seeks to vilify something in theirs, they will confront him with the
shrurd things in the religions of others and hos ward off his asaule
‘pen their own,
‘Another group of them, realizing that the arguments they advance in
‘the defense of things of this sore are insfcint to prove their complete
‘vaidiey-so that thle adversary’s sence would rest from his accepting
the validity ofthese things rather chen from his inability to argue against
‘them-were then forced to we certain things that Would drive him «>
‘ease arguing agunse them” either from shame and his inality to express
himself edequately, or from fear of being harmed,
‘And sil ohers, convinced ofthe validity oftheir ovr eeligion beyond
sny doubs, [113] hold the opinion that they should defend ie before
thes, show ito be fair and free it of suspicion, and ward off their
adversaries from i, by using any chance thing. They would not even
{idan to use falsehood, sophisry, confounding, and conteniouness be-
fexuse they hold che opinion that only one of two men would oppose
their religion. He is ether an enemy, and it is admisible to use fabe-
hood and sophisry co ward him off and to defeat him, as isthe cae
in war (bad) and combst. Or he snot an enemy, but one who, owing
to weak intlleee and poor judgment, & ignorant of the advantage he
‘Would derive from this religion; and i iv admisible wo use faleehood
tnd sephiory to make man seek his wellbeing just as i done ia the
‘ase of women and children.
NOTES
1 Reig (fog Reig ema (0) for
ing nee SE Aen Pees SpFoon she nme i which Alferbs
Pot dred Scrip of wit nd inode snd encads Ye Ssarpon
acer eine Ml eed Re SECA sd ppv td
“¢ Ebel: “epenst Tity- Grup
way, Te pee preaaes apps
“re Allbi, Anaionneof Haye bean Iarpalan
oS BRE Me on AE Btn
i}
a
Alfarabi
THE POLITICAL REGIME
Translated by Fauci M. Nejjer
‘source: Medieval Political Philosophy, 1st ed.,
‘eds. Ralph Lemer and Muhsin Mahdi (New York,
1983)
Ia. fomous lone to his exatoe
ba Titbon, Maimonide store. "Do
‘ot boy yourself wh boon the
[vo lope except for what ar com:
posed by she ie mam AbO Nase se
Fat [Alfuabi) oc, in gener,
fverthing dat he composedand
bardcalaly Rs bok on the Prncper
ff Beings all Set than fine Boor
hs angmentsenble one under:
Stand and comprehend, for he wit
‘ery eae ia sider” The work
{lard o by Maimonides is twa
Gder ewo eles the Principe of
Being (or the St Priniir and te
Poleta Regine. Te fe tide ss
{a ave bes erated fom the open
ing pusge ofthe work, which pres
the Impresion tae ie e's eaten
{be pls of the mtr won sod
their respective rks of order (2)
the fis Cus, (2) the Send Cause,
(@) the Acie Inellece, (4) the soa,
(G) fom, aod (6) mas "The eee
”
fm pa of he wot cot of on
coe of tet Se pc a of
ie ae cotton he be eok
th scl On hen one go
aso te neo pa (he ea
‘Sica pening co
Seow i te cern a
‘Srobacion raed ppt for
fscrounr apd an
‘as ple bolts Wace
pe Obl Chi a
Sia tty Si aed
fae ee care te
He estore be Pat
Wath cond cae eine
koreans Oia Se
‘es Sy mcr not
Opin of ie deme hw
“The Polical Regime is fequendly
ced by Masi suber atone of the
Fundamental woes of fab fe was
‘Sundae ico Hebrew inthe mileofthe thieenth century, The allow on eter vo che Hyderabad txt
SMES fo bued on sexe Sits al-madanyya® (035 AHO.
