Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Megger PDF
Megger PDF
Most facilities have grounded electrical systems, so that in the event of a lightning strike
or utility overvoltage, current will find a safe path to earth. A ground electrode provides the
contact between the electrical system and the earth. To ensure a reliable connection to
earth, electrical codes, engineering standards, and local standards often specify a minimum
impedance for the ground electrode. The International Electrical Testing Association specifies
ground electrode testing every three years for a system in good condition with average
up-time requirements. This application note explains earth/ground principles and safety in
more depth and then describes the principle testing methods: 3 and 4 pole Fall-of-Potential
testing, selective testing, stakeless testing and 2 pole testing.
Why Ground? systems connect the earth near • Depends on composition of the
the building with the electrical soil (e.g. clay, gravel and sand)
The US National Electrical Code system and building steel. In a • Can vary even over small
(NEC) gives two principle reasons lightning strike, the facility will distances due to the mix of
for grounding a facility. be at approximately the same different materials
• Stabilize the voltage to earth potential. By keeping the potential • Depends on mineral (e.g. salt)
during normal operation. gradient low, damage is minimized. content
• Limit the voltage rise created If a medium voltage utility line • Varies with compression and
by lightning, line surges or (over 1000 V) comes in contact can vary with time due to
unintentional contact with with a low voltage line, a drastic settling
higher-voltage lines. overvoltage could occur for • Changes with temperature,
Current will always find and nearby facilities. A low impedance freezing (and thus time of year).
travel the least-resistance path electrode will help limit the Resistivity increases
back to its source, be that a utility voltage increase at the facility. with decreasing temperature.
transformer, a transformer within A low impedance ground can • Can be affected by buried metal
the facility or a generator. Light- also provide a return path for tanks, pipes, re-bar, etc.
ning, meanwhile, will always find utility-generated transients. • Varies with depth
a way to get to the earth. Figure 1 shows a grounding Since resistivity may decrease
In the event of a lighting strike system for a commercial building. with depth, one way to reduce
on utility lines or anywhere in earth impedance is to drive an
the vicinity of a building, a low- electrode deeper. Using an array
impedance ground electrode will Ground Electrode of rods, a conductive ring or a
help carry the energy into the Impedance grid are other common ways of
earth. The grounding and bonding increasing the effective area of
The impedance from the an electrode. Multiple rods should
grounding electrode to the be outside of each other’s “areas
earth varies depending on of influence” to be most effective
two factors: the resistivity (see Figure 2). The rule of thumb is
of the surrounding earth to separate the elements by more
and the structure of the than their length. For example:
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.
Checking Connection The connections are made to:
Resistance Leading Up to • E/C1 – the ground electrode
the Electrode being tested
• S/P2 – A voltage (potential)
Before testing the electrode, start measurement stake driven into Source
by checking its connection to the earth some distance away Measure
the facility bonding system. Most from the electrode. Sometimes
Fall-of-Potential testers have the called the potential auxiliary Measure
Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation
probe is said to be within the and the measurement stakes you
Measure- influence of the electrode. Close should not take shortcuts – plot the
to the current probe the voltage Fall-of-Potential graph to be sure
ment Tips is almost the full voltage output
by the tester. But somewhere in
you are getting accurate results.
In testing a bonded array of
the middle, something interesting electrodes the combined resistance
• Bring a good, long tape
happens. of the array will be less than the
measure. As we move from the influence of lowest reading you measure for
• Finding the horizontal the electrodes and into the mass any individual electrode. If, for
part of the curve will of the earth, the test current no example, you have two 2.5 meter
require at least longer causes significant change rods spaced more than 2.5 meter
in potential. If you plot a series apart you can be confident that
5 measurements.
of measurements, moving the the combined resistance will be
• It’s a good idea to take potential stake away from the substantially less for the combined
three of your resistance electrode under test, and towards system.
readings with the P2 the current stake you will notice The three-wire measurement will
stake at 20%, 40% and a flattening of the curve. An ideal deliver good results if you use a
curve is shown in Figure 5 (see short C1 lead, or if you don’t mind
60% of the distance
previous page). The flattest part having a fraction of an ohm of lead
between E and C2. This of the curve is where we read resistance in your reading. For
will allow you to use the the earth resistance. In reality, ground resistance measurements
Tagg Slope Technique. the curve never goes entirely flat over 10 ohms, the effect of the resis-
• When placing the stakes but reaches a very gentle slope tance of the C1 lead will be small.
