country Club Inc. 375 SCRA 390
Siacor v. Gigantana 380 SCRA 306
Frenzel vs. Catito 406 SCRA 55
Melliza vs. City of Iloilo 23 SCRA 477
 Carabeo vs. Dingco 647 SCRA 200
Atilano vs. Atilano 28 SCRA 231
Londres vs. CA 94 SCRA 133
National Grains Authority vs. IAC 171 SCRA 131
Johannes Schuback & Sons Phil. Trading Corp. vs. CA 227 SCRA 719
Yu Tek & Co. vs Gonzales 29 Phil 384
Gaite vs. Fonacier 2 SCRA 831
Pineda vs. CA 409 SCRA 438
Nool vs. CA 276 SCRA 149
Noel vs. CA 240 SCRA 78
Quijada vs. CA 299 SCRA 695
Cavite Development Bank vs. Spouses Cyrus Lim 324 SCRA 346

Price and Other Consideration

Inchausti & Co. vs. Cromwell 20 Phil 345
Bortikey vs. AFP RSBS 477 SCRA 511
Penalosa vs. Santos 363 SCRA 545
Yu Bun Guan vs. Ong 367 SCRA 559
Modina vs. CA 317 SCRA 696
Mate vs. CA 290 SCRA 463
Montecillo vs. Reynes 385 SCRA 244
Macapagal vs. Remorin 458 SCRA 652
Mapalo vs. Mapalo 17 SCRA 114
Vda. De Catindig vs. Heirs of Catalina Roque 74 SCRA 83
Ladanga vs. CA 131 SCRA 361
Republic vs. Phil. Resources Development 102 Phil. 960
Torres vs. CA 320 SCRA 428
PUP vs. CA 368 SCRA 691
Ong vs. Ong 139 SCRA 133
Boston Bank of the Phils. vs. Manalo 482 SCRA 108
Lawyer’s Cooperative vs. Tabora 13 SCRA 762
McCullough vs. Aenlle 3 Phil 285
Mitsui vs. Manila 39 Phil 624
Navarro vs. Sugar’s Producer’s Corp. 11 SCRA 1180
Velasco vs. CA 51 SCRA 439
Cruz vs Fernando 477 SCRA 173
Hyatt Elevators and Escalators Corp. vs. Cathedral Heights Building Complex Assn. 636 SCRA 401
Robles vs. Lizarraga Hermanos 50 Phil 387
Bautista vs. CA 436 SCRA 141
Vales vs. Villa 35 Phil 769
Tayengco vs. CA 15 SCRA 306
Bravo-Guerrero vs. Bravo 465 SCRA 244
Uy vs. CA 314 SCRA 69
Heirs of Spouses Balite vs. Lim 446 SCRA 54
Balatbat vs. CA 261 SCRA 128

Advertisements, Invitations, Offers

Gabelo vs. CA 316 SCRA 386
Equatorial Realty Dev. vs. Mayfair Theater 264 SCRA 483
Laudico vs. Arias 43 Phil 270
Villegas vs. CA 499 SCRA 276
Logan vs. Philippine Acetylene Co. 33 Phil 173
Tuazon vs. Del Roasario-Saurez 637 SCRA 728

Acceptance of Offer
National Grains Authority vs IAC 171 SCRA 131
 Del Prado vs. Caballero 614 SCRA 102
Gomez vs. CA 340 SCRA 720
Zayco vs. Serra 44 Phil 326
Beaumont vs. Prieto 41 Phil 670
Yuvienco vs. Dacuycuy 104 SCRA 668
DBP vs. Ong 460 SCRA 170\
Limketkai Sons Milling Inc. vs CA 250 SCRA 523
Limketkai Sons Milling Inc. vs. CA 255 SCRA 626
Uraca vs. CA 278 SCRA 702
Villonco vs. Boromeo 65 SCRA 352
Oesmer vs. Paraiso Dev. Corp. 514 SCRA 228
People’s Homesite & Housing Corp. vs. CA 133 SCRA 777
Province of Cebu vs. Heirs of Rufina Morales 546 SCRA 315

Earnest Money
Escueta vs. Lim 512 SCRA 411
San Miguel Properties Philippines vs. Huang 336 SCRA 732
GSIS vs. Lopez 592 SCRA 456
Villonco vs, Bormaheco 65 SCRA 352
Spouses Doromal vs. CA 66 SCRA 575
PNB vs. CA 262 SCRA 464
Adelfa Properties, Inc. vs. CA 240 SCRA 565
Goldenrod, Inc. vs. CA 299 SCRA 141