"iledsofthe Aric snethacinbeing Tas eon i incomplete, an so are
faton ge fel M Najjar, The all che mangserips, wth the pombe
Pecencs insted in he cada: excpcon of eyailh 127%
Max aeLowes eo the species thar canor scomplih thir necessity
Ts or see thes bon se epee the asncton of
TERS ploop of them ins sale dvelingpac. Some human sociess
ekgn ches are of a medium si sl others are sal. The lage
srciets const of many naons that soca and coopers with one
‘Sener; the medium ones consist ofa nation; the small are the ones
‘Ginna by the egy. These thee ace the perce societies, Hence the
Sip teprescns the Rese degree of pevfection. associations in villages
Sferere, seats and housholds on the ober hand, are the imperfect
SESSfoa Or ter de lest pesfer the hosehald sociation, which
opie of he amsciaion inthe see, te later Beng apart of the
sodaion in he quae, ad thi in ton 2 put ofthe politcal soci
Ue RRetons in quancs and vilages ate both fo the sake of che
Shyer howe he rere pur of he ty we
Gongs only serve se go] The pola! (or ave] socety a pare
OF the sation, sod the nation h-divided nro cites. The absolutely
Sefecchanan soles ace divided into nations. A natin is diferentited
From anotier by eo eatual inge-natural make-up and natural chat~
saur_ind by something tha s compost (is conventional But as a
Seanad things which i lagwage-t mean the ior, ceough
wich men expres thenstves At afemesome nations are large and
Urher re eal
"The primary natura cause ofthe dfeences beeen nations in these
raters consis ofa varity of things. One of ther i the diferene i
thepans ofthe eal bodes Cat face them, namely, he fs that iy
the busrmost] sphere and the sphere ofthe fed sts then the cifer
fhe im the postions of the inclined spheres from the various pars of
‘fevearth andthe vrinion in ie provnity snd remotes. Prom this
follows the difercnce becween che pct of he earth tat ae the mations
Gweling-pses for from the user, chs diference reals fom the
‘ger in he pars ofthe Sa pec ha face them, fom the ifr
hee in the fed sts that face them, and from the diference in the
Sesdon ofthe ncined spheres th respec o them. From the diference
Eotstas te pars of tc eth follows the Wierence inthe vapors ing
fom the eat ance each vapor bes from a certain si es aki co
thar sll From the diference im he vapor lows the difference inthe
SESS auc tnasmuch a the war of cach county i generated from
32
ies underground vapors, and the air of each country is mixed with the
‘apors that ork thei way up to ie fom the sol Tn the same mannes,
the diference inthe air and water [of each country] follows from the
‘ference [in the pars] of che fixed sar and of the fit sphere that
face iz and from the difference in the postions of the inlined spheres
From all these differences, in turn, follows the diference in the plans
tnd inthe species of trations animals, [7] a8 2 eeslt of which nations
have diferent diets. From the ference in their des follows the dffer-
nce in the materials snd crops that go into the composition of the
Individuals who Bucceed the ones who ie. From ths, in tur, follows
the diferece in the natural make-up and natural character. Moreover,
the diference in the parts ofthe heaven that face them causes further
Gifernces in their make-up and characrer, in diferent manner from
the one mentioned above, The difference inte sir, to, causes diferences
jnvmke-up and character in a diferent manner from the one mentioned
thove. Furthermore, out of the cooperation and combination of these
Gifferences there develop diferent minutes that contribute co diferences
in the make-up and character of the nations Ie isin this manner and
(dzection that natal things fc together, ae connected with each othe,
tnd occupy thei respective rank; and this i the ement to which the
‘restal bodies contbute to their perfection. The remaining perfectons
Ste not given by the celeial bodies but by ehe Acdve Inelect and
the Active Intellece gives the emining perfecons eo no other species,
tue man.
