Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2 Brief Review of Vibration Based Machine Condition Monitoring PDF
2 Brief Review of Vibration Based Machine Condition Monitoring PDF
Condition Monitoring
Dubravko, MILJKOVIĆ, Hrvatska elektroprivreda, Vukovarska 37, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia
dubravko.miljkovic@hep.hr
BRIEF REVIEW of VIBRATION BASED MACHINE CONDITION MONITORING
ABSTRACT - In the process of channeling energy into job to be performed all machines vibrate.
Machines rarely break down without giving some previous warning. The signs of impeding failure
are generally present long before a machine totally breaks down. When faults begin to develop in
the machine, some of dynamic processes in the machine are changed as well, thereby influencing
machine vibration level, temporal and spectral vibration properties. Such changes can act as an
indicator for early detection and identification of developing faults. This paper briefly reviews the
machine condition monitoring based on vibration data analysis. After the review of major, well
established and mature approaches, new unsupervised approaches based on novelty detection are
also briefly mentioned.
14
good condition, they also generate vibrations, 3.3. On-Condition Maintenance
[5]. However, most machines produce low When implemented in off-line mode, vibration
levels of vibration when designed properly. levels are measured at fixed predetermined
When there are signs of impeding failures, intervals. Once when measurement show
overall vibration level, spectral content and increased vibration level as sign of impend-
its statistical properties change, often quite ing problem, frequency of measurements
significantly. increases as shown in Figure 2, according
to [1]. Progress in development of vibration
monitoring equipment enables implementa-
3. MAINTENANCE SYSTEMS
tion in on-line mode at acceptable cost where
15
4.1. Transducers other domain, as well as with parameters that
Transducers can be accelerometers, velocity are statistical constructs, mostly involving
and displacement probes, [8, 9]. Choice of a signal from time domain. After signal acquisi-
transducer depends on flatness of a signal tion, data transformation (e.g. FFT) and feature
spectrum in a frequency range of interest, [6, extraction is performed to extract important
10]. The most reliable, versatile and accurate information in form of various indicators.
vibration transducer is the piezoelectric acceler- Finally, the decision process is performed
ometer, [8, 9]. Most accelerometers include an by classification of features, according to
integrated circuit preamplifier (IEPE - Integrated values, into two or three categories (e.g. normal
Electronics Piezo Electric design). operation, caution, and warning).
BRIEF REVIEW of VIBRATION BASED MACHINE CONDITION MONITORING
5. SIGNAL DOMAINS
Signal captured by accelerometers can be
analyzed in various domains, [1, 2]:
16
can reconstruct any signal of finite energy, (6):
17
6.2. RMS - Root Mean Square Value
xi
The RMS value of a vibration signal is an xi* = (10)
xmax
important measure of its amplitude, (7).
yi − ymax
yi* = (11)
1 N
ymax − ymin
RMS =
N
∑x
n =1
2
n (7)
Crest factor, Cf, is defined as: L is the length of the curve in the unit square
and
PL
Cf = (8) N’=N-1 (13)
CONDITION
RMS
where Pl is the signal peak level, (8). 6.6. Organizing Data from FFT Analysis
Machine Condition
Impacting is often associated with roller bearing frequency components. It is beneficial to organ-
wear, cavitation and gear tooth wear. ize these components into smaller number of
frequency beans (e.g. octave analysis) suitable
for classification.
6.4. Kurtosis
The fourth order moment, kurtosis, is defined in 1 N i +1 −1
BASED
(9):
Bi =
N i +1 − N i
∑A
j = Ni
i Bi = 1, N b (14)
N
∑ [y(n ) − µ ]
4
k= n =1 (9)
( )
of VIBRATION
element in good condition is expected to have These are some of the most traditional features
this value. The kurtosis level rises sharply to used for machinery diagnostics. Some methods
BRIEF REVIEW
around 6 at the onset of discrete damage. The are more appropriate for detection of particular
kurtosis value falls as the damage spreads. class of problems than other.