Option Contracts
Villamor vs. CA 202 SCRA 607
Laforteza vs. Machuca 333 SCRA 643
Adelfa Properties Inc vs. CA 240 SCRA 565
Carceller vs. CA 302 SCRA 718
Nool vs. CA 276 SCRA 149
San Miguel Properties Philippines, Inc. vs. Huang 336 SCRA 737
Kilosbayan vs. Morato 246 SCRA 540
Villamor vs. CA 202 SCRA 607
Dijamco vs. CA 440 SCRA 190
Soriano vs. Bautista 6 SCRA 946
Sanchez vs. Rigos 45 SCRA 368
Montilla vs. CA 161 SCRA 167
Natino vs. IAC 197 SCRA 323
Nietes vs. CA 46 SCRA 654
Heirs of Luis Bacus vs. CA 371 SCRA 295
Limson vs. CA 357 SCRA 209

Right of First Refusal

Guerrero vs. Ynigo 96 Phil 37
Guzman, Bocaling & Co. vs. Bonnevie 206 SCRA 668
Equatorial Realty Dev. vs. Mayfair Theater 264 SCRA 483
Ang Yu Asuncion vs. CA 238 SCRA 602
Sen Po Ek Marketing Corp. vs. Martinez 325 SCRA 210
Paranaque Kings Enterprises, Inc. vs. CA 268 SCRA 727
PUP vs. Golden Horizon Realty Corp. 615 SCRA 478
Sadhwani vs. CA 281 SCRA 75

Letter of Intent to Buy and Sell

Muslim and Christian Urban Assoc., Inc. vs BRYC-V Devt. Corp. 594 SCRA 724

Form of Sales
 Gallar vs. Husain 20 SCRA 186
Universal Robina Sugar Milling Corp. vs. Heirs of Angel Teves 389 SCRA 316
Dalion vs. CA 182 SCRA 872
Talusan vs. Tayag 356 SCRA 263
Santos vs. Santos 366 SCRA 395
R.F. Navarro & Co. vs. Vailoces 361 SCRA 139
Cosmic Lumber Corp. vs. CA 265 SCRA 168
City-Lite Realty Corp. vs. CA 325 SCRA 385
Delos Reyes vs. CA 313 SCRA 632
Oesmer vs. Paraiso Dev. Corp. 514 SCRA 228
Firme vs. Bukal Enterprises and Dev. Corp. 414 SCRA 190
Yuvienco vs. Dacuycuy 104 SCRA 668
David vs. Tiongson 313 SCRA 63
Baretto vs. Manila Railroad Co. 46 Phil 964
Vda. De Jomoc vs. CA 200 SCRA 74
Soliva vs. Intestate Estate of Marcelo Villalba 417 SCRA 277
Caludel vs. CA 199 SCRA 113
Alba Vda. De Rax vs. CA 314 SCRA 36
Londres vs. CA 394 SCRA 133
Ortega vs. Leonardo 103 Phil 870
El Oro Engravers vs. CA 546 SCRA 42
Leabres vs. CA 146 SCRA 158
Limson vs. CA 357 SCRA 209
Coronel vs. CA 263 SCRA 15
Cheng vs. Genato 300 SCRA 722
Tigno vs. Aquino 444 SCRA 61
Donato C. Cruz Trading Corp. vs. CA 347 SCRA 13
Industrial Textile Manufacturing Company of the Phils, Inc. vs. LPJ Enterprises, Inc. 217 SCRA 322
Sen Po Ek Marekting Corp. vs. Martinez 325 SCRA 210

Tradition and Delivery

Kuenzle & Streiff vs. Watson & Co. 13 Phil 26
Equatorial Realty Dev. Inc. vs. Mayfair Theater. Inc. 370 SCRA 56
Santos vs. Santos 366 SCRA 395
Power Commercial Industrial Corp. vs. CA 274 SCRA 597
Alfredo vs. Borras 404 SCRA 145
Manuel R. Dulay Enterprises Inc. vs. CA 225 SCRA 678
Garcia vs. CA 312 SCRA 180
Torcuator vs. Bernabe 459 SCRA 439
Municipality of Victorias vs. CA 149 SCRA 31
Sabio vs. International Corporate Bank 364 SCRA 385
Phil. Suburban Dev. vs. Auditor 63 SCRA 397
Heirs of Arturo Reyes vs. Socco-Beltran 572 SCRA 211
Addison vs. Felix 38 Phil 404
Power Commercial and Industrial Corp. vs. CA 274 SCRA 597
Pasagui vs. Villablance 68 SCRA 18
Dy vs. CA 198 SCRA 826
Amigo vs. Teves 96 Phil 252
Heirs of Pedro Escanlar vs. CA 281 SCRA 176
Tan vs. SEC 206 SCRA 740
Francisco vs. Chemical Bulk Carriers Inc. 657 SCRA 355
Lagooon vs. Hooven Comalco Industries Inc. 349 SCRA 363
Gaite vs. Fonacier 2 SCRA 830
Mendoza vs. David 441 SCRA 172
Engel vs. Mariano Velasco & Co. 47 Phil 115
Pacific Commercial CO. vs. Ermita Market & Cold Stores 56 Phil 617
 Vallarta vs. CA 150 SCRA 336
Cebu Winland Dev. Corp. vs. Ong Siao Hua 588 SCRA 120
Roble vs. Arbasa 362 SCRA 69
Santa Ana vs. Hernandez 18 SCRA 973
Chua vs. CA 401 SCRA 54