Tn giving [these peefections) to man, the Active Intellect follows +
course salar to thit followed by the celestial bodies. Fis, it gives him
2 faculty and a principle with which, of his own accord, he seks, or is
thle to seek, the remsning perfecons. That principle consists of the
primary knowledge an the fit inteligibles preset in the rational part
‘f the sou, but gives him this Kind of knowledge and those inelligibles
‘nly after man (a) fe develop the vensive pare of the sul and the
Sppettive pare, which gives nse to the deste and aversion that adhere
to the sensitive pars. [42] (The inetuments of the lase wo faculties
‘develop from the pare of che body.) They, in turn, give sse eo the
will For, st fr, the will nothing but a desire cat follows from a
Senation, and desice takes place through the appetive pac of the sou,
and senstion through the sensve, (b) Nex, there bas to develop the
imaginative pat of the soul and the desire that adheres to it Hence 2
Second ll develops after the fist. Tie wil ia dese that follows from
[en act of the) imagination, After thee evo wil develop, it becomes
josie forthe primary knowledge that emanates from the Active ntel-
Teer to the rational pact to take pace, At this point + third kind of will
develops in man-che dese tat follows from incelecing—which is spe-
‘Sihcally called “choice” This choice pertains specifically co man, exlo-
33Petr
sive ofa other animals. By wire of i, an i able eo do either what
Bro Sbie or Uuable, noble or ue; and Because of there
i cute (The fe tv0 wily om the oer band
‘eaamd Pete animals too) When hs wil develops ams, with
isin th irae no to sek happine,and to do wi god oF
Sale obs nse fare NBO
Fo oe god withow quaint Everything wef for dhe
ware erat by which eis aad is god too, et for
ener eer bot because wel with eect Pape
eee ttng tne ero te way co happingr in ay fashion i
a eGo The good dati ofl forthe aclrement of haprines
aaa rrcphing te exis by ate orth comes big DY the
iy a Jar oom the way t happiness may be something
WL SSES Sue or tur core ino being by he wil That of it
se eatue is gen by the cesta bod, but noe Bene they
seer dee Acie llc oward its purpose o 43] hampe:
in ie cel boi ie something tat contributes to the
iar ei hee Itbec, they do not do 0 with he senion of
rae ce eave melt, aer ar the narra ehings tha bsuct
Tee punted by the celestial odie ohapes the Ac
RTE ee Rater ie nkeen inthe sobeance of the celtics
wrest Garin the mare of mace to rece, without concesing
Baa ttn wheter conibue 1 or harms, the papa of ce
saree alec, Therefore i posible ta che su total of what
ee othe cel toes soul compres mes thgs at ere
Frere Oc oter ines ngs tht ae nfevonbl, the PPOs
of the Acive Ile.
Reals good and evi, which ae the noble and he Base fe
ees thy fave thee origin specify in tan, Now dere i aly
BegTinvwieh he volumary. good ean come ito being. That
swe ele of the hun sol are Rv: the cheorets-aon
teow aon the eppeuave he imaginative, and the este
Sree ay ma cin Kew and pei knows By the
BeeSamoal face and by none ofthe reminng facles, Man
Pere Then he maker tue of the fe principles and the primary
ev als reno him by the Active Ile When he koows Ep
aaa Ey ene appeive fact, deers by the praca
mea caty open wha fe ought co doin order ro aaa. i es the
eet of te appettive fact todo the actos e hs covered
a So and fs imagine and serie faces ait 0d obey
eer an df aouang man to do the acne with wich be
She saa the everything at orgs from man wll be gd.
TRS RPNE ey tat che voluntary good comes ino eing. As fo
2, alee nthe one ht Usha se. Neher Be
34
imaginative nor the appetitive faculty perceives [44] happiness. Not
ven the ronal faculty presives happiness under all condions. The
“ssn fealeypereives happiness only when it strives o apprebend
5 Now here are many things that an can imagine thar they obghr £9
be the sim and end of ife each asthe pleasane andthe wsefl, honor, and
the lke. Whenever man negleces to pefece his theoretical-rational part
Tas to perceive happiness and hasten coward it holds something other
than bappines-whae is wefl, what is ples, domination, wha is
honorable, and the like—as an end toward which he aims in his Ute,
tleses ic with the appetitive fealty, uses che practicabrational faeaiy
to deliberate in the discovery of what enables him to attain ehis end,
tes the instruments of the tppedive faculty eo do the things he bss