18
7.1. Time Waveform 7.3. Orbit Displays
It can be used effectively to enhance A circular orbit is obtained from two sinusoidal
spectral information in the following applications: waveforms equal in amplitude. Waveforms of
low speed applications (less than 100 RPM), different amplitudes produce an elliptical orbit. If
indication of true amplitude in situations where two waveforms contain more than one discrete
impact occurs such as assessment of rolling frequency, orbit pattern increases in complexity.
element bearing defect severity, gears, sleeve This display format shows journal bearing rela-
bearing machines with X-Y probes (2 channel tive motion (bearing wear, shaft misalignment,
orbit analysis), looseness, rubs and beats, [11]. shaft unbalance, lubrication instabilities [whirl,
whip], and seal rubs) extremely well (Figure 9),
19
Caution, (15):
x > LC (15)
Warning, (16):
x > Lw (16)
a) Original signal
MONITORING
d) After FFT of demodulated signal and envelope alarms, [21]. When dealing with
frequency domain one should specify
Figure 11 Demodulation analysis reveals the spectral alarm levels for each frequency bean
problem (Figure 12).
BASED
8. DETECTION TECHNIQUES
The interpretation and correlation of vibration
data is difficult task and requires experienced
Brief Review
20
They try to mimic pattern recognition ability of 9. NOVELTY DETECTION
human expert. Higher success rate (>90%) Novelty detection is the identification of new
can be achieved. Training is accomplished with or unknown data that a machine learning
normal and faulty data. In general, the system is not aware of during training, [24, 25].
system has to be previously trained on numerous Conventional monitoring of objects’ condition
examples, usually collected by measurements relies on known cases of abnormal condition(s).
on the same or similar machinery in the past. The availability of these known cases is,
Vibration measurement data can be however, not guaranteed, and in reality it is
automatically classified in various catego- often difficult to obtain such data. Examples
ries (no damage, moderate or heavy wear, of abnormal engine behavior are rare, and
10. APPLICATIONS
Figure 14 Basic ANN architecture of
interconnected neurons Basic problems that can be detected include
imbalance, misalignment, journal bearings,
Training is usually performed by some variant rolling element bearings and mechanical
of backpropagation algorithm and presenting looseness. Applications can be found in
input-output (signal features - output indica- machinery from all fields [28]:
tion) sample pairs until network learns input-
output mapping. Beside pattern recognition
approaches, common are statistical approaches 1. Engines, turbines and generators
using Hidden Markov models and Gaussian Vibration analysis for condition assessment
Mixture Models. There also exists model based and fault diagnostics has a long history of
approach that use mathematical models. application to power and mechanical equipment.
21
This includes reciprocating engines (e.g. can avoid unscheduled shutdowns and
compressors), gas, steam, hydro and wind expensive repair costs. The method is based on
turbines. the fact that with development of most machine
faults, there is also a corresponding change in
the way machines vibrate. Machine vibrations
2. Pumps
are picked by vibration transducers (mostly
Some of the core equipment issues include accelerometers). After data preprocessing
cavitation, seal failure, bearing failure and shaft (that includes data normalization and noise
imbalance. removal) vibration signals can be analyzed in
various signal domains (e.g. temporal, spectral,
BRIEF REVIEW of VIBRATION BASED MACHINE CONDITION MONITORING
22
Handbook, Brüel & Kjær, Denmark, November [19] Miljković, D., Fault Detection Methods: A
1987 Literature Survey, MIPRO, Opatija 2011
[9] Measuring Vibration, Brüel & Kjær, [20] Robichaud, J. M., Reference Standards
Denmark, September 1982 for Vibration Monitoring and Analysis, Bretech
[10] Vibration Measurement and Analysis, Engineering Ltd., 70 Crown St., Saint John, NB
Lecture Note BA 7676-12, Brüel & Kjær, 1998 Canada E2L 3V6
[11] Dunton, T. A., An Introduction to Time [21] Utete, S. W., Clifton, D. A. and Tarassenko,
Waveform Analysis, Universal Technologies L., Trending Of Performance Parameters For
Inc., 1999 Aircraft Engine Condition Monitoring, World
Congress on Engineering Asset Management
23