Double Sales
Abrigo vs. Vera 432 SCRA 544
Liao vs. CA 323 SCRA 430
Naawan Community Rural Bank Inc. vs. CA 395 SCRA 43
Dagupan Trading Co. vs. Macam 14 SCRA 179
Sabitsana Jr. vs. Muertegui 703 SCRA 145
Lichauco vs. Berenguer 39 Phil 643
Hanopol vs. Pilapil 7 SCRA 452
Carumba vs. CA 31 SCRA 558
Radiowealth Finance Co. vs. Palileo 197 SCRA 245
Espiritu vs. Valerio 9 SCRA 761
Dischoso vs. Roxas 5 SCRA 781
Caram vs. Laureta 103 SCRA 7
Mendoza vs. Kalaw 42 Phil 236
Andalin vs. CA 280 SCRA 536
Coronel vs. CA 263 SCRA 15
Consolidated Rural Bank (Cagayan Valley), Inc. vs. CA 448 SCRA 347
Carbonnel vs. CA 69 SCRA 99
King’s Properties Corp. vs. Galido 606 SCRA 137
Expresscredit Financing Corp. vs. Velasco 473 SCRA 570
Ten Forty Realty and Dev. Corp. vs. Cruz 410 SCRA 484
Tanedo vs. CA 252 SCRA 80

Sale by a Non-Owner or by One Having Voidable Title

Mindanao Academy vs. Yap 13 SCRA 190
Estoque vs. Pajimula 24 SCRA 59Almendra vs. IAC 204 SCRA 142
Nool vs. CA 276 SCRA 149
Noel vs. CA 240 SCRA 78
Cavite Dev. Bank vs. Spouses Cyrus Lim 324 SCRA 346
Bailon-Casilao vs. CA 160 SCRA 738
Pamplona vs. Moreto 96 SCRA 775
Imperial vs. CA 259 SCRA 65
Pisuena vs. Heirs of Petra Unating 313 SCRA 384
Cruz vs. Leis 327 SCRA 570
Bucton vs. Gabar 55 SCRA 499
Heirs of Spouses Benito Gavino vs. CA 291 SCRA 495
Tagatac vs. Jimenez 53 OG No. 12, 3792
Aznar vs. Yapdiangco 13 SCRA 486
EDCA Publishing & Distributing Corp. vs. Santos 184 SCRA 614

Loss and Deterioration, Fruits and Other Benefits

Roman vs. Grimalt 6 Phil 96

Obligations of the Buyer

Torcuator vs. Bernabe 459 SCRA 439
Montecillo vs. Reynes 385 SCRA 244

Remedies in Cases of Movables

 Salvoro vs. Tanega 87 SCRA 349
D’Oro Land Realty Dev. Corp. vs. Claunan 516 SCRA 681
Caram vs. Laureta 103 SCRA 7
Allure Manufacturing, Inc. vs. CA 199 SCRA 285
Heirs of Spouses Gavino vs. CA 291 SCRA 495
Erquiaga vs. CA 367 SCRA 357
Adelfa Properties, Inc. vs. CA 240 SCRA 565

Recto Law
PCI Leasing and Finance, Inc. vs. Giraffe-X Creative Imaging, Inc. 527 SCRA 405
Levy Hermanos, Inc. vs. Gervacio, 69 Phil 52
Industrial Finance Corp. vs. Ramirez 77 SCRA 152
Zayas vs. Luneta Motor Co. 117 SCRA 726
PAMECA Wood Treatment Plant, Inc. vs. CA 310 SCRA 281
Visayan Sawmill Company, Inc. vs. CA 219 SCRA 378
Borbon II vs. Servicewide Specialists, Inc. 258 SCRA 634
Tajanlangit vs. Southern Motors, Inc. 101 Phil 606
Southern Motors, Inc. vs. Moscoso 2 SCRA 168
Delta Motor Sales Corp. vs. Niu Kim Duan 213 SCRA 259
Nonato vs. IAC 140 SCRA 255
Cruz vs. Filipinas Investment & Finance Corp. 23 SCRA 791

