• • it

• • • • •

• • t

• • • D

t

t .. It ,.

• It

• It

• • • • • • • •

.. I)

• • • • • • • It

t t t

• t

t

.. ,.

,.

I

• I)

• • • • • • • ,.

• •

• • • • • •

• •

• t

D t

• I

t

•

., • It

• • •

• • D

t t t ..

• t

•

.. • • .,

• ..

• • • • It

• • • I»

•

• ..

• • It

• • • t

" I

• t

I)

t

•

I) • • • • •

• • .,

• • t

• t

• •

,

aTOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

ID

Points Awarded

a. Financial; BTOP Match

/0

b. Technology

o LTE

o Public Safety Specific

o NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o D-Block

2. Business Model: 60 points total score Points
Awarded
a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model /5 12
b. Implementation
0 Areas Covered 15 Ii(
0 System Capacity ,/ t
0 Plan
c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area )5 )3
d. Project Costs
0 Overall /5 13
0 Long term 3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score Points
a. Application Requirements 2- 2
b. Prior Experience ,5 I
c. Application Model
0 Writing 5 r-7
0 Submission CJ
0 Assistance 1

STOP Proposals

-

-

Comments:

+r:

J/ i>

"L{

I i,

-

"- \ ."
I\~ f:-
I
-top r» {
O'!,,1 'V\ C" r
s (- " T (

:. '

-

<1 C)?

~ »:»

lrtl'I~J;__

2 ;

I

LJ /

Firm _

\ t <" I l

_ 'l

,~~\ -.~ t

~ ,

; ,<'

•

1l

; ::

r

)

RFP _

Evaluator _

Date

I

I

2

Ij

i'··

:: ,..-:

STOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

Points Awarded

a. Financial; BTOP Match

b. Technology

o LTE

o Public Safety Specific

o NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o O-Block

2. Business Model: 60 points total score

Points Awarded

a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered

o System Capacity

o Plan

c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area

d. Project Costs

o Overall

o Long term

3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score

Points Awarded

a. Application Requirements

b. Prior Experience

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

1

,

STOP Proposals

Comments:

r}) -/ rr.

7

f ..

;i, !"'-hrf ,:,~,/"

L:: ..

, , I;;

Firm _

RFP _

Evaluator _

Date __ , __ , __

2

STOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

Points Awarded

a. Financial; BTOP Match

b. Technology

o LTE

o Public Safety Specific

o NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o D-Block

2. Business Model: 60 points total score

Points Awarded

a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model

/

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered

o System Capacity

o Plan

I (

c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area

d. Project Costs

o Overall

o Long term

3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score

Points rded

a. Application Requirements

b. Prior Experience

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

1

STOP Proposals

Comments:

Firm _

RFP _

Evaluator _

Date __ , __ , __

2

'\

STOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

Points Awarded

a. Financial; BTOP Match

b. Technology

o LTE

o Public Safety Specific

o NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o D-Block

2. Business Model: 60 points total score

Points Awarded

a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered

o System Capacity

o Plan

c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area

d. Project Costs

o Overall

o Long term

3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score

Points Awa

a. Application Requirements

b. Prior Experience

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

1

,

STOP Proposals

Comments:

,

'..J ~~ t~ \~,\ ___

r> :

f(~~, ,1 ;('~J,- .1

.:;;

Finn _

RFP _

Evaluator _

Date __ , __ , __

2

STOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

Firm Name

Evaluator

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

Points Awarded

a. Financial; STOP Match

/0

b. Techn9fogy q/ LTE

o Public Safety Specific

o NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks wzWaiver timing

c/' D-Slock

---

a.

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered i

o Systeilcapacity I

o Plan

Points Awarded

10

c. Partnership Structure with the Say Area

d. Project Costs /

o Overall ('

o Long term

Points Awarded

3. STOP Application: 10 points total score

a. Application Requirements

b. Prior Experience

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

1

STOP Proposals

Comments:

/ C";,.., ~~ /$'''';;'

f '<-- ;rd""' , /.P' /

l/~?·t

Firm _

RFP, __

Evaluator __

Date , , _

2

BTOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

Points Awarded

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

a. Financial; BTOP Match

b. Technology 'I LTE ~ Public Safety Specific ~ NPSTC involvement

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o O-Block

Points Awarded

2. Business Model: 60 points total score

a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered

o System Capacity

o Plan

3~ OU'(-? iM/lf1 V;)

7.1{ Puv;'" ~ur /2J)1ffI/1 r at;;J t>( __ S

c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area

d. Project Costs

o Overall

o Long term

10

Points Awarded

3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score

a. Application Requirements

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

3

1

STOP Proposals

Comments:

d,&f17~i-- ~~.e · ~i:t ~~::tk5j)4

j~d1?~~+~

Firm

----------------

RFP

-------

Evaluator

--------

Date I I

2

'\

STOP Proposals

Evaluation and Scoring Worksheet

1. Risk Mitigation: 30 points total score

Points Awarded

a. Financial; BTOP Match

/0

b. Technology

o LTE

o Public Safety SpeCific

o NPSTC involvement

Plo

c. 700MHz Frequency Risks

o Waiver timing

o D-Block

2. Business Model: 60 points total score

Points Awarded

a. System Operation, Maintenance, Ownership Model

/

b. Implementation

o Areas Covered

o System Capacity

o Plan

I~

c. Partnership Structure with the Bay Area

I

d. Project Costs

o Overall

o Long term

12

3. BTOP Application: 10 points total score

a. Application Requirements

b. Prior Experience

c. Application Model

o Writing

o Submission

o Assistance

Points Awarded

1

aTOP Proposals

Comments:

Firm _

RFP _

Evaluator _

Date __ , __ , __

2