where changes in resistance are But for very precise measurements,
make sure the current
small. especially at low resistances, a four-
stake, the potential The extent of the influence of the wire tester allows you add a fourth
stake and the electrode electrode depends on its depth and lead to eliminate the contribution of
under test form it area. Deeper electrodes require the C1 lead. By running a separate
a straight line. that the current stake be driven potential lead (P1) to the electrode
farther away (see Table 1). For under test you can take the drop
• If you get a very high
large ground rings, grids or arrays along the C1 current lead out of the
impedance measure- the influence of the electrode may measurement.
ment or over-range, extend for hundreds of meters.
try pouring some water Table 2 gives suggested starting
around the test stakes points for current and potential
stake placement. Because of the
to improve their contact
possibility of interaction between
to earth. This isn’t an electrode rings, grids or arrays,
cheating since our inten-
tion is not to measure
the resistance of our
stakes, but to measure Table 1: Approximate Distance to Auxiliary Stakes using
the resistance of the the 62 % Rule (in meters)
electrode. Depth of Electrode Distance from E to Distance from E to
under Test (E) Potential Stake (P2) Current Stake (C2)
• Keep the potential and
current leads separated 2 15 25
to avoid signal coupling 3 19 30
between the two. 6 25 40
• At a new construction 9 31 50
site, you may want to
take multiple sets of
Table 2: Approximate Distance to Auxiliary Stakes for
measurements. Resis-
Electrode Arrays (in meters)
tance may drop over
Widest Dimension Distance from E to Distance from E to
time as the earth settles (Diagonal, diameter Potential Stake (P2) Current Stake (C2)
or Straight-line) of
Electrode Array under
Test (E)
20 30 50
The current probe generates a
voltage between itself and the 25 50 80
electrode under test. Close to the 30 70 100
electrode, the voltage is low and
becomes zero when the P stake 50 100 170
and electrode are in contact. Close 70 130 200
to the electrode, the potential
Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.
Distance From Electrode Under Test Resistance
100 10
100 20
100 30
100 40
100 50
100 60
100 70
100 80
100 90
P2 C2
E
Electrode Potential Current
Fall-of-Potential Plot
Under test Spike Spike
R (Ohms)
62 % d
15 30 45 60 75 90
P2 Distance from Electrode Under Test (meters)
d
Figure 6: Stake positions for the 62 % rule. Figure 7: Earth impedance can be found from this curve by using
the Tagg Slope Technique
The 62 % Rule The Tagg Slope Technique Calculate the slope coefficient (μ)
using three resistance measure-
You may be able to use a shortcut Large electrodes or grounding ments from 20 %, 40 % and
if your test meets the following systems require some special 60 % of the distance from the
criteria: consideration. If you’ve plot- electrode under test to the C2
• You are testing a simple elec- ted resistance readings for nine current stake.
trode (not a large grid or plate) different P2 locations and there is
• You can place the current stake no clear flattening on your graph, ( R60 % – R40 % )
30 meters or more from the then the Tagg Slope Technique µ =
( R40 % – R20 % )
electrode under test (also called the slope method) can
• The soil is uniform help establish the earth imped-
Under these conditions you can ance. Figure 7 shows an example Then go to the table in the back of
place the current stake 30 meters dataset for which there is no this application note and look up
or more from the electrode under obvious flat section. This curve is the P2/C2 ratio that corresponds
test. Place the potential stake at characteristic of a test in which to your μ. This will tell you where
62 % of the distance between the the current and potential probes to look on your graph to ascertain
current stake and the electrode never get outside the influence the earth resistance. For the
under test and take a measure- of the electrode under test. There sample data in Figure 7:
ment. As a check, take two more can be a number of reasons for a
measurements: one with the curve like this: ( 6.8 – 5.8 )
µ = = 0.71
potential probe 1 meter closer to • For electrode systems that cover ( 5.8 – 4.4 )
the electrode under test, and one large areas it may be difficult to
1 meter farther away (see Figure place stakes far enough away If we go to the table, for μ = 0.71
6). If you are on the flat portion of • You may not be able to place the corresponding P2/C2 percent-
the fall-of-potential curve then the the C1 stake at the center of age is 59.6 %. So the approximate
readings should be roughly the the electrode earth resistance would be
same and you can record the first • The area you have to place measured at (59.6 % X 100 m), or
reading as your resistance. stakes may be limited at 59.6 m. This is very close to our
If you have resistance read- 60 % point at 60 m, where we
ings at the 20 %, 40 % and 60 % read 6.8 ohms. So it would be safe
points between E and C2, then to say the earth resistance for the
you can apply the procedure to electrode under test is roughly
the data you’ve already taken. 6,8 ohms.
Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation
The Selective Method measure voltage drop. The big to generate a voltage on the
difference is that selective testing ground conductor at a unique
The Selective Method is a can accurately measure the test test frequency. It uses a second
variation of the Fall-of-Potential current in the electrode under test. transformer to distinguish the test
method, available on high-end The utility neutral, building frequency and measure the result-
ground testers like the steel and ground electrode are ing current through the circuit,
Fluke 1625. Testers with this all bonded and grounded. When which is determined by the loop
capability can measure the you inject a current into this resistance.
ground impedance of a specific system of parallel ground connec- This method is available in some
ground electrode without discon- tions the current will divide. In Fall-of-Potential testers (like the
necting it from an array or from a traditional Fall-of-Potential Fluke 1625 or Fluke 1623) or in
the electrical system. This means test you have no way of know- a single clamp on unit like the
you don’t have to wait for a shut- ing how much current is flowing Fluke GEO 30. Figure 10 shows
down to test or risk the safety between any particular electrode the connection of the source and
hazards of disconnecting the and the C2 current stake. Selec- measure clamps of the Saturn GEO X.
electrode from a live system. tive testing uses an integrated, Figure 9 (see next page) shows
The same rules for current stake high sensitivity clamp-on current the equivalent test circuit for the
and potential stake placement transformer to measure the test stakeless method. When you test
apply as with Fall-of-Potential. If current in the electrode under a building ground electrode using
the conditions are met for the 62 % test. Figure 8 shows how the this method, you are actually test-
rule (see previous page) then it current transformer fits into the ing a loop including:
can help reduce the number of test circuit. The selective ground • Electrode under test
measurements. Otherwise it’s a tester digitally filters the current • Ground electrode conductor
good idea to build a complete measurement to minimize the • The main bonding jumper
Fall of-Potential plot. You can use effects of stray currents. Being • The service neutral
the Tagg Slope Technique if your able to accurately measure the • Utility neutral-to-ground bond
curve does not flatten out. current in the electrode under • Utility ground conductors
Both the Fall-of-Potential method test effectively isolates the (between poles)
and the Selective Method use electrode and allows us to test it • Utility pole grounds
stakes to inject current and without disconnecting it from the Because this method uses the
system or from other electrodes. service as part of the circuit, it
may be used only after the service
NORMA Earth / Ground Tester
C2
Stakeless or Clamp- has been completely wired, that
is, it cannot be used prior to hook-
on Method
START
H
P2
R A Ground
Resistance 300kΩ
R
OFF 3 pole 4 pole AC Resistance ext
300kΩ
2 pole
P1
C1
SELECT E
SATURN GEO
C2
START
H
P2
DISPLAY
S
R A Ground
Resistance 300kΩ
R
OFF 3 pole 4 pole AC Resistance ext
300kΩ
2 pole
P1
CHANGE
C1
SELECT E Grounding
SATURN GEO Electrode
Voltage Conductor
U
Current
I
Equivalent Circuit
I
AC
Voltage Source
U
>10 cm
IN
Rx R1 R2 Rn-1 Rn Rx R1 R2 R3 Rn-1
Figure 9: Connections for selective Electrode Impedance Mesaurement Figure 10: Connecting the Saturn GEO X for a stakeless measurement
Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.
pole butt plates or un-insulated will indicate the earth resis- • The auxiliary electrode may
neutral conductors. The impedance tance of both electrodes. This not be outside the influence
of the utility ground electrodes method will not measure earth of the electrode under test. In
usually combines into a very low resistance. this case the reading might be
impedance. • A problem with the utility lower than reality.
Let’s take an example. Say you grounding system might inter- Because of the unknowns involved
have 40 pole electrodes of roughly fere with readings. in this technique, it is recom-
20 Ω each, and these electrodes In general, if you get readings mended only when the grounding
are connected together by a low- below 1 ohm, double-check to system and auxiliary electrode are
impedance ground wire from pole make sure you are not measuring well known.
to pole. The equivalent resistance a hard-wired conductive loop
of the 40 electrodes in parallel is: instead of the earth loop.