Remedies in Cases of Immovables

Mahusay vs. B.S. San Diego, Inc. 651 SCRA 533
Ocampo vs, CA 233 SCRA 551
JM Tuason & Co., Inc. vs Javier 31 SCRA 829
Legarda Hermanos vs. Saldana 55 SCRA 324
Presidential Decree 957
Rescission
Romero vs. CA250 SCRA 223
Froilan vs. Pan Oriental Shipping CO. 12 SCRA 276
Uy vs. CA 314 SCRA 69
Supercars Management & Dev. Corp. vs. Flores 446 SCRA 34

Maceda Law
Luzon Brokerage vs. Maritime Bldg. 86 SCRA 305
Communities Cagayan, Inc. vs. Nanol 685 SCRA 453
McLaughlin vs. CA 144 SCRA 693
Siska Dev. Corp. vs. Office of the President 231 SCRA 674
Palay, Inc. vs. Clave 12 SCRA 639
Lagandaon vs. CA 290 SCRA 330
Leano vs. CA 369 SCRA 36
Active Realty & Dev. Corp. vs. Daroya 382 SCRA 152

Conditions and Warranties

Conditions
Romero vs. CA 250 SCRA 223
Heirs of Pedro Escanlar vs. CA 281 SCRA 176
David vs. Tiongson 313 SCRA 63
Ramos vs. CA 279 SCRA 118
De Leon vs. Ong 611 SCRA 381
Power Commercial and Industrial Corp. vs. CA 274 SCRA 597
Express Warranties
Investments and Development, Inc. vs. CA 162 SCRA 636
Implied Warranties
Schmid and Oberly, Inc. vs. RJL Martinez 166 SCRA 493
 Power Commercial and Industrial Corp. vs. CA 274 SCRA 597
Jovellano vs. Lualhati 47 Phil 371
Escaler vs. CA 138 SCRA 1
JM Tuazon vs. CA 94 SCRA 413
Investments and Development, Inc. vs. CA 162 SCRA 636
Nutrimix Feeds Corp. vs. CA 441 SCRA 357
Filinvest Credit Corp. vs. CA 178 SCRA 188
NDC vs. Madrigal Wan Hai Lines Corp. 412 SCRA 375
Dino vs. CA 359 SCRA 91
Mendoza vs. David 441 SCRA 172

Legal Redemption
Misterio vs. Cebu State College of Science and Technology 461 SCRA 122
Villarica vs. CA 26 SCRA 189
Mactan Cebu International Airport Authority vs. CA 263 SCRA 736
Ong Chua vs. Carr 53 Phil 975
Catangcatang vs. Legayada 84 SCRA 51
Narvaez vs. Alciso 594 SCRA 60
Legasp vs. CA 142 SCRA 82
Lee Chuy Realty Corp. vs. CA 250 SCRA 596
Solid Homes vs. CA 275 SCRA 267
Cruz vs. Leis 327 SCRA 570

Equitable Mortgages
Matanguihan vs. CA 275 SCRA 380
San Pedro vs. Lee 430 SCRA 338
Banga vs. Bello 471 SCRA 653
Bautista vs. Unangst 557 SCRA 256
Padilla vs. Linsangan 19 Phil 66
Austria vs. Gonzales. Jr. 420 SCRA 414
Redondo vs. Jimenez 536 SCRA 639
Villa vs. Santiago 38 Phil 157
Legaspi vs. Ong 459 SCRA 122
Lumayag vs. Heirs of Nemeno 526 SCRA 51
Capulong vs. CA 130 SCRA 25

Legal Redemption
Basa vs. Aguilar 117 SCRA 128
Plan vs. IAC 135 SCRA 270
Cua vs. Vargas 506 SCRA 374
Avila vs. Barabat 485 SCRA 8
Mariano vs. CA 220 SCRA 716
Primary Structures Corp. vs Valencia 409 SCRA 371
Ortega vs. Orcine 38 SCRA 276
De Santos vs. City of Manila 45 SCRA 409
Legaspi vs. CA 69 SCRA 360

Documents of Title
Warehouse Receipts Act
Bonded Warehouse Act
Siy Cong Bieng vs. Hongkong & Shanghai Bank 56 Phil 598

Bulk Sales Law

People vs. Mapoy 73 Phil 678
Ong vs. Ong 139 SCRA 133
Retail Trade Liberalization Act
Espina vs. Zamora 631 SCRA 17
Balmaceda vs. Union Carbide Philippines 124 SCRA 893
Goodyear Tire and Rubber Co. vs. Reyes 123 SCRA 273

Anti-Dummy Law
King vs. Hernaez 4 SCRA 792
Asbestos Integrated Manufacturing, Inc. vs Peralta 155 SCRA 213
Talan vs. People 169 SCRA 586