1
Req = = 1/2Ω Two-pole Method
40 x 1/20Ω
The two-pole method uses an
Since half an ohm is small “auxiliary electrode” such as a
compared to the resistance we water pipe. Figure 12 shows the
NORMA Earth / Ground Tester
C2
START
H
P2
expect for our electrode under test, connections. The tester measures
DISPLAY
S
R A Ground
Resistance 300kΩ
R
OFF 3 pole 4 pole AC Resistance ext
300kΩ
2 pole
C1
SELECT E
measured resistance is due to the the electrode under test, the earth SATURN GEO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
FFO
NO
Source
NORMA Earth / Ground Tester
C2
START
H
P2
DISPLAY
S
R A Ground
Resistance 300kΩ
R
OFF 3 pole 4 pole AC Resistance ext
300kΩ
2 pole
P1
CHANGE
C1
SELECT E
SATURN GEO
Measure
Current Paths
Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation
Summary of Ground Electrode Test Methods
Advantages Drawbacks
Fall-of-Potential • Widely accepted • You have to disconnect the ground
• When you see the characteristic • The stakes may not be easy to
curve you know you’ve got a good drive
measurement. • There may not be space around
the ground electrode to drive the
stakes
Selective Method • Don’t have to disconnect electrode • The stakes may not be easy to
• Widely accepted drive
• When you see the characteristic • There may not be space around
curve you know you’ve got a good the ground electrode to drive the
measurement. stakes
Stakeless Method • Convenient • Assumes a low-impedance paral-
• Saves time lel path
• No disconnections • Possible to get very low readings
• No stakes by mistakenly measuring on a
hard-wired loop
Two-pole Method • Convenient • Impossible to judge the integrity
• Saves time of the “auxiliary electrode.”
• No disconnections • Can’t be sure you are outside the
• No stakes area of influence
% % % % %
0.40 64.3 0.65 60.6 0.90 56.2 1.15 50.7 1.40 43.1
0.41 64.2 0.66 60.4 0.91 56.0 1.16 50.4 1.41 42.7
0.42 64.0 0.67 60.2 0.92 55.8 1.17 50.2 1.42 42.3
0.43 63.9 0.68 60.1 0.93 55.6 1.18 49.9 1.43 41.8
0.44 63.7 0.69 59.9 0.94 55.4 1.19 49.7 1.44 41.4
0.45 63.6 0.70 59.7 0.95 55.2 1.20 49.4 1.45 41.0
0.46 63.5 0.71 59.6 0.96 55.0 1.21 49.1 1.46 40.6
0.47 63.3 0.72 59.4 0.97 54.8 1.22 48.8 1.47 40.1
0.48 63.2 0.73 59.2 0.98 54.6 1.23 48.6 1.48 39.7
0.49 63.0 0.74 59.1 0.99 54.4 1.24 48.3 1.49 39.3
0.50 62.9 0.75 58.9 1.00 54.2 1.25 48.0 1.50 38.9
0.51 62.7 0.76 58.7 1.01 53.9 1.26 47.7 1.51 38.4 Fluke. K
eeping your world
0.52 62.6 0.77 58.5 1.02 53.7 1.27 47.4 1.52 37.9 up and running. TM
0.53 62.4 0.78 58.4 1.03 53.5 1.28 47.1 1.53 37.4
0.54 62.3 0.79 58.2 1.04 53.3 1.29 46.8 1.54 36.9 Fluke Corporation
0.55 62.1 0.80 58.0 1.05 53.1 1.30 46.5 1.55 36.4 PO Box 9090, Everett, WA USA 98206
0.56 62.0 0.81 57.9 1.06 52.8 1.31 46.2 1.56 35.8
Fluke Europe B.V.
PO Box 1186, 5602 BD
0.57 61.8 0.82 57.7 1.07 52.6 1.32 45.8 1.57 35.2 Eindhoven, The Netherlands
0.58 61.7 0.83 57.5 1.08 52.4 1.33 45.5 1.58 34.7 For more information call:
In the U.S.A. (800) 443-5853 or
0.59 61.5 0.84 57.3 1.09 52.2 1.34 45.2 1.59 34.1 Fax (425) 446-5116
0.60 61.4 0.85 57.1 1.10 51.9 1.35 44.8 In Europe/M-East/Africa (31 40) 2 675 200 or
Fax (31 40) 2 675 222
0.61 61.2 0.86 56.9 1.11 51.7 1.36 44.5 In Canada (800) 36-FLUKE or
Fax (905) 890-6866
0.62 61.0 0.87 56.7 1.12 51.4 1.37 44.1
From other countries +1 (425) 446-5500 or
0.63 60.9 0.88 56.6 1.13 51.2 1.38 43.8 Fax +1 (425) 446-5116
Web access: http://www.fluke.com
0.64 60.7 0.89 56.4 1.14 50.9 1.39 43.4
©2005 Fluke Corporation. All rights reserved.
Printed in The Netherlands 06/2006
2550440 A-EN-N Rev A
Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Pub_ID: 11095-eng